Hubbry Logo
Pocatello (Shoshone leader)Pocatello (Shoshone leader)Main
Open search
Pocatello (Shoshone leader)
Community hub
Pocatello (Shoshone leader)
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Pocatello (Shoshone leader)
Pocatello (Shoshone leader)
Pocatello (Shoshone leader)
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Chief Pocatello (known in the Shoshoni language as Tondzaosha (Buffalo Robe); 1815 – October 1884) was a leader of the Northern Shoshone, a Native American people of the Great Basin in western North America. He led attacks against early settlers during a time of increasing strife between settlers and Native Americans. After making peace with the U.S. Government, he moved his people to their present reservation in Idaho and led the Shoshone during their struggle to survive following their deportation. The city of Pocatello is named in his honor.

Key Information

Biography

[edit]

Pocatello was born 1815. He was the leader at the time of the United States' arrival into Utah in the late 1840s. In the 1850s, he led a series of attacks against emigrant parties in the Utah Territory and along the Oregon Trail. He gained a reputation among Mormon leaders and Indian agents as a leader of a band of Native Americans. Brigham Young, the leader of the Mormons, attempted a policy of reconciliation and appeasement of the Shoshone, but the arrival of the United States Army in the Utah Territory in 1858 exacerbated tensions between the emigrants and the Shoshone.

In January 1863, Pocatello received advance notice of the advance of U.S. Army troops from Fort Douglas under Colonel Patrick Edward Connor, who had set out to "chastise" the Shoshone. Pocatello was able to lead his people out of harm's way from the Army, thus avoiding the catastrophe of the Bear River Massacre. Pocatello sued for peace after pursuit from the Army. Pocatello agreed to cease his attacks on Oregon Trail emigrants and southeast Idaho settlers if the government would provide compensation for the game and land preempted by these intruders on the tribe's ancestral territory. With the Fort Bridger Treaty of 1868, the chief agreed to relocate his people to the Fort Hall Indian Reservation along the Snake River. Although the U.S. government had promised $5,000 in annual supplies, the relief rarely arrived, forcing continuing suffering and struggle among the Shoshone.

In 1875, faced with starvation among his people, Pocatello led them to the Mormon missionary farm of George Hill in Corinne, Utah, with the hope that a mass conversion of his people to Mormonism would alleviate his people's suffering. Although the missionaries willingly baptized the Shoshone, the local population of white settlers did not receive the Shoshone openly and agitated for their expulsion. In response, the U.S. Army forced the Shoshone to return to the Fort Hall Reservation.

In the late 1870s Pocatello granted a right-of-way to Jay Gould to extend the Utah and Northern Railway across the Fort Hall Indian Reservation. The extension of the railroad was motivated by the increasing flood of settlers into the Idaho Territory following the discovery of gold.

After his death in 1884, Pocatello's body was interred in a deep spring in Idaho along with his clothing, guns, knives, and hunting equipment. Eighteen horses were also slaughtered and put into the spring on top of his body.[1]

Name

[edit]

In 1918, John E. Rees published a list of Idaho place names called Idaho Nomenclature. His derivation of Pokatello included po "road," ka "not," and tello "to follow," and Rees offered the meaning "he does not follow the road," referring to the chief's "stealthy habits and thieving raids."[2] An earlier reference to Pocataro occurred in 1859, when F. W. Lander, Superintendent of the U.S. Overland Wagon Road, met Chief Pocatello and arranged his release from U.S. Army custody.[3] Linguist Sven Liljeblad believed that Lander's encounter with Chief Pocatello was the first reference to the name. Liljeblad refuted John Rees' syllabic derivation of the name, reasoning that Rees had simply connected unrelated Shoshoni roots. Liljeblad concluded that Pocatello was not even a Shoshoni word. Chief Pocatello's daughter, Jeanette Lewis, confirmed that the name had no meaning in the Shoshoni language, and that the chief referred to himself as Tondzaosha, meaning "buffalo robe."[4]

[edit]

