The White Devil
View on WikipediaThis article needs more citations. (June 2008) |
| The White Devil | |
|---|---|
Title page of the 1612 edition of The White Devil | |
| Original title | The White Divel; or, The Tragedy of Paulo Giordano Ursini, Duke of Brachiano. With The Life and Death of Vittoria Corombona the famous Venetian Curtizan |
| Original language | Early Modern English |
| Written by | John Webster |
| Based on | Reports of the 1585 murder of Vittoria Accoramboni |
| Characters | Monticelso Francisco De Medici – Duke of Florence Brachiano Vittoria Corombona |
| Genre | Revenge tragedy |
| Setting | Padua and Rome, 1585 |
| Premiere | |
| Date | 1612 |
| Place | Red Bull Theatre, Clerkenwell |
The White Devil[a] is a tragedy by English playwright John Webster. According to Webster's own preface to the 1612 Quarto Edition, the play's first performance in that year was a notorious failure; he complained that the play was acted in the dead of winter before an unreceptive audience. The play's complexity, sophistication, and satire made it a poor fit with the repertory of Queen Anne's Men at the Red Bull Theatre, where it was first performed. It was successfully revived in 1630 by Queen Henrietta's Men at the Cockpit Theatre and published again in 1631.
Background
[edit]The story is loosely based on an event in Italy twenty-seven years prior to the play's composition: the murder of Vittoria Accoramboni in Padua on 22 December 1585. Webster's dramatisation of this event turned Italian corruption into a vehicle for depicting "the political and moral state of England in his own day",[1] particularly the corruption in the royal court.
The play explores the differences between the reality of people and the way they depict themselves as good, "white", or pure.
Characters
[edit]
- Monticelso – a cardinal, later Pope Paul IV.
- Francisco De Medici – Duke of Florence; in Act V disguised as the Moor "Mulinassar".
- Brachiano – otherwise Paulo Giordano Orsini, The Duke of Brachiano, husband of Isabella, and in love with Vittoria.
- Giovanni – Brachiano's son by Isabella.
- Lodovico – sometimes Lodowick, an Italian count in love with Isabella.
- Antonelli – Ludovico's friend and conspirator.
- Gasparo – Ludovico's friend and conspirator.
- Camillo – Vittoria's husband, nephew of Monticelso.
- Carlo – attendant of Brachiano, in league with Francisco.
- Pedro – attendant of Brachiano, in league with Francisco.
- Hortensio – one of Brachiano's officers.
- Marcello – an attendant to the Duke of Florence; Vittoria's younger brother.
- Flamineo – Vittoria's brother. Brachiano's secretary.
- Isabella – Francisco De Medici's sister; first wife of Brachiano
- Vittoria Corombona – a Venetian lady, sister of Flamineo. first married to Camillo – afterwards to Brachiano. Based on Vittoria Accoramboni.
- Cornelia – mother of Vittoria, Flamineo, and Marcello.
- Zanche – Moor servant to Vittoria; in love with Flamineo, then Francisco.
- Ambassadors, courtiers, lawyers, officers, physicians, conjurer, armourer, attendants, matron of the House of Convertites, ladies.
- Doctor Julio.
- Christophero – one of the line-less "ghost" characters, who helps Doctor Julio murder Isabella.
