Hubbry Logo
Voice – Social DemocracyVoice – Social DemocracyMain
Open search
Voice – Social Democracy
Community hub
Voice – Social Democracy
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Voice – Social Democracy
Voice – Social Democracy
Voice – Social Democracy
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Voice – Social Democracy (Slovak: Hlas – sociálna demokracia, Hlas-SD) is a social democratic and populist political party in Slovakia.[13] It was founded in 2020 by dissidents from Direction – Social Democracy (Smer-SD)[14] led by former prime minister Peter Pellegrini. In October 2022, it was admitted as an associate member of the Party of European Socialists (PES),[15] although its membership was later suspended in October 2023.[16]

Key Information

Several members of the party's presidium, including its founder Peter Pellegrini, are associated with bribery and abuse of power in the testimonies of cooperating defendants. In December 2020, the National Crime Agency charged Peter Žiga, a member of the party's presidium, with bribery.

History

[edit]

Party leader Peter Pellegrini joined Direction – Social Democracy (Smer–SD) in 2000. After being elected to the National Council in the 2006 parliamentary election, Pellegrini served in several positions as state secretary, minister and speaker of the National Council. He was elected vice-chairman of Smer–SD in 2014. Pellegrini succeeded Robert Fico as prime minister after the 2018 government crisis triggered by the murder of investigative journalist Ján Kuciak. Fico remained the party chairman.

Pellegrini led Smer–SD electoral list in the 2020 Slovak parliamentary election, while still serving as party vice-chairman. After winning 170,000 more personal votes than Fico, Pellegrini called for a party convention and expressed his intention to run for party chairman.

The political party was announced on 29 June 2020[17] and registered by the Ministry of the Interior on 11 September 2020.[18] The party was launched by the former prime minister Peter Pellegrini. On the day of the launch of the new party, Pellegrini left Smer–SD, along with ten more of the party's members of the National Council. It had to obtain 10,000 signatures by 25 December 2020 to be registered as a party. Pellegrini, Matúš Šutaj Eštok, and Peter Kmec formed the party's preparatory committee, and Pellegrini became the party's chairman.[19] Until the end of the term, the 11 deputies were classified as non-inscrits within the National Council.[20]

Immediately after the party was formed, its support was about 16%. In October 2020, the party became the most popular for the first time, and remained ahead in most opinion polls until January 2023. After Pellegrini visited Olaf Scholz in March 2023, some commentators perceived a shift in the preferred Slovak party of the Party of European Socialists (PES) from Smer–SD to Hlas–SD, due to more radical rhetoric from the former party.[21] Both parties were suspended from PES in October 2023 after forming a coalition with the far-right Slovak National Party.[22]

Ideology

[edit]

Hlas–SD states that it has a pro-European outlook and promotes traditional social-democratic goals within the welfare state.[23] Reflecting a more conservative stance, especially on social issues, the party refuses to promote liberalism on social issues, which it argues are not in demand. Party vice-chairman Erik Tomáš was quoted as saying: "We have a conservative voter if we talk about polls, and I can assure everyone that we have our priorities, and they are not opening up some liberal issues."[citation needed]

In July 2024, Erik Tomáš also said that the party will support intentions of Smer–SD to fight against liberalism and progressive ideologies.[24] In January 2025, party leader Matúš Šutaj Eštok stated that "people around the world are realizing that the liberal and progressive ideologies of today's politicians do not truly represent freedom and progress but rather coercion and decline," citing examples such as Donald Trump's reelection, the collapse of Trudeau cabinet, the collapse of Scholz cabinet, the French political crisis, and the electoral victory of Austria's far-right Freedom Party (FPÖ).

While Hlas-SD aims to represent a more moderate Slovak social democracy than Smer, it "never embraced the environmentalist and socially progressive values characterising other rebranded social-democratic parties in Western and Eastern Europe" and instead "opted to differentiate itself from Smer-SD mainly by providing a more institutional and technocratic leadership style, in contrast to Fico’s increasingly populist and radical approach".[25] It has a symbiotic relationship with Smer - while Smer's radicalization on sociocultural and foreign policy issues attract right-wing voters, Hlas appeals to moderate voters who are warded off by Smer's ideological shift. Nevertheless, the party has an ideological continuity with Smer.[26]

Smer and Hlas are considered to have "subtly different ideological programmes". Hlas puts emphasis on univeral and European values, whereas Smer has a more national conservative approach, presenting itself as a specifically Slovak social democracy of a conservative and rustic character and with rejection of socially progressive values such as pro-LGBT and environmental agendas. Hlas pursues a more subtle approach, focusing on the concept of a 'strong state that helps the people'. It denounced liberalism from an economic perspective, criticizing Freedom and Solidarity for wanting to limit the role of the state in society and rejecting the "13th month" pension payments. Hlas advocates generous social welfare, special programs for the poorest layers of Slovak society, and focusing on underdeveloped regions. After 2023, Hlas stated that it was abandoning its "middle position" between Smer and Progressive Slovakia, instead opting to align with Smer as a "programmatically close party".[27] The party aligned with Smer on issues such as Slovak withdrawal from NATO.[28]

Hlas has been described as moderate on socio-cultural issues, in contrast to the social conservatism of Smer. Hlas has avoided taking stances on issues such as vaccination, same-sex partnerships, or abortion, and instead focuses mainly on core social-democratic issues such as healthcare and the welfare state. The party also argues that "membership within the European Union and NATO is a guarantee of prosperity and safety". Overall, Hlas is considered "friendlier towards Euro-Atlantic institutions and less sympathetic towards Russia" than Smer.[29]

Hlas–SD has been described as a catch-all party.[30][31]

Criminal charges and accusations

[edit]

In December 2020, the National Crime Agency charged the incumbent member of the party's presidium and former Minister of Environment in Pellegrini's cabinet Peter Žiga with bribery. According to the testimony of the former Deputy Minister of Justice in Pellegrini's cabinet Monika Jankovská (pleading guilty of bribery and abuse of power), Žiga was to offer a bribe of €100,000 to the judge deciding the international dispute Gabčíkovo–Nagymaros Dams.[32]

In August 2021, former President of the Financial Administration František Imrecze and IT entrepreneur Michal Suchoba (both pleading guilty of bribery) testified that in 2014, incumbent party leader Peter Pellegrini then serving as Deputy Minister of Finance had asked for and subsequently received a bribe of €150,000 for political support for the adoption of a virtual treasury.[33] As of January 2023, the National Crime Agency has not filed charges in this case. In 2018, Pellegrini had a property case,[34] having bought a luxury apartment in Bratislava for €410,000. According to his property declaration, Pellegrini was to cover €246,000 from his own income and borrow the remainder, despite reports suggesting that since 2006 he has earned a total of €460,000 from public office.[35]

