Hubbry Logo
Lloyd CenterLloyd CenterMain
Open search
Lloyd Center
Community hub
Lloyd Center
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Lloyd Center
Lloyd Center
Lloyd Center
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Lloyd Center is a shopping mall in the Lloyd District of Portland, Oregon, United States, just northeast of downtown, that opened in 1960. It is owned by the Urban Renaissance Group and KKR Real Estate Finance Trust Inc.[4] The mall features three floors of shopping, with the third level serving mostly as professional office spaces, a food court, and U.S. Education Corporation's Carrington College. Lloyd Center also includes the Lloyd Center Ice Skating Rink, which has become the main draw for the mall. There are currently no anchors in the mall.[5] There are vacant anchor spaces left by Macy's, Marshalls, Nordstrom, and Sears. Junior anchors include Barnes & Noble. The paved lots built as part of the mall comprise 8,000 parking spaces.[6][7]

Key Information

History

[edit]

Ideas for Lloyd Center were conceived as early as 1923. The mall was named after southern Californian oil company executive Ralph B. Lloyd (1875–1953) who wished to build an area of self-sufficiency that included stores and residential locations. The mall was built 37 years later, after major events such as the Great Depression[1] and World War II, as well as Portland's conservative anti-development attitude.[8] During development, adaptive reuse activist, Jerry Bosco, co-founder of the Bosco-Milligan Foundation in the year 1987,[9] began salvaging pieces from the developing piece of land in the 50s.[10]

1960–1988

[edit]

The mall opened August 1, 1960 in a 100-store, open-air configuration. At the time, it was the largest shopping center in the Pacific Northwest and claimed to be the largest in the country.[8] In 1960, Lloyd Center was located very close to the downtown retail core and was the first major retail development to seriously challenge it, [citation needed] aimed almost exclusively at commuters utilizing Portland's then-growing freeway system, especially the adjacent Banfield Expressway.

The original anchor stores were Meier & Frank at the center, Best's and Nordstrom's Shoes anchoring the west end, J. C. Penney and Woolworth anchoring the east, and J. J. Newberry the north. The Newberry store was the national chain's largest at the time of its opening.[11] The Seattle-based Nordstrom's Shoes chain acquired Best's apparel in 1963 and rebranded all locations as Nordstrom Best in 1967. The Nordstrom nameplate was adopted in 1973.

As of 1971, Lloyd Center's five largest stores were, from largest to smallest, Meier & Frank (314,000 square feet), Newberry's (100,000 sq. ft.), Penney's (97,370 sq. ft.), F. W. Woolworth (62,734 sq. ft.) and Nordstom Best (52,891 sq. ft.).[12]

The first significant expansion to the mall since its opening in 1960 was made in fall 1972, adding six stores.[13] The 75,000-square-foot (7,000 m2) expansion included the addition of a 50,000-square-foot (4,600 m2) Lipman's store.[13] In 1973, the JCPenney store was remodeled and expanded to 144,000 square feet (13,400 m2).[14]

Frederick & Nelson acquired the Lipman's chain in 1979,[15] and the Lloyd Center Lipman's store was renamed Frederick & Nelson.[16] The store subsequently went through a dizzying succession of owners, nameplates and locations within the mall.[clarification needed] It appears that, in 1988, Nordstrom moved into the old Lipmans/Frederick and Nelson building. The Lipmans name was apparently reinstated[citation needed] at a new location in the north end of the mall in 1987, only to be replaced by that of Spokane-based The Crescent later in the same year. In March 1988, the store was acquired by Bellevue, Washington-based Lamonts.

1988–2021: renovation and new look, foreclosure

[edit]
Southwest entrance in 1992, after its remodeling and the replacement of the original Nordstrom store from 1960 with a new, larger one

By 1987, the mall was aging and enclosed malls were becoming the norm across the United States. Between 1988 and 1991 the mall was gradually renovated.[17] Nordstrom ended up demolishing the Lipmans store and opening an entirely new location on its space in August 1990. The former Nordstrom spaces had been gutted and refitted as inline stores, followed by a mall-wide renovation around late 1990-early 1991 which fully enclosed the mall and added a food court. The remodeled shopping hub was re-opened to the public in August 1991.

Glimcher Realty Trust bought the center in 1998 for $167 million.[18]

JCPenney closed in June 1998[19] and was replaced by Sears in November 1999.[20] The Newberry's store, the last in Oregon, closed in 2001, when the entire chain went out of business.[21] Macy's replaced Meier & Frank in 2006.

Mall interior in 2015

Glimcher Realty Trust sold 60% of the center to Blackstone Real Estate Partners in 2010 after a deal to sell the entire mall fell through the year before.[18] Lloyd Center was sold by Glimcher to Cypress Equities Real Estate Investment Management in June 2013.[18]

In February 2014, it was announced that Nordstrom would be closing its Lloyd Center store effective January 10, 2015.[22][23]

An 18-month, $50 million renovation began in March 2015, alongside the closure of the Regal 8 cinema.[24] Entrances to the mall were made more pedestrian-friendly and the central space was reconfigured with a spiral staircase.[25] The changes were in part a response to the increasing population of the Lloyd District from newly constructed apartment buildings.[26]

The Sears store in 2017. It closed in 2018.

In August 2016, Sears sold its 143,000-square-foot (13,300 m2) space to the mall's owners, who were reported to be planning a major remodeling of its upper floors, demolishing the fourth floor and expanding the third floor.[27] On January 4, 2018, Sears announced that its Lloyd Center store would be closing in early April 2018 as part of a plan to close 103 stores nationwide.[28]

In January 2019, it was reported that Marshalls would be closing later that month.[29]

On November 17, 2020, Macy's announced it would be closing in January 2021.[30] Following the closure of Macy's, no traditional anchor stores remain in the mall.[31][5]

On January 12, 2021, Old Navy announced that the Lloyd Center store would permanently close by the end of January. After the Old Navy closure, the first floor of the mall from the former Sears and the former Marshalls to the former Payless Shoe Source would have vacant storefronts.[citation needed]

On August 6, 2021, a two-alarm fire started in the mall's basement, damaging the mall's electrical system. The mall was closed for over three weeks while repairs were made.[32]

