Hubbry Logo
Sam LoydSam LoydMain
Open search
Sam Loyd
Community hub
Sam Loyd
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Sam Loyd
Sam Loyd
Sam Loyd
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Samuel Loyd (January 30, 1841 – April 10, 1911[1]) was an American chess player, chess composer, puzzle author, and recreational mathematician. Loyd was born in Philadelphia but raised in New York City.

Key Information

As a chess composer, he authored a number of chess problems, often with interesting themes. At his peak, Loyd was one of the best chess players in the US, and he was ranked 15th in the world, according to chessmetrics.com.

He played in the strong Paris 1867 chess tournament (won by Ignatz von Kolisch) with little success, placing near the bottom of the field.

Following his death, his book Cyclopedia of 5000 Puzzles[2] was published (1914) by his son, Samuel Loyd Jr.[3][4] His son, named after his father, dropped the "Jr" from his name and started publishing reprints of his father's puzzles.[4] Loyd (senior) was inducted into the US Chess Hall of Fame in 1987.[5]

Reputation

[edit]

Loyd is widely acknowledged as one of America's great puzzle writers and popularizers, often mentioned as the greatest. Martin Gardner featured Loyd in his August 1957 Mathematical Games column in Scientific American and called him "America's greatest puzzler". In 1898, The Strand dubbed him "the prince of puzzlers". As a chess problemist, his composing style is distinguished by wit and humour.

He is also known for lies and self-promotion, however, and he has been criticized on these grounds—Martin Gardner's assessment continues "but also obviously a hustler". Canadian puzzler Mel Stover called Loyd "an old reprobate", and Matthew Costello called him "puzzledom's greatest celebrity... popularizer, genius", but also a "huckster" and "fast-talking snake oil salesman".[6]

He collaborated with puzzler Henry Dudeney for a while, but Dudeney broke off the correspondence and accused Loyd of stealing his puzzles and publishing them under his own name. Dudeney despised Loyd so intensely that he equated him with the devil.[7]

Loyd claimed that he invented the fifteen tiles in the box and one space puzzle.[8] The actual inventor was Noyes Chapman, who applied for a patent in March 1880.[9]

An enthusiast of Tangram puzzles, Loyd popularized them with The Eighth Book Of Tan, a book of seven hundred unique Tangram designs and a fanciful history of the origin of the Tangram, claiming that the puzzle was invented 4,000 years ago by a god named Tan. This was presented as true and has been described as "Sam Loyd's Most Successful Hoax".[8]

Chess problems

[edit]
This section uses algebraic notation to describe chess moves.

Excelsior problem

[edit]
Main article: Excelsior (chess problem)
"Excelsior"
abcdefgh
8
a8 black knight
c8 black rook
d8 black bishop
b7 black pawn
f7 black pawn
h7 black pawn
b6 black pawn
b5 white rook
h5 white king
a3 black pawn
e3 black pawn
g3 white pawn
h3 white knight
b2 white pawn
c2 white pawn
e2 white rook
a1 white knight
h1 black king
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh
Mate in 5, 2nd prize, Paris Tourney, 1867
(For the solution, see "Excelsior".)

One of his best-known chess problems is the following, called "Excelsior" by Loyd after the poem[10] by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. White is to move and checkmate Black in five moves against any defense.

Loyd bet a friend that he could not pick a piece that didn't give mate in the main line, and when it was published in 1861 it was with the stipulation that White mates with "the least likely piece or pawn".

Steinitz Gambit problem

[edit]
"Steinitz Gambit"
abcdefgh
8
e8 black rook
g8 black bishop
b7 black pawn
g7 white bishop
a6 black pawn
b6 white knight
e6 black pawn
f6 white rook
a5 white rook
b5 white bishop
e5 black king
b4 white pawn
e4 white knight
h4 black pawn
c3 black pawn
g3 black bishop
a2 black knight
d2 white pawn
f2 black pawn
h2 black rook
f1 white king
h1 black knight
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh
Mate in 3, 1st prize, Checkmate Novelty Tourney, 1903

One of the most famous chess problems by Loyd. He wrote on this problem: "The originality of the problem is due to the White King being placed in absolute safety, and yet coming out on a reckless career, with no immediate threat and in the face of innumerable checks."[11]

Charles XII problem

[edit]
abcdefgh
8
g7 white rook
h6 black pawn
f5 white king
h5 black king
g3 black pawn
f2 black bishop
g2 white pawn
h2 white pawn
e1 white knight
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh

This problem was originally published in 1859. The story involves a chess incident during the siege of Charles XII of Sweden by the Turks at Bender in 1713. "Charles beguiled this period by means of drills and chess, and used frequently to play with his minister, Christian Albert Grosthusen, some of the contests being mentioned by Voltaire. One day while so engaged, the game had been played to this stage, and Charles (White) had just announced checkmate in three."

