Hubbry Logo
TiVoTiVoMain
Open search
TiVo
Community hub
TiVo
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
TiVo
TiVo
TiVo
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

TiVo
TiVo EDGE DVR
DeveloperXperi
TypeDigital video recorder
Release dateMarch 31, 1999; 26 years ago (1999-03-31)
DiscontinuedOctober 1, 2025; 25 days ago (2025-10-01)
Operating systemLinux
Websitewww.tivo.com Edit this at Wikidata

TiVo (/ˈtiːvoʊ/ TEE-voh) is a discontinued line of digital video recorders (DVR) developed and marketed by Xperi (previously by TiVo Corporation and TiVo Inc.) and introduced in 1999. TiVo provides an on-screen guide of scheduled broadcast programming television programs, whose features include "OnePass" schedules which record every new episode of a series, and wishlist searches which allow the user to find and record shows that match their interests by title, actor, director, category, or keyword. TiVo also provides a range of features when the TiVo DVR is connected to a home network, including film and TV show downloads, advanced search, online scheduling, and at one time, personal photo viewing and local music playback.

After its launch in its home market of the United States, TiVo units were also sold in Australia, Canada, Mexico, New Zealand, Puerto Rico, Sweden, Taiwan, Spain, and the United Kingdom.[1] Later models adopted the CableCARD standard, which is only deployed in the United States, and which limits the availability of certain features. TiVo discontinued its DVR hardware products in October 2025.

History and development

[edit]
Logo used from 1999 to 2015. Shown here is the 2012 version.

TiVo was developed by Jim Barton and Mike Ramsay through a corporation they named "Teleworld" which was later renamed to TiVo Inc. Though they originally intended to create a home network device, it was redesigned as a device that records digitized video onto a hard disk.

After exhibiting at the Consumer Electronics Show in January 1997, Mike Ramsay announced to the company that the first version of the TiVo digital video recorder would be released "in Q1" (the last day of which is March 31) despite an estimated 4 to 5 months of work remaining to complete the device. Because March 31, 1999, was a blue moon, the engineering staff code-named this first version of the TiVo DVR "Blue Moon".[2]

The original TiVo DVR digitized and compressed analog video from any source (antenna, cable or direct broadcast satellite). TiVo also integrated its DVR service into the set-top boxes of satellite and cable providers. In late 2000, Philips Electronics introduced the DSR6000, the first DirecTV receiver with an integrated TiVo DVR. This new device, nicknamed the "DirecTiVo", stored digital signals sent from DirecTV directly onto a hard disk.

In early 2000, TiVo partnered with electronics manufacturer Thomson Multimedia (now Technicolor SA) and broadcaster British Sky Broadcasting to deliver the TiVo service in the UK market. This partnership resulted in the Thomson PVR10UK, a stand-alone receiver released in October 2000 that was based on the original reference design used in the United States by both Philips and Sony. TiVo ended UK unit sales in January 2003, though it continued to sell subscriptions and supply guide data to existing subscribed units until June 2011. TiVo branded products returned to the UK during 2010 under an exclusive partnership with cable TV provider Virgin Media.[3]

TiVo was launched in Australia in July 2008 by Hybrid Television Services, a company owned by Australia's Seven Media Group and New Zealand's TVNZ. TiVo Australia also launched a TiVo with a 320Gb hard Drive in 2009.[4] TiVo Australia also launched Blockbuster on demand and in December 2009 launched a novel service called Caspa on Demand.[5] TiVo also went on sale in New Zealand on 6 November 2009.[6]

Janet Jackson's Super Bowl halftime show incident on February 1, 2004, set a record for being the most watched, recorded and replayed moment in TiVo history. The baring of one of Jackson's breasts at the end of her duet with Justin Timberlake, which caused a flood of outraged phone calls to CBS, was replayed a record number of times by TiVo users. A company representative stated, "The audience measurement guys have never seen anything like it. The audience reaction charts looked like an electrocardiogram."[7]

Wordmark variant from 2015 to 2020

In April 2016, Rovi acquired TiVo for $1.1 billion.[8]

In December 2019, it was announced that TiVo would merge with Xperi Corporation. The merger completed in May 2020.[9]

In early February 2024, TiVo removed the antenna version of the TiVo Edge from their website, apparently discontinuing their OTA line of DVRs.[10] The cable version of the TiVo Edge as well as the TiVo Mini LUX and TiVo Stream 4K continued to be available.

