Hubbry Logo
Kelly TaylorKelly TaylorMain
Open search
Kelly Taylor
Community hub
Kelly Taylor
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Kelly Taylor
Kelly Taylor
Kelly Taylor
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Kelly Taylor
Beverly Hills, 90210 franchise character
Kelly, portrayed by Jennie Garth, matures from adolescence to adulthood.
Portrayed byJennie Garth
Duration
  • 1990–2000
  • 2008–10
  • 2019
First appearance"Class of Beverly Hills" (1990; Beverly Hills, 90210
Last appearance"Rats and Heroes" (2010; 90210)
Created byDarren Star
In-universe information
OccupationOwned "Kelly Taylor Public Relations"
Partner in a clothing store
Volunteer at an AIDS hospice
Manager of a free clinic
Guidance Counselor (spin-off)
ParentsJackie Taylor (deceased on spin-off)
Bill Taylor
Mel Silver (step-father)
SiblingsJoy Taylor (paternal half-sister)
Erin Silver (maternal half-sister)
David Silver (step-brother)
ChildrenUnnamed Child (with Brandon Walsh; miscarried)
Sammy (son, with Dylan McKay)

Kelly Marlene Taylor, portrayed by Jennie Garth, is the lead female character of Beverly Hills, 90210 for the majority of the show's duration. Initially presented as a "spoiled teen vixen",[1] the role was gradually expanded by producers.[2] Subsequently, Kelly became instrumental in launching the first spin-off, was written with a more compassionate demeanor, overcame several perils and personal challenges, and attracted many romantic suitors and triangles. Appearing for the entirety of the series' run, the character is noted for her development from youth to adulthood.

Kelly appears prominently in a majority of the shows that compose the Beverly Hills, 90210 franchise. In addition to her role in launching the spin-off, Melrose Place, Garth was the first performer from the original show to be cast in the third spin-off, 90210. Having appeared in the most series premieres, as well as the most episodes of any figure throughout the continuity, she is the de facto central character of the Beverly Hills, 90210 franchise.

Garth's portrayal has earned recognition from critics and co-stars. In a 1995 article on the actress, TV Guide's Mary Murphy stated that, "Her signature role—the sensitive, seductive, and tortured Kelly Taylor—tapped into the very essence of teenage angst and brought her a huge cult following."[2] Actors Jason Priestley,[3] Grant Show,[4] and Sara Foster[5] have expressed admiration for Garth's work. In a 2009 article, Nellie Andreeva of The Hollywood Reporter called the character of Kelly "organic to 90210's setting."[6]

Jenny Garth sitting at a table signing a poster of Kelly while a young girl stands in front of her smiling
Jennie Garth signing a poster of Kelly for a young fan at a mall in New Jersey

Beverly Hills, 90210

[edit]

Introduction

[edit]

Throughout the course of the first series, Kelly became one of the show's most developed characters. When introduced in 1990, she was presented as, on the surface, a stereotypical spoiled type who placed high value on a posh appearance and material possessions. However, the character would become increasingly layered as the series progressed.[1]

The reasons for Kelly's behavior first started to reveal themselves in episode 7, "Perfect Mom", when Kelly was forced to confront her mother's drug addiction and alcoholism. Several of her friends, particularly the Walsh family and Andrea Zuckerman, first came to appreciate Kelly's difficulties in life when they saw her handle this problem.[7] During episode 13, "Slumber Party,"[8] Kelly revealed that she was taken advantage of by a senior during her freshmen year in high school, which had led to a promiscuous lifestyle and reputation which deeply hurt her self-esteem. The others then began to realize that Kelly had been through more difficulties than they were aware of, and later, she and Andrea would become close friends. When Andrea was pregnant and was contemplating an abortion in season 4, Kelly was one of the primary people she reached out to.[9]

Progression

[edit]

Toward the end of the second season, Kelly met a man named Jake Hanson (played by Grant Show), an emotionally guarded biker who was slightly older than her. While Jake ultimately resisted their romance, citing Kelly's age, he admitted to admiring her for her heart and kindness. This story line was used to launch the spin-off series Melrose Place.[10] Eventually, Kelly was revealed to have a notable conscience during a summer fling with Dylan McKay, the boyfriend of her friend Brenda, often being the voice of reason during their affair.[11] Kelly went through a period of minor depression during her senior year in high school in season 3. The stress caused from her love for Dylan, someone who she could not be with because of his relationship with Brenda, added to her struggles. Even when Kelly dated Dylan out in the open, following his relationship with Brenda, it caused her to temporarily lose Brenda as a friend.[12]

Also during this time, Kelly's mother had a new baby, Erin, got married, and put Kelly's childhood home up for sale. Self-consciousness over her figure, along with the anxiety she began to feel, caused her to lash out emotionally, abuse diet pills, and briefly lose control over her life.[13] The character's physical appearance is shown to play a part in her development. At various points of the series, she won the title of Spring Princess at a dance and was voted her school's most beautiful girl. Kelly is aware of her appeal, but not to the point of conceit; instead, she is sometimes shown to be troubled by it. At one point, she entered a phase in which she felt that no one took her seriously, which was heightened when Dylan gave his manuscript to Andrea for review instead of to her. During this time, she began to feel that people only liked her because she was physically attractive.[14]

Creator Darren Star has commented on the character's progression.[15] In his DVD commentary of the episode "Spring Dance", Star notes Kelly's first attempt to romance Brandon Walsh,[16] in which she'd embraced her role as Spring Princess and used a largely forward and aggressive approach. He goes on to state that in the fourth season, when Kelly was prone to expressing her affections in a more gentle and compassionate manner,[17] she made a greater impression on Brandon. While pursuing Jake on Melrose Place, a confused Kelly eventually asks, "Don't you think I'm pretty?" This contrasts with her attitude one year later, when she becomes more interested in having others appreciate her for what lies beneath the surface.[14] This development is standardized one additional year later, via her aforementioned second pursuit of Brandon Walsh, which ends in success.

