Hubbry Logo
Today We LiveToday We LiveMain
Open search
Today We Live
Community hub
Today We Live
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Today We Live
Today We Live
Today We Live
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Today We Live
Theatrical release poster
Directed byHoward Hawks
Written byWilliam Faulkner (dialogue)
Screenplay by
Based onTurn About
Saturday Evening Post 1932
by William Faulkner
Produced byHoward Hawks
Starring
CinematographyOliver T. Marsh
Elmer Dyer (aerial photography)
Edited byEdward Curtiss
Production
company
Distributed byLoew's Inc.
Release date
  • April 21, 1933 (1933-04-21) (US)
Running time
113 minutes
CountryUnited States
LanguageEnglish
Budget$663,000[1]
Box office$1,035,000[1]

Today We Live is a 1933 American pre-Code romance drama film produced and directed by Howard Hawks and starring Joan Crawford, Gary Cooper, Robert Young and Franchot Tone.[2]

Based on the story "Turnabout" by William Faulkner, which appeared in the Saturday Evening Post on March 5, 1932, the film is about two officers during World War I, who compete for the same beautiful young woman. Faulkner provided dialogue for the film, making it the only film version of his work that Faulkner co-wrote.[3]

Joan Crawford's character was added to the film to include a love interest. She met her future husband Franchot Tone on the set of the film. They married two years later.[4]

Plot

[edit]

During World War I, Diana "Ann" Boyce-Smith (Joan Crawford) is an English girl living on her father's estate in Kent. The estate is bought by a wealthy American, Richard Bogard (Gary Cooper), who seeks to move into his new property. Right as Bogard arrives, Ann and the house's servants find out that her father has been killed in action, but Ann projects calm and brave graciousness and moves to the guest cottage without complaint. Bogard finds her strength attractive and quickly falls in love with her.

Meanwhile, her brother Lt. Ronnie Boyce-Smith (Franchot Tone) and Lt. Claude Hope (Robert Young) are both British Naval officers going off to fight in the war. Ann believes she is in love with Claude, and consents to marry him. However, she soon realizes she is in true love when meeting Bogard. Though Bogard originally proclaimed his neutrality and indifference to the war, he soon joins as a fighter pilot. Ann goes to London, and though Claude is unaware of Diana's true feelings for Bogard, Ann admits her feelings for Bogard to Ronnie. Ronnie advises her to tell Claude the truth, but Ann is intent on keeping her marriage pledge. Then Ronnie shows an announcement in the paper informing her that Bogard was reported dead during a training accident.

However, there had been a mistake, and Bogard comes back unharmed. Though she is happy to see him, she disappears soon after he arrives. Bogard comes across a drunken Claude in a bar and takes him home—a home he shares with Ann. Bogard becomes jealous, and a rivalry for Ann develops between Bogard and Claude. Claude agrees to accompany Bogard on an air fight, and Bogard is surprised by Claude's expert shooting. Bogard takes a turn at Claude's shift on a boat, and Claude is blinded when hand-launching a torpedo against a German battleship.

Ann learns of Claude's blindness and says a final goodbye to Bogard, but he realizes Diana and Bogard's true feelings for one another. Diana feels it is her duty to care for Claude, and when an aerial suicide mission comes up, all three men participate, with the outcome being that both Claude and Ronnie die in action, although their boat successfully makes a torpedo run. Their sacrifice allows Bogard to survive, and although Diana is sad to lose both Ronnie and Claude, she and Bogard are reunited.

Cast

[edit]

As appearing in Today We Live (main roles and screen credits identified):[2]

A combination of model work and live action photography made for convincing aerial sequences.

