Hubbry Logo
On PhotographyOn PhotographyMain
Open search
On Photography
Community hub
On Photography
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
On Photography
On Photography
On Photography
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

On Photography is a 1977 collection of essays by American writer Susan Sontag. The book originated from a series of essays Sontag published in The New York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977.

Key Information

In On Photography, Sontag examines the history and contemporary role of photography in society. She contrasts the work of Diane Arbus with Depression-era documentary photography and explores the evolution of American photography from Walt Whitman's idealistic notions to the cynicism of the 1970s. Sontag argues that photography fosters a voyeuristic relationship with the world and can diminish the meaning of events. The book discusses the relationship between photography and politics and the tension between recording and intervention. On Photography received both acclaim and criticism, with some reviewers questioning its academic rigor.

Contents

[edit]

In the book, Sontag expresses her views on the history and present-day role of photography in societies as of the 1970s. Sontag discusses many examples of modern photography. Among these, she contrasts Diane Arbus's work with that of Depression-era documentary photography commissioned by the Farm Security Administration.

She also explores the history of American photography in relation to the idealistic notions of America put forth by Walt Whitman and traces these ideas through to the increasingly cynical aesthetic notions of the 1970s, particularly in relation to Arbus and Andy Warhol.

Sontag argues that the proliferation of photographic images had begun to establish within people a "chronic voyeuristic relation to the world."[1] Among the consequences of this practice of photography is that the meaning of all events is leveled and made equal.

As she argues, perhaps originally with regard to photography, the medium fostered an attitude of anti-intervention. Sontag says that the individual who seeks to record cannot intervene, and that the person who intervenes cannot then faithfully record, for the two aims contradict each other. In this context, she discusses in some depth the relationship of photography to politics. One of the themes that is connected with the book is the problem of the norm and the repressive function of the idea of the norm in society.[2]

Reception

[edit]

On Photography won the National Book Critics Circle Award for Criticism for 1977 and was selected among the top 20 books of 1977 by the editors of The New York Times Book Review. In 1977, William H. Gass, writing in The New York Times, said the book "shall surely stand near the beginning of all our thoughts upon the subject" of photography.[3]

In a 1998 appraisal of the work, Michael Starenko, wrote in the magazine Afterimage: "On Photography has become so deeply absorbed into this discourse that Sontag's claims about photography, as well as her mode of argument, have become part of the rhetorical 'tool kit' that photography theorists and critics carry around in their heads".[4] He added that "no other photography book, not even The Family of Man (1955), which sold four million copies before finally going out of print in 1978, received a wider range of press coverage than On Photography."[5]

In 2003, Sontag published Regarding the Pain of Others, which reassesses some of the views she espoused in On Photography. Sontag considered that book to be a sequel to On Photography.[6] Sontag's publishing history includes a similar sequence with regard to her 1978 book Illness as Metaphor and AIDS and Its Metaphors a decade later, which expands on some of the ideas contained in the earlier work.

Editions

[edit]

Earlier versions of these essays appeared in The New York Review of Books:

  • Volume 20, No. 16 (October 18, 1973).
  • Volume 20, No. 18 (November 15, 1973).
  • Volume 21, No. 6 (April 18, 1974).
  • Volume 21, No. 19 (November 28, 1974).
  • Volume 23, No. 21 & 22 (January 20, 1977).
  • Volume 24, No. 11 (June 23, 1977).

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

On Photography

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

On Photography is a 1977 book by American essayist comprising six essays that analyze photography's impact on perception, ethics, and culture. The work originated as pieces published in the New York Review of Books from 1973 to 1977 and was issued by . Essays such as "In Plato's Cave" and "The Heroism of Vision" argue that photographic images proliferate to appropriate reality yet foster detachment, offering visual possession without deeper comprehension or moral engagement with subjects, particularly in depictions of suffering. Sontag contends photography commodifies experiences in a consumer society, contributing to aestheticized passivity rather than informed action. Recipient of the 1977 for Criticism, the book has profoundly influenced visual studies and photography theory, prompting ongoing debates about the medium's epistemological limits despite critiques of Sontag's generalizations.

Publication and Composition

Origins and Essay Development

The essays that form On Photography began as a commissioned piece for The New York Review of Books, with the initial installment titled "" published on October 18, 1973. Sontag described the project's inception as stemming from a single addressing the aesthetic and moral challenges posed by the proliferation of photographic images, which unexpectedly expanded as her research revealed an underexplored subject requiring deeper exploration. This iterative process transformed the work into a series of interconnected pieces, reflecting her sustained engagement with 's cultural implications over several years. Subsequent essays appeared serially in The New York Review of Books, including a second installment on November 15, 1973, and additional contributions through 1977, allowing Sontag to refine arguments across issues such as Vol. XX, No. 16 (October 18, 1973) and Vol. XX, No. 18 (November 15, 1973). In an interview with , Sontag disclosed dedicating four years to the topic, with each essay requiring approximately six months of intensive work, underscoring the deliberate evolution from discrete critiques to a cohesive examination of photography's societal role. This development phase was marked by Sontag's self-described "progress of essays," where initial reflections on photography's democratizing yet commodifying effects prompted revisions and expansions, culminating in a unified volume that interrogated the medium's epistemological and ethical dimensions without reliance on formal photographic . The enabled real-time adjustments based on reader feedback and her evolving insights, distinguishing the essays from standalone criticism by fostering thematic continuity on issues like image appropriation and perceptual distortion.