On November 1, 2021, it was reported by local media that KKR Real Estate Finance Trust would be foreclosing on Lloyd Center by the end of the year due to payments on its $110 million debt loan not having been made since October 2020. It was stated that a comprehensive redevelopment of the site was to be considered.[33]

After 2021: redevelopment

[edit]

In a press release on December 20, 2021, Seattle-based real estate company Urban Renaissance Group announced themselves as the new owner-operators of Lloyd center and expressed intentions to listen to "existing tenants, neighbors, the broader community and City officials."[4]

The sculpture Capitalism, at the southwest entrance

The managing director of Urban Renaissance Group, Tim Kilbane, said that while store owners will not be seeing major changes to the mall for two years, they are unable to sign five-year leases due to uncertainty about future plans.[34]

Several small, art-focused local businesses relocated into the mall in 2022, citing lower rent and greater influence over the future of the location.[35][36][37]

In September 2023, Urban Renaissance Group announced a plan for the mall that would add 5000 residences into the space while keeping the local landmark ice rink but did not include a cost estimate, nor any announcement of closure for building.[38] Tax increment financing was mentioned as a method of paying for this plan.[39]

The mall continues to host community events in 2024,[40] several of which are various local entertainment events that are smaller and more unique to the area such as Portland's secret roller disco several times in the empty Marshall's,[41] a local theater company hosting productions in what was a Victoria's Secret,[42] and a performance art piece in the dry fountain sculpture Capitalism.[43] Mall staples Ross Dress for Less[44] and Cinnabon[45] have left the mall, but Jumbo's Pickleball has opened its doors in one of the mall's empty anchor spaces.[46]

Bigger organizations such Live Nation in 2018 and Anschutz Entertainment Group in 2024 have made plans to develop a larger music events space out of the mall.[47] The former Nordstrom building is set to be replaced by a live-music venue for up to 4,250 people. Demolition began in late June 2025 and opening of the venue is projected for early 2027.[48][49]

Ice rink

[edit]

Opening in 1960, the Lloyd Center Ice Rink was the world's first shopping center rink.[50] The open-air rink was widely popular, drawing more than a million visitors in its first two years,[50] and remains the mall's central attraction.[51] The Ice Rink has attracted a few notable guests over the years. Actor Jim Backus, the voice of Mr. Magoo, once did a couple's routine with a bear.[50] Robert F. Kennedy and his wife Ethel, circled Lloyd's ice just a month before his assassination in June, 1968.[50] Former Olympic figure skater Tonya Harding, at age 3, first learned to skate at the Lloyd Center rink.[50]

The Open-air Ice Rink was covered when the mall went from an open-air configuration to an atrium roof design in the 1990s. The rink was reduced in size in 2016 from a standard rectangular rink design to a smaller oval shape.[52] The redesign moved the rink to a more central location, and opened it up to be visible from all levels of the mall.[53] The renovations to the food court are supposed to make watching the skaters easier, which supposedly will keep people inside shopping longer.[54] Despite allowing for more natural light, the renovations were met with controversy by some locals, as the size was less than 4/5ths of what it was and some skaters took issue with the oval shape.[55]

Court cases

[edit]

Lloyd Center has played a role in the history of freedom of speech in the United States, especially with regard to the scope of free speech within private shopping centers. Lloyd Center was the defendant in the landmark cases of Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner, 407 U.S. 551 (1972), a decision of the U.S. Supreme Court involving First Amendment rights and private property, and Lloyd Corp. v. Whiffen, 307 Or. 674, 773 P.2d 1293 (1989), a decision of the Oregon Supreme Court.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Lloyd Center

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Lloyd Center is a regional situated in the Lloyd District of northeast , approximately one mile from downtown. Opened on August 1, 1960, it debuted as an open-air complex that its developers promoted as the world's largest , drawing over 5,000 attendees to its grand opening despite rainy weather. Originally encompassing dozens of stores and pioneering features like an on-site rink, the Lloyd Center exemplified the shift toward suburban retail hubs and has since hosted enduring community traditions, including seasonal events tied to the . Enclosed and expanded during renovations from 1988 to 1991, it grew to about 1.45 million square feet of leasable space and maintained roughly 100 tenants as a transit-accessible destination served by lines. In recent years, the mall has grappled with the broader decline of enclosed retail centers, marked by the closure of major anchors such as and the sale of vacated buildings, prompting owner Urban Renaissance Group to pursue a master plan for partial and mixed-use to revitalize the site as a public-oriented district.

History

Planning and Construction (Pre-1960)

The Lloyd Center originated from the vision of Ralph Bramel Lloyd (1875–1953), a oil magnate and real estate developer who first acquired land in Portland in 1905 and expanded holdings to over 50 acres of the former Holladay estate east of the during the 1920s and 1930s using profits from oil ventures. Lloyd conceived the project as early as 1923–1924 as a self-contained neighborhood development encompassing a massive shopping center, residential areas, business parks, and a 24-story hotel tower, with initial plans submitted in the late 1920s for a neo-Gothic hotel that were halted by the . Further proposals in 1940 outlined a high-rise commercial hub with integrated theater, art museum, and sports facilities, but these were deferred due to ; post-war refinements continued until Lloyd's death in 1953, leaving the project unrealized. Development resumed in the mid-1950s under the Lloyd Corporation, Limited—a partnership of three Lloyd family members—and Prudential Insurance Company, which financed the 50-acre site approximately 1.5 miles northeast of downtown Portland's , transforming former residential areas including an apartment complex owned by city commissioner J.E. Bennett. The design, led by architect John Graham Jr., called for an open-air regional spanning 1.2 million leasable square feet across three full floors and an intermediate level, positioning it as one of the largest such developments in the United States at the time. Construction commenced with in April 1958, marking the shift from decades of planning to active site preparation on the cleared tract. By , foundational work and structural framing were underway, incorporating innovative features like an central rink amid the retail layout, though full completion extended into 1960.

