Hubbry Logo
Manger SquareManger SquareMain
Open search
Manger Square
Community hub
Manger Square
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Manger Square
Manger Square
Manger Square
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Manger Square, in Central Bethlehem

Manger Square (Arabic: ميدان المهد; Hebrew: כיכר האבוס) is a city square in the center of Bethlehem in Palestine. It takes its name from the manger where Jesus is said to have been born which, according to Christian tradition, took place at the Grotto of the Nativity, enshrined since the fourth century in the Church of the Nativity. A particular building set in Manger Square is the Mosque of Omar, the Old City's only mosque, and the Palestinian Peace Center. The streets that lead to the square are related to the Christian faith, such as Star Street and Nativity Street.

In 1998–1999, the square was renovated to relieve the traffic congestion and currently is, to a large degree, pedestrian only. It is mainly a meeting place for locals and for the town's many pilgrims. There are rows of celtis australis trees that provide shade to its people, with benches and fountains made of yellowish-white local limestone known as Naqab marble.

Christmas celebrations

[edit]
Main article: Christmas Eve
Christmas Eve 2006 at Manger Square.
Manger Square and Mosque of Omar.

Manger Square is a focal point for all of the Christmas celebrations in Bethlehem, with a giant Christmas tree crowning the square. It is the traditional spot where locals and pilgrims sing Christmas carols before the midnight mass at the Church of the Nativity. The Greek Orthodox Patriarchate of Jerusalem and the Armenian Apostolic Church follow the Julian Calendar liturgically, whereas the Roman Catholic Church follows the modern Gregorian Calendar. Thus Christmas Eve services for the Eastern and Western confessions are held on different days. The Roman Catholic Church celebrates the Nativity on 25 December; the Orthodox celebrations are on 7 January.

Venue for sports and cultural activities

[edit]

On 21 April 2013, Manger Square was the starting and finishing line of Palestine Marathon.

Church of the Nativity siege

[edit]
Main article: Siege of the Church of the Nativity in Bethlehem

In May 2002, during an Israel Defense Forces raid on the square a part of Operation Defensive Shield, a number of locals (some of whom were armed) and peace activists took refuge in the Church of the Nativity.[1] It became the site of a five-week stand-off. The number of people inside was estimated between 120 and 240. It was alleged by Palestinians that several Palestinians inside the church compound were shot dead by Israeli snipers during the siege. The siege ended with an agreement for 13 militants to be sent via Cyprus to various European countries and another 26 to be sent to Gaza. The rest were set free. The IDF stated that 40 explosive devices were found and removed from the compound after the standoff was concluded.[2]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Manger Square

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Manger Square is the central public square in , , , situated directly in front of the , which Christian tradition identifies as the site of Christ's birth in a . Historically functioning as a for fruits, , and during the Ottoman period, the square's old market was relocated in 1929 to the Old City, after which it evolved into a key social and cultural venue. Renovated between 1998 and 2000 to alleviate and promote pedestrian access, it now primarily serves as a gathering place for pilgrims, tourists, exhibitions, concerts, and community events, particularly annual celebrations. Adjoining the square are the Mosque of Omar—Bethlehem's only mosque—the Palestinian Peace Center, souvenir shops, and the Bethlehem Municipality building established in 1872, underscoring the area's interfaith and administrative significance. As part of the World Heritage-listed pilgrimage route to the , Manger Square facilitates ceremonial processions by Christian patriarchs and embodies the site's enduring spiritual importance dating to at least the 2nd century CE.

