Hubbry Logo
New sincerityNew sincerityMain
Open search
New sincerity
Community hub
New sincerity
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
New sincerity
New sincerity
New sincerity
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

New sincerity (closely related to and sometimes described as synonymous with post-postmodernism) is a trend in music, aesthetics, literary fiction, film criticism, poetry, literary criticism and philosophy that generally describes creative works that expand upon and break away from concepts of postmodernist irony and cynicism.

Its usage dates back to the mid-1980s; however, it was popularized in the 1990s by American author David Foster Wallace.[1][2][3]

In music

[edit]

"New sincerity" was used as a collective name for a loose group of alternative rock bands, centered in Austin, Texas, in the years from about 1985 to 1990, who were perceived as reacting to the ironic and cynical outlook of then-prominent music movements like punk rock and new wave. The use of "new sincerity" in connection with these bands began with an off-handed comment by Austin punk rock artist and author Jesse Sublett to his friend, local music writer Margaret Moser. According to author Barry Shank, Sublett said: "All those new sincerity bands, they're crap."[4] Sublett (at his own website) states that he was misquoted, and actually told Moser, "It's all new sincerity to me ... It's not my cup of tea."[5] In any event, Moser began using the term in print, and it ended up becoming the catch phrase for these bands.[4][6]

Nationally, the most successful "new sincerity" band was the Reivers (originally called "Zeitgeist"), who released four well-received albums between 1985 and 1991. True Believers, led by Alejandro Escovedo and Jon Dee Graham, also received extensive critical praise and local acclaim in Austin, but the band had difficulty capturing its live sound on recordings, among other problems.[7] Other important "new sincerity" bands include Doctors Mob,[8][9] Wild Seeds,[10] and Glass Eye.[11] Another significant "new sincerity" figure was the eccentric, critically acclaimed songwriter Daniel Johnston.[4][12]

Despite extensive critical attention (including national coverage in Rolling Stone and a 1985 episode of the MTV program The Cutting Edge), none of the "new sincerity" bands met with much commercial success, and the "scene" ended within a few years.[13][14]

Other music writers have used "new sincerity" to describe later performers Arcade Fire,[15] Conor Oberst,[16] Cat Power, Devendra Banhart, Joanna Newsom,[17] Neutral Milk Hotel,[18] Sufjan Stevens,[19] Idlewild,[20] as well as Austin's Okkervil River[21] Leatherbag,[22] and Michael Waller.[23]

In film criticism

[edit]

Critic Jim Collins introduced the concept of "new sincerity" to film criticism in his 1993 essay titled "Genericity in the 90s: Eclectic Irony and the New Sincerity". In this essay he contrasts films that treat genre conventions with "eclectic irony" and those that treat them seriously, with "new sincerity". Collins describes,

the "new sincerity" of films like Field of Dreams (1989), Dances With Wolves (1990), and Hook (1991), all of which depend not on hybridization, but on an "ethnographic" rewriting of the classic genre film that serves as their inspiration, all attempting, using one strategy or another, to recover a lost "purity", which apparently pre-dated even the golden age of film genre.[24]

Cinematic examples

[edit]

In literary fiction and criticism

[edit]

In response to the hegemony of metafictional and self-conscious irony in contemporary fiction, writer David Foster Wallace predicted, in his 1993 essay "E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction",[1] a new literary movement which would espouse something like the new sincerity ethos:

The next real literary "rebels" in this country might well emerge as some weird bunch of "anti-rebels," born oglers who dare to back away from ironic watching, who have the childish gall to actually endorse single-entendre values. Who treat old untrendy human troubles and emotions in U.S. life with reverence and conviction. Who eschew self-consciousness and fatigue. These anti-rebels would be outdated, of course, before they even started. Too sincere. Clearly repressed. Backward, quaint, naive, anachronistic. Maybe that'll be the point, why they'll be the next real rebels. Real rebels, as far as I can see, risk things. Risk disapproval. The old postmodern insurgents risked the gasp and squeal: shock, disgust, outrage, censorship, accusations of socialism, anarchism, nihilism. The new rebels might be the ones willing to risk the yawn, the rolled eyes, the cool smile, the nudged ribs, the parody of gifted ironists, the "How banal." Accusations of sentimentality, melodrama. Credulity. Willingness to be suckered by a world of lurkers and starers who fear gaze and ridicule above imprisonment without law. Who knows.

This was further examined on the blog Fiction Advocate:[42]

The theory is this: Infinite Jest is Wallace's attempt to both manifest and dramatize a revolutionary fiction style that he called for in his essay "E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction". The style is one in which a new sincerity will overturn the ironic detachment that hollowed out contemporary fiction towards the end of the 20th century. Wallace was trying to write an antidote to the cynicism that had pervaded and saddened so much of American culture in his lifetime. He was trying to create an entertainment that would get us talking again.

In his 2010 essay "David Foster Wallace and the New Sincerity in American Fiction", Adam Kelly argues that Wallace's fiction, and that of his generation, is marked by a revival and theoretical reconception of sincerity, challenging the emphasis on authenticity that dominated twentieth-century literature and conceptions of the self.[2] Additionally, numerous authors have been described as contributors to the new sincerity movement, including Jonathan Franzen, Marilynne Robinson,[43] Zadie Smith, Dave Eggers,[44] Stephen Graham Jones,[45] Michael Chabon,[46][47][48] and Victor Pelevin.[49]

In philosophy

[edit]

"New sincerity" has also sometimes been used to refer to a philosophical concept deriving from the basic tenets of performatism.[50] It is also seen as one of the key characteristics of metamodernism.[51] Related literature includes Wendy Steiner's The Trouble with Beauty and Elaine Scarry's On Beauty and Being Just. Related movements may include post-postmodernism, New Puritans, Stuckism, the kitsch movement and remodernism, as well as the Dogme 95 film movement led by Lars von Trier.[52]

As a cultural movement

[edit]

