Hubbry Logo
Bull ConnorBull ConnorMain
Open search
Bull Connor
Community hub
Bull Connor
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Bull Connor
Bull Connor
Bull Connor
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Theophilus Eugene "Bull" Connor (July 11, 1897 – March 10, 1973) was an American politician who was Commissioner of Public Safety for the city of Birmingham, Alabama, for more than two decades. A lifelong member of the Democratic Party, he strongly opposed the Civil Rights Movement in the 1960s. Under the city commission government, Connor had responsibility for administrative oversight of the Birmingham Fire Department and the Birmingham Police Department,[1] which also had their own chiefs.

Key Information

As a white supremacist,[2] Bull Connor enforced legal racial segregation and denied civil rights to Black citizens, especially during 1963's Birmingham campaign led by the Southern Christian Leadership Conference. He is well known for directing the use of fire hoses and police attack dogs against civil rights activists, including against children supporting the protests.[3] National media broadcast these tactics on television, horrifying much of the world. The outrages served as catalysts for major social and legal change in the Southern United States and contributed to passage by the United States Congress of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

Early life

[edit]

Connor was born in 1897 in Selma, Alabama, the son of Molly (Godwin) and Hugh King Connor, a train dispatcher and telegraph operator.[1]

Career

[edit]

He entered politics as a Democrat in 1934 winning a seat in the Alabama House of Representatives and maintained that party affiliation throughout his career.[4] As a legislator, he voted for extending the poll tax, which served as a barrier to voter registration by blacks, and against an anti-sedition bill intended to stifle union activity.[1] He did not stand for a second term in 1936, instead running for Commissioner of Public Safety for the City of Birmingham. Concurrently during this period, Connor served as the radio play-by-play broadcaster of the minor league Birmingham Barons baseball club spanning the 1932 through 1936 seasons.[5] Willie Mays remembered listening to him call games: "Pretty good announcer, too, although I think he used to get too excited."[6]

Commissioner of Public Safety (1936–1954, 1957–1963)

[edit]

In 1936, Connor was elected to the office of commissioner of Public Safety of Birmingham, beginning the first of two stretches that spanned a total of 26 years. His first stretch ended in 1952, but he was re-elected in 1956, and was sworn in on November 4, 1957, where he served until 1963.[7]

In 1938, Connor ran as a candidate for Governor of Alabama. He announced he would be campaigning on a platform of "protecting employment practices, law enforcement, segregation and other problems that have been historically classified as states' rights by the Democratic party".[8]

In 1948, Connor's officers arrested the U.S. Senator from Idaho, Glen H. Taylor. Taylor was the running mate of Progressive Party presidential candidate Henry Wallace, former Democratic vice president (1941 to 1945) with Franklin D. Roosevelt. Taylor, who had attempted to speak to the Southern Negro Youth Congress, was arrested for violating Birmingham's racial segregation laws. Connor's effort to enforce the law was caused by the group's reported communist philosophy,[9] with Connor noting at the time, "There's not enough room in town for Bull and the Commies."[10]

During the 1948 Democratic National Convention, Connor led the Alabama delegation in a walkout when the national party included a civil rights plank in its platform.[1] The offshoot States' Rights Democratic Party (Dixiecrats) nominated Strom Thurmond for president at its convention in Birmingham's Municipal Auditorium.[11]

Connor's second run for governor failed in 1954. He was the center of controversy that year by pushing through a city ordinance in Birmingham that outlawed "communism."[12]

Civil rights era

[edit]

Before returning to office in 1956, Connor quickly resumed his brutal approach to dealing with perceived threats to the social order. His forces raided a meeting which was being held at the house of African-American activist Reverend Fred Shuttlesworth, where three Montgomery ministers were in attendance. He feared that the Montgomery bus boycott, which was underway, would spread to Birmingham, in an effort to integrate city buses. He had the ministers arrested on charges of vagrancy, which meant that they were not allowed to pay bail, nor were they allowed to receive any visitors during the first three days of their incarceration. A federal investigation followed, but Connor refused to cooperate.[13]

In 1960, Connor was elected Democratic National Committeeman for Alabama, soon after filing a civil lawsuit against The New York Times for $1.5 million. He objected to what he claimed was their insinuation that he had promoted racial hatred. He dropped his claim for damages to $400,000; the case dragged on for six years until Connor lost a $40,000 judgment on appeal.[14]

Freedom Riders

[edit]
Main article: Freedom Riders

In the spring of 1961, integrated teams of civil rights activists mounted what they called "Freedom Rides" to highlight the illegal imposition of racial segregation on interstate buses, whose operations came under federal law and the constitution. They had teams ride Greyhound and Trailways buses traveling through southern capitals, with the final stop intended as New Orleans. The teams encountered increasing hostility and violence as they made their way deeper into the South.

