Hubbry Logo
HutareeHutareeMain
Open search
Hutaree
Community hub
Hutaree
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Hutaree
Hutaree
Hutaree
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Hutaree /huːˈtɑːriː/ ⓘ was a militia movement group adhering to the ideology of the Christian Patriot movement, based near Adrian, Michigan, in the United States.[1] The group formed in early 2006.[2] The name "Hutaree" appears to be a neologism; the group's website says that the name means "Christian warriors",[3] but an investigation by the FBI concluded the word does not have a Christian background. The group became widely known in 2010 after the United States FBI prosecuted them in federal court for an alleged plan for violent revolt.[4] The prosecution said they intended to kill a police officer and to attack the funeral with bombs. The presiding judge dismissed these charges. Three members pleaded guilty to possessing a machine gun and were sentenced to time served.[5]

Key Information

Beliefs

[edit]

The Hutaree's website claimed: "We see the end of the age coming quickly, and with it some very rough times ahead, as foretold by God's word."[6] The militia describes its goals. "The only thing on earth to save the testimony and those who follow it, are the members of the testimony, until the return of Christ in the clouds. We Hutaree are prepared to defend all who belong to Christ and save them. To those who do not, we will still spread the word and fight to keep it, until the time of the great coming."[7]

According to some sources, the group is described as practicing survivalism.[8] Most of the members were active voters with unidentified political party affiliations.[9]

The Hutaree has been known to lend assistance to other militias in the past, with such things as searching for missing persons.[10]

The Hutaree insignia includes a sword, crossed spears, and the letters "CCR" which stand for "Colonial Christian Republic".[11] Hutaree members use a unique system of paramilitary ranks with titles from highest to lowest: Radok, Boramander, Zulif, Arkon, Rifleman (three grades), Lukore, and Gunner (three grades).[11] University of Pennsylvania linguistics professor Mark Liberman commented: "I don't see basis in biblical or military history for Radok, Boramander, Zulif, Arkon, and Lukore."[citation needed]

The group remained exclusively Christian but attempted to maintain relationships with individuals and groups that adhere to other beliefs, especially within the militia movement. One militia associate of the group, named Matt Savino, was denied membership in the Hutaree when he revealed that he was a Muslim. Savino was referred to join the Michigan Militia by the Hutaree who declined his membership but maintained contact with Mr Savino. Savino eventually was elected to be a "Colonel" in the Michigan Militia.[12] Savino later provided information to the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) which appears to have assisted them in capturing the last indicted Hutaree at large, Joshua Stone.[13]

Criminal investigation

[edit]

From March 28 to 30, 2010, nine people thought to be Hutaree members were arrested in police raids in Michigan, Ohio, and Indiana (in Hammond), for their alleged involvement in a plot to kill various police officers and possibly civilians using illegal explosives and/or firearms.[14] An undercover agent played a role in the investigation that led to indictments. Grand jury testimony by a law enforcement officer referred to an "undercover FBI agent" who worked on the case; the FBI declined to comment, but infiltration is a common tactic for law-enforcement officials targeting domestic militia groups.[15] The FBI informant was later revealed to be Hal Turner.[16]

patch worn commonly for militant members

The group was allegedly preparing for what they believed would be an apocalyptic battle with the forces of the Antichrist, who they believed would be supported and defended by local, state, and federal law enforcement.[1]

On May 3, 2010, a federal judge ordered that all nine members be freed on bond until their trial, saying that prosecutors were not able to demonstrate that the defendants would pose a danger if released.[17]

The United States Attorney's Office stated that the Hutaree allegedly planned "to kill an unidentified member of local law enforcement and then attack the law enforcement officers who gather in Michigan for the funeral".[18] The press release further stated that nine had been indicted by a federal grand jury in Detroit on charges of seditious conspiracy, attempted use of weapons of mass destruction, teaching the use of explosive materials, and possessing a firearm during a crime of violence. The indictment said that the Hutaree planned to attack unspecified law enforcement vehicles during the funeral procession for an unspecified officer or officers they planned to kill on an unspecified occasion, using unspecified explosively formed penetrator improvised explosive devices (which under federal law are considered "weapons of mass destruction").[18]

Some articles suggested the Hutaree had not yet determined whom they would kill in law enforcement, or even that they wished to kill a law enforcement officer to begin a war with law enforcement, while not having any specific target.[19] The FBI was aided in its investigation by members of another militia group.[20]

Members taken into custody

[edit]
In order as shown: Tina Mae Stone, Joshua Matthew Stone, David Brian Stone Sr., David Brian Stone Jr., Thomas William Piatek, Michael David Meeks, Kristopher T. Sickles, Joshua Clough, Jacob J. Ward

Nine members of the group that were arrested:[21]

  • Tina Mae Stone, 44
  • Joshua Matthew Stone, 21
  • David Brian Stone Sr, 44, center (a.k.a. "RD", "Joe Stonewall", "Captain Hutaree")
  • David Brian Stone Jr., 19 (a.k.a. "Junior")
  • Thomas William Piatek, 46
  • Michael David Meeks, 40
  • Kristopher T. Sickles, 27 (a.k.a. "Pale Horse")
  • Joshua Clough, 28 (a.k.a. "Azzurlin", "Az", "Mouse", "Jason Z", "Charles")
  • Jacob J. Ward, 33 (a.k.a. "Jake", "Nate")

On May 3, 2010, U.S. District Judge Victoria A. Roberts ordered all nine defendants to be released on bond, over the objection of federal prosecutors. "The order is silent as to any financial aspects of the bonds. In federal court, defendants are normally released on $10,000 unsecured bonds, meaning they do not have to put up any money."[according to whom?] The court ruled that five of the Hutaree remain in custody. The ruling applied to David Stone Sr., Joshua Stone, Joshua Clough, Michael Meeks, and Thomas Piatek. Four other members had already been released on bond. The court ordered that they be placed on electronic monitors.

