Community hub
Recent from talks
Contribute something
Nothing was collected or created yet.
Battle of Changban
View on Wikipedia| Battle of Changban | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Part of the Red Cliffs campaign | |||||||
 The painting "Zhao Yun's Fight at Changban" inside the Long Corridor on the grounds of the Summer Palace in Beijing | |||||||
| |||||||
| Belligerents | |||||||
| Cao Cao |
Liu Bei Liu Qi | ||||||
| Commanders and leaders | |||||||
|
Cao Cao Cao Chun |
Liu Bei Liu Qi Guan Yu Zhang Fei Zhuge Liang Zhao Yun | ||||||
| Strength | |||||||
| 5,000 elite cavalry |
2,000–10,000 infantry 100,000 mostly unarmed civilians | ||||||
| Battle of Changban | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Traditional Chinese | 長坂之戰 | ||||||
| Simplified Chinese | 长坂之战 | ||||||
| |||||||
The Battle of Changban was fought between the warlords Cao Cao and Liu Bei in October 208 in the late Eastern Han dynasty of China. The battle took place at Changban (長坂; south of present-day Duodao District, Jingmen, Hubei).[1]
Background
[edit]After Cao Cao unified northern China under his control in 207, he made arrangements for a southern campaign on Jing Province (covering present-day Hubei and Hunan), which was governed by Liu Biao at the time. Initial minor invasions led by Xiahou Dun were repelled by Liu Biao's vassal Liu Bei, whose forces were stationed at Xinye County at the northern border of Jing Province. Following that, Cao Cao personally led his armies south to attack Jing Province in August 208.
Around late August or September, when Cao Cao's forces had reached Wancheng (宛城; in present-day Nanyang, Henan), Liu Biao died of illness and was succeeded by his younger son, Liu Cong. Liu Cong's advisers Kuai Yue and Fu Xun convinced Liu Cong that he could not resist Cao Cao even with Liu Bei's help, so Liu Cong agreed to surrender. Liu Bei, who was at Fancheng at the time, was not informed of Liu Cong's decision to surrender. When Liu Bei became suspicious, he sent an attendant to Xiangyang to question Liu Cong, and only then would Liu Cong pass the news to Liu Bei through his subordinate Song Zhong (宋忠). Dismayed, Liu Bei drew his sword on Song Zhong, but did not kill him.
Liu Bei then called for a council of his advisors. Zhuge Liang suggested that Liu Bei should attack Liu Cong to secure Jing Province and defend against Cao Cao there, but Liu Bei rejected this and said, "as Liu Biao was dying, he entrusted his orphans to me. I cannot turn from this obligation and seek my own advantage. How am I to face Liu Biao after I die?". Not willing to fall into the hands of Cao Cao, Liu Bei gathered his men and marched southward. As he passed Xiangyang he called out to Liu Cong, but Liu Cong dared not see him and hid. Many officials and civilians of Xiangyang followed Liu Bei as he left, as he was greatly respected by the people.
Between 28 September and 26 October 208, Liu Cong set out from Xiangyang towards Xinye to receive Cao Cao, surrendering Jing Province. Cao Cao took command of Jing Province's military, especially its naval fleet, a component which Cao Cao's forces lacked. Fearing that Liu Bei would take the strategic Jiangling County in the south, Cao Cao swiftly gave chase to Liu Bei with a 5,000-strong elite cavalry force, leaving his baggage behind. As Liu Bei was bringing along more than 100,000 unarmed people and thousands of carts of luggage, his force could not move very quickly. Someone suggested to Liu Bei that he should abandon the people for his safety, but Liu Bei did not have the heart to desert them when the people risked their own lives to follow him. Instead, Liu Bei had Guan Yu sail ahead down the Han River with a detachment of several hundred ships and take a roundabout route to Jiangling, where they planned to rendezvous.
