Hubbry Logo
FleanceFleanceMain
Open search
Fleance
Community hub
Fleance
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Fleance
Fleance
Fleance
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Fleance
Macbeth character
Created byWilliam Shakespeare
Portrayed byAkira Kubo
Craig Stott
Lucas Barker
In-universe information
FamilyBanquo (father)
NationalityScottish

Fleance (/ˈfleɪɒns/ FLAY-onss; also spelled Fléance or Fleans; Latin: Fleanchus) is a figure in legendary Scottish history. He was depicted by 16th-century historians as the son of Lord Banquo, Thane of Lochaber, and the ancestor of the kings of the House of Stuart. Fleance is best known as a character in William Shakespeare's play Macbeth, in which the Three Witches prophesy that Banquo's descendants shall be kings. Some screen adaptations of the story expand on Fleance's role by showing his return to the kingdom after Macbeth's death.

Shakespeare's play is adapted from Holinshed's Chronicles, a history of the British Isles written during the late 16th century. In Holinshed, Fleance escapes Macbeth and flees to England, where he fathers a son who later becomes the first hereditary steward to the King of Scotland.

In real life, 'Steward' eventually became the name 'Stewart' (later changed to a pseudo Frenchification 'Stuart'), and Walter Stewart married Princess Marjorie, daughter of Robert the Bruce. Their son, Robert II, began the Stewart/Stuart line of kings in Scotland. James VI and I, son of Mary, Queen of Scots, was the ninth Stewart/Stuart monarch (eighth king) of Scotland and the first of the Stuart monarchs of England and Ireland.

James VI & I was the reigning monarch when William Shakespeare wrote and produced Macbeth, which may have been in the new king's honour.

History

[edit]

Fleance and his father Banquo are both fictional characters presented as historical fact by the Scottish historian Hector Boece, whose Scotorum Historiae (1526–27) was a source for Raphael Holinshed's Chronicles,[1] a history of the British Isles popular in Shakespeare's time. In the Chronicles, Fleance – in fear of Macbeth – flees to Wales and marries Nesta, daughter of Gruffydd ap Llywelyn, the last native Prince of Wales. They have a son named Walter who makes his way back to Scotland and is appointed Royal Steward. According to legend, he fathered the Stuart monarchs of England and Scotland.[2]

The Stuarts used their connection with Fleance and his marriage to the Welsh princess to claim a genealogical link with the legendary King Arthur. This, they hoped, would strengthen the legitimacy of their claim to the throne.[3] In 1722, however, Richard Hay, a Scottish historian, presented strong evidence that not only was James not a descendant of Fleance, but also that neither Fleance nor Banquo ever even existed. Most modern scholars now agree that Fleance is not a real historical figure.[4]

Max Förster suggested the name could be derived from the Gaelic Flannchad, lit. 'red warrior', or Flann-chú, "red hound."[5] Boece's original Latin gives the name in ablative form as Fleancho, so suggesting a nominative form *Fleanchus.[6]

In Macbeth

[edit]

Fleance appears in Shakespeare's Macbeth. However, only his childhood is portrayed; the rest of his story, as it is described in Holinshed's Chronicles, does not appear in Shakespeare's play. Scholars suggest that Shakespeare does not elaborate on Fleance's life after his escape from Scotland to avoid unnecessary distraction from the story of Macbeth himself.[7] In the First Folio, his name is spelled "Fleans" nine times, while "Fleance" only appears four times, but the latter spelling has become standard.[8]

In Act 1, Macbeth and Banquo meet the Three Witches who foretell that Macbeth will be king and that Banquo "shalt get kings, though thou be none".[9] Fleance also briefly appears in the first scene of Act 2, when his father tells him of "cursed thoughts that nature / Gives way to in repose!".[10] Macbeth, aware of the threat Banquo and his son pose to his new throne, plans to have them murdered. Before Banquo goes travelling, Macbeth asks "Goes Fleance with you?"[11] Macbeth sends three men to follow and kill them both, saying "Fleance['s] absence is no less material to me / Than is his father's."[12] Macbeth holds a banquet that night and reveals to his wife his fears of what might happen unless Fleance and Banquo are both killed.

Fleance escapes the attack upon his father

Banquo and Fleance are ambushed and while Banquo holds the assailants off he cries "Fly, good Fleance, fly, fly, fly! / Thou mayst revenge."[13] When the murderers return to Macbeth and report their failure to kill Fleance, he says, "Then comes my fit again: I had else been perfect, / Whole as the marble, founded as the rock, / As broad and general as the casing air: / But now I am cabin'd, cribb'd, confined, bound in / To saucy doubts and fears."[14] Macbeth later meets the Three Witches again and is shown a vision of a long line of kings descended from Banquo.

