Hubbry Logo
The Musical ManThe Musical ManMain
Open search
The Musical Man
Community hub
The Musical Man
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The Musical Man
The Musical Man
The Musical Man
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

"The Musical Man"
Modern Family episode
Cameron (Eric Stonestreet) as interim music director at Luke (Nolan Gould) and Manny's (Rico Rodriguez) school
Episode no.Season 2
Episode 19
Directed byMichael Spiller
Written by
  • Paul Corrigan
  • Brad Walsh
Production code2ARG19
Original air dateApril 13, 2011 (2011-04-13)[1]
Guest appearance
Episode chronology
← Previous
"Boys' Night" 		Next →
"Someone to Watch Over Lily"
Modern Family season 2
List of episodes

"The Musical Man" is the 19th episode of the American comedy television series, Modern Family's second season and the 43rd episode overall. It originally aired on April 13, 2011 on American Broadcasting Company (ABC). The episode was written by Paul Corrigan and Brad Walsh and was directed by Michael Spiller.

In the episode, Cameron takes control of the spring musical at Luke and Manny's school, while Jay's brother pays him a visit, and Phil tries to get the family to be in his new real estate advertisement.

"The Musical Man" received mixed reviews from critics. According to Nielsen Media Research, the episode was viewed by 9.6 million households and received a 3.9 rating/10% share in the 18-49 demographic marking a fourteen percent drop in the ratings from the previous episode, "Boys' Night".

Plot

[edit]

At the Pritchett-Delgados', Jay (Ed O'Neill) is expecting Donnie (Jonathan Banks), his brother, to arrive for a visit. He is preparing a prank involving a picture of his butt. When Donnie arrives the two get into a friendly fight, which foils Jay's plan involving his picture. All day long, Jay continues arranging pranks on his brother over Gloria's (Sofía Vergara) protests. Gloria berates Jay, claiming that Jay and his brother do not really know each other after Jay does not recognize Donnie's granddaughter and does not even know where Donnie lives. Jay tries to get closer to Donnie, but Donnie assumes that his wife Irene had told Jay about Donnie's recent diagnosis with prostate cancer. Donnie accuses Jay of treating him differently because he has cancer, but this news deeply affects Jay, who had not known, and Donnie asks him to keep it a secret.

Phil (Ty Burrell) has had a poster made with a picture of his entire family and has had the family van wrapped in order to advertise his real estate business, saying that his best assets are his family and his teeth, both of which can be seen in an ad that reads "I can't be satisfied until you're satisfied, let me make your dreams come true."

Haley's (Sarah Hyland) SAT scores are posted on the Internet; the scores turn out to be average, granting her possibilities at numerous colleges, but she shocks her parents by telling them that she does not want to go to college, much to Alex's (Ariel Winter) delight. Claire (Julie Bowen) then arranges to have lunch with Haley and use the opportunity to talk her into going to college. As they climb into the newly wrapped van, they fail to notice that the advertisement in its wrapped form shows Claire under the motto "I can't be satisfied", while the side with Haley's photo reads only "Let me make your dreams come true." Claire uses the opportunity to talk very positively about college life, causing her to begin to wonder if her best years are behind her.

Meanwhile, Phil has had many calls asking about the ad, but he makes such general references about what he is advertising that his callers still believe that he is selling sex services. Alex lets him know about the true intention of the callers after receiving an e-mailed photo of the van. At that same moment Claire calls, and Phil realizes that she has not seen the ad yet, so he runs to the school where he will be meeting Claire for Luke (Nolan Gould) and Manny's (Rico Rodriguez) show.

All the while, Cameron (Eric Stonestreet) is loving his role as interim music director at Luke and Manny's school, and he is taking on the upcoming spring musical performance with a little too much zest and fervor. After being pitched with the new songs that Cameron made for the show, Mitchell (Jesse Tyler Ferguson) criticizes that they are too complicated for the kids to learn by that night, which bothers Cameron. Mitchell then promises that he will always be supportive no matter what.

During rehearsals Manny asks Mitchell to deal with Cameron and his overbearing production. Mitchell refuses, but he does tell Manny what to say to Cameron, who at the end does not listen to the kids and imposes his show on them. The closing of the show involves the kids displaying letters that form the phrase "We love the world", and the letter "F" (representing Franklin Middle School) coming down from the sky. When the show starts, the kids are exhausted but continue with it, but things start to go awry when Luke cannot land because the machinery gets stuck, and the props start to fall over.

During the show Donnie starts playing pranks on Jay, which infuriates Gloria in such a manner that she hits Donnie, but Jay asks her not to do so because Donnie has cancer. Donnie walks out the auditorium followed by Jay, who wants to apologize. Donnie tells his brother that the reason he did not tell him is because he did not want to be treated differently because he gets enough of it at home, so they go back to their old rough ways. Meanwhile, Mitchell goes outside of the auditorium to scream all the objections that he has on the show and recomposes himself to go back and support Cameron.

The show still goes on with a number of mishaps, including an accident involving Joan of Arc and a fire extinguisher. As the finale comes up, the kids raise their letters but since Luke is stuck still hovering over the world, the phrase reads "We love the word", which turns worse when the "F" comes down, ending with the phrase "We love the F word." Among a shocked audience, the only one enthusiastically clapping is Mitchell while Jay gives a vague smile and Donnie and Haley are the only ones who laugh.

As everyone leaves, Claire discovers that Phil has disappeared and has been trying to rip the wrapping off with no success, so she finally sees the reason why men have been honking at her all day long. Her anger is somewhat appeased, however, when Phil tells her that out of 30 calls, about 20 to 25 were for the "hot blonde", assuring her that her best years are not over.

