Hubbry Logo
Norman CohnNorman CohnMain
Open search
Norman Cohn
Community hub
Norman Cohn
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Norman Cohn
Norman Cohn
Norman Cohn
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Norman Rufus Colin Cohn FBA (12 January 1915 – 31 July 2007) was a British academic, historian and writer who spent 14 years as a professorial fellow and as Astor-Wolfson Professor at the University of Sussex.

Key Information

Life

[edit]

Cohn was born in London, to a German Jewish father and a Catholic mother.[1] He was educated at Gresham's School[2] and Christ Church, Oxford.[2] According to the Italian scholar Lorenzo Ferrari, "Cohn grew up feeling 'a man between all worlds' with his German-Jewish surname, his mother's Catholic faith (although she never had him baptised), and his numerous German relatives".[3] He was a scholar and research student at Christ Church between 1933 and 1939, taking a first-class degree in Modern Languages in 1936 (French) and in 1939 (German).[2] He served for six years in the British Army, being commissioned into the Queen's Royal Regiment in 1939 and transferring to the Intelligence Corps in 1944, where his knowledge of modern languages found employment.[2]

In 1941, he married Vera Broido, with whom he had a son, the writer Nik Cohn. In the immediate post-war period, he was stationed in Vienna, ostensibly to interrogate Nazis, but he encountered many refugees from Stalinism, and the similarities in persecutorial obsessions evinced both by Nazism and Stalinism fueled his interest in the historical background for these ideologically opposed, yet functionally similar movements. After his discharge, he taught successively in universities in Scotland, Ireland, England, the United States and Canada.[citation needed]

In 1962, Cohn was approached by Observer editor David Astor after Astor gave a speech on the psychopathological roots of extremism. Cohn became the head of the Centre for Research in Collective Psychopathology (later, Columbus Centre), which was set up and initially financed by Astor to look into the causes of extremism and persecution. In 1966, the Centre was formally set up as a research project at the University of Sussex. From 1973 to 1980, Cohn was Astor-Wolfson Professor of History at Sussex.[2][4]

Following the death of his wife Vera, in December 2004 he married Marina Voikhanskaya, a psychiatrist of Russian origin who had protested in the 1970s against the forcible detainment of political dissidents in the Soviet Union.[3] Norman Cohn died on 31 July 2007, in Cambridge, England, at the age of 92, from a degenerative heart condition.[5][6]

Career

[edit]

Cohn's work as a historian focused on the problem of the roots of that persecutorial fanaticism which became resurgent in modern Europe at a time when industrial progress and the spread of democracy had convinced many that modern civilisation had stepped out forever from the savageries of earlier historical societies. In his The Pursuit of the Millennium, an influential work translated into more than eleven languages, he traced back to the distant past the pattern of chiliastic upheaval that marred the revolutionary movements of the 20th century. Likewise, in Europe's Inner Demons he tracked the historical sources of the mania for scapegoating minorities which, within Christendom, culminated in the Great European witchhunt.

His book Warrant for Genocide criticizes the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, an antisemitic forgery purporting to describe a Jewish conspiracy for world domination. He argued that this conspiracy theory motivated its supporters to seek the massacre of the Jewish people and became a major psychological factor in the Nazi Holocaust.

In Cosmos, Chaos and the World to Come (1993), he sought to trace the source of millennial religious themes in ancient civilizations.[2] Cohn, with his background in dealing with totalitarian regimes and the sufferings of his relatives during the Holocaust, described all his work as studies on the phenomena that sought "to purify the world through the annihilation of some category of human beings imagined as agents of corruption and incarnations of evil".[2]

His work was honoured by his election as a Fellow of the British Academy, for which he was nominated by Isaiah Berlin.[2] His The Pursuit of the Millennium was ranked as one of the 100 most influential books of the 20th century in a survey conducted by The Times Literary Supplement.[7]

As Ferrari pointed out, "the writings of Norman Cohn have gone on to influence entire generations of readers and scholars, from all sorts of backgrounds and vocations. Through their works, historians Stuart Clark (Thinking with Demons, 1997), Michael Burleigh (The Third Reich, 2000; Earthly Powers, 2005; Sacred Causes, 2006), Daniel Pick (The Pursuit of the Nazi Mind, 2012), philosophers Pierre-André Taguieff (L’imaginaire du complot mondial, 2006), John Nicholas Gray (Black Mass, 2007) and novelists William Gibson and Ian McEwan have evidenced their intellectual debt to Cohn, who—in the words of psychiatrist Anthony Storr[8]—dedicated his entire life to ‘the important parts of history other historians do not reach: the collective myths that underpin the assumptions, prejudices and beliefs which shake and shape human societies’".[3]

Works

[edit]