Battle
[edit]
Cao Cao and his cavalry caught up with Liu Bei's congregation at Changban, Dangyang, and Liu Bei had to flee for his life, galloping south with Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and Zhuge Liang, while leaving his family and the populace behind. Cao Cao's forces captured most of the unarmed civilians and Liu Bei's baggage. Xu Shu, a friend of Zhuge Liang who was also serving Liu Bei at the time, requested leave from Liu Bei and left to serve Cao Cao after learning that his mother had been captured by Cao Cao's forces. Cao Cao's subordinate Cao Chun also captured Liu Bei's two daughters during the battle.[2]
Zhang Fei commanded 20 horsemen as rearguard. He sent his troops into a nearby wooded area and had them move about frenetically as though their number was greater than it actually was. He then stood at the bridge; looking fierce and shaking his lance, he shouted: "I am Zhang Yide. Come and battle me to the death!" (Yide was Zhang Fei's courtesy name). Believing there was an ambush in the woods behind Zhang Fei, none of Cao Cao's men dared to go near him. Zhang Fei and his troops then crossed the bridges and destroyed them. While this bought some time for Liu Bei to escape, it also allowed Cao Cao's men to realize that there was no ambush at all and resume their pursuit.
As Zhang Fei retreated with Liu Bei, Cao Cao ordered his men to build pontoon bridges and launch an assault, but a timely arrival of Guan Yu and his forces prevented Cao Cao from fully attaining victory.
In the chaos, Zhao Yun disappeared to the north, prompting suspicion that he had surrendered to Cao Cao. When someone reported that to Liu Bei, Liu Bei angrily threw a ji and said "Zilong (Zhao Yun's courtesy name) would never desert me." Surely enough, Zhao Yun came back with Liu Bei's infant son Liu Shan along with Lady Gan. With this, Zhao Yun was promoted to General of the Standard (牙門將軍).
Turning east from Changban, Liu Bei and the remnants of his party had crossed the Han River to the east where Liu Qi, Liu Biao's elder son, still held control of Jiangxia Commandery. They met Guan Yu's fleet and over 10,000 men led by Liu Qi at Han Ford (漢津). Together, they sailed down the river to Xiakou (in present-day Wuhan, Hubei.)
Cao Cao did not follow up in immediate pursuit. The main objective of his drive to the south had been the base at Jiangling County, and he pressed on south to secure that base first.
Aftermath
[edit]After the Battle of Changban, the land of Jing Province west of the Han River became territories of Cao Cao. Cao Cao entered Jiangling County and pacified the officials and peasants there. Cao Cao's advisor Jia Xu suggested that Cao Cao should make full use of the resources in Jing Province to settle his troops before further territorial expansions, but Cao Cao preferred to use the momentum from his victories to attack the Jiangdong (or Wu) region next.
Lu Su, an adviser to the Jiangdong warlord Sun Quan, was originally on a mission to offer condolences for Liu Biao's death. By the time he reached Jing Province, however, Liu Cong had already surrendered and Liu Bei had fled south. Lu Su went to see Liu Bei at Changban and, after Liu Bei's defeat, followed him to Xiakou. There he asked where Liu Bei was heading after, and Liu Bei replied that he plans to take refuge under Wu Ju (吳巨), an old friend, in the distant Cangwu Commandery (east of present-day Guangxi). To this, Lu Su dissuaded Liu Bei from joining Wu Ju, saying Wu Ju was only an ordinary fellow who would not be independent for long; and persuaded Liu Bei to form an alliance with his lord Sun Quan against Cao Cao. Liu Bei was pleased at this suggestion, and sent Zhuge Liang to follow Lu Su back to meet Sun Quan and secure the alliance.
The successful formation of the Sun-Liu alliance led to the Battle of Red Cliffs shortly after in the same year, where the allied forces defeated Cao Cao's overwhelming fleet, driving him back north and forming the basis of the Three Kingdoms.
In Romance of the Three Kingdoms
[edit]In the 14th-century historical novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the battle is romanticised into a showcase of the power and bravery of Zhang Fei and Zhao Yun.
Liu Bei's wife Lady Mi and infant son A'dou (Liu Shan) are isolated from the rest during an attack by Cao Cao and his cavalry. Zhao Yun braves danger by fighting his way through enemy lines in search of Lady Mi and A'dou. He encounters the enemy general Xiahou En, defeats him and takes Cao Cao's prized Qinggang Sword that could cut through armour from him. When Zhao Yun finally finds Lady Mi and A'dou beside a well, he urges them to mount his horse quickly, but Lady Mi refuses as she does not want to be a burden to Zhao Yun. She entrusts A'dou to Zhao Yun and commits suicide by throwing herself into the well. Zhao Yun then straps A'dou to his body and fights his way out against overwhelming numbers of enemy forces, bringing A'dou safely back to Liu Bei.