Opening and Early Success (1960–1980)

The Lloyd Center opened to the public on August 1, 1960, as Portland's first regional shopping mall and an open-air complex spanning approximately 50 acres with 100 stores. Developed by California oil magnate Ralph B. Lloyd, who had acquired land in the area since 1905 and amassed wealth from oil strikes starting in 1912, the center featured anchor tenants including Meier & Frank, Nordstrom, J.C. Penney, Woolworth's, and J.J. Newberry. Portland Mayor Terry Schrunk officiated the ribbon-cutting in the presence of Governor Mark Hatfield, drawing over 5,000 attendees despite rainy weather. Promoted by its developers as the largest shopping center in the world at 1.2 million square feet, it symbolized postwar suburban retail innovation and shifted commercial activity eastward from downtown Portland. In its initial years, the Lloyd Center rapidly established itself as a premier retail destination in the , attracting families and shoppers from across the region with its mix of department stores, specialty shops, and amenities like fountains and gardens suited to the open-air design. Local accounts describe frequent weekend visits by residents living nearby, underscoring its role as a community hub amid Portland's mid-century population growth and suburban expansion. The mall's success reflected broader trends in American consumerism, where enclosed and semi-open centers drew consumers away from urban cores, though specific sales figures from the remain undocumented in available records; its sustained popularity is evidenced by minimal changes until the . By the 1970s, the center continued to thrive, prompting a modest expansion in 1972 that added six stores and 75,000 square feet of retail space, signaling strong demand and operational viability. Nostalgic recollections highlight its bustling atmosphere, with features like toy stores and record shops contributing to its appeal as a family-oriented venue through the decade. Remaining open-air until later enclosures, the Lloyd Center maintained high foot traffic and retailer interest, positioning it as a benchmark for regional malls before competitive pressures intensified in subsequent eras.

Major Renovations and Enclosure (1980s–2000s)

In the late 1980s, Lloyd Center initiated a comprehensive renovation to convert its open-air design into a fully enclosed , aligning with national trends toward climate-controlled retail environments. The project spanned from 1988 to 1991 and involved roofing over the existing walkways to create an indoor concourse. Key features added during this period included a new to enhance dining options and updates to store configurations, with larger national retailers replacing smaller local ones, which raised rental rates. Initially budgeted at $50 million, the renovations expanded in scope, reflecting broader redevelopments such as perimeter parking expansions seen across U.S. malls in the 1980s and 1990s. Anchor tenant changes accompanied the enclosure, notably Nordstrom's demolition and reconstruction of the former Lipman's department store site into a new flagship location, completed as part of the phased upgrades. By the early 2000s, subsequent minor updates focused on interior maintenance and tenant adjustments rather than large-scale structural overhauls, as the mall adapted to shifting retail dynamics. Store closures, such as J.J. Newberry in 2001, signaled emerging challenges, though the enclosure had initially boosted foot traffic.

Financial Struggles and Foreclosure (2010s–2021)

The Lloyd Center experienced significant financial difficulties throughout the 2010s, primarily driven by the departure of major anchor tenants and broader shifts in retail trends. , a key , closed its location in 2015 amid company-wide store rationalization efforts. followed in 2016, reflecting the retailer's national bankruptcy proceedings and store closures. exited in 2018, further eroding the mall's draw for shoppers. These losses reduced foot traffic and rental income, exacerbating operational challenges in an era of rising competition and changing consumer preferences away from traditional enclosed malls. In response to declining performance, owners Cypress Equities secured a $177 million from KKR Trust in 2015 to fund renovations, including upgrades to the and rink. Despite these investments aimed at modernizing the property and attracting new tenants, the initiatives failed to reverse the mall's downward trajectory, as evidenced by continued tenant vacancies and insufficient revenue growth. , the last remaining major , announced its closure in November 2020 and shuttered in January 2021, leaving no traditional anchors and resulting in over 80 job losses. The intensified these pressures, accelerating business departures and highlighting pre-existing vulnerabilities. Financial distress culminated in debt default, with payments on the KKR loan overdue since October 2020. By November , the mall owed over $110 million to KKR, prompting the lender to initiate proceedings on the 23-acre owned by Cypress Equities. KKR announced plans to repossess the site by the end of and pursue into mixed-use residential and , signaling the end of the mall's traditional . This action reflected systemic issues in the U.S. mall sector, where heavy borrowing for amenities often proved unsustainable amid structural retail declines.

Post-Foreclosure Ownership and Initial Redevelopment (2021–2024)

In late 2021, KKR Finance Trust foreclosed on Lloyd Center after the previous owner, Texas-based EB Arrow LLC, defaulted on a $92.5 million secured in 2017. KKR, a New York-based firm, assumed full of the approximately 1.2 million square-foot property by December 2021, citing the need for redevelopment amid declining retail viability and departures like in 2020. KKR quickly partnered with Urban Renaissance Group (URG), a Seattle-headquartered developer specializing in urban infill projects, which acquired partial ownership and operational control in December 2021 to stabilize tenancy and initiate planning. The partnership emphasized retaining core assets like the ice skating rink while exploring mixed-use conversion, with URG committing to invest in immediate upgrades to combat vacancy rates exceeding 50% post-foreclosure. By September 2023, KKR and URG submitted an initial master plan to the City of Portland, proposing phased demolition of much of the enclosed mall structure to restore the pre-1963 street grid, add up to 5,000 residential units, office space, enhanced retail, and public greenspaces over 25 acres. The plan prioritized pedestrian connectivity and transit integration near stations, aiming to transform the site from a declining regional mall into a dense urban neighborhood while keeping the facility operational during early construction phases. Initial redevelopment actions from 2022 to 2024 included a multi-million-dollar interior refresh, featuring a redesigned southwest entrance, renovated , and upgrades to the indoor —America's first enclosed public skating facility—to boost foot traffic and tenant retention amid broader Portland retail challenges like and . These efforts stabilized occupancy to around 70% by mid-2024, though full-scale demolition and housing construction remained pending city approvals and financing.

