Hubbry Logo
The ChrysanthemumsThe ChrysanthemumsMain
Open search
The Chrysanthemums
Community hub
The Chrysanthemums
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
The Chrysanthemums
The Chrysanthemums
The Chrysanthemums
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Chrysanthemums and Other Stories book cover

"The Chrysanthemums" is a short story by American writer John Steinbeck. It was first published in 1937 before being included as part of his collection The Long Valley the following year.

Plot summary

[edit]

The story opens with a panoramic view of the Salinas Valley in winter. The focus narrows and finally settles on Elisa Allen, cutting down the spent stalks of chrysanthemums, in the garden on her husband's ranch. Elisa is thirty-five, lean and strong, and she approaches her gardening with great energy.[1] Her husband, Henry, comes from across the yard, where he had been arranging the sale of the thirty steers. Then he offers to take Elisa to town so they can celebrate the sale. He praises her skill with flowers, and she congratulates him on doing well in the negotiations for the steer. They seem to be a well-matched couple, though their way of talking together is formal and serious. While talking about their plan to go out, Henry jokingly asks Elisa if she would like to see a fight. Showing no interest, Elisa refuses and says she wouldn't like it. They agree on dinner and a movie instead. Elisa decides to finish her transplanting before they get ready to leave for town.[2]

Elisa hears "a squeak of wheels and a plod of hoofs," and a man drives up in an old spring wagon (He is never named; the narrator simply calls him “the man”).[1] Earning a meagre living, he fixes pots and sharpens scissors and knives. He travels from San Diego to Seattle and back every year. The man chats and jokes with Elisa, but she admits that she has no work for him to do. When he presses for a small job, she becomes annoyed and tries to send him away.

Suddenly, the man's attention turns to the flowers that Elisa is tending. When he asks about them, Elisa's annoyance vanishes and she becomes friendly again. The man remembers seeing chrysanthemums before and describes them: “Kind of a long-stemmed flower? Looks like a quick puff of colored smoke?”.[1] Elisa is delighted with his description. The man tells her about one of his regular customers who also gardens. He claims this customer has asked him to bring her some chrysanthemum seeds if he ever finds some in his travels, and Elisa is happy to oblige. She invites the man into the yard and prepares a pot of chrysanthemum shoots for the putative woman's garden. She gives him full instructions for tending them. Elisa envies the man's life on the road and is attracted to him because he understands her love of flowers. In a moment of extreme emotion, she nearly reaches for him but snatches her hand back before she touches him. Instead, she finds him two pots to mend, and he drives away with fifty cents and the chrysanthemum shoots, promising to take care of them until he can deliver the chrysanthemums to the other woman.

Elisa goes into the house to get dressed for dinner. She scrubs herself vigorously and examines her naked body in the mirror before putting on her dress and makeup. When Henry sees her, he compliments her, telling her she looks "nice," “different, strong and happy”.[1] When Henry and Elisa drive into town, she sees "a dark speck" ahead on the road. It turns out the man tossed her chrysanthemum shoots out of his wagon, but kept the pot Elisa had put them in. She feels hurt. Henry does not notice and Elisa does not mention it to him. It's then that Elisa brings up an interest in the fights that night. She asks if "women ever go to the fights". Henry answers "Oh sure, some", but reminds her that she probably wouldn't like it. She agrees and says the night out alone will be plenty. She turns her head so he cannot see her crying. She also says she feels like an old woman.

Characters

[edit]

Elisa Allen - A thirty-five-year-old woman who lives on a ranch just across the Salinas River with her husband, Henry. Elisa is described as having a "lean and strong" face and eyes as "clear as water" and when wearing her gardening costume, she looks like she has a blocked and heavy figure.[1] Elisa usually spends her time in the garden, tending to her chrysanthemums.

Henry Allen - Elisa's husband who lives on the ranch with her. He loves Elisa's passion for the garden but cannot seem to understand why she never uses her gift for anything else besides the chrysanthemums.

The Man - A travelling mender who arrives on the road in a wagon that has a canvas painted with the words "Pots, pans, knives, sisors, lawn mores, Fixed." on it.[1] The man is not given a formal name throughout the story.

Symbolism

[edit]

The Language of Flowers often translate to symbolism commonly within literature. In "The Chrysanthemums," the chrysanthemum flowers are frequently used as a symbol throughout the story.