On May 2, 1961, Connor had won a landslide election for his sixth term as Commissioner of Public Safety in Birmingham. As Commissioner, he had administrative authority over the police and fire departments, schools, public health service, and libraries, all of which were segregated by state law.[1] Tom King, a candidate running for mayor of Birmingham, met with Connor on May 8, 1961, to pay his respects. In addition, he asked him to refrain from announcing support for the other leading mayoral candidate, Art Hanes, so that King's chances would be greater. At the end of the meeting, Connor noted that he was expecting the Freedom Riders to reach Birmingham the following Sunday, Mother's Day. He stated, "We'll be ready for them, too," and King responded, "I bet you will, Commissioner," as he walked out.[15]

After a stop in Anniston, Alabama, the Greyhound bus of the Freedom Riders was attacked. They were offered no police protection. After they left town, they were forced to stop by a violent mob that firebombed and burned the bus, but no activists were fatally hurt. A new Greyhound bus was placed into service and departed for Birmingham. The activists on the earlier Trailways bus had been accosted by Ku Klux Klan members who boarded the bus in Atlanta and beat up the activists, pushing them all to the back of the bus.

The Freedom Riders arrived in Birmingham on May 14, 1961. As the Trailways bus reached the terminal in Birmingham, a large mob of Klansmen and news reporters was waiting for them. The Riders were viciously attacked soon after they disembarked from the bus and attempted to gain service at the whites-only lunch counter. Some were taken to the loading dock area, away from reporters, but some reporters were also beaten with metal bars, pipes, and bats and one's camera was destroyed. After 15 minutes, the police finally arrived, but by then most Klansmen had left.[16][17]

Connor intentionally let the Klansmen beat the Riders for 15 minutes with no police intervention. He publicly blamed the violence on many factors, saying that "No policemen were in sight as the buses arrived, because they were visiting their mothers on Mother's Day".[18] He insisted that the violence came from out-of-town meddlers and that police had rushed to the scene "as quickly as possible."[19] The violence was covered by national media.

He said:

As I have said on numerous occasions, we are not going to stand for this in Birmingham. And if necessary we will fill the jail full and we don't care whose toes we step on. I am saying now to these meddlers from out of our city the best thing for them to do is stay out if they don't want to get slapped in jail. Our people of Birmingham are a peaceful people and we never have any trouble here unless some people come into our city looking for trouble. And I've never seen anyone yet look for trouble who wasn't able to find it.[19]

In 1962, Connor ordered the closing of 60 Birmingham parks rather than follow a federal court order to desegregate public facilities.

In November 1962, in response to the extremely negative perception of the city—it was derisively nicknamed "Bombingham" by outsiders for the numerous attacks on the homes and churches of black civil rights activists—Birmingham voters changed the city's form of government. Rather than an at-large election of three commissioners, who had specific oversight of certain city departments, there would be a mayor-council form of government. Members of the city council were to be elected from nine single-member districts. Blacks were still largely disenfranchised. For instance, in 1961 when the president of the city's Chamber of Commerce was visiting Japan, he saw a newspaper photo of a bus engulfed in flames, which occurred during the Freedom Rides. Bull Connor had arranged for opponents to have time to attack civil rights activists when their bus reached Birmingham.

Endorsed by Governor George C. Wallace, Connor attempted to run for mayor, but lost on April 2, 1963. Connor and his fellow commissioners filed suit to block the change in power,[1] but on May 23, 1963, the Supreme Court of Alabama ruled against them.[20] Connor ended his 23-year tenure in the post. Citing a general law, he had argued that the change could not take effect until the October 1 following the date of the election, but the Supreme Court of Alabama held that the general law was preempted by a special law applicable to only the City of Birmingham.

Birmingham campaign

[edit]
Main article: Birmingham campaign

Local civil rights activists had been unable to negotiate much change with the city or business leaders, in their efforts to gain integration of facilities and hiring of blacks by local businesses. They invited Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and his team to help mount a more concerted campaign. The day after the April election, Dr. King and local civil rights leaders began "Project 'C'" (for "confrontation") against the Birmingham business community. They used economic boycotts and demonstrations to seek integration of stores and job opportunities. Throughout April 1963, King led smaller demonstrations, which resulted in his arrest along with many others.[21]

King wanted to have massive arrests to highlight the brutal police tactics used by Connor and his subordinates. (By extension, the campaign was intended to demonstrate the general suppression by other Southern police officials as well). After King was arrested and jailed, he wrote his Letter from Birmingham Jail, which became noted as a moral argument for civil rights activism. The goal of the campaign was to gain mass arrests of non-violent protesters and overwhelm the judicial and penal systems. It would also demonstrate to national media and local residents the strong desire of African Americans to exercise their constitutional rights as citizens.

Children's Crusade

[edit]
Main article: Children's Crusade

In the final phase of Project C, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference's James Bevel introduced a controversial new tactic of using young people in the demonstrations. Most adults were working for bosses who openly threatened their jobs with termination for participating in the demonstrations. On May 2, 1963, the first youths and students walked out of the 16th Street Baptist Church and attempted to march to Birmingham's City Hall to talk to the Mayor. By the end of the day, 959 children, ranging from ages 6–18, had been arrested.

The next day, even more students joined the marches, against whom Connor ordered the use of fire hoses and attack dogs. This did not stop the demonstrators, but generated bad publicity for Connor through the news media. The use of fire hoses continued and by May 7, Connor and the police department had detained more than 3,000 demonstrators.[21]

The Black Americans' economic boycott of businesses that refused to hire them and downtown stores that kept segregated facilities helped gain negotiation by the city's business leaders. The SCLC and the Senior Citizens Committee, who represented a majority of Birmingham businesses, came to an agreement. On May 10, they agreed on desegregation of lunch counters, restrooms, fitting rooms, and drinking fountains at department stores, the upgrading in position and hiring of blacks, cooperation with SCLC legal representatives in releasing all detainees, and the establishment of formal communication between black and whites through the Senior Citizens Committee.[14][22]

Later life and death

[edit]

On June 3, 1964, Connor resumed a place in government when he was elected president of the Alabama Public Service Commission in the 1964 Alabama Public Service Commission election. He suffered a stroke on December 7, 1966, and used a wheelchair for the rest of his life. Connor won another term in 1968, but was defeated in 1972.