Analysis

[edit]

In the first scene of Act 2, Fleance meets his father, who asks him to take his sword and tells him he is reluctant to go to bed due to the "cursed thoughts that nature / gives way to in repose!"[15] On Macbeth's approach, however, Banquo demands the sword be returned to him quickly. Scholars have interpreted this to mean that Banquo has been dreaming of murdering the king. Doing so would make the throne more available for Fleance, and would fulfill the Three Witches' prophecy that his sons would become kings. Since Banquo's good nature is revolted by these thoughts, he gives his sword and dagger to Fleance to be sure he does not act on them. Still, he is so nervous at Macbeth's approach that he demands their return.[16] Other scholars have responded that Banquo's dreams have nothing to do with him killing the king, but that they have revealed to him Macbeth's bloody nature. They argue that Banquo is merely setting aside his sword for the night, but when Macbeth approaches, Banquo, having had these dark dreams about Macbeth, takes back his sword as a precaution.[17] In any case, this scene adds to the dark, uncertain, unsettling tone of the play. Fleance and his father are not even certain of what time it is throughout, as Fleance says when asked at the beginning of the scene "The moon is down; I have not heard the clock."[18][19][20]

The two scenes in which murderers attack Banquo and Fleance, Lady Macduff and Macduff's son, have been compared to Herod's attempt to murder Christ and save the throne for himself by killing all new-born children in Bethlehem.[21] The conversation between Fleance and Banquo in their own murder scene is especially dark. Banquo's first line from within "Give us a light there, ho!"[22] communicates the nighttime setting. The stage direction "Enter BANQUO, and FLEANCE, with a torch",[23] seems to foreshadow the fact that Fleance is a light for Scotland in the midst of the play's black deeds.[24]

When Macbeth returns to the witches later in the play, they show him an apparition of the murdered Banquo, along with eight kings of his family, descending through Fleance. King James, on the throne when Macbeth was written, was the ninth Stuart king. This scene thus suggests strong support for James' right to the throne by lineage, and for audiences of Shakespeare's day, was a tangible fulfilment of the witches' prophecy.[25] The apparition is also deeply unsettling to Macbeth, who not only wants the throne for himself, but also desires to father a line of kings.[26]

Theatre and screen versions

[edit]

Theatre and screen versions of Macbeth have sometimes elaborated on Fleance's role.[citation needed]

In Orson Welles's film version of Macbeth (1948), Fleance is briefly seen again at the very end of the movie. He does not speak in this scene, but he has returned to Scotland with the army of Malcolm and Macduff, and is shown along with those hailing Malcolm as the new king after the killing of Macbeth.

The BBC Shakespeare version of Macbeth shows Fleance in the final scene, implying his future role in bringing Banquo's line to the throne.[27]

In Joe MacBeth (1955), the first film to transpose Macbeth into a gang and Mafia-like setting, Fleance is replaced by a character named Lenny. Lenny's father, Banky, is killed, but Lenny escapes, and gathers a group of angry mobsters to overthrow Macbeth, who has, through a series of murders, made himself the kingpin gangster in the area. Lenny is successful in killing Macbeth in the end, but only after Macbeth has murdered most of his family.[28] In another gangster adaptation, Men of Respect (1991), Fleance is replaced by a character named Phil, who similarly helps overthrow Mike (Macbeth) after his father, Bankie (Banquo), is murdered. Phil is inducted into the gang at the end of the film, when Mal (Malcolm) has taken over, suggesting that the violent gang culture will continue through generations.[29] This sentiment echoes into the final scenes of Penny Woolcock's Macbeth on the Estate. Macduff shoots Macbeth and takes a ring (representing his high status) off Macbeth's finger. Entering a bar, he flips it to Malcolm, saying, "Hail, king." Malcolm puts it on with some show and elbows his way to the front of the bar. One of the characters he elbows is Fleance (a skinhead), who makes a mock gun out of his fingers and "shoots" at the back of the darker-skinned Malcolm's skull. Again this makes it clear that the violence will not end with the new generation.[30][31]

In Throne of Blood, a Japanese adaptation of the play, Fleance is replaced by Yoshiteru, a character played by Akira Kubo.[32] The Macbeth and Banquo characters, Washizu and Miki, are told by an old woman spinning wool in a hut that while Washizu will rule the Forest Castle one day, Miki's son Yoshiteru will eventually inherit it for himself. Washizu takes the throne and at one point is about to make Yoshiteru his heir, but changes his mind when his wife tells him she is pregnant. Washizu instead arranges to have Yoshiteru and his father killed, but Yoshiteru escapes.[33][34] Another adaptation filmed in India, Maqbool (2003), replaces Fleance with a character named Guddu. Maqbool (Macbeth) attempts to have Guddu murdered to strengthen power within the organised crime circle. Guddu, however, survives and marries the daughter of the former crime lord.[35]

In Macbett, Eugène Ionesco's 1972 stage adaptation, Fleance is merged with the Malcolm character. Macol (Malcolm), who is thought to be King Duncan's son, is revealed to be Banco's (Banquo's). Duncan, wanting a male heir, adopted Macol. Macol fills the role of Malcolm in taking the kingdom from Macbett (Macbeth) at the end of the play.[36]

