Phoenix breakwaters

Phoenix breakwatersMain

Community hub

Phoenix breakwaters

8 pages, 0 posts

0 subscribers

Recent from talks

Be the first to start a discussion here.

Recent from talks

Be the first to start a discussion here.

Contribute something

About hubMembersContent overviewUpdatesRules

Main reference articles

Phoenix breakwaters

View on Wikipedia

from Wikipedia

The Phoenix breakwaters were a set of reinforced concrete caissons built as part of the artificial Mulberry harbours that were assembled as part of the preparations for the Normandy landings during World War II. A total of 213 were built, with 212 floated or side-launched. They were constructed by civil engineering contractors around the coast of Britain. They were collected at Dungeness and Selsey, and then towed by tugboats across the English Channel and sunk to form the Mulberry harbour breakwaters replacing the initial "Gooseberry" block ships.^[1] Caissons were added in the autumn of 1944 to reinforce the existing structure to cope with the harbour continuing in use longer than planned.^[1]

Key Information

Phoenix breakwaters
A line of Phoenix caissons forming a breakwater at Arromanches in Normandy
Interactive map of the Phoenix breakwaters area
General information
Location	English Channel
Coordinates	50°34′16″N 2°26′34″W / 50.57111°N 2.44278°W / 50.57111; -2.44278
Technical details
Material	Reinforced concrete

Several Phoenix breakwaters still exist in Britain: two are part of the harbour off Castletown at Portland Harbour in Dorset, and two can be dived in less than 10 metres of water off Pagham in West Sussex. There is also a smaller Phoenix Caisson (type C) in Langstone Harbour in Hampshire.^[1]

A wrecked Phoenix breakwater is also to be seen, broken in two, in the Thames estuary off Shoeburyness in Essex. It broke while being towed from Harwich in June 1944. To avoid it causing a hazard to shipping in the Thames estuary, it was beached on the mud on the northern edge of the Thames dredged shipping channel. It is about a mile from the beach. It is not quite covered at high tide, but it is topped by a beacon to warn shipping of its presence.

Several Phoenix breakwaters were used in the Netherlands to plug gaps in the dykes, four of them for a dyke at Ouwerkerk after the North Sea Flood of 1 February 1953. These four have now been converted into a museum for the floods called the Watersnoodmuseum. One can walk through the four caissons.

Two of the B1 type Phoenix breakwaters (73 and 74) were sold to Sweden in 1949, and towed in July. Raised from Arromanches, they were initially towed to Frihamnen port in Stockholm and moved on 20 September 1956 to the newly-built heat and power plant in Hässelby where they remain as of 2021.^[2]

Four surplus caissons were used in a breakwater at Akranes, Iceland. Three were towed and delivered by mid August 1946, with the fourth following shortly.

References

[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Phoenix breakwaters.

^ ^a ^b ^c Hughes, Michael; Momber, Gary (2000). "The Mulberry Harbour Remains". In Allen, Michael J; Gardiner, Julie (eds.). Our Changing Coast: A Survey of the Intertidal Archaeology of Langstone Harbour, Hampshire. York: Council for British Archaeology. pp. 127–128. ISBN 1-902771-14-1.
^ Henrikson, Henrik (July 2019). "Betongkassunerna från andra världskriget" [The concrete caissons from World War II]. Hesselby.com (in Swedish). Retrieved 6 October 2021.

External links

[edit]