The chrysanthemums are mentioned throughout the story and can be seen a symbol of Elisa. Chrysanthemum stems are long, strong, and tough which are symbolic of Elisa's masculine qualities. However, the flower itself is delicate and tender which represents the parts of Elisa that are feminine. The contradictory characteristics of chrysanthemums being both strong yet beautiful epitomize how Elisa is atypical of a woman for being both masculine and feminine.[3] This is proven true when Elisa sees the flowers in the middle of the road and that the pot is gone; she is hurt by the discovery almost as if she is the flower herself. Elisa viewed it as letting herself be free and just getting hurt as a result. Many critics also argue that the chrysanthemums are a symbol of women's frustration.[4]

Another thing that the chrysanthemums symbolize is "Elisa's children". It is seen periodically throughout the story by how Elisa cares for and protects her chrysanthemums.[5]

Overall, the chrysanthemums symbolize Elisa's role as a woman in society. In the beginning, they symbolize her children, but as we continue reading, they start to symbolize her femininity and sexuality. Elisa gets annoyed with her life because a child and romantic encounters are nonexistent in her marriage. Her husband, Henry, also does not cater to her emotional needs and the qualities of her womanhood. She eventually thinks that things will change, but once she sees the chrysanthemums in the road, she realizes that her hopes have died as well.[5]

There is also the symbolism about confinement. The story opens by describing the setting of the fog over the Salinas Valley "like a lid on the mountains and [make] of the valley a closed pot."[6] This foreshadows Elisa's situation of being unable to truly please her husband with her gift of raising Chrysanthemums in addition to being unaware of people who may try to deceive her for personal gain.[original research?]

Film version

[edit]

A twenty-three-minute filmed version was made in 1990 by Steve Rosen for Pyramid Films of Santa Monica.

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

The Chrysanthemums

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
"The Chrysanthemums" is a by American author , first published in the October 1937 issue of and subsequently included in his 1938 collection The Long Valley. Set in California's during winter, the narrative follows Elisa Allen, the wife of a rancher, as she nurtures plants in her garden, revealing her inner strength and latent capabilities amid a routine existence marked by domestic and marital constraints. An encounter with a traveling awakens Elisa's suppressed aspirations, only for disillusionment to follow when she discovers the discarded remnants of her gifted chrysanthemums, underscoring themes of unfulfilled potential and gender-defined limitations in rural society. Renowned for its economical prose and layered symbolism—wherein the chrysanthemums represent Elisa's fertility, sexuality, and stifled ambitions—the story exemplifies Steinbeck's early mastery of character-driven realism and has been widely anthologized for its incisive portrayal of personal desolation.

Publication and Historical Context

Publication History

"The Chrysanthemums" first appeared in print in the October 1937 issue of , marking John Steinbeck's initial publication of the . This magazine appearance preceded its inclusion in Steinbeck's broader collection of works set in California's . The story was later anthologized in The Long Valley, Steinbeck's 1938 short story collection published by , which compiled several of his regional narratives from the period. No significant revisions to the text are documented between the magazine serialization and the book edition, preserving the original narrative structure and . Subsequent reprints have appeared in various Steinbeck anthologies and literary compilations, but the 1937–1938 publications remain the foundational ones.

Biographical Influences and Setting in 1930s America

The short story is set in California's Salinas Valley during a foggy December in the early 1930s, a time of economic strain under the Great Depression. The narrative centers on the Allen ranch in the Valley's foothills, where the protagonist Elisa Allen cultivates chrysanthemums in a wire-fenced garden, amid a landscape of cultivated fields stretching toward distant mountains obscured by "grey-flannel fog." This rural agricultural setting captures the isolation and seasonal dormancy of the region, with winter marking a lull in ranch activities like cattle sales, while underscoring broader challenges for western U.S. farmers, such as depressed crop prices, mechanization pressures, and influxes of migrant workers seeking stability in California's more fertile areas. Steinbeck, born in Salinas in 1902 to a family involved in local agriculture and business, drew directly from the Valley's topography, climate, and social dynamics for the story's authenticity, as evidenced by his recurring use of the area in works like . His depiction of Elisa's inner conflict reflects observations of women's circumscribed roles in 1930s , where capable individuals were often confined to domestic and supportive functions amid patriarchal norms and economic uncertainty. Biographer Jackson J. Benson proposed that Elisa was modeled on Steinbeck's first wife, Carol Henning—whom he married in and who assisted with typing and editing his manuscripts—highlighting parallels in talent, domestic entrapment, and unfulfilled potential during their shared life in modest circumstances.

