Hubbry Logo
Earl MarischalEarl MarischalMain
Open search
Earl Marischal
Community hub
Earl Marischal
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Earl Marischal
Earl Marischal
Earl Marischal
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Earl Marischal of Scotland
Arms of the house of Keith, hereditary holders of the title of Earl Marischal.
George Keith, 10th Earl Marischal, last holder of the office of Earl Marischal
TypeGreat Officer of State
Formation
  • c. 1160 (Created Marischal of Scotland)
  • c. 1458 (Raised to the Peerage as Earl Marischal)
First holder
  • Hervey de Keith
  • as Marischal of Scotland
  • William Keith, 1st Earl Marischal
  • as Earl Marischal
SuccessionHereditary

The title of Earl Marischal was created in the Peerage of Scotland for William Keith, the Great Marischal of Scotland.

History

[edit]

The office of Marischal of Scotland (or Marascallus Scotie or Marscallus Scotiae) had been hereditary, held by the senior member and Chief of Clan Keith, since Hervey (Herveus) de Keith, who held the office of Marischal under Malcolm IV and William I. The descendant of Herveus, Sir Robert de Keith (d.1332), was confirmed in the office of Great Marischal of Scotland by King Robert the Bruce around 1324.

Robert de Keith's great-grandson, William, was raised to the Peerage as Earl Marischal by James II in about 1458. The peerage died out when George Keith, the 10th Earl, forfeited it by joining the Jacobite Rising of 1715.

The role of the Marischal was to serve as custodian of the Royal Regalia of Scotland, and to protect the king's person when attending parliament. The former duty was fulfilled by the 7th Earl during the Wars of the Three Kingdoms, who hid them at Dunnottar Castle. The role of regulation of heraldry carried out by the English Earl Marshal is carried out in Scotland by the Lord Lyon King of Arms.

The separate office of Knight Marischal was first created for the Scottish coronation of King Charles I in 1633. The office is not heritable, although it has been held by members of the Keith family.

The title was forfeited in 1715, due to the last Earl's participation in the Jacobite Rising.

Marischals and Great Marischals of Scotland

[edit]
  1. Hervey de Keith (d. c. 1196)
  2. Philip de Keith (d. c. 1225), paternal grandson of Hervey de Keith, older brother of David de Keith
  3. David de Keith, paternal grandson of Hervey de Keith, younger brother of Philip de Keith (co-jointly with his brother above and paternal nephew below)
  4. Hervey de Keith (d. c. 1250), paternal nephew of David de Keith
  5. Richard de Keith (fl. 12??)[1]
  6. David de Keith (fl. 1269)[1]
  7. John de Keith (d. c. 1270)
  8. William de Keith (d. c. 1293)
  9. Sir Robert Keith (d. 1332)
  10. Sir Robert Keith (d. 1346)
  11. Sir Edward Keith (d. c. 1351)
  12. Sir William Keith (d. c. 1410)
  13. Sir Robert Keith (d. c. 1430)
  14. William Keith, Marischal of Scotland (d. 1463)

Earls Marischal of Scotland (c. 1458)

[edit]
  1. William Keith, 1st Earl Marischal (d. 1483)[2][3]
  2. William Keith, 2nd Earl Marischal (d. 1530)[3]
  3. William Keith, 3rd Earl Marischal (d. 1581)[4]
  4. William Keith, 4th Earl Marischal (d. 15??)
  5. George Keith, 5th Earl Marischal (c. 1553 – 1623)[5]
  6. William Keith, 6th Earl Marischal (c. 1585 – 1635)[6]
  7. William Keith, 7th Earl Marischal (1614 – 1671)[7]
  8. George Keith, 8th Earl Marischal (d. 1694)[8]
  9. William Keith, 9th Earl Marischal (c. 1664 – 1712)[8]
  10. George Keith, 10th Earl Marischal (c. 1693 – 1778) (forfeit 1715)[9]

Before the sequence was revised by Thomas Innes of Learney in 1927, the 1st Earl's father, William Keith (died 1463), was deemed to be the first Earl Marischal, so that the final Earl was the eleventh.[4][10]

