Hubbry Logo
Audio commentaryAudio commentaryMain
Open search
Audio commentary
Community hub
Audio commentary
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Audio commentary
Audio commentary
Audio commentary
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

An audio commentary is an additional audio track, usually digital, consisting of a lecture or comments by one or more speakers, that plays in real time with a video. Commentaries can be serious or entertaining in nature, and can add information which otherwise would not be disclosed to audience members.

History

[edit]

The Criterion Collection introduced audio commentary on the LaserDisc format, which was able to accommodate multiple audio tracks. The first commentary track, for the 1984 LaserDisc release of the 1933 film King Kong, was recorded by Ronald Haver, a curator at the Los Angeles County Museum of Art, and was inspired by the stories Haver told while supervising the film-to-video transfer process.[1] Criterion expected that the commentary would only be of interest to serious film students.[2] It received a favorable reaction, and his commentary on King Kong is considered to ultimately have started the trend.[3][4][5] Haver went on to provide commentaries for Criterion for the rest of his life.[2]

Excerpt of Haver's commentary for King Kong:

Hello, ladies and gentlemen, I'm Ronald Haver, and I'm here to do something which we feel is rather unique. I'm going to take you on a lecture tour of King Kong as you watch the film. The laserdisc technology offers us this opportunity and we feel it's rather unique — the ability to switch back and forth between the soundtrack and this lecture track.[6]

DVD and Blu-ray audio commentaries

[edit]

DVDs, Blu-rays, and 4K Ultra HD Blu-rays have made audio commentary a key component of special features. They often include commentary from cinematographers, screenwriters, actors, producers, directors, film historians, film critics and subject matter experts.[4][5] For example, American cinematographer Garrett Brown, the inventor of the steadicam, is featured throughout the audio commentary track for The Shining, where he discusses his work with the ground-breaking technology.[7][8] The DVD of the science-fiction movie Sunshine, directed by Danny Boyle, contains an audio track with English physicist and professor of particle physics Brian Cox.[9] In the cast commentary for The Silence of the Lambs, former F.B.I. criminal profiler John Douglas, an advisor to the filmmakers, offers his anecdotes about the film.[10]

The box set of The Ultimate Matrix Collection, has two audio commentaries on each film, one by philosophers who loved it; Dr. Cornel West and Ken Wilber, and one by critics who hated it; Todd McCarthy, John Powers and David Thomson.[11] The DVD release of Ghostbusters contains a video commentary track with director Ivan Reitman, Harold Ramis, and Joe Medjuck, with silhouettes of the trio added to imitate Mystery Science Theater 3000.[12] The Blu-ray edition of the film Galaxy Quest includes a tongue-in-cheek trivia commentary called "Galactopedia", by American graphic designer Michael Okuda, known for his work on Star Trek, and Denise Okuda, co-author of the Star Trek Encyclopedia.[13]

On the DVD release of Bowling for Columbine, Michael Moore allowed his interns, secretary and production assistants to record the audio commentary for his documentary.[14] In the commentary for True Romance, Quentin Tarantino, who wrote the film script, explains why he didn’t direct the movie himself, and the inspiration behind him writing the script.[15] For The Goonies audio track, many of the original cast members, Sean Astin, Josh Brolin, Corey Feldman and Martha Plimpton, along with director Richard Donner, reunited and watched the film together, offering their opinions on the classic comedy film.[15]

Film directors commentary

[edit]

Film directors can also provide their perspective into how a film is made. In his commentary for the 1970 film M*A*S*H, director Robert Altman gives background information on production and on the way the script was used and misused. He also comments on problems he had with the studio in relation to the connection with the Vietnam War.[16] Director Mel Brooks discusses in his audio commentary for Young Frankenstein how the movie was turned down by Columbia Pictures because its 2 million dollar budget was too high. He also points out the homages in his film, in relation to the history of Frankenstein movies.[16]

Director Oliver Stone in his audio commentary for Wall Street, explains how his family influenced the making of the film, and speaks candidly about the actors, mildly criticizing them, particularly Charlie Sheen.[16] In his commentary for the 2003 film Shattered Glass, director Billy Ray is joined by New Republic editor Chuck Long, who explains the differences between the film and the actual event. Ray, in his directorial debut, also admits his lack of experience, and how he relied on more experienced members of his production crew.[17]

Director Francis Ford Coppola in his audio commentary about his epic film The Godfather, recounts how the original title of the film was supposed to be "Mario Puzo's The Godfather", but that "no one remembers it that way",[18] and in the 2007 DVD release of Hearts of Darkness, a documentary about the production of Apocalypse Now, Coppola explains why it's not a good idea to film a movie in the Amazon jungle. He also talks about a scene in the film where Martin Sheen was drunk and cut his hand, and relays how the opening shot with a huge explosion in the jungle was completely unintentional.[15]

Film historians and critics

[edit]

Film historians are frequent contributors of audio commentary, including: Tim Lucas who has recorded numerous audio commentaries since his first, for Mario Bava's Black Sunday;[19] Peter Cowie has provided commentaries for numerous DVDs of Ingmar Bergman's films, including Wild Strawberries, written and directed by Bergman;[4] Donald Richie has recorded commentary tracks for many Japanese films;[4] and respected historian Rudy Behlmer, who is primarily known for his audio commentaries of American classic cinema, most notably Casablanca, Gone with the Wind and Frankenstein.[20] John Fricke has recorded, or participated in, several audio commentaries for Judy Garland's films, including The Wizard of Oz, Babes in Arms, Easter Parade, For Me and My Gal, Girl Crazy, Meet Me in St. Louis, and The Pirate.

Film critics are also frequent contributors to commentaries like: American film critic Roger Ebert who recorded DVD audio commentary tracks for many classic films, including Citizen Kane and Casablanca,[21] and Richard Schickel who has provided commentary for Double Indemnity, Strangers on a Train, On the Waterfront and The Good, the Bad and the Ugly.[22] Leonard Maltin has also offered commentary on several films including, Marx Brothers A Night at the Opera,[23] and The Harold Lloyd Comedy Collection (volume 2).[24]

Hong Kong action cinema expert Bey Logan is a frequent commenter for Asian films, including Fist of Fury,[25] The Banquet,[26] Iron Monkey,[27] Musa[28] and Bullet in the Head.[29][30]

Animation historian Jerry Beck has recorded dozens of audio commentaries for animation productions,[31] including Sinbad the Sailor[32] and the Looney Tunes Golden Collection series,[33] and historian Michael Barrier also regularly contributes commentary to selected shorts in DVD packages, including the Popeye the Sailor DVD series, and for the first five Looney Tunes Golden Collection DVD box sets.[33]

In-theater audio commentary

[edit]

In-theater audio commentary is an audio track that is downloaded before going to a movie theater, and then played back on your device while watching the film. American director Kevin Smith was one of the first filmmakers to provide this feature with Clerks II.[34][35] Rian Johnson provided in-theater commentary for The Brothers Bloom, Looper and Knives Out.[36][37] John August also used in-theater commentary for The Nines.[38]

Television series

[edit]

When complete seasons of TV series are released to DVD and Blu-ray boxsets, they often include audio commentary. Older classic shows like The Twilight Zone[39] The Monkees,[40] Night Gallery,[41] The Brady Bunch,[42] Dennis the Menace,[43] Star Trek: The Original Series,[44] Groucho Marx's You Bet Your Life,[45] The Abbott and Costello Show,[46] and The Smothers Brothers Comedy Hour[47] have all featured audio commentaries by the cast, crew members and special guest stars.