The TiVo Mini LUX went permanently out of stock in June/July 2025.[11] It is unclear when the TiVo Stream 4K was discontinued. The TiVo Edge DVR for Cable, along with all remaining hardware accessories, were removed from sale on TiVo's website in late September/early October 2025, and sales of annual and lifetime service subscriptions were discontinued, leaving monthly subscriptions as the only remaining service option for TiVo Roamio, TiVo BOLT, and TiVo Edge boxes that do not already have active service plans.[12] TiVo said to Variety that it had exited the hardware manufacturing business on October 1, 2025, and that remaining inventory had been depleted.[13]

TiVo digital video recorder

[edit]
Main article: TiVo digital video recorders

A TiVo DVR serves a function similar to that of a videocassette recorder (VCR), in that both allow a TV viewer to record programming for viewing at a later time, known as time shifting. Unlike a videocassette recorder, which uses removable magnetic tape cartridges, a TiVo DVR stores TV programs on an internal hard drive, much like a computer.

A TiVo DVR also automatically records programs that the user is likely to be interested in. TiVo DVRs also implement a patented feature that TiVo calls "trick play", allowing the viewer to pause live television and rewind and replay up to 30 minutes of recently viewed TV. TiVo DVRs can be connected to a computer local area network, allowing the TiVo device to download information, access video streaming services such as Netflix or Hulu, as well as music from the Internet.

Functions

[edit]

TiVo DVRs communicate with TiVo's servers on a regular basis to receive program information updates, including description, regular and guest actors, directors, genres, whether programs are new or repeats, and whether broadcast is in High Definition (HD). Information is updated daily into its program guide from Rovi (Tribune Media Services was used prior to September 2016[14]).

Users can select individual programs to record or a "OnePass" (formerly "Season Pass") to record all episodes of a show. There are options to record First Run Only, First Run and Repeats, or All Episodes. An episode is considered "First Run" if aired within two weeks of that episode's initial air date. OnePasses can also "bookmark" shows from internet streaming video services and show a combined view of recordings and bookmarks.

When users' requests for multiple programs are conflicting, the lower priority program in the OnePass Manager is either not recorded or clipped where times overlap. The lower priority program will be recorded if it is aired later. TiVo DVRs with multiple tuners simultaneously record the top priority programs.

TiVo pioneered recording programs based on household viewing habits;[15] this is called TiVo Suggestions. Users can rate programs from three "thumbs up" to three "thumbs down". TiVo user ratings are combined to create a recommendation, based on what TiVo users with similar viewing habits watch. For example, if one user likes American Idol, America's Got Talent and Dancing with the Stars, then another TiVo user who watched just American Idol might get a recommendation for the other two shows. As of 2023, Tivo Suggestions are no longer supported. The Thumbs Up/Down buttons can no longer be used to rate programs.

The amount of storage capacity for programs is dependent upon the size of the hard drive inside the TiVo; different models have different sized hard drives. When the space is full on the hard drive, the oldest programs are deleted to make space for the newer ones; programs that users flag to not be deleted are kept and TiVo Suggestions are always lowest priority. The recording capacity of a TiVo HD DVR can be expanded with an external hard drive, which can add additional hours of HD recording space and standard definition video recording capacity.

When not recording specific user requests, the current channel is recorded for up to 30 minutes. Dual-tuner models record two channels. This allows users to rewind or pause anything that has been shown in the last thirty minutes — useful when viewing is interrupted. Shows already in progress can be entirely recorded if less than 30 minutes have been shown. Unlike VCRs, TiVo can record and play at the same time. A program can be watched from the beginning even if it is in the middle of being recorded, which is something that VCRs cannot do. Some users take advantage of this by waiting 10 to 15 minutes after a program starts (or is replayed from a recording), so that they can fast forward through commercials. In this way, by the end of the recording viewers are caught up with live television.