Geography and Location

Physical Description and Key Landmarks

Manger Square constitutes a paved open plaza at the heart of 's Old City, serving as the primary in the area. The square's layout centers on a broad, stone-paved expanse designed for pedestrian access and gatherings, with surrounding facades featuring a mix of historical and functional architecture. Its dimensions accommodate large crowds, though exact measurements are not publicly specified in municipal records. Directly bordering the square to the east stands the , the ancient basilica marking the traditional site of Jesus's birth, alongside the adjacent Church of Saint Catherine. To the west, across the plaza, lies the Mosque of Omar, Bethlehem's sole mosque, constructed in 1860 and exemplifying interfaith proximity in the urban core. The square is encircled by commercial establishments including souvenir shops and restaurants, as well as administrative structures such as the Bethlehem Municipality headquarters and the Palestinian Peace Center. These elements form a compact, vibrant perimeter under the jurisdiction of the Palestinian Authority, which assumed control of in 1995 following the . The overall configuration emphasizes accessibility to religious sites while integrating everyday urban functions.

Historical Development

Ancient Origins and Religious Foundations

The designation "Manger Square" originates from the accounts of the in which the infant was placed following his birth in , as recorded in Luke 2:7—"And she brought forth her firstborn son, and wrapped him in swaddling clothes, and laid him in a ; because there was no room for them in the inn"—and alluded to in Matthew 2:11, where the find the child "with Mary his mother" in a house. Christian tradition has long associated this event with a specific in , a connection first attested in written sources by the early Church father around 150 AD, who described Jesus's birth occurring in "a certain cave" outside the village. This identification, corroborated by later writers like in 248 AD, reflects an unbroken oral and tradition linking the site to the nativity narrative, supported by the 's transformation into a venerated locus by the . In 326 AD, Constantine I ordered the construction of the original directly over the , enclosing it within a designed by his mother Helena's architects, which established the foundational layout of the surrounding open space as an approach to the sacred site. This paved forecourt, precursor to the modern square, facilitated early pilgrim access and was expanded during the Byzantine period under in the , with archaeological evidence including floors and structural reinforcements confirming these modifications through stratigraphical of walls and pavements. The area's religious foundations were further evidenced by excavations revealing pre-Constantinian cave dwellings and water systems repurposed for use, underscoring the site's continuity as a nativity focal point amid layered occupational history. Subsequent conquests influenced the site's preservation without fundamentally altering its core religious function: following the Arab Muslim conquest of in 637 AD under Caliph , protections were extended to Christian holy places, including Bethlehem's church, via assurances against destruction or , as documented in the broader capitulation terms for that applied regionally. Crusader forces assumed control of Bethlehem on June 7, 1099, during the , integrating the church into Latin ecclesiastical administration while conducting repairs to the basilica's nave and doors. From 1517 onward, under Ottoman Turkish rule, the square and church maintained Christian custodianship through the Status Quo arrangements, though physical expansions were restricted and the structures fell into disrepair, with the forecourt serving secular uses like markets amid ongoing denominational disputes. These phases, verified by historical charters and excavation layers, preserved the nativity tradition while limiting autonomous development of the approach area.

Modern Formation and Urban Evolution

During the Ottoman period prior to , Manger Square functioned primarily as an open-air where locals gathered to trade fruits, , and , marking its initial formalization as a central in Bethlehem's urban layout. This role persisted into the British Mandate era (–1948), during which urban regulations began shifting spatial use toward more structured public attribution, though specific infrastructure expansions in the square remain sparsely documented in municipal records. After the 1948 Arab-Israeli War, the square came under Jordanian administration as part of the West Bank's annexation, maintaining its market functions amid limited urban modernization until the in 1967 transferred control to Israeli military . Israeli oversight from 1967 to 1995 emphasized tourism infrastructure around the adjacent , indirectly influencing the square's role in accommodating growing visitor numbers despite constrained local planning autonomy. The Oslo Accords facilitated the transfer of Bethlehem, including Manger Square, to Palestinian Authority control in December 1995, enabling autonomous municipal initiatives amid rising population pressures and tourism demands. Between 1998 and 2000, renovations transformed the square by replacing asphalt with patterned stone tiles, adding edge plantings and fountains, and designating much of it as pedestrian-only to reduce congestion and improve accessibility for large crowds, in preparation for the 2000 millennium celebrations. These changes addressed urban evolution challenges from Bethlehem's expanding resident base and seasonal pilgrim influxes, prioritizing durable paving and open-space reclamation over vehicular dominance.

