Hubbry Logo
NepantlaNepantlaMain
Open search
Nepantla
Community hub
Nepantla
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Nepantla
Nepantla
Nepantla
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Nepantla is a concept used in Chicano and Latino anthropology, social commentary, criticism, literature and art. It represents a concept of "in-between-ness."[1] Nepantla is a Nahuatl word which means "in the middle of it" or "middle."[2] It may refer specifically to the space between two figurative or literal bodies of water.[3] In contemporary usage, Nepantla often refers to being between two cultures, particularly one's original culture and the dominant one. It usually refers to a position of perspective, power, or potential, but it is sometimes used to designate a state of pain or loss.[4]

History

[edit]

Nepantla was a term that was first used by Nahuas in Central Mexico, especially the Triple Alliance of Anahuac or "Aztec Empire". Book 6 of the Florentine Codex preserves the knowledge of the ilamatlācah "wise old women":

Tlachichiquilco in tihuih in tinemih tlālticpac: nipa centlami, nipa centlami. In tlā nipa xiyāuh in tlā noceh nipa xiyāuh ōmpa tonhuetziz: zan tlanepantlah in huīlōhua in nemōhua.
We travel along a mountain ridge while we live on earth, an abyss yawning on either side. If you stray too far one way or the other, you will fall away. Only by keeping to the middle way does one walk on and live."[5]

Nahuas further refined the term in Mexico during the 16th century.[6] During this time, they were being colonized by the Spaniards and the concept of being "in between" was useful to describe how the experience felt.[6] Some attribute the concept directly to the colonized Aztecs, and others have attributed anthropologist Miguel León-Portilla (1926–2019) as first describing the concept.[7] Leon-Portilla further describes how indigenous people who the Spanish conquered created their own "in between" culture.[8] They would leave behind aspects of their culture that they could not synthesize into the new culture.

Uses

[edit]

Political

[edit]

Nepantla can be described as a "liminal" space, where multiple forms of reality are viewed at the same time.[9] This concept can be useful when addressing multicultural groups of people, where finding consensus can be difficult.[9] Allowing individuals to examine concepts that seem to compete and understanding both is also a process of using nepantla.[9]

Nepantla can also describe individuals or groups who are today in conflict with a larger, perhaps more globally reaching culture or ideology.[6] Nepantla has also been identified as a tool for political change.[7] Individuals who live within two different "worlds" or "cultures" can act as a "fulcrum" to engage in political change.[7]

Academic

[edit]

Nevada State University has a four-year nepantla program created to empower first-generation college students through mentorship, access to resources, community building and professional success through self discovery.[10]

Dominican University commissions a Nepantla Undergraduate Research Journal. This journal seeks to promote the artistic expressions of faith, culture, and justice of undergraduate students. "The nepantla identity of our students also informs the ways in which they theologize; this journal will explore the many ways students engage with the divine through art and social justice".[11]

Written

[edit]

Gloria E. Anzaldúa writes about Nepantla in the context of the writing process. In her book Borderlands/La Frontera, she says, “it is one of the stages of writing, the stage where you have all these ideas, all these images, sentences and paragraphs, and where you are trying to make them into one piece, a story, plot or whatever—it is all very chaotic.” [3] Nepantla in the general definition is a space, and in this context, it is the space of construction in the writing process.

Author Victor Piñeiro speaks on his experience with Nepantla in his own life and how he portrays the concept while writing coming-of-age books including Latinx characters. While speaking about his book Time Villains, Piñeiro notes "readers who have had what Anzaldúa has described as ‘seeing’ double, first from the perspective of one culture, then from the perspective of another, will notice the small moments of Nepantla throughout the book. It's an experience I'm exploring in more depth in future books because it's so emblematic of the Latinx experience. And it's one that I'm paying more attention as I read Latinx fiction, as it's everywhere."[12]

In 2013, Christopher Soto founded Nepantla as an online journal with Lambda Literary. The mission of the journal was to nurture, celebrate, and preserve diversity within the queer poetry community. The journal existed online for three years and in that time frame it gained the attention of thousands of readers internationally. With the guidance and support of William Johnson at Lambda Literary, Soto helped Nepantla quickly become a refuge for some of the most prominent queer of color poets in the United States. In 2018, Nepantla: Queer Poets of Color was released. The title of this book uses nepantla to imply a transient feeling, the feeling of shifting between various communities and identities.[13]

Artistic

[edit]

In the arts, nepantla is a creator's imaginary world that encompasses historical, emotional and spiritual aspects of life. Nepantla as a term might also refer to living in the borderlands or being at literal or metaphorical crossroads.[14]

