Hubbry Logo
Brandon CarterBrandon CarterMain
Open search
Brandon Carter
Community hub
Brandon Carter
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Brandon Carter
Brandon Carter
Brandon Carter
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Brandon Carter, FRS (born 1942) is an Australian theoretical physicist who explores the properties of black holes, and was the first to name and employ the anthropic principle in its contemporary form. He is a researcher at the Meudon campus of the Laboratoire Univers et Théories, part of the French CNRS.

Key Information

Biography

[edit]

Carter studied at the University of Cambridge under Dennis Sciama. He found the exact solution of the geodesic equations for the Kerr/Newman electrovacuum solution, and the maximal analytic extension of this solution. In the process, he discovered the extraordinary fourth constant of motion and the Killing–Yano tensor. Together with Werner Israel and Stephen Hawking, he proved partially the no-hair theorem in general relativity, stating that all stationary black holes are completely characterized by mass, charge, and angular momentum. In 1982 with astrophysicist Jean-Pierre Luminet, he invented the concept of tidal disruption event (TDE), namely the destruction of a star passing in the vicinity of a supermassive black hole. They showed that this phenomenon could result in the violent destruction of the star in the form of a "stellar pancake", causing a reactivation of nuclear reactions in the core of the star in the stage of its maximum compression.

More recently, Carter, Chachoua, and Chamel (2005) have formulated a relativistic theory of elastic deformations in neutron stars.[1]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Brandon Carter

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Brandon Carter (born 1942 in , ) is an Australian theoretical physicist renowned for his foundational contributions to , physics, and cosmology, including the discovery of the Carter constant in the and the formulation of the . His work has profoundly influenced understandings of uniqueness, equilibrium states, and the role of observers in cosmological reasoning. Carter's research emphasizes the mathematical structures underlying gravitational phenomena, bridging classical and relativistic theories. Educated initially at the (1959–1961) and then at the , where he completed the Mathematics Tripos (1961–1964) and earned his PhD under Dennis Sciama in 1968, Carter began his career with postdoctoral positions at (1968) and the (1970). He served as a at (1973–1975) before joining the CNRS in in 1975, advancing to Directeur de Recherches at the Observatoire de Paris-Meudon (1987–2003) and holding senior positions until emeritus status in 2009. Throughout his career, Carter collaborated with leading figures such as and Werner Israel, contributing to advancements in relativistic during visiting roles at institutions including the (1987). Carter's seminal 1968 paper on the global structure of the Kerr family of gravitational fields introduced the separable structure of geodesic equations in spacetimes, revealing the Carter constant as a hidden symmetry that enables exact solutions for particle orbits. In 1971, he proved that axisymmetric black holes possess only two independent parameters—mass and —providing a key pillar of the , which asserts that stationary black holes are fully characterized without additional "hair" or quantum numbers. His 1974 formulation of the distinguished weak and strong versions, arguing that the universe's fundamental constants must permit the existence of observers like humanity, influencing debates in cosmology and fine-tuning. Elected a in 1981, Carter's prolific output of over 170 publications continues to shape research on topics from cosmic strings to interiors.

Early Life and Education

Birth and Early Years

Brandon Carter was born on 26 May 1942 near , , , establishing his Australian nationality. He spent his early childhood in the Sydney area, attending primary school at Castle Hill from 1948 to 1954. At the age of 12, Carter relocated to , near , , where he attended George Watson’s College for high school from 1954 to 1959, marking a significant transition in his formative years before pursuing higher education in physics.

Academic Training

Brandon Carter began his undergraduate studies in (physics) at the in from 1959 to 1961, under professors Jack Allen in physics and Edward Copson in mathematics. He then transferred to Pembroke College at the , where he completed his undergraduate degree through the from 1961 to 1964, focusing on and . Carter continued at Cambridge as a research student in the Department of and (DAMTP) from 1964 to 1967, earning his PhD in 1967. His doctoral thesis, titled Stationary Axisymmetric Systems in , explored space-time manifolds, horizons, causality, isometry groups, and separable solutions to Einstein's equations, laying foundational work in . Under the supervision of Dennis Sciama, Carter developed a rigorous approach to , emphasizing geometric and analytic properties of space-times. Sciama's guidance, along with influences from , shaped Carter's expertise in theory and exact solutions, drawing from his earlier curiosities about astrophysical phenomena.

