Hubbry Logo
Mind machineMind machineMain
Open search
Mind machine
Community hub
Mind machine
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Mind machine
Mind machine
Mind machine
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
A light and sound machine with headphones and strobe light goggles

A mind machine (aka brain machine or light and sound machine) uses pulsing rhythmic sound, flashing light, or a combination of these. Mind machines can induce deep states of relaxation[1] or concentration.[2]

The process applied by some of these machines is said to induce brainwave synchronisation or entrainment.[3]

History

[edit]

The influence of rhythmic sounds and drums to enter altered states of consciousness is used in different indigenous tribes (see Shamanic music), as well as optical stimulation produced by the flickering light of camp fires or pressing lightly on the eyeballs.[4] This "stroboscopic photo-stimulation produces 'photic driving', the alpha type of brain electrical activity associated with an altered state in which people are susceptible to suggestion". ([4] p. 12).

The first scientific observations were made by William Charles Wells in the 1790s who described different effects of binocular vision. His results were later transferred to be applied in binaural beats.[5] Visual experiments with flickering lights were conducted in the 1940s by William Grey Walter who used stroboscopic light flashes to measure their effects on brain activity, assessed with EEG. He reported effect not just on visual areas but on the whole cortex.[6]

The development of alpha EEG feedback (see neurofeedback) is an important starting point for biofeedback and its explicit use for entering altered states of consciousness.[7] Enterprises started to produce different types of mind machines and some scientists followed the line of research to explore if and how these devices elicit effects on brain processes.[8]

In the late 1980s and early 1990s Farley initiated an investigation concerning medical claims made by some manufacturers and sellers.[9] The FDA concluded that Light and Sound Machines were not medical devices and did not warrant regulation. Sellers and manufacturers were given guidelines for how they could advertise these devices, and were required to include a disclaimer and cautionary document with each machine.[citation needed] Nowadays, mind machines are rediscovered by some teenage cultures as so called "digital drugs", a legal way to enter altered states of consciousness.[10]

Application

[edit]

Mind machines include flashing light devices, which are similar to the Brion Gysin dreamachine in that both produce a flickering visual field. Unlike flashing light devices, the dreamachine can be used by several people at once, but has few, if any, technical features.

Technical setting

[edit]
A Brion Gysin dreamachine

Mind machines typically consist of a control unit, a pair of headphones and/or strobe light goggles. The unit controls the sessions and drives the LEDs in the goggles. Professionally, they are usually referred to as Auditory Visual Stimulation Devices (AVS devices).[11] Some mind machines available today can even connect to the Internet to download additional session material.

Regulation

[edit]

Mind machine devices are legally available throughout the United States from many sources.[10]

With some exceptions,[12] these devices commonly do not have FDA approval for medical applications in the US. They have been found by a U.S. district court to be Class III medical devices, and consequentially require FDA pre-market approval for all medical uses. One company making medical claims for a possibly unsafe device has been shut down and seen their devices destroyed.[9]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Mind machine

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
A mind machine, also known as a light and sound machine or audio-visual entrainment (AVE) device, is a portable electronic apparatus that delivers synchronized pulses of and to entrain brainwave patterns, thereby inducing targeted states of relaxation, , focus, or altered . These devices typically consist of with embedded LEDs for visual and for auditory input, often featuring programmable sessions that mimic brainwave frequencies such as alpha (8-12 Hz) for calm or (4-8 Hz) for . By leveraging the brain's natural tendency to synchronize with rhythmic external stimuli—a process known as entrainment—mind machines aim to modulate neural activity non-invasively, without pharmacological intervention. The historical roots of mind machines extend to ancient practices like rhythmic drumming and fire gazing, which prehistoric cultures (circa 5500–2350 BC) used for induction, but modern development began in the early . French psychologist employed mechanical devices, such as spinning wheels illuminated by lanterns, to reduce symptoms of depression and tension in patients at Salpêtrière . Scientific validation emerged in 1934 when and B. H. C. Matthews demonstrated "photic driving," wherein visual flicker at specific frequencies could override and align the brain's alpha rhythms, as observed via early (EEG). Further advancements included W. Gray Walter's 1950s research on the emotional and perceptual effects of , and the 1959 invention of the "Brainwave Synchronizer" by William Kroger and Sidney Schneider, an electronic tool for enhancing . By the 1980s, commercial devices like the DAVID1 (Digital Audio-Visual Integration Device) were introduced for clinical applications such as anxiety reduction, marking the transition to accessible consumer technology. Mind machines operate through physiological mechanisms involving the and sensory cortices, where repetitive stimuli—ideally matching the brain's intrinsic frequencies—trigger neural , increased cerebral blood flow, and release, such as serotonin and . They have been applied in therapeutic contexts to alleviate , anxiety, depression, and attention-deficit disorders, with studies showing benefits like improved mood after 30-minute sessions at 14 Hz for depression or enhanced via entrainment at 5.5 Hz. For instance, audiovisual stimulation has demonstrated reductions in negative affect and cognitive enhancements in controlled trials, positioning it as an accessible alternative to traditional . However, remains mixed, with some randomized controlled trials reporting significant EEG changes and symptom relief while others find limited effects beyond , underscoring the need for standardized protocols and further research, particularly for vulnerable populations like those with .

