Hubbry Logo
May SinclairMay SinclairMain
Open search
May Sinclair
Community hub
May Sinclair
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
May Sinclair
May Sinclair
May Sinclair
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

May Sinclair was the pseudonym of Mary Amelia St. Clair (24 August 1863 – 14 November 1946), a British writer who wrote about two dozen novels, short stories and poetry.[1] She was an active suffragist, and member of the Woman Writers' Suffrage League. She once dressed up as a demure, rebel Jane Austen for a suffrage fundraising event.[2] Sinclair was also a significant critic in the area of modernist poetry and prose, and she is attributed with first using the term 'stream of consciousness' in a literary context, when reviewing the first volumes of Dorothy Richardson's novel sequence Pilgrimage (1915–1967), in The Egoist, April 1918.

Key Information

Early life

[edit]

Sinclair was born in Rock Ferry, Cheshire.[3] Her mother, Amelia Sinclair, was strict and religious; her father, William Sinclair, was a Liverpool shipowner, who went bankrupt when Sinclair was seven years old and became an alcoholic.[3] Her parents separated and Sinclair lived with her mother, moving around and relying on the help of relatives.[3] At 18 years old, Sinclair was enrolled at Cheltenham Ladies College, but her mother took her out after one year.[3] She became obliged to look after her brothers, as four of the five, all older than she, were suffering from fatal congenital heart disease.[4]

Career

[edit]

From 1896 Sinclair wrote professionally to support herself and her mother, who died in 1901. An active feminist, Sinclair treated a number of themes relating to the position of women and marriage.[5] Her works sold well in the United States.

Ma(r)y Sinclair entering Kensington's Women's Social & Political Union shop in 1910

Sinclair's suffrage activities were remembered by Sylvia Pankhurst. Photographs (as "Mary Sinclair" show her around the WSPU offices in Kensington. In 1912 the Women Writers' Suffrage League published her ideas on feminism. Here she de-bunked theories put forward by Sir Almroth Wright that the suffragists were powered by their sexual frustration because of the shortage of men. She said that suffrage and the class struggle were similar aspirations and the working woman should not be in competition with the ambitions of the male working class.[6]

Around 1913, she was a founding supporter of the Medico-Psychological Clinic in London which was run by Dr Jessie Murray.[6] Sinclair became interested in psychoanalytic thought, and introduced matter related to Sigmund Freud's teaching in her novels.[5] In 1914, she volunteered to join the Munro Ambulance Corps, a charitable organization (which included Lady Dorothie Feilding, Elsie Knocker and Mairi Chisholm) that aided wounded Belgian soldiers on the Western Front in Flanders. She was sent home after only a few weeks at the front; she wrote about the experience in both prose and poetry.[7]

Her 1913 novel The Combined Maze, the story of a London clerk and the two women he loves, was highly praised by critics, including George Orwell, while Agatha Christie considered it one of the greatest English novels of its time.

She wrote early criticism on Imagism and the poet H. D. (1915 in The Egoist); she was on social terms with H. D. (Hilda Doolittle), Richard Aldington and Ezra Pound at the time. She also reviewed in a positive light the poetry of T. S. Eliot (1917 in the Little Review) and the fiction of Dorothy Richardson (1918 in The Egoist). Some aspects of Sinclair's subsequent novels have been traced as influenced by modernist techniques, particularly in the autobiographical Mary Olivier: A Life (1919). She was included in the 1925 Contact Collection of Contemporary Writers.[citation needed]

Sinclair wrote two volumes of supernatural fiction, Uncanny Stories (1923) and The Intercessor and Other Stories (1931).[5] E. F. Bleiler called Sinclair "an underrated writer" and described Uncanny Stories as "excellent".[8] Gary Crawford has stated Sinclair's contribution to the supernatural fiction genre, "small as it is, is notable".[5] Jacques Barzun included Sinclair among a list of supernatural fiction writers that "one should make a point of seeking out".[9] Brian Stableford has stated that Sinclair's "supernatural tales are written with uncommon delicacy and precision, and they are among the most effective examples of their fugitive kind".[10] Andrew Smith has described Uncanny Stories as "an important contribution to the ghost story".[11]

American critic Dorothy Parker chastised Sinclair for producing books "with one hand tied behind her and a buttered crumpet in the other.'[12]

From the late 1920s, she was suffering from the early signs of Parkinson's disease, and ceased writing. She settled with a companion in Buckinghamshire in 1932. She died on 14 November 1946.

