Hubbry Logo
AtlanticsAtlanticsMain
Open search
Atlantics
Community hub
Atlantics
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Atlantics
Atlantics
Atlantics
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Atlantics
Film poster
Directed byMati Diop
Written by
  • Mati Diop
  • Olivier Demangel
Produced by
  • Judith Lou Lévy
  • Eve Robin
Starring
CinematographyClaire Mathon
Edited byAël Dallier Vega
Music byFatima Al Qadiri
Production
companies
Distributed by
Release dates
  • 16 May 2019 (2019-05-16) (Cannes)
  • 2 August 2019 (2019-08-02) (Senegal)
  • 2 October 2019 (2019-10-02) (France)
  • 13 November 2019 (2019-11-13) (Belgium)
Running time
104 minutes
Countries
  • France
  • Senegal
  • Belgium
Languages

Atlantics (French: Atlantique) is a 2019 internationally co-produced supernatural[3] romantic drama film directed by Mati Diop, in her feature directorial debut.[4] It was selected to compete for the Palme d'Or at the 2019 Cannes Film Festival.[5][6] Diop made history when the film premiered at Cannes, becoming the first Black woman to direct a film featured in competition at the festival.[7]

The film is centered around a young woman, Ada, and her partner, Souleiman, struggling in the face of employment, class, migration, crime, family struggles, and ghosts.[8] Working mostly with unknown actors, Diop focused in the film on issues such as the refugee crisis, remorse, loss, grief, class struggle, and taking responsibility (or not) for one's actions.[9] The Atlantic Ocean is used in many ways throughout the film, including as a symbol and as an engine for change, growth, life, and death.[10]

Plot

[edit]

In a suburb of Dakar that lies along the Atlantic coast, a futuristic-looking tower is about to be officially opened. The construction workers have not been paid for months. One night, the workers decide to leave the country by sea, in search of a brighter future in Spain. Among them is Souleiman, the lover of Ada. However, Ada is betrothed to another man – the wealthy Omar. Ada is deeply worried about Souleiman, as she waits for news of his fate in the run-up to her wedding. On her wedding day, Omar's bed mysteriously catches fire in a suspected arson attack, and a young detective is assigned to investigate the case.

In the coming days, Ada falls under suspicion and is subjected to interrogations and a virginity test. Meanwhile, her friend Fanta and the young detective are both suffering from a mysterious illness. It slowly emerges that the spirits of the men lost at sea have returned and each night take possession of the bodies of other inhabitants of Dakar. Most of these spirits are focused on the tycoon whose withholding of their pay had forced them to go across the Atlantic. They demand their pay, threatening to burn the tower down otherwise. Once they receive their pay from the tycoon, the possessed force him to dig their graves so that their spirits may rest, but Souleiman wants only to be with Ada. Unfortunately, he has possessed the young detective, which initially scares Ada. But as she meets the other spirits, including one who possesses Fanta, she comes to understand them and spends a last night with the new Souleiman.

While reviewing footage from the wedding, the detective sees that he, under the possession of Souleiman's spirit, was the one who committed the arson. He closes the case.

Cast

[edit]
  • Mame Bineta Sane as Ada
  • Amadou Mbow as Issa
  • Ibrahima Traoré as Souleiman
  • Nicole Sougou as Dior
  • Aminata Kane as Fanta
  • Mariama Gassama as Mariama
  • Coumba Dieng as Thérèse
  • Ibrahima Mbaye as Moustapha
  • Diankou Sembene as Mr Ndiaye
  • Babacar Sylla as Omar
  • Abdou Balde as Cheikh

Reception

[edit]

Critical reception

[edit]

The review aggregator website Rotten Tomatoes reported that 95% of critics have given the film a positive review based on 155 reviews, with an average rating of 7.9/10. The website's critics consensus reads, "An unpredictable supernatural drama rooted in real-world social commentary, Atlantique suggests a thrillingly bright future for debuting filmmaker Mati Diop."[11] On Metacritic, the film has a weighted average score of 85 out of 100 based on 30 critics, indicating "universal acclaim".[12]

Hannah Giorgis of The Atlantic commented, "In Atlantics, the Cannes Grand Prix–winning film by the French-Senegalese director Mati Diop, the water is both a threat and a source of comfort. With soft camerawork and pointed dialogue, Diop casts a shadow over the sea and all its possibilities... The result is a transportive love story with an undercurrent of social critique that manages to be at once haunting and hopeful."[13] K. Austin Collins writing for Vanity Fair stated, "Atlantics stuns and surprises because it tries to pull off something slippery and hard to define, a ghost story (or is it a zombie story?) that’s rooted in the material reality of Dakar and its lower classes, that’s openly political, accordingly, but which also seems flickering and unreal, alive to whatever these mysteries have in store."[14] Bilal Qureshi of NPR said, "Atlantics is a ghost story about migration. It dramatizes the stories of the young men who leave countries like Senegal in hopes of reaching Europe, and how their absence — and their loss — haunts the women they leave behind."[15] Jay Weissberg writing for Variety stated, "The capricious ocean is a recurrent, mesmerizing image in Mati Diop’s feature debut Atlantics, but given its perfidious connotations for the people of Senegal, who’ve lost so many souls to its depths, the director ensures the rolling waves remain hypnotic rather than beautiful. It’s the right decision for this romantic and melancholy film, more apt than some of the flawed narrative choices that frustrate though don’t compromise the atmosphere of loss and female solidarity in the story of a young woman whose love has died at sea."[16]

