Hubbry Logo
NMC HealthNMC HealthMain
Open search
NMC Health
Community hub
NMC Health
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
NMC Health
NMC Health
NMC Health
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

NMC Health (Arabic: مستشفى المركز الطبي الجديد) was a healthcare chain and distribution business in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The company is headquartered in Abu Dhabi and has branch offices in Dubai, Ajman, Al Ain and Northern Emirates. The company operates and manages over 200 facilities in 19 countries.[2]

Key Information

The company was accused in 2019 of understating debt on its balance sheet and later revealed that debt of US$2.7 billion had not been reported.[3][4]

On 8 April 2020, NMC was placed into administration by UK High Court judge Sebastian Prentis due to the insolvency of the company caused by frauds alleged to have been committed by the founder and chairman of the board B. R. Shetty.[5][6]

In 2023 the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) censured the company for committing market abuse by understating its debts by as much as $4bn. No fine was issued as the business was not expected to have any funds left after paying debts.[7]

History

[edit]

NMC Health was founded by B. R. Shetty in 1974 as the New Medical Centre in Abu Dhabi.[8] In 1981, a new marketing & distribution division, NMC Trading was launched, which distributed medicines to pharmacies in the UAE. This division would later expand into distribution of fast-moving consumer goods, medical equipments and supplies and educational products.[9]

From 1996, NMC began expanding to other emirates, setting up the NMC Clinic in Sharjah (1996), NMC Hospital, Deira, Dubai (1999), the NMC Specialty Hospital, Dubai (2004) and NMC Specialty Hospital in Al Ain (2008). In 2009, these hospitals were awarded the JCIA accreditation.[10] In April 2012, NMC listed on the London Stock Exchange.[11][12] That same year, NMC began managing operations at the Shiekh Khalifa General Hospital in Umm Al Quwain, acquired the BR Medical Suites in Dubai Healthcare City and continued their expansion with the addition of new medical setups such as NMC Royal Hospital in Khalifa City[13] and operations in Al Ain's industrial area.[14] In 2013, the company added a day-surgery centre in Mohammed Bin Zayed City in Abu Dhabi. NMC Health opened the NMC Hospital in Dubai Investments Park, NMC Brightpoint Royal Women's Hospital, and the NMC Medical Centre in Al Ain in 2014.[10]

NMC Health acquired the Spain-based Clínica Eugin in 2015, allowing the company to become the leading integrated women's health provider from fertility through obstetrics and pediatrics in the UAE.[15] That same year, the company also acquired UAE based medical groups, Dr. Sunny Healthcare Group (leading set of medical clinics in Sharjah and Northern Emirates), Provita and Americare Group, Abu Dhabi (focused on long-term care and rehabilitation)[16] and acquired a 51% stake in Fakih IVF, another leading fertility clinic in UAE.[17]

In August 2016, the company expanded its operations into Saudi Arabia when it acquired a 70 percent stake in As Salama Hospital in Al Khobar; NMC Health also invested in a project to build a 120-bed care centre in Jeddah that will be managed by its subsidiary Provita.[18][19] In December 2016, NMC Health announced the acquisition of Al Zahra Hospital, one of the largest private hospitals in the UAE.[20] In 2017 Emirates Healthcare, owned by Abu Dhabi investment group KBBO, announced the signing of an operating and management contract with NMC Health for the management of their Emirates Healthcare assets.[21] NMC Health bought Aspen Healthcare for £10 million in August 2018.[22]

The company was selected by the Abu Dhabi National Oil Company (ADNOC) to manage operations of Ruwais Hospital in the Al Dhafra region in March 2018.[23][24]

Under-reporting of debt

[edit]

In December 2019, short-seller Muddy Waters questioned the company's statement of accounts, concerned that NMC had "manipulated its balance sheet to understate debt" and contained statements which were "hallmarks of significant fraud".[25][26]

In February 2020, Executive Vice Chairman Khalifa Butti Omeir Bin Yousef resigned from NMC. The company said a legal review was being undertaken to verify the total interests of some of its shareholders over concerns they have been incorrectly reported.[27] Later in the month shares in the company were suspended from trading amid concerns that debt had been under-reported: the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) announced an investigation.[28]

Also in February 2020, as per the regulatory fillings to the London Stock Exchange, the company disclosed about the "highly preliminary approaches" made by the private equity groups Kohlberg Kravis Roberts and Switzerland-based GK Investment for possible buyout.[29][30][31] However, Kohlberg Kravis Roberts withdrew by 11 February 2020,[32] and GK Investment withdrew by the end of February.[33]

In March 2020 the company reported that:[3][4]

it has identified over $2.7 billion in facilities that had previously not been disclosed to or approved by the Board ... The Board believes that some proceeds may have been utilised for non-Group purposes.

This meant that the actual indebtedness was not $2.1 billion as previously reported but circa $5 billion as at 30 June 2019.[34] On 24 March 2020 the total debt was then estimated at $6.6 billion.[35] Many employees were not paid at that time.[36]

On 8 April 2020, NMC went into administration in the UK due to the insolvency of the company due to alleged frauds committed by founder and then-chairman of the board B.R. Shetty.[6] Consequent to the request from the board of directors of NMC and on going investigation of potential financial irregularities, the company was suspended from its listing on the London Stock Exchange.[37]

On 15 April 2020, Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank filed a criminal complaint against NMC Health with the Attorney General's Office of UAE.[38]

In December 2020, Shetty sold the company for $1 to an Israeli-UAE consortium.[39]

In April 2021, HSBC and Standard Chartered cleared around $370M worth of positions in NMC's debt in two separate auctions as more information about likely restructuring recoveries become available.[40]

In 2023 the UK FCA censured the company for committing market abuse by understating its debts by as much as $4bn. No fine was issued as the business was not expected to have any funds left after paying debts.[7]

Operations

[edit]

