Hubbry Logo
Ann HuiAnn HuiMain
Open search
Ann Hui
Community hub
Ann Hui
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ann Hui
Ann Hui
Ann Hui
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Ann Hui On-wah BBS MBE (Chinese: 許鞍華; born 23 May 1947)[1] is a Hong Kong filmmaker and actress. One of the most critically acclaimed filmmakers of the Hong Kong New Wave, she is known for her films about social issues in Hong Kong which include literary adaptations, martial arts, semi-autobiographical works, women's issues, social phenomena, political changes, and thrillers. She served as the president of the Hong Kong Film Directors' Guild from 2004 to 2006.[2]

Key Information

Hui has won numerous awards. She won Best Director at the Golden Horse Awards three times (1999, 2011, 2014); Best Film at the Asia Pacific Film Festival; and Best Director at the Hong Kong Film Awards six times (1983, 1996, 2009, 2012, 2015, 2018).

Only two films have won a Grand Slam (Best Picture, Best Director, Best Screenplay, Best Actor, and Best Actress) at the Hong Kong Film Awards; they are Summer Snow and A Simple Life, both directed by Ann Hui. She was honored for her lifetime accomplishments at the 2012 Asian Film Awards. In 2017, the US based Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences invited Hui to become a member.[3]

Early life

[edit]

Hui was born on 23 May 1947 in Anshan, a Chinese iron-mining city in Liaoning Province.[4] Hui's mother was Japanese and her father was Chinese. In 1952, Hui moved to Macau, then to Hong Kong at the age of five. Hui attended St. Paul's Convent School.[5] She grew up in an old-fashioned Chinese family. Since her grandfather and father both loved classical literature, Hui learned to recite many ancient Chinese poems. When she was in college, Hui worked in the student theater troupe performing as an extra, doing busywork and designing posters. When she had troubles she couldn't resolve, she would go to the cinema to watch a movie.[6]

Education

[edit]

In 1972, Hui earned a master's in English and comparative literature from the University of Hong Kong. Hui studied at the London Film School for two years. Hui wrote her thesis on the works of Alain Robbe-Grillet, a French writer and filmmaker.

Career

[edit]

When Hui returned to Hong Kong after her stay in London, she became an assistant to prominent Chinese film director King Hu. She then began working for Television Broadcasts Limited (TVB) as a scriptwriter-director and produced documentaries such as Wonderful, four episodes of CID, two of Social Worker, and one of the Dragon, Tiger, Panther series. In March 1977 she directed six dramas for the Independent Commission Against Corruption,[7] a Hong Kong organization created to clean up government misconduct. Two of these films were so controversial that they were banned. A year later, Hui directed three episodes of Below the Lion Rock, a documentary series about people from Hong Kong, produced by public broadcasting station, Radio Television Hong Kong. The most recognized episode of Hui's is Boy from Vietnam (1978), which is the start of her Vietnam Trilogy.[8]

In 1979, Hui finally directed her first feature-length film, The Secret, which presents images from the gloomy and dreary old Western District, with its worn-out mansions, shadowy alleys, fallen leaves and religious rituals, such as the ceremonial rite of releasing the soul from purgatory by burning paper money and cutting off the head of a chicken.[7] The Secret earned Hui a Golden Horse Award for Best Feature Film.[9]

In the 1980s, Hui's career was growing internationally. The most popular films of that time were Eastern variations of Hollywood gangster and action films. But Hui did not follow the trend, and instead created more personal films. Many of her best films dealt with cultural displacement. In particular, her central characters are often forced to relocate to another country where they struggle to learn and survive. Hui explores the characters' reactions to new environments and their responses to their return home. During this "New Wave" period, most of her films are sharp and tough, with satirical and political metaphors, reflecting her concern for people; for women; for orphans devastated by war; and for Vietnamese refugees.[10] Her best known works in this category are The Story of Woo Viet (1981) and Boat People (1982) – the remaining two parts of her Vietnam Trilogy. Boat People won the Hong Kong Film Awards for Best Film and Best Director. Although Hui has directed some generic films, another common theme she works with is family conflict, such as in the 1990 film My American Grandson.

Hui's concern for regular people, and especially women, became the most common theme in her films. She creates stories of the experiences of women.[10] One of her most personal works is Song of the Exile (1990), a semi-autobiographical film about family connections and identity.[10] It depicts the story of a young woman, Cheung Hueyin, returning to Hong Kong for her sister's wedding after studying film in London for several years. Hueyin and her mother, who is Japanese, do not seem to have a steady relationship. As the film follows Hueyin's journey to her mother's home town in Japan, Hueyin and her mother are forced to re-examine their relationship, as both have been uprooted from their own countries. "Its narratives of migration also spoke to the displacement of the Hong Kong people as they left the colony in panic to escape the impending Chinese rule."[4] The film won both the Hong Kong Film Awards and Golden Horse Award for Best Director. She served as the president of the Hong Kong Film Directors' Guild in 2004.

In the 1990s, Hui worked on more commercial films. She directed fewer films herself, as she focused on behind-the-scenes work for other filmmakers. The theme of displacement still recurs in her work. During the mid-1990s, Hui started a film project about the Tiananmen Square massacre and the reactions of Hong Kong citizens, but the project was not completed due to lack of funding. Throughout her career, Hui has taken chances to develop more intense and ambitious films while making a name for herself.[11]

Hui said in an interview that she wanted to do more socially conscious projects. She knew the difficulties of finding projects that would do that and "attract investors as well as appeal to the public." Her goal was to "present something that is watchable and at the same time attractive" and allow the public to analyse the social issues involved. Hui is known for making controversial films; the interview, in particular, described the horrors of increased crime and unemployment rates in Tin Shui Wai, Hong Kong. Two of her films that focus on these issues are The Way We Are (2008) and Night and Fog (2009), while maintaining a motif of displacement.[12]

The 45th annual Hong Kong International Film Festival was held in April 2021. Hui was one of the six veteran Hong Kong filmmakers who directed Johnnie To Kei-Fung's highly anticipated anthology film: Septet: The Story of Hong Kong (2020). The other filmmakers were Sammo Hung, Ringo Lam, Patrick Tam Kar-Ming, Tsui Hark, Yuen Woo-ping and Johnnie To. The short films were shot entirely on 35 mm film; each touches on a nostalgic and moving story set across different time periods, with each an ode to the city.[13]

Vietnam Trilogy

[edit]

"Collectively, the three have been named the 'Trilogy of Vietnam', as they all focus on problems involving Vietnam. They are about the tragic destinies of displaced individuals seeking a place to which they can belong and who are struggling in a period of changes, leading in the end to failure."[7]

Boy from Vietnam (1978) is the first film of Hui's Vietnam Trilogy. It chronicles a teenager's illegal entry to Hong Kong and adjustment to life in the city. "As the boy locates his brother, who is already in Hong Kong, moves from a safe house and takes up work, Hui and writers Shu Kei and Wong Chi carefully shed light on the hardships immigrants face in Hong Kong. The new home, it turns out, is no promised land for refugees but more a transit point on a journey elsewhere, and a place where injustice and prejudice are common."[14] This film is historical: in the late 1970s, a large number of Vietnamese boat people illegally immigrated to Hong Kong. This film describes the experience of those who risked their lives in Hong Kong, and shows the setbacks, discrimination and exploitation they experienced when they were only teens.

In 1981, The Story of Woo Viet continued to examine the problem of Vietnamese boat people. Woo Viet, an overseas Chinese from Vietnam, smuggles himself into Hong Kong after trying many times. He gets a pen pal from Hong Kong to help him start over in the United States. However, he is stuck in the Philippines as a hired killer for saving his love. This film describes the hardship of smuggling, the memories of war, the sinister nature of refugee camps, and the crisis in Chinatown.

In 1982, the People's Republic of China, having just ended a war with Vietnam, permitted Hui to film on Hainan Island. Boat People (1982) set in 1978, after the Communist Party began its rule over Vietnam, through the point of view of a Japanese photojournalist, Shiomi Akutagawa, showed the condition of society and political chaos after the Vietnam War. Boat People was the first Hong Kong movie filmed in Communist China. Hui saved a role for Chow Yun-fat, but because at that time Hong Kong actors working in mainland China were banned in Taiwan, Chow Yun-fat declined the role out of fear of being blacklisted. Six months before filming was set to start, and after the film crew was already on location in Hainan, a cameraman suggested that Hui give the role to Andy Lau. At that time, Lau was still a newcomer in the Hong Kong film industry. Hui gave Lau the role and flew him to Hainan before a proper audition or even seeing what he looked like.