Physical Layout and Features

Architectural Design and Site Development

The Lloyd Center site, located in Portland's Lloyd District northeast of , was assembled in the late from previously developed urban land including residential apartments and small commercial buildings, forming a continuous superblock of approximately 17 acres that interrupted the city's orthogonal street grid. This departure from traditional block planning allowed for expansive parking fields encircling the retail core, with over 5,000 spaces provided to accommodate automobile-dependent shoppers, aligning with post-World War II regional center concepts. Construction emphasized durable, low-maintenance materials suited to Oregon's rainy climate, featuring walkways, landscaped planters, and modular store facades in a aesthetic with clean lines and minimal ornamentation. The open-air layout spanned about 1 million square feet across multiple levels connected by pedestrian paths, plazas, and a central , fostering a park-like ambiance with features such as splash fountains and winding staircases to draw foot traffic. Anchor tenants like , J.C. Penney, and anchored the perimeter, with their buildings integrated into the site's edges for visibility from adjacent arterials including Northeast Broadway and Multnomah . Site grading incorporated gentle slopes for drainage and views toward the , while utility infrastructure supported high visitor volumes from opening day on August 1, 1960, when it debuted with over 100 stores as the nation's largest open-air mall.

Ice Skating Rink

The Lloyd Center Rink opened on November 21, 1960, as the world's first located within a , initially operating as an open-air facility at the mall's debut. This innovative feature drew more than one million visitors during its first two years of operation, serving as a key attraction amid the mall's early success in drawing regional shoppers. The rink's design emphasized accessibility and family entertainment, with its central placement fostering integration with surrounding retail spaces. Originally unroofed to align with the mall's open-air layout, the rink was enclosed during the Lloyd Center's major renovation in the mid-1980s, transitioning to a fully indoor venue while preserving its 12,000-square-foot ice surface—smaller than standard NHL dimensions of 200 by 85 feet. This adaptation supported year-round use, accommodating public sessions, practices, and hockey activities for skaters of varying skill levels. By the , it had hosted local competitions, learn-to-skate programs, and community events, solidifying its role as a community hub despite the mall's evolving retail challenges. In recent years, the rink has undergone targeted renovations as part of the mall's broader $50 million redevelopment, including updates to seating, barriers, and infrastructure to enhance safety and appeal without altering its core footprint. These improvements, completed in phases through 2024, addressed wear from decades of heavy use while maintaining operational continuity; no full closures occurred during the 2020s amid the COVID-19 pandemic or subsequent foreclosure proceedings. As of 2025, management by the Sports Facilities Companies has expanded programming to include public skates (typically $12–$15 per session, including rentals), group lessons via the Learn to Skate USA program, private rentals at $425 per hour, broomball leagues, and themed events like "Rock and Skate" with live music on select weekends. The facility supports up to several dozen skaters per session, prioritizing youth development through affiliated clubs like Carousel Figure Skating Club, which hosts freestyle sessions and competitions. Today, the rink remains the mall's primary draw, generating steady foot traffic independent of fluctuations and contributing to local economic activity through rentals and events that attract families from Portland's Northeast quadrant. Its persistence underscores the value of experiential amenities in sustaining legacy retail properties amid e-commerce shifts, with annual attendance figures underscoring its viability even as surrounding vacancy rates exceed 50%.

Retail Spaces and Anchor Tenants

Lloyd Center's retail spaces total approximately 1.4 million square feet across three levels, with the lower levels dedicated primarily to shopping and the upper level featuring a alongside professional office spaces. The configuration supports around 100 tenants historically, though recent occupancy has declined to about 60 independent retailers, service providers, and nonprofits amid the departure of major chains. Traditional anchor tenants, which once included large department stores drawing significant foot traffic, have all vacated by 2025, leaving substantial empty spaces in former anchor pads. closed its location in 2017, followed by in 2021, with departing in September 2025; these closures reflect broader retail shifts away from enclosed malls. remains as a junior anchor, offering books and a cafe on one of the main levels. Current retail occupancy emphasizes smaller, local businesses, including novelty shops like All American Magic, arcades, pretzel stands such as , and community-oriented outlets like Secondhand Pet Supply. Food and beverage options cluster in the court area, supplemented by inline services like hair salons and academies, fostering a transitional, eclectic vendor mix as looms. Leases have shifted to month-to-month terms starting January 2026, signaling uncertainty for existing tenants.

Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner and First Amendment Challenges (1972)

In 1970, members of an anti-Vietnam War group known as The Resistance distributed handbills inside the enclosed walkways of , a privately owned in , inviting recipients to a community meeting to organize against the military draft and the war. The leaflets bore no relation to the mall's commercial operations or any specific tenant. Mall security guards enforced Lloyd Corporation's policy against non-commercial handbilling by ordering the distributors to cease and exit the premises, citing concerns over litter, congestion, and disruption to shoppers. The protesters refused, leading to their removal and subsequent lawsuit alleging a violation of their First Amendment rights to free speech. The U.S. District Court for the District of ruled in favor of the protesters, holding that Lloyd Center's policy prohibiting handbilling violated the First Amendment, as the mall's open invitation to the public transformed its interior spaces into a functional equivalent of a public forum akin to streets or parks. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed this decision, emphasizing the mall's size—spanning 50 acres with extensive public access—and its role as a modern gathering place where speech restrictions required a compelling justification. The U.S. granted and, in a 5-4 decision on June 22, 1972, reversed the lower courts in an opinion authored by Justice . The majority held that the First Amendment does not confer a right to distribute unrelated handbills in a private , as such properties remain privately owned and operated for commercial purposes, not dedicated to general public discourse. The Court distinguished malls from traditional public forums, noting ample alternative channels for expression outside the mall, such as adjacent sidewalks and streets, and rejected the notion that public invitation alone overrides property rights. This ruling upheld the mall's authority to regulate activities unrelated to its business to maintain order and prevent interference with patrons. Justice dissented, joined by Justices Brennan, Douglas, and Stewart, arguing that large regional malls like Lloyd Center serve as contemporary substitutes for downtown business districts or town squares, where First Amendment protections historically apply due to their character and the absence of viable alternatives for reaching diverse audiences. The decision reinforced property owners' control over private commercial spaces, limiting compelled access for political speech and influencing subsequent cases, such as Hudgens v. NLRB (1976), which further curtailed First Amendment claims in malls. For Lloyd Center, the ruling validated its restrictive policies, enabling consistent enforcement against unsolicited distributions and preserving its focus as a retail environment amid growing anti-war activism in Portland during the early 1970s.