Initial Serialization and Book Form

The essays constituting On Photography were initially serialized in The New York Review of Books over a four-year period from 1973 to 1977, with earlier versions appearing in issues such as volume XX, number 16 on October 18, 1973, and subsequent installments including volume XX, number 18 on November 15, 1973. This serialization allowed Sontag to develop her critiques of photography's cultural role in a periodical known for intellectual essays, reaching an audience of literary and cultural critics. These pieces were then compiled, with slight revisions to adapt them from standalone articles to a cohesive volume, and published in book form by in December 1977. The 207-page hardcover edition presented the six essays—"In Plato's Cave," "America, Seen Through Photographs, Darkly," "Melancholy Objects," "The Heroism of Vision," "Photographic Evil," and "The Image-World"—without additional illustrations or apparatus, emphasizing Sontag's textual analysis over visual examples. This transition from periodical to monograph amplified the work's impact, earning the for in 1978.

Structure and Contents

Essay Breakdown

The book On Photography consists of six essays, originally serialized in the New York Review of Books between December 1973 and June 1977, that collectively examine photography's cultural, ethical, and perceptual implications. These essays build progressively, interconnecting themes of image proliferation, detachment from reality, and the medium's dual role as both democratic tool and agent of alienation, without a formal introduction or conclusion beyond Sontag's prefatory note describing the work as "a progress of essays." In Plato's Cave opens the collection by invoking Plato's to analogize photography's influence on perception: viewers, like prisoners mistaking for reality, accept images as unmediated truth while remaining confined to superficial knowledge. Sontag argues that photographs furnish an "antidote" to personal memory's fallibility by providing concrete evidence, yet they also falsify through selection and framing, democratizing aesthetics but fostering passivity and ethical desensitization to depicted atrocities, as the surfeit of war images from onward exemplifies. She posits photography as inherently aggressive, enabling possession of the world via the camera's gaze, which transforms transient events into consumable souvenirs, ultimately eroding deeper understanding in favor of visual acquisition. America, Seen Through Photographs, Darkly shifts to American documentary traditions, contrasting Depression-era realism in Walker Evans's work—praised for its stark, empathetic portrayal of —with Diane Arbus's portraits of societal margins, which Sontag views as voyeuristic and freakish, amplifying viewers' sense of moral superiority. The essay critiques photography's claim to humanistic insight, noting how it aestheticizes suffering to confer importance on the photographer's vision, as seen in the Farm Security Administration's 1930s output of over 77,000 images that shaped public perceptions of economic hardship without prompting sustained action. Sontag highlights the medium's paradoxical allure: it invites ethical engagement but often reduces complex realities to consumable icons, darkening the American self-image through repeated confrontations with its underbelly. Melancholy Objects focuses on photography's commodification of the inanimate, drawing parallels between still-life images and Walter Benjamin's concept of aura's loss in mechanical reproduction, where objects—whether consumer goods or ruins—evoke amid modernity's disposability. Sontag examines how photographers like elevate everyday items to emblematic status, yet this elevation underscores photography's role in cataloging obsolescence, as in 19th-century daguerreotypes that mourned industrial change by fixing . She contends that such images foster a melancholic , treating the world as a collection of possessions to be inventoried, which aligns with capitalism's drive to render all experience marketable, though Sontag attributes this less to intent than to the medium's inherent stasis. The Heroism of Vision portrays the photographer as a heroic figure who masters chaos through detached observation, equating the act of framing with conquest, akin to , as evidenced by combat photographers' prioritization of composition over intervention during conflicts like the . Sontag critiques this "cool" aesthetic heroism, arguing it promotes by privileging the image over lived experience; she cites examples from Henri Cartier-Bresson's "decisive moment" theory, where timing elevates the mundane to art, but at the cost of , transforming viewers into passive connoisseurs rather than agents. Photographic Evangels targets photography's proponents—critics, educators, and artists—who evangelize it as salvific, whether as , , or social reform tool, dismissing such claims as naive amid the medium's mass dissemination via 35mm cameras post-World War II, which numbered in the millions by the 1970s. Sontag lambasts figures like for institutionalizing in museums, arguing this sanitizes its populist origins and ignores how it proliferates clichés rather than truths. She warns against viewing as inherently progressive, citing its use in from Nazi documentation to corporate advertising, where evangelists overlook the ethical voids in image-making. The Image-World, the capstone essay, addresses image saturation's existential toll, positing a where photographs supplant , creating simulated experiences that attenuate authentic feeling, as in tourism's replacement of direct encounter with postcard views. Sontag draws on Jean Baudrillard's emerging ideas of , noting how by 1977, global photo production exceeded billions annually, fostering "to understand is to possess" mentality that equates seeing with knowing, yet breeds disconnection from consequences. She concludes that escaping this requires active resistance—refusing facile images and cultivating skepticism—rather than technological fixes, emphasizing photography's complicity in modernism's visual overload.