Justin Chang in his review for the Los Angeles Times noted, "Drawing on a potent vein of local mythology, Diop weaves these paranormal elements into her canvas with thrift, ingenuity and bracing matter-of-factness. In her hands, a vengeful ghost seems no more absurd or irrational than, say, the futuristic high-rise tower that’s being erected on the coast."[17] Kelsey Adams of Now gave the film four stars out of five and wrote, "Although it’s a migrant story, it focuses on those left behind. As the distressed women grapple with the departure of their men, things turn increasingly uncanny. Unexplained arson and illnesses shift Atlantics into supernatural territory, and Diop incorporates elements of Muslim mysticism and French folklore without being gimmicky. The deft blend of fantasy and drama uses supernatural elements to home in on the abundant, unjust realities the characters face."[18] David Fear of Rolling Stone gave the film four and half stars out of five, commenting "even when things start to dip into supernatural territory, Atlantics remains oddly grounded, still dedicated to tackling a topical subject without being dogmatic. You feel as if you’re watching something that’s region-specific, yet it never makes its characters feel like “others.” Nor do you ever sense that the act of giving these often agency-less females a voice is something based in charity, because Diop makes the endeavor feel like a necessity."[19] Namwali Serpell of The Nation stated, "In its origins in Arabian thought, a djinn can be good or bad. In its origins in the black diaspora, a zombie is a slave forced to do the bidding of others. Diop mixes the two phenomena to the same counterintuitive end: The dispossessed—male and female, management and labor—rise up not as the enemy but as the communal hero."[20]

In her review for The Hollywood Reporter, Leslie Felperin noted, "Exquisitely shot by Claire Mathon and lushly scored by Fatima Al Qadiri, the film pulls together some exceedingly strong components [...] A lot of ideas about class, post-imperialism and spiritual values peek up out of the surface of the text, but they’re not developed with much rigor compared to what Diop conjured with more intensity and less time in A Thousand Suns."[21] Richard Brody of The New Yorker noted, "Diop films the characters and the city with a tactile intimacy and a teeming energy that are heightened by the soundtrack’s polyphony of voices and music; she dramatizes the personal experience of public matters—religious tradition, women’s autonomy, migration, corruption—with documentary-based fervor, rhapsodic yearning, and bold affirmation."[2] Monica Castillo of RogerEbert.com gave the film four stars out of four, commenting, "On the surface, this is a familiar story of lovers kept apart by circumstances beyond their control, but Atlantics quickly reveals itself to be so much deeper that. Diop, who co-wrote the screenplay with Olivier Demangel, blends the story with the desperation that forces them to leave home and loved ones, echoes of the refugee crisis, a look at the exploitation of the poor by the wealthy and the fetishization of virginity, purity, and marriage. The mystery of Atlantics unravels slowly, its gentle twists keep surprises hidden in plain sight."[22]

The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw gave the film four stars out of five and wrote, "Atlantique is about the return of the repressed, or the suppressed: the men who were denied their rightful pay on the building site then faced the real possibility of a watery grave. Their spirit rises up, and this becomes a ghost story or a revenge story. Atlantique may not be perfect, but I admired the way that Diop did not simply submit to the realist mode expected from this kind of material, and yet neither did she go into a clichéd magic-realist mode, nor make the romantic story the film’s obvious centre. Her film has a seductive mystery."[23] IndieWire's Eric Kohn gave the movie B+ grade and noted, "As it ventures further along its spellbinding path, Atlantics remains a deeply romantic work that magnetized the fears of people trapped by their surroundings and striving for the companionship that can rescue them from despair. It doesn’t quite let them get there, but Diop doesn’t strike a hopeless tone the whole way through. Ultimately, Atlantics shows how that even these bleak circumstances can have empowering ramifications for the women trapped by the shore, and why it’s a portal to a better life even if they stay put."[24]

Accolades

[edit]

At Cannes, the film won the Grand Prix.[25][26] It was selected as the Senegalese entry for the Best International Feature Film at the 92nd Academy Awards,[27][28] making the December shortlist.[29]

Atlantique won Best First Feature in IndieWire's 2019 Critics Poll, and was ranked fourth in Best Foreign Film.[30]

Former United States President Barack Obama named Atlantics among his favorite films and television series of 2019 in his annual list of favorite films, which he released on Twitter on 29 December 2019 and then on Facebook and Instagram the following day.[31]

Home media

[edit]

In January 2020, it was announced that Atlantics, The Irishman, Marriage Story and American Factory would receive DVD and Blu-ray releases by The Criterion Collection.[32]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Atlantics

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
(French: Atlantique), released in 2019, is a supernatural romantic drama film written and directed by Mati Diop in her feature-length directorial debut. Set in the suburbs of Dakar, Senegal, the story follows Ada, a young woman torn between her forbidden love for construction worker Souleiman—who embarks on a perilous sea journey to Europe amid unpaid wages and economic desperation—and her arranged marriage to a wealthier man, as ghostly possessions and mystical elements intertwine with themes of migration, labor exploitation, and female agency. The film premiered in competition at the 2019 Cannes Film Festival, where it won the Grand Prix, marking Diop as the first Black woman director to compete there, and served as Senegal's submission for the Academy Award for Best International Feature Film, earning a nomination but not the win. It garnered additional accolades, including wins from the Boston Society of Film Critics and nominations across over 60 categories, reflecting critical acclaim for its blend of genre elements like ghost story and social realism. Originally adapted from Diop's 2009 short film Atlantiques, the feature explores neocolonial economic pressures driving youth exodus, with a focus on the women enduring absence and societal constraints.

