Hubbry Logo
The English GameThe English GameMain
Open search
The English Game
Community hub
The English Game
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The English Game
The English Game
from Wikipedia

The English Game
GenreHistorical drama
Created by
Written by
  • Julian Fellowes
  • Tony Charles
  • Oliver Cotton
  • Ben Vanstone
  • Gabbie Asher
  • Sam Hoare
  • Geoff Bussetil
Directed by
Starring
ComposerHarry Escott[1]
Country of originUnited Kingdom
Original languageEnglish
No. of episodes6
Production
Executive producers
ProducerRhonda Smith
Production locationEngland
Running time43–55 minutes
Production company42
Original release
NetworkNetflix
Release20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)

The English Game is a British historical sports six-part television drama about the origins of association football in England. Developed by Julian Fellowes for Netflix, the six-part series was released on 20 March 2020.[2] While the series is set primarily in Lancashire, it was filmed in Yorkshire.

Premise

[edit]

In the 1870s, football in the United Kingdom was a sport for the wealthy. A working-class star and his upper-class counterpart come together to change the game forever.

Cast

[edit]

Main

[edit]

Supporting

[edit]

Recurring

[edit]

Episodes

[edit]
No.TitleDirected byWritten byOriginal release date
1"Episode 1"Birgitte StærmoseJulian Fellowes, Tony Charles, Oliver Cotton & Ben Vanstone20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)
Arthur Kinnaird is captain and star player of the Old Etonians, an upper class football team. Their opponents in the 1879 FA Cup Quarter finals are Darwen FC, a working class factory team. James Walsh, the owner of Darwen FC and the associated mill decides to secretly pay two Scottish players, Fergus "Fergie" Suter and James "Jimmy" Love to join his team in a bid to secure the FA Cup (which at the time is exclusively for amateurs). At halftime the Old Etonians lead 5-1, however after Suter is appointed as captain during the interval, Darwen recover with a progressive adjustment (spreading out their formation and focusing on passing) to draw 5 all. The Old Etonians, who also happen to be FA Board members, decide that since extra time was not previously agreed to then the Quarter final will be replayed instead. The mill has financial issues and townsfolk pitch in to help pay for the trip. The replay is handily won by Old Etonians who focus more on shutting down Suter and Love rather than playing their own game. Darwen FC are greeted positively for their efforts by the town.
2"Episode 2"Birgitte StærmoseJulian Fellowes & Ben Vanstone20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)
Suter meets with Walsh and persuades him to change some football strategies. Stokes, a team member, goes to Kinnaird’s bank to ask for a loan. Some Darwen mill workers talk about strike as a result of a prior 5 per cent wage cut. The Cotton Guild imposes another 10 per cent wage cut. Darwen workers walk out. The team refuses to train or play in matches while on strike. Suter fails to persuade Walsh to go against the guild. Workers go to the guild to demand a 5 per cent wage cut and fewer hours to help fight the oversupply that has caused the price of goods to fall. The guild refuses. Workers riot. Kinnaird is saved from the riot by Stokes. Against Kinnaird’s wishes, Stokes goes in his place to warn Colonel Jackson (the guild leader) that the mob is coming for him. Police show up and arrest Stokes and kill his dog. Stokes is put on trial and sentenced to 15 years in prison. Kinnaird testifies on behalf of Stokes and saves him from prison and gives him his loan. Walsh agrees to the 5 per cent wage cut and to work five days a week if the team plays their upcoming match. While waiting on the team at the match, Suter is approached by the manager of Blackburn FC and is offered £100 upfront and a £6 weekly wage increase. Suter turns him down as the team arrive to play.
3"Episode 3"Birgitte StærmoseJulian Fellowes & Gabbie Asher20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)
Suter goes home to Glasgow to visit his poor family and drunken, abusive father who tries to shame Suter for being paid to play. Kinnaird and his wife continue to mourn the loss of her pregnancy six months earlier. Once back in Lancashire, Suter meets with Cartwright, the Blackburn FC manager and accepts his offer but needs a few days to make it right with Jimmy, Walsh and the Darwen team. After practice with the Etonians, teammates talk about the “epidemic” of working-class teams joining the Football Association. While the gentleman scoff at the conditions of the working poor, Kinnaird comes to their defence. The Darwen team are out celebrating Jimmy’s stag party. Mr. Walsh tells Suter that he’s proud of his decision to bring Suter on to the team. Suter thanks him but doesn’t mention the deal with Blackburn. Clearly drunk, Suter gets in a fight with another Blackburn player recently hired from Partick when he compares Suter to his drunken father. The following day, at the match between Darwen and St Luke’s, Suter arrives late and plays terribly. Darwen lose 3-0 and are out of the FA Cup. Suter storms off the pitch. At home, Suter tells Doris about the deal with Blackburn and says that he will tell Jimmy after the wedding. Jimmy practises his vows and Doris overhears. At the wedding, Jimmy tells all that he finally feels like he has a home in Darwen. As Suter begins his best man’s speech, he is interrupted by a teammate who reads a Blackburn ad about Suter joining the team, shocking everyone.
4"Episode 4"Tim FywellJulian Fellowes & Sam Hoare20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)
At the Darwen mill, Walsh shames Suter for his choice to leave. Suter tries to persuade Jimmy to come with him. Jimmy refuses, saying that Darwen is his team and his family now. Cartwright shows Suter the new facilities and stands. He shows off new teammates, including Jack Hunter from Sheffield, and tells Suter he is assembling a team of the best players north of Eton. Cartwright asks Walsh for his discretion regarding Suter’s professionalism and offers him £100, and a share of receipts from next week's Blackburn versus Darwen exhibition match. After being seen talking familiarly with Mr Cartwright (with whom she previously had a child), Martha is fired from her job at the Cotton Master’s club. Mr Cartwright offers her money to help but Martha refuses, saying she needs to find her own way. At the Blackburn v Druids match, Suter struggles to mesh with his new teammates. Hunter is hailed the hero. Suter talks with Jimmy, who calls him a Judas. Suter tells Jimmy that he is trying to get his family away from his father. Suter again asks Jimmy to join Blackburn. Later, Jimmy stands up for Suter against the Darwen team and tells them he is joining Blackburn. On the way to the match between the Old Etonians and Preston, the Etonians discuss how football is becoming a booming business and is no longer just a game. The FA President complains that if it continues, only the richest teams will win and is planning to watch the exhibition match between Darwen and Blackburn to find evidence to expel them from the FA cup. The match between Darwen and Blackburn is rough and Jimmy’s leg is badly broken by a tackle and the blood loss threatens both his life and his leg.
5"Episode 5"Tim FywellJulian Fellowes & Geoff Bussetil20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)
Jimmy is told he will never play football again. Cartwright tells the Blackburn team that a portion of the match proceeds will go to help Jimmy’s recovery. Cartwright asks Suter how Martha and her daughter are doing after her job loss. After Cartwright tells his wife about the affair, she goes to Martha’s house and offers to care for her daughter, Jenie. Martha refuses. Martha tells Suter about Cartwright and Jenie. Martha goes back to talk with Mrs Cartwright and apologises for the affair with her husband. Suter and Martha kiss. Tommy, the player who injured Jimmy, visits to apologise. Suter arrives and tells Jimmy the team will support him financially and they are struggling to replace him. Later, Suter pushes Jimmy in a cart to the pub to cheer him up. Darwen teammates start to reconcile with Suter. Stokes talks about his business success making football kits. Doris asks after a job for Jimmy. Kinnaird has a falling out with his friend over the true reason behind missing the quarter-final match. After some tense discussions with his father about his football career, Kinnaird uses his football contacts to help save a vital investment. Kinnaird debates the merits of paying players with the Etonians. The Lancashire teams band together to beat the elite teams. Mr. Walsh pressures Tommy to join Blackburn to replace Jimmy. Cartwright offers Suter the captainship (and a bonus) if they make it to the final. Mrs Cartwright offers Martha a job at Brockshall and says she can bring Jenie. Two days later the FA Board meets without Kinnaird and discuss expelling Darwen and Blackburn from the cup.
6"Episode 6"Tim FywellJulian Fellowes & Ben Vanstone20 March 2020 (2020-03-20)
The FA Board votes to expel Blackburn. Kinnaird is furious. Later Kinnaird has it out with his friends about their betrayal. Walsh, now the head of the Lancashire FA, holds a meeting to figure out how to fight the ban. Suter offers to talk to Kinnaird. Walsh gives Suter a new suit so that he will fit in with the elite. Suter discusses the merits of professional players. Suter argues that the elites banning of professionals is not fair because they are not working all day to put food on the table. They both agree they play for the love of the game. At the Board meeting Suter argues in favour of letting Blackburn play. The Board stands by their decision to ban Blackburn from the cup. Walsh tells him the Lancashire FA and most other county FAs will withdraw from the FA Cup and form a new association, with Kinnaird as its president. Kinnaird argues that the working-class teams will overwhelm the elite teams unless they include the working class, and persuades the Board to let Blackburn play. At the match, the 1883 FA Cup Final, the Etonians are playing well but in a very physical way. The score is 0-0 at half-time. One of the Etonian players is injured but they agree to keep playing anyway. Suter scores with a header from Tommy's pass. In the last moments of the match, Kinnaird scores on a breakaway. The teams agree to extra time. Suter sits out a player to make the match fair and gives the players a rousing pep talk. He scores the winning goal and lifts the cup to overwhelming cheers. In 1885, the FA officially allows professional players and an amateur team never wins the cup again. Kinnaird becomes the FA President and serves for 33 years until his death in 1923.