50°34′16″N 2°26′34″W / 50.57111°N 2.44278°W / 50.57111; -2.44278

Revisions and contributors Edit on Wikipedia Read on Wikipedia

View on Grokipedia

from Grokipedia

The Phoenix breakwaters, also known as Phoenix caissons, were massive reinforced concrete structures designed and constructed in the United Kingdom as the core breakwater elements of the Mulberry artificial harbours, which were temporary floating ports essential for supplying Allied forces during the Normandy invasion on June 6, 1944.^[1] These box-like, hollow caissons featured floodable internal compartments that allowed them to be towed across the English Channel and deliberately sunk in position to create protective barriers against waves and storms, enabling the safe unloading of troops, vehicles, and supplies on open beaches where no major ports were immediately available. Varying in size across types (A through C), the largest Phoenix units measured approximately 60 meters in length, 17 meters in width, and 18 meters in height, displacing over 6,000 tons each, and were built using monolithic concrete reinforced with steel frameworks.^[2] A total of 213 Phoenix caissons were prefabricated at multiple sites along England's south coast, including Southampton, Portsmouth, and Lepe, by teams of thousands of laborers working in secrecy from 1943 to 1944, with construction involving the pouring of about 600,000 tons of concrete across the Mulberry project—and innovative techniques like sideways launching into the water for flotation before final assembly.^[2]^[3] Deployed as part of two Mulberry harbours—Mulberry A off Omaha Beach (American sector) and Mulberry B off Gold Beach (British sector)—the caissons were positioned end-to-end to form inner breakwaters, complemented by outer floating barriers called Bombardons and sunken blockships known as Gooseberries.^[3] By D+10 (June 16, 1944), these harbours were operational, unloading 24,412 tons of supplies over two days despite challenging conditions, though a severe storm on June 19 devastated Mulberry A, damaging around 23 of approximately 55 Phoenix units and forcing reliance on the surviving Mulberry B.^[1]^[4] The engineering feat of the Phoenix breakwaters was pivotal to Operation Overlord, facilitating the landing of over 2.5 million Allied personnel, 500,000 vehicles, and 4 million tons of supplies by August 1944, which accelerated the liberation of Western Europe from Nazi occupation.^[1] Post-war, many caissons were repurposed or scrapped, but several survive as historical relics, such as the two Grade II-listed examples at Portland Harbour in Dorset, England—each approximately 60 meters long, 18 meters wide, and weighing 7,000 tons—now serving as dive sites, marine habitats, and reminders of wartime innovation.^[5] Their design influenced later coastal engineering, demonstrating the feasibility of prefabricated, mobile harbor systems for amphibious operations.^[3]

Background and Development

Need for Artificial Harbours

The Allied forces faced immense logistical challenges in planning Operation Overlord, the Normandy invasion of June 1944, which required sustaining a massive buildup of troops and equipment on open beaches without immediate access to functional ports. To support the initial phases of the campaign, planners estimated a daily requirement of approximately 12,000 tons of cargo, including ammunition, fuel, food, and vehicles, to equip and maintain over 2 million personnel in the first 90 days following D-Day.^[6] This scale demanded innovative solutions to offload supplies directly onto shorelines, as traditional port infrastructure was unavailable or unreliable in the invasion zone.^[7] Existing Channel ports in occupied France posed severe limitations due to heavy German fortifications and the high likelihood of deliberate destruction to deny their use to invaders, as evidenced by the scuttling and mining of facilities like Cherbourg after its capture. Intelligence assessments confirmed that German forces would prioritize sabotaging key harbors upon detecting an assault, rendering them unusable for weeks or months and exacerbating the Allies' vulnerability during the critical early buildup. The Mulberry harbour concept emerged as a direct response, enabling rapid offloading through specialized craft such as Rhino ferries for floating roadways, DUKWs for amphibious transport, and LSTs for direct beach discharge, thereby creating temporary sheltered anchorages independent of captured ports.^[7] In a pivotal 1942 memorandum titled "Piers for use on beaches," British Prime Minister Winston Churchill urged the development of artificial harbors to address these shortcomings, emphasizing the need for floating structures that could rise and fall with tides while providing stable anchorages protected by breakwaters to facilitate sustained invasion support.^[6] This directive, issued on May 30 to Combined Operations chief Lord Louis Mountbatten, highlighted the strategic imperative of calm, protected waters for unloading, drawing on earlier ideas for concrete caissons and barges to shield against Channel swells and enemy interference.^[8] The Mulberry system, incorporating Phoenix breakwater units as part of its broader prefabricated design, thus became essential to overcoming the port dilemma and ensuring the operation's viability.^[6]