Background and Development

Origins and Influences

, born in 1982 in to a Senegalese father and French mother, drew from her dual heritage in developing Atlantics, expanding on themes of displacement and economic hardship first explored in her 2009 short film of the same name. The short, a 16-minute , follows Senegalese youths gathered around a fire discussing their aspirations and fears of attempting perilous boat crossings to amid stagnant local prospects. Diop conceived it during a 2008 trip to , her father's homeland, where she encountered young men facing chronic and limited opportunities, prompting her to document their migration impulses as a direct response to structural rather than abstract . The feature film's origins trace to a specific 2008 labor dispute in , where construction workers on a high-rise tower, including those Diop met through her cousin, went unpaid for months by their Chinese contractor, sparking strikes and desperate sea voyages in pirogues toward . This event, emblematic of neocolonial exploitation and failed infrastructure projects, causally underpinned the narrative's supernatural overlay, as Diop sought to depict not just departure but the lingering socioeconomic voids left in , particularly for women bearing the brunt of absent labor forces. Diop has emphasized that these migrations stem from tangible failures like defaults and youth disenfranchisement, rejecting framings that obscure root causes in global capital flows. Literary and folkloric influences further shaped the work, with Diop citing Fatou Diome's 2003 novel Le Ventre de l'Atlantique, which portrays the harsh realities of Senegalese and family fractures, as a parallel discovery during scripting that reinforced her focus on those awaiting remittances that rarely materialize. Senegalese oral traditions of possession and spirits, drawn from Diop's cultural immersion, provided symbolic tools to convey unresolved grievances without idealizing the as escape, instead tying it to empirical injustices like exploitative contracts and patriarchal abandonments. Through these, Diop aimed to center women's agency in narratives typically dominated by male voyagers, highlighting how amplifies gender imbalances in overlooked communities.

Pre-Production and Financing

The screenplay for Atlantics was co-written by and Olivier Demangel, expanding on Diop's 2009 Atlantiques through iterative development that incorporated firsthand observations from to ensure cultural specificity and narrative authenticity in depicting Senegalese youth experiences. Pre-production casting emphasized non-professional local talent to prioritize raw realism over polished performances, with Diop selecting unknowns such as Mame Sane for the central of Ada after extensive auditions in ; this approach minimized costs while aligning with the film's grounded portrayal of everyday social constraints. Financing relied on hybrid coproduction from French, Senegalese, and Belgian sources, including Arte France Cinéma, Cinekap, and Frakas Productions, supplemented by Canal+; this model, common for low-budget international films, totaled an estimated €2.16 million, enabling completion despite limited domestic Senegalese funding options. acquired worldwide distribution rights post-, bolstering financial viability through streaming revenue potential without upfront production investment.

Production

Filming Locations and Process

for Atlantics occurred over seven weeks in spring 2018, primarily in the suburbs of , . Key locations included the outskirts of the city and the construction site of the unfinished Tower of Diamniadio, a symbol of ambitious yet stalled infrastructure projects emblematic of regional economic realities. Director prioritized authenticity by casting predominantly non-professional actors sourced directly from Dakar's local communities, such as building sites, bars, and everyday social environments mirroring the characters' backgrounds. This approach captured genuine Wolof dialects and unpolished behaviors, compensating for the limited pool of trained performers in Senegalese cinema while enhancing the film's raw, observational realism. Only select roles, like the police chief, went to experienced actors to balance the ensemble. Filming logistics were constrained by on-location demands in coastal , where sequences involving the Atlantic Ocean required synchronization with natural tides and waves, underscoring the practical limitations of low-budget production in variable environmental conditions. Diop highlighted early challenges in script alignment, as non-professional Senegalese performers initially struggled to fully identify with the narrative's and migratory elements, necessitating iterative adjustments during rehearsals to foster organic performances.

Technical Aspects and Style

Cinematography in Atlantics was handled by , who employed digital cameras including the RED Epic for daytime sequences to achieve a dreamy quality in the visuals, complemented by the VariCam 35 and Angenieux Optimo lenses for broader . These choices facilitated fluid tracking shots that evoke the undulating movements of ocean waves, blending realism with to heighten the film's atmospheric tension between the mundane and the ethereal. Mathon's reliance on natural lighting, a hallmark of her approach, minimized artificial supplementation to capture Senegal's coastal environment authentically, earning praise for enhancing the sensory immersion without overt stylization. The sound design prioritizes diegetic elements, integrating Wolof and French dialogue with ambient recordings of ocean waves and urban Dakar sounds to ground the narrative in everyday realism, eschewing exaggerated horror effects. A minimalistic score by , featuring haunting digital synths and subtle percussion, underscores transitions without overpowering the natural acoustics, fostering a hypnotic tension that aligns with the film's shift toward supernatural abstraction. This approach has been noted for its effectiveness in amplifying emotional undercurrents through restraint, though some critiques highlight its occasional opacity in clarifying spatial . Editing by Nelly Quettier employs elliptical patterns that initially sustain a slow, observational realism in depicting labor and migration, accelerating into frenzied montages around the midpoint to mirror the intrusion of elements. This deliberate pacing shift, while innovative in conveying narrative unrest, has drawn mixed empirical responses, with reviewers citing it as divisive for potentially undermining coherence—some praising its rhythmic escalation as evocative of possession, others faulting it for abruptness that strains viewer engagement.

