Recent from talks
Nothing was collected or created yet.
-gry puzzle
View on WikipediaThe -gry puzzle is a popular word puzzle that asks for the third English word that ends with the letters -gry other than angry and hungry. Specific wording varies substantially, but the puzzle has no clear answer, as there are no other common English words that end in -gry.[1][2] Interpretations of the puzzle suggest it is either an answerless hoax; a trick question; a sincere question asking for an obscure word; or a corruption of a more straightforward puzzle, which may have asked for words containing gry (such as gryphon). Of these, countless trick question variants and obscure English words (or nonce words) have been proposed. The lack of a conclusive answer has ensured the enduring popularity of the puzzle, and it has become one of the most frequently asked word puzzles.[3][4][5]
The ultimate origin and original form of the puzzle is unknown, but it was popularized in 1975, starting in the New York area, and has remained popular into the 21st century. Various similar puzzles exist, though these have straightforward answers. The most notable is "words ending in -dous", which has been popular since the 1880s.
Answers
[edit]Various proposed answers exist, stating that the question is one of the following:
- A hoax – there is no answer, and its purpose (or effect) is to frustrate.[6]
- A trick question, with various answers depending on precise wording.
- A sincere question asking for an obscure word, most often proposed as aggry or puggry. This does not apply to wordings that explicitly ask for a very common word.
- A corruption of a more straightforward word puzzle, namely a word containing the sequence "gry", though not necessarily at the (tail) end, in which case the answer is gryphon which is uncommon but in use.[7][8][9]
This topic is a source of lively interest, both to lovers of word puzzles and lovers of words. For both groups, much of the appeal lies in the quest, either to trace the origin of the puzzle or compile a complete list of words ending in -gry.
More recently, the word hangry—a portmanteau of 'hungry' and 'angry'—has been used to refer to an irritable state induced by lack of food.[10] Oxford Dictionaries (controlled by, but less restrictive than, the Oxford English Dictionary) added hangry on 27 August 2015,[11][12][13] and the full Oxford English Dictionary added hangry in 2018.[14]
History
[edit]There are anecdotal reports of various forms of the puzzle dating to the 1950s or earlier; the ultimate origin is presumably an oral tradition or a lost book of puzzles.[15] However, the first documented evidence is from early 1975 in the New York metropolitan area, and the puzzle rapidly gained popularity in this year. The most likely source is the talk show of Bob Grant, from some program in early or mid March 1975.
Merriam-Webster, publishers of the leading American dictionaries, first heard of this puzzle in a letter dated March 17, 1975, from Patricia Lasker of Brooklyn, New York. Lasker says her plant manager heard the question on an unnamed quiz show. Since that time Merriam-Webster has received about four letters each year[3] asking the question.
The puzzle first appears in print in Anita Richterman's "Problem Line" column in Newsday on April 29, 1975. One "M.Z." from Wantagh, New York states that the problem was asked on a TV quiz program. Richterman states that she asked a learned professor of English for help when she first received the inquiry, and he did not respond for over a month. This agrees with the Merriam-Webster report, suggesting a quiz show in early or mid March 1975.
In Anita Richterman's column on May 9, 1975, several correspondents reported that they had heard the puzzle on the Bob Grant radio talk show on WMCA in New York City. This suggests either that the earlier claims of a (TV) quiz show confused a talk show with a quiz show, or that there was another unspecified quiz show that was then repeated by Grant.[16] The majority of readers gave the answer "gry", an obsolete unit of measure invented by John Locke. It is unclear whether this was the answer given on the Grant show, or what the precise wording had been.
By fall 1975 the puzzle had reached the Delaware Valley, again apparently by radio, by which time the puzzle seems to have mutated to a form in which the missing word is an adjective that describes the state of the world.[17]
The puzzle has had occasional bouts of popularity: after its initial popularity in 1975, it was popular in 1978, then again in 1995–1996.[18]
Reports of earlier versions
[edit]The most credible report of an early version was given on Stumpers-L in 1999, which reported a trick question formulation from a book of riddles entitled Things to Think About, probably dating to the 1940s:[19][20]
Talk about serendipity. New neighbor was up in her attic, and found a few pages of a book ... "Things to Think About" ... it was just 8 pages, and they were from the middle. They were all more or less riddles.
"Someone offers to give you 5 cents if you can jump across the street. Take it or leave it? What do you think?" next page, "Take it. Walk across the street and jump."
"Do you think you could bite 2 inches from the mantle? After you think about it, turn the page", next page "Of course you can, get a yard stick, and measure two inches away from the mantle and bite!"
"How many pieces of string would you need to fly a kite to the moon? Think a minute!" next page "Only one, but it would have to be a long one!"
AND THE LAST ONE ...
"There are three words in the English language that end with 'gry'. Two of these are angry and hungry. The third word is a very common word, and you use it often. If you have read what I have told you, you will see that I have given you the third word. What is the third word? Think very carefully." next page "Three, the question has nothing to do with angry, hungry, or any of the many other obscure words that end in 'gry', it is a simple question asking you what the third word in the sentance is. As you take tests, remember this."