In the 2006 modern dress film adaptation, set among gangsters in Melbourne, Fleance (Craig Stott) is depicted as a teenage boy, looking slightly older than in the original play. He also appears a bit more often, mainly in the scenes of Act V, where he sneaks on board a truck full of timber and witnesses the death of Macbeth before killing the maid and being directed home by Macduff.[citation needed]

In Joel Coen's 2021 film, Fleance (Lucas Barker) is retrieved from the Old Man (Kathryn Hunter) by (the more prominent than usual) character of Ross (Alex Hassell), who has played an ambiguous role throughout the film.[citation needed]

Influence

[edit]
The Murder of Banquo (George Fennell Robson, c. 1830); Fleance flees at lower centre.

Fleance's line "The moon is down, I have not heard the clock"[20] was the inspiration for the title of John Steinbeck's 1942 short novel The Moon is Down. Fleance's line foreshadows the evil encompassing the kingdom. The book was published just as the United States entered World War II and signalled the threat of the Axis powers by outlining the events in a European town occupied by foreign powers. Steinbeck's book became a Broadway play and a film.[37]

In 2008, Pegasus Books published The Tragedy of Macbeth Part II: The Seed of Banquo, a play by American author and playwright Noah Lukeman that endeavoured to pick up where the original Macbeth left off, and to resolve its many loose ends, particularly the prophesied ascension of the seed of Banquo. Written in blank verse, the play was published to critical acclaim.[citation needed]

Another book published in 2009 by Penguin Books, Banquo's Son, is the first in a trilogy that follows on from the Shakespearean story. The novels are written by New Zealand author and English teacher, T.K. Roxborogh.[38]

References

[edit]

Bibliography

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Fleance

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Fleance is a character in William Shakespeare's tragedy , portrayed as the young son of the thane . In the play, he accompanies his father to 's castle and escapes an assassination attempt orchestrated by the titular king, ensuring the fulfillment of the witches' prophecy that 's descendants will inherit the Scottish throne. Fleance appears only briefly in two scenes but symbolizes the inescapability of fate and the limits of 's ambition to secure his dynasty. The character derives from legendary accounts in 16th-century chronicles, including Raphael Holinshed's Chronicles of England, Scotland, and Ireland, where Fleance flees to following 's murder and sires a lineage claimed by the Stuart monarchs. These narratives, originating with Hector Boece, served to fabricate ancient Scottish ancestry for the Stuarts rather than reflecting verifiable history.

Historical Legend

Origins in Medieval and Renaissance Chronicles

The figure of Fleance first appears in Hector Boece's Scotorum Historiae a Prima Gentis Origine (1527), an early Renaissance chronicle that fabricates a lineage linking the Stuart dynasty to ancient Scottish nobility. Boece portrays Fleance as the son of Banquo, Thane of Lochaber, who alongside Macbeth defeats Norwegian invaders under Macdonwald around 1040 before aiding in the slaying of King Duncan I. A prophecy from three mystical women foretells Banquo's descendants, including Fleance's line, will inherit the throne, prompting Macbeth—after usurping power circa 1040—to orchestrate Banquo's murder during a feast. Fleance, then a youth, escapes the assassins under cover of night, fleeing to Wales where he marries the daughter of a Welsh prince and fathers Walter, who later returns to Scotland as the first hereditary Steward, founding the Stewart (Stuart) family around 1061. This account, detailed in Book XII, Chapters 3, 5, and 7 of Boece's work, lacks any basis in earlier records and was likely contrived to exalt the and legitimize Stuart claims to antiquity, especially as James IV's sought to counter English narratives of Scottish origins. Boece, a canon at with ties to the royal circle, drew on medieval traditions but embellished them for patriotic ends, introducing elements like the prophetic sisters absent or altered in priors. John Bellenden's Scots vernacular translation (1533–1536) popularized , preserving Fleance's escape quote: "Fleance, under cover of night, escaped, and was saved... by the singular favour of ." Medieval chronicles preceding Boece, such as John of Fordun's Chronica Gentis Scotorum (compiled c. 1360–1380s from 12th–13th-century sources) and Andrew of Wyntoun's Orygynale Cronykil (c. 1420), mention solely as Macbeth's co-conspirator in Duncan's 1040 murder, portraying him as a of without reference to a son, escape, or prophetic lineage. These accounts emphasize Macbeth's 17-year (1040–1057) and defeat at Lumphanan but omit any Stuart connection, reflecting reliance on like the (c. 1040 entries) that record only Macbeth's rule and battles. The absence underscores Boece's innovation, unverified by charters, genealogies, or contemporary witnesses, as no 11th-century supports Fleance's or Welsh . Raphael Holinshed's Chronicles (1577 edition, expanded 1587) adapts Boece's narrative almost verbatim, specifying Fleance's flight to then , his union with the prince's daughter, and Walter's stewardship grant from King Edgar (c. 1097), thus embedding the legend in English . Holinshed notes Fleance's descendants as Scotland's future kings "in the third and fourth degree," aligning with Stuart under James VI, who ascended in 1567. This Renaissance elaboration prioritized dynastic myth over empirical fidelity, as Boece's unsourced additions—absent from Fordun, Wyntoun, or Walter Bower's Scotichronicon (1440s)—reveal a pattern of historiographic invention to bolster monarchical prestige amid Anglo-Scottish rivalries.