Professional Career

Initial Appointments

Following the completion of his PhD at the in 1968 under the supervision of Dennis Sciama, Brandon Carter began his professional career with concurrent appointments as a at Pembroke College and a at the Institute of Astronomy from 1968 to 1972. These positions facilitated his early collaborations with leading figures in relativity, including and , contributing to foundational studies on properties during the late 1960s. In 1970, he briefly served as a Visiting at the Enrico Fermi Institute of the , broadening his exposure to interdisciplinary . By 1973, Carter advanced to a Lectureship in the Department of Applied Mathematics and Theoretical Physics (DAMTP) at Cambridge, a role he maintained until 1975. This period solidified his reputation in the UK theoretical physics community through targeted work on gravitational theories and compact objects.

Long-Term Affiliation with CNRS

Brandon Carter joined the French National Centre for Scientific Research (CNRS) in 1975 as a Maître de Recherches at the Groupe d'Astrophysique Relativiste, Département d'Astrophysique Fondamentale, located at the Meudon Observatory's Observatoire de Paris. He held this position until 1986. This appointment marked the beginning of his extended tenure within the institution, which emphasized theoretical work in astrophysics and general relativity. Over the subsequent decades, his role progressed through various senior positions, reflecting his growing influence and contributions to the field. From 1987 to 2001, Carter served as Directeur de Recherches in the Département d' Relativiste et de Cosmologie. In 1987, he also held a position at the Institute for Theoretical Physics, . He advanced to Directeur de Recherches de classe exceptionnelle from 2004 to 2008. In 2002, he transitioned to the Laboratoire de l'Univers Théorique (LuTh), where he continued as Directeur de Recherches until assuming status in 2009. His CNRS affiliation, spanning over three decades from 1975 onward, remains active in an capacity as of 2025, allowing sustained involvement in theoretical research. These positions entailed supervisory responsibilities, including mentoring junior researchers and contributing to the laboratory's direction in relativistic . The Meudon Observatory's LuTh provided Carter with a vibrant collaborative environment, centered on and compact objects, where he engaged with leading French astrophysicists such as Thibault Damour, whose overlapping tenure at the observatory from 1977 to 1994 contributed to the research setting. This setting offered access to specialized computational resources and theoretical frameworks essential for advancing relativity-based studies, fostering interdisciplinary interactions within CNRS's broader network of expertise.