She is buried at St John-at-Hampstead's churchyard, London.[13]

Philosophy

[edit]

Sinclair also wrote non-fiction based on studies of philosophy, particularly idealism. She defended a form of idealistic monism in her book A Defence of Idealism (1917).[14]

Sinclair was interested in parapsychology and spiritualism, she was a member of the Society for Psychical Research from 1914.[5][15]

Works

[edit]
Portrait of May Sinclair by E. Huggins
  • Nakiketas and other poems (1886) as Julian Sinclair
  • Essays in Verse (1892)
  • Audrey Craven (1897)
  • Mr and Mrs Nevill Tyson (1898) also The Tysons
  • Two Sides Of A Question (1901)
  • The Divine Fire (1904)
  • The Helpmate (1907)
  • The Judgment of Eve (1907) stories
  • The Immortal Moment (1908)
  • Kitty Tailleur (1908)
  • Outlines of Church History by Rudolph Sohm (1909) translator
  • The Creators (1910)
  • Miss Tarrant's Temperament (1911) in Harper's Magazine
  • The Flaw in the Crystal (1912)
  • The Three Brontes (1912)
  • Feminism (1912) pamphlet for Women's Suffrage League
  • The Combined Maze (1913)
  • The Three Sisters (1914)
  • The Return of the Prodigal (1914)
  • A Journal of Impressions in Belgium (1915)
  • The Belfry (1916)
  • Tasker Jevons: The Real Story (1916)
  • The Tree of Heaven (1917)
  • A Defence of Idealism: Some Questions & Conclusions (1917)
  • Mary Olivier: A Life (1919)
  • The Romantic (1920)
  • Mr. Waddington of Wyck (1921)
  • Life and Death of Harriett Frean (1922)
  • Anne Severn and the Fieldings (1922)
  • The New Idealism (1922)
  • Uncanny Stories (1923)
  • A Cure of Souls (1924)
  • The Dark Night: A Novel in Unrhymed Verse (1924)
  • Arnold Waterlow (1924)
  • The Rector of Wyck (1925)
  • Far End (1926)
  • The Allinghams (1927)
  • History of Anthony Waring (1927)
  • Fame (1929)
  • Tales Told by Simpson (1930) stories
  • The Intercessor, and Other Stories (1931)
  • Villa Désirée (1932)

References

[edit]

Sources

[edit]
  • Theophilus Ernest Martin Boll (1973) Miss May Sinclair: Novelist; A Biographical and Critical Introduction
  • Suzanne Raitt (2000) May Sinclair: A Modern Victorian
  • George M. Johnson (2006) "May Sinclair: The Evolution of a Psychological Novelist" in Dynamic Psychology in Modern British Fiction. Palgrave Macmillan, 2006. pp. 101–143.
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

May Sinclair

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

Mary Amelia St. Clair Sinclair (24 August 1863 – 14 November 1946), writing under the pseudonym May Sinclair, was a British , philosopher, and suffragist whose works encompassed novels, short stories, , and treatises on and .
Born into a family disrupted by financial hardship following her father's , Sinclair drew from personal experience in depicting themes of , , and emotional complexity in her fiction. Her breakthrough came with the 1904 novel The Divine Fire, which established her as a leading voice in early twentieth-century literature, followed by over twenty additional novels exploring psychological depth.
Sinclair advanced modernist techniques by coining the phrase "" in her 1918 essay reviewing Dorothy Richardson's series, a method she employed to render inner mental processes in works such as Mary Olivier: A Life (1919). As a suffragist, she affiliated with the Women's Freedom League from 1908, penned advocacy pamphlets, and integrated feminist concerns into her narratives critiquing Victorian constraints on women. In 1914, amid the outbreak of , she volunteered in with the Munro Ambulance Corps, functioning as a driver, nurse, and , and later published A Journal of Impressions in detailing frontline observations. Her later years were marked by , though her influence persisted in bridging Victorian realism with modernist innovation and philosophical inquiry into consciousness.

