Hubbry Logo
CharbCharbMain
Open search
Charb
Community hub
Charb
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Charb
Charb
Charb
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Stéphane Jean-Abel Michel Charbonnier (French: [ʃaʁbɔnje]; 21 August 1967 – 7 January 2015), better known as Charb ([ʃaʁb]), was a French satirical caricaturist and journalist. He was assassinated during the Charlie Hebdo shooting on 7 January 2015.[1][2]

Key Information

He worked for several newspapers and magazines, joining Charlie Hebdo in 1992 and becoming the director of publication in 2009.[3] Due to the publication of Muhammad cartoons, Charb became subject to death threats from extremist Muslims. From the time the magazine was firebombed in 2011, he lived under police protection until his assassination. The police officer protecting Charb on 7 January 2015 was also killed by the shooters.

Early life

[edit]

Stéphane Charbonnier was born in Conflans-Sainte-Honorine on 21 August 1967[4] and raised in Pontoise, the son of Michel Jean-Marie Charbonnier. His mother, Denise Renée-Marie Charbonnier, née Ouvrard, worked as a secretary and his father worked as a technician for Postes, télégraphes et téléphones.[5] His grandparents, Jean and Lucette Marie-Andrée (née Brunet) owned a grocery store in Pontoise. Stéphane's talent for drawing was discovered in school and he published his first drawings in Echo des collégiens at the age of fourteen. He continued to draw while studying at Lycée Camille Pissarro.[6]

Career

[edit]
Charb in Strasbourg (29 April 2009)
Charb's 2000 MRAP anti-racism campaign poster (translation: "I would hire you, but I don't like the color of ... uh ... your tie!")

In the late 1980s he started working as a cartoonist. His work included creating cartoons for the newspaper Les Nouvelles du Val-d'Oise and a magazine for the Utopia (cinéma) [fr] in Saint-Ouen-l'Aumône.[6]

Later freelance work by Charb included cartoons for L'Écho des savanes, Télérama, and L'Humanité.[7] He joined Charlie Hebdo in 1992 and was its director of publication from 2009 until his death on 7 January 2015.[8]

Charb's comic strip, Maurice et Patapon featured Maurice, a dog described by the newspaper Libération as leftist, pacifist, outgoing, and omnisexual, and a cat, Patapon, who is conservative, violent, asexual, and perverse. Libération described the series as philosophical and scatological.[5] Charb also drew the character "Marcel Keuf, le flic" ("Marcel Pig, the cop") in Fluide Glacial.[9] Charb's column in Charlie Hebdo was titled "Charb n'aime pas les gens" ("Charb does not like people"). One of his regular pieces was the monthly La fatwa de l'Ayatollah Charb (The Fatwa of the Ayatollah Charb) in Fluide Glacial.[10]

In 2007 and 2008, he was a set cartoonist on the talk show T'empêches tout le monde de dormir on television channel M6.[11] He was a long-time supporter of the French Communist Party.[12]

He also drew cartoons for anti-racism organizations such as MRAP.[13]

2011 bomb attack and subsequent threats

[edit]

On 2 November 2011, Charlie Hebdo was firebombed just before its 3 November issue was due to be published; the issue was entitled Charia Hebdo and satirically featured the Islamic prophet Muhammad as guest-editor.[14][15] Charb and two of his co-workers at Charlie Hebdo subsequently received police protection.[16]

In September 2012, a man was arrested in La Rochelle, allegedly for having called for the beheading of Charb on a Jihadist website.[17]

In a 2012 interview Charb was quoted as saying, "I am not afraid of reprisals, I have no children, no wife, no car, no debt. It might sound a bit pompous, but I'd prefer to die on my feet than to live on my knees."[18]

In 2013 he illustrated the book "The Life of Muhammad", depicting the Muslim Prophet Muhammad.[19]

Al-Qaeda put Charb on their "most-wanted list" in 2013,[20][21] after he edited an edition of Charlie Hebdo that satirised radical muslims.[22] Also on that list was Lars Vilks, as well as three Jyllands-Posten staff members: Kurt Westergaard (whose cartoons Charlie Hebdo had published), Carsten Juste, and Flemming Rose.[20][21][23] Being a sport shooter, Charb applied for permit to be able to carry a firearm for self-defence. The application was, however, not approved.[24]

On the week of the Charlie Hebdo shooting, a Charb illustration in issue for that week observed that there had not been any terrorist attacks in France, with a caricatured armed jihadist fighter turning a customary French phrase to malicious use: "Wait! ... we still have until the end of January to present our wishes" — a reference to the French tradition of offering New Year's greetings until the end of January.[25]

Beliefs

[edit]

Charbonnier was an atheist and pacifist.[10][26][27]

Two days prior to his death, Charb had completed an essay on Islamophobia.[28] One year after the massacre, it was translated to and published in English, with a foreword by Adam Gopnik, under the title Open Letter: On Blasphemy, Islamophobia, and the True Enemies of Free Expression.

Death

[edit]
See also: Charlie Hebdo shooting

Charb was killed, with seven of his colleagues, two police officers, and two other people on 7 January 2015 when a pair of gunmen stormed the Charlie Hebdo newspaper offices in Paris.[29][30] One of the police officers killed, Franck Brinsolaro, was Charb's bodyguard.[31]

His funeral was held in Pontoise and included speeches by Luz, Patrick Pelloux, Jean-Luc Mélenchon, and Pierre Laurent. The government ministers Christiane Taubira, Najat Vallaud-Belkacem, and Fleur Pellerin also attended the funeral.[32]

Personal life

[edit]

Jeannette Bougrab, a human rights attorney and former Minister for Youth and Community Life, indicated after his death that she had been Charb's life partner.[33][34][35] His family disputed this and, in a statement issued by his brother on 10 January 2015, denied the existence of any "interpersonal commitment" between Charb and Jeannette Bougrab[36] while, on the other side, several of his colleagues confirmed the relationship between Charb and Jeanette Bougrab.