Sources
[edit]Webster based The White Devil on newsletter versions of the story of the killing of Vittoria Accoramboni, while structuring the story on the basis of Democritean and Epicurean philosophy.[2]
The newsletters detailed how Vittoria, of a proud but poor family, married the nephew of Cardinal Montalto, who later became Pope Sixtus V. In 1580, she met Paolo Giordano Orsini, Duke of Bracciano, previously married to Isabella Medici of the famous Medici family. Upon meeting Vittoria, the Duke fell desperately in love with her and arranged for the Cardinal's nephew to be killed in order that he might secretly marry Vittoria. Pope Gregory soon found out and ordered Vittoria and the Duke to part and even resorted to having Vittoria imprisoned in the Castel Sant'Angelo under the suspicion of having killed her husband. In 1585 a new pope was elected and amid the confusion of change Vittoria and Bracciano married and left Rome. In the play the Pope is misnamed Paul IV (he was in fact Sixtus V, formerly Cardinal Montalto, Paul IV having died in 1559). Eight months later the Duke died and the Medici family, wishing to protect their family interests, challenged his will, which placed Vittoria to be in charge of his fortune. When Vittoria refused to co-operate, according to the play, the Medicis arranged for her to be killed. She was stabbed to death in Padua by Ludovico Orsini, a relative of her second husband.[3]
Plot summary
[edit]Count Lodovico is banished from Rome for debauchery and murder; his friends, Gasparo and Antonelli promise to work for the repeal of his sentence. The Duke of Brachiano has conceived a violent passion for Vittoria Corombona, daughter of a noble but impoverished Venetian family, despite the fact they are both married to other people. Vittoria's brother Flamineo, employed as a secretary to Brachiano, has been scheming to bring his sister and the Duke together in the hope of advancing his career, much to the dismay of their mother, Cornelia. The plan is foiled by the arrival of Brachiano's wife Isabella, escorted by her brother and Cardinal Monticelso. They are both outraged by the rumours of Brachiano's infidelity and set out to make the affair public; before that happens Brachiano and Flamineo arrange to have Camillo (Vittoria's husband) and Isabella murdered.
Vittoria is put on trial for the murder of her husband and although there is no real evidence against her, she is condemned by the Cardinal to imprisonment in a convent for penitent whores. Flamineo pretends madness to protect himself from awkward suggestions. The banished Count Lodovico is pardoned and returns to Rome; confessing he had been secretly in love with Isabella, he vows to avenge her death. Isabella's brother Francisco also plots revenge. He pens a love letter to Vittoria, intentionally allowing it to fall into the hands of Brachiano, in order to fuel his jealousy. Though at first his plan seems to work, Vittoria manages to convince Brachiano that she is faithful and the two elope. Cardinal Monticelso is elected Pope and as his first act he excommunicates Vittoria and Brachiano, who have fled Rome.
Vittoria and Brachiano, now married, hold court in Padua. Three mysterious strangers have arrived to enter Brachiano's service. These are Francisco, disguised as Mulinassar (a Moor), Lodovico and Gasparo (disguised as Capuchin monks), all conspiring to avenge Isabella's death. They begin their revenge by poisoning Brachiano. As he is dying, Lodovico and Gasparo reveal themselves to him, strangling him when he tries to raise the alarm. Next, Zanche, Vittoria's Moorish maid, who has fallen in love with her supposed countryman Mulinassar, reveals to him the murders of Isabella and Camillo and Flamineo's part in them.
Flamineo is banished from court for the murder of his brother Marcello by Brachiano's son Giovanni, the new Duke, and sensing that his crimes are catching up with him he goes to see Vittoria. He tries to persuade her and Zanche to a triple suicide by shooting him, then themselves. Vittoria and Zanche shoot Flamineo and, thinking him dead, exult in his death and their escape. Much to their surprise, Flamineo rises from the 'dead' and reveals to them the pistols were not loaded. As he tries to exact his own revenge on Vittoria, Lodovico and Gasparo enter and complete their revenge by killing all three. Giovanni and officers then arrive and the play ends with Giovanni learning of his uncle's participation in the bloody acts and arresting Lodovico and vowing that "All that have hands in this shall taste our justice" (5.6.297).
Productions
[edit]The play was written for and first performed by Queen Anne's Men at the Red Bull Theatre in Clerkenwell in the early months of 1612. The troupe usually offered simpler and more optimistic plays of the type written by their dramatist, Thomas Heywood. The play staged before Webster's seems to have been If This Be Not a Good Play, a tragicomedy by Thomas Dekker. Webster's play failed at its debut. In the prefatory epistle to the quarto, Webster praised the actors, mentioning Richard Perkins; but complained of the winter weather and above all of the audience, whose intellect he compared to that of donkeys.
The first successful modern production was that of the Marlowe Society (ADC Theatre, Cambridge, March 1920), with music by C. Armstrong Gibbs and with Eric Maschwitz as Vittoria. The Society specialised in Elizabethan and Jacobean revivals in uncut texts performed with their original economy and rapidity, and with the female roles played by men. "Anybody who enjoys hearing beautiful poetry beautifully spoken" wrote the editor of the Cambridge Review, "and tragic passion 'with dignity put on' should not miss this wonderful opportunity. What a magnificent play!"[4] "After three hundred years it must console the poet in his Elysium to know that at last his play has been played with success before a 'full and understanding auditory'. We must confess that to us it was the ritual of an initiation to the mysteries of a play which we always believed to be great, but which we never realised was quite so wonderful".[5] The production inspired the Cambridge scholar F. L. Lucas to edit the complete plays of Webster. "But in what exactly does the fascination of Webster consist?" he asked in the New Statesman.[6] "What could make the Cambridge production of The White Devil in 1920 seem still, to at least two who saw it then without any preconceptions, the most staggering performance they had ever known?"
