Hubbry Logo
ErfworldErfworldMain
Open search
Erfworld
Community hub
Erfworld
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Erfworld
Erfworld
Erfworld
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Erfworld
Erfworld Logo
AuthorRob Balder
Illustrators
  • Jamie Noguchi (B1)
  • Xin Ye (B0 & 2-5)
  • David Hahn (B3)
  • Lauri Ahonen (B3)
  • Lillian Chen (B3-5)
  • Connor Cercone (B5)
  • Rob Balder (B5)
Websitewww.erfworld.com
Current status/scheduleCancelled
Launch dateDecember 7, 2006
End dateOctober 1, 2019
Genre(s)Fantasy, comedy, parody

Erfworld is a story-driven fantasy/comedy webcomic and independently published graphic novel. The series follows Parson, a master strategy gamer summoned into a wargame by a desperate faction desiring a warlord- leaving him trapped in the game. It was written by Rob Balder, who worked with many illustrators over its run. Erfworld began publication in December 2006 on the website Giant in the Playground, better known for hosting The Order of the Stick. It moved to its own website with the completion of Book 1, as had originally been intended, and was highly popular in the early 2010s. It continued until its abrupt cancellation part way through Book 5 in October 2019.

The comic heavily features contemporary memes, pop culture references, and mechanical references to war games.[1][2] In particular, several characters and motifs are drawn from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz.[3] In juxtaposition to its warlike themes, the visual style is deliberately "cute".[4] The characters resemble dolls or toys and are unable to use profanity. The plot, setting, and characters were released under a Creative Commons Attribution, Noncommercial, ShareAlike license.[5]

Books

[edit]

Erfworld was divided into "Books" which acted as narrative divisions. Prologue and epilogue pages were usually numbered distinctly and so are represented separately here.

Vol. Title Pagecount Publication period
Prologue Body Epilogue
0 Inner Peace (Through Superior Firepower) - 81 - October 31, 2011 - October 29, 2013
1 The Battle for Gobwin Knob - 150 21 December 7, 2006 - May 22, 2009
2 Love is a Battlefield 28 114 25 October 2009 - December 3, 2013
3 Hamsterdance versus the Charlie Foxtrot - 145[a] - August 16, 2014 - March 26, 2016
4 Lies and Dolls 9 190[b] 4 March 28, 2016 - November 2, 2018
5 Temple Tantrum 35 Unpublished November 9, 2018 - October 1, 2019

Staff

[edit]
  • Rob Balder, writer for all material and illustrator for portions of Book 5.
  • Jamie Noguchi, illustrator for Book 1.
  • Xin Ye, illustrator for Book 0 and 2-5.
  • David Hahn, illustrator for Book 2 epilogues and early Book 3.
  • Arthur Chu, voice actor for animated versions of Book 2 epilogues.[8][9]
  • Lauri Ahonen, inks and colors for Book 3.
  • Lillian Chen, inks and colors for Book 3-5.[10]
  • Connor Cercone, 3D modelling for portions of Book 5.[11]

Plot

[edit]

Book 0: Inner Peace (Through Superior Firepower)

[edit]

The prequel follows two warlords- the croakamancer Wanda and Princess Jillian of Faq, who both struggle in their own ways against the might of Haffaton, a vast empire. Wanda's side Goodminton is defeated, and Olive Branch of Haffaton manipulates her into defecting. Jillian is captured by Haffaton, and taken to Efbaum, the Emerald City. The ruler of Haffaton, Judy, uses the Arkenshoes to return to her own world. In a swift maneouver, Jillian and the others from Faq are able to snipe the near-abandoned capital and assassinate Branch. The move dissolves Haffaton- and a deal with the Wizard Charlescomm heals Wanda, at the cost of razing the city.

Book 1: The Battle for Gobwin Knob

[edit]

The strategy gamer Parson Gotti is summoned from Earth into Erfworld, to be the "perfect warlord" under Lord Stanley, who faces a doomed defense of his last city. Parson orchestrates the defense using his knowledge of tabletop strategy games. As Erfworld is governed by game-like rules he is extremely skilled at this and is aided by his calculator watch which the locals consider a powerful magic item. Jillian and Wanda find themselves on opposing sides in this conflict, with Wanda deploying uncroaked units in defence of the city, Jillian aiding Prince Ansom in his siege, and Charlescomm extracting payment for intermittent aid to either side. As a last resort Parson activates the volcano beneath the city to kill their foes, which achieves a technical victory. Wanda gains control of Ansom's Arkenpliers and "decrypts" the invading army, which is then resurrected and under her command. This includes Lillith, one of Charlie's archons, and Ansom himself.

Book 2: Love is a Battlefield

[edit]

Wanda's control of the Arkenpliers allows Gobwin Knob to expand and capture many cities, striking back against the coalition that had sieged their capital. After the fall of Unaroyal, Wanda lays siege to Spacerock, the capital of Jetstone and Ansom's family home. Jillian, now queen of a refounded Faq, captures Ansom and leaves the battle. Parson is initially only guiding the attack from the rear, but attempts to transit through the Magic Kingdom's portals against convention to reach the city quickly and salvage their attack. This causes a dispute with the magicians there and leads Parson to realise that he was summoned not just to defend Gobwin Knob but to defeat Charlescomm. Parson learns of how Charlie summoned Judy to Erfworld to defeat the Wicked Witch of the West and seize the Arkendish. He is aware of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz and recognises Charlie as the Wizard. Spacerock falls, though Jetstone are able to capture Lillith and get her out of the city. Parson is forced to occupy the Magic Kingdom.

Book 3: Hamsterdance versus the Charlie Foxtrot

[edit]

With Charlescomm’s backing, Jillian attempts a decapitation strike on Gobwin Knob’s largely unprotected core. She is rebuffed by Stanley, loses Ansom, and is forced into retreat. Despite their recent advances, Parson convinces Stanley to engage with diplomacy as being at war with a coalition that includes every neighbouring land is unsustainable. With a truce with Charlie in effect, Parson meets with various factions in the Magic Kingdom, some of which oppose Charlie. Lillith is traded to Charlescomm by Jetstone, and a prison break attempt by her proves expensive for Gobwin Knob as it results in truce violations. She damages the city but makes it back to the Magic Kingdom with several assault rifles, then unknown technology elsewhere in Erfworld. Charlie pursues and the Magic Kingdom becomes a bloodbath. Wanda is captured, and Parson retreats into Transylvito, surrendering to the authorities there.