Biography

Early life and family background

Mary Amelia St. Clair Sinclair was born on August 24, 1863, in Thorncote, Rock Park, (Higher ), , , near . She was the youngest of six surviving children—seven born in total, with one dying in infancy—and the only surviving daughter in a family initially of comfortable middle-class means, complete with a large house, garden, and servants. Her father, William Sinclair (1829–1881), managed a shipping business inherited through family connections, while her mother, Amelia Hind Sinclair (1821–1901), enforced a rigid household authority described as a "cold, bitter, narrow tyranny." The family's prosperity unraveled in the late 1860s when William's shipping enterprise collapsed, culminating in around 1870, when May was seven years old; he also struggled with alcoholism, leading to separation from the family. This plunged the Sinclairs into reduced circumstances, prompting frequent relocations and the dispersal of the household, with May residing primarily with her mother thereafter. William died on November 19, 1881, further entrenching the family's reliance on limited resources amid ongoing personal losses, including the early deaths of several brothers from congenital heart defects. Amelia's strict, religiously orthodox upbringing of her children, marked by inflexibility and , dominated May's early environment in this Victorian setting of evangelical undertones and patriarchal absence. These dynamics—financial precarity, maternal dominance, and fraternal vulnerabilities—instilled in the young Sinclair a sense of premature responsibility and , shaping her resilient character amid the era's middle-class constraints.

Education and formative influences

Sinclair's formal education was limited, consisting primarily of home tuition in her early years followed by a single year at in 1881. There, under the guidance of principal Dorothea Beale, she encountered encouragement for her budding interests in writing and philosophy, with Beale recognizing her exceptional intellectual aptitude. This brief institutional exposure introduced her to German philosophical idealism, marking an early pivot toward systematic thought. Beyond formal schooling, Sinclair pursued extensive self-education, accessing her father's library to immerse herself in classical literature, English authors, history, and . She independently mastered languages including German, Greek, and French, using reading as a primary means of intellectual survival and development. Her voracious consumption of works by figures such as fueled a deepening engagement with idealistic , laying the groundwork for her later defenses of it against . Formative religious influences stemmed from a Victorian evangelical upbringing under strict , which Sinclair later critiqued as a "cold, bitter, narrow tyranny" constraining personal freedom. This environment prompted a skeptical stance toward , redirecting her toward individualized informed by philosophical and mystical traditions. Such exposures cultivated a resilient, autonomous framework, emphasizing first-hand reasoning over doctrinal authority.

Literary Career

Early supernatural fiction

Sinclair's engagement with supernatural themes emerged prominently in the early 1910s, amid her established career as a , as she explored the and in response to contemporary interests in spiritualism and psychical research. Her earliest documented fantastic tale, the The Flaw in the Crystal (1912), depicts a inventing a mechanism to protect a distant loved one from harm, blurring the lines between mental projection and intervention. This work introduced motifs of telepathic influence and ethereal barriers, drawing on Sinclair's personal interest in spiritualism, evidenced by her later membership in the starting in 1914. These explorations culminated in Uncanny Stories (1923), her first dedicated collection of , which gathered The Flaw in the Crystal alongside six shorter tales featuring ghostly apparitions, revenants, and psychic transference. Stories such as "The Nature of the Evidence" and "The Token" examine inherited familial curses and spectral visitations that challenge rational explanations, often portraying the as an intrusive force revealing hidden emotional truths. Sinclair's narratives in this vein emphasize causal disruptions from the mystical realm—such as hauntings triggered by unresolved traumas—contrasting empirical reality with intangible presences, without resolving into outright fantasy. This phase of her output aligned with Edwardian popular fiction markets, where Sinclair had already achieved commercial viability through over a dozen novels since her debut in , selling steadily to audiences drawn to gothic-tinged romances. Her supernatural works, while not her primary focus initially, contributed to her reputation as a versatile capable of merging sensational elements with psychological depth, predating her shift toward introspective realism.