Modern classics with commentaries from the creators, writers, directors and cast include (select few): Everybody Loves Raymond,[48] One Tree Hill,[48] Second City Television,[48] Smallville,[48] The Sopranos,[49] Arrested Development,[50] Buffy the Vampire Slayer,[51] Sex and the City,[52] Will & Grace,[53] Game of Thrones,[54] It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia,[55] Seinfeld[56] and Friends.[57]

Animated TV series are also a genre that frequently provide audio commentaries, which include: My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic[58] and Nickelodeon's SpongeBob SquarePants.[59] Classic cartoons include: The Flintstones,[60] The Jetsons,[61] and Tom and Jerry[62] which have all been released with audio commentaries. Adult and cult classics with audio commentaries from creators, writers, directors and cast include: South Park,[63] Beavis and Butt-Head,[64] Robot Chicken[65] and Aqua Teen Hunger Force.[66]

Music videos

[edit]

On the DVD release of Queen's Greatest Video Hits 2, which features music videos with audio commentary, band members Brian May and Roger Taylor reflect on their memories and opinions of each video.[67] On the 20th Anniversary Remastered Edition of Paul's Boutique, the Beastie Boys provide their insights on a downloadable hour long audio commentary, which offers "rambling" revelations into album characters like Johnny Ryall.[68]

The 2000 Criterion DVD re-release of The Rolling Stones Gimme Shelter, a 1970 American documentary, features audio commentary from directors Albert Maysles and Charlotte Zwerin, along with collaborator Stanley Goldstein.[69] The 2006 Fade to Red: Tori Amos Video Collection, a double DVD set, has commentary from Tori Amos on each video.[70]

Broadway plays

[edit]

The 2011 Broadway revival of Godspell featured a downloadable ten-part audio commentary series from composer Stephen Schwartz and director Daniel Goldstein, who "discuss their process and personal experiences of creating the Broadway revival".[71]

Video games

[edit]

Video game developers have also included audio commentaries in their games. Unlike DVD commentaries, in-game prompts are used to allow players to activate a relevant audio commentary for a specific area in the game. Star Wars Episode I: Battle for Naboo is believed to be the earliest video game with audio commentary.[72] Other select video games with commentary include: Portal,[73] Alan Wake,[73] Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge Special Edition,[73] Deus Ex Human Revolution Director's Cut,[73] Grim Fandango Remastered,[74] Day of the Tentacle Remastered,[75] BioShock: The Collection,[76] Firewatch,[77] Duke Nukem 3D: 20th Anniversary World Tour,[73] and Half-Life: Alyx.[78]

James Bond commentary

[edit]

Controversy surrounded the audio commentary on Criterion's 1991 laserdisc release of the first three James Bond films, Dr. No, From Russia with Love and Goldfinger.[79][80] Eon Productions notified Criterion of "185 statements in the audio commentaries which they considered to be 'inaccurate, insensitive, inflammatory or potentially libelous'".[79] The audio tracks featured commentary from various members of the production crews who worked on the films. Amongst the offensive commentary; they criticized the budgets for the three films, gossiped about Sean Connery's weight gain during From Russia with Love, and "insinuated that several female costars were bad actors and had been cast solely for their looks".[79] Additionally, when English film director Guy Hamilton was commenting about Goldfinger, which he directed, he referred to the fictional character Pussy Galore as a "dyke".[79] In response to EON’s complaints, Criterion discontinued the collection, and issued a recall of the unsold copies. The following year, they reissued the three films as single-disc versions, with all the extra features removed.[79]

References

[edit]

Sources

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Audio commentary

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Audio commentary is an optional audio track featuring recorded spoken remarks by directors, actors, production crew, film historians, or critics, synchronized to play alongside the original soundtrack of a film, television episode, or other visual media, typically included as a special feature on physical home video formats such as laserdiscs, DVDs, and Blu-ray discs. The format originated in 1984 with the Criterion Collection's laserdisc release of the 1933 film King Kong, which included the first such track: a scholarly lecture by film historian Ronald Haver analyzing the production, visual effects, and historical context of the classic monster movie. This innovation, initially targeted at niche collectors and cinephiles via the expensive laserdisc medium, transformed passive viewing into an interactive educational experience, allowing audiences to gain behind-the-scenes insights, technical details, and trivia without interrupting the primary audio. Audio commentary gained widespread popularity in the late 1990s alongside the DVD revolution, which offered affordable storage for multiple audio layers and bonus materials, making it a staple of "" releases that appealed to fans seeking deeper engagement with films. Early director-led tracks, such as those by , set precedents for personal anecdotes and creative decision-making revelations, while humorous or candid sessions—like Ben Affleck's self-deprecating roast on (1998)—highlighted the format's versatility in blending entertainment with analysis. Though less prevalent in streaming eras due to bandwidth limits and shifting production priorities, audio commentaries remain valued for fostering film and preserving oral histories from key industry figures.

History

Origins and Early Adoption

The emergence of audio commentary tracks for home video began in the early 1980s with the format, which supported multiple selectable audio channels alongside the video signal. The first recorded instance appeared on the Criterion Collection's release of the 1933 film , featuring a synchronized spoken track by film historian Ronald Haver that offered detailed analysis of production techniques, , and historical context as the film played. This marked a departure from prior home viewing, where commentary was absent or required cumbersome manual synchronization using separate audio cassettes with tapes. Technical constraints in pre-Laserdisc analog media, such as and early , restricted extras to a single primary audio channel, often necessitating audio mixing that overwrote or degraded . Laserdisc's FM-modulated analog audio (initially stereo across two channels) enabled a dedicated commentary layer without altering the film's core audio or video, allowing users to toggle tracks via player controls for real-time playback. By the mid-1980s, some Laserdiscs incorporated PCM digital audio tracks, further enhancing fidelity and capacity for uncompressed commentary, though Haver's 1984 track utilized the format's analog capabilities. Early adoption remained niche, confined to Laserdisc's and cinephile audience due to high player costs (often exceeding $500 in 1984 dollars) and limited title availability, with Criterion leading experimentation through archival restorations. Subsequent releases, such as director-led tracks on titles like in 1986, built on this foundation but preceded mass-market formats. These implementations demonstrated commentary's potential for educational enrichment, influencing later digital evolutions without relying on physical film reel overlays common in institutional screenings.