Later Litigation on Speech and Access (1980s–1990s)

In December 1985, the Lloyd Corporation filed suit in Multnomah County Circuit Court seeking to enjoin defendants Lucinda Whiffen, Hale Lee Weitzman, and Eric Stachon from soliciting signatures for initiative petitions in the common areas of the , a privately owned 50-acre in , arguing and interference with commercial operations. The trial court granted a broad prohibiting such activities without permission, but the Oregon Court of Appeals reversed, citing free expression rights under Article I, section 8 of the Oregon Constitution. In Lloyd Corporation v. Whiffen (), the affirmed the reversal on alternative grounds, holding that Article IV, section 1 of the Constitution—which reserves the initiative power to the people—entitles circulators to reasonable access for signature gathering in the mall's common areas, provided the activity is peaceful and does not substantially interfere with the owner's commercial use. The court remanded for formulation of time, place, and manner restrictions, rejecting the mall's claim that traditional public forums like adjacent sidewalks sufficed, as indoor solicitation yielded higher signature rates (up to 40 per hour versus 25 outdoors). On remand, the trial court issued rules limiting access to three designated zones (e.g., a 30-by-50-foot area west of a ), requiring 24-hour written , capping petitioners at two per , and banning activity during peak periods like the season and Rose Festival. The Court of Appeals upheld these in 1991. In the 1993 appeal, Lloyd Corporation v. Whiffen, the (in a 4-3 decision) reaffirmed the access right under Article IV, section 1 but reversed in part, invalidating the requirement, petitioner limits, and seasonal bans as insufficiently tailored to prevent interference. It upheld geographic limits to common areas (excluding individual stores) and found no unconstitutional taking of property, as the burden on the owner was minimal compared to the constitutional imperative of facilitating . This state-specific ruling expanded political access beyond federal First Amendment constraints established in Lloyd Corp. v. Tanner (1972), prioritizing initiative processes over absolute private property exclusion.

Economic Impact and Operational Challenges

Role in Portland's Retail Landscape

Lloyd Center opened on August 1, 1960, as an open-air complex with over 100 stores, establishing it as the largest retail center west of the and a pioneering urban mall in Portland's landscape. Covering approximately 1.4 million square feet, it shifted local patterns from department stores and suburban strips toward integrated, destination-based retail environments, drawing regional visitors and catalyzing development in the Lloyd District. Original anchors including , , JCPenney, , Woolworth's, and anchored its early dominance, providing apparel, department store, and variety goods that positioned it as Portland's premier hub for decades. Throughout its peak in the late , Lloyd Center served as a central economic engine, employing thousands in retail and support roles while hosting community events that blended commerce with social activity, such as around its signature rink. Its enclosed redesign in the 1990s aimed to sustain competitiveness against emerging suburban malls like Washington Square, maintaining its role as a key node in Portland's retail network despite growing automobile dependency and . The center's adjacency further embedded it in the city's transit-oriented retail fabric, facilitating access for non-driving shoppers and underscoring its integration into Portland's multimodal . By the 2010s, anchor closures—including in 2020 and in 2023—reflected broader national retail contractions, yet Lloyd Center adapted by leasing to independent vendors, evolving into a niche incubator for local artisans, pop-ups, and experiential retail amid e-commerce's erosion of traditional malls. This pivot has preserved its community-oriented function, hosting events and fostering indie economies that differentiate it from big-box competitors, though sales declines highlight its diminished share in Portland's $10 billion-plus annual retail sector dominated by online and outlet alternatives. In Portland's fragmented retail —spanning boutiques, suburban power centers, and experiential districts like Pearl—Lloyd Center endures as a transitional , bridging mall culture with adaptive, hyper-local commerce.

Decline Amid Broader Market Shifts and Local Conditions

The rise of fundamentally disrupted traditional enclosed malls like Lloyd Center, as online retailers captured increasing from physical stores reliant on high foot traffic and impulse purchases. U.S. sales grew from 5.1% of total retail in 2010 to 14.2% by 2019, accelerating further during the , which reduced mall visits by up to 50% in many markets. This shift diminished the viability of Lloyd Center's model, which lacked the experiential or open-air elements increasingly favored by consumers over sterile indoor environments. Compounding national trends, the sequential departure of anchor tenants eroded Lloyd Center's draw, initiating a retail death spiral where reduced traffic deterred surviving stores. , a longtime anchor, closed in 2015 amid company-wide retrenchment from underperforming locations, followed by in 2018 after its filing the prior year. By 2020, had also exited, leaving no major department stores to anchor leasing and visitation. These closures reflected broader retail bankruptcies and consolidations, but Lloyd Center's high debt load—stemming from prior renovations to add amenities like dining—exacerbated vulnerabilities when revenues plummeted. Locally, Portland's retail landscape amplified these pressures through stagnant urban mall performance and a pivot toward power centers and lifestyle formats. Indoor malls in the region, including Lloyd Center, saw average rents lag at $23.17 per square foot versus higher rates in open-air venues, while losing clientele to and suburban alternatives. Pre-pandemic struggles were evident, with foot already declining due to the mall's aging enclosed design and competition from newer developments, rendering it functionally obsolete by the late . The intensified this, but empirical data indicate the core issues predated 2020, aligning with a national pattern where over 1,000 U.S. malls faced similar existential threats from structural retail evolution.