1. Rxg3 Bxg3
2. Nf3 Bxh2
3. g4#
abcdefgh
8
g7 white rook
h6 black pawn
f5 white king
h5 black king
g3 black pawn
f2 black bishop
g2 white pawn
h2 white pawn
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh

"Scarcely had he uttered the words, when a (Turkish) bullet, shattering the window, dashed the White knight off of the board in fragments. Grothusen started violently, but Charles, with utmost coolness, begged him to put back the other knight and work out the mate, observing that it was pretty enough. But another glance at the board made Charles smile. We do not need the knight. I can give it to you and still mate in four!"

1. hxg3 Be3
2. Rg4 Bg5
3. Rh4+ Bxh4
4. g4#
abcdefgh
8
g7 white rook
h6 black pawn
f5 white king
h5 black king
g3 black pawn
f2 black bishop
g2 white pawn
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh

Who would believe it, he had scarcely spoken when another bullet flew across the room, and the pawn at h2 shared the fate of the knight. Grothusen turned pale. "You have our good friends the Turks with you," said the king unconcerned, "it can scarcely be expected that I should contend against such odds; but let me see if I can dispense with that pawn. I have it!" he shouted with a laugh, "I have great pleasure in informing you that there is undoubtedly a mate in 5."

1. Rb7 Be3
2. Rb1 Bg5
3. Rh1+ Bh4
4. Rh2 gxh2
5. g4#
abcdefgh
8
h6 black pawn
f5 white king
h5 black king
g3 black pawn
f2 black bishop
g2 white pawn
h2 white pawn
e1 white knight
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh

In 1900, Friedrich Amelung pointed out that in the original position, if the first bullet had struck the rook instead of the knight, Charles would still have a mate in six.

1. Nf3 Be1
2. Nxe1 Kh4
3. h3 Kh5
4. Nd3 Kh4
5. Nf4 h5
6. Ng6#
abcdefgh
8
g7 white rook
h6 black pawn
f5 white king
h5 black king
g3 black pawn
f2 black bishop
h2 white pawn
8
77
66
55
44
33
22
11
abcdefgh

In 2003, ChessBase posted a fifth variation, attributed to Brian Stewart. After the first bullet took out the knight, if the second had removed the g-pawn rather than the h-pawn, Charles would be able to mate in ten.

1. hxg3 Be1
2. Rg4 Bxg3
3. Rxg3 Kh4
4. Kf4 h5
5. Rg2 Kh3
6. Kf3 h4
7. Rg4 Kh2
8. Rxh4+ Kg1
9. Rh3 Kf1
10. Rh1#

Puzzles

[edit]

Back from the Klondike

[edit]
Main article: Back from the Klondike
"Back from the Klondike" puzzle (modern rendering)

This is one of Sam Loyd's most famous puzzles, first printed in the New York Journal and Advertiser, April 24, 1898 (as far as available evidence indicates). Loyd's original instructions were to:

Start from that heart in the center and go three steps in a straight line in any one of the eight directions, north, south, east or west, or on the bias, as the ladies say, northeast, northwest, southeast or southwest. When you have gone three steps in a straight line, you will reach a square with a number on it, which indicates the second day's journey, as many steps as it tells, in a straight line in any of the eight directions. From this new point when reached, march on again according to the number indicated, and continue on, following the requirements of the numbers reached, until you come upon a square with a number which will carry you just one step beyond the border, when you are supposed to be out of the woods and can holler all you want, as you will have solved the puzzle.

Vanishing puzzles

[edit]
Main article: vanishing puzzle

A vanishing puzzle is a mechanical optical illusion showing different numbers of a certain object when parts of the puzzle are moved around.[12]

Interactive SVG of The Disappearing Bicyclist – in the SVG file, move the pointer to rotate the disc

Loyd patented rotary vanishing puzzles in 1896 and published versions named Get Off the Earth, Teddy and the Lion and The Disappearing Bicyclist (pictured). Each had a circular card connected to a cardboard backdrop with a pin, letting it rotate.[13][14][15] In the Disappearing Bicyclist, when the disc is rotated such that the arrow points to A, 13 boys can be seen. When rotated so that the arrow points to B, only 12 boys appear.[16]

Vanishing area puzzle

[edit]
Chessboard paradox

A square with a side length of 8 units ("chessboard") is dissected into four pieces, which can be assembled into a 5x13 rectangle. Since the area of the square is 64 units but the area of the rectangle is 65 units, this seems paradoxical at first. It is just an optical illusion, however, as the pieces don't fit exactly to form a rectangle, but leave a small barely visible gap along the diagonal. This puzzle is also known as the chessboard paradox or paradox of Loyd and Schlömilch.