Cao Cao's forces pursue Zhao Yun until they arrive at Changban Bridge, where Zhang Fei stands guard alone. Zhang Fei bellows a challenge at the enemy and shocks Xiahou Jie to death. Cao Cao's soldiers also observe that the woods behind Zhang Fei are clouded in dust and believe that there is an ambush, so they retreat without a fight and Zhang Fei destroys the bridge and retreats as well. Zhang Fei had earlier ordered his men to tie tree branches to the tails of their horses and ride around in the woods, churning up dust to create an illusion of an ambush.
By then, Zhao Yun has returned with A'dou to his father safely. When he presented A'dou to Liu Bei, the warlord throws his infant son to the ground and exclaims that his son had nearly cost him one of his best warriors. Zhao Yun catches A'dou in time and reaffirms his allegiance to Liu Bei, pledging to serve his lord with his life and he does so, serving him until A'dou succeeds his father later.
Historicity
[edit]Zhao Yun's biography in the Sanguozhi briefly stated that during the Battle of Changban, after Liu Bei abandoned his family and fled, Zhao Yun protected A'dou (carrying A'dou close to him) and Lady Gan and escorted them to safety.[3] Both Lady Gan and Lady Mi also survived the battle. Zhang Fei's biography also briefly mentioned that Zhang Fei remained behind with 20 horsemen to block Cao Cao's pursuing forces. The bridge was already destroyed when Zhang Fei bellowed a challenge, similar in tone to the one in the novel, but without the highly exaggerated effect on the enemy. Cao Cao's men did not dare to come near and Zhang Fei was safe.[4] Xiahou En and Xiahou Jie are fictional characters.
In popular culture
[edit]The Battle of Changban is the highlight of Zhao Yun's and Zhang Fei's story mode in Koei's video game series Dynasty Warriors.
The battle is also featured in the 2008–2009 two-part epic film Red Cliff.
References
[edit]
- ^ History of Duodao District Archived June 27, 2007, at the Wayback Machine
- ^ (從征荆州，追劉備於長坂，获其二女輜重，收其散卒。) Sanguozhi vol. 9.
- ^ (及先主為曹公所追於當陽長阪，棄妻子南走，雲身抱弱子，即後主也，保護甘夫人，即後主母也，皆得免難。) Sanguozhi vol. 36.
- ^ (先主聞曹公卒至，棄妻子走，使飛將二十騎拒後。飛據水斷橋，瞋目橫矛曰：「身是張益德也，可來共決死！」敵皆無敢近者，故遂得免。) Sanguozhi vol. 36.
- Chen, Shou (3rd century). Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi).
- de Crespigny, Rafe (2004). Generals of the South: The foundation and early history of the Three Kingdoms state of Wu (internet ed.). Canberra: Faculty of Asian Studies, Australian National University. Archived from the original on 2007-06-07.
- de Crespigny, Rafe (1996). To Establish Peace: being the Chronicle of the Later Han dynasty for the years 201 to 220 AD as recorded in Chapters 64 to 69 of the Zizhi tongjian of Sima Guang. Vol. 2. Canberra: Faculty of Asian Studies, Australian National University. ISBN 0-7315-2526-4. Archived from the original on 2012-03-29. Retrieved 2006-12-29.
- Luo, Guanzhong (14th century). Romance of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguo Yanyi).
- Pei, Songzhi (5th century). Annotations to Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi zhu).