Publications

[edit]
  • Je suis très tolérant, MC Productions/Charb, 1996
  • Maurice et Patapon, Volumes I (2005) II (2006), III (2007), IV (2009), Hoebeke
  • Attention ça tache, Casterman, 2004 (with foreword by Philippe Geluck)
  • Charb n'aime pas les gens : chroniques politiques, 1996–2002, Agone, 2002
  • Collectif, Mozart qu'on assassine, Albin Michel, 2006, with Catherine Meurisse, Riss, Luz, Tignous et Jul
  • J'aime pas les fumeurs, Hoëbeke, 2007
  • J'aime pas la retraite, 2008 (with Patrick Pelloux)
  • C'est la Faute à la société, 12 bis, 2008
  • Dico Sarko, éditions 12 bis, 2008
  • Le Petit Livre rouge de Sarko, 12 bis, 2009
  • Eternuer dans le chou-fleur et autres métaphores sexuelles à travers le monde, text by Antonio Fischetti, Les Échappés, 2009
  • Marx, mode d'emploi, La Découverte, 2009 (with Daniel Bensaïd)
  • Le Cahier de vacances de Charlie Hebdo, Les Échappés, 2009, with Catherine Meurisse, Riss and Luz|Luz
  • Les Fatwas de Charb, Les Échappés, 2009
  • C'est pas là qu'on fait caca! Maurice et Patapon for children, Les Échappés, 2010
  • Les dictons du jour, agenda 2011, Les Échappés, 2010
  • Sarko, le kit de survie, 12 bis, 2010
  • Marcel Keuf, le flic, Les Échappés, 2011
  • La salle des profs, 12 bis, 2012
  • La vie de Mahomet, Les Échappés, 2013 (with Zineb)
  • Lettre aux escrocs de l'islamophobie qui font le jeu des racistes, éditions Les Échappés, Lettre A, 2015 (postum)
  • Illustrations for Petit cours d'autodéfense intellectuelle (Short class in Intellectual Self-Defence) by Normand Baillargeon, and Petit cours d'autodéfense en économie (éditions Lux; Short Class in Economic Self-Defence) by Jim Stanford.
  • Open Letter: On Blasphemy, Islamophobia, and the True Enemies of Free Expression (foreword by Adam Gopnik), Little, Brown, & Co., 2016 ISBN 9780316311335

See also

[edit]
Wikiquote has quotations related to Charb.

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Charb

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Stéphane Charbonnier (21 August 1967 – 7 January 2015), better known by the pseudonym , was a French satirical caricaturist and who directed the editorial staff of the irreverent weekly magazine from 2009 until his murder in an Islamist terrorist assault on the publication's offices. Born in near , Charb began his career contributing cartoons to various outlets including , Télérama, and L'Écho des savanes before joining in 1992, where his work focused on skewering political figures, religious dogmas, and societal hypocrisies through sharp, often blasphemous illustrations. His tenure as editor amplified the magazine's tradition of unyielding provocation, particularly against , which drew repeated death threats and placed him under police protection; he famously declared, "I'd rather die standing than live on my knees," encapsulating his refusal to yield to intimidation. Charb's cartoons, which targeted all religions but incurred special ire from jihadist groups—earning him a spot on al-Qaeda's most-wanted list—underscored his commitment to and free expression amid France's debates over and , though critics accused the magazine of gratuitous offense; his alongside colleagues by gunmen avenging perceived insults to highlighted the lethal risks of such in an era of rising religious militancy.

Early Life and Formation

Childhood and Family Influences

Stéphane Charbonnier, professionally known as Charb, was born on August 21, 1967, in , a suburb northwest of , and raised in the nearby town of . His family belonged to the modest ; his father, Michel Charbonnier, worked as a technician or engineer for the state-owned French postal and telecommunications service (PTT), while his mother, Denise, served as a secretary. He was the older brother of Laurent Charbonnier, and the household provided a stable, unremarkable environment typical of French suburban life. Charb showed an early aptitude for , beginning in where he sketched portraits of family members and persisted with this through , often carrying a marker to capture ideas. His mother later recalled their close bond, noting his constant drive to create visuals, which filled the home with his artwork and foreshadowed his in . Influences included widespread exposure to television programs and , which fueled his satirical inclinations amid an otherwise ordinary routine unmarked by exceptional events or privileges. Ideological tensions within the extended family contributed to his political awakening. His grandfather espoused extreme right-wing views, sparking arguments that led Charb, as a teenager, to affiliate with the (PCF) as a deliberate counter-reaction. This familial opposition, rather than direct parental guidance—neither of whom were overtly political—instilled an early commitment to left-wing ideals, blending personal rebellion with intellectual engagement.

Education and Early Artistic Development

Stéphane Charbonnier, known professionally as Charb, was born on August 21, 1967, in , , and spent his childhood in nearby . He attended the Collège des Louvrais in , where he began developing an interest in drawing by contributing illustrations to the school's newspaper. Charbonnier's formal education proceeded without notable distinction; he later described his studies as neither boring nor exhilarating. After obtaining his , he briefly enrolled at the École Estienne in to study graphic design but soon abandoned the program. He also shortened his pursuit of a in , opting instead to focus on submitting satirical drawings to various publications. His early artistic development centered on self-directed caricature and illustration, influenced by a teenage affinity for drawing that extended to schoolwork and initial pitches to local newspapers. These efforts marked the transition from amateur sketches to professional aspirations in satirical press, though formal training played a limited role in his stylistic evolution toward bold, confrontational cartooning.

Professional Trajectory

Entry into Satirical Journalism

Stéphane Charbonnier, under the pseudonym Charb, initiated his satirical drawing in adolescence, publishing initial in the newspaper Cause toujours of his collège des Louvrais in , often sketched during lessons. These early efforts extended to local periodicals and a , reflecting an emerging interest in caricature amid informal self-training, prior to his brief enrollment in studies, which he discontinued to pursue professional . Charb's formal entry into satirical journalism materialized in 1991 with contributions to La Grosse Bertha, an anti-Gulf War satirical weekly that assembled talents like Gébé, , and to critique contemporary politics through irreverent cartoons. His involvement in this short-lived venture, which folded in 1992 amid financial strains, honed his polemical style targeting authority and war. In July 1992, Charb transitioned to the relaunched , accompanying key figures Philippe Val and from La Grosse Bertha, thereby embedding himself in France's vanguard of irreverent press satire. This move solidified his career trajectory, evolving from peripheral contributor to core staff artist in a publication renowned for challenging taboos via visual provocation.