Religious and Cultural Significance

Biblical and Christian Importance

Manger Square derives its name and significance from its immediate proximity to the , which encompasses the of the Nativity venerated by as the precise site of 's birth and placement in a . The records that Mary gave birth to in and laid him in a due to lack of available guest room space (:7). This scriptural account, combined with prophecy foretelling the Messiah's emergence from ( 5:2), underpins the site's theological centrality, though the exact location relies on early Christian identification rather than direct biblical coordinates. Historical veneration of the as the site traces to the second century, with (~150 AD) referencing a near as the birthplace, and (~248 AD) noting a specific in pointed out to visitors as containing the . By the fourth century, Emperor Constantine commissioned construction of the original church over the around 326 AD, formalizing its status based on local tradition preserved amid Roman pagan use of the site. Pilgrim accounts, such as that of Egeria in the late fourth century, describe liturgical observances at 's church, attesting to its established role in early Christian devotion despite reliance on oral and emerging written testimonies over archaeological proof of the precise spot. The site's importance spans Catholic, Eastern Orthodox, Oriental Orthodox, and Protestant traditions, though custodianship of the is shared exclusively among the Greek Orthodox, Armenian Apostolic, and Roman Catholic (Franciscan) communities under the Status Quo agreement formalized by Ottoman in 1852 and affirmed internationally thereafter. This arrangement preserves denominational rights to specific areas and rites, reflecting ecumenical tensions but unified recognition of the nativity event's doctrinal weight across creeds. Bethlehem's Christian population, which constituted approximately 86% in 1950, has declined to around 12% by 2016, primarily through emigration spurred by , political instability, and localized security threats under Palestinian Authority governance since 1995, factors compounding rather than solely deriving from external pressures. This demographic shift underscores challenges to sustaining a local Christian witness at the site, even as global pilgrimage reaffirms its enduring scriptural and historical claim.

Role in Pilgrimage, Tourism, and Local Economy

Manger Square functions as the central hub for pilgrims and in , drawing crowds for its proximity to the and serving as a venue for photographs, street markets selling olive wood carvings and religious artifacts, and guided tours. Prior to escalations in regional violence, received 2 to 3.5 million visitors annually, with many focusing activities around the square during high seasons; for instance, approximately 150,000 visited during the 2019 period. These influxes peak around Christian holidays, supporting local vendors and service providers directly tied to the square's layout and events. Tourism centered on Manger Square contributes substantially to Bethlehem's , accounting for about 70% of the city's annual through expenditures on lodging, souvenirs, and guides. The square's markets and surrounding infrastructure facilitate transactions in handicrafts and hospitality, with pre-2020 peaks generating millions in seasonal income; disruptions, such as those from the and subsequent conflicts, have led to daily losses exceeding $2.5 million across tourism, disproportionately affecting as a key node. In stable years, visitor spending sustains employment in related sectors, underscoring the square's role in economic resilience amid fluctuating access. Israeli measures, including checkpoints like Checkpoint 300 and the constructed after 2002, have constrained tourist flows by complicating entry from , contributing to declines during heightened tensions such as the intifadas. Visitor numbers rebounded in relatively peaceful intervals, reaching highs around 2010 when eased restrictions allowed broader access, but slumps followed violence, reducing annual totals from millions to under 100,000 in conflict-affected years like 2024. Palestinian Authority oversight enables organized festivals in the square but coincides with internal challenges, including inadequate infrastructure and sporadic instability, which amplify risks from militarized holy sites and deter sustained recovery. Empirical data show correlates inversely with incidents, with factors like limited legislative support for planning exacerbating vulnerabilities beyond external barriers.

