Hubbry Logo
Economic Community of Central African StatesEconomic Community of Central African StatesMain
Open search
Economic Community of Central African States
Community hub
Economic Community of Central African States
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Economic Community of Central African States
Economic Community of Central African States
from Wikipedia

Key Information

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS; French: Communauté Économique des États de l'Afrique Centrale, CEEAC; Spanish: Comunidad Económica de los Estados de África Central, CEEAC; Portuguese: Comunidade Económica dos Estados da África Central, CEEAC) is an Economic Community of the African Union that promotes regional economic co-operation in Central Africa. It "aims to achieve collective autonomy, raise the standard of living of its populations and maintain economic stability through harmonious cooperation".

History

[edit]

Foundation

[edit]

At a summit meeting in December 1981, the leaders of the Customs and Economic Union of Central Africa (French acronym UDEAC) agreed in principle to form a wider economic community of Central African states. ECCAS was established on 18 October 1983 by the UDEAC members, São Tomé and Príncipe and the members of the Economic Community of the Great Lakes States (CEPGL established in 1976 by the DR Congo, Burundi and Rwanda). Angola remained an observer until 1999, when it became a full member.

ECCAS began functioning in 1985, but was inactive for several years because of financial difficulties (non-payment of membership fees by the member states) and the conflict in the Great Lakes area. The war in the DR Congo was particularly divisive, as Rwanda and Angola fought on opposing sides. ECCAS has been designated a pillar of the African Economic Community (AEC), but formal contact between the AEC and ECCAS was only established in October 1999 due to the inactivity of ECCAS since 1992 (ECCAS signed the Protocol on Relations between the AEC and the regional blocs (RECs) in October 1999). The AEC again confirmed the importance of ECCAS as the major economic community in Central Africa at the third preparatory meeting of its Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC) in June 1999.

Presided over by President Pierre Buyoya of Burundi, the summit was held in Libreville on 6 February 1998. The Heads of State and Government present at the summit committed themselves to the resurrection of the organisation. The Prime Minister of Angola also indicated that his country would become a fully fledged member. The summit approved a budget of 10 million French francs for 1998 and requested the Secretariat to:

  • Obtain assistance from UNECA to evaluate the operational activities of the secretariat; to evaluate the contributions due by member states; and the salaries and salary structures of employees of the secretariat
  • Convene an extraordinary meeting of the Council of Ministers as soon as possible to evaluate the recommendations of UNECA; the Council should then draw up proposals for a new administrative structure for the secretariat and revised contributions due by each member state.

The summit also requested countries in the region to find lasting and peaceful solutions to their political problems. The chairman also appealed to member countries to support the complete lifting of the embargo placed on his country. During the inauguration of President Bongo of Gabon on 21 January 1999, a mini-summit of ECCAS leaders was held. The leaders discussed problems concerning the functioning of ECCAS and the creation of a third Deputy Secretary-General post, designated for Angola. Angola formally joined the Community during this summit.[3]

Recent events

[edit]

The 10th Ordinary Session of Heads of State and Government took place in Malabo in June 2002. This Summit decided to adopt a protocol on the establishment of a Network of Parliamentarians of Central Africa (REPAC) and to adopt the standing orders of the Council for Peace and Security in Central Africa (COPAX), including the Defence and Security Commission (CDS), Multinational Force of Central Africa (FOMAC) and the Early Warning Mechanism of Central Africa (MARAC). Rwanda was also officially welcomed upon its return as a full member of ECCAS.

On January 24, 2003, the European Union (EU) concluded a financial agreement with ECCAS and CEMAC, conditional on ECCAS and CEMAC merging into one organization, with ECCAS taking responsibility for the peace and security of the sub-region through its security pact COPAX. CEMAC is not one of the pillars of the African Economic Community, but its members are associated with it through Economic Community of Central African States. The EU had multiple peacekeeping missions in the DR Congo: Operation Artemis (June to September 2003), EUPOL Kinshasa (from October 2003) and EUSEC DR Congo (from May 2005).

The 11th Ordinary Session of Heads of State and Government in Brazzaville during January 2004 welcomed the fact that the Protocol Relating to the Establishment of a Council for Peace and Security in Central Africa (COPAX) had received the required number of ratifications to enter into force. The Summit also adopted a declaration on the implementation of NEPAD in Central Africa as well as a declaration on gender equality.

On September 23, 2009, pursuant to Presidential Determination 2009-26[4] and as published in the Federal Register / Vol. 74, No. 183 (Presidential Documents 48363) ECCAS was made eligible under the U.S. Arms Export Control Act for the furnishing of defense articles and defense services. This makes the ECCAS organization and (theoretically) the countries under their charter eligible for U.S. Foreign Military Sales Program (i.e. government to government sales and assistance) pursuant to the Arms Export Control Act and for other such U.S. assistance as directed by a USG contract to U.S. industry for such support pursuant to the (ITAR)[1].

In 2007, Rwanda decided to leave the organisation[5] in order to remove overlap in its membership in regional trade blocks and so that it could better focus on its membership in the EAC and COMESA. Rwanda was a founding member of the organisation and had been a part of it since 18 October 1981. It subsequently rejoined ECCAS in 2016.[6] On 1 September 2020, Gilberto Da Piedade Verissimo of Angola was appointed President of the ECCAS Commission[7] with Francisca Tatchouop Belobe as vice-President.[8]

In response to the 2023 Gabonese coup d'état, the ECCAS condemned the military use of force and asked for restoration of constitutional order.[9] It also suspended Gabon's membership in the bloc on 5 September[10] and moved its headquarters from Libreville to Malabo, Equatorial Guinea.