In 1925 the Renaissance Theatre mounted a heavily cut version featuring Viola Tree and Cedric Hardwicke. The production was not well reviewed, perhaps mainly because of a failure to understand the special requirements of Renaissance dramaturgy. Webster scholar F. L. Lucas asked in the New Statesman, "Who can hope to speak passionate verse lying on one elbow on the floor?"[7]
A London production in 1947 at the Duchess Theatre directed by Michael Benthall featured Hugh Griffith as Monticelso, Patrick Macnee as Hortensio/Spanish Ambassador, Claire Bloom as one of the Ladies of Brachiano's court, Margaret Rawlings as Vittoria and Andrew Cruickshank as the Duke of Florence.
In 1965, an Off-Broadway production was staged at the Circle in the Square starring Frank Langella as Flamineo, Carrie Nye as Vittoria, Paul Stevens as Brachiano, Robert Burr as Francisco, Eric Berry as Monticelso and Christina Pickles as Cornelia. The production ran from 6 December 1965 to 17 April 1966 and won the Obie Award for Distinguished Performance (Frank Langella).
In November 1969, the National Theatre at the Old Vic in London, performed the play in a production by Frank Dunlop (who went on to found the Young Vic). The cast was largely drawn from the company. Geraldine McEwan played Vittoria, Edward Woodward Flamineo, Edward Petherbridge Lodovico, Benjamin Whitrow Camillo, Derek Godfrey Bracciano, Jane Lapotaire Zanche, Hazel Hughes Cornelia, John Moffatt Monticelso, Jane Wenham Isabella, Anthony Nicholls Francisco and Edward Hardwicke Marcello. In later performances Derek Jacobi played Lodovico. It was designed by Piero Gherardi as a crumbling wall out of which characters emerged like crawling insects in fantastic costumes of great extravagance. William Hobbs staged the fights and played the Spanish Ambassador. Mime work was by Claude Chagrin. The assistant director was Roland Joffe (since then the director of "The Killing Fields" and "The Mission").
The Royal Shakespeare Company performed The White Devil in 1996 at the Swan Theatre in Stratford-upon-Avon (later transferred to London to The Pit at The Barbican), directed by Gale Edwards with Richard McCabe as Flamineo, Philip Quast as Ludovico, Ray Fearon as Brachiano, Jane Gurnett as Vittoria, Stephen Boxer as Francisco and Philip Voss. The company returned to the play in 2014 with a production in the Swan Theatre in Stratford-upon-Avon, directed by Maria Aberg with David Sturzaker as Bracciano, Kirsty Bushell as Vittoria, David Rintoul as Cardinal Monticelso, Simon Scardifield as Francisco and Joseph Arkley as Ludovico; in this production, Flamineo, Vittoria's brother, was played by a woman (Laura Elphinstone).
On 1 March 1997, the BBC World Service broadcast an adaptation starring Anton Lesser and Helen Baxendale.
On 15 August 2010 BBC Radio 3 broadcast a production adapted and directed by Marc Beeby which, according to the BBC Radio 3 web site, "sets the action in a murky underworld of the 1950s – a world that seeks to hide its shifting alliances, betrayals and sudden violence beneath a flaky veneer of honour and respectability." The production featured Patrick Kennedy as Flamineo, Anna Maxwell Martin as Vittoria, Frances de la Tour as Cornelia, Shaun Dingwall as Brachiano, Peter Wright as Francisco, Sean Baker as Monticelso and Harry Myers as Ludovico.
On 26 January 2017 a run started at the Sam Wanamaker Playhouse, London (a venue embodying the features of a typical theatre from the period of the original seventeenth century production).[8]
The Red Bull Theatre in New York performed The White Devil in 2019.
To date, this play has never been filmed or televised.