Unlike most DVRs, TiVo DVRs are easily connected to home networks,[16] allowing users to schedule recordings on TiVo's website (via TiVo Central Online), and transfer recordings between TiVo units (Multi-Room Viewing (MRV)). Former and now discontinued features included the ability transfer recordings to and from a home computer (TiVoToGo (TTG) transfers), play music and view photos over the network, and access third-party applications written for TiVo's Home Media Engine (HME) API.

TiVo added a number of broadband features, most of which are no longer offered. These include:

Integration with Amazon Video on Demand, Jaman.com[17] and Netflix Watch Instantly,[18] offering users access to thousands of movie titles and television shows right from the comfort of their couch. Additionally, broadband connected to TiVo boxes can access digital photos from Picasa Web Albums or Photobucket. Another popular feature is access to Rhapsody music through TiVo, allowing users to listen to virtually any song from their living room. TiVo also teamed up with One True Media to give subscribers a private channel for sharing photos and video with family and friends. They can also access weather, traffic, Fandango movie listings (including ticket purchases), and music through Live365. In the summer of 2008 TiVo announced the availability of YouTube videos on TiVo.

On June 7, 2006, TiVo began offering TiVoCast, a broadband download service that initially offered content from places such as Rocketboom or, The New York Times; now there are over 70 TivoCast channels available for TiVo subscribers.

In January 2005, TiVoToGo, a feature allowing transfer of recorded shows from TiVo boxes to PCs, was added. TiVo partnered with Sonic in the release of MyDVD 6.1, software for editing and converting TiVoToGo files. In January, 2007, TiVoToGo was extended to the Macintosh with Toast Titanium 8, Roxio software for assembly and burning digital media on CD and DVD media. In August, 2005, TiVo rolled out "TiVo Desktop" allowing the copying of MPEG2 video files from PCs to TiVo for playback by DVR. As of June 5, 2013, TiVo stopped distributing the free version of TiVo Desktop for PC in favor of selling TiVo Desktop Plus.[19] Users who previously downloaded the free version of TiVo Desktop could continue to use the software without paying a fee for the Plus edition.

Parental features

TiVo KidZone (later removed in the Premiere and Roamio devices) was designed to give parents greater control over what their children see on television. This feature allows parents to choose which shows their children can watch and record. It also helps kids discover new shows through recommendations from leading national children's organizations. TiVo KidZone provides a customized Now Playing List for children that displays only pre-approved shows, keeping television as safe as possible.

Subscription service

[edit]

The information that a TiVo DVR downloads regarding television schedules, as well as software updates and any other relevant information is available through a monthly service subscription in the United States. A different model applies in Australia, where the TiVo media device is bought for a one-off fee, without further subscription costs.

Lifetime subscription

There are multiple types of Product Lifetime Service. For satellite-enabled TiVo DVRs, the lifetime subscription remains as long as the account is active; the subscription does not follow a specific piece of hardware. This satellite lifetime subscription cannot be transferred to another person. Toshiba and Pioneer TiVo DVD recording equipped units include a "Basic Lifetime Subscription", which is very similar to Full Lifetime, except only three days of the program guide are viewable; and search and Internet capabilities are not available, or at least are limited. All units (except satellite but including DVD units) can have "Product Lifetime Subscription" added to the TiVo service, which covers the life of the TiVo DVR, not the life of the subscriber. The Product Lifetime Subscription accompanies the TiVo DVR in case of ownership-transfer. TiVo makes no warranties or representations as to the expected lifetime of the TiVo DVR (aside from the manufacturer's Limited Warranty). In the past TiVo has offered multiple "Trade Up" programs where you could transfer the Product Lifetime Subscription from an old unit to a newer model with a fee. A TiVo can be used without a service-agreement, but it will act more like a VCR in that you can only perform manual recordings and the TiVo can't be connected to the TiVo service for local time, program guide data, software updates, etc. or TiVo will shut down the recording function.