Books

  • The Pursuit of the Millennium: A History of Popular Religious and Social Movements in Europe From the Eleventh to the Sixteenth Century (1957)
  • Warrant for Genocide: The Myth of the Jewish World Conspiracy and the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion" (1967), a scholarly study on the myth of the Jewish world domination conspiracy, especially as evidenced in the fabricated The Protocols of the Elders of Zion document
  • Europe's Inner Demons: An Enquiry Inspired by the Great Witch-Hunt (1975) revised edition Europe's Inner Demons: The Demonization of Christians in Medieval Christendom (1993)[9]
  • Cosmos, Chaos and the World to Come: The Ancient Roots of Apocalyptic Faith (1993, revised edition 2001)[10]
  • Noah's Flood: The Genesis Story in Western Thought (1996)[11]

Essays

  • "The Horns of Moses", Commentary, vol. 3 (September 1958)
  • "The Myth of the Jewish World Conspiracy: A Case Study in Collective Psychopathology", Commentary, vol. 41, no. 6 (June 1966) 35
  • "Monsters of Chaos", Horizon: Magazine of the Arts, no. 4 (1972), 42
  • "Permanence de Millénarismes", Le Contrat Social: revue historique et critique des faits et des idées, vol. 6, no. 5 (September 1962) 289
  • "Adamo: the Distinguished Savage", The Twentieth Century, vol. 155 (January 1954), 263
  • "The Saint-Simonian Extravaganza", The Twentieth Century, vol. 154 (July 1953), 354
  • "The Magus of the North", The Twentieth Century, vol. 153 (January 1953), 283
  • "The Saint-Simonian Portent", The Twentieth Century, vol. 152 (July 1952)
  • "How Time Acquired a Consummation", in Apocalypse Theory and the End of the World (1995), 21–37(compilation)

References

[edit]

Sources

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Norman Cohn

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Norman Rufus Colin Cohn (12 January 1915 – 31 August 2007) was a British and academic whose scholarship focused on the origins of ideologies, , and antisemitic conspiracy theories in medieval and . Cohn's most influential work, The Pursuit of the Millennium: Revolutionary Millenarians and Mystical Anarchists of the (1957), analyzed heretical movements from the eleventh to sixteenth centuries, arguing that their visions of a divinely ordained egalitarian society through violent upheaval prefigured the utopian aspirations and totalitarian methods of twentieth-century and . This book drew on extensive archival evidence to trace how marginalized social groups, amid economic distress and religious fervor, embraced millenarian prophecies promising the end of oppression and the advent of a thousand-year reign of justice. In Warrant for Genocide: The Myth of the Jewish World-Conspiracy and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion (1967), Cohn documented the fabrication of the Protocols in early twentieth-century as a blending older antisemitic tropes with modern narratives, demonstrating its pseudoscientific veneer and instrumental role in justifying pogroms and . He emphasized the document's adaptability across political spectra, from tsarist reactionaries to Nazi propagandists, underscoring how such myths exploit fears of hidden elite control to mobilize mass hatred. Educated at , where he earned a first-class degree in French in 1936, Cohn began his academic career as a lecturer in at the (1946–1951) before holding professorships in French at Magee University College, Derry (1951), and the University of Newcastle (1960). Transitioning to history, he served as Astor-Wolfson Professor at the from 1973 until his retirement in 1980, and was elected a in 1978. His interdisciplinary approach, informed by and , earned him recognition for illuminating the psychological and social mechanisms behind ideological extremism.

Early Life and Education

Family Background and Childhood

Norman Rufus Colin Cohn was born on 12 January 1915 at 41 Alleyn Park in West Dulwich, , the youngest of six sons to August Sylvester Cohn, a Jewish businessman of German origin who had acquired British nationality in the 1880s, and Daisy Ann Raimer, a devout Roman Catholic of partly German descent who spent much of her childhood in , where she met her husband during his holiday there. August Cohn, after hearing William Gladstone advocate , settled in Britain and established a family business importing and cigars from and , which provided a comfortable middle-class upbringing amid the family's relocation to following the births of their first two sons elsewhere. Cohn's mixed religious and ethnic heritage—his father's and his mother's Catholicism, though she did not have him baptized—fostered a sense of being "a man between all worlds," as he later reflected, compounded by his German-Jewish surname in an English context. The family environment emphasized intellectual pursuits, with his parents encouraging education despite the , which was for the era. During his childhood in interwar , Cohn experienced the stability of a prosperous household until economic disruptions affected the family business in , though specific personal anecdotes from this period remain limited in primary accounts. At age 13, Cohn earned a scholarship to , an independent boarding school in , where he developed an early interest in languages and history, laying the groundwork for his academic trajectory despite the school's rigorous and sometimes austere atmosphere. This period marked his transition from family influences to formal education, though he maintained a detachment from , shaped by his upbringing's pluralistic tensions.

Oxford Studies and Influences

Cohn entered , in 1933 on a scholarship to read French, with a focus on within the language curriculum. This training emphasized and , skills that later enabled his direct engagement with primary sources in his historical scholarship. He completed his undergraduate degree in 1936, earning first-class honors in medieval and modern languages. Following graduation, Cohn received a three-year to study German as part of the School, extending his expertise in and medieval texts. Cohn continued postgraduate research at until September 1939, when the Second World War interrupted his studies. The multilingual proficiency developed during this period—particularly in French and German—proved instrumental in his subsequent examination of original medieval documents related to and , facilitating rigorous source-based analysis over translated or secondary interpretations. While specific tutors from his years remain undocumented in primary accounts, the institution's emphasis on medieval and the interdisciplinary overlap between languages and shaped Cohn's methodological approach. This foundation contrasted with contemporaneous trends in academia that often prioritized theoretical abstraction, instead privileging empirical textual evidence—a hallmark of his later works.

