Recent from talks
Nothing was collected or created yet.
The Stone Roses (album)
View on Wikipedia
| The Stone Roses | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio album by | ||||
| Released | 2 May 1989[1] | |||
| Recorded | June 1988 – February 1989 | |||
| Studio | ||||
| Genre | ||||
| Length | 48:20 | |||
| Label | Silvertone | |||
| Producer |
| |||
| The Stone Roses chronology | ||||
| ||||
| Singles from The Stone Roses | ||||
| ||||
The Stone Roses is the debut studio album by the English rock band the Stone Roses. It was recorded mostly at Battery Studios in London with producer John Leckie from June 1988 to February 1989 and released later that year on 2 May by Silvertone Records.
Despite not being an immediate success, the album grew popular alongside the band's high-profile concert performances, which also helped establish them as fixtures of the Madchester and baggy cultural scenes. The record's critical standing also improved significantly in later years, with The Stone Roses now considered to be one of the greatest albums of all time. It was voted number 11 in the third edition of Colin Larkin's All Time Top 1000 Albums (2000). It has sold over four million copies worldwide.
Background
[edit]Based in Manchester, where the so-called Madchester musical movement was centred, the Stone Roses formed in 1983. Between their formation and the release of their debut album, the band had gone through different names and line-ups, trying out different sounds,[4] and released several singles on several different labels.
Bassist Mani was a fan of producer John Leckie's work with the Dukes of Stratosphear and suggested the band work with him.[5] Leckie found the band's demos for the album to be poor, noting that the tempos were too fast and there was too much reverb on the vocals.[6]
The recording took place primarily at Battery Studios in London, with additional sessions at Konk, Coconut Grove Studios in Stockport, and Rockfield Studios in Wales.[7] Leckie said that the band were "very well rehearsed" and that they "didn't seem to feel any pressure other than that they were a band making their first album and didn't want to lose the opportunity to make it good. So there wasn't any pressure to prove themselves – they knew they were good."[4] However, in a 2024 interview, Leckie commented that the band and the material were still rough when recording began, and that "I had to rehearse them and rearrange songs, giving them intros and outros, and steady tempos."[6]
Guitarist John Squire primarily used a Fender Stratocaster plugged into a Fender Twin Reverb amplifier and he occasionally employed Ibanez overdrive and chorus pedals.[6][8] Mani played a Rickenbacker bass through an Ampeg SVT bass amp.[8]
"I Am the Resurrection" was originally supposed to end with a loud, feedback-drenched coda akin to how the band performed it live, but Leckie advised them that it would sound "boring" on the album and that they should instead "do something melodic that people will remember."[6]
Squire and singer Ian Brown were unhappy with the finished mix, wanting the bass and drums to be louder and the guitars to sound "more devastating".[6] Leckie attributes this to the fact that Brown and Squire were listening to Public Enemy on "full blast" in the studio.[6]
Music and lyrics
[edit]According to writers Sean Sennett and Simon Groth, the Stone Roses "virtually invented 'Madchester' and built a template for Brit-pop" with their debut album.[9] The record has been associated with rave culture and dance music, although Angus Batey from The Quietus argued that it was a 1960s-inspired jangle pop album featuring little or no influence of dance beats or grooves, with the exception of "Fools Gold".[10] According to AllMusic's Stephen Thomas Erlewine, the rhythm section of bassist Mani and drummer Reni played in a manner that was merely suggestive of dance rhythms, while Ian Brown dispassionately sang lyrics expressing arrogant sentiments such as "I Wanna Be Adored" and "I Am the Resurrection".[11] In the opinion of Spin critic Andrew Unterberger, it sounded more like "an exercise in rock classicism", featuring accessible melodies like those of the Beatles and resonant guitars similar to the Byrds, along with "the cheeky (and quintessentially British) humor of the Smiths" and "the self-fulfilling arrogance of the Sex Pistols".[12] The melody for the song "Elizabeth My Dear" was appropriated from the English traditional ballad "Scarborough Fair".[13]
Artwork
[edit]As with most Stone Roses releases, the cover displays a work by the band's guitarist John Squire, in this case a Jackson Pollock-influenced piece titled "Bye Bye Badman", which makes reference to the May 1968 riots in Paris. The cover was named by Q magazine as one of "The 100 Best Record Covers of All Time." In the accompanying article, Squire said: "Ian [Brown] had met this French man when he was hitching around Europe, this bloke had been in the riots, and he told Ian how lemons had been used as an antidote to tear gas. Then there was the documentary—a great shot at the start of a guy throwing stones at the police. I really liked his attitude."[14] The story was also the inspiration for the lyrics to the song of the same name.[14] The background of the piece is based on the Giant's Causeway in Northern Ireland; the band had visited the causeway while playing a gig at the University of Ulster in Coleraine.[15] After his death in 2025, Mani's coffin was decorated with the artwork.[16]
Release and promotion
[edit]The Stone Roses was released on 2 May 1989[17] by Silvertone, a division of Zomba Records created to work with "new rock" acts.[18] While by this time the Madchester scene had already attracted some coverage from music publications, The Stone Roses originally received little attention from both consumers and critics in the United Kingdom.[19] Bob Stanley from Melody Maker called it "godlike" and said the foundation of the music was John Squire's guitar playing, which he deemed "beautifully flowing, certainly psychedelic, there are elements of Hendrix (especially on 'Shoot You Down') and Marr (check the fade to 'Bye Bye Badman'), but the rest is the lad's own work".[20] In Q, Peter Kane was less favourable and felt that The Stone Roses was a promising album weighed down by "strangely monotone production",[21] while NME journalist Jack Barron wrote that it was merely "quite good" while giving it a score of seven on a scale of 10;[22] the latter magazine later ranked it as the second best record of 1989 in their year-end list.[19] In The Village Voice, US critic Robert Christgau wrote that the group was "overhyped" and no different from the numerous American indie bands, asking "what do they do that the Byrds and the Buffalo Springfield weren't doing better in 1967?" He concluded that "they're surprisingly 'eclectic.' Not all that good at it, but eclectic," despite some moments of good songwriting ("Bye Bye Badman", "I Wanna Be Adored").[23]
To support the album, the band played several high-profile gigs, including one on 27 February 1989, at what was regarded as the centre of the associated Madchester and baggy scenes, Manchester's The Haçienda nightclub. Andrew Collins wrote in NME: "Bollocks to Morrissey at Wolverhampton, to The Sundays at The Falcon, to PWEI at Brixton – I'm already drafting a letter to my grandchildren telling them that I saw The Stone Roses at the Haçienda."[24] The band's debut appearance on Top of the Pops in November 1989 helped the album receive more mainstream exposure.[19] The album eventually brought them nationwide success and soon the band, along with fellow Madchester group Happy Mondays, were perceived as one of the key acts of the baggy scene.[25] Their May 1990 Spike Island gig, organised by the band and attended by over 27,000 fans, also holds a formidable reputation. Critics have frequently labelled it the "Woodstock of the baggy generation".[26] The Stone Roses has sold over four million copies worldwide, according to the 2006 book covering the album for the 33⅓ music series.[27]
Legacy and reappraisal
[edit]| Review scores | |
|---|---|
| Source | Rating |
| AllMusic | |
| The Daily Telegraph | |
| Mojo | |
| NME | 10/10[30] |
| Pitchfork | 10/10[31] |
| Q | |
| Rolling Stone | |
| Spin | 10/10[34] |
| Spin Alternative Record Guide | 9/10[35] |
| Uncut | |