Psychological novels and innovations

Sinclair's psychological novels marked a departure from her earlier themes, emphasizing introspective character studies and the nuances of . In The Combined Maze (1913), she dissects the mundane existence of a , Ranny Randall, probing his repressed ambitions, erotic longings, and entrapment within social conventions through a that anticipates modernist interiority. The novel employs subtle free indirect discourse to render Ranny's fragmented thoughts, revealing how external routines mask internal turmoil without resorting to overt experimentation. This approach highlights family pressures and unfulfilled desires, portraying psychological realism grounded in everyday constraints rather than gothic excess. By Mary Olivier: A Life (1919), Sinclair deepened this focus into a semi-autobiographical chronicle of a woman's intellectual and emotional development across decades, structured as episodic vignettes that trace repressed familial duties against aspirations for . The protagonist's inner monologues, conveyed via free indirect style, expose the fluidity of mental states influenced by Henri Bergson's concept of durée, depicting as an indivisible flow rather than discrete events—a vitalist lens distinct from the more radical stream-of-consciousness techniques later popularized by contemporaries. Sinclair's method prefigures such innovations by integrating psychological depth with narrative restraint, avoiding exhaustive soliloquies in favor of implied emotional undercurrents tied to family dynamics and self-denial. Critics acclaimed these works for their unflinching portrayal of female emotional complexity and the pursuit of independence amid patriarchal expectations, as in Mary Olivier's rejection of for creative . Sinclair's growing with Freudian ideas, including translations of psychoanalytic texts, informed her depiction of subconscious drives without dogmatic adherence, lending authenticity to characters' inner conflicts. This period's innovations earned her recognition as a bridge between Victorian realism and , with reviewers praising the novels' capacity to evoke authentic psychic realism over .

Later works and output summary

In the 1920s, Sinclair continued producing novels that explored themes of personal stagnation and spiritual constraint, such as The Life and Death of Harriett Frean (1922), which depicts the monotonous existence of a shaped by Victorian conventions, and The Allinghams (), addressing dynamics and inheritance. She also published collections of short stories, including Uncanny Stories (1923), extending her earlier interest in elements into more introspective narratives. The onset of in the late 1920s progressively impaired Sinclair's health, prompting a shift toward shorter literary forms and works with autobiographical undertones, as physical limitations curtailed her ability to sustain longer projects. Her final novel, The Intercessor (1931), marked the effective end of her creative output, after which the disease's advancement led to seclusion and cessation of writing by the early 1930s. Despite these challenges, she persisted in producing material into this period, demonstrating resilience amid deteriorating motor function and eventual mental strain. Sinclair's complete oeuvre encompassed 23 novels, 39 short stories compiled in multiple volumes, several poetry collections such as The Flaw in the Crystal (, with later verse), and essays on and , alongside occasional translations and . Her later productivity, though diminished, reinforced recurring motifs of human finitude and metaphysical aspiration, bridging her earlier experimental phases with a reflective capstone to her bibliography.

Philosophical Contributions

Influences from Bergson and idealism

May Sinclair's philosophical outlook was significantly informed by Henri Bergson's concepts of durée—the qualitative multiplicity of inner time—and élan vital, the vital impetus driving creative evolution through intuition rather than spatialized intellect. In The New Idealism (1922), she invoked Bergson's cinematographic metaphor from Creative Evolution (1907) to critique the fragmentation of time into discrete instants, arguing instead for its perception as an indivisible flow of becoming that resists mechanistic analysis. This engagement positioned Bergson's emphasis on intuitive sympathy with life's dynamic processes as foundational to her rejection of static, intellect-bound explanations of reality. Sinclair equated Bergson's with a "Life-Force," portraying it as an irrepressible creative principle that unfolds through heterogeneous durations, prioritizing direct apprehension over analytical dissection. Her adoption of these ideas, evident in her philosophical writings from the onward, aligned with Bergson's broader advocacy for as inventive rather than predetermined, influencing her view of reality as inherently processual and anti-deterministic. Parallel to Bergson, Sinclair embraced , drawing from T. H. Green's synthesis of Kantian and Hegelian thought, which posits the Absolute as a wherein finite minds participate and depends on rather than independent . Introduced to Green's works amid a around 1886, she articulated this in A Defence of (1917), defending the mind's constitutive role in experience against empiricist reductions. In The New Idealism, she fused idealist metaphysics with Bergsonian , maintaining that the indivisibility of duration underscores a mind-dependent cosmos governed by eternal relations within the Absolute.

