Hubbry Logo
Just KidsJust KidsMain
Open search
Just Kids
Community hub
Just Kids
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Just Kids
Just Kids
Just Kids
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Just Kids is a memoir by Patti Smith, published on January 19, 2010, documenting her relationship with artist Robert Mapplethorpe.[1]

Key Information

"I didn't write it to be cathartic," she noted. "I wrote it because Robert asked me to… Our relationship was such that I knew what he would want and the quality of what he deserved. So that was my agenda for writing that book. I wrote it to fulfill my vow to him, which was on his deathbed. In finishing, I did feel that I'd fulfilled my promise."[2]

Summary

[edit]

Foreword

[edit]

The memoir opens with the passing of Robert Mapplethorpe, Patti Smith’s close friend and former lover. She is asleep when he takes his last breath in the hospital, having bid him goodnight over the phone. As he struggles under heavy sedation, she senses it will be their final conversation.

The next morning, she awakens with a deep intuition of his death. Sitting in her study with a book of Odilon Redon’s artwork, an opera from Tosca plays softly on the TV. Soon after, Mapplethorpe’s younger brother calls to confirm her premonition.

Monday’s Children

[edit]

Patti Smith’s childhood begins in South Jersey in the 1950s and early ’60s, growing up in a working-class family with strict Jehovah’s Witness roots. Even as a child, she’s enthralled by books, drawing, and the idea of being an artist. Her influences are Arthur Rimbaud, Bob Dylan, and beat poetry.

In 1966, at the age of 19, she gets pregnant after a brief relationship and gives her baby up for adoption. In July 1967, she boards a bus to New York City with only a suitcase, some art supplies, and a copy of Illuminations by Rimbaud.

She works at a factory, then at Scribner’s bookstore—barely scraping by. Soon after arriving in the city, she meets Robert Mapplethorpe by chance in Brooklyn. They cross paths again weeks later at Brentano’s bookstore, and their relationship begins. They become inseparable. At first, they pose as a couple to protect each other from unwanted advances; eventually, they fall in love for real.

New York is in the middle of social problems—drugs, political unrest, and radical experimentation are everywhere. Smith and Mapplethorpe are focused on becoming artists.

Just Kids

[edit]

Living on practically nothing, they move from apartment to apartment, squatting and sometimes stealing to survive. Patti recalls their magical “bohemian fairy tale” life, where they try to make art out of everything—even poverty. In 1968, they move into the smallest room of the Allerton Hotel, and later into a loft on Hall Street, near the Pratt Institute where Robert had studied.

Robert begins to experiment with art more seriously—at first collages, talismans, and religious iconography—and later photography, especially after Patti gifts him a Polaroid SX-70 camera. Meanwhile, Patti explores writing poetry, sketches, and begins performing her work at open mics.

Robert starts to privately explore his sexuality. Though the sexual aspect of their relationship fades, their emotional bond only intensifies. Robert’s inner turmoil is evident: his Catholic guilt, his attraction to men, and his obsession with beauty create tension in his psyche and art. Patti is his muse, but he also begins to explore the erotic male form through photography and relationships with other men.

In 1969, Patti starts working at Scribner’s and watches artists like Andy Warhol and Edie Sedgwick from afar, both fascinated and alienated by their circle. Robert, meanwhile, begins to drift toward Warhol’s Factory, especially after connecting with art collector and curator Sam Wagstaff, who becomes his lover and patron later on.

Hotel Chelsea

[edit]

By 1970, Patti and Robert move into Room 1017 of the Hotel Chelsea, along with artists, writers and musicians. They befriend or observe many artistic figures, such as Janis Joplin, Jimi Hendrix, William S. Burroughs, Allen Ginsberg, and Sam Shepard (with whom Patti has a brief romance and collaborates on the play Cowboy Mouth).

Robert’s work begins to shift more toward photography, though he’s still hesitant to fully embrace it as his medium. Patti continues writing and drawing, but increasingly feels called to perform. She starts reading her poetry at St. Mark’s Church and the Poetry Project, immersing herself in the downtown literary and performance scenes.

In 1973, Patti meets guitarist Lenny Kaye, and together they start adding music to her poetry readings. This marks the beginning of what will become the Patti Smith Group. With the help of manager Jane Friedman, she transitions from poet to proto-punk frontwoman.

Separate Ways Together

[edit]

By 1974, Patti’s music career begins to take off. She records the iconic single “Hey Joe / Piss Factory”, and the Patti Smith Group gains a cult following performing at CBGB’s. In 1975, she releases her groundbreaking debut album Horses, with a cover photo taken by Robert.