Production

[edit]

In April 2018, it was announced Downton Abbey creator Julian Fellowes would write and executive produce his first Netflix series.[3] Birgitte Stærmose and Tim Fywell are directing, Rory Aitken, Eleanor Moran and Ben Pugh of 42 are executive producing, and Ben Vanstone is co-executive producing.[4]

The cast was announced in May 2019 as production began in England, mostly in the North.[4]

The epilogue reads: "In 1885 the FA changed their rules to allow professional players. An amateur team never won the FA Cup again. Arthur Kinnaird became President of the FA, serving 33 years until his death in 1923. Fergus Suter and Jimmy Love are recognised as pioneers of the modern game, which now has over four billion fans across the world."[5]

Historical accuracy

[edit]

Football

[edit]

After the first couple of episodes the exact dates of events is not explicitly mentioned, though it is suggested that the entire series takes place over just over one season, with Suter winning the cup with Blackburn the year after he joined Darwen. In fact Suter did not win the FA Cup until his sixth season in Lancashire.[6]

At the time, Blackburn had two teams: Blackburn Olympic and Blackburn Rovers. The English Game appears to merge the two sides, with the club only ever referred to as "Blackburn Football Club" or just "Blackburn" and shown playing in maroon shirts – both Blackburn Olympic and Blackburn Rovers instead played in a combination of blue and white.[7][8] The maroon colour may have been chosen to differentiate Blackburn from the Old Etonians, who are always shown wearing Eton blue shirts. Blackburn Olympic were the first club of working-class background to win the FA Cup, triumphing in the 1882–83 season. Of the two teams, Suter in fact joined Blackburn Rovers,[9] with whom he lost the 1882 FA Cup Final 1-0 against the Old Etonians before winning the cup three times in succession later in the decade.

The matches depicted in the show most closely resemble Blackburn Olympic's 1883 victory. Old Etonians' and Blackburn Olympics' matches in the quarter-finals, semis and the final are all referenced accurately except for Old Etonians' quarter-final where they in fact played Hendon.[10] Darwen are shown as being eliminated from the competition by Derby St Luke's but the Derby club did not actually participate in the FA Cup until the 1884–85 season, and the two sides never met in a competitive fixture.