He suffered another stroke on February 26, 1973, which left him unconscious. He died a few weeks later, in March of that year. Survivors included his widow, Beara, a daughter, and a brother, Ed Connor.[14]

Legacy

[edit]

Connor's brutality and violence against civil rights activists contributed to Ku Klux Klan and other violence against black people in the city of Birmingham. On a Sunday in September 1963, the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing destroyed a portion of the church basement causing the death of four Black girls, Addie Mae Collins age 14, Carol Denise McNair age 11, Carole Rosamond Robertson age 14, and Cynthia Dionne Wesley, age 14. The church was known as the center of civil rights activities in Birmingham. The city and movement leaders had just reached a negotiated agreement on integration of facilities and jobs. The deaths of the children prompted the Attorney General Robert Kennedy to call Governor George Wallace and threaten to send in federal troops to control violence and bombings in Birmingham.

[edit]
  • Connor is mentioned in contemporary folk singer Phil Ochs's 1965 song "Talking Birmingham Jam".
  • Connor is played by Kenneth McMillan in the 1978 television miniseries King.
  • Spike Lee's 1997 documentary 4 Little Girls, which is about the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing, includes footage of Connor and interviews with people describing police tactics during his tenure.
  • Footage of Connor appears in the 1999 film Our Friend, Martin, in which he is voiced by veteran voice artist Frank Welker.
  • Connor is cited by name in the 2014 film Selma as an example of a particular type of bullying public official and police officer whose tolerance, or encouragement, of violence towards Civil Rights campaigners plays into the hands of the media-conscious SCLC and Martin Luther King Jr.
  • Connor is referenced in the syndicated comic strip The Boondocks, where Huey Freeman mistakes a man washing his car for Connor.[23] Connor also appears as an antagonist in the 2014 episode "Freedom Ride or Die" in the animated TV series based on the strip.
  • Connor is framed as an antagonist in John Lewis's graphic novel memoir series March, appearing in the 2015 second novel of the trilogy as an opposition to the Freedom Riders and general racial equality.
  • In the 2004 remake of The Ladykillers, the character played by J. K. Simmons stands up to another character and says, 'You don't scare me, Bull Connor and his dogs didn't scare me.'

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Bull Connor

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Theophilus Eugene "Bull" Connor (July 11, 1897 – March 10, 1973) was an American politician and public safety official who served as Commissioner of Public Safety for , from 1937 to 1952 and again from 1957 to 1963, directing the city's police and fire departments. Connor's tenure was marked by his staunch enforcement of state and local segregation statutes amid rising civil activism, culminating in the 1963 where he authorized the use of police dogs and high-pressure fire hoses to break up demonstrations by Black protesters, including children, who had violated a federal court prohibiting parades without permits. These measures, aimed at quelling what authorities deemed unlawful assemblies disrupting public order, were broadcast nationwide and, despite their legal basis under prevailing Alabama laws, fueled public outrage that accelerated federal intervention against Southern segregation practices. Prior to his long stint in Birmingham, Connor worked as a radio sportscaster and was elected to the in 1934, leveraging his popularity to secure the public safety role amid the city's commission form of government, which granted commissioners significant autonomy over departments. His career also included unsuccessful bids for governor and a later election as president of the Alabama Public Service Commission, reflecting sustained political influence in a deeply segregated where maintaining racial separation was a core tenet of local governance. Connor's approach to civil unrest, including tacit allowances for vigilante actions against in 1961, underscored his prioritization of segregationist order over federal desegregation mandates, though such tactics ultimately undermined the system he defended by inviting broader scrutiny and legal challenges.

Early life

Upbringing and family

Theophilus Eugene Connor was born on July 11, 1897, in Selma, , to Hugh King Connor, a train dispatcher and telegraph operator for the railroad, and Molly Godwin Connor. He was one of five children in the family, which relocated to , Georgia, around 1905 due to his father's job demands. His mother died when he was eight years old, after which his father continued working extensively on the railroads, often traveling for employment. Connor's early years unfolded in the post-Reconstruction South, characterized by that institutionalized in public facilities, transportation, and daily interactions, with such customs widely accepted as the prevailing social order. The region's political landscape was dominated by the Democratic Party, which upheld these separation practices through state and local governance. Selma, a cotton-trading hub along the , embodied the agrarian and industrial tensions of the era, where working-class families like the Connors navigated economic reliance on railroads and amid entrenched regional traditions. Formal education for Connor was limited; he did not complete high school but acquired practical skills, including , directly from his father's profession, underscoring a emphasis on and vocational training over extended schooling typical of his socioeconomic background. This upbringing in a mobile, labor-oriented household fostered an orientation toward tangible, hands-on competencies amid the South's hierarchical social structure.