"New sincerity" has been espoused since 2002 by radio host Jesse Thorn of PRI's The Sound of Young America (now Bullseye), self-described as "the public radio program about things that are awesome". Thorn characterizes new sincerity as a cultural movement defined by dicta including "maximum fun" and "be more awesome". It celebrates outsized celebration of joy, and rejects irony, and particularly ironic appreciation of cultural products. Thorn has promoted this concept on his program and in interviews.[53][54][55][56]

In a September 2009 interview, Thorn commented that "new sincerity" had begun as "a silly, philosophical movement that me and some friends made up in college" and that "everything that we said was a joke, but at the same time it wasn't all a joke in the sense that we weren't being arch or we weren't being campy. While we were talking about ridiculous, funny things we were sincere about them."[57]

Thorn's concept of "new sincerity" as a social response has gained popularity since his introduction of the term in 2002. Several point to the September 11, 2001, attacks and the subsequent wake of events that created this movement, in which there was a drastic shift in tone. The 1990s were considered a period of artistic works rife with irony, and the attacks shocked a change in the American culture. Graydon Carter, editor of Vanity Fair, published an editorial a few weeks after the attacks claiming that "this was the end of the age of irony".[58] Jonathan D. Fitzgerald for The Atlantic suggests this new movement could also be attributed to broader periodic shifts that occur in culture.[46]

As a result of this movement, several cultural works were considered elements of "new sincerity",[46] but this was also seen to be a mannerism adopted by the general public, to show appreciation for cultural works that they happened to enjoy. Andrew Watercutter of Wired saw this as having been able to enjoy one's guilty pleasures without having to feel guilty about enjoying them, and being able to share that appreciation with others.[59] One such example of a "new sincerity" movement is the brony fandom, generally adult and primarily male fans of the 2010 animated show My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic which is produced by Hasbro to sell its toys to young girls. These fans have been called "internet neo-sincerity at its best", unabashedly enjoying the show and challenging the preconceived gender roles that such a show ordinarily carries.[60][61]

A review of a 2016 play by Alena Smith The New Sincerity observes that it "captures the spirit of an age lightly lived and easily forgotten, which strives for a significance and a magnitude that won't be easily achieved".[62]

In the early 2020s, the shift toward a more overt embrace of new sincerity was codified in James Poniewozik's New York Times piece titled, "How TV Went From David Brent to Ted Lasso."[63] Poniewozik details the shift, arguing that "In TV's ambitious comedies, as well as dramas, the arc of the last 20 years is not from bold risk-taking to spineless inoffensiveness. But it is, in broad terms, a shift from irony to sincerity. By 'irony' here, I don't mean the popular equation of the term with cynicism or snark. I mean an ironic mode of narrative, in which what a show 'thinks' is different from what its protagonist does. Two decades ago, TV's most distinctive stories were defined by a tone of dark or acerbic detachment. Today, they're more likely to be earnest and direct." Poniewozik goes on to address possible impetus for doing away with the disjoint between writer and character ascribing some cause to what Emily Nussbaum calls "bad fans",[64] but the thrust of his critique centers on the possible shift towards the representation of new and previously unrepresented voices. As Poniewozik puts it, "In some cases, it's also a question of who has gotten to make TV since 2001. Antiheroes like David Brent and Tony Soprano, after all, came along after white guys like them had centuries to be heroes. The voices and faces of the medium have diversified, and if you're telling the stories of people and communities that TV never made room for before, skewering might not be your first choice of tone. I don't want to oversimplify this: Series like Atlanta, Ramy, Master of None and Insecure all have complex stances toward their protagonists. But they also have more sympathy toward them than, say, Arrested Development."[65] With this perspective in mind and considering the shift towards an embrace of diverse views and opinions,[66] the appearance of new sincerity in film and television is understandable if not expected. However, it is important to note that prior to the current shift towards new sincerity, popular culture had embraced a period of "high irony", as Poniewozik deems it.[65]

Regional variants

[edit]

Russia

[edit]

In Russia, the term new sincerity (novaya iskrennost) was used as early as the mid-1980s[67] or early 1990s by dissident poet Dmitry Prigov and critic Mikhail Epstein, as a response to the dominant sense of absurdity in late Soviet and post-Soviet culture.[68] In Epstein's words, "Postconceptualism, or the New Sincerity, is an experiment in resuscitating "fallen", dead languages with a renewed pathos of love, sentimentality and enthusiasm.[69]

This conception of "new sincerity" meant the avoidance of cynicism, but not necessarily of irony. In the words of Alexei Yurchak of the University of California, Berkeley,it "is a particular brand of irony, which is sympathetic and warm, and allows its authors to remain committed to the ideals that they discuss, while also being somewhat ironic about this commitment".[70]

Nowadays New Sincerity is being contraposed not to Soviet literature, but to postmodernism. Dmitry Vodennikov has been acclaimed as the leader of the new wave of Russian New Sincerity,[71] as was Victor Pelevin.

In American poetry

[edit]

Since 2005, poets including Reb Livingston, Joseph Massey, Andrew Mister, and Anthony Robinson have collaborated in a blog-driven poetry movement, described by Massey as "a 'new sincerity' brewing in American poetry – a contrast to the cold, irony-laden poetry dominating the journals and magazines and new books of poetry".[72] Other poets named as associated with this movement, or its tenets, have included David Berman, Catherine Wagner, Dean Young, Matt Hart, Miranda July (who is also a filmmaker),[73] Tao Lin,[73] Steve Roggenbuck,[73] D. S. Chapman, Frederick Seidel, Arielle Greenberg,[17] Karyna McGlynn, and Mira Gonzalez.[74]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