On 7 June 2025, Rwanda announced its departure from the ECCAS, citing the bloc's "instrumentalisation" by the Democratic Republic of the Congo.[11][12]

Economic integration

[edit]

Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa

[edit]

The Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa (or CEMAC from its name in French) is an organization established by Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Republic of Congo, Equatorial Guinea and Gabon to promote economic integration among countries that share a common currency, the West African CFA franc.[13]

Membership in the regional communities
Country ECCAS CEMAC SADC EAC
 Angola Yes No Yes No
 Burundi Yes No No Yes
 Cameroon Yes Yes No No
 Central African Republic Yes Yes No No
 Chad Yes Yes No No
 Democratic Republic of the Congo Yes No Yes Yes
 Equatorial Guinea Yes Yes No No
 Gabon Yes Yes No No
 Republic of the Congo Yes Yes No No
 São Tomé and Príncipe Yes No No No

Objectives

[edit]

The ultimate goal is to establish a Central African Common Market. At the Malabo Heads of State and Government Conference in 1999, four priority fields for the organization were identified:

  • to develop capacities to maintain peace, security and stability - as essential prerequisites for economic and social development
  • to develop physical, economic and monetary integration
  • to develop a culture of human integration
  • to establish an autonomous financing mechanism for ECCAS

Structure

[edit]
  • Conference of Heads of State and Government
  • Council of Ministers
  • Secretariat General (one secretary-general elected for four years and three assistant secretaries-general)
  • Court of Justice
  • Consultative Commission

Treaties and protocols

[edit]
  • Treaty Establishing the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS)
  • Protocol Establishing the Network of Parliamentarians of ECCAS (REPAC)
  • Mutual Assistance Pact Between Member States of ECCAS
  • Protocol Relating to the Establishment of a Mutual Security Pact in Central Africa (COPAX)

Appendices to the ECCAS Treaty

[edit]
  • Protocol on the Rules of Origin for products to be traded between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Non-Tariff Trade Barriers
  • Protocol on the Re-export of goods within the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Transit and Transit facilities
  • Protocol on Customs cooperation within the ECCAS
  • Protocol on the Fund for Compensation for Loss of Revenue
  • Protocol on Freedom of movement and Rights of Establishment of nationals of member states within the ECCAS
  • Protocol on the Clearing House for the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in Agricultural development between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in Industrial development between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in Transport and Communications between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in Science and Technology between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Energy cooperation between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in Natural resources between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in the development of Human resources, Education, Training and Culture between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on Cooperation in Tourism between member states of the ECCAS
  • Protocol on the Simplification and Harmonization of Trade documents and Procedures within the ECCAS
  • Protocol on the Situation of Landlocked, Semi-Landlocked, Island, Part-Island and/or Least Advanced Countries

Peace and security activities

[edit]

Central African states adopted a pact of non-aggression at the end of the fifth meeting of the UN Consultative Committee on Security in Central Africa held in Yaoundé, Cameroon. The pact, adopted on 9 September 1994, was arrived at after five days of meeting and discussions between military experts and ministers of Cameroon, Central African Republic, Republic of Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Gabon and São Tomé and Príncipe. At a summit conference of the United Nations Standing Advisory Committee on Security Questions in Central Africa which took place in Yaoundé on 25–26 February 1999, member states decided to create an organisation for the promotion, maintenance and consolidation of peace and security in Central Africa, which would be called the Council for Peace and Security in Central Africa (COPAX). The COPAX Protocol has now entered into force.

Technical organs of the COPAX council

[edit]
  • The Central African Early-Warning System (MARAC), which collects and analyses data for the early detection and prevention of crises.
  • The Defence and Security Commission (CDS), which is the meeting of chiefs of staff of national armies and commanders-in-chief of police and gendarmerie forces from the different member states. Its role is to plan, organize and provide advice to the decision-making bodies of the community in order to initiate military operations if needed.
  • The Multinational Force of Central Africa (FOMAC), which is a non-permanent force consisting of military contingents from member states, whose purpose is to accomplish missions of peace, security and humanitarian relief.

The standing orders for COPAX, including those of CDS, MARAC and FOMAC were adopted in June 2002 at the 10th Ordinary Summit in Malabo.

In January 2000, Gabon hosted a regional peacekeeping exercise "Gabon 2000" with the objective of increasing the capacity of ECCAS states in the field of peacekeeping and conflict prevention and management. This exercise represented a direct application of the French RECAMP-concept (reinforcement of African peacekeeping capacities).

Extraordinary Summits of both ECCAS and CEMAC took place in Libreville on 23 June 2000. Foreign ministers from 10 Central African states met in the Democratic Republic of Congo on 16 and 17 August 2001 to discuss security in their war-torn region. The meeting was sponsored by the United Nations, and only Rwanda declined to attend.

A meeting of Defence Chiefs of Staff was held in Brazzaville in October 2003, at which it was decided that a brigade-size peacekeeping force would be created in order to intervene in unstable Central African areas.[14] This could then form one of the African Union's five planned brigades of the African Standby Force, one brigade for each region (North, West, Central, East and Southern Africa). The meeting recommended that military planners from each of the ECCAS states form a group to work out the details for the force. They also suggested the establishment of a joint peacekeeping training centre and military exercises every two years. The first of these is to take place in Chad.

MICOPAX

[edit]

The Mission for the consolidation of peace in Central African Republic (MICOPAX) is a peace operation in the Central African Republic led by the ECCAS.[15] It is involved in the Central African Republic Bush War and 2012–2013 Central African Republic conflict.

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia
from Grokipedia
The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS; French: Communauté Économique des États de l'Afrique Centrale, CEEAC) is an intergovernmental organization established on 18 October 1983 through the signing of its Constitutive Treaty in , , by founding members from the Union Douanière et Économique de l'Afrique Centrale (UDEAC), the Economic Community of the Great Lakes States (CEPGL), and . Comprising eleven member states—, , , , , , , , , , and —ECCAS seeks to accelerate economic integration and foster cooperation across economic, social, cultural, monetary, financial, and security domains to achieve balanced, self-sustained development. Headquartered in , , ECCAS operates as a pillar of the African Union's peace and security framework, emphasizing the promotion of stability in a region plagued by ethnoreligious conflicts, civil wars, border disputes, and insurgencies, such as those in the and the . Its defining characteristics include efforts to harmonize trade policies, customs procedures, and development, alongside promotion, though implementation has been hampered by overlapping memberships with sub-regional bodies like the Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa (CEMAC) and persistent governance challenges. Notable achievements encompass the establishment of mechanisms for conflict prevention and management, including the deployment of multinational forces like MICOPAX in the and hosting biennales to assess the Peace and Security Architecture's impact, yet ECCAS faces criticism for limited economic progress and difficulties in enforcing regional protocols amid member states' internal instabilities and resource constraints.