DVD Era Popularization

The DVD format's technical specifications, finalized in 1995 and commercially launched in in November 1996 before U.S. player availability in March 1997, incorporated support for up to eight simultaneous audio tracks, enabling the seamless integration of commentary alongside primary soundtracks without compromising video quality. This multi-track capability transformed audio commentaries from a niche experiment into accessible home entertainment supplements, coinciding with surging DVD adoption amid falling player prices and improved home theater setups. Early DVD releases capitalized on this, with 's late-1997 disc featuring director Luc Besson's track, which candidly addressed on-set logistical hurdles, budget overruns, and creative decisions under tight timelines. By the early 2000s, audio commentaries proliferated as a on major studio DVDs, driven by their utility in high-value editions to differentiate from basic VHS tapes and foster repeat purchases among enthusiasts. Productions from studios like , including 's dual commentary tracks on its DVD, exemplified this shift toward bundling creator insights to extend narrative engagement post-theatrical run. analyses reveal that nearly 90% of DVD advertisements emphasized bonus content such as commentaries, directly correlating with heightened perceived value and sales uplift during the format's peak, as consumers sought enriched experiences amid home video's transition to digital ownership. This era's boom reflected causal dynamics where technical feasibility met consumer demand for transparency into processes, elevating commentaries from optional extras to expected fixtures that sustained DVD's dominance until streaming disruptions.

Blu-ray and Digital Transition

The Blu-ray format, commercially launched in June 2006, provided substantially greater data capacity than DVDs—up to 25 GB for single-layer discs and 50 GB for dual-layer—enabling higher-bitrate audio tracks for commentaries that reduced compression artifacts and supported lossless codecs such as and . These advancements allowed for richer, more detailed audio reproduction in commentary tracks, preserving nuances in and ambient sound that were often diminished by the lossy or DTS formats predominant on DVDs. Boutique labels like capitalized on this by incorporating new or remastered commentaries into 4K UHD Blu-ray releases, such as their 2024 restorations featuring supervised director-approved audio enhancements and supplemental tracks recorded specifically for high-definition editions. As streaming platforms proliferated in the , audio commentaries transitioned unevenly to digital delivery, with mainstream services like largely omitting them due to bandwidth constraints, production costs, and a focus on core viewing experiences over extras. Disney+ offers limited commentaries, primarily for legacy franchises like Star Wars, but these pale in scope compared to counterparts, reflecting broader industry priorities toward scalable content rather than resource-intensive supplements. In contrast, niche streaming outlets such as the Criterion Channel sustain commentary availability by streaming dedicated tracks alongside films, with ongoing integrations as of 2025 that mirror their physical releases, including archival and newly recorded options for titles like and . Boutique physical media labels have persisted in producing Blu-ray and 4K UHD editions with fresh commentaries, defying 2020s forecasts of format obsolescence amid streaming dominance. Arrow Video, for instance, included a brand-new audio commentary by critic David Flint in their 2025 limited-edition Blu-ray of Steppenwolf, recorded exclusively for the release, alongside similar supplements in August 2025 titles like those featuring director interviews and scholar-led tracks. This endurance stems from collector demand for tangible, high-fidelity extras, with boutique operations reporting sustained viability in 2025 through curated restorations that prioritize comprehensive supplemental content over mass-market digital efficiencies.

Production and Technical Aspects

Recording Process

The recording of audio commentary tracks involves commentators viewing the media content in real time within a controlled environment, such as a studio, where they provide spontaneous remarks synchronized to the on-screen events. This process ensures natural timing, with the original audio track played at low volume or muted to facilitate clear, unprompted without interference. Sessions are conducted in a single continuous pass from start to finish, allowing participants to react directly to unfolding scenes rather than relying on scripts or post-dubbed inserts. Professional audio equipment, including high-quality assigned to each speaker, is employed to capture clean signals, often in setups designed to reduce acoustic bleed between participants. Isolation techniques, such as separate booths or directional mics, help maintain audio separation, enabling precise capture of individual contributions even in shared spaces. This setup minimizes and supports later flexibility, though the emphasis remains on live over the visuals. In multi-speaker recordings, such as or roundtables, coordination is essential to manage and avoid simultaneous speech, which could complicate audio clarity. Moderators or self-regulated pauses ensure balanced input, with participants alternating insights to cover details, , or without . These group sessions typically span 2 to 3 hours for a standard feature-length , aligning closely with the media's runtime while accommodating brief halts for reflection or technical checks.

Synchronization and Post-Production

Synchronization of audio commentary tracks to the underlying video occurs primarily through timecode alignment in digital audio workstations (DAWs) such as Avid Pro Tools, where the commentary audio is mapped to the film's master timecode to ensure cues align with specific scenes and dialogue beats. This process compensates for potential drifts arising from unscripted pauses, variable speaking rates, or minor recording inconsistencies, often using waveform visualization or automated sync tools to match audio peaks to visual events. In integrated editing environments like Blackmagic Design's DaVinci Resolve, editors employ similar timecode-based or manual nudging techniques to verify lip-sync equivalents for commentary references to on-screen action, preventing perceptual desynchronization during playback. Post-production editing refines the track for intelligibility and immersion by excising filler utterances (e.g., "um" or "ah"), crossfading segments for seamless flow, and inserting deliberate silences to accommodate critical plot moments or original audio cues, thereby maintaining narrative pacing. Audio levels are normalized and compressed to sit 10-15 dB below the primary mix, avoiding masking of or effects while preserving commentator expressiveness; this is achieved via dynamic processing plugins in DAWs. Multi-speaker tracks require additional phase alignment to eliminate comb-filtering artifacts from overlapping voices. For legacy content, such as films transitioning from analog formats like laserdisc to DVD, synchronization challenges intensify due to frame rate variances—e.g., NTSC's 23.976 fps versus PAL's 25 fps—necessitating re-recording or conformal resampling of commentary to match remastered video timelines, as mismatched rates accumulate drift over runtime. Physical media degradation or absent original timecode in pre-digital transfers further complicates alignment, often requiring forensic waveform matching or cue-sheet reconstruction from production notes. These issues were prevalent in early DVD releases of 1970s-1980s titles, where new commentaries were commissioned to align with cleaned-up transfers, ensuring temporal fidelity absent in source materials.