Trick Donkeys problem

[edit]
Main article: Famous Trick Donkeys
"Trick Donkeys" problem

One of Loyd's notable puzzles was the "Trick Donkeys". It was based on a similar puzzle involving dogs published in 1857. In the problem, the solver must cut the drawing along the dotted lines and rearrange the three pieces so that the riders appear to be riding the donkeys.

Works by Sam Loyd

[edit]
  • Sam Loyd's Book of Tangram Puzzles (ISBN 0-486-22011-7)
  • Mathematical Puzzles of Sam Loyd (ISBN 0-486-20498-7): selected and edited by Martin Gardner
  • More Mathematical Puzzles of Sam Loyd (ISBN 0-486-20709-9): selected and edited by Martin Gardner
  • The Puzzle King: Sam Loyd's Chess Problems and Selected Mathematical Puzzles (ISBN 1-886846-05-7): edited by Sid Pickard
  • Sam Loyd's Cyclopedia of 5000 Puzzles, Tricks and Conundrums with Answers ISBN 0-923891-78-1 – Complete 1914 book (public domain) scanned
  • The 8th Book of Tan (1903).

Works about Sam Loyd

[edit]

Sam Loyd Award

[edit]

The Association for Games & Puzzles International (previously the Association of Game & Puzzle Collectors, and prior to 1999, the American Game Collectors Association, AGCA), gives the Sam Loyd Award for promoting interest in mechanical puzzles through design, development, or manufacture. The following individuals have won it:[17][18]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Sam Loyd

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Samuel Loyd (January 30, 1841 – April 10, 1911) was an American puzzle inventor, composer, and best known for creating and popularizing thousands of mechanical and that influenced and games in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. Born in , , Loyd was trained as a mechanical engineer but pursued diverse interests, including self-taught , cartooning, and business ventures in contracting and music stores. He began composing chess problems at age 14, with his first published in the New York Saturday Courier on 14 April 1855, and later served as problem editor for the Chess Monthly in 1857; by 1878, he had authored , a collection of 500 chess problems. Loyd's career shifted toward puzzle design in the 1870s, where he innovated dexterity-based mechanical puzzles using rotation and sliding mechanisms, producing over 10,000 puzzles noted for their mathematical ingenuity and often deceptive simplicity. Among his verified inventions, Loyd created the Trick Donkeys puzzle in 1871, a sliding strip game that sold millions of copies, and the Get Off the Earth rotating disk puzzle in 1896, which featured optical illusions like a disappearing warrior and was licensed for political campaigns. He also contributed to cryptarithms and retrograde analysis in chess problems, including a pioneering 1859 problem requiring backward deduction of moves. Although Loyd popularized the 15 Puzzle in the 1880s by offering a $1,000 prize for solving an intentionally unsolvable variant (the 14-15 swap), the original sliding tile puzzle was invented by Noyes Palmer Chapman around 1874–1880. Loyd's work extended to books like the posthumously published Cyclopaedia of Puzzles (1914), cementing his legacy despite controversies over false invention claims for games like Parcheesi and Pigs in Clover.

Biography

Early Life and Education

Samuel Loyd was born on January 30, 1841, in , , into a wealthy family as the youngest of nine children. His father, a successful and financier, provided a comfortable upbringing that allowed young Samuel to explore his interests freely. At the age of three, the family relocated to , where Loyd spent his formative years. From an early age, he displayed remarkable talents in , , , and performing tricks, often entertaining family and friends with his quick wit and sleight-of-hand abilities. These pursuits highlighted his innate creativity and penchant for deception and surprise, which would later define his work in puzzles and chess compositions. Loyd's introduction to chess came through his older brothers, who taught him the game and sparked his lifelong passion for its strategic depths. At age 14, in 1855, he composed and published his first in the New York Saturday Courier, marking the beginning of his rapid ascent in the field. By age 16, in 1857, he was widely recognized as the leading American chess problem composer, having won prestigious contests and assumed the role of problem editor for Chess Monthly. After completing his secondary education in New York in 1858, Loyd pursued studies in steam and , aspiring to a career in that technical field due to his aptitude for and . However, his growing fascination with chess problems and recreational puzzles soon overshadowed these ambitions, drawing him toward a path centered on intellectual diversions rather than conventional practice.