Production

[edit]

With the working titles, "We Live Again" and "Turn About", Howard Hawks purchased an option on Faulkner's short story, "Turnabout" of men in combat as a star vehicle for Phillips Holmes, Charles "Buddy" Rogers, and later, Clark Gable.[5] Faulkner took only five days to write the film himself, but when Irving Thalberg, the vice-president of MGM studios at the time, insisted that Crawford be written into the script as she was contractually committed to a $500,000 salary, working or not, the first of many rewrites began.[N 1] Faulkner created the role of Ann, who was involved in a love triangle. Hawks hated the studio interference in what he considered would have been a "man's picture", but found working with Crawford was pleasant. Although touted as a classic screen pairing, Today We Live was the only time Joan Crawford and Gary Cooper performed together.[4] MGM marketed the film as a romance with the trailer focusing on the two stars, gushing on screen with the taglines, "The fiery head-strong personality of exquisite Joan Crawford" and "The calm strength, the eager romantic nature of handsome Gary Cooper."[8]

Once Crawford was signed, an effort to go for a similar star name led to Cooper coming on board, on loan from Paramount two weeks after the projected date of principal photography, although some sources indicate that Cooper, Robert Young and Franchot Tone were Hawks' first choices. Press releases had touted that Crawford had insisted on Cooper as her co-star.[9] Cooper was in a slight decline with two other "mediocre" films in release, and when the opportunity to work with Hawks came, it also aligned him with the mercurial Crawford, albeit in what he later would regard as a "misguided project".[10][N 2] A series of rewrites with both Faulkner and other screenwriters along with the cutting of key opening scenes led to a confusing jumble of versions, as the original screen time of 135 minutes of a preview print indicates.[13]

After obtaining General Douglas MacArthur's help in reserving March Field in California, individual aerial sequences were shot although footage from Howard Hughes' Hell's Angels (1930) including the bomber mission, the "dogfight" sequence complete with the head-on collision of two aircraft, was merged into the final production print.[13] Principal photography in both Culver City studio and location sites began in mid-December 1932 and wrapped in February 1933.[14] After looking at rushes of the young actors that were integral to the background of the film, it was evident that their British accents were completely unconvincing and Hawks resorted to excising their scenes altogether and entering a new rewrite, focusing more heavily on Crawford's character, with no better results. The upper-class dialogue that once was considered "snappy" now appeared to be "Hemingwayesque" and combined with the ludicrous period outfits worn by the cast, especially Crawford's outlandish gowns, made it difficult for cast members to not consider the entire exercise a farce.[15][N 3]

Reception

[edit]

Although well received in a preview, Today We Live was a very different film in its final release form, and was almost universally panned, with Variety having a litany of complaints: "... the film was 20 minutes too long. Crawford was unconvincing, Hawks used too much aerial footage from 'Hell's Angels' (1930), the "Gowns by Adrian" were extreme and annoying, and the story was superficial ... "[17] Mordant Hall in his review for The New York Times, was less strident, but noted the film was "at times vague and cumbersome. It possesses, however, the spark of sincerity, and its lack of clarity might be ascribed either to Howard Hawks's direction or to the script contributed by Edith Fitzgerald and Dwight Taylor, for there are sequences that are far too lengthy and others that would be considerably improved by more detail."[18] A modern assessment was similarly damning, "... the melodrama is more clinging than the mud of the Marne."[19]

Box office

[edit]

According to MGM records the film earned $590,000 in the US and Canada and $445,000 elsewhere resulting in a loss of $23,000.[1]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Today We Live

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Today We Live is a American pre-Code romance drama film directed by , based on William Faulkner's "Turn About" and featuring a by Faulkner himself. Set against the backdrop of , the film centers on a involving a British aristocrat, an American aviator, and a naval officer, blending elements of romance, personal sacrifice, and wartime action. Produced by (MGM), it stars as Diana "Ann" Boyce-Smith, as American pilot Richard Bogard, Robert Young as her fiancé Claude Hope, and as her brother Ronnie. The story unfolds in 1916, beginning when Bogard purchases Ann's family estate in after her father's death, leading to initial tensions that evolve into romance amid the escalating war. Hawks, known for his dynamic storytelling, incorporates thrilling aerial and naval sequences, with aerial footage borrowed from Howard Hughes's 1930 film Hell's Angels to depict intense dogfights and submarine battles. This marked the first professional collaboration between director Hawks and writer Faulkner, highlighting themes of camaraderie, jealousy, and heroism in a pre-Code era that allowed for frank depictions of relationships and mortality. Released on April 21, 1933, following a New York premiere on April 14, the film runs approximately 113 minutes and was filmed partly at March Field in for its aviation scenes. Notably, Crawford and Tone, who played siblings, met during production and married in 1935, adding a layer of real-life romance to the on-screen drama. Despite mixed contemporary reviews for its pacing, Today We Live remains a significant entry in Hawks's early career and a showcase for its star-studded cast during Hollywood's .