Military Service

World War II Intelligence Work

In 1940, Norman Cohn volunteered for the British Army and was commissioned as a lieutenant in the Queen's Royal Regiment, initially serving in a conventional infantry role. His proficiency in German, acquired through studies at Christ Church, Oxford, prompted his transfer to the Intelligence Corps in 1942, where he was assigned to an army signals unit based in Tunbridge Wells, Kent. In this capacity, Cohn engaged in signals intelligence and related analytical tasks, leveraging his linguistic skills to process intercepted communications and other German-language materials amid the Allied efforts against Nazi forces. As the war progressed into its later stages, Cohn's duties extended to field operations, including interrogations of captured German personnel. These encounters exposed him directly to the ideological underpinnings of , as he questioned members of the SS and observed the human toll of the regime, including interactions with concentration camp survivors liberated by Allied forces. His wartime experiences in the Intelligence Corps, spanning signals analysis to postwar debriefings, provided firsthand insight into the mechanisms of totalitarian violence, which later informed his scholarly examinations of apocalyptic ideologies and antisemitic myths.

Post-War Transition to Academia

Following from in 1945, Norman Cohn resumed an academic career in , securing a position as lecturer in French at the from 1946 to 1951. His wartime experience in intelligence work, which leveraged his proficiency in modern languages, facilitated this return to university teaching, though he lacked formal training in history. During his Glasgow tenure, Cohn initiated independent research into medieval apocalyptic and millenarian ideologies, marking the onset of his shift toward historical scholarship beyond his linguistic expertise. In 1951, Cohn transferred to a lectureship in French at University College of Swansea (now ), where he remained until 1960. This period solidified his transition, as he deepened his historical inquiries, culminating in the publication of The Pursuit of the Millennium in 1957—a seminal analysis of revolutionary in medieval that established his reputation as a of . The work drew on primary medieval sources and interdisciplinary insights, reflecting Cohn's self-directed pivot from language instruction to broader socio-historical themes influenced by his observations of 20th-century . By 1960, Cohn advanced to Professor of French at , University of Durham (now part of ), holding the post until 1963. This promotion underscored his growing academic stature, even as his research increasingly diverged from departmental norms toward the of mass movements. The Durham years bridged his linguistic career and subsequent interdisciplinary roles, enabling Cohn to refine methodologies that linked archaic myths to modern genocidal ideologies without institutional resistance at the time.

Academic Career

Early Lecturing Positions

Following his demobilization from military service in 1946, Cohn secured his initial academic appointment as a lecturer in French at the University of Glasgow, a position he held until 1951. In this role, primarily focused on French literature and language, he began preliminary research for what would become his landmark study The Pursuit of the Millennium, shifting his scholarly attention toward medieval millenarian movements despite lacking formal training in history. This lecturing tenure marked Cohn's entry into university teaching, bridging his linguistic expertise from Oxford with emerging interdisciplinary historical inquiries.

Professorship at Leeds University

Cohn's documented academic trajectory does not include a professorship at the ; following his role at in Derry from 1951 to 1960, he was appointed of French at , (later the ), serving from 1960 to 1963. In this position, Cohn taught and language, drawing on his training in classics and modern languages, while increasingly pursuing independent historical research outside his departmental duties. This period marked a transitional phase, as Cohn's publications, including early drafts related to medieval apocalyptic movements, began to diverge from conventional philological scholarship toward interdisciplinary analyses of ideology and violence. By 1963, Cohn relocated to the as a professorial fellow and director of the Columbus Centre for studies in and , where he later held the Astor-Wolfson Chair in from 1973 until his retirement in 1980. His time at Durham facilitated this shift, enabling focused writing amid routine lecturing, though administrative demands limited full immersion in his emerging expertise on totalitarianism's historical precedents. Cohn's productivity during these years underscores his self-directed intellectual evolution, unencumbered by rigid departmental norms in French studies.

Fellowship at Essex and Retirement

In 1966, Norman Cohn was appointed a professorial fellow at the , a position he held until 1973, during which he also served as director of the Columbus Centre, an interdisciplinary research project focused on the preconditions for persecutions and genocides. This role allowed him significant time for independent scholarship, building on his earlier work at the , where he had been professor of European history from 1951 to 1963. At Sussex, Cohn contributed to the development of the history department and pursued studies linking medieval millenarian movements to modern totalitarian ideologies. From 1973 to 1980, Cohn held the Astor-Wolfson Professorship of History at , a chair endowed to support advanced research in European . In this capacity, he published Europe's Inner Demons (1975), expanding his analysis of ritual murder libels and their role in fostering . The professorship provided resources for collaborative projects, including consultations with scholars on antisemitic tropes, though Cohn increasingly focused on writing amid growing institutional bureaucracy. Cohn retired in 1980 at age 65, at which point he was appointed of at . Post-retirement, he resided in a 300-year-old thatched in , continuing scholarly output with revisions to his major works and occasional lectures, while maintaining an active lifestyle that included long country walks. He was elected a in 1978, shortly before retirement, recognizing his contributions to . Cohn remained engaged with intellectual debates until his death on 31 July 2007, aged 92.