Professional Career and Family

After briefly pursuing studies in mechanical engineering, Sam Loyd abandoned formal engineering ambitions in the early 1860s to focus on chess composition and puzzle creation, fields in which he quickly gained prominence. He contributed extensively to chess journals, including serving as the problem editor for Chess Monthly starting in 1857, where he published innovative chess problems that showcased his analytical skills. This shift marked the beginning of a career centered on intellectual recreations rather than steady engineering employment. In 1867, Loyd traveled to and participated in the international , where he achieved a poor performance with a score of 6.5 out of 24 games, finishing near the bottom. Despite the results, the trip provided valuable networking opportunities, as he connected with European chess problem composers during visits to , broadening his influence in the field. Loyd's entry into puzzle invention accelerated in 1871, when he began commercializing designs such as the Trick Donkeys, a puzzle involving three card pieces that rearranged to alter the image. He continued this trajectory with other mechanical and , establishing himself as a prolific inventor whose works appealed to a wide audience. Financially, Loyd sustained himself through puzzle sales, commissions from manufacturers, and occasional business ventures like plumbing contracting and owning music stores, rather than a conventional role. Notable examples include selling rights to his Trick Donkeys puzzle to showman and offering a $1,000 prize for solving his famously unsolvable 15 Puzzle in the early 1880s, which generated significant publicity and revenue. In 1864, Loyd married, though details on his wife remain limited in historical records. He and his wife had a son, Samuel Loyd Jr., born August 10, 1870, who later assisted in his father's puzzle demonstrations through and acts and edited posthumous collections of his works, including the 1914 Cyclopaedia of 5000 Puzzles. Family life intertwined with Loyd's professional pursuits, as his son collaborated on stage performances that popularized the puzzles.

Chess Contributions

Overview of Chess Problems

Sam Loyd emerged as a prominent chess composer in the mid-19th century, beginning his work in the early 1850s as a teenager. At around age 14 in 1855, he submitted his first problems to outlets like the New York Saturday Courier and Chess Monthly, where he quickly gained recognition by winning a competition and assuming the role of problem editor from 1860. His compositions appeared in major publications such as Chess Monthly (1857–1861), American Chess Nuts (1868), Chess Strategy (1878), and later columns in Scientific American Supplement (starting 1877), the Philadelphia Evening Bulletin, and the British Chess Magazine, helping to establish chess problems as a staple in American periodicals. Loyd's style emphasized artistic flair, wit, and unexpected surprises, drawing inspiration from European composers like Loveday and Shinkman while infusing an original American eccentricity. He composed over 1,000 problems across various forms, favoring brevity with three-move setups as the ideal for clarity and impact, minimal piece usage for economy, and dynamic elements like deceptive keys and humorous themes over rigid model mates or crowded boards. His innovations included pioneering strategic sacrifices—such as Rook, , and self-sacrifices—ideal mates for aesthetic perfection, helpmate problems, and block-threat motifs that added layers of subtlety and solver engagement. As a player, Loyd demonstrated solid skill, achieving a peak world ranking of 15th according to Chessmetrics calculations from October 1868 to July 1869, with a highest rating of 2445 in July 1870, though his record was modest (e.g., 6 wins, 17 losses, 1 draw at the 1867 ). His broader contributions popularized chess composition in the United States by organizing solving , editing columns, and creating accessible yet brilliant works that bridged recreational and artistic chess, earning him posthumous induction into the U.S. Chess Hall of Fame in 1987. This legacy is exemplified in iconic pieces like the problem, which showcased his flair for thematic pawn promotions.

Excelsior Problem

The Excelsior problem, composed by Sam Loyd in 1858, was first published in the London Era in January 1861 and later awarded second prize in the 1867 Paris chess problem tournament. It requires White to mate in five moves, featuring a thematic sequence where a pawn advances from its starting position on the second rank all the way to promotion on the eighth rank, embodying the "excelsior" motif of ascent inspired by Henry Wadsworth Longfellow's poem of the same name. The position features White's king on h5, rooks on b5 and e2, knights on a1 and h3, and pawns on b2, c2, and g3; Black's king is trapped on h1, with a knight on a8, rook on c8, bishop on d8, and pawns on a3, b6, b7, e3, f7, and h7. The black king is confined in the corner, limiting defensive options, while White's on the queenside supports the key advance. The initial move involves a to force Black's response and clear the path for promotion. The solution begins with 1. b4!, prompting 1... Rc5+ 2. bxc5 a2; White then continues 3. c6 Bc7 4. cxb7 Bxg3, culminating in 5. bxa8=# (or 5. bxa8=#). This sequence highlights the b2-pawn's improbable journey—advancing, capturing twice, and promoting while delivering —demonstrating Loyd's ingenuity in using an unassuming pawn as the mating force after his friend Denis Julien bet against it. Regarded as a of chess composition, the earned widespread acclaim for its elegance and surprise, influencing the development of the "excelsior" theme in problem design, where a pawn completes a full ascent to promotion in the solution. It remains a staple in chess education, illustrating strategic pawn play, sacrifices, and tactical precision, and has inspired numerous variations while retaining its status as a benchmark for creative problem-solving.