The Welsh Exile Narrative and Stewart Genealogy

In the medieval chronicles that shaped the legend, Fleance, son of the of , escapes an assassination attempt orchestrated by following Banquo's murder around 1045. Hector Boece's Scotorum Historiae (1527) describes Fleance fleeing under cover of darkness to , where he receives protection from a Welsh prince, identified in later accounts as Gruffydd ap Llywelyn (d. 1063), the last native prince of unified . There, Fleance enters into a liaison with the prince's daughter—named Nesta or Guenta in variants—resulting in the birth of a son, Walter, before Fleance is slain by the prince for dishonoring his host. Raphael Holinshed's Chronicles of , and (1577), drawing from Boece, elaborates the exile without mentioning Fleance's death: Fleance arrives in in fear of , marries the daughter of Gruffydd ap Llywelyn, and fathers Walter fitz Fleance, thereby forging a cross-border alliance. Holinshed emphasizes the secrecy of the union, portraying Fleance as either husband or paramour, which produces the progenitor of the Stewart line. This narrative served Stuart propagandists by invoking Welsh royal blood, potentially linking to Arthurian myths through Gruffydd's lineage, to bolster claims of ancient nobility. Walter, raised in Wales, returns to Scotland in the early amid Norman influences post-1066. Historical confirm a as dapifer regis (king's steward) under David I (r. 1124–1153), an office made hereditary by 1150, marking the family's rise. Walter's descendants include Alan fitz Walter (d. c. ), who fought in the Third Crusade (1189–1192), and Walter Stewart (d. 1327), who married (d. 1316), daughter of Robert I, securing the succession. Their son, Robert Stewart (1316–1390), became Robert II, first Stewart king of Scots (r. 1371–1390), entailing through this purported Banquo-Fleance line to legitimize Stewart rule over rival claims. The genealogy traces unbroken male descent: Fleance → Walter (1st Steward) → Alan → Walter (2nd Steward, d. 1241) → → James (5th Steward, 1332–1333) → Walter (6th Steward, d. 1327) → Robert II. Stewart chroniclers like those in Andrew Stewart's Genealogical History (early ) amplified this to connect pre-Christian kings like Fergus I (r. c. 330 BCE) via , though Boece and Holinshed limit it to thanes of the . (r. 1567–1625) endorsed the tale in royal genealogies to affirm divine-right and Anglo-Scottish unity post-1603.

Modern Scholarly Debunking of the Legend

The legend of Fleance, portraying him as the son of who escaped assassination and founded the Stewart dynasty through marriage in , originated in Hector Boece's Historia Gentis Scotorum (1527), where Boece introduced and Fleance as figures absent from earlier chronicles to fabricate an ancient Scottish lineage for the Stewarts, enhancing their monarchical legitimacy amid Tudor-Stuart rivalries. Prior Scottish histories, such as those by John of Fordun and Andrew of Wyntoun in the 14th-15th centuries, contained no references to , Fleance, or their purported Welsh exile and progeny linking to Walter FitzAlan, the first hereditary Steward of Scotland (d. 1177). Genealogical records trace the Stewarts to Breton origins, descending from Alan fitz Flaad, a Breton noble who entered English service post-1066 Conquest and whose son Walter fitz Alan received the Scottish steward office from David I around 1150, establishing the family through documented feudal grants rather than mythical flight and royal Welsh union. No contemporary 11th-century evidence supports Fleance's existence or the Banquo-Stewart connection, which Boece likely contrived by conflating disparate traditions, including possible echoes of lost Stewart origin tales, to align with Renaissance historiographic tendencies favoring noble antiquity. By the , Scottish antiquarian Richard Hay systematically refuted the Fleance descent in his genealogical inquiries (), demonstrating through charter analysis and absence of medieval attestations that neither nor Fleance were historical, and that James VI/I's Stewart lineage derived solely from Walter fitz Alan's Breton forebears without 11th-century Scottish intermediaries. Modern concurs, viewing the narrative as a post-medieval fabrication unsupported by primary sources like royal charters or , with DNA and onomastic studies further aligning Stewarts with Norman-Breton migrations rather than native thanes. This consensus underscores how chroniclers like Boece prioritized dynastic over empirical record, a critiqued in source-critical works since the Enlightenment.

