Hubbry Logo
Stuart NashStuart NashMain
Open search
Stuart Nash
Community hub
Stuart Nash
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Stuart Nash
Stuart Nash
Stuart Nash
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Stuart Alexander Nash (born August 1967) is a New Zealand politician and lawyer. He was a member of the House of Representatives for Labour Party from 2008 to 2011, and was re-elected in 2014 election as a representative of Napier electorate. In October 2017 when Jacinda Ardern became Prime Minister of New Zealand, Nash entered Labour Cabinet, with a portfolios of Police, Revenue, Small Business and Fisheries. In the second Ardern term Nash was handed the Economic Development, Tourism, Forestry, and Small Business portfolios. In early April 2023, Nash confirmed that he would not be contesting the 2023 election.

Key Information

Nash is the great-grandson of Sir Walter Nash, 27th Prime Minister of New Zealand in the Second Labour Government from 1957 to 1960.

Early, professional, and personal life

[edit]

Stuart Alexander Nash was born in August 1967 in Napier, to his parents, Jenny and Hal Nash. He is one of the three of four children. Nash grew up in Napier, and he was educated at Napier Boys' High School. Nash holds master's degrees in Law, Forestry Science, and Management from the University of Canterbury. Before moving back to his home town of Napier, he was the Director of Strategic Development at Auckland University of Technology.[2]

He is married to Sarah Nash, and they have four children.[3]

In March 2024, he and his wife Sarah both purchased the former Napier courthouse with the intention of renovating it into their family home and Airbnb accommodation. Built in 1875, the building had survived the 1931 earthquake. For the 35 years priors, it had served as the local Department of Conservation office. The courthouse was vested in Mana Ahuriri Trust as a part of their Treaty of Waitangi settlement. The trust decided to sell the building in 2023.[4]

Political career

[edit]
New Zealand Parliament
Years Term Electorate List Party
2008–2011 49th List 36 Labour
2014–2017 51st Napier none Labour
2017–2020 52nd Napier 11 Labour
2020–2023 53rd Napier 12 Labour

Early political career

[edit]

In 2005, Nash was a Labour candidate for the safe National seat of Epsom, placing third behind Rodney Hide and Richard Worth; having been directed by then-Prime Minister Helen Clark to ask Labour supporters to vote for the National candidate, Richard Worth, in a strategy designed to defeat ACT MP, Rodney Hide. The tactic didn't work, with Hide winning; though at 9,915 Labour received the highest number of party votes in this electorate since the introduction of the MMP parliamentary system in 1996.[5] Placed at number 60 on the party list, Nash failed to get elected.[6]

Election to Parliament on the list

[edit]

In 2007, Nash contested the Labour Party selection for Napier seat in 2008 election, but lost to Russell Fairbrother, a list MP and a former Napier electorate MP.[7] However, Nash was ranked at number 36 on the party list and was subsequently elected to parliament.[8]

After becoming a list MP Nash was appointed Labour's spokesperson for Revenue, and associate spokesperson for Trade and Forestry by Labour leader Phil Goff.[9] On 15 June 2010, Opposition Leader Phil Goff appointed Nash to be portfolio spokesperson for Forestry, a position formerly held by Mita Ririnui. In February 2011 Phil Goff announced his new caucus line up and Nash was ranked 27th, retaining all his portfolio responsibilities.[10]

2011–2014

[edit]
Nash and Phil Goff addressing community groups in 2011

In the 2011 general election, Nash contested Napier electorate seat held by National Cabinet Minister Chris Tremain. Nash reduced Tremain's 2008 majority of 9,018 votes by 5,300 votes (the highest reduction achieved against a sitting National electorate MP) but still came second. As well, Nash was ranked 27 on the Labour list, higher than in 2008 but not high enough on the Labour list to return to Parliament as a List MP.[11]

After leaving Parliament, Nash signed on as the chief-of-staff for newly appointed party leader David Shearer. However, Nash resigned after just four months into the job and returned to his home town of Napier, citing the birth of his new child and focusing on winning back the electorate there.[12]

2014–current: Return to Parliament

[edit]

In February 2014, Nash was selected as Labour's candidate for Napier to contest the 2014 general election.[13] National's Tremain had retired and was succeeded by Wayne Walford, and Nash had a majority of 3,850 votes over Walford.[14] The electorate was also contested by Garth McVicar for the Conservative Party, and McVicar's 7,603 votes cut into traditional National Party votes.[14][15][16]

Nash retained the Napier electorate in 2017, increasing his majority and becoming only the second Labour MP after Damien O'Connor to win and hold a seat off the National party this century.[17] Nash was elected as a Cabinet Minister by the Labour Party caucus following Labour's formation of a coalition government with New Zealand First and the Greens.[18] On 26 October, he was appointed as Minister of Police, Revenue, Small Business and Fisheries.[19]

During the 2020 general election, Nash retained his seat in Napier by a final margin of 5,856.[20] On 2 November 2020, Jacinda Ardern announced that Nash would be dropping the Police, Revenue and Fisheries portfolios, and would pick up the Economic and Regional Development, Forestry, and Tourism portfolios, while retaining Small Business.[21]

In mid November 2021, Nash claimed that farming advocacy group Groundswell NZ's website promoted racism and vaccine hesitancy in response to a question by ACT Member of Parliament Mark Cameron. When Cameron reiterated his question, Nash told Cameron to avoid posing with someone holding an anti-vaccination sign at a Groundswell protest. In response to Stuart's remarks, Groundswell co-founder Bryce McKenzie emphasised the group's efforts to combat racism and vaccine hesitancy among its ranks. McKenzie added that the group had accepted the resignation of Groundswell member and Tatua Dairy board of directors member Ross Townshend for posting an offensive image depicting Foreign Minister Nanaia Mahuta as a gang member.[22]