Emotional

[edit]

Nepantla as a concept has also been identified as a painful experience, where a person's sense of self has been "shattered."[15] It can also signify a personal state of "invisibility and transition."[16] Anzaldúa described nepantla as time where individuals experience a loss of control and suffer anxiety and confusion as a result.[17] Nepantleras are people who help people with transitions and identity issues, they use healing practices, writings, art, and more. Nepantleras can be associated with curanderas.[18]

Quotes

[edit]

"The world is in a constant state of Nepantla."—Maria E. Fránquiz[19]

“Now I call [the concept of borders and borderlands] Nepantla, which is a Nahuatl word for the space between two bodies of water, the space between two worlds.  It is a limited space, a space where you are not this or that but where you are changing” [20]- Gloria E. Anzaldúa[3]

"I use the word nepantla to theorize liminality and to talk about those who facilitate passages between worlds, whom I’ve named nepantleras." -Gloria E. Anzaldúa[21]

"Living between cultures results in 'seeing' double, first from the perspective of one culture, then from the perspective of another. Seeing from two or more perspectives simultaneously renders those cultures transparent. Removed from that culture's center you glimpse the sea in which you've been immersed but to which you were oblivious, no longer seeing the world the way you were enculturated to see it."—Gloria E. Anzaldúa[17]

"You're experiencing nepantla. We feel that in South Texas. We have these two cultures coalescing, and this third one emerges. We eat hot dogs and tacos. We drink hot chocolate and Lone Star Beer." -- Santa Barraza[22]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Nepantla

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Nepantla is a term denoting an intermediate or liminal state, literally meaning "in the middle," "between," or "in the midst of," and serving as a core concept in Aztec metaphysics to describe the dynamic equilibrium and transformative processes underlying reality. In Nahua , nepantla embodies the and flux of —the sacred, self-generating energy that weaves the —where creative and destructive forces intersect in ontologically ambiguous patterns, such as the rhythmic "bobbing" or "" motions observed in natural phenomena like flow or celestial cycles. This principle underscores a of constant becoming, rejecting static being in favor of relational, processual interdependence, as evidenced in Aztec codices and oral traditions interpreting the as a living, animated fabric sustained through ritual balance. While later appropriations in 20th-century Chicana theory adapted nepantla to denote cultural or identity "borderlands," these build upon rather than originate the term's emphasis on transitional tensions, often extending it into subjective psychological or sociopolitical realms amid post-colonial reinterpretations.

Etymology and Pre-Columbian Origins

Linguistic Roots in

is a term from , the liturgical and literary variant of the Uto-Aztecan language spoken by Nahua peoples in central from at least the 14th century through the Spanish conquest in 1521. The word first appears in written records within early colonial-era linguistic documentation, including the Arte para aprender la lengua mexicana by Franciscan friar Andrés de Olmos, compiled around 1547, and the Vocabulario en lengua castellana y mexicana y mexicana y castellana by Alonso de Molina, published in 1571. These sources, drawn from native informants and aimed at missionary and administrative use, consistently translate nepantla as "en medio" (in the middle), "entre" (between), or "en el medio de" (in the midst of), reflecting its role as an adverbial or locative expression denoting spatial or relational intermediacy. In morphology, nepantla exemplifies the language's agglutinative nature, where bound morphemes combine to convey position and state, though it lacks a widely attested simple root decomposition in classical grammars beyond its holistic form indicating a liminal or medial position. Modern lexicographers, such as Frances Karttunen in her analytical dictionary (1983), affirm this translation, linking it to usages in colonial texts where it describes literal intervals—such as the space between rows of plants or bodies of —and extends to transitional phases in time or condition. Pre-conquest oral traditions, reconstructed through these records and archaeological correlations, suggest nepantla informed Nahua descriptions of cosmological boundaries, like the threshold between day and night or human and divine realms, though direct epigraphic evidence is absent due to the non-alphabetic pre-Hispanic . The term's endurance in contemporary Nahuatl dialects, spoken by approximately 1.7 million people as of 2020 data from Mexico's INEGI, underscores its foundational status, with variants like nepantlah preserving the core semantics of midst or interval amid phonetic shifts. Scholarly analyses emphasize that colonial entries, while filtered through European frameworks, preserve authentic Nahua conceptualizations, as cross-verified by internal consistencies across multiple 16th-century sources.