Plot Summary

In , , Souleiman and his fellow young construction workers, owed three months' wages by their employer for building a luxury tower overlooking the Atlantic Ocean, grow increasingly desperate amid economic hardship. Unable to secure payment from the corrupt developer Mr. N’Diaye, the men, including Souleiman, board a for a hazardous voyage to in pursuit of better prospects, departing without resolution. Souleiman shares a clandestine romance with Ada, a teenager whose conservative father has arranged her marriage to Omar, the son of a wealthy who has returned from studies in . Heartbroken upon learning of Souleiman's unexplained departure, Ada proceeds with wedding preparations while concealing her grief and loyalty to her lost lover. As rumors spread that the migrants' boat has sunk with no survivors, a wave of phenomena afflicts the community: young women, including Ada's friends like the bar worker and conservative Mariama, fall into trance-like possessions, channeling the aggrieved spirits of the drowned men to demand restitution from their exploiter. Amid these hauntings, which ignite fires and disrupt social norms, a young named Issa investigates the disturbances, succumbing to illness and visions that blur the lines between the living and the dead, while Ada confronts her constrained future and the unresolved injustices fueling the unrest.

Cast and Performances

Mame Bineta Sane stars as Ada, a young woman navigating love, loss, and societal pressures in ; Ibrahima Traoré portrays Souleiman, her migrant lover who disappears at sea; and Amadou Mbow plays Issa, Ada's wealthy but unloved fiancé arranged by her family. Supporting performers include Nicole Sougou as Dior, Ada's friend and coworker, and Amina Kane as Fanta, contributing to the ensemble of women affected by the men's exodus. The cast largely consists of non-professional, first-time actors selected by director to capture authentic Senegalese working-class experiences, with Diop emphasizing their natural suitability for the roles during . Sane's debut as Ada drew particular acclaim for its restraint and nuance, effectively conveying grief, longing, and quiet defiance through subtle expressions and minimal dialogue, aligning with the film's atmospheric tone. Critics generally praised the ensemble's raw authenticity, which enhanced the story's realism amid elements, though some observed an unpolished quality in delivery that occasionally strained the narrative's pacing. Traoré and Mbow's portrayals supported the central romance without overshadowing Sane, maintaining focus on the women's perspectives in a centered on migration's aftermath.

Themes and Motifs

Economic Disparities and Migration Realities

The film Atlantics portrays economic disparities through the exploitation of young male laborers in , who construct a high-rise tower for an affluent developer but remain unpaid for months, symbolizing systemic labor abuses tied to rather than equitable growth. This narrative reflects 's construction sector vulnerabilities, where enables crony networks to delay or withhold wages, as evidenced by persistent irregularities in public procurement and private projects favoring politically connected firms. In 2023, scored 43 on Transparency International's , underscoring governance lapses that perpetuate such over merit-based development. These fictional events echo real-world drivers of migration in during the late , when fueled risky Atlantic crossings; the national rate for ages 15-24 reached 19.8% in 2019, amid stagnant job creation despite GDP growth averaging 6% annually from 2014-2019. Local policy failures, including inadequate enforcement of labor laws and overreliance on foreign aid without structural reforms, contributed to economic stagnation for unskilled youth, prompting departures via overloaded pirogues toward the . Empirical from the indicates that the Atlantic route's fatality rate often exceeds 10%, with at least 569 confirmed deaths from West African launches in 2020 alone, and thousands more presumed lost annually in the peak. Success rates for these voyages remain below 50%, as many boats capsize due to poor conditions and navigational errors, highlighting individual choices in illegal migration amid high personal risks rather than inevitable structural . While Atlantics effectively spotlights overlooked African economic inertia—such as Senegal's failure to diversify beyond and remittances, which comprised 9.5% of GDP in —it draws for underemphasizing agency-driven alternatives like local or reforms that have shown promise in comparable contexts. The film's focus on migration as a tragic exodus risks glossing over causal realities, including voluntary participation in unregulated voyages despite known perils, over narratives of external blame like colonial legacies, thereby balancing awareness of disparities with incomplete .