Key Roles at Charlie Hebdo

Stéphane Charbonnier, known professionally as Charb, joined in 1992 as a staff , contributing satirical illustrations that targeted political figures, religious institutions, and social hypocrisies. His work featured prominently in the weekly publication, often appearing on covers and interior pages, with a distinctive style emphasizing sharp, irreverent commentary through . Charb maintained a regular weekly section titled Charb n'aime pas les gens ("Charb Doesn't Like People"), in which he enumerated pet peeves and societal irritants in a polemical, list-based format, blending humor with critique of contemporary French culture and politics. This column solidified his role as a core creative voice within the , influencing its tone of unfiltered . He also collaborated on layouts and visual elements, leveraging his background in to shape the publication's aesthetic. In 2009, amid financial restructuring following near-bankruptcy, Charb assumed the position of directeur de publication (director of publication), a legally responsible role for content oversight and editorial direction, succeeding Philippe Val. This elevated his influence from artistic contributor to key administrative figure, though he continued producing cartoons until his death.

Leadership as Editor-in-Chief

Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, succeeded Philippe Val as director of publication and editor-in-chief of in 2009. Under his leadership, the magazine maintained its hallmark irreverent satire, targeting political figures, religious institutions, and societal taboos without concession to external pressures. Charb emphasized an editorial line rooted in left-wing and , describing the publication's stance as "left-wing, secular, and anti-clerical" while defending the right to mock all religions equally. Charb's tenure was marked by deliberate provocations, such as the 2011 cover depicting the Prophet Muhammad with the headline "100 lashes if you don't die of laughter," which precipitated a of the offices on November 2, 2011. Despite this attack, which destroyed the publication's offices and equipment, Charb refused to alter the magazine's content or adopt , stating in interviews that yielding to threats would undermine journalistic freedom. He oversaw the rapid relocation and resumption of publication, with the next issue printed at a secure facility and distributed widely, underscoring his commitment to continuity amid adversity. Throughout his leadership, faced escalating threats, including Charb's inclusion on al-Qaeda's most-wanted list in 2013 for cartoons mocking . Circulation remained modest, hovering around 40,000 to 50,000 copies per week prior to the 2015 attack, reflecting the magazine's niche appeal among readers valuing unfiltered over mass-market conformity. Charb's personal column, "Charb n’aime pas les gens" ("Charb Doesn't Like People"), exemplified his acerbic style, critiquing human folly across ideological lines while reinforcing the publication's anti-authoritarian ethos. His approach prioritized causal resilience against intimidation, viewing as a bulwark against , though it drew criticism from some former contributors who accused him of stubbornness in editorial disputes.

Core Beliefs and Intellectual Stance

Political Leanings and Left-Wing Roots

Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, identified with the libertarian left tradition in French politics, emphasizing while maintaining a critical distance from orthodox . In a 2012 , he described himself as "a socialist, but not a communist," reflecting a preference for egalitarian principles without rigid ideological adherence. His views aligned with radical left skepticism toward authority, including state power and religious institutions, consistent with Charlie Hebdo's satirical tradition of targeting hypocrisy across the . Charb's electoral support consistently favored the (PCF), which he backed in nearly every vote throughout his adult life. At the PCF's Fête de event in on June 7, 2014, he stated, "I've almost always voted communist... I just almost took my card in the Socialist Party when I was in high school," underscoring his longstanding sympathy for communist causes rooted in working-class solidarity rather than fleeting opportunism. He later expressed support for the left-wing Front de Gauche coalition, which included the PCF, as a broader alliance against neoliberal policies. Early in his career, Charb's left-wing roots manifested through anti-racist activism, including contributions of cartoons to the Mouvement contre le racisme et pour l'amitié entre les peuples (MRAP), a prominent French organization founded in 1949 to combat discrimination. This involvement highlighted his commitment to universalist left ideals of equality and opposition to , though he later clashed with MRAP over its criticisms of Charlie Hebdo's depictions of , viewing such responses as concessions to religious sensitivities incompatible with secular . His proximity to communist circles was further evident in personal affiliations and the playing of L'Internationale at his funeral on January 16, 2015, signaling enduring ties to proletarian leftist symbolism. Despite these foundations, Charb's politics evolved toward a more uncompromising defense of free expression, critiquing segments of the left for tolerating Islamist extremism under the guise of .

Militant Secularism and Anti-Clericalism

Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, was a self-identified militant atheist who viewed religion as inherently incompatible with rational inquiry and individual freedom. Throughout his career at Charlie Hebdo, he consistently advocated for an uncompromising form of French laïcité, interpreting it not merely as state neutrality toward religion but as an active barrier against clerical influence in public life and education. In a 2012 interview, Charb described Charlie Hebdo as "a newspaper of the left" committed to laïcité without taboos on religion, race, or identity, emphasizing that satire must challenge all sacred cows to uphold republican values. Charb's manifested prominently in his cartoons, which ridiculed Catholic clergy, popes, and sacraments alongside other faiths, reflecting 's tradition of equating religious dogma with superstition and power abuse. For instance, his drawings often depicted priests as hypocritical or predatory figures, critiquing the Catholic Church's historical role in French society and its resistance to secular reforms like the 1905 law separating church and state. This stance aligned with his broader rejection of religious exemptions from criticism, as he argued in writings that allowing any faith to dictate limits on expression eroded the secular foundation of the Republic. In public statements, Charb defended militant as essential to combating what he saw as creeping and Christian alike, warning that tolerance of threatened democratic pluralism. He co-authored works and editorials asserting that true laïcité required mocking prophets and gods to demystify them, positioning not as mere disbelief but as a proactive defense against theocratic tendencies. Despite accusations of provocation, Charb maintained that anti-clerical fostered societal resilience, citing France's revolutionary heritage of dismantling clerical privileges as a model for contemporary challenges.