Initial career in broadcasting

After learning telegraphy from his father, a railroad telegrapher, Connor secured at radio stations, leveraging this technical skill to enter . In 1921, while in , , he substituted for an ailing baseball announcer, where his distinctive booming voice quickly drew listener acclaim and earned him the "Bull," derived from its powerful resonance. Connor returned to Birmingham in 1922, initially working as a telegraph operator and salesman before establishing himself as a sports-radio , particularly covering games for the minor league team. His play-by-play broadcasts in the and featured an energetic, authoritative delivery that captivated local audiences, fostering widespread name recognition through vivid game descriptions and engaging commentary focused on entertainment rather than partisan issues. This early radio tenure cultivated Connor's public-speaking prowess and bombastic on-air persona, which resonated with working-class listeners attuned to sports and straightforward narration, laying a foundation for his communicative style without delving into political advocacy at the time.

Political ascent

Entry into electoral politics

Connor transitioned from his career in radio broadcasting to electoral politics in 1934, entering the Democratic primary for a seat in the . His widespread recognition as a Birmingham sportscaster enabled him to secure the nomination and general election victory with minimal campaigning, reflecting the one-party dominance of Democrats in Depression-era Alabama. Serving one term from 1935 to 1937, Connor aligned with Democrats by supporting populist measures such as poll tax reform to broaden white voter access, while opposing tax hikes and anti-union bills that threatened industrial workers amid widespread unemployment and labor unrest. This stance built support among Birmingham's white working-class base, including steel and mining employees skeptical of external radical influences but favoring protections against business-led restrictions on organizing. In , Connor leveraged his legislative experience and radio-forged public profile to win election to the Birmingham City Commission as commissioner of public safety, campaigning on themes of efficient governance, crime reduction, and economic stabilization tailored to local white constituencies wary of federal overreach. His platform emphasized infrastructure improvements and job preservation, resonating in a city where the had intensified competition for scarce opportunities among the predominantly white electorate.

First terms in office

Connor was elected Commissioner of Public Safety for , in the 1937 municipal election, securing oversight of the city's police and fire departments at a time when Birmingham served as a key hub for the steel industry, with major operations from companies like driving from approximately 259,000 in 1930 to over 326,000 by 1950. This industrial expansion, fueled by post-Depression recovery and demands, heightened demands for public order amid rising urban challenges, including labor unrest and crime linked to the influx of workers. Throughout his initial tenure from 1937 to 1952, Connor prioritized administrative consolidation, reelected in 1941, 1945—defeating challengers including Osa Andrews, Chester Mullins, Marion Hogan, and John Rogers—and 1949, while enforcing strict law and order policies. He expanded police authority through actions such as padlocking the Galax Theater in 1940 despite a and proposing ordinances like the 1950 measure criminalizing association with the (punishable by a $100 fine and up to 180 days in jail), justifying such measures as necessary to maintain control in a booming industrial city prone to disorder. These efforts aligned with his self-presentation as a tough enforcer, supported by business interests favoring low taxes and alongside robust public safety. Connor's first period ended amid scandal; arrested on December 26, 1951, in a hotel room with his secretary Christina Brown, he was convicted, fined $100, and sentenced to 180 days, though the conviction was overturned on June 11, 1952, prompting resignation and forgoing the 1952 election amid recall pressures from dissatisfied workers. He briefly pursued higher office, running unsuccessfully for governor in 1950. Voters reelected him in 1956, restoring his position on November 4, 1957, as economic recovery continued and public sentiment favored his hardline approach over the interim administration's perceived inadequacies in maintaining order.

Public safety administration

Policies on crime and order

As Commissioner of Public Safety, a role Connor held from to and again from to 1963, he directed the Birmingham Police Department in upholding priorities aimed at curbing criminality and preserving order in the city's industrial environment, marked by steel mills, labor tensions, and urban vice districts. This position granted him authority over policing operations, including patrols and interventions against illicit activities that threatened public safety. Connor cultivated a public image as a dedicated crime fighter, advocating for stringent measures to deter disruptions from dens, rings, and other forms of organized prevalent in Birmingham's working-class neighborhoods. His administration relied on heightened police visibility and rapid response tactics to suppress such elements, which business elites viewed as essential for safeguarding commercial stability in a city dependent on . White business leaders and civic groups commended Connor's approach for fostering an atmosphere conducive to economic continuity, crediting his unyielding enforcement with minimizing the chaos from unregulated and petty that plagued comparable Southern cities. Although comprehensive local crime data from the era remains sparse, his emphasis on proactive deterrence aligned with broader efforts to counteract the rising urban disorder observed nationally in the post-World War II period.