Cosmological Role in Aztec Philosophy

In Aztec philosophy, nepantla designates the primordial motion-change process that interlaces complementary opposites—known as inamic polarities, such as or hot and cold—in a balanced, reciprocal manner to generate and sustain the . This , analyzed extensively by philosopher James Maffie, functions as the most fundamental metaphysical pattern, antedating other forms of motion like ollin (earthquake-like undulation) and malinalli (twisting), and embodying a "middling" or betwixt-and-between dynamic that unifies disparate forces through agonistic tension. Cosmologically, nepantla underpins the ongoing creation of as a grand process, modeled on the backstrap where threads are creatively interlaced to produce fabric; here, the impersonal divine energy serves as the cosmic artisan, perpetually weaving the universe's fabric in the current Fifth Sun era. This process integrates destructive and creative aspects, ensuring equilibrium amid flux and preventing collapse into extremes, as nepantla motion-change "weaves together malinalli and ollin to form the fabric of the Fifth Age." The role of nepantla highlights Aztec metaphysics' emphasis on over static being, contrasting with dualistic Western ontologies by prioritizing horizontal, non-hierarchical interactions that foster transformation in the "in-between" space. Symbolized by motifs like or X-shaped , it reflects a where cosmic stability arises not from resolution of but from their sustained, mutuality-driven , as evidenced in ethnohistorical linguistic and archaeological sources interpreted by Maffie.

Introduction to Modern Conceptualization

Gloria Anzaldúa's Adaptation

, a Chicana feminist theorist born in 1942, repurposed the term nepantla—traditionally denoting an intermediary cosmological space—in her 1987 book Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza to articulate the lived experience of border-dwelling subjects, particularly mestizas confronting intersecting oppressions of race, gender, sexuality, and culture. She framed nepantla as a psychological and existential "threshold" or liminal zone where rigid binaries (such as Anglo/Mexican, heterosexual/, or male/female) collide, generating tension but also generative potential for identity reconstruction. This adaptation shifts the concept from its pre-Columbian roots in Aztec duality and balance toward a modern tool for analyzing hybrid consciousness amid U.S.-Mexico border dynamics and internalized colonial legacies. In Anzaldúa's formulation, inhabiting nepantla demands enduring discomfort and ambiguity, as the individual mediates "opposing perspectives" without resolution into fixed categories, fostering a "mestiza " capable of synthesizing contradictions into innovative worldviews. She emphasized its role in creative processes, likening it to a space of "constant displacement" that propels transformation, especially for women of color who reject assimilation into dominant norms. This draws on her autohistoria-teoría method, blending personal narrative, myth, and theory to validate embodied knowledges over hegemonic discourses. Anzaldúa further evolved nepantla in later writings and interviews, integrating it with the "Coatlicue state"—a mythic descent into chaos preceding rebirth—and the pursuit of conocimiento, a spiritual-epistemic awakening through turmoil. In her posthumously published Light in the Dark/Luz en lo Oscuro (2015), nepantla emerges as an infinite conceptual expanse enabling ethical relationality across differences, though she cautioned its instability risks psychological fragmentation without communal support. This adaptation underscores nepantla's utility as a decolonial , privileging fluidity over , yet grounded in the material realities of marginalization rather than abstract .

Extensions by Other Theorists

AnaLouise Keating, a professor of who collaborated closely with Anzaldúa and edited her posthumous works such as Light in the Dark / Luz en lo Oscuro (2015), has significantly extended the nepantla concept by framing it as a dynamic site for and relational . Keating elaborates nepantla as a liminal zone not merely of personal tension but of active agency, introducing "nepantleras" as bridge-builders who cultivate "perspectives from the cracks" to challenge dominant narratives and foster collective awakening. This extension integrates nepantla with ancillary ideas like nos/otras—a rethinking of self/other binaries as interdependent entities—and spiritual activism, positioning nepantleras as ethical agents who navigate cultural and ideological borders to enact systemic change. Keating's interpretations, drawn from Anzaldúa's unpublished and late writings, emphasize nepantla's potential for generating conocimiento, a form of situated knowledge that prioritizes holistic, non-hierarchical understanding over fragmented identities. In educational theory, nepantla has been adapted through comparative frameworks, such as Stephanie Abraham's 2014 proposal for a "nepantla " that synthesizes Anzaldúa's liminal transformations with Mikhail Bakhtin's concept of ideological becoming. Abraham argues that this hybrid approach disrupts authoritative discourses in classrooms by encouraging students to engage conflicting ideologies—akin to nepantla's "collision of worlds"—fostering hybrid literacies and decolonial perspectives, as illustrated in her analysis of multilingual student narratives challenging Eurocentric histories. Such extensions apply nepantla to institutional settings, viewing educators as nepantleras who facilitate "double vision" to reconstruct knowledge from marginalized standpoints. Beyond , nepantla influences queer and decolonial discourses, where theorists like those in Anzaldúan studies extend it to non-binary identities as sites of psychic reconfiguration. For instance, applications in theory interpret nepantla as a "place" for embodying fluidity outside binary norms, building on Anzaldúa's emphasis on cuerpoespíritu (body-spirit ) to rigid categorizations. However, these developments remain rooted in Anzaldúa's framework, with limited divergence into broader postcolonial paradigms, where parallel uses of "border thinking" (e.g., by ) draw from origins but prioritize epistemic delinking over personal-spiritual .