Public Safety and Crime Data

The Lloyd District, encompassing the Lloyd Center mall, exhibits crime rates substantially exceeding national averages. Overall crime in the area is 176% higher than the U.S. average, with s 88% above national levels, yielding a 1 in 16 chance of becoming a victim of or . Robbery rates stand at 1,110.6 per 100,000 residents compared to the national 135.5, at 662.1 versus 282.7, and at 21.4 against 6.1. crimes, including thefts prevalent in retail settings, contribute to this elevated risk, with the district's total crime rate reported as 247% higher than national figures in analyses of common offenses like and . Retail theft has persistently impacted the Lloyd Center, mirroring broader Portland trends exacerbated by organized rings and reduced prosecutions post-2020. A 2012 flash robbery targeted the mall's Nordstrom store, involving coordinated theft by groups. In 2018, police investigated social media threats of mass thefts ("flash mobs") at the mall, prompting heightened security. Shoplifting and organized retail crime surged citywide, with Portland Police Bureau operations in 2025 recovering stolen goods from theft rings operating near malls, though specific Lloyd Center recoveries were not isolated in reports. A robbery occurred inside the mall on March 27, 2025, amid ongoing concerns from visitors and residents about unchecked theft driving store closures. Violent incidents, particularly shootings, have marked the area, with multiple events at or adjacent to the mall. On December 21, 2023, a in the Lloyd Center parking garage injured one person, with suspects fleeing before police arrival. A man was killed in a July 28, 2024, in the Lloyd District, identified as Jacob Forrest, 45. Other notable cases include a , 2025, of Hassani Abdi Musa, 25, by ; a September 10, 2025, fatal ; a 2015 parking structure leading to four indictments; a 2016 incident where a gunshot victim was transported from the mall area to a ; a 2017 teen fatality in nearby Holladay Park; and a 2010 mall interior with no injuries but an arrest for . The district recorded 12 s in 2024, per population-adjusted rates.
Notable Violent Incidents at or Near Lloyd CenterDateDetailsSource
Parking garage shooting, one injuredDec. 21, 2023Victim wounded; suspects fled
of Jacob Forrest, gunshotJul. 28, 2024Lloyd District shooting
of Hassani Abdi Musa, shootingSep. 9, 2025Lloyd District
Portland-wide violent crime declined in 2025, with homicides down 51% in the first half-year versus 2024, but Lloyd District metrics remain elevated relative to city trends, as tracked in Portland Police Bureau's interactive neighborhood offense dashboards. Residents have reported heightened insecurity, including two homicides near apartment buildings in September 2024 and animal abuse incidents. Official data from the Portland Police Bureau's open portals allow neighborhood-specific filtering for Lloyd District, revealing persistent property and violent offenses above city medians.

Recent Developments and Future Outlook

Phased Redevelopment Plans (2024–2025)

In 2024, Urban Renaissance Group, the mall's owners, submitted a conceptual master plan to the City of Portland for review under a Design Advice Request process, outlining a transformation of the 29.3-acre site into a mixed-use development featuring housing, retail, offices, and public spaces while preserving the ice rink and maintaining mall operations throughout. This followed architectural work by ZGF Architects, which proposed reconnecting the site's superblock to the urban grid, eliminating peripheral parking barriers, and integrating open plazas and promenades, with design completion targeted for that year. Concurrently, in April, city land use review intakes addressed initial site enhancements, including electric vehicle charging stations, reconfigured parking, new vehicle ramps, and landscaping upgrades to support ongoing retail viability. A May report detailed proposals for a new performing arts facility in collaboration with ZGF and consultants, emphasizing phased integration to avoid disrupting tenants. By September 2024, the Portland Design Commission signaled approval for an "iconic" concert venue as part of early-phase activations, advancing toward formal permitting. These efforts aligned with broader site preparation, including the October sale of a shuttered anchor store for $9 million, which owners earmarked for and funding. The phased approach prioritizes incremental additions over wholesale closure, with the mall reporting 90% tenant renewals and 32 new leases since late 2021 to sustain economic activity amid planning. In 2025, momentum accelerated with groundbreaking on a two-story on October 22, developed by Monqui Presents and AEG Presents following a permit issuance; the facility includes a , food services, artist amenities, and offices to draw regional entertainment traffic without halting core mall functions. This builds on completed phase one renovations from prior years, such as entrance and updates, positioning 2025 initiatives—like the forthcoming 16-screen cinema with luxury seating and bar, plus expanded local dining—as bridges to long-term of the 1960s-era enclosed structure. Overall, these 2024–2025 steps focus on feasibility testing and revenue-generating anchors to finance the multi-decade shift toward an open-air, neighborhood-integrated district, though full implementation depends on subsequent city approvals and market conditions.

New Additions like Music Venue and Site Acquisitions

In October 2025, Monqui Presents and AEG Presents broke ground on a new mid-sized music venue at Lloyd Center, utilizing the former Nordstrom space. The two-level facility spans approximately 66,000 square feet, with flexible seating for 2,000 to 4,250 attendees and a movable stage to accommodate varied event formats. Developers project an opening in early 2027, positioning the venue to address Portland's shortage of mid-capacity performance spaces between small clubs and large arenas. The $70 million project incorporates the existing Nordstrom basement for support functions, aiming to draw national acts while integrating with the mall's ongoing revitalization. Concurrently, Lloyd Center's owners, including KKR Real Estate Finance Trust and Urban Renaissance Group, acquired the former store site for $9 million in October 2025 as part of phased redevelopment. The purchase consolidates control over the 65-year-old mall's footprint, enabling potential and mixed-use reconfiguration amid broader plans to modernize the property. This acquisition follows the mall's 2022 ownership transition and aligns with efforts to attract new tenants, having secured 32 leases since then. These moves signal incremental investments in non-retail amenities and land assembly, though full-scale transformation remains contingent on economic viability and urban planning approvals.

Prospects for Revitalization Versus Persistent Risks

The Lloyd Center's revitalization hinges on Urban Renaissance Group's (URG) phased redevelopment strategy, which envisions transforming the 29-acre site into a mixed-use neighborhood featuring residential units, office spaces, and public amenities over the next decade, with an estimated multibillion-dollar investment. Key milestones include the September 2025 demolition of the former anchor to make way for a 4,000-seat developed by Monqui Presents and AEG, slated to open in early 2027, alongside approvals for an "iconic" concert facility advanced by the Portland Design Commission in October 2024. The sale of the shuttered building for $9 million in October 2025 signals ongoing site acquisitions to support density increases, grid reconnection, and open-air public spaces designed by ZGF Architects to counter the mall's historical inward focus and parking superblock. These initiatives aim to leverage the site's connectivity and proximity to downtown Portland for economic resurgence, with URG committing to keep core retail operations viable during phased construction to retain community anchoring. Proponents, including URG's Tom Kilbane, highlight potential for high-density integration that could draw foot traffic and investment, mirroring successful urban mall repurposings elsewhere by blending experiential retail with entertainment. Persistent risks, however, temper optimism, particularly surrounding public safety in the Lloyd District, where residents reported two homicides outside a nearby apartment complex and an elevator animal abuse incident in September 2024, amid broader concerns over vagrancy and gang activity that have historically eroded mall patronage. Although Portland-wide violent crime declined 17% in the first half of 2025 compared to 2024, with homicides dropping 51%, localized vulnerabilities persist due to entrenched urban decay factors like homelessness and retail vacancy rates exceeding 50% at Lloyd Center pre-redevelopment. Economic headwinds further complicate execution, as national shifts and competition from newer Portland retail hubs challenge transitional leasing, with URG issuing short-term contracts signaling potential full-site closure risks if tenant retention falters. Regulatory delays, financing dependencies, and adjacent developments like Holy Rosary Church's housing project could strain , underscoring causal links between unresolved and socioeconomic stressors and the mall's prior stagnation. Success will require sustained municipal support and measurable safety improvements to avoid perpetuating the "ghost mall" trajectory observed in underperforming peers.

