Hubbry Logo
Eardrum (album)Eardrum (album)Main
Open search
Eardrum (album)
Community hub
Eardrum (album)
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Eardrum (album)
Eardrum (album)
from Wikipedia

Eardrum
Studio album by
ReleasedAugust 21, 2007
Recorded2006–2007
GenreHip hop[1]
Label
Producer
Talib Kweli chronology
The Beautiful Struggle
(2004)
Eardrum
(2007)
Revolutions per Minute
(2010)

Eardrum is the third studio album by American hip hop artist Talib Kweli. The album was released on August 21, 2007, by Blacksmith Records and Warner Bros. Records. The album features guest appearances from Res, Jean Grae, UGK, Raheem DeVaughn, Roy Ayers, Kanye West, Norah Jones, Coi Mattison, Lyfe Jennings, will.i.am, Sa-Ra, KRS-One, Musiq Soulchild, Strong Arm Steady, Sizzla, Justin Timberlake and Marsha Ambrosius.

Reception

[edit]
Professional ratings
Aggregate scores
SourceRating
Metacritic73/100[2]
Review scores
SourceRating
AllMusicStarStarStarHalf star[3]
The A.V. ClubA−[4]
Entertainment WeeklyA[1]
NowStarStarStarStarStar[5]
The ObserverStarStarStar[6]
The PhoenixStarStarStar[7]
Pitchfork Media7.4/10[8]
PopMattersStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStar[9]
RapReviewsStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarStarHalf star[10]
Rolling StoneStarStarStar[11]

Critical response

[edit]

Eardrum scored 73 out of 100 from Metacritic based on "generally favorable reviews".[2] Some than most reviews are average or mixed: Uncut gave it a score of three stars out of five and said, "Kweli, whose wordy rhymes can often read better than they flow, sounds nimble and at ease most of the time."[2] Vibe gave it three stars out of five and said it "lacks cohesiveness."[2] Spin gave it a score of five out of ten and said, "Though Kweli can't change his voice he was born with, he needs to figure out how to make it as compelling as his material."[2] Hot Press gave it an above average review, however, and said, "Kweli's collaborative work has set the bar so high that his solo efforts routinely fail to meet these exalted expectations."[12]

Metacritic, XXL gave it a score of XL (the equivalent of four out of five stars) and said, "Unlike 2004's The Beautiful Struggle, which clumsily juxtaposed grungy backpack beats with basic mainstream medleys, Eardrum is a more sonically cohesive endeavor. Having more fun with the music and ignoring his critics, Talib wants to proves about sometimes, the only one worth listening to is yourself".[13] HipHopDX gave it four stars out of five and said, "There is still room for improvement, but this largely the album from Kweli that everyone has been waiting for."[14] AllHipHop gave it a score of 8.5 out of 10 and said it "still delivers enough solid work to be worth checking out no matter what your expectations."[15] About.com gave it a score of four-and-a-half stars out of five and said, "While it's questionable as to whether Eardrum can hold up against his previous classics, it is without a doubt that this is most certainly Talib Kweli’s most effective release to date."[16] AbsolutePunk gave it a score of 74% and said, "Though highly inconsistent due to its extraordinary number of songs, Eardrum impresses as a whole, making the early cop out absolutely unneeded. Talib Kweli refuses to disappoint".[17] Los Angeles Times gave it a favorable review and said, "Kweli's commanding delivery and the well-executed songs on his sixth album... consistently provide pointed commentary... and masterful production".[18]

Commercial performance

[edit]

Eardrum debuted at number 2 on the US Billboard 200, selling 60,000 copies in its first week, marking it as Kweli's highest-debuting album to date. In its second week, the album fell down to number 20, selling 25,000 copies, in total of 85,500 copies in the United States.[19] As of 2013, the album has sold 239,000 copies in United States.[20]