Arms

[edit]
Coat of arms of the Earl Marischal
Crest
A Hart's Head erased proper armed with ten Tynes Or.
Escutcheon
Argent on a Chief Gules three Palets Or; behind the shield two Baton Gules semy of Thistles ensigned on the top with an Imperial Crown Or placed saltirewise being the insignia of the office of Great Marischal of Scotland.
Supporters
On either side a Hart proper attired as in the Crest.
Motto
Veritas Vincit (Truth conquers)

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Earl Marischal

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Earl of Marischal was a title in the , created around 1455 by King James II for William Keith, 4th Lord Keith, who held the hereditary office of Great Marischal of Scotland responsible for marshalling the royal household and bearing the great seal. The Keith family, originating as warriors from the , elevated the earldom through military service, including Sir Robert Keith's cavalry charge at the in 1314, and administrative roles in the Scottish court. Successive Earls Marischal wielded significant influence, with George Keith, 5th Earl, advising James VI and contributing to the in , while later holders like the 9th Earl safeguarded the at against Cromwell's forces in 1651. The title's prominence extended to patronage of learning, as the 7th Earl founded in in 1593, which later merged into the . The earldom ended in in 1716 when George Keith, 10th Earl, supported the , leading to forfeiture of titles and estates; he escaped to , where descendants pursued military and diplomatic careers. This event marked the extinction of the line, though the office of Knight Marischal persists non-hereditarily.

Origins and Establishment

Early Marischals of Scotland

The office of Marischal of Scotland emerged in the late as a hereditary position within the royal household, derived from Norman administrative structures adapted to the Scottish court, where the title denoted responsibility for the custody and management of the king's horses and stables. Hervey de Keith, a Scoto-Norman nobleman who held lands in the barony of Keith (later Keith-Marischal) in Humbie Parish, , is the first recorded holder of this office, serving as Great Marischal under King William the Lion (r. 1165–1214). He witnessed royal charters between 1189 and 1195, indicating his integration into court functions, and died around 1185 or before 1196, after which the role passed to his heirs. The Marischal's duties centered on practical equestrian oversight, including the care, provisioning, and deployment of royal mounts, reflecting the marshal's broader medieval as a stable master evolved from farriery and veterinary tasks to encompass for the monarch's forces. This position lacked the elevated noble status of later peerages, functioning instead as an administrative appointment tied to the Keith family's landholdings and loyalty to . Hereditary succession was formalized during the Wars of Scottish Independence when King , in recognition of the Keiths' support, confirmed the office to Sir Robert de Keith (d. 1332) via a charter dated 7 November 1324, granting him the lands of Keith Marischal and perpetual tenure of the Marischal role for his descendants. Sir Robert, who had succeeded to the position around 1293–1294 and commanded the Scottish cavalry at the in 1314, exemplified the office's growing military relevance amid the conflicts with England. This confirmation solidified the Keith lineage's custodianship without conferring earldom, maintaining the role's focus on royal equine and logistical services.

Creation of the Earldom in 1458

In 1458, King James II of Scotland elevated the hereditary office of Great Marischal to the status of an earldom within the , granting the title to William Keith, the incumbent Great Marischal and previously styled as Lord Keith or Sir William Keith. This creation occurred before 4 July 1458, marking the only instance in Scottish peerage history where a great officer of state was styled as an earl by virtue of that office alone. The elevation rewarded Keith's demonstrated loyalty to during a period of intense feudal instability, as James II sought to reward reliable supporters amid efforts to curb the power of overmighty nobles. The political context of mid-15th-century underscored the strategic nature of this grant. James II, reigning from 1437 to 1460, had decisively weakened the Black Douglas faction in 1455 by orchestrating the murder of the 9th at , thereby dismantling a major threat to royal authority and redistributing lands and influence to loyalists. Keith's alignment with the king positioned the family advantageously, transforming their custodianship of the marischal office—responsible for marshalling royal ceremonies and forces—into a hereditary that enhanced their prestige and landholdings, including estates like Dunnottar. Further bolstering Keith's standing were matrimonial alliances that wove the family into the pro-royal nobility. William Keith had married Margaret Hamilton, daughter of , whose house had risen as rivals to the Douglases and gained favor under James II through military and . This union not only secured economic and territorial ties but also exemplified the crown's tactic of fostering stability through inter-noble marriages, countering the factionalism that had plagued since the minority of James II. The earldom's establishment thus reflected a deliberate consolidation of monarchical power, embedding the Keiths as key pillars in the evolving feudal order.