Transition from television to film

[edit]

Hui left television in 1979, making her first feature, The Secret, a mystery thriller based on a real-life murder case and starring Taiwanese star Sylvia Chang. It was immediately hailed as an important film in the Hong Kong New Wave. The Spooky Bunch (1981) was her take on the ghost story genre, while The Story of Woo Viet (1981) continued her Vietnam Trilogy. Hui experimented with special effects and daring angles; her preoccupation with sensitive political and social issues is a recurrent feature in most of her subsequent films. Boat People (1982), the third part of her Vietnam Trilogy, is the most famous of her early films. It examines the plight of the Vietnamese after the Vietnam War.[15]

In the mid-1980s Hui continued her string of critically acclaimed works. Love in a Fallen City (1984) was based on a novella by Eileen Chang, and the two-part, ambitious wuxia adaptation of Louis Cha's first novel, The Book and the Sword, was divided into The Romance of Book and Sword (1987) and Princess Fragrance (1987). In 1990, one of her most important works to date, the semi-autobiographical The Song of Exile, was released. The film looks into the loss of identity, disorientation and despair faced by an exiled mother and a daughter faced with clashes in culture and historicity. As in the film, Hui's mother was Japanese.

Post-hiatus work

[edit]

After a brief hiatus in which she returned briefly to television, Hui returned with Summer Snow (1995), about a middle-aged woman trying to cope with everyday family problems and an Alzheimer's-inflicted father-in-law. In 1996, she was a member of the jury at the 46th Berlin International Film Festival.[16]

Eighteen Springs (1997) reprises another Eileen Chang novel. Hui's Ordinary Heroes (1999), about Chinese and Hong Kong political activists from 1970s to the 1990s, won the Best Feature at the Golden Horse Awards.

In 2002, her July Rhapsody, the companion film to Summer Snow about a middle-aged male teacher facing a mid-life crisis, was released to good reviews in Hong Kong and elsewhere. Her film, Jade Goddess of Mercy (2003), starring Zhao Wei and Nicholas Tse, was adapted from a novel from Chinese writer Hai Yan.

In 2008, Hui directed the highly acclaimed domestic drama, The Way We Are. In an interview with Esther M. K. Cheung, Hui recalls working on The Way We Are being the same as working during her "earlier TVB days".

The film has no plot yet people did not find that distracting. I am also very proud of the film's relative technical merits. I was doing completely the same thing as before. People watch the film without knowing why its believable and why it's not boring.[17]

The Way We Are was followed by Night and Fog. "The two films revolve around the mundane lives of the inhabitants of Tin Shui Wai's public housing blocks."[18] In an interview with Muse magazine, Hui explains how she sees the two films as about something uniquely Hong Kong: "[on Night and Fog] I think that this film can represent something; it can express a kind of feeling about the middle and lower class, and maybe even Hong Kong as a whole. Everyone can eat at McDonald's or shop at malls. That's a way of life, but spiritually, there's dissatisfaction, especially with families on welfare. They don't really have any worries about life, but there's an unspeakable feeling of depression.[19]

A Simple Life (2011) premiered at the 68th Venice International Film Festival where it was nominated for the Golden Lion. The film centres on the relationship of two characters, Ah Tao (Deanie Ip) and Roger (Andy Lau). It is a tale about a master and his long-time servant and was based on the relationship producer Roger Lee had with his servant. The film was chosen as Hong Kong's submission to the Academy Awards but did not make the shortlist.[20] Hui could not afford to film A Simple Life until she found Andy Lau. "You make a movie and a lot of people ask you why you do it, and this time I was moved by one person's behavior, by the script." "Because she has always shot a very authentic Hong Kong theme, the reaction on the mainland will not be too special", said Andy Lau. When Hui reached him, she said something that made him sad: "I haven't had enough money for a long time. Can you help me?" Andy Lau said it touched him. "I feel so sad. Sometimes when you make a movie, they say, aren't you afraid to lose money? It's not the best-selling, it's not the most famous, but sometimes you're moved, maybe it's the action, maybe it's the script, and the many little drops add together to make me do it. I work hard to make money every day, so I won't be stupid". He invested 30 million yuan before Yu Dong (president of Bona Film Group Limited) joined. "Both the director and I wanted the film to come out, so we calculated the cost and used it to produce, what I lost was just my salary, just count it as finding someone to play with me for two months."[21]

Hui's 2014 film The Golden Era premiered out of competition at the 71st Venice International Film Festival. It was a biopic based on the lives of writers Xiao Hong and Xiao Jun. Tang Wei and Feng Shaofeng starred.

Our Time Will Come (Chinese: 明月幾時有) is a 2017 war film, starring Zhou Xun, Eddie Peng and Wallace Huo. It revolves around the resistance movement during Japan's occupation of Hong Kong. Mark Jenkins writes, "Fictionalized from actual events, the sumptuously photographed drama centers on Lan (Zhou Xun), a teacher before the Japanese closed the local schools. After she helps smuggle out a noted author (Guo Tao), the young woman is recruited by the insurgents' swashbuckling leader (Eddie Peng). Lan eventually learns that her ex (Wallace Huo Chienhwa) has infiltrated the occupation headquarters, where he discusses classical Chinese verse with a Japanese officer (Masatoshi Nagase, who also portrayed another poetry lover in 'Paterson')."[22] The film opened in China on 1 July 2017, to commemorate and to coincide with the 20th anniversary of the handover of Hong Kong from the United Kingdom to China.

In 2022, Hui was invited to be the Jury President of the 59th Golden Horse Awards.[23]

In February 2024, Hui served as a jury member at the 74th Berlin International Film Festival.[24]

Style, themes and legacy

[edit]

Hui starts with the female perspective, depicting the hearts of women. Most of her films show daily life of women in Hong Kong and create vivid female images through delicate artistic expression. In her movies, women are independent individuals with their own personality. Her films are always full of a sense of drama, but they do not make the audience feel hopeless. They all have an atmosphere of grief, but without pessimism. In her films, there is no terrible conflict, but she uses a plain method to represent the female world. In her movies, women always feel powerlessness, but not all surrender to fate, and they work hard and strive. Hui's feminist films are rich with women's emotions and female consciousness, making the audiences feel the struggle and warmth of women's lives.[25]

As one of the leading figures of Hong Kong's New Wave, Hui has continuously challenged herself and broadened her film career while bringing the audience surprises. This is highlighted in women's stories forming her artistic style. As a female, Hui has created female images using a film language which is unique in the Hong Kong film industry.[26]

In addition, Hui's works discuss the ideas of race and sex in Asian cultures in a sharp tone. Her semi-autobiography work Song of the Exile is one of the examples, showing how a female's identity has been strugglingly constructed in such a cultural context. Audrey Yue writes, "When it was released in 1990, the film's themes of cross-cultural alienation, inter-ethnic marriage, generational reconciliation and divided loyalties resonated with the British colony's 1997 transition to Chinese sovereignty."[4] This "cunningly metaphoric" is said to be one of the most important features of a Hong Kong director in the last few years.[27]

Of Song of the Exile, Audrey Yue writes, "The central motif is the diaspora as the inheritance of exile ... Unlike the term 'exile' that more specifically refers to the psychological condition of people who have been forcefully removed from the homeland, the concept of 'diaspora' focuses more on the conditions of displacement (and resettlement) in the hostland. Migration, mobile work contracts, globalization and cosmopolitanism have enabled the formation of a new world of shifting populations or ethnoscapes."[4]

Hui's films reflect diverse female images. Firstly, she creates submissive women, for example, with Sum Ching in The Story of Woo Viet (1982), Cam Nuong in Boat People (1982), Mang Tit Lan in Zodiac Killers (1991), and Ling in Night and Fog (2009). Facing the injustice of life, these women will only passively accept the arrangement of fate, and silently endure the hardship of life. Hui gives more attention and sympathy to such women, and such films permeate her deep thinking on female destiny. However, Hui also creates female characters with strong sense of rebellion, such as Bai Liu-Su in Love in a Fallen City (1984), May Sun in Summer Snow (1995), Gu Manzhen in Eighteen Springs (1997), and Xiao Hong in The Golden Era (2014). In these films, women are no longer the submissive and cowardly appendages of traditional patriarchy. Instead, they become women who have the courage to fight for their rights.[26]

Ambiguous references to politics are also present. The political dimensions in Hui's films are unconscious. According to Ka-Fai Yau, Hui has said in an interview that she does not understand politics and therefore just does not think about it. But this denial of the political seems at odds with her films and how spectators have viewed them.[28] She also revealed her attitudes on her intention of constructing the stories by reflecting the conditions in social reality:

Filmmakers usually use their eyes to tell a story very subjectively, mixing in a lot of what they think the situation is and how they react to it, but maybe I should set up the problems in this particular situation clearly and show the dilemma rather than adding my solution and qualifying that objective thing with many personal intrusions.[29]

In an interview with Esther M. K. Cheung, Hui revealed:

I distinctly prefer making realist films with a modern-day setting. I don't like costume films, though I can make them. Sometimes I make films just for the sake of making a living.[17]