Audio Formats and Delivery

Audio commentary tracks on DVDs are encoded as separate streams using mandatory formats like Dolby Digital (AC-3) or uncompressed PCM, allowing playback alongside or instead of the primary via disc menus. Blu-ray Discs extend this capability, supporting up to eight simultaneous audio tracks encoded in codecs such as LPCM for lossless stereo delivery, , DTS, , or , with commentary typically rendered in stereo to prioritize dialogue clarity over surround immersion. These standards enable isolated playback options, where metadata tags distinguish commentary streams (e.g., director-only versus mixed with cast) for user selection through player interfaces, ensuring synchronization without altering the video timeline. In streaming platforms, commentary tracks—when offered—are integrated as selectable audio variants within adaptive bitrate manifests like HLS or DASH, encoded primarily in efficient compressed formats such as AAC or Enhanced AC-3 (E-AC3) to optimize bandwidth and device compatibility as of 2025. Services like Disney+ provide them for select titles, such as Marvel films, via extras menus rather than channel switching, while broader adoption remains sparse compared to . Metadata embedding facilitates multi-language support and track isolation, but compression artifacts can reduce fidelity relative to lossless disc versions. Delivery has transitioned from embedded multiplexing on physical discs, which guarantees offline access and full bitrate retention, to cloud-streamed separation of audio assets, reducing storage needs but heightening dependency on internet stability. This shift impacts regions with bandwidth constraints, where streaming commentaries may buffer or default to lower quality, whereas discs maintain consistent playback regardless of connectivity, underscoring physical media's edge in reliability for archival or low-infrastructure settings. By 2025, hybrid approaches emerge, with some platforms offering downloadable extras mirroring disc-like isolation for improved accessibility.

Types of Commentary Tracks

Creator-Led Commentaries

Creator-led commentaries feature audio tracks primarily narrated by a film's director, , or principal , delivering direct explanations of creative decisions, from script development to on-set choices and refinements. These tracks emphasize the causal factors behind artistic intent, such as deliberate stylistic elements or pivots, often drawing on the creator's unmediated recollections to illuminate the original production context. By providing this primary perspective, they enable listeners to evaluate the work through the lens of intended outcomes rather than aggregated secondary analyses. In Michael Mann's commentary for Thief (1981), recorded in 1995 alongside for the film's release, Mann details technical innovations like the manipulation of light and shadow to evoke urban isolation, as well as casting selections that aligned with his vision for authentic criminal archetypes, reflecting the relative autonomy of his feature debut outside heavy studio oversight. Likewise, Sidney Lumet's track on (1975) explicates the construction of complex character motivations for Al Pacino's role and the strategic deployment of cinematographic techniques to heighten tension, underscoring how such choices stemmed from script-to-screen fidelity. These commentaries achieve value in safeguarding auteurial rationale against later distortions or revisionist readings, offering empirical anchors to the work's genesis that prioritize verifiable production events over interpretive overlays. Fan and critic evaluations consistently favor creator-led tracks for their perceived genuineness, with figures like praised for commentaries that dissect mechanics in a manner surpassing cast or crew variants in instructional depth. Nonetheless, some accounts note limitations, including tendencies toward undue self-praise or reticence on errors, which can prioritize affirmation over candid appraisal of shortcomings.

Scholarly and Critical Commentaries

Scholarly and critical audio commentaries feature analyses by film historians, academics, or critics who dissect a work's technical innovations, historical influences, and cultural reception without direct involvement from creators. These tracks emphasize detached evaluation, often highlighting directorial techniques, production contexts, and stylistic precedents through evidence-based discussion rather than anecdotal reminiscence. Unlike creator-led variants, they prioritize verifiable history and formal analysis, serving as supplementary educational tools for understanding cinematic craft from first principles of , , and . An early exemplar appears on the 1985 Image Entertainment release of (1941), where film historian Paul Mandell provides a track unpacking Orson Welles's innovative deep-focus cinematography, narrative structure influenced by newsreels, and thematic echoes of real-life figures like , drawing on archival production records without creator participation. Similarly, the Criterion Collection's editions frequently incorporate such commentaries, including Adrian Martin's 2017 scholarly discussion of structural motifs in films like Hearts and Minds (1974) and Joseph McBride's historical breakdown of directorial choices in various titles, focusing on empirical evidence from scripts and era-specific technologies. These tracks, originating with pioneers like Ron Haver's 1984 commentary on (1933) examining stop-motion effects and genre precedents, have persisted into Blu-ray eras, offering rigorous dissections that reveal causal links between technical decisions and on-screen outcomes. Such commentaries hold empirical value for education, enabling listeners to correlate observable film elements with documented production methods, as seen in tracks that quantify innovations like Welles's use of low-angle shots to convey power dynamics in Citizen Kane, supported by lighting diagrams and set designs from RKO Studios records. They facilitate objective appraisal of craft over subjective intent, fostering causal realism in interpreting how formal choices drive audience perception. However, critiques highlight risks of imposing interpretive lenses that prioritize social or ideological readings—often aligned with academia's prevailing left-leaning frameworks—at the expense of pure technical causality, as broader film criticism trends demonstrate politically inflected analyses overshadowing structural mechanics. Mainstream releases' normalization of such tracks from institutionally biased sources can thus embed unexamined assumptions, underscoring the need for cross-verification against primary production data to maintain truth-seeking fidelity.

Cast, Crew, and Fan-Based Tracks

Cast and crew audio tracks often feature participants delivering anecdotal, retrospective reflections on their roles, emphasizing personal stories over structured analysis. These commentaries, typically recorded years after production, capture informal exchanges that highlight on-set dynamics and decision-making. For example, ' solo track for (1974) reveals insights into improvisational humor and casting hurdles, such as recruiting performers for satirical Western tropes, delivered in his signature comedic style. Crew-focused tracks, particularly from technical specialists in effects-intensive productions, detail practical obstacles like resource constraints and innovative workarounds. In films relying on pre-CGI practical effects, such as puppetry or prosthetics-heavy projects, crew members explain synchronization issues and material limitations, providing viewers with granular views of execution challenges absent in cast-only discussions. These accounts underscore causal factors in visual storytelling, like budget-driven compromises affecting final shots. Fan-based tracks diverge by prioritizing entertainment through parody, as seen in offerings, which originated from alumni of and sync scripted jests to any film for download. These overlays emphasize satirical exaggeration of plot flaws or dialogue, fostering community-driven critique but often sidelining factual production trivia in favor of humor. While expanding access to commentary for obscure titles, they risk diluting substantive discourse with subjective riffing. Critics note inconsistencies in these tracks, such as uneven participation leading to silent gaps or mismatched timing, which disrupt immersion compared to polished creator-led versions. Spoilers arise frequently from candid revelations about alternate takes or endings, potentially undermining first-time viewings. Nonetheless, cast, crew, and fan contributions achieve broader dissemination of insider , enabling enthusiasts to appreciate causal realities of without institutional gatekeeping.