Critiques of materialism and realism

In her 1917 treatise A Defence of Idealism: Some Questions and Conclusions, Sinclair mounted a direct challenge to the realist philosophy associated with , which posits physical objects and sensory data as the primary constituents of independent of mind. She argued that such realism commits a fundamental error by subordinating and to empirical verification, thereby failing to recognize the self-evident of an immaterial absolute that underpins subjective experience. Sinclair further critiqued scientific for its mechanistic portrayal of the universe, which she contended strips human agency of genuine causation by equating mental processes with neural firings or physical laws, thus denying the irreducible primacy of will and ethical discernment. Drawing on direct apprehension of inner states—what she termed empirical —she maintained that , such as the felt imperative of , reveals a non-physical dimension that cannot encompass without contradiction, as it presupposes the very transcendence it seeks to eliminate. Her election as the first female member of the in 1917 provided a platform to extend these critiques through formal discourse with professional philosophers, where she emphasized physicalism's inadequacy in accounting for as a causal force rather than an epiphenomenon. Sinclair's interventions there underscored that materialist frameworks, by prioritizing observable data over lived , undermine free will's evident operation in , rendering ethical responsibility illusory—a position she rejected as empirically untenable given the immediacy of volitional acts.

Engagement with psychoanalytic ideas

In 1913, May Sinclair became a founding member of the Medico-Psychological Clinic in , an institution established by Dr. to offer psychoanalytic therapy rooted in Freudian principles, with a focus on treating women through exploration of unconscious conflicts and integrating medical and psychological approaches. The clinic emphasized accessible care, including Freud-inspired techniques to address neuroses, and Sinclair actively supported its operations as a proponent of psychoanalysis's potential to uncover repressed drives while adapting it to her broader philosophical commitments. Sinclair endorsed Freudian insights into sexual drives and the unconscious but rejected the theory's deterministic implications, insisting that human agency and spiritual dimensions transcended mechanical causation by forces. She critiqued Freud's model of as arising primarily from repression, instead framing it as a vitalistic process amenable to voluntary sublimation and idealistic will, thereby preserving individual freedom against reductive materialism. This stance aligned her engagement with to Bergsonian , where unconscious elements fueled creative evolution rather than pathological inevitability, as evident in her essays reconciling psychic repression with dynamic life-force. In her psychological novels, Sinclair incorporated Freudian motifs of the unconscious—such as sublimation and infantile conflicts—but subordinated them to an affirmative vision of transcendent selfhood, portraying characters who achieve liberation through idealistic volition rather than therapeutic alone. This selective adaptation distinguished her from orthodox Freudianism, emphasizing spiritual agency as a counter to overemphasis on inherited or environmental compulsion, and informed her reviews linking psychoanalytic case studies to vitalist metaphysics.

Political and Social Involvement

Suffrage advocacy and feminism

May Sinclair actively supported through non-militant channels, joining the Women's Freedom League in 1908 after disapproving of the Women's Social and Political Union's arson tactics. The League advocated constitutional methods for enfranchisement, aligning with Sinclair's preference for intellectual persuasion over confrontation. She also participated in the Women Writers' League, contributing literary efforts to the cause. Sinclair contributed statements to the Votes for Women newspaper and authored pamphlets such as Feminism (1912), arguing for suffrage and economic equality on grounds of individual capability rather than collective agitation. In essays like The Intelligence of Woman (1910? context from search), she challenged biological determinist arguments that denied women rational intellect, crediting them instead with mere instinct or intuition, thereby undermining physicalist objections to their political agency. Her advocacy emphasized personal liberty and self-reliance, portraying suffrage as essential for women's autonomous development. In her fiction, Sinclair depicted female independence through characters pursuing intellectual and emotional , rejecting marital or societal constraints without endorsing radical extremism. Symbolizing her restrained reformist stance, she dressed as —a figure of subtle —for a suffrage fundraising event, evoking literary precedent over militant spectacle. This approach drew criticism for conservatism, as her focus on subjective was seen by some as ambivalent toward organized militancy, prioritizing psychological depth over mass action. Nonetheless, her writings advanced a grounded in empirical defense of women's mental faculties against materialist dismissals.