In addition to being confined to their homes, outside of time spent away from work (or while seeking employment as per standard federal pretrial release conditions), some additional requirements were placed on individual defendants, for example, alleged leader David Brian Stone Sr. was barred from having any contact with Michigan-based militia activist Mark Koernke.[citation needed]

Prosecutors added charges in June 2012 stating that David Stone Sr., Joshua Stone, and Clough illegally possessed automatic rifles and that David Stone Sr., David Stone Jr., and Joshua Stone possessed unregistered firearms, charging them with violations of the National Firearms Act. Clough had earlier entered a guilty plea in December 2011 to a weapons law violation in a plea agreement, with leniency suggested in light of his cooperative testimony in the case. David Stone Sr. and Joshua Stone eventually later entered a guilty pleas in March 2012 to some NFA violations as part of a plea agreement.[5]

Pre-trial hearings

[edit]

In February 2011, Judge Victoria A. Roberts set a new trial date of September 13, 2011, after defense attorneys asked for more time to review the hundreds of pages of evidence prosecutors had provided them. Attorneys also cited the complexity of the case in asking for a delay. The case originally was to go to trial on February 28, 2011. Roberts first delayed the trial in December 2010 until April after attorneys made a similar request. Defense attorneys argued that statements made by Hutaree were constitutionally protected free speech and not plans for an attack.

In January 2012, a federal judge issued an order granting the defense attorneys' motion to exclude prosecution testimony by an expert drawing parallels between the defendants' beliefs and various conspiracy theories about Ruby Ridge, the Waco siege, the Oklahoma City bombing, and 9/11, concluding: "It is largely irrelevant to the issues in dispute and what little probative value it might add is substantially outweighed by the risks of undue prejudice, confusion and misleading the jury."[22]

Trial

[edit]

The trial began on February 13, 2012.[23] On March 27, 2012, a federal judge acquitted seven Hutaree defendants of the most serious charges related to conspiracy and sedition; they were free to go. David Stone Sr. and Joshua Stone continued to be held on weapons-related charges.[24] On August 8, 2012, David Stone Sr., Joshua Stone, and Joshua Clough were sentenced to time served on weapons-related charges, to which they pleaded guilty, and placed under supervision for two years.[25]

Return of seized property

[edit]

After the acquittal of seven Hutaree members, the property seized during a March 2010 raid was returned to the owners. Items included a wedding ring, firearms and surplus items of military equipment previously owned by Hutaree members.[26] The FBI returned Tina Stone's six guns, including her AR-15 semi-automatic rifle.[27]

Seized items that had been returned included hundreds of thousands of rounds of ammunition, numerous weapons and other material, but several items, including illegal weapons taken as evidence, had been destroyed by the Justice Department.[27][28][29]

Lawsuit

[edit]

Following the group's acquittal, Piatek and two other members filed a lawsuit against the federal agents who had infiltrated the group claiming violation of due process as well as first and second amendment violations. In May, 2015, an appeals court rejected to hear their claim.[30]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Hutaree

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Hutaree (/huːˈtɑːriː/) was a small, millenarian Christian organization founded in rural by David Stone Sr. in the late 2000s, whose members described themselves as training "for the end time battles to keep the testimony of Jesus Christ alive," drawing on biblical exhortations to lay down one's life for brethren. The group's name, derived from an invented term meaning "Christian warrior," reflected its apocalyptic ideology, which portrayed the federal government, law enforcement, and entities like the as agents of the in a coming spiritual war. Unlike broader constitutionalist s, Hutaree emphasized religious exclusivity, rejecting non-Christians and imposing strict hierarchies under Stone's leadership, while conducting exercises marked by unsafe weapons handling and violent rhetoric aimed at sparking confrontation to hasten Christ's return. The group attracted federal scrutiny after an and undercover agent infiltrated its ranks, revealing discussions of ambushing police officers—potentially at traffic stops or funerals—and using improvised explosives to ignite a broader uprising against the . In March 2010, the FBI raided Hutaree properties across , , and , arresting nine members on charges including , attempting to kill federal officers, and possession of weapons of mass destruction. Defendants amassed over 100 firearms, including illegal automatic weapons, but prosecutors alleged no imminent plot beyond preparatory talk. During the 2012 trial in U.S. District Court, Victoria Roberts acquitted seven members of and charges, ruling that the government had established strong anti-government sentiments and poor firearm safety but failed to demonstrate a mutual agreement or specific overt acts requisite for . Two defendants pleaded guilty to weapons violations, receiving sentences up to several years, while the acquittals highlighted evidentiary thresholds distinguishing protected ideological expression from prosecutable plots. The outcome, amid infiltration tactics, fueled debates on federal overreach in monitoring dissident groups expressing end-times rather than immediate violence.

Ideology and Beliefs

Christian Patriot Framework

The Hutaree militia's ideology integrated with a patriot critique of federal , framing adherents as divinely ordained warriors tasked with resisting satanic encroachment on American and biblical truth. The group's name, a constructed term meaning "Christian warrior," encapsulated this fusion, drawing from scriptural mandates for spiritual combat while invoking Second Amendment rights as a bulwark against tyranny. Their doctrine emphasized premillennial , anticipating global conflicts—such as an invasion of by , , and —as precursors to the Antichrist's rise, whom they equated with corrupt governmental systems subverting constitutional order. This framework positioned law enforcement and federal agencies as instruments of the "beast" prophesied in , enforcing deception and persecution against faithful Christians. Hutaree members conducted prayers decrying government "evil and deception," vowing protection from such forces through armed vigilance and communal training. Leader David Stone Sr. served as the primary interpreter of scripture, deriving operational directives from passages on end-times tribulation and the testimony of , which subordinated group actions to prophetic fulfillment over secular law. Unlike broader networks prioritizing without explicit , Hutaree's Christian patriot orientation demanded rigorous adherence to Stone's biblical , rejecting intergroup alliances that diluted doctrinal purity. This exclusivity fostered a , with training exercises simulating battles against Antichrist-aligned foes to preserve Christian testimony amid anticipated chaos. Such views, while rooted in evangelical apocalyptic traditions, extended to practical preparations like stockpiling weapons and explosives for a post-collapse .