History

Establishment in 1983

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) was established on 18 1983 through the signing of its Constitutive in , . The treaty aimed to promote and collective self-reliance among Central African nations by creating a framework for a common market, free movement of goods, services, and capital, and coordinated physical infrastructure development. The founding signatories comprised the six member states of the Union Douanière et Économique de l'Afrique Centrale (UDEAC)—, , , , , and —along with the three members of the Communauté Économique des Pays des Grands Lacs (CEPGL)—, , and —and the island nation of , totaling ten initial participants. This grouping sought to build on existing subregional and economic unions to address shared challenges such as , conflicts, and dependence on external markets, with provisions for of economic policies and establishment of institutions. The entered into force on 18 December 1984 following by the required states, marking the formal of ECCAS as a regional economic community under the broader African integration efforts inspired by the Organization of African Unity. Early objectives emphasized raising living standards through industrial cooperation, agricultural development, and resource pooling, though implementation faced delays due to political instability in several founding members.

Expansion and Institutional Milestones

ECCAS experienced a period of dormancy starting in the late , attributed to member states' non-payment of dues and escalating regional conflicts that undermined economic cooperation efforts. The organization ceased effective operations until revival initiatives gained momentum in the mid-1990s. A pivotal institutional milestone occurred at the extraordinary summit of Heads of State and Government in , , on 6 February 1998, where leaders pledged to resurrect ECCAS and broaden its mandate beyond economics to encompass peace, security, and conflict prevention. This revival process included key protocols strengthening institutional frameworks: the signed in 1996, followed by the Protocol on Peace, Security, and Regional Stability adopted on 24 February 1999, which established the Council for Peace and Security in Central Africa (COPAX) to coordinate responses to threats like cross-border conflicts and political instability. COPAX's creation represented a shift toward operationalizing security mechanisms, including early warning systems and deployments. In 2008, ECCAS launched the Mission for the Consolidation of Peace in Central Africa (MICOPAX), its first multinational force, deployed initially to the to stabilize post-conflict environments. Membership expansion remained modest post-founding, with acceding as the 11th full member following the 1998 revival, integrating its post-civil war economy into regional trade frameworks. Fluctuations included Rwanda's withdrawal in 2007 amid regional tensions, followed by its confirmed return on 18 August 2016, restoring the bloc to 11 states and enhancing geopolitical coverage in the area. These developments underscored ECCAS's evolution from a largely inactive economic entity to a prioritizing stability as a prerequisite for integration, though implementation has been hampered by persistent funding shortfalls and overlapping mandates with bodies like the Economic and Monetary Community of (CEMAC).

Recent Developments and Setbacks (2010s–2025)

In the 2010s, ECCAS intensified its focus on peace and security amid recurrent conflicts in member states, particularly through the operationalization of the and deployments under the (FOMAC), which supported stabilization efforts in the () following the 2013 crisis. By 2018, ECCAS and the reaffirmed commitment to the African Initiative for Peace and Reconciliation in , emphasizing early warning mechanisms via the Regional Mechanism for Conflict Prevention, Management, and Resolution (MARAC). These initiatives contributed to partial de-escalation in hotspots, with the organization hosting a 2022 regional to assess the Africa Peace and Security Architecture's impact in . Economic integration advanced modestly with the continuation of the established in 2004, aligned with ECCAS Vision 2025 and the African Development Bank's Central Africa Regional Integration Strategy Paper (2019–2025), which reported progress in infrastructure and trade facilitation by 2024. Partnerships expanded, including EU capacity-building programs for regional projects as of December 2024 and diplomatic engagements with in July 2023 to bolster cooperation. Setbacks persisted due to political instability, exemplified by inconsistent responses to coups: ECCAS refrained from suspending Chad after the April 2021 overthrow of President Idriss Déby, citing transitional needs amid jihadist threats, which drew criticism for undermining democratic norms. In contrast, following the August 2023 coup in Gabon, ECCAS suspended the country on September 4, 2023, upheld the measure in December 2023, and planned to relocate its headquarters from Libreville, highlighting enforcement challenges. Ongoing conflicts in the Democratic Republic of Congo prompted a November 2023 retreat to revitalize the 2013 Peace, Security, and Cooperation Framework, yet violence continued. Institutional weaknesses compounded issues, including chronic underfunding, overlapping mandates with bodies like CEMAC, and limited economic diversification, which hampered Vision 2025 goals amid high public debt constraining fiscal responses to security threats as noted in June 2025 UN assessments. Rwanda's July 2025 withdrawal from ECCAS underscored frustrations with persistent instability and slow integration, reducing membership cohesion. Despite these, ECCAS maintained efforts in conflict mediation, with FOMAC leadership transitions in August 2023 signaling operational continuity.

Member States

Composition and Admission Criteria

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) comprises eleven member states: , , , , , , , , , , and . These countries represent a geographic focus on , with territories aligned to the region's economic and political integration objectives under the framework. ECCAS originated from the merger of existing subregional groupings, with its foundational members signing the Constitutive Treaty on 18 October 1983 in Libreville, . The initial signatories included the six members of the Union Douanière et Économique de l'Afrique Centrale (UDEAC)—, , , , , and —and the three members of the Communauté Économique des Pays des Grands Lacs (CEPGL)—, (then ), and —plus São Tomé and Príncipe. The treaty entered into force on 18 December 1984 after by a sufficient number of states. Subsequent expansions occurred through accession. Angola joined as an observer before becoming a full member in 1999, reflecting ECCAS's revival after a period of dormancy from due to conflicts and funding shortages. Rwanda, an original member, faced suspension or withdrawal amid regional instability, including the 1994 genocide, and sources indicate returns or confirmations in 2002 or as late as 2016, though it remains active in the community as of 2023. Admission to ECCAS is governed by the Constitutive Treaty, which implicitly limits membership to sovereign African states whose territory lies wholly or partially within . Prospective members must accede to the treaty following approval by the Conference of Heads of State and Government, typically upon recommendation from the , ensuring alignment with goals without formalized economic or political preconditions beyond geographic eligibility and consensus among existing members. This process emphasizes political agreement over strict quantitative criteria, as evidenced by Angola's integration despite prior .