Overview

General Information

Today We Live is a 1933 American pre-Code romance set during , directed and produced by . The was co-written by —adapting his own "Turn About"—along with Edith Fitzgerald and Dwight Taylor. Hawks, known for his versatile direction across genres, brought together a notable cast including , , Robert Young, and for this production. The film runs for 113 minutes and was produced at a cost of $663,000, reflecting the studio's investment in high-profile talent during the early sound era. It was released by on April 21, 1933, marking one of the last major pre-Code releases before the stricter enforcement of the Production Code in 1934. A notable off-screen development occurred during filming, as lead actress met her future husband, , her co-star in the picture; the pair married two years later in 1935.

Release and Distribution

The film was produced under the working titles We Live Again and Turn About before finalized Today We Live for release. distributed the film domestically through its established theater chain, with a New York premiere on April 14, 1933, followed by a nationwide U.S. release on April 21, 1933. The studio's strategy capitalized on the star power of and , whom had borrowed from specifically for the production to fulfill Crawford's contractual commitments and attract audiences with their on-screen pairing. Promotional materials, including lobby cards and posters, prominently featured the duo in romantic and dramatic poses to highlight the film's wartime romance elements. As a pre-Code production, Today We Live received certification from the Motion Picture Producers and Distributors of America (MPPDA) without significant alterations, reflecting the lax enforcement of the Production Code prior to its stricter implementation in 1934. Internationally, handled distribution through its foreign affiliates, prioritizing North American markets before expanding to overseas territories; for instance, the film premiered in on October 1, 1933, on January 6, 1934, and later in on May 24, 1935, with releases in other European countries following a similar staggered pattern. In the UK, it reached audiences by mid-1933, though promotional efforts there faced mixed reception due to the film's British setting.

Background and Development

Literary Origins

Today We Live originated from William Faulkner's short story "Turn About," first published in The Saturday Evening Post on March 5, 1932. The story, one of Faulkner's several World War I-themed works, centers on the experiences of an American volunteer aviator in the British Royal Flying Corps and his interactions with British military personnel. At its core, "Turn About" unfolds against the backdrop of aerial and naval operations, highlighting the bonds of camaraderie formed between soldiers from different branches and nations amid the perils of combat. Themes of sacrifice emerge through the characters' willingness to undertake high-risk missions, underscoring the personal costs of war and mutual reliance in the face of death. These elements reflect Faulkner's interest in the psychological and ethical dimensions of warfare, drawn partly from his own brief service in the Canadian during the war's final months. Faulkner had minimal prior involvement with Hollywood before this adaptation; his engagement with the project in represented his initial foray into professional screenwriting. Optioned by director and subsequently commissioned by , the film diverged significantly from the source material by incorporating a central female protagonist, absent in the all-male of "Turn About," to broaden its dramatic scope and appeal. This addition shifted the story's focus, introducing romantic tensions while retaining the wartime setting and themes of loyalty and peril.