Production

[edit]

"The Musical Man" was written by Paul Corrigan and Brad Walsh. This episode marked their seventh script collaboration.[2][3] The episode was directed by Michael Spiller his twelfth directing credit for the series.[1][4] It features the first appearance of Jonathan Banks as Jay's brother, Donnie.[1] The episode was filmed between February 1,[5] and February 2, 2011.[6]

Reception

[edit]

Ratings

[edit]

In its original American broadcast, "The Musical Man" was viewed by an estimated 9.608 million households and received a 3.9 rating/10% share among adults between the ages of 18 and 49.[7][8] This marked a fourteen percent drop in the ratings from the previous episode, "Boys' Night" and made it the lowest rated episode of the second season.[8] Despite this, it became the second highest rated program on Wednesday after American Idol.[8] The episode also became the third highest rated scripted program of the week behind NCIS and The Office.[9]

Reviews

[edit]

The episode received mixed reviews from critics.

TV Squad writer Joel Keller called the episode "one of the best episodes of the season" praising the show's use of character humor writing that "a show can slide into after almost two high-ly-acclaimed seasons." He also praised the ending featuring the kids holding up the sign "We Love The F Word" writing that "it was one of those classic farcical moments where every little element came together to a really funny crescendo."[10] New York's Rachel Maddux wrote that while two storylines were funny one felt "tacked on" commenting that it felt "like a bad fake beard in a school play that you really want to watch but can't because two old dudes are fighting outside the gymnatorium".[11]

Christine Ziemba of Paste wrote that the episode "tried to cram in way too much for its three storylines" and mainly criticized Cameron and Mitchell's plotline writing that "[the plot] was supposed to be the focal point of the episode, but it fell flat". She ultimately rated it a 6.7/10, calling it a "respectable" episode.[12]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Musical Man

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Music Man is an American musical comedy with book, music, and lyrics by , based on a story he co-wrote with Franklin Lacey, that premiered on Broadway on December 19, 1957. Set in 1912 , it follows fast-talking con artist , who arrives in the small town of posing as a boys' band organizer to sell instruments and uniforms before skipping town with the profits, only to unexpectedly fall in love with the skeptical librarian Marian Paroo, leading to his redemption and genuine community impact. The show's score evokes early 20th-century Americana through a blend of marches, barbershop quartets, and romantic ballads, with iconic numbers such as "", "", and "", which highlight themes of optimism, family, and small-town values. The original Broadway production, directed by Morton DaCosta and starring Robert Preston as Hill and Barbara Cook as Paroo, ran for 1,375 performances at the Majestic Theatre, making it one of the longest-running musicals of its era. It earned widespread acclaim for its heartfelt storytelling and Willson's autobiographical influences, drawing from his upbringing and experiences as a . The Music Man won five Tony Awards in 1958, including Best Musical, Best Performance by a Leading Actor in a Musical, and Best Choreography, solidifying its status as a theatrical landmark. A 1962 film adaptation, directed by Morton DaCosta and also starring Preston and Shirley Jones as Marian, was nominated for six Academy Awards, including Best Picture, and grossed over $14 million at the box office. The musical has seen multiple revivals, notably a 2000 Broadway production directed by Susan Stroman nominated for eight Tony Awards, and a 2022 revival featuring Hugh Jackman as Hill and Sutton Foster as Paroo, which ran for 419 performances and received six Tony nominations. Licensed for thousands of community and school productions worldwide, it remains a staple of American musical theater, celebrated by the Smithsonian Institution as one of Broadway's "great glories."

Background and Development

Inspiration and Creation

, born on May 18, 1902, in , drew heavily from his Midwestern upbringing to conceive The Music Man. His childhood was immersed in the town's vibrant musical culture, where he received and lessons from his mother, Rosalie Reiniger Willson, a dedicated music teacher and church pianist who instilled in him a lifelong passion for melody and performance. Willson's early exposure to the Mason City Municipal Band, which inspired him to take up the as a teenager, shaped his vision of small-town America as a place of communal harmony and youthful ambition. The idea for the musical germinated in 1949 during a conversation with friends, where Willson reminisced about his youth, prompting him to envision a tribute to his home state, initially titled The Silver Triangle. He initially pitched it to in the late 1940s as a , but it was rejected; by 1951, producers Cy Feuer and Ernie Martin encouraged him to develop it as a Broadway show. Despite multiple rejections from producers over the next several years due to its unconventional structure, Willson persisted, collaborating with Franklin Lacey in 1953 to co-write the story and refine the narrative. This timeline of development, spanning from the late 1940s through the mid-1950s, reflected Willson's determination to capture the essence of life. Autobiographical threads run deeply through the musical, with the fictional serving as a thinly veiled portrait of Mason City and its residents. The protagonist, , emerges as a composite of various con artists and charismatic figures Willson encountered during his youth, blending elements of traveling salesmen and opportunists who passed through town to create a roguish yet redeemable . Willson himself, who began leading bands as a young musician, infused Hill's character with echoes of his own early experiences promoting in tight-knit communities, transforming personal anecdotes into a celebration of Midwestern resilience and transformation. Willson's creative process was marked by significant hurdles, as he composed the music before fully developing the book, resulting in nearly 40 songs that he struggled to integrate into a cohesive structure. This backward approach led to years of revisions, including a three-year stall over the opening scene's , and repeated producer doubts about the show's length and pacing. By 1957, during out-of-town tryouts, Willson and his team slashed the runtime from three hours and cut dozens of numbers—reducing from around 40 to 18—to streamline the narrative, finally readying it for its triumphant Broadway premiere.