Book 4: Lies and Dolls

[edit]

Parson and his friends face torture in Transylvito, and their captors learn that Jillian is being supported by Charlie. Transylvito sits at the centre of a diplomatic push from both Gobwin Knob and Charlescomm- with their leader Don King debating which group to side with, and determine what contingencies and espionage the two have in play. Jillian manages to capture Gobwin Knob’s original capital with little resistance in Parson and Stanley’s absence- though their seat of power had earlier been moved to Spacerock. Ultimately, Don King is assassinated by his own underling over an internal dispute and his successor Caesar aligns Transylvito with Gobwin Knob. They intervene on behalf of their allies and capture Faq, isolating Jillian. Fighting breaks out in the normally neutral Magic Kingdom when casters attempt to start executing prisoners. Wanda is freed and flees underground, resulting in Minecraft themed attacks from tunneling casters and Charlie’s archons. The towers of each capital develop into sentient “temples” that become involved in side administration. Parson is tricked into using a scroll intended to send him back to Earth, but he is instead teleported to Spacerock. An increasingly frail Charlie attacks and blackmails Transylvito, while Parson and Stanley prepare for another invasion of the Magic Kingdom.

Book 5: Temple Tantrum

[edit]

Fumo, a barbarian warlord pops on a remote island. He is picked up by Tidepod and later the Signamancer Noah, of the tiny Nestlý side. They occupy a small island, formerly home to the lost kingdom of Archezoa. The island is a prearranged tropical refuge for Hippiemancers fleeing violence in the Magic Kingdom.

Prior to its cancellation, Balder had described the new characters in the Book 5 prologue as having been set up for a larger, worldwide politics story. The narrative would have later returned to Parson and his companions.[6]

Publication

[edit]
Erfworld's writer, Rob Balder

Erfworld was initially hosted at GiantITP, the platform for the fantasy webcomic The Order of the Stick. As planned, Erfworld moved to its own website after the conclusion of Book 1 on May 22, 2009. The change was announced on GiantITP a few weeks earlier, and Balder and Noguchi released a statement on the day. The dedicated website retained a banner link back to The Order of the Stick in gratitude to Rich Burlew for hosting it originally.[12] Following on the success of the Order of the Stick Kickstarter project, in February 2012, author Rob Balder launched the Erfworld "Year of the Dwagon" Kickstarter, seeking funding for a motion comic project. The Kickstarter was extremely successful, resulting in funding of almost $85,000, making it the fourth-largest comics category Kickstarter project at the time.[13]

Erfworld was an early adopter of crowdfunding, featuring the Toolshed, a Patreon-like funding mechanism that was created specifically for the comic and its site. The website was totally overhauled in May 2016, and a points system rewarded fan contributions. Users could earn "Shmuckers"- Erfworld's currency- which offered store credit. Toolshed members were also rewarded with Shmuckers.[10] Amid advertising issues on the website, Balder adopted crowdsourced fan cryptomining to fund it. This was called "Mine4erf", and was first announced on February 18, 2018.[14][15] Between the income from Toolbox and cryptomining, they were able to remove all ads from the website that May.[16]

Cancellation

[edit]

The comic was facing funding issues in November 2018 due to a number of factors, including a decline in the value of cryptocurrency. Since the removal of ads from the site, cryptomining had been a significant source of income. The comic also moved to a less frequent schedule, due to health issues and other factors.[6] Baldur announced that the comic would take a pause from its normal focus on Parson and his allies, introduce new characters to set up story for Book 5, and increase its reliance on 3D imagery. 3D had been present to a degree since the comic's debut, but for Book 5 he hired Connor Cercone to aid with modeling, and to train the other artists in the discipline. Balder also intended to use the new character introductions in Book 5 to "canonize" character rewards for Kickstarter backers.[6]

In May 2019, Balder announced that Lillian Chen would be leaving the project- though her role would not need to be replaced due to the new 3D imagery angle. In the same news post Rob explained that an undisclosed personal tragedy had occurred and, as a result, Erfworld would not be updating again "for the foreseeable future, possibly the rest of the year." This new event was dubbed Horrible Thing II.[17] Nonetheless, updates did resume later in 2019. The final update was Book 5 prologue page 35, released on October 1, 2019.[18]

On October 11, the website's front page was replaced with an announcement, signed by Rob and Linda Balder, which announced the end of Erfworld as a webcomic as a result of a string of personal tragedies.[19] The Erfworld updates previously published remain available in an online archive, and the website's store remains available. Outside of this, all former functionality of the site was restricted to users with "heartstrings" badges. It also announced that any further updates would only be available to this group of users.[19] A few days later, the original copy of Book 1 was taken down from the GiantITP website.[20][21]

[edit]

The first two books were made available in print, as hardcover volumes.

# Title Release date ISBN
1 The Battle for Gobwin Knob March 1, 2011 9780983137832
2 Love is a Battlefield June 14, 2014 9780983137870

Additionally, Love is a Battlefield was also made available as three smaller softcover issues, which collectively cover the full book. These versions contain some bonus material, such as character bios for the Thinkamanacers.