The Office of Great Marischal

Duties and Evolution of Responsibilities

The Great Marischal served as one of Scotland's , with core responsibilities centered on the management of the royal stables, horses, and transportation logistics for the sovereign and court. This included provisioning and maintaining equine resources essential for royal travel and military support, reflecting the office's origins in medieval marshaling duties akin to those of a chief and organizer of processions. The role encompassed arranging ceremonial formations, such as ordering ranks during state events, coronations, and parliamentary assemblies, ensuring orderly conduct and security in public displays of . A key function involved custodianship of the —the , , and —particularly during parliamentary sessions, where the Marischal safeguarded these from theft or damage. This duty extended to personal protection of the king within , positioning the office as a guardian of both symbols of and the monarch's immediate safety amid gatherings of nobles and officials. After the in 1603, which relocated the Stuart monarchs primarily to , the logistical elements of stable and transport oversight diminished in practice, as Scottish royal progresses became infrequent. Ceremonial and custodial roles endured symbolically in residual Scottish state functions, including any lingering ary rituals, until the office's attainder following the rendered it vacant. The evolution underscored a shift from active administrative oversight to titular prestige, aligned with broader centralization of royal authority away from .

Role in Scottish Governance and Monarchy

The Great Marischal, as one of Scotland's ancient , held a prominent advisory role in the , contributing to the governance of the realm by providing counsel on matters of state during periods of royal minority or absence. For instance, during ' minority in the mid-16th century, the office's holder served among the regency guardians and on her upon her return, helping to maintain administrative continuity amid factional instability. This involvement underscored the Marischal's function in bolstering monarchical authority through institutional stability, as the officer routinely attended council meetings to deliberate on royal policies and enforcement. In ceremonial aspects of , the Great Marischal enforced protocol at key events, including parliaments and , where duties encompassed safeguarding the sovereign's person and managing the royal —such as , sword, and sceptre—to symbolize unbroken Scottish sovereignty. At the 1633 of Charles I in , the Marischal officiated by fastening the king's spurs, a act reinforcing hierarchical order and the officer's custodial responsibility over symbols of royal power. Such roles extended to escorting the Lord High Commissioner into Parliament House, ensuring the dignified procession that affirmed ceremonial preeminence in legislative proceedings. These functions causally linked the office to monarchical legitimacy by ritualistically embedding Scottish traditions into governance structures. The office's prominence waned with the 1707 Union of Parliaments, embodying resistance to the erosion of distinct Scottish institutions under centralized British authority. In the final sessions, the sitting Earl Marischal lodged a formal against the union articles, highlighting how the Great Marischal's hereditary oversight of national regalia and ceremonies represented enduring emblems of pre-union autonomy that the treaty subordinated to Westminster's framework. This stance reflected broader tensions, as the role's emphasis on independent management clashed with the union's integration of Scottish offices into a unified state apparatus, diminishing the Marischal's influence on sovereign affairs thereafter.