History

Early Origins

The use of rhythmic auditory and visual stimuli to induce altered states of consciousness dates back to prehistoric and indigenous practices, where such methods facilitated spiritual journeys and healing rituals. In Siberian , prolonged drumming and dancing served as primary techniques for shamans to enter states, enabling communication with spirits and resolution of community issues. Similarly, among Native American groups like the Ojibway, shamans employed drumming, chanting, and ritual enclosures such as shaking tents to achieve ecstatic for and curing illnesses. Flickering firelight also played a role in these traditions, with its photic driving effect—observed in evening gatherings around campfires—contributing to trance induction by promoting dissociation and visionary experiences in both Siberian and Native American contexts. Early European explorations of visual illusions through optical devices emerged in the late , laying groundwork for understanding perceptual effects from structured light and motion. Italian scholar , in his 1593 work , described experiments using septa to present dissimilar images or colors to each eye, inducing suppression and alternation in perception akin to , which produced striking without mechanical rotation. These manual setups prefigured more complex devices, though rotating mechanisms for illusions, such as revolving disks with sequential images, appeared later in the as precursors to motion simulation. By the late , systematic observations of visual stimulation advanced these ideas. In 1792, British physician William Charles Wells documented experiments on binocular color rivalry, noting how one hue dominated during phases of apparent transparency when viewing contrasting stimuli through tubes, highlighting the brain's selective processing of conflicting inputs. These pre-19th-century efforts shifted toward empirical inquiry, paving the way for 20th-century scientific formalization of such phenomena.

Scientific Foundations

The scientific foundations of mind machines trace back to early 20th-century explorations of flicker therapy and mid-century neurophysiological research on brainwave synchronization through sensory stimulation. French psychologist , at the turn of the , employed mechanical flicker devices, such as spinning wheels illuminated by lanterns, to reduce symptoms of depression, tension, and hysteria in patients at Salpêtrière Hospital. Scientific validation emerged in 1934 when and B. H. C. Matthews demonstrated "photic driving," wherein visual flicker at specific frequencies (8-12 Hz) could override and align the brain's alpha rhythms, as observed via early (EEG). In the 1950s, British neurophysiologist William Grey Walter conducted pioneering experiments using stroboscopic lights to explore EEG responses, with key work published in his 1953 book The Living Brain. Walter synchronized intermittent photic flashes to , typically in the 8-12 Hz range, observing that this entrainment could induce states of relaxation by aligning brain rhythms with the external stimulus. His findings demonstrated how flicker could drive alpha activity, laying early groundwork for devices that manipulate mental states via visual input. Building on such insights, the saw the emergence of , particularly alpha EEG , which enabled conscious control over brainwave patterns. Psychologist Joe Kamiya at the developed key protocols starting in the late 1950s but prominently in the , using auditory feedback to train subjects to modulate alpha activity. In his 1962 experiments, participants learned to discriminate the presence or absence of with near-perfect accuracy after 50-500 trials, reporting associations between increased alpha and states of relaxed alertness, while visual imagery suppressed it. By 1966, Kamiya's work extended to frequency control, where subjects adjusted alpha cycle durations by up to 15% over sessions, establishing direct links between trainable brainwave patterns and subjective mental states like calmness or focus. The late 1950s marked the transition to integrated electronic prototypes combining light and sound for entrainment, drawing from prior photic driving research. The Brainwave Synchronizer, invented in 1959 by William Kroger and Sidney Schneider, was an electronic clinical photic stimulator using a xenon strobe light adjustable to brainwave frequencies alongside auditory elements to induce hypnotic relaxation; it was applied in clinical contexts through the 1970s. A seminal 1973 study by Kinney et al. further validated photic driving mechanisms, showing that rapid visual stimulation at around 10 Hz elicited overlapping evoked potentials that synchronized EEG alpha rhythms, with optimal entrainment observed at delays matching natural brain cycles. These advancements provided empirical support for multisensory approaches in altering neurological states, influencing subsequent mind machine designs.