Steinitz Gambit and Charles XII Problems

One of Sam Loyd's early chess compositions, the Charles XII problem, was published in 1859 in the Chess Monthly and draws inspiration from an apocryphal incident during the 1713 siege of Bender, where Swedish King XII was reportedly playing chess against a minister amid Turkish gunfire. In the narrative crafted by Loyd, the king announces mate in three, but a stray bullet removes White's on f3; undeterred, Charles declares he can still mate in four moves by effectively the piece and proceeding with tactical precision. The position features White's rook on g1, pawns on g2 and h2, and other pieces positioned to exploit Black's exposed and on g3, with the solution unfolding as 1. hxg3 Be3 2. Rg4 Bg5 3. Rh4+ Bxh4 4. g4#, employing a rook on h4 to deflect the bishop and deliver inevitable pawn mate. This mate-in-four demonstrates Loyd's youthful tactical ingenuity at age 18, blending historical storytelling with themes of resilience and piece to create an engaging, multi-layered puzzle that highlights his emerging prowess in problem construction. In contrast, the Steinitz Gambit, composed later in Loyd's career and awarded first prize in the 1903 Novelty Tourney of the Canadian magazine Checkmate, represents a pinnacle of paradoxical play dedicated to chess world champion Wilhelm Steinitz. The setup positions White's king on g1 with pawns advanced for promotion (e.g., on the seventh rank), facing Black's aggressive array including a rook on e8, bishop on f8, and pawns poised to check; the black king stands on e8, exposed yet threatening. The stunning key move, 1. Ke2, appears to recklessly expose the king to multiple checks—mirroring Steinitz's infamous 5. Ke2 in the 1879 Zukertort match—but instead deflects Black's attacks, allowing White to respond to any of ten possible checks with 2. Ke3 and force mate via pawn promotion on the third move, such as 2... Qe1+ 3. Ke4 Qd1+ 4. Ke5 Qd6+ 5. Ke4 Qc5+ 6. Kd3 and promotion with checkmate. This mate-in-three exemplifies themes of discovery and strategic withdrawal, where the "gambit" of king safety leads to unavoidable mate, showcasing Loyd's mature ability to craft problems with deceptive quiet moves that subvert expectations. Together, these problems illustrate Loyd's evolution from the narrative-driven sacrifices of his 1859 youth to the subtle, opening-inspired paradoxes of 1903, bridging his early experimentation with later technical mastery in chess composition. Both have been prominently featured in influential anthologies, such as Alain C. White's 1913 collection Sam Loyd and His Chess Problems, underscoring their enduring impact on puzzle literature and their role in demonstrating Loyd's versatility across decades.

Puzzles and Inventions

Back from the Klondike

Sam Loyd created the puzzle "Back from the Klondike" in 1898, capitalizing on the contemporaneous excitement surrounding the in and the . First published in the New York Journal and Advertiser on April 24, 1898, the puzzle was framed as a narrative challenge for a lost miner seeking to return to camp with his gold. Loyd designed it specifically to confound Leonhard Euler's classic maze-solving rule of working backward from the exit, incorporating a whirlpool-like structure that traps standard traversal methods in loops. The puzzle is presented on a grid resembling a map, typically depicted as an 11x11 array of squares (though effective play occurs within a central 9x9 region) with numbers from 1 to 9 scattered irregularly. The miner begins at a central "heart" square marked with the number 3, representing the mine's location. Players move exactly the number of steps indicated by the current square in any of eight directions (north, south, east, west, or the four diagonals), landing on another numbered square that dictates the next move length. The objective is to escape the grid by jumping one step beyond its border to reach the camp, simulating the miner's arduous return path through treacherous terrain. This setup creates an illusion of inescapable cycles, emphasizing Loyd's signature misdirection in pathfinding. The solution, described by as "sneaky," requires a precise sequence of nine moves: southwest twice (covering 3 then 2 steps), northeast three times (2, 3, and 1 steps), southwest three more times (1, 3, and 2 steps), and finally southeast once (1 step), culminating in an exit to the southeast border. This path exploits the grid's deceptive layout, where apparent loops resolve through diagonal jumps that bypass the whirlpool effect, revealing the miner's successful return. An alternate route exists through a "troublesome 2" square, but the primary solution highlights the puzzle's paradoxical nature, as forward progress seems impossible without backtracking. "Back from the Klondike" became one of Loyd's most enduring works, widely reprinted in newspapers and puzzle collections, contributing to his commercial empire that reportedly sold millions of puzzle items overall. Its clever defiance of maze-solving conventions exemplified Loyd's talent for blending thematic storytelling with mathematical trickery, influencing later jumping-maze designs in .