Public Uses and Events

Christmas and Festive Celebrations

Manger Square hosts Bethlehem's primary celebrations, centered on a large erected annually and illuminated in early December, such as on December 3 in 2022 or December 2 in 2018, drawing thousands of attendees including dignitaries and locals for the . These events feature parades of uniformed Palestinian scouts in yellow and gold capes marching through the square, accompanied by music and drums, alongside markets selling crafts and nativity scenes. The festivities culminate in at the nearby on December 24 for Western Christians, often broadcast internationally, with crowds gathering in the square for concerts and illuminations. Since 1995, following the and the establishment of Palestinian Authority control over , the PA has organized these annual events, with attending midnight mass and addressing gatherings in Manger Square during the inaugural celebrations. Arafat's participation in 1996 further highlighted the square's role in post-Oslo symbolic displays of Palestinian governance amid the holiday observances. Pre-2023 events typically attracted thousands to tens of thousands of pilgrims and visitors in peak years, such as the bustling crowds reported in 2019, though numbers varied based on regional conditions. Adaptations accommodate both Western (December 25) and Eastern Orthodox (January 7) calendars, with additional processions, scout parades, and services filling the square for Orthodox rites, including Greek, Coptic, and Syriac communities converging for evening liturgies and cultural performances. Nativity scenes and festive decorations adorn the area, maintaining traditions with roots in early Christian practices but scaled up in modern organized festivals.

Sports, Cultural Activities, and Community Gatherings

Manger Square hosts annual cultural festivals that highlight Palestinian traditions, such as the Olive Harvest Festival held each October, featuring displays of local produce, music, and artisanal demonstrations centered on olive oil production, a staple of regional heritage. The event, which has occurred regularly since the early 2000s, draws community participation and vendors to the square, transforming it into a marketplace of traditional foods and crafts. The Cultural Festival, organized to promote Palestinian arts and identity, includes performances like folk dances in Manger Square, as seen in the 2021 launch event with flash mobs and group dances emphasizing communal expression through rhythm and movement. These activities, incorporating music, theater, and heritage elements, have been featured since the festival's inception in the 2010s, providing a platform for local artists amid regional challenges. Sports events in the square focus on community runs, including the , an annual race open to youth, families, and visitors that starts or gathers at Manger Square to encourage and local . Larger endurance events, such as the Marathon, have also originated from the square, routing participants through 's streets to symbolize resilience and mobility in the community. These gatherings, including markets and performances, support social cohesion among Bethlehem's diverse residents by facilitating public interaction, though the square's compact size—approximately 0.5 hectares—and intermittent security restrictions from unrest often limit scale and frequency, particularly during heightened tensions. Since the Palestinian Authority assumed control in the mid-1990s, such events have increasingly incorporated elements affirming local identity, distinct from religious observances.

Conflicts and Security Incidents

2002 Church of the Nativity Siege

The 2002 siege of the Church of the Nativity occurred from April 2 to May 10 amid Israel's Operation Defensive Shield, a military campaign in the West Bank launched in response to escalating Palestinian suicide bombings during the Second Intifada that had killed over 400 Israelis since September 2000. On April 2, approximately 200 Palestinians—including armed militants from groups like Hamas and Fatah, Palestinian police, and civilians—entered the church compound after gunmen in Manger Square fired at advancing Israeli Defense Forces (IDF), prompting the IDF to surround the site and impose a blockade. The militants had initially sought refuge near the church, exploiting its status as a Christian holy site to deter Israeli counteraction, with eyewitness accounts confirming armed fighters positioned themselves inside the basilica and cloisters alongside about 50 resident monks and nuns. During the 39-day standoff, the IDF cut off water, electricity, and most food supplies to pressure the militants to surrender, while allowing limited under international mediation; inside, tensions rose as militants reportedly seized food stores from and pilgrims, leading to shortages and internal conflicts. Israeli snipers from rooftops killed seven —identified as militants—and wounded around 40 others in exchanges of fire originating from the church, with no IDF casualties reported from the site. Palestinian forces occasionally fired from windows and the courtyard, while the IDF avoided direct assault to minimize damage to the fourth-century structure, though critics on both sides accused the other of risking the site's integrity: Palestinians for militarizing a sacred refuge, and for prolonged tactics that left the compound without utilities. Negotiations, brokered by U.S., , and Vatican intermediaries, culminated in an agreement on May 10, under which about 123 exited into Manger Square for screening; of these, 13 senior militants were deported to (initially , then redistributed to countries like and ), while 26 others were sent to Gaza, and the remainder released or detained locally. The resolution averted a storming of the church but highlighted the militants' strategic use of religious sites, as verified by clergy and eyewitness reports, amid broader actions that dismantled terrorist infrastructure across the .