I have no idea who the author was, or the publisher. From the paper, it would guess it was from the 40s, as it looks like WW2 type paper. Connie
Alternative versions
[edit]Trick versions
[edit]- This version only works when spoken: There are three words in English that end in a "gree". The first two are "angry" and "hungry", and if you've listened closely, you'll agree that I've already told you the third one.[3][21]
- The answer is "agree".
- There are three words in the English language that end with the letters 'g', 'r', and 'y'. Two are "hungry" and "angry". The third word is something everyone uses every day. Everyone knows what the third word means. What is the third word?[3][22]
- The answer is "energy". The riddle says that the word ends in the letters g-r-y; it says nothing about the order of the letters. Many words end with "-rgy", but energy is something everyone uses every day.
- There are at least three words in the English language that end in "g" or "y". One of them is "hungry", and another one is "angry". There is a third word, a short one, which you probably say every day. If you are listening carefully to everything I say, you just heard me say it three times. What is it?[3][23]
- The answer is "say". This version depends upon the listener confusing the spoken word "or" and the spoken letter "r".
- There are three words in the English language that end in "gry". Two words that end in "gry" are "hungry" and "angry". Everyone knows what the third word means, and everyone uses them every day. If you listened very carefully, I have already stated to you what the third word is. The three words that solve this riddle are...?[3][24]
- The answer is the three-word sentence "I am hungry". This version asks for three words that end in "gry", not three words each of which ends in "gry".
- I know two words that end in "gry". Neither one is angry or hungry. What are they?[3][25]
- The answer is "angry" and "hungry". Since these are words, they are not capable of being angry or hungry.
- Give me three English words, commonly spoken, ending in g-r-y.[3][25]
- There are many possible answers, such as "Beg for mercy", or "Bring your money".
- There are three words in the English language that end g-r-y. One is angry and another is hungry. The third word is something that "everyone" uses. If you have listened carefully, I have already told you what it is.[3]
- The answer is "every". First word is "fuming" which ends with "g". The word "fuming" is angry (when personified). Second word is "eager" which ends with "r". The word "eager" is hungry (when personified). Third word is "every" which ends with "y". The word "everyone" uses the word "every".
Meta-puzzle versions
[edit]The remaining versions are a form of meta-puzzle, in the sense that they make no use of the actual letters "gry" themselves, which therefore are a red herring. The red herring only works because there is another puzzle that does use these letters (even though that puzzle has no good answer).
- Think of words ending in "gry". "Angry" and "hungry" are two of them. There are only three words in "the English language". What is the third word? Hint: The word is something that everyone uses every day. If you have listened carefully, I have already told you what it is.[3][26]
- The answer is "language", and the logic is as follows: There are only three words in "the English language"; the third word is "language". Since this version requires quotation marks around the phrase, "the English language", the written version gives away the trick.
- Angry and hungry are two words in the English language that end in "gry". "What" is the third word. The word is something that everyone uses every day. If you have listened carefully, I have already told you what it is.[3][22]
- The answer is "what". But again, the quotation marks spoil the puzzle when it is printed.
- There are three words in the English language that end with "gry". Two of these are "angry" and "hungry". The third word is a very common word, and you use it often. If you have read what I have told you, you will see that I have given you the third word. What is the third word? Think very carefully.[3][27]
- The answer is "three", the third word in the paragraph. The rest of the paragraph is a red herring.
- There are three words in the English language that end in "gry". The first "one" is "hungry", the second "one" is "angry", what is the third "one"? If you have read this carefully I have given a clue.[3][28]
- The answer is the word "one", which is the third "one". Again the quotation marks ruin the written puzzle, so this version is usually written without the quotation marks and with the word "one" capitalized.
Similar puzzles
[edit]There are numerous similar puzzles, giving letter sequences that rarely occur in words.[29] The most-notable of these is the -dous puzzle of finding words ending in -dous, which was popular in the 1880s. This took various forms, sometimes simply listing all words or all common words,[30][31] sometimes being posed as a riddle, giving the three common words, tremendous, stupendous, and hazardous, and requesting the rarer fourth, which is jeopardous. This form originated in 1883, with an A.A. of Glasgow writing to George Augustus Henry Sala in his "Echoes of the Week" column in the Illustrated London News.[32][33] This question has had enduring popularity,[34] even inspiring a contest,[35] though the words have proven less stable: today jeopardous is considered too rare, and the formerly unpopular horrendous has taken its place; this change occurred as early as 1909.[36] At times other words such as hybridous have been accepted.[35] Today hazardous is typically the omitted word, and differs from the others in being a visible compound hazard + -ous. This puzzle has continued in popularity through the end of the 20th century,[37][38] with recent versions giving it as an alternative to the gry puzzle.[39] There is a Russian puzzle which goes: "There are three words in the Russian language which end in -zo. Two of them are zhelezo "iron" and puzo "belly". What is the third word?" There is quite a handful of other nouns that end in -zo, in the Russian language, but most of them are fairly obscure terms like авизо, abbreviations or proper names like Кензо. Another similar one is words ending in -cion, of which the common words are coercion, scion, and suspicion.[30][36]
The most similar to the gry puzzle in form is to find three words that contain the letter sequence shion, to which the answer is cushion, fashion, and parishioner; this is typically stated by giving cushion and fashion, and requesting the third word, namely parishioner.[29][40] This can be modified to finding words ending with -shion, in which case the answer is the obsolete word parishion, which is a synonymous variant of parishioner. This has not been nearly as popular as the gry puzzle.