Interconnections Among Essays

The essays in On Photography form a cohesive progression, with foundational ontological questions in "In Plato's Cave" informing subsequent critiques of cultural, ethical, and perceptual dimensions. The opening essay posits photography as a medium that simultaneously affirms and distorts reality, likening viewers to prisoners fixated on shadows in Plato's allegory, a metaphor that recurs implicitly in later pieces to underscore the detachment fostered by images. This establishes a core tension—photography's evidentiary power versus its reductive aestheticization—which threads through "America, Seen Through Photographs, Darkly," where Sontag examines how American war and documentary images, such as those from the era, commodify suffering while purporting to reveal truth, extending the cave analogy to national self-perception. Building on these ideas, "Melancholy Objects" interconnects with prior essays by shifting from human subjects to inanimate ones, critiquing how transforms everyday commodities into melancholic icons, thereby linking the perceptual heroism introduced earlier to broader consumerist appropriation. Sontag argues that still-life evokes possession akin to the "imaginary possession" of reality described in the first essay, reinforcing 's role in mediating desire and loss across object and event. Similarly, "The Heroism of Vision" elaborates on the detached, transformative gaze of the photographer—echoing the interpretive freedom in Plato's shadows—as a form of conquest, which critiques the evangelistic optimism dismantled in "Photographic Evangels." Here, Sontag targets figures like for promoting 's artistic redemption, contrasting their idealism with the ethical voids highlighted in preceding discussions of and . The collection culminates in "The Image-World," which synthesizes interconnections by addressing the proliferation of images in late-20th-century , drawing on motifs of saturation and ethical numbness from all prior essays to warn of a world where photographs supplant direct experience. This final piece resolves the arc from philosophical to cultural , positing images as a new that desensitizes rather than enlightens, with explicit callbacks to the cave's unregenerate lingering in visual abundance. Such linkages demonstrate Sontag's deliberate , where each refines the critique without rigid linearity, prioritizing thematic resonance over isolated analysis.

Core Themes and Arguments

Photography as Appropriation and Spectacle

In Sontag's analysis, functions as a mechanism of appropriation, enabling the to symbolically seize and possess elements of reality. She contends that "to is to appropriate the thing photographed," establishing a relational dynamic akin to acquiring and, by extension, exerting power over the subject. This process transforms transient experiences into owned artifacts, as evidenced by historical uses where cameras served settlers and tourists in claiming unfamiliar territories, such as the "" of American Indian communities through prolific imaging in the late . Sontag describes the 's role as one that "loots and preserves, denounces and consecrates," highlighting the dual exploitation and sanctification inherent in capturing subjects. This appropriative impulse extends to a of lived events, where photographs substitute for direct , fostering a surrogate form of . Sontag observes that photography yields "a ’s relation to events," blurring the boundary between participation and passive acquisition, as individuals increasingly rely on images to validate and enhance their realities. In her view, this dependency cultivates "aesthetic " pervasive in industrial societies, rendering citizens "image-junkies" hooked on visual surrogates that pollute mental faculties by prioritizing captured over unmediated . By 1977, when On Photography was published, Sontag linked this to broader cultural shifts, noting how photographs occurrences with an air of incontrovertibility, yet they reduce complex phenomena to consumable tokens devoid of contextual depth. Sontag further posits photography as a generator of , miniaturizing experiences and converting history into detached, consumable displays. She argues that cameras "transform history into ," neutralizing emotional distress and promoting a voyeuristic stance that levels disparate events into uniform visual entertainment. Within capitalist frameworks, this aligns with the demand for image-saturated , where recycles reality into an endless supply of aesthetic items, akin to a " or museum-without-walls" in which subjects are depreciated as mere articles for appreciation. Sontag emphasizes that such imaging sustains societal operations by framing dually: as mass to captivate consumers and as target for authorities, thereby objectifying the world while fueling perpetual replenishment through new images. Ultimately, these dynamics erode authentic engagement, as "having an experience becomes identical with taking a photograph of it," per Sontag's , substituting symbolic possession for substantive interaction and perpetuating a cycle of visual over critical discernment.

Ethical Dimensions of Imaging Suffering

In On Photography, contends that images of suffering, particularly those from wars and disasters, often function as a form of , allowing viewers to consume distant atrocities without personal risk or commitment to action. She argues that photographers, in pursuing the decisive moment, adopt a detached stance akin to , recording pain for aesthetic or documentary value rather than intervening, which raises questions about in the spectacle of horror. This ethic of observation over participation, Sontag suggests, inheres in the medium itself, as the camera's mechanical objectifies victims, stripping them of agency and reducing their experiences to frozen, consumable artifacts. Sontag highlights how repeated exposure to such images—exemplified by photographs circulated in the 1960s and 1970s—can erode , transforming outrage into numbness or banal . Photographs, she writes, "anesthetize" rather than mobilize, fostering a false sense of comprehension that substitutes vicarious experience for genuine understanding or ethical response. This desensitization stems from photography's inherent aggression: the act of framing imposes the photographer's perspective, often aestheticizing brutality in ways that prioritize visual impact over the subject's humanity, as seen in iconic images like Nick Ut's 1972 photograph of a napalmed , which Sontag critiques for its in galvanizing protest while commodifying trauma. Ethically, Sontag questions the power dynamics in imaging the vulnerable, where is rarely obtained and subjects become for the photographer's or viewer's , echoing colonial-era tropes of the "exotic" . She posits that this process not only exploits the afflicted but also absolves audiences of responsibility, as the image's immediacy creates an illusion of engagement without demanding political or humanitarian follow-through. Critics of Sontag's view, however, note that such photographs have historically spurred reforms, as with Depression-era images influencing policies in the 1930s, suggesting her emphasis on ethical paralysis overlooks photography's potential for advocacy. Nonetheless, Sontag maintains that the ethical peril lies in photography's tendency to aestheticize , turning ethical imperatives into visual pleasures that ultimately "shrivel sympathy."