2023 ministerial indiscretions and resignation

[edit]

In mid–March 2023, Nash resigned as Minister of Police following revelations he asked the Police Commissioner Andrew Coster to appeal a decision Nash felt was too light, a breach of the expectation that the Government remains neutral in regards to operational Police matters.[23] On 16 March, Nash faced further calls from the opposition National and ACT parties to resign from his remaining portfolios after revelations that the Attorney-General David Parker had reprimanded Nash for making remarks during a 2020 Newstalk ZB interview calling for murder suspect Eli Epiha to be imprisoned for his actions during the murder of Matthew Hunt. At the time, Epiha was facing trial and had not yet been convicted for murdering Hunt.[24] Nash subsequently admitted to a third incident of misconduct where he contacted the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) to advocate for a migrant health professional in Napier in September 2022. In response, Hipkins demoted Nash to the bottom of the Cabinet rankings as a "final warning" but declined to strip him of his remaining cabinet portfolios.[25]

On 28 March it was revealed that in 2020 Nash emailed two of his donors, who were commercial property owners, about a commercial rent relief policy Cabinet was discussing.[26] The Cabinet Manual, part of New Zealand's unwritten constitution,[27] sets out that "discussion at Cabinet and Cabinet committee meetings is informal and confidential", and that any proposals "likely to be considered at forthcoming meetings, outside Cabinet-approved consultation procedures" are not allowed to be disclosed. In the email, Nash expressed his view that "I am as annoyed (and surprised) about the final outcome of the 'commercial rent relief package' as you are".[28] Prime Minister Chris Hipkins advised the Governor General to strip Nash of his ministerial portfolios the same day.[29]

On 3 April, Nash announced that he would not be contesting the 2023 New Zealand general election. In a statement published on Facebook, he stated while his work as a minister in the Ardern Cabinet "has been rewarding, and both intellectually and professionally stimulating, it has also been incredibly taxing on relationships with family and friends." Prior to Nash's announcement, Hipkins had asked the Cabinet Secretary to conduct a review into communications between Nash and his donors in order to identify further breaches of Cabinet confidentiality and both perceived or real conflicts of interest.[30][31] Despite his dismissal, on 26 April 2023 Nash was granted the use of the prefix "The Honourable" for life, in recognition of his term as a Member of the Executive Council.[32]

On 16 June, a Cabinet Office report cleared Nash of confidentiality breaches but identified a conflict of interest in the government appointment of a donor and high school friend Phil McCaw, who had donated the sum of NZ$6500 to Nash's 2020 election campaign. While Nash had managed McCaw's conflict of interest by getting another minister to appoint McCaw but failed in the continual management of the problem.[33] Newshub reported that the Cabinet office had examined five years worth of Nash's communications and that a senior minister had disputed the inclusion of McCaw's appointment within the probe.[34] On 19 June, the Chief Ombudsman Peter Boshier found that Nash had breached Official Information Act by improperly withholding emails in which he discussed confidential Cabinet briefings with two donors, Troy Bowker and Greg Loveridge, during the COVID-19 pandemic in June 2020.[35]

Post-politics

[edit]

In late February 2024, Nash criticised his former Labour Party colleagues' legislation targeting gang assets, claiming that it did not go far enough. In March 2023, the Labour government had passed the Criminal Proceeds (Recovery) Act 2023, which allowed Police to seize gang leaders' properties, cars, bikes and bling valued at NZ$30,000 or above in compliance with the New Zealand Bill of Rights. Nash argued that there should be no limit on the amount of gang assets seized. Nash claimed that former Justice Minister Kiri Allan had blocked efforts to introduce tougher anti-gang legislation on the grounds that it targeted Māori people. Nash pressed for the National-led coalition government to do away with the $30,000 limit on the seizure of gang assets.[36] In response, Labour MP Willie Jackson accused Nash of grandstanding, "lacking class" and pitching for contracts around Wellington.[37]

In April 2025, amid rumours that he was considering contesting the 2026 general election as a New Zealand First candidate, Nash confirmed that he was no longer a member of the Labour Party and did not deny the rumours.[38] He spoke at a New Zealand First party conference in September, criticising Labour for being "woke".[39]

In September 2025, Nash made national headlines in New Zealand for using sexist slurs when asked for a definition of a woman, stating that a woman is "a person with a pussy and a pair of tits" in an interview on internet radio station The Platform with host Sean Plunket.[40][41] He later contacted the show and asked for the comment to be removed.[42] On 11 September, Nash resigned from his job at recruitment company Robert Walters after his employer launched a review into his radio remarks.[43] He also resigned from the board of the New Zealand Taxpayers' Union.[44]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Stuart Nash

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Stuart Alexander Nash (born August 1967) is a politician known for his tenure as a Labour Party and cabinet minister. He entered in 2008 as a list MP, lost his position in 2011, and reclaimed the Napier electorate seat in 2014, holding it until the 2023 election. Nash served in various ministerial roles under the Sixth Labour Government from 2017, including Police, , Fisheries, and Small Business, later expanding to , , and , where he advanced initiatives like expanding the police workforce to record levels and firearms reforms. His career has been defined by a direct communication style that yielded policy successes but also sparked controversies, such as public admissions of influencing police decisions and disclosing confidential cabinet discussions to private contacts, resulting in his dismissal from ministerial duties in March 2023. Following Labour's 2023 defeat, Nash has pursued opportunities with , including a recent bid for candidacy amid further public gaffes on social issues.

Personal Background

Early Life and Education

Stuart Alexander Nash was born in August 1967 in Napier, New Zealand. He grew up in Napier as the eldest of four siblings. Nash attended Napier Central School for his primary education, becoming the fifth generation of his family to do so. He then progressed to Napier Boys' High School for secondary education, where he served as a prefect and captain of the debating team, while participating in sports including rugby, cricket, and tennis. For tertiary education, Nash earned a degree in history from . He subsequently obtained a in forestry from the .