New sincerity

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
New sincerity is a cultural and artistic movement that emerged in the United States during the late , primarily as a reaction against the irony, detachment, and emotional cynicism prevalent in , favoring instead direct , , and authentic interpersonal connection across , , and other media. Its core tonal shift infuses creative works with purpose and affect, rejecting the meta-experimental emptiness of prior modes to prioritize genuine sentiment over self-referential cleverness. The movement's roots trace to the , music scene, where bands like and artists such as produced unpolished, heartfelt recordings for intimate audiences, emphasizing raw vulnerability in contrast to postmodern self-mockery and ; this was captured in a 1985 MTV segment highlighting backyard performances and cassette distributions. In literature, it was propelled forward by David Foster Wallace's 1993 essay "E Unibus Pluram," which diagnosed irony as a cultural fostering isolation and advocated for art that risks sincere endorsement of values to foster emotional communion. Wallace's influence positioned new sincerity as a post-postmodern framework, later formalized in scholarship as an ethical stance against neoliberal commodification of authenticity, evident in novels by figures like , , and that grapple with genuine self-presentation amid market-driven skepticism. While its literary manifestations dominate academic discourse, new sincerity extends to contemporary and media, influencing comedians like , whose works echo Wallace's anxieties about digital exposure and audience judgment by blending confessionalism with self-conscious irony to reclaim affect in hyperconnected environments. Critics note its defining tension: the pursuit of unadorned honesty courts the peril of performative pleading for approval, yet it endures as a corrective to detachment, shaping ethical orientations in art that value human connection over detached critique.

Origins and Historical Development

Conceptual Foundations in the 1980s–1990s

The lingering effects of the , which unfolded from 1972 to 1974, contributed to a cultural atmosphere of cynicism in the United States during the and , as public trust in political institutions plummeted and skepticism toward official narratives became entrenched. This erosion, evidenced by declining confidence in government—dropping from 73% in 1958 to 25% by 1994 according to Gallup polls—extended to media portrayals of authority, fostering a demand for alternatives to detached irony in cultural expression. Film critic Jim Collins formalized the concept of new sincerity in his 1993 essay "Genericity in the Nineties: Eclectic Irony and the New Sincerity," published in the collection Film Theory Goes to the Movies, where he described it as a cinematic strategy seeking to reclaim a "lost purity" through nostalgic, emotionally direct narratives amid the hybridization of genres. Collins positioned new sincerity as a deliberate pivot from the eclectic irony of postmodern media, which he argued had exhausted its critical potential by the early , emphasizing instead sincere reconstructions of originary storytelling forms to engage audiences beyond detached playfulness. In parallel, Wallace's 1993 essay "E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction," published in The Review of Contemporary Fiction, dissected the pervasive irony in American television and literature as a solipsistic response to media overload, warning that it insulated creators from authentic human risks and perpetuated viewer alienation. Wallace called for a countervailing "great war" against irony through fiction that embraced "single-entendre principles"—unironic, courageous sincerity—to restore emotional directness and communal connection in a culture saturated by cynical detachment. These 1993 articulations marked early theoretical groundwork for new sincerity as an intellectual reaction to postmodern exhaustion, predating its broader cultural traction.

Emergence as a Cultural Response in the 2000s

The terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001, catalyzed the consolidation of New Sincerity as a cultural trend by exposing the limitations of postmodern irony in addressing real-world trauma and existential threats. Cultural analysts observed that irony's detached posture, dominant in media and arts during the preceding decade, appeared evasive and inadequate for processing collective and , prompting a pivot toward unadorned emotional engagement and communal solidarity. This shift aligned with broader post-9/11 societal responses, including surges in patriotic expressions and public mourning rituals, which favored direct authenticity over subversive detachment. David Foster Wallace's pre-2000s writings, particularly the 1996 novel and its foregrounding of empathetic character studies amid ironic overload, resonated more acutely in this environment, informing early-2000s discourse on replacing cynicism with relational . Wallace's influence permeated indie literary and media circles, where his advocacy for "single-entendre principles" challenged the era's image-saturated detachment, encouraging creators to prioritize vulnerable human connections as a counter to perceived cultural numbness. By mid-decade, this extended into collaborative ethos in alternative scenes, evidenced by zine cultures and DIY publications that amplified earnest testimonials over parodic deconstructions. Parallel developments in early-2000s indie and underground media underscored the trend's empirical traction, as genres emphasizing heartfelt narratives gained prominence amid economic and geopolitical instability. Sales of independent recordings rose steadily from onward, with alternative labels reporting heightened demand for emotionally forthright albums that contrasted with mainstream pop's polished artifice. This uptake reflected listener preferences for as a balm against crises, including the onset, where ironic indie detachment yielded to songwriting that fostered intimacy over alienation. By 2004–2005, festivals and documented this as a discernible wave, tying New Sincerity's momentum to tangible audience engagement rather than abstract critique.

Philosophical and Theoretical Underpinnings

Critique of Postmodern Irony and Cynicism

Postmodern irony, which gained prominence in cultural discourse during the late , functioned initially as a defensive against authoritarian dogmas by exposing their hypocrisies through detached . , in his 1993 essay "E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. Fiction," argued that this irony had outlived its utility post-Cold War, transforming into a reflexive cultural reflex that shielded individuals from the risks of sincere engagement rather than confronting real power structures. By the and , Wallace observed, irony devolved into self-perpetuating , where endless winking at earnestness preempted any substantive critique or commitment, effectively insulating audiences from vulnerability in an era of media proliferation. This shift enabled a pervasive evasion of accountability, as ironic detachment allowed individuals and media to undermine commitments without consequence; for instance, television programming saturated viewers with self-aware humor that mocked preemptively, fostering a climate where public discourse prioritized clever subversion over accountable assertion. Such irony eroded interpersonal and institutional trust by conditioning responses to prioritize over belief, creating causal barriers to or ethical reckoning, as genuine appeals could be dismissed as naive targets for ridicule. In hypercommercialized media environments of the decade, this mode facilitated advertiser-friendly ambiguity, where products and alike evaded scrutiny through layered detachment, further insulating elites from demands for transparency. Cultural analyses from the period link this ironic dominance to measurable declines in civic participation, with studies documenting reduced trust in institutions and lower engagement rates correlating with rising media-induced cynicism. Robert Putnam's examination of trends revealed a sharp drop in organizational memberships and involvement from the through the , attributing part of the erosion to television's role in promoting isolated, ironic spectatorship over participatory norms. This aligns with observations that irony's nihilistic undertones contributed to broader disengagement, as empirical metrics showed rates falling by over 50% in some demographics and interpersonal trust plummeting from 77% in 1960 to 35% by 1993, fostering a feedback loop where cynicism justified withdrawal. Such patterns underscore irony's causal impediment to genuine connection, prioritizing self-protection over the relational authenticity required for societal cohesion.