NMC Health operates two business segments, healthcare distribution and services. The healthcare arm operates an international network of hospitals around the UAE and Europe. It is the largest private healthcare provider in the UAE and provides medical services including diagnostics, outpatient clinics, gynecology, obstetrics, human reproduction and pharmacy retail.[41] In 2017, it operated more than 45 locations and more than 15 pharmacies, and employed over 1,200 doctors who saw more than 11,000 patients daily.[42][43] NMC Health's distribution and services arm operates the subsidiary, NMC Trading, which engages in wholesale trading of pharmaceuticals, medical equipment, food and cosmetics.[44] NMC Trading has distribution rights for companies such as, Nestlé, Pfizer, Siemens, Samsung, Sanofi and Henkel.[42]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

NMC Health

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

NMC Health PLC was a healthcare provider founded in 1974 by as a and in , , which expanded into the largest private operator of medical facilities in the UAE.
The company operated across multiple sectors including multi-specialty hospitals, maternity and fertility s, long-term care facilities, day surgery centers, and pharmaceutical distribution, generating over half its revenue from hospital services by 2018. It pursued aggressive growth through acquisitions, expanding from five facilities in the UAE to over 100 across 17 countries between 2012 and 2018, with expenditures exceeding $1.8 billion on more than 29 businesses.
NMC Health listed on the London Stock Exchange in 2012 at an initial valuation of $665 million, achieving a peak of $11 billion by 2018. However, its trajectory reversed following a December 2019 report by short-seller alleging inflated cash balances, overstated asset values, and understated debt, prompting an internal investigation. The probe uncovered $2.7 billion in previously undisclosed debt, with total liabilities estimated at $6.6 billion against reported figures around $2.1 billion, including systematic use of off-balance-sheet financing.
The UK determined that NMC committed market abuse by disseminating misleading , understating debt by as much as $4.1 billion in its 2019 interim results (reported $2.1 billion actual $6.2 billion) and $3.91 billion in March 2019 (reported $1.99 billion actual $5.91 billion). Shares were suspended in February 2020 and the company entered administration on April 9, 2020, with delisting shortly thereafter; no funds are expected for shareholders after claims. This collapse highlighted vulnerabilities in rapid expansion financed through undisclosed leverage and dual accounting practices at senior levels.

Founding and Early Development

Origins and Initial Operations

NMC Health originated in 1974 when , an Indian-born who had relocated to the in 1973, established the New Medical Centre as a modest and diagnostic clinic in . This venture addressed the burgeoning need for accessible pharmaceutical and basic medical services amid the UAE's rapid post-oil boom development, where the influx of workers created demand for private healthcare options despite government-provided free services. The initial operations centered on retail pharmacy dispensing and elementary diagnostic procedures, targeting primarily South Asian expatriates and other foreign residents who formed a significant portion of Abu Dhabi's population in the mid-1970s. Shetty's decision to launch the represented a calculated , as it competed indirectly with state-subsidized care, yet capitalized on gaps in personalized, prompt services for non-citizens underserved by public facilities. Early challenges included limited in the nascent UAE healthcare landscape and reliance on imported pharmaceuticals, but the operation benefited from Shetty's professional background and the economic vibrancy fueled by oil revenues. By the late 1970s, NMC Health had initiated modest expansion into additional outpatient clinics within , leveraging contracts with local employers and government entities to serve expatriate workforces in sectors like and . This phase marked verifiable early growth through incremental facility additions and pharmacy network buildup, with operations remaining focused on cost-effective basic care rather than specialized treatments, laying empirical groundwork via steady volume increases tied to demographic shifts. Specific metrics from this period are sparse, but the model's stemmed from low-overhead retail and synergies, avoiding capital-intensive expansions.

Leadership Under B.R. Shetty

B.R. Shetty, an Indian-born pharmacist, arrived in Abu Dhabi in 1973 with approximately US$8 in capital and established the New Medical Centre (NMC) in 1975 as the UAE's first private healthcare facility, initially operating as a modest pharmacy and clinic where his wife, Chandrakumari Shetty, served as the sole doctor. This founding reflected Shetty's recognition of unmet demand for affordable primary care amid the UAE's rapid economic development and expatriate influx, leveraging his pharmaceutical expertise to address gaps left by public systems. Under Shetty's direction, NMC pursued by expanding from pharmacy distribution and outpatient services into inpatient hospital operations, opening its first hospital in 1981 and further developing facilities by 1985 to encompass comprehensive medical centers. This strategy prioritized scalable, high-volume service delivery over premium pricing, enabling broad accessibility in a market dominated by state providers and focusing on cost efficiencies to build patient throughput. Early profitability stemmed from Shetty's adoption of a staffing model reliant on Indian healthcare professionals, whose lower structures relative to local or Western hires allowed NMC to maintain competitive pricing while scaling operations without proportional cost escalation. This approach capitalized on the UAE's -heavy demographics, fostering rapid growth from a single outlet to multi-site presence by the late 1980s through operational leverage rather than high-margin specialization.

Expansion and Growth

Geographic and Service Expansion

NMC Health began its geographic expansion within the during the 1990s, establishing operations in Sharjah in 1996 and in 1999, capitalizing on the country's oil-driven economic boom that attracted a surge in population and heightened demand for private healthcare services. This period aligned with UAE government policies promoting and involvement in healthcare to complement public facilities amid rapid and workforce influx. By the 2000s, NMC extended into other (GCC) countries and , acquiring hospitals and clinics to build a regional network responsive to cross-border patient flows and similar economic expansions in the region. Key moves included stakes in facilities serving growing populations, with the company's footprint growing from fewer than five facilities in 2012 to over 100 by 2018 across multiple countries including via the 2016 acquisition of a 70% stake in As Salama Hospital in Al Khobar. By 2017, NMC operated or managed 129 facilities spanning 13 countries, serving millions annually through a combination of owned and partnered sites driven by expatriate demographics and regional healthcare trends. Service diversification accelerated in the , with NMC incorporating specialized offerings beyond general hospitals, including treatments through its 2015 majority stake acquisition in Fakih IVF, a leading provider in the UAE, and expansions into diagnostics and maternity care to address rising demand from diverse patient bases. These additions complemented core inpatient services, enabling NMC to capture segments like reproductive health amid UAE's expatriate-heavy , which increased overall healthcare utilization without relying solely on volume from basic care. The strategy positioned NMC as a multi-service provider, with specialty clinics forming a growing portion of its operations by the mid-2010s, aligned with economic policies fostering private innovation in high-value care areas.