Composition and Book

Meredith Willson composed the music and lyrics for over a period of eight years, drawing on his background as a flutist, conductor, and arranger to create a score that evokes early 20th-century American small-town life. The musical style integrates lively marches reminiscent of , harmonious barbershop quartets, ragtime-infused patter, and romantic waltzes, resulting in 17 original songs supplemented by reprises that advance the narrative and highlight ensemble dynamics. This eclectic blend reflects Willson's intent to capture the rhythmic pulse of Midwestern Americana, with marches driving communal energy and barbershop harmonies underscoring fraternal bonds. Willson wrote nearly forty songs during the development process, discarding twenty-two unused pieces through multiple revisions to refine the score's emotional and structural coherence. One key number, the "," originated in 1950 as a gentle evoking longing, evolving into a pivotal romantic duet that contrasts the show's boisterous energy. These compositional choices stemmed briefly from Willson's upbringing, where childhood memories of local bands and quartets informed the authentic, nostalgic tone. The book, co-authored by Willson and Franklin Lacey, structures the around witty, fast-paced dialogue that seamlessly transitions into songs, emphasizing rapid patter sequences and large-scale ensemble numbers to propel the plot and reveal character motivations. This approach prioritizes rhythmic speech patterns akin to salesmanship, integrating spoken lines with musical motifs to heighten comedic tension and communal spirit. Pre-Broadway tryouts in prompted significant revisions, including the modification or elimination of several songs to streamline pacing and focus the storytelling, culminating in a final runtime of approximately 2.5 hours. These adjustments ensured the integration of music and book, balancing high-energy ensembles with intimate moments for a cohesive theatrical experience.

Synopsis

Act I

The first act of The Music Man opens on a train in 1912, where a group of traveling salesmen rhythmically complain about competition from modern conveniences and specifically warn of the notorious Harold , who poses as a boys' band organizer to sell instruments and uniforms before skipping town. As the train approaches , , Hill (played as a charismatic fast-talker) steps off, revealing his latest scheme to exploit the town's naivety by forming a nonexistent that requires no musical training, only his patented "think system." In , a conservative Midwestern town resistant to outsiders, Hill reunites with his old partner-turned-local Marcellus Washburn, who informs him of the arrival of a new pool table at the local —a perfect catalyst for stirring . Hill quickly adapts, interrupting a to declare the pool table a gateway to , launching into the rousing number "," where he rhetorically escalates the threat to the community's youth and positions himself as the savior through . His persuasive oratory sways the skeptical residents, including the pompous Mayor and his officious wife Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn, who leads a cadre of gossipy school board members that soon form a under Hill's influence. Meanwhile, the act introduces Marian Paroo, the prim and intelligent town librarian and piano teacher, who embodies intellectual skepticism toward Hill's glib promises; during a lesson with her young student , Marian dismisses the band idea as fraudulent. In conversation with her mother, she reveals her romantic frustrations, later expressed in "Goodnight, My Someone." Hill targets Marian's reclusive younger brother Winthrop, a lisping boy mocked for his shyness, promising him a that will boost his confidence and indirectly winning Marian's cautious approval by drawing Winthrop out of his shell. As Hill's con gains momentum, the school board quartet—constable , real estate agent , feed store owner Jacey Squires, and Ewart Dunlop—serenades the town with barbershop harmonies, amplifying the festive atmosphere and Hill's credibility despite Marian's lingering suspicions. Tension builds in the library, where Hill corners Marian during closing time, flirting outrageously in "Marian the Librarian" and nearly kissing her, only for her to rebuff him while grappling with an unexpected attraction. The act's rising action culminates in widespread enthusiasm for the band, with families eagerly placing orders for instruments and uniforms from Hill's supplier, marked by the arrival of rival salesman Charlie Cowell, who attempts to expose Hill as a but is thwarted by timely interruptions. The town celebrates the delivery in the exuberant ensemble number "Wells Fargo Wagon," as Winthrop receives his and the community imagines parades ahead, though Marian's lingering suspicions foreshadow potential unraveling of the scheme.

Act II

Act II begins with the residents of , now equipped with instruments and uniforms, deeply invested in Harold Hill's scheme, as the town unites in rehearsals and preparations for , highlighting the positive changes Hill has inspired despite his fraudulent intentions. As doubts mount, Marian Paroo confronts Hill in the library, revealing her awareness of his lack of musical expertise; however, she softens toward him upon recognizing the genuine good he has brought to her brother Winthrop and the town, marking a pivotal deepening of their romance. Tensions escalate when rival salesman Charlie Cowell arrives and exposes Hill as a con artist to the mayor and others, prompting Hill to plan his escape from River City. Despite his intentions to flee, Hill hesitates upon seeing Winthrop's newfound confidence and happiness with the band, choosing instead to stay and face the consequences, which underscores his evolving attachment to the community and Marian. The town gathers for the concert, where the boys' band performs disastrously due to their inexperience, yet their earnest effort and enthusiasm win over the audience, preventing Hill's arrest and allowing the ruse to unravel into redemption through collective goodwill. In the resolution, Hill is redeemed not by skill but by the emotional impact he has had, as Marian publicly defends him out of love, leading to his decision to remain in . The community unites in celebration, reprising themes of romance and unity, with Hill and Marian embracing a future together amid the town's transformed spirit.