- Sima, Guang (1084). Zizhi Tongjian
Battle of Changban
View on GrokipediaBackground
Historical Context
By 207 AD, Cao Cao had unified northern China following his victory over Yuan Shao at the Battle of Guandu in 200 AD, through a series of campaigns that subdued Yuan Shao's heirs and eliminated rival warlords in the region. After Guandu, Cao Cao pursued Yuan Shao's forces, capturing vast supplies and weakening his opponent's position, then in 204 AD crossed the Yellow River to attack and seize key cities like Ye, consolidating control over Ji Province by 205 AD. His decisive campaign against the Wuhuan nomads in 207 AD at White Wolf Mountain further secured the northern frontiers, establishing undisputed dominance over the North China Plain north of the Yangtze River.[5] In mid-208 AD, Liu Biao, the governor of Jing Province, died of illness in the 13th year of the Jian'an era, with his younger son Liu Cong succeeding him amid internal family rivalries and the influence of advisors like Cai Mao and Zhang Yun. Liu Cong, lacking strong military support, surrendered Jing Province to the advancing Cao Cao shortly thereafter, in the autumn of 208 AD, allowing Cao Cao's forces to occupy the provincial capital at Xiangyang without significant resistance and claim control over the entire territory. This surrender was advised by officials such as Kuai Yue and Fu Xun, who argued that resistance, even with aid from Liu Bei, would be futile against Cao Cao's overwhelming army.[6] Jing Province, encompassing the middle Yangtze River valley in what is now primarily Hubei and Hunan provinces, held immense strategic importance as a fertile, waterway-rich region that served as a vital link between northern and southern China during the late Han dynasty. Bordered by the Huai River to the north and the Nanling Mountains to the south, it featured expansive lakes like Dongting, swampy lowlands drained for rice agriculture, and the Han River as a key tributary feeding into the Yangtze, facilitating trade, naval mobility, and military campaigns. The province's position along the middle and upper Yangtze made it a contested gateway for controlling western expansions and resisting northern incursions, as seen in earlier Qin conquests and Han rebellions. The Battle of Changban occurred south of the present-day Duodao District in Jingmen, Hubei, within this critical corridor.[7][2] Liu Bei, who had earlier formed an alliance with Liu Biao around 200 AD and was governing the northern commanderies of Jing Province from Xinye, was initially unaware of Liu Cong's surrender due to his distant position and the rapid developments following Liu Biao's death. Upon learning of Cao Cao's occupation of the province, Liu Bei faced immediate peril and began his retreat southward.[8]Prelude to the Retreat
In the years leading up to 208 AD, Liu Bei served as a subordinate administrator in Jing Province under the governorship of Liu Biao, who had granted him a base at Xinye where he encamped and attracted growing numbers of supporters and braves.[9] Liu Biao, however, remained wary of Liu Bei's ambitions and maintained defenses against him despite their alliance.[9] Liu Biao's death in mid-208 AD led to his son Liu Cong succeeding him as governor, but Liu Cong quickly surrendered Jing Province to Cao Cao's advancing armies in the ninth month (September).[9] Upon receiving news of the surrender while encamped at Fan near Xiangyang, Liu Bei initiated an urgent southward flight toward Jiangling to evade capture.[9] This retreat formed part of Cao Cao's broader campaign to conquer Jing Province after his consolidation of northern China.[10] The evacuation was severely hampered by the presence of over 100,000 accompanying civilians and refugees, including families and dependants, who traveled in several thousand carts and slowed progress to barely ten li (about four kilometers) per day through the Dangyang region.[9] Liu Bei's own military forces during this phase numbered between 2,000 and 10,000 infantry, largely lightly armed and supplemented by local recruits rather than professional soldiers.[10] Zhuge Liang, serving as a key advisor, urged Liu Bei to strike preemptively against Liu Cong and claim Jing Province for himself, but Liu Bei rejected the proposal in favor of a defensive withdrawal.[9] Guan Yu played a crucial advisory and logistical role, being dispatched ahead with several hundred boats to secure the Han River and rendezvous with the main group at Jiangling, facilitating the transport of personnel across waterways.[9] These measures highlighted the improvised nature of the retreat, prioritizing survival amid the collapse of Jing Province's defenses.[10]The Battle
Cao Cao's Pursuit