Initial Concepts and Planning

The initial concepts for the Phoenix breakwaters emerged in 1942 as part of broader efforts within Combined Operations to address the logistical challenges exposed by the failed Dieppe Raid, where inadequate port facilities highlighted the need for artificial harbors to support amphibious invasions.^[8] Under the leadership of Lord Louis Mountbatten, Chief of Combined Operations, and with strategic input from General Alan Brooke, Chief of the Imperial General Staff, planning began through Allied inter-service committees focused on preliminary materials and requirements for temporary ports.^[8] These efforts were spurred by Winston Churchill's May 30, 1942, memorandum urging the development of "piers for use on beaches" to enable rapid unloading without reliance on captured enemy ports.^[6] Early ideation evolved through testing various prototypes, including the "Hippo" concrete caisson pierheads designed by engineer Hugh Iorys Hughes and the "Whale" floating steel roadways invented by Alan Beckett, which informed the integrated Mulberry harbour system.^[9]^[10] By early 1943, these concepts coalesced into a comprehensive plan for prefabricated concrete breakwaters code-named "Phoenix," approved by the British Chiefs of Staff in May 1943 as a critical component of Operation Overlord, before final endorsement at the Quebec Conference in August.^[11]^[12] Mountbatten played a pivotal role in advocating for the project, arranging demonstrations and securing resources amid debates over feasibility.^[13] The planning phase emphasized utmost secrecy to prevent Axis intelligence from uncovering the scale and purpose, with disinformation campaigns and restricted access to prototypes ensuring compartmentalization.^[8] The project's immense scope demanded extraordinary resources, including 330,000 cubic yards of concrete and 31,000 tons of steel specifically for the Phoenix caissons across both Mulberry harbors.^[14] This material mobilization underscored the strategic imperative for self-contained harbors in WWII logistics, enabling the sustainment of over a million troops without immediate capture of deep-water ports.^[8]

Design

Types and Specifications

The Phoenix caissons were classified into six principal types—A1, A2, B1, B2, C1, C2, and C3—tailored to different water depths and beach profiles for their role in creating the inner breakwaters of the Mulberry artificial harbours.^[15] These types varied significantly in scale to match operational requirements, with the largest A1 units measuring approximately 200 feet in length, 50 to 60 feet in width, and 60 feet in height, achieving a displacement of around 6,000 tons.^[16]^[10] In comparison, the smallest units, such as C3 in the C series, displaced as little as 1,672 tons and were suited to shallower gradients.^[15] Drafts ranged from 12 to 20 feet during towing, enabling controlled submersion to depths of up to 62 feet upon arrival, facilitated by internal watertight compartments that allowed ballast flooding for buoyancy adjustment and scuttling.^[17]^[15] Each caisson consisted of reinforced concrete walls supported by steel frameworks, divided into multiple compartments including ballast chambers for stability.^[15] Across the 212 units produced, the project consumed 330,000 cubic yards of concrete and 31,000 tons of steel.^[18]^[19]

Engineering Features

The Phoenix breakwaters featured a hollow box-girder construction made of steel-reinforced concrete, providing structural integrity while allowing buoyancy during transit across the English Channel.^[17] This design incorporated multiple watertight compartments—typically divided by internal concrete bulkheads into numerous cells, such as 22 in representative units—enabling controlled buoyancy through ballast systems.^[17] These systems utilized pumps and wire-guided sluice valves to flood or empty compartments, facilitating the caissons' flotation for towing and precise sinking in position by regulated water ingress, often achievable in about 15 minutes.^[20] For defensive capabilities during transit and deployment, the flat upper decks of the Phoenix units included mountings for anti-aircraft guns, such as 40 mm Bofors, to provide protection against aerial threats while the caissons were towed into place.^[21] The overall configuration supported efficient assembly, with provisions like internal access ways and reinforced pads on the deck suitable for cranes and shear legs used in positioning and minor adjustments during lineup. These elements allowed the caissons to be interlocked end-to-end via bolted connections and alignment aids, forming seamless, continuous breakwater lines that enhanced stability and operational cohesion. Durability was prioritized through the robust hollow box-girder form, engineered to resist the rough conditions of the English Channel, including waves up to 10 feet high, by mimicking ship-like stability against wave action.^[22] To maintain functionality and avoid sediment accumulation, the design included limber-like openings in the central buttress and lower sections, permitting tidal flow through the structure and thereby preventing silting within the enclosed harbor areas.^[17] These features were consistent across the variations in Phoenix caisson types, adapting the core principles to different sizes and roles in the Mulberry harbors.^[19]