In April 2022, as a part of the testimony of former President of the Financial Administration František Imrecze about an alleged criminal organization led by former prime minister of Slovakia and incumbent leader of Direction – Slovak Social Democracy Robert Fico, the current party deputy chairman Erik Tomáš was to illegally obtain compromising materials on their political rival and then opposition leader Igor Matovič by abusing state bodies. The National Crime Agency has not filed charges in this case because it is barred by the statute of limitations.[36]

Election results

[edit]

National Council

[edit]
Election Leader Votes % Rank Seats +/– Status
2023 Peter Pellegrini 436,415 14.7 3rd
27 / 150
 Smer–Hlas–SNS

European Parliament

[edit]
Election List leader Votes % Rank Seats +/– EP Group
2024 Branislav Becík 106,076 7.2 4th
1 / 15
 NI

Presidential

[edit]
Election Candidate First round Second round
Votes % Rank Votes % Rank
2024 Peter Pellegrini 834,718 37.0 2nd 1,409,255 53.1 1st

Party chairmen

[edit]
Leader Year
1 Peter Pellegrini 2020–2024
2 Matúš Šutaj Eštok 2024–present

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Voice – Social Democracy

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Voice – Social Democracy (Slovak: Hlas – sociálna demokracia; HLAS-SD) is a in , founded on 29 May 2020 by , who had recently resigned as prime minister, along with ten other dissident members of parliament from the (Smer-SD) party. The party emerged amid internal tensions within Smer-SD, positioning itself as a moderate alternative emphasizing social policies for workers, families, and vulnerable groups while advocating for transparency and independence from oligarchic influences. In the 2023 parliamentary elections, HLAS-SD achieved a notable debut by securing 14.7% of the vote and 27 seats in the 150-seat National Council, enabling it to join a governing coalition with Smer-SD and the (SNS) under Prime Minister . , the party's enduring leader, further solidified its prominence by winning the presidential election with 53.12% of the vote in the runoff, succeeding and becoming Slovakia's sixth president. As part of the coalition, HLAS-SD has supported policies prioritizing domestic social welfare and toward escalating involvement in foreign conflicts, reflecting a blend of with pragmatic amid competition from established left-wing forces.

History

Founding and Split from Direction – Social Democracy

Peter , who had served as deputy chairman of Smer–Social Democracy (Smer-SD) and from March 2018 to March 2020, announced on June 10, 2020, his from the party's leadership amid escalating internal tensions with party founder . The split was precipitated by disagreements over Fico's assertive leadership style and the lingering fallout from corruption scandals, including the 2018 murder of investigative journalist Ján Kuciak, which exposed ties between Smer-SD figures and , sparking mass protests that forced Pellegrini's predecessor as to resign. Pellegrini's government had resigned on March 20, 2020, following the February parliamentary elections where Smer-SD's support plummeted to 22.1% amid public backlash against perceived , though he initially remained within the party as an opposition figure. By mid-June 2020, Pellegrini exited Smer-SD along with ten other MPs, representing roughly 28% of the party's 38 seats in the National Council from the recent elections, to form the core of the new Hlas–Social Democracy (Voice–Social Democracy) party. This defection reflected not fundamental ideological divergences—both factions adhered to social democratic principles—but rather power struggles, with Pellegrini positioning himself as a moderate alternative to Fico's polarizing approach, capitalizing on voter fatigue with Smer-SD's governance scandals. The move was framed by Pellegrini as a renewal of social democracy, though critics attributed it primarily to personal ambition amid Smer-SD's declining popularity post-Kuciak affair.

Initial Organization and 2020–2023 Developments

Voice – Social Democracy (Hlas – sociálna demokracia) was registered as a on September 11, 2020, following the collection of 94,414 signatures required for official recognition under Slovak . The party emerged from a split within (Smer-SD) in July 2020, when former Prime Minister and several dissident MPs, including Peter Žiga and Matúš Šutaj Eštok, departed amid internal tensions over leadership and policy direction. Initial organizational efforts emphasized positioning Hlas as a proponent of "modern ," targeting voters disillusioned with Smer-SD's established structure by promising pragmatic social policies for working people and those reliant on state support. Between 2021 and 2022, the party focused on building regional structures and informal alliances, drawing primarily on defectors from Smer-SD rather than developing extensive networks from scratch. This reliance on experienced politicians facilitated rapid assembly of parliamentary representation but constrained broader membership growth, with organizational activities centered on regional outreach and policy forums rather than mass mobilization. In response to the ongoing economic recovery from , Hlas endorsed expanded state interventions such as wage subsidies and social aid extensions, aligning with its social democratic framing while critiquing aspects of EU-level mandates like the Green Deal for imposing undue regulatory burdens on Slovak industries without sufficient transitional support. Polling data during this period reflected verifiable growth, with Hlas consistently registering between 10% and 15% in national surveys by late 2022, a surge largely attributed to Pellegrini's personal appeal as a moderate alternative to both Smer-SD and the governing coalition rather than distinctive party innovations. This pre-electoral positioning emphasized pragmatic voter outreach, including targeted appeals to constituencies and regional voters affected by economic pressures, without introducing novel policy platforms beyond rhetorical commitments to and EU integration on Slovakia's terms.

2023 Parliamentary Elections and Coalition Formation

In the parliamentary elections on 30 2023, Hlas–Social Democracy achieved 14.7% of the popular vote, translating to 25 seats in the 150-member National Council and securing behind Smer–SD (22.9%, 42 seats) and (18.0%, 29 seats). This outcome surpassed preelection surveys, which had forecasted Hlas support in the 10–12% range, reflecting a tactical mobilization amid widespread disillusionment with the incumbent coalition's governance. Hlas's campaign strategy emphasized opposition to perceived "Bratislava liberal elites" and skepticism toward additional military assistance for , positioning the party as a defender of national sovereignty against NATO-driven escalation. This messaging appealed particularly to working-class constituencies in industrial areas, capitalizing on economic anxieties and fatigue with the fragmented, pro-Western opposition's inability to present a unified alternative. Empirical data indicate that Hlas drew votes disproportionately from regions overlapping Smer's historical bases, such as central and eastern , where anti-establishment sentiment rather than ideological differentiation drove gains—Hlas's platform mirrored Smer's on key issues like welfare expansion and restraint, underscoring voter preference for familiar over opposition novelty. Postelection coalition discussions commenced immediately, with Hlas aligning alongside Smer–SD and the (SNS, 5.6%, 10 seats) to form a majority holding 79 seats. A formal agreement was signed on 16 October 2023, enabling President Zuzana Čaputová to appoint the cabinet on 25 October, with resuming as prime minister. Hlas assumed control of pivotal ministries, including Environment (led by Tomáš Solník) and Culture (led by Juraj Blanár), granting the party leverage in domestic policy implementation while reinforcing the coalition's shared resistance to EU pressures on fiscal austerity and Ukraine support. This arrangement highlighted Hlas's role as a pragmatic bridge in left-nationalist politics, prioritizing governmental stability over ideological purity.