Solution techniques
[edit]The standard way to solve such puzzles is to use a reverse dictionary, or to perform an exhaustive search through a dictionary, either manually, which is tedious and error-prone, or using computer tools such as grep, which requires an electronic word list. At the origin of the gry puzzle, the standard reverse dictionary in modern English was the "Air Force Reverse Dictionary" (formally the Normal and Reverse Word List, compiled under the direction of A. F. Brown), which did not have additional answers for gry. The most plausible answer at the time was meagry, found in the Oxford English Dictionary.[17] A more elaborate strategy is to list words that have endings similar to gry, such as -gary, and then search a larger dictionary for obsolete variants ending in -gry, for example begry for beggary.[41]
From around 1980 electronic word lists became widely available on Unix systems, and searching for answers to the gry puzzle was an occasional benchmark; this also turned up gryphon in some cases, if match is not required to be at the end.[7] This is now easily done in milliseconds on modern personal computers:
grep gry$ /usr/share/dict/words # Search for words ending in gry
grep gry /usr/share/dict/words # Search for words containing gry
This usually turns up results with prefixes (e.g., overangry, powerhungry) and the aforementioned more obscure words (e.g., aggry and puggry).
References
[edit]- ^ (Uncommon such words include aggry and puggry.) Both Webster's Third New International Dictionary of the English Language, Unabridged (Merriam-Webster, Inc., 2002, ISBN 0-87779-201-1) and the Oxford English Dictionary, Second Edition (Oxford University Press, 1989, ISBN 0-19-861186-2) contain the compound word "aggry bead". To find a third word ending in -gry that is not part of a phrase, you must turn to archaic, obsolete, or uncommon words, or personal or place names.
- ^ Collins English Dictionary contains aggry as a standalone word. The only -gry words playable in Scrabble are aggry, ahungry, angry, hungry and puggry.
- ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m Cole, Chris (1999). Wordplay, A Curious Dictionary of Language Oddities. Sterling Publishing Co., Inc. pp. 96–100. ISBN 0-8069-1797-0.
- ^ Daly, Matthew. "Usenet rec.puzzles Frequently Asked Questions". nugry (noo-gree or nyu-gree) n. 1. A newcomer who fails to follow established rules or procedures. 2. One who shows his inexperience by acting inappropriately. 3. One who posts the -GRY puzzle to rec.puzzles, in violation of the FAQ. Archived from the original on 26 March 2007. Retrieved 2007-04-22.
- ^ Fundis, Lois. "STUMPER-L Reference Librarian Listserver archives October 1999 (#1042)". "Gry is a fightin' word to some of us by now; others will take your question as a reminder to change the oil in their cars (every three months).".
- ^ Safire, William (27 July 1980). "On Language: Ending with "gry"". The New York Times Magazine: 8–10., reprinted in Safire, William (1982). What's the Good Word?. pp. p. 63–64, 'ending with "gry"'.
- ^ a b USENIX Association, Software Tools User Group, Summer Conference Proceedings. Vol. 2. 1983. p. 343. One test was to find words containing the letter sequence "gry". The "grep gry /usr/dict/words" ran significantly faster on the Concept than on the VAX (the words found were angry, hungry, and gryphon).
- ^ Beard, Robert. "The Third English Word Ending on "gry"". facstaff.bucknell.edu. Archived from the original on June 6, 2017., quotes a Rush Elkins who heard it in 1969 or 1970 at the University of Florida, in which case appearing anywhere in the word was ok, and later realized that it was gryphon.
- ^ "gry words". Newsgroup: rec.puzzles. October 1, 1995.
- ^ Salis, Amanda (July 20, 2015). "The science of 'hangry:' Why some people get grumpy when they're hungry". CNN. Retrieved 27 May 2016.
- ^ "English Dictionary, Thesaurus, & Grammar Help | Lexico.com". Lexico Dictionaries | English. Archived from the original on 1998-12-06. Retrieved 2020-04-19.
- ^ "Oxford Dictionaries Adds 'Fat-Shame,' 'Butthurt' and 'Redditor'". Time.
- ^ Compton, Lindsey (August 27, 2015). "'Wine o'clock,' 'cat cafe,' 'hangry' added to Oxford dictionary". chicagotribune.com.
- ^ "New words notes January 2018". Oxford English Dictionary. January 25, 2018.
- ^ "World Wide Words: I Spy Gry!". World Wide Words. October 26, 1996.
- ^ Chris Cole (2012). "The Origin of the -Gry Problem". Word Ways. 34 (1).
- ^ a b Beaman 1976, "A Philadelphia Story", pp. 43–44.
