Hubbry Logo
Atacama skeletonAtacama skeletonMain
Open search
Atacama skeleton
Community hub
Atacama skeleton
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Atacama skeleton
Atacama skeleton
Atacama skeleton
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Ata's skull

Ata (Spanish pronunciation: [ˈata]) is the common name given to the 6-inch (15 cm) long skeletal remains of a human fetus[1][2] found in 2003 in the ghost town of La Noria, in the Atacama Desert of Chile. DNA analysis done in 2018 on the premature human fetus identified unusual mutations associated with dwarfism and scoliosis, though these findings were later disputed. The remains were found by Oscar Muñoz, who later sold them; the current owner is Ramón Navia-Osorio, a Spanish businessman.[3]

Overview

[edit]

DNA analysis on the premature human fetus identified unusual mutations associated with dwarfism and scoliosis, although other research contested genetic abnormalities, finding that the skeleton showed normal fetal development. There is unfounded speculation by people such as UFO theorist Steven M. Greer that Ata is an extraterrestrial. Such speculation led to Ata's inclusion in the 2013 UFO film Sirius and captured the attention of Stanford University geneticist Garry P. Nolan, who contacted the production team and analyzed the remains of the skeleton.[4] The results of his DNA analysis show the skeleton to be human[5] and not of extraterrestrial origin.[1][6]

Analysis

[edit]

Although initially thought to be older, the fetal remains have been dated to as recently as the late 1970s,[2] and have been found to contain high-quality DNA, suitable for scientific analysis. The remains have an irregularly shaped skull and a total of 10 ribs, as opposed to 12 for adult humans,[5] and potential signs of oxycephaly.[7] Considering that the frontal suture of the skull is very open and the hands and feet not fully ossified, anatomist and paleoanthropologist William Jungers has suggested that it was a human fetus that was born prematurely and died before or shortly after birth. An alternative hypothesis by Nolan is that Ata had a combination of genetic disorders that led to the fetus being aborted before term, and pediatric radiologist Ralph Lachman has said that dwarfism alone could not account for all the features found in the fetus.[7]

During the DNA analysis by Nolan, the B2 mtDNA haplotype group was found in the remains. Haplogroups identify human genetic populations that often are associated distinctly with particular geographic regions around the globe. Combined with the alleles found in the mitochondrial DNA contained in the remains, the findings suggested that Ata is indigenous to the western region of South America.[7]

In March 2018, Nolan published additional results, stating that the fetus had a rare bone aging disorder, as well as other genetic mutations in genes associated with dwarfism, scoliosis, and abnormalities in the muscles and skeleton.[8][9][10] The researchers identified 64 unusual mutations[11] in 7 genes linked to the skeletal system,[9][12] and they noted that finding so many mutations that specifically affect skeletal development has never been reported before.[10][11][13]

Controversy

[edit]

A subsequent study,[14] published in September 2018 by an international research team led by New Zealand's University of Otago Associate Professor of Bioarchaeology Siân Halcrow, questioned the March 2018 study by Nolan, stating: "As experts in human anatomy and skeletal development, we find no evidence for any of the skeletal anomalies claimed by the authors. Their observations of 'anomalies' represent normal skeletal development in the fetus, cranial moulding from delivery, and potential post-mortem taphonomic effects" and that the team was "sceptical" concerning the genomic results. The authors also raised ethical concerns about the work by Nolan, saying that "studies such as these that do not address ethical considerations of the deceased and their descendant communities threaten to undo the decades of work anthropologists and others have put in to correct past colonialist tendencies."[14]

Genome Research, the publisher of the 2013 study, responded by stating that the ethical standards did not cover work on "specimens of uncertain biological origins, such as the Atacama skeleton", but also stated their intention to review their own policies on such studies.[15] The authors of the Genome Research article published a response acknowledging the ethical concerns and calling for the repatriation of the remains. The researchers defended their work by clarifying that no members of the senior authorship team or their laboratories ever handled the skeleton directly, nor were they involved in its acquisition, removal, or export. Instead, they were provided with a small sample of bone (about 1 mm3), removed by the Sirius documentary team in Spain, and their involvement was strictly limited to analysis of that sample, having no responsibility for the actions of previous handlers. They also made it clear that at the start of the research, it was not known that the specimen was human, nor had the age of the skeleton been determined. The researchers emphasized their intention to resolve the controversies surrounding the specimen, rather than perpetuate unethical practices.[16]