Family and Personal Life

Nash was previously married to Kristin, whom he met at ; the couple wed at a young age, lived and worked in in , and later relocated to . With Kristin, Nash has two children: daughter Sophia, born in 2002, and son Charlie, born in 2005. Nash's second marriage is to Sarah Nash; together they have two children, son Will (born circa 2012) and daughter Isabella (born circa 2013). The family resides in Napier, where in March 2024 Nash and Sarah purchased the historic former Napier Courthouse on , intending to convert it into their home; Nash's father had practiced law there for decades, and his grandfather was also connected to the site. By January 2025, the couple had transformed the building into a family residence shared with their younger children, a named Beau, and a named Coco, while the older children visit occasionally. In personal pursuits, Nash participates in the parliamentary cross-party rugby team and maintains an interest in sports generally.

Pre-Political Career

Nash holds a Master of Laws degree, along with master's degrees in management and forestry science, qualifying him as a lawyer. His family's longstanding involvement in the legal profession in Napier, including his grandfather and father practicing as lawyers there, provided early exposure to the field. However, specific details of Nash's own legal practice prior to his business and political careers remain sparsely documented in public sources, with his professional focus shifting toward commercial endeavors leveraging his legal training.

Business Ventures and Achievements

Prior to entering , Nash held roles in both private and organizations, including positions with large exporters and small businesses. His experience encompassed operations in and , particularly in the sector. Nash spent approximately eight years working for a petrochemical importing company, where he managed the importation of derivatives primarily from and the for distribution throughout . In this role, he handled trading and logistics aspects of the business, gaining practical expertise in international supply chains and commodity markets. He later drew on this background during his political career to advocate for inquiries into fuel pricing and cost structures, citing his direct involvement in trading. No publicly documented independent business ventures or entrepreneurial achievements, such as founding companies or leading major initiatives outside employment, are attributed to Nash in this period. His pre-political business contributions appear centered on operational rather than or ownership.

Political

Entry into Politics and 2008 Election

Following a successful career in business and strategic development, Stuart Nash decided to enter politics in the mid-2000s, motivated by his experiences living and working overseas, which reinforced his view of New Zealand as an exceptional country deserving of strong leadership to foster economic and community growth. As the great-grandson of Labour Prime Minister Sir Walter Nash, he drew inspiration from this family legacy but emphasized his independent drive to effect change, particularly in his hometown of Napier. Nash aligned with the Labour Party, valuing its focus on working people and regional development, and leveraged his commerce background to position himself as a pragmatic candidate capable of bridging business and policy. Nash first contested a general election in 2005 as the Labour candidate for Epsom but placed third, prompting a shift to contesting the more winnable Napier electorate in 2008. Selected as Labour's Napier candidate, he was ranked 36th on the party's list, a position described by Labour President Mike Williams as strengthening the team's talent pool with Nash's expertise in strategic development from his role at Auckland University of Technology. The 2008 general election occurred on 8 November 2008, amid a national contest where Labour sought to retain power under Helen Clark against John Key's National Party. In Napier, a traditionally competitive seat held by Labour until National's Chris Tremain captured it in 2005, Nash campaigned on local issues like economic revitalization and community investment, but lost to Tremain by a margin reflecting National's broader provincial gains. Despite the electorate defeat, Labour secured sufficient party votes nationwide to allocate seats, enabling Nash to enter as a MP for the 49th term, marking his formal entry into national politics at age 41. This outcome positioned him to focus on policy scrutiny from opposition benches as Labour transitioned to status post-election.

First Parliamentary Term (2008-2011)

Stuart Nash entered Parliament as a Labour Party following the 2008 general election, securing the 36th position on the party's list and entering the 49th Parliament as Labour moved to opposition. In January 2009, Labour leader appointed Nash to the shadow frontbench as Shadow Minister for Revenue, with associate shadow roles in and , positioning him to scrutinize government economic policies during the global aftermath. Nash focused on provincial economic issues, founding and chairing the Labour Provincial Caucus Committee to advocate for and address disparities in economic recovery efforts outside urban centers. His parliamentary contributions included his on 16 December 2008, where he emphasized economic resilience and local Napier concerns such as operations and . As a junior opposition MP, Nash engaged in select committee work and questioned ministers on revenue collection, trade agreements, and sustainability, though no major or high-profile interventions are recorded from this period. In the 2011 general election held on 26 November, Nash contested the Napier electorate for Labour but lost to National's Wayne , ending his first parliamentary term after one term in the . His defeat reflected Labour's broader national losses, with the party securing fewer seats amid voter shifts toward the National-led government.

Opposition Period (2011-2014)

Following the 2011 New Zealand general election on 26 November 2011, Nash lost his seat in as Labour's party vote fell to 27.3%, insufficient to retain him at number 42 on the party list. Labour leader resigned shortly after the defeat, paving the way for to win the leadership contest on 13 December 2011; Nash was promptly appointed Shearer's chief of staff to assist in opposition strategy against the National-led government. This role lasted only a few months, with Nash resigning in April 2012 amid reported tensions within Shearer's office, after which Alastair Cameron replaced him. Post-resignation, Nash shifted focus to regaining the Napier electorate, which Labour had lost to National's Chris Tremain in 2011 by 4,179 votes. He launched an intensive local campaign around early 2012, described as 30 months of "bloody hard work" involving and advocacy on regional issues like and operations. During this out-of-Parliament phase, Nash contributed to Labour's broader opposition critique of National's policies, including public commentary on and party renewal, while rejecting an approach post-2011 election to front a new centre-left party in competition with Labour. Nash's efforts culminated in the 20 September 2014 general election, where he reclaimed Napier for Labour with 14,341 votes (45.8% of the electorate vote), defeating Tremain by 3,850 votes amid a tight national race that saw Labour secure 25% party vote overall. This victory marked his return to as an electorate MP, ending the opposition interlude outside the House.