# Title Pages ISBN
1 Meet the Jetstones 60[22] 9780983137801
2 It's Raining Men 80[23] 9780983137825
3 Lots of Sects, and Violence 56[24] 9780983137863

Balder discussed printing books 3 and 4 in November 2018, acknowledging that it was an intention but challenging financially and logistically- creating new art for covers as well as funding the actual print run. It was then earmarked for development in January or February 2019, but did not eventuate.[6]

Reception

[edit]

Erfworld was recognized as one of the top 10 graphic novels of 2007 by Time magazine[25] and received positive reviews and promotion from webcomics authors,[26][27] and Time author/journalist Lev Grossman in his articles "Webcomics are the New Blogs"[28] and "Erfworld: It's a Boopin' Good Webcomic!"[29] The addition of Erfworld to GiantITP was noted in "First Watch", Dragon magazine's monthly section on new developments in gaming and entertainment.[30] Additionally, Erfworld was reviewed by Webcomic Overlook, receiving four stars out of five,[31] and was profiled by NPR.[4]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Erfworld

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Erfworld is a fantasy/comedy webcomic series created by Rob Balder that integrates mechanics from strategy and role-playing games into a narrative-driven world. The story centers on Parson Gotti, a strategy game enthusiast from Earth who is magically summoned to Erfworld—a realm governed by the rules of a massive, turn-based strategy game—as the chief warlord for the beleaguered side of Gobwin Knob during a critical war. Launched in late 2006 on the Giant in the Playground forums, Erfworld quickly gained popularity among gamers and was recognized as one of Time magazine's Top 10 Graphic Novels of 2007. The first book, The Battle for Gobwin Knob, was illustrated by Jamie Noguchi, while subsequent volumes featured artwork by Xin Ye and, later, a collaboration with Lauri Ahonen starting in 2015. Serialized online with dense, pun-filled dialogue and minimalist yet detailed visuals, the series explores themes of leadership, fate, and the intersection of game logic with fantasy tropes, appealing primarily to tabletop and video game enthusiasts. The comic was also released in print as graphic novels through independent publishing, with Balder funding expansions via campaigns, such as the 2012 "Year of the Dwagon" project. However, in October 2019, Balder announced the permanent discontinuation of Erfworld due to personal tragedies, leaving the archives available but halting new content. Despite its abrupt end, the series built a dedicated fanbase, including a comprehensive wiki and active community discussions on its innovative blend of gaming and epic storytelling.

Overview

Premise

Erfworld is a fantasy series centered on Gotti, an overweight, socially isolated enthusiast from , who is abruptly summoned to the titular world as a . The summoning occurs through a rare and expensive spell known as "Summon Perfect Warlord," cast by the side of Gobwin Knob at a cost of 500,000 shmuckers, which pulls the ideal commander from across all existence into the world, preserving the individual's real-world appearance, personality, and expertise in tactical simulations. arrives disoriented in his everyday —a , , and —thrust into a role he initially perceives as a bizarre dream or , but soon recognizes as a literal gamified reality. The world of Erfworld operates under rigid, game-like rules enforced by the Titans, god-like creators who shaped its mechanics as a simulation, complete with turns, units, and resources. Distinctive traits include an absence of night and day cycles, resulting in perpetual daylight across the plane; units that "pop" into existence from city garrisons or via magical casting rather than traditional birth; and a semi-permanent form of termed "croaking," where fallen units can potentially be revived through "uncroaking" by specialized casters, turning them into undead servants loyal to their new master. These elements blend with turn-based strategy tropes, where magic disciplines like naffatry (fire-based) and (necromancy) interact with combat stats and movement allowances. , dubbed "Lord Hamster" by his allies due to his Earthly physique, leverages his gamer intuition to interpret and exploit these systems. Upon arrival, is immediately embroiled in Gobwin Knob's desperate defense against the , a vast coalition of nineteen city-states united to eradicate the side's ruler, Stanley the Tool, whom they view as a dangerous tyrant. Led by Prince Ansom of Jetstone as Chief , the invading forces vastly outnumber Gobwin Knob's meager troops, setting up a high-stakes where Parson must devise strategies to survive the onslaught and potentially turn the tide. This inciting conflict highlights the series' exploration of an outsider navigating an alien, rule-bound cosmos, where failure means permanent croaking or enslavement.

Style and themes

Erfworld's stylistic approach blends full-color illustrated panels with text-only "klogs," which serve as blog-like interludes providing insider perspectives on events, and infographics that diagram the world's game-like rules and mechanics for reader clarity. The artwork, primarily by illustrator Jamie Noguchi, features a cute, super-deformed aesthetic with exaggerated proportions—such as oversized heads on tiny necks—contrasting violent themes to create a cute effect, while incorporating dynamic action sequences and fanciful creature designs like "dwagons" and "gwiffins." Early strips employ simpler, uncluttered panels reminiscent of fantasy , evolving into more intricate and colorful compositions with complex backgrounds as the series advances through its books. Humor permeates the narrative through layered puns on concepts, such as "turnamancy" for time manipulation and "erfworld" as a phonetic twist on "Earthworld," alongside pop nods like KISS-inspired makeup and meta-satire critiquing RPG tropes, including rigid turn-based combat and troop management mechanics. This style satirizes gaming by embracing its absurdities—evident in sound effects like "Fer-Durrrp!" for magical summons—while highlighting the incongruity of modern sensibilities clashing with medieval fantasy elements. The comic explores profound themes, including the conflict between and predestined fate in a governed by immutable rules, where prophecies warp reality to ensure fulfillment. It delves into the ethics of and , portraying moral ambiguities in warlord decisions and the human cost of conquest, as seen in ambiguous figures like Stanley the Tool. Romance emerges within the gamified society, complicating alliances and loyalties in arcs like Book 2's "," while the immigrant experience is embodied by protagonist Parson Gotti, a modern Earthling navigating cultural dislocation and adaptation in this alien realm. Initially light-hearted and comedic, Erfworld's tone shifts toward darker drama in later volumes, integrating personal tragedies, ethical quandaries, and the bittersweet , all while maintaining its whimsical visual charm to underscore the grotesquery of its world.

Creation and production

Development history

Erfworld was created by Rob Balder, a and known for his earlier work on the Partially Clips. The initial concept emerged in 2006 as a collaborative project hosted on the Giant in the Playground forums, where Balder sought artists to illustrate his scripted story blending fantasy tropes with game-like . The comic began serialization as a forum-based webcomic, with Balder handling the writing and initial illustration collaborations. The first strip was released on December 7, 2006, marking the start of Book 1, The Battle for Gobwin Knob, illustrated primarily by Jamie Noguchi. Balder drew inspiration from strategy games, role-playing games like , and narratives such as and , aiming to create a humorous fantasy world governed by rigid, game-inspired rules. Following the completion of Book 1 on May 22, 2009, Erfworld transitioned from the Giant in the Playground hosting to its own dedicated , erfworld.com, to support expanded production and community features. In February 2012, Balder launched a campaign that raised approximately $85,000 to fund print editions and project expansions. Book 0, (Through Superior Firepower), began on October 31, 2011. In May 2016, the project introduced the system as part of a overhaul, a Patreon-like model with a points system (Shmuckers) that provided subscribers with full access to new content and behind-the-scenes materials, along with a temporary that was removed in 2018; this allowed Balder to focus on it full-time. Balder discussed potential expansions, including RPG adaptations to further explore the universe's mechanics, though these plans remained unrealized.