Pocatello appears in Sid Meier's Civilization V as the playable leader of the Shoshone Civilization.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Pocatello (Shoshone leader)

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Pocatello (c. 1815 – October 1884), also known as the "White Plume," was a headman of the Hukandeka band of the Northwestern Shoshone, whose territory spanned the Great Basin in present-day northwestern Utah and southern Idaho.
By the late 1850s, he had earned leadership of a band numbering around 400 through consensus rather than heredity, directing actions amid increasing white settler encroachment that disrupted traditional Shoshone food sources and migration routes.
In the 1860s, Pocatello orchestrated retaliatory raids on emigrant wagon trains along trails such as the California Trail and against Mormon settlements, including the 1862 incident at Massacre Rocks where ten emigrants were killed, prompting military responses from U.S. forces.
He evaded the Bear River Massacre of January 1863, in which U.S. troops under Colonel Patrick Edward Connor killed approximately 400 Shoshone, and subsequently signed the Box Elder Treaty that year, pledging peace in exchange for annual supplies valued at $5,000—provisions that were frequently undelivered.
Later relocating to the Fort Hall Indian Reservation in Idaho for government aid, Pocatello briefly converted to Mormonism in 1875 before federal authorities compelled his return to the reservation; he died in 1884 and was interred with his possessions and horses in a deep spring in southern Idaho, now submerged under the American Falls Reservoir.
His band's aggressive resistance to cultural disruption from white expansion defined his legacy, as chronicled in historical accounts drawn from settler reports, military records, and Indian agent correspondence, though interpretations vary between viewing him as a defender of his people's way of life or a perpetrator of violence against civilians.

Early Life

Birth and Family Background

Pocatello was born circa 1815 in the Grouse Creek region of present-day northwestern , within the traditional territory of the Northwestern bands who inhabited the and surrounding areas. As a member of these nomadic groups, his early life involved seasonal movements for resources such as roots, berries, fish, and game, including migrations to buffalo hunting grounds in present-day . Historical records indicate that Pocatello was the son of a Shoshone woman captured by Plains Indian raiders—most likely Blackfeet—and subsequently raised among her captors, which exposed him to influences beyond traditional Shoshone practices in the . No specific names for his parents are documented in primary accounts, but this mixed upbringing likely contributed to his eventual prominence as a war leader and band headman, overseeing an initial group of about 15 families by 1847. His band's range extended across parts of modern , , and , reflecting the fluid alliances and territories typical of Northwestern Shoshone kinship networks prior to Euro-American encroachment.

Rise to Leadership Among Northwestern Shoshone

Pocatello, born around 1815 in the Grouse Creek Valley of present-day northwestern , belonged to the Northwestern Band of , a semi-nomadic group ranging across parts of modern , , , and . Traditional was decentralized and consensus-based, with headmen emerging through demonstrated prowess in hunting, warfare, and resource provision rather than hereditary succession. By the late , as Mormon settlers began arriving in the region, Pocatello had already established himself as headman of his band, leading approximately 400 Hukandeka by 1857—a following that expanded to around 1,000 members in subsequent years. His ascent stemmed from reputation as a fearless and resourceful provider, particularly through leading extended buffalo hunts into territories, which secured vital sustenance and prestige among band members facing environmental pressures and competition from neighboring tribes. Pocatello's band operated as one of several autonomous Northwestern groups, alongside those under leaders like Sagwitch and Bear Hunter, prior to the disruptions of the ; his influence grew via successful raids and survival strategies that attracted followers amid declining game and increasing external threats. This organic consolidation of authority reflected cultural norms, where leaders maintained loyalty by delivering tangible benefits like meat from hunts and protection from rivals, without formal titles or centralized power structures.