Track listing

[edit]
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
1."Everything Man" (featuring Res)Madlib3:16
2."NY Weather Report"
Nick Speed4:35
3."Hostile Gospel Pt. 1 (Deliver Us)"
Just Blaze5:22
4."Say Something" (featuring Jean Grae)
  • Talib Kweli Green
  • Jean Grae
will.i.am3:43
5."Country Cousins" (featuring UGK & Raheem DeVaughn)
  • A Kid Called Roots
  • Sha-La Shakier
4:31
6."Holy Moly"Talib Kweli GreenePete Rock2:08
7."Eat to Live"
Madlib3:07
8."In the Mood" (featuring Roy Ayers & Kanye West)
  • Talib Kweli Greene
  • Kanye West
  • Brian Potter
Kanye West3:55
9."Soon the New Day" (featuring Norah Jones)
  • Talib Kweli Greene
  • Otis Jackson Jr.
  • Paul Charles
  • John Mason
4:02
10."Give 'Em Hell" (featuring Coi Mattison & Lyfe Jennings)
4:27
11."More or Less" (featuring Dion)
Hi-Tek4:40
12."Stay Around"
  • Talib Kweli Greene
  • Peter Phillips
  • Robert Bell
  • Ronald Bell
  • George Brown
  • Cynthia Huggins
  • Claydes Charles Smith
  • Dennis Thomas
Pete Rock4:15
13."Hot Thing" (featuring will.i.am)
will.i.am3:48
14."Space Fruit (Interlude)" (featuring Sa-Ra)Sa-Ra1:31
15."The Perfect Beat" (featuring KRS-One)
  • Swiff D
  • Hi-Tek
3:49
16."Oh My Stars" (featuring Musiq Soulchild)
DJ Khalil3:40
17."Listen!!!"
Kwamé3:28
18."Go With Us" (featuring Strong Arm Steady)
E. Jones3:59
19."Hostile Gospel Pt. 2 (Deliver Me)" (featuring Sizzla)
DJ Khalil4:21
20."The Nature" (featuring Justin Timberlake)
  • Talib Kweli Greene
  • William Adams
  • Justin Timberlake
5:01
Bonus tracks
No.TitleWriter(s)Producer(s)Length
21."Hush" (featuring Jean Grae)Chad Beatz3:55
22."Take It Back" (featuring Marsha Ambrosius)
  • Talib Kweli Greene
  • Marsha Ambrosius
Karriem Riggins5:14
23."Getting My Grown Man On" (featuring Little Brother)
  • Talib Kweli Greene
  • Little Brother
Midi Mafia3:50

Chart positions

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
Eardrum is the third studio album by American hip hop artist Talib Kweli, released on August 21, 2007, through Blacksmith Music and Warner Bros. Records. The project follows Kweli's releases on Rawkus Records and Geffen Records, featuring 20 tracks that blend conscious rap with soulful and gospel-infused production. Clocking in at over 78 minutes, the album addresses themes of spirituality, personal struggle, social issues, and urban life, serving as a manifesto-like statement on Kweli's artistic evolution. The album's production roster includes renowned hip hop contributors such as , , , , , , and , who craft a cohesive sound drawing from , , and traditions. Guest appearances abound, with notable features from on "Soon the New Day," on "The Nature," providing on tracks like "," and rappers including , , , Freeway, and Strong Arm Steady. Standout singles include "Hot Thing" produced by and "Say Something" featuring , both of which highlight Kweli's sharp lyricism and collaborative energy. Recorded across studios like Electric Lady and Baseline, Eardrum emphasizes Kweli's role as alongside collaborators, resulting in a polished yet introspective listening experience. Commercially, Eardrum achieved Kweli's highest chart debut to date, entering the US at number two and selling 60,479 copies in its first week. It also peaked at number two on the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart, demonstrating strong initial support from fans despite Kweli's underground roots. Critically, the album garnered generally favorable reviews, with a Metascore of 73 out of 100 on based on 22 publications, praised for its mature themes and sonic consistency but occasionally critiqued for uneven pacing and overly ambitious scope. Publications like lauded its return to Kweli's strengths in Quality and Train of Thought, calling it a "solid return to form" with confident delivery, while others noted it as a step forward in his solo catalog. Over time, has been recognized as a pivotal work in Kweli's , influencing discussions on conscious hip hop's place in the mainstream and showcasing the Blacksmith Records roster. Its enduring appeal lies in tracks like "Give 'Em Hell" and "NY Weather Report," which exemplify Kweli's blend of and , solidifying his reputation as a lyrical powerhouse.