Relationship to Reality and Perception

In "In Plato's Cave," the opening essay of On Photography, invokes Plato's allegory to argue that photographs function as shadows or intermediaries that captivate perception, preventing direct engagement with . Humankind, she contends, lingers in the cave, reveling in images rather than truth, with amplifying this detachment by presenting the world as a collection of frozen, isolated moments. Photographs do not merely document but appropriate it, positioning the viewer in a relation of simulated and power over the subject, while furnishing ostensible evidence that resolves doubt through visual proof. Yet this evidentiary power is illusory; the camera renders atomic and manageable, obscuring interconnectedness and depth in favor of superficial opacity, thereby implying comprehension without fostering true understanding. Sontag further posits that inverts the between and , with increasingly evaluated for its to photographic standards rather than vice versa. This mediation cultivates a chronic , leveling the significance of events by encouraging detached observation and tacitly prolonging for capture, as the act of photographing transforms experiencing into possessing traces of . In advanced societies, cameras define dually—as mass and object—recycling the world into consumable forms that prioritize acquisition over immersion. Consequently, photographic seeing supplants unmediated vision, enlarging what merits attention while neglecting the ordinary, and de-Platonizing by conflating material images with things themselves, rendering images hyper-real. Extending this in "The Image-World," Sontag describes as defined by image production and consumption, where photographs provide mock possession of time—past, present, or future—substituting for lived encounter. Reality, once interpreted through sparse images, now drowns in their proliferation, fragmenting perception into classified records that exempt viewers from direct calamity while fostering an illusion of control. Though the camera captures a trace of akin to a , its interpretive aligns it more with paintings, blurring primitive with modern alienation and ultimately constructing rather than revealing the perceived world.

Philosophical and Cultural Context

Influences on Sontag's Perspective

Susan Sontag's critique of photography in her 1977 collection drew substantially from Walter Benjamin's theories on mechanical reproduction, particularly his 1935-1936 essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," which argued that technological duplication erodes art's traditional "" of uniqueness and ritual value. Sontag extended this to photography's mass dissemination, portraying it as a democratizing force that simultaneously commodifies experience and fosters passive spectatorship, reducing complex realities to flattened, interchangeable images. She referenced Benjamin's ideas on image captions as mechanisms to contextualize and elevate photographs beyond mere fashion, using them to underscore photography's potential for ideological manipulation rather than inherent truth-telling. Elements of , including Theodor Adorno's analyses of the culture industry, informed Sontag's view of as an instrument of capitalist appropriation, where images circulate as consumer goods that simulate engagement without demanding ethical response or . Adorno's emphasis on mass culture's alienation from authentic dialectics resonated in her essays' portrayal of photographs as surrogates for lived reality, perpetuating a that insulates viewers from material conditions. This intellectual lineage, rooted in Marxist critiques of reification, shaped her rejection of photography's claim to objectivity, positioning it instead as a symptom of modern estrangement. Philosophically, Sontag framed her arguments through Plato's in the opening essay, likening photographs to shadows on the wall—projections that users mistake for substantial knowledge while obscuring deeper truths about the world. Her prior formalist stance, articulated in the 1966 essay "," further influenced this perspective, prioritizing direct sensory apprehension over interpretive overlays, which she applied to critique photography's tendency to prioritize surface aesthetics over substantive insight. Sontag's personal encounters with wartime imagery, notably photographs circulating in the early 1970s, amplified her ethical skepticism toward visual documentation of suffering, viewing it as a form of that desensitizes rather than mobilizes action. Her leftist political engagements, including anti-war activism and observations of American media saturation, underscored these concerns, framing as complicit in the era's consumerist detachment from causal realities of power and violence.