Public Listing and Capital Raising

NMC Health completed its initial public offering on the London Stock Exchange on April 2, 2012, raising £117 million (approximately $187 million) by issuing 55.7 million ordinary shares at £2.10 each. This marked the first listing of an Abu Dhabi-based company on the LSE and valued NMC at around £390 million post-IPO, facilitating entry into the FTSE 250 index. The proceeds supported expansion initiatives, including capital projects, amid the company's positioning as the UAE's largest private healthcare operator serving a growing expatriate and local population. Subsequent capital raising included debt issuances to fund ongoing growth. In November 2018, NMC issued a $400 million with a 5.95% profit rate, maturing in 2023, listed on international markets. Earlier that year, it launched $300 million in 1.875% convertible bonds due April 2025, providing flexible financing convertible into equity. These instruments, alongside , enabled aggressive investments, contributing to reported expansion from $490 million in 2012 to $2.1 billion in 2018. The capital inflows appealed to investors due to NMC's high reported growth trajectory, with revenues achieving a compound annual growth rate of approximately 27% over the 2012–2018 period, fueled by demographic pressures in the Gulf region's emerging healthcare market, including rising demand from a young, diverse population and limited public sector capacity. This performance underpinned NMC's market capitalization surge to $11 billion by 2018, attracting institutional interest in high-yield emerging market healthcare plays.

Business Model and Operations

Core Healthcare Services

NMC Health's core healthcare services encompassed a network of hospitals, specialty clinics, and pharmacies primarily serving the expatriate-dominated population in the . The company's portfolio included multi-specialty hospitals offering inpatient and outpatient care, with key emphases on maternity and , , and elective procedures such as day surgeries for orthopedics and . Pharmacies provided retail dispensing and integrated with clinical services for chronic disease management, contributing to the group's position as a leading supplier of medical products. The operational model leveraged a workforce heavily composed of physicians, predominantly from the , to maintain cost efficiencies amid competitive pricing pressures in the UAE's private healthcare sector. This staffing approach enabled lower operational costs compared to local or Western-trained providers, facilitating affordable access for insured expatriates and supporting high-volume service delivery. NMC's facilities emphasized efficiency in routine and elective care, with partnerships covering a significant portion of patients under mandatory UAE schemes for residents. By 2019, the group reported treating approximately 4 million in the first half of the year, reflecting a 16.7% year-over-year increase and underscoring its scale in outpatient and . In , total patient treatments exceeded 7.5 million, driven by expansions in networks and ties with insurers that reimbursed for high-volume procedures like maternity deliveries and cardiac consultations. This volume positioned NMC as the largest private healthcare provider in the UAE prior to its financial challenges, with services oriented toward preventive and rather than complex tertiary interventions.

Facilities and Workforce

NMC Health operated more than 25 hospitals and over 200 clinics and specialty centers primarily in the , with additional facilities in through its majority stake in Saudi Medical Care Group and limited presence in via partnerships. These assets included multi-specialty hospitals equipped for inpatient and outpatient care, day surgery centers, and diagnostic facilities, reflecting substantial physical infrastructure that continued operating post-administration despite financial misreporting. The company's hospital network featured a total licensed bed capacity of approximately 2,207 beds as of mid-2019, excluding joint venture contributions, with investments in modernizing infrastructure such as advanced imaging and surgical suites funded through debt financing and operational cash flows. These expansions prioritized high-acuity services like cardiology and oncology, supported by equipment upgrades and facility renovations verifiable through pre-scandal site inspections and regulatory filings, underscoring tangible operational scale amid later revelations of overstated revenues. NMC Health employed over 20,000 staff members pre-2020, including more than 2,000 physicians and the remainder in , paramedical, and support roles, with staffing ratios aligned to UAE healthcare standards requiring adequate coverage for volumes exceeding 3 million annually. The workforce was bolstered by ongoing training programs in clinical protocols and , as documented in internal audits and reports from bodies like JCI, which certified several facilities for operational standards independent of financial irregularities. This supported diverse services across owned assets, with recruitment focused on specialists to address local shortages, though post-collapse analyses confirmed employment levels through payroll verifications rather than solely self-reported figures.

Achievements and Market Position

Industry Recognition

NMC Health was promoted to the effective September 18, 2017, marking it as the first Middle Eastern company to join the UK's leading blue-chip index. This inclusion reflected the company's and trading volume thresholds met during FTSE Russell's quarterly review, with shares rising 22% in the preceding quarter to approximately 2,670 pence. Prior to its 2020 administration, NMC Health held the position of the largest private healthcare provider in the by revenue, operating over 20 facilities and serving millions of patients annually across general hospitals, specialty centers, and pharmacies. In 2018, the company was named a finalist for the "Best Building of a " by Healthcare Business International, recognizing its expansion and branding efforts in the regional market. Independent surveys, such as those conducted for the Health Authority Abu Dhabi, documented patient satisfaction data at NMC facilities, including evaluations of care quality and service delivery in the early 2010s, though specific aggregate scores varied by location and year.