Background

Conception and development

Eardrum served as Talib Kweli's third solo studio album, arriving three years after his previous release, (2004), amid his determination to regain artistic autonomy following frustrations with , which had constrained his creative output on prior projects. Kweli expressed dissatisfaction with the major label's handling, prompting him to critique it directly in tracks like "More or Less," where he rapped, "More blacksmithing, def jerks, less ." This period of reflection fueled his vision for a project that prioritized universal appeal and enjoyment while preserving conscious hip-hop's depth for working-class audiences. In 2006, Kweli founded the independent label Blacksmith Music, signing a distribution deal with to enable broader reach without sacrificing control, marking a pivotal shift toward in his career. This partnership allowed him to build a roster including artists like and Strong Arm Steady, with Eardrum positioned as the label's flagship release to launch the "Blacksmith movement." Initial songwriting sessions emphasized raw, conscious rap themes drawn from personal and socio-political experiences, setting the stage for an album that blended introspection with accessibility. Drawing inspiration from hip-hop's golden era, Kweli adopted a back-to-basics approach for Eardrum, focusing on timeless songcraft and live instrumentation to evoke the organic sounds of his formative influences, such as producers and . He explained the album's title by stating, "I named the album Eardrum because I wanted people to focus on the musicality of what I do," aiming to create tracks that "stand the test of time" over heavy sampling. This pre-production emphasis on live elements and classic hip-hop roots underscored Kweli's goal of producing an engaging, response-driven record that honored his lyrical heritage.

Recording and production

The recording sessions for Eardrum spanned from 2006 to early 2007, primarily taking place across multiple studios in New York and , including Sound on Sound in New York, the in Los Angeles, and additional facilities like K1 Studios in . These sessions marked Talib Kweli's first project under his own Blacksmith Music label, allowing for a collaborative environment that drew on his established relationships in the industry. A diverse roster of producers contributed to the album, blending underground and mainstream talents to shape its sound. , Kweli's longtime collaborator from , produced "Oh My God" featuring Dion, incorporating soulful samples and crisp drum patterns. handled several tracks, including the atmospheric "Soon the New Day" and "Everything Man," emphasizing looped instrumentation for a raw feel. delivered booming, orchestral beats for "Say Something" featuring and "Hostile Gospel Pt. 1 (Deliver Us)," while provided the upbeat soul flip on "Give 'Em Hell." contributed funky, live-infused production to "Hot Thing," adding bass-heavy grooves recorded with assistance from engineers like Joe Peluso. Other notable producers included on "In the Sun" with and "Oh My Stars," as well as Sa-Ra on "More or Less." Guest features enriched the album through Kweli's extensive network in hip-hop and beyond. Norah Jones appeared on "Soon the New Day," a collaboration initiated by Kweli's manager to bridge hip-hop and influences, with Jones adding ethereal vocals over Madlib's production. Justin Timberlake contributed background vocals and co-production to the closing track "The Nature," an opportunity that emerged from mutual industry connections during Timberlake's transition into more production-focused work. joined Raheem DeVaughn on "Country Cousins," facilitated by Kweli's ties to Southern rap scenes through shared tours and label affiliations, bringing gritty verses that complemented the track's laid-back vibe. provided on "." The production overall prioritized organic elements, such as live drums from on multiple cuts and minimal digital processing on horns and keys from musicians like and Steve Pageot, evoking the hands-on authenticity of 1990s hip-hop.