Electorate MP and Ministerial Roles (2014-2023)

Nash won the Napier electorate in the 2014 general election, securing 15,250 votes against National candidate Wayne Waugh's 11,517, for a of 3,733 votes. As an electorate MP, he focused on regional issues including economic development and infrastructure in the area, while Labour remained in opposition until 2017. He was re-elected in the 2017 general election with 20,677 votes to National candidate Elliott's 15,457, increasing his majority to 5,220 votes, as Labour formed a . On 26 October 2017, Nash entered Cabinet as Minister for , Minister of , Minister of Fisheries, and Minister of Police. In these roles, he oversaw policing reforms, including increased funding for frontline officers, and revenue policy adjustments such as the bright-line test extension for property sales. Nash retained the Napier seat in the 2020 general election, polling 21,325 votes against National's Katie Nimon's 15,469 for a majority of 5,856 votes. Following the election, his portfolios shifted on 6 November 2020 to include Minister of , Minister of Forestry, and Minister for Economic and Regional Development, while retaining responsibility for ; Revenue and Fisheries ended, but he continued substantive oversight of Police until reassignment. In these capacities, he managed tourism recovery post-COVID-19 lockdowns and promoted regional growth initiatives like the Shovel Ready Projects fund. By early 2023, Nash held Minister for , Minister for and Fisheries, and Minister of , with a brief acting stint and resumption of Police from 1 February until his resignation from that portfolio on 15 March amid a breach of Cabinet confidentiality. On 28 March 2023, dismissed him from all remaining ministerial roles. Throughout this period, Nash maintained his electorate duties in Napier, advocating for local priorities such as gang enforcement and economic resilience despite national party vote splits in the electorate.

Key Policy Positions and Initiatives

As Minister for Economic and Regional Development from 2020 to 2023, Nash prioritized attracting foreign investment and supporting small-to-medium enterprises (SMEs) to boost and regional growth. In September 2022, he launched the Active Investor Plus Visa program, which offered residency pathways to high-net-worth individuals committing at least NZ$5 million to managed funds or NZ$15 million to direct business investments, aiming to channel capital into high-growth sectors while easing restrictions on foreign property purchases for qualifying investors. He also unveiled the "Do Good, Do Well" global investment campaign on September 19, 2022, in New York, promoting New Zealand's stable environment for ethical, high-return investments in areas like sustainable technology and primary industries. Nash advanced industry-specific transformation plans to address low productivity, including the Advanced Manufacturing Industry Transformation Plan released on March 13, 2023, which targeted , skills training, and to lift wages and export value in , a sector contributing about 10% to GDP. In May 2022, he announced the expansion of the with an additional NZ$100 million in equity financing for SMEs, building on its prior NZ$300 million allocation to improve access to patient capital for scaling operations. These initiatives aligned with broader Provincial Growth Fund investments, which exceeded NZ$2 billion by November 2021, funding projects like advanced manufacturing equipment in regions such as Southland. In his role as Minister of Police from 2017 to 2018 and again from 2020 to 2023, Nash emphasized strengthening against and . He introduced the Arms (Prohibited Firearms, Magazines, and Parts) Amendment Bill in 2019, enacting stricter controls on semi-automatic weapons and buy-back schemes following the , 2019, mosque attacks that killed 51 people, with over 56,000 firearms surrendered by December 2019. Nash also announced a ban on patches in public buildings like courts, schools, and hospitals in 2020, extending to 28 other identifiers by 2021 under anti-patch laws to deter . He advocated for expanded police resourcing, including 1,800 additional officers recruited between 2017 and 2023, and targeted gang asset seizures, though Nash later stated in February 2024 that Cabinet had diluted stronger proposals he favored, limiting forfeiture to convicted members rather than associates. Nash supported the Industry Transformation Plan, released in 2022, to grow low-carbon wood processing and exports, projecting an additional NZ$3.5 billion in value by 2030 through sustainable harvesting and innovation. In small business policy, he endorsed shorter payment terms for suppliers, highlighting Fonterra's shift to 20-day payments for milk processors in 2019 as a model to ease pressures on SMEs.

Internal Party Dynamics

Nash's position within the Labour Party caucus positioned him as a representative of its more centrist and pragmatic wing, emphasizing business-friendly economic policies and a tough stance on law and order that contrasted with the party's progressive factions focused on and . As Minister of from 2017 to 2023, he advocated for initiatives like the Provincial Growth Fund to stimulate regional economies, aligning with his pre-political business background and appealing to moderate voters, though this occasionally drew scrutiny from left-leaning colleagues wary of market-driven approaches. His tenure as Minister of Police from 2017 to 2023 amplified these dynamics, as Nash pushed for enhanced police powers, including the 2021 banning gang patches in public and proposals to revive elements of a three-strikes sentencing for repeat serious offenders—policies that faced internal resistance from caucus members concerned about disproportionate impacts on communities and over-reliance on punitive measures. These efforts highlighted factional divides, with Nash's advocacy often requiring negotiation to secure party support amid broader debates on . During the Labour-NZ First-Greens (2017-2020), Nash's effective engagement with coalition partners, particularly on fisheries and economic portfolios, helped bridge gaps, but public criticisms—such as his 2020 labeling of stakeholders as "criminals" and attribution of delays to NZ First—exposed strains in maintaining unified government messaging, indirectly pressuring Labour's leadership to manage discipline. Nash's outspoken style further contributed to internal tensions, as seen in incidents like his 2021 dismissal of the Groundswell farmer protests as containing "racism and anti-vax" elements, which provoked backlash and necessitated party-wide damage control amid rural discontent. Despite such frictions, he demonstrated loyalty to , publicly defending in August 2022 by warning that a mid-term leadership change would cause Labour to "implode," reflecting his role in stabilizing amid slipping polls.