Conflicts with Settlers

Pre-Mormon Era Interactions

The Northwestern , including bands in the territory later associated with Pocatello, initiated contact with Euro-Americans through the fur trade as early as , when trappers from American and European interests entered their lands in present-day southern and northern . These early interactions were predominantly economic, involving exchanges of pelts, horses, and foodstuffs for manufactured goods such as metal tools, cloth, and firearms, which the Shoshone integrated into their nomadic and gathering lifestyle. Pocatello, born circa 1815 in the Grouse Creek Valley of northwestern Utah, grew up amid these encounters, though records indicate he did not yet hold leadership positions during this period. In 1834, American trader Nathaniel Jarvis Wyeth established as a on the , strategically located in core Northwestern territory to facilitate commerce with local bands. groups, including those in the vicinity of Pocatello's kin, frequented the post for trade, benefiting from access to and goods after Wyeth's initial venture transitioned to British control. Relations remained largely peaceful, with trappers often relying on guides and intelligence for navigating the region's harsh terrain and avoiding rival tribes like the Blackfeet. By the early 1840s, the onset of emigrant traffic along the —beginning with organized wagon trains in 1841—introduced new dynamics, as overland parties depleted game, forage, and water sources traditionally used by hunters. While Pocatello's band is not documented in specific pre-1847 raids, these resource pressures foreshadowed tensions, with isolated thefts of reported but no widespread violence attributed to his group prior to Mormon arrival in the that year. Pocatello assumed formal leadership of a small band of about 15 families around 1847, coinciding with the escalation of settler incursions.

Raids on Immigrant Trails and Early Settlements

In the early 1860s, Pocatello's band of Northwestern conducted raids along key immigrant routes such as the and , targeting emigrant trains in southern as a response to and territorial encroachment by increasing numbers of white travelers and . These actions intensified after the discovery of gold in and in 1862, which drew heavier traffic through Shoshone hunting grounds, destroying game and forage essential to their survival. Specific attacks attributed to Pocatello's warriors occurred in August 1862 near Massacre Rocks and City of Rocks, where they ambushed wagon trains, killing emigrants, wounding others, and seizing and goods. On August 9, 1862, an assault on a train near Massacre Rocks resulted in one death, multiple injuries, and stolen stock, as recorded in emigrant Henry M. Judson's diary; the same day at City of Rocks, an Iowa-bound train endured a prolonged , losing two men wounded and 50 . Over August 8–10, additional strikes hit trains like the Smith Train near , claiming five lives, 11 wagons, and substantial property including $17,500 in cash and 90 head of . These raids forced emigrants to form larger, armed convoys for protection and contributed to the diversion of traffic to safer cutoffs like Goodale's. Raids extended to early settlements and infrastructure, including widespread assaults on stage stations across northern and southern in 1862, disrupting mail and freight routes amid broader retaliation for prior killings of their people and the arrival of U.S. military forces like Johnston's Army in 1858. In one notable incident that year, Pocatello appeared in , with 60 warriors, demanding trade goods and displaying items such as dresses and scalps taken from and immigrants, signaling ongoing hostilities tied to emigrant incursions. Such actions terrorized isolated pioneers but were framed by accounts as provoked defenses against the devastation of their traditional lifeways by overland migration.

Relations with Mormon Settlers

Initial Hostilities and Retaliatory Actions

As expanded into territories, including beginning in 1855, competition intensified for grazing lands, game, and water resources previously used by Pocatello's Northwestern Shoshone band. This encroachment prompted initial hostilities, characterized by demands for food and goods from settlers as compensation for depleted resources, with Pocatello confronting Mormon communities to secure provisions and avert among his people. Retaliatory actions escalated into thefts of horses and property from farms, as bands, under leaders like Pocatello, sought to punish for unprovoked killings of tribesmen and destruction of traditional areas. In one instance, following the killing of two by white men in 1859, Pocatello dispatched a war party that killed six travelers, though such direct violence targeted emigrants more than established Mormon settlements. Reports indicate stole dozens of horses from northern farmers, returning some under pressure but retaining others, reflecting a pattern of raiding to reclaim losses rather than outright warfare against , who often complied with tribute demands to maintain fragile . These actions, while disruptive, were sporadic and economically motivated, with Pocatello's band avoiding large-scale assaults on Mormon villages due to ongoing negotiations and provisions provided by settlers, distinguishing them from broader raids on wagon trains. Tensions peaked amid the (1857–1858), when federal troop movements heightened fears, but Shoshone-Mormon clashes remained limited to property crimes and demands, setting the stage for later diplomatic shifts.