See also

[edit]
  • Alyoshenka, a similar fetus allegedly found in a village in Russia

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Atacama skeleton

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Atacama skeleton, known as Ata, comprises the naturally mummified remains of a human female fetus discovered in 2003 in La Noria, an abandoned nitrate-mining town in Chile's Atacama Desert. Measuring approximately 15 centimeters in length, it exhibits pronounced skeletal anomalies, including a turricephalic (cone-shaped) cranium, ten pairs of ribs instead of the typical twelve, elongated limbs, and accelerated bone ossification inconsistent with its overall size. These features initially led to unsubstantiated claims of extraterrestrial origin promoted by ufologists, but whole-genome sequencing established its unequivocally human nature, with ancestry tracing to Andean Native American populations admixed with European and East Asian components. The analysis identified novel homozygous mutations in at least seven genes—such as COL1A1, COL2A1, FLNB, and PCNT—implicated in multiple forms of skeletal dysplasia, including those causing dwarfism, scoliosis, and craniofacial malformations, likely compounded by prenatal exposure to environmental toxins like nitrates prevalent in the region. Estimated to represent a preterm infant who perished shortly after birth around 40 years prior to discovery, Ata's case underscores the complexity of rare genetic disorders and the pitfalls of speculative interpretations absent empirical genetic evidence. While some anthropologists have questioned the sufficiency of the identified mutations to account for all morphological traits, the genomic data definitively refute non-human hypotheses and highlight opportunities for advancing understanding of bone development pathologies.

Discovery and Provenance

Initial Finding

The Atacama skeleton, known as Ata, consists of the mummified remains of a humanoid approximately 15 cm (6 inches) in length, discovered in 2003 in the abandoned nitrate mining town of La Noria in Chile's . Accounts of the precise circumstances of the find vary, with some reports indicating it was uncovered wrapped in white cloth secured by a violet ribbon, while others describe it enclosed in a pouch located behind or within an abandoned church. The discovery was made by a local individual, possibly a treasure hunter or resident scavenging for valuables in the deserted settlement, amid the arid conditions that facilitated natural mummification. These inconsistencies in highlight challenges in tracing the artifact's early history, as documented in forensic reviews, though the 2003 date and La Noria location remain consistently reported across scientific analyses.

Chain of Custody and Early Handling

The Atacama skeleton, commonly referred to as Ata, was discovered in 2003 by Chilean local , who was searching for artifacts in the abandoned nitrate mining of La Noria in Chile's . reportedly found the mummified remains wrapped in white cloth tied with a violet ribbon, or alternatively in a leather pouch, on a shelf or near an abandoned church in the area. Muñoz sold the specimen shortly after discovery for approximately 30,000 an pesos (equivalent to about 40 euros at the time), citing its unusual appearance as a factor in the transaction; accounts vary on whether the buyer was a local owner or another intermediary, but it changed hands at least once more within . The rapid sales reflect informal handling typical of artifact trading in remote regions, with limited documentation of or legal export permissions. The skeleton was subsequently acquired by Ramón Navia-Osorio, a Spanish businessman and private collector, who transported it to without apparent authorization from Chilean authorities. This export has raised questions about legality, as Chilean officials later alleged illegal exhumation and , noting the absence of permits and the specimen's status as potential cultural patrimony. Navia-Osorio has retained ownership since, providing samples for scientific analysis while the full remains remain in his possession in . The opaque has complicated subsequent research, underscoring challenges in verifying origins for informally acquired biological specimens.

Physical Description and Anomalies

Morphological Features

The Atacama skeleton, commonly referred to as Ata, consists of mummified remains measuring approximately 15 cm (6 inches) in length, comparable to the size of a fetus or preterm . Its overall structure exhibits disproportionately mature bone development relative to its stature, with radiographic evidence suggesting equivalent to that of a 6- to 8-year-old despite the diminutive size. The skull is notably elongated and cone-shaped, featuring an angular profile with irregularly shaped, sunken, and slanted eye sockets resembling a in form. The cranium displays accelerated and deformities consistent with skeletal , including a flattened appearance in profile views. The facial region shows underdevelopment, with a small and prominent orbital cavities. The torso includes only 10 pairs of (20 total) rather than the typical 12 pairs (24 total) observed in humans, as confirmed by . Limb bones appear elongated relative to the body size, contributing to an atypical proportion, though specific phalangeal anomalies such as fusion or reduction are noted in forensic examinations without altering digit count. The and lower extremities exhibit dysplastic features, including irregular fusion patterns. These morphological traits, while anomalous, align with severe congenital disorders rather than origins, as substantiated by multiple forensic and radiographic studies. Some researchers argue the represents a normal preterm with environmental influences exaggerating features, but the reduced rib count and cranial elongation remain objectively verified deviations.