Meanwhile, Robert comes into his own as a photographer. With support from Sam Wagstaff, he begins producing powerful, often controversial images of the male nude, BDSM, and religious iconography. His photographs are both celebrated and criticized for their provocative beauty. He exhibits in major galleries and solidifies his reputation in the art world.

The two grow apart physically—Patti marries Fred "Sonic" Smith in 1980 and moves to Detroit to start a family, eventually having two children—but she and Robert never lose their connection. They call and write to each other constantly. Robert sends her letters, photos, and small gifts.

Patti writes that she never stopped being his “guardian”, and he never stopped being her “twin flame”.

Holding Hands with God

[edit]

In 1986, Robert is diagnosed with AIDS. Patti, now living quietly in Detroit, re-enters his life more fully to support him. Robert continues to make art with astonishing discipline, photographing until he physically can’t. Patti visits him in New York and San Francisco, sometimes with her young children.

They collaborate once again: she writes poems and texts to accompany his work; he asks her to help curate and narrate his legacy. Patti describes Robert’s final exhibitions, particularly The Perfect Moment, which solidifies his place in art history.

Robert dies on March 9, 1989, at the age of 42. Patti is with him in his final days, praying, reading poetry, and holding his hand. She mourns him deeply, but finds solace in the promise they made: that she would tell their story.

Title

[edit]

The title comes from the chapter "Just Kids":[3]

We were walking toward the fountain of Washington Square Park in New York City, the epicenter of activity, when an older couple stopped and openly observed us. Robert enjoyed being noticed, and he affectionately squeezed my hand.

"Oh, take their picture," said the woman to her bemused husband, "I think they're artists."

"Oh, go on," he shrugged. "They're just kids."

Critical reception

[edit]

Just Kids won the 2010 National Book Award for Nonfiction.[4] It was Publishers Weekly's Top 10 Best Books (2010), ALA Notable Book (2011), Los Angeles Times Book Prize finalist (Current Interest, 2010), New York Times bestseller (Nonfiction, 2010), and National Book Critics Circle Award finalist (Autobiography/Memoir, 2010).

Just Kids was featured on the January 19, 2010, episode of Fresh Air, with Smith being interviewed by Terry Gross.[5] Just Kids was also featured on KQED's Forum with Michael Krasny on January 28, 2010, and KCRW's Bookworm with host Michael Silverblatt in March 2010.[6] It was the Book of the Week on BBC Radio 4 from 1–5 March 2010, with Smith reading five 15-minute excerpts from her book.[7]

Television series

[edit]

In August 2015, it was announced that Showtime was developing a limited series based on the memoir. The network landed the rights partly because Smith wanted to collaborate with writer John Logan, being a fan of his series Penny Dreadful.[8] However, the show has not yet been put in the works.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Just Kids

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
is a memoir by American musician, poet, and visual artist , published on January 19, 2010, that chronicles her early adulthood in during the late and , focusing primarily on her romantic and artistic relationship with photographer . Smith and Mapplethorpe met by chance in 1967, both aspiring artists navigating poverty, creative ambition, and the vibrant yet gritty Chelsea Hotel scene, where their partnership provided mutual support amid personal and professional hardships. The narrative traces their evolution from lovers to lifelong friends, highlighting Mapplethorpe's later exploration of his and his rise to prominence in photography, while Smith launched her music career, all set against the cultural ferment of pre-punk New York. Just Kids received the in 2010, praised for its lyrical prose and evocative portrayal of youthful idealism and artistic genesis. Though lauded for its intimacy and historical insight into the era's underbelly, the has been noted for its selective focus on personal myth-making over exhaustive factual scrutiny of the bohemian milieu.

Publication and Background

Writing Process and Motivations

Patti Smith committed to writing Just Kids following a request from Robert Mapplethorpe on March 8, 1989, the day before his death from AIDS-related complications on March 9. Mapplethorpe, aware of his terminal illness, urged Smith to document their shared early experiences in New York City, emphasizing the authenticity of their youthful artistic pursuits amid poverty and ambition. This promise formed the core motivation for the memoir, which Smith described as a fulfillment of her responsibility to preserve an unvarnished record of their bond, free from later sensationalism surrounding Mapplethorpe's controversial photography. The writing process spanned nearly two decades, with Smith delaying the project due to her ongoing music career, family obligations, and emotional weight of revisiting the period. She began in earnest around 2000 but completed the manuscript only in time for publication on January 19, 2010, by . Smith relied on her contemporaneous journals, letters, and photographs from the and to reconstruct events chronologically, aiming for a precise, narrative-driven account rather than introspective analysis. In interviews, she noted a meandering creative approach involving and immersion in personal artifacts, supplemented by self-editing before with editor Betsy Lerner, who provided structural guidance without altering the raw voice. Smith's motivations extended beyond the personal promise to capture the essence of an artist's formation in a pre-commercialized New York, highlighting resilience against hardship without romanticizing vice or excess. She expressed intent to offer readers insight into the origins of her own lyrical influences and Mapplethorpe's evolving vision, grounded in empirical details of their daily survival—such as scavenging for food and shelter—rather than mythic narratives. The memoir's restrained tone reflects Smith's deliberate choice to prioritize fidelity to lived events over interpretive flourish, as evidenced by her avoidance of hindsight judgments on their choices.