Construction

Sites and Contractors

The construction of the Phoenix breakwaters involved a collaborative effort by 19 British civil engineering firms, which were contracted starting in 1943 to fabricate the reinforced concrete caissons essential to the Mulberry harbours.^[23] This effort employed approximately 15,000 workmen across the project. Prominent among these contractors were companies such as Bovis & Co., responsible for building six A1-type units at dry docks in Portsmouth, and Edmund Nuttall Sons & Co., which contributed to several variants. Other key participants included Sir Robert McAlpine & Sons, Taylor Woodrow, and John Cochrane & Sons, each handling specific orders for different caisson sizes and types. These firms operated at over 30 coastal locations across Britain, leveraging existing dry docks and tidal basins to facilitate the large-scale pouring and assembly of the structures. Notable sites included Southampton's docks, where secrecy measures concealed the work amid wartime activity; Harwich's facilities on the east coast; Gravesend in the Thames estuary; and Teesside's industrial basins in the northeast.^[24]^[25] The distributed approach allowed for parallel production but required coordination to standardize designs amid varying local conditions. To preserve operational security for the Allied invasion, the sites adhered to stringent secrecy protocols, often disguising the projects as unrelated industrial endeavors or decoy operations to evade Axis intelligence.^[23] Despite severe material shortages and the challenges of wartime rationing, the contractors completed a total of 213 units in under 12 months, demonstrating remarkable efficiency in reinforced concrete fabrication.^[26] Following fabrication, the caissons were towed to designated collection points at Dungeness on the Kent coast and Selsey Bill in West Sussex, where they were mustered and prepared for the subsequent Channel crossing as part of the broader Mulberry deployment. This staging process ensured the units could be organized into convoys without revealing the full scale of the artificial harbour initiative until after D-Day.^[27]

Building Process

The construction of the Phoenix caissons began with the assembly of steel formwork to create the hollow, cellular structure of each unit, designed to allow for buoyancy during transport and controlled sinking upon deployment. This formwork was erected on sites along the coasts of England, including the south, east, and northeast, where civil engineering contractors built the caissons in dry docks, graving docks, or specially excavated tidal basins. The concrete was poured to form the lower part of the structure in the dry dock. After the concrete hardened, internal bulkheads, reinforcements, and compartments were fitted to divide the caisson into watertight cells, enabling ballast control for floating and submergence; the remainder of the structure was completed from inside after launching.^[28] Once the concrete structure was complete, the caissons underwent internal outfitting and sealing before launching. Smaller types, such as B1 and B2, were side-launched into adjacent tidal basins using winches and ramps to slide them into the water at high tide, while larger units like A1 were floated off directly from dry docks as water was pumped in to raise the level. By June 1944, 212 of the 213 ordered caissons had been successfully floated, with the remaining unit (A1-01) suffering structural failure during construction and being scrapped. The overall effort consumed approximately 1.5 million cubic yards of aggregate in addition to 330,000 cubic yards of concrete and 31,000 tons of steel across all units.^[29] Quality controls were rigorous to ensure each caisson could withstand the stresses of ocean transit. The process was carried out under strict secrecy, with construction sites camouflaged and workers sworn to silence, contributing to the rapid production timeline from late 1943 to spring 1944.