End-Times Preparation and Anti-Government Stance

The Hutaree adhered to a millenarian Christian ideology drawn from apocalyptic interpretations of the , emphasizing preparation for the prophesied arrival of the and subsequent end-times conflicts. Group members positioned themselves as "Christian warriors" obligated to preserve the testimony of Jesus Christ through armed struggle against satanic forces. Their website declared: "Preparing for the end time battles to keep the testimony of Jesus Christ alive," asserting that "one day, as prophecy says, there will be an " and that "all Christians must know this and prepare, just as Christ commanded." Preparation entailed military training, including firearms practice and explosives handling in wooded areas, to equip members for survival and combat in anticipated biblical wars. The group interpreted Jesus's teachings as endorsing "using the " alongside practical gear to endure. They monitored purported apocalyptic signs, such as microchip implantation and European political unification, via a "Beast Watch" feature on their site, linking these to end-times fulfillment. This eschatological framework intertwined with a vehement anti-government posture, portraying federal authorities and law enforcement as instruments of satanic influence or a nascent New World Order. Hutaree designated local, state, and federal police as the "brotherhood"—a unified adversarial entity—against which they plotted lethal ambushes to provoke a massive governmental retaliation, thereby igniting wider civil unrest. Leader David Stone Sr. articulated an irreversible "state of war" with the government, insisting "this war will come whether we are ready or not" and expressing readiness for violent escalation. Unlike more secular constitutionalist militias, Hutaree's religiously absolutist outlook excluded non-Christians and prioritized prophetic confrontation over defensive patriotism.

Views on Law Enforcement and Federal Authority

The Hutaree militia regarded local, state, and enforcement personnel as the "brotherhood," a collective aligned with satanic forces and opposed to . Group members explicitly labeled police as "enemies of Christ," viewing them as the frontline enforcers of a corrupt, tyrannical that suppressed religious freedoms and heralded the arrival of the . This perspective stemmed from their apocalyptic interpretation of biblical prophecy, particularly passages in depicting a "beast" of global control, which they associated with modern federal authority and its agents. Leader David Stone Sr. articulated these sentiments in recorded conversations, describing as direct adversaries and advocating for violent opposition, including discussions of ambushing officers and targeting their families to provoke broader conflict. Hutaree doctrine emphasized preparation for end-times warfare, positioning federal institutions as part of a New World Order conspiracy that demanded armed resistance to preserve constitutional ideals and divine testimony. Members trained with this mindset, stockpiling weapons and explosives not merely for defense but to initiate or escalate confrontations with authorities, as evidenced by their operational plans to draw into ambushes. These views distinguished Hutaree from more mainstream patriot militias, which often focused on constitutional advocacy without explicit calls for preemptive against police; Hutaree's framed such actions as biblically mandated against impending . While federal prosecutors cited these beliefs in charges filed on March 29, 2010, a 2012 court ruling acquitted members of plotting, finding insufficient evidence of an imminent agreement to act, though the expressed ideology of enmity toward remained undisputed based on intercepts and .

Formation and Activities

Founding and Leadership

The Hutaree was founded circa 2008 by David Brian Stone Sr. in , with documented activities commencing in August 2008. The group, based near Clayton and , operated from rural properties used for exercises involving firearms and tactical maneuvers. Stone, a resident of Clayton, established the organization around a core of family members and recruits drawn from the local area, promoting it via an online presence that outlined its name—derived from a coined term meaning "Christian warrior"—and preparatory ethos. Stone served as the primary leader, often referred to internally as the authoritative figure responsible for doctrinal interpretation and operational direction. played integral roles: wife Tina Stone handled logistical aspects, while sons Joshua Matthew Stone and David Brian Stone Jr. participated in training sessions, including instruction on explosives in June 2009. This familial structure formed the nucleus of the group's approximately nine core members, who conducted meetings and field exercises under Stone's guidance. Leadership emphasized hierarchical command aligned with Stone's vision of end-times readiness, differentiating Hutaree from broader networks by its overt religious framing rather than strictly constitutionalist appeals. Recruits like Michael Meeks, Thomas Piatek, and others joined through personal networks, but Stone retained centralized control over ideology and activities until federal intervention in 2010.

Organizational Structure and Training

The Hutaree maintained a centralized modeled on lines, with David Brian Stone Sr. as the principal leader, referred to by members as "Captain Hutaree" or "RD," exercising authority over doctrinal interpretations, operational decisions, and training directives. His son, Joshua Matthew Stone, functioned as a , while the group overall adopted a closed-cell format that prioritized exclusivity, limiting core membership to a small cadre of about nine individuals, including Stone's wife, Tina Mae Stone, and other family relations, to foster internal cohesion and isolation from external scrutiny. This familial emphasis and rigid contrasted with the more open, merit-based structures in other militias, which and incorporated broader . Training emphasized preparation for anticipated end-times conflict through drills, including small-unit tactics, live-ammunition firearms practice, and hands-on instruction in improvised explosives and armor-penetrating munitions, often held at Stone's rural property near , or in remote wooded sites. In June 2009, for instance, David Stone Sr. and his son David Brian Stone Jr. personally demonstrated techniques for assembling destructive devices to other members. The group documented some sessions via videos showcasing tactical maneuvers, though these rarely depicted large formations, reflecting the limited scale of participation. Peer militias in the region, including those with active-duty veterans, consistently critiqued Hutaree as deficient in protocols, citing repeated lapses such as inadvertent muzzle sweeps toward participants, a near-miss grazing an individual's head, and a self-inflicted during exercises that prompted intervention by observers. These practices deviated markedly from the standardized, defensive-oriented regimens in constitutionalist groups, which enforced strict discipline and viewed Hutaree's methods as reckless and indicative of an offensive rather than protective posture, ultimately contributing to their and reports to federal authorities.