Uncompromising Defense of Free Speech Versus Religious Taboos

Charb viewed free speech as an inviolable principle that encompassed the right to blaspheme and satirize religious beliefs without exception, arguing that any accommodation of taboos—particularly those enforced through threats of violence—represented a surrender to . In his writings and public statements, he emphasized that religions, like political ideologies, must withstand criticism and ridicule to maintain a healthy secular society, rejecting calls for as a form of intellectual cowardice that ultimately erodes democratic freedoms. This stance was informed by his commitment to laïcité, France's secular tradition, which he interpreted as requiring equal irreverence toward all faiths to prevent any from imposing doctrinal limits on expression. Central to Charb's defense was his posthumously published Open Letter: On Blasphemy, Islamophobia, and the True Enemies of Free Expression (2015), where he dismantled the accusation of "Islamophobia" as a tactic to conflate critique of Islamic tenets with racism, thereby shielding religious dogma from debate. He contended that protecting religious sensibilities over free expression fosters a paternalistic dynamic, particularly among certain leftist intellectuals who, in his view, hypocritically defended Islam from satire while ignoring its internal critics. Charb argued that satire targets absurdities in extremism, not believers per se, stating that caricaturing jihadists as "looking ridiculous" distinguishes them from ordinary Muslims and immigrants without endorsing blanket insults. He warned that self-censorship born of fear empowers fanatics, as those unable to respond with humor—as his eventual assassins could not—pose the true danger to open discourse. Charb applied this consistently by defending the publication of provocative cartoons, insisting no religious figure or warranted special immunity: "What twisted theory makes humor less compatible with than with any other ?" He dismissed blasphemy laws and offense-based restrictions as relics that prioritize faith over reason, equating them to the fanatics' rebranding of criticism as . In a 2012 Le Monde interview amid escalating threats, he encapsulated his defiance: "It perhaps sounds a bit pompous, but I prefer to die standing than live on my knees," a sentiment underscoring his that yielding to would validate religious claims to and betray the satirical mission of exposing all power to mockery. This unyielding position extended to rejecting any equivalence between verbal offense and physical violence, positioning free speech as a bulwark against theocratic encroachment rather than a provocation meriting restraint.

Confrontations with Extremism

The 2006 Muhammad Cartoons Reprint and Initial Backlash

In February 2006, , under editor Philippe Val, republished the twelve editorial s of the Prophet originally printed by the Danish newspaper on September 30, 2005, alongside additional original drawings by its staff cartoonists, including Stéphane Charbonnier (Charb). The decision was framed by the magazine as a defense of free expression in response to pressures following violent protests and boycotts in Muslim-majority countries over the Danish originals, which had already resulted in over 100 deaths globally by early 2006. Charb contributed a depicting in a provocative pose, aligning with the publication's satirical style that equated religious reverence with potential . The reprint, featured on the cover of the February 8, 2006, issue retitled Charia Hebdo (a pun on Sharia law), immediately drew condemnation from French political figures, including President Jacques Chirac, who described it as an "overt provocation" likely to inflame tensions. Muslim organizations in France, such as the Union of Islamic Organizations of France (UOIF) and the Great Mosque of Lyon, filed a criminal complaint against Charlie Hebdo for "publicly inciting hatred or violence on the basis of religion," arguing the images insulted believers and risked communal discord. Protests erupted outside the magazine's Paris offices, with demonstrators chanting threats and burning issues, while Charb and other staff received personal death threats, marking an escalation in hostility toward the publication's irreverence toward Islamic taboos. The legal challenge proceeded to trial in Paris, where Charlie Hebdo defended the reprint as protected under Article 10 of the , emphasizing satire's role in critiquing dogma without endorsing violence. On March 22, 2007, the court acquitted Val and the magazine, ruling that the cartoons, while offensive to some, did not cross into punishable and instead constituted legitimate journalistic expression; fines were imposed only on a far-right politician who had republished them with inflammatory commentary. Charb later cited the episode as emblematic of his commitment to unyielding , stating in interviews that yielding to religious sensitivities would erode press freedom, a stance he maintained despite the verdict's limited deterrent effect on subsequent threats. The backlash underscored deepening divides in over accommodating Islamist demands versus upholding laïcité, with the reprint amplifying Charlie Hebdo's reputation for confrontation.

2011 Firebombing and Heightened Threats

On November 2, 2011, shortly after midnight, the offices of were struck by an arson attack when a petrol bomb was thrown through a window, igniting a fire that completely destroyed the premises and all internal equipment. The incident occurred hours after the distribution of the magazine's issue No. 1011, subtitled Charia Hebdo, which mocked the Islamist party's victory in Tunisia's elections by naming the Prophet as fictional guest editor and including satirical caricatures of him. No staff were present at the time, preventing injuries, but the attack was the first physical assault on the publication despite prior controversies. Stéphane Charbonnier, known professionally as Charb and serving as the magazine's director, confirmed the devastation, stating "there is nothing left" and attributing the act to "idiot extremists" rather than the Muslim community at large. He noted that had received several explicit threats via and in the preceding days, underscoring the premeditated nature of the violence. Charb expressed no regrets over the content, insisting that should not be shielded from satirical scrutiny under press freedoms, and vowed the magazine would continue undeterred. The attack's immediate aftermath included the hacking of Charlie Hebdo's website, where content was replaced with messages decrying the publication, such as "F*** Charlie Hebdo." Police investigations pointed to Islamist radicals, with a later convicted in connection to the . Following the event, threats against Charb and the staff intensified, becoming recurrent and leading to permanent police protection for the magazine's operations, though Charb personally declined individual security details. This escalation highlighted the growing peril faced by those challenging religious taboos through , with Charb emerging as a primary target due to his editorial leadership.

Personal Security and Refusal to Yield

Following the 2011 firebombing of 's offices, Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, was placed under police protection due to escalating death threats linked to the magazine's satirical . This security detail included a dedicated , Franck Brinsolaro, assigned to him by French authorities, reflecting the gravity of risks from Islamist extremists after the publication's reprint of Danish Muhammad cartoons in and subsequent provocations. Despite these measures, Charbonnier occasionally declined to utilize his full protection, prioritizing his as over constant vigilance, a choice that underscored his aversion to a life constrained by fear. Charbonnier's stance embodied an unyielding commitment to free expression, rejecting any compromise with religious taboos or extremist demands. In a interview, he declared, "I prefer to die standing than live on my knees," emphasizing that required confronting all subjects, including , without . He reiterated this defiance to the that year, stating, " isn’t sacred to me. I live under French . I don’t live under Koranic ," framing his work as adherence to secular principles rather than submission to theological sensitivities. Even after listed him among its most-wanted targets in , Charbonnier persisted in editorial decisions that invited backlash, arguing that yielding would embolden aggressors and erode democratic norms. This refusal extended to practical responses to intimidation; in another 2012 statement, he asserted, "I prefer to die than live like a rat," rejecting the idea of altering Charlie Hebdo's output to appease threats, which he viewed as incompatible with journalistic integrity. His bodyguard's presence on January 7, 2015, during the fatal attack highlighted the inadequacy of security against determined assailants, yet Charbonnier's pre-attack tweet mocking leader exemplified his ongoing provocation over capitulation. Through such actions, he positioned personal risk as secondary to upholding secular critique, influencing peers to prioritize principle amid rising extremism.