The first episode depicts Darwen playing just one replay against the Old Etonians in the 1878–79 FA Cup and losing. In fact, Darwen took the Old Etonians to two replays – after the first match was drawn 5–5, the first replay finished 2–2 before Old Etonians finally beat them at the third attempt by a score of 6–2.[11]

Personal

[edit]

Fergus "Fergie" Suter and James "Jimmy" Love joined Darwen separately, with the former joining second in 1878 – Suter was a stonemason, not a mill worker, and would not have come to Darwen to work in a mill. Jimmy Love did not join Darwen to be a paid player, but in fact fled his home in Glasgow when a warrant was put out for his arrest over debts he owed.[12] There is no evidence that he ever joined a Blackburn team permanently, though he did appear for Blackburn Rovers in a friendly against Darwen in 1879.[12] His footballing career was ended in 1880, though not because of a bad tackle but instead as he was recruited into the Royal Marines. Three years later he died of enteric fever while garrisoned with them in Egypt.[12]

A recurring storyline in the series is Arthur Kinnaird's failure to have a child and the resulting effects that it has, particularly on his wife who sees child-raising as her raison d'être. In reality, Arthur and his wife had no such problems. They had their first child in 1876, several years before the start of the show, and went on to have another six children over the following quarter of a century, most of whom survived childhood.[13] Alma Kinnaird is shown as having a miscarriage in the second episode, which – though not specified – must have taken place in late 1879. This could not have happened as Alma in fact gave birth to the couple's second child in August of that year.[13]

Release

[edit]

A trailer was released on 5 March 2020.[14]

Reception

[edit]

On Metacritic, the series has a weighted average score of 62 out of 100, based on four critics, indicating "generally favorable reviews".[15]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
The English Game is a six-part British historical drama miniseries created by and released on on 20 March 2020, dramatizing the origins and professionalization of in late 19th-century through the rivalry and collaboration of two real historical figures: aristocratic banker Arthur Kinnaird and working-class Scottish mill worker turned footballer . The series centers on the class tensions of Victorian Britain, portraying how amateur public school traditions clashed with emerging working-class professionalism, culminating in events like the between Old Etonians and Olympic, which symbolized football's shift toward paid players despite bans on professionalism until 1885. It draws on documented figures such as Kinnaird, who won five FA Cups and later became FA president, and Suter, a pioneer in passing tactics credited with influencing Rovers' dominance, though the narrative composites events for dramatic effect, including fictionalized team dynamics and personal arcs not fully supported by primary records. Produced with high-fidelity period recreations using period-appropriate kits and venues like Darwen's football ground, the received praise for its visual authenticity and evocation of football's raw physicality but faced criticism for historical liberties, such as altering timelines of rule changes and exaggerating social reforms tied to the sport's evolution. While earning a 7.6 rating on from over 18,000 users for its engaging portrayal of the game's , it holds a 53% critics' score on , with reviewers noting formulaic plotting reminiscent of Fellowes' that prioritizes class melodramas over precise sporting history. No major awards followed, but it contributed to renewed interest in football's pre-professional era amid Netflix's push into British period dramas.

Overview

Premise and Themes

The English Game is a six-part British historical sports drama miniseries created by and released on on , 2020. The series dramatizes the early development of in during the and , portraying how the transitioned from an amateur pursuit dominated by upper-class gentlemen to a professionalized game accessible to the working classes. It centers on the rivalry and alliance between , a skilled Scottish working-class footballer who defects to the northern mill town club and pioneers paid play, and Arthur Kinnaird, an aristocratic Old Etonian captain of the elite , as they confront entrenched social hierarchies through competition in the . Central themes revolve around class conflict, depicting the Victorian-era divide where southern amateur "gentlemen" clubs enforced unpaid participation to preserve the sport's moral purity and exclusivity, while northern working-class teams like sought to sustain players amid industrial poverty. This tension culminates in challenges to the Football Association's amateur rules, mirroring real debates that led to the sport's legalization of in 1885. The narrative also explores professionalism and democratization, illustrating football's role in eroding class barriers as working-class innovation—such as Suter's passing tactics—outmaneuvered the upper classes' reliance on individual and brute force, fostering the game's mass appeal and eventual global dominance. Personal themes of loyalty, betrayal, and redemption underscore these societal shifts, with characters facing scandals like and violence that reflect the era's raw, unregulated matches. While emphasizing empirical historical catalysts like the 1878-79 clashes between northern pros and southern amateurs, the series attributes the sport's evolution to causal pressures from industrialization and wage labor rather than benevolent reform.

Episode Summaries

Episode 1

The episode introduces the contrasting worlds of 19th-century English football through two protagonists: upper-class banker Arthur Kinnaird, a multiple winner with the Old Etonians, and Scottish footballer , recruited alongside teammate Jimmy Love by cotton mill owner James Walsh to bolster the working-class team's chances in the . Walsh, facing economic pressures, pays the Scots under the table to play, marking an early instance of professionalism in a dominated by amateurs from elite schools. A pivotal match between and the Old Etonians showcases brutal tactics, with Arthur's team prevailing 5-0 amid rough play and class tensions, while Fergus innovates passing strategies against traditional kicking. Personal backstories emerge, including Arthur's grief over a lost child and Fergus's integration into mill life.

Episode 2

Fergus revitalizes by teaching passing tactics adapted to weather conditions, boosting team performance despite a mill wage cut sparking worker unrest and high emotions. , reflecting on the previous defeat, forms an unexpected bond in Darwen after encountering locals, challenging his privileged worldview. Meanwhile, and wife grapple with personal loss, while Fergus navigates life away from , including tensions with Jimmy over strategy shifts. The episode explores early professionalism's risks, as hidden payments strain loyalties, and culminates in 's improved play hinting at upset potential against establishment teams.

Episode 3

Fergus returns to , confronting his abusive father and weighing a lucrative offer from rival Rovers' owner Cartwright, which promises £100 signing bonus and £6 weekly—tempting amid family hardships but risking his ties. Arthur adopts a more egalitarian approach to football, irking his elite Old Etonians teammates and family, while investing in shirts and honoring his late son. aids working-class women at a refuge, intervening for Betsy during . loses to St. Luke's, exiting the , as Fergus's move leaks, fracturing his friendship with Jimmy during the latter's wedding celebrations.

Episode 4

Martha receives troubling health news, while and Alma uncover a distressing secret. Fergus, now at , faces adjustment challenges in his elevated role, clashing with teammates. A heated match in descends into disorder, underscoring professionalism's volatility. Walsh and Cartwright negotiate amid rivalries, as personal stakes intensify with Fergus reconciling with Jimmy for a key game against , highlighting shifting allegiances in the push toward the .