Financial Milestones Pre-Scandal

NMC Health reported significant revenue expansion in the years leading up to 2018, growing from US$490 million in 2012 to US$2.1 billion in 2018, driven primarily by organic growth in its healthcare and distribution segments within the UAE and broader GCC region. This trajectory reflected the company's positioning as the largest private healthcare provider in the UAE, with audited financial statements showing consistent year-over-year increases, including a 28% rise from 2017 to 2018. EBITDA margins during this period hovered around 20-22%, with the group achieving a 22% margin in 2017 on reported EBITDA of US$353.4 million, underscoring operational efficiency in hospital operations and pharmaceutical distribution prior to subsequent revelations. The company's financial performance supported robust shareholder returns through escalating payouts, which rose from 6.2 pence per share in to 13 pence in , reflecting confidence in sustained profitability as per audited results. Share price appreciation mirrored this growth, peaking in August when reached $11 billion, equivalent to over £25 per share at prevailing exchange rates, amid investor optimism about NMC's regional dominance and expansion potential. Strategic alliances, including distribution agreements with pharmaceutical suppliers and ties to UAE health initiatives, contributed to verifiable cash inflows, bolstering the distribution segment's 13% growth to $487 million in 2017. These partnerships enhanced reliability and access, aligning with audited figures that portrayed NMC as a high-growth entity in a burgeoning Middle Eastern care market before the 2019-2020 scrutiny.

Financial Irregularities and Collapse

Early Signs of Overstatement

Despite robust reported growth of 28.3% to US$2.1 billion in 2018, NMC Health's began showing moderation, with half-year organic expansion of 13.1% in 2019 aligning with guided ranges of 12-13% for the full year, amid a UAE economy that expanded only 1.7% in 2018 due to subdued oil prices and global trade tensions. The company's return on invested capital deteriorated progressively, falling from 17% in 2016 to 4% in 2017 and 3% in , signaling inefficient capital allocation and potential overpayment for acquisitions that failed to deliver proportional value. Related-party transactions escalated markedly, comprising 7.8% of total costs in compared to lower proportions in prior years, with purchases of healthcare inventory from related entities rising to US$130.1 million from US$78.8 million in 2017, and management fees paid to affiliates increasing to US$10.7 million from US$1.8 million. Amounts due to related parties also grew to US$47.7 million by year-end . The board's review of internal controls in the 2018 highlighted enhancements needed for integrating acquired businesses but affirmed overall effectiveness, with auditors reporting no material weaknesses or significant deficiencies in or control environments at the time. Investor skepticism manifested in share price volatility during 2019, prompting NMC to announce a US$200 million buyback program in to capitalize on what it described as "exceptional price volatility," amid broader concerns over acquisition-driven expansion and leverage. Gearing rose to 59% in 2018 from 55% the prior year, with net debt at US$1.89 billion, underscoring reliance on syndicated loans and bonds for funding growth.

Muddy Waters Report and Initial Response

On December 17, 2019, , a U.S.-based firm specializing in short-selling investigations, released a asserting that NMC Health's contained significant discrepancies. The highlighted red flags in NMC's reported cash balances suggesting material overstatement, inflated asset purchase prices and capital expenditures indicative of potential , and deliberate understatement of by approximately $320 million for fiscal year 2018 through the exclusion of clinic lease obligations from the balance sheet. NMC Health rejected the allegations two days later, on , , labeling the report "false and misleading" and defending its accounting practices, including the monitoring and disclosure of capital expenditures across its projects. The company reaffirmed its revenue and profit forecasts for and 2020, maintaining that its financial position remained strong. countered by describing NMC's rebuttal as "misleading and outright false." The report triggered an immediate market reaction, with NMC's shares plunging by about one-third on December 18, 2019, and losing more than half their value in the ensuing weeks amid . This initial share price collapse reflected heightened doubts about the company's disclosures, despite NMC's denial.

Debt Underreporting Revelation

In February 2020, NMC Health announced that an independent review had identified potential inconsistencies in its bank statements and ledger entries, prompting the initial admission of approximately $2 billion in unreported liabilities, primarily consisting of undisclosed borrowings not reflected in the company's financial statements. This revelation stemmed from forensic examinations revealing dual sets of accounting records, with the accurate versions showing significantly higher debt levels than those disclosed to the market and board. By March 2020, the scope expanded dramatically when NMC disclosed an additional $2.7 billion in hidden from unauthorized loan facilities, previously unknown to the board and used for unspecified purposes, pushing the total identified liabilities to around $5 billion at that point. Further scrutiny uncovered another $1.6 billion, elevating the overall to $6.6 billion by late March 2020, encompassing conventional loans, financing disguised as payables, and other obligations that tripled the previously reported figure of $2.1 billion as of June 2019. This escalation highlighted systemic underreporting, where was systematically omitted from public filings between March 2019 and February 2020, reaching peaks of up to $4 billion in understated amounts. The mechanisms enabling this underreporting involved circular financing arrangements with related entities in the UAE and , including founder-linked companies, where funds were looped through interconnected loans and vendor advances to mask true indebtedness and inflate apparent . Independent probes by company-appointed investigators and subsequent administrators confirmed these tactics through evidence of falsified supplier confirmations and fabricated invoices for medical supplies, which were used to justify and conceal billions in disguised borrowings presented as routine . Such practices underscored profound failures, as board oversight was circumvented via opaque, related-party transactions that prioritized short-term expansion over transparent financial reporting.