Withdrawals, Suspensions, and Membership Disputes

Rwanda announced its withdrawal from the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) on June 8, 2025, citing repeated violations of its rights as a member state and the organization's instrumentalization by the (DRC). The decision followed the 26th Ordinary Summit of ECCAS heads of state, held in , , where expected to assume the rotating chairmanship but was bypassed in favor of retaining the position. accused ECCAS of pandering to DRC demands amid ongoing bilateral tensions, including mutual allegations of support for armed groups in eastern DRC. Rwanda had joined ECCAS in 2007 as part of the integration of former Economic Community of the Great Lakes States (CEPGL) members, making its exit the first formal withdrawal in the organization's . On , , Rwanda's cabinet reiterated the withdrawal, emphasizing that continued membership lacked justification given the disregard for constitutive texts guaranteeing equitable participation. No immediate response from ECCAS or affected members altered the announcement, though analysts noted the move underscored deeper fractures in regional diplomacy, potentially weakening ECCAS's cohesion on security and economic fronts. No recorded suspensions of ECCAS member states have occurred, despite internal conflicts in countries like the and that prompted ECCAS peacekeeping deployments. Membership disputes beyond the Rwanda-DRC chairmanship row remain limited, with stable adherence among the remaining 10 members—, , , , , , DRC, , , and —as of October 2025.

Core Economic and Development Goals

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) pursues core economic objectives centered on promoting harmonious cooperation and balanced, self-sustained development in all fields of economic activity, including industry, , , and , as stipulated in its foundational . These goals emphasize eliminating internal duties and non-tariff barriers to establish a (), with progressive implementation targeted over initial stages of four years each, leading to a with a and unified policy toward third countries. The framework also mandates harmonization of national economic policies to foster collective , , and improved living standards, particularly by supporting landlocked, island, and least-developed member states through financial and technical assistance via a dedicated Cooperation and Development Fund. Development goals extend to facilitating the free movement of , services, capital, and persons, alongside sectoral integration in , , and to drive self-sufficiency and resource utilization. enhancement forms a key pillar, exemplified by the Consensual for (PDCT-AC), which prioritizes 14 regional projects in roads, rail, air, and sea connectivity to reduce trade costs and boost intra-regional . integration targets the creation of a unified market through the Central African Power Pool (PEAC) and interconnections, such as those linking to the Inga Dam, to address chronic supply deficits and promote sustainable utilization of hydroelectric resources. Agricultural and rural development objectives focus on increasing production and elevating rural living standards via harmonized policies, including the (PAC-CEEAC) and Regional Agricultural Investment Program (PRIASAN), both adopted in May to enhance and export competitiveness. The revised treaty reinforces these aims by envisioning an economic union that integrates markets and policies, contributing to broader aspirations under Vision 2025 for . Overall, these goals prioritize endogenous growth through local training, , and policy convergence, aiming to transform ECCAS into a common market that mitigates external dependencies.

Peace, Security, and Political Cooperation Mandates

The Treaty establishing the Economic Community of Central African States, signed on 18 October 1983 in Libreville, Gabon, mandates political cooperation among member states to foster regional stability as a prerequisite for economic and social progress. Article 4 delineates core objectives, including the promotion of harmonious inter-state relations and the building of capacities to preserve peace, security, and stability, explicitly recognizing these as foundational to development efforts. These mandates were reinforced through supplementary protocols addressing conflict dynamics in . The , adopted on 8 July 1996 in by nine member states, obliges parties to reject force or threats thereof in and to cultivate peaceful bilateral ties, forming one pillar of ECCAS's framework. The Mutual Assistance Pact of 2000 further commits states to collective defense against external aggression, mandating joint military coordination and readiness, including standby force concepts. Central to operationalizing these goals is the Protocol on the for and in (COPAX), established in 2000 and entering force in 2004, which empowers ECCAS to prevent, manage, and resolve intra- and inter-state conflicts while upholding principles of sovereignty and non-interference. COPAX coordinates the Multinational Force of (FOMAC), a brigade-sized contingent of approximately 4,800–5,000 troops for observation, , and humanitarian interventions, alongside the Central African Early Warning Mechanism (MARAC) for real-time threat monitoring and reporting to inform decisions. Decision-making under COPAX typically requires consensus or a two-thirds majority, with deployments triggered by events such as coups, aggression, or severe internal disturbances. Politically, the mandates emphasize governance stability to underpin security, including support for democratic transitions and conflict , though protocols stress non-intervention in domestic affairs absent consensus. These instruments align ECCAS with broader peace architecture, prioritizing early warning, , and post-conflict reconstruction over coercive measures.

Key Treaties, Protocols, and Amendments

The Treaty Establishing the Economic Community of Central African States, signed on 18 October 1983 by founding members from the Union Douanière et Économique de l'Afrique Centrale and the Communauté Économique des Pays des Grands Lacs, entered into force on 18 December 1984. This instrument sets forth a 12-year phased integration process toward economic autonomy, including establishment of a within four years, a by the eighth year, and harmonization of economic policies thereafter. Initial protocols appended to the treaty addressed implementation details, such as the Protocol on for intra-community trade and the Protocol on Non-Tariff Trade Barriers. Contemporaneous supplementary protocols included the Protocol on and Right of Establishment of Nationals of Member States and the Protocol concerning the Revenue Loss Compensation Fund, both adopted on 18 October 1983 to facilitate labor mobility and mitigate fiscal impacts of trade liberalization. In response to post-Cold War instability, member states signed the on 8 July 1996 in , pledging to renounce force or threats against any member's , , or political independence, thereby laying groundwork for . The Protocol Relating to the Establishment of the Council for Peace and Security in Central Africa (COPAX), adopted in February 1999, created organs for conflict prevention, , resolution, , and a mutual assistance pact, operationalizing security cooperation amid regional crises like those in the . A revised Treaty Establishing the was adopted on 18 December 2019 in , , with subsequent ratifications including Cameroon's on 28 April 2020; revisions strengthen institutional architecture by providing for a , Court of Justice, and enhanced executive powers to address implementation gaps from the original framework. Additional protocols encompass the 17 June 2002 instrument instituting the Network of Parliamentarians of Central Africa (REPAC) to foster legislative harmonization. Procedures for further amendments require proposals from member states, approval by the Conference of Heads of State and Government, and upon by two-thirds of members.