Gender Dynamics and Social Structures

In the film, protagonist Ada experiences profound internal conflict stemming from her father's arrangement of her marriage to the affluent Omar, despite her romantic attachment to Souleiman, a construction worker who later migrates by sea; this narrative mirrors the empirical reality of parental involvement in Senegalese marriages, where first unions are typically arranged by families to uphold social and economic norms, particularly in rural areas where child marriage affects 30% of girls before age 18 and 9% before age 15. Ada's resistance underscores limited female autonomy within traditional structures, where women's choices in partners are constrained by patriarchal authority and familial expectations, a dynamic prevalent in Senegal's Wolof and Lebu communities depicted in the story. The portrayal of female relationships highlights authentic elements of sisterhood and communal resilience among women navigating abandonment and societal pressures, as seen in the bonds formed by Ada and her peers amid the men's departure, reflecting how Senegalese women often sustain households and social networks in the absence of male providers. This depiction earns praise from critics for centering the agency of women "left behind" by migration, emphasizing their emotional and collective endurance against rigid hierarchies. However, the film's reliance on supernatural possession as a mechanism for female against marital and economic constraints risks idealizing through mystical means, potentially diverting from verifiable causal pathways to agency, such as expanded and labor participation, which have driven a 14 percentage point rise in female-to-male employment ratios in from 2006 to 2011. While some interpretations frame the narrative as a critique of unyielding , this overlooks the film's depiction of male migrants' sacrifices—risking perilous sea voyages to fulfill obligations and remit earnings—highlighting interdependent roles where men's departures stem from shared economic imperatives rather than unilateral dominance. Such overemphasis on patriarchal victimhood, common in media analyses amid broader institutional biases favoring gendered narratives, understates of mutual familial duties in Senegalese , where polygamous structures and migration patterns impose burdens on both sexes, with nearly half of married women cohabiting with co-wives and men bearing provider responsibilities amid high rates. A balanced assessment recognizes the film's strength in evoking women's constrained realities without endorsing resolutions over pragmatic advancements like policy-driven , which has elevated women to 46% of parliamentary seats by 2024 despite persistent rural traditionalism.

Supernatural and Symbolic Elements

The supernatural elements in Atlantics center on the spirits of drowned migrant workers who return from the Atlantic Ocean to possess young women in , compelling them to demand restitution for unpaid wages from their former employer. These possessions manifest as trance-like states during which the women march nocturnally, their eyes whitening in a visual cue drawn from Senegalese involving djinn spirits, particularly the "rab" or lover spirits that inhabit female bodies to assert unresolved claims. Director , in interviews, described this motif as rooted in local possession rituals observed in Wolof and communities, where spirits temporarily override the living to resolve earthly grievances, though the film's adaptation prioritizes narrative propulsion over ethnographic precision. The ocean serves as a potent symbol of devoured labor and unfulfilled aspirations, its waves visually evoking both the migrants' perilous voyage—undertaken on an overcrowded pirogue that capsizes—and the broader extraction of value from exploited workers, akin to a gravitational force pulling lives into oblivion. Diop has characterized the sea as a "mystical place" in Senegalese cosmology, bridging the physical migration route with ancestral and diasporic connections, yet its depiction amplifies emotional resonance through recurring motifs like crashing surf and reflective surfaces that mirror fractured identities. This symbolism causally underscores the film's critique of economic abandonment, transforming abstract losses into tangible hauntings that demand accountability, thereby extending realism into metaphor without relying on literal documentation of hardships. However, the integration of these elements has drawn scrutiny for its abrupt pivot from to spectral drama, potentially undermining coherence by subordinating verifiable exploitation—such as construction site defaults—to spectacle. Reviews note this transition as a "swift cross" from everyday to otherworldly agency, which, while innovative, risks diluting the causal weight of migrant precarity by framing through possession rather than institutional . The film's achievements lie in fusion, where fidelity enhances atmospheric dread via empirical cues like synchronized bodily movements in possession scenes, yet flaws emerge when utility overshadows the grounded mechanics of labor disputes, prioritizing poetic evasion over unflinching causal dissection.

Release and Commercial Performance

Festival Premieres and Distribution

Atlantics premiered at the in the In Competition section on May 23, where it received the Grand Prix award. The film's selection marked a historic milestone, as director became the first Black woman to compete in Cannes' main competition. Following Cannes, it screened at the (TIFF) in September 2019, including a director Q&A on September 11. Additional North American exposure came via the (NYFF) from September 27 to October 13, 2019. Netflix secured worldwide distribution rights, opting for a limited theatrical rollout in select markets before wide streaming availability. In , Ad Vitam handled theatrical release shortly after , while in , distributor Cinekap managed local screenings. The U.S. limited theatrical debut occurred on November 15, 2019, followed by global streaming on starting November 29. This approach emphasized festival prestige and digital accessibility over extensive cinema runs, reflecting the film's arthouse nature and niche appeal in non-Western markets like , where theatrical infrastructure limited broader exhibition.

Box Office Results and Financial Outcomes

Atlantics generated a worldwide theatrical gross of $407,963 from its limited release between 2019 and 2020. The film's primary market was , where it earned $344,938 after opening on October 2, 2019. Other territories, including the with $32,882, contributed minimally to the total. In the United States, theatrical earnings were negligible, as prioritized streaming distribution over wide cinema rollout following its acquisition of global rights (excluding select regions like ) in May 2019. The production budget was estimated at €2,160,000 (approximately $2.4 million USD at contemporaneous exchange rates), rendering theatrical revenue insufficient for recovery without ancillary deals. Netflix's streaming model amplified visibility for this arthouse title—characterized by its Senegalese-French co-production, non-English languages (primarily Wolof and French), and supernatural themes—but such platforms often yield opaque financial returns for independents, favoring content licensing over profit-sharing proportional to production costs. Commercial underperformance stemmed from inherent market constraints: niche appeal limited to and art-house audiences, subtitle barriers deterring mainstream viewers, subdued marketing amid 2019's blockbuster dominance (e.g., Avengers: Endgame), and the pandemic's disruption of 2020 releases. These factors underscore broader realities for non-Western films, where cultural specificity and lack of broad commercial hooks constrain viability, even as prestige from outlets like elevates profiles without commensurate economic gains.