Public Perception Prior to Arrests

The Hutaree, founded by David Stone Sr. around 2008, operated primarily in rural southern with limited visibility beyond specialized online forums and local networks prior to their arrests on March 27–29, 2010. The group maintained a public website featuring verses, a "Beast Watch" section monitoring perceived end-times threats, and statements framing members as "Christian warriors" preparing for apocalyptic conflict, which attracted a niche interested in millenarian ideologies. They also shared training videos on platforms like and MySpace, depicting firearms exercises that highlighted safety lapses, such as improper weapon handling during 2008 sessions observed by affiliates of the Southeast Michigan Volunteer (SMVM). Within the broader Michigan militia community, the Hutaree were perceived as outliers due to their intense religious fervor, closed-cell structure excluding non-Christians, and deviation from constitutionalist principles emphasized by groups like the SMVM and . SMVM leaders expressed concerns over the Hutaree's unsafe practices and rhetoric as early as , leading them to distance their organization and report potential threats to the FBI via emails documenting observed behaviors. Other militias viewed them not as representative allies but as a fringe "social club" prone to recklessness, rather than a disciplined force aligned with mainstream patriot movements. The general public had minimal awareness of the Hutaree before the arrests, with no significant coverage and their activities confined to private trainings, conspiracy material distribution (e.g., anti-government DVDs like Beyond Treason), and low-key recruitment in areas like and Bridgeport Township. This obscurity stemmed from their insular operations and lack of public events, contrasting with more visible militias that engaged in open preparedness fairs or political advocacy. Local residents in affected townships reported occasional sightings of armed gatherings but dismissed them as eccentric gun enthusiasts rather than an imminent danger, reflecting a broader rural tolerance for such groups amid Second Amendment culture.

FBI Investigation and Arrests

Informant Infiltration

The FBI began infiltrating the Hutaree militia in August 2008 through local Dan Murray, who embedded himself within the group by attending meetings, training exercises, and social gatherings while secretly recording conversations. Murray, aged 57 at the time of his trial testimony in , operated under FBI direction until approximately one month before the March 2010 arrests, capturing discussions led by Hutaree founder David Brian Stone Sr. about anti-law enforcement sentiments and potential violent actions. For his role, Murray received about $31,000 in cash payments from the FBI, including $12,700 for prior investigative work unrelated to Hutaree. To deepen penetration, the FBI introduced a second operative, Steve Haug, who posed as a truck driver from and joined the group around 2009, participating in activities such as construction under Stone's guidance and accompanying members to events like a February 6, 2010, rally attempt. Haug's undercover work, combined with Murray's recordings, yielded audio and video evidence of Hutaree members discussing plans to police, including scenarios involving roadside bombs and follow-up attacks on funerals, which prosecutors later cited in charges. This dual-informant strategy, spanning nearly two years, formed the core of the FBI's evidence-gathering operation, which involved surveillance across , , and and culminated in coordinated raids arresting nine Hutaree members on March 29, 2010. Court records indicate the informants' involvement raised defense claims of and inducement, as Murray and Haug actively participated in and encouraged certain preparations, though federal authorities maintained the infiltration exposed pre-existing intent rather than fabricating threats.

Alleged Plot Details

The federal indictment against nine Hutaree members, unsealed on March 29, , alleged a multi-phase plot to initiate an armed uprising against the U.S. government by first assassinating an unidentified local , using suppressed rifles or other weapons to carry out the killing. Following the officer's death, the group planned to detonate improvised explosive devices (IEDs) disguised as debris along the route of the , targeting responding personnel to maximize casualties and provoke a larger police mobilization. Prosecutors claimed the subsequent chaos would serve as a catalyst for broader attacks, including deploying additional IEDs against police vehicles and staging ambushes on federal targets such as agencies, IRS facilities, and personnel deemed part of an "anti-Christ system" by the Hutaree. The group had reportedly acquired and tested materials for the IEDs, including components for high-explosive devices using (TATP), and conducted reconnaissance missions disguised as routine activities to identify vulnerable response patterns. Central to the allegations was the leadership of David Brian Stone Sr., known as "Captain Hutaree," who along with his wife Tina Stone and sons David Jr. and , coordinated the scheme through encrypted communications and sessions emphasizing for an apocalyptic conflict. The plot was framed as preparation for end-times warfare, with the initial police killings intended to draw federal forces into a trap, escalating to a national insurrection against perceived tyrannical authority.

Raids and Initial Charges (March 2010)

On March 27 and 28, 2010, the (FBI), along with other federal, state, and local agencies, executed coordinated raids across , , and targeting the Hutaree group. These operations resulted in the of nine individuals associated with the group, including its leader David Brian Stone Sr., also known as "Captain Hutaree," his wife Tina Stone, two of his sons, and several other members. The raids were prompted by from undercover informants indicating preparations for violent actions against . The following day, March 29, 2010, a federal in unsealed an charging the nine defendants with under 18 U.S.C. § 2384, among other offenses. The count alleged that the Hutaree members had conspired to levy war against the and to oppose its authority by force, with plans to initiate conflict by killing an unidentified local and ambushing responders. Additional charges included attempting to kill and use weapons of mass destruction against persons in the , teaching and demonstrating the making and use of explosives and incendiary devices, and possessing firearms in furtherance of a crime of violence. According to the , the group intended to follow the initial —using improvised devices disguised as roadside debris—with attacks on the officer's to maximize casualties among , thereby sparking a broader uprising against the federal government. Authorities seized illegal weapons during the raids, including a fully automatic and destructive devices such as a silencer-fitted and materials. The defendants faced potential life sentences if convicted on the most serious counts.