"Hui also uses voice-over as a device to link scenes and shots. This is a hallmark of Hui's films. In Hui's features, voice-over functions not solely to (1) narrate the plot and (2) bring to the surface the interior thoughts and feelings of the characters, but also (3) to catalyze the connection between shots. In most cases, voice-over is employed to give oral expression to the interior thoughts and feelings of the characters"[7]

The 2021 documentary film Keep Rolling provides an insight into her life's work. It was directed by Hui's frequent collaborator Man Lim-chung in his directorial debut.[30]

Filmography

[edit]

As filmmaker

[edit]
Year Title Role Notes
1978 Below the Lion Rock: From Vietnam; Bridge; Road. Director "From Vietnam" - Hui's first part to her Vietnam Trilogy
1979 The Secret Director Hui's first feature film. The suspense drama about a real-life double murder.[31][32][33]
1980 The Spooky Bunch Director A satiric film about a Cantonese opera company that must go to Cheung Chau to perform for a wealthy man haunted by a ghost.[5]
1981 The Story of Woo Viet Director Starring Chow Yun-fat, the film is Hui's second part to her Vietnam Trilogy, which follows the story of a South Vietnamese refugee in Hong Kong. It was screened at the Director's Fortnight of the Cannes Film Festival.
1982 Boat People Director The third installment of Hui's Vietnam Trilogy. The film was an Official Selection at Cannes and Best Film at the Hong Kong Film Awards
1984 Love in a Fallen City Director Taking place just before the Japanese invasion of Hong Kong, a young man pursues an introverted divorcee.
1987 The Romance of Book and Sword Director/Writer The first part of Hui's Qing Dynasty epic. The film is based on a novel from an old folk's tale.[5]
1987 Princess Fragrance Director The second part of Hui's Qing Dynasty epic. The film journeys through the final half of the Louis Cha's novel The Book and the Sword.[5]
1988 Starry Is the Night Director A school counselor has an affair with a young student and parallels a past affair the counselor had with her professor.[34]
1990 Song of the Exile Director A film loosely based on Hui's experience of returning to Hong Kong after her time in London. The film also reflects the female protagonist's relationship with her Japanese mother.[5]
1990 The Swordsman (uncredited) Director "A kung-fu manual known as the sacred scroll is stolen from the Emperor's library. An army detachment is sent to recover it. Meanwhile, a young swordsman and his fellow disciple are accidentally drawn into the chaos."[35]
1990 My American Grandson Director An elderly Chinese man becomes the caretaker of his 12-year-old grandson.
1991 Zodiac Killers Director Ben, a Chinese student in Japan, falls for Meng and agrees to help her deliver a tape containing information that could start a war between the yakuza families.[36]
1993 Boy and His Hero Director
1995 Summer Snow Director A comedy-drama about a working woman and her husband and son. The woman must care for her father-in-law, whom she had never gotten along with. The film has received several awards.[5]
1996 The Stunt Woman Director The melodrama about a stunt woman (Michelle Yeoh), who is struggling in Hong Kong's film industry.
1997 Eighteen Springs Director A period film of 1930s Shanghai, where a young woman falls in love with a factory worker who is set up with an arranged marriage.
1997 As Time Goes By Director/Writer A man regrets his wish for time to speed up when it comes true.
1999 Ordinary Heroes Director/Producer The film revolves around the lives of social reform activists in Hong Kong. It competed at the 49th International Berlin Film Festival in 1999.[37]
2001 Visible Secret Director/Producer "An unemployed hairdresser and a strange nurse meet at a club and start a romance. Since meeting her, the young man encounters unexplained things which she says are spirits she can see."[38]
2002 July Rhapsody Director/Producer The film is about the relationships of a young female student falling in love and seducing her teacher.[37][39]
2003 Jade Goddess of Mercy Director The film is an adaptation of a popular book that describes the lives of everyday police men. The protagonist is a female police officer, who must deal with choices between three men in her life and her career.
2006 The Postmodern Life of My Aunt Director/Writer A woman in her sixties discovers she is falling behind in the times, as she loses her job as an English tutor.
2008 The Way We Are Director This drama tells the story of a working woman, Kwai, who must take care of her teenage son and ailing mother. Kwai befriends an older woman, and the two learn to help each other.
2009 Night and Fog Director/Producer A family struggles in Tin Shui Wai, while a marriage between a husband and wife turns fatal.
2010 All About Love Director/Producer The film portrays the difficulty and challenges which lesbians in Hong Kong must face.
2011 A Simple Life Director/Producer A story about an elderly female servant, who has watched over a family for many generations.[33]
2014 The Golden Era Director With the Republic of China era as the background, this is the story of legendary female writer Xiao Hong's life and loves.[33]
2017 Our Time Will Come Director Based on the true story of the "Dong Jiang column", set in the 1940s, the film tells the story of legendary woman Fang Gu (Zhou Xun), who is one of the key figures during the Japanese occupation of Hong Kong.
2020 Love After Love Director/Producer Based on Eileen Chang's novella, Aloeswood Incense: The First Brazier, the film is a love story set in 1940s Hong Kong. The film tells the story of a young girl who travels from Shanghai to Hong Kong in pursuit of education, but ends up working for her aunt seducing rich and powerful men.
2020 Septet: The Story of Hong Kong Director Seven of Hong Kong's leading filmmakers have come together to each direct a short film set in Hong Kong during one decade from the 1950s to the 2020s.
2023 Elegies Director Documentary

As actress

[edit]

Ann Hui has appeared mostly in cameo roles in several films:

Awards

[edit]

Film awards

[edit]
Year Festival Category Nominated work Result
1983 2nd Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Boat People Won
Best Picture Won
1988 7th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director The Romance of Book & Sword Nominated
1990 Asia Pacific Film Festival Best Film Song of the Exile Won
Rimini Festival Best Film Nominated
Golden Horse Film Festival and Awards Best Film Nominated
1991 10th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Nominated
Best Picture Nominated
1995 45th Berlin International Film Festival[40] Golden Bear Summer Snow Nominated
Golden Horse Film Festival and Awards Best Film Won
Golden Bauhinia Awards Best Director Won
Best Picture Won
Hong Kong Film Critics Society Best Picture Won
Créteil International Women's Film Festival Best Film Won
68th Academy Awards Best Foreign Language Film Not nominated
1996 15th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Won
Best Picture Won
1999 36th Golden Horse Awards Best Director Ordinary Heroes Won
72nd Academy Awards Best Foreign Language Film Not nominated
49th Berlin International Film Festival[41] Golden Bear Nominated
2000 19th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Nominated
2001 8th Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards Best Director Visible Secret Won
2002 21st Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Nominated
July Rhapsody Nominated
2004 26th Moscow International Film Festival[42] Golden George Jade Goddess of Mercy Nominated
Verona Film Festival Audience Award Won
Best Film Nominated
2007 14th Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards Best Director The Postmodern Life of My Aunt Won
2008 27th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Nominated
15th Hong Kong Film Critics Society Awards Best Director The Way We Are Won
2008 Fukuoka Prize[43] Grand Prize Ann Hui Won
2009 28th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director The Way We Are Won
2010 29th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Night and Fog Nominated
2011 48th Golden Horse Awards Best Director A Simple Life Won
84th Academy Awards Best Foreign Language Film Not nominated
2012 31st Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director Won
2015 34th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Director The Golden Era Won
Best Film Won
2017 54th Golden Horse Awards Best Director Our Time Will Come Nominated
2018 12th Asian Film Awards Best Director Nominated
37th Hong Kong Film Awards Best Film Won
Best Director Won


Personal awards

[edit]
Year Festival Category
1997 47th Berlin International Film Festival[44] Berlinale Camera
Order of the British Empire Awarded MBE (Member of British Empire)
2012 Hong Kong International Film Festival Lifetime Achievement Award[45]
Asian Film Awards Lifetime Achievement Award[45]
2014 19th Busan International Film Festival Asian Filmmaker of the Year[5]
2020 77th Venice International Film Festival Golden Lion for Lifetime Achievement[46][33][47]
2021 20th New York Asian Film Festival Star Asia Lifetime Achievement Award[48][49]

Further reading

[edit]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ann Hui

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Ann Hui On-wah (許鞍華; born 23 May 1947) is a Hong Kong film director, producer, screenwriter, and actress. Born in Anshan, Liaoning Province, China, to a Chinese father and Japanese mother, Hui relocated to Macau as a child before settling in Hong Kong at age five. She earned bachelor's and master's degrees in English and comparative literature from the University of Hong Kong, followed by film studies at the London Film School. A pioneering voice in Hong Kong cinema during the late 1970s and 1980s, Hui has directed nearly 30 feature films that explore the everyday struggles of ordinary people, including Vietnamese refugees and residents amid Hong Kong's social transformations. Her work has garnered widespread acclaim, including a record six Best Director awards at the Hong Kong Film Awards and three at the Golden Horse Awards, alongside lifetime honors such as the 2020 Venice Golden Lion for Lifetime Achievement.