Rise in prominence

[edit]

The evolution of Kelly's character led to developments both on-screen and off. In a 1995 article on Garth, TV Guide reported that the show's creators made a conscious decision to place her character at center stage. An anonymous producer cites "faith in Jennie as an actress," further stating that he and producer Aaron Spelling "knew she had the chops to do it."[2] This development would gradually lead to Kelly supplanting Brenda as the prominent female lead, as the former received what the producer called "better story lines."[2] Reportedly, these matters became a source of tension between Garth and Shannen Doherty, who played Brenda.[2] Following Doherty's final appearance on the show in 1994, however, Garth stated, "We were friends at work, and I miss her most of the time."[18]

The approach of season 3 marked the beginning of Kelly's rise from supporting player to the main character.

Ultimately, throughout the first five seasons, Kelly gained an increasing degree of screen presence and growth. Amidst her continuing development,[19] her role in launching the spin-off, her prominent triangle with Brenda and Dylan,[20] her later affections with male lead Brandon,[21] and the launch of a second triangle with Brandon and Dylan,[22] Kelly became the character that several major events or changes were based around. Additionally, she was given varying involvement in noted story lines not surrounding her—including Dylan's family trauma, Brenda's acting pursuits, and David's recovery from drug use.[23][24] Her status would become standardized throughout the course of the series' run.[1]

In addition to Melrose Place, she would later be used to help launch the third spin-off, 90210 (with Garth being the first performer from the original show to be cast).[25] This development would make Kelly Taylor the most prominent figure in the collective franchise, via the most appearances in episodes and series premieres.[26][27] Shannen Doherty, who returned as Brenda in the third spin-off, reported that she and Garth, like their characters, had renewed their friendship, stating, "Now we’re really good friends—and I love her."[28]

Adulthood

[edit]

Kelly faced several difficult issues and obstacles, often with the assistance of loved ones, including her occasionally difficult home life, her alcoholic mother and absent father. She also was trapped in a fire and burned, tricked into joining a cult,[29] and became addicted to cocaine and going to rehab.[30] In addition, she was stalked by a girl from rehab and who tried to kill her in a double suicide, she was shot in a drive by after which she endured getting amnesia,[31] she was raped then shot her rapist in self-defense,[32] becoming unexpectedly pregnant and having a miscarriage, and learning that it would be difficult for her to have children because of a condition called endometriosis.[33] In overcoming these matters, she was able to become a better person and help others.[34]

Tori Spelling's Donna Martin and Kathleen Robertson's Clare Arnold were among Kelly's best friends and roommates. Tiffani Thiessen's Valerie Malone, who replaced Brenda, became Kelly's nemesis, but right before Valerie's departure, the two women formed a truce.[35]

Kelly's two most prominent romantic relationships were with Jason Priestley's Brandon and Luke Perry's Dylan. In season 5, she was faced with making a choice between the two, as a result of Brandon proposing and Dylan confessing his feelings for her and asking her to leave with him on a trip around the world. She declined to choose between the two men at that time, instead stating, "I choose me," but also affirming her love for both of them. In the seventh season, however, she finally stated that she had chosen Brandon.[36] She nearly married Brandon, but the two decided that they were not ready.[37] Following Jason Priestley's departure from the series, Jennie Garth became the officially billed lead, with the character of Kelly further maturing, reuniting romantically with Dylan, and starting her own PR firm.

Melrose Place

[edit]

For the launch of the series Melrose Place in 1992, Jennie Garth made a multi-episode special guest appearance. During the final episodes of Beverly Hills, 90210 season 2, Grant Show played his Melrose Place character Jake, who started a relationship with Kelly which led into early episodes of the spin-off. During Kelly's appearances, her relationship with Jake was largely on-and-off due to his discomfort with her youth. In the end, after weeks of trying to break up with Kelly, Jake pretended to cheat on her, prompting her to leave him.[38] Afterward on both Beverly Hills, 90210 and Melrose Place, Kelly, Donna, Jake, and others made occasional comments concerning Kelly and Jake's brief relationship.

90210

[edit]

In 2008, Kelly Taylor returned in the spin-off 90210, now working as a guidance counselor at her alma mater West Beverly Hills High School. It was revealed that in the intervening years, she attained a master's degree and had a son named Sammy with Dylan. She and Dylan ended their relationship soon after. It was also revealed that West Beverly principal Harry Wilson was Kelly's neighbor growing up.[39]

Kelly's tenuous relationship with her mother Jackie (Ann Gillespie) continued in the series' first season, with tension arising due to Jackie's drunken negligence of Erin, a recurring character in the original series and a regular in the spin-off.[40] She also resumed her friendship with Brenda Walsh. However, their relationship was briefly strained by Kelly's and possibly Brenda's lingering feelings for former boyfriend Dylan McKay, as well as Brenda sleeping with Kelly's ex-boyfriend, Ryan Matthews, a teacher at West Beverly.[41] Following Brenda's discovery that she could not have children, she and Kelly made amends once again.[42]

On the night of Donna's moving-back party, Kelly and Ryan met at a convenience store. She was told by a fortune teller that she would meet a man with a six-pack. In his hands, Ryan was holding a six-pack of beer. Kelly and Ryan then went to his apartment, where they were last seen making out.[43] Ultimately, she and Ryan chose not to pursue a romantic relationship.