2023 Election and Exit from Parliament

Following his dismissal from Cabinet on 28 March 2023, Stuart Nash announced on 3 April 2023 that he would retire from politics and not contest the Napier electorate in the 2023 general election. Labour Party selected businessman Mark Hutchinson as its candidate for Napier, whom Nash endorsed in May 2023, stating confidence in Hutchinson's ability to represent the electorate. The general election occurred on 14 October 2023, with National Party candidate Katie Nimon defeating Hutchinson in Napier by a margin of approximately 4,000 votes, thus reclaiming the seat for National after Labour's hold since 2014. Nash's decision not to stand ensured his exit from Parliament at the end of the parliamentary term, concluding his tenure as the electorate's representative that began in 2014.

Controversies

2023 Cabinet Resignation and Breach of Confidentiality

On 28 March 2023, Prime Minister dismissed Stuart Nash from all his ministerial portfolios following the revelation of a breach of Cabinet confidentiality rules. The breach involved an Nash sent on 23 June 2020 to two businessmen, Cameron Smith and Andrew King—both former donors to his electoral campaigns—disclosing details of a Cabinet decision. In the , Nash informed the recipients that Cabinet had opted not to proceed with a recommended to impose additional requirements on overseas in , which included a potential emissions levy on large exporters. Hipkins described the action as a "clear breach of and Cabinet confidentiality," stating that Nash had fundamentally violated his trust. The email came to light in March 2023 amid an Official Information Act request related to Nash's communications with donors. Hipkins learned of the disclosure approximately five days before the dismissal, prompting an immediate review that confirmed the violation of the Cabinet Manual's provisions on . Nash, who held roles including Minister for , and Resources, and , accepted responsibility, issuing a public apology to his Napier constituents and confirming his intention to contest the 2023 general election as a list MP. He acknowledged in a statement that he had "got this wrong, too many times," referencing prior controversies including an earlier from the Police portfolio on 16 March 2023 over unauthorized discussions with the police commissioner. A subsequent review, released on 16 June 2023, examined Nash's broader ministerial communications with donors and found no evidence of additional confidentiality breaches beyond the 2020 email. However, it highlighted "lower level" concerns regarding the government's appointment processes involving individuals linked to Nash's donors, though these did not constitute formal violations of Cabinet rules. The incident underscored ongoing scrutiny of Nash's interactions with figures, contributing to his demotion from Cabinet but not immediately ending his parliamentary tenure.

Policy Influence Allegations

In March 2023, Stuart Nash was dismissed from Cabinet after it emerged that he had emailed two owner donors in June 2020, disclosing confidential Cabinet discussions on a proposed rent relief package amid , which could have advantaged their business interests by signaling no imposition of rent controls or freezes. The recipients, who had contributed to Nash's campaigns, were informed of Cabinet's decision against commercial rent intervention, prompting allegations of undue donor favoritism and potential policy signaling for private gain. A subsequent review, released on 14 June 2023, examined Nash's communications with six declared donors but found no additional breaches of beyond the 2020 email; however, it identified a in Nash's May 2022 appointment of donor Phil McCaw—who had given NZ$6,500 on 3 August 2020 and held business ties valued at around NZ$180 million—to chair the Startup Advisors Council, where Nash managed the conflict informally rather than fully recusing or transferring responsibility as required by the Cabinet Manual. The review noted Nash's use of personal and for donor contacts, along with deleted text messages, which limited scrutiny and raised transparency concerns under the Official Information Act, though it deemed these inconsistencies lower-level rather than major violations. Separate allegations arose from Nash's tenure as Forestry Minister (2017–2023), where he received NZ$19,503.80 in 2020 donations from timber industry figures, including NZ$5,000 from Andrew Kelly (former Lumber Link director, prior donations of NZ$5,000 in 2017 and NZ$31,000 in 2014), NZ$9,503.80 from Taupo-based Tenon, and NZ$5,000 from Rotorua-based Red Stag, amid his oversight of policies expanding and allocating NZ$200 million via the Regional Fund. Critics, including transparency advocates, argued these ties created perceived influence over land-use and slash management inquiries, though Nash maintained compliance with disclosure rules and no recusal was needed, as officials—not he—appointed another donor-linked figure, Red Stag's Marty Verry, to a forestry advisory group in 2021. Further scrutiny highlighted donor , such as McCaw's use of Nash's ministerial email to seek removal from an Department study on high-wealth individuals, suggesting potential sway over , though the June 2023 review's limited scope—excluding direct donor interviews or broader —drew criticism from political analysts like Bryce Edwards for insufficient depth and failure to address systemic "insider trading"-like risks in donor-minister relations. Nash denied any policy , asserting communications were routine and conflicts managed per guidelines, with no evidence of altered decisions emerging from investigations. The episode spurred calls for registration reforms, led by the , to mitigate such perceptions.