Core Tenets of Authenticity and Emotional Directness

New sincerity posits authenticity as the deliberate embrace of genuine , rejecting the pervasive ironic detachment that characterized late postmodern culture. This tenet holds that unfiltered enables direct engagement with human experience, fostering vulnerability without the protective layer of cleverness or . articulated this in his critique of irony as a "defense mechanism" that shields individuals from the discomfort of earnest connection, arguing instead for a "single-entendre principle" where communication prioritizes straightforward meaning over layered ambiguity. Such authenticity demands , recognizing one's limitations while committing to , as opposed to irony's tendency to undermine through perpetual . Central to this framework is "difficult" sincerity, which entails earnest informed by rigorous self-examination rather than naive . Proponents distinguish this from mere emotionalism by emphasizing a disciplined that confronts personal flaws and societal illusions head-on, akin to Heidegger's concept of Eigentlichkeit—authenticity as resolute ownership of one's existence amid inauthenticity's distractions. This approach counters irony's obfuscation by promoting causal clarity in understanding motivations: sincere expression reveals the direct links between emotions, intentions, and actions, unclouded by detached commentary that prioritizes aesthetic cleverness over substantive insight. Empirical supports this, showing that authentic self-expression correlates with higher , reduced stress, and enhanced resilience, as it aligns behavior with internal states without the induced by performative irony. Philosophically, new sincerity grounds emotional directness in a realist appraisal of human agency, where unvarnished truth-seeking exposes causal realities obscured by cynical postures. Wallace and aligned thinkers viewed irony as stultifying, preventing the "hard work" of and moral reckoning by substituting witticism for substantive engagement. This tenet thus requires not blind but a vigilant —one that acknowledges irony's temptations yet chooses to achieve deeper interpersonal and self-understanding, substantiated by studies linking authenticity to improved outcomes over incongruent ironic facades. In essence, it privileges causal realism by treating emotions as reliable indicators of underlying truths, demanding evidence-based self-scrutiny to validate claims of genuineness.

Manifestations in Literature

Key Writers and Novels

David Foster Wallace's Infinite Jest (1996) stands as a foundational text in New Sincerity , employing maximalist techniques such as extensive footnotes and digressive structures to pursue sincere depictions of isolation, , and human connection amid postmodern detachment. The novel's 1,079 pages, including 388 endnotes, facilitate a granular examination of emotional authenticity, contrasting ironic postmodern play with earnest complexity in characters' inner lives. Wallace's approach, rooted in his 1993 essay critiquing irony's dominance in and media, positions the work as a deliberate pivot toward vulnerability and moral seriousness. Dave Eggers' A Heartbreaking Work of Staggering Genius (), a blending raw with meta-commentary, exemplifies New Sincerity's embrace of personal candor over detached cleverness, detailing the author's abrupt orphaning and makeshift parenting of his brother. Its self-aware digressions and direct appeals to readers underscore a commitment to unfiltered emotional exposure, rejecting ironic distancing in favor of democratized narrative intimacy. Published amid rising memoir popularity, the book sold over 200,000 copies in its first year and received the finalist nod, signaling early traction for sincerity-driven prose. George Saunders' short story collections, such as (1996) and Tenth of December (2013), advance New Sincerity through absurd yet compassionate portrayals of ordinary suffering, using speculative elements to highlight genuine without postmodern cynicism. Saunders' precise, humane —evident in stories like "Sea Oak," where relatives dispense blunt life advice—prioritizes ethical directness, influencing post-2000 fiction by modeling amid dystopian settings. Jennifer Egan's A Visit from the Goon Squad (2010), a novel-in-stories incorporating PowerPoint chapters and nonlinear timelines, embodies New Sincerity's fusion of innovative form with unflinching emotional realism, tracing aging musicians' regrets and redemptions. The work's 2011 Pulitzer win and its structural experiments, which serve character-driven authenticity rather than gimmickry, reflect the movement's maturation in blending with depth. These texts collectively demonstrate New Sincerity's impact, as evidenced in scholarly monographs analyzing their role in countering irony's fatigue through verifiable stylistic and thematic commitments to truth-telling.

Evolution in Literary Criticism

The term "new sincerity" entered in the early , initially as a descriptor for a cultural shift away from postmodern irony, with David Foster Wallace's 1993 essay "E Unibus Pluram: Television and U.S. " marking a pivotal moment in its application to contemporary American prose. Critics began framing it as a response to the exhaustion of ironic detachment, evidenced by increased scholarly references in journals such as Review of Contemporary Fiction, where Wallace advocated for that fosters genuine emotional engagement over detached skepticism. Bibliometric analyses of literary databases indicate a marked rise in the term's usage starting from 1993, correlating with broader discussions of post-ironic in American . Post-2000 academic formalized new sincerity as a potential post-postmodern , with scholars positioning it as a tonal shift toward and relational in narrative, distinct from modernism's sincerity and postmodernism's playfulness. Articles in periodicals like debated its role in revitalizing reader empathy, arguing that it counters irony's alienating effects by prioritizing authentic affective responses, as seen in analyses of late-20th-century novels that blend self-reflexivity with unmediated sentiment. This evolution reflected a broader critical trend toward examining neoliberal influences on form, with monographs such as Adam Kelly's New Sincerity: American Fiction in the Neoliberal Age (2020) synthesizing it as an ethical orientation amid cultural exhaustion. Critics have acknowledged achievements in restoring intimacy but also highlighted limitations, particularly the potential for solipsistic in autofictional modes associated with new sincerity, where subjective authenticity risks collapsing into self-enclosed loops devoid of external verification. Scholarly examinations, including those of Wallace's influence, note how attempts at emotional directness can inadvertently echo postmodern , fostering isolated interiority rather than communal resonance. These debates underscore an ongoing tension in : while new sincerity expands empathetic horizons beyond cynicism, its reliance on personal testimony invites critiques of unverifiable inwardness, as explored in post-2010 analyses linking it to hybridity and digital-era self-presentation.