In the second season, Kelly began to spend more time with Harry, much to the chagrin of his wife Debbie. It was implied that both Kelly and Harry had begun to develop feelings for each other. However, Garth refused to participate in a proposed story line involving an affair.[44] Upon learning that Jackie was dying of cancer, Kelly was initially distant from her mother and protective of Erin (who is commonly called by her surname Silver), eventually causing Silver to move out and live with Jackie. The day after Silver's "half-birthday," Jackie was admitted to the hospital. After talking to Silver, Kelly gained the strength to visit their mother. Eventually, Kelly and Jackie made amends before Jackie's untimely death. Garth departed the series following season 2, later citing problems with the newly appointed show-runner, Rebecca Sinclair, and the direction the show took.[45] Although not written out after her last appearance, she was mentioned several times later in the show, indicating that she was still around looking after her sister, just not on screen.[46]

BH90210

[edit]

Reception

[edit]
The character Naomi Clark (AnnaLynne McCord, left), of 90210, has been compared to Kelly Taylor.

With regard to Garth's long-running portrayal, Nellie Andreeva of The Hollywood Reporter acknowledged the character of Kelly as being "organic to 90210's setting,” in a 2009 article.[6] On November 24, 2008, SOAPnet aired a Beverly Hills, 90210 marathon titled "Kelly's Leftovers,” dedicated to the character's love life.[47] While discussing the Melrose Place spin-off in a 2009 interview, Grant Show, who played Jake Hanson in the original, communicated that he would be open to appearing, if Jennie Garth did so as Kelly Taylor.[4] After being confirmed to direct a season one episode of the spin-off, 90210, Jason Priestley commented that he hoped Jennie Garth would be among the actors present.[3] Sara Foster, who was cast as Jen Clark in the spin-off, has stated that she was excited and nervous about meeting Garth, who she'd watched in the original series.[5]

In its biographical article on the actress, Yahoo! states that "playing the popular tramp-turned-good girl Kelly through the years afforded Garth the opportunity to not only grow up on camera in front of America, but to fully develop her character and improve her acting chops each season."[48] Additionally, Kelly Taylor has been cited by the media as an inspiration for the character Naomi Clark (AnnaLynne McCord), introduced in 90210.[49][50] On September 2, 2010 (9/02/10), Reuters.com featured an article on the original series, quoting a Twitter message in which Garth stated, "Love to the original cast and crew. And the new kids too."[51]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Kelly Taylor

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Kelly Marlene Taylor is a fictional protagonist and lead female character in the American teen drama television series Beverly Hills, 90210 (1990–2000), portrayed by actress Jennie Garth. Introduced as a spoiled, affluent socialite and the most popular girl at West Beverly Hills High School, Taylor resides with her neglectful mother and grapples with family dysfunction from the outset. Her storylines prominently feature a high-profile love triangle with bad-boy Dylan McKay and newcomer Brenda Walsh, alongside evolving relationships with other suitors like Brandon Walsh and later partners such as Colin Robbins and Matt Durning. Over the series' ten seasons, Taylor undergoes substantial character development, transitioning from a superficial, status-obsessed teen to a more resilient and responsible adult who confronts traumas including , , and , while co-founding a with friend . The character recurs in crossover appearances on and reprise roles in the 2008 spin-off 90210 as a guidance counselor, underscoring her enduring centrality to the franchise. Garth's portrayal earned her recognition as an emblem of teen television, blending vulnerability with tenacity amid the show's exploration of privilege and consequence in Beverly Hills society.

Character Overview

Introduction and Background

Kelly Taylor is a fictional character and the central female protagonist of the Fox teen drama series Beverly Hills, 90210, portrayed by Jennie Garth across all ten seasons from 1990 to 2000. As a student at West Beverly Hills High School, Taylor is depicted as the archetype of a popular, attractive blonde preoccupied with fashion, social status, and peer dynamics in the affluent Beverly Hills setting. Her character embodies the tensions of adolescent life, blending superficiality with underlying emotional depth. Taylor's background features family instability that shapes her early vulnerabilities, including an absent father and a mother grappling with , fostering an insecure home life. Introduced as somewhat bratty and competitive, she befriends newcomer Brenda Walsh while displaying initial and , highlighting her self-focused traits amid a desire for stability often sought through friendships. These elements position her as a "defrosting ," evolving from popularity-driven decisions to greater personal insight. Throughout the series, Taylor's narrative arc underscores resilience, as she confronts hardships that test her confidence and empathy, marking her transition from a stereotypical high school elite to a more mature figure. Garth's portrayal, which propelled her to , captured this progression in a show that became a cultural for exploring teen issues in a privileged context.

Creation and Casting

Jennie Garth was cast as Kelly Taylor at age 18 for the role in , a teen drama series created by and produced by Aaron Spelling's company for the network. The character was conceived as part of an ensemble representing affluent students, forming a tight-knit group of friends amid explorations of social issues, with Kelly positioned as the popular, blonde archetype often involved in romantic and peer conflicts. Star, drawing loosely from his own high school experiences, emphasized developing relatable teen dynamics in the pilot script he wrote, which debuted on October 4, . The casting process prioritized relatively unknown young actors to authentically depict adolescents, with Garth selected to embody Kelly's evolution from a somewhat superficial to a more complex figure over the series' run. Garth later reflected that aspects of her personal background merged with the character's scripted traumas, contributing to the portrayal's longevity across all 10 seasons from 1990 to 2000.