Narrative Structure

Plot Summary

The short story "The Chrysanthemums" by , first published in in October 1937 and later included in the collection The Long Valley (Viking Press, 1938), centers on Elisa Allen, a rancher's wife in California's during a foggy winter afternoon. Elisa tends vigorously to her garden, demonstrating physical strength and gardening expertise while wearing heavy gardening gloves, a man's hat, and a blue dress with an "apron" over it. Her husband, Henry, approaches to discuss a successful sale and invites her to join him on a trip to Salinas for dinner and possibly a match or . This highlights her domestic isolation on the ranch. A in a shabby drawn by a and two dogs arrives, seeking work repairing pots and pans; Elisa initially rebuffs him, asserting no need for his services, but engages when he compliments her cultivation and shares tales of selling such flowers to appreciative women in distant towns, stirring her suppressed sense of adventure and capability. She gifts him shoots in an old pot for his supposed resale, cleans up meticulously, dresses in her finest attire, and rides to town with Henry feeling invigorated; en route home, however, she spots the discarded flowers and pot roadside, recognizing the tinker's insincere flattery merely to acquire the pot, which leaves her weeping "weakly—like an old woman" as the story closes.

Key Characters

Elisa Allen is the protagonist of the story, depicted as a 35-year-old woman who is lean, strong, and clear-eyed, residing on a in California's during the 1930s. She possesses a talent for cultivating chrysanthemums, which she tends with precision and affection in her fenced garden, reflecting her inner vitality and capacity for nurturing despite her domestic constraints. Elisa exhibits a mix of suppressed energy and emotional depth, yearning for broader experiences beyond her routine life, as evidenced by her animated response to the tinker's tales of distant adventures. Henry Allen, Elisa's husband, serves as the owner and embodies pragmatic focused on business matters such as sales and ranch operations. He interacts with Elisa in a cordial but somewhat detached manner, commenting on her skills while inviting her to join him in town, yet failing to grasp her deeper frustrations or emotional needs. Henry's character highlights the limitations of their marital dynamic, where his well-intentioned but superficial engagement underscores Elisa's isolation. The Tinker, an itinerant traveling with pots and repair tools, represents an external for Elisa's momentary awakening. Described as a rugged, persuasive figure with a laden with household goods, he engages Elisa by feigning interest in her chrysanthemums to secure work, thereby drawing out her fantasies of freedom and adventure. His opportunistic nature culminates in discarding the chrysanthemums after obtaining a pot sale, symbolizing the superficiality of the connection he offers.

Literary Techniques

Setting and Atmosphere

The short story unfolds in California's during a foggy December in , a period marked by agricultural challenges in the region. The primary location is Henry Allen's ranch in the foothills, where protagonist Elisa Allen maintains a fenced amid the broader rural expanse of wire fences and cultivated fields. This foothill ranch setting evokes the isolation of Depression-era farming life, with hay-cutting activities paused under overcast skies. Steinbeck establishes the atmosphere through the pervasive "grey-flannel fog of winter" that blankets the valley, closing it off from the and surrounding mountains like a lid on a pot, fostering a of and detachment from external influences. The cold, tender air and light southwest wind introduce a subdued mood of quiet waiting and mild among farmers for , yet underscore an underlying stagnation that permeates the and characters' lives. This foggy confinement parallels Elisa's internal repression, amplifying themes of limited horizons in a rural environment where personal vitality clashes with environmental and economic desolation. The ranch's orderly yet barren features—such as the white farmhouse, stone post pillars, and Elisa's wire garden fence—contrast with the blooming chrysanthemums, heightening atmospheric tension between and sterility. This duality evokes a restrained emotional undercurrent, where the valley's natural beauty harbors subtle , reflective of broader constraints in isolated agrarian settings.

Symbolism and Motifs

The chrysanthemums function as the central symbol in Steinbeck's narrative, embodying Elisa Allen's latent vitality, feminine sexuality, and frustrated aspirations. Cultivated with meticulous care in the winter season when they lie dormant, the flowers parallel Elisa's own robust yet constrained potential, thriving under her attention much as she yearns for recognition beyond her domestic role. This symbolism extends to her childlessness, with the plants evoking maternal instincts channeled into gardening rather than family. The itinerant and his wagon represent elusive and masculine , contrasting sharply with Elisa's enclosed life and stirring her suppressed desires for and excitement. His opportunistic awakens her briefly, symbolizing a transient escape from gender-bound limitations, yet underscoring the motif of as he discards her gifted shoots after securing a repair job. The tinker's transient nature thus motifs human disconnection, highlighting how superficial interactions fail to bridge profound isolation. The reinforces motifs of confinement and emotional stasis, depicted as a "closed pot" that traps potential like the valley's winter barrenness mirrors Elisa's inner . This atmospheric enclosure symbolizes broader human limitations, with the encroaching motif evoking psychological barriers that prevent fulfillment, even as Elisa glimpses distant mountains representing unattainable horizons. Recurring images of strength—such as Elisa's vigorous with or her armored care—interweave with these, motifing repressed power that surfaces momentarily but dissipates, as seen in the discarded pot of shoots she later spies roadside.