Episode 5

Guilt-ridden Fergus learns shocking developments from , prompting introspection amid his Blackburn ambitions. Walsh and Cartwright forge an alliance to counter threats, while the FA imposes severe measures on without 's consultation, escalating rules debates. prioritizes family over football, contrasting Fergus's cup pursuit, as teams advance toward the final with mounting personal and institutional conflicts.

Episode 6

Fergus travels to to petition the FA for professionalism's acceptance, advocating change. As the nears between and Old Etonians, urges peers to prioritize the game's integrity over class barriers. Resolutions unfold with balancing family news of pregnancy and football, Fergus bidding farewells, and the final symbolizing football's evolution from elite pastime to mass pursuit, culminating in Blackburn's victory.

Cast and Production

Principal Cast and Character Inspirations

stars as Arthur Kinnaird, the aristocratic banker and footballer who became the first president of (FA), serving from 1890 until his death in 1923; Kinnaird, a real historical figure from the Old Etonians club, played in nine finals between 1873 and 1887, winning five, and advocated for the sport's codification while representing upper-class interests. Kevin Guthrie portrays Fergus Suter, a Scottish immigrant and skilled player from Partick Thistle who joined in 1878, introducing the passing style of play from and becoming one of the earliest professional footballers in England by receiving wages covertly, which challenged amateur rules; Suter later moved to Blackburn Olympic and Rovers, contributing to their dominance in the early FA Cups.
ActorCharacterReal-Life Inspiration
Arthur KinnairdHistorical FA president and Old Etonians player (1847–1923)
Scottish footballer who professionalized play at (1857–1904)
Margaret Alma KinnairdWife of Arthur Kinnaird, philanthropist and co-founder of the Young Women's Christian Association (YWCA) in 1855
Martha AlmondFictional working-class woman inspired by mill workers supporting early football clubs
James AlmondComposite based on mill owners like those at who recruited Scottish talent to boost local teams
Supporting roles include as Francis Peabody, a fictional FA administrator embodying establishment resistance to change, and as Tom Walker, drawing from anonymous working-class players in early clubs like . The characterizations blend historical accuracy with dramatic invention, such as Suter's recruitment by , which echoes real 1878 events but compresses timelines for narrative purposes.

Production Development and Challenges

The English Game was conceived by as a dramatization of association football's formative years, emphasizing class divisions between public school amateurs and working-class professionals. Announced on April 18, 2018, at a event in , the six-part series was commissioned as a original produced by the London- and Los Angeles-based company 42. Fellowes, who wrote the scripts alongside Tony Charles and , centered the narrative on real events like the 1879 quarter-final between the Old Etonians and to illustrate the sport's transition from elite pastime to mass entertainment. Historical accuracy in football's evolution, including Scottish influences on professionalism, was informed by consultant Andy Mitchell, a . Filming spanned five and a half months in 2019, primarily in to evoke 1870s , with locations including Yorkshire's Broughton Hall, (reconfigured as a mill town), Bradford's Little Germany, and for match sequences; hosted recreated public school games. Key production hurdles arose in authenticating period football, requiring actors to train for four weeks in 1870s-style play—marked by hacking, fewer restrictions, and equipment like heavy woolen kits and weighted leather balls—under choreographer Mike Delaney, a former . A significant delay occurred when , portraying Arthur Kinnaird, fractured his wrist in a tackle scene, suspending filming for one month. Director Brigitte Staermose managed these logistics to balance dramatic pacing with historical fidelity.

Filming Techniques and Historical Recreation

The production team employed specialized football choreography to recreate the raw, unstructured nature of 1870s association football, which differed markedly from modern play due to lax rules on physical contact, such as permitted "hacking" or shin-kicking, and the absence of advanced tactics like offside traps. Mike Delaney, serving as football choreographer, trained actors in period-specific techniques drawn from historical accounts, emphasizing chaotic scrums, limited passing, and endurance-based play on uneven pitches to achieve authenticity rather than polished athleticism. This approach avoided anachronistic flair, focusing instead on the game's embryonic brutality and working-class improvisation against upper-class formality. Filming of match sequences utilized high-speed cameras typically deployed for contemporary coverage, adapted to capture the frenetic action of 19th-century fixtures while maintaining visual dynamism without compromising period immersion. Scenes were shot on location in , including estates and the for transport sequences, selected for their preserved and landscapes evocative of industrial . Interiors, such as mills and gentlemen's clubs, were constructed or redressed to reflect socioeconomic divides, with sets avoiding modern conveniences to mirror the era's rudimentary facilities. Historical recreation extended to costumes and props, where production designer Lucia Ivaneska and costume teams sourced fabrics and designs true to 1870s conventions: upper-class players in tailored and caps contrasting with working-class teams in simple wool jerseys and , underscoring class tensions without exaggeration. Props like hand-stitched leather balls and unmarked goalposts were replicated from archives, ensuring visual fidelity to the sport's pre-professional phase. Behind-the-scenes efforts prioritized empirical reference to primary sources, such as reports, over stylistic liberties, though some dramatization occurred for narrative flow. This methodical process contributed to the series' reputation for evoking the era's grit, as noted in production notes emphasizing research-driven accuracy over .