Broader Political Tensions and Impacts on Christian Community

Following the , and Manger Square came under Palestinian Authority (PA) control in December 1995, marking the transfer of the city's administration from Israeli oversight. This shift enabled the militarization of public spaces in , including the square, as PA security forces and affiliated militias engaged in internal factional violence, such as clashes between loyalists and operatives, often spilling into central areas and placing nearby Christian holy sites in the crossfire. Empirical data from NGO reports indicate a marked increase in anti-Christian incidents under PA , including , of churches, and linked to rising Islamist influences, with PA officials frequently failing to prosecute perpetrators due to and within security apparatuses. The Christian population in Bethlehem has plummeted from approximately 86% in 1950—when the area was under Jordanian control—to about 10-12% as of the 2017 Palestinian census, reflecting accelerated under PA rule compared to earlier periods. Primary drivers include targeted violence, such as beatings and kidnappings of , alongside economic boycotts by Muslim groups pressuring Christian businesses and land expropriations facilitated by weak PA enforcement against Islamist networks. PA , documented in audits revealing millions in unaccounted funds and mismanagement, has eroded religious freedoms by prioritizing factional loyalties over minority protections, fostering an environment of impunity. While some Palestinian sources attribute emigration to Israeli security measures and economic restrictions, independent analyses and local Christian testimonies emphasize internal causal factors like religious coercion and governance failures under PA control, contrasting sharply with areas under Israeli administration. For instance, Bethlehem's Christian share was around 60% during Israeli control until 1995, whereas Israel's overall Christian population has grown to 1.8% (187,900 individuals) as of 2023, with Arab Christian communities in Nazareth expanding due to relative stability and economic opportunities absent in PA territories. This disparity underscores how PA incitement—evident in school curricula and media glorifying militancy—and institutional corruption have disproportionately impacted the Christian community, leading to a 80-90% demographic decline in PA-controlled areas per recent studies.

Recent Developments and Challenges

Tourism Fluctuations and Economic Effects

Following the Second Intifada (2000–2005), tourism to , with Manger Square as its focal point for pilgrim gatherings, experienced severe declines, as and closures reduced visitor numbers from pre-2000 levels of over 1 million annually to near halt, with hotel occupancy dropping below 10% in peak seasons. Recovery began after 2005 with eased restrictions, culminating in a 2010 peak of approximately 1.5 million visitors to the city, driven by improved security and international marketing of events in the square. This represented a 60% year-over-year increase, though much revenue flowed to Israeli operators due to controls. Pre-COVID highs reached around 2 million visitors yearly by 2019, sustaining square-adjacent shops and hotels. Subsequent slumps included the (2020–2022), which halved hotel guests and caused $200 million in losses for Bethlehem's tourism-dependent enterprises, including those around Manger Square, through global travel bans and local lockdowns. Israeli entry restrictions during this period, aimed at curbing virus spread amid cross-border movement, further limited access, dropping daily hotel from 8,000 guests to minimal levels. Numbers partially rebounded in late 2022 but plunged again post-October 2023 amid Gaza conflict spillover, with 2024 visitors falling below 100,000— a 95% drop from 2019—leading to hundreds of square-area business closures and exceeding 30% in roles. These fluctuations tie to verifiable conflict variables: Israeli security barriers and checkpoints, erected post-2002 in response to over 1,000 suicide bombings from areas during the , reduced terrorism by 90% but impose delays on tourists, correlating with lower peaks despite demand. Palestinian Authority governance issues, including documented in public funds, exacerbate losses by diverting potential festival and investments, though tourism revenue shortfalls compound annual business losses estimated at tens of millions for square-reliant vendors during downturns. Attempts to diversify beyond religious pilgrimages—such as promoting walks or adventure sites near Manger Square—have faltered amid recurrent instability, with deterring non-faith-based visitors and failing to offset religious tourism's dominance, which accounts for over 65% of local GDP. Persistent barriers to movement, rooted in threat mitigation, limit broader appeal, underscoring tourism's vulnerability to regional dynamics over internal diversification efforts.