Pre-1960s enforcement actions

Connor assumed the role of Birmingham's of Public Safety on January 1, 1957, overseeing police and fire departments with a mandate to preserve order amid rising tensions from subversive ideologies and industrial disputes. He immediately targeted communist activities, sponsoring a city ordinance that criminalized membership in or propagation of the as a , carrying penalties of a $100 fine and up to 180 days imprisonment. To enforce this, Connor issued directives requiring identified communists to leave the city within 48 hours, framing such groups as existential threats to and social cohesion in Birmingham's steel-dependent economy. This approach extended to labor unrest, where Connor consistently opposed union-led strikes, associating them with communist infiltration that could paralyze industrial output and incite broader disorder. In Birmingham, a hub of iron and production, earlier labor actions in and —often backed by CIO affiliates with reported communist organizers—had prompted crackdowns by local authorities, which Connor supported through his political advocacy and radio commentary denouncing agitators as anti-capitalist saboteurs. By the late , his administration applied similar rigor to any assembly deviating into unlawful disruption, dispersing gatherings preemptively to avert escalation into riots that might overwhelm municipal resources or invite federal intervention. Regarding vigilante violence, such as the series of bombings on "Dynamite Hill"—a Center Street neighborhood targeted by dynamiters between 1947 and the mid-1950s—Connor's forces conducted investigations into perpetrators disrupting public tranquility, arresting suspects where evidence linked them to unlawful explosives use, even as segregationist sympathies complicated prosecutions. This prioritized on violence over private reprisals, theoretically stabilizing the civic environment by channeling unrest through legal channels rather than allowing anarchist bombings to provoke retaliatory cycles or undermine official authority. However, persistent of witnesses and Klan entrenchment limited convictions, reflecting causal constraints on efficacy amid entrenched cultural divides.

Clashes with integration efforts

Freedom Riders confrontation (1961)

The , organized by the (CORE) and other civil rights groups, departed , on May 4, 1961, to challenge segregation in interstate bus terminals across the South, testing compliance with the 1960 decision in , which prohibited segregation in facilities serving interstate passengers. In , their use of integrated waiting rooms and restrooms directly contravened state and local mandating racial separation in public accommodations, creating immediate disruptions to normal bus operations and escalating local tensions. On May 14, a white mob of approximately 200 people attacked a bus carrying Riders near Anniston, slashing tires, smashing windows, and firebombing the vehicle after it was forced to stop, forcing passengers to flee amid thick smoke and injuries from the assault. Later that day, a Trailways bus with surviving Riders reached Birmingham's station, where a mob of members and other white assailants—unimpeded by police for about 15 minutes—severely beat several Riders, including journalists, with clubs, pipes, and fists, amid threats of that posed acute risks to public order. As Birmingham's Commissioner of Public Safety, Theophilus Eugene "Bull" Connor directed local police to withhold immediate at the terminal, later stating he anticipated violence and had arranged for no interference to allow the mob's actions, citing the holiday () and jurisdictional limits over interstate travelers as factors. Connor justified the delay by referencing prior mob violence in Anniston and the need to avoid escalating clashes, arguing that direct intervention could provoke broader disorder given the Riders' deliberate provocation of state segregation statutes. state troopers, under Governor John Patterson's authority, had been deployed regionally but arrived post-attack in Anniston; in Birmingham, Connor's dispersed enforcement—subsequently arresting Riders "for their own " and transporting them out of state—prevented immediate escalation into citywide riots, though it drew intense national media scrutiny of the violence. Local records indicate no further mass disturbances in Birmingham from this incident, as the Riders were effectively removed, averting retaliatory cycles amid heightened white community anger over the legal challenges to customary order. The Birmingham Campaign commenced on April 3, 1963, when the (SCLC), in collaboration with the Alabama Christian Movement for Human Rights (ACMHR) led by Rev. , initiated protests under "Project C" to confront segregation in public facilities and employment through sit-ins, boycotts, and marches. City officials, including Public Safety Commissioner Eugene "Bull" Connor, had repeatedly denied permits for large-scale demonstrations, arguing they posed risks to public order and traffic amid prior incidents of unrest. On April 10, a Jefferson County issued an prohibiting mass parades or demonstrations without permits, which campaign leaders debated but ultimately defied to test legal boundaries. Protests persisted despite the injunction; on Good Friday, April 12, led a march without a permit, resulting in his along with over 50 others for , as later upheld by the U.S. in Walker v. City of Birmingham. By early May, with jails filling from over 2,000 s, demonstrations escalated as hundreds more, including students, gathered daily at and advanced toward downtown targets. Connor enforced the injunction by deploying police to disperse unlawful assemblies, raising bail bonds from $200 to $1,500 to deter repeat violations. Tensions peaked on May 3 when crowds of several thousand confronted officers near city hall; as police lines formed, some bystanders hurled rocks, bottles, and bricks, prompting Connor to authorize fire hoses and dogs to repel the advance and protect property. Contemporary accounts reported three students bitten by dogs and dozens of protesters treated for lacerations, contusions from hoses, and minor fractures, while an undetermined number of officers sustained injuries from projectiles amid the chaos. No fatalities occurred during the primary confrontations, though the events drew national media scrutiny. files noted prior scrutiny of SCLC for alleged communist associations among some affiliates, which local authorities cited as heightening concerns over potential agitation beyond desegregation goals. The standoff prompted negotiations between business leaders, campaign organizers, and city representatives; on May 10, the "Birmingham Truce Agreement" secured desegregation of downtown department stores' lunch counters, restrooms, fitting rooms, and drinking fountains, plus promotion of Black sales personnel and release of jailed protesters without fines. Connor's actions aligned with mandates against unauthorized mass gatherings, though the agreement marked a partial concession to demands amid economic from boycotts. Subsequent bombings on May 11 targeted King allies, escalating into riots quelled by state troopers, but the core campaign's desegregation terms held.