The Stone Roses was acclaimed by critics and musicians in subsequent years,[19] being viewed as an even more important album than when it was first released, as reflected by its high ranking in polls of the greatest albums of all time.[36] Reassessing it for NME upon its 1991 re-release, Mary Anne Hobbs deemed The Stone Roses "the most fluent crossover album of the last decade", and on its cultural impact, wrote: "Indie-dance was activated, its underground sister the rave scene outed, and Britain went Baggy."[30] Rolling Stone's David Fricke later called it "a blast of magnificent arrogance, a fusion of Sixties-pop sparkle and the blown-mind drive of U.K. rave culture",[33] while BBC Music's Chris Jones said it served as a peerless testament to the fusion of rock and dance music inspired by "working class hedonism" at the end of the 1980s.[37]
Mojo reviewer Pat Gilbert strongly recommended its 1999 reissue to listeners and stated that the album "set the tone for rock music in the '90s",[38] while in Q, Ian Gittins wrote that with the album's "mercurial, timeless anthems", the band became "spokesmen for their generation".[32] Bernadette McNulty of The Daily Telegraph believed the 2009 reissue polished the band's bold mix of discordant psychedelic sounds and clever dance beats, but that its legacy as a fabled debut album was enhanced more by the darker, masculine music that followed in Manchester during the 1990s.[28] Zeth Lundy of The Boston Phoenix said it "has been deified by such dubious tastemakers as the NME and Oasis's Noel Gallagher — and the rest of us really like it too".[39] PopMatters critic Jennifer Makowsky argued that "the psychedelic, drug-powered pop songs on the album earned the band a well-earned place in alternative music history."[40]
There have also been a few minority opinions questioning the critical acclaim that the album has received. American music journalist Jim DeRogatis felt The Stone Roses had been highly overrated by critics, pointing to a "lame retread disco beat" and "oh-so-dated chiming guitars",[41] while Neil Kulkarni from The Quietus said its first three songs were enjoyable but preceded a "right barrel-load of shite afterwards".[42] In an article on overhyped records for The Guardian, Peter Robinson said that The Stone Roses was "an average rock album – lyrically pedestrian and with a sonic policy swerving from the play-safe to the over-indulgent".[43] Fiona Sturges of The Independent found Brown's singing and the band's lyrics to be remarkably poor, and objected to the editors of NME voting The Stone Roses the best British album of all time.[44] After the record was voted the second-best ever in a UK public poll, Channel 4 broadcast a presentation of the results in which three of the presenters—musician Bob Geldof, critic Paul Gambaccini, and artist Justine Frischmann—were critical of the album's inclusion in the top 100 and attributed it to the generation of listeners who voted rather than the record's quality.[45][46]
Accolades
[edit]In 1997, The Stone Roses was named the second greatest album of all time in a "Music of the Millennium" poll conducted by HMV, Channel 4, The Guardian and Classic FM.[46] In 1998, Q magazine readers placed it at number 4,[47] while in 2000 the same magazine placed it at number 29 in its list of the "100 Greatest British Albums Ever."[48] In 2004, the album was voted the best British album of all time in The Observer's poll of 100 musicians and critics.[49] In 2006, Q placed the album at number 5 in its list of "40 Best Albums of the '80s".[50] In 2008, it was named the fifth "greatest British album ever" by a Q magazine/HMV poll.[51]
In 2000, it received the "greatest album ever" award at the NME Premier Awards show, and in 2006, the album topped the magazine's "100 Greatest British Albums Ever" list.[52] In 2005, Spin magazine ranked it 78 on its list of the "100 greatest albums of the past twenty years."[53] In the same year, when revising their list of the "500 Greatest Albums of All Time" for book format, Rolling Stone included it as one of eight new entries, placing it at number 497; in the 2012 revised list, they placed the album at number 498, saying that the album "single-handedly launched Nineties Brit pop", and in the 2020 update of the list the album's rank climbed to number 319.[54][55] In 2006, Time named it one of "The All-TIME 100 Albums".[56] In 2003, Pitchfork named it the 39th best album of the 1980s.[57] In 2012, Slant Magazine listed the album at number 28 on its list of "Best Albums of the 1980s".[58] The album was also included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die.[59] It was voted number 11 in the third edition of Colin Larkin's All Time Top 1000 Albums (2000).[60]
In 2006, British Hit Singles & Albums and NME organised a poll of which, 40,000 people worldwide voted for the 100 best albums ever and The Stone Roses was placed at number seven on the list.[61] In 2010, The Stone Roses won the Mojo Classic Album award. Upon announcing the award, Mojo noted how the band "managed to sum up an era and to create a piece of work that also transcends the time in which it was made."[62] In 2013 The Flaming Lips and friends honoured the record with The Time Has Come to Shoot You Down… What a Sound, a reworking of the entire album.[63] In 2014, the staff of PopMatters included the album on their list of "12 Essential Alternative Rock Albums from the 1980s".[40] In 2013, the album ranked number 7 on NME's The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.[64]
In 2020, it came third in the BBC Radio 2 "Ultimate 80's Album" poll,[65] beating albums such as "Thriller" by Michael Jackson, "Appetite for Destruction" by Guns N' Roses and "Purple Rain" by Prince. The listeners poll, which had "tens of thousands of votes", had a list of 50 albums to choose from that were selected by a panel of music experts. The shortlist was based on sales from each year of the decade, alongside a selection of albums that have endured the test of time.[citation needed] In 2025, Radio X included the album in its list of "The 25 best indie debut albums of the 1980s".[66]
Re-releases
[edit]
In 1999, on the 10th anniversary of its release, a two-disc special edition re-release of The Stone Roses reached number nine on the UK Albums Chart. In 2007, a remastered version was released by Silvertone as a Carbon Neutral Entertainment CD (with tips about Energy Saving). In 2009, the remastered 20th anniversary edition was released in several formats: the standard 11-track album (with the bonus track "Fools Gold") on CD and 12" vinyl LP (the LP version includes a bonus one-sided 7" single featuring the unreleased demo track "Pearl Bastard"); a deluxe edition 2CD/1DVD set, featuring the album on disc one, a 15-track collection of unreleased demos titled The Lost Demos on disc two, and a DVD featuring a 1989 live performance titled Live in Blackpool; and a 3CD/3LP/1DVD collector's edition box set, which features:[67]
- The remastered 11-track album on one CD and one LP
- The Lost Demos on one CD
- The B-sides on one CD
- Two LPs
- Live in Blackpool DVD
- A 48-page booklet, containing unpublished photos and new interviews
- Six 12"-sized art prints featuring John Squire's original single artwork
- A lemon-shaped USB stick, featuring digital files of:
- The album, the demos, and the B-sides
- Five previously unreleased "backwards tracks"
- Six music videos
- Up at Sawmills: The Making of Fools Gold documentary video
- Exclusive desktop wallpapers, ringtones, and a 48-page digital booklet
Track listing
[edit]All tracks are written by Ian Brown and John Squire.
| No. | Title | Length |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | "I Wanna Be Adored" | 4:52 |
| 2. | "She Bangs the Drums" | 3:43 |
| 3. | "Waterfall" | 4:37 |
| 4. | "Don't Stop" | 5:17 |
| 5. | "Bye Bye Badman" | 4:04 |
| 6. | "Elizabeth My Dear" | 0:53 |
| 7. | "(Song for My) Sugar Spun Sister" | 3:25 |
| 8. | "Made of Stone" | 4:10 |
| 9. | "Shoot You Down" | 4:10 |
| 10. | "This Is the One" | 4:58 |
| 11. | "I Am the Resurrection" | 8:12 |
All tracks are written by Ian Brown and John Squire.
| No. | Title | Length |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | "I Wanna Be Adored" | 4:52 |
| 2. | "She Bangs the Drums" | 3:43 |
| 3. | "Elephant Stone" | 3:00 |
| 4. | "Waterfall" | 4:37 |
| 5. | "Don't Stop" | 5:17 |
| 6. | "Bye Bye Badman" | 4:04 |
| 7. | "Elizabeth My Dear" | 0:53 |
| 8. | "(Song for My) Sugar Spun Sister" | 3:25 |
| 9. | "Made of Stone" | 4:10 |
| 10. | "Shoot You Down" | 4:10 |
| 11. | "This Is the One" | 4:58 |
| 12. | "I Am the Resurrection" | 8:12 |
| 13. | "Fools Gold" | 9:53 |
Note: The song "Elephant Stone" had been previously released as a single in October 1988 in the UK only, but was added to the US pressings of the album. The album was reissued later in 1989 with Fools Gold added.