World War I support and war work

In August 1914, shortly after the outbreak of , May Sinclair signed the "Authors' Declaration" in , publicly affirming British writers' support for the Allied war effort against German aggression. On 25 September 1914, at the age of 51, she joined the Munro Ambulance Corps—a volunteer unit led by Dr. Hector Munro—and traveled to to provide aid to wounded soldiers amid the German invasion. There, she contributed as a secretary, reporter, and ambulance driver, witnessing frontline conditions in and before the corps' operations were disrupted by military restrictions in early October. Sinclair's direct experiences informed her 1915 publication A Journal of Impressions in Belgium, a semi-fictionalized that documented Belgian , displacements, and the brutality of the occupying forces, thereby serving as to rally British and refute arguments for neutrality. The book emphasized the empirical reality of unprovoked invasion—drawing on firsthand accounts of destroyed towns like Louvain and executed —to justify Allied intervention as a defensive necessity, contrasting sharply with anti-war positions held by some suffragists who prioritized international over national . Throughout the war, Sinclair integrated her advocacy with patriotic imperatives, contending in essays and fiction that women's wartime service in munitions factories, , and voluntary demonstrated their stake in , rendering female enfranchisement essential for post-war social order and reconstruction. Her novels Tasker Jevons: The Real Story (1916) and The Tree of Heaven (1917) further propagated this view, depicting family sacrifices and redemptive national struggle to boost , while critiquing conscientious objectors and pacifists as detached from the causal threats posed by . These works, grounded in her observations, prioritized empirical defense of liberal institutions against authoritarian expansion over abstract feminist , though contemporaries like pacifist reformers accused her of subordinating women's international solidarity to imperial loyalty.

Broader social criticisms

Sinclair critiqued the repressive moral codes of Victorian society, which she viewed as fostering hypocrisy by enforcing outward conformity at the expense of genuine individual ethics and spiritual depth. In her non-fiction essays and social observations, she highlighted how such codes stifled personal authenticity, prioritizing social propriety over intrinsic moral responsibility, as evidenced in her depictions of middle-class family dynamics where inherited moral failings were perpetuated through unexamined conventions rather than confronted through self-examination. This perspective aligned with her broader rejection of materialistic priorities that equated social status with ethical virtue, arguing instead for a cultivation of inner spiritual individualism to counter superficial collectivist norms. Influenced by idealistic principles, Sinclair addressed and eugenic concerns not as deterministic forces dictating social outcomes, but as challenges surmountable by personal will and moral effort, thereby critiquing overly mechanistic views of that underpinned some socialist doctrines. In Mary Olivier: A Life (1919), the protagonist transcends familial legacies of , madness, and weakness through deliberate self-discipline, underscoring individual agency over inherited or class-based inevitability—a stance that promoted but invited accusations of for sidelining collective structural interventions favored by progressive reformers. Her rejection of pseudo-scientific in social heredity extended to opposing claims that rigidly linked class or to moral incapacity, favoring empirical of character formation through lived choices. This approach, while grounded in observable patterns of self-overcoming, alienated leftist critics who saw it as insufficiently attuned to systemic inequalities.

Legacy and Critical Reception

Introduction of "stream of consciousness"

May Sinclair first applied the term "" to literary technique in her April 1918 review of the initial volumes of Dorothy Richardson's Pilgrimage (Pointed Roofs, Backwater, and ), published in The Egoist. Adapting the phrase from psychologist William James's 1890 description of thought processes in —where James characterized consciousness as a continuous, flowing "stream" rather than discrete ideas—Sinclair used it to denote Richardson's method of immersing the narrative in the protagonist Miriam Henderson's unbroken inner experience. Sinclair wrote: "In identifying herself with this life, which is Miriam's , Miss Richardson has invented the form for rendering it," highlighting a fluid, non-dramatic depiction of mental activity that eschewed conventional plot-driven exposition for direct psychological immersion. Sinclair positioned this approach as a pursuit of authentic realism, arguing that traditional novelistic forms imposed artificial barriers on the raw flow of individual perception and cognition. By focusing on the "content" of —the ceaseless, associative progression of thoughts, sensations, and impressions—she advocated for a narrative mode that captured life's immediacy over contrived dramatic arcs, enabling readers to access the "independently assertive reality" of subjective experience. This adaptation predated similar applications in works by and , though Sinclair emphasized its roots in empirical observation of mental processes rather than stylistic experimentation alone, framing it as a tool for truthful representation unbound by external plotting. While Sinclair's review popularized the term for modernist fiction, she qualified its use by insisting on formal discipline to convey causal connections within the mental flux, critiquing undifferentiated streams that dissolved coherence. In the Egoist piece, she noted that Richardson's lay in balancing immersion with discernible progression, avoiding the pitfalls of formless that could obscure underlying realities. This discernment underscored Sinclair's view of the technique not as an end in itself but as a means to penetrate deeper truths of interiority, influencing subsequent critical discourse on psychological in .