Composition

Musical style

Eardrum exemplifies the hip-hop genre through its foundation in beats, layered with soul samples and jazz elements, evoking the raw energy and lyrical density of 1990s East Coast rap. The production draws from soul influences, such as Gamble & Huff's orchestral flair, and jazz textures reminiscent of , creating a cohesive yet varied soundscape that balances introspection and momentum. Soulful samples, like the Fred Williams interpolation in "Listen!!!," integrate with gospel-tinged choruses and R&B drama to ground the album in classic hip-hop sampling traditions. Track variations highlight the album's dynamic range, from the mellow funk of "In the Mood," featuring vibraphone by and a continuous croon for an infectious groove, to the introspective, catchy pop of "Hot Thing" that emphasizes mid-tempo restraint. Live instrumentation adds texture, as seen in Pete Rock's soulful flips, while tempo shifts—such as double-time flows in certain cuts—enhance the overall rhythmic vitality without disrupting the laid-back cohesion. These elements foster a pleasing, soothing listen that prioritizes finesse over aggression. Spanning 20 tracks in its standard edition, with most songs averaging 3 to 4 minutes, Eardrum demonstrates deliberate sequencing to build sonic progression, starting with slinking twilight soul and evolving through gospel swells and jazz-infused builds for a narrative-like flow. Guest contributions, such as ' ethereal vocals on "Soon the New Day" and ' vibraphone on "In the Mood," enhance the soulful and jazz textures. This structure, shaped by a roster of producers including , , and , underscores the album's nod to East Coast hip-hop's emphasis on thoughtful arrangement.

Lyrics and themes

The lyrics on Eardrum center on themes of , personal resilience, and the evolution of hip-hop, reflecting Talib Kweli's commitment to conscious rap amid industry pressures. In tracks like "Give 'Em ," Kweli critiques religious stereotypes and divisions, highlighting how they perpetuate biases against communities with lines such as "They got us thinking that like to make bombs / But real believe in paradise and resisting ." Similarly, "NY Weather Report" addresses urban struggles and the "/gangster mentality," portraying cycles of violence where "Females left to raise up a son/from the day he was one until he 20 and he raised up a ." These elements underscore Kweli's focus on societal inequities and communal endurance. Kweli's storytelling approach features dense, multisyllabic rhyme schemes that weave references to Black history, urban life, and interpersonal relationships into intricate narratives. His delivery transitions smoothly between aggressive flows and reflective verses, as seen in "Say Something," where he challenges hip-hop's commercialization by declaring "Hip Hop’s not dead, it was on vacation," urging listeners to engage beyond superficial trends. The track "Ms. Hill" exemplifies his relational depth, serving as a tribute to that praises her uplifting influence and mission in hip-hop, interpreting her work as a force to "uplift the heel" through skillful, empowering artistry. Collaborations amplify these motifs, particularly Jean Grae's verse on "Say Something," which bolsters themes of female empowerment with its bold, unapologetic tone, daring detractors to "Open your mouth, ‘Say Something’ / I fuckin’ dare you!" The album's narrative arc progresses from depictions of struggle in "The Perfect Beat," featuring and emphasizing perseverance in hip-hop's competitive landscape, to triumphant resolution in "Say Something," where Kweli reflects on overcoming personal and artistic obstacles: "I came in the game with nothing / Stop frontin, nigga, talk shit now!" This structure mirrors Kweli's career trajectory, evolving from label constraints to independent assertion.

Release and promotion

Singles

The lead single from Eardrum, "Hot Thing" featuring , was released in 2007 as a digital download, radio edit, and 12-inch vinyl to build anticipation for the album. "Say Something" featuring arrived in July 2007 in formats including digital EP, radio edit, and 12-inch vinyl, emphasizing the album's lyrical depth. It was accompanied by a .