Ongoing Regional Conflicts and Cancellations

In , restrictions combined with Israeli entry limitations significantly muted public events in Manger Square, limiting foreign tourist access and reducing attendance at celebrations to a fraction of pre- levels, with Palestinian officials criticizing the measures as politically motivated barriers to . By 2022, showed partial recovery, with increased visitor numbers during the holiday season drawing crowds to the square for festivities after two years of subdued activity, signaling a rebound in economic activity tied to eased controls. This upturn was abruptly halted by escalations following Hamas's October 7, 2023, attack on , which initiated the ongoing Gaza war and prompted Palestinian Authority (PA) and church leaders to cancel traditional events in Manger Square for 2023 and 2024, including the absence of the annual lighting and decorations, resulting in an empty square and attendance at historic lows. Decisions for these cancellations, framed by PA officials as solidarity with Gaza amid over 20,000 Palestinian deaths reported in the conflict, contrasted with empirical data showing the war's origins in Hamas's assault that killed 1,200 Israelis and took 250 hostages, highlighting how militant actions in Gaza have cascaded into regional disruptions affecting sites like . The square's future use remains contingent on of hostilities, as World Bank assessments indicate that while external conflicts drive short-term tourism drops—evidenced by near-total visitor absence in 2023-2024—sustained recovery also hinges on PA-internal factors such as reforms to enhance and reduce , which have historically correlated with higher pilgrim inflows independent of isolated ceasefires.