Staff and artists

Rob Balder served as the primary writer for all books in the Erfworld series, handling scripting, lettering, and overall narrative direction. His wife, Linda Balder, supported the through production oversight and , including interactions with fans and backers. The artistic evolved across the series due to scheduling constraints, with multiple illustrators contributing to maintain momentum amid production delays. Jamie Noguchi illustrated Book 1 from 2006 to 2009, establishing the comic's initial visual style characterized by clean lines and expressive character designs. Xin Ye took over as the primary artist for Book 0 and Books 2 through 5, providing most of the illustrations and color work from 2011 to 2019, which brought a more detailed and vibrant aesthetic to the ongoing narrative. contributed illustrations for portions of between 2014 and 2016, focusing on key sequences during transitional periods in the storyline. As delays mounted in later books, Rob Balder increasingly participated in the artwork, self-illustrating select sections of Book 5 in 2018 and 2019 to advance the project. Additional contributors included colorists who enhanced the visual polish, along with forum moderators for community engagement and occasional guest artists for side projects and specials; the series featured no major co-writers beyond Balder's lead role.

Fictional universe

World mechanics and magic

Erfworld functions as a turn-based strategy world, where each side—a political consisting of a , cities, and units—takes sequential turns beginning . During a side's turn, its units can move across hex-tiled up to their move rating, engage in , cast spells, and perform other actions, but all activity ceases at the end of the turn, with unused move resetting to zero. Combat occurs when opposing stacks enter the same hex, resolving based on unit stats including (durability), move (distance per turn), and (offensive capability), often favoring numerical superiority or leadership bonuses from . Units in Erfworld are created through , a process that occurs naturally in cities at a rate determined by the city's level and available resources, or deliberately via magic or artifacts; popped units emerge fully formed with predefined stats and roles, such as , fliers, or specialists, and require upkeep paid in shmuckers—the universal gold-like currency used for production, , and . Loyalty binds units to their side, measured in levels from "loyal" to "disloyal," influenced by timely pay, inspiring from warlords or rulers, and morale factors; low loyalty risks units disobeying orders or defecting, while high loyalty enhances performance and prevents turnover. Non-leader units lack outside their side's turn, acting as automatons guided by commands, though leaders retain autonomy for strategic decisions. The revolves around casters, specialized units who channel power through one of 21 disciplines organized into eight classes derived from the presence or absence of three elements: , Motion, and . Disciplines within each class are further divided along three axes: Erf, Fate, and Numbers. Examples include naffatcy (fire-based destruction under the Naughtymancy class), healomancy (restorative spells in the Clevermancy class), the eyemancy class with disciplines including lookamancy (scrying), thinkamancy, and foolamancy (illusions), (stage-like tricks and summoning in the Hocus Pocus class), and stofball (elemental manipulation like fire or ice in the Naughtymancy class). is limited by a caster's juice reserves, which deplete with use and recharge over turns or via links with other casters of complementary disciplines; natural limits prevent overuse, and spells often require line of sight or specific conditions. Death in Erfworld, termed croaking, removes a unit from play, sending its essence to an as a unless uncroaked—a spell typically from croakamancy (under Naughtymancy) that revives the unit with boosted but potential stat penalties or altered allegiance. Artifacts like the Arkentools—ancient relics attuned to rulers—amplify magic, enabling feats such as mass summoning (Arkenhammer), unbreakable constructs (Arkenshield), or enhanced decryption (Arkenpliers, a form of uncroaking). governs alliances, allowing sides to declare , shmuckers or units, or form natural alliances with non-human races, though risks and penalties. These enforce a perpetual state of conflict, as sides expand or perish based on and strategic exploitation.

Sides, races, and units

In the fictional universe of Erfworld, sides represent the primary political and military factions, each centered around a and potentially additional controlled cities, governed by a single ruler who serves as the side's absolute authority. Rulers are classified as either , who can produce royal heirs to ensure continuity, or , who lack this ability and risk side dissolution upon their death without an heir. Examples include Gobwin Knob, a volcanic fortress side ruled by Overlord Stanley the Tool, and Jetstone, a royal side led by Slately from its capital at Spacerock. Sides can form alliances, such as the Royal Coalition, a temporary pact among multiple royal sides aimed at common strategic goals like eliminating non-royal threats. Races and species in Erfworld form the biological foundation for units, with humans as the dominant race capable of leading most sides and popping a wide variety of units. Non-human races include gobwins, diminutive humanoids often serving as weak but numerous in sides like Gobwin Knob; dwagons, draconic flying mounts used for aerial transport and combat; elves, agile archer specialists from tribal groups like the or Atrium elves; and marbits, rabbit-like plains dwellers known for their evasion tactics and alliance potential. Hybrids such as pikers, combining and traits for pike-wielding , illustrate the diverse popping mechanics that blend racial characteristics. These races often exist as allies—independent tribes that can ally with sides, pop their own units using resources like shmuckers, and communicate internally without standard language, as seen with hobgobwins who inherently know their chief's will. Units are the functional components of sides, categorized by role and capabilities, and are "popped" into existence fully formed in a side's capital at the start of each turn. Warlords function as elite leader units, providing command to boost nearby stacks' performance and often serving as field commanders under the . Casters are specialized magic-wielding units, such as thinkamancers or croakamancers, who cast spells from one of Erfworld's disciplines but require significant upkeep and cannot be easily replaced. Heavies include durable constructs like golems or units designed for frontline assault, while encompasses basic troops such as knights for charges or archers for ranged support. Special units like decryptors—undead warriors reanimated through croakamancy or similar magic—offer unique tactical advantages, such as zero upkeep after revival, though they originate from fallen enemies or allies. Key locations tied to these elements include the , a neutral haven where casters from various sides reside without allegiance, facilitating council and spellcasting free from side conflicts.