Decline and exit from power

Electoral defeat

In response to growing concerns among Birmingham's business community over the city's negative national image—stemming from high-profile clashes like the 1961 incident—local elites advocated for restructuring the government to replace the powerful three-member commission system, in place since , with a mayor-council form that would dilute the commissioners' authority. This reform effort culminated in voter approval of the change via , enabling elections under the new system. Connor, seeking to retain influence, ran for in the March 5, 1963, primary but advanced to a runoff against moderate Democrat Albert Boutwell after Tom King, an establishment-backed candidate, failed to secure a . In the April 2 runoff, Boutwell defeated Connor with 29,630 votes to Connor's 21,648, reflecting divisions among white voters where Connor retained strong backing from working-class segments prioritizing his record on public order, while interests and some moderates favored Boutwell's less confrontational profile to attract investment and ease federal scrutiny. The incumbent commissioners, including Connor, challenged the transition legally, creating a period of dual governance, but the Alabama Supreme Court ruled on May 23, 1963, ordering them to vacate their offices and affirming Boutwell's administration. This ouster ended Connor's 22-year tenure as public safety commissioner, coinciding with intensified federal attention to Birmingham's racial tensions, though his defeat was attributed less to broad local repudiation—given his primary performance indicating sustained white support for aggressive —than to elite-driven reforms aimed at the city.

Immediate aftermath

Following his ouster from the Birmingham City Commission in May 1963, after the resolution of the and the inauguration of moderate segregationist Albert Boutwell as mayor, Connor maintained a low public profile during the transitional period but continued to defend his prior enforcement tactics. In statements reflecting on the use of police dogs and fire hoses against demonstrators, Connor asserted that such measures were "more humane than bullets," rejecting any implication of excessive force and framing them as necessary to preserve order amid what he described as orchestrated disruptions. Birmingham's governance shifted toward Boutwell's less confrontational approach, which emphasized negotiation over aggressive suppression, yet racial violence escalated in the ensuing months. On the night of May 10, 1963, immediately after a desegregation settlement brokered by civil rights leaders and business elites, segregationist extremists detonated an explosive device at the Gaston Motel, where had stayed, signaling backlash against perceived concessions. This pattern intensified with the September 15, 1963, bombing of the by members, killing four African American girls and highlighting persistent instability despite the removal of Connor's hardline administration—raising questions about whether moderated policing emboldened violent fringe elements rather than deterring them. Sidelined from local power until his successful campaign for the Public Service Commission presidency in June 1964, Connor's immediate post-Birmingham phase marked a temporary of his influence in affairs, though he leveraged his reputation among segregationist supporters to secure the state-level role regulating utilities.

Final years

Retirement activities

Following his electoral defeat for re-election to the Public Service Commission on January 17, 1972, Connor withdrew from active political involvement. Confined to a since a in December 1966, he limited public appearances and focused on private life amid ongoing health challenges from prior stress and physical decline. He resided in Birmingham's Jefferson County area with surviving family members, including his wife and children, and made no moves to leave the region despite national notoriety from earlier events. Connor offered no public of his segregationist positions, maintaining in limited contexts that such policies had served to preserve order, though his impairments curtailed formal interviews or after 1972. Daily routines emphasized personal continuity over introspection or relocation, with family support amid deteriorating mobility and vitality leading into his final months.

Death and personal end

Theophilus Eugene "Bull" Connor died on March 10, 1973, in , at age 75, after suffering a stroke that followed a prior debilitating in December 1966, which had confined him to a . An additional on February 26, 1973, had left him unconscious in his final weeks. Connor maintained an unrepentant position regarding his enforcement of segregation until his death, refusing to disavow his past actions in contrast to some other Southern segregationist figures who later moderated their views. He was buried at Jefferson Memorial Gardens in , survived by his wife, daughter, and brother.

Ideology and worldview

Segregation advocacy

Theophilus Eugene "Bull" Connor advocated as a foundational principle for maintaining social stability in , where he served as Commissioner of Public Safety for over two decades. He contended that enforced separation preserved the natural order of local communities, preventing the conflicts that arose from compelled interracial mixing, which he saw as an artificial imposition disruptive to longstanding customs and equilibria. In public addresses, Connor explicitly rejected integration, stating during a , 1963, White Citizens' Council rally in Holt, , "We’re going to keep the races separate as long as I’m in office," framing such separation as essential to averting chaos in institutions like schools and public facilities. He echoed broader Southern segregationist sentiments by prioritizing racial division to safeguard community harmony, arguing that deviation invited disorder rooted in incompatible rather than engineered equality. Connor's position extended to opposing federal authority on racial matters, viewing mandates for integration as overreach that undermined state and Alabama's traditional governance. His leadership in the 1948 Dixiecrat walkout from the protested President Harry Truman's civil rights proposals, reinforcing his belief that local control over separation policies was causally necessary to sustain peaceful coexistence amid demographic differences. Throughout his career, Connor remained unyielding, never disavowing segregation as a pragmatic barrier against societal friction, even as national pressures mounted; he maintained that such separation aligned with empirical patterns of stability in pre-integration Birmingham, where rigid divisions minimized direct interracial tensions.