Organizational Structure

Principal Institutions and Organs

The principal organs of the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) are outlined in its revised founding , adopted on December 18, 2019, and effective from December 28, 2019, following institutional reforms aimed at enhancing governance efficiency. These organs encompass six main bodies responsible for policy formulation, execution, and advisory functions, while associated institutions handle legislative, judicial, and financial oversight. The structure emphasizes hierarchical decision-making, with the Conference of Heads of State and Government as the supreme authority. The Conference of Heads of State and Government constitutes the highest decision-making organ, tasked with defining ECCAS's general policy, approving budgets, and appointing key officials such as the President of the Commission. It convenes in ordinary session at least annually and in extraordinary sessions when convened by the Chairperson or a of members, ensuring strategic direction across , peace, and security domains. The Council of Ministers, comprising foreign affairs and other designated ministers from member states, supports the Conference by preparing dossiers, recommending policies, and monitoring implementation; it meets twice yearly in ordinary sessions. The Commission, elevated to its current status in December 2019 as the primary executive organ, implements decisions, coordinates activities, and manages day-to-day operations from its headquarters in , Gabon (temporarily relocated to , , amid regional political events in late 2023). Headed by a President and supported by Vice-Presidents and directors, it oversees sectoral programs and reports directly to the . Advisory bodies include the Specialized Technical Committees, which provide expertise on specific areas like and ; the , representing member states in ongoing deliberations; and the Interstate Committee of Experts, offering technical recommendations to facilitate consensus. Among the key institutions, the Community Court of Justice interprets the , resolves disputes, and ensures compliance with community law, while the Community Parliament—still in the process of full establishment—advises on legislative matters to foster democratic integration. The Court of Auditors conducts financial audits to promote transparency, and specialized agencies, such as the Conference of Ministers in Charge of Forests (COMIFAC), address sector-specific mandates. These elements collectively underpin ECCAS's operational framework, though implementation challenges persist due to varying member commitments and resource constraints.

Decision-Making Mechanisms and Funding

The supreme decision-making body of the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) is the , which convenes at least once annually and adopts binding decisions on strategic policies, institutional matters, and amendments by consensus, unanimity, or a two-thirds majority of members present and voting, provided a of two-thirds of states is met. The , comprising and other designated ministers from member states, prepares technical dossiers for the Conference, adopts regulations and directives executable after 30 days of publication, and employs the same voting modalities as the Conference. The Executive Commission, led by an Executive Secretary appointed by the Conference for a four-year renewable term, implements these decisions, coordinates daily operations, and supervises specialized technical committees and the Council for Peace and Security (COPAX) in security-related deliberations. Decisions take effect immediately upon notification and are directly applicable in member states, with non-compliance enforceable via sanctions, including suspension of rights, though enforcement has been inconsistent due to political sensitivities among members. ECCAS funding relies primarily on annual contributions from member states, scaled by the according to economic indicators such as GDP shares, with delays exceeding one year potentially leading to suspension of voting rights or other privileges. To diversify revenue, the establishes the Contribution Communautaire d'Intégration (CCI), a 0.7% levy on the CIF value of imports from third countries, intended to generate autonomous funds for integration projects; however, implementation remains partial, with only select states applying it consistently, limiting projected revenues to far below the potential $192 million annually if fully operationalized. The annual process involves the Commission drafting proposals, approval, and adoption by the Community Parliament, as seen in the 2025 of 38 billion FCFA (approximately 63.4 million USD), which reflects tightened expenditures amid chronic arrears and irregular collections from national budgets. External support from development partners, including loans, grants, and technical , supplements these sources, often funding specific programs like operations, though this dependency exposes ECCAS to donor priorities and has contributed to operational shortfalls in self-financed initiatives.

Economic Integration Efforts

Trade Liberalization and Customs Initiatives

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) initiated its trade liberalization process through the launch of a (FTA) on 1 July 2004, aimed at progressively eliminating tariffs and non-tariff barriers on intra-regional trade among member states. This step built on the foundational objectives outlined in the 1983 ECCAS Treaty, which mandates the removal of customs duties and equivalent charges on imports and exports between members to foster . The FTA's implementation sought to boost intra-ECCAS trade, which remains low at under 5% of total member trade volumes as of recent assessments, hampered by infrastructure deficits and overlapping regional arrangements. Supporting the , ECCAS adopted a Protocol on Cooperation (Annex V to the ), requiring members to harmonize customs procedures, standardize documentation, and coordinate policies to facilitate cross-border movement of . Key measures include protocols on transit facilities, re-export of , and simplification of controls, intended to reduce administrative delays and costs. These initiatives align with broader goals of establishing a by standardizing external tariffs, with an initial target date of 2008 for a (CET). Progress toward the has been incremental but incomplete, with the operationalization of a full CET delayed due to divergent national schedules and limited of agreements. In April 2022, ECCAS convened experts to align national with the (HS) 2022 nomenclature as a prerequisite for CET development, focusing on classifying over 5,000 lines to ensure uniformity in duties on third-country imports. By July 2023, the ECCAS Commission advanced proposals for a regional industrialization plan tied to formation, emphasizing value-added processing to complement reductions. Despite these efforts, challenges persist, including inconsistent , political instability in member states like the and of Congo, and competition from sub-regional bodies such as CEMAC, which maintains its own CET since 2010. Intra-regional trade volumes have shown modest growth post-FTA, but non- barriers like poor road connectivity and regulatory discrepancies continue to undermine liberalization gains.