Skeletal Abnormalities

The Atacama skeleton, measuring approximately 108 mm in length, displays several morphological features atypical for a human fetus at term. Its cranium is notably elongated and cone-shaped, with enlarged orbital cavities and a prominent sagittal keel, deviating from standard fetal proportions. Radiographic examination further revealed fusion of the metopic suture and partial ossification of carpal bones, suggesting accelerated bone development inconsistent with typical gestational timelines. The consists of only 10 pairs of ribs per side, fewer than the usual 12 in humans, accompanied by asymmetrical positioning and reduced thoracic volume. The pelvis exhibits dysplastic traits, including flattened iliac wings, narrow sciatic notches, and an overall immature morphology with unfused , which contrasts with expected development for a of estimated 38-40 weeks . Limb bones, such as the femora, appear short and bowed, with unusual distal tibial fusion. The hands and feet each contain 11 phalanges rather than the standard 14, indicating possible or fusion anomalies. These skeletal characteristics were interpreted by initial forensic analysts as evidence of severe , potentially linked to genetic affecting growth and . Critiques from bioarchaeological experts, however, contend that features like cranial elongation and variations in rib count fall within normal developmental variation for a preterm around 30 weeks , exacerbated by postmortem mummification in the arid Atacama environment, rather than signifying pathological . They argue that radiographic interpretations of "accelerated" overlook standard fetal atlases showing similar traits in non-pathological cases, emphasizing the need for contextual reassessment.

Initial Speculations and Media Attention

UFO and Paranormal Claims

The Atacama skeleton's discovery in 2003 elicited immediate speculation within UFO and circles regarding its extraterrestrial origins, attributed to morphological anomalies including a length of approximately 15 cm, an elongated cranium, enlarged eye sockets, and only 10 pairs of rather than the typical 12. These features were interpreted by proponents as incompatible with known developmental pathologies, suggesting instead a non-terrestrial entity. In the 2013 documentary Sirius, ufologist Steven Greer presented the skeleton as of alien life, hypothesizing it as a preserved specimen of an extraterrestrial potentially thousands of years old. Greer explicitly rejected classifications of it as a deformed , emphasizing radiographic of advanced fusion and phalangeal development atypical for a . Jaime Maussan, a prominent UFO investigator who acquired and studied the remains, advanced claims in 2023 that the skeleton represented an extinct species of diminutive, cave-dwelling terrestrial humanoids that coexisted with Chile's before Spanish colonization. Drawing on indigenous oral traditions relayed by an Aymara associate, Maussan cited physical traits such as absent patellae, triangular clavicles, elongated digits, and hardened foot calluses as indicators of ambulatory capability rather than embryonic status. These assertions, disseminated via media appearances, persisted despite contradictory forensic data, reflecting ongoing fringe interpretations unaligned with empirical genetic findings.

Popularization in Documentaries

The Atacama skeleton, informally named Ata, was prominently featured in the 2013 documentary Sirius, directed by Steven Greer, which posited it as evidence of extraterrestrial life or advanced alien technology. The film included preliminary DNA testing that Greer interpreted as anomalous, suggesting non-human origins despite initial sequencing indicating human genetic material, thereby amplifying speculation in UFO communities. Released on April 22, 2013, Sirius portrayed Ata's elongated skull, small stature (approximately 15 cm in length), and other morphological anomalies as incompatible with known human developmental pathologies, drawing parallels to alleged ancient alien visitations. This presentation in Sirius spurred public interest and media coverage, with the skeleton depicted as a mummified humanoid potentially thousands of years old, though subsequent radiocarbon dating placed its death around 40 years prior to discovery in 2003. Greer's narrative emphasized unverified claims of hybrid biology, influencing online discussions and ufology events, but overlooked early forensic indicators of human infancy and genetic disorders. Scientific consultations initiated during the film's production, including by Stanford pathologist Garry Nolan, provided initial radiographs revealing human-like bone structures, yet the documentary prioritized sensational interpretations over emerging empirical data. Post-Sirius exposure, Ata's image circulated in subsequent UFO-themed media, but no other major documentaries replicated its central role in promoting hypotheses; instead, follow-up analyses in peer-reviewed studies affirmed Ata as a with multiple congenital mutations, such as those affecting bone development and . The film's claims, lacking rigorous peer validation at release, exemplified how unconfirmed anomalies can propagate via visual media, contrasting with causal explanations rooted in documented genetic variations observed in isolated populations.