Screenplay Adaptation

The screenplay for Today We Live originated from William Faulkner's "Turn About," published in on March 5, 1932. In July 1932, director , who had optioned the story, presented a treatment co-authored with Faulkner to MGM producer , leading to Faulkner's signing of a six-week contract with the studio that month. This marked the beginning of their , with Faulkner completing the first draft of the —initially titled Turn About—in August 1932, a process that took just five days and focused on the original all-male war narrative involving British naval officers. Faulkner's involvement extended to dialogue and revisions, earning him credits for story and dialogue; this remains his only full screen credit for adapting one of his own works into a . Studio demands significantly altered the script's structure, transforming it from a buddy adventure centered on male camaraderie into a romantic drama featuring a . To fulfill Joan Crawford's $500,000 contractual obligation to , the character of Ann—a strong-willed Englishwoman—was inserted in the first draft, shifting the focus to her relationships with the American pilot Richard Bogard () and her fiancé Claude Hope (Robert Young), while her brother Ronnie () plays a supporting role. This addition, which Faulkner resisted but incorporated, replaced war-centric themes with romantic tensions, as noted in the second draft where the war and love storylines are segregated until their late integration. Edith Fitzgerald and Dwight Taylor then rewrote the first half after Faulkner's temporary departure to , producing a second draft that emphasized these changes, while Faulkner returned to revise the final script by adding one key scene. Working titles evolved from Turn About to We Live Again before settling on Today We Live, with production commencing in late 1932. Faulkner's prose influenced the script's stylistic elements, particularly in its clipped, unsentimental , which Crawford specifically requested to align her character's speech with the men's terse style—evident in exchanges like Ronnie's understated wartime banter: "We're . We can make it." This approach retained echoes of Faulkner's modernist economy from "Turn About," avoiding verbose exposition in favor of implied emotional depth amid action sequences. Despite multiple drafts—Faulkner authored three in total—the final version balanced his contributions with Hollywood conventions, highlighting the challenges of adapting literary subtlety to studio-mandated romance.

Production

Casting Process

The casting of Today We Live was heavily influenced by Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer's contractual obligations to , who was brought in to fulfill a $500,000 commitment despite the story's original all-male focus from William Faulkner's "Turnabout." Studio executives insisted on rewriting the screenplay to center a female lead, adding the character of Diana "Ann" Boyce-Smith to incorporate romantic elements and leverage Crawford's star power. Director had already selected as Richard Bogard, Robert Young as Claude Hope, and as Ronnie Boyce-Smith before approaching Crawford, aiming to assemble a strong ensemble for the drama. Initial co-stars considered included and Charles "Buddy" Rogers. MGM borrowed Cooper from , though negotiations delayed his involvement until two weeks after production began in mid-December 1932. This marked the only on-screen starring pairing of Crawford and Cooper, a combination promoted for its romantic appeal despite their characters' limited shared screen time. Supporting roles included Louise Closser Hale as Applegate and Roscoe Karns as ["Mac"] McGinnis, chosen to provide and grounding amid the leads' intensity. Authenticity challenges arose with the film's British setting, particularly as initial plans for childhood flashback scenes were scrapped when child actors failed to master required British accents. The principal cast, all American, delivered lines in their natural accents despite portraying British characters, a decision that prioritized star familiarity over linguistic precision but drew later criticism for inauthenticity. Behind-the-scenes dynamics added intrigue, as Crawford and Tone met during production and developed a budding romance that influenced the set's atmosphere, eventually leading to their marriage in 1935. This personal connection helped shape the film's interpersonal tensions, though it remained secondary to studio-driven casting logistics.

Filming and Technical Aspects

Principal photography for Today We Live began in late December 1932 and wrapped in February 1933, primarily taking place at the Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer (MGM) studios in Culver City, California. The production schedule was influenced by the need to accommodate the stars' commitments, with director Howard Hawks overseeing a tight timeline for the film's blend of romance and war drama elements. Key filming locations included in , where aerial sequences were shot over several weeks by cinematographer Elmer Dyer to capture authentic World War I-era flying scenes. To enhance the aerial action, the production incorporated from ' Hell's Angels (1930), including bomber expeditions, dogfights, and a plane collision, which helped achieve visual realism without extensive new shoots. The film's black-and-white cinematography was handled by Oliver T. Marsh, utilizing the Sound System for dialogue synchronization. Technical challenges arose during production, particularly with achieving historical accuracy for the setting through period-appropriate costumes and props, which required meticulous sourcing to depict British estates and military environments. Additionally, issues with British accents plagued the shoot; child actors cast for early scenes struggled to master them, resulting in those sequences being deleted and contributing to adjustments from an initial 135-minute preview cut to a final runtime of approximately 113 minutes. The total reached $659,710, with overruns attributed to script rewrites and the reshoots necessitated by these technical hurdles.