Marketing and release

Eardrum was released on August 21, 2007, through Talib Kweli's independent label Blacksmith Music in conjunction with , representing Kweli's strategic shift toward greater artistic control via his own imprint while benefiting from major-label distribution infrastructure. The promotional campaign utilized early and digital tools to connect directly with fans, including Kweli's active presence for personal blogs and album previews, a dedicated group, and the debut of BlacksmithTV.com featuring videos on his creative process and daily life. Additional tactics encompassed making the lead single available as a and establishing a 718-area-code for personalized fan messages, all part of a broader "full-force blitz" to amplify reach in the evolving online music landscape. Live performances tied into the rollout, with Kweli touring key markets in the weeks leading up to release, such as a at the Domino Room in , on August 17, 2007, to generate buzz through direct audience engagement. The physical packaging included a booklet with art direction and design by Matt Taylor, featuring cover imagery centered on Kweli's portrait against an urban backdrop that evoked the album's auditory theme. International versions varied, with the UK edition incorporating bonus tracks like "Hostile Gospel Pt. 2 (Deliver Me)" featuring Sizzla, alongside standard global distribution through Warner Bros. affiliates; the overall strategy built anticipation for robust initial sales, positioning Eardrum as a major hip-hop contender.

Reception and legacy

Critical reception

Eardrum received generally favorable reviews upon its release in 2007, earning a Metascore of 73 out of 100 on based on 22 critic reviews, indicating "generally favorable" reception. Critics frequently lauded Talib Kweli's intricate and the album's varied production. rated it 7.3 out of 10, praising Kweli's relaxed confidence and the cohesive integration of gospel, soul, and hip-hop influences from producers including , , and . awarded 4.5 out of 5 stars, highlighting the production's diversity that ranged from soulful grooves to jazz-infused beats, creating a dynamic backdrop for Kweli's wordplay. Some reviews pointed to inconsistencies in pacing and filler material as drawbacks. Rolling Stone gave it 3 out of 5 stars, noting that although admirably consistent overall, the album "lacks a knockout track to counterbalance the occasional filler." Vibe magazine assigned 3 stars out of 5, critiquing its lack of cohesiveness amid Kweli's otherwise compelling verses. Retrospective evaluations have underscored Eardrum's importance in the conscious rap landscape. In a 2017 Albumism tribute marking its 10-year anniversary, the album was described as "eclectic and ambitious," credited with helping revive lyric-focused hip-hop by blending traditional elements with contemporary soul aesthetics during a period dominated by mainstream trends. Mojo called it "a welcome return to form," emphasizing its reconnection to Kweli's in thoughtful, socially aware rap.

Commercial performance

Eardrum debuted at number 2 on the chart, selling 60,000 copies in its first week according to Nielsen SoundScan data. The album also reached number 2 on the Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums chart. By the end of its second week, it had sold an additional 25,000 units, bringing the US total to 85,000 copies. As of 2013, Eardrum had sold approximately 239,000 copies in the , reflecting steady physical and digital sales without reaching thresholds. Post-2013 growth in streaming equivalents has contributed to its longevity, bolstered by tour bundling and increased digital availability, though no updated RIAA reports specify exact figures through 2025. Internationally, the album peaked at number 82 on the and number 5 on the UK Hip Hop and R&B Albums Chart, with one week on the main albums chart. European sales remained modest, aligning with its independent distribution model outside the .

Accolades and influence

The album's influence extends to subsequent conscious rap works, where it demonstrated how to integrate with accessible production and . As a pivotal release, Eardrum served as a bridge between underground authenticity and commercial viability in hip-hop. Culturally, the album's enduring sonic footprint is evident in its production style, while its themes of resilience and justice remain relevant amid social movements.