Scientific Analyses

Forensic Examinations

Forensic examinations of the Atacama skeleton, informally known as Ata, were initiated in by a team led by immunologist at , utilizing high-resolution photography, radiography, and computed tomography (CT) scans to assess authenticity and morphological features. These analyses confirmed the specimen consisted of genuine osseous tissue exhibiting arterial shadows and joint structures typical of human bones, ruling out fabrication or construction. The examinations identified several anomalies, including an apparent count of only ten pairs of ribs rather than the typical twelve in humans, elongated cranial proportions, and irregularities in the phalanges of the hands and feet, such as fused or absent bones. Bone age estimation from the radiographs suggested developmental maturation inconsistent with the specimen's overall size, prompting initial hypotheses of accelerated aging conditions like , though this was not substantiated by subsequent genetic data. The crown-to-heel length of approximately 15 cm was used to estimate a of around 15 weeks, aligning with a preterm rather than a mature or non-human entity. No evidence of trauma, perimortem injury, or pathological fractures was reported, with mummification attributed to the hyper-arid environment facilitating natural without preservation. Subsequent forensic anthropological reviews, published in 2018, challenged the interpretation of these radiographic findings as indicative of or novel syndromes, asserting that the observed features—such as cranial elongation and rib variation—fall within normal ranges for preterm fetal skeletons subjected to taphonomic and environmental exposure. Experts emphasized that standard bioarchaeological protocols, including consultation with physical anthropologists prior to advanced testing, could have clarified these traits without invoking rare pathologies, highlighting methodological gaps in the initial examinations. ![Atacama skeleton skull profile view][float-right] These evaluations collectively affirmed Ata's classification as a fetal , with anomalies better explained by intrauterine growth constraints and post-mortem alterations than extraterrestrial origins or undocumented diseases, though debates persist over the necessity and of invasive sampling for such determinations.

Radiographic and Histological Studies

In 2012, immunologist conducted radiographic examinations, including X-rays and computed tomography (CT) scans, on the Atacama skeleton (Ata) to assess its authenticity and structural features. These imaging techniques revealed genuine human bone tissue, evidenced by arterial shadows and natural patterns, refuting claims of a or artificial assembly. Specific anomalies included a severely misshapen, elongated cranium and only 10 pairs of ribs rather than the typical 12 in humans. The epiphyseal plates displayed density and development consistent with a aged 6 to 8 years, despite the skeleton's overall length approximating that of a 22-week , indicating accelerated bone maturation. CT scans further corroborated the human skeletal architecture, including phalangeal structures with human-like epiphyses. In preparation for genetic analysis published in 2018, additional scans identified dysmorphic features in the and right , facilitating targeted bone marrow extraction for . These radiographs confirmed skeletal dysplasias but aligned with developmental variants rather than non- origins. Histological examinations of bone tissue were not extensively detailed in primary analyses, though microscopic evaluation of marrow samples supported DNA yield consistent with modern bone microstructure. No peer-reviewed reports identified non- cellular or tissue compositions, reinforcing the radiographic evidence of provenance.

Genetic and Pathological Findings

Whole-Genome Sequencing Results

DNA was extracted from the bone marrow of a rib bone from the Atacama skeleton (Ata) and subjected to whole-genome sequencing using the Illumina HiSeq platform, generating 377,333,714 paired-end reads of 101 base pairs each. This yielded an average genome coverage of 11.5×, with 89.77% of reads uniquely mapping to the human reference genome (hs37d5). Alignment rates were substantially higher to the human genome (97%) compared to chimpanzee (88.01%) or rhesus macaque (64.79%) references, unequivocally confirming Ata's origin as Homo sapiens. Sequencing quality was high, showing minimal DNA damage (evidenced by a twofold increase in C→T and G→A transitions at read ends) and negligible contamination, with analysis yielding a heterozygosity rate near zero and an authenticity probability of approximately 1.00. Variant detection via the GATK suite identified 3,356,569 single variants (SNVs), 518,365 insertions/deletions (indels), and 6,401 structural variations, aligning with expectations for a diploid . Sex was determined as female based on low Y-chromosome alignment (ratio R_Y = 0.0018) and absence of reads mapping to the SRY gene. The raw sequencing data were deposited in the NCBI Sequence Read Archive under accession SRP083100, enabling independent verification. These results, reported by a team including researchers from and UC San Francisco, provided the foundational genomic dataset for subsequent analyses of Ata's pathology and ancestry.