Personnel
[edit]Credits are adapted from the album's liner notes.[68]
The Stone Roses
- Ian Brown – vocals
- Mani – bass guitar
- Reni – drums, backing vocals, piano on "She Bangs the Drums"
- John Squire – guitars, backing vocals on "She Bangs the Drums"
Production
- Peter Hook – production on "Elephant Stone"
- John Leckie – production, mixing engineering on "Elephant Stone"
- Paul Schroeder – engineering
- John Squire – artwork
Charts
[edit]| Chart (1989–90) | Peak position |
|---|---|
| Australian Albums (ARIA)[69] | 36 |
| Dutch Albums (Album Top 100)[70] | 44 |
| New Zealand Albums (RMNZ)[71] | 11 |
| Norwegian Albums (VG-lista)[72] | 12 |
| Swedish Albums (Sverigetopplistan)[73] | 30 |
| UK Albums (OCC)[74] | 19 |
| US Billboard 200[75] | 86 |
| Chart (2004) | Peak position |
|---|---|
| UK Albums (OCC)[74] | 9 |
| Chart (2009) | Peak position |
|---|---|
| UK Albums (OCC)[74] | 5 |
Certifications
[edit]| Region | Certification | Certified units/sales |
|---|---|---|
| United Kingdom (BPI)[1] | 5× Platinum | 1,500,000‡ |
|
‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone. | ||
References
[edit]- Footnotes
- ^ a b "British album certifications – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses". British Phonographic Industry. Retrieved 28 January 2024.
- ^ Bugelsteiber, Christopher (28 March 2025). "Formation and Members of The Stone Roses". Club Madchester. Retrieved 11 April 2025.
- ^ Gwinn, Ian (10 August 2018). "Remembering 1968: May '68 and The Stone Roses' The Stone Roses". History Workshop Online. Retrieved 23 July 2023.
- ^ a b Howard, Tom (2 May 2019). "Unpicking the brilliance of The Stone Roses' classic debut album, 30 years since its glorious release". NME. Retrieved 16 February 2021.
- ^ "Flashback: March 1989". The Guardian. 15 March 2009. Archived from the original on 27 November 2024. Retrieved 18 April 2025.
Mani had an album by Dukes of Stratosphear, alter egos of XTC, and said: 'Listen to that, whoever's done it is a genius, because he's got those late 60s psychedelic sounds on it.' I didn't like it but knew it was clever, so we settled on John Leckie as the producer.
- ^ a b c d e f Aston, Martin (2 May 2024). "Inside The Making Of The Stone Roses' Debut Album: "Of course, John and Ian hated the record."". Mojo Magazine. Archived from the original on 4 December 2024. Retrieved 18 April 2025.
- ^ Robb 2012, pp. 211–215.
- ^ a b Frost, Matt (26 September 2022). "Producer John Leckie looks back on recording The Stone Roses classic I Am The Resurrection: "I knew it was going to be good, but I didn't think I'd still be talking about it years later!"". musicradar. Archived from the original on 13 January 2025. Retrieved 4 May 2025.
- ^ Sennett & Groth 2010, p. 64.
- ^ Batey, Angus (11 December 2014). "The Resurrection Show: The Stone Roses' Second Coming Revisited". The Quietus. Retrieved 6 October 2015.
- ^ a b Erlewine, Stephen Thomas. "The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses". AllMusic. Retrieved 6 July 2014.
- ^ "The 300 Best Albums of the Past 30 Years (1985–2014)". Spin. 11 May 2015. p. 3. Retrieved 6 October 2015.
- ^ Robb 2012, p. 241.
- ^ a b "The 100 Best Record Covers of All Time". Q (special ed.). London. 2001.
- ^ "'Bye Bye Badman'". john-squire.com. Archived from the original on 7 April 2013. Retrieved 10 March 2017.
- ^ Glynn, Paul (22 December 2025). "Stone Roses' Mani's star-studded Manchester send-off". BBC News. Retrieved 22 December 2025.
- ^ Robb 2012, p. 238.
- ^ Strong 2004.
- ^ a b c d e Kelly, Danny (September 2009). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". Uncut. No. 148. London. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
- ^ Stanley, Bob (29 April 1989). "Love Resurrection". Melody Maker. London. p. 33.
- ^ Kane, Peter (May 1989). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". Q. No. 32. London.
- ^ Barron, Jack (29 April 1989). "Rock Follies". NME. London. p. 33.
- ^ Christgau, Robert (29 May 1990). "Consumer Guide". The Village Voice. New York. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
- ^ Tilton 2013.
- ^ Larkin 2011.
- ^ Dower, John (director) (2003). Live Forever: The Rise and Fall of Brit Pop. Passion Pictures.
- ^ Green 2006.
- ^ a b McNulty, Bernadette (20 August 2009). "Stone Roses: The Stone Roses, CD review". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 27 October 2009. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
- ^ Savage, Jon (September 2009). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". Mojo. No. 190. London.
- ^ a b Hobbs, Mary Anne (21 September 1991). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". NME. London. p. 34.
- ^ Granzin, Amy (11 September 2009). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". Pitchfork. Retrieved 27 November 2011.
- ^ a b Gittins, Ian (December 1999). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". Q. No. 159. London. p. 164. Archived from the original on 12 December 2000. Retrieved 27 April 2019.
- ^ a b Fricke, David (20 August 2009). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses: Legacy Edition". Rolling Stone. No. 1085. New York. p. 84. Archived from the original on 16 August 2009. Retrieved 16 August 2009.
- ^ Hultkrans, Andrew (September 2009). "Reissues". Spin. Vol. 25, no. 9. New York. p. 86. Retrieved 11 November 2018.
- ^ Bernstein 1995, pp. 376–377.
- ^ Jones 2008, p. 96.
- ^ Jones, Chris (8 May 2007). "The Stone Roses The Stone Roses Review". BBC Music. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
- ^ Gilbert, Pat (December 1999). "The Stone Roses: The Stone Roses". Mojo. No. 73. London. p. 103.
- ^ Lundy, Zeth (15 September 2009). "Review: The Stone Roses". The Boston Phoenix. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
- ^ a b "Hope Despite the Times: 12 Essential Alternative Rock Albums from the 1980s". PopMatters. 27 August 2014. p. 2. Archived from the original on 22 January 2018. Retrieved 27 October 2015.
- ^ DeRogatis, Jim (20 June 2004). "The view from America". The Observer. London. Archived from the original on 24 September 2014. Retrieved 15 September 2014.
{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link) - ^ Kulkarni, Neil (19 August 2009). "The Stone Roses". The Quietus. Retrieved 17 March 2012.
- ^ Robinson, Peter (4 December 2004). "Don't believe the hype". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 12 September 2014.
- ^ Sturges, Fiona (14 August 2009). "The Stone Roses – A 'classic' that is nothing but fool's gold". The Independent. London. Archived from the original on 18 June 2022. Retrieved 27 June 2014.
- ^ Music of the Millennium. Episode 4. 29 January 1998. Channel 4.
Bob Geldof: "Number two? Forget it, that's ridiculous. They shouldn't be in there: they have a decent album – good luck to them – but that's preposterous...it's, hey, a generation thing, man."
Justine Frischmann: "Isn't it?"
Paul Gambaccini: "Exactly. This tells you who voted, more than anything else." - ^ a b "Spin of the Century". Irishtimes.com. 31 January 1998. Retrieved 17 March 2019.