Negotiations and Shift Toward Accommodation

In the early , as raids by Pocatello's band intensified along emigrant trails, Mormon leader implemented a policy of provisioning the with food and goods to avert further violence, reasoning that such measures were more cost-effective than sustained conflict. This strategy aimed to mitigate the pressures of settler expansion, which had depleted game herds essential to Shoshone subsistence, thereby reducing incentives for retaliatory attacks. A notable interaction occurred in 1862 when Pocatello entered Brigham City with approximately 60 warriors, demanding trade items and presenting goods such as dresses alongside scalps taken from immigrants in and , signaling both defiance and a willingness to engage directly with settlers rather than solely through raids. This episode underscored ongoing tensions but also marked an early, albeit coercive, form of amid the broader context of Mormon-Shoshone exchanges facilitated by Young's appeasement efforts. The on January 29, 1863, conducted by U.S. Army Colonel against a encampment led by Chief Bear Hunter, resulted in over 250 Native deaths and dismantled a key rival leadership structure, leaving Pocatello—who had fled the site—as a prominent surviving figure among the Northwestern Shoshone. This devastating federal military intervention demonstrated the asymmetry in firepower, compelling Pocatello to recalibrate from confrontation to pragmatic accommodation to safeguard his band's survival against further incursions. In response, Pocatello began advocating for cessation of hostilities in exchange for restitution addressing the ecological and territorial losses inflicted by settlement and traffic, aligning with Young's provisioning model while prioritizing preservation over prolonged resistance. This pivot reflected a causal recognition that unyielding raids invited , as evidenced by the massacre's toll, and opened pathways for formalized agreements that balanced minimal concessions with .

Diplomatic Efforts and Treaties

Treaty of Box Elder (1863)

The Treaty of Box Elder, signed on July 30, 1863, at Box Elder in Utah Territory (present-day Brigham City), established peace between the United States and the Northwestern Bands of Shoshone following years of conflict exacerbated by settler encroachment and the Bear River Massacre of January 1863, which killed between 200 and 400 Shoshone. Negotiated by James Duane Doty, Governor of Utah Territory and acting Superintendent of Indian Affairs, the agreement mirrored terms from the earlier Fort Bridger Treaty with Eastern Shoshone bands, aiming to secure safe passage for emigrants, military, and infrastructure through Shoshone lands. Chief Pocatello, as a leading figure among the Northwestern Shoshone, played a central role in the negotiations and affixed his mark as one of the principal signatories representing ten bands, alongside eight other chiefs. The treaty's key provisions included re-establishing "friendly and amicable relations," granting the rights to construct roads, military posts, telegraph lines, and railroads across defined Shoshone territories bounded on the west by the Raft River and on the east by the Portneuf Mountains, without explicit land cession by the Shoshone. ) In exchange, the U.S. committed to providing immediate relief goods and an annual of $5,000 worth of , provisions, and other necessities to compensate for disrupted grounds and resources. Although ratified by the U.S. Senate, the treaty's implementation fell short, with annuities often undelivered and leading to further territorial displacement for the bands despite the absence of formal land title extinguishment. Pocatello's agreement marked a strategic shift toward accommodation amid diminishing traditional lifeways, temporarily halting hostilities and facilitating Mormon settlement expansion in northern . Later legal challenges, including Northwestern Shoshone claims before the Indian Claims Commission, resulted in partial compensation in 1968 for unfulfilled obligations, though without restoring .