Following the conquest of Jing Province in the autumn of 208 AD, Cao Cao launched an aggressive pursuit of Liu Bei to prevent him from forming an alliance with Sun Quan in the east, which could threaten Cao's southern flank.[9] This strategic imperative drove Cao Cao to prioritize speed over heavy logistics, as he sought to capture or eliminate Liu Bei before he could consolidate forces or reach potential allies.[9] Cao Cao's forces advanced southward rapidly in the seventh month of Jian'an 13 (August 208 AD) toward Xiangyang and beyond.[11] Upon learning that Liu Bei had already passed through Xiangyang, Cao Cao personally led a vanguard of 5,000 elite troops in urgent pursuit, covering more than 300 li (approximately 125 kilometers) in a single day and night to close the distance.[9] This force was primarily composed of cavalry units optimized for mobility, contrasting sharply with Liu Bei's slower, infantry-heavy retreat burdened by a large civilian entourage of families and refugees.[9] The pursuit navigated challenging terrain around Dangyang, including narrow paths, steep slopes such as the Long Slope at Changban, and river crossings like Han Ford, which funneled the armies into confined spaces and amplified the risks of ambush or delay.[9] By reaching Changban, Cao Cao's cavalry-focused advance had effectively cornered Liu Bei's forces in this rugged region, setting the stage for confrontation.[11]Key Engagements at Changban
The Battle of Changban unfolded circa October 208 AD at Changban in Dangyang County, Jing Province, during Liu Bei's desperate retreat southward following Cao Cao's conquest of Jing Province.[12] Cao Cao's vanguard, comprising elite light cavalry, closed the distance rapidly, advancing approximately 300 li in a single day to overtake Liu Bei's routed forces.[2] This relentless pursuit scattered Liu Bei's army and accompanying civilians, creating chaos along the Han River where defensive stands became critical to survival.[12] In the midst of the turmoil, Zhao Yun executed a daring solo rescue, cradling the infant Liu Shan—Liu Bei's son and future Emperor Zhaolie—and shielding Lady Gan, the child's mother, from encroaching enemy troops.[13] Zhao Yun navigated through the fray, ensuring their safe extraction despite the overwhelming odds, an act that preserved the Shu Han lineage amid the collapse of Liu Bei's defenses.[13] Concurrently, Zhang Fei mounted a bold rear-guard action at Changban Bridge with just twenty horsemen, holding the position long enough to demolish the structure and bellow a fearsome challenge to Cao Cao's approaching vanguard: "I am Zhang Yide of Yan! Come and fight me to the death!"[3] His ferocious demeanor and tactical demolition intimidated the pursuers, none of whom dared advance immediately, thereby buying precious time for Liu Bei's main force to withdraw.[3] As the retreat intensified, Guan Yu's naval contingent arrived from the Yangtze River, ferrying several hundred ships to provide transport and support for the link-up with Liu Bei at Hanjin Ford.[11] This timely intervention halted further immediate pressure from Cao Cao's forces, enabling the remnants of Liu Bei's army to consolidate and continue southward.[14] The engagements exacted a heavy toll, with Liu Bei's civilian entourage and soldiers suffering devastating losses—most of the army dispersed, captured, or slain—while Cao Cao's troops remained largely intact, though their momentum was sufficiently blunted to prevent total annihilation.[12]Aftermath
Immediate Results
Following the chaotic engagements at Changban, Liu Bei abandoned the bulk of his baggage train and much of the civilian refugee column that had accompanied his retreat from Xinye, enabling a swift evasion southward with a mere handful of followers, including Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun. This desperate measure allowed him to reach the Han River at Hanjin, where he rendezvoused with Guan Yu's naval forces and reinforcements led by Liu Qi, before proceeding to Xiakou in the vicinity of modern-day Wuhan by late October 208 AD.[2] The rescue of Liu Bei's infant son, Liu Shan, and his concubine Lady Gan—Liu Shan's mother—amid the rout was primarily attributed to Zhao Yun, who ventured back into enemy-held territory to extract them, ensuring their survival despite heavy losses elsewhere in the family entourage. Zhang Fei's defiant stand at the Changban bridge further served as a critical delaying tactic against Cao Cao's vanguard cavalry.[4] Cao Cao's troops, having routed Liu Bei's main force, secured occupation of the western Han River territories in Jing Province, including the strategic city of Jiangling, but refrained from an immediate continuation of the pursuit due to the imperatives of consolidating gains and managing overextended supply lines for the southward advance. As winter set in along the Yangtze, active hostilities temporarily subsided, with both sides focused on fortifying positions amid the seasonal onset of colder weather and logistical strains.[15]Strategic Repercussions