Major Works

The Pursuit of the Millennium (1957)

The Pursuit of the Millennium: Revolutionary Millenarians and Mystical Anarchists of the Middle Ages was first published in 1957 by Secker & Warburg in . The book analyzes revolutionary millenarian movements across medieval and , spanning roughly the eleventh to sixteenth centuries, with a focus on northern regions amid social upheavals such as the , , and peasant revolts. Cohn traces these movements' roots to apocalyptic traditions in Jewish and early Christian texts, particularly the , which envisioned a divinely ordained thousand-year reign of the saints on earth after the destruction of evil forces. He argues that such chiliastic expectations, promising collective salvation through the violent overthrow of the existing order, appealed primarily to the oppressed lower classes—peasants, artisans, and the poor—who interpreted contemporary crises as signs of the imminent . Cohn's central thesis posits that these medieval movements exhibited recurring patterns: charismatic prophets or leaders claiming direct divine , demands for the immediate realization of paradise on earth (often involving communal abolition and sexual liberation), and fantasies of annihilating elites and persecutors. Key case studies include the eleventh-century Patarines in , who blended with social revolt; the thirteenth-century Amaurians and , advocating mystical anarchism and antinomianism; processions during the fourteenth-century plagues, which escalated into mass hysteria and attacks on ; and the 1534-1535 Anabaptist kingdom in , where radical prophets like Jan Matthys and Jan van Leiden enforced , communalism, and apocalyptic warfare, leading to the sect's violent suppression. Cohn emphasizes the movements' potential, noting how they rejected gradual reform or spiritual renunciation in favor of total, coercive transformation, often resulting in terror against perceived enemies. The work extends its analysis to parallels with twentieth-century totalitarian ideologies, suggesting that the medieval pursuit of a classless through mass mobilization and prefigures modern revolutionary , including both communist and fascist variants, though Cohn highlights continuities in the mythic structure of promised redemption via destruction. Drawing on primary sources like chronicles, inquisitorial records, and prophetic writings, Cohn challenges romanticized views of these sects as mere spiritual dissenters, instead portraying them as proto-totalitarian in their intolerance and utopian absolutism. Revised editions, such as the 1970 version, incorporated additional evidence on anti-Semitism's role in millenarian pogroms and expanded discussions of heretical groups, but the 1957 original established the interpretive framework that thrived on socioeconomic distress and provided a psychological escape through .

Warrant for Genocide (1967)

Warrant for Genocide: The Myth of the Jewish World-Conspiracy and the Protocols of the Elders of Zion is a 1967 historical analysis by that traces the origins, dissemination, and lethal consequences of the fabricated document known as The Protocols of the Elders of Zion. Published in by Eyre & Spottiswoode and in the United States by , the 296-page book argues that the Protocols, purporting to reveal a plot for global domination, originated as a plagiarism by Russian antisemites in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, drawing heavily from Maurice Joly's 1864 satirical Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and —a critique of unrelated to —and Hermann Goedsche's 1868 novelistic chapter "In the Rabbi's House." details how the text was fabricated around 1903 by agents of the Russian secret police, the , amid pogroms and revolutionary unrest, to discredit liberal reforms by blaming . Cohn's central thesis posits that the Protocols functioned not merely as a but as a potent providing ideological justification—"warrant"—for genocidal violence against , by depicting them as an existential threat orchestrating wars, economic crises, and moral decay. He examines its rapid spread post-1905 , with printings in exceeding 2 million copies by 1919, and its translation into multiple languages, including and Japanese, despite exposés like of London's 1921 serialization proving its . The book highlights the Protocols' pivotal role in Nazi propaganda: referenced it in (1925), and it informed the fabricated "Jewish world conspiracy" narrative central to the (1935), (1938), and the , where over 6 million were murdered between 1941 and 1945. Cohn substantiates this with archival evidence from Russian émigré publications and Nazi-era imprints, such as the 1933 German edition endorsed by . The work extends beyond the Protocols to contextualize it within broader antisemitic tropes, including medieval blood libels and 19th-century conspiracy theories like those in Édouard Drumont's La France juive (1886), arguing that such myths persisted due to their adaptability to crises, from the to Bolshevik Revolution fears. Cohn critiques the failure of liberal societies to counter these fabrications effectively, noting how post-1921 debunkings by figures like Lucien Wolf did little to stem its influence in authoritarian contexts. Reception among scholars praised its meticulous documentation and demystification of conspiracy lore; in Commentary (1967) commended its exhaustive research despite the "unexhilarating" subject, while it earned the 1968 for contributions to race relations understanding. Its impact endures in , informing analyses of how forged narratives enable mass atrocities, though some later critics, like those in Holocaust historiography, debate the extent of the Protocols' direct causal role versus broader ideological currents.

