Scabdates
Scabdates
Main page
S

Scabdates

logo
Community Hub0 subscribers
Read side by side
Scabdates
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Scabdates
Live album by
The Mars Volta
ReleasedNovember 8, 2005
RecordedMay 2004–May 2005, Various live performances
GenresProgressive rock, experimental rock
Length72:54
LabelsGold Standard Laboratories
Universal Records
Strummer
ProducerOmar Rodríguez-López
The Mars Volta chronology
Frances the Mute
(2005) 		Scabdates
(2005) 		Amputechture
(2006)

Scabdates is the second official live recording from the band The Mars Volta. It was released on November 8, 2005 and features music recorded between May 2004 and May 2005 during the tours in support of De-Loused in the Comatorium and Frances the Mute. In 2011, NME magazine named it one of the 50 greatest live albums of all time.[1] The "And Ghosted Pouts" section of "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" was used in the film Get Him to the Greek.

Overview

[edit]

Only three of the band's songs are represented on Scabdates, which mainly comprises expansions on musical themes which appear elsewhere in their work, or entirely new segments altogether, such as the lengthy exposition on "Cicatriz"; which, when combined with its introduction "Haruspex", accounts for over 48 minutes of the album. Its lengthy jam incorporates themes which would later be used in "Cassandra Gemini" almost a year later on Frances the Mute. By contrast, the Scabdates version of "Concertina" is shorter than its studio counterpart released on the Tremulant EP. The album ends with Cedric thanking the audience by telling them to "go home and take a bath."

Portions of the album include overdubbing and tape effects that were not part of the original live recordings. "Abrasions Mount the Timpani" features field recordings of mewling babies and airliner announcements that Omar recorded on the road, while "Cicatriz" incorporates an eight-minute psychedelic sound collage of other Mars Volta live performances (notably performances of "Eunuch Provocateur" and "Cassandra Gemini"), alongside field recordings of the band and others talking and laughing. The album, like many live albums before it, was also mixed to sound as if it came from one performance.

Rodriguez subsequently commented on the compilation of the album that:

I listened to my favorite live records, and said, "Okay, that's nice. What would I want as a fan?" When I was a kid, I always wanted little moments about the band on tour, so I could imagine them in my head. You hear our live record, and it starts with sound check and our technicians speaking about what's wrong with the microphone. And then there's us backstage, and then it goes into the concert, and then in the middle of a song, I put in some conversations we had on the tour bus. All these things are really appealing to me. A lot of people who were upset said, "This is not a live album. It includes all this other bullshit. And it has overdubs!" It has no overdubs, it was just mixed in a creative way.[2]

Reception

[edit]
Professional ratings
Aggregate scores
SourceRating
Metacritic(58/100) [3]
Review scores
SourceRating
AllmusicStarStarStarHalf star [4]
Entertainment WeeklyB [5]
IGN(5/10) [6]
Paste(4/10) [3]
Pitchfork Media(3.5/10) [7]
PopMattersStarStarStarStarStarStar [8]
Punknews.orgStarStarStarHalf star [9]
Rolling StoneStarStarStar [10]
Sputnikmusic(2/5) [11]
Tiny Mix TapesHalf star [12]
Ultimate Guitar(8.4/10) [13]

The Mars Volta have freely encouraged the trading of bootlegged live performances, but Scabdates was lauded by many fans for its superior sound quality and for being the first official recording that captured the Volta's lengthy experimental workouts during live performances. Some critics were not impressed with the band's jam sessions, with IGN describing the album as "sonic meandering which some regard as genius and others find to be a futile exercise in pretentious instrumental masturbation."[6]

The album scored a 58/100 on Metacritic, indicating "mixed or average reviews".[3] Some reviews were positive: Under the Radar gave it a score of seven stars out of ten and called it "One of those rare live offerings: a document that actually complements the band's catalog."[3] NME gave it a score of seven out of ten and called it "marvelous".[3]