Plot

Synopsis

In 1916, during , the father of young English aristocrat Diana "Ann" Boyce-Smith dies in action, leaving the family estate in in financial distress. American Richard Bogard purchases the property, displacing Ann and her brother Ronnie, a naval officer preparing to depart for . Their neighbor, British naval officer Claude Hope, proposes marriage to Ann, who accepts out of duty before seeing both men off . Ann and Bogard develop an initial antagonism that evolves into romance during their time on the estate. As the war intensifies, Ann travels to join Ronnie and Claude, volunteering with the ambulance corps while honoring her engagement to Claude. Bogard, having enlisted as a volunteer pilot in the Royal Flying Corps, invites Claude on a perilous bombing raid over lines, leading to a tense reunion where Ann confesses her lingering feelings for Bogard but remains loyal to her fiancé. Jealousy fuels Bogard's risky decisions as the men engage in fierce aerial combat against German forces. The narrative culminates in a high-stakes mission to sink a German using torpedoes, during which Claude is blinded but conceals his to protect his comrades. Learning of Ann's true affections, Claude and Ronnie embark on a final suicide run to destroy another enemy vessel, sacrificing themselves heroically to ensure Ann's future happiness. With the war's toll exacted, Bogard survives and reunites with Ann back in , free to pursue their love as the fallen are remembered as wartime heroes.

Key Themes

The central in Today We Live functions as a primary vehicle for examining and redemption within the wartime context, intertwining personal affections with the demands of . Ann, portrayed as an independent English ambulance driver in , navigates her engagement to the British naval officer Claude while developing feelings for the American pilot Bogard, creating tension that propels the . This manifests in their competing displays of bravery—Claude through daring torpedo runs and Bogard via aerial maneuvers—culminating in redemptive acts where personal jealousies yield to collective duty, as seen in the ultimate sacrifice of Claude and Ronnie to protect their comrades and Ann. The film depicts heroism through vivid portrayals of pilots' and sailors' camaraderie, showcasing bonds forged in the heat of battle among characters like Bogard and his squadron, as well as Ronnie and Claude, who share risks in bombing raids and dogfights that underscore mutual reliance and valor. Yet, this heroism is tempered by the theme of war's futility, illustrated by the senseless sacrifices that claim lives, such as Claude and Ronnie's fatal joint mission to sink an enemy , which emphasizes the emotional and physical toll on individuals despite their noble intentions. These elements highlight the pre-Code era's willingness to blend glorification with subtle critique of conflict's human cost. Gender dynamics are explored through Ann's agency in a male-dominated wartime story, reflecting the film's pre-Code boldness in allowing her to assert autonomy as an active participant on lines, driving ambulances amid shellfire and influencing the men's decisions without being confined to passive domesticity. Her romantic choices challenge rigid gender expectations, positioning her as a catalyst for the rivals' growth rather than a mere , though ultimately framed within the era's patriarchal structures. Motifs reinforce these ideas: aerial symbolizes the protagonists' emotional turmoil, with high-stakes dogfights paralleling the turbulence of the , while contrasts between Ann's initial opulent English estate and the grim battlefield underscore war's disruptive force on personal lives and societal norms.