Appearances in Beverly Hills, 90210

High School Years (Seasons 1-4)

Kelly Taylor appears as a central character from the series premiere of , portraying a junior at West Beverly Hills High School who embodies the archetype of the popular, attractive student navigating social hierarchies and personal insecurities. Introduced alongside her longtime friend , Kelly quickly befriends the Walsh twins, and Brandon, who have recently relocated from , integrating them into her circle despite initial cultural clashes. Her early storylines highlight family dysfunction, particularly her mother Jackie's issues, which surface during events like a school where Jackie's impaired behavior embarrasses Kelly and draws attention from her peers. A pivotal moment in season 1 occurs in the episode "," where Kelly confides in about a traumatic date-rape with her ex-boyfriend Ross Webber, a senior who exploited her trust, marking an early exploration of her vulnerability beneath her poised exterior. This revelation underscores Kelly's guarded nature and contributes to her relational hesitancy, as seen in her brief romance with Steve Sanders, which ends amid typical teenage conflicts by the spring dance. Throughout seasons 1 and 2, Kelly grapples with her mother's escalating drug problems and , forcing her to assume adult responsibilities, including interventions that strain their bond but foster Kelly's resilience. Her absent father, Bill Taylor, further exacerbates feelings of abandonment, though his influence remains peripheral during high school. By season 3, Kelly's romantic arc intensifies with the emergence of a mutual attraction to , evolving into a serious relationship that sets the stage for the iconic with Walsh, testing loyalties within the group. This period showcases Kelly's growth from superficial to a more emotionally complex figure, balancing academic pressures, peer dynamics, and budding maturity. In season 4, tragedy strikes during a clandestine rave hosted by , where a house fire traps Kelly, resulting in second- and third-degree burns to her right wrist, ear, neck, and face, profoundly impacting her and future aspirations in modeling. Despite physical recovery, the incident amplifies her insecurities, culminating in the group's high school graduation, a milestone that transitions her toward amid lingering trauma. These years establish Kelly as a character defined by adversity, from sexual trauma and familial neglect to physical scarring, shaping her evolution through empirical challenges rather than unexamined privilege.

College and Relationship Turbulence (Seasons 5-7)

In season 5, Kelly enrolls at California University alongside her friends, but her transition to college life is immediately complicated by physical and emotional recovery from severe burns sustained during a house fire at the end of the previous season, affecting her right wrist, ear, and the entire right side of her neck. These injuries lead her to develop an to prescription painkillers, exacerbating her vulnerability to manipulation. She enters a relationship with , who proposes marriage early in the season, but Kelly declines, citing her unreadiness amid ongoing personal instability. Kelly's entanglement with Patrick Finley, a charismatic figure leading a pseudo-spiritual organization with cult-like characteristics, further disrupts her relationship with Brandon, as Finley pressures her to sever ties with her past life and influences her to break up with Brandon. Brandon and eventually intervene to extract her from the group, highlighting the coercive dynamics at play. Her painkiller dependency intensifies during this period, contributing to erratic behavior and strained friendships, though she begins addressing it through support from peers like . Transitioning into season 6, Kelly briefly leaves for a modeling assignment in New York before returning with a new boyfriend, artist Colin Robbins, whose own substance issues draw her into cocaine use, deepening her struggles. The relationship with Colin proves volatile, marked by his infidelity and mutual drug-fueled conflicts, ultimately ending in betrayal and contributing to Kelly's overdose scare. Amid coursework and social pressures, she faces additional threats, including by Tara Marks, a mentally unstable acquaintance who later escalates to violence in subsequent seasons. By season 7, Kelly focuses on academic completion, graduating from California University with her core group of friends, including Brandon. Relationship turbulence peaks as she navigates lingering effects of recovery and briefly discovers she is pregnant, undergoing a that prompts emotional confrontation with her vulnerabilities. She reconciles romantically with Brandon toward the season's end, marking a tentative stabilization after years of relational instability with him, Dylan, and others. Throughout these seasons, Kelly's experiences underscore patterns of seeking validation through tumultuous partnerships while grappling with substance dependency and external manipulations.

Adulthood and Maturity (Seasons 8-10)

In season 8, Kelly Taylor transitions into professional adulthood following her graduation from California University, securing employment at a firm amid struggles common to the group's post-collegiate job search. Recovering from a severe inflicted in the season 7 finale, she undergoes and contends with temporary before regaining her memories, demonstrating resilience in resuming her career and social ties. Her romantic involvement with lawyer Matt Durning deepens, providing stability as she navigates family dynamics, including her father's engagement to Valerie Malone's mother. Kelly's initial reluctance toward an abandoned infant's placement with a gay couple highlights lingering personal biases, though the storyline resolves with her acceptance of the . Season 9 marks Kelly's entry into marriage and motherhood; she weds Matt Durning after a period of , and the couple has a son named Dylan Michael Durning, shifting her focus toward familial responsibilities. Professionally dissatisfied with her partnership in Donna Martin's clothing boutique, Kelly pivots toward independent ventures in . A harrowing occurs when she is raped by a parking valet in an alley en route to meet , leading to emotional withdrawal; she confides in close friends Dylan and Donna, eventually processing the trauma with their support and resuming her daily life. This ordeal underscores her growing capacity for vulnerability and recovery, contributing to her maturation beyond youthful . By season 10, Kelly exhibits further independence, divorcing Matt after discovering his infidelity and assuming primary custody of their son, prioritizing her role as a single mother. Seeking personal growth, she enrolls in a self-improvement led by Professor Gregory Manos, which evolves into a cult-like dependency; intervention by and prompts her exit, reinforcing lessons in discernment and self-reliance. Kelly launches her own firm, symbolizing entrepreneurial maturity and financial autonomy as the series concludes with her established as a capable adult balancing career, , and friendships.