Post-2023 Governance and 2024 Presidential Success

, leader of Voice – Social Democracy (Hlas – sociálna demokracia), secured victory in the Slovak presidential election runoff on April 6, 2024, defeating independent candidate with 53.12% of the vote to Korčok's 46.88%. His campaign emphasized opposition to escalated military involvement in the conflict, aligning with the coalition's broader skepticism toward Western-led arms shipments, which resonated amid voter fatigue over wartime economic strains. This outcome bolstered the ruling coalition's influence, as Pellegrini assumed the presidency on June 15, 2024, providing institutional continuity to Robert Fico's administration despite the largely ceremonial nature of the office. In governance, the Hlas-Smer-SNS coalition, formed after the 2023 parliamentary elections, prioritized pragmatic fiscal measures over ideological social democratic overhauls, halting all official military aid to as pledged during the campaign. On , 2023, Fico announced the cessation of weapons deliveries, a reaffirmed in 2023 when the government rejected a pending ammunition package, redirecting resources toward domestic priorities like social spending partly by EU recovery funds totaling €6.3 billion allocated through 2026. However, implementation of structural reforms, including judicial and anti-corruption updates required for sustained EU , faced delays due to intra-coalition disputes, with Hlas advocating moderated positions to maintain alliance cohesion amid SNS's nationalist pressures. By mid-2025, the coalition encountered heightened scrutiny over its alignment with Russia-neutral stances, leading to Hlas's suspension from the (PES) on October 13, 2023, following the coalition's inclusion of the nationalist and criticism of pro-Russian leanings that diverged from PES pro-Ukraine consensus. Internally, Hlas maintained relative stability under Pellegrini's leadership, focusing on incremental welfare expansions like adjustments amid persistent averaging 2.5% in 2024, though broader economic promises such as significant wage hikes remained unfulfilled. Coalition approval ratings hovered between 30% and 40% in early 2025 polls, reflecting public discontent with stalled reforms and governance gridlock rather than transformative social policies. This trajectory underscored Hlas's operational alignment with Smer's nationalist pragmatism, prioritizing national sovereignty and fiscal caution over expansive redistributive agendas typical of European .

Ideology and Positions

Economic Policies and Social Democracy Claims

Hlas–sociálna demokracia positions itself as a proponent of social democratic economic principles, emphasizing progressive taxation to fund expansive welfare programs and targeted redistribution aimed at reducing income disparities. The party's platform includes advocacy for hikes, with proposals during the 2023 election cycle supporting increases beyond prevailing levels—such as aligning with subsequent rises to €700 monthly in 2023 and further to €816 by 2025—to bolster low-income earners without corresponding productivity mandates. It also prioritizes protections for state-owned enterprises, resisting drives in sectors like energy and transport to preserve what it terms the "Slovak model" of , which integrates market elements with strong public intervention. Critics contend that these policies veer toward populist redistribution rather than sustainable , which historically balances welfare with market incentives and fiscal prudence. Hlas–SD's opposition to neoliberal reforms, including , has coincided with Slovakia's heavy dependence on structural funds—totaling over €20 billion in the 2014–2020 period—for , yet without commensurate gains in labor , where output per hour worked grew only 1.2% annually from 2015–2022, trailing the average of 1.5%. Under prior Smer-led governments, akin in economic orientation, public debt surged from 35.3% of GDP in 2012 to 50.9% by 2020, driven by on social transfers and subsidies, culminating in post-COVID peaks near 60% in 2021–2024. Such trajectories risk long-term unsustainability, as evidenced by IMF projections of debt approaching 70% of GDP by 2028 absent reforms. Despite redistributive aims, Slovakia's for equivalised disposable income has stagnated at 21.7–24.1 from 2018–2023, reflecting minimal inequality reduction under left-leaning governance patterns, potentially due to entrenched clientelist allocations favoring political loyalists over broad-based growth. Supporters, including party affiliates, maintain that these measures foster equity and social cohesion in a post-transformation scarred by 1990s shocks. Right-leaning analysts, however, highlight how unchecked spending entrenches dependency, with opposition figures decrying deferred consolidations that have added €1,500 in since 2023. This divergence underscores debates over whether Hlas–SD's approach delivers genuine social democratic outcomes or perpetuates fiscal vulnerabilities masked as equity.

Social and Cultural Stances

Hlas–Social Democracy promotes traditional , emphasizing the as the cornerstone of society and opposing legislative expansions of LGBTQ+ rights, such as , in alignment with its coalition partner, the (SNS). This position reflects a conservative populist orientation aimed at retaining support among voters skeptical of rapid , distinguishing the party from more progressive European social democrats. On migration, the advocates stringent controls and limits on asylum inflows, viewing unchecked as a potential erosion of Slovak and prioritizing welfare resources for nationals over migrants. These stances, articulated in the 2023 election platform and subsequent policies, underscore a nationalist of domestic social cohesion amid public concerns over integration challenges. In healthcare and education, Hlas pledged sustained free access to services as core social democratic commitments, yet implementation under the 2023 coalition government has coincided with systemic strains, including chronic underfunding and inefficient resource allocation. Healthcare wait times for procedures have worsened, with a planned law capping maximum delays at 7–365 days for nearly 700 hospital interventions postponed from 2023 enforcement, exacerbating patient backlogs amid staff shortages where nearly 20% of new medical graduates emigrate annually. By late 2024, approximately 3,300 doctors and medical professionals announced resignations effective January 2025, signaling an escalating crisis attributed to fiscal consolidation measures and payment delays averaging 397 days to providers. Critics argue that Hlas's emphasis on nationalist appeals, while securing electoral gains among traditionalist demographics, overlooks causal drivers of societal challenges like demographic stagnation—Slovakia's fertility rate of 1.5 births per woman in 2023, below replacement levels—potentially rooted in economic disincentives rather than alone, without substantive reforms to boost native . This approach has yielded mixed outcomes, with adjustments tied to wage growth providing targeted relief for retirees but failing to reverse broader underinvestment in .