Assassination

The January 7, 2015 Attack

On January 7, 2015, at approximately 11:30 a.m., two brothers, Saïd Kouachi and Chérif Kouachi, armed with assault rifles and shouting "Allahu Akbar," forced their way into the offices at 10 Rue Nicolas-Appert in Paris's 11th during an meeting. The attackers, who had scouted the location and specifically sought out Stéphane Charbonnier (known as Charb), first killed his assigned police bodyguard, Franck Brinsolaro, before entering the conference room. Charb, seated at the table, was among the first targeted, shot dead along with eight other staff members and a maintenance worker in the ensuing gunfire that lasted several minutes. The Kouachi brothers, self-identified Islamists affiliated with , justified the assault as revenge for the magazine's satirical depictions of the Islamic prophet , declaring upon entry that they avenged the Prophet and belonged to . They fired indiscriminately, killing a total of 12 people—including Charb, fellow cartoonists Cabu, Wolinski, Tignous, and Honoré, columnist , psychoanalyst , copy editor , and Frédéric Boisseau—while wounding 11 others; outside, responding officer Ahmed Merabet was fatally shot while wounded on the ground. Charb, who had long anticipated such violence due to his refusal to censor content despite prior threats and a 2011 firebombing, died at age 47 without yielding to demands for submission. The gunmen escaped in a hijacked after , prompting a nationwide manhunt; they were killed two days later in a police operation near . The attack, the deadliest on journalists in modern French history, stemmed directly from Islamist targeting perceived , with the perpetrators trained in and radicalized through prior jihadist connections.

Charb's Final Acts and Statements

In the days leading up to the January 7, 2015, attack on Charlie Hebdo's offices, Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, finalized his book Lettre aux escrocs de l'islamophobie qui font le jeu des racistes (Letter to the Fraudsters of Islamophobia Who Play into the Hands of Racists), completing it on January 5. In this work, Charb critiqued the misuse of the term "Islamophobia" to equate criticism of Islamic doctrine with racism, arguing that such conflation undermines free speech and benefits extremists by shielding religious ideas from scrutiny. He contended that genuine anti-Muslim prejudice exists but must be distinguished from legitimate opposition to Islamist ideology, warning that politicized accusations of Islamophobia enable censorship and play into the hands of both radicals and opportunists. The book, published posthumously in April 2015, represented Charb's culminating defense of secularism and satire against what he saw as intellectual dishonesty in public discourse. Charb's final creative contribution appeared in the Charlie Hebdo issue released on January 7, 2015—the very day of —a cartoon he drew depicting an armed militant declaring, "Still no attacks in ," met with a response from a figure wearing a Charlie Hebdo T-shirt: "Wait a bit...!" This prescient image underscored his persistent satirical engagement with terrorism threats, reflecting an awareness of escalating risks without yielding to . Despite police protection and prior incidents, including the 2011 firebombing of the magazine's offices, Charb maintained that satire's role demanded confrontation with taboos, a position he had articulated consistently in prior years, such as in a 2012 interview where he stated, "I'd rather die standing than live on my knees," emphasizing defiance over submission to threats. During the attack itself, Charb was attending the weekly editorial when the gunmen entered around 11:30 a.m., shouting "Allahu Akbar" and targeting staff systematically. Eyewitness accounts from survivors, including Philippe Honoré and Fabrice Nicolino, describe chaos in the conference room where Charb was located, but no verified record exists of specific words or actions by him in those final moments amid the gunfire that killed him and 11 others. His preparedness for such risks was evident in his ongoing work and , yet he rejected heightened precautions that might compromise the magazine's output, prioritizing journalistic integrity.

Legacy and Cultural Impact

Immediate Aftermath and Global Free Speech Debate

The assassination of Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, and the killing of 11 others in the January 7, 2015, attack on Charlie Hebdo's offices prompted immediate declarations of national mourning by French President , who described the assault as an act of "barbarism" targeting freedom itself. The "Je suis Charlie" hashtag emerged within hours, symbolizing defiance against censorship and violence, and quickly amassed millions of uses on worldwide, reflecting broad initial solidarity with the victims' commitment to unrestricted . Tributes to Charb highlighted his pre-attack statements, such as preferring "to die standing up than live on [his] knees," underscoring his role as a symbol of unyielding secular expression amid prior threats. On January 11, 2015, the Marche républicaine (Republican March) drew an estimated 3.7 million participants across France, including 1.5 million in —the largest public demonstration in the nation's history—with over 40 world leaders, such as German Chancellor and British Prime Minister , joining to affirm unity against terrorism. Charlie Hebdo's next issue, released January 14 under surviving staff direction, featured a cover by cartoonist Luz depicting holding a "" sign with the caption "Tout est pardonné" (All is forgiven); initial print run of three million copies sold out instantly, leading to reprints totaling nearly eight million, dwarfing the magazine's typical circulation of 60,000. The events catalyzed a polarized global discourse on free speech boundaries, with advocates like the framing the attack as a direct assault on press freedom requiring absolute defense of offensive content to preserve democratic norms. Critics, including some journalists and multicultural commentators, argued for "responsible" expression to avoid inflaming religious communities, equating of with unnecessary provocation in pluralistic societies, a view echoed in post-attack forums hosted by organizations like . This tension exposed inconsistencies, as participating leaders from nations with speech restrictions joined the marches, prompting accusations of performative solidarity over substantive commitment to unrestricted critique of religious taboos. In Muslim-majority countries, reactions varied from condemnations of the violence to defenses of religious sensitivities, highlighting causal rifts between secular and demands for deference to prophetic depictions.