Historical Foundations

Real-Life Figures and Events

(FA) was established on October 26, 1863, at the in , following a letter from , a solicitor and founder of , proposing unified rules to resolve disputes among varying football codes. , born in Hull in 1831, drafted the initial 13 laws of the game in December 1863, emphasizing principles like no carrying the ball and prohibiting hacking, which helped standardize distinct from rugby. These foundational efforts addressed chaos in pre-1863 matches, where public school teams played by ad-hoc rules favoring their styles. Fergus Suter, born November 21, 1857, in , emerged as a pivotal figure in early , transitioning from play with Partick Thistle to in 1878, where he received payments—reportedly £15 annually plus bonuses—marking one of the first documented cases of "broken-time" compensation for lost wages. A skilled half-back known for passing tactics over , Suter helped , a mill town club, reach the quarterfinals in 1879, defeating higher-class teams including a 5-5 draw (won on replay) against the elite Old Etonians at Eton Field on January 11, 1879. He later joined Blackburn Rovers, contributing to their dominance, though he did not play for Blackburn Olympic. Arthur Kinnaird, 11th Lord Kinnaird (1847–1923), embodied aristocratic involvement, captaining the Wanderers and Old Etonians to five wins while appearing in a record nine finals between 1873 and 1883; he played versatile positions, including , and advocated for passing over hacking. An Eton and alumnus, Kinnaird co-organized the first pseudo-international match in 1872 ( vs. at ) and served as FA president from 1890 to 1923, influencing amid rising debates. The on March 31 at Kennington Oval symbolized class tensions, with working-class Blackburn Olympic defeating the amateur Old Etonians 2–1 after extra time before 8,000 spectators; goals by James Costley and John McKay highlighted tactical endurance and passing, as Olympic's miners and factory workers outlasted the public school side. This upset, coached by Jack Hunter, accelerated professionalism's acceptance, contrasting prior Old Etonians dominance (winners in 1879 and 1882) and foreshadowing clubs' rise.

Evolution of Football Rules and Professionalism

The codification of association football rules in England began in the mid-19th century amid efforts to standardize disparate variants played at public schools and universities. Influential early sets included the of 1848, which prohibited carrying the ball and emphasized kicking, and the of 1857, developed by Sheffield Football Club—the world's oldest club, founded that year—which allowed some handling but prioritized local play. These efforts culminated in the formation of the (FA) on 26 October 1863, when representatives from 11 and suburban clubs met at the to establish uniform laws, explicitly distinguishing the game from rugby by banning running with the ball. The FA's inaugural 1863 Laws of the Game comprised 14 rules (later standardized to 13), specifying a maximum pitch size of 200 by 100 yards, goals defined by posts 8 yards apart with a crossbar or tape at 8 feet high, no carrying or throwing the ball, prohibition of hacking or tripping, and an requiring three opponents between the ball and goal line when receiving a pass. Revisions followed rapidly to address ambiguities and promote fair play: in , the laws clarified kicking or only, eliminated remaining handling allowances, and adjusted offside to two opponents; by 1871, the was introduced, and free kicks for fouls were formalized in 1872. Further changes in the 1870s included the mandatory crossbar in 1875 and limits on handling in 1875, reflecting growing emphasis on over brute force, though enforcement varied regionally until the FA's authority strengthened. Parallel to rule standardization, emerged as a contentious shift from the FA's , rooted in southern middle-class ideals of gentlemanly play without compensation. In northern industrial areas, working-class players from mills and mines faced lost wages for matches, leading to covert "boot money" payments by the 1870s; clubs like and Rovers openly recruited Scottish talent, prompting FA bans on reimbursements in 1883. A peaked in 1884 when the FA expelled Preston North End and others for , risking a northern breakaway; on 20 July 1885, after delegate pressure, the FA legalized player payments, stipulating registration and maximum wages initially capped at 6 shillings per day. This enabled the formation of the Football League in 1888 by 12 clubs under William McGregor, professionalizing competition and boosting attendance to tens of thousands per match in northern grounds by the 1890s.

Class Structures in 19th-Century British Sport

In 19th-century Britain, sporting activities were sharply stratified by , reflecting broader Victorian societal hierarchies where leisure pursuits served distinct purposes across strata. Upper- and middle-class participants, often alumni of elite public schools such as Eton, Harrow, and Rugby, engaged in codified games emphasizing amateurism, physical discipline, and character formation under the influence of , a movement promoting robust Christian manhood through athletics. Working-class individuals, concentrated in industrializing northern and midland regions, initially participated in informal, folk-derived variants of games like football, which evolved into organized forms tied to workplaces, churches, and public houses, prioritizing communal recreation amid grueling labor schedules. This divide manifested in rule-making, participation norms, and , with elite institutions imposing standards that clashed with proletarian practicalities, such as the necessity of compensation for time away from paid work. Association football exemplified these tensions, originating from public school variants developed by the 1830s, where schools devised bespoke rules—often verbally transmitted—to channel youthful energies without excessive violence. (FA), established on October 26, 1863, at the in by predominantly southern, middle-class former pupils, standardized rules favoring a handling-prohibited "dribbling" game suited to lighter, less robust players, while enshrining amateurism as a against "" viewed as corrupting. Governing bodies like the FA initially restricted membership and competition to gentlemen amateurs, excluding manual laborers to preserve the sport's ethical purity, though middle-class clubs such as (founded 1857) began bridging gaps through early organized matches. By the 1870s, football permeated working-class communities in and the , where mill workers and miners formed teams that outcompeted sides through superior fitness and tactical innovations, including imported Scottish passing techniques. Economic pressures—lost wages from match days—prompted covert payments, breaching FA bans and fueling a north-south schism, as northern clubs like and achieved successes (e.g., Blackburn Olympic's 1883 victory) with hired proletarian talent. This underground professionalism, tolerated in practice but condemned ideologically, highlighted causal realities: industrial capitalism's wage dependency clashed with aristocratic ideals, driving demand for . The crisis peaked in 1884–1885, when northern clubs threatened a breakaway federation, compelling the FA to legalize on July 20, 1885, permitting player wages to reflect market realities and sustain participation. This concession, ratified after acrimonious debates, acknowledged working-class dominance—evidenced by crowds exceeding 10,000 at professional matches—and paved the way for the Football League's inception in 1888, comprising 12 founding clubs, six from , institutionalizing class integration through commercial structures. Subsequent developments, including player unions by the , further eroded elite control, transforming football from a gentlemanly pursuit into a mass rooted in proletarian agency. Similar patterns appeared in and athletics, where northern professional leagues challenged southern amateur hegemony, underscoring how economic imperatives ultimately reshaped British sporting class dynamics.