Narrative Style and Point of View

The "The Chrysanthemums" employs a third-person limited point of view, centered primarily on the Elisa Allen, which grants readers access to her internal thoughts, emotions, and sensory perceptions while restricting insight into the minds of other characters. This perspective enables Steinbeck to delve deeply into Elisa's psychological state—her suppressed vitality, fleeting sense of during the tinker's visit, and ultimate disillusionment—without omniscient that would reveal external motivations, such as those of her husband Henry or the tinker. Steinbeck's narrative style is characterized by vivid, sensory descriptions that blend realism with subtle psychological depth, often mirroring Elisa's confined existence through the repetitive rhythms of her gardening and the stark imagery of the fog. The prose is concise and economical, employing simple sentence structures punctuated by bursts of introspective revelation, such as Elisa's imagined adventures beyond her life, to evoke isolation and unfulfilled potential without overt sentimentality. This approach aligns with Steinbeck's broader technique in his , where objective observation of actions and contrasts with selective interior to heighten dramatic irony, as readers perceive the tinker's more clearly than Elisa does in the moment.

Themes and Interpretations

Gender Roles and Personal Fulfillment

In John Steinbeck's 1937 "The Chrysanthemums," Elisa Allen embodies the constraints imposed by early 20th-century rural American gender norms, where women's primary domains were confined to and child-rearing, limiting opportunities for intellectual or vocational expression. Elisa, depicted as physically strong and adept at ranch work, derives a measure of personal agency through her meticulous cultivation of chrysanthemums, which she nurtures with a fervor suggestive of untapped creative and sensual energies; however, her husband Henry's offhand remark that her flowers "look like a quick puff of colored smoke" reveals how such pursuits are often trivialized as mere hobbies rather than legitimate extensions of capability. This portrayal aligns with historical data from , when U.S. Census Bureau records indicate that only about 24% of married women were in the formal , with rural women like Elisa facing even narrower prospects amid the Great Depression's emphasis on male breadwinning. Elisa's encounter with the itinerant tinker catalyzes a fleeting sense of fulfillment, as his feigned interest in her chrysanthemums prompts her to envision herself adopting his rugged, autonomous lifestyle—sharpening knives or repairing pots—thereby transcending domestic boundaries. She dresses in masculine attire, symbolizing a rejection of femininity's passivity, and experiences a surge of vitality, declaring the chrysanthemums capable of "mountain to desert to mountain," mirroring her own suppressed wanderlust. Yet, this empowerment proves illusory; upon discovering the tinker has discarded her prized shoots en route to profit from mere pots, Elisa confronts the gendered deception, weeping "like an old woman" in resignation. Literary critic Stanley Renner argues this sequence illustrates a "strong, capable woman kept from personal, social, and sexual fulfillment by the prevailing conception of a woman's role," a view supported by stylistic analyses noting Steinbeck's grammatical choices that emphasize Elisa's isolation within patriarchal structures. Such interpretations, while prevalent in post-1960s scholarship influenced by second-wave feminism, draw from the story's empirical depiction of 1930s Salinas Valley life, where women's aspirations clashed with economic realities prioritizing male labor. The narrative ultimately underscores personal unfulfillment as a causal outcome of rigid divisions, with Elisa's serving as a proxy for broader thwarted by societal expectations rather than innate limitations. Unlike male characters like Henry, who engage in business and wine-tasting outings, Elisa's horizons shrink to the ranch fence, fostering evident in her "blocked energy" and awareness of "strength going to waste." Scholarly examinations, including those from the Steinbeck Review, critique overly reductive feminist readings by noting Steinbeck's intent to highlight universal human frustration, yet affirm the story's grounding in gendered inequities, as Elisa's epiphany reinforces her without resolution. This resonates with contemporaneous accounts, such as interviews from 1938-1939 documenting rural women's sentiments of "pent-up" abilities amid farm isolation.