Cast and Characters

Principal Performers

The principal performers in Today We Live were billed in the order of , , Robert Young, and . starred as Diana "Ann" Boyce-Smith, an English socialite whose family estate is lost in , leading her to take on roles as a wartime driver and nurse. Under her contract, Crawford was added to the originally all-male story to incorporate a female lead, marking a significant adaptation from William Faulkner's source material. By 1933, Crawford had established herself as one of MGM's top female stars, following breakout successes in dramatic roles such as Grand Hotel (). Gary Cooper portrayed Richard Bogard, the charismatic American volunteer pilot who becomes entangled in a romantic rivalry. This was the only collaboration between Cooper and Crawford. Cooper was loaned to from for the production, reflecting inter-studio arrangements common in the era. In 1933, Cooper was a major leading man, fresh from starring roles in (1932) and the comedy (1933). Franchot Tone played Ronnie Boyce-Smith, Ann's carefree brother and fellow pilot who provides comic relief amid the war's tensions. Tone, signed to an contract after Broadway successes, was cast early in alongside Young. His Hollywood career was gaining momentum in 1933, building on his film debut in The Wiser Sex (1932) and leading to a string of notable supporting roles. Robert Young appeared as Claude Hope, the steadfast British naval officer and Ann's childhood neighbor who competes for her affection. Like Tone, Young was selected by director before Crawford's involvement and was under contract. By 1933, Young had become a reliable supporting player at the studio, appearing in over a dozen films since his screen debut in 1931, including The Kid from Spain (1932).

Role Interpretations

embodied Ann Boyce-Smith as a figure of glamour intertwined with vulnerability, capturing the character's evolution from sheltered English aristocrat to a woman hardened by the exigencies of . Her performance highlighted Ann's emotional turmoil in the , blending poised elegance with moments of raw desperation, though some observers noted the role strained her typical screen persona. Crawford's attempt at a British accent, required for the character's heritage, drew mixed responses; she later reflected on her discomfort with it, feeling it compromised her authenticity, while contemporary critics found it serviceable but unconvincing in conveying upper-class English inflection. Gary Cooper's depiction of the American pilot Bogard exemplified stoic heroism, marked by understated physicality and quiet intensity that defined his early leading man style. He portrayed Bogard as a rugged outsider thrust into the British social circle, with his arc culminating in sacrificial valor amid aerial combat. Cooper's dynamic with Crawford infused their romantic scenes with a palpable tension, contrasting his laconic demeanor against her expressive fervor, though the screenplay's pacing sometimes muted their on-screen spark. Franchot Tone and Robert Young brought contrasting energies to the film's central romantic triangle, enhancing the interpersonal conflicts among the male characters vying for Ann's affection. Tone infused his role as Ronnie with levity and charm, delivering a sensitive, nuanced that lightened the drama's heavier moments and provided emotional grounding as Ann's brother. In contrast, Young's portrayal of Claude conveyed intensity and earnest devotion, particularly in a standout scene of raw grief that underscored the character's unyielding passion. Their interplay, alongside Cooper, created a layered ensemble dynamic reflective of era-specific techniques emphasizing restrained and subtle rivalry.

Reception

Contemporary Reviews

Upon its release in April 1933, Today We Live received mixed contemporary reviews, with critics divided on its blend of romance, war drama, and star power. The New York Times commended the film's overall sincerity and the earnest performances, particularly highlighting Joan Crawford's effort in the lead role, Robert Young's excellent portrayal of the aviator Claude Hope, and Franchot Tone's solid work as Ronnie Boyce-Smith, while noting Gary Cooper's believable depiction of the naval officer Richard Bogard. However, the review pointed out vagueness and cumbersomeness in the plotting, criticizing implausible coincidences, abrupt romantic developments, and anachronistic costumes that undermined the World War I setting's authenticity. Variety's assessment was more negative, describing the 110-minute New York version as 20 minutes too long and faulting the superficial story for lacking depth. The trade paper found Crawford unconvincing and miscast as the English aristocrat-turned-ambulance driver, critiquing her performance amid excessive "Gowns by Adrian" that overshadowed the narrative. It also highlighted the reuse of aerial combat footage from ' Hell's Angels (1930), which contributed to pacing issues and a sense of recycled in the aviation sequences. The Hollywood Reporter offered a more optimistic take, suggesting that once trimmed to exhibition length, the film would deliver strong value, largely due to the star appeal of Crawford and Cooper. The review praised ' direction as "well nigh perfection," crediting his handling of the action elements and ensemble dynamics for elevating the melodramatic tone. Despite these positives, it acknowledged the need for to address runtime bloat and maintain momentum across the and wartime sacrifices. Common themes across these critiques included the film's melodramatic excess, particularly in its romantic entanglements and emotional appeals, which some saw as sincere but others as overwrought. Pacing problems were frequently cited, with the early London-based romance dragging before the Boulogne war sequences gained traction. Pre-Code liberties, such as the bold depiction of the and implied sensuality in wardrobe, drew little explicit comment but aligned with the era's loosening moral standards before the Production Code's full enforcement.