- ^ Stumpers-L, Good Gry-f! How many words end in -gry?, by Glenn Kersten, December 1999: "Fortunately, the popularity of the -gry puzzle has lessened since the boom era of 1995-1996, but SLS Reference Service still receives the question from time to time. Since the same question was a fad in 1978 (see our articles in the November and December 1978 issues of Points of Reference), it looks as though reference librarians should prepare for a 17-year cycle. Hmmm, remind you of anything? The next plague should hit reference desks in the year 2012."
- ^ Stumpers-L, C V [Connie] (22 Oct 1999 20:55:23 -0500 (CDT).). "gry and other short subjects", quoted at Lois Aleta Fundis (November 29, 2006). "Words that end in -gry". lfundisriversnorth. Archived from the original on 2010-07-17.
- ^ Stumpers-L, Good Gry-f! How many words end in -gry?, by Glenn Kersten, December 1999: "One enterprising reference librarian found an eight-page pamphlet (no copyright date, but from the appearance probably printed in the 1940s) entitled Things to Think About. The booklet was filled with riddles, including the following: [quote: "There are three words ..."]
- ^ "ANSWER TO THE...GRY PUZZLE?". Newsgroup: rec.puzzles. Retrieved June 12, 2012.
- ^ a b "a very difficult riddle". Newsgroup: rec.puzzles. Retrieved June 12, 2012.
- ^ Marilyn vos Savant (March 9, 1997). "Ask Marilyn". Parade magazine.
- ^ "Chandeliegry Puzzle". Newsgroup: rec.puzzles. Retrieved June 12, 2012.
- ^ a b "The -Gry Puzzle". The Contest Center.
- ^ "The Elvis Duran Morning Show". WHTZ (New York City). 1996-03-28.
- ^ "What is the third word?". Newsgroup: alt.english.usage. May 6, 1996.
- ^ "Sorry-off topic, BUT do you know the answer?". Newsgroup: alt.personals. Aug 8, 1996.
- ^ a b The Word Circus: A Letter-perfect Book, by Richard Lederer, Dave Morice, 1998, p. 259
- ^ a b Notes and Queries, Vol. VI, No. 10, 1889, October, p. 365
- ^ The Brooklyn Magazine, Volumes II, Number 2, 1885, May, p. 85
- ^ Collected in Echoes of the year Eighteen Hundred and Eighty-Three,p. 337
- ^ See credit of Sala in Tidbits, 1884 February 2, p. 246; reprint: p. 327
- ^ Graphite, 1909 March, "'Dous' Sequel", p. 1076
- ^ a b The Spatula, Volume 2, 1895, p. 360
- ^ a b Editor and Publisher, Volume 9, 1909, p. 89
- ^ The Game of Words, Willard Epsy, 1971
- ^ Beaman 1976, "Kickshaws: An Earlier Kickshaw", p. 40.
- ^ The Word Circus: A Letter-perfect Book, by Richard Lederer, Dave Morice, 1998, p. 229
- ^ Weeds in the Garden of Words: Further Observations on the Tangled History of the English Language, Kate Burridge, 2005, p. 82, p. 184
- ^ Scheetz 1989, p. 198–199.
- Beaman, Ralph G. (February 1976). "Kickshaws". Word Ways. 9 (1).
Further reading
[edit]- Eckler, A. Ross. "-Gry Words in the OED". Word Ways, 25:4 (November 1992): 253–54.
- Francis, Darryl. "Some New -Gry Words". Word Ways, 30:3 (August 1997).
- Partridge, Harry B. "Gypsy Hobby Gry". Word Ways, 23:1 (February 1990): 9–11. A response to Scheetz's article, "In Goodly Gree", q.v.
- Pearce, Murray R. "Who's Flaithbhertach MacLoingry?" Word Ways, 23:1 (February 1990): 6–8. A response to Scheetz's article, "In Goodly Gree", q.v.
- Scheetz, George H. "Colloquy". Word Ways, 10 (August 1977): 152. Scheetz expands on Beaman, q.v.
- Scheetz, George H. (November 1989). "In Goodly Gree: With Goodwill". Word Ways. 22 (4): 195–204. The first comprehensive historical overview of the -gry puzzle, including a list of 51 words ending in -gry. Scheetz was invited to write this article by A. Ross Eckler, editor of Word Ways.
External links
[edit]- Merriam-Webster: What is the third common "-gry" word?
- rec.puzzles Frequently Asked Questions: 2.2. What are the three common English words that end in -GRY?