Accuracy and Interpretations

Fidelity to Historical Records

The miniseries The English Game adheres to the broad historical trajectory of association football's development in 19th-century , accurately depicting the Football Association's (FA) formation in 1863 to codify rules amid rival public school variants, the initial amateur ethos dominated by upper-class teams like the Old Etonians, and the gradual incursion of working-class northern clubs introducing and tactical innovations. It correctly portrays the pre-1885 ban on player payments, which clubs circumvented through "broken-time" allowances and under-the-table wages, culminating in the FA's legalization of on 26 July 1885 following northern clubs' threats to form a breakaway league. Fergus Suter, depicted as a pioneering Scottish immigrant, aligns with records: born 21 November 1857 in , he played for Partick Thistle before joining in 1878, where he and teammate Jimmy Love were the first known players covertly paid £1 weekly plus bonuses—equivalent to about £120 today—effectively launching professionalism. Suter's transfer to Rovers in 1880, motivated by higher covert pay of £3 weekly, contributed to their victories in 1884, 1885, and 1886, though the series truncates this to a single dramatized triumph and omits his later career, including three consecutive titles. Arthur Kinnaird's portrayal as an aristocratic captain resisting change captures his real status as an Old Etonian who won five FA Cups (1873, 1875, 1877 with Wanderers; 1879, 1881 with Old Etonians) and later served as FA president from 1890 to 1923, but exaggerates his active playing role into the 1880s; he had largely transitioned to administration by 1882, not captaining Old Etonians in finals against northern teams as shown. The series' central 1879 FA Cup quarter-final between Darwen and Old Etonians reflects reality—Darwen, a mill workers' team, forced two draws before a 2–1 loss on 12 February 1879 at The Oval, attended by 1,500—but condenses it to one replay for pacing, ignoring the full three-match saga. The climactic working-class victory over aristocrats draws from Blackburn Olympic's 2–1 upset of Old Etonians in the 1883 final (10 April, goals by John McKinnell and Thomas Dobson), but attributes it to a fictionalized Rovers side under Suter, merging events from Rovers' 1–0 loss to Old Etonians in the final with Olympic's triumph to heighten class antagonism. Personal elements, such as Suter's backstory tragedies or Kinnaird's marriage, lack primary evidence and serve dramatization, while the depicted "passing game" from accurately revolutionized the sport's tactics, supplanting public school kicking styles by the early 1880s. Overall, while compressing a of events into six episodes sacrifices chronological precision, the production faithfully conveys causal drivers like economic incentives and regional rivalries in football's , corroborated by club archives and contemporary match reports.

Fictional Elements and Dramatizations

The The English Game blends historical foundations with invented personal narratives and condensed events to emphasize themes of class conflict and the rise of professionalism in football. While real figures like and Arthur Kinnaird anchor the plot, creator employs dramatizations to forge emotional connections and narrative cohesion, often prioritizing storytelling over strict chronology. Key fictional elements include character backstories lacking historical evidence, such as Suter's abusive alcoholic father and his romance with Martha Almond, which escalates into a with a fictional Blackburn Rovers manager, Mr. Cartwright. Alma Kinnaird's subplot, involving aid to a bereaved mother in recovering a baby and tensions with her husband and father-in-law, is entirely contrived, despite her real marriage to in 1875. Jimmy Love's arc, depicting a leg injury and transfer to , is invented; records show he joined before Suter and later enlisted in the Royal Marines, dying of fever without playing for . Dramatizations extend to event timelines and club portrayals for dramatic effect. The series merges the (where Rovers lost 1-0 to the Old Etonians) with 1883 (a 2-1 win by Olympic), fabricating a Rovers victory climax unattested in records. Suter's recruitment to is shown as simultaneous with 's, though Love preceded him, and Suter likely initiated the move himself amid rumors of an illegitimate child rather than family abuse. is unified as one club, conflating Rovers and Olympic—distinct rivals whose successes Suter contributed to separately in 1884–1886. These alterations streamline the evolution from amateur public-school football to working-class but sacrifice precision; for example, Suter's real stemmed from payments at around 1878, not the heightened personal stakes depicted. Such choices reflect Fellowes's style in prior works, using history as a framework for accessible rather than documentary fidelity.

Critiques of Class Narrative Portrayal

Critics have contended that The English Game oversimplifies the class dynamics of 19th-century British football by framing them as a stark binary conflict between rigid, upper-class amateurs from public schools and innovative, oppressed working-class professionals from the industrial north. This narrative, while dramatizing the tensions leading to the legalization of professionalism in 1885, neglects the historical nuance of more fluid class interactions, including significant middle-class involvement in clubs and the persistence of aristocratic participation even after the shift to paid play. Historian Dilwyn Porter has emphasized that football's evolution involved gradual integration rather than outright displacement of elites, with figures like Arthur Kinnaird, the 11th Lord Kinnaird, actively supporting the sport's growth without fully relinquishing influence. The series' depiction of aristocratic resistance—portrayed through caricatured opponents who embody snobbery and opposition to change—has drawn accusations of stereotyping, reducing multifaceted historical actors to mustache-twirling antagonists while idealizing working-class grit. Reviewers note that this approach prioritizes emotional resolution over causal accuracy, presenting class reconciliation as a feel-good triumph rather than the pragmatic adaptations driven by mutual economic interests in expanding the game. In truth, , founded in 1863 by public school alumni, codified rules that working-class teams largely adopted, indicating less outright warfare and more a shared framework amid evolving professionalism debates. Such portrayals risk reinforcing a selective historiographical lens that emphasizes victimhood and upheaval, potentially underplaying how elite institutional structures endured and shaped modern football's governance, as evidenced by the continued dominance of amateur ideals in early competitions until the 1880s. While the series highlights real events like the 1883 FA Cup final between Old Etonians and Blackburn Olympic, critics argue it compresses timelines and motivations to fit a class-war arc, diverging from showing cooperative rule refinements rather than pure antagonism. This , though engaging, has been faulted for prioritizing narrative symmetry over empirical fidelity to the incremental, interest-aligned processes that professionalized the sport.

Release and Market Performance

Distribution Strategy

The English Game was released as a Netflix original series, with all six episodes premiering simultaneously on , 2020, across 's global platform. This binge-release format, standard for originals, enabled subscribers to access the complete immediately, fostering extended viewing sessions and reducing fragmentation typical of weekly episodic drops on traditional television. The distribution eschewed conventional broadcast networks or theatrical runs in favor of direct-to-streaming exclusivity, aligning with Netflix's model of proprietary content to drive subscriber retention and algorithmic recommendations. Produced by UK-based , the series was commissioned as part of Netflix's investment in European originals to appeal to international audiences interested in British historical dramas and sports heritage. Global rollout occurred in over 190 countries where operates, without region-specific delays, to synchronize promotional campaigns and capitalize on unified buzz. This strategy, informed by data analytics on viewer preferences for period pieces and football-related content, positioned the series for broad accessibility amid 's 167 million paid subscribers at the time. Subsequent availability on secondary platforms like Prime Video in select markets occurred post-exclusivity window, but retained primary distribution rights.