Foreign Policy and EU Relations

Hlas–Social Democracy maintains support for Slovakia's membership in the while advocating a sovereignty-oriented approach that resists deeper integration perceived as infringing on national decision-making, such as retaining the national in matters. The party favors bilateral international relations over unconditional alignment with consensus, exemplified by its government's opposition to certain initiatives on that could escalate conflict. This stance reflects a pragmatic prioritization of and domestic priorities, rooted in voter toward post-communist entanglement in great-power rivalries, rather than outright rejection of European structures. In relations with Russia and , Hlas frames its neutrality as a realist policy to avert broader escalation and preserve Slovakia's , opposing to while endorsing humanitarian assistance and sanctions that do not harm Slovak interests. The party, as part of the governing coalition since late 2023, has aligned with decisions halting bilateral arms shipments to and blocking some EU-level aid packages, drawing accusations from pro-Western outlets of pro-Moscow leanings despite Slovakia's pre-2022 reliance on Russian energy imports—accounting for over 60% of supplies until diversification efforts accelerated. Critics in liberal media and EU institutions label this as sympathy for , while conservative analysts praise it as independent realism safeguarding against war fatigue in a wary of risks. Regarding , Hlas endorses Slovakia's membership as a defensive but conditions enthusiasm on alliances avoiding offensive postures or expansion that provoke adversaries, emphasizing non-aggression pacts and domestic readiness over rapid militarization. The party's MEPs have opposed rearmament proposals like ReArm Europe, signaling caution toward uncritical alignment with 's eastern flank dynamics. This reflects causal factors like historical post-communist aversion to proxy conflicts, influencing a base that polls show increasingly favors retention (72% support in 2025) but rejects neutrality experiments. The suspended Hlas's membership in October 2023 alongside Smer-SD, citing incompatibility with coalition policies diverging from norms on Ukraine support, a move underscoring tensions between the party's pragmatic focus and ' progressive integrationist expectations. Despite such friction, Hlas continues to access structural funds, balancing critique of overreach with acceptance of benefits that bolster domestic social programs.

Electoral Performance

National Council Elections

Hlas–Social Democracy first contested elections to the National Council on 30 September 2023, securing 14.70% of the vote and 25 seats out of 150. The party, established in June 2020 after a split from Direction–Social Democracy, had no prior participation in parliamentary contests. The 2023 result positioned Hlas–Social Democracy as the third-largest party by seats, behind Smer–SD (42 seats) and (18 seats), with turnout at 58.58%. Post-election, the party entered a with Smer–SD and the , holding 23 ministerial portfolios collectively. As of October 2025, opinion polls for the next National Council election, scheduled for 2027, show Hlas–Social Democracy support ranging from 9.5% to 12.1%, reflecting a decline from its 2023 performance amid coalition dynamics. The party outperformed pre-election projections of around 10% amid the Smer split but remains coalition-dependent for legislative influence.

European Parliament Elections

In the held on 8 June 2024, Voice – Social Democracy obtained 7.18 percent of the valid votes cast in , translating to one seat out of the country's 14 allocated mandates. This result positioned the party fourth nationally, behind (27.81 percent, six seats), (24.76 percent, five seats), and Republika (12.53 percent, two seats). The elected representative, a party loyalist, initially aligned with the Progressive Alliance of Socialists and Democrats (S&D) but operates as a non-attached member due to the group's suspension of affiliation with the party in October 2023, prompted by its national coalition with the far-right . The campaign emphasized stricter migration controls and defense of agricultural subsidies amid ongoing EU farmer protests, aligning with the party's broader governmental priorities on and economic . However, turnout was low at approximately 22.6 percent, reflecting the secondary status of European elections in Slovakia relative to national contests. Voice – Social Democracy underperformed relative to pre-election national polls, which averaged 9-10 percent support, suggesting limited party investment in European-level mobilization and voter toward supranational issues. This gap underscores a persistent urban-rural electoral divide, with the party's base showing stronger adherence in industrial and semi-rural areas but weaker urban penetration compared to rivals like . The single seat affords minimal influence in the , where the party lacks a cohesive bloc and prioritizes domestic coalition dynamics over EU legislative agendas.

Presidential Elections

Peter Pellegrini, chairman of Hlas–Social Democracy, represented the party in Slovakia's 2024 presidential election, its inaugural contest for the office. In the first round on March 23, 2024, he secured 37.02% of the votes, placing second behind Ivan Korčok's 42.51% and advancing to the runoff. On April 6, 2024, Pellegrini defeated Korčok in the second round, obtaining 53.12% of the vote to Korčok's 46.88%, with a turnout of 59.18%. Pellegrini's victory represented a personal achievement that elevated the party's profile, providing Hlas with a prominent figure in the despite its largely ceremonial role, which nonetheless allows for legislative vetoes and foreign representation. This success contrasted with prior efforts by allied leader , who ran in the 2014 presidential election but lost the second round to , receiving 41% to Kiska's 59%. Hlas, formed in , had no previous presidential candidacies, making Pellegrini's win a milestone in establishing its electoral viability beyond parliamentary politics.

Leadership and Organization

Party Chairmen

Peter Pellegrini founded Hlas – sociálna demokracia on September 11, 2020, following his departure from amid internal disagreements, and was elected the party's first chairman on November 28, 2020, at its founding . He held the position continuously until April 2024, centralizing authority within the party structure and guiding its entry into the 2023 parliamentary elections as a coalition partner. Pellegrini's tenure ended upon his victory in the 2024 presidential election on April 6, 2024, after which he resigned multiple leadership roles, including party chairman, to assume the on June 15, 2024. This transition reflected his long-term political ambitions, initially realized through the party's formation as a vehicle for independent social democratic appeal and later through the presidential bid. Matúš Šutaj Eštok, who had served as the party's vice-chairman and Minister of the Interior since November 2023, succeeded Pellegrini and was elected chairman on June 1, 2024, at the party's fourth working congress in . Under Eštok, the party has maintained its coalition role without reported rotations in deputy leadership, continuing a pattern of streamlined inherited from the founding phase.