Reception and Analysis

Critical Evaluations

Atlantics garnered widespread critical acclaim upon its release, earning a 95% approval rating on based on 159 reviews, reflecting praise for its atmospheric blend of romance, elements, and . Critics highlighted the film's dreamlike quality and evocative portrayal of longing, with awarding it four out of four stars for its slow-unraveling mystery that conceals surprises in plain sight while centering the emotional toll of absence on those left behind. The described it as a "suspenseful, sensual, exciting" fable of resistance and , emphasizing its haunting fusion of genres to explore in . Similarly, commended its groundbreaking reckoning with capital-labor dynamics, positioning the film as a poignant intervention in narratives of class struggle and exploitation amid global economic pressures. However, dissenting voices critiqued the film's pacing, particularly a perceived sluggishness in the first half that induced for some viewers, alongside underdeveloped characters and a narrative perceived as clichéd and lacking depth. One labeled it the most overrated foreign film of 2019, arguing its self-centered protagonists and thin storyline failed to sustain engagement despite stylistic flair. While lauded for framing migration through economic grievances, certain analyses faulted its ideological emphasis on systemic forces over agency or local failures contributing to workers' plights, potentially oversimplifying causal pathways in Senegalese .

Audience and Cultural Responses

The film garnered a moderate reception, evidenced by an IMDb user rating of 6.7 out of 10 based on 11,048 votes as of recent data. On , verified scores stood at 64% positive from over 100 ratings, with an average of 3.4 out of 5, reflecting a divide between appreciation for its atmospheric storytelling and criticisms of pacing or turns. Netflix's acquisition of worldwide rights in May 2019 and subsequent streaming release on November 15, 2019, significantly expanded accessibility beyond limited theatrical runs, yet viewership data remains undisclosed, suggesting the film's reach relied more on algorithmic promotion than mass appeal. Among diaspora communities, particularly Senegalese expatriates and African immigrant groups in and , Atlantics resonated strongly for its unflinching portrayal of clandestine migration risks, with viewers citing personal connections to the economic desperation driving young men to . User reviews highlighted emotional identification with the protagonists' plights, framing the narrative as a exploration of absent loved ones and unresolved , though some non-diaspora audiences reported detachment from its cultural specificity and blend of romance with ghostly possession. This polarization underscores a gap between the film's arthouse intimacy—favoring those attuned to Senegalese and gender tensions—and broader relatability for casual viewers seeking conventional plot resolution. In , the film's cultural uptake focused on its evocation of real-world migration crises, sparking local dialogues on and the perilous journeys to , as noted in post-release interviews with director . However, engagement in origin markets appeared subdued relative to its international festival buzz, with limited theatrical penetration and reliance on for domestic access, signaling a potential disconnect where global acclaim outpaced everyday resonance amid competing local media on similar themes. Broader discussions occasionally critiqued the work for aestheticizing African struggles through Western lenses, though audience forums emphasized its role in humanizing overlooked narratives of class exploitation and female agency.

Awards and Recognitions

Atlantics received the Grand Prix at the , the first such win for a Senegalese production and for director as the first Black woman to claim the award. This recognition spotlighted Diop's feature debut for its blend of supernatural elements and social commentary on migration, positioning her as a pioneering voice in African cinema. Senegal submitted the film for the Best International Feature Film category at the in 2020, though it advanced no further in the process. Diop personally garnered the inaugural Award for emerging female talent at the , affirming her rising influence amid limited theatrical distribution. Additional honors included nominations at the Gotham Independent Film Awards and Film Independent Spirit Awards, which celebrated its stylistic innovation over commercial appeal. These accolades, focused on independent artistry, contrasted with the film's muted box-office returns, illustrating awards' role as prestige signals decoupled from market performance.

Controversies and Critiques

Narrative and Pacing Issues

Critics have frequently highlighted the film's protracted initial buildup, spanning approximately the first half of its 105-minute runtime, as a primary structural weakness that establishes mundane social and romantic tensions in before pivoting to supernatural elements around the 50-minute mark. This extended realism-focused prelude, emphasizing unfulfilled migrations and interpersonal conflicts, has been characterized as overly languorous, with reviewers noting it risks disengaging audiences unaccustomed to such deliberate exposition. The abrupt genre shift to ghostly possessions and unresolved mysteries, intended to symbolize unresolved grievances, often disrupts the causal continuity established earlier, resulting in a fragmented pacing that some attribute to Mati Diop's relative inexperience in managing feature-length structures following her short-film background. While proponents argue this slow-burn approach fosters atmospheric tension akin to ethnographic realism—mirroring the stagnation of economic despair in —the execution remains divisive, with the delayed payoff alienating viewers seeking tighter progression over meditative drift. Empirical reception data underscores this unevenness, as audience feedback on platforms reflects a split where the methodical suits arthouse sensibilities but falters in sustaining broader , countering claims of seamless artistry by evidencing executional trade-offs in balancing introspection with propulsion.