Release and Initial Context

was released in hardcover by , an imprint of Publishers, on January 19, 2010. The 304-page detailed Patti Smith's early years in and her relationship with artist , drawing from her experiences in the late and . A paperback edition followed on November 2, 2010. Upon release, the book received widespread critical acclaim for its evocative portrayal of bohemian New York. The New York Times praised it as "the most spellbinding and diverting portrait of funky-but-chic New York in the late '60s and early '70s that any alumnus has committed to print." Reviewers highlighted Smith's prose style, which blended poetic elements from her background with introspective narrative, marking a significant literary debut beyond her music career. In November 2010, Just Kids won the , announced on , affirming its place among top works of the year. Smith, accepting the award tearfully, noted the memoir's roots in her personal promise to Mapplethorpe, contributing to its emotional resonance with readers and critics. The win elevated the book's profile, leading to strong sales and recognition as a notable contribution to American literary memoirs.

Content Overview

Patti Smith and Robert Mapplethorpe's Early Lives

Patricia Lee Smith was born on December 30, 1946, in , , to parents Grant Smith, a machinist, and Beverly Smith, who had worked as a vocalist before becoming a waitress. As the eldest of four children in a working-class household, she experienced a childhood marked by a severe bout of around age four, which reportedly caused recurring hallucinations and influenced her later artistic sensibilities. The family relocated frequently during her early years, moving from Chicago to the Germantown area of and eventually settling in Pitman and Deptford Township, , where she attended Deptford Township High School. Smith developed an early interest in literature, poetry, and visual arts, drawing inspiration from figures like Rimbaud and , though her formal education reflected practical constraints; she briefly attended Glassboro State College (now ) on an art scholarship but left without completing a degree to pursue independent creative endeavors. By her late teens, she worked odd jobs including as a waitress and factory worker in , fostering a sense of independence amid modest circumstances that shaped her bohemian ethos before her 1967 move to . Robert Michael Mapplethorpe was born on November 4, 1946, in Floral Park, , New York, into a middle-class suburban family of Irish descent as the third of six children raised under strict Roman Catholic discipline. His father, Harry Irving Mapplethorpe, worked as an , and the household emphasized conventional values in a safe, orderly environment that Mapplethorpe later described as quintessentially American suburbia, contrasting sharply with his eventual artistic path. Early creative inclinations emerged through and , influenced by the family's modest means and religious routine, including weekly Mass attendance. Mapplethorpe enrolled at the in around 1966 to study graphic arts, commercial , and , initially participating in the as a short-haired conventional student before dropping out in 1969, one course shy of a B.F.A., amid growing disillusionment with structured academia and a shift toward experimental , assemblage, and found-object works. His pre-New York artistic explorations remained rooted in suburban until his late teens, when exposure to countercultural shifts prompted a departure from familial expectations toward urban independence.

Formation of Relationship in New York City

Patti Smith arrived in on July 3, 1967, leaving her home in with limited resources and aspirations toward artistic pursuits. Seeking shelter, she entered the former apartment of mutual friends who had relocated, where she encountered Robert Mapplethorpe asleep on the floor; he awoke, smiled, and escorted her on foot to the friends' new residence. This chance meeting marked the inception of their bond, as both, then in their early twenties and feeling like societal outsiders, recognized a shared affinity for nonconformity and creative ambition. In the ensuing days, Smith and Mapplethorpe spent their first evening together exploring downtown Manhattan, including St. Mark's Place, immersing themselves in the city's bohemian undercurrents amid the era's cultural ferment. Their connection deepened rapidly, evolving into a romantic relationship characterized by mutual support; they soon formalized a pact to care for one another while pursuing their respective artistic paths—Smith drawn to poetry and performance, Mapplethorpe to visual arts as a student at Pratt Institute. By that fall, the pair secured a shared residence at 160 Hall Street in , directly across from , where Mapplethorpe continued his studies in . Living amid financial precarity—often scavenging for sustenance and sheltering in sublets or squats—they pooled meager earnings from odd jobs, such as Smith's work at a bookstore, to sustain their bohemian existence. This early fostered an intense creative , with Mapplethorpe introducing Smith to avant-garde influences like Rimbaud and the Chelsea Hotel scene, while she encouraged his shift from to . Their relationship, though initially romantic, laid the groundwork for a lifelong artistic grounded in reciprocal inspiration and resilience against urban hardships.