Applications Across Domains

In Borderlands and Identity Politics

Gloria Anzaldúa adapts the concept of nepantla—meaning "tierra que está en medio" or land in the middle—in her 1987 work Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza to describe the liminal space of cultural, linguistic, and psychological hybridity along the U.S.-Mexico border. This borderlands territory represents not merely a geographic divide but a site of perpetual transition where Chicanas confront conflicting worlds, forging identities amid indigenous, Mexican, and Anglo-American influences. Anzaldúa portrays this state as "a constant state of transition," essential to mestiza existence, where individuals embody multiplicity: "I am a wind-swayed bridge, a crossroads inhabited by whirlwinds." In identity politics, nepantla informs the development of mestiza consciousness, a framework for navigating hybrid subjectivities that rejects essentialist binaries in race, gender, and sexuality. Anzaldúa's theory critiques exclusionary practices within Chicano nationalism and mainstream feminism, which often marginalize queer and mixed-race voices, proposing instead a tolerant pluralism that accommodates contradictions and promotes cross-cultural coalitions. By emphasizing relational and dynamic identity formation, nepantla enables resistance to assimilationist pressures, transforming personal alienation into a basis for broader social critique and alliance-building among the marginalized, as seen in her "theories of the flesh" derived from embodied struggles against racism, sexism, and homophobia. The concept extends to contemporary applications in , where nepantla frames the experiences of borderland inhabitants as opportunities for liberation through conocimiento, a of critical that weaves dual cultural realities into unified, transformative identities. This liminal positioning fosters a "new politics of difference," challenging monolithic identity claims and advocating for multiracial feminist strategies that address migration's crises, such as deportability and cultural non-belonging. In this view, nepantla underscores hybridity's potential for coalition-making, where shared in-betweenness bridges divides between oppressed groups and even oppressors, promoting educational and political reforms attuned to realities.

In Academic and Philosophical Discourse

In philosophical discourse, nepantla is invoked to interrogate ontological states of flux and , positing existence not as fixed essences but as perpetual transitions between opposing forces, akin to Aztec cosmological processes of rupture and reconstitution. This conceptualization challenges binary ontologies prevalent in Western metaphysics, emphasizing a relational being-in-the-world where identity emerges from tension rather than resolution. Drawing from roots, philosophers interpret nepantla as embodying a that integrates spiritual and material dimensions, facilitating rebirth through conflict. Epistemologically, nepantla frames knowledge production as arising from border epistemologies, where marginalized perspectives—such as those of mestiza consciousness—disrupt hegemonic discourses by synthesizing disparate worldviews. In decolonial philosophy, it critiques coloniality's imposition of dualistic reason, advocating instead for hybrid epistemologies that validate indigenous and subaltern ways of knowing as sites of transformative insight. Scholars like those engaging Anzaldúa's framework argue this liminal space enables critical reflection on inherited tenets, fostering pluralistic inquiry unbound by cultural purity. However, its application remains concentrated in continental and feminist philosophy, with limited uptake in analytic traditions due to its experiential and non-formalized methodology. Extensions in speculative link nepantla to aesthetic and ethical transformations, viewing it as a methodological tool for navigating identity crises in multicultural contexts. For instance, it underpins philosophical inquiries into non-normative ontologies, where nepantla's "in-between" disrupts heteronormative and essentialist categories, promoting fluid ethical relationality. This underscores nepantla's role in fostering resilience amid ontological instability, though critics within question its vagueness in delineating verifiable criteria for liminal knowledge claims.