Other reviews were pretty average, mixed or negative: The Austin Chronicle gave it three stars out of five and said: "Seventy-three crack-in-the-earth's-crust minutes liquefy into the same basic miasma as the sophomore LP that inspired them, yet more streamlined, less apt to wander into the ambient dead zones like 'Caviglia,' a problematic disconnection of the disc's overall forward thrust."[14] Uncut also gave it three stars and said, "Your appreciation of Scab Dates will be predicated on a high tolerance to long bongo solos and songs called things like 'Abrasions Mount The Timpani'."[3] Prefix Magazine gave it an average review and said the album "does an adequate job of capturing what is best experienced in the flesh."[15] Blender gave it two stars out of five and said, "The songs get lost in waves of wah-wah long before a long, slow fade into random-noise oblivion."[3] Pitchfork Media gave it a score of 3.5 out of ten and said it was "neither a concession nor a step forward, revealing inclinations that feel half as indulgent as they should when following a record like Frances the Mute, and about half as interesting to listen to."[7]

As of February 2007 it has sold 64,000 copies in United States.[16]

Track listing

[edit]

Like Frances the Mute, portions of Scabdates were cut into separate sections for the CD pressing. "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" was spread along three tracks, while "Cicatriz" was spread across five; the fifth section, "Part IV", begins with the sound collage mentioned above. On vinyl, "Cicatriz" was split along three sides: "Cicatriz" ended side B, "Parts I-III" on side C, and "Part IV" taking up Side D.

Finalized track listing

[edit]
No.TitleLength
1."Abrasions Mount the Timpani"4:07
2."Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" (Gust of Mutts - And Ghosted Pouts)13:23
3."Caviglia"2:46
4."Concertina"4:17
5."Haruspex"5:24
6."Cicatriz" (Cicatriz - Part I - Part II - Part III - Part IV)42:58

CD pressing

[edit]
No.TitleLength
1."Abrasions Mount the Timpani"4:07
2."Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt"5:57
3."Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt A. Gust of Mutts"2:34
4."Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt B. And Ghosted Pouts"4:52
5."Caviglia"2:46
6."Concertina"4:17
7."Haruspex"5:24
8."Cicatriz"8:16
9."Cicatriz A. Part I"2:34
10."Cicatriz B. Part II"7:39
11."Cicatriz C. Part III"4:29
12."Cicatriz D. Part IV"20:01

Source of recordings

[edit]
05/12/2004 – Wiltern Theatre – Los Angeles, CA
  • "Haruspex"
  • "Cicatriz"
05/13/2004 – Wiltern Theatre – Los Angeles, CA
  • "Caviglia"
05/05/2005 – Roseland Ballroom – New York City, NY
  • "Abrasions Mount the Timpani"
  • "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt"
05/06/2005 – Roseland Ballroom – New York City, NY
  • "Gust of Mutts / And Ghosted Pouts"
05/10/2005 – Avalon Ballroom – Boston, MA
  • "Concertina"

Personnel

[edit]

The Mars Volta

[edit]

Recording personnel

[edit]
  • Jonathan Debaun – recording, engineer
  • Omar Rodriguez-Lopez – mixing
  • Howie Weinberg – mastering
  • Roger Liam – mastering assistant

Artwork

[edit]
  • Danielle Van Ark – photographs
  • Sonny Kay – design, layout
  • Omar Rodríguez-López – art direction
  • Cedric Bixler-Zavala – art direction

Charts

[edit]
Chart performance for Scabdates
Chart (2005) Peak
position
Australian Albums (ARIA)[17] 87
US Billboard 200[18] 76