Early Life and Education

Childhood and Family Origins

Ann Hui was born on May 23, 1947, in , Province, in northeastern (then known as ), to an ethnic Chinese father and a Japanese mother. Her mixed parentage reflected the complex intercultural dynamics of the region following Japan's occupation during , with her mother's Japanese heritage stemming from that era's historical migrations and alliances. The family relocated amid the political upheavals of revolutionary , first to Macao and then to [Hong Kong](/page/Hong Kong) when Hui was five years old, seeking stability away from the mainland's turmoil. This early displacement shaped Hui's diasporic perspective, influencing her later focus on themes of migration and identity in her films, though her childhood in provided a foundation in a vibrant, multicultural urban environment. Limited public details exist on her dynamics beyond her parents' origins, as Hui has maintained privacy regarding personal matters, emphasizing instead the broader socio-historical context of her upbringing in interviews.

Academic Training and Influences

Ann Hui earned a with first-class honours in English and from the , followed by a degree in the same field from the same institution. Her master's thesis focused on the works of , the French author known for experimental narratives and rejection of traditional plotting, reflecting an early academic engagement with innovative literary forms that emphasized subjective perception over linear storytelling. This literary background, combined with familial exposure to —recited from a young age due to her grandfather's and father's affinity for ancient literature—shaped her appreciation for narrative depth and cultural specificity in storytelling. In 1975, Hui advanced her training at the London Film School, where she completed a with first-class honours after two years of study in filmmaking techniques, including directing and production. During this period, she encountered the acclaimed wuxia director , whose mastery of visual storytelling and genre innovation influenced her approach to blending artistry with commercial viability; upon returning to , she apprenticed as his assistant on martial arts s, gaining practical insights into set dynamics and narrative adaptation from to screen. This hands-on mentorship complemented her formal education, emphasizing editing and nonfiction techniques honed later at , where she directed documentaries that prioritized empirical observation of social realities over stylized fiction.

Career Development

Initial Work in Television and Documentaries

Upon returning to Hong Kong after completing her film studies at the in 1974, Ann Hui initially assisted veteran director before joining , where she directed television serials and short documentaries focused on social issues. In 1977, she produced and directed six educational films for the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC), emphasizing themes through narrative-driven content that blended factual reporting with dramatic elements. In 1978, Hui contributed to public broadcaster Radio Television Hong Kong (RTHK)'s anthology series Below the Lion Rock, directing three episodes that portrayed the everyday struggles of ordinary residents amid rapid social changes. The most prominent of these, The Boy from Vietnam (also titled From Vietnam), aired on November 18, 1978, and depicted a Vietnamese teenager's clandestine arrival in as a , his search for family, and adaptation to local hardships as a . Running approximately 54 minutes, the episode employed documentary-style realism to highlight the influx of , drawing from real experiences without overt didacticism. These television works marked Hui's early experimentation with hybrid forms, merging observational techniques—such as on-location shooting and non-professional actors—with scripted to evoke empathy for marginalized communities, including refugees and the . This approach, honed under constraints typical of Hong Kong's public and in the late , foreshadowed her later feature films' emphasis on and human resilience. By 1979, having established her reputation in television, Hui transitioned to theatrical features, leaving behind these formative broadcast projects.

The Vietnam Trilogy and Breakthrough

Ann Hui's Vietnam Trilogy comprises three works centered on the experiences of Vietnamese refugees fleeing post-war hardships: Below the Lion Rock: The Boy from Vietnam (1978), The Story of Woo Viet (1981), and Boat People (1982). These films emerged from Hui's direct engagement with the influx of boat people arriving in during the late and early 1980s, drawing on her volunteer work at refugee camps to depict the human cost of political upheaval in . The trilogy marked Hui's shift toward feature-length narrative cinema, blending documentary realism with dramatic storytelling to address themes of displacement, survival, and cultural dislocation. Below the Lion Rock: The Boy from Vietnam, a 1978 episode in the public affairs anthology series Below the Lion Rock, served as the trilogy's inception. Directed amid Hong Kong's hosting of tens of thousands of Indochinese refugees, it follows a young Vietnamese boy's adaptation to life in the territory, highlighting initial encounters with asylum seekers. Produced for , the film reflected Hui's roots in television while foreshadowing her focus on marginalized communities overlooked by mainstream cinema. The Story of Woo Viet, released on April 24, 1981, expanded the trilogy into Hui's second feature film. Starring Chow Yun-fat as Woo Viet, a Vietnamese refugee navigating criminal underworlds in Hong Kong to fund his passage to the United States, the narrative exposes the exploitation and desperation faced by undocumented migrants. Shot on location with non-professional actors from refugee backgrounds, it received praise for its gritty authenticity and contributed to Hui's emerging reputation for social commentary, though it garnered moderate box-office success compared to her subsequent work. Boat People, released in 1982, culminated the trilogy and achieved Hui's critical breakthrough. Set in three years after the fall of Saigon, the film follows Japanese photojournalist Shiomi Akutagawa (played by ) as he uncovers systemic oppression, forced labor, and famine under the communist regime, prompting mass exodus by sea. Hui's on-location shooting in , secured through rare permissions, lent unprecedented , with the production employing Vietnamese refugees for authenticity. At the 2nd Hong Kong Film Awards, it secured five major prizes, including Best Picture and Best Director for Hui, alongside international screenings that elevated her profile as a voice on crises. The film's unflinching portrayal of authoritarian brutality drew acclaim for humanizing victims of ideological excess, solidifying Hui's transition to commercial viability while establishing her as a pioneer of cinema's socially engaged strand.

Expansion into Commercial Cinema

Following the acclaim for her Vietnam Trilogy, which concluded with Boat People in 1982, Ann Hui transitioned toward commercially viable projects, adapting literary works and embracing popular genres to navigate Hong Kong's competitive film market during the economic boom. This shift allowed her to sustain a directorial career amid industry pressures for box-office appeal, while retaining elements of social observation. Her early post-trilogy efforts included Love in a Fallen City (), a period romance adapted from Eileen Chang's novella, starring and , which explored themes of love and exile in 1940s but incorporated dramatic staging and star power to attract mainstream viewers. Hui's most explicit venture into commercial genre filmmaking came with two wuxia adaptations in 1987: The Romance of Book and Sword and its sequel Princess Fragrance, based on Louis Cha's (Jin Yong) epic novel depicting 18th-century rebel intrigue against the Qing dynasty. These productions, filmed partly in mainland China with a Chinese cast including Ti Lung and Yang Lihua, emphasized martial arts spectacle, historical pageantry, and heroic narratives—hallmarks of Hong Kong's lucrative swordplay cycle—departing from her prior realism to prioritize action sequences and mass entertainment. The films capitalized on the genre's popularity, driven by studios like Golden Harvest, though Hui later reflected on their technical challenges and her limited experience in effects-heavy action as a pragmatic response to market demands rather than artistic preference. This phase demonstrated Hui's adaptability, blending New Wave sensibilities with commercial formulas; for instance, the duo critiqued imperial hypocrisy amid swashbuckling plots, echoing her interest in power dynamics but tailored for broader release. Subsequent works like Starry Is the Night (1988), a , further illustrated her genre experimentation, contributing to her reputation for balancing artistic integrity with financial viability in an industry dominated by high-grossing action and romance. By the decade's end, these efforts had established her as a versatile figure capable of mainstream hits, paving the way for later successes such as Summer Snow (1995), a dramedy that grossed over HK$40 million and won multiple awards for its accessible portrayal of .

Periods of Hiatus and Resurgence

Following the commercial failure of her 1991 film My American Grandson, which explored generational and cultural clashes between and , Ann Hui experienced a period of inactivity in directing lasting roughly three to four years. This hiatus stemmed directly from the project's poor reception, prompting a temporary withdrawal from theatrical projects amid 's evolving landscape in the early . Hui's resurgence began with Summer Snow (1995), a dramedy depicting a middle-class family's struggles with an elderly member's , which marked her return to critical and commercial acclaim. The film earned praise for its empathetic portrayal of domestic tensions, with critic Paul Fonoroff noting in the that it represented Hui's strongest work to date after her break. Summer Snow secured multiple Hong Kong Film Awards, including Best Director and Best Film, revitalizing her career and enabling subsequent projects like The Stunt Woman (1996) and Ordinary Heroes (1999). This pattern of selective pauses amid consistent output characterized Hui's later decades, though no extended hiatuses comparable to the early 1990s occurred; she maintained productivity through the 2000s and 2010s with films such as July Rhapsody (2002) and A Simple Life (2011), the latter earning international recognition including a Golden Lion nomination at the Venice Film Festival. Her ongoing resurgence into the 2020s, evidenced by Love After Love (2020) and Elegies (2023), reflects sustained relevance in Hong Kong cinema despite industry contractions.