Box Office Performance

Today We Live generated total worldwide rentals of $1,035,000 (producer's share of box office receipts), comprising $590,000 from the United States and Canada and $445,000 from overseas markets. These figures represent distributor rentals, not total ticket sales gross, which would have been significantly higher. Despite featuring major stars Joan Crawford and Gary Cooper, the film incurred a net loss of $23,000 for MGM (after accounting for production costs exceeding $663,000, overhead, and distribution expenses), primarily due to the challenging economic climate. The picture underperformed relative to other 1933 releases starring its leads; for instance, Crawford's subsequent Dancing Lady earned domestic rentals of $1,490,000, marking it as a significant hit for the studio, while Cooper's Design for Living also achieved stronger returns. efforts emphasized the star power of Crawford and Cooper to drive ticket sales, but the film's April 1933 release during the height of the limited overall profitability amid widespread audience austerity.

Legacy

Critical Reassessment

In the and , film scholars reevaluated Today We Live as an early exemplar of ' hybrid genre blending war action with romantic melodrama, particularly through its depiction of male aviators' bonds and sacrificial heroism amid aerial combat. This reassessment positioned the film within Hawks' recurring motifs of professional men under pressure, contrasting its initial dismissal by emphasizing the director's innovative overlap of frontline intensity and interpersonal tensions. Critics also praised its pre-Code sensuality, noting how Joan Crawford's portrayal of Diana Boyce-Smith conveys bold physical allure and emotional vulnerability in scenes of wartime courtship, unhindered by later censorship constraints. William Faulkner's screenplay contributions received particular attention for infusing the film with subtle literary depth, transforming a standard Hollywood vehicle into a text marked by modernist stylistic touches in its terse, rhythmic . Scholars highlight how Faulkner's adaptation of his "Turnabout" retains elliptical phrasing and ironic undertones in exchanges among the pilots, elevating the script beyond conventional war-romance tropes despite extensive rewrites by others. This influence is credited with lending the film a distinctive verbal economy, as seen in Hawks' embrace of banter to underscore themes of camaraderie and loss. Modern critiques from the through the have applied feminist lenses to Crawford's central role, interpreting Diana as a figure of assertive who disrupts the male-centric world by driving the narrative's romantic rivalries and moral choices. These readings emphasize her character's evolution from aristocratic detachment to active participant in the , challenging passive female archetypes in early sound-era cinema. Comparisons to other films, such as Wings (1927), underscore Today We Live's unique integration of spectacle with interpersonal drama, though it shares motifs of aerial sacrifice and youthful . The film figures prominently in scholarly biographies of Hawks, where it is analyzed as a pivotal early collaboration with Faulkner that foreshadowed the director's mature explorations of masculine professionalism. programming notes have further spotlighted its relative obscurity, presenting it as an underappreciated pre-Code artifact that bridges and genre experimentation.

Cultural Impact and Preservation

Today We Live has left a modest but notable mark on the genre of -war films, particularly through director Howard Hawks's early exploration of aerial combat and its psychological toll during . The film's depiction of dogfights and pilot camaraderie influenced Hawks's subsequent works, such as Ceiling Zero (1936), by establishing motifs of high-risk heroism and male bonding amid wartime peril, though it is often regarded as the least accomplished of his aviation dramas. The rare on-screen teaming of and has been examined in star studies for its contrast of Crawford's glamorous intensity against Cooper's understated masculinity, highlighting a unique intersection of MGM's leading talents in a pre-Code romance-war hybrid that remains their sole collaboration. In terms of preservation, Today We Live entered the in the United States due to non-renewal of its , allowing unrestricted access to prints and enabling widespread . It received a manufactured-on-demand DVD release from in 2009 and a Blu-ray edition on September 30, 2025. Modern audiences can access the film through (TCM) broadcasts, which have featured it in programming dedicated to classic war dramas and star retrospectives, as well as full-length uploads and clips on stemming from its status. Academic screenings occasionally include it in studies of Hawks or Faulkner, but no major restoration efforts, such as 4K remastering or archival reissues beyond the 2025 Blu-ray, have been documented as of November 2025. Beyond its genre contributions, the film serves as William Faulkner's entry point into Hollywood , adapting his "Turnabout" into his first credited and securing him subsequent contracts at . As a pre-Code production released just before the Hays Office's strict enforcement in 1934, it exemplifies the era's leniency toward mature themes like and wartime sacrifice, often cited in histories of Hollywood's transitional censorship landscape.