Regulatory Probes and Findings

In November 2023, the UK's (FCA) issued a public against NMC Health Plc, determining that the company had committed market abuse by disseminating false and misleading information about its debt levels in financial reports published between 2016 and 2019. The FCA specifically identified understatements of debt totaling up to approximately $4 billion (£3.2 billion) in key disclosures, including the 2019 half-yearly results and full-year results, which portrayed a healthier financial position than existed and thereby deceived investors regarding the company's leverage and liquidity risks. This conduct violated Article 15 of the EU Market Abuse Regulation (MAR), as it involved disclosing information likely to give a false or misleading signal about NMC's assets, liabilities, and financial position, undermining market integrity without any offsetting public interest. The FCA opted not to impose a financial penalty, citing NMC's and administration status, though it noted the breach warranted a substantial fine in ordinary circumstances. In the UAE, where NMC operated its core assets, the Central Bank of the UAE (CBUAE) initiated probes into related financial misconduct, directing licensed banks in April 2020 to freeze accounts held by NMC's founder and his family amid revelations of overstated cash and hidden debts. The Emirates Securities and Commodities Authority (SCA), as regulator of the (DFM) and (ADX) where NMC's subsidiaries were listed, cooperated in investigations uncovering inflated revenues and undisclosed related-party transactions that masked the group's true financial distress. These efforts contributed to trading suspensions and asset preservation measures, though SCA findings emphasized systemic disclosure failures rather than isolated errors, aligning with broader forensic evidence of manipulated accounting practices. Independent administrators appointed following NMC's December 2019 suspension and April 2020 administration detailed the fraud's scope in subsequent reports, revealing that actual indebtedness reached approximately $6.6 billion—far exceeding the reported $2.1 billion—through mechanisms like fictitious balances, undisclosed borrowings, and supplier financing. These investigations, conducted by firms including as joint administrators, corroborated patterns of deliberate concealment, including internal documents outlining payment manipulations and "cheat sheets" for fraudulent schemes, which amplified the debt underreporting identified by regulators. The reports underscored causal links between executive-directed irregularities and the collapse, estimating overstatements in holdings by hundreds of millions and highlighting failures in internal controls that enabled sustained to creditors and markets.

Auditor Liability and Lawsuits

(EY) served as NMC Health's from 2014 to 2019, issuing unqualified opinions on the company's during a period later revealed to involve significant overstatements of and assets, as well as undisclosed exceeding $4 billion. Administrators appointed following NMC's 2020 collapse accused EY of negligence in failing to detect these irregularities, alleging the firm overlooked multiple red flags, including unverified trade receivables, inconsistent access, and evidence of undisclosed borrowings and related-party guarantees. From a verification standpoint, auditors are obligated under international standards to independently corroborate rather than rely solely on client-provided data, particularly when discrepancies arise; EY's procedures reportedly lacked sufficient skepticism, such as not adequately testing receivable confirmations or probing inconsistencies that masked financing. In July 2021, NMC's administrators, Alvarez & Marsal, initiated a against EY in the , seeking approximately $2.5 billion (£2 billion at the time) in to cover liabilities stemming from the hidden debts and guarantees that triggered the company's . The claim escalated in scope during pre-trial proceedings, with administrators arguing EY's audit failures enabled the to persist undetected, directly contributing to losses; by May 2025, the suit demanded up to £2.7 billion, encompassing NMC's full exposure to obligations. The 's (FRC) supported these allegations in a draft report disclosed during the trial, citing "extremely serious" lapses in EY's professional judgment and audit execution, including misrepresentation of document access to regulators. EY has defended itself by asserting that the irregularities resulted from a "pervasive and collusive" fraud orchestrated by NMC's senior executives and shareholders, involving forged documents and impersonation, which rendered detection "impossible" even with standard procedures. The firm maintains it relied appropriately on representations from NMC management and component auditors, and that administrators' selective pursuit of claims—such as dropping actions against certain UAE-connected parties—undermines the suit's credibility. Trial proceedings, which began in May 2025 and continued into October, have highlighted tensions between auditor duties to challenge client data versus the practical limits of uncovering deliberate concealment, with EY contesting the full damages quantum as disproportionate to any proven causal link. No final judgment has been issued as of October 2025.

Criminal and Civil Actions Against Executives

In April 2020, Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank (ADCB) filed a criminal complaint with the UAE Attorney General's office against NMC Health founder B.R. Shetty, former CEO Prasanth Murali, and five other individuals, including alleged secret majority shareholders Khalifa Al Mehairbi and Mohammad Amin, charging them with fraud, forgery of financial records, and collusion to mislead stakeholders. These charges stemmed from allegations of concealing approximately $4 billion in off-balance-sheet debt and related-party transactions that contributed to the company's collapse. No convictions have been publicly reported for these top executives as of late 2025, with proceedings ongoing amid jurisdictional challenges; Shetty, who relocated outside the UAE post-resignation, faced travel restrictions lifted by an Indian court in 2024 but has not returned to face trial. Civil actions against executives have primarily been driven by NMC's administrators. In July 2023, the administrators filed a $4 billion lawsuit in the (ADGM) courts against and Murali, alleging they orchestrated fraudulent schemes including secret debt accumulation and misrepresentation of financial health, seeking damages for losses to creditors and shareholders. Separately, a High Court ordered a worldwide asset freeze on and other former executives in February 2021 to preserve recoveries amid fraud claims. Investor-led actions include a U.S. securities filed in 2020 against NMC directors and executives for misleading statements, with claims deadlines in 2021, though primarily targeting the company and auditors rather than personal liability of executives. No major investor settlements against executives have materialized, with recoveries focused through administration proceedings.

Restructuring and Post-Collapse Status

Administration and Asset Management

In April 2020, following revelations of substantial unreported debt totaling approximately USD 6.6 billion, the English High Court appointed Ben Cairns and Richard Fleming of Alvarez & Marsal as joint administrators for NMC Health Plc to oversee the insolvency process and maximize value for creditors. The administrators prioritized the disposal of non-core assets while stabilizing core UAE hospital operations, with creditor recovery efforts focused on a creditor hierarchy that favored secured lenders and banks holding the bulk of the debt. Concurrently, on 27 April 2020, NMC Health requested and effected the delisting of its shares from the London Stock Exchange after a two-month trading suspension, reflecting the company's diminished viability as a listed entity amid the administration. Asset management under administration involved targeted sales of international and non-essential holdings to generate proceeds exceeding USD 5 billion for creditor repayment, with priority allocated to senior secured debt holders such as Abu Dhabi Commercial Bank. Notable disposals included the April 2021 sale of the Eugin Group fertility business to Fresenius SE for USD 525 million and the divestiture of a 53 percent stake in Saudi German Health (SMGC), marking the offloading of remaining international operations. Debt restructuring efforts culminated in creditor approvals for a plan that transferred ownership of 34 core NMC group companies to a , effectively converting portions of the into equity stakes to facilitate operational continuity and partial recovery. This process, overseen by the administrators, emphasized empirical valuation of assets and strict adherence to priorities, though NMC Health Plc itself remained in administration to pursue litigation claims for further distributions.