2025 Gender Comments and Professional Fallout

On September 9, 2025, during an interview on the New Zealand media outlet The Platform, former Labour MP Stuart Nash was asked to define "what a woman is." Nash responded with a vulgar statement equating womanhood to possession of female genitalia and breasts, later describing his own remark as "crude and disrespectful." The comment, which aligned with empirical biological markers of female sex but employed explicit language, drew immediate backlash from media and political figures, including NZ First leader Winston Peters, who expressed disbelief. Nash issued a public apology via LinkedIn that day, stating the remark was "wrong and unacceptable" and expressing regret for any offense caused. Mainstream outlets, often reflecting institutional biases toward progressive gender norms, labeled the statement "deeply inappropriate," "sexist," and "misogynistic," prioritizing offense over the underlying factual basis in human dimorphism. The professional repercussions followed swiftly. Nash, serving as commercial director at recruitment firm Robert Walters since his 2023 parliamentary exit, faced a formal internal review initiated by the company over the remarks. On September 11, 2025, he resigned from the role amid the probe, with reports indicating the firm viewed the comments as incompatible with its professional standards. Further fallout included Nash's exclusion from a government-led trade delegation to the , scheduled to promote New Zealand's new investor "golden visa" alongside Immigration Minister . Trade Minister cited the comments as a potential "," leading to Nash's removal around September 18, 2025. In response, Nash sent text messages to McClay questioning the decision and using , escalating the incident. This episode highlighted tensions between unvarnished biological assertions and expectations of in post-political and advisory roles.

Post-Parliamentary Activities

Return to Private Sector

Following his departure from Parliament in September 2023, Nash joined the international recruitment firm Robert Walters as Commercial Director, based in , leveraging his extensive government and business experience to support the company's expansion in and talent advisory services. In this role, he focused on commercial strategy and client relations in sectors including , , and , drawing on his prior ministerial portfolios in and . Nash also co-founded Nash Kelly Global, a advisory firm specializing in investment migration and residency services for ultra-high-net-worth individuals, particularly through investor programs. As CEO, he provides strategic guidance on government relations, policy navigation, and relocation, capitalizing on his role in shaping 's investor reforms during his time as Minister for . The firm assists clients with applications under the Active Plus , which requires investments starting at NZ$5 million over four years or NZ$15 million over three years, targeting sectors like technology and . On September 11, 2025, resigned from Robert Walters following a formal internal review prompted by his use of crude language in a radio defining a biologically, which the company deemed "deeply inappropriate." He stated the decision was mutual to avoid further distraction, while continuing to lead Kelly Global amid ongoing demand for its services in the evolving landscape.

Political Commentary and NZ First Engagement

Following his resignation from Parliament in April 2023, Stuart Nash began offering public commentary critical of the Labour Party, arguing that it had deviated from its traditional focus on working-class interests under leader . In a 2025 , Nash stated that Labour was "abandoning" its core voters, positioning himself as aligned with policies prioritizing economic over what he described as ideological excesses. Nash's engagement with New Zealand First intensified in early September 2025, when he appeared as a guest speaker at the party's 32nd annual general meeting in Palmerston North on September 5. There, he publicly declared his allegiance to the party, praising its defence of "common sense" and potential to hold the government accountable, while NZ First leader Winston Peters endorsed Nash as a "seamless fit" for a list candidacy in the 2026 election. Nash explicitly left open the possibility of campaigning for or joining NZ First, stating he was not yet a member but supported its platform as a counter to Labour's direction. This alignment drew immediate scrutiny, as Nash's rapid pivot—from Labour Cabinet minister to NZ First sympathizer—highlighted tensions within New Zealand's , with critics noting his great-grandson status of Labour founder as ironic. However, Nash's involvement faced setbacks shortly after; on September 9, 2025, during an on The Platform, he provided a crude biological , prompting backlash, a public from Peters, and Nash's issuance of an apology. The incident led to his removal from a planned government trade delegation to the on September 18 and resignation from a role, underscoring risks in NZ First's recruitment of high-profile defectors. Despite the controversy, Nash continued commentary via media appearances, framing his NZ First affinity as driven by unfinished policy goals in policing and economic reform.

Ongoing Influence and Future Prospects

Following his departure from Parliament in 2023, Nash has maintained visibility through public commentary critiquing the Labour Party's shift away from its traditional working-class base, as expressed in a January 2025 interview where he argued that founding principles have been forsaken, prompting his formal exit from the party. This rhetoric resonated with some conservative-leaning audiences, evidenced by his September 2025 address to the New Zealand First convention, where he declared allegiance to the party and positioned himself as aligned with its nationalist priorities, receiving endorsement from leader Winston Peters as a potential "seamless fit" for candidacy. Nash's influence persists in policy advocacy via his private firm, Nash Kelly Global, which lobbied for exemptions to New Zealand's foreign buyer ban for high-net-worth investors under golden visa programs, contributing to legislative easing announced on September 2, 2025. However, Nash's prospects for electoral return dimmed after controversial statements in early September 2025, where he defined a woman biologically as "a person with a p*y and a pair of ts" during a media interaction, prompting backlash including from Peters, who expressed being "unimpressed." This led to his resignation from initial NZ First engagement efforts, as reported on September 10, 2025, amid questions over his viability as a candidate. Analysts have assessed his political rehabilitation as protracted, recommending avoidance of 2026 election bids due to accumulated credibility erosion from prior scandals and this episode. As of October 2025, Nash's future in appears constrained, with no confirmed nominations and reliance on media platforms like The Platform for discourse on "unfinished business," though without formal commitments. His ongoing sway may derive more from business networks and informal conservative networks than institutional roles, potentially influencing regional dynamics where he retains local recognition from pre-2023 tenure. Absent a strategic pivot, prospects for high-level re-entry remain low, per contemporaneous reporting.