Harmonization with Sub-Regional Bodies like CEMAC

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) pursues harmonization with the Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa (CEMAC) to mitigate overlaps in membership and policy domains, as CEMAC comprises six ECCAS states: Cameroon, Central African Republic, Chad, Republic of the Congo, Equatorial Guinea, and Gabon. This coordination seeks to align economic integration initiatives, particularly in trade and customs, to prevent conflicting obligations for shared members. Key efforts include the adoption of a unified (CET) applicable to both CEMAC and ECCAS frameworks, aimed at streamlining tariff structures and promoting consistent external policies. Complementary measures involve the elimination of tariff and non-tariff barriers, alongside harmonized agricultural and industrial policies, to foster seamless intra-regional . A Steering Committee has been established to oversee policy alignment between the two bodies, focusing on sectoral such as facilitation. Trade protocols further support this integration, including the ECCAS-CEMAC trade protocol that addresses the gradual removal of technical barriers to trade among members and with external partners. Instruments for the , such as simplified trade documents and procedures, have been harmonized, with training programs conducted by the Economic Commission for (UNECA) on accreditation to the ECCAS/CEMAC Preferential regime. These steps build on the ECCAS provisions for cooperation, which mandate of procedures to enhance regional economic cohesion. Despite these initiatives, challenges persist in fully synchronizing broader ECCAS objectives with CEMAC's deeper monetary and , often requiring consultations to resolve discrepancies in timelines and enforcement. The has supported capacity-building for both organizations to improve technical alignment, emphasizing knowledge generation for effective policy execution. Overall, remains incremental, with progress noted in trade liberalization but limited by institutional overlaps and varying member commitments.

Challenges in Monetary and Fiscal Coordination

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) encounters substantial hurdles in achieving monetary coordination owing to the absence of a unified currency across its 11 member states, with only six—C , , , , , and —participating in the Central African Economic and Monetary Community (CEMAC)'s zone managed by the (BEAC). Non-CEMAC members, including , , , (until its withdrawal in June 2024), and São Tomé and Príncipe, maintain independent national currencies and monetary policies, fostering divergence in inflation targets, interest rates, and regimes that undermine regional stability. This heterogeneity, compounded by oil-dependent economies in CEMAC contrasting with more diversified or conflict-affected non-members, has stalled ECCAS's aspirations for broader monetary integration as outlined in its 1983 treaty. Fiscal coordination remains elusive due to decentralized budgeting practices, particularly within CEMAC where common clashes with nationally varied fiscal stances, resulting in procyclical spending tied to volatile commodity revenues. The CEMAC Convergence and Stability Pact of 1999, intended to enforce criteria such as budget deficits below 3% of GDP and public debt under 70%, has seen persistent non-compliance, with fiscal slippages exacerbating vulnerabilities during oil price downturns, as evidenced by widened deficits post-2014. Across ECCAS, high public debt levels—averaging over 50% of GDP in several members by 2023—constrict fiscal space for convergent policies, while inadequate revenue mobilization and reliance on external further fragment harmonization efforts. Institutional and political barriers amplify these issues, including overlapping mandates between ECCAS and CEMAC that dilute , financial shortfalls from unpaid member contributions, and recurrent conflicts disrupting implementation. Attempts to delineate roles—CEMAC focusing on monetary affairs and ECCAS on —have not resolved coordination gaps, as personal leadership ties rather than robust mechanisms drive decisions, leading to stalled merger discussions at the July 2024 summit. Consequently, intra-ECCAS trade remains below 5% of total trade, reflecting unaddressed macroeconomic divergences that perpetuate economic isolation.

Peace and Security Activities

Framework for Conflict Prevention and Resolution

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) established its core framework for conflict prevention and resolution through the Protocol Relating to the Establishment of a Mechanism for Conflict Prevention, Management, Resolution, , and , adopted on February 24, 1999, in , . This protocol operationalizes Article 3 of the ECCAS , which prohibits among member states and promotes peaceful dispute settlement, while addressing regional instability driven by political crises, resource disputes, and cross-border threats. The framework emphasizes preventive , early intervention, and , with implementation advancing after ratification by key members around 2004. Central to this framework is the Council for Peace and Security in Central Africa (COPAX), created in February 2000 as ECCAS's primary organ for coordinating peace efforts. COPAX, comprising heads of state or their representatives from the 11 member states, decides on preventive actions, sanctions, or military deployments, and aligns with the African Union's architecture. Supporting organs include the Commission for Defense and Security (CDS), which assesses threats and recommends operations; the Multinational Joint Committee for the Prevention and Settlement of Disputes (MARAC), functioning as an early warning mechanism; and the Central African Multinational Force (FOMAC), a standby of up to 6,500 personnel for rapid deployment in or enforcement roles. Prevention mechanisms prioritize monitoring via MARAC's network, which aggregates data from national focal points, , and intelligence sources to detect tensions such as electoral disputes or ethnic conflicts, enabling diplomatic or before escalation. Resolution tools encompass arbitration through COPAX-mediated talks, humanitarian assistance for displaced persons and refugees, and FOMAC interventions adhering to , including , , and reintegration (DDR) programs for ex-combatants. The framework also promotes , democratic transitions, and cross-border cooperation on issues like in the , as outlined in supplementary protocols from 2009 and 2013. Operational effectiveness relies on member state contributions for FOMAC's logistics and funding, though challenges persist in timely mobilization due to overlapping mandates with sub-regional bodies like CEMAC. COPAX decisions require consensus, fostering sovereignty-respecting interventions while integrating with continental early warning systems for broader threat analysis.

Specific Missions and Interventions (e.g., MICOPAX)

The Mission for the Consolidation of Peace in the (MICOPAX), authorized by ECCAS in 2008, represented a key military intervention to stabilize the country following the 2006-2008 Bush War and subsequent rebel threats to the capital . Deployed from July 2008 until its transition in December 2013, MICOPAX succeeded the Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa (CEMAC)-led Force Multinationale en Centrafrique (FOMUC), incorporating elements of the prior force while expanding under ECCAS command with contributions primarily from , , , and other member states. The mission's mandate focused on protecting civilians, securing key infrastructure, facilitating humanitarian access, and supporting the restoration of state authority amid persistent militia violence and political instability. By October 2013, amid escalating rebel advances that ousted President in March, MICOPAX comprised 2,589 uniformed personnel, including 2,220 military troops and 379 police, though logistical constraints and limited funding hampered full operational capacity. ECCAS financed the mission through member state contributions and external support, including €6.3 million from the European Union's African Peace Facility in 2013 for logistics and sustainment. Authority transferred to the African Union-led International Support Mission to the (MISCA) on 19 December 2013, following ECCAS-AU consultations, as MICOPAX forces integrated into the successor operation to address intensified sectarian clashes. MICOPAX operated within the broader framework of the ECCAS of (FOMAC), a standby brigade-level force established in for rapid deployment in regional crises, encompassing roles in observation, , , and humanitarian assistance. While FOMAC has not led other large-scale named interventions comparable to MICOPAX, it supported ECCAS mediation efforts in conflicts such as the 2016 post-election unrest and São Tomé and Príncipe's 2003 coup attempt, deploying observers or limited contingents for stabilization. No additional major ECCAS-led military missions beyond the CAR context have been documented as of 2023, with subsequent regional security responses increasingly coordinated through or mechanisms.