Scientific Contributions

Advances in Black Hole Theory

Brandon Carter made seminal contributions to black hole theory in the late 1960s and early 1970s, focusing on the geometric and dynamical properties of rotating and charged spacetimes described by the Kerr and Kerr-Newman metrics. In his 1968 paper, Carter analyzed the global structure of the Kerr family of solutions, which encompasses both the vacuum and the charged Kerr-Newman metric. He demonstrated that these spacetimes admit a high degree of integrability for motion, arising from the existence of four independent constants of motion. This integrability allows the to be solved explicitly via quadratures, revealing the complete structure of particle trajectories around these s. Central to this analysis was Carter's discovery of an additional conserved quantity, now known as the Carter constant, which supplements the energy EE, the azimuthal angular momentum LzL_z, and the rest mass mm for timelike geodesics (or the null condition for photons). The Carter constant QQ emerges from the separability of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation in Boyer-Lindquist coordinates for the Kerr metric. The Hamilton-Jacobi equation for a test particle is given by 12gμνpμpν=−12m2,\frac{1}{2} g^{\mu\nu} p_\mu p_\nu = -\frac{1}{2} m^2, where pμ=∂S/∂xμp_\mu = \partial S / \partial x^\mu are the canonical momenta derived from the action SS. Assuming separability S=St(t)+Sr(r)+Sθ(θ)+Sϕ(ϕ)S = S_t(t) + S_r(r) + S_\theta(\theta) + S_\phi(\phi), the equation separates into radial and angular parts. The angular part yields (dSθdθ)2=Q−cos⁡2θ[a2(m2−E2)+Lz2sin⁡2θ],\left( \frac{d S_\theta}{d \theta} \right)^2 = Q - \cos^2 \theta \left[ a^2 (m^2 - E^2) + \frac{L_z^2}{\sin^2 \theta} \right], where aa is the black hole's spin parameter. The separation constant QQ is conserved and takes the explicit form Q=pθ2+a2(m2−E2)cos⁡2θ+Lz2cot⁡2θQ = p_\theta^2 + a^2 (m^2 - E^2) \cos^2 \theta + L_z^2 \cot^2 \theta when expressed in terms of the momenta at a given θ\theta. This form highlights QQ's interpretation as a measure of squared total angular momentum, combining contributions from motion in the θ\theta-direction and the projection orthogonal to the equatorial plane. Carter showed that this constant holds for both Kerr and Kerr-Newman metrics, enabling the full integration of geodesics and underscoring the hidden symmetries in these spacetimes. The separability of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation, and thus the existence of the Carter constant, stems from an underlying Killing-Yano tensor, a skew-symmetric tensor fμνf_{\mu\nu} satisfying ∇λfμν+∇[λfμν]=0\nabla_\lambda f_{\mu\nu} + \nabla_{[\lambda} f_{\mu\nu]} = 0. Carter developed this framework, showing that the square of the Killing-Yano tensor yields a Killing tensor Kμν=fμσfσνK^{\mu\nu} = f^\mu{}_\sigma f^{\sigma\nu}, which generates the quadratic conserved quantity associated with QQ. In the Kerr-Newman spacetime, the principal Killing-Yano tensor is f=dt∧dr+asin⁡2θ(dt−asin⁡2θdϕ)∧dθf = dt \wedge dr + a \sin^2 \theta (dt - a \sin^2 \theta d\phi) \wedge d\theta (up to normalization), ensuring separability not only for geodesics but also for the massive Klein-Gordon, Dirac, and Maxwell equations. This geometric structure explains the complete solvability of wave equations in these backgrounds and has profound implications for black hole stability and perturbation theory. Carter's work also advanced the no-hair theorem, which posits that stationary black holes are uniquely characterized by their mass, charge, and angular momentum. In 1971, he proved that any asymptotically flat, stationary, axisymmetric vacuum black hole exterior must be described by the Kerr metric, establishing uniqueness up to these three parameters. This result built on earlier work by Werner Israel for non-rotating black holes and was complemented by collaborations with Stephen Hawking and David Robinson, who extended uniqueness proofs to include electromagnetic fields (Kerr-Newman) and non-axisymmetric cases. Carter's axisymmetric theorem relies on the rigidity of event horizons and the absence of ergoregions outside the standard solutions, rigorously confirming that no additional "hair" (such as multipole moments beyond the Kerr parameters) can exist. Furthermore, in his 1968 analysis, Carter constructed the maximal analytic extension of the Kerr-Newman solution, revealing its with multiple horizons, an , and infinite chains of asymptotically flat regions connected through the ring singularity. The for this extension features Cauchy horizons and closed timelike curves in inner regions, highlighting potential instabilities but confirming the spacetime's global completeness away from the singularity. This extension provides the foundational framework for understanding violations and the predictability of interiors in .

Formulation of the Anthropic Principle

Brandon Carter first proposed the during a in , , held from 10 to 12 to commemorate the 500th anniversary of Nicolaus Copernicus's birth. Organized by the and chaired by , the event focused on cosmological theories and observational data, where Carter was invited to discuss implications of observer-dependent predictions in cosmology. In his lecture, Carter articulated the principle as a framework to explain why the appears compatible with the existence of observers like humans, reacting against overly stringent interpretations of the that would render such compatibility coincidental. Central to Carter's formulation was the distinction between the weak anthropic principle (WAP) and the strong anthropic principle (SAP). The WAP states that "our location in the Universe is necessarily privileged to the extent of being compatible with our existence as observers," meaning that observed cosmic properties, such as the universe's age aligning with the timescale for biological evolution, must permit the emergence of observers; this serves as a selection effect rather than a fundamental law. In contrast, the SAP asserts that "the Universe (and hence the fundamental parameters on which it depends) must be such as to admit the creation of observers within it at some stage," implying a more prescriptive constraint that the universe's structure is inherently required to support life, potentially through mechanisms like a multiverse ensemble. This dichotomy addressed philosophical tensions between mediocrity (humans as typical observers) and the apparent fine-tuning evident in cosmological observations. Carter connected the to "large number coincidences" in cosmology, such as the rough equality between the Hubble time scale (approximately the inverse of the involving the ) and of the , or the particle density times the scaling similarly to the inverse square of the . These dimensionless ratios, first highlighted by and others, suggested non-trivial relations among fundamental constants like the , electromagnetic , and particle es, which must be finely tuned for stable stars, planetary systems, and ultimately life to form. By applying the WAP, Carter argued that such coincidences are not mere accidents but consequences of the requirement for observer-compatible conditions, supporting conventional cosmology over alternative theories like Dirac's hypothesis of a varying . Philosophically, this shifted discussions from seeking exact numerical predictions to understanding selection biases in what observers can measure, influencing debates on fine-tuning without invoking . Carter's ideas were fully elaborated in his seminal 1974 publication, "Large Number Coincidences and the in Cosmology," which appeared in the proceedings of the symposium. The paper provided a conceptual breakdown, using the principles to derive predictions like the approximate equality of the cosmic expansion rate to the inverse proton lifetime, emphasizing that these arise from the necessity of long-lived structures for observation. It also explored implications for biological , suggesting that the WAP constrains evolutionary timescales to fit within the universe's habitable phase. In later developments, Carter extended anthropic reasoning to the , introduced in his 1983 paper "The and Its Implications for Biological Evolution." This argument posits that, assuming s are randomly sampled from all past and future observers, the current population rank (around the 60 billionth) implies a high probability that the total number of s will not vastly exceed current estimates, suggesting the species' future is limited—potentially by within —due to selection effects in a finite . Philosophically, it underscores the SAP's tension with infinite futures, prompting reflections on humanity's place in cosmic history and the universe's longevity for observers.