Contemporary influence and decline in fame

Sinclair achieved peak popularity in the early twentieth century, with novels such as The Divine Fire (1904) earning widespread acclaim and bestseller status, particularly in the United States where it outperformed expectations compared to Britain. Her 1917 novel The Tree of Heaven ranked among top-selling books in the U.S., reflecting strong transatlantic appeal during the . Friendships with key modernists like and positioned her as a patron and influencer in circles, where she facilitated connections such as introducing Pound to Ford. Her fame waned sharply after the early 1920s due to the onset of , which manifested around 1920 and progressively impaired her physically and mentally, halting her writing by the late 1920s and forcing seclusion by 1930. This personal decline coincided with the end of , diminishing the relevance of her wartime writings, and broader intellectual shifts favoring and over the she defended in works like A Defence of Idealism (). These trends rendered her philosophical commitments increasingly marginal, as analytic approaches supplanted idealist ones in British thought. Critics characterized Sinclair as a transitional author bridging Victorian realism and , rather than a core innovator, with her accessible seen as less radical than the fragmented styles of Joyce or Woolf. Some attributed her obscurity to stylistic conservatism that prioritized readability over experimental disruption, while others noted gender biases in canon formation that overlooked ' contributions. Proponents countered that her deliberate restraint represented an innovative balance, rejecting 's excesses in favor of coherent psychological depth. By her death in , these factors had consigned her to relative obscurity amid evolving literary priorities.

Modern scholarly reassessment and debates

In the early , the establishment of the in 2013 has facilitated a scholarly revival, hosting events and bibliographies that highlight her contributions to and , countering her prior marginalization in literary canons. This resurgence is evidenced in post-2000 publications, including edited volumes like May Sinclair: Moving Towards the Modern (2006), which reposition her as a transitional figure bridging Victorian realism and experimental through psychological innovation. Such works cite her frequent appearances in studies for pioneering interiority, yet note her limited inclusion in core curricula, attributable in part to academic preferences for materialist narratives over her idealistic frameworks. Debates persist regarding Sinclair's , with recent analyses, such as a 2023 reassessment of her suffrage-era writings, arguing that her emphasis on subjective —prioritizing personal over —challenges characterizations of ambivalence or , instead framing it as a robust defense of women's inner against patriarchal constraints. This individualist strain contrasts with dominant collectivist interpretations in contemporary feminist scholarship, which often favor systemic advocacy, prompting critiques that Sinclair's approach undervalues structural inequities in favor of spiritual . Her philosophical , elaborated in defenses like A Defence of Idealism (1917), receives renewed attention for integrating Bergsonian with monistic , positing as causally primary against reductive ; proponents view this as prescient amid critiques of realism's dominance in empirical sciences. Critics, however, contend that Sinclair's renders her overly speculative and detached from verifiable social causation, diminishing its empirical rigor compared to contemporaries like Woolf or Joyce. Her enthusiastic support for , including frontline , fuels ongoing contention, as it aligns her with interventionist rather than the valorized in progressive historiography, complicating her rehabilitation within anti-militarist academic paradigms. These debates underscore unresolved tensions: while Sinclair's psychological depth anticipates psychoanalytic realism, her spiritual causalism and hawkish stances invite from materialist scholars, potentially perpetuating obscurity through institutional biases favoring secular, collectivist authors over idealist individualists.