Appearances in Spin-offs and Sequels

Melrose Place Crossover (1997-1998)

Kelly Taylor's only crossover appearances in occurred during the spin-off's inaugural season in 1992, not in 1997–1998. In the pilot episode, aired July 8, 1992, Kelly arrives at the Melrose Place apartment complex seeking to rekindle her romance with Jake Hanson, a former fling from , highlighting the shared universe between the shows. She continues pursuing Jake in episodes 2 ("Friends & Lovers," July 15, 1992) and 3 ("Lost & Found," July 22, 1992), where Jake ultimately ends the relationship due to their age difference and differing life stages, with Kelly portrayed as a high school senior. These brief appearances served primarily to promote to the 90210 audience, establishing Jake's backstory and the apartment complex's connection to Beverly Hills. No verifiable records indicate Kelly Taylor appeared in Melrose Place during its sixth season (September 22, 1997–May 18, 1998). While Melrose Place maintained loose ties to the 90210 franchise through shared producers and occasional references, Kelly's storyline remained confined to Beverly Hills, 90210, focusing on her personal growth, relationships, and business ventures in Beverly Hills during that period. The absence of further crossovers underscores the shows' diverging narratives post-launch, with Melrose Place emphasizing independent adult dramas in rather than integrating original 90210 characters like Kelly beyond the initial hook.

90210 Revival (2008-2013)

Jennie Garth reprised her role as Kelly Taylor in the CW's 90210 spin-off series, which premiered on September 2, 2008, and ran until May 13, 2013.) In this continuation, Kelly is established as the guidance counselor at West Beverly Hills High School, interacting with a new generation of students including Annie Wilson and Naomi Clark. Her character is portrayed as a single mother to a young son named Sammy, fathered by Dylan McKay during an off-screen reconciliation after the original series finale. Kelly's storylines in the first season focus on her professional duties and personal challenges, such as mentoring students amid school dramas and confronting family issues with her mother, Jackie Taylor, who battles . She reunites with Brenda Walsh (), assisting her in directing the school musical after the original director steps down, highlighting their evolved friendship despite past rivalries. Garth appeared in 20 episodes, primarily during season 1 (2008–2009), providing continuity from the original series through guest spots by other alumni like as . Garth departed the series after the first season, citing that Kelly's arc had reached a natural conclusion, with the character moving to for a fresh start away from Beverly Hills. Kelly does not appear in subsequent seasons, though her influence lingers through references to her counseling role and , such as Silver's relation as Jackie's daughter. The portrayal emphasized Kelly's maturity and resilience, drawing from her original character's growth into adulthood.

BH90210 Meta-Series (2019)

BH90210 is a six-episode meta-miniseries that premiered on on August 7, 2019, and concluded on September 12, 2019, featuring heightened, fictionalized versions of the original cast members, including , as they navigate personal dramas while attempting to the iconic teen drama. In this self-referential format, Kelly Taylor does not appear as a standalone character; instead, the series weaves in nostalgic callbacks and direct visual homages to her through Garth's portrayal of a semi-autobiographical "Jennie Garth," who grapples with the lingering shadow of her most famous role. These elements underscore the cultural weight of Taylor's archetype—the affluent, resilient blonde navigating romance, , and peril—while critiquing the that defined Garth's career post-90210. A prominent reference occurs in episode 2, "The Pitch," which opens with a depicting Garth reverted to her teenage Kelly Taylor persona, clad in the character's signature early-1990s fashion amid West Beverly High settings. This sequence rapidly devolves into a surreal nightmare montage replaying Taylor's most traumatic original-series arcs, including her struggles with drug addiction, a shooting at a mall, and involvement, blending humor with exaggeration to lampoon the soap-operatic excess of those storylines. Additional in the episode nod to iconic moments, such as Brian Austin Green's character dedicating Roxette's "Listen to Your Heart" to "Kelly," evoking the season 1 resolution between Taylor, , and Brenda Walsh. Throughout the series, Garth's character voices irritation at being perpetually reduced to the "sexy blonde Kelly Taylor," reflecting real-world perceptions of how the role overshadowed her post-90210 opportunities and fueled . Interpersonal tensions among the versions, such as Garth's fictionalized rift with (mirroring onetime Brandon-Kelly chemistry turned sour), indirectly invoke Taylor's relational dynamics from the original show. The pitch within the revives discussions of Taylor's centrality, positioning her as a for fan , though the meta-layer prioritizes the actors' contemporary lives over literal reprises. This approach yielded mixed reception, with some praising the bold but others critiquing it as unevenly tonally shifting from to .