The Keith Family's Tenure

Rise of the Keiths to the Title

The Keith family, originating from Norman settlers in , derived their name from the barony of Keith in , acquired by Hervey de Keith around 1150 through marriage to the local heiress under a granted by King David I. Hervey, a Scoto-Norman noble, became the first recorded holder of the hereditary office of Marischal of , responsible for marshalling the king's forces, with his son formally styled as "Marischal of the King of Scots" in a 1176 . This early establishment positioned the Keiths as minor nobility tied to royal service rather than independent warlords, with initial landholdings centered on fertile estates that provided agricultural revenue and strategic proximity to . The clan's ascent accelerated through unwavering loyalty during the Wars of Independence, exemplified by Sir Robert Keith, hereditary Marischal, who led a contingent for I Bruce at the on June 24, 1314, contributing to the Scottish victory over English forces numbering around 20,000. In recognition, Bruce rewarded Keith with extensive grants of forfeited Comyn lands in northeastern , totaling thousands of acres in areas like and by 1320, formalized in a of November 7, 1324, that also confirmed the upgraded office of Great Marischal and the Keith Marischal barony. These acquisitions shifted the family's power base northward, incorporating productive coastal and inland territories that bolstered economic stability through rents, fisheries, and trade routes, while enabling the Keiths to prioritize crown allegiance over entanglement in destructive noble feuds, such as those between the Bruces and the Black Douglases. Subsequent strategic marriages further consolidated holdings, including unions with Fraser and Cheyne heiresses in the that brought additional estates in Kincardine, , and expanded properties, alongside control of fortifications like Inverugie Castle in . This socio-economic foundation—rooted in diversified land revenues exceeding those of many regional lords and defensible assets—sustained the Keiths' role as reliable royal officers amid Scotland's feudal instabilities. By the mid-15th century, under William Keith, the Great Marischal, this trajectory of service and accumulation prompted King James II to elevate him to the as Earl Marischal on or before 1458, transforming the family from office-holders into titled earls with enhanced parliamentary influence.

Succession and Family Dynamics

The Earldom of Marischal passed through ten generations of the Keith family from its creation for William Keith, 1st , in 1458 until the forfeiture of George Keith, 10th , following the Jacobite Rising in 1716. Succession adhered closely to , with the title typically devolving to eldest sons, though premature deaths occasionally shifted inheritance to grandsons or siblings, reflecting standard noble demographic patterns of high mortality among heirs rather than deliberate disputes. Unlike many Scottish clans marked by fratricidal conflicts over land or influence, the Keith Marischals experienced no significant intra-family litigation or violence over the succession, maintaining cohesion through strategic marriages that bolstered alliances without fragmenting core estates. Early transitions exemplified smooth paternal lines: the 1st 's son succeeded as 2nd Earl in 1483, who in turn passed the title to his grandson as 3rd Earl upon his own death in 1527, as his son had predeceased him without disrupting the chain. The 3rd Earl's heir, , died in 1580, prompting succession by his son George as 4th Earl in 1581; George, born around 1553, married twice—first to Margaret Home, producing the heir (5th Earl), and later to Margaret Ogilvy—to mitigate risks of childlessness, a pragmatic response to the era's high rates. This pattern continued with 5th Earl (d. 1635) succeeded directly by his son as 6th Earl. Mid-line lateral shifts occurred without contention: the 6th (d. 1671), whose first marriage to Elizabeth Seton yielded daughters but no surviving sons, and whose second to Anne Douglas produced no issue, was followed by his brother George as 7th Earl. George 7th (d. 1694) begat as 8th Earl, who died in 1712, succeeded by his son George as 10th Earl (numbering varies slightly in sources, but sequence consistent). Later demographic pressures proved terminal: the 10th Earl remained childless, his failure to secure legitimate heirs—amid the forfeitures—ending the , as branches like the Earls of Kintore diverged earlier without claim. This outcome underscored broader patterns where prolonged wars and limited eroded noble houses absent robust contingency planning.