Service availability

[edit]

The TiVo service is available in the United States, United Kingdom, Canada, Mexico, Spain and Taiwan at present. Over the years since its initial release in the United States, TiVo Series1 and Series2 DVRs have also been modified by end users to work in Australia, Brazil, Canada, New Zealand, the Netherlands, and South Africa.

TiVo went on sale in New Zealand in the first week of November 2009.[6]

The TiVo Service came to an end in Australia on 31 October 2017.[20] The electronic programming guide and TiVo recording features are no longer available, thus making all TiVo machines in Australia virtually useless.

United Kingdom
[edit]

The TiVo service was launched in the United Kingdom in the autumn of 2000. It sold only 35,000 units over the next 18 months. Thomson, makers of the only UK TiVo box, abandoned it in early 2002 after BSkyB launched its Sky+ integrated "set-top" decoder and DVR, which dominated the market for DVRs in homes subscribing to BSkyB's paid-for satellite television service. Many manufacturers, including Thomson[21][22] have launched integrated decoder boxes/DVRs in the UK for other digital platforms, including free satellite, terrestrial, cable and IPTV.

A technical issue caused TiVo Suggestions to stop recording for S1 UK TiVo customers in late September 2008, but this was fixed in late January 2009.[23]

Since December 2010, UK TiVo units that were not already on an active monthly subscription or lifetime subscription could no longer be re-activated. BSkyB who were operating the support for TiVo no longer had full access to the TiVo systems to activate accounts.[citation needed]

The TiVo S1 subscription service was maintained for both lifetime and monthly subscriptions until 1 June 2011.[24] A community project known as AltEPG was established in March 2011 with the aim of providing a replacement for the discontinued subscription service. This project now provides programme guide data and software upgrades for S1 TiVos.[25]

On 24 November 2009, cable television provider Virgin Media entered into a strategic partnership with TiVo.[3] Under the mutually exclusive agreement, TiVo developed a converged television and broadband interactive interface to power Virgin Media's next generation, high definition set top boxes. TiVo will become the exclusive provider of middleware and user interface software for Virgin Media's next generation set top boxes. Virgin Media will be the exclusive distributor of TiVo services and technology in the United Kingdom. Virgin Media released its first TiVo co-branded product in December 2010.[26] On 17 March 2011, Virgin Media enabled access to a third tuner.[27]

As of 12 February 2015, Virgin Media has 2 million TiVo customers, 50% of their TV customers.[28]

Hardware anatomy

[edit]
Main article: TiVo DVRs
The TiVo "peanut" remote

The TiVo DVR was designed by TiVo Inc., which currently provides the hardware design and Linux-based TiVo software, and operates a subscription service (without which most models of TiVo will not operate). TiVo units have been manufactured by various OEMs, including Philips, Sony, Cisco, Hughes, Pioneer, Toshiba, and Humax, which license the software from TiVo Inc. To date, there have been six "series" of TiVo units produced.

TiVo DVRs are based on PowerPC (Series1) or MIPS (Series2) processors connected to MPEG-2 encoder/decoder chips and high-capacity IDE/ATA hard drives. Series1 TiVo units used one or two drives of 13–60 GB; Series2 units have drives of 40–250 GB in size. TiVo has also partnered with Western Digital to create an external hard drive, the My DVR Expander, for TiVo HD and Series3 Boxes. It plugs into the TiVo box using an eSATA interface. It expands the High-Definition boxes by up to 67 hours of HD, and around 300 hours of standard programming. Other TiVo users have found many ways to expand TiVo storage, although these methods are not supported by TiVo, and may void the warranty.

Some recent models manufactured by Toshiba, Pioneer, and Humax, under license from TiVo, contain DVD-R/RW drives. The models can transfer recordings from the built-in hard drive to DVD Video compliant disc, playable in most modern DVD systems.

Most standalone TiVo DVRs have coax/RF-in and an internal cable-ready tuner, as well as analog video input — composite/RCA and S-Video, for use with an external cable box or satellite receiver. The TiVo unit can use a serial cable or infrared blasters to control the external receiver. They have coax/RF, composite/RCA, and S-Video output (newer models have HDMI output for video and audio), and the DVD systems also have component out. Audio is RCA stereo, and the DVD systems also have digital optical out.