Work on Neutron Stars and Elasticity

In the early 1980s, Brandon Carter collaborated with Jean-Pierre Luminet to pioneer the concept of tidal disruption events (TDEs), in which a star venturing too close to a experiences extreme tidal forces that stretch and shred it into a thin, pancake-like structure before fragmenting the material. This process, detailed in their seminal analysis, predicts that the compressed stellar debris can undergo thermonuclear detonation, producing luminous flares observable as bursts of radiation from galactic nuclei. Their model highlighted the relativistic dynamics of such encounters, emphasizing the role of the black hole's tidal radius in determining the star's fate and the subsequent accretion of debris onto the . Shifting focus to compact objects in later decades, Carter advanced the understanding of neutron star interiors through relativistic elasticity theories, particularly addressing the crust's response to gravitational perturbations. In a foundational paper, he established the framework for general relativistic high-pressure elasticity, adapting Hookean models to the extreme conditions of where nonlinear effects dominate due to immense densities. This quasi-Hookean idealization proved essential for modeling elastic deformations in the stellar crust, bridging Newtonian intuitions with full relativistic . Building on this, 2005 collaboration with Elie Chachoua and Nicolas Chamel developed a comprehensive covariant formulation for the dynamics of magneto-elastic solids in neutron star crusts, incorporating both Newtonian and relativistic limits. The theory derives equations governing the energy-momentum tensor for elastic perturbations, including magneto-elastic modes akin to Alfvén waves, and accounts for superfluid interactions within the lattice. This enables precise calculations of tidal deformability, a key parameter measuring how external gravitational fields distort the star's shape. A specific outcome of this elastic framework is the tidal Love number for neutron stars, which quantifies quadrupolar deformations induced by tidal fields from a companion object. The dimensionless Love number k2k_2 relates to the star's compactness C=GMc2RC = \frac{GM}{c^2 R} and dimensionless tidal deformability Λ\Lambda via k2=32C5Λ,k_2 = \frac{3}{2} C^5 \Lambda, where Λ=c10λG5M5\Lambda = \frac{c^{10} \lambda}{G^5 M^5} and λ\lambda is the dimensional tidal deformability; lower k2k_2 values indicate stiffer equations of state resistant to deformation. In the context of Carter's models, this parameter has profound implications for gravitational wave astronomy, as the phase shift in binary neutron star inspirals—observed in events like GW170817—constrains nuclear physics through the induced quadrupole moment, with elastic crust contributions enhancing the overall tidal response. Throughout the 2000s, Carter extended his research to exotic models, including stars, cosmic strings, and dynamics, exploring their roles in astrophysical phenomena. His 2000 overview of classical dynamics provided a geometric foundation for treating cosmic strings as one-dimensional branes and higher-dimensional structures, deriving in curved spacetimes without reliance on gauge-dependent auxiliaries. These models addressed vorton stability and string evolution in the early , while his superfluid frameworks from the same era incorporated multi-fluid effects relevant to trapping and emission in proto- phases.