Commercial Development

The commercialization of mind machines gained momentum in the , with early clinical devices paving the way for consumer products. The DAVID1 (Digital Audio-Visual Integration Device), designed in 1984, was introduced for applications such as and anxiety reduction in clinical settings. Synetic Systems, a precursor to MindPlace, began selling microprocessor-controlled light and sound systems in 1988, marking one of the earliest entries into the consumer market for audio-visual entrainment technology. This period saw the rise of portable units like the early models from Synetic, which leveraged advancing electronics to make accessible beyond laboratory settings. In the 1990s, the market expanded with refined products such as the , released by MindPlace, which featured programmable sessions using bi-color LED goggles and stereo headphones for immersive experiences. Companies like MindPlace continued to innovate, building on 1980s foundations with devices derived from predecessors like the MindLab and Esprit, fostering broader adoption among wellness enthusiasts. The shifted mind machines toward digital formats, with apps and downloads enabling easy access to binaural beats and entrainment sessions without dedicated hardware. A notable trend emerged in the , dubbed "digital drugs," where youth experimented with audio files mimicking psychoactive effects through binaural beats, sparking parental concerns and media coverage. Examples include apps like Binaural Beats Therapy, developed in 2010 and offering customizable frequencies for relaxation and focus, which proliferated on platforms like . This digital evolution democratized the technology, integrating it into smartphones and streaming services for global reach.

Technology

Core Components

Mind machines, also known as audio-visual entrainment () devices, feature a central that serves as the microprocessor-based hub for managing session parameters. This unit typically includes programmable capabilities for selecting frequencies, patterns, and durations, often via an intuitive interface such as buttons or a backlit LCD display for navigating pre-programmed sessions. For instance, devices like the Kasina Mind Media System employ a colored LCD screen to display session options and status, allowing users to choose from over 70 built-in programs without requiring external software. Audio delivery systems in mind machines consist of headphones or built-in speakers designed to output binaural beats or within specific frequency ranges, such as 4-40 Hz, corresponding to , alpha, beta, and gamma brainwave patterns. These components ensure synchronized pulsed audio signals, with providing immersive delivery; examples include the standard sets bundled with the DAVID Delight Pro, which support entrainment through rhythmic tones. Visual delivery is achieved through specialized equipped with light-emitting diodes (LEDs) or, in earlier models, incandescent bulbs for photic , creating flickering patterns to engage the . Modern variants often incorporate advanced LED arrays for multi-color output, such as the Ganzframes in MindPlace systems, which produce 255 shades per color for varied session experiences. Accessories complement the core hardware, including rechargeable power sources like USB-compatible batteries or AC adapters, interconnecting cables for and , and optional features such as USB ports for loading custom content. Devices like the Laxman Innertainment system exemplify this with USB interfaces and accompanying software for user-created sessions, alongside carry cases and stimulus cables for portability and expanded functionality. As of 2025, newer devices like the ROSHIWave IN-SIGHT incorporate brainwave disentrainment protocols alongside traditional entrainment for enhanced and performance applications.