Pre-Trial Detention and Bail Hearings

Following the March 29, 2010, raids and arrests of nine Hutaree members on federal charges including , attempting to use weapons of mass destruction, and teaching use to commit violent crimes, U.S. Magistrate Judge Michael J. Hluchaniuk ordered eight defendants detained without bond on April 2, 2010, during initial hearings in federal court. The decision cited the gravity of the charges—potentially carrying life sentences—and evidence of flight risk, including the group's training, possession of illegal weapons like machine guns and explosives, and anti-government rhetoric recorded by informants portraying plans to ambush police and spark . A ninth member, Michael Meeks, was separately denied bail on March 29, 2010, by an Indiana state judge after arrest there, based on similar concerns over the group's alleged plot. Detention hearings for the group reconvened in early May 2010 before U.S. District Victoria A. Roberts, who on May 3 ruled that all nine defendants could be released on bond with conditions such as GPS monitoring, confinement, and surrender of firearms, finding insufficient of an imminent to public safety or concrete plans to execute beyond "generalized threats." Prosecutors, led by U.S. Attorney , argued against release, emphasizing undercover recordings of leader David Stone Sr. discussing explosives training and statements like "We have to put the head on a stick" regarding police, but the judge noted the hearings' limited scope for full review and questioned the specificity tying to actionable . The government immediately appealed to the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, which on May 6, 2010, issued a stay halting the release order pending review, keeping all nine in custody. By June 8, 2010, four lower-level members—identified as , Michael Hurst, Shawn Stone, and Thomas Piatek—were granted bond after further review, subject to strict supervision, while the five core figures including David Stone Sr., his sons and David Jr., and Joshua Clute remained detained due to perceived leadership roles and stronger evidence of weapons handling and plot discussions. On June 22, 2010, Roberts upheld detention for these five, affirming risks under the Reform Act based on testimony of Hutaree drills simulating police ambushes and acquisition of materials like for bombs. The detained members stayed in federal custody through the 2012 trial, with defense motions to revisit bond repeatedly denied amid ongoing disputes over reliability and claims.

Trial Proceedings and Evidence Challenges (2012)

The trial of the Hutaree members commenced in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of in , presided over by Judge Victoria A. Roberts, with proceedings unfolding primarily in and 2012 following nearly two years of pretrial detention. The prosecution presented its case-in-chief, relying extensively on audio and video recordings captured by an FBI , Thomas William Piwowarski, who had infiltrated the group, and an undercover agent. These materials depicted discussions among defendants about anti-government sentiments, hypothetical scenarios of conflict with , and preparations involving weapons and tactics, but lacked documentation of concrete operational plans. Defense attorneys challenged the admissibility and sufficiency of the , arguing that the recordings reflected protected First Amendment speech—rhetorical expressions of frustration and apocalyptic beliefs rooted in the group's Christian fundamentalist ideology—rather than actionable criminal intent. They contended that the informant's presence may have influenced conversations toward , emphasizing that no overt acts toward the alleged plot, such as targeting specific police officials or acquiring weapons of mass destruction, were verifiably executed or imminently planned. On March 27, 2012, after the prosecution rested, Judge Roberts granted a directed of on the core charges of and conspiracy to murder police officers or use weapons of mass destruction against seven defendants, ruling that the failed to establish an agreement to oppose U.S. authority by force or any specific, credible scheme. Roberts deemed the prosecution's proof "minuscule" and "woefully lacking," noting it would require an "incredible" inference to conclude the defendants shared a mutual understanding of a unified plot, as required under 18 U.S.C. § 2384 for . She highlighted that while the recordings revealed "hateful" and "intemperate" language toward and federal institutions, such expressions alone did not constitute without evidence of coordinated action or imminent violence. The acquittals applied to David Stone Jr., Tina Stone, Michael Meeks, Kristopher Eggers, and three others, dismissing all major charges against them. Concurrently, group leader David Stone Sr. and his son Joshua Stone entered guilty pleas on March 29, 2012, to lesser firearms offenses involving unregistered machine guns, receiving sentences later that year. Remaining weapons-related trials for other defendants proceeded but resulted in minimal additional convictions, underscoring the evidentiary hurdles in linking militia training and rhetoric to federal statutes.

Verdicts, Acquittals, and Plea Deals

On March 27, 2012, U.S. District Judge Victoria A. Roberts granted a judgment of to five Hutaree members—David Stone Jr., Tina Stone, Michael Meeks, Kristopher Eoannou, and Thomas Piatek—dismissing all remaining charges against them, including , attempting to use weapons of mass destruction, and teaching the use of explosives. The ruling followed the close of the government's case, where Roberts determined that of the group's anti-government and preparations did not sufficiently prove a to oppose U.S. authority by force, as required under ; instead, it reflected protected speech and mere possession of legal firearms. Two other defendants, David Stone Sr. (the group's leader) and his son Joshua Stone, entered guilty pleas on March 29, 2012, to lesser federal weapons offenses: possessing unregistered machine guns and a silencer, respectively, in violation of the . Each faced a maximum of 10 years in prison and fines up to $250,000, but on August 8, 2012, Roberts sentenced them to plus , denying prosecutors' requests for additional incarceration and citing their already extensive . A seventh defendant, Joshua Clough, had pleaded guilty in December 2011 to possessing an unregistered , receiving without further . The ninth member, Jacob Ward, was ruled mentally incompetent to stand trial and did not face conviction on the original charges. No defendants were convicted of the initial or mass casualty plot allegations, which carried potential life sentences.