Recognition and Influence

Awards and Honors

Brandon Carter was invited to present lectures at the Symposium No. 63 in , , in 1973, an event commemorating the 500th anniversary of Nicolaus Copernicus's birth, where he first articulated the . This prestigious invitation underscored his emerging influence in theoretical shortly before the publication of his seminal 1974 paper on large number coincidences and the in cosmology. (Note: The IAU proceedings confirm the symposium details.) In recognition of his foundational contributions to black hole physics and , Carter was elected a (FRS) on March 19, 1981. This honor, one of the highest distinctions in British science, followed a decade of impactful work, including advancements in the understanding of Kerr black hole geodesics and equilibrium configurations. Despite the profound influence of his research on topics such as the —which has shaped discussions in cosmology and —Carter did not receive major accolades like the . This relative gap in high-profile awards reflects the often delayed or selective recognition of theoretical contributions in , even as his ideas continue to inform contemporary debates.

Lasting Impact in Physics

Brandon Carter's foundational contributions to black hole theory, particularly his co-development of the alongside , Werner , and others, have profoundly shaped modern . The theorem posits that stationary s are fully characterized by just three parameters—mass, charge, and angular momentum—implying no other "hair" or distinguishing features. This framework has been empirically validated through and Virgo detections of mergers, where the ringdown phase of matches predictions from the , confirming the absence of additional parameters and supporting the theorem's universality. Carter's rigorous mathematical description of the Kerr 's global structure provided the essential basis for these observations, enabling precise waveform modeling that distinguishes from other compact objects. Extensions of his work appear in analyses of signals, where Carter's conserved quantities and separability properties facilitate efficient numerical simulations of inspirals and mergers. His influence extended to Hawking's research, as Carter collaborated closely on mechanics and the area theorem, which Hawking later built upon in his analogies, fostering a in understanding stability and . In cosmology, Carter's formulation of the in 1974 has sustained influence in post-2000 debates on fine-tuning and theories, serving as a for interpreting why physical constants appear life-permitting. The weak , which he distinguished from stronger variants, argues that observers must inhabit a compatible with their , a concept invoked in landscapes and models to explain apparent coincidences without invoking design. Recent discussions, including proposals for testable predictions in scenarios, continue to reference Carter's framework as a logical constraint on cosmological parameter selection. As of 2025, Carter's ideas remain relevant in pursuits, with his equilibrium states cited in explorations of holographic principles and AdS/CFT correspondence, though direct extensions are more archival than novel. His seminal 1974 anthropic paper has amassed over 500 citations by recent counts, underscoring enduring impact, while works exceed thousands, reflecting their integration into observational like tidal disruption events modeled via Kerr geodesics.

References

  1. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRev.174.1559
  2. https://people-lux.obspm.fr/carter/
  3. https://indico.obspm.fr/event/1346/
  4. https://inspirehep.net/authors/1014398
  5. https://personal.utdallas.edu/~mxv091000/images/royal-society/Fellows1660-2007.pdf
  6. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10714-009-0887-6.pdf
  7. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110810104546391
  8. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10714-009-0887-6
  9. https://people-lux.obspm.fr/carter/Thesis/index.html
  10. https://inspirehep.net/authors/1014398?ui-autocomplete=%7B%22order%22%3A1%2C%22sort%22%3A%22year%22%2C%22pagesize%22%3A25%2C%22from%22%3A%222008%22%7D
  11. https://www.ihes.fr/~damour/CVTDAMOURSept2019.pdf
  12. https://luth.obspm.fr/
  13. http://cosmology.com/Anthropic100.html
  14. https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/1974IAUS...63..291C/abstract
  15. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-94-010-2220-0_25
  16. https://gwern.net/doc/existential-risk/1974-carter.pdf
  17. https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10714-011-1257-8.pdf
  18. https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsta.1983.0096
  19. https://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/15273/1/gigo9e.pdf
  20. https://www.nature.com/articles/296211a0
  21. https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rspa.1972.0164
  22. https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0507006
  23. https://www.templeton.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/01/HAI_Multiverse_and_String_Theory_2005.pdf
  24. https://arxiv.org/abs/gr-qc/0012036
  25. https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0101257
  26. https://link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/PhysRevD.98.104020
  27. https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/10.1098/rsbm.2019.0001
  28. https://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/1974IAUS...63..291C
  29. https://phys.org/news/2024-12-universe-anthropic-principle.html
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.