Artistic Development and Shared Struggles

In the late 1960s, after meeting in during the summer of 1967, and dedicated themselves to artistic exploration amid acute financial deprivation. Both around 21 years old, they shared a modest apartment on Hall Street in , spending late nights painting and immersing themselves in music records, which fueled their creative synergy. Smith channeled her ambitions into poetry and drawing, influenced by Romantic poets like , while urging Mapplethorpe toward —a medium he embraced after initial experiments with sketching, starting with affordable Polaroid cameras due to their constrained means. Mapplethorpe's early photographic work included portraits of Smith, marking the beginnings of his distinctive style, as they collaborated side by side in dimly lit spaces, honing unrefined talents into focused disciplines. Smith later extended her poetry into performance and , while Mapplethorpe refined his lens-based art, each progression intertwined with the other's encouragement. Their shared hardships encompassed chronic , with periods of including sleeping on streets, and deliberate sacrifices such as forgoing meals to afford art supplies—often weighing a against drawing materials. Living in squalid, low-rent hotels plagued by addicts and instability, they endured Mapplethorpe's bouts of illness like trench mouth and , emblematic of their precarious immersion in the city's fringes, before relocating to the Chelsea Hotel in 1969, a notorious artist enclave that amplified both risks and inspirations. Despite these adversities, their bond provided critical sustenance, with Mapplethorpe affirming Smith's destiny for recognition—"Patti, you got famous before me"—and Smith reciprocating faith in his vision, enabling both to persist from raw aspiration toward professional breakthroughs in , , and eventually and .

Separation, Later Years, and Mapplethorpe's Death

As their romantic partnership evolved, Smith and Mapplethorpe ended their physical relationship around 1970, coinciding with Mapplethorpe's initial forays into photography, though they preserved an enduring artistic and personal friendship thereafter. Smith later reflected that this shift allowed each to pursue individual growth—hers toward and , his toward self-exploration through —without severing their mutual support. Despite occasional physical distance, such as Mapplethorpe's temporary moves, their bond persisted as a cornerstone of creative inspiration, with Smith appearing as a muse in his early portraits and Mapplethorpe contributing the iconic cover image for her 1975 debut album . In the ensuing decades, Smith achieved breakthroughs in punk rock and poetry, including her rise with the Patti Smith Group, while Mapplethorpe established himself as a provocative photographer known for black-and-white portraits, floral still lifes, and explicit depictions of sadomasochism and male nudes, earning acclaim and controversy through exhibitions at institutions like the in the late 1970s and 1980s. Their friendship endured amid these parallel trajectories, marked by ongoing collaboration and emotional reliance; Smith described Mapplethorpe's duality—spanning tenderness and intensity—as a constant in her life, even as his work increasingly explored themes of sexuality and power. Mapplethorpe's health deteriorated in the mid-1980s amid the AIDS epidemic, leading to his diagnosis in 1988, after which he focused on completing major projects, including the X Portfolio series. Mapplethorpe died on March 9, 1989, at age 42 from AIDS-related complications in a hospital, following a rapid decline that included and other opportunistic infections. Smith, aware of his terminal condition, penned a poignant final letter in early 1989 expressing enduring love and shared history, which he received but could not reply to before his death; she later incorporated reflections on this loss into her , emphasizing their unbreakable connection forged in youth. His passing prompted Smith to retreat from public life temporarily, channeling grief into writing and family, while Mapplethorpe's estate continued to advocate for AIDS research and posthumously.