References

  1. https://www.bethlehem-city.org/en/manger-square
  2. https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1433/
  3. https://jerusalemfoundation.org/old-project/manger-square/
  4. https://www.beinharimtours.com/manger-square/
  5. https://www.bethlehem-city.org/en/mosqueofomar
  6. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+2%3A7%2C+Matthew+2%3A11&version=KJV
  7. https://theconversation.com/bethlehem-and-beyond-how-christianitys-earliest-sites-were-identified-151719
  8. https://biblearchaeologyreport.com/2021/12/10/o-little-town-of-bethlehem-2/
  9. https://www.britannica.com/place/Church-of-the-Nativity
  10. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1296207412001653
  11. https://nativitylover.com/archaeological-finds-under-church-of-the-nativity
  12. https://www.islamicity.org/11511/capture-of-jerusalem-the-treaty-of-umar/
  13. https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/bas-onsite/church-of-the-nativity/
  14. https://socratesjourney.org/88-bethlehem-and-the-church-of-the-nativity/
  15. https://thisweekinpalestine.com/on-the-edge/
  16. https://www.bethlehem-city.org/en/history-of-bethlehem
  17. https://read.dukeupress.edu/radical-history-review/article/2017/129/125/131952/Colonization-and-Resistance-at-Bethlehem-s-Manger
  18. https://www.jpost.com/features/in-thespotlight/this-week-in-history-bethlehem-changes-hands
  19. https://www.southcoasttoday.com/story/lifestyle/1997/11/10/bethlehem-planners-want-manger-square/50591026007/
  20. https://www.wrmea.org/2000-march/peace-center-completes-rehabilitation-of-manager-square-for-year-long-bethlehem-2000-observances.html
  21. https://www.holylandsite.com/bethlehem-nativity-church
  22. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Luke+2&version=NIV
  23. https://www.ccel.org/ccel/schaff/anf01.viii.iv.lxxviii.html
  24. https://www.historyhit.com/locations/church-of-the-nativity/
  25. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1582160
  26. https://www.jerusalemstory.com/en/article/what-status-quo
  27. https://www.beinharimtours.com/church-of-the-nativity-bethlehem/
  28. https://www.ncronline.org/bethlehems-declining-christian-population-casts-shadow-over-christmas
  29. https://jcpa.org/article/demographics-dont-lie-the-christian-population-in-pa-and-hamas-controlled-areas-is-declining/
  30. https://www.bethlehem-city.org/en/the-city-economy
  31. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/dec/24/no-room-in-bethlehems-inns-as-tourists-return-for-christmas-season
  32. https://www.timesofisrael.com/palestinians-in-bethlehem-look-beyond-religious-tourism/
  33. https://time.com/5752224/bethlehem-christmas/
  34. https://www.travelandtourworld.com/news/article/bethlehem-artisans-struggle-as-conflict-and-us-tariffs-take-toll-on-tourism-and-exports/
  35. https://www.haaretz.com/middle-east-news/palestinians/2024-08-28/ty-article-magazine/.premium/life-has-been-hell-inside-bethlehem-the-west-banks-tourism-capital-turned-ghost-town/00000191-97e9-d13a-ab93-dfff37850000
  36. https://nextcity.org/features/checkpoint-300-and-the-architecture-of-control
  37. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2010/dec/26/bethlehem-tourism-boom-israel
  38. https://halifax.citynews.ca/2024/12/24/bethlehem-marks-a-second-subdued-christmas-during-the-war-in-gaza/
  39. https://i-rep.emu.edu.tr/xmlui/bitstream/handle/11129/5142/Odehmustafa.pdf?sequence=1
  40. https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20181210-tourism-in-bethlehem-booming-as-christmas-nears/
  41. https://ffhl.org/its-officially-christmas-in-bethlehem/
  42. https://www.timesofisrael.com/thousands-gather-in-bethlehem-for-christmas-tree-lighting/
  43. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/christmas-festivities-begin-in-bethlehem
  44. https://www.timesofisrael.com/thousands-flock-to-bethlehem-for-christmas-celebrations/
  45. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/bethlehem-bustling-as-pilgrims-flock-there-to-celebrate-christmas-today-2019-12-24/
  46. https://www.nytimes.com/1995/12/25/world/christmas-in-bethlehem-arafat-at-midnight-mass.html
  47. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1995/12/24/o-little-town-greet-arafat/0251f22f-a5dd-4724-9756-76d3a420b480/
  48. https://time.com/archive/6929473/christmas-in-bethlehem/
  49. https://www.beinharimtours.com/news/christmas-in-bethlehem/
  50. https://www.jpost.com/travel/travel-news/orthodox-christmas-continues-in-the-holy-land