Productions

Original Broadway Production

The original Broadway production of The Music Man was directed by Morton DaCosta and choreographed by , with Robert Preston starring as and Barbara Cook as Marian Paroo. The musical, featuring book, music, and lyrics by , underwent out-of-town tryouts in New Haven and to refine its staging and pacing; during the Philadelphia engagement at the Shubert Theatre from November 18 to December 14, 1957, several songs were modified or cut to streamline the show. Following these adjustments, the production previewed on December 17, 1957, and officially opened on December 19, 1957, at the Majestic Theatre in . It enjoyed a successful run of 1,375 performances, transferring to the on October 24, 1960, before closing on April 15, 1961, and grossed over $8 million during its tenure. The show's acclaim was further elevated by its Tony Award wins in 1958, including Best Musical, in a Musical for Preston, Best Featured Actress in a Musical for Cook, and Best Featured Actor in a Musical for David Burns, which helped solidify its status as a Broadway hit. After closing, the production embarked on a national tour across the that continued into 1962.

Revivals and International Productions

The first Broadway revival of The Music Man opened on June 5, 1980, at the City Center, directed and choreographed by , and starred as and Meg Bussert as Marian Paroo. This limited engagement, which followed a seven-month national tour, ran for 21 performances before closing on June 22, 1980. A more successful revival, directed and choreographed by , opened on April 27, 2000, at the , with as and as Marian Paroo. The production ran for 699 performances, closing on December 30, 2001. The most recent Broadway revival, directed by and choreographed by Warren Carlyle, began previews on December 20, 2021, at the and officially opened on February 10, 2022, starring as and as Marian Paroo. It ran for 373 performances, closing on January 15, 2023. Following the original 1957 production, launched its first national tour on August 18, 1958, starring as and Joan Weldon as Marian Paroo, which continued until March 17, 1962. Additional U.S. tours occurred in the early 1960s as an extension of the original run and in the 1980s, tied to the Dick Van Dyke revival, which toured for seven months prior to its New York engagement. In April 2025, Big League Productions announced a new national tour, directed by Matt Lenz, set to launch in January 2026 and visit over 100 cities. Internationally, the musical premiered in on March 5, 1960, at the Princess Theatre in , starring Ted Scott as Harold Hill and Carolyn Maye as Marian Paroo, running until July 30, 1960, before transferring to Sydney's Tivoli Theatre from December 13, 1960, to March 25, 1961. The UK West End production opened on March 16, 1961, at the , starring as Harold Hill and Patricia Lambert as Marian Paroo, and ran for 395 performances until February 24, 1962. The Broadway revival incorporated modern updates, including inclusive casting with a diverse ensemble featuring actors of color in principal and ensemble roles, such as Rema Webb as Mrs. Squires and Kelechi Ezie as Oliver Hix. The production faced significant delays due to the , originally scheduled for previews in September 2020 but postponed multiple times, with further interruptions including a 10-day shutdown during previews in December 2021 after cast members, including Jackman, tested positive.

Cast and Characters

Principal Roles

Harold Hill is the central protagonist of The Music Man, portrayed as a charismatic and self-proclaimed band leader who arrives in , , with a scheme to sell musical instruments and uniforms to unsuspecting residents. His smooth-talking demeanor and persuasive charm enable him to manipulate the town's fears and aspirations, positioning him as a figure who catalyzes community transformation while evolving from a fraudulent opportunist to a genuine hero through unexpected personal growth. Marian Paroo, the librarian and piano teacher, serves as the story's intellectual and moral anchor, initially skeptical of Harold's intentions and dedicated to protecting her community from deception. Representing themes of intellect and budding romance, she challenges the con man's facade, ultimately becoming his romantic counterpart and facilitating his redemption arc as a symbol of principled resistance turned to belief. Marcellus Washburn functions as Harold's loyal old friend and comic ally, a former partner in schemes now settled in as a billiards parlor employee. His humorous, supportive nature provides relief amid the escalating tensions, embodying the of a reformed who aids the while highlighting the allure and pitfalls of their shared past. Mayor George Shinn, alongside the ensemble of town leaders, satirizes small-town authority through his blustery and pompous demeanor, often leading the charge against perceived threats like Harold's arrival. As a collective representation of community foibles, these figures underscore the musical's critique of provincial narrow-mindedness, serving as obstacles that expose the town's vulnerabilities and hypocrisies. Among the supporting characters, Winthrop Paroo, Marian's shy younger brother, embodies innocence and vulnerability, his lisp and withdrawal transforming under the influence of Harold's promises to symbolize the redemptive power of music and confidence-building. Mrs. Paroo, the warm Irish widow and mother to Marian and Winthrop, acts as the familial nurturer, gently encouraging her daughter's emotional openness while anchoring the household in traditional values. The —comprising gossipy school board members Olin Britt, Oliver Hix, Ewart Dunlop, and Jacey Squires—delivers musical commentary through harmonious barbershop-style numbers, functioning as the collective voice of the community and providing both comic skepticism and unifying spirit.