Themes and Interpretation

Pursuit of Art Amid Hardship

In Just Kids, depicts her and Robert Mapplethorpe's early years in as a period of acute financial deprivation, where both, originating from working-class families—Smith from southern and Mapplethorpe from —arrived in 1967 with scant resources and no safety net, driven solely by ambitions in , , and . Smith, 20 years old upon her arrival on July 28, 1967, met the 21-year-old Mapplethorpe that same day at a acquaintance's apartment, and they quickly formed a partnership that prioritized artistic experimentation over economic security, often subsisting on scavenged or donated food while residing in sublets and rundown accommodations. By 1968, the pair relocated to the Chelsea Hotel's cheapest room (Room 99), a $15-per-week space that served as both shelter and studio amid the hotel's eclectic artist community, yet their existence there underscored persistent scarcity: Smith took low-wage jobs, such as factory work and later at Scribner's bookstore, while Mapplethorpe resorted to occasional and odd modeling gigs to fund basic needs, all while forgoing steady employment that might have diverted time from creation. Despite such —including periods of hunger, illness, and eviction threats—they channeled limitations into output, with Smith producing poetry and collages from salvaged materials and Mapplethorpe experimenting with a $3.99 plastic camera and handmade frames from discarded wood, viewing austerity as integral to authentic expression rather than an obstacle. This ethos of endurance manifested in deliberate choices, such as Mapplethorpe's abandonment of commercial graphic design training at to pursue undiluted by market demands, and Smith's rejection of conventional paths post-high school to immerse in Greenwich Village's literary scene, where they supported each other's visions through shared rituals like museum visits on free days and late-night critiques. Their bond provided psychological ballast against isolation; Smith recounts in the how Mapplethorpe's encouragement sustained her during bouts of mononucleosis and self-doubt, while she in turn bolstered his shift toward provocative imagery, illustrating a causal dynamic where interpersonal commitment amplified resilience amid material hardship. Ultimately, this phase forged their trajectories—Smith toward punk poetry and music by the mid-1970s, Mapplethorpe toward controversial portraiture—demonstrating how unyielding focus on craft, undeterred by poverty's toll, yielded breakthroughs in a city that rewarded audacity over affluence.

Influence of 1960s-1970s Counterculture

Smith and Mapplethorpe's experiences in Just Kids exemplify the 's ethos of communal living and artistic nonconformity, as they arrived in in 1967 amid a vibrant scene of poverty-driven creativity and rejection of bourgeois norms. Smith, having left a factory job in , and Mapplethorpe, a college dropout, subsisted on meager resources—often scavenging food or trading art for rent—while immersing themselves in the bohemian underworld of the and later the Chelsea Hotel starting in 1970. The Chelsea, a dilapidated yet iconic residence for figures like and , served as their base, fostering an environment of unbridled experimentation where residents bartered talents and defied conventional morality, including casual drug use and fluid relationships. This era's countercultural spirit profoundly shaped their artistic development, drawing from beat generation precursors like Allen Ginsberg and William S. Burroughs, whom Smith encountered at venues such as Max's Kansas City, described in the memoir as the "social hub of the subterranean universe." Their collaborations—Mapplethorpe photographing Smith in androgynous poses inspired by poets like Rimbaud, and Smith's poetry evolving into proto-punk performances—inherited the 1960s emphasis on authenticity over commerce, evident in her disdain for Andy Warhol's pop art, which she viewed as emblematic of a superficial culture she actively shunned. The duo's alignment with groups like the Fugs, known for dissonant, satirical music, prefigured punk's raw edge while embodying the counterculture's fusion of literature, music, and visual art as tools for personal and social rebellion. Yet Just Kids also subtly critiques aspects of the , highlighting its subjective and often chaotic nature rather than idealizing it uncritically; Smith portrays the scene's freedoms—sexual, artistic, and racial—as enabling their bond but not without hardships like illness and exploitation. Their trajectory from hippie-adjacent to the more disciplined punk ethos of the mid- reflects a cultural shift from communal idealism to 1970s individualism, with Mapplethorpe's later turn to explicit challenging even countercultural boundaries on subjects. This portrayal underscores the memoir's role as a of New York's "funky-but-chic" underbelly, where countercultural ideals sustained dreamers amid .

Personal Bonds and Loss

Smith and Mapplethorpe's relationship, as chronicled in Just Kids, originated as a romantic liaison upon their meeting on July 3, 1967, but evolved into a deep, non-sexual companionship after Mapplethorpe recognized his exclusive attraction to men in the early . Smith describes this shift not as a rupture but as a refinement of their "alchemical connection," marked by unwavering loyalty amid New York's bohemian underbelly, where they shared scant resources, artistic ambitions, and a pact to succeed or perish together. This bond endured separations—Smith's rise in and Mapplethorpe's ascent in provocative —sustained by correspondence, mutual inspiration, and Smith's role as a stabilizing presence during his later excesses. The underscores their interdependence, with Smith portraying Mapplethorpe as her artistic and emotional anchor, who in turn drew from her resilience during his own explorations of sadomasochistic themes and celebrity portraits. Despite diverging paths, their connection remained familial; Smith recounts nursing him through dependencies and celebrating his breakthroughs, framing their tie as one of "innocence and experience" forged in poverty's . This portrayal aligns with Smith's interviews, where she emphasizes their shared as the foundation for lifelong trust, unmarred by conventional romantic dissolution. Mapplethorpe's decline from AIDS, diagnosed in the mid-1980s, culminated in his death on March 9, 1989, at age 42 from related complications, a loss Smith depicts as shattering yet transformative. The day prior, amid acute suffering, he extracted her promise to chronicle their youth, a she fulfilled in Just Kids over two decades later. In the book, Smith appends a poignant farewell letter written post-mortem, affirming their eternal linkage: "Robert, your death has made me a better person," reflecting on grief's alchemical refinement of character rather than mere . This narrative of loss prioritizes their pre-fame intimacy over Mapplethorpe's controversial later oeuvre, attributing enduring value to their formative pact amid irreversible severance.