In Literature and Artistic Expression

In Gloria Anzaldúa's seminal work Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza (1987), nepantla denotes a liminal threshold in the writing process and personal transformation, where individuals confront internal conflicts and cultural hybridity amid identities. Anzaldúa positions this in-between space as essential for mestiza consciousness, enabling the synthesis of fragmented experiences in Chicana literature. The concept permeates subsequent literary output, notably in Nepantla: An Anthology Dedicated to Queer Poets of Color (Nightboat Books, 2018), edited by Christopher Soto, which compiles from over 100 contributors spanning U.S. history to explore intersecting marginalizations and fluid identities. This anthology, originating from the online journal Nepantla founded in 2014 by Soto and Lambda Literary, amplifies voices navigating racial, sexual, and national nepantlas, with works like those by Chen Chen and Kiki Petrosino emphasizing rupture and resilience. Authors such as Pat Mora invoke nepantla in Nepantla: Essays from the Land in the Middle (Arte Público Press, 2015), reflecting on Latina experiences in border regions through essays blending and . Similarly, Sergio Troncoso's Nepantla Familias (Texas A&M University Press, 2023) deploys the term to examine familial tensions in Mexican-American narratives of assimilation and cultural retention. In artistic expression, nepantla shapes border art, as Anzaldúa articulates in her 1990 essay "Border Arte: Nepantla, el Lugar de la Frontera," advocating for hybrid forms that disrupt binary representations through multimedia installations and . Galleries like the Nepantla Cultural Arts Gallery in , established to center Chicana/o Latinx traditions, host exhibitions embodying this , such as by Chicano artists in 2022 that depict in-between cultural spaces. Recent museum shows, including "Nepantla" at the Museum of Art Fort Collins (opened October 2024) with 36 and Latino artists from and addressing identity and struggle, and "Nepantla: The Land is The Beloved" at Tacoma Art Museum (May–September 2024) featuring fragmented borderland motifs, underscore its role in visual critiques of displacement and .

In Psychological and Emotional Frameworks

In Gloria Anzaldúa's framework, nepantla denotes a psychological liminal space where individuals experience the of straddling conflicting cultural, racial, and personal identities, enabling the simultaneous holding of multiple contradictory perspectives as a pathway to transformative awareness. This mental state, drawn from cosmology but adapted to modern mestiza , involves heightened vulnerability to inner conflicts, where rigid binaries dissolve, fostering a that Anzaldúa describes as essential for personal evolution beyond fixed self-conceptions. Psychologically, it aligns with theories in , manifesting as an adaptive response to identity fragmentation rather than mere , though it demands resilience to avoid stagnation in . Emotionally, nepantla evokes intense distress, characterized by chaos, disorientation, and acute pain from "shattered worldviews and self-identities," as Anzaldúa articulates in her writings on borderlands existence. This state amplifies feelings of loss, uncertainty, and exposure, akin to a between worlds that triggers visceral responses such as over cultural ruptures or anxiety from uncontrollable shifts, yet it also opens access to intuitive knowledge derived from "inner feelings" and imaginal processes. Anzaldúa posits that enduring this emotional turbulence—often likened to the Coatlicue state of immobility and despair—culminates in "conocimiento," a spiritually informed that integrates fragmented emotions into a cohesive, albeit hybrid, of . Empirical extensions in psychological frame such experiences as paradoxical meaning-making under uncertainty, where emotional receptivity in nepantla enhances across divides but risks burnout without resolution strategies. In therapeutic contexts, nepantla-inspired approaches emphasize embracing this in-between emotional terrain for trauma recovery, particularly among marginalized groups navigating intergenerational wounds from and migration, as seen in Anzaldúan analyses of psyche reframing. However, critiques note that perpetual may exacerbate instability without grounded interventions, underscoring nepantla's dual role as both catalyst for growth and potential source of prolonged distress.