Liu Bei's successful retreat to Xiakou following the Battle of Changban in October 208 AD allowed him to regroup and establish vital diplomatic ties with Sun Quan, the ruler of Wu in the lower Yangtze region.[2] From Xiakou, Liu Bei dispatched his strategist Zhuge Liang to negotiate directly with Sun Quan, overcoming initial hesitations to forge the Sun-Liu alliance, a coalition explicitly aimed at countering Cao Cao's southward expansion.[2] This partnership proved instrumental in mobilizing combined naval and land forces against Cao Cao's invading army. The alliance directly set the stage for the Battle of Red Cliffs later that winter in 208 AD, where Sun Quan's forces under Zhou Yu, supported by Liu Bei's contributions, decisively defeated Cao Cao's fleet through fire ships and coordinated assaults, burning over 800 vessels and forcing Cao Cao's withdrawal amid heavy casualties and disease.[2] The victory at Red Cliffs halted Cao Cao's momentum, preserving southern independence and enabling Liu Bei to secure a foothold in southern Jing Province, including commanderies like Nanjun, which became the base for his future campaigns.[16] While Cao Cao consolidated control over northern Jing Province after the battle, appointing loyal officials and integrating local elites into his administration to stabilize the region, he ultimately failed to eradicate Liu Bei as a strategic rival, allowing the latter to evade total destruction and rebuild his forces.[17] This outcome shifted the balance in the broader conflict, as Cao Cao's inability to press his numerical advantage fully transitioned Jing Province into a contested frontier rather than a unified northern appendage. In the long term, the events surrounding Changban contributed to the pivotal survival of Liu Bei's faction, marking a critical juncture that facilitated the emergence of the Shu-Han state amid the fragmentation of Han authority.[16] By preventing Liu Bei's elimination, the battle indirectly reinforced the tripartite division of China into the states of Wei (under Cao Cao's successors), Shu (founded by Liu Bei in 221 AD), and Wu (under Sun Quan), a geopolitical structure that endured until the Jin dynasty's reunification in 280 AD.[18]Historical Accounts
Primary Sources
The primary historical record of the Battle of Changban is found in Chen Shou's Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi), a comprehensive chronicle compiled around 289 AD during the Jin dynasty, drawing primarily from official Wei state archives and other contemporary documents. As the earliest surviving systematic history of the Three Kingdoms period, the Sanguozhi provides a factual, unembellished account of the event within the biographies of key Shu Han figures, emphasizing the chaotic retreat of Liu Bei's forces rather than dramatic heroism. The text's Shu book (volumes 32–40) details the pursuit as part of Cao Cao's conquest of Jing Province in 208 AD, portraying the battle as a desperate rearguard action amid Liu Bei's southward flight toward Jiangxia.[1] In Liu Bei's biography (Sanguozhi 32), the event is succinctly described: upon reaching Changban in Dangyang County, Liu Bei, accompanied by Zhuge Liang, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun, suffered defeat and fled south with only a few dozen horsemen, abandoning his wives and children in the chaos of Cao Cao's rapid advance.[2] This account underscores the scale of the pursuit, noting that Cao Cao's forces covered 300 li in a single day and night to overtake the fleeing army, forcing Liu Bei to prioritize survival over family. Zhang Fei's biography (Sanguozhi 36) elaborates on the rearguard defense: with just twenty cavalry, Zhang Fei held the riverbank at Changban, destroyed the bridge to impede the enemy, and stood ready with his lance, boldly challenging pursuers by declaring, "This is Zhang Yide; come and fight me to the death!" None dared approach, allowing the main force to escape and averting immediate disaster.[3] Zhao Yun's biography (Sanguozhi 40, note: corrected volume for consistency with standard) highlights his individual valor: amid the rout, Zhao Yun ventured back into enemy lines, rescued Liu Bei's infant son Liu Shan (carried on horseback) and his mother Lady Gan, slaying over fifty foes in the process before rejoining the group.