Viewership Metrics

The English Game, released on on March 20, 2020, experienced strong initial uptake, ranking second on 's global top 10 list for the week of March 23–29, 2020, reflecting significant viewer engagement during early that boosted streaming overall. By late 2025, the series had amassed approximately 18,362 user ratings on , averaging 7.6 out of 10, indicating a solid but niche audience draw for a historical rather than blockbuster appeal. Demand analytics from Parrot Analytics reported U.S. audience demand for the series at 0.9 times the average for TV shows in recent 30-day periods, underscoring moderate long-term interest compared to mainstream content. did not publicly disclose exact viewing hours or completed views for the six-episode run, consistent with the platform's selective reporting practices for non-flagship titles prior to its 2023 policy shift toward broader metrics transparency.

Critical and Public Reception

Professional Reviews

Professional critics gave The English Game mixed reviews upon its release on , , praising its production quality and dramatized football sequences while critiquing the scripting, , and handling of historical and class themes as formulaic or overwrought. On , the holds a Tomatometer score of 53% based on aggregated assessments, contrasting with an score of 83%. Metacritic assigns a score of 62 out of 100 from four reviews, indicating generally favorable but divided sentiment. Lucy Mangan of The Guardian described the series as an "own goal," faulting its "dire" opening episode, clichéd mill worker accents rendered as "t'm'ill," and romanticized portrayal of 1870s football origins, though noting slight improvement in later episodes. A review in The Athletic (New York Times) echoed concerns over "awkward, clunky" dialogue unsuitable for sporting purists but highlighted effective football match depictions and the intrigue of class tensions in amateur vs. emerging professional play. Esquire advised against viewing it as a substitute for live football, criticizing the narrative's reliance on Victorian-era rivalries between Darwen and Blackburn Rovers as insufficiently compelling amid lockdown viewing. In The Arts Fuse, the series was deemed "excellent" for tracing soccer's shift to mass appeal through real figures like but flawed by abrupt character arcs that swung antagonists to protagonists without nuance. John Serba of Decider, contributing to Metacritic's aggregate, called it "entertaining in a flimsy, forgettable way," fulfilling period drama expectations without innovation. Overall, reviewers appreciated the historical backdrop of the Football Association's formation and the 1879 but found ' script, known from , hindered by melodramatic class warfare tropes unsubstantiated by primary records of the era's sporting evolution.

Audience Feedback and Debates

Audience reception to The English Game has been generally positive, with viewers appreciating its production values, character development, and depiction of early football matches. On , the holds a 7.6/10 rating from over 18,000 user reviews, where many praised its compelling , high-quality visuals, and thrilling sequences as elements of a "beautiful and well-made ." Similarly, audience score stands at 83%, with reviewers highlighting enjoyable narratives accessible to non-football enthusiasts, likable characters, and authentic period costumes and sets. user score of 6.6 indicates favorable but tempered approval, often noting entertainment value despite perceived flaws in depth. Feedback frequently emphasized the series' role in educating viewers on football's evolution, with users describing it as an "eye-opener" into 19th-century play styles and a "fun watch" blending and , though some observed heavier non-football plotlines than anticipated. Positive sentiments extended to its portrayal of social tensions, including class divides, which resonated with audiences interested in , even as casual viewers found the personal stories engaging beyond athletic action. Debates among audiences and commentators centered on historical fidelity versus dramatic license, with criticisms that the series combined real events—such as those involving Blackburn Olympic and —into fictionalized narratives for narrative cohesion, rather than adhering strictly to records. While some viewers accepted these alterations as necessary for accessibility, akin to dramatic conventions in other historical works, others argued they diluted the sport's authentic progression from upper-class pastimes to working-class dominance, potentially oversimplifying causal factors like industrialization and rule changes. Class portrayal sparked further discussion, with the series' emphasis on working-class innovation challenging elite exclusivity lauded for highlighting merit-based competition, yet critiqued for formulaic depictions that echoed creator ' prior works without deeper of socioeconomic shifts. Audience segments, including football historians, debated whether such dramatizations accurately captured the era's tensions or risked romanticizing outcomes, though empirical reception data shows these concerns did not broadly deter enjoyment, as evidenced by sustained viewership and repeat recommendations.

Strengths and Weaknesses in Storytelling

The narrative structure of The English Game effectively intertwines personal character arcs with the historical evolution of , highlighting the tension between amateur gentlemanly play and emerging through the contrasting perspectives of protagonist Arthur Kinnaird, an aristocratic banker and player, and , a skilled Scottish mill worker seeking paid opportunities. This approach yields strengths in depicting inspirational triumphs, such as Darwen's challenges against elite teams, which underscore themes of merit-based competition and in a visually engaging manner with tactical nods to 19th-century passing innovations versus brute force. Compelling elements include the depth in main characters' internal conflicts—Kinnaird's shift from elitist arrogance to advocacy for working-class inclusion and Suter's moral dilemmas over —bolstered by strong performances that humanize the class divide. However, the storytelling falters in predictability and heavy-handed melodrama, adhering to creator ' familiar upstairs-downstairs formula of stereotypical toffs versus resilient proles, which reduces nuance and renders plot developments foreseeable from the outset. Critics noted a dire opening laden with expository and a subsequent pivot from thrilling match sequences to overwrought personal tragedies—such as and —that overshadow the sport itself, diminishing narrative momentum after the first installment. Character development often veers into without sufficient subtlety, with supporting figures like rivals or bosses serving formulaic roles, leading to a sense of manipulation over organic progression despite the cast's efforts to inject vitality. Overall, while the maintains watchability through its uplifting core, its reliance on clichés and uneven focus undermines deeper dramatic tension.