Vanishing Puzzles

Sam Loyd patented a series of transformation puzzles in 1896 that created optical illusions of vanishing figures through the rearrangement of dissected picture elements. These mechanical devices typically featured a fixed background with a rotatable central disk containing matching segments of images, allowing users to align parts in ways that made specific figures appear or disappear without altering the physical area of the puzzle. The core mechanism relied on irregular spacing and patterns in the artwork, ensuring that rotation redistributed visual elements to obscure one figure while maintaining the overall composition's integrity. A prominent example is Loyd's "Get Off the Earth" puzzle, which depicted 13 Chinese warriors encircling a ; rotating the disk caused one to vanish, giving the illusion that half the apparent "crowded" area had cleared. This effect stemmed from the precise of the figures into segments, where the vanished element was hidden through subtle overlaps in the new alignment rather than actual removal. Loyd commercialized the puzzle widely, reportedly selling over 10 million copies, often tying it to promotional themes like political campaigns or amusement parks. Loyd extended the vanishing principle to area-based paradoxes through geometric dissections, where pieces rearranged to form shapes of seemingly different areas while conserving the true total. In his chessboard paradox, Loyd claimed to have presented at the 1857 American Chess Congress, an 8×8 square (64 square units) was cut into four pieces—two triangles and two quadrilaterals—and reassembled into a 5×13 (apparent 65 units), creating the of an extra unit emerging. The mathematical basis involved mismatched slopes along the diagonal edge (3/8 versus 2/5, derived from ratios 3, 5, 8), producing a thin gap of exactly 1 unit disguised as a straight line; reversing the arrangement yields an apparent vanishing of that unit. This exploited gaps and overlaps inherent in the to fool visual of area. Variants of Loyd's vanishing puzzles included linear sliding designs like the disappearing bicyclist, where 13 boys on bikes rearranged to show only 12 through similar slope-induced overlaps. These innovations influenced subsequent paradox studies in , inspiring analyses of visual deception and geometric illusions in works on Fibonacci-based dissections.

Trick Donkeys and Other Mechanical Puzzles

One of Sam Loyd's early and most enduring inventions was the Trick Donkeys puzzle, introduced in 1871. This card-based mechanical puzzle features a printed of two whose horns are seemingly interlocked by chains, divided into three pieces along perforated lines: the two donkeys and a background landscape. The challenge presented to solvers is to separate the donkeys without cutting or breaking the chains, creating an illusion of impossibility through apparent . The solution involves carefully cutting along the perforations and reassembling the pieces in a specific orientation, revealing that the horns can be unhooked by rotating one donkey relative to the other, thus exploiting a hidden geometric arrangement rather than true linkage. Loyd extended his mechanical puzzle designs to dexterity-based challenges, most notably associating himself with Pigs in Clover, though he falsely claimed its invention in a 1891 interview. Released in 1888 and patented by C.W. Crandall, this puzzle consists of a wooden or tin box with a maze-like layout, where players must manipulate small metal balls—representing pigs—through channels and barriers into a central pen symbolizing a patch, relying on tilting and precise hand control. Despite not originating the design, Loyd promoted variations and incorporated similar principles in his work, emphasizing physical manipulation to achieve a satisfying reveal of order from chaos. He also created sliding puzzles, such as block-based challenges where pieces shift within a frame to form images or sequences, and card tricks involving hidden mechanisms for surprise transformations. Loyd's approach to these mechanical puzzles prioritized tactile engagement and unexpected resolutions, often patenting iterative versions to refine user interaction—such as adjustable components for varying difficulty—while drawing on principles of and manual skill to captivate audiences. For instance, his designs frequently used everyday materials like cards, wood, or metal to make puzzles accessible, fostering a sense of accomplishment through trial-and-error manipulation. The commercial success of Pigs in Clover, which Loyd later capitalized on through promotion, sparked a nationwide craze in , with demand so intense that production struggled to keep pace, selling over a million units across the and by late and inspiring numerous imitators.

Publications

Major Works by Loyd

Sam Loyd's early major publication in the realm of chess was , a book of problems released in 1878 that showcased his compositional skills and contributed to his reputation as a leading American chess problemist. This work focused on strategic elements of chess composition, drawing from his experience as problem editor for Chess Monthly since 1857. In the puzzle domain, Loyd made significant contributions through ongoing columns in starting in the late 1870s, where he illustrated and described mechanical and mathematical recreations with his own woodcut sketches, publishing one per week from August 1877 onward. These columns highlighted his inventive style, blending humor and ingenuity to engage readers with diverse brainteasers. Loyd self-published Sam Loyd's Puzzle Magazine beginning in 1907, featuring selections of his creations that had appeared in newspapers and periodicals across the . The magazine exemplified his characteristic content style: richly illustrated pages accompanied by witty introductions that added narrative flair to the challenges. One of his most notable books, The Eighth Book of Tan (1903), presented over 700 tangram puzzles, many original to Loyd, while fabricating a narrative claiming the tangram's origins in a 4,000-year-old Chinese to lend an air of ancient mystery. Throughout his career, Loyd compiled over 5,000 puzzles of various types, though a comprehensive collection remained unpublished during his lifetime.