References

  1. https://natlib.govt.nz/records/38318712
  2. https://rtnz.org.nz/speaker-stuart-nash/
  3. https://hvchamber.org.nz/arlo/events/158-political-series-you-are-invited-to-a-business-breakfast-with-the-minister-for-small-business-hon-stuart-nash/
  4. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/largest-police-workforce-nz-history
  5. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/minister/hon-stuart-nash-2017?page=2
  6. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/stuart-nash-is-a-controversial-minister-who-wasnt-afraid-to-speak-his-mind/F44WYPBHFBCV3PMTCXORMRC72U/
  7. https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/16-03-2023/what-stuart-nash-did-wrong-and-why-he-had-to-go
  8. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/former-labour-minister-stuart-nash-makes-his-pitch-to-become-nz-first-mp/2YD5V3CGYNCF5KWHGI5PAH3WWM/
  9. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/former-labour-mp-stuart-nash-resigns-after-comment-about-women/OZGT4MG655GDVCKX4KGBS4COYE/
  10. https://thetopcelebrity.com/biography/stuart-nash-politician-bio-wiki-age-networth-education-family
  11. https://www.geni.com/people/Stuart-Nash/6000000069541736039
  12. https://knowledgebank.org.nz/audio/nash-stuart-alexander-interview/
  13. https://rotary9930.org/stories/join-zoom-meeting-and-listen-to-stuart-nash-mp-for-napier-minister-of-police-fisheries-revenue-and-small-business
  14. https://huttvalleychamberofcommerce.arlo.co/w/events/158-political-series-you-are-invited-to-a-business-breakfast-with-the-minister-for-small-business-hon-stuart-nash
  15. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/stuart-nash-my-dream-is-to-end-up-in-a-labour-cabinet/5QPUDH54KUMC4FOHHGR7PTL4KE/
  16. https://www.thepost.co.nz/culture/360556546/aroha-challenges-and-joys-marrying-politician
  17. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/stuart-nash-and-family-to-transform-historic-napier-courthouse-into-home/P2CVAIGRCFDFDDUTQLFNHMWQIA/
  18. https://www.stuff.co.nz/home-property/360522159/courtroom-lounge-home-former-napier-mp-stuart-nash
  19. https://www.stuff.co.nz/business/money/66341740/fuel-costs-inquiry-demanded
  20. https://www.theprofit.co.nz/nash-rolls-sleeves-up-for-smes/
  21. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/q-and-a-minister-for-small-business-stuart-nash/QLZFNL6J5F2KDNWSZKATDCCJEM/
  22. https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PA0808/S00518.htm
  23. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/nash-faces-nervous-wait/VRPR5JJNUUMDXWCAH3VQXFAAVM/
  24. https://www.otatoungahereconference.org.nz/speakers/hon-stuart-nash/
  25. https://www.dpmc.govt.nz/sites/default/files/2023-06/nash-pr-review-hon-stuart-nashs-ministerial-communications-donors.pdf
  26. https://natlib.govt.nz/records/35160740
  27. https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/vote-08/news/726849/Five-newcomers-to-Labours-frontbench
  28. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/napier-vote-2011-stuart-nash/DMTBAW6C3WSIU55KHDKZV2YQII/
  29. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cEK_CsOVGn4
  30. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/national-holds-hawkes-bay-nash-out/4EYES3WWUDVSCKOQHGPWMBVLBE/
  31. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/nash-sees-the-positive-side/TCQIN232JATL276QUCWB4PNU7U/
  32. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/487255/labour-mp-stuart-nash-will-leave-politics-at-october-election
  33. https://thestandard.org.nz/later-stuart-2/
  34. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/tension-behind-nashs-departure/U5ZANTLLFZAXKAUTM5LPTL2BRQ/
  35. https://www.stuff.co.nz/national/politics/10553595/Stuart-Nash-its-all-about-bloody-hard-work
  36. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/256477/labour-mp-asked-to-set-up-new-party
  37. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/stuart-nash-his-only-interview/FRGROTZGGRBKLCB6JWWUFJNGUM/
  38. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/nash-wins-napier/22ROFT6J5V2MKQVQCC2S2SQCY4/
  39. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/go-after-gangs-stuart-nash-says-napier-has-told-him-the-priority-this-term/J4NPOEC34L37J7LNSC4LHAWAQI/
  40. https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/electionresults_2017/electorate-details-29.html
  41. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/statement-prime-minister-stuart-nash
  42. https://www.electionresults.govt.nz/electionresults_2020/electorate-details-26.html
  43. https://www.treasury.govt.nz/publications/information-release/economic-and-regional-development-portfolio-budget-2022-information-release
  44. https://www.1news.co.nz/2023/03/28/nash-dismissed-from-all-ministerial-portfolios/
  45. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/voting-results-show-napier-voters-split-again-between-red-and-blue/AECGZJDFV6WUOAUMFDP3CUXDEM/
  46. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20250902409508/en/New-Zealand-Eases-Foreign-Buyer-Ban-with-Exemption-for-Golden-Visa-Holders-Reform-Championed-by-Stuart-Nash-of-Nash-Kelly-Global
  47. https://www.nzte.govt.nz/blog/new-zealand-launches-new-global-investment-drive-do-good-do-well
  48. https://www.mbie.govt.nz/business-and-employment/economic-growth/previous-economic-development-work/industry-transformation-plans/advanced-manufacturing
  49. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/unleashing-business-potential-across-nz
  50. https://insidegovernment.co.nz/regional-investment-passes-2billion-milestone/
  51. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/minister/hon-stuart-nash-2017?page=6
  52. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/police-minister-stuart-nash-announces-ban-on-comanchero-gang-patch-in-public-buildings/ZNR7VRKUITEAPAYVO5QXJ3BXRI/
  53. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/510204/stuart-nash-claims-labour-cabinet-softened-its-gang-asset-seizure-policy
  54. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/minister/hon-stuart-nash-2017?page=10
  55. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/portfolio/labour-2020-2023/forestry
  56. https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/23-04-2024/have-gang-numbers-really-skyrocketed-in-recent-years