Subsequent Agreements and Alliances

Following the Treaty of Box Elder, Pocatello pursued ongoing negotiations with U.S. Indian agents to secure annuities and provisions promised under the agreement, as congressional failure to appropriate funds left the Northwestern increasingly destitute amid rapid settler encroachment and depletion of traditional food sources. By the mid-1870s, with game scarce and starvation prevalent, Pocatello consented to the relocation of his band to the in southeastern , joining and Bannock groups already there under the terms of the 1868 Treaty. This administrative arrangement, formalized around 1876 without a new formal treaty, was predicated on federal assurances of rations and protection, reflecting Pocatello's pragmatic accommodation to federal consolidation policies aimed at concentrating nomadic bands on established reservations to facilitate control and resource distribution. The relocation solidified an informal alliance with U.S. authorities, as Pocatello's band upheld the peace commitments of 1863 by refraining from raids and cooperating with reservation agents, even as rations often fell short of needs and exacerbated hardships. This stance contrasted with unrest among other subgroups and avoided entanglement in conflicts like the 1878 , preserving fragile federal support amid broader pressures from railroad expansion and mining booms that further fragmented lands. Pocatello's emphasized survival through compliance rather than resistance, though it yielded no additional land reservations or enforceable rights for the Northwestern bands, underscoring the treaty's limitations in protecting aboriginal territories.

Identity and Name

Traditional Shoshone Name and Significance

Pocatello's traditional name in the language was Tondzaosha (also rendered as Tonaioza), which translates to "buffalo robe." This personal name, used among his band of Northwestern (Hukandeka), predated the anglicized moniker "Pocatello" adopted by white settlers and is attested in oral histories and early ethnographic accounts as his primary identifier within tribal contexts. The literal meaning evokes the buffalo, a central resource for sustenance, clothing, and ritual, underscoring how indigenous names often derived from natural elements or personal attributes tied to survival in the environment. Historical records indicate Pocatello held multiple names over his lifetime, with "" being the most commonly referenced, potentially signifying a youthful event or characteristic, though precise etymological origins remain undocumented beyond linguistic translation. As a band leader by the , this name carried authority in intratribal affairs, distinguishing him from other chiefs like Sagwitch or Bear Hunter in negotiations and networks.

Origins and Interpretations of "Pocatello"

The name "Pocatello," by which the leader became known to Anglo-American settlers and in the mid-19th century, bears no direct relation to his traditional Shoshone appellation, Tondzaosha (alternatively rendered as Tonaioza), which translates to "buffalo robe" in Shoshone, referencing a garment or personal characteristic associated with him. This native name is attested in Shoshone dictionaries compiled during early interactions, such as Joseph A. Gebow's lexicon, and corroborated by the chief's daughter, who emphasized its descriptive origin tied to buffalo hide attire. Linguistic analysis indicates that "Pocatello" lacks roots in Shoshone or closely related Bannock languages, which notably lack the phoneme /l/ and would require phonetic adaptation for such a form; the chief's daughter explicitly stated it held no meaning in her language. A persistent folk etymology posits a breakdown into Shoshone elements—po ("road" or "trail"), ka ("not"), and tello ("to follow")—yielding interpretations like "he does not follow the road" or "one who will not keep the middle of the road," purportedly alluding to the leader's independent or raiding tendencies during conflicts over immigrant trails. However, this derivation is unsupported by Shoshone grammar or lexicon, as confirmed by historical linguists, and appears to stem from 19th-century speculation rather than empirical attestation; modern Shoshone borrowings like Pokendada derive inversely from English usage, not vice versa. Alternative hypotheses trace "Pocatello" to non- influences, such as a Bannock rendering (given the chief's alliances with that tribe) or a possible Ute-language equivalent, reflecting intertribal naming practices among Numic-speaking peoples. Early records, including Frederick W. Lander's expedition accounts, variantize it as "Pocatara" and speculate ties to descriptors like "white plume" (poca from terms for "white" and orra for "quill"), though interpreters' limitations and absence of verified equivalents undermine this. Overall, the name's adoption likely arose from phonetic approximations by English speakers during treaties and surveys in the 1850s–1860s, evolving into a fixed identifier despite its opaque , which persists without scholarly consensus.