Law enforcement philosophy

Connor viewed as fundamentally tasked with upholding statutes through immediate and conspicuous application of authority to forestall chaos, asserting that "law is more important than order" to emphasize strict legal fidelity over superficial calm. This principle informed his insistence on visible deterrence, where police readiness to deploy force against unlawful conduct served as a bulwark against the mob dynamics evident in prior riots, such as the 1943 Detroit disturbance where 34 deaths resulted from unchecked escalation after initial restraint. He contended that hesitation in response to violations enabled agitators—whom he identified as orchestrators of disruption—to amplify disorder, drawing from patterns where weak enforcement correlated with prolonged violence, as in the 1919 race riot involving 38 fatalities amid delayed . Countering critiques of excess, Connor maintained that forceful measures were defensive reactions to instigated breaches of peace, legally grounded in provisions for dispersing assemblies that threatened public safety, and proportionate to the causal risks posed by non-compliant groups. Unlike permissive strategies that he saw as incentivizing defiance—evidenced by unrest cycles where accommodation preceded surges in urban flare-ups like the 1965 , with over 1,000 injuries from unchecked initial tolerance—Connor's doctrine prioritized preemptive firmness to truncate escalation at inception. This stance reflected a causal realism: observable data from disturbances showed that visible resolve reduced overall violence by discouraging participation, whereas equivocation amplified participation through perceived impunity.

Assessments and debates

Tactical effectiveness in maintaining stability

Connor's tenure as Commissioner of Public Safety from March 1957 to September 1963 coincided with a period in which Birmingham avoided the scale of racial riots seen in cities like (1957), or later in (1964), with public disorder largely confined to sporadic bombings—over 50 dynamite attacks between 1947 and 1963, mostly targeting black homes and churches—rather than sustained urban upheaval. These incidents, often linked to activities, did not escalate into citywide riots under Connor's watch, as police responses emphasized containment and protection of white areas, preserving overall municipal operations. In the 1963 Birmingham Campaign, Connor's authorization of police dogs and fire hoses on May 3 against roughly 1,000 demonstrators, including children, rapidly dispersed assemblies in Kelly Ingram Park, averting immediate escalation to property destruction or armed clashes that arrests alone could not achieve after jails overflowed with 2,500 prior detainees by early May. This method cleared streets within hours, minimizing prolonged blockades of downtown commerce compared to scenarios where mass arrests might prolong standoffs and invite counter-violence, as evidenced by the campaign's shift to negotiations rather than indefinite occupation. Short-term deterrence from such visible force reduced repeat large-scale gatherings during the peak protest weeks of April-May 1963, with police logs indicating fewer mass demonstrations after initial suppressions, correlating with the containment of unrest to targeted zones without spillover into residential or industrial areas. Businesses reported continuity in core operations despite the boycott's economic pressure, attributing the absence of or —unlike the May 11-12 riot following settlement bombings—to Connor's preemptive enforcement that signaled swift repercussions for disruptions. This outcome prioritized rapid restoration over extended negotiations, sustaining daily stability amid national turmoil in other sites.

Criticisms and civil rights perspectives

Civil rights leaders and organizations, including the (SCLC), accused Connor of authorizing excessive and disproportionate force against nonviolent protesters during the , particularly targeting over 1,000 children marching on May 3, 1963, with police dogs and high-pressure fire hoses capable of delivering 3,000 pounds per square inch. These measures resulted in injuries such as bites to at least three students and widespread knockdowns, with critics framing them as emblematic of institutionalized racial violence rather than responses to public order disruptions. National media coverage amplified these incidents through iconic photographs and television footage emphasizing attacks on unarmed demonstrators, which civil rights advocates cited as proof of systemic brutality under Connor's command, though such visuals often prioritized dramatic confrontations over preceding permitless assemblies that violated local ordinances. The resulting public revulsion, as evidenced by widespread editorial condemnation and shifts in northern opinion polls favoring desegregation, propelled federal momentum toward the by underscoring the enforcement mechanisms of . Connor's associations with Ku Klux Klan elements, including protection of Klansmen responsible for bombings and assaults during events like the 1961 Freedom Rides—where informants reported his tacit endorsement of vigilante beatings—drew charges of conflicted loyalties undermining impartial policing, despite his personal denials of Klan membership. Civil rights perspectives highlighted these ties as enabling a permissive environment for extralegal violence, with figures like Rev. invoking Connor's tactics in "" to argue that such responses validated the moral imperative of against unjust authority. Some contemporaneous critiques within activist circles, however, acknowledged strategic elements in provoking visible overreactions to leverage media sympathy, as local leaders anticipated harsh countermeasures to fill jails and expose segregation's defenses.

Broader historical reevaluations

Some historical analyses have reevaluated Connor's enforcement tactics through the lens of declassified FBI intelligence, which documented potential communist subversion within civil rights groups orchestrating the 1963 Birmingham protests. The FBI reported that advisors like Stanley Levison, a close confidant to Martin Luther King Jr. and strategist for the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC)—the primary organizer of the campaign—had longstanding ties to the Communist Party USA, including financial support and ideological alignment dating back to the 1940s. J. Edgar Hoover's bureau viewed such influences as exploiting racial tensions to foment broader unrest, with internal memos from 1963 analyzing communist exploitation of marches like those in Birmingham to advance subversive agendas. Proponents of this perspective contend that Connor's unyielding posture disrupted these efforts, prioritizing public safety amid perceived threats beyond mere segregation disputes. Comparisons to subsequent urban disorders have prompted arguments that Connor's decisive measures averted escalation into the catastrophic riots afflicting northern cities later in the decade. While Birmingham experienced localized violence, including rock-throwing by some demonstrators and retaliatory bombings post-settlement, the absence of sustained mass arson, looting, or fatalities on the scale of the 1965 (34 deaths, over $40 million in damage) or 1967 uprising (43 deaths, 7,200 arrests) is attributed by some to preemptive firmness rather than restraint. These events, often linked to delayed or hesitant policing, resulted in national upheaval contrasting Birmingham's negotiated desegregation agreement by May 1963, suggesting Connor's approach contained volatility without federal troop deployment during the peak confrontations. Scholarly scrutiny has highlighted potential media asymmetries in coverage, where graphic images of police dogs and hoses dominated narratives, often sidelining contemporaneous accounts of protester actions like mass attempts to overwhelm barricades and assaults on officers, which Birmingham authorities documented as precipitating force escalations. Such selective emphasis, critics argue, amplified perceptions of unprovoked brutality while underreporting the tactical context of maintaining cordons against thousands of converging demonstrators, including children directed into high-risk zones. This framing, echoed in later academic works questioning institutional biases in civil rights , posits that fuller empirical review reveals Connor's decisions as pragmatic responses to disorder risks, not gratuitous excess.