-gry puzzle
View on GrokipediaThe Puzzle
Standard Formulation
The standard formulation of the -gry puzzle presents a riddle challenging solvers to identify a third English word ending in the suffix "-gry" (pronounced /ɡri/), given that "angry" and "hungry" are two such words.[6] The core phrasing typically reads: "There are only three words in the English language that end in '-gry': angry and hungry are two of them. What is the third word?"[5] This setup relies on English orthography, where the suffix is spelled identically across the examples, and phonetics, as solvers anticipate a common lexical item matching the pattern without delving into obscure or archaic terms. The puzzle's structure encourages a straightforward search within everyday vocabulary, implying the third word is equally familiar and adjective-like in usage.[6] Its first documented appearance in print occurred in a "Problem Line" column in Newsday on April 27, 1975, where a reader inquired: "Q. On a TV quiz program, it was mentioned that there are three words in the English language that end in the letters 'gry.' It's driving me batty that I can only think of two of the words—angry and hungry. What is the third word? M.Z., Wantagh."[7] This version attributes the riddle to a New York City television quiz show earlier that year, marking its transition from oral to written dissemination.Common Interpretations
Solvers of the -gry puzzle commonly assume the existence of a third everyday English word ending in -gry, in addition to "angry" and "hungry," driven by the riddle's assertion that such a word must exist within the language. This expectation prompts many to consult dictionaries, thesauruses, and word lists in a quest for the missing term, often cycling through obscure or archaic entries that fail to align with the puzzle's implication of commonality. The resulting frustration arises from the puzzle's apparent incompleteness, as standard references confirm only two prevalent words fitting the description, leaving searchers without resolution.[1][5] This leads to varied interpretations of the puzzle as a deliberate trick question intended to confound through misdirection, a linguistic curiosity probing the boundaries of English etymology, or a vocabulary test challenging one's recall of rare terms. The sense of unsolvability intensifies because the phrasing creates a false premise—no third common word materializes despite exhaustive efforts—turning what seems like a straightforward query into an enduring mental challenge. Early documented reactions, such as a March 17, 1975, letter to Merriam-Webster from Patricia Lasker of Brooklyn, NY, a quiz show participant seeking the elusive word, highlight this interpretive struggle and the puzzle's capacity to captivate without immediate payoff.[7] Psychologically, the puzzle derives its appeal from inducing cognitive dissonance, where the conviction that a logical third word exists clashes with the absence of evidence, compelling solvers to persist in dictionary dives or creative word associations in an attempt to reconcile the discrepancy. Studies on riddle-solving reveal that such puzzles exploit ingrained mental models, fostering frustration through repeated dead ends and overanalysis, yet this tension often heightens engagement by mimicking real cognitive conflicts. For example, listener responses on Bob Grant's 1975 radio program echoed this dynamic, with callers expressing exasperation after fruitless searches for the supposed word, underscoring the puzzle's draw through unresolved intellectual tension.[8][7]History
Early Reports
The earliest reports of the -gry puzzle appear in oral traditions, with anecdotes suggesting circulation as folklore prior to its documented appearances, though no confirmed printed evidence exists before 1975.[9] One unverified account traces a version to a radio quiz show in 1965, where the question sought three English words containing the sequence "G-R-Y," such as angry, hungry, and gryphon.[5] These pre-1975 stories, including claims of origins in a "lost book" of puzzles or World War II military folklore, remain anecdotal and lack substantiation from primary sources.[7] Scholars suggest the puzzle may have folk origins as a variant of older wordplay riddles, possibly corrupted over time through oral transmission, but extensive searches yield no verifiable print records from the 1940s or earlier, such as references in riddle books from that decade.[9] The absence of early documentation points to its evolution as an informal brainteaser shared verbally among groups like educators or entertainers. The shift to documented form occurred in 1975 in New York, marking the puzzle's transition from oral anecdote to written record. On March 17, 1975, Patricia Lasker of Brooklyn wrote to Merriam-Webster inquiring about a quiz show question: "There are three words that end in ‘gry’, one is angry, the other is hungry. Please tell me the third word."[7] Shortly after, on April 27, 1975, Newsday's "Problem Line" column by Anita Richterman addressed a similar query from a reader frustrated by the same quiz show riddle, highlighting its growing local buzz.[7] These accounts, likely stemming from a New York City television or radio broadcast, represent the first reliable sightings, preceding broader popularization.[9]Popularization
The -gry puzzle first appeared in print on May 9, 1975, in Anita Richterman's "Problem Line" column in Newsday, a Long Island newspaper, where readers submitted proposed solutions such as "puggry," "aggry," and "gry," generating immediate local interest and discussion.[7] That same year, the puzzle gained broader traction through its broadcast on Bob Grant's talk radio show on WMCA in New York City, sparking a frenzy of caller submissions and propelling it to national attention as listeners across the Northeast shared and debated it.[9][7] Subsequent revivals in print media sustained its momentum, including a feature in the Fall 1975 issue of RQ, the journal of the American Library Association, where librarians reported frequent public queries at reference desks.[7] By 1978, the puzzle had reemerged in various newspaper columns, followed by prominent exposures such as William Safire's "On Language" column in The New York Times Magazine on July 27, 1980, and Jack Mabley's piece in the Chicago Tribune on April 17, 1981, which amplified its reach through syndication.[10][7] In the mid-1990s, proto-internet discussions began appearing on Usenet newsgroups like rec.puzzles and alt.usage.english, marking an early shift to digital dissemination.[11] The puzzle's spread was driven by word-of-mouth in schools and offices during the late 1970s, its inclusion in riddle anthologies that popularized brain teasers, and the rise of email chains in the 1990s that circulated variations among early internet users.[7] Peak interest in the 1970s and 1980s manifested in thousands of reported submissions to media outlets and advice columns, highlighting ongoing public fascination.Proposed Solutions