Later Years

Post-Treaty Leadership and Band Survival

Following the Treaty of Box Elder in 1863 and subsequent agreements, Pocatello relocated his band of approximately 1,000 Northwestern to the in southeastern , where they faced severe challenges to survival amid disrupted traditional economies. The U.S. government promised annual supplies valued at $5,000, but deliveries were inconsistent, exacerbating hunger and dependence on inadequate rations. This led Pocatello's people to resume raiding and plundering for resources, as reservation lands proved insufficient for sustaining their horse-based, foraging lifestyle amid encroaching settlement and declining buffalo herds. In a bid to secure food and stability, Pocatello led his band in May 1875 to , where they sought into the Mormon Church and assistance from George Hill's farm; however, federal troops compelled their return to due to opposition from local non-Mormon settlers. This episode highlighted Pocatello's pragmatic leadership in pursuing alliances for survival, though it underscored the band's precarious position between federal policies and settler pressures. Despite these efforts, the endured ongoing and cultural erosion on the overcrowded reservation, which spanned 1.8 million acres but supported multiple bands with limited . By the late 1870s, Pocatello gradually withdrew from active leadership in reservation affairs, reflecting the toll of unfulfilled treaty obligations and the erosion of his authority amid collective hardships. His band's survival hinged on adaptive measures like intermittent raiding and opportunistic diplomacy, yet systemic failures in annuity distribution perpetuated vulnerability, contributing to a population decline from pre-contact estimates through disease, conflict, and starvation. Pocatello's tenure thus exemplified the causal link between territorial dispossession via treaties and the protracted struggle for Shoshone autonomy and sustenance in the post-treaty era.

Death and Succession

Pocatello died in October 1884 on the , after having withdrawn from tribal leadership and reservation affairs in his final years amid ongoing hunger and disillusionment with unfulfilled promises and Mormon influences. Per his explicit instructions, his body—dressed in full regalia and accompanied by clothing, guns, knives, and hunting gear—was bound together and lowered into a deep, bottomless spring near Bannock Creek in southern , where he had resided; eighteen horses were then slaughtered and rolled into the spring atop the bundle as part of traditional funerary rites. Leadership among Shoshone bands, including Pocatello's Hukandeka group, was not hereditary but earned through demonstrated ability, influence, and accomplishments in warfare, hunting, and , leading to fluid transitions rather than designated succession upon a chief's death or withdrawal. No single successor is documented for Pocatello's band post-1884; by then, many Northwestern had dispersed or integrated into reservation structures at , with affairs handled by emergent leaders or councils amid declining traditional autonomy.

Legacy and Assessments

Contributions to Shoshone Preservation

Pocatello's primary contribution to Shoshone preservation lay in his strategic following the on January 29, 1863, where U.S. forces under Colonel killed approximately 250 to 400 Northwestern , decimating related bands. By relocating his band preemptively, Pocatello evaded the attack, preserving a core group of warriors and families estimated at around 150 fighters, which allowed his leadership to endure amid widespread tribal losses from conflict and starvation. This maneuver, informed by intelligence on military movements, shifted from retaliatory raids—conducted to reclaim resources depleted by emigrant trains and settlers—to negotiations that prioritized survival over continued warfare, which risked total eradication given the imbalance in firepower and numbers. Through the Treaty of Box Elder, signed on July 30, 1863, Pocatello and other chiefs ceded two-thirds of traditional hunting grounds in southern Idaho and northern Utah in exchange for $5,000 annually in supplies and $2,000 in immediate aid, halting attacks on overland trails and securing temporary respite from U.S. military reprisals. Although federal deliveries were inconsistent, leading to persistent hunger and sporadic raids into the 1860s, the agreement formalized peace, enabling Pocatello's band to regroup rather than face annihilation campaigns like those post-Bear River. He further advanced preservation via the Fort Bridger Treaty of July 3, 1868, committing to the Fort Hall Reservation along the Snake River in Idaho, which established a designated land base of approximately 1.8 million acres for Shoshone-Bannock groups, despite overcrowding and unkept promises of food annuities. This relocation, delayed until the mid-1870s through diplomatic maneuvering—including brief alliances with Mormon settlers for aid—prolonged nomadic hunting practices before full settlement, mitigating immediate cultural collapse. On the reservation, Pocatello maintained authority until his death in 1884, fostering band cohesion amid adaptation to confined lands and government oversight, which laid groundwork for the -Bannock Tribes' continuity. In the late 1870s, he authorized a railway right-of-way across , potentially introducing economic opportunities like employment, though primarily benefiting external interests; this pragmatic concession reflected efforts to integrate without full assimilation, preserving tribal identity as evidenced by ongoing traditions documented in tribal records. His leadership thus transitioned the band from existential threat to institutional survival, averting the fate of unreserved groups extinguished by unchecked expansion.