Characters

Main characters

Parson Gotti is the central protagonist of Erfworld, a enthusiast summoned from to serve as Chief of the side Gobwin Knob. Originally an ordinary office worker and creator of the Hamstard, Parson possesses extensive knowledge of turn-based strategy games, which he applies as meta-knowledge to navigate and exploit Erfworld's game-like mechanics. Nicknamed "Lord Hamster" due to his appearance and affinity for the animal, he begins as a , bewildered by his forced role, but gradually evolves into a strategic genius capable of turning the tide of wars through innovative tactics. Stanley the Tool, originally known as Stanley the Plaid, is the Overlord of Gobwin Knob, a human ruler who rose from the rank of a common piker through prowess in personal combat to claim leadership of his nearly extinct Plaid tribe. A brilliant tactician in direct battles, Stanley is deeply obsessed with acquiring the powerful artifacts known as Arkentools, viewing them as essential to his side's survival and his own legitimacy as a ruler. Despite his martial skills, he is a flawed leader, often shortsighted in and reliant on advisors. Wanda Firebaugh serves as the Chief Croakamancer—and thus a specialized necromancer—for Gobwin Knob, wielding the Placid Solution Arkentool to command undead units in battle. A member of the lost tribe, she was originally aligned with the side Haffaton, from which she escaped a tragic fate involving the loss of her family and subjugation under its tyrannical ruler, leading to her defection and unwavering loyalty to Stanley. As Stanley's primary advisor, Wanda plays a pivotal role in key conflicts, including the summoning of Parson Gotti to bolster their forces, and frequently influences decisions to advance her pursuit of power and vengeance. Prince Ansom is the noble heir and Chief Warlord of Jetstone, serving as the initial primary antagonist to Gobwin Knob as the leader of the Royal Crown Coalition assembled to conquer it. Characterized by his rigid adherence to chivalry and traditional warfare, Ansom embodies honor but struggles with adaptability in the face of unconventional threats. Throughout the narrative, he is croaked—killed and turned into an undead unit—once, only to be decrypted into a loyal servant of Gobwin Knob, marking a profound shift from foe to ally. Charlie rules Charlescomm as its and sole Predictamancer, a master caster who foresees probabilities to manipulate events from afar as an enigmatic figure oscillating between ally and antagonist. Operating from a single fortified city defended by his elite units, Charlie employs advanced Thinkamancy to create a "thinkspace" network for remote communication, negotiation, and subtle control over other sides. His affable demeanor masks a calculating nature focused on personal gain, making him a formidable wildcard in Erfworld's geopolitical struggles.

Recurring supporting characters

Sizemore Rockwell serves as the primary Dirtamancer for the side of Gobwin Knob, utilizing his abilities to manipulate earth for tunneling operations and the animation of golems, including unconventional ones made from refuse. As an ethical , he frequently experiences internal conflict over his to his , stemming from his moral reservations about certain wartime actions and the broader mechanics of Erfworld's magic system. Jillian Zamussels is a formidable originally from the fallen side of , later taking service with Jetstone after its conquest; her flipper-like appendages reflect her amphibious heritage, and she is driven by a deep-seated quest for revenge against those responsible for her homeland's destruction. This motivation shapes her complex and shifting alliances across sides, often prioritizing personal vendettas over strict . Maggie functions as Gobwin Knob's Thinkamancer, excelling in magical communications that facilitate coordination among units and casters, while also playing a key role in the side's council discussions and strategic deliberations. Her expertise in linking casters enhances group spellcasting efficiency, though she maintains a reserved demeanor amid the high-stakes interpersonal dynamics of her service. Vurp and Bart Lightrail are a pair of warlords in the service of Jetstone, often depicted as a bumbling duo providing through their ineptitude and exaggerated aristocratic pretensions. Representing the side's traditional , they embody outdated chivalric ideals, frequently stumbling into situations that highlight the rigid hierarchies and pompous customs of their class. Janis is a prominent Carnymancer based in the , offering counsel to figures like Prince Ansom of Jetstone through her manipulation of fate and perception via carnivalesque magic. Her advisory influence proves crucial in forging early inter-side alliances, leveraging her abilities to subtly alter probabilities and negotiations in pursuit of broader diplomatic goals.

Publication history

Webcomic serialization

Erfworld debuted as a on December 7, 2006, launching on the Giant in the Playground forums with an initial six-page block introducing the story's fantasy setting, characters, and plot. The series transitioned to its dedicated website, erfworld.com, on May 22, 2009, after Book 1 concluded, allowing for expanded features like integrated forums and archives now hosted at archives.erfworld.com. Updates followed an irregular schedule, beginning with 1-3 illustrated pages per week during the early phases but progressively slowing to monthly or longer gaps as production demands grew. blended full-color pages with narrative text updates known as "klogs"—first-person journal entries from protagonist Gotti—alongside occasional filler artwork and illustrated prose segments to maintain momentum during artist availability constraints. Initially, all content was freely accessible online, fostering a dedicated reader community through integrated discussion forums on the hosting platforms. In , the model shifted to include a , charging $3 per month for complete archive access and exclusive updates, while retaining free availability for earlier strips. The serialization was organized into distinct books—such as Book 1: The Battle for Gobwin Knob and subsequent volumes—each building to an that bridged to the next arc, culminating in approximately 800 total updates across illustrated pages, klogs, and supplementary material before production halted in 2019. The first collected edition of Erfworld, titled The Battle for Gobwin Knob, was published in 2010 by ERF Books as a full-color volume containing approximately 196 pages of strips from the initial arc, along with bonus materials such as a supporter thank-you page. This edition measured 11.02 x 8.27 x 0.51 inches and focused on the core narrative of Parson's summoning and the defense of Gobwin Knob, including 150 full-color pages supplemented by additional content like character illustrations. The second volume, , appeared in print in 2012, initially released as three softcover issues by ERF Books before a collected softcover edition: Meet the Jetstones (60 pages), (94 pages), and Lots of Sects, and Violence (54 pages), totaling around 208 pages of full-color content with illustrated extras such as Wanda dress-up dolls. These volumes explored the Jetstone-Marbiton and related battles, maintaining the series' pun-laden, strategy-game aesthetic. Plans for printed editions of Volumes 3 and 4 were announced but ultimately unrealized due to production delays, with a 2019 campaign aimed at funding Love is a Battlefield printing and initiating artwork for Book 3. Both volumes were available in hardcover and softcover formats through the official Erfworld store, including digital PDF versions for subscribers that mirrored the print extras. No official adaptations into RPG systems, animations, or full audiobooks exist, though fan-created content includes the unofficial Second Dawn: The Erfworld RPG, a wargame-inspired supplement developed in 2023 that adapts the comic's turn-based mechanics for player campaigns. Community-driven audiobook readings of the series' text interludes and epilogues have been produced, such as audio versions of Book 2 epilogues shared on since 2013.