Isolation, Deception, and Human Limitations

Elisa Allen's isolation emerges from her confinement to the domestic sphere on the ranch, where her horticultural prowess contrasts sharply with her from her husband Henry and the broader . Despite her proficiency in cultivating chrysanthemums—described as robust and aromatic—she feels "blocked and heavy" in a dominated by male ranching activities, underscoring a profound personal and social estrangement. This isolation intensifies her yearning for purpose beyond , as evidenced by her initial reluctance to engage with the passing , whom she views suspiciously from afar. The tinker's arrival introduces as a for Elisa's fleeting and subsequent disillusionment. Posing as a seeking repair work, he feigns interest in her chrysanthemums by mirroring her enthusiasm and claiming to sell such plants to affluent women in town, thereby exploiting her suppressed desires for and recognition. Elisa responds by gifting him shoots in a , experiencing a rare surge of vitality—"her eyes were as bright as water"—and even fantasizing about joining his nomadic life. However, the tinker's insincerity is revealed when Elisa later discovers the discarded pot and withered flowers by the road, confirming his opportunistic ruse to obtain the pot for resale rather than genuine appreciation. This , rooted in the tinker's pragmatic tactics amid economic hardship, exposes the fragility of human connections predicated on . These elements converge to illuminate human limitations, particularly Elisa's constrained agency within her marital and societal roles. Her brief exhilaration from the encounter—manifested in donning masculine attire and sharing wine with Henry—dissipates into quiet weeping as she confronts the unbridgeable gap between her inner capabilities and external realities, symbolized by the "bright wine" turning "dark" in the canyon. Steinbeck portrays this not merely as gender-specific oppression but as a universal shortfall: Elisa's potential for growth, akin to her nurtured , withers under unchanging routines and biological sterility, with no children to extend her nurturing beyond the garden. The story's close, with Elisa resigned to "hoe the long row," reflects a causal realism wherein individual aspirations yield to inexorable personal and environmental bounds, a theme resonant with Steinbeck's depiction of the human condition in Depression-era constraints.

Broader Human Condition Beyond Gender

In John Steinbeck's "The Chrysanthemums," the protagonist Elisa Allen's inner turmoil extends beyond gendered constraints to encapsulate a fundamental aspect of the : the pervasive creative frustration that arises when individual potential clashes with environmental and existential limitations. Critics have identified this as a recurring motif in Steinbeck's oeuvre, where characters grapple with stifled capacities for growth and expression, mirroring the broader human experience of yearning for vitality amid routine stagnation. Elisa's meticulous cultivation of her chrysanthemums represents not merely domestic labor but a symbolic outlet for untapped agency, reflecting the universal drive to impose order and meaning on an indifferent —a struggle emblematic of humanity's quest to transcend mere survival. The tinker's transient momentarily awakens in Elisa a profound longing for adventure and purpose, illustrating the susceptibility to as a temporary for dissatisfaction. This interaction evokes a deeper existential tension, where aspirations for collide with the inescapability of one's circumscribed , a theme Steinbeck employs to probe the of unfulfilled desires applicable to any individual ensnared by societal or . Her subsequent disillusionment upon witnessing the discarded flowers underscores the harsh reckoning with reality's constraints, portraying resignation not as defeat but as a courageous acknowledgment of the condition's inherent enigmas and the of comforting deceptions. Ultimately, the posits that such episodes of awakened potential highlight the ephemeral of aspirations, fostering a stoic acceptance of suffering as intrinsic to existence. Steinbeck's depiction aligns with his non-teleological , emphasizing of life's patterns over purposive narratives, thereby inviting readers to confront their own illusions of and the persistent gap between inner and outer confinement. This broader lens reveals "The Chrysanthemums" as an exploration of resilience amid limitation, where the fog-shrouded serves as a for the obscured horizons that define mortal striving.

Critical Reception

Initial Responses and Steinbeck's Reputation

"The Chrysanthemums" first appeared in the October 1937 issue of and was subsequently collected in Steinbeck's The Long Valley (1938), where it emerged as one of the volume's standout pieces. Contemporary reviewers praised the story's concise prose and evocative portrayal of isolation in the , highlighting Steinbeck's skill in capturing subtle emotional undercurrents without . The collection as a whole received acclaim for its craftsmanship, remaining on bestseller lists for months and demonstrating Steinbeck's command of the short form amid his rising prominence. Initial critical responses emphasized the narrative's technical precision and atmospheric depth rather than explicit , with figures like expressing particular admiration for its artistry. This positive reception contrasted with some later interpretive emphases on gender dynamics, as early assessments focused on universal human frustrations depicted through Elisa Allen's restrained vitality. By 1938, Steinbeck's reputation had been elevated by the commercial and critical success of (1937), which earned the Award for its stage adaptation, positioning him as a chronicler of working-class struggles. "The Chrysanthemums" reinforced this stature by showcasing his range beyond proletarian themes, illustrating individual psychological confines in a domestic setting and affirming his versatility as a stylist attuned to rural California's textures. The story's inclusion in The Long Valley thus contributed to Steinbeck's broadening appeal, bridging his empathetic realism with introspective character studies.