Brainwave Entrainment Mechanisms

Brainwave entrainment refers to the process by which external rhythmic stimuli synchronize neural oscillations in the brain to specific frequencies, leveraging the brain's natural tendency to follow periodic inputs through mechanisms like the frequency-following response (FFR). This synchronization, often measured via (EEG), aims to guide brain activity into desired states associated with particular frequency bands. The primary EEG frequency bands targeted in entrainment include delta (0.5–4 Hz, associated with deep ), (4–8 Hz, linked to and light ), alpha (8–12 Hz, related to relaxation and closed-eye ), beta (12–30 Hz, involved in active concentration and focus), and gamma (above 30 Hz, connected to higher and ). These bands represent distinct oscillatory patterns in activity, with entrainment techniques modulating them to influence physiological and mental states. Photic driving, a visual entrainment method, involves flashing lights at target frequencies to elicit FFR in the , where neural responses rhythmically align with the stimulus rate—for instance, 10 Hz flashes to promote synchronization. This phenomenon, first observed in EEG studies of intermittent photic stimulation, produces measurable steady-state visual evoked potentials that mirror the driving frequency and its harmonics. Auditory entrainment utilizes sound-based stimuli to align auditory pathways with desired rhythms. Binaural beats occur when two slightly differing tones are presented separately to each ear (e.g., 200 Hz to the left and 210 Hz to the right, yielding a 10 Hz perceived beat), processed in the superior olivary complex to generate a low-frequency modulation that entrains cortical oscillations. Monaural modulation, by contrast, delivers amplitude-modulated tones to both ears simultaneously, creating beats at the cochlear level that propagate through the auditory system to induce similar entrainment effects. Combined modalities enhance entrainment by integrating photic and auditory stimuli, potentially amplifying through cross-modal interactions in the .

Applications

Therapeutic and Wellness Uses

Mind machines, employing theta-frequency through audio-visual stimulation (AVS), have demonstrated potential in alleviating . A involving patients with found that 30-minute sessions of binaural beats significantly reduced pain intensity and use after both acute and one-week applications. In the context of migraine therapy, a comprehensive of studies indicated benefits for individuals suffering from headaches and s, with entrainment protocols contributing to symptom relief alongside other psychological effects. For anxiety and stress reduction, mind machines utilize alpha-wave targeting (typically 8-12 Hz) to induce relaxation states. Clinical trials have shown that binaural beat sessions in the alpha range effectively lower anxiety levels, as evidenced by improved mood and reduced state anxiety in participants undergoing preoperative entrainment. These approaches are often integrated with in clinical settings, where real-time EEG monitoring enhances the entrainment process to promote emotional regulation and stress mitigation, as supported by reviews of AVS applications in therapeutic . In addressing sleep disorders such as , delta-frequency programs (0.5-4 Hz) within mind machines facilitate deeper restorative . A pilot on older adults with and comorbid pain reported that nightly 30-minute AVS sessions progressing from alpha to delta frequencies reduced severity from moderate to mild levels over one month. Specific protocols, including low-frequency (e.g., 2 Hz) combined with synchronized light pulses, have been explored to enhance consolidation by entraining slow-wave activity, though further validation is ongoing in clinical contexts. For ADHD and , beta (13-30 Hz) and gamma (30-100 Hz) stimulation via mind machines supports improved focus and . Studies on children with ADHD using AVS protocols over multiple sessions (typically 20-30 minutes, two to three times per week) have shown significant gains in and reduced , a practice integrated into clinics since the . Additionally, 40 Hz gamma entrainment has been linked to enhanced sustained in preliminary trials on cognitive performance. As of 2025, ongoing research explores for neurodegenerative applications like , building on therapeutic uses.