Portrayal in Shakespeare's Macbeth

Narrative Role and Key Scenes

Fleance functions as a pivotal figure in Macbeth, embodying the witches' prophecy that Banquo's descendants will inherit the Scottish throne, thereby underscoring themes of inescapable fate and dynastic insecurity for the childless Macbeth. As Banquo's young son, Fleance symbolizes the continuity of Banquo's line, which Macbeth perceives as a direct threat to his usurped rule, prompting him to orchestrate the assassination attempt on both father and son in Act 3. His survival reinforces the prophecy's inexorability, contrasting Macbeth's futile efforts to defy supernatural predictions and secure a lasting legacy. Fleance first appears in Act 2, Scene 1, where he accompanies his father during a late-night encounter with at . Carrying a to their way, the boyish Fleance highlights Banquo's paternal vigilance and familial bond, as Banquo expresses concern for his son's safety amid the night's unease and mentions dreams disturbed by the witches' equivocations. This brief interaction foreshadows the peril to Banquo's lineage, with Fleance's innocence amplifying the tragedy of the impending violence. The character's most critical scene unfolds in Act 3, Scene 3, during the ambush by Macbeth's hired murderers near the palace grounds. As and Fleance approach by torchlight, the assassins extinguish the flame to launch their attack, killing after a desperate struggle in which he urges his son to "Fly, good Fleance, fly, fly, fly!" Fleance escapes into the darkness, evading capture despite the murderers' efforts, an outcome that thwarts Macbeth's scheme and signals the prophecy's persistence. This escape not only advances the plot by heightening Macbeth's paranoia but also affirms the witches' foresight, as Fleance's survival ensures the eventual kingship of 's heirs, including the historical . Fleance does not reappear onstage, yet his offstage flight reverberates through the narrative, embodying the limits of tyrannical ambition against predestined succession.

Thematic Function in Prophecy and Succession

Fleance's survival serves as the pivotal mechanism ensuring the fulfillment of the witches' to that "thou shalt get kings, though thou be none," positioning him as the direct conduit for a dynastic lineage destined for the Scottish throne. In Act III, Scene 3, Fleance escapes the murderers hired by , who explicitly targets him to sever 's bloodline and nullify the equivocal forecast of future kingship. This evasion not only preserves the 's ambiguity—leaving open the possibility of its realization—but also amplifies the play's exploration of fate's inexorability against human agency, as 's proactive violence inadvertently affirms the supernatural decree rather than subverting it. Thematically, Fleance embodies the tension between disrupted and restored succession, contrasting Macbeth's tyrannical usurpation with the organic continuity of hereditary rule. By fleeing into the night, he represents the enduring threat of legitimate inheritance, fueling Macbeth's descent into and further atrocities, as the unkillable heir symbolizes an uncontainable providential order. This narrative arc underscores kingship as inherently tied to lineage, where Macbeth's childlessness and moral corruption bar him from true succession, while Fleance's vitality hints at a restorative aligned with divine sanction. In the broader Jacobean context of the play's composition around , Fleance's role reinforces themes of prophetic legitimacy, mirroring contemporary ideologies that validated monarchical succession through bloodlines purportedly ordained by fate or providence. His function thus critiques ambition's futility against predestined order, with the prophecy's persistence via Fleance affirming that true transcends individual will, a motif resonant with audiences under James I's rule.

Adaptations Across Media

Theatrical Interpretations and Expansions

In theatrical productions of , Fleance's portrayal typically underscores the prophecy's assurance of Banquo's descendants' royal future, with his escape during the Act III, Scene iii ambush serving as a pivotal moment of thwarted villainy and inexorable fate. Directors frequently heighten the scene's suspense through staging choices, such as dim lighting or chase sequences, to emphasize 's partial failure and the enduring threat to his usurped throne. Modern stage interpretations often amplify Fleance's symbolic weight by integrating him into broader thematic explorations of innocence, lineage, and moral consequence. In the Royal Shakespeare Company's 2024 production at The Other Place, directed by Harriet Bailey, Fleance (played by Myles Owen) receives expanded emotional connections, including hugs from and her direct intervention to urge him to flee the murderers, portraying her as a catalyst for surrogate maternal impulses that contrast her in Duncan's . This choice, as noted in production reviews, humanizes while reinforcing Fleance's role as a vessel for dynastic continuity, evoking audience sympathy for the vulnerable heir amid the play's . Other productions reinterpret Fleance to critique power's generational toll. The Folger Theatre's 2018 staging, directed by Folger Ensemble and Two River Theater Company, features young Fleance (Owen Peakes) vocally calling out to his ambushed father onstage, intensifying the of Banquo's death and the restorative force of rightful succession against 's tyranny. Similarly, Now Theatre & Film's 2022 Macbeth Redux deviates from convention by altering Fleance's demeanor—portrayed with atypical assertiveness—to signal early hints of the avenging ruler he becomes in legend, blending Shakespeare's text with subtle nods to post- narratives of Stewart ancestry. Expansions beyond Shakespeare's canon remain scarce in pure theater, with few standalone plays centering Fleance's exile or return; instead, directors embed legendary elements—like his eventual kingship—through framing devices or epilogues in select experimental stagings, prioritizing textual fidelity while evoking Holinshed's chronicles. These approaches maintain Fleance as a narrative fulcrum for debates on predestination, avoiding overt sequels that risk diluting the original's tragic ambiguity.