Identified Mutations and Conditions

Whole-genome sequencing of the Atacama skeleton, reported by Bhattacharya et al. in 2018, revealed multiple genetic variants in genes associated with skeletal and developmental disorders. The analysis identified novel single nucleotide variants (SNVs) and other alterations that the authors linked to the specimen's phenotype, including dwarfism-like stature, cranial asymmetry, and rib malformations. These findings positioned Ata as a with a genetic profile consistent with Chilean admixture, though the mutations were proposed as contributors to a complex rather than a single . The specific mutations included:
GeneMutation TypeAssociated Conditions
COL1A1Novel SNV; frameshift deletionEhlers-Danlos syndrome;
COL2A1Novel SNV
KMT2DNovel SNVKabuki syndrome (skeletal anomalies)
FLNBNovel SNVAtelosteogenesis;
ATRNovel SNV type 1
TRIP11Novel SNVAchondrogenesis type 1A
PCNTHomozygous SNVMicrocephalic osteodysplastic type II
These variants, particularly the novel missense SNVs, were interpreted as disrupting bone growth pathways, potentially explaining features like advanced and elongated limbs disproportionate to torso size. The study emphasized their rarity and combination, suggesting a unique polygenic for the observed absent in typical clinical cases. Interpretations of these ' role have faced scrutiny from bioarchaeologists, who contend that the skeletal features align more closely with those of a preterm experiencing severe and postmortem taphonomic alterations, rather than confirming via alone. Such critiques highlight potential overreliance on genomic data without sufficient integration of , arguing that environmental and developmental factors could account for anomalies without invoking unverified mutation-phenotype links.

Age and Ancestry Determination

Whole-genome sequencing and radiographic analyses determined that the Atacama skeleton, known as Ata, represents the remains of a modern human individual, with DNA degradation patterns indicating an age of less than 500 years for the specimen itself, consistent with a post-mortem interval of approximately 40 years prior to its discovery in 2003. This places the time of death around the early 1960s, supported by the preservation of high-quality, modern DNA suitable for sequencing. Developmental age assessments revealed discrepancies between overall size and skeletal maturity. The specimen's crown-heel length of approximately 15 cm corresponds to a gestational age of about 15 weeks, typical for a mid-second-trimester human . However, epiphyseal and other bone features indicated a more advanced developmental stage equivalent to 6–8 years postnatally, attributed to precocious bone development linked to multiple genetic mutations causing skeletal dysplasia. These mutations, including novel variants in genes such as COL1A1, COL2A1, and FLNB, disrupted normal growth plate function and , resulting in accelerated but malformed bone maturation disproportionate to the fetal body size. Radiographic studies confirmed this mismatch, showing phalangeal and cranial patterns atypical for a but aligned with dysplastic conditions. Ancestry was inferred from whole-genome sequencing using (PCA) and ADMIXTURE modeling against reference populations from the and Native American datasets. The results indicated an admixed profile consistent with Chilean origin: approximately 58% European, 25% East Asian (a proxy for ancient Siberian components in Native American lineages), and 25.7% Andean Native . This genetic makeup aligns with historical admixture patterns in northern , reflecting post-colonial European and indigenous contributions without evidence of or anomalous heritage. The analysis confirmed Ata as a Homo sapiens with no archaic or extraterrestrial markers, emphasizing the role of local environmental and genetic factors in her .