Track listing and credits

Standard edition track listing

The standard edition of Eardrum features 20 tracks with a total runtime of 78:12, all primarily written by (credited as Talib Kweli Greene). The sequencing begins with upbeat, collaborative openers like "Everything Man" and "NY Weather Report" to immediately engage listeners with Kweli's signature conscious rap flow over dynamic production. This U.S. release excludes bonus tracks found on international versions, such as the Japanese edition's additional cuts like "" and "So Low."
No.TitleFeatured artist(s)DurationProducer(s)Writer(s)
1"Everything Man"RES3:16Talib Kweli Greene, Otis Jackson Jr.
2"NY Weather Report"4:35Nick SpeedTalib Kweli Greene, Nick Speed, M. Clervoix
3"Hostile Gospel Pt. 1 (Deliver Us)"MeLa Machinko, Youth Chorus5:22Talib Kweli Greene, Justin Smith, P. Greedus, D. Marouani
4"Say Something"3:43Talib Kweli Greene, William Adams, T. Ibrahim, , J. Casey
5"Country Cousins", 4:31A Kid Called Roots, Sha-La ShakierTalib Kweli Greene, P. Lawrence, S. Hollis, et al.
6"Holy Moly"2:08Talib Kweli Greene, Peter Phillips, ,
7"Eat To Live"Kendra Ross3:07Talib Kweli Greene, Otis Jackson Jr., , T. Smith
8"In The Mood", 3:56Talib Kweli Greene, Kanye West, B. Potter
9"Soon The New Day"4:02 (co-produced by Eric Krasno)Talib Kweli Greene, Otis Jackson Jr., P. Charles, J. Mason
10"Give 'Em Hell"Coi Mattison, 4:27, DJ BattlecatTalib Kweli Greene, Terrace Martin, K. Gilliam, et al.
11"More Or Less"Dion4:41Talib Kweli Greene, Tony Cottrell, Dion Jenkins
12"Stay Around"4:16Talib Kweli Greene, Peter Phillips, R. Bell, et al.
13"Hot Thing"3:48Talib Kweli Greene, William Adams, J. Watson
14"Space Fruit (Interlude)"Sa-Ra1:31Sa-RaO. Keith, S. Husayn
15"The Perfect Beat"3:49Swiff D, Talib Kweli Greene, S. Thornton, L. Parker,
16"Oh My Stars"3:41Talib Kweli Greene, T. Johnson, K. Abdul-Rahman, A.F. Greene
17"Listen!!!"3:58Talib Kweli Greene, Kwamé Holland, Fred Williams
18"Go With Us"Strong Arm Steady3:59E. JonesTalib Kweli Greene, E. Jones, J. Smith, et al.
19"Hostile Gospel Pt. 2 (Deliver Me)"4:21Talib Kweli Greene, M. Collins, K. Abdul-Rahman, D. Hinds
20"The Nature"5:01 (co-produced by Eric Krasno, Adam Deitch)Talib Kweli Greene, Justin Timberlake

Personnel

Talib Kweli performed lead vocals and contributed to songwriting throughout the album. Guest vocalists included on piano and vocals for "Soon the New Day," Res providing backing vocals on multiple tracks, on "Say Something," and (Bun B and ) on "Country Cousins," on vibraphone for "In the Mood," on "In the Mood," Dion on "More or Less," on "The Perfect Beat," on "Oh My Stars," on "Hostile Gospel Pt. 2 (Deliver Me)," and on "The Nature." Additional musicians featured Eric Krasno on bass, keyboards, drum programming, strings, and synthesizer; on drums, keyboards, and electric piano ( and ); Fyre Dept. on guitar, drums, and keyboards; Ryan Zoidis on ; on ; Steve Pageot on ; and DJ Rhettmatic on scratches. Producers credited on the album were Nick Speed, , , , , Swiff D, , , Sa-Ra, Battlecat (with ), and E. Jones, with co-production by Eric Krasno and on select tracks. Engineers included recording engineers Brian Herman, Mike Hogue, Jamil "Face" Johnson, , Cory Mo, Billy Durst, Anthony Kilhoffer, Richard Reitz, Eric Krasno, and Ethan Willoughby; mixing engineers Dylan "3-D" Dresdow, Steve B. "Baughman," Neal Pogue, and ; and assistant engineers Joe Peluso and Billy Durst. Editing was handled by Joel Hamilton. Executive producers were , Corey Smyth, and Tom Whalley, with co-executive production by "" Dave Dar. A&R direction came from Corey Smyth and Naim Ali, with A&R administration and coordination by Liza Joseph, Midori Nishijima-Kim, and Ben Gaffin. Creative direction was provided by Denise A. Williams, and art direction and design by Matt Taylor. Recording sessions occurred at multiple studios, including Baseline Studios and in New York, NY; Henson Recording Studios and Paramount Recording Studios in Hollywood, CA; and others such as The Crib in Brooklyn, NY, and Tek Lab in KY. Specific producer assignments are detailed in the track listing section.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.