- ^ "Q Readers' All Time Top 100 Albums". Q (137). February 1998.
- ^ "The 100 Greatest British Albums Ever". Q (165). June 2000.
- ^ "Stone Roses 'top British album'". BBC News. 20 June 2004. Retrieved 30 October 2006.
- ^ "40 Best Albums of the '80s". Q (241). August 2006.
- ^ "Oasis top best British album poll". BBC News. 18 February 2008. Retrieved 25 May 2010.
- ^ "NME's best British album of all time revealed". NME. 26 January 2006. Retrieved 30 October 2006.
- ^ "100 Greatest Albums, 1985–2005". Spin. 20 June 2005. Archived from the original on 4 August 2009. Retrieved 5 October 2009.
- ^ "The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time". Rolling Stone. 22 September 2020. Archived from the original on 8 February 2023.
- ^ Wenner, Jann S., ed. (2012). Rolling Stone – Special Collectors Issue – The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time. USA: Wenner Media Specials. ISBN 978-7-09-893419-6
- ^ "The All-TIME 100 Albums". Time. 2 November 2006. Retrieved 25 May 2010.
- ^ "Pitchfork Feature: Top 100 Albums of the 1980s". Pitchfork. 20 November 2002. Archived from the original on 23 January 2013. Retrieved 12 January 2012.
- ^ "The 100 Best Albums of the 1980s". Slant Magazine. 5 March 2012. Retrieved 12 January 2012.
- ^ Robert Dimery; Michael Lydon (7 February 2006). 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die: Revised and Updated Edition. Universe. ISBN 0-7893-1371-5.
- ^ Colin Larkin, ed. (2000). All Time Top 1000 Albums (3rd ed.). Virgin Books. p. 39. ISBN 0-7535-0493-6.
- ^ "Oasis album voted greatest of all time". The Times. London. 1 June 2006. Archived from the original on 8 April 2007. Retrieved 27 November 2011.
- ^ "MOJO Honours List 2010: The Winners Revealed!". Mojo. 10 June 2010. Archived from the original on 13 June 2010. Retrieved 27 November 2011.
- ^ ""The Stone Roses" Remake Confirmed for Black Friday – Tracklist, Photos, Videos". The Future Heart. 15 November 2013. Retrieved 15 November 2013.
- ^ "The 500 Greatest Albums Of All Time: 100-1". NME. 25 October 2013.
- ^ Davies, Gary (11 October 2020). "Your Ultimate 80s Album – Revealed!". BBC. Retrieved 11 October 2020.
- ^ "The 25 best indie debut albums of the 1980s". Radio X. Retrieved 9 September 2025.
- ^ The Stone Roses (box set). The Stone Roses. Silvertone Records. 2009. 88697430302.
{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link) - ^ The Stone Roses (liner notes). The Stone Roses. Silvertone Records. 1989. ORE LP 502.
{{cite AV media notes}}: CS1 maint: others in cite AV media (notes) (link) - ^ "Australiancharts.com – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses". Hung Medien. Retrieved 3 March 2017.
- ^ "Dutchcharts.nl – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses" (in Dutch). Hung Medien. Retrieved 3 March 2017.
- ^ "Charts.nz – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses". Hung Medien. Retrieved 3 March 2017.
- ^ "Norwegiancharts.com – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses". Hung Medien. Retrieved 3 March 2017.
- ^ "Swedishcharts.com – The Stone Roses – The Stone Roses". Hung Medien. Retrieved 3 March 2017.
- ^ a b c "Stone Roses Songs and Albums | Full Official Chart History". Official Charts Company. Retrieved 7 August 2020.
- ^ "The Stone Roses Chart History (Billboard 200)". Billboard. Retrieved 23 May 2008.
- Bibliography
- Bernstein, Jonathan (1995). "Stone Roses". In Weisbard, Eric; Marks, Craig (eds.). Spin Alternative Record Guide. Vintage Books. ISBN 0-679-75574-8.
- Green, Alex (2006). The Stone Roses. A & C Black. ISBN 0826417426.
- Jones, Carys Wyn (2008). The Rock Canon: Canonical Values in the Reception of Rock Albums. Ashgate Publishing. ISBN 978-0754662440. Retrieved 9 July 2014.
- Larkin, Colin (2011). "Stone Roses". The Encyclopedia of Popular Music (5th concise ed.). Omnibus Press. ISBN 978-0857125958.
- Robb, John (2012). The Stone Roses and the Resurrection of British Pop: The Reunion Edition. Random House. ISBN 978-1448118793. Retrieved 6 October 2015.
- Sennett, Sean; Groth, Simon (2010). Off the Record: 25 Years of Music Street Press. University of Queensland Press. ISBN 978-0702246531.
- Strong, Martin C. (2004). The Great Rock Discography. Canongate Books. ISBN 1841956155.
- Tilton, Ian (2013). Set in Stone: Ian Tilton's Stone Roses Photographs. Music Sales Group. ISBN 978-0857127853.
External links
[edit]- The Stone Roses at Discogs (list of releases)
- The Stone Roses at MusicBrainz
- The Stone Roses (Adobe Flash) at Radio3Net (streamed copy where licensed)
The Stone Roses (album)
View on GrokipediaOrigins and Production
Band Formation and Early Influences
The Stone Roses originated in Altrincham, Greater Manchester, where vocalist Ian Brown and guitarist John Squire first connected as classmates at Altrincham Grammar School for Boys, bonding over shared enthusiasm for punk and post-punk acts such as The Clash and Sex Pistols.[10] They assembled the band's embryonic lineup as The Patrol in 1983, featuring Brown on vocals, Squire on guitar, bassist Pete Garner, and rotating drummers amid the local post-punk scene.[10] Drummer Alan "Reni" Wren joined in 1984, introducing a more dynamic rhythm section, while rhythm guitarist Andy Couzens completed the early configuration; the group rebranded as The Stone Roses around 1985 and performed their debut show that year at Manchester's Moonlight Club.[11][10] The band's nascent sound drew from a broad palette, including 1960s psychedelia via The Byrds and Jimi Hendrix, 1970s hard rock like Led Zeppelin, and funk alongside dub reggae influences such as Augustus Pablo and Sly & Robbie, which particularly appealed to Brown and shaped their rhythmic experimentation.[10][11] Punk persistence manifested in admiration for local outfits like Slaughter and the Dogs, whose Wythenshawe origins and semi-success fueled aspirations for Manchester breakout, while broader post-punk echoes from The Smiths and New Order informed their jangly guitar textures and indie edge.[12][10] These elements coalesced into an evolving fusion of aggressive riffs, danceable grooves, and psychedelic flair, distinct from the emerging house-dominated Madchester milieu yet primed for its rock-dance synthesis.[13] Personnel shifts refined this foundation: Couzens exited in 1986 amid stylistic clashes, shifting to roadie duties, and Garner departed the following year, supplanted by bassist Gary "Mani" Mounfield—formerly of Primal Scream—who injected funk precision and bass drive drawn from his mod-punk background.[10] The resultant quartet of Brown, Squire, Mani, and Reni, stabilized by 1987, channeled these influences into potent singles like "Sally Cinnamon" (1987), bridging raw punk energy with psychedelic pop structures en route to their self-titled debut.[11][10]Pre-Album Singles and Development
The Stone Roses' earliest recording, the double A-side single "So Young"/"Tell Me", was released in September 1985 on the independent Thin Line Records label as a limited 12-inch vinyl pressing of approximately 500 copies.[14] Produced by Martin Hannett, known for his work with Joy Division and New Order, the tracks showcased the band's initial post-punk and garage rock leanings, with raw guitar work from John Squire and Ian Brown's nascent vocal style.[15] This debut received minimal commercial attention but marked the group's first step beyond local Manchester gigs. The band's second single, "Sally Cinnamon", emerged on 28 May 1987 via FM Revolver Records, shifting toward a more melodic, jangly guitar sound influenced by 1960s psychedelia and contemporaries like The Smiths.[16] Written primarily by vocalist Ian Brown, the song's unrequited love theme and extended structure—clocking in at over five minutes—garnered airplay on John Peel's BBC Radio 1 show and peaked at number 46 on the UK Indie Chart, fostering a growing cult following in the North West England indie scene.[17] B-sides like "Trading Up" and "All for One" further demonstrated evolving songcraft, though sales remained limited to around 1,000 copies initially. Post-"Sally Cinnamon", lineup adjustments solidified the group's core: guitarist Andy Couzens exited in late 1987 amid creative tensions, with bassist Gary "Mani" Mounfield joining from The Mock Turtles, while drummer Alan "Reni" Wren had already integrated by 1986, replacing earlier members.[18] Intensive live performances across Manchester venues, amid the emerging "Madchester" acid house crossover, allowed refinement of psychedelic-tinged rock material, drawing from influences like The Doors and Jimi Hendrix. In 1988, after fielding offers from major labels, they signed a £100,000 deal with Silvertone Records, enabling professional demos and the October release of "Elephant Stone"—produced by Peter Hook—which introduced baggy rhythms and echoed album tracks like "I Wanna Be Adored", signaling readiness for full-length recording at Battery Studios in London.[3]Recording Process and Technical Details