Notable Holders and Achievements

Contributions in Diplomacy and Education

George Keith, the 5th Earl Marischal (c. 1553–1623), advanced Scottish diplomacy through his leadership of the embassy to Denmark in 1589, where he negotiated the marriage alliance between King James VI and Anne of Denmark, acting as the king's proxy during the ceremony on 20 August that year. This mission secured a key Protestant marital tie amid European religious tensions, bolstering Scotland's position against Catholic influences without entangling in the era's more radical confessional conflicts. His role underscored a pragmatic approach to foreign relations, prioritizing dynastic stability over ideological extremism during the Reformation's aftermath. In education, Keith founded in on 19 July 1593, endowing it with revenues from former ecclesiastical lands to establish a center for Protestant , , and , explicitly as a complement to the older and to foster Reformed scholarship independent of lingering Catholic sympathies in academia. The institution, granted a by King James VI, trained ministers and scholars, contributing to the solidification of Presbyterian in northeast ; by the early , it had enrolled students in and , drawing on Keith's personal fortune estimated at over £20,000 Scots annually from his estates. Keith's infrastructure initiatives, including the construction of Stonehaven's pier around 1587 concurrent with granting the town burgh status, enhanced maritime trade routes vital for Aberdeen's mercantile networks and indirectly supported educational expansion by generating regional wealth; these developments predated similar efforts at and aligned with his avoidance of factional religious strife, as he backed James VI's moderate policies against both ultra-Protestant and pro-Catholic factions. Such investments elevated the Keith clan's prestige through tangible public benefits but imposed fiscal pressures, as the college's upkeep and harbor works diverted funds from private holdings amid royal fiscal demands.

Military and Political Engagements

Sir Robert Keith, hereditary Great Marischal of Scotland, commanded the approximately 600 light horsemen in Robert the Bruce's army during the on 23–24 June 1314, contributing to the decisive Scottish victory in the Wars of Independence by harassing English supply lines and pursuing the retreating forces. This role underscored the Marischals' early military alignment with the Bruce cause, though the family's limited independent martial resources—reliant on royal summons—highlighted constraints compared to larger clans like the Douglases or Campbells. In the , William Keith, 4th Earl Marischal (d. 1581), navigated the turbulent politics surrounding , joining her in 1561 and hosting her at in 1562 amid her efforts to consolidate power against Protestant lords. His support reflected a pragmatic loyalty to the crown rather than ideological fervor, avoiding the extremism of both Marian ultra-Catholics and radical reformers, though it exposed the Keiths to risks from shifting alliances following Mary's deposition in 1567. George Keith, 5th Earl Marischal (c. 1553–1623), exemplified cautious political maneuvering under James VI by adhering to moderate , steering clear of Catholic excesses associated with figures like the Earl of and radical Presbyterian factions. His tenure involved restrained responses to regional feuds, including clashes with the Gordons of over northeastern influence and tensions with the Hays of Erroll, where royal mediation was often required due to the Keiths' dependence on court favor rather than autonomous military might. These engagements bolstered loyalty and territorial stability but revealed strategic vulnerabilities: over-reliance on monarchical patronage left the family susceptible to dynastic upheavals, unlike more self-sufficient highland kindreds that leveraged private armies for leverage.

Decline and Forfeiture

Involvement in the Jacobite Rising of 1715

George Keith, 10th Earl Marischal, aligned with the Jacobite cause in the 1715 rising primarily due to dynastic loyalty to the Stuart line and widespread Scottish resentment toward the 1707 Act of Union, which many viewed as a forfeiture of parliamentary sovereignty and economic subordination to England despite compensatory payments for losses like the Darien scheme. His family's prior anti-Union stance, exemplified by his father William Keith, 9th Earl, underscored this position, framing Jacobitism as a vehicle for restoring Scottish autonomy under a native monarchy rather than Hanoverian rule imposed via parliamentary maneuver. Keith's military experience under Marlborough provided tactical acumen, but his commitment reflected pragmatic calculation amid episcopal and Tory networks disillusioned by the post-Union settlement's erosion of traditional privileges. Upon John Erskine, 6th Earl of Mar, raising the Jacobite standard at on September 6, , Keith proclaimed as James VIII at shortly thereafter, mobilizing approximately 1,000 men from the northeastern counties under his feudal authority. These forces contributed to early consolidations, with Keith's contingent joining Huntly's troops to bolster the rising's northern momentum before converging on the main army at Perth by early . This rapid recruitment highlighted localized anti-Union grievances, particularly among Episcopalians and landowners chafing under Hanoverian policies, yet revealed the limits of ad hoc feudal levies lacking unified command or supply lines. At the on November 13, 1715, Keith commanded two squadrons of cavalry on the Jacobite right wing in the second line, leveraging his combat experience to support the advance against John Campbell, 2nd Duke of 's government forces. Though the Jacobites initially pressed their numerical superiority—outnumbering roughly two-to-one—their uncoordinated faltered against disciplined regulars, resulting in a tactical stalemate that claimed as victory while Mar withdrew northward. The engagement exposed causal weaknesses: feudal mobilization proved insufficient against professional armies, with poor terrain coordination and delayed French aid undermining strategic depth. The rising's collapse followed, as logistical strains and the Pretender's belated arrival in December yielded no decisive reinforcement, prompting Keith's flight to the continent by early 1716 amid dispersing Jacobite remnants. This outcome underscored Jacobitism's reliance on continental support against English overreach, yet highlighted how post-Union integration had eroded Scotland's capacity for sustained , favoring Hanoverian stability through superior resources and divided Scottish loyalties. Keith's involvement thus exemplified resistance rooted in preservation, but its failure stemmed from mismatched military paradigms rather than ideological deficiency alone.