Critical Reception

Positive Assessments and Achievements

Just Kids received the in 2010, recognizing its evocative depiction of Smith's early years and relationship with Mapplethorpe in 1960s and 1970s . The award, presented on November 17, 2010, highlighted the memoir's lyrical quality and emotional depth, with Smith dedicating it to Mapplethorpe during her acceptance speech. Critics praised the book's prose and authenticity. The New York Times described it as "the most spellbinding and diverting portrait of funky-but-chic New York in the late '60s and early '70s that any alumnus has committed to print," commending its vivid recreation of the era's artistic scene. called it "riveting and exquisitely crafted," noting Smith's chronicle of her intense life with Mapplethorpe as a musician, poet, and visual . The Guardian characterized the work as "widely praised," emphasizing its account of their transition from flatmates to influential artists amid shared hardships. The memoir's commercial success included strong initial sales following its January 19, 2010, publication by , bolstered by Smith's established reputation in music and . Its enduring appeal is evidenced by sustained reader engagement, with over 340,000 ratings averaging 4.2 on as of recent data, reflecting broad appreciation for its themes of friendship, ambition, and loss.

Criticisms and Skeptical Views

Some reviewers have argued that Just Kids presents an overly sanitized and romanticized depiction of the authors' early struggles in , downplaying the raw hardships of and personal setbacks. For instance, the narrative emphasizes artistic aspirations and serendipitous encounters while glossing over severe privations, such as chronic hunger or the grittier aspects of bohemian survival, leading to a portrayal that feels more fable-like than unflinchingly realistic. Similarly, critic Tom Carson in noted the memoir's evocative style but implied a selective focus on "funky-but-chic" elements of the era, potentially idealizing the countercultural milieu at the expense of its causal undercurrents like exploitation or transience. Critics have also pointed to notable omissions in Smith's account, including her pre-New York experience of giving birth to and relinquishing a child for adoption in 1967, which is absent despite its relevance to her motivations and emotional landscape during the period covered. This selective memory contributes to skeptical views that the book functions as a hagiographic tribute to Mapplethorpe, prioritizing mythic elevation over comprehensive self-scrutiny or the complexities of their bond, such as his emerging substance issues and shifting sexuality. Furthermore, some readers and reviewers have critiqued the prose for excessive name-dropping of era luminaries—Jimi Hendrix, Sam Shepard, and others—which can dilute the intimacy and render the text tiresome rather than illuminating. Stylistic shortcomings have drawn comment as well, with detractors describing the pacing as languid and the recollections as aloof or vague, attributing this to the distance of hindsight that imbues events with undue poise rather than immediacy. These elements have fueled broader about the memoir's balance, particularly given mainstream acclaim that may overlook flaws in venerating 1960s-1970s , where empirical grit yields to lyrical . Such views, though minority amid the book's 2010 win, underscore debates over memoirs' fidelity to causal realism versus .

Adaptations and Media

Planned Television Series

In August 2015, Showtime announced the development of a limited television series adaptation of Patti Smith's memoir Just Kids, chronicling her early relationship with artist in 1960s and 1970s . The project is co-written and executive produced by Smith and screenwriter John Logan, whose prior efforts include Showtime's . Logan had initially pursued a before the network greenlit the series format in a competitive bidding process. Smith's involvement extends to production under her Desert Wolf Productions banner, emphasizing fidelity to the memoir's account of their shared artistic struggles and bohemian milieu. As of October 2025, the series remains in development without announced , production start, or details, consistent with many announced adaptations that stall post-acquisition.