Film and Television Depictions

In film adaptations of Shakespeare's Macbeth, Fleance is most often depicted in the pivotal murder scene of Act 3, Scene 3, where he flees the assassins hired by Macbeth, preserving the prophecy of Banquo's lineage ascending to the throne despite Macbeth's efforts to eradicate it. Orson Welles's 1948 production features Christopher Welles as Fleance, who appears briefly at the film's close amid the restoration of order, silently embodying the enduring threat to Macbeth's usurpation. Roman Polanski's 1971 film adheres closely to the play's text for Fleance's escape, portraying the as a swift, shadowy figure vanishing into the night after Banquo's death, with no further expansion but emphasizing the futility of Macbeth's violence through the prophecy's persistence. Later adaptations occasionally amplify Fleance's symbolism. In Justin Kurzel's 2015 Macbeth, Lochlann Harris plays Fleance as an eyewitness to the brutal slaying, heightening the child's trauma; the film deviates by concluding with Fleance retrieving Macbeth's bloodied sword from the corpse-strewn battlefield, a visual cue to the witches' foretold succession of Banquo's heirs. Joel Coen's stark 2021 The Tragedy of Macbeth casts Lucas Barker in the role, retaining its brevity as a mute harbinger of dynastic inevitability without altering the . Television versions similarly confine Fleance to essential appearances, though some filmed stage productions add interpretive depth. Alan Stebbings portrayed Fleance in a 1949 telecast, capturing the boy's innocence amid ambush. The BBC's 1983 Macbeth from the Television Shakespeare series features Alastair Henderson as Fleance, staging the flight with period authenticity to underscore themes of thwarted tyranny. In Rupert Goold's 2010 production, broadcast on PBS's Great Performances and set in a wartime context, Bertie Gilbert embodies Fleance during the murder, with the adaptation's modern echoes amplifying the generational curse on Macbeth's ambition. Across these media, Fleance rarely speaks or drives plot beyond his survival, serving primarily as a narrative device for inexorable fate rather than a fully fleshed character.

Influence on Broader Literature and Culture

The legendary survival of Fleance, as son of and progenitor of the Stuart kings in Shakespeare's , has inspired that extrapolates his exile and role in royal genealogy. T.K. Thorne's Banquo's Son (2016) depicts Fleance's adoption by Welsh commoners after fleeing Macbeth's assassins, portraying his upbringing in martial skills and honor as a foundation for future kingship, thereby extending the play's themes of lineage and resilience against tyranny. This narrative expansion reflects broader literary interest in filling Shakespeare's gaps regarding Fleance's fate, often romanticizing his journey to and marriage into the as a bridge to Scottish . Such works, including alternate histories like Bloodlines where Fleance assumes the of a fractured , use his character to explore political instability and blood-right legitimacy in medieval settings. In cultural discourse, Fleance embodies the motif of escaped ensuring dynastic continuity, influencing interpretations of fate and in Shakespearean studies and occasionally appearing in discussions of Stuart , where the Banquo-Fleance line was invoked to legitimize James VI and I's rule post-1603. However, these references remain secondary to Macbeth's central , with Fleance's legacy more prominent in niche genealogy-themed than mainstream culture.

Critical Analysis and Debates

Traditional Readings on Fate, Lineage, and Monarchy

In traditional literary criticism of Macbeth, Fleance's survival and implied future kingship exemplify the inexorable triumph of providential fate over tyrannical disruption, reinforcing the Jacobean doctrine of hereditary monarchy as a divinely sanctioned order. The witches' prophecy to Banquo—that he would beget a line of kings—positions Fleance as the vessel for this destiny, his escape from Macbeth's assassins in Act 3, Scene 3 underscoring the futility of mortal interference in cosmic succession. Early interpreters, drawing from Shakespeare's sources like Holinshed's Chronicles (1577), viewed this narrative arc as a cautionary affirmation that legitimate bloodlines persist despite violence, with Fleance's flight to exile symbolizing the resilience of rightful rule against usurpation. This reading aligns with Stuart-era , where the play's depiction of Banquo's lineage culminating in figures resembling (as shown in the Act 4, Scene 1 apparition of future kings) served to validate monarchical absolutism and the . Critics such as those in 17th- and 18th-century commentaries emphasized how Fleance's role counters Macbeth's ambition by illustrating causal inevitability: the disruption of natural hierarchy through murder invites chaos, but fate restores equilibrium through unbroken descent. James I's own The True Law of Free Monarchies (1598) echoed this by asserting kings as God's lieutenants, a principle dramatized in Fleance's preservation as the seed of enduring sovereignty, thereby flattering the royal patron while warning against rebellion. Such interpretations also highlight lineage as a metaphysical bulwark against , with Fleance's youth and innocence contrasting Macbeth's moral decay to evoke the sanctity of paternal inheritance in monarchical stability. Traditional scholars, including 19th-century figures like Edward Dowden, argued that the prophecy's fulfillment via Fleance critiques secular power grabs, positing not as elective but as fated continuity ordained by higher powers, a view rooted in the era's rejection of contractual kingship in favor of providential realism.