Adaptations
[edit]In 1707, Nahum Tate's adaptation of the play, titled Injur'd Love: or the Cruel Husband, was published.[9]
Notes
[edit]- ^ Full original title: The White Divel; or, The Tragedy of Paulo Giordano Ursini, Duke of Brachiano. With The Life and Death of Vittoria Corombona the famous Venetian Curtizan
References
[edit]- ^ Webster, John (1960). Russell Brown, John (ed.). The White Devil. London: Methuen. p. 4. OCLC 317509591.
- ^ Kroll, Norma (1973). "The Democritean Universe In Webster's "The White Devil"". Comparative Drama. 7 (1): 3–21. ISSN 0010-4078. JSTOR 41152599.
- ^ Murphy, Caroline P. (2008). Murder of a Medici Princess. Oxford University Press. p. 346. ISBN 9780195314397.
- ^ Cambridge Review, 12 March 1920
- ^ Cambridge Review, 30 April 1920
- ^ New Statesman, 1 March 1924
- ^ New Statesman, 17 October 1925
- ^ Shenton, Mark (2 February 2017). "The White Devil review at Sam Wanamaker Playhouse, London – 'thrilling and ferocious'". The Stage.
- ^ Spencer, Hazelton (1934). "Tate and the White Devil". ELH. 1 (3): 235–249. doi:10.2307/2871756. ISSN 0013-8304.
Further reading
[edit]- Webster, John (1612). The White Devil, or Vittoria Corombona: a Tragedy (First ed.). London: Thomas Archer. OCLC 46303316.
- Webster, John (1996). The White Devil (Simon Trussler ed.). London: Nick Hern Books. ISBN 978-1854593450.
- The short story 'A Christmas in Padua' in F. L. Lucas's The Woman Clothed with the Sun (1937) retells the final hours in December 1585 of Vittoria Accoramboni (the original of Webster's White Devil), slanting the narrative from her perspective.
External links
[edit]- The White Devil at the Internet Off-Broadway Database (archived)
- John Webster at IMDb
The White Devil public domain audiobook at LibriVox
The White Devil
View on GrokipediaHistorical Context and Composition
Webster's Career and Influences
John Webster, born circa 1580 in London to a prosperous family involved in coach-making and tailoring, entered the theatrical world by the early 1600s as a member of the Jacobean dramatic scene under King James I. His career initially centered on collaborative efforts with contemporaries, including Thomas Dekker on the city comedies Westward Ho! (performed 1604) and Northward Ho! (1605), which satirized London society and drew responses from rivals like Ben Jonson.[7] Later collaborations extended to Thomas Middleton, William Rowley, and John Fletcher on works such as A Cure for a Cuckold (circa 1620s) and tragicomedies, reflecting the era's demand for joint authorship amid theater companies' need for frequent new material.[8] Webster's independent output remained sparse, with his reputation resting primarily on two major tragedies post-1610: The White Devil (1612) and The Duchess of Malfi (1613–1614), marking a shift toward stark explorations of moral corruption in a period of intensifying Jacobean pessimism about human nature and power.[9] Webster's dramatic style in The White Devil drew heavily from the Senecan revenge tragedy tradition, which emphasized stoic fatalism, rhetorical excess, and cycles of vengeance originating in the Roman playwright Seneca's works like Thyestes. This influence manifested in structured acts of retribution and choruses underscoring inevitable downfall, adapted to Jacobean tastes for psychological depth over Elizabethan optimism.[10] He also engaged with Shakespearean drama, explicitly naming Shakespeare among admired predecessors in the 1612 quarto's prefatory address "To the Reader," where Webster positioned himself as inheriting a legacy of "monumental labours" from Elizabethan giants while lamenting the era's drift toward superficial spectacle.[11] Machiavellian elements, inspired by Niccolò Machiavelli's The Prince (1532), informed Webster's portrayal of pragmatic amorality and political intrigue as intrinsic to elite behavior, evident in borrowings from Italian scandals that highlighted vice as a fixed human propensity rather than a product of external forces.[12] In the same preface, Webster critiqued audiences for favoring "variety of action" and "antic clownage" over substantive tragedy, revealing his commitment to deliberate craftsmanship akin to Euripides, whom he cited as a model for measured pacing against hasty commercial output. This self-reflexive stance underscored his influences from Ben Jonson and George Chapman, praising their intellectual rigor while decrying the "stale" conventions diluting Jacobean stages.[12] Such commentary, grounded in the 1612 publication's context of initial performance failure at the Red Bull Theatre, positioned The White Devil as a deliberate retort to prevailing tastes, prioritizing unflinching realism in human frailty over crowd-pleasing diversions.[11]Real-Life Sources and Italian Scandals