Recovery Efforts and 2025 Developments

Following the completion of its $7.6 billion in March 2022, which enabled the continuation of operations across its entities without disruption, NMC Healthcare implemented a four-pillar focused on portfolio expansion, asset optimisation, , and financial to drive recovery and growth. In portfolio expansion efforts during 2025, the company acquired the JCI-accredited Orthoplus Bone Centre in , adding orthopaedics and capabilities; launched the Marina Walk paediatric centre in and a multi-speciality centre at Nakheel Mall; and expanded NMC Royal Khalifa by 26 beds, with two additional facilities pending regulatory approval in at Al Riyadh Medical City and . Asset optimisation included renovations at Dubai Investment Park to develop a 220-bed featuring a trauma centre and women and children facilities, alongside a connecting bridge at Al Nahda to boost emergency and maternity capacity. Operational efficiency advanced through a with for AI-powered data analytics across its 83 UAE facilities, aimed at improving and outcomes, complemented by the formation of an AI steering committee; service line growth encompassed new , wellness, and programs, plus development of a transplant centre at NMC Royal Hospital Sharjah, while securing enterprise-wide JCI accreditation—one of only 13 globally. Company leadership described these initiatives as enabling the group to "reach more s, deliver more specialised services, and do so more efficiently than ever before." Despite these operational advancements, recovery faced headwinds from protracted litigation, including a May 2025 trial in where administrators pursued $2.6 billion in damages against EY for alleged negligent auditing that failed to detect pre-collapse , described by claimants as "disgraceful" over seven years. Ongoing creditor disputes, such as a September 2025 DIFC court ruling on entitlements from the restructuring and a failed defence amendment by founder in a debt claim, continued to tie up resources and highlight unresolved liabilities. These legal entanglements, stemming from the 2020 collapse, posed risks to financial stability, though core operations across facilities remained active as of October 2025.

Key Controversies and Broader Implications

Governance Failures

NMC Health's was characterized by concentrated control in the hands of founder , who established the company in 1974 and served as non-executive chairman until 2020, alongside major shareholders holding approximately 48% of shares in 2018, including Shetty's 15.8% stake and board representation by allies such as Khalifa bin Butti Al Muhairi (as Bin Yousef). This structure, with Shetty transitioning from CEO in 2017 but retaining significant influence, limited counterbalancing by independent directors, as the board of 11 members included only five truly independent non-executives (55% independence excluding chairs), meeting thresholds on paper but failing in practice to prevent override. The exemplified oversight weaknesses, comprising four members in where financial expertise was minimal after a key member's departure in March , with the subsequent chairman lacking qualifications and one member being a former EY partner—the firm's —raising potential conflicts of interest. Internal audits were outsourced without rigorous external validation, contributing to undetected dual systems that masked underreporting, such as presenting USD 1.99 billion in liabilities versus actual USD 5.91 billion as of March 2019, and board unawareness of over USD 2.7 billion in undisclosed facilities. Critics, including activist investors, highlighted these lapses as evidence of board capture, where independence was nominal due to relational ties in an context, enabling fraudulent concealment without challenge. In the UAE regulatory environment, where NMC operated amid rapid expansion via 29 acquisitions from to that elevated leverage to 3.1 times, lax enforcement of disclosure norms facilitated related-party risks, with such transactions comprising 7.8% of costs and 36.7% of payables by , including undisclosed linked to affiliates totaling USD 227 million in and USD 332 million in 2019. While 66.67% of independent directors were foreigners, potentially diluting localized scrutiny in an economy with weaker institutional checks compared to the listing requirements, some analyses attribute tolerance for opacity to necessities of high-growth sectors like healthcare in the Gulf, where aggressive financing supported scaling from five to over 100 facilities across 17 countries. However, from the collapse underscores how inadequate controls and enforcement gaps causally enabled systemic , rather than mere growth imperatives.

Alleged Ties to Influential Figures

In 2025, (EY), facing lawsuits over its auditing of NMC Health, alleged in court proceedings that connections to Sheikh Mansour bin Zayed Al Nahyan, a prominent UAE royal and , shielded key figures involved in the company's from scrutiny. EY claimed that Saeed and Khalifa bin Falah Al Otaiba, two major shareholders in NMC Health, leveraged their close ties to Sheikh Mansour to secure billions in loans from UAE banks, which were more willing to extend credit due to these associations despite the company's underlying financial distress. These assertions positioned Sheikh Mansour as an "effective shadow owner" of NMC Health, according to EY's submissions, suggesting that royal influence facilitated off-balance-sheet debt accumulation totaling around $4 billion hidden by executives including founder . The allegations emerged amid ongoing litigation in the UK, where EY defended against claims of in failing to detect the that led to NMC's 2020 collapse, arguing that the royal connections created an environment of undue protection for the perpetrators. However, these claims remain unproven, with no public evidence of direct royal orchestration of the or personal financial benefit to Mansour; EY's position has been characterized by critics as a defensive tactic to shift blame from its own auditing oversights. Investigations by administrators and regulators, such as the Dubai Financial Services Authority and UK's , have primarily focused on individual executive actions—like falsified supplier invoices and undisclosed loans—without substantiating systemic royal complicity. Such reports have prompted discussions on potential in UAE practices, where elite networks may enable riskier lending and delayed , though evidence ties the misconduct directly to NMC's rather than broader institutional failures. No formal charges or admissions involving Sheikh Mansour have materialized as of October 2025, underscoring the distinction between alleged influence and proven culpability in the .