References

  1. https://www.lloydcenter.com/information/
  2. https://www.opb.org/article/2021/11/12/portland-oregon-lloyd-center-mall-redevelopment-memories/
  3. https://portland.daveknows.org/2011/08/01/august-1-1960-grand-opening-of-lloyd-center-mall/
  4. https://www.southeastexaminer.com/2021/12/lloyd-centers-evolution/
  5. https://www.oregonlive.com/retail/2025/10/shuttered-lloyd-center-anchor-sells-for-9-million.html
  6. https://katu.com/news/local/demolition-of-former-nordstrom-building-marks-new-era-for-lloyd-center-mall-demolition-of-former-nordstrom-at-lloyd-center-marks-progress-in-renewal-plan
  7. https://www.zgf.com/work/6670-urban-renaissance-group-lloyd-center-redevelopment
  8. https://www.oregonlive.com/entertainment/2015/11/vintage_oregon_who_is_the_lloy.html
  9. https://mall-hall-of-fame.blogspot.com/2009/10/lloyd-center-northeast-multnomah-street.html
  10. https://www.oregonlive.com/opinion/2021/11/opinion-lloyd-center-was-a-mall-for-a-different-moment.html
  11. https://vintageportland.wordpress.com/2013/09/24/lloyd-center-construction-1959/
  12. https://www.oregonlive.com/retail/2025/08/lloyd-center-turns-65-as-vendors-celebrate-and-prepare-for-whats-next.html
  13. https://www.wweek.com/news/dr-know/2021/12/11/what-was-on-the-lloyd-center-land-before-a-mall/
  14. https://www.pdxmonthly.com/news-and-city-life/2021/06/can-we-save-the-lloyd-center
  15. https://www.oregonlive.com/window-shop/2016/06/lloyd_center_vintage_photos.html
  16. https://portlandtribune.com/2021/11/22/lloyd-center-mall-memories-from-once-booming-shopping-site/
  17. https://www.facebook.com/groups/296569815544787/posts/1076993994169028/
  18. https://www.oregonlive.com/entertainment/2015/11/vintage_oregon_readers_remembe.html
  19. https://www.facebook.com/thebcpreacher/videos/lloyd-center-portlands-forgotten-historic-mall-the-mall-opened-august-1-1960-in-/1142618373415913/
  20. https://www.reddit.com/r/Portland/comments/1dux77/toyland_at_lloyd_center_1960s/
  21. https://www.reddit.com/r/Portland/comments/mt0p2w/went_to_lloyd_center_today_its_almost_dead_as_a/
  22. https://www.oregonlive.com/business/2021/01/lloyd-center-on-the-brink-as-businesses-depart-en-masse-this-mall-is-going-down.html
  23. https://www.wweek.com/news/2021/11/01/lender-to-lloyd-centers-owners-says-it-will-foreclose-on-the-struggling-mall/
  24. https://www.opb.org/article/2021/11/01/lloyd-center-portland-redevelopment/
  25. https://www.oregonlive.com/business/2021/11/lender-says-it-will-foreclose-on-redevelop-lloyd-center-mall.html
  26. https://www.bizjournals.com/portland/news/2021/12/01/lloyd-center-retail-malls-debt-loans-redevelopment.html
  27. https://www.kgw.com/article/news/local/lloyd-center-mall-foreclosure/283-486aef01-48e3-46cd-828e-2a9e2076536a
  28. https://www.oregonlive.com/business/2021/12/seattle-developer-urban-renaissance-group-plans-lloyd-center-revamp.html
  29. https://www.bizjournals.com/portland/news/2021/12/20/lloyd-center-new-owner-foreclosure-ice-skating.html
  30. https://www.koin.com/local/multnomah-county/new-owners-plan-to-redevelop-lloyd-center-mall/
  31. https://www.wweek.com/news/business/2023/09/21/owners-of-lloyd-center-unveil-master-plan-for-mall-that-restores-street-grid-and-adds-housing/
  32. https://www.opb.org/article/2023/09/21/portland-lloyd-center-mall-city-grid-overhaul/
  33. https://hookyclub.org/lloyd-centers-future/
  34. https://www.lloydcenter.com/renovation/
  35. https://www.oregonlive.com/business/2023/09/lloyd-center-owners-reveal-plan-to-redevelop-portland-mall-build-housing.html
  36. https://buildingonhistory.blogspot.com/2021/11/visiting-lloyd-center-ghost-town.html
  37. https://vintageportland.wordpress.com/2010/10/14/lloyd-center-1962/
  38. https://vintageportland.wordpress.com/2025/10/17/lloyd-center-mall-1962/
  39. https://www.oregonlive.com/portland/2014/09/lloyd_center_ice_rink_see_hist.html
  40. https://www.lloydcenter.com/ice-rink/
  41. https://www.usfigureskating.org/news/article/carousel-fsc-lloyd-center-ice-rink-growing-future-skating
  42. https://www.lloydice.com/
  43. https://www.dci-engineers.com/work/lloyd-center-remodel
  44. https://www.facebook.com/SportsFacilitiesCompanies/posts/were-proud-to-share-that-the-sports-facilities-companies-sfc-is-now-managing-one/1242516341226909/
  45. https://www.lloydice.com/public-skate
  46. https://portlandtribune.com/2022/06/25/skip-the-sunblock-come-cool-down-at-lloyd-center-ice-rink/
  47. https://www.courthousenews.com/portlands-lloyd-center-mall-isnt-dead-just-different/
  48. https://chainstoreage.com/awaiting-redevelopment-oregon-mall-fills-spaces-indie-retailers
  49. https://www.lloydcenter.com/interactive-map/
  50. https://www.oregonlive.com/retail/2025/07/5-ways-a-65-year-old-mall-has-become-portlands-coolest-hangout-spot-for-now.html
  51. https://www.koin.com/local/multnomah-county/lloyd-center-mall-memories-from-once-booming-shopping-site/