Criticisms and Controversies

Debates on Cultural Appropriation

The adaptation of nepantla from cosmology into Chicana theory by has sparked debates over whether such reinterpretations represent authentic cultural reclamation or a form of appropriation that dilutes indigenous meanings. Anzaldúa positioned nepantla as a mestiza space of transformation amid cultural borders, drawing on Aztec notions of to describe Chicana experiences of . Critics, however, have questioned the romanticization of pre-Columbian concepts by mestizo-identified Chicanas, arguing that it imposes modern psychological frameworks onto ancient ontologies without direct communal transmission from contemporary Nahua communities. For instance, some indigenous scholars view Chicano , including symbolic uses of terms like nepantla, as selective appropriation that prioritizes mestizo over pure indigenous revalorization, often lacking empirical ties to living Aztec descendants. Anzaldúa herself addressed these tensions, warning of external threats from and dominant institutions that could commodify border art and nepantla-inspired expressions, turning them into "trendy" pop culture rip-offs sold at inflated prices, such as replicas of indigenous artifacts marked up tenfold from Mexican markets. She also reflected introspectively on internal risks, admitting her own "passive consuming and appropriating" of indigenous elements and cautioning Chicana/o artists against misappropriating language and imagery without deeper accountability. These concerns highlight causal risks of economic incentives driving superficial adoption, where corporate mainstreaming erodes the transformative intent of nepantla as a site of resistance rather than consumption. In contemporary discourse, extensions of nepantla beyond Chicana contexts—such as in or general studies by non-Latinx academics—have prompted accusations of outsider appropriation, imputing sole interpretive ownership to specific ethnic groups. Proponents counter that rigid gatekeeping ignores historical evidence of , rendering appropriation debates redundant given that all traditions borrow and evolve through contact, as seen in Aztec philosophy's own syncretic influences. Empirical data on verifiable harm remains sparse, with no large-scale studies documenting tangible losses to Nahua communities from theoretical appropriations; instead, debates often pivot on intent, where Chicana distinguishes authentic mestiza participation—rooted in lived —from profit-driven dilutions. Anzaldúa's framework thus underscores nepantla as inherently contested, embodying the very in-between tensions it theorizes.

Philosophical and Ontological Critiques

Critics have questioned the ontological foundations of nepantla as adapted by Anzaldúa, arguing that its emphasis on and inadvertently perpetuates colonial racial hierarchies rather than subverting them. The concept draws on mestiza identity, which historically denoted a engineered racial category in Spanish colonial designed to create a buffer class between Europeans and , often tied to eugenic-like policies aimed at diluting indigenous bloodlines. This raises ontological concerns about whether nepantla represents authentic cultural synthesis or a repackaged form of imposed mestizaje that masks ongoing power imbalances in . Philosophical analysis of Anzaldúa's Borderlands framework reveals tensions with , despite its fluid . Scholars contend that nepantla's portrayal of transformative in-betweenness strategically invokes essentialist tropes of mestiza consciousness—fixed traits like tolerance and duality—to forge new identities, concentrating essentializing effects in Chicana contexts rather than fully dissolving categorical boundaries. Elizabeth Fuss's examination underscores this deployment, suggesting that such maneuvers, while politically expedient, undermine the theory's claim to pure anti- by reintroducing ontological fixity under the guise of perpetual transition. Ontological critiques also highlight the risks of endorsing eternal , which diverges from anthropological models like Victor Turner's, where serves as a temporary rite leading to reaggregation and stable structure. Anzaldúa's nepantla, by contrast, posits ongoing suspension as normative being, potentially fostering subjection through unresolved ambiguity and power dynamics within borderlands spaces. This framework has been faulted for overlooking how sustained ontological groundlessness can reinforce marginalization, as liminal subjects remain vulnerable to external definitions without achieving integrative resolution.

Perspectives on Stability vs. Perpetual Liminality

Gloria Anzaldúa conceptualized nepantla as a persistent liminal zone of ambiguity and transition, where individuals confront cultural, psychic, and spiritual contradictions, describing it as "an unstable, unpredictable, precarious, always-in-transition space lacking clear boundaries". This view positions perpetual liminality not as a deficit but as essential for mestiza consciousness, enabling ongoing transformation rather than resolution into fixed states. Anzaldúa emphasized that living in nepantla involves "a constant state of displacement—an uncomfortable, even alarming feeling" that disrupts entrenched identities and fosters new paradigms, rejecting stability as a form of stagnation. In contrast to anthropological notions of , such as Victor Turner's temporary "betwixt and between" phases in rites of passage that culminate in reintegration and stability, Anzaldúa's nepantla resists such closure, aligning instead with a Nahua ontological framework where liminality defines all . Philosopher James Maffie interprets pre-Columbian Nahua thought as viewing nepantla as a "permanent state of liminality" rather than a transient interval, with "becoming and transitions as the norm" supplanting Western preferences for absolute, stable truths and binary oppositions. This perspective critiques stability-oriented models as illusory, arguing that fixed identities limit adaptability and obscure the fluid, processual nature of reality, as echoed in analyses where nepantla exposes the "groundlessness" of selfhood. Critics and comparative theorists, however, highlight tensions in embracing perpetual liminality, noting its potential to romanticize instability without practical pathways to coherence. For instance, while Anzaldúa's framework draws parallels to Mikhail Bakhtin's "ideological becoming"—an endless clash yielding provisional meanings without finality—some applications in warn against conflating nepantla solely with , as this implies an exit to stability that undermines its deconstructive power. In literary and identity contexts, unresolved nepantla states are juxtaposed against narratives equating stability with fulfillment, suggesting that endless fluidity may exacerbate alienation rather than resolve it, particularly for marginalized groups seeking cultural anchorage. Such views underscore a debate: whether nepantla's valorization of flux empowers resistance or perpetuates unease without affirming viable, enduring identities.