Attainder and Loss of the Title

Following the participation of George Keith, 10th Earl Marischal, in the , the British Parliament passed an act of attainder against him in 1716, declaring him guilty of high treason and forfeiting his titles, including Earl Marischal, to the Crown. This legislation stripped the Keith family of their hereditary custodianship of the Scottish regalia, which had been entrusted to them since the , and separated the office of Great Marischal—responsible for ceremonial duties such as coronation protocols—from the family line. The forfeiture extended to extensive estates, notably in , a key Keith stronghold overlooking the , which was seized and subsequently sold by to recover debts and redistribute lands, effectively dismantling the family's economic and territorial power base in northeast . Other properties, including Inverugie Castle and associated lands valued at tens of thousands of pounds, were similarly alienated, with sales proceeds directed toward government funds rather than restitution. Despite Keith's survival in exile—fleeing to the and later serving in Prussian and diplomatic roles until his on May 28, 1778, in —no parliamentary reversal occurred, rendering the title extinct upon his demise without male heirs holding it. The Knight Marischal office, distinct from the , persisted as a non-hereditary appointment, assigned to others for state functions and excluding the Keiths thereafter, underscoring the post-Union policy of centralizing authority by curbing autonomous noble offices in . This outcome exemplified the systematic suppression of Jacobite-aligned , prioritizing Hanoverian consolidation over feudal traditions.

Legacy and Aftermath

Architectural and Institutional Impacts

George Keith, the 5th Earl Marischal, founded in on 2 April 1593, chartering it as a Protestant to advance theological and in the wake of the , countering the Catholic-leaning traditions at nearby . The college's establishment reflected the earl's commitment to institutional reform, funding initial construction and staffing with Reformed scholars to train ministers and lay leaders for northeast Scotland. Despite the Keith family's attainder and forfeiture of estates after the 10th Earl's role in the Jacobite Rising, endured as a public asset, merging with on 15 September 1860 under the Universities (Scotland) Act 1858 to form the , where it continues to house faculties in law, medicine, and social sciences. This persistence underscores the causal resilience of endowments tied to communal utility over dynastic reversals. The 5th Earl also directed architectural enhancements to family strongholds, rebuilding the seat at Keith Marischal in in 1589 with Renaissance-style features, including roof trusses from Norwegian timber acquired via diplomatic ties. At , the hereditary Keith constabulary since the 14th century, he oversaw a large-scale reconstruction around 1581–1593, converting medieval fortifications into a more habitable palace with added ranges and defensive works, though later damaged by Cromwellian forces in 1651 and further declined post-forfeiture. These private builds, while emblematic of Keith , largely succumbed to and conflict, leaving archaeological remnants rather than intact structures. In contrast, the earl's public harbor projects at and , initiated in the 1590s using imported materials, facilitated trade and fishing, with Stonehaven's pier rebuilt multiple times and Peterhead's Port Henry operational by 1593, enduring as functional infrastructure beyond the title's extinction.[](https://portal.historicenvironment.scot/apex/f?p=1505:300:::::VIEWTYPE,VIEWR EF:designation,LB39733) Anecdotes of the 5th Earl's extravagance, such as acquiring a pet in 1593 for Dunnottar—housed in a dedicated known as the —illustrate the scale of his resources, drawn from maritime ventures and royal favor, though such quirks yielded no lasting institutional footprint. Overall, the Keiths' tangible legacies prioritized enduring public endeavors like and ports, which withstood political upheavals through inherent societal value, unlike privatized estates vulnerable to sequestration.