Controversies and Criticisms

Challenges to Human Classification

The Atacama skeleton exhibited several morphological features that initially prompted speculation about its human classification, including an overall length of approximately 15 cm, an elongated cranium with a pronounced , enlarged orbital cavities, and a notably underdeveloped and facial structure. These traits, combined with the presence of only 10 pairs of ribs rather than the typical 12 in , were cited by investigators such as ufologist Steven Greer as inconsistent with known human developmental or fetal remains. Greer, in his 2013 documentary Sirius, argued that the skeleton's hand and foot phalanges showed fused or atypical configurations not matching terrestrial or deformed , further suggesting a non-human origin potentially thousands of years old. Preliminary radiographic examinations added to these doubts, revealing bone ossification patterns equivalent to those of a 6- to 8-year-old despite the specimen's diminutive size, which appeared incompatible with a typical preterm or . Forensic pathologist and radiologist Lachman, consulted in early analyses, described the features as indicative of an unprecedented involving multiple dysplasias, yet unable to fully reconcile the discrepancies with established conditions at the time. Proponents of extraterrestrial hypotheses, including Greer, emphasized the absence of matching precedents in for such a combination of traits, positioning the skeleton as evidence against classification without invoking unverified genetic data. ![Profile view of the Atacama skeleton's elongated skull][float-right] Subsequent critiques from within have questioned the interpretive framework of these anomalies even after human DNA confirmation, arguing that claims of severe may overstate skeletal deviations from normal fetal variation, with some features potentially attributable to postmortem preservation artifacts or incomplete preservation rather than inherent non-human traits. For instance, a evaluation by skeletal biologists led by Calen P. Knigge contended that the reported dysmorphic elements, including cranial shaping and rib configuration, lack robust evidence for pathological novelty when assessed against comparative fetal assemblages, though this does not endorse non-human origins. These morphological and interpretive challenges, largely amplified by non-peer-reviewed sources in circles, have persisted in popular discourse despite genomic sequencing establishing unequivocal human nuclear and profiles.

Ethical and Methodological Disputes

The Atacama skeleton, acquired by a Chilean miner named Oscar Muñoz in 2003 and subsequently sold to a collector who transported it to the United States, prompted ethical concerns from Chilean authorities regarding its provenance and handling. The Chilean National Monuments Council initiated an investigation in 2018, alleging that the remains were illegally exhumed from a site near La Serena and smuggled out of the country without export permits, in violation of national heritage laws protecting archaeological finds. This led to demands for the skeleton's repatriation for proper reburial, with critics arguing that its treatment disregarded indigenous cultural sensitivities and the dignity of human remains, potentially constituting desecration of an undisturbed burial context. Further ethical disputes arose over the conduct of genetic and forensic research, particularly the 2013 whole-genome sequencing study published in Genome Research, which analyzed samples without prior approval from Chilean oversight bodies or documented chain-of-custody verification. Chilean scientists and ethicists protested that the research bypassed archaeological and forensic protocols, treating the specimen as a curiosity of uncertain origin rather than adhering to standards for human ancestral remains, which require contextual analysis and community consultation. The study's publisher later clarified that U.S. human subjects research regulations did not apply, as the sample was initially classified outside standard ethical guidelines for biological specimens of debated origin, though this stance drew criticism for enabling invasive testing absent rigorous provenance checks. Opponents, including bioethicists, contended that such analyses lacked justification given the absence of informed consent equivalents for non-living human materials and risked perpetuating exploitative narratives divorced from cultural repatriation norms. Methodologically, the analyses faced scrutiny for insufficient interdisciplinary integration, particularly the omission of anthropological expertise in interpreting skeletal morphology prior to genetic sequencing. A 2018 critical evaluation by an international team, including experts from the , argued that claims in the Genome Research study of anomalies such as missing ribs, an elongated cranium, and unprecedented mutations overstated dysplasia features, finding instead that radiographic evidence aligned with known human fetal skeletal variations from premature birth and environmental factors in the . Critics highlighted methodological flaws, including reliance on limited samples without full skeletal inventory or comparative anthropological metrics, which could have clarified the specimen's human developmental pathology—consistent with conditions like dystrichiasis-lacrimo-ductular dysplasia—rather than implying extraterrestrial traits. This approach was faulted for prioritizing genomic novelty over holistic forensic reconstruction, potentially biasing interpretations toward sensationalism and undermining reproducibility in paleogenomic studies of atypical remains.