The Stone Roses' debut album was recorded primarily at Battery Studios in London, with producer John Leckie overseeing sessions that spanned from June 1988 to February 1989.[13] Initial tracking began with a week at Battery on or around June 17, 1988, capturing foundational elements amid the band's relative inexperience and limited budget constraints.[19] Leckie, drawn to the band's raw potential after producing their early single "So Young," focused on preserving their live energy while refining arrangements, often working with pre-existing demos transferred from lower-fidelity formats.[20] Supplementary recording occurred at Konk Studios in London and Rockfield Studios in Monmouthshire, Wales, to accommodate overdubs, additional instrumentation, and experimentation with the band's psychedelic influences.[3] Guitarist John Squire predominantly used a Fender Stratocaster through a Fender Twin Reverb amplifier, emphasizing clean tones and subtle effects to achieve the album's jangling, reverb-drenched sound, though he explored various amps and guitars during the process.[3] Bassist Mani and drummer Reni laid down rhythms emphasizing groove and space, with Leckie prioritizing minimal overdubs to maintain organic feel. Technical aspects centered on Battery's facilities, including an 82-channel Trident Series 80B mixing console and a 24-track Otari MTR90 Mk II tape machine for multitrack recording, which allowed for layered guitars and Ian Brown's distinctive vocal treatments.[13] In-house engineer Paul Schroeder, experienced in dance music mixing, contributed to the final blends, integrating the band's rock elements with subtle electronic textures derived from their Manchester club scene roots.[21] Sessions for tracks like "I Wanna Be Adored" and "She Bangs the Drums" were completed under suboptimal conditions, relying on Leckie's hands-on operation of available 16-track equipment for vocals and overdubs before full production escalation.[20] The process reflected a balance of ambition and pragmatism, yielding a raw yet polished sound without extensive post-production polish.Musical and Lyrical Content
Genre and Sonic Characteristics
The Stone Roses' debut album is classified as alternative rock, incorporating elements of psychedelic pop and dance grooves, which positioned it as a cornerstone of the Madchester scene that blended indie rock with emerging rave culture.[22][23] This fusion reflected the band's Manchester roots amid the late 1980s acid house movement, yielding a sound that prioritized euphoric, groove-oriented rock over strict genre boundaries.[23] Critics have noted its avoidance of pure dance categorization, emphasizing instead a guitar-rock foundation with elastic rhythms suitable for both clubs and traditional rock settings.[21] Sonically, the album features John Squire's layered guitar work, characterized by intricate fingerwork, mighty riffs, cascading arpeggios, and flanged solos reminiscent of Jimi Hendrix, providing psychedelic textures and punchy drive.[22][21] The rhythm section, anchored by Mani's rumbling basslines and Reni's whip-cracking, breakbeat-influenced drums, delivers sly, lockstepping grooves that infuse rock structures with danceable propulsion and clarity.[22][23][21] Ian Brown's vocals add emotional nuance, often delivered in a laid-back, mumbled style that contrasts the instrumentation's vibrancy, contributing to the album's cohesive yet accessible energy.[22] Produced by John Leckie over 55 working days from October 1988 to March 1989 across studios including Battery, Konk, and Rockfield, the album employs meticulous overdubs and careful sequencing for a slick, crystalline sonic profile that enhances low-end rumble and guitar crispness.[22][21] This approach, aided by engineer Paul Schroeder's dance-mixing expertise, ensures rhythmic punch without muddiness, drawing influences from 1960s psychedelia like the Byrds and Buffalo Springfield while integrating contemporary dance sensibilities.[22][21] The result is a bright, broad-spectrum sound that prioritizes euphoric hooks and extended solos, distinguishing it from contemporaneous indie efforts through its seamless rock-dance hybridity.[22][23]Lyrics, Themes, and Song Structures
The lyrics of The Stone Roses, primarily penned by vocalist Ian Brown, exhibit an abstract, impressionistic style marked by fragmented imagery, mumbled delivery, and a blend of Manchester dialect with broader cultural references, evoking a sense of detached coolness and introspection.[23] Common themes include the pursuit of fame and adoration, hedonistic escapism through drugs and romance, anti-establishment sentiment targeting monarchy and authority, and affirmations of Mancunian identity and resilience amid industrial decay.[23][21] These elements draw from the band's immersion in psychedelic rock, acid house, and 1960s counterculture, though Brown's sparse, non-literal phrasing invites multiple interpretations, with some critics viewing it as deliberately enigmatic rather than profoundly philosophical.[24] Song structures on the album typically adhere to rock conventions—verse-chorus frameworks augmented by John Squire's extended guitar passages—but incorporate psychedelic extensions, dynamic builds, and rhythmic grooves influenced by funk and dance music, reflecting the band's live-oriented ethos.[25] For instance, "I Wanna Be Adored" opens the album with a minimalist, hypnotic intro featuring sustained bass and reverb-heavy guitar, progressing through repetitive verses that escalate in intensity before resolving in a swirling coda, thematically satirizing vanity and messianic ego as Brown intones lines like "I don't have to sell my soul / He's already in me."[26] "She Bangs the Drums," a concise rocker clocking in at under three minutes, employs a straightforward verse-chorus structure with propulsive drums and jangling guitars, its lyrics celebrating euphoric romance and timeless youth: "I can feel it, but I can't grasp it," underscoring transient passion.[27] Tracks like "Made of Stone" feature abrupt dynamic shifts, with verses giving way to anthemic choruses and a descending melodic close that defies expectation, thematically probing emotional numbness and resilience in the face of loss or betrayal through surreal queries such as "Are you made of stone?"[24] "This Is the One," inspired by the 1968 Paris student protests according to band accounts, builds from sparse verses to a triumphant, repetitive chorus evoking revolutionary fervor and communal unity, with structure emphasizing rhythmic repetition over complex progression.[28] The album's closer, "I Am the Resurrection," bifurcates into two distinct sections: an initial lyrical portion with defiant, biblically inflected boasts of rebirth and vengeance ("I am the resurrection, come for me"), transitioning at the three-minute mark into an eight-minute instrumental jam dominated by Squire's fluid, effects-laden guitar solos over a loose funk groove, symbolizing triumphant liberation from personal and societal constraints.[25] Shorter pieces like "Daybreak" and "Shoot You Down" maintain tighter structures with verse-bridge resolutions, their lyrics laced with psychedelic drug allusions and sharp romantic barbs, respectively, while "(Song for My) Sugar Spun Sister" and "So Young" fuse baggy rhythms with themes of narcotic highs and defiant adolescence.[23] Overall, the album's lyrical ambiguity and structural expansiveness prioritize mood and groove over narrative clarity, aligning with the band's rejection of rigid songwriting norms in favor of improvisational energy.[21]Artwork and Design
Cover Art Creation and Inspiration
The cover artwork for The Stone Roses was painted by the band's guitarist, John Squire, utilizing an abstract expressionist style influenced by Jackson Pollock's action painting techniques, such as drip and flick methods, to create a vibrant, chaotic green-dominated composition titled Bye Bye Badman.[29][30][31] Squire, who handled visual design for much of the band's output, completed the piece in 1989 ahead of the album's May release on Silvertone Records.[29][32] The geometric patterns within the painting drew partial inspiration from the hexagonal rock formations of the Giant's Causeway in Northern Ireland, a location the band had visited, blending natural elemental motifs with artistic abstraction.[29] Thematically, the artwork connects to the album's track "Bye Bye Badman," which alludes to the May 1968 Paris student riots, during which demonstrators used lemons to neutralize tear gas effects—a detail echoed in the song's lyrics and symbolized on the cover through overlaid French tricolour elements and citrus imagery.[30][28] This integration of historical protest symbolism with Pollock-esque spontaneity underscored the band's fusion of visual art and music, reflecting Squire's broader artistic influences from 1960s counterculture.[33][34]Packaging and Visual Symbolism