Legacy and Controversies

Cultural and Artistic Impact

has shaped perceptions of the 1960s and 1970s New York City bohemian art scene by chronicling the raw struggles and creative ferment experienced by Patti Smith and Robert Mapplethorpe in environments like the Chelsea Hotel. The memoir details their mutual pledge to prioritize art over conventional stability on Memorial Day 1967, illustrating a model of dedication amid poverty and uncertainty that resonates with accounts of the era's avant-garde underbelly. Its 2010 National Book Award for Nonfiction elevated the work's status, selling over one million copies worldwide and fostering renewed scholarly and public interest in Mapplethorpe's formative years, distinct from his later polarizing homoerotic . By humanizing Mapplethorpe as a supportive collaborator in Smith's poetic and musical evolution, the book contextualizes their intertwined trajectories, influencing interpretations of punk rock's roots and photographic innovation. Artistically, Just Kids underscores symbiotic relationships in creative genesis, portraying how Smith and Mapplethorpe's shared hardships and encouragements fueled individual breakthroughs—Smith toward her 1975 debut album , Mapplethorpe toward collage and Polaroid experimentation. This narrative has been credited with validating artmaking as a viable, albeit grueling, life path, inspiring reflections on perseverance in contemporary creative circles despite scant direct attributions from named artists.

Debates Over Mapplethorpe's Work and Memoir's Portrayal

Mapplethorpe's photographic oeuvre, particularly his depictions of homoerotic themes, sadomasochistic practices, and nude figures including children, ignited significant public and legal debates in the late 1980s and early 1990s. The touring retrospective The Perfect Moment (1988–1990), organized by the Institute of Contemporary Art at the University of Pennsylvania, featured over 150 works, including explicit images that prompted accusations of obscenity and challenges to federal arts funding. In June 1989, the Corcoran Gallery of Art in Washington, D.C., canceled its scheduled hosting amid pressure from conservative politicians and donors, fearing backlash over taxpayer-supported National Endowment for the Arts (NEA) grants totaling $30,000 for related projects; this decision fueled broader discussions on censorship and the boundaries of publicly funded art. The controversy escalated in October 1989 when the (CAC) in opened the exhibit, leading to the indictment of the museum and its director, Dennis Barrie, on seven counts of under law—five for photographs of consensual adult gay sadomasochism and two for images of nude children. The September 1990 trial, the first in U.S. history to prosecute an art museum for , centered on whether the works lacked "serious artistic value" per the (1973) test; defense experts, including artists and curators, argued the images exemplified classical aesthetic traditions and contemporary expression, while prosecutors emphasized community standards of indecency. The jury acquitted Barrie and the CAC after two days of deliberation, affirming First Amendment protections for provocative art but intensifying partisan divides over NEA appropriations, which Congress conditioned on content restrictions in 1990. Patti Smith's Just Kids (2010), which chronicles their formative years in –1970s New York, portrays Mapplethorpe primarily as a struggling, idealistic artist grappling with identity and medium, emphasizing mutual artistic inspiration over his later explicit explorations. Smith acknowledges his emerging and their brief romantic involvement but frames it through a lens of shared bohemian hardship and spiritual , noting her own initial lack of toward his orientation as a regret. Critics have debated this depiction's selective focus, arguing it romanticizes an earlier, less controversial phase while eliding the mature themes—such as ritualized and racial —that defined his posthumous notoriety and legal battles, potentially presenting a hagiographic counter-narrative to perceptions of his work as emblematic of unchecked sexual provocation. Supporters counter that the memoir's scope is deliberately autobiographical and chronological, capturing pre-fame authenticity without obligation to adjudicate his evolved oeuvre's ethical or artistic merits.