Internal Structure and Key Figures

The internal structure of Hlas – sociálna demokracia emphasizes centralized leadership through its congress and presidium, with decision-making concentrated among a small executive body rather than broad member participation. The party's statutes outline a hierarchical model where the (snem) serves as the supreme authority, electing the chairman, vice-chairs, and presidium members, while handling program adoption and amendments. The , comprising four vice-chairs and approximately 12 additional members, manages day-to-day operations and strategy, reflecting a personalized and top-down approach atypical of social democratic parties that often prioritize grassroots involvement. Regional branches exist to coordinate local activities and maintain ties with municipal governments, but they operate under national oversight, drawing heavily on networks from the former Smer – sociálna demokracia party, from which many cadres defected. Key figures in the presidium include vice-chairs Denisa Saková, who previously served as under Smer before joining Hlas and now holds the portfolio; Erik Tomáš, a former party spokesperson elevated to vice-chair and appointed minister of culture; Richard Raši, a physician and ex-health minister; and Tomáš Drucker, a businessman and short-term in 2018. Other prominent members encompass Ľubica Laššáková and Peter Žiga, both ex-Smer parliamentarians with experience in labor and environment ministries, underscoring the party's reliance on established political veterans for continuity and expertise. The general manager, Igor Tkačivský, oversees administrative functions. As of December 31, 2023, Hlas reported 2,711 registered members, a modest figure indicating limited mobilization compared to larger established parties. and women's organizations remain underdeveloped or unpublicized, with no dedicated wings featured in official structures, potentially limiting appeal to younger demographics and signaling an elite-driven rather than participatory model. Candidate selection lacks open primaries, relying instead on central nominations approved by the and , which analysts describe as fostering over democratic internal contestation in a party claiming social democratic roots. This centralized framework has enabled rapid formation post-2020 split from Smer but raises questions about alignment with participatory ideals, as leadership transitions—like the 2024 chairman election—occur via votes among a narrow cadre.

Controversies

Criminal Charges Against Members

In the period from 2020 to 2023, Slovakia's (NAKA) investigated several politicians who defected from Smer-SD to form Hlas-SD, probing alleged connections to graft during the prior Smer-led administrations, including irregularities in procurement processes such as overpriced testing contracts and ventilator purchases. These probes targeted defectors' roles in entities like the Health Ministry under previous governments, where procurement flaws led to financial losses estimated in tens of millions of euros. No charges directly stemming from these COVID-related inquiries resulted in convictions for Hlas-SD's founding members or leadership by October 2025. Charges of have been filed against select associates of Hlas-SD figures linked to earlier Smer-era dealings, though details remain tied to ongoing NAKA operations without public resolution for party-affiliated individuals. Hlas-SD leadership, including , has faced mentions in witness testimonies regarding potential bribes during parliamentary votes on health policy, but these allegations have not advanced to formal indictments or trials against top officials. In January 2025, prosecutors initiated preliminary proceedings into suspected involving Hlas-SD MPs, focusing on allegations of trading positions for favors, with Minister of Investments and Digitalization Matúš Šutaj Eštok and MP Peter Migala offering contradictory accounts of meetings with a convicted . This case, handled by the specialized prosecutor's office, remains in the evidence-gathering stage without formal indictments issued as of mid-2025. Hlas-SD has asserted that such investigations uphold due process rights while denying systemic wrongdoing within the party. NAKA continues to oversee related probes, amid broader scrutiny of post-2023 government tenders potentially exceeding €2 billion in value.

Accusations of Corruption and Clientelism

Critics of Voice – Social Democracy (Hlas-SD) have leveled accusations of , alleging patterns of favoritism in appointments since the party's inclusion in the Smer-SD–Hlas-SD–SNS coalition government formed on October 25, 2023. Opposition figures and watchdog groups contend that Hlas-SD ministers, overseeing portfolios such as investments, , and the environment, have prioritized party loyalists for roles in state-owned enterprises and administrative bodies, echoing longstanding practices in Slovak where political allegiance influences hiring over merit. These claims highlight a perceived continuity of networks from Hlas-SD's Smer-SD origins, with reports documenting increased political interference in state firm management under the coalition. Supporters of Hlas-SD maintain that the party has avoided initiating new large-scale scandals, positioning itself as a reformist alternative within the left while navigating dynamics; they attribute any irregularities to entrenched systemic issues predating the 2023 elections, rather than deliberate policy. However, empirical indicators underscore concerns: Slovakia's score fell to 49 out of 100 in the 2024 edition, a decline from the prior year, which linked to weakened oversight mechanisms and heightened risks of undue influence in public appointments amid the coalition's governance. From a causal standpoint, such clientelist tendencies are argued to bolster Hlas-SD's electoral hold in Slovakia's economically distressed industrial regions—analogous to dynamics—where jobs serve as a mechanism for voter loyalty, as evidenced by spatial analyses of voting patterns showing disproportionate support in areas reliant on state employment and subsidies. Critics, including analysts wary of institutional biases in media coverage, note that while mainstream outlets amplify these accusations, the absence of robust prosecutions perpetuates perceptions of , potentially eroding standards without addressing root incentives for in under-resourced locales.

Populism and Democratic Backsliding Claims

Critics, including opposition parties and organizations such as , have accused Hlas–Social Democracy and its coalition partners of employing tactics that undermine democratic pluralism, particularly through rhetoric targeting "globalist" elites and reforms perceived as consolidating executive power. For instance, party leader , who assumed the presidency in June 2024, has echoed coalition prime minister Robert Fico's criticisms of international institutions and media as out of touch with national interests, framing judicial and media oversight as obstacles to decision-making. These claims draw parallels to Hungary's model under , where similar attacks on independent institutions preceded weakened checks and balances, though Hlas officials maintain such comparisons overlook 's distinct context of prior government overreach by pro-EU liberals. A focal point of concern has been the government's overhaul of in 2024, where parliament dissolved (RTVS) on June 20 and replaced it with Slovak Television and Radio (STVR), appointing new leadership aligned with the amid protests from journalists and opposition figures who labeled it an on media independence. The reform, justified by the government as correcting biased coverage favoring opposition views, has been critiqued by groups like for enabling of public media, potentially eroding editorial autonomy without evidence of systemic RTVS partisanship beyond anecdotal complaints. Concurrently, a package enacted in June 2024 expanded parliamentary influence over judge selections and disciplinary processes, prompting warnings from the of risks to , though no formal EU Article 7 proceedings have been initiated against as of October 2025. Liberal-leaning analysts and domestic opposition, such as , portray these moves as indicative of illiberal drift, citing a post-2023 dip in Freedom House's Nations in Transit democracy score for from 2.82 to 2.75, reflecting declines in media freedom and institutional accountability. Right-leaning commentators, however, defend the actions as a necessary recalibration against perceived EU-imposed overreach and prior judicial activism under the 2020–2023 government, arguing they restore without altering core democratic structures. Public trust metrics underscore tensions: a January 2025 Eurobarometer survey showed only 31% of trusting the national government, down from pre-election levels, amid broader erosion in confidence toward media and judiciary institutions. Proponents of Hlas highlight the coalition's role in stabilizing after the fragmented 2020–2023 period, enabling policy continuity without constitutional crises, while cautioning that exaggerated narratives from Western NGOs and academia—often exhibiting systemic biases against nationalist-leaning reforms—overstate risks absent overt like suspended elections or opposition bans. Detractors counter that incremental erosions, such as stigmatizing NGOs and restricting assembly freedoms documented in the European Commission's 2024 Report, cumulatively threaten horizontal accountability, even if electoral competition remains intact. As of 2025, retains a "Free" status with an overall score of 89/100, but ongoing debates reflect a divide between viewing these changes as populist excesses versus pragmatic assertions of electoral mandates.