Evaluation of Operational Effectiveness

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) has deployed limited peace support operations under its Council for Peace and Security in (COPAX), primarily the Mission for the Consolidation of Peace in the (MICOPAX) from 2008 to 2013, which succeeded the Community of Sahel-Saharan States' FOMUC mission with approximately 700 troops initially focused on monitoring ceasefires and protecting civilians. This force aimed to stabilize post-2003 conflict dynamics but operated under a restrictive peace support mandate that prohibited offensive actions, constraining its ability to counter armed groups effectively. Operational effectiveness has been undermined by chronic under-resourcing and inadequate troop strength; during the 2012-2013 rebellion, MICOPAX's limited personnel failed to prevent the overthrow of President or widespread atrocities, prompting reinforcement to 2,000 troops in April 2013, yet violence escalated with over 1 million displacements and thousands killed. The mission's handover to the African Union-led MISCA in 2013 and eventual UN transition highlighted ECCAS's inability to sustain independent operations amid funding shortfalls, with member states contributing irregularly due to domestic priorities and reliance on external donors like the EU's Africa Peace Facility. Broader evaluations indicate partial successes in diplomatic facilitation, such as ECCAS-brokered talks contributing to the 2013 Libreville Peace Agreement, but these yielded short-term ceasefires without addressing root causes like resource predation and weak governance, as evidenced by recurring cycles of violence in through 2024. ECCAS's early warning mechanism via the Multinational Joint Committee on Prevention (MARAC) has generated reports on threats in regions like the , yet translation into actionable deployments remains rare, with only sporadic interventions in and demonstrating marginal deterrence against coups. Overall, institutional frameworks exist, but causal factors including fragmented political will among autocratic member regimes and logistical deficits have rendered ECCAS operations reactive and insufficient for regional stabilization, contrasting with more robust AU or UN successors.

Achievements and Impacts

Documented Successes in Stability and Cooperation

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) has recorded specific contributions to regional stability through its and security mechanisms, particularly in the (). The Multinational Joint Task Force in (MICOPAX), operational from 2008 to 2013, supported law and order maintenance, disarmament processes, and humanitarian access protection amid conflict escalation. ECCAS's Extraordinary Summit decisions in January 2014 facilitated political transition advancements in by endorsing frameworks that stabilized interim governance and paved the way for subsequent missions. More recently, ECCAS mediation efforts, including support processes led by the presidents of Congo and , contributed to peaceful power transitions in member states like and between 2021 and 2023, reducing immediate risks of violence during electoral periods. In cooperation domains, ECCAS protocols on the free movement of persons, adopted early in its integration process, have enabled visa-free travel and residency rights across several member states, notably , , , and , fostering cross-border labor mobility and trade despite implementation gaps elsewhere. The Central African Power Pool (PEAC), established in April 2003, has advanced energy cooperation by interconnecting national grids and developing a regional , with progress in hydroelectric resource sharing that leverages the subregion's 60% share of Africa's potential. ECCAS-UN collaboration has yielded operational gains in conflict monitoring, as evidenced by encouraging outcomes from joint early warning and capacity-building efforts reported in September 2024, enhancing data-sharing for preventive diplomacy. Additionally, the organization's revival of the for Peace, Security, and Cooperation in the through a regional retreat in October-November 2023 demonstrated coordinated multilateral engagement to address cross-border threats. These instances reflect targeted institutional outputs amid broader challenges, with ECCAS's Council of the Peace and Security in providing a platform for sustained dialogue since its 1999 activation.

Measurable Economic and Social Outcomes

Intra-regional trade within ECCAS remains limited, accounting for approximately 5.9% of member states' total trade in 2021, lower than in other regional economic communities such as at 10.18%. This low share reflects persistent barriers including inadequate infrastructure, overlapping memberships with bodies like CEMAC, and non-tariff obstacles, despite protocols aimed at liberalization since the . ECCAS exhibits the lowest intra-regional trade as a of GDP among African RECs, constraining collective economic gains from scale and diversification. Aggregate GDP for ECCAS member states reached levels supporting 8.8% of Africa's total economy in 2023, with projections to 11.6% by 2043 driven largely by resource-rich members like the Democratic Republic of Congo and , though attribution to ECCAS-specific integration is minimal amid external factors such as commodity prices. Regional infrastructure deficits, including poor transport and energy access, limit potential GDP boosts; World Bank analysis estimates that aligning infrastructure to standards could add 5 percentage points to annual growth, highlighting untapped but unrealized synergies. Economic growth in ECCAS has shown some pro-poor effects, reducing the depth of poverty through and broader expansion, as evidenced in comparative studies with , yet overall per capita GDP lags at around $1,631 in recent aggregates. Social outcomes reflect high vulnerability, with extreme poverty rates projected to exceed 65% in countries like the by 2043 under current trajectories, exacerbated by conflicts and weak development. Remittances play a key role in alleviation and across ECCAS, supporting macroeconomic stability, though harmonization efforts have yet to yield broad reductions in inequality. and indicators remain poor, with regional integration indices scoring low at 0.373 for in 2019, impeding social progress despite peace frameworks intended to foster stability. Scenarios emphasizing , , and reforms offer pathways to greater mitigation by 2043, but empirical realization tied to ECCAS initiatives remains constrained.