References

  1. https://ai-analytics.wharton.upenn.edu/wp-content/uploads/2023/06/NMC-Health-Case_2023.06.06.pdf
  2. https://www.agbi.com/companies/nmc-health/
  3. https://www.fca.org.uk/publication/final-notices/nmc-health-plc-2023.pdf
  4. https://www.fortuneindia.com/enterprise/br-shetty-prescribing-growth/103582
  5. https://startuptalky.com/b-r-shetty-nmc-neopharma/
  6. https://m.economictimes.com/nri/nris-in-news/br-shetty-the-staggering-rise-and-incredible-fall-of-a-billionaire/articleshow/75381757.cms
  7. https://www.arabianbusiness.com/lists/390735-admired-companies35nmc-health
  8. https://www.forbesindia.com/article/india-rich-list-2013/br-shetty-building-a-health-care-empire/36519/1
  9. https://www.reuters.com/article/business/timeline-nmc-healths-expansion-and-ailments-idUSKBN20B0S0/
  10. https://swotanalysisexample.com/blogs/brief-history/nmc-brief-history
  11. https://www.forbes.com/sites/anismuslimin/2018/06/11/why-this-indian-billionaire-is-betting-on-education-with-his-philanthropy/
  12. https://usuaebusiness.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Healthcare-Report-Final-1.pdf
  13. https://tracxn.com/d/acquisitions/acquisitions-by-nmc-healthcare/__bUXl7amMqKGLKCRw2uWhEz_HlOA438c1O9Pz6mShfls
  14. https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/N/LSE_NMC_2017.pdf
  15. https://m.edarabia.com/nmc-health-buys-majority-stake-in-fakih-ivf/83759/
  16. https://www.reuters.com/article/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/nmc-health-acquires-minority-stakes-in-fakih-ivf-and-as-salama-hospital-idUSFWN1OY0OS/
  17. https://theanalyst.co.uk/notes/nmc-health-a-trip-to-the-uae/
  18. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-04-02/nmc-health-raises-117-million-pounds-from-initial-share-sale
  19. https://www.meed.com/nmc-health-raises-187m-from-london-ipo/
  20. https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/N/LSE_NMC_2012.pdf
  21. https://www.gulfcapitalmarket.org/market-data/dcm-new-issuance/
  22. https://cbonds.com/bonds/427457/
  23. https://nmc.ae/en/speciality/cardiac-sciences-5
  24. https://my1health.com/hospital/united-arab-emirates/abu-dhabi/nmc-hospital
  25. https://cdn.gmtresearch.com/public-ckfinder/hall-of-shame/NMC%2520Health/H1_Rept_HYE-Jun2019_NMC-Health.pdf
  26. https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/N/LSE_NMC_2016.pdf
  27. https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReportArchive/N/LSE_NMC_2015.pdf
  28. https://growjo.com/company/NMC_Healthcare
  29. https://static-cdn.nmc.ae/strapi/nmc_adgm_six_month_progress_report_23_apr_2021_c4e3a01c_1979_490d_b8c0_ed66017184ab_226a6861e0.pdf
  30. https://www.annualreports.com/HostedData/AnnualReports/PDF/LSE_NMC_2018.pdf
  31. https://english.alarabiya.net/business/banking-and-finance/2022/03/21/UAE-hospital-operator-NMC-sells-its-53-pct-stake-in-Saudi-Medical-Care-Group
  32. https://nmc.ae/en
  33. https://www.health-tourism.com/medical-centers/nmc-healthcare/
  34. https://static-cdn.nmc.ae/strapi/press_release_english_q3_results_and_date_of_restructuring_01_nov_2021_5c9ae2fe_5c44_4821_ade3_e496da9b5241_19c6edace4.pdf
  35. https://www.thenationalnews.com/business/markets/london-listed-nmc-healthcare-to-join-ftse-100-this-month-1.625358
  36. https://www.tradearabia.com/News/202587/NMC-Health-promoted-to-UK%27s-FTSE-100-index
  37. https://saudigazette.com.sa/article/516619
  38. https://www.wam.ae/en/article/hszr5s7l-nmc-health-1st-middle-east-company-listed-ftse
  39. https://www.healthcarebusinessinternational.com/awards/nmc-healthcare-best-building-of-a-brand-winner-2017/
  40. https://www.scribd.com/document/263422566/NMC-Hospital-Abu-Dhabi-2011-06-08
  41. https://uk.advfn.com/stock-market/london/nmc-health-NMC/share-news/NMC-Health-Plc-Final-Results/76882240
  42. https://www.investing.com/equities/nmc-health-dividends
  43. https://www.reuters.com/article/economy/uae-economy-rebounds-in-2018-but-more-slowly-than-expected-idUSKCN1RC0KD/
  44. https://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2020/05/19/the-nmc-health-debacle-four-red-flags/
  45. https://www.ii.co.uk/analysis-commentary/stockwatch-volatile-ftse-100-stock-fresh-money-ii509047
  46. https://muddywatersresearch.com/research/nmc/mw-is-short-nmc/
  47. https://www.reuters.com/article/markets/nmc-health-calls-muddy-waters-report-false-and-misleading-idUSL8N28T5QG/
  48. https://www.reuters.com/article/markets/stocks/uaes-nmc-health-reaffirms-outlook-a-day-after-muddy-waters-report-idUSL4N28S1V1/
  49. https://www.cnbc.com/2020/01/02/abu-dhabis-nmc-health-in-messy-dispute-with-us-short-seller-muddy-waters.html
  50. https://caia.org/blog/2020/01/07/shorting-nmc-health-the-waters-are-muddy
  51. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-12-17/muddy-waters-short-report-sends-nmc-health-to-record-plunge
  52. https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/nov/17/collapsed-hospital-operator-nmc-health-misled-markets-over-32bn-of-debt-says-watchdog
  53. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-10/nmc-unauthorized-loan-facilities-boost-debt-to-about-5-billion