Legacy and Contemporary Relevance

Influence on Cultural Studies

The concept of nepantla, introduced by Gloria Anzaldúa as a Nahuatl term denoting an "in-between" liminal space, has exerted considerable influence on cultural studies by framing cultural identity as inherently hybrid and transformative rather than fixed or binary. Anzaldúa elaborated this idea in her 1987 book Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza, where nepantla represents the psychological and epistemological terrain navigated by mestiza subjects amid cultural ruptures, such as those along the U.S.-Mexico border. This framework challenges essentialist views of culture prevalent in earlier anthropological models, instead emphasizing mestizaje as a site of creative tension and resistance to hegemonic norms. Cultural studies scholars have adopted nepantla to dissect how subordinated groups forge new cultural forms through border-crossing, paralleling but grounding in indigenous epistemologies concepts like Homi Bhabha's "third space" while prioritizing lived experiences of racialized and gendered marginalization. In cultural theory, nepantla has informed analyses of and , particularly in postcolonial and contexts, by highlighting the generative potential of cultural ambiguity over assimilation or purity. For example, it underpins examinations of how Latinx communities negotiate multiple linguistic and ethnic affiliations, fostering a "mestiza consciousness" that integrates fragmented identities into coherent yet fluid wholes. This has extended to critiques of , where nepantla serves as a tool for understanding cultural flows as contested rather than unidirectional, influencing works on media, migration, and urban . Unlike more abstract models, Anzaldúa's nepantla insists on embodied, often painful transformation, which has leveraged to foreground agency in subaltern narratives. The term's permeation into Chicana/o/x and Latinx has also reshaped interdisciplinary approaches to visual and performative arts, positioning nepantla as a methodological lens for interpreting expressions of and coalition-building. Scholars invoke it to analyze artworks and performances that embody cultural "nepantleras"—figures who mediate differences—thus expanding beyond textual analysis to include somatic and spiritual dimensions of identity. This influence persists in contemporary debates on , where nepantla critiques Western cultural binaries while advocating for epistemic pluralism rooted in pre-colonial thought systems.

Recent Developments and Exhibitions

The concept of nepantla has seen renewed application in exhibitions, particularly those addressing hybrid identities, border experiences, and cultural transitions. At the Museum of Art Fort Collins, the group exhibition "Nepantla," curated by , ran from October 4, 2024, to January 5, 2025, and examined the "in-between" space through works evoking traditions, politics, and community complexities. Similarly, the Tacoma Art Museum's "Nepantla: The Land is The Beloved," on view from May 18, 2024, to September 6, 2026, incorporated Anzaldúa's framework to feature artists engaging with settler colonial histories and land-based narratives. In 2025, the NEPANTLA PROJECT, curated by Nadia Guitteau of ALRATITOstudio, transformed hacienda ruins in Telchac Pueblo, , into an immersive site-specific exhibition from October 23 to 28, showcasing photography, sculptural furniture, textiles, ceramics, and paintings by creators from , the , and to evoke liminal dialogues between past and present. This event emphasized cross-cultural exchanges in a jungle setting, blending contemporary design with regional materials like henequén fibers. Academic and gallery contexts have also hosted related shows, such as "Nepantla: Maps for Uncharted Futures," a solo exhibition by Uruguayan-American artist Ana Vizcarra Rankin at Brookdale Community College's Center for from October 12 to December 12, 2024, which used mapping motifs to probe postcolonial place-making and personal narratives. In New York, Ethan Cohen Gallery presented Ray Smith's "Nepantla" starting September 19, 2024, with abstract paintings probing universal human conditions beyond fixed identities. These exhibitions demonstrate nepantla's persistence as a lens for visualizing fluidity in an era of global migration and cultural intersection, often prioritizing empirical explorations of lived borderlands over abstract theory.