Deployment

Transportation and Installation

The transportation of the Phoenix caissons commenced in early June 1944, immediately following the D-Day landings on June 6, to support the rapid establishment of artificial harbors off the Normandy coast. A total of 146 caissons were allocated for the two Mulberry harbors, with Mulberry A positioned off Omaha Beach for American forces and Mulberry B off Arromanches (Gold Beach) for British forces; additional caissons supplemented the Gooseberry blockship harbors at other beaches such as Utah, Juno, and Sword. Of the 146 caissons allocated to the Mulberry harbors, several (around 10-15) were lost during transit across the Channel due to weather and structural issues.^[30] These massive concrete structures, weighing up to 6,000 tons each, were floated from construction sites in southern England and mustered at embarkation points like the Solent before crossing the English Channel.^[10]^[31]^[16] Towing operations relied on fleets of tugboats, with approximately 132 to 200 tugs deployed overall for Mulberry components, typically using 4 to 5 tugs per caisson or 10 to 15 per convoy to manage the slow transit. Convoys proceeded at speeds of 2 to 5 knots, covering the roughly 100-mile distance across the Channel in 2 to 3 days, often under nighttime blackout conditions to evade German detection. Positioning was achieved using buoys and cables to align the caissons precisely off the target beaches, after which crews opened sea valves to flood the compartments and sink them controllably in water depths of 10 to 30 feet, with the process taking 10 to 30 minutes. By June 18, 1944, 75 caissons were in place, enabling the harbors' operational readiness.^[10]^[16]^[31] The operations faced significant logistical challenges, including weather delays that postponed some tows and the inherent risks of handling such unwieldy loads in tidal waters with 18-foot swings. One notable incident involved the C1-128 caisson, built at Tilbury Docks, which sprang a leak during initial floating-out in June 1944; diverted to the Thames Estuary for repairs, it grounded on West Knock Sand, broke in two, and sank before reaching the Channel crossing. Despite these hurdles, the coordinated effort ensured the breakwaters formed the core of the Mulberry harbors, facilitating vital supply lines for the Normandy campaign.^[31]^[10]^[32]

Role in Normandy Landings

The Phoenix breakwaters played a pivotal role in Operation Overlord by forming the primary concrete barriers of the Mulberry artificial harbors, enabling the rapid unloading of supplies essential for the Allied foothold in Normandy. Installation of the first caissons began on June 9, 1944 (D+3), allowing Mulberry A at Omaha Beach to become operational by June 14-16 (D+8 to D+10) and achieve initial offload rates of around 5,000-6,000 tons per day.^[6]^[10]^[33] Mulberry B at Arromanches (near Gold Beach) followed suit, becoming fully functional within days and sustaining operations through the summer, though both harbors faced severe challenges from a gale-force storm between June 19 and 22, 1944, which rendered Mulberry A largely unusable and reduced its capacity by over 50% due to extensive damage to its Phoenix components.^[8]^[33]^[34] These breakwaters integrated seamlessly with complementary Mulberry elements, creating sheltered waters where inner floating piers—constructed from Whale roadway units linking to Spud pierheads—facilitated all-tide access for supply vessels, thereby protecting them from Channel swells and supporting the discharge of the majority of initial materiel. Through late summer 1944, the surviving Mulberry infrastructure, bolstered by salvaged Phoenix units from the damaged American harbor, handled up to 80% of the Allies' supply needs, landing millions of tons of cargo, vehicles, and troops until the capture of Antwerp in September provided a permanent deep-water port.^[8]^[7] Beyond the main Mulberries, additional Phoenix units, numbering around 50-60, were repurposed for the Gooseberry breakwater systems at the invasion beaches including Utah, Gold, Juno, and Sword, enhancing sheltered anchorages for blockships and smaller craft to augment over-the-beach logistics in the critical early phases. In autumn 1944, additional reinforcements were deployed to Mulberry B despite ongoing vulnerabilities, though the June storm had already claimed 21 Phoenix units through sinking or displacement, underscoring the breakwaters' resilience amid harsh conditions while highlighting design limitations against extreme weather.^[33]^[8]^[34]