Ideological Interpretations and Debates

Interpretations of Atlantics often frame its narrative as an for anti-colonial resistance and feminist agency, with the possessed women embodying collective revolt against exploitative labor and patriarchal constraints imposed by global . Scholarly analyses, such as those emphasizing the film's "spectral return" of drowned migrants, position the ghosts as symbols of unresolved postcolonial injustices, critiquing Western modernity's role in perpetuating dependency in . This reading aligns with broader academic discourse on migration as a symptom of neocolonial extraction, where the serves as a site of and prophetic defiance against inherited structures of power. Counterarguments highlight the film's selective emphasis on external victimhood narratives, which downplay endogenous governance failures contributing to and emigration pressures. Senegal's persistent , evidenced by its 43 out of 100 score on the 2023 —ranking it 70th out of 180 countries—undermines portrayals attributing migration solely to foreign capital or colonial legacies, as domestic mismanagement diverts resources from and job creation. Such critiques, less prominent in media outlets prone to systemic progressive biases, advocate for causal realism by stressing individual and institutional agency over romanticized spectral justice, noting the film's omission of male migrants' perspectives on risks like toxic decision-making in pirogue voyages. Debates also center on the film's handling of migration's human costs, praised for centering left-behind women but faulted for supernatural romanticization that eclipses empirical fatalities on the Atlantic route. In 2024 alone, at least 1,062 deaths or disappearances were recorded on this path from to , with incidents like the September capsizing off claiming 26 lives underscoring the perils of undocumented crossings driven by local policy gaps rather than ghosts. Economically, while remittances provide short-term relief, 's brain drain— with approximately 640,000 natives abroad out of a 16 million in 2019—exacerbates skill shortages in key sectors, yielding net losses for origin communities despite incentives for investment in connected regions. These empirical realities challenge idealized interpretations, urging policy-focused reforms over symbolic hauntings to address root causes like and incentives.