John Webster's The White Devil derives its plot from the documented adulterous affair and serial murders involving Vittoria Accoramboni and Paolo Giordano Orsini, Duke of Bracciano, during the 1580s in Italy. Accoramboni, born around 1557, had married Francesco Peretti—a lawyer and nephew of the future Pope Sixtus V—in 1577, but Orsini, a powerful nobleman, pursued her amid his own marital troubles. Orsini orchestrated Peretti's stabbing death on October 26, 1581, in Rome, employing assassins including members of the Accoramboni family, such as Vittoria's brother Marcello, to facilitate the liaison.[13] Orsini had earlier eliminated his first wife, Isabella de' Medici, on July 16, 1576, at the family's villa in Cerreto Guidi; while the official report attributed her death to apoplexy during hair washing, contemporary accounts and historians indicate Orsini strangled her in retaliation for her affair with his cousin Troilo Orsini, with possible complicity from Isabella's brother Francesco I de' Medici to preserve family alliances.[14][15] Following Peretti's murder, Orsini and Accoramboni wed secretly in November 1581, defying Pope Gregory XIII's opposition, which led to her brief imprisonment and their subsequent exile to Salò and Padua. Pope Sixtus V, seeking vengeance for his relative Peretti, intensified persecution; Orsini succumbed to illness—possibly exacerbated by poison—on November 13, 1585, after which Accoramboni and her brothers Marcello and Flaminio were assassinated on December 22, 1585, in Padua by agents linked to the Medici and papal interests.[16][17] Webster sourced these events from Italian news relations (avisi) and chronicles circulating in Europe, including accounts like the Relatione della morte accaduta in Padou (1586), which detailed the scandals with emphasis on aristocratic intrigue and familial vendettas. In Protestant England, such narratives were amplified through lenses of anti-Catholic polemic, portraying Italian papal and noble circles as exemplars of systemic corruption and unchecked vice, as evidenced in English compilations like George Reynolds' The Triumphs of God's Revenge Against the Crying and Execrable Sinne of Wilfull and Premeditated Murther (1621), which framed the Accoramboni-Orsini killings as providential judgments on premeditated crimes within a decadent Catholic hierarchy—though Reynolds' work postdated the play, it echoed prior sensationalized reports Webster accessed. These sources prioritized empirical details of the murders' mechanics and motives over moralizing, underscoring causal chains of ambition, infidelity, and retaliation among Renaissance elites rather than fabricating events wholesale.[18]Publication and Initial Staging
The White Devil was composed in the early Jacobean period, with most scholarly estimates placing its writing between late 1610 and 1611, based on Webster's use of sources published by 1608 and allusions to contemporary events.[19] The play received its first known performance in early 1612 by Queen Anne's Men at the Red Bull Theatre, an open-air venue in Clerkenwell known for its boisterous public audiences.[20] [21] The quarto edition appeared later in 1612, printed by Nicholas Okes for publisher Thomas Archer, marking Webster's first sole-authored play to reach print.[22] In the prefatory address "To the Reader," Webster defended the work's complex rhetoric and moral portrayals, asserting it depicted "true characters of vice" rather than simplistic morality plays, while lamenting that the Red Bull's "full house" of spectators—unaccustomed to intricate tragedy—failed to appreciate its depth, preferring spectacle over substance.[21] Contemporary accounts and Webster's own comments indicate a tepid initial reception, attributed to the mismatch between the play's demanding style and the rowdy, less discerning crowd at the public Red Bull, which contrasted with the more elite indoor theatres favored by sophisticated playgoers.[20] [21] The venue's reputation for disorderly audiences, including apprentices and laborers, likely exacerbated the disconnect, as the tragedy's philosophical density and lack of dumb shows did not align with expectations for popular entertainment.[21]Synopsis
Overall Structure and Key Events