Trick-Based Answers
One prominent trick-based resolution to the -gry puzzle posits that the third word is "language," derived from a specific phrasing of the riddle: "There are three words in the English language..." In this interpretation, "language" is the third word in the phrase "the English language," exploiting the puzzle's self-referential structure to create misdirection rather than identifying a genuine -gry-ending word.[9] This trick relies on punctuation and phrasing ambiguity, as the written form often includes quotes around "the English language" to highlight the deception, making it evident upon close reading but effective in oral transmission.[4] Another common misdirection involves "agree," stemming from a phonetic variant of the puzzle where the riddle concludes with "...and if you've listened closely, you'll agree that I've already told you the third one." Here, "agree" ends in the sound "a-gree," mimicking "-gry" through homophonic play, but it does not actually terminate in the letters g-r-y, thus qualifying as a playful hoax rather than a linguistic solution.[4] Similarly, "what" serves as a trick answer in early formulations, positioning it as the third word in the interrogative sentence structure of the riddle itself, again prioritizing verbal sleight-of-hand over etymological accuracy.[9] Additional misdirections include proposing "gry" as the word itself, treating the suffix as a standalone entity, or inventing non-standard terms like "skulldugry" (a corruption of "skullduggery") and "augry" (from "augury"), which bend or fabricate usage to fit the pattern without adhering to common English nouns or adjectives.[12] These tricks succeed by capitalizing on the puzzle's vague premises—such as the erroneous claim of only three -gry words—encouraging solvers to overlook the absence of legitimate morphology in favor of humorous wordplay.[13] Historically, the "language" trick gained traction shortly after the puzzle's debut on Bob Grant's WMCA radio talk show in New York City in 1975, where listener responses frequently invoked it as a clever resolution during on-air discussions.[9] Its appeal persisted into print, appearing in joke collections and wordplay anthologies throughout the late 20th century, often as a staple of riddle books to illustrate misdirection in language games.[12]Linguistic Candidates
One linguistic approach to resolving the -gry puzzle involves identifying rare or archaic English words that genuinely end in the suffix "-gry," beyond the obvious "angry" and "hungry." These candidates, while verifiable in historical lexicons, are typically obsolete or highly specialized, failing to qualify as the "common" third word implied by the riddle's phrasing.[1] Among verified examples is "aggry," an obsolete term referring to a type of variegated glass bead of ancient manufacture, primarily associated with West African artifacts found in regions like Ashanti and Fante. The Oxford English Dictionary (OED) records its usage from the late 17th to 19th centuries, with the earliest citation in 1683 describing such beads as ornamental items.[14] Similarly, "puggry" (or variant "pugree") denotes a light scarf or cloth strip wound around a hat or helmet for sun protection, derived from Hindi and used in colonial contexts; the OED attests it from 1893 onward, though it remains archaic in modern English. Another rare entry is "gry," a nonce unit of measurement in typography equivalent to 1/7200 inch (approximately 0.003528 mm or 0.01 point), proposed in 1998 by type designer Hermann Zapf from the Greek γρῦ (grû, “a trifle”) to denote minuscule linear distances in typesetting. This term appears sporadically in specialized printing literature but lacks widespread adoption.[15] A more historically prominent candidate is "gry," an obsolete unit of length proposed by philosopher John Locke in his 1690 Essay Concerning Human Understanding, defined as approximately 1/10,000 inch (the width of a child's hair or a "trifle"), later revived in 19th-century decimal schemes but never commonly used.[13] Proposed archaic terms like "shalmgry" have surfaced in puzzle discussions as potential solutions, but no credible dictionary entry confirms its existence, suggesting it as a misinterpretation or fabrication. Likewise, "gryphon" (a mythical creature) is often miscited due to phonetic similarity, though it orthographically ends in "-phon," not "-gry," as clarified by etymological sources tracing the word to Greek "gryps" (hooked or curved).[16] These words fail as puzzle solutions because of their extreme rarity and absence from everyday vocabulary; for instance, the OED catalogs only a handful of -gry endings overall, most obsolete or compounds like "land-hungry," while Merriam-Webster explicitly states that "angry" and "hungry" are the sole common examples, with no third standard word in contemporary usage.[17][1] Their low frequency—often limited to historical or niche contexts—contrasts sharply with the puzzle's expectation of a familiar term akin to "angry" or "hungry."Variations
Meta-Puzzle Forms