Europe's Inner Demons (1975)

Europe's Inner Demons: An Enquiry Inspired by the Great Witch-Hunt, published in 1975 by Heinemann in association with University Press, investigates the intellectual and social origins of the stereotypes that underpinned the mass persecutions during Europe's early modern witch hunts. Cohn's central thesis posits that the image of witches as members of a clandestine, Devil-worshipping sect—engaging in pacts with , nocturnal flights to sabbaths, orgiastic rituals, , and —emerged not from genuine folk practices or surviving pagan cults, but from fabricated fantasies constructed by churchmen, lawyers, and inquisitors. He systematically debunks theories, such as Margaret Murray's notion of witches as remnants of a pre-Christian , by scrutinizing primary sources and demonstrating the absence of evidence for widespread Satanic conspiracies. Cohn traces these delusions to the 12th and 13th centuries, when accusations of diabolical heresy were leveled against marginalized Christian groups like the Cathars and , incorporating earlier motifs such as ritual murder and incestuous rites borrowed from Greco-Roman stereotypes of magicians and Eastern sects. These fantasies coalesced around four core elements: maleficium (harmful sorcery), pacts with demons, shape-shifting or night-flying, and membership in a secret anti-Christian society. Inquisitorial procedures, including , elicited coerced confessions that reinforced the , transforming isolated superstitions into a self-perpetuating doctrinal framework accepted as empirical truth by secular and ecclesiastical bureaucracies. Cohn highlights how this belief in a Satanic pact became the linchpin of witch trials, enabling the execution of tens of thousands—primarily women—across from the late 15th to 17th centuries, as authorities projected societal anxieties onto scapegoated individuals. In later chapters, Cohn reconstructs the evolution of the witch stereotype through specific historical episodes, such as the 14th-century charges of and blood rituals against , which paralleled heretic accusations and foreshadowed witch-hunt dynamics. He argues that the persecutions represented not spontaneous popular hysteria but a rationalized, state-sanctioned process driven by elite credulity in these "inner demons" of the European psyche. A postscript speculates on psychohistorical factors, suggesting that the fantasies reflected deep-seated projections of forbidden desires rather than objective threats. The book, part of the Columbus Centre series on dynamics, has been translated into multiple languages and reissued, influencing subsequent by emphasizing the role of invented conspiracies in mass .

Other Contributions

In 1993, Cohn published Cosmos, Chaos, and the World to Come: The Ancient Roots of Apocalyptic , a study examining the prehistoric and ancient origins of millenarian ideas across Mesopotamian, Egyptian, Zoroastrian, and early Jewish traditions, positing their transmission into biblical and subsequent Western apocalyptic thought. The book drew on archaeological, textual, and mythological evidence to argue that these motifs of cosmic renewal amid chaos predated monotheistic scriptures, providing a deeper historical context for the medieval movements analyzed in his earlier works. Cohn also directed the Columbus Centre for Studies in the Dynamics of Persecution and Genocide at the University of Sussex from 1963 until his retirement in 1980, where he edited the centre's monograph series on collective psychopathology and mass violence, fostering interdisciplinary research into the psychosocial roots of extremism. Post-retirement, he contributed to founding the Montreal Institute for Genocide Studies at Concordia University in 1985, advising on its initial framework for investigating historical genocides through empirical and causal analysis. Additionally, Cohn authored scholarly articles and book reviews in outlets such as Commentary magazine—addressing antisemitic myths and conspiratorial psychologies—and The New York Review of Books, critiquing works on Satan, medieval religion, and biblical origins.

Core Intellectual Themes

Millenarian Revolutions and Modern Totalitarianism

Cohn's analysis in The Pursuit of the Millennium (1957) identified revolutionary —a belief in an imminent, divinely ordained earthly paradise achieved through collective violence against perceived cosmic enemies—as a recurring pattern in , with striking continuities to twentieth-century regimes. He focused on medieval European movements among the marginalized, such as the and Anabaptists of in 1534–1535, where adherents envisioned a classless emerging from the of elites, framed as agents of . These sects propagated doctrines like the "Eternal Evangel," a supposed lost gospel promising radical equality, which justified terror and expropriation, mirroring the ideological mechanisms of later mass politics. Central to Cohn's thesis was the secular adaptation of millenarian in ideologies like and National Socialism, which replaced theological with historicist inevitability while retaining its core dynamics: a Manichaean dividing into pure elect ( or ) and irredeemable devils ( or ), a prophetic interpreting history's , and a compulsory community pursuing via and . For instance, Bolshevik , as articulated by Lenin from onward, promised a communist post-class extermination, enforced through the that claimed over 1.5 million lives by 1922, echoing medieval heretics' communal property seizures and executions of dissenters. Similarly, Nazi racial , crystallized in Hitler's (1925), projected a thousand-year after eradicating "Jewish-Bolshevik" conspirators, paralleling the antisemitic phantasies of figures like the Flagellants during the in 1348–1350. Cohn emphasized that such movements thrived amid social dislocation, weaponizing among the dispossessed against scapegoats, fostering totalitarian mobilization rather than mere reform. Cohn cautioned against viewing these parallels as direct causation, instead highlighting structural affinities: both medieval and modern variants operated as "political religions" demanding total allegiance, intolerant of pluralism, and culminating in genocidal praxis. In , the 1930s under Stalin executed or imprisoned millions under the guise of purifying the vanguard for paradise, akin to Anabaptist Münster's theocratic tyranny. Nazism's , systematically murdering six million from 1941–1945, embodied the millenarian rite of exorcism, expunging evil to inaugurate the new order. This framework underscored Cohn's broader insight into ideology's capacity for fanaticism, where rational critique yields to myth-driven violence, a pattern observable in the estimated 100 million deaths from totalitarian experiments in the twentieth century.