Criticisms and Controversial Actions

Pocatello directed raids against Mormon settlements and emigrant wagon trains in the 1850s and early 1860s, amid escalating territorial encroachments that depleted Shoshone food sources and hunting grounds. These operations, which involved theft of horses and livestock as well as fatalities among travelers, prompted U.S. military reprisals, including Colonel Patrick Edward Connor's Bear River Massacre in January 1863, where over 250 Northwestern Shoshone were killed in response to attributed attacks. From the settler perspective, Pocatello embodied the archetype of a hostile "outlaw chief," feared for orchestrating violence along routes like the Oregon Trail and Pony Express lines during the Civil War era, though empirical accounts indicate the raids targeted fewer victims relative to the scale of migration and were often retaliatory rather than unprovoked massacres. Contemporary white accounts criticized Pocatello for perpetuating a cycle of strife that hindered regional development, with some labeling his band as "fierce and bloodthirsty" for killings that, while numbering in the dozens across multiple incidents, fueled demands for subjugation. oral histories and later analyses counter that such actions were survival imperatives against starvation induced by overland traffic and settler grazing, which reduced buffalo and other game by up to 90% in affected valleys by 1860; nonetheless, Pocatello's strategic tolerance of sporadic violence post-treaty has drawn scrutiny for undermining long-term autonomy. The 1863 Treaty of Box Elder, signed July 30 after Pocatello's brief detention by Connor, remains contentious: critics among Native advocates argue it represented coerced capitulation, yielding vague land acknowledgments without enforceable protections and exposing bands to reservation confinement by 1878, while U.S. interpretations treated it as mere amity without ceding , as affirmed in the 1945 ruling Northwestern Bands of Indians v. . This accord halted overt hostilities but invited unfulfilled annuity promises, highlighting Pocatello's pragmatic yet divisive choice to prioritize immediate survival over prolonged resistance.

Enduring Impact and Modern Views

Chief Pocatello's most prominent enduring impact is the naming of , after him in 1889, reflecting his earlier grant of a right-of-way through Shoshone lands to the Utah Northern Railroad in the 1870s, which facilitated regional development. The city, now home to over 55,000 residents and serving as an educational and transportation hub with , perpetuates his name amid the very settler expansion his band resisted. Commemorations include a erected in Pocatello between 2005 and 2008 to honor his leadership and promote reconciliation between tribal members and non-Natives, as well as historical markers detailing his role in Shoshone resistance and survival near sites like Massacre Rocks. Within Shoshone-Bannock tribal contexts, Pocatello is remembered as a preserver of his people's continuity, with his story featured at the Shoshone-Bannock Tribal Museum in , , and the Shoshone Cultural Center, emphasizing his strategic relocation of the band to evade the 1863 and subsequent treaty negotiations that secured partial survival on the Reservation established in 1868. Descendants, such as tribal members Jan and Nancy Naki, portray him as a spiritually guided protector who prioritized band welfare amid resource scarcity and unfulfilled federal promises of annual supplies under the 1863 Treaty of Box Elder and 1868 Treaty. Modern historical assessments view Pocatello as a pragmatic leader who adapted to overwhelming settler and military pressures, conducting retaliatory raids—such as those on emigrant trains in 1862—only after provocations like livestock theft and habitat loss, then shifting to to avert his band's annihilation following the Bear River events that killed 250–400 . Historians like W. Paul Reeve describe him not as an aggressor but as responding to existential threats, contrasting with 19th-century settler accounts that depicted him as a raider; this duality persists, with Native perspectives lauding his foresight and settler-descended views acknowledging his outmaneuvering of U.S. forces for survival. Scholarly works, including Brigham D. Madsen's 1986 , underscore his role in delaying total subjugation of the Northwestern until his death in 1884.