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Scabdates

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Scabdates is a live album by the American progressive rock band The Mars Volta, released on November 8, 2005, by Universal Records.[1][2] Recorded during live performances from May 2004 to May 2005 using a mobile studio, it captures the band's intense and improvisational stage energy across 12 tracks totaling 72 minutes and 49 seconds.[1][3] The album primarily features material from The Mars Volta's debut studio album, De-Loused in the Comatorium (2003), along with selections from their Tremulant EP (2002), presented in extended, multi-part formats that highlight the group's experimental and psychedelic influences.[4] Notably absent are tracks from their recently released second studio album, Frances the Mute (2005), allowing Scabdates to serve as a document of their earlier touring repertoire.[4] Key performances include the sprawling "Cicatriz ESP," segmented into five parts spanning nearly 40 minutes, and the opening sound collage "Abrasions Mount the Timpani," which incorporates field recordings from the band's tours.[4][2] Produced and mixed by bandleader Omar Rodríguez-López at Sound City Studios in September 2005, with mastering by Howie Weinberg at Masterdisk in New York City, Scabdates was issued in various formats including CD and double vinyl picture disc, emphasizing its role as the band's second official live release.[3] The album underscores The Mars Volta's reputation for complex, riff-driven compositions and Cedric Bixler-Zavala's dynamic vocals, bridging their post-hardcore roots with progressive rock innovation.[4]

Background

Tour Context

The Mars Volta embarked on extensive tours in 2004 and 2005 to support their debut album De-Loused in the Comatorium (2003) and follow-up Frances the Mute (2005), performing over 120 shows across North America, Europe, and South America during this period.[5] These tours marked a pivotal phase in the band's career, transitioning from the raw energy of their post-hardcore roots to expansive live spectacles that highlighted their growing mastery of progressive rock. Key performances included two nights at the Wiltern Theatre in Los Angeles on May 12 and 13, 2004, during the De-Loused tour, where the band delivered intense, riff-driven sets drawing heavily from the album's material.[6] Similarly, in 2005, they played consecutive shows at the Roseland Ballroom in New York on May 5 and 6, coinciding with the Frances the Mute promotion, featuring elongated explorations of tracks like "L'Via L'Viaquez" and "Cygnus...Vismund Cygnus."[7] The band's lineup during these tours achieved a level of stability that allowed for cohesive yet dynamic performances, centered on core members Cedric Bixler-Zavala on vocals, Omar Rodríguez-López on guitar and production oversight, Jon Theodore on drums, Paul Hinojos on bass, and Isaiah "Ikey" Owens on keyboards.[8] Hinojos, a former At the Drive-In colleague, had been contributing as a sound manipulator since 2003 but formally joined as bassist midway through the 2005 U.S. tour after departing Sparta.[9] Additional support came from Marcel Rodríguez-López on guitar, who began integrating into live sets around this time, and guest appearances by John Frusciante on guitar for select dates, including South American shows in late 2004 and U.S. performances in 2005, adding layers of improvisational interplay.[10] Live shows evolved significantly from relatively structured renditions of album tracks in early 2004 to highly improvisational jams by 2005, reflecting the band's experimental progressive rock ethos through extended solos, ambient soundscapes, and seamless transitions between songs.[4] Performances often stretched individual pieces into multi-part epics, with wordless instrumental sections emphasizing complex riffage and rhythmic interplay, as seen in bootlegs from the Wiltern and Roseland shows where tracks like "Cicatriz ESP" ballooned to over 20 minutes.[11] This shift underscored their refusal to adhere to conventional setlist formats, instead treating concerts as fluid, collaborative explorations that captivated audiences with chaotic energy and technical virtuosity.[12] The tours were not without challenges, including lineup adjustments stemming from the post-At the Drive-In diaspora, such as Hinojos's abrupt departure from Sparta in May 2005 to fully commit to The Mars Volta.[9] Additionally, guitarist Omar Rodríguez-López suffered a stomach ailment in mid-2005, forcing the cancellation of several European dates and highlighting the physical toll of their demanding schedule.[13] Bixler-Zavala's lyrics, performed with raw intensity during these shows, drew from personal loss, particularly the 1996 suicide of friend Julio Venegas, infusing sets with themes of grief and resilience that resonated through the live interpretations.[14] This emotional undercurrent connected to broader album motifs like cicatrices, symbolizing scars as enduring emotional wounds.[4]