Meta-puzzle forms of the -gry puzzle shift the focus from identifying an actual English word ending in -gry to exploiting the riddle's own phrasing and structure for a self-referential solution. In one classic variant, the puzzle is worded as: "There are three words in the English language that end in -gry. One is angry and the other is hungry. What is the third word?" The answer points to "language" as the third word in the introductory phrase "the English language," emphasizing everyday usage without relying on the suffix -gry itself.[13] Another common self-referential twist proposes "gry" as the third word, interpreting it as the suffix or an archaic term (such as John Locke's 1690 usage for a unit of length), thereby commenting on the puzzle's linguistic premise.[5][13] Additional variants highlight structural elements of the riddle. For instance, some formulations suggest the third word is "three," referring to the opening words "there are three," which cleverly loops back to the puzzle's claim of exactly three such words. Similarly, a version emphasizing "one" in repeated phrasing (e.g., "one is angry and the other one is hungry") leads to "agree" as the answer, playing on the homophone "a gree" to mimic -gry. These forms avoid literal word searches, instead revealing the riddle's wording as the key to resolution.[5] These meta-puzzle iterations emerged in the 1980s within print collections of riddles and brain teasers, evolving from the original 1975 formulation into more playful, structure-focused challenges. They gained widespread popularity in the 1990s through email forwards and online discussions, where participants debated and shared variations that questioned the puzzle's premise.[5][13] The appeal of these self-referential forms lies in their transformation of the -gry puzzle into a meta-commentary on language riddles, exposing how misdirection and phrasing can create illusory problems. By revealing the setup as the solution, they encourage reflection on the nature of wordplay, distinguishing them from trick-based answers that merely evade the question.[5][13]Modern Adaptations
In the digital era since the 2010s, the -gry puzzle has persisted through online linguistic communities, where participants rephrase the riddle to engage younger audiences, often referencing modern portmanteaus like "hangry"—a blend of "hungry" and "angry" denoting irritability from hunger—sometimes proposed as a third -gry word, though the puzzle's traditional hoax relies on no such common suffix-ending term existing prior to its origin.[18] These adaptations highlight the puzzle's enduring appeal as a trick question, with discussions frequently clarifying its intentional ambiguity rather than seeking obscure lexical solutions. The puzzle has found cultural footing in audio media, notably on public radio and podcasts dedicated to language curiosities, such as "A Way with Words," where episodes dissect the riddle's structure, trace its variations, and explain why no third common word exists beyond "angry" and "hungry."[19] Such features underscore its role in broader explorations of English wordplay, adapting the classic format for listeners interested in etymology and riddle mechanics. During the 2020s, attention has continued in scholarly and enthusiast forums, driven by archival inquiries into the puzzle's origins and evolutions, though without introducing novel solutions; instead, these conversations emphasize historical debunking and the riddle's status as a linguistic red herring. As of 2025, discussions maintain the enigma's relevance without resolving its core tease.[18] This reflects a broader fascination with viral word puzzles in online academic exchanges.Linguistic Analysis
English Words in -gry
In English, the orthographic sequence "-gry" appears at the end of a small number of words, with "angry" and "hungry" being the most prevalent in modern usage. These adjectives describe emotional states of irritation or desire for food, respectively, and are integral to everyday vocabulary. Other attested words include "aggry," referring to a type of variegated glass bead historically traded in West Africa, particularly in regions like Ghana. "Puggry" (also spelled "pugree" or "puggaree") denotes a light scarf or cloth band wrapped around a hat or helmet, often for sun protection, as seen in colonial-era headwear like pith helmets.[20] The term "gry" functions as an obsolete unit of length, equivalent to 1/120 of an inch or 1/10 of a line, primarily in historical printing and measurement contexts. A modern slang example is "hangry," a portmanteau of "hungry" and "angry," meaning bad-tempered or irritable due to hunger.[2] Compound or derived terms like "ahungry," "anhungry," or "power-hungry" incorporate "-gry" but are extensions of base words rather than independent lexical items. These rarer words appear in specialized historical, technical, or regional contexts: "aggry" emerged in 17th-century trade descriptions, while "puggry" gained prominence in 19th-century British colonial attire, and "gry" dates to pre-metric measurement systems from the 18th century onward.[14] Corpus linguistics data from the Google Books Ngram Viewer illustrates the dominance of "angry" and "hungry," which show steady or increasing frequencies from the 1800s to the present, reflecting their core role in English prose. In contrast, "aggry" and "puggry" exhibit low peaks in the 19th century before declining to near-zero post-1900, aligning with their niche historical applications, while "gry" remains negligible throughout, underscoring its obsolescence. It is important to distinguish words spelled with "-gry" from those sharing the phonetic ending /ɡri/ or /dʒri/, such as "energy" or "allergy," which end in "-gy" and are thus orthographically distinct despite similar pronunciation in some dialects. This spelling-specific focus highlights the lexical rarity of true "-gry" endings in standard English.Etymology and Rarity