Origins of Anti-Semitic Conspiracies

Norman Cohn traced the of a Jewish world-conspiracy to early Christian polemics against in the 2nd to 4th centuries CE, which evolved into a full demonological by the in , portraying collectively as agents of engaged in crimes against . This framework accused not merely of theological deviance but of organized, secretive plots to undermine , with the emerging as a pivotal : in 1144, in , , were charged with ritually murdering the boy William to obtain his blood for , a claim echoed in 1168 in , France, and persisting into the 20th century in . Cohn emphasized that such libels imputed to a conspiratorial intent to desecrate Christian sacraments and symbols, fostering the image of a hidden, malevolent cabal. These medieval accusations intensified during crises, as seen in the Black Death of 1347–1351, when were blamed for poisoning wells to spread the plague—a charge first leveled in 1321 in and , leading to the destruction of approximately 300 Jewish communities across , , and through massacres and burnings. Cohn argued that this transformed sporadic religious animosity into a of as a unified, supranational wielding supernatural or alchemical powers to annihilate Christian society, providing a prototype for later genocidal rationales. While economic resentments and papal protections occasionally mitigated pogroms, the underlying myth endured, adapting to portray as an eternal, Satanic counterforce to civilization. In Cohn's analysis, the conspiracy motif gained modern traction after the , with figures like Abbé Barruel in 1797 linking to Freemasons and as architects of secular upheaval, but its core drew directly from medieval precedents rather than emerging from 19th-century . This continuity culminated in The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, a fabricated around 1895 by the Tsarist , which plagiarized non-anti-Semitic works like Maurice Joly's 1864 satire on while infusing them with the ancient trope of Jewish elders plotting global domination through finance, press, and revolution. Exposed as plagiarism by of in 1921, the Protocols nonetheless proliferated, becoming central to Adolf Hitler's worldview in (1925) and Nazi propaganda, where medieval demonology merged with pseudoscientific racial theory to justify as a against an omnipotent Jewish threat. Cohn contended that this myth's longevity stemmed from its adaptability to apocalyptic anxieties, enabling totalitarian regimes to frame as redemptive necessity.

Myths of Demonic Cults and Persecution

In Europe's Inner Demons: An Enquiry Inspired by the Great Witch-Hunt (1975), Norman Cohn examined the stereotype of a "diabolical "—an imagined network of secret sects worshiping the through rituals involving sexual orgies, , , and pact-making—which he argued lacked any empirical foundation in medieval or . This fantasy, Cohn contended, emerged from ancient Roman slanders against early Christians, accusing them of thyestean banquets and incestuous rites, and was revived in the 12th and 13th centuries to demonize heretical groups such as the Cathars and . He emphasized that inquisitorial records, often cited as evidence, derived primarily from coerced confessions under , with no corroborating archaeological, documentary, or from neutral sources indicating organized Satanic cults. Cohn traced the causal mechanism of these myths to theological shifts in late medieval Christianity, where heightened emphasis on the Devil's agency—formalized in texts like the (1487)—fused heretical deviance with supernatural malevolence, enabling authorities to justify preemptive persecution. Accusations against heretics mirrored pagan stereotypes, including claims of shape-shifting, weather magic, and , but Cohn demonstrated through comparative analysis that such elements were projections rather than reflections of actual practices; for instance, Cathar dualism rejected outright, contradicting devil-worship charges. This pattern persisted into the witch hunts (ca. 1450–1750), where an estimated 40,000–60,000 executions occurred, driven by the same unfounded paradigm rather than genuine threats, as secular and ecclesiastical elites amplified folklore into prosecutable doctrine. By critiquing 20th-century theories like the "witch-cult hypothesis"—which posited survival of pre-Christian fertility religions—Cohn underscored the absence of pre-existing pagan equivalents to the full diabolical stereotype, attributing its coherence to Christian demonology's internal logic. He warned that these persecutions exemplified how societal anxieties, channeled through elite ideologies, could fabricate enemies from marginal groups, a dynamic observable in later moral panics but rooted in verifiable historical distortions rather than collective psychology alone.