Long-Term Influence on Satire and Secularism

Charb's commitment to satirical irreverence toward religious authority, particularly , as expressed in his decisions and writings, has enduringly shaped French cartooning by exemplifying a refusal to self-censor amid threats, thereby sustaining a tradition of scurrilous political rooted in Enlightenment-era of . His aim, articulated in interviews, was to "banalize" through repeated ridicule until it elicited no greater outrage than critiques of Catholicism, a strategy that post-2015 influenced Charlie Hebdo's persistence in publishing caricatures, with the magazine issuing special editions in 2020 and 2025 that provoked backlash but affirmed the viability of unyielding humor against taboos. This approach has inspired subsequent cartoonists to prioritize provocation over accommodation, countering trends toward caution in media outlets wary of Islamist reprisals, though it has not eliminated broader in satire. In advancing , Charb's posthumously published Open Letter to the Fraudsters of Islamophobia Who Play Into Racists' Hands (2015) defended laïcité by rejecting exemptions for from criticism, arguing that equating religious offense with enables to dictate public discourse—a thesis that has fueled defenses of republican neutrality against demands for protections. The 2015 attack amplified this influence, catalyzing intensified enforcement of secular policies, such as expanded anti-separatism laws in 2021, while exposing fractures in French intellectual circles, where left-leaning factions increasingly prioritize over uncompromising laïcité. By 2025, secular militants invoked Charb's legacy to critique dilutions of state , linking his murder to ongoing Islamist violence that underscores the causal link between and suppressed expression. Empirically, Charb's stance has validated the risks of religious taboos through persistent threats—evident in Charlie Hebdo's heightened security and sales fluctuations post-attack—yet reinforced satire's role in normalizing critique, with circulation stabilizing around 100,000-150,000 weekly by the late as a testament to resilient readership valuing his model over safer alternatives. This dual legacy highlights satire's tension with secular realism: while inspiring bold expression, it has not averted societal debates framing such work as divisive, though data on repeated Islamist plots against the magazine affirm the necessity of Charb's uncompromising defense against faith-based .

Recent Commemorations and Recognition Efforts

In March 2023, the city of , where Charb was born, inaugurated Rue Stéphane Charbonnier (Charb) in his honor, with the ceremony attended by local officials including the prefect of . This naming recognized his contributions to satirical drawing and his defiance against threats, as highlighted by participants who emphasized his local roots and national symbolism for press freedom. On October 7, 2025, marking the 10th anniversary of the attack, the magazine's editorial team, led by director Riss, along with Charb's family, publicly requested his transfer to the as a symbol of republican defense of and free expression. The petition, addressed to President , argued that Charb's unyielding stance against religious extremism embodied values antithetical to the attackers' ideology, with Riss describing the proposal as a way to "engrave" these principles in French history rather than mere commemoration. As of late October 2025, no official response from the government has been issued, though the request gained media attention amid broader anniversary events for the 2015 attacks. These initiatives reflect ongoing efforts to honor Charb individually amid collective remembrances of the January 7, 2015, victims, including ceremonies and publications tied to the decade anniversary that referenced his leadership and cartoons as pivotal to the magazine's resilience. No posthumous awards specifically named for Charb have been documented, though his work continues to influence discussions on satire's role in countering extremism.

Publications and Creative Output

Major Books and Collections

Charb produced several comic series and collections of satirical essays, often compiling his work from . His debut comic series, Maurice et Patapon, followed the anticapitalist adventures of a dog and cat duo, with the first volume published in 1999 and subsequent installments appearing through 2013. Among his essay collections, Petit traité d'intolérance: les fatwas de Charb (2008) gathered provocative columns critiquing societal hypocrisies and religious dogmas, followed by a second volume. Charb n'aime pas les gens assembled his Charlie Hebdo pieces targeting public figures he opposed. In January 2013, Charb released La Vie de Mahomet, a biography of illustrated in collaboration with others, which prompted threats and a against him. Posthumously published in April 2015, Lettre aux escrocs de l'islamophobie qui font le jeu des racistes—completed two days before his death—defended satirical scrutiny of against accusations of racism, arguing that no merits exemption from criticism.

Signature Cartoons and Thematic Contributions

Charb's signature cartoon series Maurice et Patapon debuted in Charlie Hebdo in 1998, featuring weekly three-panel strips of an anti-capitalist orange dog named Maurice—vulgar, tolerant, and sexually obsessed—and a black-striped yellow cat named —psychorigid, uptight, and contemptuous—who critiqued societal hypocrisies through scatological and irreverent gags. He also developed Marcel Keuf, le flic, a bigoted policeman character for Fluide Glacial, and the satirical chronic La fatwa de l'Ayatollah Charb in the same magazine, alongside a weekly Charlie Hebdo section from 2009 titled Charb n’aime pas les gens, where he voiced acerbic disdain for politicians, public behaviors, and cultural pieties. His drawing style followed the French caricature tradition of exaggerated "big nose" features for light gags but delivered uncompromising black humor, as seen in provocative covers like Charlie Hebdo issue #54 on 7 July 1993, portraying accused serial rapist Pierre Chanal assaulting the Unknown Soldier, or issue #1057 on 19 September 2012, with a nude Prophet Muhammad interior alongside a Jew and Muslim exclaiming "Faut pas se moquer!" (One must not mock!). Other notable works included 2010 covers lampooning French immigration minister Éric Besson in garb and President amid corruption scandals with minister Brice Hortefeux. Thematically, Charb's output promoted atheism and laïcité (French secularism) by satirizing without favoritism, targeting Catholic, Jewish, and especially Islamist through —such as a 2012 of an Islamist delaying New Year's wishes until January's end—while defending them as free-speech assertions against , not offenses to ordinary believers. His cartoons equally assailed political authority, portraying Sarkozy as a decaying and critiquing , far-right movements, and corruption from a pacifist, republican perspective aligned with leftist ideals yet defiant of religious impositions. Charb maintained that held no sacred value for him and that must operate under French civil law, not religious prohibitions, even amid threats and a 2011 attack he attributed to "idiot ."

Personal Dimensions

Relationships and Private Life

Stéphane Charbonnier, known as Charb, maintained a highly private personal life, rarely discussing or relationships in public interviews. In a 2012 statement, he emphasized his lack of dependents, declaring, "I am not afraid of reprisals, I have no children, no , no , no ," reflecting his deliberate choice to avoid vulnerabilities amid threats from Islamist extremists due to his satirical work. He had no known marriages or biological children, and his surviving consisted of his parents and a brother at the time of his death. Following the January 7, 2015, attack on , Jeannette Bougrab, a French and former junior minister of Algerian origin, publicly identified herself as Charb's partner of three years, claiming they lived together with her adopted daughter, who referred to him as "dad." Bougrab asserted that Charb had foregone children due to anticipated risks, stating, "He never had children because he knew he was going to die." However, Charb's family contested Bougrab's claims, formally denying any romantic relationship and asserting she had limited contact with him, which led to her exclusion from his January 2015 funeral. The family described the assertion as fabricated, prompting a public dispute and highlighting tensions over his legacy. No independent verification of the relationship beyond Bougrab's statements and the family's refutation has emerged in contemporaneous reports.