Recent Projects and Adaptations

In 2020, Hui directed Love After Love (Di lu xiang), an adaptation of Eileen Chang's 1944 "Aloeswood Incense: The First Brazier," marking her third film based on the author's works following Love in a Fallen City (1984) and Eighteen Springs (1997). The narrative follows a young woman from who relocates to 1930s for education, navigating familial obligations, financial dependency on her aunt, and romantic entanglements amid pre-war tensions, with Hui emphasizing the story's "brutal" depiction of human motivations. Starring as the protagonist, alongside and Fan Wei, the film premiered out of competition at the on September 6, 2020, and received mixed reviews for its visual period authenticity but criticism for perceived deviations from Chang's concise prose in favor of melodramatic expansion. That same year, Hui contributed the segment "Headmaster" to the anthology : The Story of Hong Kong, a collaborative project produced by featuring seven directors chronicling the city's history across decades through ordinary lives. Set in 1961, Hui's episode portrays a primary school class under the guidance of a reserved headmaster and an unmarried English teacher, exploring themes of unfulfilled desires, educational rigor, and social restraint in post-war society, with critics noting it as one of the anthology's stronger, more poignant entries. Hui's most recent directorial effort, the 2023 documentary Elegies (Shi), profiles Hong Kong's contemporary poetry scene through intimate interviews with poets including the unrestrained Huang Canran, the cosmopolitan Liu Waitong, and the late , capturing their daily routines, creative processes, and reflections on the form's cultural decline amid and political shifts. Produced by PicaPica Media, the film dissects poetry's role in preserving identity, with Hui drawing from personal encounters to map the "topography" of urban verse against the city's commercial dominance, earning praise for its tone on artistic marginalization.

Artistic Approach and Thematic Concerns

Directorial Style and Techniques

Ann Hui's directorial style is characterized by a commitment to social realism, drawing heavily from her early documentary work and emphasizing naturalistic portrayals of ordinary lives amid historical and social upheavals. Influenced by Taiwanese New Cinema directors such as Hou Hsiao-hsien and Edward Yang, she prioritizes character-driven narratives that emerge organically from extensive research, allowing stories to unfold through subtle, everyday details rather than overt dramatics. In films like The Way We Are (2008), Hui employs a minimalist framework with "studied spontaneity" and "actuality staging" to evoke documentary verisimilitude, using everyday objects—such as newspapers or plastic bags—as poetic motifs to underscore themes of routine and resilience without analytical exposition. Her approach often vacillates between restrained observation and genre experimentation, as seen in the swaying handheld photography of Boat People (1982), which heightens intra-frame contrasts through long takes to convey precarious survival in post-war Vietnam. Technically, Hui favors techniques that prioritize structural integrity over stylistic flourishes, asserting that "structure [is] even more important than how you shoot your ," with the script's dictating camera placement, , and overall aesthetic cohesion. She integrates jittery handheld shots for immediacy in dynamic scenes, juxtaposed with static long takes and inert framings to sustain visual interest through dense , as in the cramped interiors of The Way We Are that reflect generational spatial dynamics. remains unobtrusive, avoiding rapid analytical cuts in favor of single, extended takes—such as a 31-second unbroken conversation—to preserve subtlety and compel viewer interpretation. complements this restraint, relying on ambient diegetic elements like ringing tones or sparse piano motifs for emotional underscoring, while minimizing nondiegetic scores to avoid sentimentality. In directing actors, Hui adopts a passive, documentary-like demeanor, observing and approving authentic behaviors on set while fostering trust through preparation—reviewing performers' past roles and delivering candid feedback to elicit their best efforts without excessive retakes. This hands-on, research-intensive process, honed from television and commercial work, reflects her philosophy of sustained observation over theoretical abstraction, enabling a versatile adaptation across genres from intimate dramas to period epics. Her oeuvre thus balances formal precision with humanistic empathy, prioritizing the "sheer joy" of reactive to capture unadorned truths of Hong Kong's socio-political fabric.

Recurring Themes in Social Realism

Ann Hui's social realist films consistently foreground the everyday hardships of marginalized groups, emphasizing migration, displacement, and amid political turmoil. In The Story of Woo Viet (1981) and Boat People (1982), part of her Vietnam Trilogy, she documents the plight of Vietnamese refugees escaping post-war communist , depicting their encounters with , labor exploitation, and makeshift communities in Hong Kong's refugee camps, where over 200,000 boat people arrived between 1975 and 1982. These works draw from real eyewitness accounts and Hui's own visits to camps, portraying not heroic escapes but the grinding realism of family separations and economic desperation. Another persistent motif is the erosion of traditional family structures under urban pressures and demographic shifts, particularly the burdens of elder care in Hong Kong's rapidly aging society. Summer Snow (1995) illustrates a working-class family's navigation of Alzheimer's caregiving alongside financial strain, reflecting the rise in elderly dependency ratios as Hong Kong's population aged. Similarly, A Simple Life (2011) examines the reciprocal bonds between a lifelong domestic helper and her affluent employer, underscoring themes of , isolation, and the of personal relationships in a materialistic urban environment where over 30% of the population lived in by the . Hui recurrently spotlights resilience against institutional neglect, as in Ordinary Heroes (1999), which chronicles 1980s social activists aiding prostitutes, orphans, and the mentally ill amid Hong Kong's pre-handover anxieties, drawing from real figures like activist Yip Kim-wah to critique apathy toward the vulnerable. Her approach to avoids sentimentality, employing naturalistic performances and to capture unvarnished portraits of working-class existence, evident in The Way We Are (2008), a slice-of-life depiction of residents grappling with and domestic tensions in isolated new towns housing over 300,000 low-income families. These narratives prioritize causal links between policy failures—such as refugee policies or housing shortages—and personal suffering, informed by Hui's documentary background and commitment to amplifying voiceless communities.

Critical Evaluations of Her Oeuvre

Ann Hui's films have been widely praised by critics and scholars for their humanistic portrayal of marginalized lives and social undercurrents in and beyond, often blending documentary realism with narrative depth to evoke empathy without didacticism. Her oeuvre, spanning over four decades, is noted for foregrounding the "cinematics of ," capturing the struggles of ordinary individuals amid geopolitical shifts, such as colonial legacies and post-1997 anxieties, which positions her work at the margins of mainstream cinema while influencing its evolution. This approach, rooted in her training and collaborations, earns acclaim for bridging personal stories with broader historical contexts, as seen in her exploration of and identity in films like Song of the Exile (1990), where familial reconciliation serves as a lens for societal understanding. Key works such as Boat People (1982) exemplify Hui's strength in humanizing victims of , depicting Vietnamese ordeals with stark visual contrasts between official and raw suffering, which critics describe as a persistent, unflinching vision prioritizing individual agency over overt political allegory. However, some evaluations critique the film for offering sympathy to the oppressed without sufficient historical or analytical rigor, potentially reverting to emotional conservatism rather than probing systemic causes. Similarly, her social realist dramas like Summer Snow (1995) are lauded for sensitively addressing taboo subjects such as in families, winning international recognition including a Best Actress award at the , yet broader New Wave contributions faced mixed reception for uneven quality amid genre experimentation. Scholarly analyses highlight Hui's stylistic innovations, including non-linear narratives and montages that challenge patriarchal viewing norms, particularly through female-centric perspectives that subvert traditional melodramas while negotiating commercial demands. As a female filmmaker, her emphasis on "dis-embodied female voices" in works like Ah Kam (1996) disrupts male-dominated spectatorship, fostering narratives of resilience amid cultural flux, though some argue her gender discourse remains surface-level in phallocentric genres. Critics like Ackbar Abbas interpret her personal-political interplay as essential for decoding Hong Kong's "disappearing" culture, while others, such as Li Cheuk-to, note a tendency toward nostalgic simplification of colonial dynamics. Recent evaluations of her later films, including documentaries like Keep Rolling (2020) and Elegies (2023), affirm Hui's enduring relevance, portraying her as a persevering figure whose eclectic output—from horror to historical epics—sustains thematic consistency in identity and , even if eschewing mainstream appeal. This body of work is credited with enriching cinema's , influencing subsequent generations by prioritizing causal human experiences over ideological imposition, though occasional critiques persist regarding depth in geopolitical allegories.