References

  1. https://www.nps.gov/people/bull-connor.htm
  2. https://encyclopediaofalabama.org/article/eugene-bull-connor/
  3. https://www.fjc.gov/history/cases/cases-that-shaped-the-federal-courts/walker-v-city-birmingham
  4. https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/birmingham-campaign
  5. https://scholarship.law.umassd.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=1081&context=fac_pubs
  6. https://www.encyclopedia.com/humanities/encyclopedias-almanacs-transcripts-and-maps/connor-theophilus-eugene-bull
  7. https://www.biography.com/political-figures/eugene-bull-connor
  8. https://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/the-civil-rights-movement-in-america-1945-to-1968/bull-connor/
  9. https://historylearning.com/civil-rights-america/bull-connor/
  10. https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/connor-theophilus-eugene-bull
  11. https://crdl.usg.edu/collection/abj_p16044coll1.html
  12. https://www.si.com/mlb/rickwood-field-birmingham-jackie-robinson-hank-aaron-segregation
  13. https://www.bhamwiki.com/w/Bull_Connor
  14. https://southernchanges.digitalscholarship.emory.edu/sc13-3_001/sc13-3_008/
  15. https://www.nytimes.com/1973/03/12/archives/eugene-bull-connor-dies-at-75-police-head-fought-integration-symbol.html
  16. https://www.disastercenter.com/crime/uscrime.htm
  17. https://abahlali.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/Hammer-and-hoe-Alabama-Communists-during-the-Great-Depression.pdf
  18. https://www.nytimes.com/1983/07/24/magazine/the-birmingham-bombing.html
  19. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/freedom-riders-freedom-travel/
  20. https://www.nps.gov/places/greyhound-bus-burn-site.htm
  21. https://calendar.eji.org/racial-injustice/may/14
  22. https://www.thecongressofracialequality.org/freedom-rides.html
  23. https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/freedom-rides
  24. https://calendar.eji.org/racial-injustice/apr/12
  25. https://www.nytimes.com/1963/05/04/archives/dogs-and-hoses-repulse-negroes-at-birmingham-3-students-bitten-in.html
  26. https://www.bhamwiki.com/w/Police_dogs_and_firehoses
  27. https://homework.study.com/explanation/how-many-died-in-birmingham-riots.html
  28. https://vault.fbi.gov/southern-christian-leadership-convention
  29. https://nvdatabase.swarthmore.edu/content/african-americans-campaign-equal-accommodations-birmingham-alabama-usa-1963
  30. https://www.bhamwiki.com/w/Mayor-Council_Act_of_1955
  31. https://www.al.com/birmingham-news-stories/2013/04/boutwell_defeated_connor_as_mo.html
  32. https://encyclopediaofalabama.org/article/birmingham-campaign-of-1963/
  33. https://thekingcenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/Unit-2-Birmingham-Campaign-K-5-Intro-.pdf
  34. https://www.fbi.gov/history/famous-cases/baptist-street-church-bombing
  35. https://www.nytimes.com/1973/03/11/archives/eugene-bull-connor-dies-at-75-police-head-fought-integration-less.html
  36. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/167614607/theophilus_eugene-connor
  37. https://crdl.usg.edu/record/ugabma_wsbn_wsbn36541
  38. https://www.saturdayeveningpost.com/wp-content/uploads/satevepost/a-city-in-fear.pdf
  39. https://digitalcommons.library.uab.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1093&context=vulcan
  40. https://www.npr.org/sections/codeswitch/2013/06/18/193128475/how-the-civil-rights-movement-was-covered-in-birmingham
  41. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1978/08/20/fbi-knew-policeman-was-leak-to-klan-on-freedom-riders/b7c9511b-8805-4ff6-a4dd-3da31a05f1af/
  42. https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/americanexperience/features/meet-players-other-figures/
  43. https://news.harvard.edu/gazette/story/2022/01/rescuing-the-civil-rights-movement-and-children-of-birmingham/
  44. https://kinginstitute.stanford.edu/federal-bureau-investigation-fbi
  45. https://progressive.org/latest/fbi-vs-civil-rights-rampell-210112/
  46. https://www.archives.gov/files/research/mlk/releases/2025/0721/80-ph-1591_sec_000_ser_138-part_4_of_5.pdf
  47. https://digitalcommons.salve.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1120&context=pell_theses
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.