Conceptual Intent

Scabdates serves as a live document intended to preserve The Mars Volta's improvisational prowess and the visceral energy of their stage performances, drawing from recordings captured during the band's intensive touring period in 2004 and 2005. Guitarist and primary architect Omar Rodríguez-López compiled the material using his mobile recording setup, selecting segments that highlight the group's post-At the Drive-In cohesion and experimental expansion of their sound, with extended jams transforming studio compositions into sprawling, unpredictable explorations. This focus on recent material underscores the band's growth into a unified entity capable of seamless, high-stakes improvisation, distinct from their earlier punk-rooted influences.[4] Thematically, the album extends motifs of scarring and emotional healing from De-Loused in the Comatorium, most prominently through the multi-part rendition of "Cicatriz ESP," where Spanish for "scar" evokes persistent psychological wounds amid chaotic sonic eruptions. Improvisational interludes like "Haruspex"—a word denoting ancient divination practices—introduce ritualistic, trance-like segments that amplify the band's thematic interest in altered states and recovery, bridging the structured narratives of prior studio works with raw, unfiltered live expression.[15] Rodríguez-López's vision emphasizes surrealism and emotional intensity over conventional song structures, infusing the recordings with ambient collages and dreamlike textures to evoke the hallucinatory quality central to The Mars Volta's aesthetic. By prioritizing representative tour dates from this era, such as performances in late 2004, the album captures a pivotal moment of artistic maturation, where field recordings and subtle enhancements contribute to an immersive, otherworldly atmosphere without overshadowing the core live vitality.[16]

Recording and Production

Live Sources

The live sources for Scabdates were compiled from select concerts during The Mars Volta's 2004–2005 North American tour, capturing the band's raw energy and improvisational style in front of audiences. Primary material came from two nights at the Wiltern Theatre in Los Angeles on May 12 and 13, 2004, during the tour for De-Loused in the Comatorium, along with shows at the Roseland Ballroom in New York City on May 5 and 6, 2005, and the May 10, 2005, concert at the Avalon Ballroom in Boston, Massachusetts, during the tour for Frances the Mute. These 2005 performances emphasized their reputation for dynamic, unpredictable live sets.[17][18] By drawing from these specific U.S. dates, the album highlighted peak moments from the tour without incorporating European legs, allowing for focused selection amid the band's grueling schedule.[17] The use of multi-night recordings enabled the selection of optimal takes to showcase the band's variable live improvisations, where songs often morphed through extended jams and spontaneous shifts. Engineer Jonathan Debaun handled on-site multi-track audio capture using the E-Clat mobile studio setup during these tour dates, ensuring high-fidelity preservation of the performances' intensity and nuance.[19][4]

Studio Enhancements

Following the live recordings captured on the E-Clat mobile studio from May 2004 to May 2005, Omar Rodríguez-López compiled the material into a cohesive double album, integrating field recordings he captured of the band during the tour to add atmospheric depth and thematic layers without compromising the core spontaneity of the performances.[19] These field recordings, which included ambient tour sounds, were woven into the mix to enhance the immersive quality of tracks like the extended improvisations in "Cicatriz," preserving the chaotic energy of the original shows while refining overall clarity.[19] Rodríguez-López handled the mixing himself at Sound City Studios in September 2005, working under a strict time constraint to balance the raw live essence with polished cohesion across the lengthy jams.[19] The editing process involved selecting and sequencing segments from multiple concert sources to maintain the album's flow, particularly challenging for sprawling pieces such as "Cicatriz," which spans over 40 minutes in its final form split across several parts, ensuring the improvisational freedom remained intact despite format limitations.[1] Once mixed, the masters were promptly forwarded to Howie Weinberg at Masterdisk in New York City for final mastering, assisted by Roger Lian, to optimize loudness and fidelity for the disc's dynamic, extended structures.[19] This post-production approach emphasized augmentation over overhaul, allowing the live sources—drawn from U.S. tour dates—to retain their unfiltered intensity.[19]