Reception, Criticisms, and Legacy

Academic Praise and Influence

Norman Cohn's The Pursuit of the Millennium (1957) garnered significant academic acclaim for its pioneering examination of medieval millenarian movements, earning praise from historians such as for its "great learning and an admirably lively style" and from for its scholarly depth. also endorsed the work on its first-edition dust jacket, highlighting its innovative treatment of apocalyptic fantasies as legitimate historical phenomena rather than mere delusions. The book was selected by the Times Literary Supplement in 1995 as one of the 100 most influential works of the twentieth century, underscoring its foundational role in establishing the of . Cohn's Warrant for Genocide (1967), which traced the origins and persistence of anti-Semitic conspiracy myths like The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, received the in 1968 for advancing understanding of and genocidal ideologies. His later Europe's Inner Demons (1975) was lauded for rigorously debunking the proposed by and clarifying the sociocultural dynamics of European witch persecutions. Cohn's scholarship profoundly influenced the study of by drawing causal connections between medieval apocalyptic sects and twentieth-century ideologies such as and , shaping interpretations of collective and genocidal myths. Through his leadership of the Columbus Centre at the from 1963 to 1980, he fostered interdisciplinary research on violence and genocide, impacting subsequent scholars including historians and Michael Burleigh, philosopher John Gray, and even literary figures like . His works remain in print, translated into multiple languages, and continue to inform fields ranging from medieval history to modern studies, as evidenced by ongoing academic colloquia dedicated to his legacy.

Key Criticisms and Debates

Critics have argued that Cohn's interpretive framework in The Pursuit of the Millennium (1957) is overly one-sided, emphasizing violent and revolutionary aspects of medieval millenarian movements while downplaying their diversity and non-apocalyptic variants. Bernard McGinn, a leading scholar of apocalypticism, assessed the model as lacking balance and thus unconvincing, reflecting a broader scholarly consensus that Cohn selectively highlighted pathological elements to draw parallels with modern totalitarianism, potentially at the expense of nuanced socio-religious contexts. This approach has sparked debates on whether Cohn's portrayal of movements like the Anabaptist kingdom of Münster in 1534–1535 as prototypical of apocalyptic violence relies on polemically inspired assumptions, prompting historiographical reexaminations of evidence for genuine folk beliefs versus elite fabrications. In Europe's Inner Demons (1975), Cohn's thesis that witch-hunt stereotypes originated primarily from intellectual fantasies of organized Satanic cults among elites—rather than widespread popular superstitions—has faced scrutiny for underestimating grassroots demonological traditions in medieval and . While Cohn traced these myths to earlier heresiological accusations against groups like the Cathars, critics contend his dismissal of real subversive sects or folk practices as mere projections overlooks archaeological and testimonial evidence of localized rituals that may have fueled persecutions, leading to ongoing debates in about the interplay between top-down inquisitorial agendas and bottom-up credulity. Cohn's recurring psycho-historical speculations, such as linking millenarian fervor to authoritarian personalities or inner demons to projection mechanisms, have been critiqued as speculative and insufficiently grounded in empirical data, venturing beyond rigorous into unverified causal explanations. These elements, evident in concluding chapters across his major works, underscore debates on the limits of applying modern psychological lenses to pre-modern phenomena without accounting for cultural specificities. Despite such reservations, Cohn's analyses remain debated for their provocative illumination of myth-making's role in mass violence, though detractors warn against overgeneralizing medieval irrationality as a direct precursor to 20th-century ideologies.

Enduring Relevance to Contemporary Ideologies

Cohn's examination of revolutionary in The Pursuit of the Millennium (1957) identifies structural parallels between medieval apocalyptic sects—such as the , who sought violent communal utopia—and twentieth-century totalitarian regimes, including and , where ideologies promised imminent salvation through mass mobilization and elimination of perceived enemies. These movements, Cohn argued, drew on a recurring pattern of chiliastic fantasy, blending egalitarian visions with coercive enforcement, which persisted beyond the into modern political religions that sacralized state power and justified terror. This framework retains applicability to contemporary extremist groups exhibiting millenarian traits, such as ISIS's ideology, which envisions end-times purification via global , echoing the medieval Anabaptists' seizure of in 1534–1535 to establish a divine kingdom. In Warrant for Genocide (1967), Cohn traced the Protocols of the Elders of Zion—a 1903 Russian forgery alleging a Jewish plot for —to its role in inciting , with over 20 editions circulated by 1945 fueling Nazi . This analysis underscores the enduring mechanics of anti-Semitic conspiracism, observable today in online narratives blending historical tropes with modern grievances, such as claims of globalist cabals, where empirical fabrication persists despite debunking, as the Protocols influenced over 100 million readers historically despite proven plagiarism from earlier satires. Cohn's causal emphasis on how such myths exploit socioeconomic distress without evidence of actual cabals informs scrutiny of ideologies that attribute systemic ills to shadowy elites, prioritizing verifiable agency over unfalsifiable plots. Cohn's Europe's Inner Demons (1975) dissected the medieval myth of Satanic cults engaging in ritual infanticide and orgies, which justified witch hunts killing tens of thousands between 1450 and 1750, revealing projections of elite fears onto marginalized groups rather than real organized devil-worship. This pattern manifests in late-twentieth-century Satanic Panic, with over 12,000 unsubstantiated abuse allegations in the U.S. by 1990, and extends to QAnon's 2017 emergence, positing a pedophile cabal in government, paralleling accusations that Cohn linked to no empirical cults but to fantasy-driven persecutions. Such recurrences highlight Cohn's insight into ideological resilience: accusations amplify via without proportional evidence, as seen in QAnon's growth to millions of adherents by 2020, despite lacking verified high-level involvement, thus cautioning against uncritical acceptance of source narratives in polarized media environments prone to .