Portrayal and Performance

Jennie Garth's Interpretation

Jennie Garth initially perceived Kelly Taylor as a stereotypical spoiled Beverly Hills , characterized by entitlement and a desire for instant gratification, which she described as "very cut-and-dry on paper." However, Garth infused the role with elements of her own Midwestern sensibility, delivering lines in a natural, authentic manner that blended vulnerability with the character's surface-level sharpness, transforming Kelly from a one-dimensional into a more relatable figure who endured beneath her "bitch from Beverly Hills" facade. This personal collision, as Garth reflected, was pivotal: "That character and me sort of collided, and that’s how Kelly Taylor became the Kelly Taylor that you know, lasted for 10 years," allowing her to intuitively channel real emotions, such as grief from her father's heart attack, into Kelly's dramatic arcs. Garth found portraying Kelly liberating, embracing the character's unapologetic wit and dry humor—traits she recognized within herself—without reservation, which made the role feel like "an old comfortable sweater" by later seasons. She approached the evolution of Kelly's struggles—grappling with isolation and self-discovery amid traumas like , , and involvement—by drawing on innate , noting that "putting myself in that character’s shoes... came really, really naturally." A defining moment in her interpretation was Kelly's season 5 declaration, "I choose me," rejecting a romantic triangle in favor of self-prioritization, a scripted line that resonated deeply with Garth and evolved into her personal for empowerment and midlife reinvention. Reflecting post-series, Garth acknowledged the role's overshadowing influence on her identity, crediting it for shaping her amid the disorienting effects of early fame, though she later explored this entanglement meta-fictionally in (2019) to process its long-term impact. Despite the character's endurance through 304 episodes of adversity, Garth expressed minor regrets, such as experimenting with unflattering hairstyles during intense periods, but favored the lighter early storylines for their foundational tone. Overall, her portrayal emphasized Kelly's underlying resilience and quest for autonomy, mirroring Garth's own growth from youthful uncertainty to self-assured maturity.

Key Acting Challenges and Evolution

Jennie Garth's portrayal of Kelly Taylor demanded versatility in depicting the character's shift from youthful superficiality to profound adversity, requiring her to navigate increasingly complex emotional terrain over the show's decade-long run from 1990 to 2000. Initially cast at age 19, Garth conveyed Kelly's early high school persona as a privileged yet insecure blonde , focusing on peer rivalries and light romance, but the role evolved to encompass mature themes like family dysfunction and personal reinvention by the years (seasons 5-7, 1994-1997). This progression challenged her to mature onscreen, mirroring her own transition into adulthood amid the production's grueling schedule of 22-30 episodes per season. The most demanding arcs arrived in adulthood phases (seasons 8-10, 1997-2000), where Kelly endured layered traumas including a causing (season 8 premiere, July 30, 1997), cocaine (season 9, 1998-1999), and a graphic by a colleague leading to her fatally the perpetrator (season 9 episodes 24-26, May 1999). Garth's performance in the aftermath episode "Agony" (aired May 19, 1999) showcased raw vulnerability, with Kelly withdrawing into isolation while confiding in confidants, highlighting Garth's ability to portray dissociative shock and tentative recovery without over-dramatization. These storylines, which Garth reportedly advocated for to deepen Kelly's arc beyond "bad things happening to beautiful people," tested her capacity for sustained intensity across physical stunts, addiction simulations, and psychological unraveling. Garth later described the role's toll as exhausting, noting it fostered a "case of " due to the immersive 10-year commitment starting in her late teens, yet profoundly shaped her: "Those 10 years on that show had a very large impact on me as an ." Her evolution as an paralleled Kelly's resilience, transitioning from reactive teen emoting to nuanced depictions of agency amid chaos, such as choosing in pivotal moments like the iconic "I choose me" declaration (season 9 finale, May 26, 1999). This growth enabled Garth to infuse authenticity drawn from personal maturation, though she acknowledged occasional feelings of being underappreciated in the ensemble dynamic.

Reception and Analysis

Critical Perspectives

Critics have observed that Kelly Taylor's initial portrayal as a privileged, superficial in early seasons of evolved into a more nuanced depiction of personal growth amid adversity, with actress noting the character's shift from "cut-and-dry" stereotypes to displaying vulnerability and wit. This development allowed exploration of themes like familial neglect and peer dynamics, though some analyses argue the writers layered excessive hardships—such as cocaine addiction, , and cult involvement—prioritizing dramatic escalation over consistent psychological realism. The season 4 date-rape storyline, involving an by college acquaintance Ross Webber, has elicited mixed responses; while the episode prompted national discussions on during a period of limited media coverage, critics faulted its early dialogue for incorporating victim-blaming elements, including Kelly's self-reproach over her "sexy" dress and the attacker's justification tied to her appearance. Later, the narrative affirmed "no means no" through supportive friends, yet broader commentary on television critiques such casual references to Kelly's trauma in group settings as diminishing the gravity of . Feminist interpretations commend specific arcs, such as Kelly's resolution of the central with and , where she rejects both suitors to focus on , serving as an early example of the "I choose me" trope that challenges patriarchal romantic expectations. However, reviews highlight traits like her intermittent and relational volatility as outdated or problematic by contemporary standards, potentially reinforcing of female instability rather than .