References

  1. https://maysinclairsociety.com/biography/
  2. https://findingaids.library.upenn.edu/records/legacy/upenn_rbml_MsColl184
  3. https://spartacus-educational.com/Wsinclair.htm
  4. https://campuspress.yale.edu/modernismlab/may-sinclair/
  5. https://www.poetryfoundation.org/poets/may-sinclair
  6. https://fantastic-writers-and-the-great-war.com/the-writers/may-sinclair/
  7. https://www.amazon.com/Divine-Fire-Sinclair-Original-Classics/dp/1544295480
  8. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/59165/59165-h/59165-h.htm
  9. https://www.lwcurrey.com/pages/books/95729/may-sinclair/uncanny-stories
  10. https://www.hippocampuspress.com/other-authors/fiction/if-the-dead-knew-the-weird-fiction-of-may-sinclair
  11. https://www.murrayewing.co.uk/mewsings/2019/05/11/uncanny-stories-by-may-sinclair/
  12. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/373884/summary
  13. https://dokumen.pub/may-sinclair-re-thinking-bodies-and-minds-9781474415767.html
  14. https://academic.oup.com/book/31997/chapter/267766572
  15. https://livrepository.liverpool.ac.uk/3175179/1/385391.pdf
  16. https://maysinclairsociety.com/author/maysinclairsociety/
  17. https://bura.brunel.ac.uk/bitstream/2438/13582/1/FulltextThesis.pdf
  18. https://etheses.whiterose.ac.uk/id/eprint/9896/1/432236.pdf
  19. https://books.openedition.org/pulm/26801
  20. https://www.theguardian.com/books/booksblog/2013/aug/01/may-sinclair-readable-modernist
  21. https://maysinclairsociety.com/works/
  22. https://www.britannica.com/biography/May-Sinclair
  23. https://www.isfdb.org/cgi-bin/ea.cgi?14934
  24. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/09608788.2022.2030670
  25. https://research-portal.st-andrews.ac.uk/files/281198056/Moravec_2022_BJHP_Taking_time_seriously_CC.pdf
  26. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-the-american-philosophical-association/article/idealism-and-pantheism-of-may-sinclair/49506F32D093ECB338E296282326DCF6
  27. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/24692921.2023.2269827
  28. https://durham-repository.worktribe.com/OutputFile/1317023
  29. https://praymont.blogspot.com/2013/05/may-sinclair-novelist-and-philosopher.html
  30. https://maysinclairsociety.com/may-sinclair-and-psychology/
  31. https://www.euppublishing.com/doi/abs/10.3366/pah.2004.6.2.177
  32. https://books.openedition.org/pulm/26796
  33. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/may-sinclair/portrait-of-the-female-character-as-a-psychoanalytical-case-the-ambiguous-influence-of-freud-on-may-sinclairs-novels/CA39EBC1E8738332B640D9696FACE6A8
  34. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/4bc6/a2012463f10de66bd72d7e51447e86635b79.pdf
  35. https://archive.org/details/feminismmaysinclair1912
  36. http://www.annebronte.org/2020/03/08/iwd-may-sinclair-and-the-three-brontes/
  37. https://core.ac.uk/download/235414851.pdf
  38. https://pure.port.ac.uk/ws/files/6595746/https_mail_attachment.googleusercontent.com_attachment_ui_3D2_26ik_3D0f6a2d9a07_26view_3Datt_26th_3D142515c8686b7b28_26attid_3D0.pdf
  39. https://warpoets.org.uk/worldwar1/poets-and-poetry/may-sinclair/
  40. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/31332/31332-h/31332-h.htm
  41. https://maysinclairsociety.com/may-sinclairs-impressions-of-war/
  42. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110422467-029/html
  43. https://www.rem.routledge.com/articles/sinclair-may-1863-1946
  44. https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/74/article/582574/pdf
  45. https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/soc/philosophy/people/battersby/c._battersby-may-sainclair.pdf
  46. https://pureportal.bcu.ac.uk/en/publications/its-in-tblood-heredity-in-may-sinclairs-the-three-sisters
  47. https://maysinclairsociety.com/may-sinclair-and-stream-of-consciousness/
  48. https://daily.jstor.org/dorothy-richardson-and-the-stream-of-consciousness/
  49. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1207571
  50. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/374011/pdf
  51. https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/lic3.12573
  52. https://www.nytimes.com/1946/11/15/archives/miss-may-sinclair-a-british-novelist-author-of-divine-fire-dies.html
  53. https://www.arosebooks.com/best-selling-books-1910-1919/
  54. https://alexanderdouglas.medium.com/is-reality-spiritual-the-forgotten-may-sinclair-c7e84ad240bc
  55. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1057/9780230598805_4
  56. https://api.pageplace.de/preview/DT0400.9781351919074_A30913657/preview-9781351919074_A30913657.pdf
  57. https://maysinclairsociety.com/
  58. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/257377/summary
  59. https://epe.lac-bac.gc.ca/100/201/300/rhetor-journal/2013/www.cssr-scer.ca/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Rhetor3_Gough1.pdf
  60. https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=7539&context=gc_etds
  61. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/0950236X.2018.1457073
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.