Prevailing Academic Interpretations

Academic interpretations of John Steinbeck's "The Chrysanthemums," published in 1937, predominantly emphasize feminist themes, portraying protagonist Elisa Allen as emblematic of women's confinement within rigid gender roles during the early 20th century. Scholars such as Stanley Renner argue that the story depicts a "strong, capable woman kept from personal, social, and sexual fulfillment by the prevailing conception of a woman's role," with Elisa's gardening symbolizing her stifled vitality and potential for broader agency. This view aligns with broader feminist literary criticism that emerged post-1960s, interpreting Elisa's interaction with the tinker as a momentary awakening to her repressed desires, only to underscore the inescapability of patriarchal structures when she discovers the discarded chrysanthemum shoots. The chrysanthemums themselves are frequently analyzed as multifaceted symbols in these readings: representing Elisa's children, her inner self, or latent sexuality, with their cultivation mirroring her nurturing yet frustrated domestic existence. Feminist analyses, such as those highlighting Elisa's "struggle against the " and journey toward self-discovery, position her as transcending binary gender constraints, though often concluding in disillusionment that reinforces systemic inequality. These interpretations gained traction amid , framing the narrative as a of how societal expectations limit women's ambition and , evidenced by Elisa's of the tinker's itinerant and her subsequent emotional collapse. While dominant in academia—particularly in literary studies influenced by gender-focused paradigms since the —such readings have faced scrutiny for overemphasizing victimhood; critics like Renner note the story's undertones of traditionalist complaints about women's dissatisfaction rather than outright advocacy for feminist upheaval. Nonetheless, prevailing scholarship, including stylistic analyses of Elisa's portrayal, consistently foregrounds as the story's core tension, attributing her isolation to cultural norms that confine capable women to ornamental roles. This consensus reflects interpretive priorities in departments, where empirical biographical details of Steinbeck's era (e.g., 1930s rural gender dynamics) are often subordinated to ideological lenses prioritizing female subjugation.

Critiques and Alternative Readings

Critics have challenged the dominant feminist interpretations of "The Chrysanthemums," which often frame Elisa Allen as a symbol of repressed victimized by patriarchal structures, arguing instead that such readings impose modern ideological lenses on Steinbeck's text and overlook its portrayal of individual human flaws and limitations. Stanley Renner, in a analysis, posits that the story is "informed far less by feminist sympathies than by traditional 'masculist' complaints," depicting Elisa not as an empowered figure stifled by society but as a hysterical, immature woman whose demands for adventure and fulfillment reveal selfishness and emotional instability rather than systemic . Renner emphasizes Elisa's "fencing in" of her husband Henry and her disdain for domestic routines as evidence of her own confining tendencies, suggesting the narrative critiques female entitlement more than male dominance, a perspective that counters the tendency in academic to romanticize her chrysanthemum-tending as latent sexual or creative potential. Alternative readings extend this critique by interpreting Elisa's arc through Freudian lenses of , viewing the story as an early 20th-century depiction of psychological dysfunction rather than gendered . In a 2018 study, scholars argue that "The Chrysanthemums" embodies Freudian observations of hysterical patients, with Elisa's symptoms—such as her intense attachment to her flowers, sudden emotional shifts, and fixation on masculine activities like —mirroring clinical cases of repressed desires manifesting in exaggerated, non-adaptive behaviors, rather than a coherent against norms. This approach highlights causal mechanisms rooted in individual psyche over societal constructs, positing the tinker's encounter as a transient exposing Elisa's underlying instability, discarded like the chrysanthemums themselves, without implying broader or victimhood. Beyond psychosexual or gender-specific frames, some interpretations reposition the within Steinbeck's recurring motif of creative afflicting individuals across classes and sexes, diminishing the uniqueness of Elisa's experience as a commentary on universal human discontent rather than female-specific alienation. William Osborne's 1976 reading frames the tinker's interaction as an "education" for Elisa, awakening latent capacities but ultimately underscoring the futility of external validations in sustaining inner vitality, aligning the story with Steinbeck's broader oeuvre on thwarted aspirations in works like "The White Quail." These alternatives critique the prevalence of feminist lenses in literary scholarship—often amplified by institutional preferences for of systemic victimhood—as potentially obscuring the text's empirical focus on personal agency, deception's sting, and the limits of , evident in Elisa's fleeting crumbling into without reference to marital or societal reform.

Adaptations and Legacy

Film and Other Adaptations

"The Chrysanthemums" was adapted for television as an episode of The Robert Herridge Theater, a syndicated produced by Mac and Ava Productions and distributed by Film Sales Inc., with a date of May 5, 1960, and an air date of August 18, 1960. The production featured actors including Nina Capriola as the Elisa Allen and Paul Henri in a supporting role, capturing the story's themes of isolation and unfulfilled desire through dramatic staging. A short film adaptation, running approximately 23 minutes, was produced by Pyramid Film & Video in 1990 and distributed on VHS for educational purposes, often used in high school and college settings to illustrate Steinbeck's narrative techniques and character development. The film faithfully recreates the Salinas Valley setting and Elisa's interactions with the tinker, emphasizing visual symbolism such as the chrysanthemums to convey her emotional repression. For the stage, Matthew Spangler created a dramatic suitable for chamber theater, which premiered at the Steinbeck Institute in , on July 6, 2007. The script employs a narrator to frame the Salinas Valley fog and integrates minimalist staging to highlight Elisa's , drawing on Steinbeck's original for while condensing the narrative for live performance. No major radio dramas or feature-length films have been produced, though the story's dramatic elements have inspired occasional student and independent short films.