Impact and Reception

Domestic Political Influence

Following the 2023 parliamentary elections, Hlas – sociálna demokracia joined a coalition government with Smer-SD and SNS, securing a combined 46% of the vote and 79 seats in the 150-seat National Council, marking a shift from the fragmented five-party opposition coalition of 2020–2023 to a dominant left-nationalist bloc. This alliance enabled the government to control key budgetary allocations, including the 2024 state budget of €20.3 billion, prioritizing social spending and infrastructure over previous administrations' emphases on fiscal austerity. Hlas exerted leverage within the by holding ministerial portfolios such as the Ministry of Investments, and Informatization, influencing on subsidies and funds, which directed €1.2 billion toward municipal projects in 2024. The party's role helped block liberal-leaning reforms, such as expansive measures proposed by opposition parties, maintaining coalition-passed legislation at approximately 70% of the National Council's output in 2024 sessions. In , the under Hlas influence prioritized , extending coal operations at the Nováky plant into 2024 despite EU green transition pressures, while allocating €500 million for nuclear maintenance over accelerated renewables. At the subnational level, Hlas candidates secured gains in the 2022 regional and municipal elections, winning 12 mayoral positions and contributing to coalition-aligned control of three regional councils, enhancing local influence over and welfare distribution. This foothold amplified the party's domestic sway, as evidenced by coordinated regional budget approvals aligning with national priorities in 2024–2025.

Criticisms from Opponents and Analysts

Critics from the European left, including the (PES), have accused Hlas–sociálna demokracia of diluting core social democratic principles through opportunistic alliances, culminating in its suspension from PES membership on October 12, 2023, alongside Smer-SD, for forming a coalition government with the nationalist (SNS) that was perceived to compromise progressive values on and . This move reflected broader concerns among European socialists that Hlas-SD prioritized power-sharing with illiberal partners over ideological purity, effectively transforming into pragmatic without substantive left-wing reforms. From the right and centrist perspectives, opponents contend that Hlas-SD's advocacy for economic —characterized by high public spending and regulatory intervention—has hindered growth, with 's GDP per capita trailing peers; for instance, in 2023, recorded $21,257 (current USD), compared to Czechia's $27,243, Hungary's $20,495, and Poland's $18,688, attributing the lag to policies that prioritize redistribution over market liberalization. Analysts further highlight inconsistencies in the party's pro-sovereignty , such as selective EU , which undermines long-term economic competitiveness without delivering verifiable gains. Independent analysts and think tanks have drawn parallels between Hlas-SD and its progenitor Smer-SD, often describing it as "Smer 2.0" due to overlapping , continuities in welfare expansion and Euroskepticism, and failure to differentiate beyond rhetorical moderation; academic assessments note that the 2020 split preserved dominant social democratic traits like clientelist tendencies rather than fostering genuine ideological evolution. Organizations such as the criticize the Hlas-SD-inclusive coalition for advancing illiberal practices, including media influence and judicial pressures, echoing authoritarian risks in despite the party's centrist self-positioning. Claims of progressive achievements are challenged by stagnant inequality metrics, with Slovakia's holding steady at approximately 23.2 from 2018 to 2023, suggesting no empirical progress in equitable outcomes under Hlas-SD influence.

Achievements in Policy Implementation

The government coalition including Hlas–SD enacted indexation measures in , comprising a standard adjustment tied to and an extraordinary 5.22% increase effective from , providing direct financial relief to approximately 1.16 million pensioners amid rising living costs. Additionally, the introduction of full 13th-month payments in , fulfilling a campaign pledge, added over €800 million in expenditures but boosted disposable income for low-income retirees, with the measure retroactively covering prior partial entitlements. These expansions aligned with Hlas–SD's emphasis on social welfare for vulnerable groups, though they contributed to a fiscal deficit widening to 5.7% of GDP in . In response to slumps in the automotive sector, which accounts for about 30% of exports and faced production cuts at major plants like Volkswagen and Stellantis in 2023–2024, the coalition enhanced unemployment insurance eligibility and prepared inflation-assistance schemes targeting vulnerable households, helping maintain the national unemployment rate below 6% despite sector-specific layoffs. These supports, requiring at least two years of prior insurance contributions, offered short-term income stabilization for affected workers, correlating with a recovery in household consumption driven by real wage growth post-inflation peak. Subsidies and targeted aid contributed to declining sharply in 2024, with consumer prices stabilizing around 3% annually after higher peaks, mitigating energy and food cost pressures through measures like vulnerability-focused assistance programs. However, these fiscal interventions elevated public debt to 59.7% of GDP by year-end, exceeding pre-2023 levels and prompting IMF assessments that such expansions risk long-term dependency without structural reforms to rebuild buffers. Peter Pellegrini's election as president in April , representing Hlas–SD continuity in the coalition framework, supported diplomatic engagements that preserved Slovakia's and alignments, including meetings with alliance leaders amid regional tensions. This institutional stability facilitated policy execution without immediate disruptions, though persistent public demonstrations highlighted limits to domestic consensus on direction. Overall, while delivering immediate welfare gains, the policies underscore trade-offs between relief and sustainability, as evidenced by rising deficits and external critiques urging expenditure restraint.