Musical Content

Track Listing

Scabdates presents its live recordings in a format that highlights the band's improvisational style, with the core content structured around six principal tracks on the conceptual level, though the CD edition subdivides them into 12 individual tracks to accommodate player indexing and flow. The album's total runtime is approximately 73 minutes, underscoring the focus on expansive, multi-part compositions drawn from various tour performances.[2][20] The CD track listing is as follows:
No.TitleDuration
1"Abrasions Mount the Timpani"4:07
2"Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt"5:56
3"Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt: A. Gust of Mutts"2:34
4"Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt: B. And Ghosted Pouts"4:52
5"Caviglia"2:46
6"Concertina"4:17
7"Haruspex"5:24
8"Cicatriz"8:16
9"Cicatriz: A. Part I"2:33
10"Cicatriz: B. Part II"7:39
11"Cicatriz: C. Part III"4:27
12"Cicatriz: D. Part IV"20:05
Tracks 2–4 represent subdivisions of the full "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" performance, while tracks 8–12 form the extended "Cicatriz" suite, totaling 42:58 and incorporating elements from "Cicatriz," "This Apparatus Must Be Unearthed," and "Miranda That Ghost Just Isn't Holy Anymore" as a continuous medley.[2][21] The vinyl edition, released as a double LP picture disc, organizes the material across four sides without subdivisions in track numbering but following a similar sequence to maintain the album's immersive structure. Side A includes "Abrasions Mount the Timpani" through "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt: B. And Ghosted Pouts"; Side B covers "Caviglia" to the initial "Cicatriz"; Side C features "Cicatriz: A. Part I" to "Part III"; and Side D concludes with "Cicatriz: D. Part IV."[3]

Song Expansions

The live rendition of "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" on Scabdates extends the original 8:42 studio version from De-Loused in the Comatorium to 13:23, incorporating additional guitar solos and rhythmic shifts that amplify its chaotic energy.[22][3] Divided into three segments—"Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" (5:56), "A Gust of Mutts" (2:34), and "And Ghosted Pouts" (4:52)—the performance builds through a raw, noisy crescendo before delving into riff-heavy explorations and screeching vocals, diverging from the studio's more structured precision.[23] This expansion highlights the band's tendency to stretch familiar material into immersive jams during their 2004–2005 tour.[4] The "Cicatriz" suite forms the album's centerpiece, merging the 12:29 studio track "Cicatriz ESP" from De-Loused in the Comatorium into a sprawling 42:58 epic that encompasses "This Apparatus Must Be Unearthed" (originally 4:58 from the same album).[22][2] Spanning five parts—"Cicatriz" (8:16), "Part I" (2:33), "Part II" (7:39), "Part III" (4:27), and "Part IV" (20:00)—it features over 30 minutes of improvisational jamming, vocal experimentation, and thematic callbacks to loss, including organ solos, wah-pedal guitar sections, psychedelic interludes, and chaotic overdubs with Spanish clips and mariachi elements.[4][23] These extensions transform the suite into a dynamic narrative arc, with frantic picking, noisy swells, and moody repetitions that evoke the tour's improvisational style.[23] "Haruspex" and "Caviglia" function as short interstitials at 5:24 and 2:46, respectively, bridging the album's larger compositions without direct studio counterparts at the time of recording.[3] "Haruspex" builds tension through a mostly wordless jam, serving as a prelude to the "Cicatriz" suite, while "Caviglia" acts as a brief palette cleanser with minimalistic, transitional phrasing.[4][23] "Concertina," drawn from the 4:54 version on the Tremulant EP, appears in a concise 4:17 interlude on Scabdates, emphasizing Cedric Bixler-Zavala's raw, emotive vocals amid a tighter, up-tempo arrangement with tasteful saxophone.[24][3] This rendition prioritizes live intimacy over the EP's extended structure, showcasing the band's ability to distill intensity in shorter form.[23] Across Scabdates, the tracks shift from the studio albums' polished precision to live chaos, deepening explorations through improvisation without introducing new compositions, as evidenced by the tour's emphasis on extended, unpredictable performances.[4][23]