Broader Impact

Influence on Football Historiography

The Netflix series The English Game (2020) popularized a framing the professionalization of as a class-driven , emphasizing working-class northern clubs' challenge to southern public-school amateurs in the 1880s, which has shaped public by amplifying themes of and through sport. This depiction, centered on the between Olympic and the Old Etonians, drew from real events but conflated details from Olympic and rival Rovers to heighten drama, influencing subsequent popular accounts to prioritize individual heroism—such as Fergus Suter's alleged introduction of the passing game from —over gradual evolutionary developments. Historians have noted the series' role in reviving interest in overlooked aspects of football's origins, such as the contributions of mill-town teams to tactical innovation and the Football Association's legalization of in , prompting amateur enthusiasts to explore primary sources like match reports from the era. However, it has faced criticism for embedding inaccuracies into lay , including anachronistic portrayals of soccer's dominance over other codes like rugby in the 1870s and oversimplified binaries of "" elites versus "passing" proletarians, which echo but exaggerate longstanding debates on Scottish influences without engaging evidence of parallel English innovations. Specialist discussions, such as those at the 2025 Footycon conference, continue to assess whether the series has net broadened engagement with archival history or entrenched fictionalized myths, like the mythic role of Queen's Park in tactical evolution, potentially complicating rigorous causal analyses of football's codification. In educational contexts, the series has been employed as an accessible entry point for teaching 19th-century through football, encouraging students to dramatized events against FA records and contemporary newspapers, though educators caution against accepting its narrative uncritically due to selective emphasis on class antagonism over economic factors like and expansion driving club formation. Academic reviews underscore minimal direct alteration to scholarly , which relies on empirical works predating the series—such as analyses of the or Cambridge University influences—but acknowledge its indirect effect in stimulating public queries that refine popular debunkings of origin legends. Overall, while not reshaping peer-reviewed frameworks, The English Game has fostered a hybrid blending entertainment with history, where its class-focused lens persists in media retellings despite evidentiary pushback from data-driven reconstructions.

Cultural Depictions of Merit and Competition

The series portrays merit in football as the primacy of individual , tactical innovation, and physical prowess over aristocratic privilege, exemplified by the character Fergus Suter's transition from a skilled Scottish mill worker to a professional player for , where his abilities elevate a working-class team to contention in the 1870s. This depiction aligns with historical precedents, such as Darwen's 1879 quarter-final run against Old Etonians, where the underdogs' merit-based preparation—emphasizing passing and endurance—challenged upper-class amateurism rooted in public school traditions. is rendered as a raw, egalitarian arena, with the structured as a knockout tournament open to all clubs since its in 1871, allowing meritocratic upsets like Blackburn Olympic's 2-1 victory over the Old Etonians in the 1883 final—the first working-class triumph, achieved through disciplined team play rather than individual patronage. These elements underscore a cultural of football as a merit-driven to rigid Victorian class structures, where competition fosters ; Arthur Kinnaird, modeled on the real 11th Lord Kinnaird who played in nine finals between 1877 and 1887, evolves from defending amateur purity to embracing professionalism's logic, reflecting the Football Association's 1885 legalization of paid play after debates over "broken-time" payments for workers. The series' emphasis on such dynamics draws from causal historical shifts, including working-class adoption of codified rules from 1863 onward, which prioritized verifiable outcomes on the pitch over birthright, though it dramatizes tensions like accusations of professionalism as "corruption" by elites. In broader English cultural terms, this reinforces football's role in embedding ideals of fair contest and earned ascent, evident in the sport's expansion to over 1,000 clubs by 1885, where meritocratic selection—via trials and performance—democratized participation beyond gentlemanly pursuits. Critics note the portrayal's optimism about merit transcending class, yet historical records substantiate 's leveling effect: post-1885, northern working-class clubs dominated, winning 12 of the first 20 Football League titles from , driven by talent scouting over social networks. The narrative avoids unsubstantiated by grounding depictions in events like the 1878-79 Darwen-Old Etonians matches, where merit—honed through factory-sponsored training—prevailed in aggregate scores, signaling football's evolution into a performance-based domain. This cultural lens, while dramatized, captures enduring British sporting ethos, where metrics like goals scored and wins accrued validate merit, influencing modern views of talent hierarchies in professional leagues.

Legacy in Media Representations of Sport

The English Game contributed to media representations of sport by foregrounding the historical role of class tensions in the development of , depicting the sport's transition from an amateur, upper-class pastime dominated by public school teams to a professional endeavor driven by working-class mill workers in . The series illustrates how tactical innovations, such as the Scottish "passing game" introduced by figures like , enabled underdog teams like to challenge elite opponents, culminating in events like Blackburn Olympic's 1883 FA Cup victory over the Old Etonians by a score of 2–1 on March 31, 1883. This portrayal counters romanticized views of football's origins as solely an English invention, emphasizing of regional and cross-border influences that prioritized and strategy over brute force. The miniseries' focus on the 1885 Football Association decision to legalize —prompted by mounting evidence of under-the-table payments to players—has informed subsequent depictions in sports media, highlighting sport's evolution through economic incentives and merit-based competition rather than gentlemanly ideals. By dramatizing these shifts, The English Game sparked public discourse on football's , with analyses noting its role in renewing interest among global audiences in how and labor dynamics shaped the sport's mass appeal. Academic commentary has praised its utility in illustrating Victorian-era societal structures, using football as a microcosm for broader themes of industrial mobility and resistance to entrenched hierarchies. In the landscape of sports historiography within media, the series stands out for its causal emphasis on working-class agency, as seen in the portrayal of mill workers adapting the game amid 19th-century Lancashire's textile economy, where teams drew from local factories employing over 100,000 operatives by the 1870s. This approach has influenced representations by providing a template for narratives that integrate verifiable archival details, such as the Darwen club's 1879 tour of the United States, over fictionalized or ideologically driven accounts. However, critiques from sports historians point to omissions, including the minimal acknowledgment of early women's involvement in football variants, which predated the series' timeline but were systematically marginalized in official records. Overall, its legacy lies in promoting depictions grounded in primary historical tensions, fostering a more realist view of sport as a product of competitive incentives and social contestation.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.