Alignment with Broader Intellectual Currents

Sontag's analysis in On Photography engages with the Frankfurt School's , particularly its interrogation of mass culture's alienating effects, as seen in her extension of Walter Benjamin's 1935 essay "The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction," where photography's mechanical reproducibility erodes the unique "" of artistic objects while enabling bourgeois appropriation of reality. She adapts Benjamin's framework to argue that photographs transform experiences into consumable souvenirs, fostering a detached spectatorship that prioritizes collection over ethical engagement with the imaged world. This alignment underscores photography's dual role in democratizing access to images and reinforcing capitalist spectacle, akin to Theodor Adorno's and Max Horkheimer's 1944 critique of the "culture industry" as standardized entertainment that stifles critical thought. The essays also intersect with semiotic traditions, echoing ' earlier explorations in "The Rhetoric of the Image" (1964), which dissect photographs as polysemous signs blending and to propagate ideological myths. Sontag builds on this by emphasizing photography's claim to unmediated truth while highlighting its rhetorical power to aestheticize suffering, as in her discussion of war imagery that invites rather than action, thereby critiquing the perceptual distortions Barthes attributed to punctum and studium. Unlike Barthes' structuralist focus, however, Sontag prioritizes moral consequences over linguistic decoding, aligning her work with a pragmatic toward representation that anticipates postmodern doubts about referential fidelity without fully embracing . Furthermore, On Photography resonates with contemporaneous Marxist-inflected visual critiques, such as John Berger's (1972), which similarly indicts advertising and reproduced art for perpetuating class hierarchies through visual . Sontag's insistence on photography's complicity in turning reality into parallels Guy Debord's 1967 Society of the Spectacle, where images mediate social relations, substituting passive consumption for authentic participation; yet she grounds this in empirical observations of photographic practice, from tourist snapshots to documentary ethics, rather than abstract dialectics. This positioning reflects the transition from modernist faith in technological progress to postmodern wariness of simulated experience, though Sontag's essays maintain a commitment to humanist values amid cultural saturation by 3.5 billion photographs produced annually by the mid-1970s.

Reception and Critiques

Initial Critical Response

Upon its publication in December 1977, On Photography garnered widespread attention across literary, art, and photography periodicals, marking an extraordinary moment in cultural criticism. The book, compiling six essays originally published in The New York Review of Books from 1973 to 1977, was selected by the as one of the 20 best books of 1977 and received the for Criticism that year. Critics praised the work's intellectual vigor and provocative insights into photography's societal role. Janet Malcolm, in a New York Times review, described it as a "brief but brilliant work" comprising "elegant and carefully connected essays" that raise "important and exciting questions" with "clarity, skepticism, and passionate concern," positioning it as a foundational text that "shall surely stand near the beginning of all our thoughts upon the subject." Similarly, Douglas Davis in Newsweek lauded its passionate elevation of photography's cultural significance, while Cornell Capa, founder of the , expressed gratitude in a 1978 letter for Sontag's role in reawakening critical discourse on the medium's value and power. These responses highlighted the book's success in framing photography not merely as an art form but as a pervasive influence on and . However, the reception included pointed criticisms, particularly from within photography circles, who viewed Sontag's analysis as hostile or insufficiently grounded. Michael Lesy in Afterimage characterized it as an "unacknowledged autobiography" reliant on "inventive, witty, and perversely whimsical suppositions" rather than primary research into photographic practice. Colin L. Westerbeck Jr. in argued that the book effectively sought to "off" or murder , driven by personal animus rather than objective inquiry. in faulted its overly abstract theorizing, disconnected from concrete social realities. Such critiques underscored a divide: while general critics appreciated the philosophical breadth, practitioners often saw it as dismissive of photography's aesthetic and technical merits.

Awards and Long-Term Recognition

On Photography received the for Criticism in 1977, recognizing its incisive analysis of photographic practices and cultural implications. The award, presented annually by the National Book Critics Circle to honor outstanding nonfiction criticism, highlighted the book's compilation of six essays originally published in the New York Review of Books between 1973 and 1977. This distinction affirmed Sontag's contribution amid competition from works like Arlene Croce's Afterimages and Morris Dickstein's Gates of Eden. Over subsequent decades, the book has garnered sustained acclaim as a foundational text in visual studies, with publishers describing it as "one of the most highly regarded books of its kind" due to its enduring examination of photography's ethical and perceptual dimensions. Its influence persists in academic and artistic circles, evidenced by frequent citations in discussions of image saturation and , and it remains in continuous print through editions like the 2001 Picador reissue. Scholarly assessments, such as those in 2019 analyses, position it as "the most prescient and influential book ever written on the medium," underscoring its prescience regarding photography's role in mediating reality amid proliferating images.

Key Criticisms and Counterarguments

Critics of On Photography have charged Sontag with undervaluing the medium's potential to evoke and drive ethical or political responses, particularly in depictions of suffering. Susie Linfield, in a 2006 analysis, argues that Sontag's depiction of as "voyeuristic," "predatory," and "exploitative"—which posits an insurmountable divide between viewers and subjects—dismisses evidence that images can forge emotional connections and inform action, as seen in photographs like Damir Sagolj's 1994 image of a Marine consoling a girl amid Bosnian atrocities. Linfield counters that such works resist mere spectatorship, challenging Sontag's blanket assertion that photographs fail to bridge understanding or imagination. Sontag's arguments have also been faulted for inconsistency and a reliance on over coherent analysis, with examples selectively deployed to undermine photography's artistic legitimacy. An critique from 1977 describes the book as an assault aimed at "offing" photography's status as , pointing to contradictory claims—such as photography being both insufficiently laborious and overly mechanical—and misapplications of historical cases like Eadweard Muybridge's motion studies, which Sontag uses to generalize about the medium's impersonality despite their atypical scientific focus. The review contends that Sontag infers broad traits from isolated instances, as in her treatment of Eugène Atget's oeuvre, where consistent stylistic elements contradict her narrative of aimless documentation. Additional rebukes highlight Sontag's Marxist framework as breeding factual errors and cultural , sidelining photography's democratic accessibility in favor of "superior" like . A.D. Coleman, in a 2017 examination, identifies inaccuracies such as misattributing W. Eugene Smith's 1971 "Tomoko and Mommy" and critiques Sontag's borrowed ideas from , arguing her disdain for mass practices—like tourist snapshots—reveals a class bias inconsistent with Marxist . Counterarguments defend Sontag's work as a prescient of image proliferation's dehumanizing effects in , where commodifies without necessitating deeper engagement. Linfield herself acknowledges the enduring incisiveness of Sontag's 1977 insights into 's role as "mental ," even while disputing their totality, suggesting the critique's provocative force lies in highlighting genuine risks of aesthetic detachment from . Sontag's later refinement in Regarding the Pain of Others (2003)—affirming photographs' evidentiary power while reiterating limits on their motivational efficacy—demonstrates self-correction, bolstering claims that her original essays function as necessary warnings rather than outright rejection. These responses emphasize that criticisms often stem from defenders' attachment to 's affirmative uses, yet Sontag's emphasis on ethical vigilance amid visual abundance retains causal relevance in an era of unchecked consumption.