Recreational and Performance Enhancement

Mind machines find recreational application in facilitating deeper and creative states through entrainment (4-8 Hz), which promotes enhanced visualization and access to subconscious imagery. Users often employ these devices during personal sessions to stimulate lucid dreaming, where individuals gain awareness and control within dreams, fostering imaginative exploration. This practice has gained traction in and spiritual communities, where theta sessions complement traditional techniques like to unlock intuitive insights and artistic inspiration. For peak performance enhancement, entrainment (around 40 Hz) is utilized to induce heightened focus and cognitive acuity, particularly among athletes and professionals. Devices deliver pulsed and sound to synchronize brain activity, enabling pre-event sessions that boost reaction times and mental clarity, as seen in executive coaching programs aimed at improving under pressure. Representative examples include athletes using gamma protocols to enter flow states during training, mirroring the neural patterns associated with optimal performance. In entertainment contexts, mind machines contribute to "digital drugs" trends via binaural beat apps like , launched in the mid-2000s, which simulate resembling recreational substances through audio tracks mimicking or . These have been integrated into group experiences at raves and wellness retreats, where participants share synchronized sessions for collective mood elevation and immersive sensory play. Customization allows users to program mind machines for targeted mood alteration, such as 40 Hz patterns to evoke or relaxation, using software interfaces on devices like audio-visual entrainment (AVE) systems. This personalization enables tailored sessions for , drawing on adjustable frequencies to suit individual preferences for emotional uplift without therapeutic intent.

Scientific Evidence and Effects

Research on Efficacy

Research on the efficacy of mind machines has primarily involved controlled trials and reviews examining techniques such as photic stimulation, audiovisual entrainment, and binaural beats, with methodologies often including EEG measurements to assess and self-reported scales for psychological outcomes. A seminal comprehensive of 20 peer-reviewed studies from 1950 to 2007 analyzed the psychological effects of , including photic stimulation protocols using rhythmic light flashes to induce targeted brainwave states like alpha or . The found photic stimulation effective for treating or preventing migraines in two studies and muscle in another two, with EEG driving responses observed in 70-100% of participants across various trials, indicating reliable entrainment but calling for more rigorous controls to confirm therapeutic benefits. Subsequent studies have explored audiovisual entrainment specifically for anxiety reduction, employing sessions of 20-30 minutes with synchronized light and sound patterns to promote EEG in beta or alpha ranges. A 2014 small-scale study on audiovisual entrainment (n=6 anxious individuals) demonstrated reductions in automatic processing bias toward stressful events and explicit reports of anxiety levels following 30-minute alpha-targeted sessions, though results varied by participant. These findings suggest potential short-term benefits for anxiety through altered neural processing, though placebo-controlled designs highlighted individual differences in responsiveness. Meta-analyses on binaural beats, a core component of many mind machines, have yielded mixed results regarding cognitive enhancement while showing more consistent benefits for relaxation. A meta-analysis of 22 randomized controlled trials reported a small to moderate overall (Hedges' g=0.45) on anxiety, perception, and combined, with stronger outcomes for short-term relaxation protocols using or delta frequencies, but inconsistent impacts on or tasks. Limitations included small sample sizes in over 60% of trials (n<50), heterogeneous methodologies, and short intervention durations, underscoring the need for larger, long-term studies to validate cognitive claims. In the 2020s, research has increasingly focused on app-based mind machines, integrating binaural beats and photic elements via smartphones. A 2023 study on theta entrainment (4-8 Hz) for (n=31) showed significant increases in theta power across regions post a single 15-minute session, as measured by EEG. However, gaps persist in long-term efficacy data, with most studies limited to acute effects and lacking diverse populations, emphasizing ongoing methodological refinements for broader validation. Recent research as of 2025 continues to explore entrainment (AVE), with a narrative review highlighting promising but mixed results for therapeutic applications. For instance, AVE at specific frequencies has shown benefits for depression (e.g., reduced symptoms with 14 Hz over 20 sessions), (improved symptoms with alpha-to-delta transitions over 4 weeks), and cognitive enhancement (e.g., via 5.5 Hz ), though evidence remains heterogeneous due to varying protocols. A 2024 randomized trial positioned stimulation as an accessible alternative to breath-focused , demonstrating enhancements in mood and . Limitations include small samples, lack of , and the need for more rigorous controlled trials, particularly to address risks for photosensitive individuals.