Posthumous and Biographical Works

Following Sam Loyd's death in 1911, his son Samuel Loyd Jr. compiled and edited Sam Loyd's Cyclopaedia of 5,000 Puzzles, Tricks and Conundrums with Answers, published in 1914 by the Lamb Publishing Company. This extensive anthology assembles over 5,000 of Loyd's creations, including puzzles, tricks, riddles, and conundrums, with approximately 1,000 illustrations, making it the largest single-volume collection of his and mechanical inventions. Another significant posthumous work dedicated to Loyd's chess legacy is Sam Loyd and His Chess Problems (1913), authored by British chess enthusiast Alain C. White as part of his Christmas Series. Spanning nearly 500 pages with diagrams, the book provides a biographical overview of Loyd's life intertwined with detailed analyses of over 300 of his chess problems, emphasizing their ingenuity and historical context in problem composition. Modern biographical studies have further illuminated Loyd's contributions. Andrew Soltis's Sam Loyd: His Story and Best Problems (1995, Chess Digest) combines a narrative of Loyd's personal and professional life with curated selections of his top puzzles and chess compositions, drawing on primary sources to contextualize his innovations. In the mid-20th century, edited Mathematical Puzzles of Sam Loyd (1959, ), praising Loyd as "America's greatest puzzlist" for his whimsical yet mathematically rigorous designs, and selected 70 representative puzzles from Loyd's vast output to showcase his enduring appeal. Samuel Loyd Jr. assumed an editorial role in several posthumous efforts, helping to organize and authenticate his father's unpublished materials while addressing inconsistencies in Loyd's self-reported inventions.

Reputation and Legacy

Critical Reception and Controversies

Sam Loyd received widespread acclaim for his contributions to and puzzle design, with mathematician and author hailing him as "America's greatest puzzler" due to the bizarre imagination, originality, trickiness, and whimsy that characterized his work. Gardner emphasized Loyd's innovative blending of mathematical challenges with artistic elements and humorous narratives, which elevated puzzles beyond mere brainteasers into engaging forms of entertainment. This reception underscored Loyd's influence in popularizing puzzles that integrated logic, , and wit, inspiring generations of enthusiasts. However, Loyd's reputation was marred by numerous controversies stemming from his false claims of invention and self-promotional tactics. He repeatedly asserted ownership of the 15-puzzle, beginning in 1891 and continuing until his death, despite evidence that Noyes Palmer Chapman patented it in 1880 and it gained popularity under Matthias J. Rice's commercialization in 1879. Similarly, Loyd falsely claimed to have invented Parcheesi, an adaptation of the ancient Indian game Pachisi, though Selchow & Righter had trademarked it in 1874 based on earlier designs. He also misattributed the dexterity puzzle Pigs in Clover to himself in 1891, overlooking Charles Crandall's 1889 patent and its associated craze. These fabrications, detailed in Jerry Slocum and Dic Sonneveld's analysis, highlighted Loyd's pattern of exaggerating achievements to enhance his persona. Loyd's controversies extended to personal rivalries, particularly with British puzzler Henry Ernest Dudeney, who was upset when Loyd published Dudeney's submitted puzzles under his own name without credit. This feud, noted as a key rivalry in , arose from mutual exchanges of ideas that soured into accusations, with Dudeney expressing upset over Loyd's unacknowledged use of his work. Loyd's most notorious self-promotion was the 1903 hoax in The Eighth Book of Tan, where he fabricated a 4,000-year history for the puzzle, inventing a mythical Chinese scholar and ancient manuscripts to lend it exotic origins; this deception, exposed by philologist Sir James Murray in 1910, persisted in some publications despite being debunked. Despite these flaws, Loyd's enduring legacy in remains significant, as his puzzles continue to influence the field long after his death on April 10, 1911, in . Historians like Gardner acknowledge that, while Loyd's dishonesty undermined aspects of his credibility, his creative output fostered a lasting appreciation for puzzles that merge math, art, and humor.

Sam Loyd Award and Modern Influence

The Sam Loyd Award, established in 1998 by the Association of Game and Puzzle Collectors (now known as the Association for Games & Puzzles International, or AGPI), recognizes living individuals who, as entrepreneurs, have significantly promoted interest in mechanical puzzles through design, development, manufacture, or distribution. Named in honor of Loyd's prolific inventions and marketing innovations in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, the award has been presented to notable figures such as Jerry Slocum in 2006 for his contributions to puzzle history and collecting, Stewart Coffin in 2000 for his interlocking wooden puzzles, and Gary Foshee in 2015 for his designs and work. Loyd's influence extends into the through digital adaptations of his puzzles, particularly the 15-puzzle, which has inspired numerous mobile applications and online recreations that replicate the sliding tile mechanics for educational and entertainment purposes. His works continue to feature prominently in studies of , where puzzles like the 14-15 slider are analyzed for their connections to and solvability invariants. In recognition of his chess compositions, Loyd was inducted into the U.S. Chess Hall of Fame in 1987, alongside , highlighting his enduring impact on problem-solving in the game. Recent developments underscore Loyd's ongoing relevance, with continued reprints of his collections—such as ' editions of Mathematical Puzzles of Sam Loyd—keeping his original works accessible to new generations. Academic discussions of his paradoxes, including the (a vanishing area where an 8×8 square rearranges into a 5×13 , seemingly gaining area), appear in education resources to demonstrate fallacies and trigonometric approximations. No major controversies have emerged regarding Loyd's legacy since 2022, allowing focus on his positive contributions. On a broader scale, Loyd shaped the puzzle industry by pioneering mass-market mechanical and mathematical amusements, influencing collectors and creators like Jerry Slocum, whose extensive research and museum-quality archive build directly on Loyd's foundational hoaxes and innovations.