Editions and Adaptations

Publication Variants

"On Photography" originated as a series of six essays published in The New York Review of Books from 1973 to , including "America, Seen Through Photographs, Darkly" (June 14, 1973), "The Heroism of Vision" (August 14, 1974), "Melancholy Objects" (April 10, 1975), and others compiled into the book form. The essays were later assembled into a single volume, first published in by as a hardcover edition with 196 pages, featuring a black cloth binding and illustrated designed by Christine Betts. This initial printing, identified by the statement "First printing, 1977," established the core text without illustrations, focusing solely on Sontag's prose arguments. Subsequent print editions proliferated across publishers and formats. A paperback version appeared in 1979 from Penguin Books, spanning 224 pages and broadening accessibility. Picador issued a trade paperback in 2001 (ISBN 9780312420093), retaining the original content while updating cover design for contemporary markets. Macmillan published a 2023 edition under its Picador imprint, maintaining the unillustrated format but with refreshed packaging. Digital and specialized variants emerged later. An electronic edition was released in by RosettaBooks ( 0-7953-2699-8), converting the text for e-readers without altering the essays. In 2022, produced the first illustrated edition, incorporating photographs curated by curators such as Lyle Rexer to visually complement Sontag's critiques, released on September 13 with insights from contemporary scholars. These variants preserve the unaltered essay sequence—"In Plato's Cave," "America, Seen Through Photographs, Darkly," "Melancholy Objects," "The Heroism of Vision," "Photographic Evil," and "The Image-World"—across formats, with no substantive revisions to Sontag's original wording reported in publisher records.
Edition TypePublisherYearFormatKey Features
First Edition1977196 pages, unillustrated, original
Paperback1979224 pages, expanded accessibility
Trade Paperback2001ISBN 9780312420093, modern cover
ElectronicRosettaBooks2005ISBN 0-7953-2699-8, digital conversion
Illustrated2022First with curated images, scholarly notes
No abridged, expanded, or censored variants exist; all maintain fidelity to the 1977 compilation, reflecting Sontag's intent as a "progress of essays about the meaning and role of in America today."

Translations and Global Reach

On Photography has been translated into multiple languages, enabling its ideas to reach international audiences beyond the original English edition published in 1977. Notable translations include Spanish (Sobre la fotografía), first issued by Alfaguara in 2006 and later by Debolsillo in 2014; Italian, published by Einaudi in 2004; and Polish (O fotografii), released by Karakter in 2009. These editions, along with others, reflect the book's adaptation for diverse linguistic contexts, often retaining Sontag's critical examination of photography's cultural role. The work's global dissemination aligns with the broader translation of Sontag's oeuvre into 32 languages, underscoring its status as a cornerstone text in visual studies. International publishers, such as Penguin in , have distributed English-language versions alongside local translations, contributing to sustained readership in regions like and . This reach has amplified the book's impact in non-Anglophone academic and artistic circles, where it informs discussions on and representation, as evidenced by its inclusion in foreign-language editions persisting over decades.

Influence and Legacy

Shaping Photography Theory

Susan Sontag's On Photography (1977) fundamentally challenged prevailing assumptions in photographic discourse by framing the medium not as a transparent window on but as a selective, interpretive practice that mediates and distorts experience. In essays such as "In Plato's Cave," Sontag argued that photographs offer only fragmentary truths, akin to Platonic shadows, which viewers mistake for comprehensive understanding, thereby fostering a false sense of mastery over the world. This perspective shifted theoretical focus from technical or aesthetic formalism toward 's epistemological limits, influencing subsequent analyses of image credibility in an era of mass reproduction. The book's ethical interrogations—particularly regarding the voyeuristic consumption of images depicting —established a moral framework for critiquing and practices. Sontag contended that proliferating atrocity photographs desensitize audiences, commodifying pain without prompting action, as viewers treat distant horrors as aesthetic or informational entertainment. This resonated in postmodern , where was increasingly examined as an instrument of power and within , prompting theorists to question the medium's claims to objectivity and . By integrating photography into broader cultural and philosophical debates, On Photography bridged with visual studies, inspiring interdisciplinary approaches that prioritize and viewer agency over intrinsic image properties. Its emphasis on photography's role in shaping and public apathy toward real-world events laid groundwork for later works, including Sontag's own partial revisions in (2003), while remaining a cornerstone text cited in over 10,000 scholarly articles for its enduring provocation of debates on visual and representation.