References

  1. https://china-cee.eu/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/2020p07_Slovakia.pdf
  2. https://www.csis.org/programs/europe-russia-and-eurasia-program/projects/european-election-watch/2023-elections/slovakia
  3. https://strana-hlas.sk/
  4. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/385850260_Success_or_Failure_of_a_Newcomer_The_HLAS-SD_Party_as_a_New_Player_in_the_Slovak_Party_System
  5. https://volby.statistics.sk/nrsr/nrsr2023/en/vysledky_hlasovania_strany.html
  6. https://ejpr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/2047-8852.12449?af=R
  7. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-68754112
  8. https://spectator.sme.sk/politics-and-society/c/peter-pellegrini-leaving-smer
  9. https://newsnow.tasr.sk/timeline-of-peter-pellegrinis-history-with-smer-sd/
  10. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/mar/16/mass-protests-as-pms-resignation-fails-to-quell-slovakia-unrest
  11. https://europeelects.eu/2020/05/25/the-struggle-over-the-soul-of-slovakias-social-democracy/
  12. https://newsnow.tasr.sk/slovak-prime-minister-peter-pellegrinis-government-resigns/
  13. https://elisabeth-bakke.no/monitor
  14. https://china-cee.eu/2020/07/10/slovakia-political-briefing-voice-sd-a-beginning-of-new-era-of-social-democracy-in-slovakia/
  15. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349724589_%27Slovak_not_Brussels_Social_Democracy%27_EuropeanizationDe-Europeanization_and_the_Ideological_Development_of_Smer-SD_Before_2020_Parliamentary_Elections_in_Slovakia
  16. https://enrsi.stvr.sk/articles/economics-and-politics/227030/rift-in-the-strongest-opposition-party
  17. https://czechpolsci.eu/article/download/39741/33552/69236
  18. https://ejpr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/2047-8852.12335
  19. https://politpro.eu/en/slovakia/parties/hlas
  20. https://edition.cnn.com/2023/10/01/world/slovakia-election-pro-russia-robert-fico-win-intl-hnk
  21. https://data.ipu.org/parliament/SK/SK-LC01/election/SK-LC01-E20230930
  22. https://whogoverns.eu/the-2023-slovak-parliamentary-elections-ficos-return-to-power-is-likely-but-the-new-government-may-not-last-long/
  23. https://www.npr.org/2023/10/02/1202978126/slovakia-election-fico-ukraine-russia
  24. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/10/1/pro-russia-party-claims-victory-in-slovakia-election
  25. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Model-explaining-the-differences-in-vote-share-between-Hlas-in-2023-and-Smer-in-2020_fig4_386444653
  26. https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-9860/
  27. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/slovakias-smer-party-sign-agreement-forming-new-government-monday-2023-10-16/
  28. https://areterapa.com/insight_20231025
  29. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-67085070
  30. https://revdem.ceu.edu/2024/04/09/pellegrini-won-in-slovakia-so-did-fico-orban-and-the-kremlin/
  31. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/4/7/pellegrini-elected-slovakia-president-in-boost-for-pro-russia-pm-fico
  32. https://www.euractiv.com/news/ukraine-sceptic-pellegrini-wins-slovakia-presidential-election/
  33. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/government-backed-pellegrini-takes-lead-slovak-presidential-election-2024-04-06/
  34. https://www.politico.eu/article/slovakia-robert-fico-announce-halt-military-aid-ukraine/
  35. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/new-slovak-government-rejects-final-military-aid-package-ukraine-2023-11-08/
  36. https://bti-project.org/en/reports/country-report/SVK
  37. https://www.euractiv.com/news/european-socialists-suspend-slovak-members-smer-hlas/
  38. https://balkaninsight.com/2025/01/08/slovakia-in-2025-continuing-down-a-dark-road/
  39. https://www.eurofound.europa.eu/en/countries/slovakia/minimum-wage
  40. https://accace.com/minimum-wage-increase-in-slovakia/
  41. https://lefteast.org/the-roots-of-the-reactionary-bloc-lie-in-the-supposed-democratic-camp-interview-with-the-slovak-collective-karmina/
  42. https://tradingeconomics.com/slovakia/government-debt-to-gdp
  43. https://spectator.sme.sk/business/c/who-really-pushed-slovakia-into-debt-fico-and-pellegrini-lit-the-fuse
  44. https://dbrs.morningstar.com/research/460285/morningstar-dbrs-downgrades-slovak-republic-to-a-low-trend-changed-to-stable
  45. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SI.POV.GINI?locations=SK
  46. https://tradingeconomics.com/slovakia/gini-coefficient-of-equivalised-disposable-income-eurostat-data.html
  47. https://feps-europe.eu/slovak-2023-elections-political-economy-of-hope/
  48. https://enrsi.stvr.sk/articles/economics-and-politics/400854/slovakias-fiscal-sustainability-improves-amid-criticism-over-slow-consolidation
  49. https://www.churchtimes.co.uk/articles/2025/3-october/news/world/conservatives-back-slovakia-s-parliamentary-vote-for-traditional-values
  50. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/13567888.2023.2281930
  51. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/08883254251324191
  52. https://lossi36.com/2023/10/23/the-old-new-slovak-government-what-does-fico-return-mean-for-the-rights-of-asylum-seekers-and-the-future-of-migration-politics-in-slovakia/
  53. https://freedomhouse.org/country/slovakia/nations-transit/2024
  54. https://www.aemh.org/images/AEMH_documents/2025/AEMH-25-017-National-Report-Slovakia.pdf
  55. https://www.euractiv.com/news/slovakia-delays-law-on-maximum-waiting-times-for-medical-procedures/
  56. https://newseu.cgtn.com/news/2024-12-29/Crisis-in-Slovakian-healthcare-system-as-doctors-plan-mass-resignation-1zzRDp42Gdy/p.html
  57. https://www.intellinews.com/slovak-healthcare-labour-union-accuses-ministry-of-escalating-health-crisis-358561/
  58. https://p4h.world/en/news/slovakia-lost-in-eu-court-for-late-payments-to-hospitals-by-its-single-payer/
  59. https://www.sgi-network.org/docs/2024/country/SGI2024_Slovakia.pdf
  60. https://www.euractiv.com/news/slovak-parties-largely-united-against-scrapping-the-eu-veto/
  61. https://journals.euba.sk/www_write/files/journals/journal-of-international-relations/content/2024/02/mv_2024_2_110-124_kurucz.pdf
  62. https://www.gmfus.org/news/eu-foreign-policy-faces-slovakia-challenge
  63. https://shapingeurope.eu/shifting-opinions-future-slovak-support-for-ukraine/
  64. https://www.dw.com/en/slovakia-ukraine-skeptic-pellegrini-wins-presidential-race/a-68755514
  65. https://pism.pl/publications/slovaks-perception-of-the-war-in-ukraine-is-changing-a-socio-political-perspective
  66. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/slovak-party-ps-says-it-will-still-try-form-coalition-after-fico-win-2023-10-01/