References

  1. https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Loyd/
  2. https://www.lindahall.org/about/news/scientist-of-the-day/sam-loyd/
  3. https://www.chesshistory.com/winter/extra/loyd.html
  4. https://en.chessbase.com/post/puzzle-artist-sam-loyd-january-30-1841-to-april-10-1911
  5. https://www.kunstschach.ch/docs/White_Sam%20Loyd%20and%20his%20chess%20problems%201913.pdf
  6. http://billwall.phpwebhosting.com/articles/loyd_sam.htm
  7. https://www.samloyd.com/about-sam-loyd/
  8. http://www.edochess.ca/tournaments/t116.html
  9. https://libraries.indiana.edu/sam-loyd-puzzle-king
  10. https://www.samloyd.com/about-sam-loyd-junior/
  11. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Sam-Loyd
  12. http://chessmetrics.com/cm/CM2/PlayerProfile.asp?Params=199510SSSSS3S077849186810121000000000018110100
  13. https://www.sportsmuseums.com/hallsoffame/other-halls-of-fame/world-chess-hall-of-fame/u-s-chess-hall-of-fame-inductees/
  14. https://en.chessbase.com/post/chebase-puzzles-loyds-excelsior-261013
  15. https://en.chessbase.com/post/chess-problems-excelsior-again
  16. https://en.chessbase.com/post/chessbase-puzzles-loyd-s-steinitz-gambit
  17. https://www.uschess.org/index.php/February/64-Square-Problem-Tour.html
  18. https://cs.gettysburg.edu/~tneller/papers/iccg10.pdf
  19. https://www-cs-faculty.stanford.edu/~knuth/loyd-cyc.txt
  20. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24950467
  21. https://amagicclassroom.com/uploads/3/4/5/2/34528828/klondike__sam_loyd_.pdf
  22. https://patents.google.com/patent/US563778A/en
  23. https://www.futilitycloset.com/2010/01/15/a-vanishing/
  24. https://www.thebeliever.net/get-off-the-earth/
  25. https://improbable.com/2013/12/29/sam-lloyds-get-off-the-earth-puzzle/
  26. https://mathblag.wordpress.com/2011/08/28/a-paradoxical-dissection/
  27. https://www.cut-the-knot.org/Generalization/CevaPlus.shtml
  28. https://www.themarginalian.org/2012/02/23/the-disappearing-bicyclist/
  29. https://www.mebondbooks.com/2022/06/27/the-false-claims-of-puzzle-writer-sam-loyd/
  30. https://www.puzzlemuseum.com/singma/singma5/SOURCES/SOURCE2.DOC
  31. https://artsandculture.google.com/story/american-board-and-card-game-history-the-strong/dgVhZCrQ9FmHJw?hl=en
  32. https://thesecretlifeofmarbles.com/marbles-in-motion-the-maze/
  33. https://www.samloyd.com/product/our-puzzle-magazine-special-edition/
  34. https://archive.org/details/8thbookoftan700t0000loyd
  35. https://www.mathpuzzle.com/loyd/
  36. https://djm.cc/library/Cyclopedia_of_Puzzles_Loyd.pdf
  37. https://books.google.com/books/about/Sam_Loyd_and_His_Chess_Problems.html?id=v6rfPAAACAAJ
  38. https://store.doverpublications.com/products/9780486204987
  39. https://www.amazon.com/Cyclopedia-Puzzles-tricks-Conundrums-Answers/dp/0923891781
  40. https://homepages.gac.edu/~jsiehler/306090/Bibliography/05-gardner-tangrams.pdf
  41. https://www.chesshistory.com/winter/extra/puzzles.html
  42. https://mathshistory.st-andrews.ac.uk/Biographies/Dudeney/
  43. http://www.gamesandpuzzles.org/index.php/awards/agpi-awards
  44. https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=appinventor.ai_prof_carlosfranca.SamLoyd
  45. https://worldchesshof.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/2013-hof-redesign3web.pdf
  46. https://www.cut-the-knot.org/Curriculum/Fallacies/SamLoydSon.shtml
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.