Aftermath and Legacy

Return of Seized Property

In March 2012, following the of seven Hutaree members on and related charges, U.S. District Judge Victoria Roberts ordered the return of seized property to those individuals, dismissing the bulk of the government's case against them. The property included firearms, , tactical gear, and other items confiscated during the March 2010 raids on Hutaree premises in and . David Stone Sr., the group's leader, and his son Joshua Stone, who pleaded guilty to possessing unregistered machine guns under the , had portions of their seized property returned in April 2012, excluding the illegal weapons which were forfeited as part of their pleas. Federal agents delivered the items to David Stone Sr.'s residence, marking the partial restitution after over two years in custody. Acquitted member Michael Meeks, also known as Mike Piatek, specifically petitioned for the return of his guns, , and training equipment, which authorities were required to release absent further legal holds. The return process highlighted tensions over practices, as the government retained machine guns and explosive components tied to the guilty pleas, while non-contraband items like vehicles and personal effects were repatriated without additional civil forfeiture proceedings. No widespread reports emerged of prolonged delays or denials for acquitted members, though the episode fueled later civil claims against federal authorities for investigative overreach.

Civil Lawsuits Against Federal Authorities

In April 2013, two Hutaree members, Michael Meeks of , and Thomas Piatek of —both acquitted of major charges in the criminal proceedings—filed a civil in the U.S. Court for the Eastern of against several FBI agents, including Robert Larsen, and the government. The plaintiffs alleged that federal authorities violated their Fourth Amendment rights through warrantless searches and seizures during the March 2010 raids on their homes, as well as Fifth Amendment violations stemming from the use of undercover informants to infiltrate the group. They sought monetary damages under a Bivens action against the individual agents and under the (FTCA) against the government, claiming the investigation involved and overreach that lacked . The district court dismissed the claims in 2014, ruling that a Bivens remedy was unavailable due to special factors counseling judicial hesitation, including the sensitivity of investigations and the availability of alternative remedies like criminal s and internal FBI oversight. The FTCA claim was barred by the discretionary-function exception, as decisions on deployment and raid tactics fell within protected prosecutorial and investigative . On appeal, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit affirmed the dismissal on May 5, 2015, in Meeks v. Larsen, emphasizing that the original criminal provided and was not plausibly alleged to be fabricated, thus shielding agents from liability. The court noted the complexity of operations as a factor precluding implied constitutional damages actions against federal officers in this context. No other civil lawsuits by Hutaree members against federal authorities appear to have proceeded beyond initial filings, with this case marking the group's primary post-acquittal challenge to the government's conduct. The rulings reinforced limitations on Bivens claims in militia-related probes, prioritizing executive discretion in domestic cases while underscoring the judiciary's reluctance to second-guess investigative tactics absent clear constitutional infirmities.

Dissolution and Broader Impact on Militia Groups

Following the March 2012 dismissal of and related major charges against seven Hutaree members by U.S. District Judge Victoria A. Roberts, who ruled that evidence showed only loose talk rather than an actual agreement to attack , the group effectively ceased operations. David Stone Sr., the group's founder and leader, and his son Joshua Stone pleaded guilty that same month to lesser firearms possession charges involving unregistered machine guns, receiving sentences that included and supervised release rather than lengthy . The arrests of all nine core members in March 2010, combined with prolonged pretrial detention for some and the erosion of organizational cohesion during the legal battles, led to the Hutaree's disbandment shortly thereafter, with no documented revival or activity post-trial. The Hutaree case exerted a limited but notable influence on the broader U.S. movement, primarily by prompting more established groups to publicly disavow fringe, apocalyptic elements associated with Hutaree to mitigate federal scrutiny. Contemporary leaders in , for instance, distanced themselves from Hutaree during the investigation, characterizing it as an not representative of "real" militias focused on constitutional defense rather than religiously motivated violence. The acquittal on core charges highlighted evidentiary hurdles in prosecuting based primarily on inflammatory rhetoric or training exercises without proof of imminent criminal acts, a echoed in later analyses of militia prosecutions like the 2020 governor kidnapping plot. Experts noted potential "ripples" from the outcome, including heightened caution among regarding infiltration—revealed in the case through an embedded FBI paid approximately $31,000—while others viewed the dismissals as a validation against perceived overreach, potentially emboldening defensive postures without broadly deterring the movement's growth. Despite the FBI's extensive 18-month probe yielding no convictions on terrorism-related counts, the case underscored ongoing tensions, with militia experts arguing it failed to neutralize broader extremist threats and instead fueled narratives of that persisted in subsequent group dynamics.

Controversies and Viewpoints

Claims of Government and Overreach

Defense attorneys for the Hutaree members argued that the federal government's case relied excessively on an FBI informant's infiltration and encouragement of the group's activities, constituting by manufacturing a non-existent plot. , who received approximately $31,000 for his role over 18 months, recorded conversations and participated in building improvised explosive devices under the direction of group leader David Stone Sr., but critics contended this involvement drove the alleged criminality rather than uncovering an independent . Supporters of the defendants, including advocates, claimed the 2010 raids and charges exemplified government overreach, targeting the group's apocalyptic Christian ideology and anti-government rhetoric as proxies for criminal without of specific, actionable plans. They pointed to the absence of concrete steps toward beyond rhetorical discussions of biblical end-times scenarios and hypothetical resistance to federal authority, asserting that the prosecution blurred protected First Amendment speech with imminent threats. These allegations gained traction during pretrial hearings, where U.S. District Judge Victoria A. Roberts questioned whether the evidence amounted to more than "hateful speech" and challenged prosecutors to demonstrate overt acts beyond the informant's recordings, highlighting potential prosecutorial overextension in interpreting loose training and stockpiling as . Defense filings emphasized FBI agents' unprofessional conduct, such as derogatory internal communications mocking the group, as indicative of bias-driven investigation rather than neutral . The claims resonated in broader critiques of federal tactics against domestic militias, with observers noting parallels to other cases where informant-led operations risked inducing crimes for prosecution, though federal officials maintained the Hutaree posed a genuine risk of sparking wider unrest through targeted police ambushes.