Applications in Visual and Media Studies

Sontag's essays in On Photography have been integrated into visual studies curricula to dissect the medium's epistemological limits, emphasizing how photographs construct rather than capture , often reducing complex events to consumable . In programs like the MA in Photography & Urban Cultures at , the text is assigned for its analysis of 's interpretive processes, prompting students to evaluate claims of democratic access against evidence of elite control over image narratives. This application underscores Sontag's argument that fosters a "touristic" , prioritizing spectacle over substantive engagement, a framework used to critique visual hierarchies in urban documentation projects. In , the book informs examinations of photojournalism's ethical pitfalls, particularly its tendency to aestheticize and desensitize through repetitive exposure. Scholars apply Sontag's thesis—that images promote passivity by simulating possession of the world without demanding action—to analyses of war coverage, as seen in extensions of her ideas to the "violent " in conflict reporting, where photographs risk commodifying atrocity for viewer gratification. For example, her critique of photography's "pornographic" relation to reality has been cited in studies of media power dynamics, revealing how visual saturation erodes response, with empirical support from reception data showing diminished after prolonged bombardment. Visual culture theorists leverage Sontag's concepts to explore photography's role in and , applying her warnings about the medium's archival illusions to extensions like social platforms. In foundational reading lists, such as those at , On Photography is positioned as essential for tracing photography's evolution into broader visual economies, where it challenges assumptions of indexical truth by evidencing manipulation in historical and contemporary contexts. This has practical utility in course syllabi, including those at the University of Alabama's Photographic Discourse, where excerpts serve as case studies for debating image authority versus narrative fabrication. Such applications highlight the text's enduring relevance in countering overly celebratory views of visual media, grounded in Sontag's evidence from 19th- and 20th-century photographic practices.

Contemporary Reassessments in Digital Era

The ubiquity of , driven by smartphones and , has prompted reassessments that largely affirm Susan Sontag's warnings in On Photography about the medium's tendency to commodify and distance human experience from . By 2025, an estimated 2.1 trillion photographs are projected to be captured worldwide, with 94% originating from mobile devices, creating an unprecedented surfeit of images that echoes her depiction of as an "insatiable" mode of appropriation. This digital deluge intensifies the "blizzard of images" she critiqued, where proliferation risks numbing viewers to suffering and reducing encounters to consumable tokens rather than immersive realities. Platforms such as exemplify this dynamic, with users uploading hundreds of billions of images annually to "store" the world in curated feeds, often prioritizing aesthetic validation over direct engagement—a process Sontag likened to touristic possession without ethical reciprocity. Critics note that this environment fosters desensitization, as repeated exposure to viral depictions of violence, such as those circulating during protests, mirrors her argument that photographs of atrocity can aestheticize horror and erode moral urgency. Yet, digital tools also introduce fragility absent in analog eras; unlike durable prints, cloud-stored images are prone to deletion or obsolescence, underscoring photography's impermanence and complicating Sontag's view of it as a possessive archive. Digital manipulation further challenges Sontag's qualified trust in photographs as partial traces of , with software and AI-generated content, including deepfakes, enabling seamless fabrications that undermine evidentiary claims she once probed. While Sontag emphasized photography's interpretive limits over literal truth, contemporary analysts argue that algorithmic alterations amplify her concerns about images constructing rather than reflecting reality, potentially eroding epistemic trust in visual media. Some reassessments, however, contend that smartphone-enabled —evident in real-time documentation of events like the Arab Spring—counters her portrayal of passive spectatorship by facilitating immediate dissemination and , though this often reverts to voyeuristic sharing patterns. Overall, these developments render Sontag's framework prescient yet incomplete, demanding extensions to account for algorithmic curation and synthetic imagery in shaping public perception.