References

  1. https://catalog.afi.com/Catalog/moviedetails/7233
  2. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0024675/
  3. http://pre-code.com/today-we-live-1933-review-with-joan-crawford-gary-cooper-and-franchot-tone/
  4. https://letterboxd.com/film/today-we-live/
  5. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/today-we-live-review-1933-movie-1093323/
  6. https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Today-We-Live-%281933%29
  7. https://doi.org/10.14325/mississippi/9781628461015.003.0001
  8. https://www.studiobinder.com/blog/what-is-the-hays-code-1934/
  9. https://www.altfg.com/franchot-tone/
  10. https://www.alamy.com/gary-cooper-and-joan-crawford-in-today-we-live-1933-directed-by-howard-hawks-credit-mgm-album-image703310904.html
  11. https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/features/deep-focus/pre-code-hollywood
  12. https://www.nytimes.com/1933/05/28/archives/forthcoming-pictorial-offerings-ed-wynns-plans-the-last-adam-with.html
  13. https://onlinebooks.library.upenn.edu/webbin/cinfo/satevepost
  14. https://www.gradesaver.com/short-stories-of-william-faulkner/study-guide/summary-turnabout
  15. https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/1/article/974167/pdf
  16. https://gardenandgun.com/feature/william-faulkners-hollywood-odyssey/
  17. https://go.gale.com/ps/i.do?id=GALE%257CA538247998&sid=googleScholar&v=2.1&it=r&linkaccess=abs&issn=0277335X&p=AONE&sw=w
  18. https://www.biblio.com/book/turnabout-film-contract-signed-faulkners-first/d/840033068
  19. https://central.bac-lac.gc.ca/.item?id=NR82922&op=pdf&app=Library
  20. https://brightlightsfilm.com/the-cinematic-faulkner-framing-hollywood/
  21. https://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title/1184/today-we-live
  22. https://objects.lib.uidaho.edu/etd/pdf/Cardwell_idaho_0089N_11155.pdf
  23. https://lfq.salisbury.edu/_issues/48_1/to_put_it_all_into_words_is_a_hell_of_a_hard_thing_faulkners_adaptation_of_history_and_fiction_in_a_ghost_story_war_birds.html
  24. https://www.jstor.org/stable/48678769
  25. https://commonreader.wustl.edu/c/flight-and-film/
  26. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24907815
  27. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Gary-Cooper
  28. https://www.garycooper.com/blog/today-we-live-4czr7
  29. https://www.franksmovielog.com/reviews/today-we-live-1933/
  30. https://www.nytimes.com/1933/04/15/archives/joan-crawford-and-gary-cooper-in-the-first-picture-derived-from-a.html
  31. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/01439689200260081
  32. https://dokumen.pub/howard-hawks-new-perspectives-9781838711627-9781844575411.html
  33. https://www.filmcomment.com/article/masculine-feminine-howard-hawks/
  34. https://britishacademy.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.5871/bacad/9780197263518.001.0001/upso-9780197263518-chapter-9
  35. https://archive.org/details/todaywelive_201701
  36. https://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=36956
  37. https://www.facebook.com/ClassicQueenJoan/posts/-joan-crawford-and-gary-cooper-star-in-1933s-today-we-live-airing-on-us-tcm-earl/1329704442490914/
  38. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qwSVCtUvSro
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.