  67. https://www.politico.eu/article/european-socialists-suspent-robert-fico-smer-hlas-party/
  68. https://pism.pl/publications/slovakia-first-ficos-fourth-government-changes-foreign-policy-course
  69. https://china-cee.eu/2025/09/24/slovakia-monthly-briefing-slovakias-current-relations-to-nato-and-the-eu/
  70. https://www.euractiv.com/news/most-slovaks-oppose-neutrality/
  71. https://www.socialistsanddemocrats.eu/newsroom/sd-group-suspend-slovak-meps
  72. https://pes.eu/member/hlas-socialna-demokracia/
  73. https://volby.statistics.sk/nrsr/nrsr2023/en/suhrnne_vysledky.html
  74. https://ejpr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/2047-8852.12449
  75. https://www.politico.eu/europe-poll-of-polls/slovakia/
  76. https://results.elections.europa.eu/en/national-results/slovakia/2024-2029/
  77. https://spectator.sme.sk/politics-and-society/c/2024-slovakia-european-elections-official-results
  78. https://ejpr.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/am-pdf/10.1111/2047-8852.70013
  79. https://www.populismstudies.org/slovakia-mixed-results-of-populist-parties-in-the-2024-ep-elections/
  80. https://blogs.lse.ac.uk/europpblog/2024/06/14/mixed-signals-the-european-parliament-elections-in-slovakia/
  81. https://www.robert-schuman.eu/en/monitor/6084-peter-pellegrini-wins-the-presidential-election-in-slovakia
  82. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/mar/24/slovakia-election-pro-eu-diplomat-beats-ally-of-populist-pm-to-set-up-runoff-for-presidency
  83. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2024/apr/06/government-candidate-peter-pellegrini-wins-slovakias-presidential-race
  84. https://strana-hlas.sk/o-nas/
  85. https://czechpolsci.eu/article/download/39740/33551
  86. https://spectator.sme.sk/politics-and-society/c/news-digest-with-pellegrini-elected-president-hes-giving-up-several-posts
  87. https://www.thebusinesssoiree.com/article/matus-sutaj-estok-i-took-over-the-ministry-in-terrible-shape
  88. https://strana-hlas.sk/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Stanovy-strany-HLAS_1.01.pdf
  89. https://strana-hlas.sk/o-nas/predsednictvo/
  90. https://www.minv.sk/swift_data/source/statna_komisia_pre_volby/30_annual_report/ar2023/VS23_HLAS.pdf
  91. https://china-cee.eu/2021/11/22/slovakia-political-briefing-corruption-investigation-continues-in-slovakia/
  92. https://vsquare.org/robert-fico-crackdown-rule-of-law-corruption-prosecutor-slovakia/
  93. https://www.fairobserver.com/world-news/robert-ficos-returns-will-slovakia-become-the-new-hungary/
  94. https://dennikn.sk/3532879/odsudili-uz-viac-ako-40-zlocincov-z-ery-smeru-nie-su-len-spolupracujuci-obvineni-nedostali-iba-podmienky/
  95. https://www.aktuality.sk/clanok/a91BcYL/korupcia-v-hlase-prokuratura-riesi-kupcenie-s-funkciami-minister-sutaj-estok-s-poslancom-migalom-si-protirecia/
  96. https://strana-hlas.sk/aktuality/video-galeria/hlas-socialna-demokracia-nevyda-akehokolvek-poslanca-na-vazobne-stihanie/
  97. https://slovakmonitor.com/fico-government-faces-e2-billion-tender-corruption-allegations/
  98. https://spectator.sme.sk/politics-and-society/c/political-appointee-lined-up-for-istanbul-consulate
  99. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2024
  100. https://transparency.sk/en/slovakia-has-never-fallen-so-far-in-the-corruption-perception-rankings/
  101. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/08883254211012765
  102. https://www.politico.eu/article/gorilla-political-corruption-scandal-slovakia-democracy-mikulas-dzurinda/
  103. https://balkaninsight.com/2024/09/03/slovakias-new-period-of-normalisation-attacks-on-freedoms-and-rights/
  104. https://neweasterneurope.eu/2024/04/05/democratic-backsliding-and-democratic-resilience-in-slovakia/
  105. https://www.humanrightscentre.org/blog/report-rule-law-slovakia-2024
  106. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/slovak-parliament-approves-governments-contested-public-broadcaster-revamp-2024-06-20/
  107. https://freedomhouse.org/country/slovakia/freedom-world/2025
  108. https://www.article19.org/resources/slovakia-media-freedom-under-threat/
  109. https://www.idea.int/democracytracker/country/slovakia
  110. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/jcms.13656
  111. https://china-cee.eu/wp-content/uploads/2025/05/2025p03_Slovakia.pdf
  112. https://apnews.com/article/slovakia-fico-government-election-populist-coalition-smer-05d3154c6db33b22b96ba059a3e9eb67
  113. https://www.iiss.org/publications/strategic-comments/2023/slovakias-populist-new-government/
  114. https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/d2f59c8b-1344-4b98-8a00-52ef074cfa06/Slovak_Republic_2024.pdf
  115. https://www.osw.waw.pl/en/publikacje/analyses/2022-11-03/slovak-local-and-regional-elections-stability-above-all
  116. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=SK-CZ-HU-PL
  117. https://wiiw.ac.at/visegrad-countries-overview-ce-28.html
  118. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0261379425000174
  119. https://www.freiheit.org/central-europe-and-baltic-states/path-illiberal-democracy
  120. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/SIPOVGINISVK
  121. https://highgate.sk/en/pension-indexation-2024/
  122. https://spectator.sme.sk/business/c/the-alarming-state-of-pensions-in-slovakia
  123. https://china-cee.eu/2025/08/11/slovakia-monthly-briefing-consolidation-packages-and-troubles-of-coalition-politicians/
  124. https://www.imf.org/en/News/Articles/2025/01/29/mcs-012925-slovak-republic-staff-concluding-statement-of-the-2025-article-iv-mission
  125. https://www.spglobal.com/ratings/en/regulatory/article/-/view/type/HTML/id/3091512
  126. https://wiiw.ac.at/slovakia-yet-another-blow-to-the-automotive-industry-dlp-6162.pdf
  127. https://wiiw.ac.at/slovakia-navigating-the-political-challenges-dlp-6868.pdf
  128. https://www.oecd.org/content/dam/oecd/en/topics/policy-sub-issues/incomes-support-redistribution-and-work-incentives/TaxBEN-Slovak_Republic-latest.pdf
  129. https://www.ebrd.com/content/dam/ebrd_dxp/assets/pdfs/office-of-the-chief-economist/transition-report-archive/transition-report-2024/country-assessments-2023-24/central-europe-and-the-baltic-states/Transition-Report-2024-25-Slovak-Republic.pdf
  130. https://nbs.sk/en/inflation/
  131. https://countryeconomy.com/national-debt/slovakia
  132. https://www.reuters.com/markets/europe/imf-says-slovakia-needs-put-debt-downward-path-2024-03-13/
  133. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SsSNflRG18E
  134. https://mia.mk/en/story/gashi-%25E2%2580%2593-pellegrini-slovakia-remains-north-macedonias-firm-supporter-on-european-path
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.