Modern Interpretations and Potential Biases

In contemporary , Fleance is frequently interpreted as a pivotal symbol of prophetic inevitability and the restoration of legitimate order, his survival after the assassination attempt in Act III, Scene III highlighting Macbeth's inability to sever Banquo's bloodline despite calculated violence. This reading posits Fleance not merely as a passive but as an agent of cosmic continuity, embodying the witches' forecast that Banquo's descendants would inherit kingship, thereby critiquing unchecked ambition's collision with predestined causality. Analyses from the early reinforce this by linking his torch-bearing presence during the murder to motifs of emergent piercing tyrannical obscurity, signifying for monarchical renewal aligned with the play's exploration of moral retribution. Such interpretations extend to adaptations, where Fleance's evasion underscores themes of sin's inescapability and dynastic , as seen in filmic renderings that preserve his in thwarting usurpation while amplifying psychological tension. For example, discussions of post-2000 productions emphasize how his escape precipitates Macbeth's descent into , framing it as evidence of a naturalistic order resisting artificial disruption. This aligns with causal analyses viewing the character's arc as illustrative of human limits against providential design, rather than mere . However, potential biases emerge in ideological overlays common to modern Shakespeare studies, where feminist or postcolonial frameworks reinterpret Fleance's lineage through lenses of gendered power or racial otherness, often prioritizing contemporary equity narratives over the text's Jacobean endorsement of hereditary monarchy. Feminist perspectives, for instance, may cast the targeting of Fleance as emblematic of patriarchal erasure of alternative inheritances, yet this risks eliding Shakespeare's flattery of James I via Banquo's line, rooted in verifiable 17th-century genealogical claims rather than abstract gender critique. Similarly, racialized soundscape analyses extend "whiteness" motifs to the play's figures, potentially projecting modern identity constructs onto a narrative historically unconcerned with such categories, reflecting academia's documented tilt toward deconstructive methodologies that undervalue empirical historical fidelity. These tendencies, while enriching thematic breadth, can introduce anachronistic distortions, as evidenced by critiques noting humanities scholarship's vulnerability to confirmation biases favoring ideological coherence over textual or contextual primacy.

Controversies in Historical versus Fictional Framing

The portrayal of Fleance in Shakespeare's Macbeth draws from chronicles that presented him as a historical figure whose lineage led to the Scottish kings, yet modern scholarship establishes him as a 16th-century invention without basis in medieval records. Hector Boece, in his 1527 Scotorum Historiae, first introduced Banquo and Fleance as father and son, with Fleance fleeing Macbeth's assassins, exiling to Wales, marrying the Princess of North Wales, and fathering Walter, progenitor of the Stewart dynasty—a narrative absent from earlier sources like John of Fordun's 14th-century Chronica Gentis Scotorum. This genealogy was propagated to bolster the legitimacy of the Stewart monarchs, including James VI of Scotland (later James I of England), who traced his ancestry through Fleance to justify his rule as divinely ordained rather than through the elective tanistry system of medieval Scotland. Shakespeare amplified this fictional lineage in (performed circa 1606), depicting Fleance's escape in Act III, Scene III as fulfilling the witches' that Banquo's descendants would inherit the , a motif aligning with James I's interests following his 1603 ascension to the English . While Raphael Holinshed's 1587 Chronicles, Shakespeare's , echoed Boece's account and softened Banquo's complicity in Duncan's to portray him as virtuous—contrary to Boece's of him as Macbeth's accomplice—the play further idealized the figure to emphasize over historical disputes. Actual 11th-century events involved mac Findlaích seizing power after defeating Duncan I in battle in 1040, ruling until 1057 without recorded rivalry from a or pursuit of his son; Fleance's role thus serves dramatic rather than verifiable chronology. Controversies arise from this , as the play's enduring popularity has perpetuated pseudo-history, obscuring Macbeth's legitimate rule under Gaelic customs and inflating Stewart claims amid rival English narratives. Critics argue Shakespeare, aware of unreliability through access to varied sources, prioritized Jacobean flattery—evident in the 1606 performance context post-Gunpowder Plot—over fidelity, transforming Boece's Tudor-era into cultural canon that influenced perceptions of Scottish . While some traditional readings defend the adaptation as rooted in contemporary "history," skeptics highlight systemic biases in , where monarchs commissioned flattering genealogies; Boece's work, for instance, served James V's court by retrofitting ancient nobility to Stuarts, lacking empirical corroboration from contemporary annals like the . This framing debate underscores tensions between empirical medieval records and fictionalized royal ideology, with Fleance embodying causal manipulation of lineage for political realism rather than truth.