  51. https://enjoybethlehem.com/see/manger-square
  52. https://academic.oup.com/edited-volume/34256/chapter/290415800
  53. https://www.bethlehem.ps/en/Category/23/bethlehem-%25E2%2580%2593-festivals
  54. https://reliefweb.int/report/occupied-palestinian-territory/palestine-wide-participation-olive-harvest-festival
  55. https://www.bethlehemculturalfestival.com/event-archive/flash-mob-in-manger-square/
  56. https://www.prosperoworld.org.uk/bethlehem-cultural-festival
  57. https://www.bethlehem-city.org/en/bethlehem-5k-run
  58. https://www.merip.org/2018/05/running-as-resistance-in-occupied-palestine/
  59. https://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/2011/dec/22/archive-big-day-in-little-town-1995
  60. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/operation-defensive-shield
  61. https://jcpa.org/article/the-vatican-and-the-standoff-at-the-church-of-the-nativity/
  62. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/1919666.stm
  63. https://sanjosepeace.org/a-palestinian-christian-eyewitness-remembers-the-israeli-military-siege-of-the-church-of-the-nativity/
  64. https://www.wrmea.org/2001-december/centuries-long-immunity-from-attacks-on-bethlehem-s-church-of-nativity-ends.html
  65. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/1950331.stm
  66. https://electronicintifada.net/content/israeli-distortions-during-siege-church-nativity/3984
  67. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2002/may/06/israel
  68. https://www.baptistpress.com/resource-library/news/bethlehem-standoff-ends-as-palestinians-exit-church/
  69. https://jcpa.org/article/palestinian-crimes-against-christian-arabs-and-their-manipulation-against-israel/
  70. https://www.opendoors.org/research-reports/country-dossiers/WWL-2025-Palestinian-Territories-Persecution-Dynamics
  71. https://jcpa.org/wp-content/uploads/2011/11/Christian-Persecution-Weiner.pdf
  72. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/another-bleak-christmas-bethlehem-christian-families-quit-west-bank-2024-12-01/
  73. https://persecution.org/2008/01/13/bethlehem-churches-bear-brunt-of-religious-hatred/
  74. https://www.ynetnews.com/article/hkavbxyhjl
  75. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/palestinian-authority-history-and-overview
  76. https://www.state.gov/reports/2019-report-on-international-religious-freedom/israel-west-bank-and-gaza/west-bank-and-gaza
  77. https://www.facebook.com/hnaftali/posts/bethlehems-christian-population-has-plummetedfrom-60-under-israeli-control-to-le/1114731230334678/
  78. https://cmc-terrasanta.org/en/media/terra-santa-news/35960/statistics-on-christians-in-israel
  79. https://allarab.news/new-study-on-why-palestinian-christians-are-abandoning-bethlehem/
  80. https://unispal.un.org/pdfs/Beth_Rep_Dec04.pdf
  81. https://www.archbalt.org/boost-in-tourism-to-bethlehem-in-2010-pleases-palestinian-businesses/
  82. https://fox5sandiego.com/news/ap-bethlehem-is-set-to-mark-a-second-subdued-christmas-during-the-war-in-gaza/
  83. https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/covid-palestine-bethlehem-lack-pilgrims-tourism-tatters
  84. https://jcpa.org/whistleblower-exposes-palestinian-authority-corruption/
  85. https://english.wafa.ps/Pages/Details/140054
  86. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2007/12/25/bethlehems-struggles-continue
  87. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160738324000938
  88. https://www.972mag.com/bethlehem-tourism-christmas-israel/
  89. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/12/24/bethlehem-resumes-christmas-celebrations-covid-restrictions
  90. https://www.timesofisrael.com/bethlehem-welcomes-back-christmas-visitors-as-post-pandemic-tourism-soars/
  91. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/no-christmas-tree-bethlehem-holiday-pared-down-over-gaza-war-2023-12-02/
  92. https://www.npr.org/2024/12/24/nx-s1-5236858/christmas-celebrations-in-bethlehem-are-canceled-for-a-second-year
  93. https://apnews.com/article/bethlehem-christmas-israel-hamas-war-e408a3e48d18c69a7a0b018505cdc732
  94. https://www.cnn.com/2023/12/24/middleeast/bethlehem-christmas-gaza-war-intl
  95. https://www.timesofisrael.com/bethlehem-plans-muted-christmas-festivities-under-shadow-of-israel-hamas-war/
  96. https://thedocs.worldbank.org/en/doc/7600aee6c75eff4cf9b71ea1fe4016db-0280012023/original/NoteWBG-dec11-CLEAN.pdf
  97. https://mas.ps/cached_uploads/download/migrated_files/20141911102123-1-1640016282.pdf
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.