Applications in Music

Indie Rock and Alternative Genres

In the 2000s, and alternative genres underwent a notable stylistic evolution, departing from the emotional detachment and ironic postures rooted in punk and early influences toward confessional lyrics and direct . This change was particularly pronounced in the wave, where bands incorporated personal narratives and vulnerability into their sound, reflecting a broader cultural pivot away from cynicism toward raw authenticity. The DIY ethos underpinning these genres played a causal role in fostering this , as independent production methods—facilitated by declining costs of recording technology and —allowed creators to bypass corporate expectations of detached coolness and prioritize unfiltered, intimate artistic output. This self-reliant approach contrasted with mainstream rock's irony-driven , enabling alternative acts to emphasize human connection and unpolished vulnerability in both lyrics and performance. Listener and provided empirical validation for this shift, with mid-2000s indie releases featuring emotional depth achieving significant chart penetration, including multiple #1 debuts and top-10 albums, alongside high acclaim in rankings that underscored their thoughtful resonance over ironic detachment. The indie boom, propelled by , further amplified these sincere styles, marking a measurable uptick in cultural integration via media placements and sales trajectories distinct from prior decades' niche confinement.

Influential Artists and Albums

Sufjan Stevens' Illinois, released on July 5, 2005, stands as a cornerstone of orchestral sincerity in indie music, featuring intricate arrangements with oboes, banjos, and choral elements that convey earnest historical and personal storytelling about the state. The album's ambitious scope, blending , and classical influences across 22 tracks, earned critical acclaim for its vulnerability and avoidance of ironic detachment, positioning Stevens as a key figure in the new sincerity movement. Its reception fostered deep fan engagement through perceived authenticity, with sales exceeding 300,000 copies and enduring appeal evidenced by its adaptation into the 2024 Broadway musical Illinoise. However, some critiques highlighted risks of pretension in its elaborate production and thematic density. Arcade Fire's debut album , issued on September 14, 2004, similarly embodied orchestral sincerity via swelling strings, organs, and group vocals that processed grief and renewal without postmodern cynicism. Drawing from family losses during recording, the record's raw emotional directness—exploring death, childhood, and suburban isolation—revitalized indie rock's connection to audiences, cultivating loyalty through unfeigned . Critics associated it with new sincerity for restoring heartfelt expression amid irony's dominance, though detractors occasionally dismissed its intensity as overwrought. Conor Oberst, performing as Bright Eyes, advanced confessional sincerity with raw, faltering vocals and introspective lyrics on albums like Lifted or the Story Is in the Soil, Keep Your Ear to the Ground (August 13, 2002) and I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning (January 25, 2005), prioritizing unpolished emotional exposure over detachment. Oberst's style, marked by themes of despair, love, and self-doubt, symbolized the movement's rejection of hipster irony, building a devoted following via perceived genuineness that contrasted prevailing detachment. This approach rekindled artist-fan bonds but drew accusations of pretension from those viewing his theatrical delivery and prolific output as contrived.

Presence in Film and Visual Arts

Stylistic Features and Directorial Approaches

Directors associated with employ symmetrical framing and tableau-style compositions to evoke a structured emotional , countering the fragmentation of postmodern aesthetics with visual order that mirrors characters' quests for genuine connection. This approach uses deliberate artifice—vibrant color palettes and centered blocking—not for ironic distance but to amplify heartfelt quirks and vulnerability, transforming stylized whimsy into a vehicle for . Pacing in these films tends toward deliberate restraint, allowing unhurried reveals of character interiority that reject cynical deflection in favor of raw, post-ironic exposure. Such techniques prioritize causal links between visual form and emotional authenticity, where imposes clarity on interpersonal turmoil, fostering viewer without mockery. These stylistic hallmarks contributed to the niche appeal of 2000s indie cinema, as evidenced by the domestic gross of $52.4 million for Wes Anderson's The Royal Tenenbaums (2001), a blending quirky formalism with sincere familial dynamics on a reported budget of approximately $40 million. Festival circuits like , where such works premiered, underscored their cultural resonance amid broader indie resurgence.

Canonical Films and Examples

David Lynch's The Straight Story (1999) exemplifies New Sincerity through its unadorned depiction of Alvin Straight's 240-mile journey on a lawnmower to visit his estranged brother, prioritizing raw human vulnerability over Lynch's signature surrealism. The film earned critical acclaim for its emotional directness, with reviewers noting its G-rated restraint as a deliberate embrace of pathos amid everyday Americana, contrasting Lynch's prior works like Blue Velvet (1986). However, some analyses highlight residual self-awareness in its folksy dialogue and pacing, interpreting these as subtle ironic undercurrents rather than pure authenticity. Greta Gerwig's performance in Noah Baumbach's (2012) embodies New Sincerity by blending self-deprecating awareness of millennial with unfiltered optimism in Frances Halladay's pursuit of dance and friendship in . Contemporary reception lauded its black-and-white and improvised feel for capturing genuine relational without cynicism, positioning it as a rejoinder to ironic indie tropes. Detractors, however, contend that the film's quirky, self-conscious humor—such as Frances's bungled romantic gestures—preserves postmodern detachment, undermining claims of unqualified sincerity. Wes Anderson's The Life Aquatic with Steve Zissou (2004) navigates New Sincerity via the titular oceanographer's quixotic quest for a mythical , intertwining stylized artifice with heartfelt explorations of loss and paternity. Reviews from its release praised the balance of Anderson's symmetrical visuals and wit with authentic emotional arcs, particularly Bill Murray's portrayal of grief-stricken resolve, as a shift toward pathos-driven . Critics divided on its execution, with some viewing the film's elements—like multilingual crew banter and fabricated marine lore—as ironic veneers that dilute , while others see them as tools amplifying naive human striving.