Enduring Influence in Literature

"The Chrysanthemums" continues to exert influence through its integration into the American short story canon, where it exemplifies Steinbeck's technique of layering personal frustration with broader , a method that resonates in subsequent realist exploring individual agency. Published initially in Harper's Magazine in October 1937 and collected in The Long Valley the following year, the story has been reprinted in numerous anthologies, ensuring its exposure to generations of readers and writers. Its portrayal of Elisa Allen's stifled vitality—symbolized by the discarded shoots—has informed critical discussions on creative and , prompting later authors to delve into similar motifs of domestic confinement in rural settings. Scholarly volumes dedicated to Steinbeck's oeuvre highlight the story's legacy in shaping interpretations of gender dynamics within modernist , with critics noting its everywoman as a template for examining unfulfilled potential in female protagonists across 20th-century narratives. For instance, the narrative's focus on ephemeral empowerment followed by disillusionment parallels thematic concerns in post-World War II American fiction, where characters grapple with societal roles amid , though direct allusions remain rare. Recent eco-feminist readings extend its symbolic framework, linking the chrysanthemums' fragility to environmental and personal resilience, thereby influencing interdisciplinary literary studies. The story's endurance stems from its concise distillation of human limitations, as evidenced by ongoing academic analyses that cite it as a benchmark for Steinbeck's psychological depth, influencing pedagogical approaches to short in university curricula. While some interpretations emphasize feminist undertones, potentially amplified by institutional biases in literary favoring identity-based lenses, the work's core appeal lies in its empirical depiction of isolation's causal effects on ambition, grounded in Steinbeck's observations of life during the Depression. This realism has sustained its citation in critiques of American individualism, bridging early 20th-century regionalism with modern explorations of .