Continuation of the Keith Line and Modern Relevance

Following the forfeiture of the title after the 1715 Jacobite Rising, George Keith, 10th Earl Marischal, sought refuge abroad, initially in before relocating to in 1716. There, he entered military service under Frederick William I and later became a trusted advisor to , rising to the rank of . Keith's diplomatic roles included Prussian ambassador to France from 1751 and to from 1759 to 1761, as well as governor of from 1752. In 1763, he returned to , regaining possession of some family estates through royal favor but without restoration of the , which remained attainted; he died unmarried in 1778, ending the direct male line of the earls. Cadet branches of the Keith family persisted in Scotland and extended to North America through emigration in the 18th and 19th centuries. Descendants of collateral lines, such as those tracing to early Keith settlers, established communities in regions like and , maintaining the surname amid following the Jacobite upheavals. In Scotland, surviving Keith kindred upheld clan ties despite the loss of the marischal estates, with family septs like Marshall emerging post-forfeiture among some adherents. Contemporary Clan Keith societies, including the Clan Keith Society International and its American branch, preserve the family's heritage through genealogy research, events, and stewardship of historical sites. These organizations promote visits to , the clan's longtime stronghold overlooking the , emphasizing its role as a symbol of Keith resilience from the 14th century onward. No formal revival of the Earl Marischal title has occurred, as it remains attainted under British peerage law, though the office of Great Marischal was reassigned historically. The Keiths' Jacobite alignment in , driven by loyalty to Stuart claims amid post-1707 Union frictions, underscored a broader Scottish resistance to Hanoverian centralization, viewing the rising as a defense of devolved constitutional traditions against London-dominated governance. This perspective informs ongoing Scottish identity discourses, where echoes of pre-Union autonomy advocacy—exemplified by the marischals' ceremonial independence—resonate in debates over and national , without reliance on dormant titles.

Heraldry

Arms and Symbols of the Earls

The heraldic arms of the Earls Marischal featured a shield blazoned as argent, on a chief gules three paleways or, consisting of a silver field with three gold vertical bars on a red upper section. This design differentiated from variant Keith arms, such as those with a gold chief bearing red paleways, by employing the gules chief to denote the family's exalted status as hereditary Great Marischals. Distinguishing the Marischal office, the arms were augmented with two red batons, semé of thistles and topped with imperial crowns, crossed in behind the shield; these evolved from earlier axe symbols of marshals, representing to enforce order in royal proceedings. The batons underscored the prestige of the Great Marischal , absent in other Keith branches' . These arms appeared in visual records like seals and stone carvings, including a Dunnottar Castle inscription bearing the quartered elements from familial alliances, such as with the Homes. Post-forfeiture, adaptations persisted in Clan Keith badges, retaining the core blazon and crest of a roebuck's head cabossed proper, attired or, emerging from a crest coronet.