References

  1. https://www.npr.org/2010/01/15/122582840/patti-smith-remembers-life-with-mapplethorpe
  2. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/18/books/18book.html
  3. https://www.kirkusreviews.com/book-reviews/patti-smith/just-kids-2/
  4. https://www.nationalbook.org/books/just-kids/
  5. https://www.npr.org/2010/11/18/131406120/patti-smith-s-just-kids-wins-nonfiction-award
  6. https://www.audible.com/blog/an-in-depth-interview-with-patti-smith
  7. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/how-patti-smiths-just-kids-changed-my-life/
  8. https://www.kingsreview.co.uk/interviews/conversation-with-patti-smith
  9. https://archives.nypl.org/mss/23973
  10. https://www.npr.org/2010/01/19/122722618/just-kids-punk-icon-patti-smith-looks-back
  11. https://longfellowbooks.com/book/9780066211312
  12. https://www.amazon.com/Just-Kids-Patti-Smith/dp/0060936223
  13. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/31/books/review/Carson-t.html
  14. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/11/18/books/18awards.html
  15. https://www.cleveland.com/books/2010/11/patti_smiths_just_kids_wins_na.html
  16. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2010/nov/18/patti-smith-national-book-award
  17. https://www.biography.com/musicians/patti-smith
  18. https://rockhall.com/inductees/patti-smith/
  19. https://highprofiles.info/interview/patti-smith/
  20. https://www.highroadtouring.com/artists/patti-smith-and-her-band/
  21. https://www.mapplethorpe.org/biography
  22. https://www.tate.org.uk/art/artists/robert-mapplethorpe-11413/photographs-robert-mapplethorpe
  23. https://www.getty.edu/art/collection/person/103KMY
  24. https://www.service95.com/patti-smith-on-robert-mapplethorpe
  25. http://www.oceanstar.com/patti/poetry/shots.htm
  26. https://dsps.lib.uiowa.edu/downtownpopunderground/story/patti-smith-moves-to-new-york-city/
  27. https://www.theguardian.com/music/2010/jan/31/patti-smith-robert-mapplethorpe
  28. https://nublockmuseum.blog/2018/03/07/collection-spotlight-patti-smith-robert-mapplethorpe/
  29. https://brieswax.substack.com/p/beautiful-breakups-art
  30. https://www.interviewmagazine.com/culture/patti-smith-and-robert-mapplethorpe
  31. https://pattismith.substack.com/p/world-aids-day
  32. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/patti-smith-robert-mapplethrope-final-letter-1989/
  33. https://www.openculture.com/2024/06/patti-smith-reads-her-final-letter-to-robert-mapplethorpe.html
  34. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2010/feb/13/just-kids-patti-smith-biography
  35. https://whitehotmagazine.com/articles/review-patti-smith-just-kids/2118
  36. https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1002&context=kb_pubs
  37. https://wp.nyu.edu/writingnewyork3/storyboard-9/
  38. https://camasonian.com/19981/ae/just-kids-an-ode-to-the-beatniks-and-the-subjectivity-of-counterculture/
  39. https://npg.si.edu/blog/just-kids-patti-smith-and-robert-mapplethorpe
  40. https://www.mcnallyjackson.com/book/9780060936228
  41. https://www.npr.org/transcripts/122722618?storyId=122722618
  42. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/arts/conversation-patti-smith-1
  43. https://www.jimdero.com/News%25202010/PattiSmithMapplethorpe.htm
  44. https://www.seattleweekly.com/music/qa-patti-smith-on-christ-cobain-and-robert-mapplethorpe/
  45. https://pattismith.substack.com/p/remembering-robert-mapplethorpe
  46. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/32315914-just-kids
  47. https://746books.com/2014/07/30/no-711-just-kids-by-patti-smith/
  48. https://www.connotationpress.com/book-review/449-book-review-just-kids-by-patti-smith
  49. https://www.rocktownhall.com/blogs/book-review-patti-smiths-just-kids/
  50. https://www.paramountpressexpress.com/showtime/releases/?view=43285
  51. https://www.rollingstone.com/tv-movies/tv-movie-news/patti-smith-plots-just-kids-memoir-adaptation-series-for-showtime-57173/
  52. https://www.billboard.com/music/rock/patti-smith-just-kids-showtime-series-6663020/
  53. https://www.theguardian.com/music/2015/aug/12/patti-smith-to-turn-just-kids-memoir-into-tv-show
  54. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2023545/
  55. https://www.apollonejournal.org/apollon-journal//a-pretty-little-place-patti-smiths-just-kids-and-the-artistic-domestic-space-1
  56. https://www.bookey.app/topic/exploring-the-legacy%253A-how-many-copies-has-just-kids-sold-worldwide%253F
  57. https://artsemerson.org/2019/10/10/the-story-of-smith-and-mapplethorpe-from-just-kids-to-revolutionaries/
  58. https://www.huckmag.com/article/what-patti-smiths-just-kids-taught-me-about-priorities
  59. https://quod.lib.umich.edu/m/mqr/act2080.0049.419/--dying-art-form-and-loss-in-patti-smiths-just-kids?g=mqrg%3Brgn=main%3Bview=fulltext%3Bxc=1
  60. https://politicalresearch.org/1991/05/01/mapplethorpe-censorship-controversy
  61. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/when-art-fought-law-and-art-won-180956810/
  62. https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/robert-mapplethorpe/
  63. https://blogs.getty.edu/iris/i-defended-mapplethorpe-in-the-trial-that-drew-the-line-between-art-and-obscenity/
  64. https://bulletin.hds.harvard.edu/into-the-infinite-together/
  65. http://www.billdawers.com/2011/01/03/some-thoughts-on-just-kids-by-patti-smith/
  66. https://www.bookforum.com/culture/just-kids-by-patti-smith-4981
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.