Post-War Fate and Legacy

Surviving Examples

Several Phoenix breakwaters survive in the United Kingdom, repurposed or preserved as historical remnants of the Mulberry harbours. At Portland Harbour in Dorset, two Type A1 caissons remain in place as permanent breakwaters, having been positioned there in 1946 to provide shelter for vessels. These structures, originally intended for Normandy but repurposed post-war, demonstrate the durability of the Phoenix design in ongoing maritime use.^[35]^[5] In Langstone Harbour near Hayling Island, Hampshire, the Type B2 caisson B2-117 lies partially submerged after developing a hull crack during construction in 1944, preventing its deployment to Normandy; it now serves as a visible underwater relic accessible at low tide. Further along the south coast, off Pagham Harbour in West Sussex, a Type A-1 caisson stands as an outer breakwater unit, protected since 2019 for its rarity and engineering significance in the Mulberry system. In the Thames Estuary off Shoeburyness, Essex, the wrecked Type C1 caisson C1-128, broken in two after springing a leak during towing from Tilbury Marshes in June 1944, rests on the seabed as a designated scheduled monument, highlighting the logistical challenges of wartime transport.^[36]^[37]^[36] Internationally, surplus Phoenix units found new roles in coastal engineering after the war. In the Netherlands, four caissons were utilized in 1953 to repair dyke breaches at Ouwerkerk following the North Sea flood; these have since been incorporated into the Watersnoodmuseum, where visitors can walk through the structures to learn about flood history and wartime engineering. In Sweden, two Type B1 caissons, numbers 73 and 74, were acquired in 1949 and towed to Hässelby in western Stockholm, where they continue to function as coastal protection elements against erosion. Similarly, in Iceland, four Type B caissons were purchased by Akranes in 1946 and integrated into the local harbour extension for breakwater purposes, aiding maritime operations in the North Atlantic.^[38]^[39]^[40] An estimated 10 to 15 Phoenix breakwaters remain intact worldwide, with several recognized for their historical value. In the UK, units such as the Pagham A-1 type and the Thames Estuary C1-128 are listed by Historic England as scheduled monuments, ensuring protection from development and promoting public awareness of their role in the Normandy landings. Additionally, a Type C unit off Littlestone-on-Sea in Kent survives remarkably intact as a scheduled monument. These surviving examples underscore the engineering robustness of the Phoenix design, originally deployed as floating breakwaters off Normandy beaches in 1944.^[17]^[37]^[20]

Historical Significance

The Phoenix breakwaters, as integral components of the Mulberry harbours, represented a groundbreaking engineering milestone by proving the feasibility of prefabricated reinforced concrete caissons for constructing large-scale temporary maritime structures under wartime constraints.^[23] These 6,000-ton units, sunk to form protective breakwaters, showcased innovative modular design and rapid deployment techniques that bypassed traditional port infrastructure, influencing subsequent developments in amphibious engineering and post-war civil port projects through their emphasis on prefabrication and portability.^[3]^[41] In the context of World War II, the Phoenix breakwaters were pivotal to Operation Overlord's success, enabling the rapid sustainment of Allied forces on Normandy's beaches by providing sheltered anchorages for supply ships. In the first week following D-Day on June 6, 1944, the Mulberry B harbour at Gold Beach alone facilitated the landing of approximately 180,000 troops via around 200 anchored vessels, while over the initial 10 days, supporting structures like Rhino ferries discharged about 16,000 vehicles at Omaha Beach despite challenges.^[41]^[23] The devastating storm of June 19-20, 1944, destroyed the American Mulberry A but spared much of Mulberry B, underscoring weather vulnerabilities while affirming the breakwaters' overall resilience and role in delivering millions of tons of supplies to sustain the invasion's momentum.^[33]^[3] The cultural legacy of the Phoenix breakwaters endures as symbols of Allied ingenuity, with remnants of the Arromanches Mulberry B serving as prominent memorials along the Normandy coast, drawing visitors to reflect on their logistical triumph.^[42] They have been chronicled in influential works such as Dwight D. Eisenhower's Crusade in Europe and featured in documentaries like D-Day / Mulberry Harbours - Battle Stations, highlighting their strategic importance.^[3]^[43] Annual D-Day commemorations at sites like Arromanches-les-Bains continue to honor this innovation, reinforcing its place in collective memory as a testament to engineering resolve.^[44]

Info Pages

Talk Pages

Special Pages

Phoenix breakwaters

Recent from talks

Recent from talks

Contribute something

Contribute something

Media Pages

Timelines

Articles

Notes collections