Responses from Scientific Community

The scientific community has overwhelmingly affirmed that the Atacama skeleton, commonly known as Ata, is of origin, specifically a exhibiting severe congenital abnormalities rather than extraterrestrial or non-human traits. Genomic sequencing conducted by researchers including at revealed a with Chilean ancestry and mutations in genes such as FOXE1 and MIP, consistent with skeletal dysplasias like an underossified cranium and elongated limbs, as detailed in a 2018 Genome Research publication. This analysis, building on earlier tests confirming humanity in 2013, effectively refuted speculative claims of alien provenance promoted in media and documentaries like Sirius. However, responses to the genetic study's interpretive claims included pointed criticisms from forensic anthropologists. A 2018 examination by Siân E. Halcrow and colleagues at the , published in Forensic Anthropology, analyzed radiographs and photographs of Ata and found no substantiation for the reported dysplasias or pathological anomalies beyond those attributable to postmortem mummification in the arid Atacama environment and typical fetal variation at 30-40 weeks gestation. The critics argued that the Stanford team's emphasis on "extraterrestrial-like" features, such as 10 ribs and a bent , sensationalized normal human developmental traits and overlooked established forensic indicators of intrauterine death and natural , urging caution against overinterpreting degraded samples without contextual archaeological data. Ethical objections emerged prominently from Chilean scientists and indigenous representatives, who condemned the extraterritorial analysis as a violation of national heritage laws and cultural protocols. In March 2018, the Chilean Society of Biological Anthropology and government officials protested the removal and testing of Ata without authorization, labeling it "biopiracy" and demanding repatriation, as Ata was discovered in 2003 near La Noria and sold illicitly. This prompted broader discourse on for ancient remains, with bioethicists invoking frameworks like the to highlight tensions between scientific inquiry and respect for descendant communities, particularly in regions with histories of colonial exploitation. Nolan's team countered that the sample did not constitute human subjects under U.S. regulations, given its fetal and mummified status, but acknowledged the need for improved international guidelines. Despite disputes, the consensus underscores Ata's value in illuminating rare genetic interactions in disorders, with the sequencing contributing to on mutations affecting , though researchers emphasize integrating genomic findings with multidisciplinary forensic validation to avoid methodological overreach.

Implications for and

Contributions to Medical Genetics

The whole-genome sequencing of the Atacama skeleton, published in 2018, identified novel missense single variants in seven genes—COL1A1, COL2A1, FLNB, KMT2D, ATR, TRIP11, and PCNT—linked to disorders such as , , microcephalic osteodysplastic type II, and atelosteogenesis. These variants, previously undocumented in association with such compounded skeletal effects, explained the specimen's , including its 15 cm stature, elongated cranium, and advanced equivalent to 6-8 years despite fetal . The findings advanced by demonstrating that severe dysplasias can result from synergistic interactions among rare homozygous and heterozygous mutations across disparate loci, rather than single-gene dominance, thus revealing the polygenic underpinnings of extreme bone malformations. This polygenic model expands diagnostic paradigms for idiopathic skeletal disorders, where standard single-gene testing often fails, and informs potential gene-editing targets by cataloging variant effects on and formation pathways. Additionally, the high-coverage (averaging 30x depth) from desiccated fetal tissue validated sequencing protocols for low-biomass samples, enabling retrospective of archived remains to uncover hidden genetic contributors to congenital anomalies. Such insights bolster precision medicine approaches, prioritizing multifactorial screening in prenatal and pediatric genetics to predict and mitigate rare dysplastic outcomes.

Lessons on Evidence-Based Inquiry

The Atacama skeleton case exemplifies the pitfalls of relying on superficial morphological traits to infer extraordinary origins, as initial claims of non-human or extraterrestrial nature stemmed from visual anomalies like elongated and reduced limbs, which were later attributed to severe genetic dysplasias through empirical genomic scrutiny rather than . Whole-genome sequencing conducted in revealed Ata as a of South American ancestry, with homozygous mutations in genes such as COL1A1 (linked to development disorders) and novel variants in Homozygous and MIR10A, underscoring how rare, compounded pathologies can mimic implausible hypotheses absent rigorous testing. This progression highlights the principle that evidence-based inquiry demands falsifiable hypotheses tested against comprehensive datasets, rejecting unfalsifiable alternatives like alien provenance due to their incompatibility with and available causal mechanisms. A core lesson lies in combating confirmation bias, where proponents of pseudoscientific narratives, including ufologists who publicized the specimen as evidence of non-terrestrial life shortly after its 2003 discovery, selectively emphasized anomalous features while ignoring terrestrial precedents for dwarfism and dysostosis. Genomic analysis not only refuted these by confirming 100% human DNA alignment to modern reference genomes but also illuminated undiagnosed mutation interactions, demonstrating that interdisciplinary integration—merging genetics, pathology, and anthropology—outweighs anecdotal or ideologically driven interpretations. Critics, including some bioarchaeologists, later faulted the study's limited skeletal consultation and potential sampling biases, reinforcing the need for methodological transparency and peer validation to mitigate overreach, even in data-rich investigations. The episode further illustrates the media's role in distorting evidence hierarchies, as early sensational coverage amplified unverified alien claims from informal documentaries, delaying scientific engagement until formal sequencing in 2017–2018, which estimated Ata's age at approximately 40 weeks gestation based on epiphyseal development and DNA degradation patterns. This delay underscores the value of institutional skepticism toward viral anomalies, prioritizing reproducible molecular evidence over public intrigue, while ethical lapses—such as the specimen's undocumented export from Chile—emphasize that credible inquiry requires provenance verification to avoid conflating artifactual with biological signals. Ultimately, the resolution via peer-reviewed genomics serves as a benchmark for discerning viable from spurious claims, affirming that causal explanations grounded in known biology prevail when extraordinary assertions lack corroborative data.