  57. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/510299/labour-dismissive-of-stuart-nash-criticism-over-gang-asset-seizures-he-s-got-no-class
  58. https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/29-03-2023/a-brief-history-of-stuart-nashs-big-mouth
  59. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/business/420272/fishing-industry-unimpressed-by-stuart-nash-s-comments
  60. https://thespinoff.co.nz/politics/13-12-2020/agent-of-chaos-the-inside-story-of-the-labour-nz-first-coalition-government
  61. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/aug/20/jacinda-arderns-iron-grip-on-new-zealands-labour-party-is-slipping-and-that-means-trouble
  62. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/stuart-nash-to-retire-from-politics-at-election-after-sacking-and-scandals/NXFXTXW4RRFNXOGSGOYTL2KERA/
  63. https://www.1news.co.nz/2023/04/03/stuart-nash-to-stand-down-from-politics-at-next-election/
  64. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/490266/stuart-nash-backs-labour-s-new-candidate-for-napier-mark-hutchinson
  65. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/election-2023-results-the-race-for-napier/A2MORZXJLJFK7H7UIUDMTRLSY4/
  66. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/stuart-nash-dismissed-cabinet
  67. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/prime-minister-chris-hipkins-to-make-announcement-on-stuart-nashs-future/BJKYRLJCMBCWDGI57BJCQIGWMU/
  68. https://newsroom.co.nz/2023/03/30/evidence-nash-breached-official-information-act/
  69. https://www.odt.co.nz/news/national/nash-breaks-silence-i-got-wrong-too-many-times
  70. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/stuart-nash-report-released
  71. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/492084/stuart-nash-did-not-share-confidential-information-with-other-donors-probe-finds
  72. https://democracyproject.nz/2023/06/19/bryce-edwards-the-troubling-report-into-stuart-nashs-conflicts-of-interest/
  73. https://democracyproject.nz/2023/03/29/bryce-edwards-nashs-sacking-means-a-deeper-probe-into-cabinet-insider-trading-is-required/
  74. https://newsroom.co.nz/2021/06/08/donations-create-conflict-issue-for-nashs-forestry-portfolio/
  75. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/hawkes-bay-today/news/napier-mp-stuart-nash-says-forestry-donations-involve-no-conflict-of-interest/64LNGR326VLHJHW7HW3S4IUOFA/
  76. https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/350470121/questions-raised-over-donations-received-by-stuart-nash-from-timber-forestry-industry
  77. https://www.beehive.govt.nz/release/review-stuart-nash%25E2%2580%2599s-communications-donors
  78. https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/360818390/stuart-nash-offers-crude-definition-what-woman
  79. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/572769/former-labour-mp-stuart-nash-resigns-after-comment-about-women
  80. https://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/news/politics/ex-mp-stuart-nash-s-employer-begins-formal-review-into-deeply-inappropriate-remarks-about-women/
  81. https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/360819476/ex-labour-minister-stuart-nashs-comments-crude-and-crass-ruth-richardson
  82. https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/360820813/former-labour-mp-stuart-nash-resigns-after-comment-about-women
  83. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/573470/a-distraction-stuart-nash-dumped-from-us-trade-trip-after-crude-comments
  84. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/stuart-nash-swears-at-trade-minister-todd-mcclay-after-being-thrown-off-business-delegation/EXOAFQ6GMJEYTJTDLFMSPWY3VA/
  85. https://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/BU2309/S00381/former-cabinet-minister-stuart-nash-to-join-global-recruitment-company-robert-walters.htm
  86. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/sacked-cabinet-minister-stuart-nashs-new-corporate-gig-revealed/D37RJOXD4JBJXJN3SK44F5XYLU/
  87. https://www.nashkellyglobal.com/
  88. https://www.nashkellyglobal.com/about-us
  89. https://www.nashkellyglobal.com/government-advisory
  90. https://nz.linkedin.com/in/stuartnash
  91. https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/360815495/former-labour-minister-stuart-nash-declares-allegiance-nz-first
  92. https://www.newstalkzb.co.nz/on-air/the-country/audio/stuart-nash-former-labour-mp-on-his-move-to-nz-first/
  93. https://www.stuff.co.nz/politics/360815550/former-labour-mp-stuart-nash-guest-speaker-nz-firsts-annual-meeting
  94. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/political/572298/former-labour-mp-stuart-nash-not-closing-door-on-campaigning-for-nz-first
  95. https://www.thepost.co.nz/politics/360815536/nz-first-and-stuart-nash-want-make-labours-life-harder
  96. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/what-stuart-nashs-gaffe-means-for-nz-first-somethings-cooking-in-te-pati-maori-audrey-young/4VB6Z2332ZDV3MIHOYYKUZNN5A/
  97. https://www.interest.co.nz/public-policy/135181/political-parties-are-struggling-find-reliable-talent-fill-their-ranks-nz
  98. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dklEGg_KHT8
  99. https://newsroom.co.nz/2025/01/24/our-political-forebears-would-roll-in-their-graves-well-let-them-roll/
  100. https://www.marketwatch.com/press-release/new-zealand-eases-foreign-buyer-ban-with-exemption-for-golden-visa-holders-reform-championed-by-stuart-nash-of-nash-kelly-global-fad2a2cc
  101. https://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/politics/a-person-with-a-py-and-a-pair-of-ts-winston-peters-unimpressed-with-potential-nz-first-mp-stuart-nashs-woman-description/C3QN43Y5ONFV7OUTXI5HEEPANQ/
  102. https://www.iheart.com/podcast/211-heather-du-plessis-allan-d-24837940/episode/the-huddle-does-stuart-nash-have-293662139/
  103. https://fairpolicycommentary.substack.com/p/stuart-nash-and-his-political-future
  104. https://theplatform.kiwi/podcasts/episode/stuart-nash-on-his-potential-return-to-politics-nz-first-conference
  105. https://thespinoff.co.nz/the-bulletin/08-09-2025/a-rough-weekend-for-labour-as-smaller-parties-muscle-in
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.