Fan Reception and Debates

Kelly Taylor has elicited divided responses among fans of Beverly Hills, 90210, with many praising her character arc from a superficial high socialite to a resilient adult confronting personal traumas, while others criticize her as whiny, self-righteous, and disloyal, particularly in her romantic entanglements. In fan polls on platforms like , Kelly frequently emerges as the top female character, outranking peers such as and , reflecting her enduring appeal as a central figure in the series' drama. A persistent debate centers on the involving Kelly and Walsh, where fans remain split on whether Dylan belonged with Kelly or , with Kelly's pursuit of Dylan after 's departure to drawing accusations of betrayal from loyalists. , who portrayed Kelly, has acknowledged the intensity of this divide, expressing nervousness about revisiting the storyline in retrospective discussions, as it continues to polarize viewers decades later. Anti-Kelly sentiments on forums highlight her jealousy toward Dylan's family connections and perceived regression in maturity, contrasting with defenses of her underlying vulnerabilities revealed through storylines like drug addiction and . Additional fan disputes include Kelly's friendships, such as her rivalry with Valerie Malone, where supporters debate loyalty amid plot twists, and her evolution's authenticity, with some viewing later seasons' events—like the parking lot shooting—as diminishing her agency. Despite criticisms, Kelly's complexity fosters ongoing engagement, as evidenced by dedicated queries soliciting fans' favorite moments and rationales for admiration, underscoring her status as a multifaceted in teen drama discourse.

Controversial Storylines and Criticisms

Kelly Taylor's narrative frequently incorporated heavy themes such as , , and psychological manipulation, which occasionally sparked debate over their execution and realism. In the season 1 episode "Slumber Party" (aired November 2, 1990), Kelly reveals to her friends that she was raped at age 15 by an older acquaintance, framing it as a formative trauma that influenced her guarded personality. This disclosure was part of the series' early efforts to address and teen vulnerability, but the storyline's later expansion in season 10, where Kelly identifies and confronts her assailant Walter Crenna—leading to his arrest after a struggle—drew criticism for relying on dramatic confrontations over nuanced recovery processes. Another contentious arc involved Kelly's descent into an in season 3 (episodes 14–24, aired January–May 1993), triggered by a classmate's comment on her weight, escalating to , diet pill , and at her 18th birthday party on March 18, 1993 (episode 24). While intended to highlight pressures among affluent youth, the plot was faulted for abrupt resolution—Kelly enters but faces minimal long-term repercussions—undermining the severity of anorexia and bulimia as chronic conditions. Kelly's entanglement with a in seasons 5–6 (prominently episodes 20–32, aired April–October 1995) represented a shift toward elements, as she joins the Wellness Center group under leader Joe Ward's influence, undergoing that strains friendships and leads to her institutionalization. This storyline, inspired by real cult scandals, was criticized as one of the series' most implausible and poorly motivated, portraying Kelly's vulnerability as overly susceptible to manipulation without sufficient buildup, contributing to perceptions of the character as a contrived for escalating drama. Subsequent arcs, including her in season 7 (starting episode 1, aired June 11, 1996) and facial scarring from a fire in season 6 (episode 16, aired February 7, 1996), amplified complaints that writers overburdened Kelly with traumas—ranging from shootings to —rendering her arcs sensationalized rather than substantive.

Cultural Impact and Legacy

Kelly Taylor's storylines, including her season 1 revelation of a childhood in the episode "" (aired October 9, 1990), helped pioneer discussions of in prime-time teen television, confronting viewers with the long-term psychological effects on survivors at a time when such topics were rarely depicted with emotional depth in youth-oriented programming. This narrative arc, alongside arcs involving and recovery in seasons 5–6 (1994–1995), positioned the character as a vehicle for addressing and stigma, influencing how later series like and handled similar traumas. A defining moment of self-prioritization occurred in the ninth-season episode "I Choose You" (aired May 19, 1999), when Kelly declares, "I choose me," rejecting a toxic romantic dynamic in favor of personal healing; later described this line as emblematic of empowerment, noting its adoption by fans as a for independence and boundary-setting. The character's evolution from an initially superficial to a resilient single mother in later seasons underscored themes of personal agency, resonating with audiences navigating post-adolescent challenges and contributing to the of flawed yet redeemable female protagonists in serialized . Garth has credited Kelly's multifaceted portrayal—encompassing vulnerability, sarcasm, and growth—with shaping her own post-90210 career, enabling her to leverage the role's emotional range for advocacy on resilience and family dynamics in subsequent projects. The character's legacy persists through the franchise's expansions, including her appearances as a guidance counselor and mother in the 90210 spin-off (2008–2013) and the meta-series (2019), where archival footage and callbacks reinforced her status as a cultural touchstone for generational and evolving roles in media. Streaming availability on platforms like Paramount+ since 2023 has sustained viewership among new demographics, affirming the show's—and Taylor's—role in defining 1990s while critiquing its excesses.