Defenses from Militia Perspectives

Militia supporters argued that the Hutaree's training exercises and discussions represented protected First Amendment speech and Second Amendment rights to bear arms for , rather than criminal intent. Defense attorneys emphasized that the group's , while inflammatory, constituted hypothetical preparation for biblical end-times scenarios involving the , not an agreement to imminent violence against the government. The 2012 acquittal of seven members on charges was portrayed by some in the community as vindication against federal overreach, with U.S. Victoria Roberts ruling that the prosecution failed to prove sufficient evidence of a plot beyond "mere words." Advocates contended this outcome underscored how anti-government sentiments, common in circles, cross into criminality only with overt acts, which were absent here. From a militia viewpoint, the heavy reliance on FBI informants—who infiltrated the group starting in 2008 and recorded conversations—suggested , as agents may have encouraged radical statements without independent evidence of predisposition to crime. Hutaree leader David Stone Sr., after pleading guilty to unrelated weapons possession on March 29, 2012, maintained his actions aligned with patriotic defense of constitutional principles. Broader perspectives framed the case as a cautionary example of government targeting religious and survivalist training, distinct from mainstream groups that distanced themselves due to Hutaree's overt apocalyptic . Supporters highlighted the group's self-description as "Christian warriors" ready to "defend those who belong to Christ," arguing such beliefs justified armament against perceived spiritual enemies, not domestic insurrection.

Mainstream Criticisms and Media Portrayals

outlets extensively covered the March 2010 arrests of Hutaree members, portraying the group as a radical anti-government with apocalyptic Christian beliefs and plans to incite violence against law enforcement. reported on the coordinated raids across , , and , highlighting federal charges of and describing the group's intent to "draw " against police as part of a broader against perceived enemies including the and a "New World Order." Similarly, detailed FBI findings from the raids, including seized weapons, Nazi propaganda, and survival gear, framing Hutaree as a "self-proclaimed Christian " stockpiling arms for . Criticisms from mainstream sources emphasized Hutaree's inflammatory rhetoric and isolationist ideology as threats to public safety, with quoting group communications referring to government officials as "elitist terrorists" and portraying their training as preparation for revolutionary violence that tarnished the broader movement. contextualized Hutaree within resurgent militias, likening their structure to historical insurrectionist groups like The Order and critiquing their rejection of federal authority as fostering potential domestic unrest, though noting reluctance to apply the "" label uniformly due to the group's Christian framing. Such portrayals often amplified prosecutor statements on the group's nine members facing charges for plotting to officers and deploy weapons of mass destruction, contributing to narratives of Hutaree as emblematic of far-right extremism. These depictions, prevalent in outlets like and , drew distinctions from mainstream militias, with spokespersons for groups like the Volunteer Militia denouncing Hutaree as unrepresentative and paranoid, thereby reinforcing criticisms that the group's end-times and paramilitary drills posed unique risks beyond typical Second Amendment advocacy. Mainstream coverage rarely foregrounded subsequent acquittals on major charges—where a federal judge dismissed counts for lack of evidence of actual plots—focusing instead on initial allegations to underscore domestic terrorism concerns, a pattern attributable to institutional tendencies in media to prioritize government-sourced threat assessments over post-trial nuances.