References

  1. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5880234/
  2. https://www.ucsf.edu/news/2018/03/410076/once-mysterious-atacama-skeleton-illuminates-genetics-bone-disease
  3. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324117905_The_Atacama_skeleton
  4. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2018/mar/22/genetic-tests-reveal-tragic-reality-of-atacama-alien-skeleton
  5. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5932602/
  6. https://www.dw.com/en/atacama-mummy-mystery-solved-alien-like-skeleton-was-a-human/a-43101263
  7. https://www.bbc.com/news/science-environment-43489246
  8. https://science.howstuffworks.com/life/genetic/atacama-skeleton.htm
  9. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/chilean-government-investigating-whether-alien-skeleton-was-illegally-exhumed-180968630/
  10. https://thebabyhistorian.com/2022/05/11/the-atacama-mummy/
  11. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/28/science/atacama-mummy-chile.html
  12. https://www.iflscience.com/why-is-the-atacama-skeleton-so-controversial-67200
  13. https://arstechnica.com/science/2018/04/how-debate-around-one-unique-skeleton-shifted-from-aliens-to-mutations-to-ethics/
  14. https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2018/03/mysterious-skeleton-shows-molecular-complexity-of-bone-diseases.html
  15. https://www.livescience.com/62097-tiny-skeleton-not-alien.html
  16. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1879981718300548
  17. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326461059_On_engagement_with_anthropology_A_critical_evaluation_of_skeletal_and_developmental_abnormalities_in_the_Atacama_preterm_baby_and_issues_of_forensic_and_bioarchaeological_research_ethics_Response_to_B
  18. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/03/dna-proves-alien-is-actually-a-girl-so-who-was-she/556625
  19. https://www.ancient-origins.net/news-history-archaeology/tiny-alien-skeleton-scientists-say-no-not-everyone-convinced-009788
  20. https://www.dailymail.co.uk/sciencetech/article-12735651/alien-mummy-Chile-Atacama-skeleton-remains-ancient-species-tiny-cave-dwelling-human-Maussan.html
  21. https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/03/dna-proves-alien-is-actually-a-girl-so-who-was-she/556625/
  22. https://creation.com/sirius-documentary
  23. https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/tiny-alien-skeleton-found-chile-was-likely-result-genetic-mutations-180968576/
  24. https://carlzimmer.com/was-a-tiny-mummy-in-the-atacama-an-alien-no-but-the-real-story-is-almost-as-strange/
  25. https://www.science.org/content/article/bizarre-6-inch-skeleton-shown-be-human
  26. https://www.nbcnews.com/sciencemain/teensy-alien-looking-skeleton-chile-poses-medical-mystery-6c9700442
  27. https://genome.cshlp.org/content/28/4/423.full
  28. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29567674/
  29. https://www.discovermagazine.com/atacama-alien-update-dna-details-of-six-inch-skeleton-1416
  30. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/03/22/science/ata-mummy-alien-chile.html
  31. https://digitalcommons.wayne.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1150&context=humbiol_preprints
  32. https://cosmosmagazine.com/people/ethics/atacama-skeleton-research-prompts-anger-and-ethics-concerns/
  33. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30025270/
  34. https://www.ancient-origins.net/news-general/atacama-mummy-0010444
  35. https://www.forbes.com/sites/kristinakillgrove/2018/07/18/international-experts-refute-alien-mummy-analysis-question-ethics-and-legality/
  36. https://theconversation.com/rights-of-the-dead-and-the-living-clash-when-scientists-extract-dna-from-human-remains-94284
  37. https://genome.cshlp.org/content/early/2018/03/21/gr.223693.117.full.pdf
  38. https://childhoodbioarchaeology.org/2018/07/19/faulty-science-in-dna-analysis-of-the-atacama-alien-mummy/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.