References

  1. https://www.criterion.com/current/posts/6372-mati-diop-s-atlantics
  2. https://www.npr.org/2019/11/23/780847003/atlantics-is-a-haunting-refugee-story-of-the-women-left-behind-in-senegal
  3. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/atlantics
  4. https://www.bam.org/film/2025/the-black-worker-atlantics
  5. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-news/2020-oscars-senegal-selects-atlantics-international-feature-film-category-1244919/
  6. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10199586/awards/
  7. https://www.barbican.org.uk/read-watch-listen/screentalks-archive-mati-diop-on-atlantics
  8. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/nov/09/atlantics-director-mati-diop-as-a-mixed-race-girl-theres-always-a-visible-and-invisible-side-of-you
  9. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1620690/
  10. https://www.rogerebert.com/interviews/a-language-possessed-and-reconquered-mati-diop-on-atlantics
  11. https://lafrolesite.wordpress.com/2019/10/02/interview-mati-diop-realisatrice-atlantique-depeindre-femmes-de-mon-film-sont-survivantes/
  12. https://mk2films.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/4/2019/02/atlantics-cannes-dp-en-hd.pdf
  13. https://variety.com/2020/artisans/awards/atlantics-mati-diop-artisans-1203460863/
  14. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10199586/companycredits/
  15. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10199586/
  16. https://www.netflix.com/title/81082007
  17. https://www.vogue.co.uk/arts-and-lifestyle/article/mati-diop-interview
  18. https://reverseshot.org/reviews/entry/2606/atlantics
  19. https://www.reuters.com/article/lifestyle/award-winning-film-atlantics-offers-haunting-take-on-life-in-senegal-idUSKBN1XN1B7/
  20. https://www.dazeddigital.com/film-tv/article/46939/1/atlantics-cast-mati-diop-fatima-al-qadiri-interview
  21. https://supamodu.com/2020/film/atlantics-mati-diop/
  22. https://cinema-scope.com/cinema-scope-online/atlantics-mati-diop-france-senegal-belgium-contemporary-world-cinema/
  23. https://deadline.com/2019/05/atlantics-mati-diop-cannes-ones-to-watch-interview-1202609427/
  24. https://shotonwhat.com/atlantics-2019
  25. https://www.afcinema.com/Claire-Mathon-AFC-discusses-her-work-on-Mati-Diop-s-film-Atlantique.html
  26. https://keithandthemovies.com/2020/04/24/review-atlantics-2019/
  27. https://www.moviemaker.com/year-on-fire-how-claire-mathon-shot-portrait-of-a-lady-on-fire-and-atlantics/
  28. https://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/atlantics-movie-review-2019
  29. https://lareviewofbooks.org/article/ocean-of-sound
  30. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/389466593_Listening_to_Mati_Diop%27s_Atlantique_Sound_Waves_and_the_Acoustics_of_Memory
  31. https://floodmagazine.com/72139/in-conversation-fatima-al-qadiri-on-her-haunted-digital-score-for-mati-diops-atlantics/
  32. https://www.bidoun.org/articles/atlantics
  33. https://larsenonfilm.com/atlantics
  34. https://www.theringer.com/2019/11/29/movies/atlantics-review-netflix-mati-diop
  35. https://necsus-ejms.org/realism-as-ontological-unrest-digital-aesthetics-and-reparative-dynamics-in-mati-diops-atlantics/
  36. https://www.bfi.org.uk/sight-and-sound/reviews/atlantics-first-look-mati-diops-paranormal-take-migration-crisis
  37. https://filmotomy.com/festival-de-cannes-review-atlantics-2019/
  38. https://www.slashfilm.com/566720/atlantics-review/
  39. https://variety.com/2019/film/reviews/atlantics-review-1203217085/
  40. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/14/movies/atlantics-review.html
  41. https://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/atlantics/cast-and-crew
  42. https://variety.com/video/atlantics-mati-diop-senegal-academy-awards/
  43. https://www.alternateending.com/2019/12/atlantics-2019.html
  44. https://www.forgetfulfilmcritic.com/home/2020/04/10/atlantics
  45. https://www.womaninrevolt.com/atlantics-2019-by-mati-diop/
  46. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/movies/movie-reviews/atlantics-review-1211196/
  47. https://www.u4.no/publications/senegal-overview-of-corruption-and-anti-corruption
  48. https://www.transparency.org/en/cpi/2023
  49. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.UEM.1524.ZS?locations=SN
  50. https://www.thenewhumanitarian.org/news-feature/2020/12/7/senegal-canary-islands-migration-overfishing-coronavirus-restrictions
  51. https://www.girlsnotbrides.org/learning-resources/child-marriage-atlas/regions-and-countries/senegal/
  52. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/369973658_Marital_Trajectories_Women%27s_Autonomy_and_Women%27s_Well-Being_in_Senegal
  53. https://www.nybooks.com/online/2019/12/14/atlantics-migrations-left-behind-women-brought-into-focus/
  54. https://www.indiewire.com/awards/consider-this/atlantics-netflix-mati-diop-feminist-gender-1202193087/
  55. https://www.imf.org/-/media/Files/Publications/WP/2019/wpiea2019241-print-pdf.ashx
  56. https://newprairiepress.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2208&context=sttcl
  57. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s12134-020-00802-0
  58. https://data.unwomen.org/country/senegal
  59. https://lwlies.com/article/atlantics-and-the-transformative-power-of-water
  60. https://www.empireonline.com/movies/reviews/atlantics/
  61. https://www.festival-cannes.com/en/f/atlantique/
  62. https://www.okayafrica.com/the-mati-diop-cannes-win-that-amplified-african-cinemas-rich-legacy/254946
  63. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Azsq_Gh0jis
  64. https://www.filmlinc.org/nyff2019/films/atlantics/
  65. https://www.movieinsider.com/m17558/atlantics
  66. https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Atlantique-%28France%29
  67. https://www.boxofficemojo.com/title/tt10199586/
  68. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/netflix-acquires-worldwide-rights-cannes-films-atlantics-i-lost-my-body-1213743/
  69. https://about.netflix.com/news/netflix-acquires-cannes-film-festival-award-winners-atlantics-and-i-lost-my-body
  70. https://www.thenation.com/article/archive/atlantics-mati-diop-review/
  71. https://mfqreviews.medium.com/atlantics-the-most-overrated-foreign-film-of-2019-5726e5d71068
  72. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt10199586/reviews/
  73. https://theplaylist.net/mati-diop-atlantics-interview-20191129/
  74. https://www.vulture.com/2019/11/mati-diop-atlantics.html
  75. https://andscape.com/features/atlantics-by-mati-diop-haunts-its-audience-with-a-senegalese-story-of-love-class-and-capitalism/
  76. https://www.huffpost.com/entry/mati-diop-cannes-grand-prix-black-woman_n_5ced7a07e4b01f1875a5b66f
  77. https://variety.com/2019/film/awards/africa-oscar-entries-structural-challenges-1203425464/
  78. https://www.indiewire.com/features/general/atlantics-mati-diop-tiff-award-1202167042/
  79. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment-arts/movies/story/2019-11-20/mati-diop-atlantics-cannes-academy-award-entry-netflix
  80. https://www.rogerebert.com/festivals/tiff-2019-atlantics-bacurau-zombi-child
  81. https://www.filminquiry.com/nyff-2019-report-3/
  82. https://smashcutreviews.com/atlantics-nyff-review/
  83. https://www.maifeminism.com/exhausted-bodies-spectral-return-in-atlantique-2019/
  84. http://www.thirdtext.org/salawu-atlantics
  85. https://online.ucpress.edu/fq/article/76/3/55/195560/Wake-WorkSpectral-Poetics-and-Haunted-Revenge-in
  86. https://knowledgehub.transparency.org/assets/uploads/kproducts/HelpDeskSenegal_Overview-of-corruption-and-anti-corruption_Final.pdf
  87. https://www.opengovpartnership.org/members/senegal/commitments/sn0015/
  88. https://mixedmigration.org/uncounted-unknown-migrant-deaths-disappearances-atlantic/
  89. https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/death-toll-capsized-migrant-boat-offshore-senegal-rises-26-2024-09-10/
  90. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-demographic-economics/article/withincountry-distribution-of-brain-drain-and-brain-gain-effects-a-case-study-on-senegal/E6B623EC088E3E78AC391AF1A1E906D8
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.