References

  1. https://www.playshakespeare.com/macbeth/characters/3009-fleance
  2. https://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/macbeth/character/fleance/
  3. https://study.com/academy/lesson/fleance-in-macbeth-character-analysis.html
  4. https://shakespeare-navigators.ewu.edu/macbeth/Fleance.html
  5. https://shakespeare-navigators.ewu.edu/macbeth/Holinshed/index.html
  6. https://www.wikitree.com/wiki/Lochaber-2
  7. https://www.exclassics.com/boece/Boece.pdf
  8. https://ia801601.us.archive.org/12/items/historychronicle01boec/historychronicle01boec.pdf
  9. https://referenceworks.brill.com/display/entries/EMCO/SIM-000676.xml?language=en
  10. https://www.historytoday.com/archive/real-macbeth-king-scots-1040-1054
  11. https://blog.history.ac.uk/2023/11/kings-and-witches-exploring-the-sources-of-macbeth-in-the-ihr-library/
  12. https://historum.com/t/hector-boeces-invention-of-banquo-the-stuarts-ancestor.194084/
  13. https://archive.org/details/historyofstewart00leeh
  14. https://archive.org/stream/historyofstewart00leeh/historyofstewart00leeh_djvu.txt
  15. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/shakespeare-survey/spectacle-representation-and-lineage-in-macbeth-41/E4335BEF92891E5DD45ACB63F1B1601A
  16. http://www.medievalgenealogy.org.uk/sources/round/stewarts1.shtml
  17. https://www.oxfordreference.com/display/10.1093/oi/authority.20110803100538360
  18. https://www.rsc.org.uk/shakespeare-learning-zone/macbeth/character/relationships
  19. https://www.rsc.org.uk/shakespeare-learning-zone/macbeth/story/scene-by-scene
  20. https://www.folger.edu/explore/shakespeares-works/macbeth/read/3/3/
  21. https://www.sparknotes.com/shakespeare/macbeth/section5/
  22. https://www.litcharts.com/shakescleare/shakespeare-translations/macbeth/act-3-scene-3
  23. https://snaprevise.com/guide/macbeth/character-analysis/fleance
  24. https://www.enotes.com/topics/macbeth/themes/prophecy
  25. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/macbeth/themes/fate
  26. https://www.enotes.com/topics/macbeth/themes/dynastic-succession
  27. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/395361784_Macbeth_by_William_Shakespeare_A_Critical_Summary
  28. https://www.bellshakespeare.com.au/macbeth-historical-background-2
  29. https://theatreandtonic.co.uk/blog/macbeth-at-the-other-place-rsc-review
  30. https://www.facebook.com/groups/452768566054770/posts/1476326387032311/
  31. https://dctheaterarts.org/2018/09/05/a-new-dynasty-commands-the-stage-in-the-folger-theatres-macbeth/
  32. https://www.thinkingtheaternyc.com/2022/08/review-macbeth-redux-does-well-by-both.html
  33. https://www.facebook.com/rennowtheatrefilm/
  34. https://journals.shu.ac.uk/index.php/EMLS/article/download/423/169/1508
  35. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0040558/
  36. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0067372/
  37. https://movies.stackexchange.com/questions/55556/what-does-the-ending-of-2015s-macbeth-mean
  38. https://www.rivalmagazinela.com/rival-online/lucas-baker-is-fleance-in-the-tragedy-of-macbeth
  39. https://bbc-video-uk.fandom.com/wiki/BBC_Shakespeare_-_Macbeth
  40. https://historicalnovelsociety.org/reviews/banquos-son/
  41. https://hardcover.app/books/bloodlines-8b28f565-e2de-43a6-908d-4ff644e3194e
  42. https://www.annabelfrage.com/2020/10/27/much-medieval-mayhem-how-shakespeare-inspired-a-fascination-with-all-things-medieval/
  43. https://www.pearsonschoolsandfecolleges.co.uk/asset-library/pdf/Secondary/english-literature/accessible-shakespeare/AS-Macbeth-Sample-Chapter.pdf
  44. https://grammar.trinitymat.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Year-11-English-BBand-T2.pdf
  45. https://anunexpectedjournal.com/adaptation-and-cultural-apologetics-sin-guilt-and-cosmic-justice-across-five-macbeth-films/
  46. https://media.christendom.edu/2018/05/light-thickens-political-tyranny-and-personal-freedom-in-macbeth/
  47. https://www.academia.edu/36430967/Patriarchal_Dominance_in_Shakespeares_Macbeth_Viewing_from_A_Feminist_Perspectives
  48. https://www.academia.edu/89004343/_Blanched_with_Fear_Reading_the_Racialized_Soundscape_in_Macbeth
  49. https://dsq-sds.org/article/id/340/
  50. https://www.shakespearesglobe.com/discover/blogs-and-features/2014/11/05/the-gunpowder-plot-and-shakespeares-macbeth/
  51. https://shakespeareoxfordfellowship.org/shakespeare-in-scotland/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.