The packaging of the 1989 debut album by The Stone Roses incorporated symbolic elements derived from historical protest imagery, most notably through the inclusion of lemon slices within guitarist John Squire's cover artwork. These slices, positioned as abstract motifs with one forming the "O" in "Roses," evoked the May 1968 Paris student riots, during which demonstrators employed lemons to counteract the effects of police tear gas.[35][29] This reference aligned with the album's track "Bye Bye Badman," which Squire confirmed drew lyrical and visual inspiration from the events, positioning the lemons as emblems of defiance and resilience against authority.[35] Initial Silvertone pressings featured an embossed rendition of the band name on the sleeve, providing a tactile emphasis to the visual design and underscoring the artisanal intent behind the physical format.[36] The lemon motif, while primarily integrated into the front artwork, extended into the band's broader iconography associated with the release, appearing on stickers and promotional ephemera to reinforce themes of rebellion and cultural disruption.[35] This symbolic layering contributed to the album's cohesive aesthetic, blending abstract expressionism with politically charged undertones without overt textual explanation in the liner notes.Release and Initial Promotion
Launch Strategy and Distribution
The Stone Roses' self-titled debut album was released on 2 May 1989 by Silvertone Records in the United Kingdom.[2] Silvertone, an imprint of Zomba Records established to sign and develop new rock acts, had inked a five-album contract with the band in 1988 after receiving promising demos previously rejected by labels like Rough Trade.[3][37] The launch strategy centered on building anticipation through a series of independent singles targeted at the indie and emerging Madchester scenes, starting with "Elephant Stone" in October 1988—produced by New Order's Peter Hook—and followed by "Made of Stone" in March 1989.[38] These releases, along with live performances in Manchester's club circuit including at The Haçienda, fostered organic word-of-mouth momentum rather than relying on major label advertising budgets.[38] Supplementary exposure included a January 1989 television performance of "Waterfall" on Tony Wilson's The Other Side of Midnight.[38] Distribution was managed primarily by Silvertone within the UK, leveraging Zomba's infrastructure for domestic retail and radio play, while international variants were handled through licensing partners such as RCA Records for the United States release.[39] Initial overseas rollout was limited, reflecting the label's focus on UK indie markets, with broader availability expanding as critical acclaim grew.[40] The contract's terms, which granted Silvertone significant control over masters and royalties, later contributed to disputes but facilitated the album's entry into specialist stores and charts upon launch.[37]Marketing, Tours, and Live Performances
Silvertone Records, the album's distributor, pursued a low-budget marketing approach emphasizing pre-release singles and point-of-sale materials, such as 24-inch by 24-inch cardboard display artwork featuring the album's cover. The lead promotional single "Made of Stone," released on 6 March 1989, introduced tracks from the album and reached number 90 on the UK Singles Chart, marking the band's first national chart entry despite modest sales. This grassroots strategy, constrained by Silvertone's lack of major-label resources, relied on word-of-mouth buzz within Manchester's indie scene rather than extensive advertising campaigns. Following the album's release on 2 May 1989, The Stone Roses supported it through intensive live performances across the UK, leveraging their reputation for high-energy, chaotic shows to build audience momentum. Notable early post-release gigs included a performance at Preston Guild Hall on 30 May 1989 and a concert at Blackpool Empress Ballroom later that year, the latter broadcast by BBC and later regarded as legendary for capturing the band's raw charisma and crowd engagement. These appearances, often featuring extended jams and frontman Ian Brown's provocative stage presence, helped elevate the album's profile amid initial commercial indifference. By autumn 1989, the band expanded promotion with a European tour, performing in venues such as Valencia, Spain on 23 September, Milan, Italy on 28 September, and Hamburg, West Germany on 3 October. Live sets typically drew heavily from the debut album, with tracks like "I Wanna Be Adored" and "She Bangs the Drums" fostering the Madchester movement's ecstatic atmosphere and contributing to the record's slow-burning word-of-mouth success. The tours underscored the band's strategy of prioritizing visceral, in-person experiences over traditional media hype, as their onstage chemistry—marked by Reni's dynamic drumming and John Squire's psychedelic guitar work—proved instrumental in converting skeptics.Commercial Performance
Sales Figures and Chart Trajectories
Upon its release on 2 May 1989, The Stone Roses entered the UK Albums Chart on 13 May 1989 at number 32, marking a modest debut despite critical acclaim for tracks like "I Wanna Be Adored" and "She Bangs the Drums."[41] The album climbed gradually amid growing buzz from the Madchester scene, reaching its initial peak of number 19 by late 1989, buoyed by the band's live performances and the October 1989 single "Fools Gold/What the World Is Waiting For," which hit number 8 on the UK Singles Chart and retroactively boosted album interest.[41] However, it dropped off the chart after limited weeks, reflecting the era's fragmented indie distribution via Silvertone Records and lack of major label push initially.[6] The album's chart trajectory shifted in 1990 with sustained word-of-mouth and festival appearances, prompting re-entries; it accumulated over 20 weeks on the UK Top 75 by mid-decade, though never cracking the Top 10 during its original run.[41] Reissues, particularly the 2009 remaster, propelled it to a chart high of number 5, with further climbs during anniversary editions—such as number 1 on the Official Vinyl Albums Chart in 2015—and reunion hype in 2016, extending its total UK chart span to 97 weeks in the Top 100 across multiple eras.[42] Internationally, performance was negligible; it peaked at number 36 on the Australian Albums Chart in 1990 but saw no significant US Billboard 200 entry, underscoring its primarily British cult status at launch.[43] Sales accumulated steadily post-release, with the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) certifying the album Gold (100,000 units) by late 1989, followed by Platinum (300,000 units) in 1990, and escalating through multi-platinum awards as demand surged.[44] By the mid-1990s, certifications reached quadruple Platinum, and in recognition of enduring physical and digital equivalent sales, the BPI awarded 5× Platinum status for 1,500,000 units shipped in the UK alone. Worldwide, the album has sold over four million copies, per analysis in the 2006 33⅓ series monograph, driven largely by UK and European markets rather than North America, where it remained a niche import.[45] No major certifications exist outside the UK, aligning with its limited transatlantic breakthrough.[46]Certifications and Market Impact