References

  1. https://nahuatl.wired-humanities.org/content/nepantla
  2. https://www.mexicolore.co.uk/aztecs/home/aztec-philosophy
  3. https://ndpr.nd.edu/reviews/aztec-philosophy-understanding-a-world-in-motion/
  4. https://www.willbuckingham.com/aztec-philosophy/
  5. https://upcolorado.com/university-press-of-colorado/item/download/394_8a9a95dc98ce468fe44e580436764531
  6. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/15348431.2017.1295859
  7. https://online.ucpress.edu/lalvc/article/1/2/3/92095/Thoughts-from-Nepantla
  8. https://oxfordre.com/communication/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228613.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228613-e-606
  9. https://michiganlawreview.org/journal/nepantla-coatlicue-conocimiento/
  10. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/15348431.2017.1295859
  11. https://themillions.com/2019/01/nepantla-and-gloria-anzalduas-queer-of-color-legacy.html
  12. https://rdw.rowan.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1020&education_facpub
  13. https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1362219.pdf
  14. https://journals.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/index.php/helix/article/download/112141/107933
  15. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/254694002_From_Borderlands_and_New_Mestizas_to_Nepantlas_and_Nepantleras_Anzalduan_Theories_for_Social_Change
  16. https://nepantlerablog.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/from-borderlands-and-new-mestizas-to-nepantlas-and-nepantleras-a-2.pdf
  17. https://www.jstor.org/stable/42001223
  18. https://rdw.rowan.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1020&context=education_facpub
  19. https://www.fsrinc.org/non-binary-transgender-nepantla/
  20. https://muse.jhu.edu/issue/1402
  21. http://www.ressjournal.com/Makaleler/1844021878_3.pdf
  22. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5325/jspecphil.31.1.0001
  23. https://philpapers.org/rec/ANTWWT
  24. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/390713470_Living_and_leading_in_nepantla_an_expansive_ontological_and_epistemological_approach_to_educational_leadership
  25. https://davidbowles.medium.com/nepantla-1-definitions-296c18198528
  26. https://nightboat.org/book/nepantla-an-anthology-dedicated-to-queer-poets-of-color/
  27. https://lambdaliterary.org/2015/10/what-are-the-nepantla-poets-reading/
  28. https://www.patmora.com/books/nepantla/
  29. https://www.tamupress.com/book/9781648432682/nepantla-familias/
  30. https://icaa.mfah.org/s/en/item/809763
  31. https://www.nepantlaculturalarts.com/about
  32. https://southseattleemerald.org/arts-culture/2022/03/23/nepantla-cultural-arts-gallery-features-comics-art-show-by-chicano-artists
  33. https://moafc.org/exhibitions/nepantla/
  34. https://www.coloradoan.com/story/sponsor-story/fort-collins-museum/2024/10/31/chicano-and-latino-artists-show-life-between-two-worlds-in-nepantla/75943167007/
  35. https://www.tacomaartmuseum.org/exhibit/nepantla/
  36. https://shareok.org/bitstreams/745cc1eb-a1da-4af7-9da0-c0d898c4c78d/download
  37. https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/spc3.12980
  38. https://brill.com/display/book/9789004506725/BP000083.xml
  39. https://cfshrc.org/article/a-fullness-of-feeling-queer-rhetorical-listening-and-emotional-receptivity/
  40. https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=5671&context=etd
  41. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/education/articles/10.3389/feduc.2024.1454303/full
  42. https://diversityreadinglist.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/Mestizaje-Race-and-Aesthetics-in-Latin-America.pdf
  43. https://ailleurs.hypotheses.org/files/2018/11/6.-ANZALDUA-Border-Arte.pdf
  44. https://forum-nepantla.org/tag/nepantlera/
  45. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/cgi-viewcontent.cgi?article=1669&context=etd
  46. https://politicaltheology.com/gloria-anzaldua/
  47. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1354508
  48. https://www.academia.edu/65202726/The_Power_and_Subjection_of_Liminality_and_Borderlands_of_Non_Binary_Folx
  49. https://ices.library.ubc.ca/index.php/criticaled/article/view/183601/184430
  50. https://www.academia.edu/42910962/Being_In_Between_and_Becoming_Undone_Bardos_Heterotopias_and_Nepantla
  51. https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=6903&context=etd
  52. https://openyls.law.yale.edu/bitstream/handle/20.500.13051/18345/Nepantla-Coatlicue-Conocimiento.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
  53. https://kohljournal.press/frontier-frontera-borderlands
  54. https://brill.com/display/book/9789004506725/BP000087.xml?language=en
  55. https://alratitostudio.com/nepantla/
  56. https://midcitybeat.com/artandculture/%25F0%259F%258C%25BF-nepantla-art-design-and-identity-in-the-yucatan-jungle/
  57. https://www.brookdalecc.edu/nepantla-maps-for-uncharted-futures-opening-in-the-cva/
  58. https://www.ecfa.com/exhibitions/128-ray-smith-nepantla-225-west-17th-street/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.