[4] These passages collectively depict a disorganized retreat marked by tactical improvisation, without the exaggerated feats of single-handed combat found in later narratives.[1] Pei Songzhi's annotations to the Sanguozhi, completed in 429 AD under the Liu Song dynasty, supplement Chen Shou's text with excerpts from lost works, enhancing the account's depth while maintaining historical rigor. Drawing from sources like the Zhao Yun Bie Zhuan (a separate biography of Zhao Yun), Pei notes additional details on Zhao's loyalty, including Liu Bei's defense of him against accusations of defection during the crisis—Liu Bei reportedly struck an accuser with his halberd, affirming that "Zilong would never abandon me." These annotations confirm the rescue's peril but avoid amplifying it into legend, instead cross-referencing it with Wei records to corroborate the pursuit's intensity. Pei Songzhi's work, which expands the original by about five times through over 150 cited texts, underscores the Sanguozhi's compilation from official annals, memorials, and eyewitness reports, lending it high reliability as a near-contemporary synthesis.[1] Beyond the Sanguozhi, contemporary references to the battle are sparse and indirect, reflecting its status as a minor skirmish in broader campaigns. Cao Cao's biography in the Wei book (Sanguozhi 1) briefly alludes to the Jing Province offensive, confirming the rapid advance that scattered Liu Bei's followers and captured much of his baggage, but omits tactical specifics like Changban. Similarly, the Wu book chronicles (Sanguozhi volumes 46–65) mention the retreat's aftermath in the context of Liu Bei's alliance with Sun Quan, noting the chaos that drove refugees toward the Yangtze but providing no direct battle details. These limited corroborations, derived from rival states' records, affirm the event's disarray without contradiction, positioning the Sanguozhi as the authoritative core text for the battle's historical outline.[1]Scholarly Interpretations
Modern historians have scrutinized the reported force sizes in accounts of the Battle of Changban, particularly the claim of approximately 100,000 civilians accompanying Liu Bei's retreat. Such large numbers are often viewed as exaggerations common in late Han and Three Kingdoms-era records, where figures served rhetorical purposes rather than precise enumeration.[1] In contrast, Cao Cao's pursuing forces consisted of light cavalry detachments capable of rapid movement, though exact numbers for the vanguard are not definitively established in primary sources. Geographic reconstructions of the battle rely on modern mapping to trace Liu Bei's retreat route southward along the Han River from Xiangyang toward Jiangling, positioning Changban (present-day Dangyang County, Hubei Province) as a critical choke point amid dense forests and waterways. These efforts highlight how the terrain—characterized by narrow paths and riverine barriers—facilitated ambushes and delays, though ancient floodplains and sedimentation have significantly altered the landscape, complicating site identification. Scholars emphasize the absence of direct archaeological evidence, such as weapons caches or mass graves, attributable to these environmental shifts and the transient nature of the engagement, which left minimal material traces compared to fortified battles.[1] Assessments of tactical decisions portray Cao Cao's pursuit as an instance of effective maneuver warfare, where his reliance on fast-moving cavalry detachments prioritized speed and led to the rout of Liu Bei's forces, though it failed to achieve complete annihilation due to the terrain and rearguard actions. On Liu Bei's side, the strategy appeared ad hoc, centering on individual heroics such as Zhang Fei's bridge defense to stall the advance, which bought time for the main party's escape but relied heavily on personal valor rather than structured formations, reflecting the improvised command structure amid the collapse of Jing Province defenses.[1] Post-2000 scholarship on the battle remains limited, with few groundbreaking discoveries due to the scarcity of new primary materials, but it increasingly underscores Changban's narrative role in Shu-Han legitimization efforts, framing the retreat as a heroic preservation of Han imperial lineage against Cao Cao's usurpation. This perspective aligns with broader reevaluations of the period's historiography, where events like the battle served to propagate Shu's claim as the rightful successor state, influencing later cultural memory despite the military setback.[1]Fictional and Cultural Depictions
In Romance of the Three Kingdoms