Release

Formats and Packaging

Scabdates was initially released on November 8, 2005, in compact disc and double vinyl LP formats through Gold Standard Laboratories in partnership with Universal Records.[2][25] The CD edition utilized a standard jewel case packaging with a six-page fold-out insert featuring photography by longtime collaborator Danielle Van Ark, capturing the band's intense live performances.[19][26] The double LP was pressed as a picture disc set, housed in a single sleeve with black inner sleeves, accompanied by a 23" x 9" foldout poster and an eight-page inlay booklet.[3] No bonus tracks were included across formats.[19][3] Regional variations were minimal, with the Australian CD release following the standard U.S. edition without additional extras, issued via Universal's local distribution.[2]

Promotion and Distribution

Scabdates was released on November 8, 2005, through the independent label Gold Standard Laboratories (GSL), with distribution handled by the major label Universal Records.[2][27] The album's promotion was closely tied to The Mars Volta's ongoing tour supporting their 2005 studio album Frances the Mute, capturing live energy from performances during that cycle to appeal to the band's dedicated progressive rock audience.[4] GSL, co-managed by bandleader Omar Rodríguez-López since 2001, maintained artistic control while leveraging Universal's infrastructure to bridge indie credibility with broader commercial reach.[28][29] Distribution focused primarily on the U.S. market, with international rollout facilitated through Universal's global network, including editions in Europe, Japan, Mexico, and other regions.[2] The campaign emphasized word-of-mouth among prog rock enthusiasts rather than major television appearances, aligning with the band's experimental ethos.[4]

Personnel

Band Members

The core band members performing on the live recordings featured in Scabdates were drawn from The Mars Volta's lineup during their 2004–2005 tour, capturing the group's dynamic and improvisational style in concert settings.[2] Cedric Bixler-Zavala provided lead vocals and lyrics, serving as the central figure in the band's improvisational delivery, often extending vocal lines into chaotic, emotive explorations that defined their live energy.[2] Omar Rodríguez-López handled lead guitar and overall artistic direction, acting as a multi-instrumentalist who shaped the performances through intricate riffs and on-stage orchestration.[2] Jon Theodore played drums, delivering a solid rhythmic foundation that anchored the extended jams and allowed for the band's progressive explorations to unfold.[2] Juan Alderete de la Peña contributed on bass guitar, providing the low-end drive essential to the tour's intensity.[17] Isaiah "Ikey" Owens rounded out the core sound on keyboards, layering atmospheric textures that enriched the psychedelic and experimental elements of the live sets.[2] Supporting the lineup were Marcel Rodríguez-López on percussion and sound manipulation, adding rhythmic depth and textural elements; Paul Hinojos on effects and sound manipulation, drawing from his background as a founding member of At the Drive-In; Adrian Terrazas-Gonzalez on saxophone, clarinet, and flute for select dates, introducing woodwind improvisations that expanded the sonic palette.[2][17]