Broader Cultural and Regional Variations

New sincerity has been interpreted through an existentialist lens, particularly via Jean-Paul Sartre's concepts of authenticity and , which emphasize reflective against or "." Unlike traditional sincerity vulnerable to irony's undermining, new sincerity integrates postmodern as a dialectical element, allowing earnest affirmation amid awareness of cultural cynicism. This framework, proposed in analyses of contemporary works, adapts Sartrean ideas to the digital era's heightened reflexivity, where individuals navigate performative identities while striving for genuine expression. In , new sincerity manifests in social media's evolution toward confessional and earnest content, particularly post-2010, as platforms encourage vulnerable sharing over detached irony. This shift aligns with "homo digitalis" dynamics, where authorial self-consciousness—evident in figures like —blends vulnerability with meta-awareness, bequeathing sincerity as a counter to algorithmic detachment. Such permeation fosters causal effects like reduced emotional alienation, as users prioritize relational authenticity in culture and viral testimonials, reflecting broader societal moves away from irony-saturated discourse. These integrations extend new sincerity's influence by grounding philosophical in everyday digital practices, potentially mitigating irony's role in eroding communal trust. Empirical observations of rising trends on platforms like and post-2010 underscore this, with content creators favoring unfiltered narratives that prioritize emotional directness over subversive detachment.

American Poetry and Other Regional Expressions

In , the New Sincerity manifested through a variant of confessionalism that prioritized unmediated emotional authenticity, particularly among post-2000 poets reacting against postmodern irony. Dorothea Lasky (born 1978), for instance, exemplifies this approach in collections such as Black Life (2010) and (2014), where raw commitment to personal emotion supplants detached experimentation, aligning with broader metamodern oscillations between and irony. This sincere confessionalism built on mid-20th-century precedents like but emphasized direct object-rendering and vulnerability without shame, as seen in Lasky's focus on beauty and relational authenticity. The movement gained traction via in the mid-2000s, with Joseph Massey's "East Shit and Die: A Manifesto for The New Sincerity" (circa 2005) decrying ironic and advocating that fosters genuine reader connections through transparent sentiment. Associated poets included Andrew Mister, Robinson, and Reb Livingston, whose works promoted unadorned emotional rendering over conceptual abstraction, tracked in literary discussions from 2006 onward. These efforts marked an empirical uptick in sincerity-oriented publications, evidenced by journal features and online manifestos clustering in U.S.-based outlets between 2005 and 2010, contrasting with persistent experimental irony in broader circles. Regionally, New Sincerity expressions remained predominantly American, with European poetry exhibiting less pronounced shifts toward explicit sincere confessionalism amid enduring postmodern influences. For example, while U.K. poets like explored sincerity in collections such as (2018), these lacked the manifesto-driven, anti-irony framing central to U.S. variants, reflecting divergent post-2000 trajectories where American works more frequently integrated personal vulnerability as a deliberate aesthetic counter to neoliberal detachment. This regional variance appears in publication patterns, with U.S. documenting sincerity's resurgence via specific poet cohorts, whereas European sustained hybrid ironic forms longer.

Criticisms and Controversies

Claims of Residual Irony and Superficiality

Critics within scholarship have contended that new sincerity's self-referential structures perpetuate ironic distance, thereby subverting purported authenticity. In analyses of Wallace's fiction, such as (1996), scholars like Edward Jackson and Joel Nicholson-Roberts argue that the movement's epistemological —intended to foster sincere readerly engagement—fails to transcend postmodern irony, instead embedding undecidability and that preclude unmediated expression. This self-awareness, they posit, cross-contaminates sincerity with the very ironic postures it seeks to reject, rendering authenticity provisional rather than absolute. Adam Kelly, examining Wallace's dialectic of sincerity, further highlights its paradoxical operation, where sincere avowals in narrative forms like testimonials rely on formulaic, unoriginal language that acknowledges artifice, thus inviting ironic contamination from media-saturated environments. Wallace's own essay "E Unibus Pluram" (1993) critiques irony as a pervasive postmodern reflex but employs metafictional techniques that mirror this irony, suggesting new sincerity's efforts at escape are inherently reflexive and incomplete. In the digital era, this residual irony manifests as performative sincerity, amplified and commodified through platforms like , where expressions of become metrics-driven spectacles for social validation. Critics argue that such dynamics expose new sincerity's superficiality, transforming personal disclosure into alienated performance akin to Wallace's warnings about televisual , where authenticity devolves into consumable content devoid of genuine interpersonal congruence. Left-leaning interpretations frame lingering irony as essential progressive against unexamined emotionalism, while right-leaning counterarguments decry it as evasion of clarity, though both underscore new sincerity's incomplete rupture from ironic precedents.

Debates on Cultural and Political Implications

Proponents of new sincerity argue that it serves as a bulwark against the cynicism embedded in media and political discourse, where irony allows elites to evade substantive accountability by reframing earnest critiques as naive or outdated. In the , this dynamic was evident in coverage of populist movements, where ironic detachment in outlets like and fostered passive consumption of outrage rather than galvanizing action, thereby insulating established power structures from disruption. Christy Wampole, in reflections following the 2016 U.S. presidential election, contended that irony's saturation in politics had rendered it ineffective for critique, necessitating a pivot to to foster genuine and pierce the veil of post-truth ambiguity. Critics, however, decry new sincerity as perilously naive, vulnerable to manipulation in an era of where earnestness blends indistinguishably with fabrication, potentially amplifying demagoguery under the guise of authenticity. For instance, Donald Trump's 2016 campaign exemplified this tension: supporters lauded his unfiltered rhetoric as a sincere rejection of , contrasting sharply with media irony that dismissed his appeals as inconsistent or bigoted without direct rebuttal. Yet detractors warned that such "shameless sincerity" risked eroding by prioritizing emotional bluntness over evidence, echoing broader concerns that media's ironic norms—often biased toward institutional preservation—enable evasion while branding populist as irrational. Defenders counter that new sincerity acts as an antidote to , which irony perpetuates by undermining absolute values and fostering detachment that corrodes communal trust and traditional ethical frameworks. In , this manifests as "open positioning" by figures embracing direct , as seen in populist surges where voters rejected elite irony for perceived , with data from 2018 indicating demands for "new sincerity 1.0" in reducing rhetorical compared to conventional politicians. This approach, rooted in calls for moral over cynical mockery, aims to rebuild eroded by decades of postmodern skepticism, though it invites risks of exploitation absent rigorous verification.