The White Devil is divided into five acts, following the standard framework of Jacobean revenge tragedies, with events propelled by a dense sequence of betrayals and retributions in a corrupt Italian aristocratic milieu.[23] The plot hinges on Duke Brachiano's adulterous seduction of Vittoria Corombona, which triggers the murders of her husband Camillo—trapped and killed in a contrived accident—and Brachiano's wife Isabella, poisoned through a tainted portrait to clear obstacles for their liaison.[4][24] These crimes lead directly to Vittoria's public arraignment and trial before papal authorities, where she is accused of adultery and complicity in Camillo's death, resulting in her sentencing to confinement in a house for repentant courtesans; judicial corruption enables her release and secret marriage to Brachiano shortly thereafter.[4][24] Flamineo, Vittoria's scheming brother, facilitates the affair and subsequent manipulations, including his own stabbing of brother Marcello in a fit of rage, while Brachiano's political enemies, including the banished Count Lodovico, plot countermeasures that include poisoning Brachiano via a rigged tournament helmet.[4] The rapid escalation culminates in a chaotic finale of reciprocal violence: Lodovico and accomplices stab Vittoria and her maid Zanche, shoot Flamineo (who feigns death before retaliating), and trigger a cascade of stabbings that eliminates the surviving principals, linking initial deceptions causally to mass annihilation.[4][24]Act Summaries
Act 1The play commences with Count Lodovico, recently returned from banishment for crimes including murder, discussing his political misfortunes with Antonelli and Gasparo.[25] French and English ambassadors converse on Italian affairs, noting Duke Brachiano's infatuation with Vittoria Corombona, the wife of Camillo.[25] In Vittoria's residence, her brother Flamineo promotes her liaison with Brachiano while mocking Camillo's jealousy.[25] Brachiano declares his adulterous desire to Vittoria, who reciprocates cautiously; Flamineo proposes murdering Camillo by enticing him into a vaulting house and demolishing the ceiling to simulate an accident.[25] Vittoria's mother Cornelia overhears the scheme and denounces the immorality, though her protests are dismissed.[25] Act 2
A dumb show portrays Brachiano's wife Isabella kissing a poisoned portrait, resulting in her death.[25] Brachiano rebuffs Isabella's plea for reconciliation, insisting on separation.[25] Another dumb show depicts Camillo trapped in the vaulting house, where the roof collapses, killing him as planned.[25] Vittoria and her maid Zanche face trial before Cardinal Monticelso, Ambassador Francisco, and attorneys for Camillo's murder and adultery.[25] Vittoria contests the accusations with bold speeches, but Monticelso convicts her, sentencing her to house arrest in a convertite institution for penitent women.[25] Brachiano departs the proceedings in fury.[25] Act 3
Confined in the convertite house, Vittoria spurns offers of spiritual reform and receives a visitor: a supposed Moor named Mulinassar (Brachiano in disguise), attended by a page.[25] The Moor persistently woos her with jewels and flattery, gradually revealing his true identity as Brachiano.[25] Vittoria accepts his suit; Flamineo facilitates their escape from the house.[25] Brachiano weds Vittoria, assuming control as her protector, and relocates with her, Flamineo, Zanche, and Vittoria's son Giovanni to Padua.[25] Act 4
In Padua at Brachiano's court, Francisco de' Medici, disguised as the Moor Mulinassar, joins forces with the newly pardoned Lodovico to orchestrate vengeance against Brachiano.[25] Cornelia enters in distracted grief, bewailing the fates of Vittoria and Flamineo while singing dirges.[25] A dispute erupts over Zanche's affections, leading Flamineo to stab his brother Marcello to death; Brachiano initially condemns Flamineo to execution but revokes the sentence.[25] Zanche confides court intrigues in a letter to her former master, which Francisco seizes.[25] Preparations advance for poisoning Brachiano via helmet, beard, and gloves during an upcoming tournament.[25] Act 5
Cardinal Monticelso ascends as Pope Paul IV, issuing excommunication against Brachiano and Vittoria.[25] Amid a masque of demons, disguised Lodovico and Gasparo present Brachiano with tainted armor, inducing his torment and demise from poison.[25] Vittoria, Flamineo, and Zanche exchange accusations of betrayal and infidelity.[25] The assassins, posing as Capuchin friars, infiltrate and strangle Vittoria and Zanche, then mortally wound Flamineo.[25] Giovanni, now Duke, arrives to arrest Lodovico and Gasparo, condemning them to torture.[25]