In the 14th-century historical novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms by Luo Guanzhong, the Battle of Changban is dramatized across chapters 40 through 42 as a pivotal moment of heroism for Shu Han forces amid their desperate retreat from Cao Cao's advancing army. The narrative builds tension through Zhuge Liang's strategic foresight, where he advises Liu Bei to evacuate Xinye and execute a fire attack on pursuing Wei troops before fleeing toward Jiangling, emphasizing the need to prioritize survival over holding untenable positions.[19] This portrayal amplifies Zhuge Liang's role as a prescient advisor, contrasting his minimal mention in historical records like the Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi). The novel's core drama centers on Zhao Yun's legendary exploits in chapter 41, where he is tasked with protecting Liu Bei's family during the chaos at Dangyang. Separated from the main force, Zhao Yun charges through Cao Cao's lines "seven in and seven out," slaying over fifty enemy officers—including the famed Xiahou En to claim his Qinggang Sword—and ultimately rescues the infant Liu Shan (A-Dou) after a perilous journey.[20] In a poignant fictional addition, Lady Mi, Liu Bei's sister-in-law, sustains wounds while shielding the child and, refusing to slow Zhao Yun's escape, commits suicide by leaping into a well with Liu Shan in her arms; Zhao Yun dives in to save the baby, leaving her body behind as a symbol of selfless sacrifice.[20] This episode, absent from historical accounts where Lady Gan (not Mi) survived the retreat, elevates Zhao Yun to near-mythic status as a loyal guardian.[21] Chapter 42 shifts focus to Zhang Fei's exaggerated rearguard action at Long Slope Bridge (Changban), where he positions himself with just a handful of riders—often depicted as 20 or 30—against Cao Cao's purported million-strong horde. With the bridge partially demolished, Zhang Fei unleashes a thunderous roar, taunting Cao Cao by invoking his past slaughters at Xuzhou and calling the enemy "cowards" for hesitating, causing the Wei vanguard to falter in terror and buy crucial time for Liu Bei's escape. This bluff starkly contrasts the historical reality of Cao Cao deploying only about 5,000 cavalry in pursuit, underscoring the novel's embellishment of individual valor over numerical odds. Overall, these fictional flourishes serve to glorify Shu Han's heroes—Zhuge Liang as the intellectual mastermind, Zhao Yun as the indomitable warrior, and Zhang Fei as the fearsome deterrent—while portraying Wei's overwhelming might as ultimately thwarted by moral superiority and personal bravery, a recurring theme in the novel to legitimize Liu Bei's claim to the Han mandate.[21]In Modern Media
The Battle of Changban has been prominently featured in the Dynasty Warriors video game series developed by Koei Tecmo, where it serves as a key playable stage emphasizing Zhao Yun's daring rescue of Liu Bei's infant son amid chaotic retreats. This mission first appeared in Dynasty Warriors 3, released in 2001, and has been recurrent in subsequent installments, including the 2025 title Dynasty Warriors: Origins, allowing players to experience the battle from perspectives like Liu Bei's forces or Cao Cao's pursuers.[22][23] In cinema, John Woo's epic film Red Cliff (2008–2009) incorporates the battle as an early sequence, highlighting Zhang Fei's dramatic defense of the Changban Bridge with a thunderous shout to deter Cao Cao's cavalry and Zhao Yun's heroic charge through enemy lines to safeguard Liu Bei's family. The depiction blends intense action choreography with themes of individual valor against overwhelming odds, setting the stage for the larger Battle of Red Cliffs.[24][25] The battle also appears in television adaptations, such as the 2010 Chinese series Three Kingdoms, where episode 36, titled "Zhao Yun Fights at Changban," dramatizes Zhao Yun's solo breakthrough against Cao Cao's army, including the loss of his horse and his unyielding protection of the young Liu Shan. Manga and anime adaptations draw on similar elements; for instance, Mitsuteru Yokoyama's Sangokushi manga (1971–1987) and its 1991 anime counterpart cover the Changban period as part of Liu Bei's flight, while the manhua The Ravages of Time (2001–present) reinterprets the event with strategic depth focused on Sima Yi's schemes, often merging historical records with novelistic flair.[26][27] In contemporary Chinese culture, the Battle of Changban symbolizes profound loyalty and bravery, particularly through Zhao Yun and Zhang Fei's exploits, which continue to inspire narratives of heroic sacrifice in popular history and media, reinforcing ideals of personal integrity amid national turmoil.[28][29]References
- https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Translation:Records_of_the_Three_Kingdoms/Volume_36/Guan_Yu