Applications by Media Type

Film and Cinema Releases

Audio commentaries are most commonly integrated into home video editions of , particularly special editions on DVD and Blu-ray, where they synchronize director, cast, or crew insights with the on-screen action to elucidate creative decisions and . This format emerged in the mid-1980s with releases, such as Criterion Collection's pioneering track for The King of Comedy (1982), and became ubiquitous by the DVD era in the late , often bundled as a key bonus feature to incentivize purchases of collector's sets. In franchise-heavy cinematic releases, such as the series, commentaries are standard across re-issues, with films like Dr. No (1962) featuring multiple tracks on Ultimate Edition DVDs, including one with director Terence Young and cast/crew members discussing location challenges and early spy genre innovations. Subsequent Bond titles on Blu-ray similarly offer layered tracks—e.g., isolated director analyses or breakdowns—allowing viewers to select perspectives that deepen understanding of tropes and technical feats without altering the theatrical experience. Theatrical applications remain experimental and infrequent, typically limited to or promotional screenings where live overlays the film, as in select events tied to independent releases, though these diverge from the passive home-viewing model by incorporating interaction. Such variants underscore commentaries' role in bridging archival preservation with real-time appreciation, though they risk disrupting narrative immersion compared to post-production tracks.

Television and Episodic Content

Audio commentaries for television series have been a staple of physical media releases, particularly in complete season or series box sets on DVD and Blu-ray, where they offer episode-by-episode analysis tailored to the serialized format's incremental narrative progression. Unlike standalone films, these tracks often address how individual installments contribute to overarching character arcs, thematic continuity, and plot causality, such as the psychological motivations driving Tony Soprano's decisions in The Sopranos (1999–2007), as discussed by creator David Chase in the pilot episode commentary. The complete series release includes at least 25 such tracks featuring Chase, writers like Terence Winter, actors including Michael Imperioli and Edie Falco, and directors, providing retrospective insights into production decisions that shaped the show's causal chain of events from family dynamics to criminal enterprises. In long-running animated series like and , commentaries extend comprehensively to every episode within season box sets, enabling creators such as and staff to dissect episodic humor, , and continuity callbacks that build viewer investment over time. This format suits television's episodic pacing by allowing synchronized breakdowns of self-contained stories within serialized worlds, though challenges arise in aligning commentary with cliffhangers or mid-season pivots, where discussants must balance revealing causal links to prior episodes without preempting future developments, potentially disrupting real-time viewing flow. For instance, in procedurals or dramas with filler episodes—those advancing minimal plot—the tracks may yield thinner analytical depth, focusing more on technical execution like dialogue timing rather than profound narrative revelations. While dominates, streaming platforms in the have rarely incorporated legacy commentaries for older series, often omitting them to prioritize core video streams and incentivize disc purchases, as seen with The Sopranos tracks absent from Max despite the service hosting the show. This scarcity contrasts with revivals or re-releases, where select older titles receive updated Blu-ray editions with new tracks to contextualize enduring appeal, though adoption remains limited compared to film counterparts. The episodic structure's pros include enriched lore for rewatches, fostering causal realism in understanding motivations like recurring moral dilemmas, but cons involve variable quality across uneven episodes and the logistical hurdles of coordinating multiple voices for season-spanning arcs.

Video Games and Interactive Media

Valve introduced in-game developer commentary in Half-Life 2 (2004), featuring optional audio nodes activated by players at specific points during gameplay to discuss level design, AI behaviors, and technical challenges, marking an early adaptation of DVD-style tracks to interactive environments. This system extended to sequels like Half-Life 2: Episode One (2006) and Episode Two (2007), where commentaries highlighted narrative integration with mechanics, such as physics-based puzzles. Similar implementations appeared in titles like Portal (2007), using the Source engine's modular nodes to provide context on puzzle iteration without disrupting player agency. In narrative-driven games, commentaries often sync to cutscenes or key gameplay sequences, as in The Last of Us Part I (2022 remake of the 2013 original), where director and actors like overlay discussions on writing, , and emotional beats during cinematics. (2007) included audio logs and developer tracks revealing environmental storytelling and choice-consequence systems, while (2016) offered a full audio tour mode replaying the game with creators commenting on dialogue branching and atmosphere. These tracks emphasize empirical design feedback, such as playtesting data influencing enemy AI or level pacing. The interactive nature of games necessitates modular or trigger-based commentaries to accommodate player-driven paths, unlike linear film tracks; for instance, Half-Life 2's nodes activate contextually without forcing sequences, allowing replayability for full coverage. In branching narratives, developers may produce segmented audio for alternate routes, as explored in games like (2010), where commentaries address horror pacing across variable story outcomes, or use post-release updates for expanded insights. Post-2010s digital platforms and streaming tools facilitated this evolution, enabling devs to release patch-specific commentaries via platforms like , as with 's 20th anniversary update (2024) adding retrospective audio on engine optimizations and unused features. This approach provides causal analysis of iterative development, drawing from telemetry data on player behaviors to inform future content.

Music Videos, Theater, and Other Formats

Audio commentary for , often provided by directors or artists, focuses on elucidating visual symbolism, challenges, and creative inspirations, typically as standalone discussions rather than fully synced tracks given the format's brevity of 3-5 minutes per video. For instance, director Richard Carleau's 2013 commentary on One Direction's "" breaks down layered scenes and directorial intent. Recent examples include Saman Kesh's 2025 breakdown of Ed Sheeran's "Azizam," covering filming and stylistic choices. Such tracks, common in DVD extras or online releases since the early , aid in decoding abstract elements but offer limited depth due to runtime constraints, contrasting with longer-form commentaries. In Broadway cast albums, commentary manifests as supplemental audio tracks or separate releases that analyze songs, staging, and performer interpretations, enhancing listener comprehension of narrative and musical innovations. The 2018 Broadway cast recording of Carousel incorporates explicit audio commentary segments alongside its tracks, providing production context. A milestone occurred in 2019 with the Godspell revival, which introduced Broadway's first audio commentary by director Daniel Goldstein, overlaid on a performance recording to highlight directorial decisions without altering the core audio. Similarly, Hamilton's September 2025 track-by-track commentary on Amazon Music features insights from creator Lin-Manuel Miranda and cast members like Leslie Odom Jr., dissecting lyrical and thematic elements song-by-song. Synced commentary for live theater archival recordings remains exceptional owing to performance variability—nightly differences in delivery, audience reactions, and —which complicates precise alignment and risks undermining the medium's spontaneity. Instead, supplementary formats like director notes or post-performance discussions prevail, as in accessibility-focused audio descriptions that narrate visuals live via devices but prioritize access over analytical depth. These niche applications illuminate artistry in ephemeral or concise media, though brevity and liveness curtail exhaustive exploration compared to scripted formats.