Cancellation and aftermath

The cancellation of Erfworld was announced on October 11, 2019, following the release of the final update in Book 5 on October 1, 2019. The official statement on the website, signed by creator Rob Balder and his wife Linda, declared the webcomic permanently discontinued due to horrific and unbearable events in their personal lives. This abrupt end left Book 5 unfinished, with ongoing temple conflicts unresolved and no planned conclusion for the storyline. In the aftermath, the full archives of all published updates remain freely accessible online. The official store continues to offer print editions, merchandise, and digital downloads. Community forums are inactive, with the dedicated board showing no active sections. Rob Balder has not announced any new projects related to Erfworld as of November 2025, and the website maintains its discontinuation notice without updates.

Plot overviews

Book 0: Inner Peace (Through Superior Firepower)

Book 0: Inner Peace (Through Superior Firepower) serves as a to the main Erfworld series, set approximately 50 turns prior to the events of The Battle for Gobwin Knob. This text-only installment, comprising 81 episodes, was serialized on the official Erfworld website from October 31, 2011, to October 29, 2013. It centers on the early lives and development of Wanda Firebaugh, a Croakamancer from the side of Goodminton, and Jillian Zamussels, the Chief Warlord of . The narrative begins with the expansion of Haffaton, a side led by the Signamancer , which pursues a doctrine of through non-violent and fate manipulation to build an empire. This approach fosters internal tensions, culminating in a coup that reshapes the side's direction. The story then transitions to the response from , involving an that tests alliances and individual allegiances amid escalating conflicts. Throughout, the plot examines the mechanics of fate magic, which influences decisions and outcomes, while highlighting the struggles of personal loyalty in a world governed by strategic imperatives. Central themes revolve around internal moral conflicts, contrasting the pursuit of peace with the necessity of superior firepower, and the profound influence of Arkentools—powerful ancient artifacts capable of altering the balance of power in Erfworld. The book delves into how characters grapple with predestined paths versus free will, using philosophical interludes to explore these ideas within the broader lore of magic and warfare. Wanda's role as a caster bound by fate and Jillian's leadership in Faq's defense underscore these tensions without resolving into the main series' timeline. As a text-heavy work, Inner Peace (Through Superior Firepower) features dense prose and reflective passages that expand on Erfworld's conceptual framework, distinguishing it from the illustrated format of subsequent books. Written by series creator Rob Balder during a production hiatus for the artwork, it provides essential backstory on world mechanics like while maintaining a spoiler-free lens on character origins.

Book 1: The Battle for Gobwin Knob

Book 1: The Battle for Gobwin Knob is the inaugural volume of the Erfworld series, serialized from December 7, 2006, to May 22, 2009, spanning 150 full-color pages that establish the core narrative arc of an invasion and defense.https://forums.giantitp.com/archive/index.php/t-178724.html The story centers on Parson Gotti, an Earth-based strategy gamer who is inexplicably summoned to the of Erfworld as a perfect to lead the beleaguered side of Gobwin Knob.https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=132 This summoning thrusts him into a governed by game-like rules, where he must orchestrate the defense against a formidable known as the Royal Alliance, comprising multiple enemy sides intent on conquering the strategic Gobwin Knob territory.https://www.comixtalk.com/american_erfs_rob_balder_and_jamie_noguchi/ Throughout the arc, Parson employs innovative tactics drawn from his gaming expertise, forging unexpected alliances and leveraging the unique mechanics of Erfworld to turn the tide in an underdog campaign.https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=132 The narrative unfolds as a high-stakes military campaign, highlighting Parson's adaptation to his new role amid the rigid hierarchies and magical constraints of this fantasy realm.https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%201 Key developments include the formation of strategic partnerships with unlikely allies, such as non-human races, which challenge traditional power dynamics in the world.https://www.sjgames.com/ill/archive/April_23_2014/Supporting_Erfworld Central themes explore the disorientation of being transported into a simulated environment, the exhilaration and peril of achieving improbable victories against overwhelming odds, and the psychological weight of in a war where lives are expendable units.https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=132 These elements underscore Parson's internal conflicts as he navigates ethical dilemmas inherent to commanding forces in a turn-based, fate-bound universe.https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/17727977-erfworld Artistically, the book features illustrations by Noguchi, whose dynamic panel layouts and expressive character designs capture the chaos of battles and the whimsy of the game's lore.https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=132 Noguchi's work is complemented by foundational world-building infographics—informational sidebars and diagrams that elucidate Erfworld's rules, units, and magic systems, providing essential context without interrupting the flow of the story.https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Webcomic/Erfworld These visual aids, integral to the series' style, blend humor with exposition to immerse readers in the game's from the outset.https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%201

Book 2: Love is a Battlefield

Love is a Battlefield is the second book in the Erfworld series, serialized online from October 2009 to December 3, 2013, and spanning 114 full-color comic pages along with 59 illustrated text updates, 25 epilogues, and approximately 85,000 words of prose. This installment shifts the narrative from defensive survival to offensive expansion, centering on the growth of the Gobwin Knob side as it consolidates power and launches a major . The story unfolds across multiple perspectives, providing a multifaceted view of a pivotal conflict that tests the fledgling empire's stability. Key events highlight Gobwin Knob's territorial and strategic advancements, including the ambitious assault on Spacerock, the capital of Jetstone. As the side expands, interpersonal dynamics among leaders and units intensify, revealing tensions, loyalties, and emerging betrayals that complicate command structures and alliances. The romance arc introduces personal stakes amid the warfare, weaving emotional entanglements into the broader tactical maneuvers. Central themes explore and within the rigid hierarchies of , examining how empire-building exacts personal and political costs. The delves into the of , portraying how initial triumphs breed new vulnerabilities and ethical dilemmas in a turn-based world of magic and . Artistically, the showcases Xin Ye's illustrations, known for their intricate depictions of large-scale battles and unit interactions, enhancing the epic scope of engagements. Compared to Book 1, there is a heightened focus on relational developments, with character expressions and dialogues underscoring romantic and dramatic tensions. contributed to the epilogues, adding varied stylistic elements to the prose sections.