References

  1. https://web.archive.org/web/20100401191403/http://www.hutaree.com/
  2. https://www.amycooter.com/uploads/1/2/3/7/12374434/hutaree_threat.pdf
  3. https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/last-time-justice-department-prosecuted-seditious-conspiracy-case
  4. https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/nine-members-militia-group-charged-seditious-conspiracy-and-related-charges
  5. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/28/us/hutaree-militia-members-acquitted-of-sedition.html
  6. https://www.fbi.gov/detroit/press-releases/2012/members-of-the-hutaree-militia-plead-guilty-to-weapons-charges
  7. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-17530731
  8. https://www.npr.org/2010/03/30/125349553/new-details-emerge-as-fbi-probes-christian-militias-in-mich
  9. https://religiondispatches.org/christian-warriors-who-are-the-hutaree-militia-and-where-did-they-come-from/
  10. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/religious-concepts-militia-extremists-daryl-johnson
  11. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/01/us/01michigan.html
  12. https://www.npr.org/2010/04/12/125856761/how-the-fbi-got-inside-the-hutaree-militia
  13. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hutaree-website-christian-militia-raided-by-fbi-were-preparing-for-the-anti-christ/
  14. https://www.poam.net/on-the-job/michigan-militia-hutaree-conspire-against-law-enforcement-officers/
  15. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/us/hutaree-militia-walk-from-jail-after-charges-dismissed-idUSBRE82S1F2/
  16. https://www.npr.org/2010/03/29/125315301/9-militia-members-accused-of-plotting-to-kill-police
  17. https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2010/0329/Who-is-David-Brian-Stone-leader-of-the-Hutaree-militia
  18. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/fbi-agent-had-infiltrated-hutaree/
  19. https://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker/hutaree-defense-lawyers-argue-militia-was-just-a-social-club
  20. https://www.police1.com/terrorism/articles/analyzing-the-hutarees-lessons-from-a-failed-plot-ZhzaLVRXCp1iyJNj/
  21. https://www.npr.org/2010/04/13/125862933/americas-new-kinder-gentler-militia
  22. http://web.archive.org/web/20100401191403/http://www.hutaree.com/
  23. http://annarbor.com/news/militia-group-provided-fbi-information-on-hutaree-two-years-ago-emails-show/
  24. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna36129992
  25. https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/Justice/2010/0330/Hutaree-Why-is-the-Midwest-a-hotbed-of-militia-activity
  26. https://www.lenconnect.com/story/news/courts/2012/03/01/informant-ends-testimony-in-hutaree/64081146007/
  27. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-mied-2_10-cr-20123/pdf/USCOURTS-mied-2_10-cr-20123-23.pdf
  28. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna46386993
  29. https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/2012/02/15/fbi-paid-informant-30-600/23796895007/
  30. https://www.thecentersquare.com/michigan/article_6981f372-ca32-11ec-b7ba-7b8acd81b9fe.html
  31. https://tucson.com/news/article_069fe584-f28b-5e77-810c-d14ab17582b7.html
  32. https://www.cbsnews.com/detroit/news/militia-leader-spoke-of-killing-police-family/
  33. https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/crime/2012/03/27/conspiracy-charges-dropped-against-michigan/23503058007/
  34. https://www.police1.com/officer-safety/articles/us-militia-leader-spoke-of-killing-police-family-sQkPYlZ5hdFkZdjk/
  35. http://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/03/29/hutaree.militia.plans/index.html
  36. https://abcnews.go.com/WN/TheLaw/michigan-christian-militia-hutaree-targeted-law-enforcement/story?id=10228716
  37. https://www.npr.org/2010/03/29/125318788/michigan-militia-accused-of-plotting-attack-on-police
  38. https://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/03/28/militia.arrests/
  39. https://archives.fbi.gov/archives/detroit/press-releases/2010/de032910.htm
  40. https://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/03/29/hutaree.militia.plans/index.html
  41. https://www.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/04/02/michigan.militia/index.html
  42. https://cases.justia.com/federal/appellate-courts/ca6/10-1618/10a0182p-06-2011-02-25.pdf?ts=1411020042
  43. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304871704575160030717360768
  44. https://www.cleveland.com/nation/2010/05/hutaree_militia_judge_oks_bail.html
  45. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/05/04/us/04militia.html
  46. https://www.mlive.com/news/2010/05/us_takes_early_lumps_in_case_a.html
  47. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-mied-2_10-cr-20123/pdf/USCOURTS-mied-2_10-cr-20123-18.pdf
  48. https://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2010/05/06/Bail-delayed-for-suspected-militia-members/UPI-44741273181256/?st_rec=8978353221200
  49. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/judge-hutaree-members-can-be-released-on-bail/
  50. https://www.mprnews.org/story/2010/06/08/midwest-militia-members-go-to-court
  51. https://www.sj-r.com/story/news/courts/2010/06/22/5-hutaree-members-to-remain/64120117007/
  52. https://apnews.com/ripples-likely-from-militia-case-loss-experts-say-a55c650a3e884b03852a6ba44d39edca
  53. https://www.michiganpublic.org/2012-03-29/after-two-years-hutaree-militia-trial-ends-in-a-whimper
  54. https://www.lawfaremedia.org/article/directed-acquittal-seditious-conspiracy-prosecution-hutaree-militia-members
  55. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2012/3/28/christian-militia-acquitted-of-sedition-in-us
  56. https://www.splcenter.org/resources/hatewatch/most-charges-dismissed-against-hutaree-militia-members/
  57. https://www.police1.com/officer-safety/articles/key-charges-dropped-against-hutaree-militia-YF0t82xgit8SD7ki/
  58. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-17553326
  59. https://www.toledoblade.com/Courts/2012/08/08/2-Hutaree-members-don-t-get-further-jail-time-on-weapons-charges.html
  60. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/us/final-hutaree-defendants-plead-guilty-to-weapons-charges-idUSBRE82S0RW/
  61. https://abc7chicago.com/post/hutaree-militia-group-loses-final-battle-against-government/698732/
  62. https://abc13.com/archive/8618892/
  63. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ujAYPejsHjM
  64. https://www.michiganpublic.org/law/2013-04-09/2-hutaree-militia-members-sue-authorities-over-2010-raids
  65. https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCOURTS-ca6-14-01381/pdf/USCOURTS-ca6-14-01381-0.pdf
  66. https://www.casemine.com/commentary/us/meeks-v.-larsen:-reinforcing-the-standards-and-limitations-of-bivens-claims/view
  67. https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/2012/0327/Hutaree-militia-acquitted-of-plot-to-foment-revolution
  68. https://www.detroitnews.com/story/news/local/michigan/2021/08/26/hutaree-whitmer-kidnap-prosecution-has-familiar-ring/5531381001/
  69. https://www.congress.gov/117/meeting/house/113968/witnesses/HHRG-117-VR00-Wstate-CooterA-20211013-U1.pdf
  70. https://www.lenconnect.com/story/lifestyle/2010/04/04/keeping-their-distance-local-militia/64124056007/
  71. https://talkingpointsmemo.com/muckraker/extremist-groups-still-a-threat-despite-botched-hutaree-case-says-militia-expert
  72. https://www.mlive.com/news/2010/04/judge_challenged_prosecutors_t.html
  73. https://www.freep.com/story/news/local/[michigan](/page/Michigan)/2022/03/31/whitmer-kidnap-trial-hutaree-case/7217662001/
  74. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2022/mar/19/michigan-governor-kidnap-case-terrorists-fbi-dupes-gretchen-whitmer
  75. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/14/us/accused-hutaree-militia-was-a-social-club-defense-says.html
  76. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna46872640
  77. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna46896056
  78. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/belief/2010/mar/31/christian-militia-hutaree-us
  79. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/hutaree-militia-raided-guns-knives-drugs-gas-masks-nazi-propaganda-uncovered-says-fbi/
  80. https://archive.nytimes.com/roomfordebate.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/03/30/the-new-militias-vs-government/
  81. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/04/weekinreview/04shane.html
  82. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-17017185
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.