Neurological and Psychological Impacts

Mind machines, through mechanisms like audio-visual entrainment and binaural beats, can induce measurable changes in activity, including increased interhemispheric EEG coherence. Specifically, binaural beats at alpha frequencies (around 10 Hz) enhance phase synchronization between auditory cortices across hemispheres, promoting more unified neural processing. Psychologically, mind machines targeting frequencies (4-8 Hz) show mixed effects on and mood, with some studies indicating potential influences on recall. Short-term impacts include acute relaxation, evidenced by post-session reductions in levels following beta-frequency entrainment during stress, which helps mitigate the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis response. Long-term regular use may promote through sustained phase synchronization, though evidence remains preliminary. Individual responsiveness to mind machines varies significantly, influenced by factors like age and baseline EEG patterns; younger individuals or those with higher baseline alpha power often exhibit stronger entrainment effects, while older adults or those with atypical rhythms show diminished responses. traits, such as openness, and prior experience with further modulate outcomes, with experienced users demonstrating more pronounced shifts in oscillatory activity.

Regulation and Safety

The legal frameworks governing mind machines, which include devices and software for via light, sound, or binaural beats, vary significantly by jurisdiction, primarily focusing on their classification as non-medical consumer products unless therapeutic claims are made. In the United States, the (FDA) classifies mind machines as low-risk general wellness products under its 2016 policy if they are promoted solely for maintaining or encouraging a healthy without diagnosing, treating, curing, mitigating, or preventing diseases. This exempts them from premarket review as medical devices, treating them instead as Class I devices subject to basic good manufacturing practices. However, makers are prohibited from unsubstantiated therapeutic claims; violations can lead to enforcement actions, such as the FDA's 2022 warning letter to NeuroField, Inc., for marketing magnetic stimulation devices with for unapproved medical uses like treating depression and anxiety, deeming them adulterated and misbranded. Similarly, the (FTC) has pursued cases against companies for of cognitive enhancement technologies, including actions in the such as the 2016 settlement with for unsubstantiated claims. Internationally, regulations emphasize safety compliance without endorsing efficacy for non-medical uses. In the European Union, mind machines qualify as electrical equipment under the Low Voltage Directive (2014/35/EU) and Electromagnetic Compatibility Directive (2014/30/EU), requiring CE marking to certify conformity with essential safety and performance standards before market placement. Medical claims would reclassify them under the Medical Device Regulation (EU) 2017/745, necessitating notified body assessment and clinical evidence, but most are sold without such claims to avoid stringent oversight. Variations exist globally; for instance, Australia's Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) lists unproven therapeutic devices as "listed medicines" requiring evidence for claims, enforced via border controls and consumer protection laws. Recent developments in the reflect heightened scrutiny on digital formats, such as app-based binaural beats branded as "digital drugs" simulating psychoactive effects. Regulators, including the FDA and FTC in the , apply frameworks to curb deceptive marketing of unsubstantiated claims of altered states or addiction simulation that could mislead vulnerable users, particularly youth. In parallel, aspects have evolved; key patents for hemispheric synchronization methods, like held by for inducing desired brain states via audio signals, expired in 2010 after their 20-year term, enabling broader adoption of similar technologies while trademarks like Hemi-Sync remain protected for branded applications.

Health Risks and Precautions

Mind machines, which utilize flickering lights and pulsed sounds for audio-visual entrainment (AVE), pose notable photosensitive risks, particularly for individuals with or undiagnosed . Exposure to flashing lights in the 10-20 Hz range can trigger seizures in approximately 3% of with epilepsy, with even lower in the general (1 in 4,000 children and 1 in 20,000 adults over 25). These seizures are typically self-limiting but may result in falls or injury, and individuals with a of photosensitivity are strongly advised to avoid such devices due to the potential for provocation even without prior . Additionally, those prone to migraines may experience exacerbated symptoms from the visual stimuli, while individuals with heart conditions, including arrhythmias, face risks from heightened physiological arousal during sessions. Psychological concerns associated with mind machine use are generally minimal but can include temporary dissociation or over-reliance on the device for relaxation, potentially leading to avoidance of natural mechanisms. Rare reports highlight increased anxiety, , or emotional following intense or prolonged sessions, particularly if users have underlying vulnerabilities. Overuse has been linked to mild side effects such as , headaches, or , which usually resolve quickly but underscore the need for moderation to prevent psychological discomfort. To mitigate these risks, established usage guidelines emphasize starting with short sessions of 5-10 minutes at low and intensities, gradually increasing duration only if tolerated. Users should remain seated or lying down in a safe environment, avoiding operation of machinery or immediately after sessions, and adjust settings to comfortable levels to prevent overstimulation. Manufacturer protocols require clear disclaimers on packaging, and consultation with a healthcare provider is recommended prior to use, especially for those on medications like stimulants or tranquilizers, which may interact adversely. In clinical settings, EEG monitoring can help assess real-time responses for safer application. Vulnerable populations warrant particular caution, with mind machines contraindicated for pregnant individuals due to unestablished fetal safety and potential risks. Children under 12, and those under 26 more broadly, should avoid use owing to developing neurological sensitivity and higher prevalence. Individuals with pacemakers or implanted cardiac devices are also advised against exposure, as the entrainment may induce irregular heart rhythms, though light-based mechanisms pose less than other modalities.