Book 3: Hamsterdance versus the Charlie Foxtrot

Hamsterdance versus the Charlie Foxtrot, the third book in the Erfworld series, encompasses 145 pages serialized from August 16, 2014, to March 26, 2016, centering on an arc of widespread chaos and precarious alliances in the wake of Gobwin Knob's consolidation of power. The narrative expands beyond the besieged capital to explore the ripple effects of prior conflicts, emphasizing how small missteps can unravel grand strategies in a world bound by magical and tactical rules. This installment delves into the fragility of coalitions, where former enemies must navigate trust and betrayal amid escalating threats. Key events unfold through a series of failed invasions launched by a coalition of Royal factions against Gobwin Knob, which expose vulnerabilities and spark disorder across Erfworld. In the , a hub for casters, turmoil erupts as these magic users confront the fallout from earlier upheavals, leading to internal rebellions and fractured loyalties that threaten the balance of power. Gotti, elevated to the role of Lord , shifts from command to intricate diplomatic efforts aimed at undermining Charlescomm's pervasive influence, seeking to dismantle the opposing alliance through negotiation and cunning. These maneuvers underscore the high stakes of inter-side politics, where every carries the risk of unintended consequences. The book explores core themes such as the inherent unpredictability of war, even within a structured turn-based system, and the disruptive force of caster rebellions that challenge established hierarchies. Strategic miscalculations by leaders on all sides drive the plot, illustrating how overreliance on superior numbers or magic can lead to catastrophic reversals, forcing characters to adapt in real time to evolving threats. These elements highlight the series' blend of strategy gaming tropes with deeper commentary on and contingency planning. Artistically, the volume benefits from David Hahn's guest illustrations for the initial segments, noted for their dynamic action panels that capture the frenzy of invasions and tense diplomatic standoffs with vivid energy and fluid motion. Subsequent pages transition to Xin Ye's artwork, assisted by Lauri Ahonen on inking, preserving the comic's characteristic detailed world-building while amplifying the chaotic scope through expansive layouts and expressive character designs. This collaborative approach enhances the visual storytelling, making the alliance arc's complexities more engaging and immersive.

Book 4: Lies and Dolls

Book 4: Lies and Dolls spans 190 pages and was serialized from March 28, 2016, to November 2, 2018, marking a shift toward an intrigue and arc in the Erfworld narrative. This installment delves into the personal and strategic challenges faced by key figures following prior conflicts, emphasizing internal dynamics over large-scale battles. The story builds on the established world mechanics, introducing elements that test loyalties and reveal underlying structures of power within the fantasy realm. Central to the plot is Parson's interrogation, which uncovers layers of manipulation and strategy, alongside the dramatic fall of Faq, highlighting vulnerabilities in longstanding alliances. The emergence of temple elements and doll-like constructs adds mystery and innovation to the proceedings, serving as pivotal devices that influence character decisions and plot progression. These developments create a tense atmosphere of , where characters navigate and to assert their agency. Supporting character arcs, such as those involving resilience amid isolation, contribute to the arc's emotional depth without overshadowing the core intrigue. The book explores themes of , where truths are obscured to maintain control, and resilience, as protagonists endure psychological and physical trials. Hidden powers emerge as a motif, suggesting untapped potentials within the world's rules, while shifting alliances underscore the fluidity of trust in a turn-based . These elements foster a focused on intellectual and emotional battles, contrasting with the more action-oriented prior volumes. Artistically, Lies and Dolls features the work of illustrator Xin Ye, whose style emphasizes atmospheric shading and expressive character designs to heighten psychological tension. The panels often convey confinement and introspection through detailed backgrounds and subtle facial cues, enhancing the themes of isolation and cunning. This visual approach, in collaboration with writer Rob Balder, maintains the comic's pun-laden humor while amplifying dramatic stakes.

Book 5: Temple Tantrum

Book 5: Temple Tantrum serves as the intended finale to the Erfworld series, centering on a climactic arc involving ancient temples and their activation within the world's lore. The book remains unfinished, comprising only a 35-page that explores the broader implications of prior events through new perspectives. Serialized on the official Erfworld website, it ran from November 9, 2018, to October 1, 2019, marking the last updates before the series' hiatus. The narrative shifts focus to new protagonists, including the barbarian warlord Fumo, who emerges as a key figure in a remote setting, alongside other characters like the caster Paige and figures from emerging sides such as and . These introductions set the stage for events revolving around temple activations, which trigger escalating tantrums—metaphorical and literal outbursts of conflict and disruption across factions. Revelations about the underlying mechanics of Erfworld, including the roles of the Titans, unfold gradually, heightening tension toward an anticipated climax without reaching resolution. Central themes emphasize faith in the world's divine creators, portrayed through temple rituals and believer dynamics, while tantrums symbolize against predetermined fates and systemic constraints. The incomplete status underscores an unfinished potential for tying together lingering narrative threads, such as post-Book 4 geopolitical shifts, leaving the story's ultimate outcomes ambiguous. Artistically, the book features Rob Balder handling illustrations personally for the first time in the main series, adopting a mix of super-deformed character designs and experimental panel layouts to accommodate irregular update schedules caused by production . This self-illustration approach allows for tighter integration of text and visuals, enhancing the thematic emphasis on disruption and amid the arc's unfinished scope.