Original and Notable Casts

The original Broadway production of The Music Man, which opened on December 19, 1957, at the Majestic Theatre, starred Robert Preston as the con artist Harold Hill, Barbara Cook as the librarian Marian Paroo, David Burns as the pompous Mayor Shinn, and Iggie Wolfington as Hill's old friend Marcellus Washburn. Other principal cast members included Pert Kelton as Mrs. Paroo, Eddie Hodges as Winthrop Paroo, Danny Carroll as Tommy Djilas, and Helen Raymond as Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn. Preston, Burns, and Cook all received Tony Award recognition for the 1958 ceremony: Preston won Best Actor in a Musical, while Burns and Cook won Best Featured Actor in a Musical and Best Featured Actress in a Musical, respectively.
RoleActor/Actress
Harold HillRobert Preston
Marian ParooBarbara Cook
Mayor ShinnDavid Burns
Marcellus WashburnIggie Wolfington
Mrs. ParooPert Kelton
Winthrop ParooEddie Hodges
Tommy DjilasDanny Carroll
Eulalie Mackecknie ShinnHelen Raymond
Notable replacements during the original run included Eddie Albert, who succeeded Preston as Harold Hill in January 1959 and performed the role for 18 months, followed briefly by Bert Parks. In the 1962 film adaptation directed by Morton DaCosta, Robert Preston reprised his role as , joined by as Marian Paroo, as Marcellus Washburn, and as Mayor Shinn. The 1980 Broadway revival at the City Center, directed by Michael Montel, featured in his Broadway musical debut as and Meg Bussert as Marian Paroo, with Iggie Wolfington as Mayor Shinn and as Mrs. Paroo. This production later transferred to the Majestic Theatre. The 2000 Broadway revival, directed and choreographed by Susan Stroman at the Neil Simon Theatre, starred Craig Bierko in his Broadway debut as Harold Hill and Rebecca Luker as Marian Paroo, alongside Max Casella as Marcellus Washburn and Paul Benedict as Mayor Shinn. Bierko earned a 2001 Tony nomination for Best Actor in a Musical. Subsequent replacements for Hill included Robert Sean Leonard and Eric McCormack. The 2022 Broadway revival at the Winter Garden Theatre, directed by Jerry Zaks, starred Hugh Jackman as Harold Hill, Sutton Foster as Marian Paroo, Shuler Hensley as Marcellus Washburn, and Jefferson Mays as Mayor Shinn. Jackman and Foster both received 2022 Tony nominations for Best Actor and Best Actress in a Musical, respectively. A notable replacement was Megan Hilty, who took over as Marian Paroo later in the run, though the production closed on January 15, 2023, without additional Tony wins for its cast. Internationally, the 1961 West End production at the starred as and Patricia Lambert as Marian Paroo, with Bernard Spear as Mayor Shinn. Early productions of , including the original Broadway run and the 1962 film, featured predominantly white casts, reflecting the limited diversity in mid-20th-century American theater and ; principal roles lacked performers from underrepresented racial or ethnic groups until later revivals introduced more varied ensembles in supporting parts.

Musical Numbers

Act I Songs

The Act I songs of The Music Man propel the narrative from the introduction of con artist and the insular town of to the sparking of romance and community excitement, blending songs, marches, and ballads in Meredith Willson's idiomatic American musical style that draws on , , and folk traditions. The opening number, "Rock Island," features in a rhythmic that imitates a train's chugging motion through overlapping and strict four-beat , establishing the era's commercial hustle and foreshadowing Hill's instrument-selling scam as they cross into . "Iowa Stubborn," performed by the River City townspeople, is a jaunty folk tune characterized by repetitive melodic motifs and chip-on-the-shoulder , portraying the community's defensive pride and reluctance to embrace outsiders, which Hill must overcome to execute his plan. Hill's persuasive in "(Ya Got) Trouble" unfolds as a high-energy with accelerating tempo and descending melodic phrases, convincing the townsfolk that a new pool hall threatens their youth's morals, thereby creating demand for his nonexistent boys' band. A quieter interlude comes with "Piano Lesson," a conversational duet between librarian Marian Paroo and her mother Mrs. Paroo that segues into Marian's lyrical waltz "Goodnight, My Someone," offering tender contrast through its simple piano accompaniment and wistful melody, revealing Marian's hidden romantic dreams during a mundane lesson with her student Amaryllis. "Seventy-Six Trombones" erupts as Hill's boastful ensemble march in cut time, with call-and-response choral elements and vivid imagery of a grand parade, igniting the townspeople's enthusiasm for the band while showcasing the score's brass-heavy orchestration to symbolize musical transformation. "Sincere," a harmonious number performed by the school board members (Olin Britt, Oliver Hix, Ewart Dunlop, and Jacey Squires), expresses their vocal aspirations and introduces their role in the community dynamics. In the jaunty "The Sadder But Wiser Girl for Me," Hill shares a cynical with sidekick Marcellus Washburn in uptempo comedic style, expressing his aversion to innocent women like Marian in favor of worldly ones, highlighting his roguish philosophy amid the con's progression. "Pick-a-Little, Talk-a-Little," a gossipy led by Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn and the ladies of , warns Hill about Marian's supposed scandalous reputation through rapid-fire chatter and clucking sounds, advancing the plot's social tensions. This is followed by "Goodnight, Ladies," a brief barbershop harmony farewell by the quartet as they depart, providing a light comedic transition. The act builds with "Marian the Librarian," a flirtatious ragtime number with syncopated rhythms and dance breaks, where Hill boldly courts the resistant Marian in the , blending humor and attraction to deepen their dynamic and emphasize the score's playful brass accents. The act closes with "My White Knight," Marian's poignant reflecting her longing for an ideal, honorable suitor, contrasting her growing suspicions about Hill and heightening the romantic tension leading to .