References

  1. https://www.theguardian.com/news/2007/aug/09/guardianobituaries.obituaries
  2. https://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/27/world/europe/27cohn.html
  3. https://www.thebritishacademy.ac.uk/documents/1658/161p087.pdf
  4. https://www.cdamm.org/articles/norman-cohn
  5. https://www.independent.co.uk/news/obituaries/professor-norman-cohn-403843.html
  6. https://www.normancohntrust.org.uk/norman-cohn/
  7. https://www.cdamm.org/assets/articlePDFs/20904-norman-cohn.pdf
  8. https://www.thetimes.com/uk/science/article/professor-norman-cohn-7gzrklgzskc
  9. https://www.smh.com.au/national/studied-those-who-thought-the-end-was-nigh-20070811-gdqu2k.html
  10. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/obituaries/1559275/Professor-Norman-Cohn.html
  11. https://www.the-independent.com/news/obituaries/professor-norman-cohn-403843.html
  12. https://www.abebooks.com/first-edition/pursuit-millennium-Norman-Cohn-London-Secker/32282697560/bd
  13. https://networks.h-net.org/node/6873/reviews/7384/allen-cohn-pursuit-millennium-revolutionary-millenarians-and-mystical
  14. http://resolutereader.blogspot.com/2014/07/norman-cohn-pursuit-of-millennium.html
  15. https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/norman-cohn-the-pursuit-of-the-millennium
  16. https://journal.media-culture.org.au/mcjournal/article/view/1803
  17. https://www.h-net.org/reviews/showpdf.php?id=4989
  18. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/the-pursuit-of-the-millennium-9780195004564
  19. https://www.h-net.org/reviews/showrev.php?path=141461079742078
  20. https://www.commentary.org/articles/walter-laqueur/warrant-for-genocide-by-norman-cohn/
  21. https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/719288.Warrant_for_Genocide
  22. https://researchoutput.csu.edu.au/files/333468698/331395807_published_article.pdf
  23. https://www.anisfield-wolf.org/winners/warrant-for-genocide-the-myth-of-the-jewish-world-conspiracy-and-the-protocols-of-the-elders-of-zion/
  24. https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/12BCE920626154995E3CBEE438363D34/S000708740001668Xa.pdf/middle-ages-europes-inner-demons-an-enquiry-inspired-by-the-great-witch-hunt-by-norman-cohn-london-heinemann-for-sussex-university-press-1975-pp-xvi-302-pound450.pdf
  25. https://www.commentary.org/articles/gerald-strauss/europes-inner-demons-by-norman-cohn/
  26. https://psychiatryonline.org/doi/pdf/10.1176/ajp.133.6.722?download=true
  27. https://www.jstor.org/stable/j.ctt1npzfk
  28. https://www.concordia.ca/offices/archives/honorary-degree-recipients/1985/06/norman-cohn.html
  29. https://www.commentary.org/author/norman-cohn/
  30. https://www.nybooks.com/contributors/norman-cohn/
  31. https://www.amazon.com/Pursuit-Millennium-Revolutionary-Reformation-Totalitarian/dp/B0007I6TOQ
  32. https://www.denverpost.com/2007/08/27/historian-drew-links-between-medieval-sects-totalitarianism/
  33. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2007-sep-02-me-passings2.s1-story.html
  34. https://www.commentary.org/articles/norman-cohn/the-myth-of-the-jewish-world-conspiracy-a-case-study-in-collective-psychopathology/
  35. https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/0A19B1B4BB8AE5E77964756F420E05A5/S0009640700033588a.pdf/europes-inner-demons-an-enquiry-inspired-by-the-great-witch-hunt-by-norman-cohn-the-columbus-centre-series-studies-in-the-dynamics-of-persecution-and-extermination-london-chatto-heinemann-for-sussex-u.pdf
  36. https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/E/bo3641171.html
  37. https://online.ucpress.edu/nr/article/21/4/38/70571/Thinking-inside-the-CagesNorman-Cohn-Anabaptist
  38. https://www.jstor.org/stable/4284647
  39. https://compass.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1478-0542.2006.00310.x
  40. https://openjournals.library.sydney.edu.au/LA/article/view/17603/14932
  41. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9902059/
  42. https://www.newstatesman.com/world/2019/10/why-conspiracy-theories-are-deeply-dangerous
  43. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2019/07/why-are-right-wing-conspiracies-so-obsessed-with-pedophilia/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.