References

  1. https://keithclan.net/information-references/succession-of-the-keiths-as-great-marischals-of-scotland/
  2. https://www.electricscotland.com/history/nation/marischal.htm
  3. https://clankeith-usa.org/history-of-clan-keith
  4. https://keithmarischal.com/
  5. https://www.undiscoveredscotland.co.uk/usbiography/k/georgekeith.html
  6. https://www.patrickspeople.scot/ourfamily/1723.htm
  7. https://www.dunnottarcastle.co.uk/history
  8. https://www.geni.com/people/William-Keith-1st-Earl-Marischal/6000000003645832280
  9. https://electricscotland.com/webclans/earldoms/chapter5s1.htm
  10. https://www.petandvetmag.com/post/knight-s-work-the-role-of-the-mediaeval-marshal
  11. https://clankeith-usa.org/history-of-clan-keith-from-the-scottish-clan-family-encyclopedia
  12. https://doriccolumns.wordpress.com/monarchs-of-scotland/earls-marischal/
  13. https://www.dunnottarholdings.com/aboutCastle.php
  14. https://www.parliament.uk/about/living-heritage/evolutionofparliament/legislativescrutiny/act-of-union-1707/overview/union-of-the-crowns/
  15. https://www.1902encyclopedia.com/S/STA/great-officers-of-state.html
  16. https://spcr.ac.uk/about/historical-introduction/
  17. https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Keith-581
  18. https://www.rps.ac.uk/mss/1706/10/217
  19. https://www.scotclans.com/blogs/clans-jk/keith-clan-history
  20. https://www.strath.ac.uk/studywithus/centreforlifelonglearning/genealogy/geneticgenealogyresearch/bannockburnprojectdocumentary/keithsirrobert/
  21. http://www.cracroftspeerage.co.uk/marischal1458.htm
  22. https://www.st-andrews.ac.uk/history/ssne/item.php?id=1535
  23. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctv6jm8j4
  24. https://doriccolumns.wordpress.com/marischal-college/
  25. https://www.scottish-places.info/people/famousfirst380.html
  26. https://electricscotland.com/history/other/keith_george.htm
  27. http://www.fdca.org.uk/1587_George_Keith_Earl_Marischal.html
  28. https://stonehavenhistory.wordpress.com/old-town/
  29. https://www.britishbattles.com/scottish-war-of-independence/battle-of-bannockburn/
  30. https://www.plowden-wardlaw.de/Keith.php
  31. https://boydellandbrewer.com/blog/early-modern-and-modern-history/a-protestant-lord-in-james-vis-scotland/
  32. https://theses.gla.ac.uk/7480/1/2016kerr-petersonphd.pdf
  33. https://www.historyreconsidered.net/scottish-history/house-stuart
  34. https://dokumen.pub/union-and-revolution-scotland-and-beyond-1625-1745-9781474410168.html
  35. https://www.electricscotland.com/history/genhist/hist56.html
  36. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/20946/20946-h/20946-h.htm
  37. https://www.electricscotland.com/history/genhist/hist57.html
  38. https://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/education/resources/jacobite-1715/account-sheriffmuir/
  39. https://electricscotland.com/webclans/families/keiths.htm
  40. https://www.geni.com/people/George-Keith-10th-Earl-Marischal/6000000012380320489
  41. https://www.facebook.com/groups/183261891706020/posts/1916339605064898/
  42. https://www.abdn.ac.uk/about/history/our-historic-timeline/
  43. https://www.undiscoveredscotland.co.uk/usfeatures/universities/aberdeen.html
  44. https://www.castlesandmanorhouses.com/page.php?key=Dunnottar%20Castle
  45. https://www.aberdeenshire.gov.uk/media/4z3kuoln/the-historic-harbours-trail-leaflet.pdf
  46. https://www.jamesboswell.info/biography/george-keith-10th-earl-marischal
  47. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803100134596
  48. https://www.rowberry.org/rickhsite/keithh.htm
  49. https://bagtownclans.com/index.php/2025/03/28/septs-of-clan-keith/
  50. https://clankeith-usa.org/
  51. https://aura.abdn.ac.uk/bitstream/handle/2164/25491/Bow_etal_JICH_A_Commonwealth_Union_For_AAM.pdf
  52. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/modern-intellectual-history/article/jacobite-groundwork-of-james-steuarts-political-economy/A8BC170AC67DA663CD8E4979AD832E53
  53. https://keithclan.net/information-references/keith-great-marischals-of-scotland/
  54. https://keithclan.net/information-references/keith-arms/
  55. https://keithclan.net/information-references/understanding-the-coat-of-arms/
  56. https://drawshield.net/reference/public-arms/e/earl-marischal-of-scotland.html
  57. https://www.electricscotland.com/books/pdf/scottisharmorial00macd.pdf
  58. https://www.scotclans.com/blogs/clans-jk/keith-crest-coats-of-arms
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.