Act II Songs

Act II of The Music Man features a sequence of songs that propel the narrative toward romantic resolution and communal celebration, contrasting the scheming introductions of Act I with more intimate reflections and triumphant ensembles. The musical numbers incorporate tempo shifts—from upbeat dances to lyrical solos and harmonious reprises—to trace the emotional arc from doubt to unity, as Harold Hill's con unravels into genuine connection with Marian Paroo and the River City residents. The act opens at the high school gymnasium with "It's You," a lighthearted number sung by the school board members (Olin Britt, Oliver Hix, Ewart Dunlop, and Jacey Squires) alongside Eulalie Mackecknie Shinn and her Ladies' Greek Tableau dancers, serving as a comic interlude that pokes fun at small-town through close-harmony serenading. This is followed by the lively "," led by Marcellus Washburn with Harold, Marian, Tommy Djilas, Zaneeta Shinn, and the ensemble, which injects ensemble fun through a spirited dance routine that thaws social tensions at the . A brief "Pick-a-Little" by Eulalie and the gossip ladies underscores the ongoing town chatter, transitioning to the porch scene where the performs "Lida Rose," a harmonious to idealized romance that parallels Marian's solo "Will I Ever Tell You." In this lyrical reflection, Marian delivers an internal monologue contemplating her unspoken feelings for Harold, heightening the act's emotional depth through with the quartet's upbeat . Winthrop Paroo then sings "," a charming solo expressing his newfound confidence after receiving his during the arrival of the instruments. A reprise of "It's You" by the townspeople, including boys and girls, builds communal spirit before the pivotal "Till There Was You," a romantic waltz ballad duet between Marian and Harold on the footbridge, where they confess their love and resolve personal conflicts in a moment of tender vulnerability. The ensemble then erupts in "The Wells Fargo Wagon," an exuberant march celebrating the delivery of the band's instruments by the arriving wagon, with the townspeople, led by Winthrop, expressing joy and anticipation for the musical transformation. The act culminates in reprises of "Seventy-Six Trombones" and "Goodnight, My Someone," blending Harold and Marian's voices in a march that unifies the ensemble, leading into the "Till There Was You" reprise by Harold and a grand finale with the entire company, celebrating the town's transformed harmony and the band's inaugural performance.

Recordings and Adaptations

Cast Recordings

The original Broadway cast recording of The Music Man, released in 1958 by Capitol Records, features Robert Preston as Harold Hill and Barbara Cook as Marian Paroo. Recorded shortly after the show's premiere, it captures the full score and dialogue highlights from the production. The album topped the Billboard Best Selling Pop Albums chart for 12 weeks and remained on the chart for a total of 245 weeks, establishing it as one of the longest-charting cast albums of its era. It received the first Grammy Award for Best Musical Theater Album in 1959 and was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1998 for its historical and artistic significance. Certified platinum by the RIAA, the recording has sold over one million copies in the United States. The 1961 Original London Cast recording, starring Van Johnson as Harold Hill and Patricia Lambert as Marian Paroo, was released by HMV (EMI) following the West End production at the Adelphi Theatre. Produced in stereo, it includes the complete score with British performers and has been reissued on CD by Sepia Records, preserving its lively orchestral arrangements. Revival cast recordings include the 2000 New Broadway Cast album, featuring Craig Bierko as Harold Hill and Rebecca Luker as Marian Paroo, released by Decca Broadway. Capturing the Tony-nominated revival directed by Susan Stroman, it emphasizes the ensemble's barbershop quartet energy. The 1980 City Center revival with Dick Van Dyke received no full commercial recording, though private stage monitors exist. The 2022 Broadway revival cast recording, led by Hugh Jackman as Harold Hill and Sutton Foster as Marian Paroo, was released digitally on September 23, 2022, by MM Recordings (under Accidental Jacket Entertainment), with physical editions following on December 9. Produced by the revival's original cast at Manhattan Center Studios, it highlights the updated choreography's brass band flair.

Film and Television Versions

The 1962 film adaptation of The Music Man, produced by Warner Bros. and directed by Morton DaCosta, who also helmed the original Broadway production, starred Robert Preston reprising his role as Professor Harold Hill and Shirley Jones as Marian Paroo. Released in Technicolor, the film featured elaborate dance sequences choreographed by Onna White, enhancing the visual spectacle of numbers like "Seventy-Six Trombones" with vibrant, large-scale production values suited to the screen. While largely faithful to the stage version, the adaptation replaced the song "My White Knight" with a new number, "Being in Love," performed by Jones, to better fit the cinematic flow. The film grossed approximately $15 million at the box office, making it one of the top-grossing releases of 1962. Warner Bros. Records released a soundtrack album featuring the film's score, including the new song "Being in Love," in both stereo and mono formats. At the , won the Oscar for Best Music Scoring of a Musical Picture (adaptation and treatment) for Ray Heindorf's work, and received nominations for Best Picture, Best Art Direction (Color), Best Costume Design (Color), Best Film Editing, and Best Sound. Critics praised the film's energetic performances, particularly Preston's charismatic lead, and its preservation of Meredith Willson's score, though some noted it captured the stage's charm faithfully but lacked the intimate "magic" of live theater in translating to the screen. In , ABC aired a made-for-television adaptation directed by Jeff Bleckner, starring as and as Marian Paroo, with supporting roles filled by as Mayor Shinn and as Mrs. Shinn. This version retained the full score from the original musical without alterations, emphasizing the songs' integrity while updating the sets and costumes for a slightly more contemporary aesthetic within the 1912 setting. Produced by and , the telefilm aired as part of The Wonderful World of Disney and included modern production elements like enhanced lighting and camera work to suit the small screen. released an original TV featuring the full score performed by the cast. Reviews highlighted Broderick's and Chenoweth's strong vocal performances and chemistry, though some critiqued the timing of its broadcast amid contemporary events as tonally mismatched, and noted it as a solid but less innovative take compared to the 1962 film. No major film or television adaptations of The Music Man have been produced since 2003.