References

  1. https://historytogo.utah.gov/pocatello-chief/
  2. https://archivesspace.lib.utah.edu/repositories/3/archival_objects/232034
  3. https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=108331
  4. https://www.idahostatejournal.com/news/local/chief-pocatello-remembered/article_f0f86a6c-b0a5-521b-9d6f-f7f33e179c2f.html
  5. https://history.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/2018/08/0037.pdf
  6. https://www.thelatinlibrary.com/chron/civilwarnotes/pocatello.html
  7. https://nwbshoshone.com/about/history/
  8. http://idaho.untraveledroad.com/Bannock/Pocatello/31WSign.htm
  9. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=9338&context=etd
  10. https://www.postregister.com/chronicle/news/oregon-trail---part-3-fort-hall/article_79e07621-d72e-5e87-96fe-8ca467ac7447.html
  11. https://www.legendsofamerica.com/id-forthall/
  12. http://freebooks.uvu.edu/NURS3400/index.php/ch09-shoshone-culture.html
  13. https://www.oregonencyclopedia.org/articles/fur_trade_in_oregon_country/
  14. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/25203406/chief_tondzaosha-pocatello
  15. https://history.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/0234.pdf
  16. https://www.kfhmuseum.org/2023/09/08/chief-pocatello-at-brigham-city/
  17. https://issuu.com/utah10/docs/uhq_volume63_1995_number2/s/165458
  18. https://thesimonscenter.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Ethics-Symp-2019-p11-21.pdf
  19. https://issuu.com/utah10/docs/uhq_volume35_1967_number1/s/104118
  20. https://mendonutah.org/history/cv/military/military-history-cc.htm
  21. https://blog.cedsolutions.com/648/today-in-military-history-treaty-of-box-elder-signed/
  22. https://utahindians.org/archives/shoshone/history.html
  23. https://historytogo.utah.gov/uhg-history-american-indians-ch-2/
  24. https://blog.oup.com/2013/07/treaty-of-box-elder-shoshones/
  25. https://www.govinfo.gov/link/statute/13/664
  26. https://ictnews.org/archive/native-history-shoshone-massacred-then-signed-treaty-that-helped-mormons/
  27. https://www.wyohistory.org/encyclopedia/coming-wind-river-eastern-shoshone-treaties-1863-and-1868
  28. https://grousecreek.com/chief-pocatello/
  29. https://www.idahostatejournal.com/opinion/columns/untangling-the-complicated-history-of-pocatellos-name/article_b83749bf-217a-5e38-9cfc-60b24ecd73da.html
  30. http://www.native-languages.org/definitions/pocatello.htm
  31. https://wheninyourstate.com/idaho/the-shoshone-chief-who-outmaneuvered-a-u-s-colonel-and-saved-his-people/
  32. https://indianz.com/News/2014/08/11/opinion-chief-pocatello-forced.asp
  33. https://www.idahostatejournal.com/opinion/columns/local-history-about-pocatello-is-wrong/article_e6706311-37bb-5099-90fa-6c599955093f.html
  34. https://www.mendonutah.net/history/pocatellos_revenge.htm
  35. https://www.idahostatejournal.com/news/online/who-was-chief-pocatello/article_653cad6e-d752-11df-b5a1-001cc4c03286.html
  36. https://www.hmdb.org/m.asp?m=108286
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.