References

  1. https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780312420093/onphotography/
  2. https://sites.evergreen.edu/politicalshakespeares/wp-content/uploads/sites/156/2016/01/Sontag_On_Photography.pdf
  3. https://cmc.marmot.org/Record/.b12106835
  4. https://stlcc.searchmobius.org/instances/feb5f3ed-5b0f-5571-885e-cd33756d5dfa
  5. https://www.theartnewspaper.com/2022/09/05/in-pictures-susan-sontags-influential-1977-book-on-photography-is-reissued
  6. https://www.amazon.com/Photography-Susan-Sontag/dp/B00GEG2O2Q
  7. https://www.nybooks.com/articles/1973/10/18/photography/
  8. https://www.lab404.com/3741/readings/sontag.pdf
  9. https://artedeximena.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/08/on-photography.pdf
  10. https://www.artforum.com/columns/susan-sontags-on-photography-209266/
  11. https://www.supersummary.com/on-photography/in-platos-cave-summary/
  12. https://aestheticsofphotography.com/on-photography-susan-sontag/
  13. https://www.coursehero.com/lit/On-Photography/america-seen-through-photographs-darkly-summary/
  14. https://www.artsy.net/article/artsy-editorial-susan-sontags-radical-views-shape-photography
  15. https://writing.upenn.edu/library/Sontag-Susan-Photography.pdf
  16. http://timothyquigley.net/vcs/sontag-op1.pdf
  17. https://jasongoroncy.com/2015/02/25/susan-sontag-on-photographing-suffering/
  18. https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/sep/17/the-pictures-will-not-go-away-susan-sontag-and-photography
  19. https://www.nocaptionneeded.com/2014/05/sontag-photography-moral-knowledge/
  20. https://medium.com/counterarts/sontags-controversial-take-on-photography-59cd790b0048
  21. https://aeon.co/essays/does-photography-make-us-act-or-inure-us-to-despair
  22. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/03087298.2023.2428107
  23. https://danielleowensby.wordpress.com/2016/03/16/photography-and-the-pain-of-others/
  24. https://static1.squarespace.com/static/599112efcd39c3b3ad2118b0/t/607f50bde1c62e3ea70c7a88/1618956478271/Susan%2BSontag%2C%2B%2525E2%252580%25259CThe%2BImage%2BWorld%2C%2525E2%252580%25259D%2BOn%2BPhotography%2C%2B152-180.pdf
  25. https://www.yatesweb.com/walter-benjamin-mechanical-reproduction/
  26. https://theexaminedlife.org/library/on-photography
  27. https://hmu.edu/cameras-eye-my-eye-re-reading-susan-sontags-on-photography-1977/
  28. https://rupkatha.com/v9n135/
  29. https://www.alittlesense.org/sontag-on-photography-summary
  30. https://the-artifice.com/susan-sontag/
  31. https://rupkatha.com/V9/n1/v9n135.pdf
  32. https://jameselkins.com/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/Elkins-Photography-Theory.pdf
  33. https://melbournecameraclub.org.au/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Basic_Critical_Theory_for_Photographers..pdf
  34. https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/210602602.pdf
  35. https://api.pageplace.de/preview/DT0400.9781000524048_A42643909/preview-9781000524048_A42643909.pdf
  36. https://stewartspiked.com/access?docid=Q25o039&FilesData=Susan_Sontag_On_Photography_Pdf.pdf
  37. https://archive.nytimes.com/www.nytimes.com/books/00/03/12/specials/sontag-onphoto.html
  38. http://timothyquigley.net/vcs/sontag-starenko.pdf
  39. https://openlab.citytech.cuny.edu/greenarth1100sp2019-405/files/2019/02/Sontags-reception.pdf
  40. https://www.bookcritics.org/past-awards/1977/
  41. https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781429957113/onphotography/
  42. https://www.bostonreview.net/articles/susie-linfield-why-photography-critics-hate-photographs/
  43. https://www.nearbycafe.com/artandphoto/photocritic/2017/11/05/susan-sontag-off-photography-1/
  44. https://www.peterharrington.co.uk/on-photography-166792.html
  45. https://www.biblio.com/9780374226268
  46. https://www.abebooks.com/servlet/SearchResults?cm_sp=mbc_srp_fe&rr=on&isbn=9780374226268&fe=on
  47. https://www.goodreads.com/work/editions/768174-on-photography
  48. https://www.amazon.com/Photography-Susan-Sontag/dp/0312420099
  49. https://us.macmillan.com/books/9781250374745/onphotography/
  50. https://www.penguin.co.uk/books/56464/on-photography-by-susan-sontag-ed--susan-sontag/9780141035789
  51. https://www.penguin.com.au/books/on-photography-9780140053975
  52. https://www.blind-magazine.com/en/stories/revisiting-susan-sontag/
  53. https://www.bhphotovideo.com/explora/photography/features/getting-started-with-photo-theory-szarkowski-sontag-and-barthes
  54. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/343245187_Susan_Sontag%27s_Melancholy_Object_in_the_Wake_of_Post-Postmodernism_A_Case_Study_of_the_Portrait_of_Klein_by_Hannah_Diamond
  55. https://daily.jstor.org/photographs-european-refugee-crisis/
  56. https://www.jstor.org/stable/41178326
  57. https://www.gold.ac.uk/pg/ma-photography-urban-cultures/
  58. https://www.academia.edu/6604023/Against_Photography_Susan_Sontag_and_the_Violent_Image
  59. https://journals.ku.edu/amsj/article/download/2936/2895/0
  60. https://guides.libraries.indiana.edu/c.php?g=1041101&p=9925853
  61. http://oira.ua.edu/syllabus/202010/19558
  62. https://petapixel.com/2025/06/18/the-number-of-photos-taken-in-2025-is-expected-to-exceed-two-trillion/
  63. https://phototrend.fr/en/2025/06/more-than-2-trillion-photos-taken-in-2025/
  64. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/08/magazine/mag-08Riff-t.html
  65. https://www.pirelli.com/global/en-ww/life/lifestyle/arts-culture/reading-susan-sontag-in-the-era-of-instagram-50269/
  66. https://leicaphilia.com/photography-truth-and-your-truth-what-you-can-take-away-from-sartre-sontag-barthes-and-baudrillard/
  67. https://savageminds.org/2011/05/31/sontags-argument-photographic-interventions/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.