Reception and Legacy

Critical Reception

Upon its Broadway premiere on December 19, 1957, received widespread acclaim for its exuberant score and nostalgic evocation of small-town Americana. of described the musical as "a warm and genial of " with that was "as as and a Fourth of July oration," praising its joyous energy and Meredith Willson's tuneful compositions. Other critics echoed this enthusiasm, highlighting the show's infectious charm and Robert Preston's charismatic performance as con artist , though some, like in the Herald Tribune, noted the plot's reliance on contrivances to sustain its whimsical narrative. The 1962 film adaptation, directed by Morton DaCosta and starring Preston reprising his role alongside Shirley Jones, garnered mixed reviews despite its faithful rendering of the stage production. Critics lauded Preston's dynamic portrayal, with Bosley Crowther of The New York Times calling it a "spirited and engaging" performance that captured the essence of the Broadway original. However, the film's extended runtime of 151 minutes drew criticism for pacing issues and unnecessary elaborations, as noted by Variety, which described it as occasionally "overlong" while still appreciating its visual spectacle and musical numbers. Revivals have sustained the musical's popularity while prompting evolving critiques. The 2000 Broadway production, directed and choreographed by , was celebrated for its fresh energy and meticulous staging, with of commending its "downright magic" and vibrant ensemble that renewed the show's timeless appeal. In contrast, the 2022 revival starring and received mixed responses; while Foster's spirited turn as Marian Paroo was widely praised for its comic timing and vocal prowess, Jesse Green of critiqued director Jerry Zaks's overly cautious approach, which resulted in pacing that felt flat and lacked the original's frenetic con-man urgency. Overall, holds a strong critical legacy. Its celebration of Americana and community through memorable songs like "" remains a hallmark, though modern analyses highlight dated gender roles, such as Marian's arc reinforcing traditional expectations of female redemption through romance. Post-2022 discussions have also addressed representation gaps, including a 2021 New York Times examination of the original script's excised disabled character—a boy in a wheelchair—revealing lost opportunities for inclusivity amid the 2022 revival's rehearsals. Audience reception remains robust, with Playbill polls and Show-Score data indicating approval ratings above 85% for recent productions, underscoring the musical's enduring crowd-pleasing quality.

Awards and Cultural Impact

The original Broadway production of The Music Man won six in 1958, including Best Musical, Best Performance by a in a Musical (Robert Preston), Best Performance by a Featured Actress in a Musical (), Best Performance by a Featured Actor in a Musical (David Burns), Best Choreography (), and Best Conductor and Musical Director (Herbert Greene). Its original cast album received the first Grammy Award for Best Original Cast Album at the inaugural ceremony in 1959. Revivals have also garnered significant recognition. The 2000 Broadway revival earned two Tony Awards: Best Choreography (Susan Stroman) and Best Performance by a Featured Actor in a Musical (Michael McKean). It additionally won Outer Critics Circle Awards for Outstanding Revival of a Musical, Outstanding Director of a Musical (Stroman), and Outstanding Choreography (Stroman), along with a Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Set Design (Thomas Lynch). The 2022 Broadway revival received one Tony Award for Best Orchestrations (Jonathan Tunick) and an Outer Critics Circle Award nomination for Outstanding Costume Design (Play or Musical). The 1980 Broadway revival won a Drama Desk Award for Outstanding Revival of a Musical. The 1962 film adaptation received six Academy Award nominations, including Best Picture, Best Art Direction-Set Decoration (Color), Best Cinematography (Color), Best Costume Design (Color), Best Film Editing, and Best Sound; it won for Best Music Scoring of a Musical Picture (Ray Heindorf). The film also won the Golden Globe for Best Motion Picture - Musical or Comedy. The Music Man has had a lasting cultural footprint, particularly in promoting and community bands. The musical's narrative of a con artist transforming a town through a boys' band has influenced programs by highlighting the value of ensemble music-making and instrumental access for youth. The Music Man Foundation, established in his honor, funds initiatives in , health, and community programs to foster similar impacts. Its enduring popularity in amateur theater is evident in its frequent staging by high schools and community groups, with Music Theatre International licensing thousands of productions annually worldwide. The show has permeated pop culture through parodies and references. It inspired the The Simpsons episode "" (1993), where con artist Lyle Lanley echoes Harold Hill's salesmanship in a scheme parodying the musical's themes. The signature song "" appears in various media, including a reference in the Buffy the Vampire Slayer musical episode "" (2001), and has been adapted into arrangements and commercial advertisements evoking parades and brass ensembles. As of November 2025, no major new awards have been announced for recent productions, though regional stagings continue, such as at Lyric Arts in , and a national tour is scheduled to begin in 2026.