Political Dimensions and Public Stance

Depictions of Authoritarian Systems

Boat People (1982), the final installment of Ann Hui's Vietnam trilogy, provides her most direct cinematic examination of a communist authoritarian regime, set in Vietnam three years after the 1975 communist victory and takeover of Saigon. The film centers on a Japanese photojournalist, played by , dispatched to capture the official narrative of postwar reconstruction and socialist harmony, only to uncover systemic brutality including forced labor in re-education camps, public executions for , ethnic of Hoa Chinese communities, and a network of enforced by local cadres and informants. Hui constructed these portrayals from extensive interviews with over 100 Vietnamese boat refugees who had fled to , emphasizing empirical accounts of rationed scarcity, suppressed religious practices, and coerced participation in state propaganda events that masked underlying and repression. The depiction underscores causal mechanisms of authoritarian control, such as the regime's monopolization of information and economy, which fostered black-market desperation, familial betrayals for survival, and mass exodus attempts by sea—over 800,000 Vietnamese fled between and , with Hui's narrative capturing the perilous "boat people" driven by these conditions. Filmed on location in shortly after the 1979 , the production incorporated testimonies to illustrate how initial ideological conformity crumbled under lived hardships, including scenes of cadre-enforced denunciations and child labor in collective farms. While some left-leaning critics in the West labeled the film as anti-communist for highlighting these realities without endorsing the regime's reforms, Hui insisted her focus remained on amid systemic rather than ideological . Hui extends her scrutiny to non-communist in Our Time Will Come (2016), which reconstructs the Japanese of from 1941 to 1945, portraying imperial enforcers' tactics of resource extraction, public beheadings, and collaborationist puppet regimes to suppress local resistance. Drawing from historical records and survivor narratives, the film details underground networks supplies and intelligence against Japanese oversight, revealing parallels in authoritarian reliance on fear, informants, and cultural erasure—such as bans on Chinese education and forced labor affecting over 10,000 Hong Kongers. These elements highlight resistance as a response to totalizing control, with Hui using period-specific details like ration coupons and broadcasts to ground the depiction in verifiable wartime oppression.

Reflections on Hong Kong Society and Identity

Ann Hui's films frequently examine 's distinct societal fabric and evolving sense of identity, portraying it as a hybrid cultural space shaped by colonial legacies, migration, and tensions with . Through social realist narratives, she highlights the everyday struggles of ordinary residents, including class disparities, familial bonds, and the erosion of local traditions amid and political transitions. Her works often underscore 's linguistic and cultural autonomy, contrasting it with encroaching Sino-centric influences post-1997 . In (2011), Hui depicts the life of Ah Tao, a longtime domestic helper whose illness and death symbolize the decline of traditional identity in a post-handover increasingly oriented toward mainland integration. The film contrasts Ah Tao's rooted local customs—such as home-cooked meals—with the protagonist Roger's accommodation to broader Chinese economic dominance, reflecting broader societal shifts toward . Similarly, Ordinary Heroes (1999) chronicles 1980s social activists aiding Vietnamese refugees and laborers, framing their principled isolation as emblematic of 's core identity: resilient yet marginalized pursuits of in a pragmatic, apolitical society. Hui's exploration of identity extends to historical displacements, as in Song of the Exile (1990), where a woman's journey across , , and interrogates "floating" hybrid identities amid political upheavals, prefiguring handover anxieties. In Love After Love (2020), adapted from , she reconstructs 1940s colonial as a restless, multicultural hub of refugees and elites, emphasizing liminal East-West identities and the era's social hierarchies rarely documented today. However, Our Time Will Come (2017), focusing on wartime resistance against Japanese occupation, adopts a mainland co-production perspective that portrays Hong Kong's as interdependent with , diverging from Hui's typical assertion of local distinctiveness. In interviews, Hui has reflected on generational divides in identity , stating her cohort "knows our identity better" and urging youth to temper aggressive assertions, viewing as a non-confrontational avenue for societal expression. Her oeuvre thus serves as a of Hong Kong's societal mutations—from postcolonial flux to post-handover —prioritizing memory and ethical dilemmas over overt polemics.

Engagement with Broader Geopolitical Issues

Ann Hui's engagement with broader geopolitical issues manifests primarily through her cinematic explorations of historical conflicts and their ripple effects on migration, identity, and authoritarian in . Her Vietnamese refugee trilogy—beginning with the television documentary The Boy from Vietnam (1978), followed by The Story of Woo Viet (1981), and culminating in Boat People (1982)—addresses the aftermath of the and the establishment of communist rule in 1975. Boat People, shot on location in , portrays the desperation of civilians under Vietnam's socialist regime, including forced labor, surveillance, and perilous escapes by sea, drawing from real testimonies to humanize the crisis that displaced over 1.6 million Vietnamese between 1975 and 1995. This work implicitly critiques the geopolitical fallout of U.S. intervention, Soviet-Vietnamese alignment, and subsequent Sino-Vietnamese border conflicts in 1979, while serving as an allegory for Hong Kong's anxieties over its 1997 to amid ongoing Sino-British negotiations. In Our Time Will Come (2016), Hui examines Hong Kong's resistance to Japanese occupation during World War II, focusing on the East River Column's guerrilla operations from 1942 onward, which involved smuggling intellectuals like Mao Dun to mainland China and sabotaging imperial forces. The film highlights the interplay of British colonial legacies, Japanese cultural suppression, and Chinese nationalist-communist alliances in the broader Sino-Japanese War (1937–1945), portraying Hong Kong's wartime identity as intertwined with mainland support rather than autonomous. Co-produced with China's Bona Film Group and approved by state censors, it opened in mainland China on July 1, 2017—timed with the 20th anniversary of Hong Kong's handover—reflecting a narrative emphasis on regional unity against external aggression, though Hui has emphasized personal stories over ideological endorsement. Hui has maintained that her films avoid explicit political advocacy, prioritizing humanistic dilemmas over partisan statements, as evidenced by her reflections on the 1989 events, which prompted her to question personal loyalties amid Hong Kong's insulated worldview compared to the overt political upheavals in and . Song of the Exile (1990), spanning locations from to and , further illustrates this by tracing diaspora driven by wartime displacements and the Chinese (1966–1976), underscoring how geopolitical shifts—such as Japan's pre-war migrations and post-war repatriations—fracture familial and cultural ties without resolving them ideologically. Despite such thematic depth, Hui has distanced her work from deliberate geopolitical commentary, noting in 1991 that Hong Kong filmmakers often lack the direct exposure to continental power struggles that shapes narratives elsewhere in the region.

Controversies and Critiques

Reception and Backlash to Boat People

Upon its release in 1982, Boat People received widespread critical acclaim in , winning five awards at the second Hong Kong Film Awards, including Best Picture, Best Director for Ann Hui, Best Screenplay, Best New Performer, and Best Art Direction. The film was selected for the at the , where it was praised for its unflinching portrayal of oppression and human suffering under Vietnam's post-war communist regime, drawing on testimonies from actual Vietnamese refugees resettled in . Critics highlighted its technical achievements, such as realistic depictions of re-education camps, public executions, and forced labor, which humanized the "boat people" exodus and elevated Hui's status within the . Internationally, the film garnered recognition for its narrative focus on survival amid totalitarian control, with reviewers noting its basis in empirical accounts of Vietnamese atrocities following the 1975 , rather than ideological fabrication. However, it faced backlash from left-leaning Western critics, who dismissed it as anti-communist lacking historical context, accusing it of a one-sided portrayal that ignored broader geopolitical factors in Vietnam's reconstruction. At its U.S. premiere during the , detractors argued the film's emphasis on regime brutality decontextualized events, prioritizing emotional impact over nuanced analysis of post-colonial dynamics. The depiction of systemic violence— including informant networks, , and mass escapes—provoked political , with some viewing it as an critiquing beyond , potentially applicable to other communist states. Chinese authorities expressed displeasure, possibly due to the film's indirect reflections on socialist governance parallels, while French officials objected amid sensitivities over Indochina's legacy. In , the government banned Hui and her early works in the early explicitly because of Boat People, citing its content as incompatible with official narratives on . Despite such opposition, the film's evidentiary grounding in experiences lent credibility to its claims, countering labels by prioritizing causal accounts of displacement over partisan .

Debates Over Political Neutrality

Ann Hui's film Boat People (1982), which portrayed the dire post-war conditions in including re-education camps and widespread persecution, sparked significant controversy over perceived political bias against the communist regime. The film's release elicited attacks from various political factions in and abroad, with detractors accusing Hui of anti-communist and exploiting Vietnamese suffering to advance an ideological agenda. In response to the backlash, Hui publicly asserted her ideological neutrality, describing Boat People as a humanist narrative focused on individual survival rather than partisan politics, and emphasizing that her intent was not to critique any system but to document human endurance based on eyewitness accounts from Vietnamese refugees. This defense marked an early instance of Hui distancing her oeuvre from explicit ideology, a position she would reiterate amid subsequent debates. Debates persisted into later years, particularly as Hui's works engaged Hong Kong's evolving identity amid the 1997 handover to and ensuing tensions. Critics questioned whether films like Ordinary Heroes (1999), which examined Chinese migrant laborers and political dissidents in 1960s-1970s , implicitly favored pro-democracy or localist sentiments over Beijing's narrative. Hui maintained that her portrayals stemmed from personal and historical inquiry rather than advocacy, though some observers noted the films' alignment with liberal critiques of . In public statements, Hui has expressed reluctance to overtly politicalize her commentary, stating in a that she preferred her films to implicitly convey views on Hong Kong's struggles without direct pronouncements, amid sensitivities post-2019 protests. Several of her productions faced bans or restrictions in and due to depictions challenging official histories, fueling arguments that her "neutrality" masked subtle resistance to centralized control. Despite such , Hui has consistently rejected labels of partisanship, framing her career as rooted in social observation over doctrinal alignment.