Legacy and Contemporary Relevance

Long-Term Influences on Art and Society

New sincerity has exerted a lasting influence on post-postmodern artistic practices by prioritizing authentic emotional engagement over detached irony, fostering hybrid forms that retain self-reflexivity while emphasizing genuine human experience. In , this manifests in the evolution toward post-postmodern narratives that integrate sincere personal testimony with metafictional elements, as seen in the works of authors responding to the perceived exhaustion of postmodern playfulness. Scholars note that this shift, traceable to the through figures like , has persisted into contemporary fiction, where vulnerability serves as a counter to neoliberal detachment, enabling deeper explorations of individual agency. In broader art forms, new sincerity's tonal emphasis on earnestness has informed metamodern , blending oscillation between and irony to address cultural fragmentation without fully abandoning critique. This has contributed to a revival of modes in and , where authors deploy not as evasion but as a means to authenticate narrative voice, influencing genres like that foreground amid metafictional doubt. Empirical analyses of post-2000 literary trends indicate a measurable uptick in such hybrid , with academic surveys of U.S. highlighting its role in displacing pure by 2010. On the societal level, new sincerity correlates with expanded discourses on that valorize emotional vulnerability as a pathway to resilience, aligning with data from longitudinal studies showing increased public endorsement of and from the early onward. This cultural pivot has demonstrably rebuilt trust in interpersonal and institutional contexts by modeling unadorned authenticity, as evidenced in rising participation in vulnerability-focused frameworks, which grew by over 40% in book sales and program enrollments between 2000 and 2015 per industry reports. However, this emphasis has drawn criticism for potentially fostering over-emotionalism, where unchecked sentiment risks eroding analytical rigor, as argued in literary critiques that distinguish sincere expression from sentimental excess that prioritizes feeling over evidence-based reasoning. Critics, including those examining Wallace's legacy, contend that new sincerity's push for raw exposure can mask residual irony or performative , leading to societal outcomes like heightened in public confessions rather than substantive trust restoration. Balanced assessments acknowledge its causal role in mitigating postmodern alienation—evident in reduced cynicism metrics in cultural attitude surveys post-1990s—yet warn of pitfalls in amplifying emotional without corresponding safeguards against manipulation or superficiality. Overall, these influences underscore a causal realism in : rebuilds connective tissue in fragmented societies but demands vigilance against devolving into unexamined .

Recent Developments Post-2010s

In the digital era of the 2020s, new sincerity has evolved through confessional and self-reflexive comedy, as seen in Bo Burnham's Inside (2021), a special that critiques isolation while embracing vulnerable emotional disclosure, extending Wallacean into performative digital spaces. This work exemplifies by layering metafictional awareness over earnest pleas for connection, achieving over 30 million views in its first month and prompting analyses of as a counter to algorithmic detachment. Scholars position such efforts within , where oscillates with ironic frames to address audience exhaustion from perpetual online performance. TikTok's short-form ecosystem highlights adaptations of new sincerity amid irony's dominance, with creators navigating a "cringe-sincerity cycle" in niches like , where exaggerated trends initially invite mockery but foster authentic engagement as users claim personal stakes. By 2024, critiques of an "irony epidemic" on the platform—fueled by viral detachment and meme saturation—have spurred calls for as , echoing Wallace's view that genuine feeling disrupts cynical norms in hyper-mediated environments. Gen Z contributors often blend this earnestness with absurdity, prioritizing raw relatability over polished detachment, as evidenced in that amassed billions of views under authenticity-focused hashtags by mid-decade. Scholarship from 2023 onward examines new sincerity's resilience against digital fragmentation, arguing it persists in post-postmodern and by prioritizing embodied over relativistic play, as in novels confronting neoliberal through unadorned . A 2025 frames this as a return to "emotional honesty" in , rejecting ironic detachment for narratives of moral clarity, with examples drawing over 1 million streams on platforms emphasizing viewer . Debates persist on whether algorithmic curation dilutes its potency, yet proponents cite its integration into hybrid —sincerity laced with self-aware critique—as adaptive to fragmented attention economies.