Lifestyle and Extracurricular Interests

Charb maintained a minimalist , deliberately avoiding conventional markers of personal stability such as , children, ownership, or even automobile possession, which he viewed as encumbrances to his commitment to free expression. In a 2012 interview, he remarked, "I have no kids, no wife, no car, no . It sounds pompous, but I prefer to die standing than on my knees," underscoring a that placed ideological above material security or familial obligations. This austere approach extended to his daily habits, where he was reportedly intolerant of despite broader defenses of personal freedoms. Beyond his professional satirical work, Charb's extracurricular engagements centered on political activism and secular advocacy. A self-identified communist, he remained a "companion of the road" to the (PCF), fostering close ties with leftist publications like while critiquing what he saw as inconsistencies in contemporary socialism, such as accommodations to religious extremism. As a militant atheist, he actively promoted laïcité (French secularism) in public forums, arguing against religious influence in politics and education, though he did not formally affiliate with organizations beyond his journalistic output. These pursuits reflected his broader interest in challenging authority through intellectual and ideological means rather than organized leisure activities.

References

  1. https://www.askart.com/artist/Charb/11257457/Charb.aspx
  2. https://www.imdb.com/name/nm3142249/bio/
  3. https://www.lambiek.net/artists/c/charb.htm
  4. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30710545
  5. https://nypost.com/2015/01/08/slain-charlie-hebdo-editor-i-prefer-to-die-standing-than-live-on-my-knees/
  6. https://time.com/3657402/charlie-hebdo-stephane-charbonnier-paris-attack/
  7. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/08/world/europe/charlie-hebdo-editor-made-provocation-his-mission.html
  8. https://www.theguardian.com/media/2015/jan/13/stephane-charbonnier
  9. https://www.thetimes.com/travel/destinations/europe-travel/france/paris/stephane-charbonnier-r5zjlz73vf6
  10. https://www.sudouest.fr/justice/attaques-a-paris/lettre-a-mon-fils-la-mere-de-charb-raconte-son-petit-bonhomme-2564941.php
  11. https://www.leparisien.fr/faits-divers/je-brillais-dans-ses-yeux-l-amoureuse-de-charb-raconte-son-7-janvier-10-09-2020-8382228.php
  12. https://www.europe1.fr/emissions/le-billet-de-patrick-cohen/extrait-on-etait-tres-complices-la-mere-de-charb-revient-sur-lenfance-de-son-fils-4041342
  13. https://www.programme-tv.net/biographie/418030-charb/
  14. https://www.universalis.fr/encyclopedie/charb/
  15. https://www.mediatheques-enthieracheducentre.fr/node/218245
  16. https://www.gallimard.fr/auteurs/charb
  17. https://www.ouest-france.fr/charlie-hebdo/attentat-charlie-hebdo-charb-disait-ne-craindre-personne-3099935
  18. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2015-01-09/victims-of-the-paris-terror-attack/6006348
  19. https://www.britannica.com/event/Charlie-Hebdo-shooting
  20. https://www.vox.com/2015/1/7/7511001/charlie-hebdo-attack-paris
  21. https://www.cpj.org/data/people/stephane-charbonnier-charb/
  22. https://www.nbcnews.com/storyline/paris-magazine-attack/charlie-hebdo-founder-says-hes-upset-slain-editor-charb-n286676
  23. http://isj.org.uk/socialism-satire-and-charlie-hebdo/
  24. https://www.ladepeche.fr/article/2014/06/07/1895795-charb-fete-humanite-communisme-solution-crise.html
  25. https://www.gillespichavant.com/blog/2015/01/09/charb-jai-quasiment-toujours-cote-communiste/
  26. https://kids.kiddle.co/Charb
  27. https://bataillesocialiste.wordpress.com/2015/01/17/5-dessins-de-charb/
  28. https://socialism.com/fs-article/freedom-socialist-editorial-charlie-hebdo-we-got-it-wrong/
  29. https://www.hudson.org/national-security-defense/charlie-hebdo-and-france-s-irreligious-tradition
  30. https://ricochet.media/international/lost-in-translation-charlie-hebdo-free-speech-and-the-unilingual-left/
  31. https://www.latimes.com/books/la-ca-jc-charb-20160110-story.html
  32. https://www.amazon.com/Open-Letter-Blasphemy-Islamophobia-Expression/dp/0316311332
  33. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/01/07/375561888/10-dead-after-shootout-at-satirical-magazines-office-in-paris
  34. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/europe/france/11341599/Prophet-Muhammad-cartoons-controversy-timeline.html
  35. https://www.cjr.org/watchdog/charlie_hebdo_cartoons.php
  36. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/timeline-violence-marks-15-year-furore-over-cartoons-of-prophet-mohammad-idUSKBN27I1U3/
  37. https://jcpa.org/article/the-mohammed-cartoon-controversy-israel-and-the-jews-a-case-study/
  38. https://www.rferl.org/a/1075438.html
  39. https://www.dw.com/en/book-by-slain-charlie-hebdo-editor-published-posthumously/a-18386831
  40. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-15550350
  41. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2011/nov/02/french-magazine-bomb-muhammad-cartoon
  42. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/11/02/141928567/french-newspaper-firebombed-after-satire-involving-prophet-muhammad
  43. https://www.npr.org/2015/01/08/375662732/charlie-hebdo-laughed-in-the-face-of-violence-will-future-satirists
  44. https://www.refworld.org/reference/annualreport/cpj/2015/en/108486
  45. https://time.com/3658358/paris-terror-attack-charlie-hebdo-mohamed/
  46. https://abcnews.go.com/International/charlie-hebdo-editor-2012-id-prefer-die-silenced/story?id=28057120
  47. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30708237
  48. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jan/09/-sp-charlie-hebdo-timeline-events
  49. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jan/07/cartoonists-victims-charlie-hebdo-attack