Artistic and Commercial Compromises

Throughout her career, Ann Hui has resisted commercial pressures that could undermine her artistic independence, such as declining offers in the early 1990s to direct Category III or sword-fighting epics, which she viewed as threats to her creative autonomy. Instead, she has reworked popular genres like into forms of counter-cinema, subverting formulaic expectations while incorporating accessible elements such as established stars and narrative conventions to achieve modest commercial stability across her 15 films examined in scholarly analyses up to the mid-1990s. This approach allowed her to maintain experimental techniques, including innovative use of flashbacks in films like The Secret (1979) and Song of the Exile (1990), without fully conforming to Hong Kong's market-driven industry norms. Hui's navigation of these tensions is evident in specific projects that straddle artistic and commercial boundaries. For instance, Song of the Exile (1990) emerged as a hybrid she later critiqued as "too much of a cross between things... something between a commercial film and an art movie," unintentionally blending personal lyricism with broader appeal, though she expressed dissatisfaction with its lack of inventive execution. Following early breakthroughs like Boat People (1982), Hui endured a decade of box office disappointments, including consecutive failures with The Stunt Woman (1996) and Eighteen Springs (1997), the latter an adaptation featuring prominent actors that nonetheless underperformed financially despite her conscious efforts to avoid overly commercial dilutions. These setbacks, reflected upon in the 2020 documentary Keep Rolling, underscored her persistence amid commercial shortfalls, as she characterized the period as one of repeated market rejections for her socially conscious works. In interviews, Hui has emphasized strategic choices to preserve her vision, such as selecting collaborators based on sympathy to the project rather than commercial prestige, noting that half her career energy has gone toward negotiations in Hong Kong's adverse climate rather than pure creation. She has also ventured into , including epics and romantic comedies, alongside personal dramas, to sustain her output without fully capitulating to profit-driven formulas. This balancing act reflects her broader philosophy of prioritizing purpose over profit, enabling endurance in an industry where artistic experimentation often clashes with financial imperatives.

Legacy and Recognition

Influence on Hong Kong New Wave and Beyond

Ann Hui emerged as a foundational figure in the cinema movement, which began in 1979 and challenged the dominant commercial formulas of the era by incorporating , experimental techniques, and international influences from her training at the London Film School. Her early works, such as The Secret (1979) and The Spooky Bunch (1980), introduced nuanced explorations of local folklore and urban alienation, diverging from the industry's formulaic and comedies to emphasize character-driven narratives and documentary-style authenticity. As one of the few female directors in this predominantly male cohort—alongside peers like and Patrick Tam—Hui's presence helped diversify the movement's perspectives, particularly through her focus on marginalized voices, including refugees and working-class women, as seen in The Story of Woo Viet (1981), which examined Vietnamese boat people's struggles in . Hui's contributions extended the New Wave's emphasis on , broadening cinema's creative scope by integrating themes of class disparity, gender dynamics, and postcolonial identity, which influenced the industry's shift toward more introspective and globally resonant storytelling. Her film Boat People (), shot on location in despite risks, exemplified this by critiquing authoritarian oppression through firsthand refugee testimonies, setting a precedent for politically engaged filmmaking that elevated cinema's artistic credibility on the international stage. This approach not only critiqued local societal issues but also anticipated the territory's anxieties, fostering a cinematic language that prioritized empirical observation over escapist entertainment. Beyond the New Wave's peak in the 1980s, Hui's enduring career—spanning over four decades and including six Best Director wins at the Hong Kong Film Awards—has shaped subsequent generations by modeling persistence in mainstream viability for independent voices, particularly women filmmakers facing industry barriers. Her humanistic lens on aging, migration, and cultural hybridity in later films like A Simple Life (2011) continues to bridge local narratives with universal themes, influencing directors to prioritize social realism amid Hong Kong's evolving political landscape. While Hui has expressed skepticism about direct mentorship, stating in 2020 that young filmmakers require autonomy rather than elder intervention, her oeuvre serves as a cultural archetype, inspiring a reevaluation of Hong Kong identity in global cinema contexts.

Awards and Professional Honors

Ann Hui has garnered extensive recognition for her contributions to cinema, particularly through competitive awards at major Asian film festivals. She holds the record for the most Best Director wins at the Hong Kong Film Awards, with six victories spanning films such as Boat People (1982), Summer Snow (1995), Ordinary Heroes (1999), A Simple Life (2011), The Golden Era (2014), and Our Time Will Come (2017). At the Golden Horse Awards, she secured the Best Director prize three times—for Ordinary Heroes in 1999, A Simple Life in 2011, and The Golden Era in 2014—along with a Best Feature Film award for The Secret in 1979. Her films have also excelled in ensemble categories, with The Secret earning Best Feature Film at the and Boat People claiming Best Film and Best Director at the Hong Kong Film Awards. Later works like Ordinary Heroes swept multiple Golden Horse categories, including Best Film in 1999. In terms of lifetime honors, Hui received the for Lifetime Achievement at the 77th in 2020, marking her as the first female director to earn this distinction. Earlier accolades include the Berlinale Camera Award in 1997 and the Fukuoka Prize in 2008 for her influence across Asian cinema. Recent recognitions encompass the Asian Filmmaker of the Year award and a Lifetime Achievement honor at the Imagineindia Festival in 2025, alongside selection for the International Film Festival's lifetime award in 2024. Professionally, Hui has served in leadership roles such as jury chair for the Golden Horse Awards in 2016 and 2022, vice chairman of the Society in 2008, and president of the Hong Kong Film Awards. She has also been conferred honorary university fellowships by institutions including the and for her cultural impact.

Enduring Impact on Cinema and Culture

Ann Hui's contributions to Hong Kong cinema have profoundly shaped the industry's artistic trajectory, particularly through her role in the movement of the late 1970s and early 1980s, where she introduced and introspective narratives that contrasted with dominant commercial genres like kung fu films. Her films, such as Boat People (1982) and Ordinary Heroes (1999), emphasized humanistic storytelling and historical reflection, broadening creative possibilities and elevating local cinema's international profile by blending independent sensibilities with mainstream appeal. This shift influenced subsequent generations of filmmakers, fostering a legacy of genre experimentation and social engagement that persists in 's output. Culturally, Hui's oeuvre has enduringly documented Hong Kong's evolving identity, capturing pre-1997 anxieties, refugee experiences, and everyday struggles of ordinary citizens, thereby preserving amid rapid sociopolitical changes. Works like The Way We Are (2008) and Our Time Will Come (2017) highlight themes of resilience and , resonating beyond screens to inform public discourse on local history and marginalization. Her focus on underrepresented voices, including women and the working class, has contributed to a more nuanced cultural narrative, challenging stereotypical portrayals and inspiring scholarly analysis of Hong Kong's sociocultural fabric. Hui's legacy is underscored by extensive accolades, including six Best Director wins at the Hong Kong Film Awards—for Boat People (1982), Summer Snow (1995), The Way We Are (2008), (2011), The Golden Era (2014), and Our Time Will Come (2017)—and three Golden Horse Best Director awards in 1999, 2011, and 2014. In 2020, she became the first female director to receive the Venice Film Festival's for Lifetime Achievement, alongside honors like the 1997 Berlinale Camera Award and the 2025 Imagineindia Lifetime Achievement Award, affirming her as a pivotal figure whose innovations continue to influence Asian cinema's global dialogue. Retrospectives, such as those at the , further evidence her sustained cultural relevance.