Notable Examples and Franchises

Franchise-Specific Tracks

In the series, franchise-specific audio commentary tracks frequently feature returning producers like , who has contributed to discussions across films spanning decades, providing context on production choices that sustain loose narrative continuity amid actor transitions from to . These tracks highlight decisions such as reintroducing elements like as a persistent threat, reconciling variances in Bond's backstory without enforcing rigid timelines, as producers emphasize each installment's self-containment while nodding to prior lore. The mid-2000s Ultimate Edition DVD releases exemplified this approach, with tracks pairing Wilson with directors like for (1995) or for You Only Live Twice (1967), delving into scripting adaptations from novels and practical effects that bridged eras, such as gadget designs echoing earlier gadgets. Similarly, Roger Moore's 2005-recorded solo commentaries for his 1970s-1980s films offered actor perspectives on evolving stunt work and character portrayal, illustrating how the series adapted to changing cinematic technologies while preserving core tropes. Such multi-era insights have empirically heightened fan engagement, as evidenced by collector enthusiasm for the banned 1991 tracks—featuring candid crew interviews on Dr. No (1962)—which, despite producer recall due to unauthorized revelations, spurred ongoing online and among enthusiasts, enhancing replay value and forum discussions. However, later updates to these tracks in re-releases have drawn fan critiques for perceived sanitization, where original unfiltered and editor anecdotes were edited or omitted to align with contemporary oversight, potentially diluting raw historical context.

Experimental or Unique Commentaries

Experimental audio commentaries deviate from conventional structured discussions by incorporating unconventional recording dynamics, such as intoxication or interpersonal tensions, to capture raw, unpolished insights into filmmaking. The 1997 film , directed by and , features a notorious drunken commentary track on its 2001 DVD release, recorded with the directors, actors , Andrew Kemler, and while under the influence of alcohol, resulting in chaotic, candid revelations about the low-budget production's improvisational chaos and personal anecdotes that standard sessions might suppress. This approach contrasts with polished franchise tracks by emphasizing spontaneous humor over scripted reverence, highlighting causal pressures like tight schedules that foster creative desperation. Adversarial commentaries, where participants engage in debates or refuse in-character restraint, further test format limits by exposing production frictions. In some tracks, commentators' conflicting views devolve into arguments, as noted in fan analyses of sessions marked by "adversarial relationships" that prioritize confrontation over consensus, potentially unveiling authentic creative disputes but amplifying subjective biases. Such dynamics, evident in early independent releases, underscore realism in collaborative breakdowns, where unfiltered clashes reveal decision-making hierarchies more transparently than harmonious narratives. These experimental variants offer value in disclosing unvarnished truths—intoxication lowers inhibitions to elicit empirical details on on-set mishaps otherwise sanitized—yet carry risks of , as impaired or heated recollections can conflate fact with exaggeration, demanding viewer discernment over passive acceptance. Unlike consistent franchise efforts, they prioritize boundary-pushing authenticity, though their rarity stems from production liabilities like legal waivers for alcohol-influenced content.

Reception, Impact, and Criticisms

Educational and Analytical Benefits

Audio commentaries on releases enable viewers to gain deeper insights into directorial techniques and thematic intentions, often through real-time, scene-specific explanations that reveal decision-making processes otherwise opaque in the final cut. These tracks frequently include shot-by-shot breakdowns of , choices, and construction, allowing analytical dissection of how elements contribute to overall impact. For example, Martin Scorsese's commentary on (1976, Sony DVD/Blu-ray) provides detailed visual and thematic analysis, illustrating causal relationships between character psychology and stylistic elements like and pacing, which enhance comprehension beyond passive viewing. In educational contexts, such commentaries serve as primary resources for studying craft fundamentals, with film instructors incorporating them to prioritize empirical breakdowns of production realities over interpretive overlays. Graduate-level courses have utilized DVD supplements, including audio tracks, to facilitate student-led analyses of contemporary practices, fostering skills in evaluating authorial choices directly from creators. This approach underscores director intent as a baseline for technique evaluation, as seen in recommendations for tracks that demystify on-set improvisations and refinements, enabling learners to reconstruct causal chains in . By focusing on verifiable production details—such as budget constraints influencing or script revisions for motivational logic—commentaries counter superficial readings, grounding analysis in the material conditions of creation rather than external ideologies. This evidentiary emphasis promotes rigorous , where learners verify thematic causality through creators' accounts, as evidenced in commentaries dissecting violence's innate drivers in narrative arcs. Such benefits extend to aspiring filmmakers, who report commentaries functioning as informal lectures on practical execution, akin to dissections of intent versus outcome.

Entertainment Value and Audience Engagement

Audio commentaries frequently captivate audiences through spontaneous humor, insider banter, and self-deprecating anecdotes from creators, often eclipsing the film's scripted content in amusement value. For example, ' track for (1987) features the director erupting in laughter at his own gags, as if rediscovering them after years, which enthusiasts describe as hilariously infectious and a standalone comedic experience. Similarly, commentaries on films like (2001) and (2001) are lauded for their irreverent, off-the-cuff exchanges that amplify repeat viewings purely for the levity. These elements transform passive watching into an interactive, laughter-driven event, where participants' unfiltered personalities—such as directors mocking their own directorial choices—foster a sense of camaraderie with fans. This anecdotal appeal drives listener loyalty by incentivizing multiple plays, as humorous tracks encourage separating the audio from visuals for focused enjoyment or layering it over rewatches to uncover layered jokes. Film reviewers note that strong commentaries elevate mediocre films into enduring favorites, extending through sheer entertainment without relying on analytical depth. In the era, such bonuses countered one-and-done consumption by adding replay value, though they do not compensate for fundamentally weak —engaging commentary merely highlights, rather than redeems, substantive flaws in production or narrative. Amid streaming's high churn, where users abandon content after single viewings, these tracks historically bolstered retention for owned media, providing a causal buffer via novel, personality-infused content that streaming platforms have largely omitted.

Limitations, Spoilers, and Decline in Availability

Audio commentaries frequently pose a risk of spoilers, as participants often discuss plot developments, twists, and thematic intentions in real-time, potentially undermining the intended narrative surprises for first-time viewers. For instance, in the commentary for Looper (2012), contributors explicitly warn of spoilers, suggesting pausing or skipping sections. Similarly, the track for (2007) advises against first-viewing listens due to revelatory content that diminishes suspense. Directors and cast commonly recommend subsequent watches for commentaries to preserve initial immersion. Certain tracks exhibit or unproductive segments stemming from unprepared commentators who fail to synchronize insights with on-screen action, leading to awkward silences or redundant praise. This issue arises when participants, such as filmmakers or historians, lack detailed notes or , resulting in lulls where little substantive analysis occurs. Examples include some releases where rushed production yields sparse , frustrating listeners seeking continuous value. Post-2020, audio commentaries have largely declined on major streaming platforms from big studios, with services like and rarely including them for licensed or original content beyond select early experiments. This shift reflects streaming's focus on streamlined delivery and data-optimized features, sidelining extras amid falling sales (down over 80% from 2004 peaks). Boutique physical labels, such as , persist with commentaries on Blu-ray editions, catering to niche collectors valuing archival depth. Economically, recording commentaries incurs notable costs, including participant fees—such as Arnold Schwarzenegger's $75,000 for Total Recall (1990)—plus studio time, editing, and synchronization, often without direct revenue tie-ins on ad-limited streaming models. Low stems from minimal user engagement metrics for extras, as platforms prioritize core playback over supplementary tracks, contrasting with DVD/Blu-ray eras where they boosted sales. This causal dynamic favors cost-cutting in , sustaining commentaries mainly in premium physical formats.