References

  1. https://www.mtishows.com/the-music-man
  2. https://www.broadway.com/shows/music-man/
  3. https://www.broadway.com/shows/music-man/story/
  4. https://www.tonyawards.com/winners/year/1958/
  5. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0056262/
  6. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/the-music-man-12495
  7. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/the-music-man-526102
  8. https://www.iowapbs.org/iowapathways/mypath/2568/meredith-willson
  9. https://www.commentary.org/articles/terry-teachout/the-man-behind-the-music-man/
  10. https://ouriowaheritage.com/our-iowa-heritage-the-iowa-music-man-meredith-willson/
  11. https://www.investors.com/news/management/leaders-and-success/willson-wrote-broadway-musical-the-music-man/
  12. http://www.portwashington.com/moveweb/Guidewrite/willson.html
  13. https://www.goodmantheatre.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/MusicMan_LargePrintProgram.pdf
  14. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/history/willsons-music-man-presents-musical-americana
  15. https://www.windrep.org/Meredith_Willson
  16. https://academic.oup.com/book/39334/chapter/338964295
  17. https://stageagent.com/shows/musical/839/the-music-man
  18. https://www.bard.org/study-guides/synopsis-the-music-man/
  19. https://www.nsmt.org/the-music-man-synopsis.html
  20. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/the-music-man-2664
  21. https://www.broadwayworld.com/shows/creative.php?showid=6128
  22. https://catdir.loc.gov/catdir/enhancements/fy0641/2004045440-s.html
  23. https://playbill.com/production/the-music-man-majestic-theatre-vault-0000007849
  24. https://www.ibdb.com/tour-production/the-music-man-528013
  25. https://www.ibdb.com/broadway-production/the-music-man-13314
  26. https://ovrtur.com/production/2883347
  27. https://playbill.com/article/the-music-man-will-launch-100-city-national-tour-in-2026
  28. https://meredithwillson.com/mw_musical/the-music-man
  29. https://ovrtur.com/production/2883342
  30. https://nypost.com/2020/10/09/hugh-jackmans-covid-delayed-the-music-man-sets-new-2022-opening-night/
  31. https://variety.com/2022/legit/news/music-man-hugh-jackman-broadway-1235425152/
  32. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/02/theater/music-man-broadway-hugh-jackman.html
  33. https://www.bard.org/study-guides/characters-the-music-man/
  34. https://castalbums.org/recordings/Music-Man-The-1957-Original-Broadway-Cast/2895/
  35. https://www.tonyawards.com/nominees/year/1958/category/any/show/any/
  36. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0056262/fullcredits/
  37. https://playbill.com/production/the-music-man-neil-simon-theatre-vault-0000000847
  38. https://www.tonyawards.com/nominees/year/2001/category/any/show/any/
  39. https://playbill.com/production/the-music-manwinter-garden-theatre-2021-2022
  40. https://www.tonyawards.com/shows/music-man/
  41. https://www.broadwayworld.com/shows/The-Music-Man-333081/cast
  42. https://castalbums.org/recordings/The-Music-Man-1961-Original-London-Cast/1973
  43. https://www.musicalwriters.com/studying-broadway-musicals/the-music-man/
  44. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/rockisland.htm
  45. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/iowastubborn.htm
  46. https://www.musicalsmagazine.com/features/article/behind-the-song-meredith-willson-s-ya-got-trouble-from-the-music-man
  47. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/pianolesson.htm
  48. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/seventysixtrombones.htm
  49. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/sincere.htm
  50. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/thesadderbutwisergirlforme.htm
  51. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/pickalittle.htm
  52. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/goodnightladies.htm
  53. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/marianthelibrarian.htm
  54. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/mywhiteknight.htm
  55. https://ovrtur.com/production/2881267
  56. https://www.allmusicals.com/m/musicmanthe.htm
  57. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/itsyou.htm
  58. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/shipoopi.htm
  59. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/lidarose.htm
  60. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/williever.htm
  61. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/garyindiana.htm
  62. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/tilltherewasyou.htm
  63. https://www.allmusicals.com/lyrics/musicmanthe/thewellsfargowagon.htm
  64. https://www.discogs.com/release/4765706-Meredith-Willson-The-Music-Man-Original-Broadway-Cast
  65. https://www.grammy.com/awards/hall-of-fame-award#t
  66. https://playbill.com/article/the-definitive-list-of-the-43-best-selling-cast-recordings-of-all-time
  67. https://www.allmusic.com/album/the-music-man-original-london-cast--mw0000238955
  68. https://www.sepiarecords.com/sepia1173.html
  69. https://www.amazon.com/Meredith-Willsons-Music-Broadway-Revival/dp/B00004TJ9M
  70. https://ovrtur.com/recording/178947626
  71. https://www.broadway.com/buzz/202492/the-music-man-starring-hugh-jackman-sutton-foster-to-release-cast-recording/
  72. https://www.playbill.com/article/hugh-jackman-sutton-foster-led-the-music-man-revival-records-broadway-cast-album
  73. https://www.nytimes.com/1962/08/24/archives/screen-preston-stars-in-music-manfilm-version-of-stage-comedy-opens.html
  74. http://mercurie.blogspot.com/2010/05/music-man-movie-not-play.html
  75. https://www.worldwideboxoffice.com/movie.cgi?title=The%2520Music%2520Man&year=1962
  76. https://www.discogs.com/release/1834439-Meredith-Willson-The-Music-Man-Original-Soundtrack
  77. https://www.oscars.org/oscars/ceremonies/1963
  78. https://variety.com/1961/film/reviews/the-music-man-3-1200420065/
  79. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0293437/
  80. https://variety.com/2003/tv/reviews/the-music-man-6-1200543446/
  81. https://www.nytimes.com/2003/02/14/movies/tv-weekend-bad-timing-right-here-in-river-city.html
  82. https://www.allmusic.com/album/the-music-man-original-tv-soundtrack--mw0000593126
  83. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/02/10/theater/the-music-man-review.html
  84. https://www.startribune.com/chanhassen-s-music-man-captivates-while-toning-down-archaic-gender-politics/568613272
  85. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/12/15/theater/music-man-disability-meredith-willson.html
  86. https://www.show-score.com/broadway-shows/the-music-man-broadway
  87. https://www.broadwayworld.com/tonyawardsshowinfo.php?showname=The%20Music%20Man
  88. https://www.grammy.com/awards/1st-annual-grammy-awards
  89. https://www.susanstroman.com/productions/the-music-man
  90. https://www.broadwayworld.com/shows/The-Music-Man-6131.html
  91. https://www.oscars.org/oscars/ceremonies/1962
  92. https://www.filmaffinity.com/en/movie-awards.php?movie-id=987341
  93. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/music/music-man-film
  94. https://www.musicmanfoundation.org/
  95. https://www.slashfilm.com/1182360/conan-obriens-love-of-the-music-man-helped-him-write-the-simpsons-marge-vs-the-monorail/
  96. https://www.wikiwand.com/en/articles/Seventy-six_Trombones
  97. https://www.lyricarts.org/music-man
  98. https://themusicmantour.com/tour-dates/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.