In the United Kingdom, The Stone Roses was certified 4× Platinum by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI), recognizing shipments of 1,200,000 units as of the mid-1990s. This status was built incrementally through multiple awards issued between 1989 and 1995, starting with Gold for 100,000 units and progressing to Platinum thresholds amid rising demand following the band's growing live reputation and word-of-mouth promotion.[5][44] The certifications reflect the album's transformation from modest initial sales—peaking outside the top 30 upon release—to a cornerstone of UK indie rock commerce, with the BPI's criteria at the time emphasizing physical shipments over pure retail figures. No certifications were granted by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) in the United States, where the album achieved limited commercial traction, selling fewer than 500,000 copies and failing to meet gold threshold requirements. Similar outcomes occurred in other major markets, underscoring the band's primarily domestic orientation despite international distribution through Silvertone Records. Globally, estimates place total sales above four million units, driven largely by enduring UK demand and retrospective catalog purchases, though these figures derive from industry analyses rather than audited certifications.[47] The album's market impact extended beyond raw units to catalyze the viability of the Madchester and baggy genres within the UK independent sector, enabling labels like Silvertone to invest in guitar-dance hybrids that later informed Britpop's commercial explosion. Its slow-burn success model—fueled by underground buzz rather than heavy radio play—demonstrated the potential for indie releases to achieve platinum-level returns through grassroots momentum, influencing A&R strategies toward regional scene-building over instant hits. Sustained catalog performance, including re-entries tied to reunions and anniversaries, further amplified its economic footprint, with UK sales comprising the bulk of revenue streams into the 2000s.[5]Critical Reception
Contemporary Reviews and Responses
Upon its release on 2 May 1989, The Stone Roses garnered enthusiastic praise from key figures in the British music press, though responses varied in intensity and not all critics placed it at the pinnacle of the year's output. Bob Stanley, writing in Melody Maker on 29 April 1989, described the album as "godlike," lauding John Squire's guitar playing as the "spine of the LP" with "beautifully flowing, liquid lines" and concluding that "this is simply the best album in the world."[48][49] NME provided supportive coverage overall, positioning the band by year's end as creators of "one of the decade's finest debut LPs," though individual reviewer Jack Barron offered a more lukewarm assessment amid broader positive industry buzz.[50][51] More reserved opinions highlighted production and consistency issues. In Q magazine, Peter Kane acknowledged the album's promise as a debut but critiqued its "strangely monotone production," suggesting it weighed down an otherwise intriguing effort from the Manchester quartet. Melody Maker's end-of-year polling reflected this tempered view, ranking The Stone Roses below albums like The Cure's Disintegration, the Pixies' Doolittle, and Kate Bush's The Sensual World, indicating it was respected but not unanimously seen as the era's definitive statement.[52] The album's reception aligned with the emerging "Madchester" scene, where its blend of jangly guitars, baggy rhythms, and psychedelic influences resonated with indie tastemakers, fostering word-of-mouth momentum despite modest initial sales of around 6,000 copies in the first week. Critics like Stanley emphasized its organic, unpolished vitality as a counterpoint to prevailing indie trends, attributing its appeal to the band's raw Mancunian energy rather than contrived innovation. This early critical goodwill, particularly from Melody Maker and NME, helped cement its cult status among UK youth culture outlets by late 1989, even as broader commercial breakthrough awaited the 1990 single "One Love."[53]Long-Term Reappraisals and Debates
Over time, the album's critical reputation has solidified into one of widespread acclaim, with retrospective assessments frequently positioning it among the greatest British rock records. In 2000, it was voted the "greatest album ever" at the NME Premier Awards, a designation reconfirmed in subsequent polls as the "Greatest British Album."[24] Pitchfork's 2009 review of the reissue praised its cohesion, arguing it transcended the singles-vs-album divide by integrating standout tracks into a unified whole, blending psychedelia, jangle-pop, and groove effectively.[22] Similarly, a 2019 Paste Magazine retrospective marked its 30th anniversary by deeming it "singular" and near-perfect, crediting its fusion of influences for enduring appeal amid the Madchester scene's cultural shift.[54] Debates persist, however, over whether this elevation reflects musical excellence or inflated nostalgia tied to the band's brief dominance and the era's hedonistic vibe. Detractors, including Fiona Sturges in a 2009 Independent analysis, labeled it "fool's gold," arguing that while singles like "I Wanna Be Adored" and "Waterfall" shine, much of the tracklist relies on hazy production and atmosphere rather than robust songwriting, rendering it the product of hype rather than substance. This view echoes in later critiques, such as a 2023 Melophobe retrospective, which described the album as a "musical anomaly" of disparate styles that coheres more through zeitgeist capture than intrinsic innovation, questioning its reappraisal amid the band's failure to sustain momentum post-release.[55] Proponents counter that its influence on Britpop and indie rock—evident in its rhythmic swagger and guitar textures—justifies the status, though empirical sales growth (from modest UK chart entry to multi-platinum) underscores how live performances and word-of-mouth amplified its legend beyond initial recordings.[56] The discourse often hinges on causal factors like the band's self-sabotage after the album, including legal battles and lineup stasis until Second Coming in 1994, which fueled myths of untapped potential but also invited skepticism about overestimation. While rankings in outlets like NME affirm its canonical place, forums and contrarian pieces from the 2010s highlight a divide: enthusiasts value its raw energy as a snapshot of Manchester's acid-house crossover, whereas skeptics attribute acclaim to regional loyalty and retrospective revisionism, unsubstantiated by consistent global metrics beyond UK-centric polls.[57][24] This tension reveals broader tensions in rock canon formation, where cultural symbolism sometimes eclipses forensic analysis of composition and execution.Legacy and Influence
Cultural and Musical Impact
The Stone Roses' debut album pioneered a fusion of jangly indie rock, psychedelia, and dance elements, drawing from acid house and funk grooves prevalent in late-1980s Manchester, which crystallized the Madchester sound of baggy trousers and rhythmic propulsion.[58] This sonic blend, evident in tracks like "I Wanna Be Adored" with its hypnotic basslines and "She Bangs the Drums" with its upbeat swing, bridged rock traditionalism and emerging rave culture, influencing subsequent indie-dance hybrids.[23] The record's production by John Leckie emphasized loose, ecstatic grooves that prioritized feel over precision, setting a template for guitar bands incorporating electronic pulses without full genre abandonment.[59] Musically, the album exerted a foundational influence on Britpop, with its confident swagger and melodic hooks inspiring Manchester successors like Oasis, whose Noel Gallagher credited the Roses' sound as shaping indirect lineages in British guitar music.[60] Blur's early baggy phase on Leisure (1991) echoed the Roses' rhythmic looseness before pivoting elsewhere, while the overall optimistic, guitar-led populism laid groundwork for mid-1990s acts prioritizing regional identity and anthemic choruses over grunge's introspection.[61] This impact stemmed from the album's rejection of punk's austerity in favor of expansive, groove-oriented structures, fostering a wave of bands that reclaimed British rock's celebratory edge.[23] Culturally, the album symbolized Manchester's resurgence amid Thatcher-era deindustrialization, embodying northern defiance through its hedonistic ethos tied to the Haçienda club's rave scene, where rock fans adopted ecstasy-fueled dancing and baggy attire as markers of youth rebellion.[62] Guitarist John Squire's album artwork—a Pollock-esque abstraction of a lemon sliced to reveal rose petals—elevated visual aesthetics in rock, influencing sleeve design with its drip-painted chaos and thematic nod to renewal, while reinforcing the band's artistic autonomy.[30] The record reshaped British youth culture by merging subcultural silos, promoting a fluid identity of music, drugs, and fashion that prioritized communal euphoria over individualism, though its short-lived band trajectory amplified mythic status over sustained output.Accolades and Rankings