Reception

Critical reviews

Erfworld garnered acclaim for its unique fusion of turn-based strategy gaming mechanics with fantasy narrative. In 2007, Time magazine ranked the first volume, The Battle for Gobwin Knob, sixth on its list of the Top 10 Graphic Novels of the year, praising its setup of a depressed strategy-obsessed nerd summoned to a game-like world. Critics highlighted the series' satirical take on gaming tropes and innovative world-building. A 2010 Wired review called it "the geekiest comic ever" and "incredibly geeky in a fantastic way," applauding its humor that both satirizes and embraces strategy games while appealing to gamers and non-gamers alike, alongside artwork that balances bitter and sweet tones effectively. The Webcomic Overlook gave it 4 out of 5 stars in 2008, lauding the engaging mystery of the RPG world's rules, the unpredictable storytelling, and the protagonist's strategic outsider perspective, with art inspired by Jean Giraud evoking fanciful designs and vibrant colors. Some reviews pointed to early flaws in characterization and style. The Webcomic Overlook noted the protagonist's initial unlikability due to poor and arrogance, alongside bland one-dimensional allies and grating childlike such as "dwagons" and "Gobwin Knob." Analytical discussions have explored Erfworld's gamification philosophy, examining how its mechanics reflect real-world strategy and in a simulated . On RPG.net, contributors dissected the series' and narrative implications, viewing it as a lens on player agency and world rules akin to tabletop RPGs. Retrospectives in 2025 underscore its enduring niche appeal among gaming enthusiasts, crediting the innovative premise for a dedicated following despite the unfinished status.

Community and legacy

The Erfworld fandom demonstrated strong engagement throughout the series' run, with dedicated forums on the official erfworld.com site fostering discussions from the comic's 2006 launch until its 2019 discontinuation. Community members contributed to the Erfworld Wiki, a volunteer-driven resource that cataloged the series' lore, characters, and mechanics as a vital effort endorsed by the creators. Fans produced artwork inspired by the comic's distinctive style, with galleries featuring character illustrations and scene recreations shared on platforms like DeviantArt. Additionally, enthusiasts developed RPG campaigns and systems based on Erfworld's turn-based strategy elements, including the unofficial "Second Dawn" game, which adapts the world's rules for tabletop play. The series cultivated a niche following among , drawn to its meta-exploration of tropes and RPG conventions, as highlighted in profiles of its gaming-centric narrative. Cultural impact extended to fan-generated memes and puns, such as recurring jokes around the character Stanley's epithet "the Tool" and the comic's wordplay-heavy , which became hallmarks of community humor. Erfworld's legacy endures through archival preservation, with the full comic accessible via the official mirrors at archives.erfworld.com, maintaining its availability despite the lack of official revival. The unfinished narrative has inspired ongoing , including works like "The Last Turn" that extend the storyline, reflecting the series' lasting appeal within creative circles. Community responses to the cancellation blended grief over the abrupt end with appreciation for the innovative storytelling.

References

  1. https://www.cnn.com/2011/10/07/living/web-comic-spotlight-erfworlds-rob-balder
  2. http://comixtalk.com/american_erfs_rob_balder_and_jamie_noguchi/
  3. https://hugonoms2017.fandom.com/wiki/Xin_Ye_and_Lauri_Ahonen
  4. http://fleen.com/2019/10/14/new-arrivals-and-an-unexpected-departure/
  5. https://erfworld.com/
  6. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%201/1
  7. https://www.erfworld.com/book-1-the-battle-for-gobwin-knob/
  8. https://archives.erfworld.com/
  9. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Webcomic/Erfworld
  10. https://webcomicoverlook.wordpress.com/2008/08/20/the-webcomic-overlook-52-erfworld/
  11. https://www.wired.com/2010/01/erfworld-geekiest-comic-ever/
  12. https://www.dragon-quill.net/erfworld-fate-and-poor-planning/
  13. https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=148
  14. https://www.ovff.org/pegasus/people/rob-balder.html
  15. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1554093685/erfworld-year-of-the-dwagon
  16. https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=132
  17. https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=145
  18. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1554093685/erfworld-print-book-2-and-draw-book-3
  19. https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=category&category_id=264
  20. https://scratchpad.fandom.com/wiki/Erfworld_Magic
  21. https://forums.giantitp.com/showthread.php?102348-Erfworld-Magic-Fundamentals
  22. https://archives.erfworld.com/book%2B2/43
  23. https://archives.erfworld.com/book%2B2/70
  24. https://scratchpad.fandom.com/wiki/Parson_Gotti
  25. https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Characters/Erfworld
  26. https://scratchpad.fandom.com/wiki/Stanley_the_Tool
  27. https://scratchpad.fandom.com/wiki/Wanda_Firebaugh
  28. https://tropedia.fandom.com/wiki/Erfworld/Characters
  29. https://scratchpad.fandom.com/wiki/Erfworld_Characters
  30. https://scratchpad.fandom.com/wiki/Charlie_%28Erfworld%29
  31. https://forums.giantitp.com/showthread.php?1629153-Greetings-from-Erfworld
  32. https://forums.giantitp.com/showthread.php?103605-Notes-About-the-Erfworld-Book
  33. https://forums.giantitp.com/archive/index.php/t-178724.html
  34. https://forums.giantitp.com/showthread.php?42736-Erfworld-Descriptive-Table-of-Contents
  35. https://www.amazon.com/Erfworld-Book-Battle-Gobwin-Knob/dp/0983137811
  36. https://store.erfworld.com/cart.php?target=product&product_id=144
  37. https://www.amazon.com/Erfworld-Meet-Jetstones-Issue-Battlefield/dp/0983137803
  38. https://forums.sufficientvelocity.com/threads/second-dawn-the-unofficial-erfworld-rpg.119514/
  39. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3F18tIYl3rY
  40. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%205
  41. https://forums.erfworld.com/
  42. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%200
  43. http://fleen.com/2011/10/25/like-molasses-only-not-delicious/
  44. https://archives.erfworld.com/book%2B0/1
  45. https://archives.erfworld.com/book%2B0/68
  46. https://archives.erfworld.com/book%2B0/75
  47. https://archives.erfworld.com/book%2B0/81
  48. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%202
  49. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%204
  50. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%2B5/1
  51. https://archives.erfworld.com/Book%2B5/8
  52. https://forum.rpg.net/index.php?threads/erfworld-epistemology.851846/
  53. http://werwolfesden.blogspot.com/2025/03/erfworld.html
  54. https://forums.giantitp.com/showthread.php?64399-Erfworld-Wiki
  55. https://www.deviantart.com/tag/erfworld
  56. https://wanderinginn.com/the-last-turn/
  57. https://exilian.co.uk/forum/index.php?topic=6024.0
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.