Controversies

Revealing or Contentious Statements

In the audio commentary track for Brazil (1985), recorded by director Terry Gilliam in 1996 for the Criterion Collection laserdisc edition, Gilliam explicitly recounts his legal and public battles with Universal Pictures executive Sidney Sheinberg, who unilaterally edited the film's ending from its original bleak dystopian resolution to a more commercially palatable version titled the "Love Conquers All" cut, released on December 25, 1985, without Gilliam's approval. Gilliam describes how this interference stemmed from Sheinberg's insistence on altering the narrative to avoid alienating audiences, highlighting causal tensions between executive risk aversion and directorial intent during the film's post-production in 1985. Gilliam further reveals in the same track that he resorted to guerrilla tactics, including smuggling a print of his preferred 142-minute version to the Film Festival on December 6, 1985, to bypass studio control and generate public support, an action that escalated the dispute and ultimately pressured Universal to release his cut theatrically in limited markets starting January 17, 1986. This unfiltered disclosure exposes empirical evidence of studio practices in the , providing raw data on how bureaucratic interventions can distort artistic output, though it drew retrospective criticism from some industry observers for portraying executives as antagonists without acknowledging commercial imperatives like the film's $15.1 million domestic gross against a $15-20 million . For Total Recall (1990), actor Arnold Schwarzenegger's DVD commentary, recorded alongside director , features Schwarzenegger delivering literal play-by-play narrations of on-screen actions, such as describing his character's movements in real-time—"Here Arnold grabs the gun and shoots"—which candidly underscores his focus on physical execution over during filming in 1989-1990. This approach, while revealing the pragmatic, stunt-driven mindset behind Schwarzenegger's performance in sequences like the Mars mutant reveal, sparked debate among listeners for its perceived lack of , contrasting with Verhoeven's more contextual insights and illustrating how participant candor can expose disparities in commentary contributions. Such statements in audio tracks yield unvarnished empirical details on production frictions—evident in Gilliam's documentation of specific edit timestamps altered by Sheinberg and Schwarzenegger's step-by-step breakdowns—offering causal clarity on processes often obscured in promotional materials. However, they have elicited backlash for "problematic" frankness, as when Gilliam's revelations fueled narratives of studio villainy that some outlets, influenced by Hollywood self-preservation, downplayed as exaggerated, despite verifiable outcomes like the dual-release formats. This tension underscores the tracks' role in preserving primary-source candor against sanitized retrospectives.

Ideological Biases and Production Disputes

Audio commentaries conducted by film historians or critics have drawn criticism for injecting political interpretations into discussions of ostensibly apolitical elements, such as technical craftsmanship or narrative structure, often aligning with prevailing left-leaning academic perspectives that prioritize socio-political framing over empirical production details. For instance, tracks emphasizing identity or power dynamics in like horror or action have been noted to overshadow insights into directing choices or decisions, potentially normalizing biased readings that diverge from the creators' original causal intents. In the case of Apocalypse Now (1979), Francis Ford Coppola's audio commentary elucidates production disputes exacerbated by the film's Vietnam War setting, including studio reluctance to engage controversial war themes amid post-The Green Berets (1968) industry aversion to such topics, which led to clashes over budget overruns—totaling $31.5 million against a $12 million plan—and narrative fidelity to Conrad's Heart of Darkness. These tensions mirrored the war's chaos, with Coppola recounting on-set typhoons, actor health crises (e.g., Martin Sheen's heart attack on May 25, 1977), and Marlon Brando's unprepared arrival in 1976, underscoring creator-studio frictions where Warner Bros. pressured cuts to align with commercial viability rather than unfiltered artistic exploration of moral ambiguity in conflict. Proponents of creator primacy argue that director-led tracks counteract such impositions by restoring , revealing how studios historically altered visions—e.g., executive overrides in —thus enabling audiences to discern authentic causal drivers from mediated ones. In 2025, boutique Blu-ray releases, such as those from labels emphasizing unedited director inputs like James Gunn's planned track for (2025), exemplify resistance to trend-driven narratives by prioritizing raw, independent creator perspectives over homogenized studio or critic overlays. This approach fosters truth-seeking analysis, bypassing institutional filters that might otherwise embed unsubstantiated ideological priors.