References

  1. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12564294/
  2. https://indyneurofeedback.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Article-1-AVE-History-and-Physiological-Mechanisms.pdf
  3. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9850804/
  4. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-75943-8
  5. https://hraf.yale.edu/ehc/summaries/altered-states-of-consciousness
  6. https://scholarscompass.vcu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1302&context=ess
  7. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/261956873_Early_views_on_binocular_rivalry
  8. https://precinemahistory.com/chapter-five/
  9. https://karger.com/ene/article/62/5/316/124200/From-Stroboscope-to-Dream-Machine-A-History-of
  10. https://isnr-jnt.org/article/download/16584/10551
  11. https://mindplace.com/pages/about-us
  12. https://mindplace.com/pages/legacy-devices
  13. https://mindplacesupport.com/proteus/
  14. https://mindplacesupport.com/forum/showthread.php?2144-Love-the-Procyon
  15. https://www.npr.org/2010/07/14/128519787/researcher-dispels-notion-music-can-get-kids-high
  16. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ihunda.android.binauralbeat&hl=en_US
  17. https://mindplace.com/products/kasina-mind-media-meditation-system
  18. https://mindalive.com/collections/ave-devices/products/david-delight-pro
  19. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10198548/
  20. https://mindplace.com/collections/light-sound
  21. https://www.mindplace.com.au/p/laxman-innertainment-light-and-sound-mind-machine-1
  22. https://www.mindmachines.com/
  23. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4989477/
  24. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK539805/
  25. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9749579/
  26. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3407313/
  27. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7082494/
  28. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7204407/
  29. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32564499/
  30. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18780583/
  31. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38736759/
  32. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC12564294/
  33. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sleep.2021.03.025
  34. https://news.eeginfo.com/applying-audio-visual-entrainment-technology-for-attention-and-learning-part-3/
  35. https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2025.08.25.671937v1
  36. https://www.brain.fm/blog/the_power_of_theta_brainwaves_focus_relaxation_creativity
  37. https://www.mendi.io/blogs/brain-health/theta-brain-waves-benefits-and-how-to-increase-them
  38. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39535938/
  39. https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/you-20/201007/i-dosing-digital-drugs-and-binaural-beats
  40. https://mindalive.com/collections/ave-devices
  41. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/23246357_A_comprehensive_review_of_the_psychological_effects_of_brainwave_entrainment
  42. https://www.scirp.org/journal/paperinformation?paperid=50557
  43. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30073406/
  44. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10700810/
  45. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26541421/
  46. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4428073/
  47. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/18387357.2024.2374759
  48. https://www.avensonline.org/wp-content/uploads/JNP-2332-3469-11-0053.pdf
  49. https://www.fda.gov/regulatory-information/search-fda-guidance-documents/general-wellness-policy-low-risk-devices
  50. https://www.fda.gov/inspections-compliance-enforcement-and-criminal-investigations/warning-letters/neurofield-inc-621767-02282022
  51. https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2016/01/lumosity-pay-2-million-settle-ftc-deceptive-advertising-charges-its-brain-training-program
  52. https://patents.google.com/patent/US5213562A/en
  53. https://www.epilepsy.com/what-is-epilepsy/seizure-triggers/photosensitivity
  54. https://photosonix.com/medical-disclaimer/
  55. https://brainworksneurotherapy.com/brainwave-entrainment/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.