Criticisms and Limitations

Institutional and Governance Shortcomings

The Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) suffers from chronic institutional capacity deficits, including understaffed and under-resourced mechanisms such as the for Central Africa (FOMAC), which operates with only 4,800–5,000 personnel despite recurrent regional crises demanding broader deployment. This limitation stems from member states' failure to contribute adequately in finances, intelligence, and personnel, leading to heavy reliance on external actors like the and for operational support, which diminishes ECCAS's autonomy and perceived legitimacy. Between 1992 and 1997, ECCAS was effectively inactive due to unpaid member contributions, highlighting persistent funding shortfalls that undermine its core functions. Governance structures within ECCAS exhibit low effectiveness, as evidenced by a 2023 Governance Security Index score of 0.60—the lowest among African Regional Economic Communities—reflecting inadequate coordination and enforcement amid political instability, including coups and extended presidential tenures in member states like (term limits removed in 2005). The ECCAS Commission faces both institutional capacity weaknesses and conceptual gaps in policy formulation, as noted in World Bank assessments, exacerbating overlaps with sub-regional bodies like the Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa (CEMAC), which result in conflicting tariffs and diluted integration efforts. Regional governance indicators, per the Ibrahim Index, scored 44 out of 100 in 2016, trailing the African average of 50.8, with infrastructural deficits (integration score of 0.373) further hampering institutional delivery. Decision-making processes are compromised by inter-state mistrust and national loyalties, as seen in the Council for Peace and Security in (COPAX), where rival heads of state prioritize over , yielding incomplete data for the Early Warning Mechanism (MARAC). Enforcement remains feeble; for instance, ECCAS failed to avert unconstitutional term extensions in (2015) and the of Congo (2011–2016), and its MICOPAX mission (2008–2013) deployed just 700 troops, proving ineffective against the 2012–2013 rebellion. Only five of eleven members have ratified the African Charter on Democracy, Elections, and Governance, signaling weak commitment to supranational norms. Implementation of key protocols, such as free movement of persons and goods, falters due to poor and , with and ethnic-linguistic divides fostering roadblocks (e.g., 284 in ) and hostile relations like those between and . Regional trade constitutes merely 2% of total trade, undermined by these institutional voids and rivalries among leaders, which prioritize domestic interests over harmonized policies.

Failures in Conflict Resolution and Integration

Despite its mandate under the 1999 Protocol on Peace and Security to mediate and deploy forces for conflict prevention, ECCAS has demonstrated limited efficacy in resolving intra-state and cross-border disputes, often due to insufficient resources, narrow mandates, and member states' resistance to supranational authority. In the (), the ECCAS-led Multinational Force in the Central African Republic (MICOPAX), authorized in 2008 with approximately 700 troops from , , and Congo-Brazzaville, failed to contain the rebellion that erupted in December 2012 and toppled President in March 2013. The mission's restrictive peace support mandate, focused on monitoring rather than robust enforcement, coupled with chronic underfunding and logistical deficiencies, rendered it unable to prevent the ensuing between Muslim and Christian militias that displaced over 1 million people by 2014. ECCAS member states provided minimal additional personnel or moral support, reflecting a broader aversion to external oversight that prioritized national over . In the (DRC), ECCAS interventions have similarly faltered amid protracted eastern conflicts involving over 100 armed groups as of 2024. The organization's mediation efforts contributed to the disputed 2011 elections, where incumbent secured 49% of the vote amid widespread fraud allegations, enabling him to cling to power until 2019 and fueling cycles of rebellion that have killed millions since the 1990s. Despite issuing statements in February 2025 urging M23 rebels to halt offensives in —where fighting displaced 7 million by mid-2025—ECCAS lacked mechanisms for enforcement, allowing the conflict to persist without resolution. This ineffectiveness stems from ECCAS's historical dormancy during the Second Congo War (1998–2003), when financial shortfalls and overlapping memberships with other bodies like the diluted focus and resources. These security shortcomings have exacerbated failures in regional integration, as persistent instability deters cross-border trade, infrastructure investment, and policy harmonization. ECCAS's 1998 Protocol on the Free Movement of Persons and Goods remains largely unimplemented, with poor road networks—such as the incomplete corridors—and communication gaps hindering the flow of over 300 million across 11 member states. Conflicts in and DRC have stalled economic corridors, reducing intra-ECCAS trade to under 5% of total commerce by 2020, far below targets set in the 1983 . Rwanda's withdrawal from ECCAS in June 2025, prompted by accusations of bias in addressing DRC insurgencies, underscored deepening divisions that undermine and joint initiatives. Overall, ECCAS's under-resourced Council for Peace and Security in has convened sporadically, issuing non-binding resolutions that fail to compel compliance amid national priorities and elite interests.

Sovereignty Concerns and Resource Inefficiencies

Member states of the Economic Community of Central African States (ECCAS) have expressed reservations about regional mechanisms infringing on national , particularly in and interventions where non-interference principles clash with mandates. For instance, ECCAS's deployment of forces like the against insurgencies has been met with reluctance, as states prioritize over supranational oversight, limiting the organization's ability to enforce decisions. This resistance stems from a broader African preference for revised intervention norms that safeguard fledgling statehood against external or regional encroachment. Economic integration efforts under ECCAS, compounded by overlaps with the Economic and Monetary Community of Central Africa (CEMAC), further erode sovereign control in fiscal and monetary domains. CEMAC's treaty lacks explicit sovereignty safeguards, enabling communitarization that subordinates national policies to regional bodies, a dynamic extending to ECCAS's broader harmonization goals. Such arrangements, while aimed at stability, have prompted critiques that they diminish states' independent policymaking capacity without commensurate benefits, as evidenced by persistent monetary autonomy debates in the CFA franc zone. Resource inefficiencies plague ECCAS operations due to chronic underfunding and inconsistent member contributions, with conflicts and fiscal shortfalls halting integration from the early onward. Between 1992 and 1999, non-payment of dues by members caused severe financial paralysis, a pattern contributing to Rwanda's 2025 withdrawal amid ongoing ineffectiveness. Institutional weaknesses, including inadequate human and financial inputs, exacerbate this, as ECCAS struggles with operational capacity despite ambitious mandates. Duplication across regional entities amplifies , with ECCAS and CEMAC maintaining parallel institutions like parliaments, courts, and bodies, leading to redundant expenditures and coordination failures. Multiple memberships foster and diluted efforts, undermining resource allocation in a region marked by fragility and limited budgets. Proposals to merge ECCAS and CEMAC by harmonizing structures, discussed at the July 2025 summit, seek to address these overlaps but highlight entrenched political hurdles to rationalization.

References

Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.