References

  1. https://www.hollywoodinsider.com/dvd-commentary-history/
  2. https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/5982-the-commentary-that-made-home-video-history
  3. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4byeD0jO15U
  4. https://www.modeemi.fi/~leopold/AV/LdFaq/Introduction.html
  5. https://analoghousou.com/2012/02/04/the-joy-of-laserdiscs/
  6. https://covell.ca/2022/02/12/obsolete-tech-7-2/
  7. https://www.filmdetail.com/2011/09/20/interesting-audio-commentaries-dvd-blu-ray-laserdisc/
  8. https://www.soundandvision.com/content/flashback-1997-dvd-players-go-sale
  9. https://videofileblog.com/2024/08/19/fifth-element-1997-home-video-visual-history-laserdisc-dvd-bluray-4k/
  10. https://ultimatepopculture.fandom.com/wiki/Audio_commentary
  11. https://www.amraandelma.com/dvd-marketing-statistics/
  12. https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=354426
  13. https://www.highdefdigest.com/news/show/Criterion_Collection/4kuhd/bluray/criterion-kicks-off-2024-with-new-4k-uhd-and-bluray-upgrades-and-debuts/48475
  14. https://www.theverge.com/23709897/directors-commentary-streaming-netflix-mike-flanagan-podcasts-vergecast
  15. https://entertainment.ie/movies/movie-news/disney-plus-director-commentaries-416988/
  16. https://www.criterionchannel.com/commentaries
  17. https://www.arrowvideo.com/p/blu-ray/steppenwolf-limited-edition-blu-ray/16247825/
  18. https://www.blu-ray.com/news/?id=36532
  19. https://variety.com/2025/film/news/boutique-blu-ray-labels-thrive-digital-age-sxsw-london-1236422030/
  20. http://www.fthismovie.net/2019/07/celluloid-ramblings-how-to-do-audio.html
  21. https://www.quora.com/How-long-do-DVD-movie-commentaries-take-to-record-I-assume-they-are-loosely-scripted-with-notes-but-not-enough-such-that-it-doesnt-sound-conversational
  22. https://www.344audio.com/post/the-ultimate-guide-to-audio-post-production-sound-design
  23. https://www.reddit.com/r/AudioPost/comments/hqineh/commentary_track_sync_issues_podcast/
  24. https://itsupplychain.com/5-common-challenges-in-converting-old-media-and-how-to-solve-them/
  25. https://gearspace.com/board/post-production-forum/451934-what-do-commentary-track-dvd.html
  26. https://www.sony.com/electronics/support/articles/00029663
  27. https://www.free-codecs.com/guides/why-eac3-is-the-next-big-thing-in-audio.htm
  28. https://boards.straightdope.com/t/are-there-commentary-tracks-on-netflix-or-other-streaming-services/1000499
  29. https://www.primetimer.com/quickhits/audio-commentary
  30. https://cinephiliabeyond.org/thief-michael-manns-cinema-debut-stole-worlds-attention/
  31. https://filmschoolrejects.com/30-things-we-learned-from-the-thief-commentary-a895492ff2a8/
  32. https://www.indiewire.com/features/craft/best-dvd-commentaries-on-filmmaking-1234879164/
  33. https://www.andsoitbeginsfilms.com/2018/09/an-exhaustive-and-unofficial-guide-to.html
  34. https://tongal.com/blog/community-guest-post/top-5-directors-commentaries
  35. https://www.wired.com/story/how-we-learn-filmmaker-commentary-tracks/
  36. https://movies.fandom.com/wiki/Audio_commentary
  37. https://www.adrianmartinfilmcritic.com/essays/audio.html
  38. https://letterboxd.com/journal/audio-commentary-physical-media/
  39. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bci3PStWJ4w
  40. http://commentaramafilms.blogspot.com/2011/09/few-of-my-favorite-audio-commentaries.html
  41. https://completecolorado.com/2018/12/14/film-critics-increasingly-bias-their-work-through-a-political-left-lens/
  42. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/249908381_DVD_Supplements_A_Commentary_on_Commentaries
  43. https://filmschoolrejects.com/19-things-we-learned-from-the-blazing-saddles-commentary-a1779300fd29/
  44. https://www.ign.com/articles/2004/10/13/the-must-hear-commentary-list
  45. https://www.rifftrax.com/home
  46. https://www.ign.com/articles/2004/10/12/the-bad-commentary-behavior-list
  47. https://www.highdefdigest.com/blog/roundtable-audio-commentaries/
  48. https://www.amazon.com/James-Bond-Ultimate-Octopussy-Moonraker/dp/B000ICM5VC
  49. https://www.slashfilm.com/1728184/banned-james-bond-laserdisc-commentaries-wildest-moments/
  50. https://archive.thedigitalbits.com/reviews2/sopranosseason1.html
  51. https://tvacdb.sandboxen.com/series/Sopranos
  52. https://www.reddit.com/r/thesopranos/comments/oobbuw/is_there_a_way_to_watch_the_series_with/
  53. https://developer.valvesoftware.com/wiki/Commentary_System
  54. https://www.combineoverwiki.net/wiki/Developer_commentary
  55. https://www.thegamer.com/games-with-developer-commentary/
  56. https://www.thegamer.com/the-last-of-us-dev-commentary-naughty-dog-too-many-voices/
  57. https://www.theverge.com/2016/9/21/12991786/firewatch-audio-tour-commentary-bioshock
  58. https://www.howtogeek.com/i-love-video-game-developer-commentaries-these-are-my-favorites/
  59. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IjpRG98kRF4
  60. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZttAmkpJRs
  61. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ODOqdJu5tE
  62. https://open.spotify.com/album/5uteT8q6ujaFIxyaGJe1Rf
  63. https://www.backstage.com/magazine/article/godspell-feature-broadways-first-ever-audio-commentary-52659/
  64. https://music.amazon.com/albums/B0FQ18J1PD
  65. https://veroniiiica.com/audio-description-for-broadway/
  66. https://www.hometheaterforum.com/community/threads/htf-review-james-bond-ultimate-edition-vol-4.249560/
  67. https://pbfiles.proboards.com/thread/532/ultimate-bond-dvd-editions
  68. https://spycommandfeatures.wordpress.com/continuity-in-james-bond-films/
  69. https://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/review/24871
  70. https://www.mi6-hq.com/news/index.php?itemid=2813
  71. https://www.filmbuffonline.com/FBOLNewsreel/wordpress/2014/05/11/listen-to-the-banned-commentary-tracks-from-criterions-james-bond-laserdiscs/
  72. https://hmssweblog.wordpress.com/2012/01/03/the-banned-007-commentaries-what-was-the-fuss/
  73. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-05-01-ca-1343-story.html
  74. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=834CpwtqQ3o
  75. https://www.culturesnob.net/2006/07/drunken-commentary-track-incid/
  76. https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/5s5edy/the_worst_and_best_commentary_tracks_youve_heard/
  77. https://allthetropes.org/wiki/DVD_Commentary
  78. https://forum.dvdtalk.com/dvd-talk/387440-please-help-what-dvd-has-drunken-audio-commentary.html
  79. https://framescinemajournal.com/article/film-studies-with-high-production-values/
  80. https://research.library.fordham.edu/comm_facultypubs/2/
  81. https://www.quora.com/Does-anyone-watch-DVD-commentaries-Why-or-why-not
  82. https://www.heroscapers.com/threads/dvd-audio-commentaries.32510/
  83. https://www.facebook.com/groups/videostorebackrooms/posts/1785634525399449/
  84. https://benwilliamsworld.wordpress.com/2020/10/07/the-art-of-a-good-dvd-commentary/
  85. https://tedium.co/2017/02/21/dvd-audio-commentary-decline/
  86. https://www.avforums.com/threads/listen-to-commentary-before-watching-the-film.1746965/
  87. https://johnaugust.com/2007/the-nines-audio-commentary
  88. https://www.cageyfilms.com/2011/05/the-real-pleasure-of-fake-commentaries/
  89. https://forum.blu-ray.com/showthread.php?t=364967
  90. https://www.movie-censorship.com/news.php?ID=4291
  91. https://www.austinchronicle.com/screens/hearing-voices-11714708/
  92. https://www.cracked.com/article_23866_6-hilariously-uncomfortable-rants-dvd-commentaries.html
  93. https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/kecpu9/how_arnold_schwarzenegger_changed_the_dvd/
  94. https://www.tasteofcinema.com/2016/15-entertaining-dvd-commentaries-every-film-fan-must-listen-to/
  95. https://www.historians.org/perspectives-article/the-historian-and-film-challenges-ahead/
  96. https://www.academia.edu/126531272/A_Knowledge_of_Horror_or_the_Horror_of_Knowledge_Frightfully_Insightful_Directors_Commentaries_on_Blu_rays_and_DVDs
  97. https://variety.com/2019/vintage/features/apocalypse-now-production-1203309358/
  98. https://cinephiliabeyond.org/apocalypse-now/
  99. https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20250701-the-inside-story-of-the-wildest-shoot-in-film-history-apocalypse-now
  100. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/aug/09/francis-ford-coppola-apocalypse-now-is-not-an-anti-war-film
  101. https://cinemaslave.wordpress.com/2007/07/05/audio-commentaries-or-bust/
  102. https://www.reddit.com/r/DC_Cinematic/comments/1mhlnnc/it_looks_like_were_getting_audio_commentary_for/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.