  54. https://www.arabnews.com/node/1646511/business-economy
  55. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2020-03-12/nmc-health-says-review-turns-up-evidence-of-suspected-fraud
  56. https://www.thisismoney.co.uk/money/markets/article-8612775/Hospitals-provider-Health-probed-issuing-fake-invoices.html
  57. https://www.fca.org.uk/news/press-releases/fca-censures-nmc-health-plc-administration-market-abuse
  58. https://globalinvestigationsreview.com/article/nmc-health-avoids-fca-fine-not-disclosing-4-billion-debts
  59. https://jp.reuters.com/article/business/businessman-shetty-seeks-india-probe-of-nmc-finablr-ex-ceos-over-6-billion-sca-idUSKBN26X0Z5/
  60. https://www.studocu.com/row/document/ahmadu-bello-university/corporate-finance/nmc-health-fraud-case-study-governance-failures-and-forensic-insights-jfia/122271503
  61. http://web.nacva.com/JFIA/Issues/JFIA-2022-No3-11.pdf
  62. https://www.loopergoodwine.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/NMC.pdf
  63. https://www.mlex.com/mlex/financial-crime/articles/2348485/nmc-health-audit-investigators-found-fraud-cheat-sheets-uk-court-told
  64. https://www.accountancyage.com/2025/05/20/ey-faces-2bn-lawsuit-over-extremely-serious-audit-failings-at-nmc-health/
  65. https://www.reuters.com/sustainability/boards-policy-regulation/ey-negligently-missed-huge-fraud-collapsed-hospital-operator-3-bln-uk-trial-2025-05-19/
  66. https://thefinancestory.com/ey-audit-failure-of-nmc-health-scandal
  67. https://www.cityam.com/ey-accused-of-missing-red-flag-in-nmc-collapse/
  68. https://uk.finance.yahoo.com/news/ey-2bn-legal-fight-over-195002662.html
  69. https://www.internationalaccountingbulletin.com/news/ey-lawsuit-nmc-health-fraud-case/
  70. https://www.ft.com/content/a7156bb5-c023-4365-a03a-fa8eb9f1baea
  71. https://www.mlex.com/mlex/financial-crime/articles/2399211/ey-buried-head-in-sand-over-nmc-health-audit-work-uk-court-told
  72. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/10/14/sheikh-mansour-ties-shielded-nmc-health-fraudsters-ey-claim/
  73. https://www.agbi.com/analysis/law/2025/08/nmc-ey-court-case-spotlights-issues-with-big-fours-offshoots/
  74. https://www.aninews.in/news/world/middle-east/criminal-charges-filed-against-br-shetty-5-others-in-uaes-nmc-case20200416082637
  75. https://gulfnews.com/business/banking/criminal-charges-filed-in-nmc-case-1.1586945585095
  76. https://www.khaleejtimes.com/uae/nmc-founder-br-shetty-to-return-to-uae-after-indian-court-lifts-travel-ban
  77. https://www.msn.com/en-ae/money/news/nmc-files-case-against-founder-br-shetty-in-4bn-fraud-suit/ar-AA1dIQVq
  78. https://www.thenewsminute.com/karnataka/assets-billionaire-br-shetty-frozen-worldwide-uk-court-143481
  79. https://portnoylaw.com/complaints/nmccomplaint.pdf
  80. https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/nmc-health-plc-s-subsidiaries-enter-83657/
  81. https://www.alvarezandmarsal.com/insights/joint-administrators-alvarez-marsal-announce-historic-release-administration-nmc
  82. https://static-cdn.nmc.ae/strapi/nmc_health_plc_administrators_proposals_28_may_2020_9673ee7d_a034_43ae_8e3e_9275fe48993e_2f17b10876.pdf
  83. https://www.reuters.com/article/business/healthcare-pharmaceuticals/nmc-health-to-delist-from-london-stock-exchange-idUSL3N2CF27W/
  84. https://www.reuters.com/article/business/nmc-health-requests-delisting-from-lse-idUSKCN2290OU/
  85. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-08-11/scandal-hit-nmc-seeks-to-exit-administration-after-debt-crisis
  86. https://www.arabnews.com/node/2060111/business-economy
  87. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/nmc-creditors-approve-plan-take-control-firms-units-end-administration-2021-09-01/
  88. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-02/nmc-creditors-back-restructuring-with-administration-exit-near
  89. https://www.thenationalnews.com/business/banking/2021/09/01/nmc-creditors-approve-restructuring-plan-that-allows-34-companies-to-exit-administration/
  90. https://www.kirkland.com/news/press-release/2022/03/kirkland-represents-nmc-on-restructuring
  91. https://www.zawya.com/en/press-release/companies-news/nmc-healthcares-four-pillar-strategy-delivers-tangible-results-in-2025-odulgqgi
  92. https://www.thenationalnews.com/news/uk/2025/05/19/auditor-ey-sued-for-26-billion-in-damages-by-uae-hospital-operator-nmc/
  93. https://www.difccourts.ae/rules-decisions/judgments-orders/court-first-instance/state-bank-india-difc-branch-v-1-nmc-healthcare-llc-2-nmc-speciality-hospital-llc-abu-dhabi-3-new-medical-centre-llc-dubai-4-new
  94. https://www.agbi.com/law/2025/06/br-shettys-defence-bid-fails-as-banks-pursue-nmc-debt/
  95. https://www.mondaq.com/shareholders/954688/nmc-scandal-and-its-corporate-governance
  96. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/business/2025/05/22/sheikh-mansour-shadow-owner-hospital-tainted-frau-claims-ey/
  97. https://www.thetimes.com/business-money/companies/article/sheikh-mansour-was-effectively-a-shadow-owner-of-nmc-court-told-980vtv6wj
  98. https://www.easterneye.biz/nmc-health-fraud-uae-links/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.