The Stone Roses debut album has received widespread acclaim in retrospective polls, particularly within British music journalism, where it frequently tops lists of the greatest British or all-time albums. In a 2004 Observer Music Monthly poll of musicians, critics, and industry figures, it was voted the greatest British album ever, surpassing The Beatles' Revolver.[63] Similarly, NME's 2006 poll of its writers ranked it number one among the 100 greatest British albums, ahead of The Smiths' The Queen Is Dead.[64] These rankings underscore its enduring status as a cornerstone of UK indie and Madchester music, though such polls reflect subjective consensus among UK-centric voters rather than universal metrics. In broader all-time album rankings, the album has placed highly in UK publications but lower internationally. Q magazine's list of the 100 greatest albums of all time positioned it at number three, behind Radiohead's OK Computer and Oasis's Definitely Maybe.[65] It also featured in Rolling Stone's 2003 edition of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time, highlighting its influence on alternative rock despite limited US commercial breakthrough.[66] Contemporary honors included winning Album of the Year at the 1989 NME Awards, alongside band awards for Best New Band and Band of the Year, based on reader and critic votes following its release.[67]| Publication | Year | Rank | List Title |
|---|---|---|---|
| Observer Music Monthly | 2004 | 1 | 100 Greatest British Albums |
| NME | 2006 | 1 | 100 Greatest British Albums |
| Q Magazine | 2000 | 3 | 100 Greatest Albums Ever |
Criticisms of Hype and Overestimation
Some music critics have contended that The Stone Roses has been disproportionately elevated by retrospective polls and cultural nostalgia, overshadowing its musical shortcomings. In a 2006 poll conducted by The Observer and NME, the album was voted the greatest British album of all time, surpassing works such as The Beatles' Revolver and The Clash's London Calling.[57] However, Fiona Sturges, writing in The Independent, dismissed this ranking as unwarranted, labeling the band "second only to The Doors as the most overrated band in pop history" and the album itself "bloody awful."[57] Sturges argued that the album's acclaim stems more from its timely alignment with the late-1980s Madchester movement—blending indie rock with acid house and baggy aesthetics amid a stagnant UK music scene—than from inherent quality.[57] She highlighted frontman Ian Brown's vocals as a primary flaw, describing them as a "muffled, tuneless moan" akin to "an old guy grabbing the karaoke mike at chucking-out time," which undermines tracks despite John Squire's competent guitar work.[57] Lyrics, often praised for their swagger, were critiqued as simplistic and repetitive, with songs like "I Wanna Be Adored" consisting largely of the titular phrase reiterated over ten times without deeper substance.[57] American music journalist Jim DeRogatis echoed these sentiments, asserting the album was "highly overrated by critics" for relying on a "lame retread disco beat" and "oh-so-dated" psychedelic elements that failed to innovate beyond 1960s influences.) Such views posit that the record's influence on subsequent acts like Oasis and the broader indie-dance crossover, while culturally significant, inflated its artistic standing beyond what the songwriting and production—marked by occasional filler and unpolished execution—merit.[57]Re-Releases and Variants
Early Remasters and Expansions
The debut album by The Stone Roses underwent initial reissues in the early 1990s amid the band's rising popularity, often incorporating non-album singles as expansions to the standard 11-track lineup. For instance, some international editions, including early U.S. and Canadian pressings from 1989 onward, appended the previously released single "Elephant Stone" to the tracklist, extending the runtime and providing listeners with additional material from the band's Silvertone era. Subsequent variants in the decade, such as certain CD and double vinyl reissues, added tracks like the full-length version of "Fools Gold," reflecting efforts to bundle early singles with the core album content without significant audio remastering. These editions prioritized accessibility in expanding markets but retained the original 1989 mastering, which some audiophiles later critiqued for its compressed dynamics compared to later treatments.[2] The first dedicated digital remaster arrived in 2009 for the album's 20th anniversary, overseen by Silvertone/Legacy and involving enhanced audio processing to improve clarity and depth while preserving the original production's raw energy. Released on August 10, 2009, in the UK, this remaster formed the basis for three tiered packages: the Special Edition, a single CD with the 11 remastered tracks plus one bonus track; the Legacy Edition, expanding to two CDs (remastered album and lost demos), a B-sides disc, and a DVD of the band's 1989 Blackpool Tower live performance; and the Collectors Edition, which further included triple vinyl LPs, additional B-sides content, and a 48-page booklet with rare photos and liner notes.[68][69][70] These 2009 expansions drew from archival material, including early demos and live footage, to contextualize the album's development, though critics noted that the remaster's boosted low-end could sometimes overpower the mix's subtlety relative to the 1989 original. The reissues sold respectably, with the deluxe sets appealing to collectors, but they also sparked debates on forums about whether the changes altered the album's intended lo-fi aesthetic. No major remasters preceded this era, as prior reissues focused primarily on track additions rather than sonic overhaul.[71]Recent Editions and Developments (Post-2010)
In the wake of The Stone Roses' reunion announcement on October 25, 2011, which spurred renewed commercial interest in their back catalog amid sold-out tours through 2017, the debut album experienced periodic vinyl represses to satisfy collector demand without introducing new remastering or bonus material beyond the 2009 version. A 2014 UK edition by Sony featured the 11-track album on 180-gram black vinyl, adhering to the digitally remastered audio supervised by producer John Leckie and vocalist Ian Brown. These represses maintained fidelity to the original Silvertone configuration, reflecting sustained analog market viability for the title. More recently, amid vinyl resurgence trends, a United States repress on standard black vinyl entered preorder in October 2025, with a scheduled street date of November 28, 2025, via independent distributors.[72] This edition, limited in scope to the core album tracks, underscores the recording's enduring appeal without archival expansions, as no comprehensive post-2010 variants—such as deluxe boxes or alternate mixes—have materialized from the band or label. Digital streaming platforms have perpetuated access via the 2009 remaster, contributing to over 500 million global streams by 2023, though physical editions remain geared toward audiophiles.[73]Album Components
Track Listing
The original 1989 UK release of The Stone Roses features eleven tracks, all written by vocalist Ian Brown and guitarist John Squire unless otherwise noted.[2][74]| No. | Title | Writer(s) | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | "I Wanna Be Adored" | Brown, Squire | 4:52 |
| 2. | "She Bangs the Drums" | Brown, Squire | 3:23 |
| 3. | "Waterfall" | Brown, Squire | 4:37 |
| 4. | "Don't Stop" | Brown, Squire | 5:17 |
| 5. | "Bye Bye Badman" | Brown, Squire | 4:00 |
| 6. | "Elizabeth My Dear" | Brown | 0:53 |
| 7. | "(Song for My) Sugar Spun Sister" | Brown, Squire | 3:25 |
| 8. | "Made of Stone" | Brown, Squire | 2:53 |
| 9. | "Shoot You Down" | Brown, Squire | 3:13 |
| 10. | "This Is the One" | Brown, Squire | 4:58 |
| 11. | "I Am the Resurrection" | Brown, Squire | 3:42 |
Personnel and Contributions
The debut album The Stone Roses credits the band's core members with primary performances: Ian Brown on lead vocals, John Squire on guitars and backing vocals, Gary "Mani" Mounfield on bass guitar, and Alan "Reni" Wren on drums and backing vocals.[2] Reni additionally contributed piano on "She Bangs the Drums" and harmonizer elements across tracks.[75] Production was led by John Leckie, who oversaw recording sessions primarily at Battery Studios in London from late 1988 into early 1989, focusing on refining the band's psychedelic rock and dance influences through structured rehearsals and tempo stabilization.[3] [13] Engineering duties fell to Paul Schroeder, who handled mixing and technical execution.[2] No additional musicians are credited on the album's core tracks, emphasizing the quartet's self-contained contributions.[2]| Role | Contributor(s) |
|---|---|
| Lead vocals | Ian Brown |
| Guitars, backing vocals | John Squire |
| Bass guitar | Gary Mounfield |
| Drums, backing vocals | Alan "Reni" Wren |
| Producer | John Leckie |
| Engineer | Paul Schroeder |