References

  1. https://fukuoka-prize.org/en/laureates/detail/566ac468-aa90-4ba1-8fab-da3e5d7122f8
  2. https://www4.hku.hk/hongrads/graduates/dr-ann-on-wah-hui-ann-hui-on-wah
  3. https://www.scmp.com/culture/film-tv/article/2094988/pictures-ann-hui-officially-most-celebrated-director-hong-kong-film
  4. https://cine-scope.com/2020/06/15/ann-hui-director/
  5. https://www.ff2media.com/blog/2023/03/09/filmmaker-ann-hui-an-icon-of-the-hong-kong-new-wave/
  6. https://www.livemint.com/mint-lounge/art-and-culture/ann-hui-film-director-hong-kong-china-11734585212576.html
  7. https://variety.com/2024/film/news/ann-hui-kerala-film-festival-award-hong-kong-1236231638/
  8. https://www.theyshootpictures.com/huiann.htm
  9. https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2002/filmmaker-profiles/hui/
  10. https://hkmdb.com/db/people/view.mhtml?id=4443&display_set=eng
  11. https://variety.com/2014/film/asia/ann-hui-asian-filmmaker-year-busan1201317988-1201317988/
  12. https://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/abstract/document/obo-9780199791286/obo-9780199791286-0385.xml
  13. https://complit.hku.hk/index.php/complits-alumni/
  14. https://www.hkbu.edu.hk/en/about/honorary-doctorates-and-honorary-university-fellows/ann-hui-on-wah.html
  15. https://thecinematheque.ca/series/ann-hui
  16. https://www4.hku.hk/honfellows/honorary-university-fellows/ms-ann-on-wah-hui
  17. https://www.quinzaine-cineastes.fr/en/director/ann-hui
  18. https://www.mplus.org.hk/en/cinema/ann-hui-vietnam-trilogy/below-the-lion-rock-the-boy-from-vietnam/
  19. https://mubi.com/en/us/films/the-boy-from-vietnam
  20. https://www.filmarchive.gov.hk/documents/18995340/19057014/e-48-more-happenings.pdf
  21. https://www.ovid.tv/ann-hui
  22. https://www.mplus.org.hk/en/cinema/ann-hui-vietnam-trilogy/
  23. https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/7702-boat-people-becoming-refugees
  24. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0082534/
  25. https://www.mplus.org.hk/en/cinema/ann-hui-vietnam-trilogy/the-story-of-woo-viet/
  26. https://oncriterion.wordpress.com/2019/03/18/the-story-of-woo-viet-1981/
  27. https://www.criterion.com/films/30455-boat-people
  28. https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/7704-boat-people-persistence-of-vision
  29. https://www.sensesofcinema.com/2024/cteq/boat-people/
  30. https://variety.com/2014/film/asia/asian-filmmaker-of-the-year-ann-hui-a-critical-appreciation-1201317998/
  31. https://www.scmp.com/magazines/style/celebrity/article/3085667/ann-huis-best-films-ranked-boat-people-simple-life-5
  32. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0093962/
  33. https://asianmoviepulse.com/2024/08/film-review-the-romance-of-book-and-sword-1987-by-ann-hui/
  34. https://www.filmarchive.gov.hk/en/web/hkfa/2024/silver/pe-event-2024-silver-fs-film12.html
  35. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3321929/why-director-ann-huis-rare-spins-martial-arts-and-horror-film-genres-were-special
  36. https://hongkong.universitypressscholarship.com/view/10.5790/hongkong/9789888028566.001.0001/upso-9789888028566-chapter-3
  37. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3326926/how-ann-hui-skilfully-tackled-dementia-summer-snow-award-winning-hong-kong-film
  38. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm0401176/
  39. https://inreviewonline.com/2022/03/17/love-after-love/
  40. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3155376/love-after-love-director-ann-hui-accepts-criticism-film-its
  41. https://www.hkonscreen.org/events/love-after-love
  42. https://variety.com/2020/film/reviews/love-after-love-review-ann-hui-1234762087/
  43. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3186495/septet-story-hong-kong-movie-review-johnnie-produced
  44. https://windowsonworlds.com/2022/11/05/septet-the-story-of-hong-kong-%25E4%25B8%2583%25E4%25BA%25BA%25E6%25A8%2582%25E9%259A%258A-sammo-hung-ann-hui-patrick-tam-yuen-wo-ping-johnnie-to-the-late-ringo-lam-tsui-hark-2022/
  45. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3242438/elegies-movie-review-ann-hui-documentary-dual-portrait-hong-kong-poets-huang-canran-and-liu-waitong
  46. https://inreviewonline.com/2024/02/02/elegies/
  47. https://iffr.com/en/iffr/2024/films/elegies
  48. https://windowsonworlds.com/2023/11/13/elegies-%25E8%25A9%25A9-ann-hui-2023/
  49. https://variety.com/2020/film/global/venice-film-festival-ann-hui-1234765279/
  50. https://mspace.lib.umanitoba.ca/bitstreams/3cf5484d-fb65-4dc7-9326-7111a473791d/download
  51. https://www.ejumpcut.org/archive/JC62.2024/GaryBettinson/3.html
  52. https://www.mplus.org.hk/en/magazine/ann-hui-filmmaking-evolution/
  53. https://www.cinemaescapist.com/2021/08/interview-ann-hui-director-nyaff/
  54. https://www.ejumpcut.org/archive/JC62.2024/GaryBettinson/notes.html
  55. https://www.easternkicks.com/features/ann-hui-interview/
  56. https://u.osu.edu/mclc/journal/abstracts/yau/
  57. https://ff2media.com/blog/2020/06/15/ann-hui-telling-the-stories-of-social-issues-in-hong-kong-through-cinema/
  58. https://cjdproject.web.nycu.edu.tw/2020/05/06/the-non-fictitious-destiny-of-youth-in-hong-kong/
  59. https://www.ukchinafilm.com/social-realism/
  60. https://imagineindiafestival.com/2025/01/20/ann-hui-a-career-spanning-independent-cinema-to-the-mainstream/
  61. https://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199791286/obo-9780199791286-0385.xml
  62. https://imagineindia.net/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/fulltext.pdf
  63. https://hnmag.ca/review/viff-ann-hui-endeavours-to-keep-rolling/
  64. https://asianmoviepulse.com/2023/10/documentary-review-elegies-2023-by-ann-hui/
  65. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3189282/why-boat-people-starring-andy-lau-and-george-lam-ann-huis
  66. https://www.janusfilms.com/films/2092
  67. https://www.criterionchannel.com/boat-people
  68. https://bombmagazine.org/articles/1991/07/01/ann-hui/
  69. https://www.slantmagazine.com/dvd/boat-people-blu-ray-review-ann-hui/
  70. https://chajournal.blog/2017/11/09/our-time-will-come-and-dunkirk/
  71. https://sffilm.org/event/boat-people/
  72. https://www.ff2media.com/blog/2020/06/15/ann-hui-telling-the-stories-of-social-issues-in-hong-kong-through-cinema/
  73. https://iafor.org/archives/journals/iafor-journal-of-asian-studies/10.22492.ijas.2.1.05.pdf
  74. https://www.timeout.com/movies/ordinary-heroes
  75. https://www.jstor.org/stable/41490983
  76. https://mubi.com/en/notebook/posts/once-upon-a-time-in-hong-kong-ann-hui-on-love-after-love
  77. https://zolimacitymag.com/ann-hui-looks-at-hong-kongs-wartime-resistance-from-a-mainland-perspective/
  78. https://thecinematheque.ca/films/2025/boat-people
  79. https://www.americancinemapapers.com/files/BOAT_PEOPLE.htm
  80. https://thegeekshow.co.uk/boat-people-1982-blu-ray-review/
  81. https://www.academia.edu/70337234/Hong_Kong_cinema_under_one_country_two_systems_production_reception_and_policy
  82. https://www.straitstimes.com/lifestyle/entertainment/hong-kong-director-ann-hui-describes-fantastic-struggle-to-make-new-film
  83. https://www.newindianexpress.com/cities/kochi/2024/Dec/17/i-am-not-very-popular-with-men-they-think-i-am-too-loud
  84. https://www.melbournecinematheque.org/category/present-year/keep-rolling-ann-huis-counter-cinema/
  85. https://windowsonworlds.com/tag/ann-hui/
  86. https://hub.hku.hk/bitstream/10722/35480/1/FullText.pdf
  87. https://cccheryl0820.wordpress.com/2023/08/01/movie-review-keep-rolling-the-documentary-of-a-hong-kong-film-director-ann-hui/
  88. https://resolve.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/846064DE189965E1FC629E902DD6BCA8/9781139167116c8_p176-196_CBO.pdf/film_work_of_ann_hui.pdf
  89. https://www.movementsinfilm.com/hong-kong-new-wave
  90. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3230793/how-hong-kong-new-wave-cinema-classics-nomad-and-story-woo-viet-early-movies-patrick-tam-and-ann-hui
  91. https://www.thegardencinema.co.uk/season/hong-kong-new-wave-1979-1989/
  92. https://www.bjiff.com/Banner/202407/t20240703_179119_ext.html
  93. https://focushongkong.uk/strand/celebrating-ann-hui-season/
  94. https://www.robertcmorton.com/hong-kong-new-wave/
  95. https://www.berghahnbooks.com/downloads/intros/CheungNew_intro.pdf
  96. https://imagineindiafestival.com/2024/10/17/ann-hui-gets-the-lifetime-achievement-award-at-imagineindia-2025/
  97. https://www.tatlerasia.com/people/ann-hui
  98. https://filmmuseum.at/en/film_program/scope?schienen_id=1675071188589
  99. https://www.goldenhorse.org.tw/news/detail/618?r=en
  100. https://www.scmp.com/lifestyle/entertainment/article/3225186/hong-kong-new-wave-cinema-key-movies-and-directors-tsui-hark-ann-hui-and-how-they-changed-filmmaking
  101. https://beverlyboy.com/filmmaking/what-was-the-hong-kong-new-wave-in-cinema/
  102. https://feature-asia.com/people/creatives/ann-hui/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.