  50. https://www.the-independent.com/news/world/charlie-hebdo-editor-s-final-book-letter-to-the-islamophobia-frauds-who-play-into-the-hands-of-racists-10193565.html
  51. https://www.landesatlantiquesud.com/en/fete-manifestation/lettre-aux-escrocs-de-lislamophobie-qui-font-le-jeu-des-racistes-ecrit-par-charb-adaptation-gerald-dumont/
  52. https://actualitte.com/article/43296/presse/lettre-aux-escrocs-de-l-039-islamophobie-le-testament-de-charb
  53. https://www.businessinsider.com/the-editor-of-charlie-hebdos-last-cartoon-is-tragically-prescient-2015-1
  54. https://www.lemonde.fr/actualite-medias/article/2015/01/07/charb-je-prefere-mourir-debout-que-vivre-a-genoux_4550759_3236.html
  55. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/01/08/world/europe/charlie-hebdo-paris-shooting.html
  56. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/je-suis-charlie-defending-press-freedom-in-france/
  57. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/how-cartoonists-think-about-free-expression-and-islamic-extremism/2015/01/07/22797d04-96bb-11e4-8005-1924ede3e54a_story.html
  58. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-30765824
  59. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jan/11/paris-france-anti-terror-rally-massive-show-unity
  60. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/france-nearly-4-million-attend-unity-rallies-setting-record/
  61. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/charlie-hebdo-sells-out-paris-prophet-muhammad-cover-2-million-more/
  62. https://www.thestar.com/opinion/editorials/attack-on-charlie-hebdo-was-a-direct-assault-on-freedom-of-speech-editorial/article_0220fdc4-ad31-5ed0-b3b4-50ad8e32f5fa.html
  63. https://www.opensocietyfoundations.org/voices/journalists-paris-debate-limits-free-expression
  64. https://news.un.org/en/story/2015/01/488222-journalism-after-charlie-paris-unesco-hosts-day-reflection-free-speech-debate
  65. https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2016/1/14/charlie-hebdo-free-speech-debate-nobody-is-listening
  66. https://www.pbs.org/newshour/classroom/daily-news-lessons/2015/01/free-speech-debate-follows-french-terror-attacks
  67. https://www.economist.com/culture/2025/01/04/ten-years-after-the-charlie-hebdo-attack-satire-is-under-siege
  68. https://www.vox.com/2015/1/7/7507883/charlie-hebdo-explained-covers
  69. https://www.csmonitor.com/World/Europe/2025/0108/charlie-hebdo-islam-satire-religion
  70. https://www.nytimes.com/2015/04/17/world/europe/book-by-slain-charlie-hebdo-editor-argues-islam-is-not-exempt-from-ridicule.html
  71. https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2025/01/11/the-turbulent-history-of-the-french-left-s-divisions-over-islam-and-secularism-since-charlie-hebdo-attack_6736928_7.html
  72. https://www.mediapart.fr/en/journal/politique/110125/ten-years-after-charlie-hebdo-attack-secular-militants-extend-war-words-against-french-left
  73. https://www.courthousenews.com/10-years-after-attack-charlie-hebdo-is-uncowed-and-still-provoking/
  74. https://english.elpais.com/international/2025-02-01/france-a-crisis-of-faith-in-secularism-10-years-after-the-charlie-hebdo-attack.html
  75. https://actu.fr/ile-de-france/pontoise_95500/charlie-hebdo-une-rue-charb-inauguree-a-pontoise_58207743.html
  76. https://www.leparisien.fr/val-d-oise-95/charlie-hebdo-pontoise-baptise-une-rue-en-lhonneur-du-dessinateur-charb-tue-dans-lattentat-de-2015-18-03-2023-QRV4RRWKSZHTRDXQIRPSV64J6M.php
  77. https://www.lemonde.fr/actualite-medias/article/2025/10/07/charlie-hebdo-et-la-famille-de-charb-demandent-que-le-dessinateur-entre-au-pantheon_6644959_3236.html
  78. https://charliehebdo.fr/2025/10/societe/et-si-on-transferait-charb-au-pantheon/
  79. https://rmc.bfmtv.com/actualites/societe/charb-au-pantheon-il-symbolisait-tout-ce-que-detestaient-les-terroristes-souligne-riss_AV-202510080244.html
  80. https://www.lefigaro.fr/culture/charlie-hebdo-et-la-famille-du-dessinateur-demandent-l-entree-de-charb-au-pantheon-20251007
  81. https://www.la-croix.com/culture/charlie-hebdo-et-la-famille-de-charb-demandent-que-le-dessinateur-entre-au-pantheon-20251007
  82. https://www.liberation.fr/economie/medias/un-numero-special-de-charlie-hebdo-pour-les-dix-ans-des-attentats-de-janvier-2015-20241231_4KPTOGEU3FAC3DUF4QKJBZPBLQ/
  83. https://cartoonistsrights.org/10th-anniversary-charlie-hebdo-attack/
  84. https://www.bedetheque.com/auteur-4250-BD-Charb.html
  85. https://www.eyrolles.com/Accueil/Auteur/charb-74939/
  86. https://lesechappes.com/ouvrages-auteurs/charb/
  87. https://www.latimes.com/world/europe/la-fg-charlie-hebdo-magazine-editor-archive-story.html
  88. https://www.france24.com/en/20150416-france-charlie-hebdo-charb-book-islam-published-posthumously
  89. https://qz.com/323616/partner-of-charlie-hebdo-editor-charb-is-dead-murdered-because-he-drew-in-a-magazine
  90. https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/charlie-hebdo-editors-heartbroken-girlfriend-4949740
  91. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2903278/Girlfriend-murdered-Charlie-Hebdo-magazine-editor-says-knew-going-die-blames-police-failng-prevent-massacre.html
  92. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2904897/Ex-Muslim-politician-girlfriend-Charlie-Hebdo-editor-Charb-NOT-relationship-claims-family-spark-furious-row.html
  93. https://www.the-independent.com/news/people/why-jeannette-bougrab-the-girlfriend-of-late-charlie-hebdo-editor-charb-has-been-ordered-to-stay-away-from-his-funeral-9974411.html
  94. https://www.belfasttelegraph.co.uk/news/world-news/jeannette-bougrab-girlfriend-of-late-charlie-hebdo-editor-charb-ordered-to-stay-away-from-his-funeral-after-family-denies-relationship/30906104.html
  95. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-01-07/elite-security-guard-couldn-t-save-french-cartoonist-shot-dead
  96. https://www.humanite.fr/medias/charb/il-etait-des-notres-charb-ce-drole-de-coco
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.