  52. https://www.reddit.com/r/Portland/comments/1nn67lf/the_lloyd_center_nordstroms_is_now_gone_being/
  53. https://www.lloydcenter.com/directory/
  54. https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/lloyd-corporation-ltd-v-tanner/
  55. https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/407/551/
  56. https://www.oyez.org/cases/1971/71-492
  57. https://www.law.cornell.edu/supremecourt/text/407/551
  58. https://www.quimbee.com/cases/lloyd-corp-v-tanner
  59. https://constitutionallawreporter.com/2019/08/13/lloyd-corp-v-tanner-1972/
  60. https://www.thefire.org/supreme-court/lloyd-corp-ltd-v-tanner-et-al
  61. https://law.justia.com/cases/oregon/supreme-court/1989/307-or-674.html
  62. https://law.justia.com/cases/oregon/supreme-court/1993/315-or-500.html
  63. https://www.facebook.com/groups/ForgottenOregon/posts/3732549730346271/
  64. https://missoulacurrent.com/portland-lloyd-center/
  65. https://www.opb.org/article/2023/06/11/indie-businesses-thrive-portland-oregon-lloyd-center-mall-future/
  66. https://www.pdxmonthly.com/news-and-city-life/2022/11/lloyd-center-mall-portland-future-indie-stores
  67. https://oregonbusiness.com/19302-mall-rats/
  68. https://www.axios.com/local/portland/2023/10/13/lloyd-center-closing-shut-down-new-building
  69. https://prosperportland.us/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/Lloyd-Holladay-TIF-Report.pdf
  70. https://www.oregonlive.com/retail/2025/07/how-portlands-ghost-mall-became-the-citys-coolest-startup-incubator.html
  71. https://pdxscholar.library.pdx.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?filename=4&article=1062&context=realestate_pub&type=additional
  72. https://www.wweek.com/news/2021/11/17/six-ways-to-redefine-portland-using-one-dead-mall/
  73. https://www.areavibes.com/portland-or/lloyd/crime/
  74. https://www.niche.com/places-to-live/n/lloyd-district-portland-or/
  75. https://www.nestapple.com/most-dangerous-neighborhoods-in-portland/
  76. https://www.securityinfowatch.com/video-surveillance/video/10743572/video-flash-rob-flash-mob-at-malls-nordstrom-store
  77. https://katu.com/news/local/portland-police-bureau-investigates-rumors-of-flash-robbery-planned-at-lloyd-center
  78. https://www.portland.gov/police/news/2025/6/2/retail-theft-mission-results-arrests-recovery-stolen-merchandise
  79. https://www.kptv.com/2023/12/21/one-shot-lloyd-center/
  80. https://www.kgw.com/article/news/crime/man-dead-shooting-lloyd-district-portland/283-1296b1e3-886a-45fd-ba81-97668baf96c8
  81. https://projects.oregonlive.com/data-points/homicides/2025/
  82. https://www.kgw.com/article/news/crime/1-injured-shooting-lloyd-center/283-9f72f837-fabf-49da-8956-53e964b56067
  83. https://www.portland.gov/police/news/2025/9/10/update-man-killed-shooting-lloyd-district-neighborhood-identified
  84. https://www.portland.gov/mayor/keith-wilson/news/2025/8/8/portland-sees-decline-violent-crime-homicides-down-51-first-half
  85. https://www.oregonlive.com/crime/2025/08/portland-homicides-drop-51-in-2025-steepest-decline-among-major-us-cities-report-finds.html
  86. https://www.portland.gov/police/open-data/reported-crime-data
  87. https://www.kptv.com/2024/09/13/lloyd-district-apartment-residents-raise-concerns-over-safety-security/
  88. https://www.urbanrengroup.com/new-vision-for-lloyd-center-revitalization-submitted-to-city-of-portland/
  89. https://djcoregon.com/news/2024/04/01/lloyd-center-redevelopment-in-portland-land-use-review-intakes-april-1-2024/
  90. https://www.portland.gov/council/documents/report/accepted/456-2024
  91. https://djcoregon.com/news/2024/09/20/proposed-lloyd-center-project-near-approval/
  92. https://www.wweek.com/news/2025/10/22/developers-break-ground-on-new-lloyd-center-music-venue/
  93. https://www.kgw.com/article/news/local/portland-music-venue-lloyd-center-under-construction/283-9c2f70f7-db95-47ab-80c2-ea0e71ce3f29
  94. https://djcoregon.com/?p=513013
  95. https://www.portlandmercury.com/music/2025/09/26/48043627/monqui-ing-around-lloyd-center
  96. https://oregonbusiness.com/lloyd-center-music-venue-to-begin-construction-next-month/
  97. https://www.koin.com/news/portland/monqui-presents-venue-breaks-ground-at-lloyd-centers-former-nordstrom-location/
  98. https://www.bizjournals.com/portland/news/2025/10/22/lloyd-center-owners-buy-former-sears-site-for-9m.html
  99. https://portlandartmuseum.org/event/portlands-next-horizon/
  100. https://www.koin.com/news/portland/portland-sees-decline-in-violent-crime-homicides-2025-national-report-says/
  101. https://finance-commerce.com/2025/09/portland-lloyd-district-church-redevelopment/
  102. https://www.facebook.com/seattletimes/posts/portlands-lloyd-center-will-be-redeveloped-but-the-old-ghost-mall-has-lured-doze/1158713906291999/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.