Production Team

The production of Scabdates was handled internally by the band, with no external producers involved, emphasizing The Mars Volta's self-directed approach to capturing and refining their live performances.[19] Jonathan Debaun served as the primary recording engineer, capturing audio from multiple concerts using a mobile studio setup between May 2004 and May 2005; he engineered the entire project, ensuring high-fidelity live recordings from various tour dates.[19][30] Omar Rodríguez-López took on the roles of producer, mixer, and assembler, overseeing the compilation of tracks from the sourced live recordings into a cohesive album; he directed the process to preserve the band's improvisational energy while adding minimal refinements.[2][30] The mixing was conducted to balance the raw live elements, with Rodríguez-López handling overdubs where necessary to enhance clarity without altering the performance's authenticity.[2] Mastering was performed by Howie Weinberg at Masterdisk in New York City, optimizing the final mixes for both vinyl and CD formats to achieve dynamic range and tonal consistency suitable for wide distribution.[19][3] Assisted by Roger Lian, Weinberg's work focused on polishing the assembled recordings while maintaining their live intensity.[3] Additional support came from unnamed tour technicians who aided in on-site setup and monitoring during the recording sessions, though specific credits for these roles remain unlisted.[2]

Artwork

The artwork for Scabdates was art directed by The Mars Volta's Omar Rodríguez-López and Cedric Bixler-Zavala, who incorporated scar motifs to evoke the album's central "scab" concept, symbolizing raw, unpolished live performances as imperfect layers over the band's studio recordings.[3] Photography was provided by Danielle Van Ark, whose images capture frenetic, abstract depictions of the band in motion—blurs of instruments, amplifiers, and performers amid sweaty intensity—creating wound-like visual textures that align with the album's visceral energy.[1][3] The overall design and layout, including adaptations for the digipak and gatefold packaging, were handled by Sonny Kay, ensuring a cohesive presentation that avoids traditional band portraits in favor of evocative, non-literal elements.[3] Influences from surrealist aesthetics are evident in the eerie, dreamlike collages and hypnotic live shots interspersed throughout the booklet, while punk roots contribute to the raw, unrefined edge that complements the live album's chaotic spirit.[31]

Reception and Impact

Critical Response

Upon its release, Scabdates received mixed reviews from critics, who were divided on the album's raw live energy and extended improvisations. The album holds a Metacritic score of 58 out of 100, indicating mixed or average reviews based on 14 critic assessments.[32] Positive responses highlighted the album's vitality and how it captured the band's dynamic stage presence. Entertainment Weekly described it as "exhausting, self-indulgent, and also kind of awesome," appreciating its intense execution despite its excesses.[32] Similarly, NME praised it as "marvellous," noting the raw energy that complemented the band's studio catalog.[32] AllMusic awarded it 3.5 out of 5 stars, commending the improvisations that expanded familiar tracks into thrilling live interpretations.[1] Critics on the negative side focused on the album's perceived overindulgence and lack of cohesion. Pitchfork gave it a 3.5 out of 10, deeming the approach pretentious and self-indulgent.[4] IGN rated it 5 out of 10, describing it as "experimental sonic meandering" and lambasting the lengthy passages as "instrumental masturbation" that prioritized virtuosity over structure.[33] Blender echoed this sentiment with a score of 40 out of 100, faulting the tracks for dissolving into "random-noise oblivion" amid waves of effects.[32] Overall, reviews reflected a tension between admiration for the live expansions—particularly in songs like "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt," where the band's improvisational flair shone—and condemnations of self-indulgence that rendered portions aimless. In 2011, NME ranked Scabdates at number 39 on its list of the 50 greatest live albums of all time, recognizing its place among notable concert recordings.

Commercial Performance

Scabdates debuted at number 76 on the US Billboard 200 chart in November 2005, selling 15,860 copies in its first week according to Nielsen SoundScan data.[34] The album achieved modest commercial success, reflecting The Mars Volta's niche appeal within the progressive rock genre.[4] As of 2025, it remains available for digital streaming on platforms like Spotify, though it has not received any RIAA certification.[20] Limited promotion, focused primarily on the band's ongoing tour rather than widespread marketing, contributed to its restrained sales performance relative to the group's studio releases.[35]