References

  1. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/31/arts/television/31gart.html
  2. https://www.biography.com/movies-tv/beverly-hills-90210-cast-where-are-they-now
  3. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/beverly-hills-90210-riverdale-actors-remember-luke-perry-1192332/
  4. https://screenrant.com/beverly-hills-90210-kelly-taylor-best-worst-character-traits/
  5. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0001259/bio/
  6. https://variety.com/2017/tv/news/fox-the-mick-jennie-garth-1202631523/
  7. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/news/general-news/beverly-hills-90210-read-thrs-738053/
  8. https://screenrant.com/kelly-taylor-dramatic-character-arc-beverly-hills-90210/
  9. https://www.charactour.com/hub/characters/view/Kelly-Taylor.Beverly-Hills-90210
  10. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/celebrity/jennie_garth
  11. https://ew.com/tv/jennie-garth-reflects-on-mixed-90210-message/
  12. https://www.eonline.com/photos/28634/trashed-dressing-rooms-co-star-couplings-fist-fights-and-firings-secrets-of-the-original-beverly-hills-90210-revealed
  13. https://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/31/arts/television/31star.html
  14. https://interviews.televisionacademy.com/interviews/darren-star
  15. https://lemonadamedia.com/podcast/how-to-choose-yourself-jennie-garth/
  16. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0098749/episodes/?season=1
  17. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0522914/
  18. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0522922/
  19. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0098749/episodes/?season=3
  20. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0522841/
  21. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0098749/episodes/?season=4
  22. https://www.vice.com/en/article/how-90s-tv-shows-got-drugs-hilariously-wrong/
  23. https://www.televisionofyore.com/recaps-of-beverly-hills-90210/beverly-hills-90210-season-5-episode-20
  24. https://teendramawhore.substack.com/p/kelly-taylor-trauma-beverly-hills-90210
  25. https://www.televisionofyore.com/recaps-of-beverly-hills-90210/beverly-hills-90210-season-7-episode-29
  26. https://www.reddit.com/r/BeverlyHills90210/comments/1dd4lf5/kelly_taylor_wins_ranking_brandons_girlfriends/
  27. https://www.televisionofyore.com/recaps-of-beverly-hills-90210/beverly-hills-90210-season-8-episode-23
  28. https://www.theringer.com/2019/08/07/tv/90210-beverly-hills-best-moments
  29. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0522731/
  30. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ocaLrtGc0f8
  31. https://www.tumblr.com/the-daily-90210/59797692079/episode-10x2610x27-the-penultimateode-to-joy
  32. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103491/fullcredits/
  33. https://www.tvmaze.com/characters/90182/melrose-place-kelly-taylor
  34. https://melroseplace.fandom.com/wiki/Pilot
  35. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0103491/episodes/?season=6
  36. https://www.thetvratingsguide.com/2020/04/spinoff-stories-beverly-hills-90210.html
  37. https://www.eonline.com/news/1407502/tori-spelling-reveals-if-she-regrets-90210-reboot-after-jennie-garths-comments
  38. https://90210-usa.fandom.com/wiki/Kelly_Taylor
  39. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1280051/
  40. https://tscpodcast.com/who-is-jennie-garth/
  41. https://www.eonline.com/news/1401776/these-beverly-hills-90210-secrets-are-saucier-than-kissing-your-ex-at-your-best-friends-wedding
  42. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt8179162/
  43. https://www.vulture.com/2019/08/bh90210-review.html
  44. https://screenrant.com/bh-90210-kelly-taylor-easter-eggs-jennie-garth/
  45. https://www.usmagazine.com/celebrity-news/news/bh90210-every-beverly-hills-90210-reference-in-the-quasi-revival/
  46. https://www.tvfanatic.com/bh90210-season-1-episode-1-review-the-reunion/
  47. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/tv/story/2019-08-04/beverly-hills-90210-reboot-fans
  48. https://www.rollingstone.com/tv-movies/tv-movie-reviews/bh90210-review-867673/
  49. https://www.purewow.com/news/jennie-garth-has-this-regret-about-playing-kelly-taylor-on-90210
  50. https://people.com/jennie-garth-looks-back-at-iconic-i-choose-me-line-from-90210-exclusive-8630363
  51. https://ew.com/jennie-garth-reflects-on-iconic-i-choose-me-beverly-hills-90210-line-8630495
  52. https://www.cnn.com/2019/08/15/entertainment/jennie-garth-90210
  53. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-04-09/what-we-can-learn-from-90210-90s-tv-series/12109714
  54. https://uwm.edu/cultures-communities/wp-content/uploads/sites/219/2018/10/The-Careless-Language-Of-Sexual-Violence-The-Rumpus.net_.pdf
  55. https://slate.com/culture/2019/07/i-choose-me-cliche-90210-the-bold-type-crazy-ex-girlfriend.html
  56. https://screenrant.com/beverly-hills-90210-kelly-taylor-character-never-fly-today/
  57. https://www.reddit.com/r/BeverlyHills90210/comments/pl59cj/kelly_taylor_is_the_best_characters_on_90210/
  58. https://www.reddit.com/r/BeverlyHills90210/comments/13jewcp/what_are_your_overall_thoughts_on_kelly_taylor/
  59. https://www.facebook.com/groups/2204895837/posts/10159748383640838/
  60. https://www.quora.com/Were-there-fans-of-Beverly-Hills-90210-that-really-liked-the-horrible-betrayal-of-Dylan-and-Kelly-against-Brenda
  61. https://www.usmagazine.com/entertainment/news/jennie-garth-nervous-to-watch-dylan-kelly-brendas-90210-drama/
  62. https://www.fanforum.com/f265/anti-kelly-taylor-thread-62874959/
  63. https://www.instagram.com/p/CFyYsf1j2fU/
  64. https://www.instagram.com/p/CxoBoGXxvzg/
  65. https://screenrant.com/saddest-moment-each-season-beverly-hills-90210/
  66. https://screenrant.com/beverly-hills-90210-subplots-that-were-werent-wrapped-up/
  67. https://decider.com/2019/02/12/beverly-hills-90210-kelly-taylor-injustices/
  68. https://www.hollywoodoutbreak.com/2025/10/03/remembering-beverly-hills-90210-tvs-most-iconic-teen-drama/
  69. https://www.tvinsider.com/1169926/jennie-garth-90210-what-i-like-about-you-reboot/
  70. https://cordcuttersnews.com/35-years-ago-today-beverly-hills-90210-premieres-on-fox-defining-a-generation/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.