The ending "-gry" in English words is not a productive suffix but appears in a limited number of terms derived from ancient Germanic roots or later borrowings. In "angry," it stems from Middle English angri, formed by adding the adjectival suffix -y to anger, itself borrowed from Old Norse angr meaning "grief" or "sorrow," reflecting a historical association of anger with emotional distress.[21] Similarly, "hungry" originates from Old English hungrig, a compound of hungor ("hunger") and the suffix -ig, akin to Proto-Germanic hungraz, denoting a state of deprivation without implying a dedicated "-gry" morpheme.[22] Later instances of "-gry" entered English through colonial encounters. The term "aggry," referring to ancient variegated glass beads traded in West Africa, first appears in English records around 1683, likely borrowed from an indigenous African language during early European trade expeditions in the 1700s, though its precise origin remains uncertain.[14] In the 1800s, "puggry" (also spelled "puggree"), denoting a cloth strip wound around a hat for sun protection, was adopted from Hindi pagṛī ("turban") amid British colonial expansion in India.[23] The rarity of "-gry" in English stems from the language's morphological preferences, which favor suffixes like -ry (as in "entry" or "country") or -ery (as in "bakery") for forming nouns and adjectives, rather than the non-productive "-gry" sequence limited to a handful of legacy words.[24] Phonologically, the cluster /ɡri/ is uncommon at the end of native adjectives and nouns, possibly due to historical sound shifts in Germanic languages that reduced such endings in favor of more fluid terminations. Usage of "-gry" words has declined since the Industrial Revolution, with most surviving as archaic, regional, or specialized terms and no documented new coinages in standard English, underscoring the ending's obsolescence in contemporary word formation.[25]Similar Puzzles
Other Word-Ending Riddles
One notable example of a word-ending riddle similar to the -gry puzzle is the "-dous" conundrum, which was popularized in the 20th century, as discussed in a 1990 column referencing a puzzle posed by Isaac Asimov.[26] This riddle typically challenges solvers to name two words ending in "-dous" besides "tremendous" and "stupendous," with the expected answers being "hazardous" and "horrendous"—the only four common English words featuring this rare suffix. Lists of rarer terms like "apodous" (lacking feet) and "cephalodous" (having a head) appeared in late 19th-century publications, such as the 1889 "Bizarre Notes and Queries," highlighting interest in exploring English's limited vocabulary for certain endings.[27] Another variant involves riddles phrased around words ending in "-ix," such as "What ends in 'ix'?" Solvers often propose words like "phoenix," but trick responses exploit misdirection through orthographic surprises. This format mirrors the -gry puzzle's emphasis on phonetic or orthographic surprises, though it lacks a singular definitive solution and appears in modern wordplay collections rather than historical records. In the 19th century, newspapers frequently published riddles centered on rare suffixes to test readers' lexical knowledge, often contrasting scarcity in endings like "-dous" with the abundance of "-tion" derivatives (e.g., over 1,000 nouns such as "action" and "invention"). These puzzles, appearing in outlets like American periodicals, relied on English's irregular morphology—borrowed from Latin and Greek—to create misdirection and delight through unexpected scarcity or commonality.[27] The shared mechanism across such riddles involves leveraging the language's uneven word formation, where solvers anticipate patterns that prove elusive or deceptive.Broader Brain Teasers
The -gry puzzle exemplifies lateral thinking puzzles, a category popularized by Edward de Bono in the 1960s and expanded through collections of situation-based riddles that rely on misdirection to reveal counterintuitive solutions. For instance, the "man in the elevator" riddle describes a dwarf who takes the elevator to the tenth floor but walks up stairs on rainy days, with the key being his use of an umbrella to reach higher buttons when carrying it.[28] Similarly, the "albatross soup" puzzle involves a man who orders the dish, tastes it, and then suicides, resolved by the revelation that shipwreck survivors had eaten his wife, mistaking albatross for human flesh.[29] The -gry puzzle functions analogously as an unresolved lateral challenge, prompting solvers to question assumptions about language patterns without providing closure, thereby honing creative reinterpretation skills. It also aligns with hoax riddles, which spread virally through misdirection and apparent paradoxes, much like the "missing dollar" urban legend. In this classic, three guests pay $30 for a room, the clerk refunds $5 (keeping $25), the bellboy pockets $2 and returns $3, leading to the false equation of $27 (room plus tip) plus $2 stolen equaling $29—where is the dollar? The hoax lies in the irrelevant addition; the total is simply $25 to the hotel plus $5 returned, with no missing amount.[30] Like these enduring tales, the -gry puzzle thrives on its ambiguous, unsolvable allure, circulating online and in print since the 1970s to captivate audiences with linguistic trickery rather than logical resolution. From a cognitive science perspective, puzzles like -gry test pattern recognition and frustration tolerance, engaging processes central to insight problem-solving. Studies in the 1990s, such as Baumeister et al. (1998), demonstrated that effortful tasks like persisting on unsolvable puzzles can deplete self-regulatory resources (ego depletion), reducing performance on subsequent tasks, as solvers grapple with blocked progress before potential "aha" moments.[31] Neuroimaging research shows that riddle-solving activates prefrontal cortex regions for detecting linguistic anomalies, fostering adaptive thinking amid uncertainty, though the -gry's lack of resolution amplifies emotional strain without reward.[32] In the 2010s, the -gry puzzle's essence echoes in modern brain teaser apps and interactive formats, such as "Who is? Brain Teaser & Riddles," which presents visual-linguistic conundrums requiring lateral leaps, and escape rooms that integrate wordplay riddles into immersive narratives.[33] These physical or digital experiences, booming since around 2012 in the West, use misdirection-heavy clues—like cryptic phrases unlocking mechanisms—to build team-based frustration and euphoria, mirroring the -gry's viral, shareable challenge.[34]References
- https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/puggry