References

  1. https://www.bookrags.com/The_Chrysanthemums/
  2. https://www.sparknotes.com/short-stories/the-chrysanthemums/
  3. https://sits.sjsu.edu/curriculum-resources/the-long-valley/plot-synopsis/index.html
  4. https://www.lonestar.edu/symbolism-chrysanthemums.htm
  5. https://www.lonestar.edu/chrysanthemums.htm
  6. https://steinbeck.stanford.edu/metaphor
  7. https://www.litencyc.com/php/sworks.php?rec=true&UID=25295
  8. https://www.encyclopedia.com/education/news-wires-white-papers-and-books/chrysanthemums
  9. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums
  10. https://www.supersummary.com/the-chrysanthemums/summary/
  11. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/literary-devices/setting
  12. https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/the-chrysanthemums/setting.html
  13. https://interestingliterature.com/2021/07/john-steinbeck-the-chrysanthemums-summary-analysis/
  14. https://www.sparknotes.com/short-stories/the-chrysanthemums/context/
  15. https://www.enotes.com/topics/chrysanthemums/criticism/criticism/r-s-hughes-essay-date-1989
  16. https://penguinrandomhouse.com/books/354360/the-long-valley-by-john-steinbeck/
  17. https://www.coursehero.com/lit/The-Chrysanthemums/character-analysis/
  18. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/characters/elisa-allen
  19. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/characters
  20. https://www.sparknotes.com/short-stories/the-chrysanthemums/characters/
  21. https://www.sparknotes.com/short-stories/the-chrysanthemums/summary/
  22. https://www.gradesaver.com/the-chrysanthemums/study-guide/imagery
  23. https://study.com/academy/lesson/the-chrysanthemums-summary-setting.html
  24. https://literaryfictions.com/fiction-1/the-chrysanthemums-by-john-steinbeck-2/
  25. https://www.enotes.com/topics/chrysanthemums/questions/the-influence-of-the-salinas-valley-setting-on-3112721
  26. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/themes/desolation-and-fertility
  27. https://www.confidentwriters.com/blog/the-chrysanthemums-summary-and-analysis/
  28. https://ivypanda.com/essays/setting-in-steinbecks-the-chrysanthemums-and-updikes-aampp/
  29. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/symbols
  30. https://www.sparknotes.com/short-stories/the-chrysanthemums/symbols/
  31. https://study.com/academy/lesson/the-chrysanthemums-themes-symbolism-analysis.html
  32. https://www.gradesaver.com/the-chrysanthemums/study-guide/symbols-allegory-motifs
  33. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/themes/deception-and-authenticity
  34. https://www.enotes.com/topics/chrysanthemums/questions/irony-and-symbolism-in-john-steinbeck-s-the-3138173
  35. https://www.bartleby.com/essay/The-Chrysanthemums-Symbolism-3271FBD10C74555C
  36. https://gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/symbolism-in-john-steinbecks-the-chrysanthemums/
  37. https://www.ipl.org/essay/Symbolism-In-The-Chrysanthemums-By-John-Steinbeck-9CA2976790738204
  38. https://www.supersummary.com/the-chrysanthemums/analysis/
  39. https://www.enotes.com/topics/chrysanthemums/questions/john-steinbecks-chrysanthemums-what-point-view-205703
  40. https://www.cram.com/essay/Point-Of-View-In-The-Chrysanthemums-By/70A221161DB8D4D9
  41. https://literariness.org/2020/06/23/analysis-of-john-steinbecks-stories/
  42. https://old.ntinow.edu/browse/1B0lnz/3S9063/the__chrysanthemums__by__john-steinbeck-analysis.pdf
  43. https://www.cliffsnotes.com/study-notes/15381357
  44. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/d7b1/f32c38e60ded671b07ee56017355e0fce968.pdf
  45. https://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/psup/ils/article/20/4/429/199088/The-Marriage-of-Hysteria-and-Feminism-in-John
  46. https://www.jstor.org/stable/26281497
  47. https://scholarlypublishingcollective.org/psup/steinbeck/article/20/1/73/382599/Steinbeck-s-The-Chrysanthemums-Elisa-Still-Hoes
  48. https://gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/peoples-limitations-in-john-steinbecks-the-chrysanthemums/
  49. https://www.setumag.com/2020/01/re-reading-john-steinbecks.html
  50. https://www.jstor.org/stable/23240414
  51. https://steinbeckintheschools.com/the-long-valley-reading-guides/critical-reception
  52. https://apenglish.forumotion.net/t137-the-chrysanthemums-steinbeck
  53. https://www.quora.com/Is-John-Steinbeck-given-enough-respect-in-the-literary-canon
  54. https://www.nytimes.com/1938/09/25/archives/the-short-stories-of-john-steinbeck-the-long-valley-by-john.html
  55. https://www.academia.edu/13111935/A_feminist_reading_of_the_Chrysanthemums_by_Steinbeck
  56. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/the-chrysanthemums/themes/gender-power-and-ambition
  57. https://www.enotes.com/topics/chrysanthemums/criticism/criticism/stanley-renner-essay-date-1985
  58. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/365510654_The_portrayal_of_female_character_in_John_Steinbeck%27s_The_Chrysanthemums_A_stylistic_analysis
  59. https://www.aithor.com/essay-examples/formal-analysis-of-john-steinbecks-the-chrysanthemums
  60. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/242161/summary
  61. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326842620_Female_Characters%27_Role_in_Rise_and_Fall_of_Modern_American_Society_A_Case_Study_of_John_Steinbeck%27s_Masterpieces
  62. https://www.academia.edu/31707982/A_STORY_OF_REPRESSED_FEMINISM_EXPLORING_STEINBECK_S_WOMEN_CHARACTERS_WITH_SPECIAL_REFERENCE_TO_THE_CHRYSANTHEMUMS
  63. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1696909/
  64. http://ctva.biz/US/Anthology/RobertHerridgeTheater.htm
  65. https://archives.calstate.edu/concern/archives/kh04dv372
  66. https://www.bookrags.com/studyguide-chrysanthemums/adaptations.html
  67. http://pyramidmedia.com/homepage/search-by-title/humanities/three-by-steinbeck-detail.html
  68. https://dcmp.org/media/7876-the-chrysanthemums
  69. https://steinbeckinstitute.org/doc/thechrysanthemumsdaptation.pdf
  70. https://www.enotes.com/topics/chrysanthemums/critical-essays/essays-criticism/kind-play-dramatic-elements-steinbecks
  71. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327980179_A_STORY_OF_REPRESSED_FEMINISM_EXPLORING_STEINBECK%27S_WOMEN_CHARACTERS_WITH_SPECIAL_REFERENCE_TO_%27THE_CHRYSANTHEMUMS%27
  72. https://hcpl.bibliocommons.com/v2/record/S203C611721
  73. https://imaginaryworlds.us/blogs/forever-chrysanthemums-between-reverence-memory-and-global-tradition/chrysanthemums-in-literature-and-music-from-waka-poetry-to-puccini
  74. https://www.academia.edu/36819288/An_eco_feminist_reading_of_John_Steinbecks_The_Chrysanthemums
  75. https://papersowl.com/examples/john-steinbeck/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.