References

  1. https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/lic3.12744
  2. https://joss.tcnj.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/176/2019/04/2019-Galik-submission.pdf
  3. https://www.sup.org/books/literary-studies-and-literature/new-sincerity
  4. https://www.aei.org/articles/a-crime-that-made-cynicism-the-rule/
  5. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/style/as-years-go-by-watergate-drifts-toward-myth/2014/06/14/cff4080c-aa8a-11e1-b15f-a61faf9b4d76_story.html
  6. https://ropercenter.cornell.edu/sites/default/files/2018-07/103045.pdf
  7. https://www.euppublishing.com/doi/full/10.3366/film.2020.0136
  8. https://www.taylorfrancis.com/chapters/edit/10.4324/9780203873243-17/genericity-nineties-jim-collins
  9. https://jsomers.net/DFW_TV.pdf
  10. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/210594382.pdf
  11. https://www.atlantis-press.com/article/125944247.pdf
  12. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344759345_New_Sincerity_VS_Irony_Analysis_of_the_Existing_Cultural_and_Political_Discourses_in_the_Media_Space
  13. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/religion-and-philosophy/new-sincerity
  14. https://scholarsarchive.library.albany.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4594&context=legacy-etd
  15. https://www.academia.edu/1041012/David_Foster_Wallace_and_the_New_Sincerity_in_American_Fiction
  16. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/329180159_New_Sincerity_New_Worldliness_The_Post-911_Fiction_of_Don_DeLillo_and_David_Foster_Wallace
  17. https://blog.audionetwork.com/the-edit/music/best-selling-indie-artists
  18. https://scholarshare.temple.edu/bitstreams/7a01c802-3b7f-4e50-b0e8-7acc9c8a3df2/download
  19. https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/10.1086/717927
  20. https://www.jstor.org/stable/20866542
  21. https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstreams/284fd880-09ea-4806-9e65-3a049d30f7ba/download
  22. https://prospect.org/infrastructure/strange-disappearance-civic-america/
  23. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/americas-civic-condition-a-glance-at-the-evidence/
  24. https://digitalworks.union.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1284&context=theses
  25. https://www.academia.edu/40119828/New_Sincerity_and_David_Foster_Wallace_in_the_Modern_Era_Ironic_Authenticity_Social_Media_and_Netflix_Culture
  26. https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/e965/fee7b81c38e4fb8a1fce8c534121ba5eda7f.pdf
  27. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0092656622000046
  28. https://integratedlistening.com/blog/the-impact-of-authenticity-on-your-mental-emotional-and-physical-health/
  29. https://www.psychowellnesscenter.com/Blog/how-authenticity-is-linked-to-positive-mental-health-outcomes/
  30. https://ir.vanderbilt.edu/items/a63fd792-d5c2-4b9a-b67d-a2df32cfaceb
  31. https://revistas.ucm.es/index.php/CJES/article/view/70628
  32. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110209389.107/html
  33. https://slate.com/culture/2025/02/dave-eggers-heartbreaking-work-staggering-genius-book-toph.html
  34. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0950236X.2025.2554371?src=
  35. https://suddenfictionbooks.com/book/9781503640696
  36. https://www.metacriticjournal.com/article/317/new-sincerity-and-the-literary-self-portrait-a-case-study-across-modernism-postmodernism-and-beyond
  37. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/00111619.2020.1727831
  38. https://orbit.openlibhums.org/article/id/454/
  39. https://doi.org/10.1093/cww/vpab036
  40. https://pitchfork.com/features/article/7704-the-decade-in-indie/
  41. https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/new-sincerity-trend-within-music/
  42. https://pitchfork.com/features/lists-and-guides/7710-the-top-200-albums-of-the-2000s-20-1/
  43. https://music.sufjan.com/album/illinois
  44. https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/7514-illinois/
  45. https://www.minnesotaconnected.com/blog/music-review-carrie-and-lowell-is-another-masterpiece-from-sufjan-stevens/
  46. https://alongsideyour78s.wordpress.com/2015/11/16/sufjan-stevens-illinois/
  47. https://againstprofphil.org/2017/04/24/an-introduction-to-metamodernism/
  48. https://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/452-funeral/
  49. https://classicalbumsundays.com/modern-classic-arcade-fire-funeral/
  50. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/05/arts/music/arcade-fire-we-album-review.html
  51. https://thepointmag.substack.com/p/the-sincerity-files
  52. https://www.nytimes.com/2005/01/16/arts/music/mr-sincerity-tries-a-new-trick.html
  53. https://consequence.net/2025/01/bright-eyes-anniversary-editorial/
  54. https://www.thelineofbestfit.com/features/longread/bright-eyes-interview-more-than-the-sum-of-its-parts
  55. https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-album-reviews/bright-eyes-lifted-album-review-1235412554/
  56. https://www.studiobinder.com/blog/wes-anderson-symmetry/
  57. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/322489622.pdf
  58. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44866264
  59. https://www.the-numbers.com/movie/Royal-Tenenbaums-The
  60. https://cinemawavesblog.com/film-blog/new-sincerity-films-meaning-and-best-examples/
  61. https://thereveal.substack.com/p/the-long-goodbye-of-david-lynchs
  62. https://jcplikesfilms.wordpress.com/2014/01/19/10-frances-ha-noah-baumbach/
  63. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17400309.2011.635035
  64. https://offscreen.com/view/irony-control-and-distance-in-the-life-aquatic-with-steve-zissou
  65. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/374414637_Bequeathing_new_sincerity_in_the_age_of_the_homo_digitalis_Confessionalism_and_authorial_self-consciousness_in_David_Foster_Wallace_and_Bo_Burnham
  66. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/0013838X.2020.1847830
  67. https://www.robertpeake.com/archives/188-the-new-sincerity-movement-in-poetry.html
  68. http://labos.ulg.ac.be/cipa/wp-content/uploads/sites/22/2015/07/8_ashton.pdf
  69. http://jacketmagazine.com/35/morris-sincerity.shtml
  70. https://journals.openedition.org/transatlantica/8133?lang=en
  71. https://createdtoread.com/poetry-review-sincerity-by-carol-ann-duffy/
  72. https://orbit.openlibhums.org/article/id/429/
  73. https://post45.org/2014/10/dialectic-of-sincerity-lionel-trilling-and-david-foster-wallace/
  74. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14735784.2018.1496843
  75. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14797585.2021.1922803
  76. https://www.pastemagazine.com/politics/donald-trump-and-the-new-sincerity-artists-have-mo
  77. https://www.documentjournal.com/2024/10/when-post-irony-renders-real-and-fake-indistinguishable-irreverence-becomes-a-political-weapon/
  78. https://eng.globalaffairs.ru/articles/populists-are-now-lying/
  79. https://www.atlantis-press.com/proceedings/iccessh-20/125944247
  80. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/371904507_New_Sincerity_in_Post-postmodern_Art
  81. https://sandrogalea.substack.com/p/the-underrated-value-of-sincerity
  82. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/394764250_Digital_humor_analysis_of_Bo_Burnham%27s_Netflix_comedy_special_Inside_new_sincerity_postirony_and_metamodernism_at_play
  83. https://intransition.openlibhums.org/article/id/16444/
  84. https://styleanalytics.substack.com/p/cringe-sincerity-cycle
  85. https://liminul.xyz/the-irony-epidemic-social-contagion-and-the-death-of-sincerity-in-the-tiktok-age/
  86. https://sarahwilson.substack.com/p/the-new-sincerity-gen-z-are-awesome
  87. https://beverlyboy.com/filmmaking/what-is-new-sincerity-in-film/
  88. https://www.washingtonindependentreviewofbooks.com/bookreview/new-sincerity-american-fiction-in-the-neoliberal-age
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.