Legacy

A section from Scabdates, the live album by The Mars Volta, gained cultural visibility through its inclusion in the 2010 comedy film Get Him to the Greek, directed by Nicholas Stoller. In the movie, the track's "And Ghosted Pouts" segment from "Take the Veil Cerpin Taxt" is played by Jonah Hill's character to showcase the band's euphoric live energy, contributing to a memorable scene that introduced the album to a broader audience beyond prog rock enthusiasts.[36] In retrospective assessments, Scabdates has been recognized for its raw documentation of the band's improvisational prowess during their early tours. NME ranked it at number 39 on its 2011 list of the 50 greatest live albums of all time, praising its chaotic yet captivating representation of The Mars Volta's stage presence amid the era's prog revival.[37] Despite receiving mixed reviews upon release for its experimental structure and lengthy jams, Scabdates endures as a key entry in The Mars Volta's discography, valued for preserving the frenetic, boundary-pushing essence of their performances that influenced subsequent generations of progressive rock acts. Its availability on streaming platforms has sustained fan interest, highlighting the album's role in the band's broader legacy of innovation in live recordings.[36][38]

References

  1. Scab Dates - The Mars Volta | Album - AllMusic
  2. The Mars Volta - Scabdates
  3. The Mars Volta - Scabdates
  4. The Mars Volta: Scab Dates Album Review | Pitchfork
  5. The Mars Volta Tour Statistics: De-Loused in the Comatorium
  6. The Mars Volta Setlist at Wiltern LG Theatre, Los Angeles
  7. The Mars Volta Setlist at Roseland Ballroom, New York
  8. The Mars Volta Songs, Albums, Reviews, Bio & M... - AllMusic
  9. Paul Hinojos Joins The Mars Volta | Bands | News | Scene Point Blank
  10. John and TMV together on stage...again - Invisible Movement
  11. The Mars Volta - Scab Dates | Punknews.org
  12. Review: Mars Volta spurns convention - Daily Bruin
  13. Mars Volta Tour Troubles - SPIN
  14. https://stereogum.com/2227442/mars-volta-de-loused-in-the-comatorium-turns-20/reviews/the-anniversary/
  15. The Mars Volta: Scab Dates - PopMatters
  16. Texas Platters - The Austin Chronicle
  17. The Mars Volta - Scabdates
  18. The Mars Volta Concert Setlist at Avalon, Boston on May 10, 2005
  19. The Mars Volta - Scabdates
  20. Scab Dates - Album by The Mars Volta | Spotify
  21. THE MARS VOLTA Scab Dates reviews - Prog Archives
  22. https://www.discogs.com/master/9154-The-Mars-Volta-De-Loused-In-The-Comatorium
  23. The Mars Volta - Scab Dates (album review ) - Sputnikmusic
  24. https://www.discogs.com/master/9308-The-Mars-Volta-Tremulant-EP
  25. The Mars Volta to release live album - NME
  26. https://www.discogs.com/release/5782181-The-Mars-Volta-Scabdates
  27. Scab Dates - The Mars Volta - Amazon.com
  28. Scabdates by The Mars Volta (Album, Progressive Rock): Reviews ...
  29. https://www.discogs.com/artist/274511-Omar-Rodriguez-Lopez
  30. Gold Standard Labs Closes Its Doors - XLR8R
  31. https://www.discogs.com/artist/565173-Paul-Hinojos
  32. The Mars Volta - Scabdates - Kids Grass
  33. The Mars Volta - Scabdates
  34. The Mars Volta - Scabdates Review - Rocknworld.com
  35. Scab Dates by The Mars Volta Reviews and Tracks - Metacritic
  36. The Mars Volta - Scabdates - IGN
  37. Soundscan / Billboard Top 200 Albums 11.16.05 - Prince.org
  38. Mars Volta Stretches Out On Live Album - Billboard
  39. The mind-melting magic of The Mars Volta - Blunt Magazine
  40. NME's 50 Greatest Live Albums Of All Time - What Are Yours?
  41. https://stereogum.com/1254741/deconstructing-the-rise-demise-and-legacy-of-the-mars-volta/columns/sounding-board/
User Avatar
No comments yet.