Until 2006, standalone TiVo systems could only record one channel at a time, though a dual-tuner Series2DT (S2DT) box was introduced in April 2006. The S2DT has two internal cable-ready tuners and it supports a single external cable box or satellite receiver. The S2DT is therefore capable of recording two analog cable channels, one analog and one digital cable channel, or one analog cable and one satellite channel at a time, with the correct programming sources. Note, however, that the S2DT, unlike earlier units, cannot record from an antenna. This is due to an FCC mandate that all devices sold after March 2007 with an NTSC tuner must also contain an ATSC tuner. TiVo therefore had to choose between adding ATSC support, or removing NTSC support. With the S2DT they opted to remove NTSC; the Series3 supports NTSC and ATSC, along with digital cable channels (with CableCards).

The Series2 DVRs also have USB ports, currently used only to support network (wired Ethernet and WiFi) adapters.[29] The early Series2 units, models starting with 110/130/140, have USB1.1 hardware, while all other systems have USB2.0. There have been four major generations of Series2 units. The TiVo-branded 1xx and 2xx generations were solid grey-black. The main difference was the upgrade from USB 1.1 to the much faster USB 2.0. The 5xx generation was a new design. The chassis is silver with a white oval in the faceplate. The white oval is backlit, leading to these units being called "Nightlight" boxes. The 5xx generation was designed to reduce costs, and this also caused a noticeable drop in performance in the system menus as well as a large performance drop in network transfers. The 5xx generation also introduced changes in the boot PROM that make them unmodifiable without extensive wiring changes. The 6xx generation resembles the previous 5xx model, except that it has a black oval. The 6xx is a new design and the only model available today is the S2DT with dual tuners and a built-in 10/100baseT Ethernet port as well. The 6xx is the best performing Series2 to date, outperforming even the old leader, the 2xx, and far better than the lowest performing 5xx.

Some TiVo systems are integrated with DirecTV receivers. These "DirecTiVo" recorders record the incoming satellite MPEG-2 digital stream directly to hard disk without conversion. Because of this and the fact that they have two tuners, DirecTiVos are able to record two programs at once. In addition, the lack of digital conversion allows recorded video to be of the same quality as live video. DirecTiVos have no MPEG encoder chip, and can only record DirecTV streams. However, DirecTV has disabled the networking capabilities on their systems, meaning DirecTiVo does not offer such features as multi-room viewing or TiVoToGo. Only the standalone systems can be networked without additional unsupported hacking.

DirecTiVo units (HR10-250) can record HDTV to a 250 GB hard drive, both from the DirecTV stream and over-the-air via a standard UHF- or VHF-capable antenna. They have two virtual tuners (each consisting of a DirecTV tuner paired with an ATSC over-the-air tuner) and, like the original DirecTiVo, can record two programs at once; further, the program guide is integrated between over-the-air and DirecTV so that all programs can be recorded and viewed in the same manner.

In 2005, DirecTV stopped marketing recorders powered by TiVo and focused on its own DVR line developed by its business units. DirecTV continues to support the existing base of DirecTV recorders powered by TiVo.

On 8 July 2006, DirecTV announced an upgrade to version 6.3 on all remaining HR10-250 DirecTiVo receivers, the first major upgrade since this unit was released. This upgrade includes features like program grouping (folders), a much faster on-screen guide, and new sorting features.

In September 2008, DirecTV and TiVo announced that they have extended their current agreement, which includes the development, marketing and distribution of a new HD DIRECTV DVR featuring the TiVo service, as well as the extension of mutual intellectual property arrangements.

Since the discontinued Hughes Electronics DirecTV DVR with TiVo model HR10-250, all TiVo units have been fully HDTV capable. Other TiVo models will only record analog standard definition television (NTSC or PAL/SECAM). The Series3 "TiVo HD, and TiVo HD XL" DVRs and the Series4 "TiVo Premiere and TiVo Premiere XL" DVRs are capable of recording HDTV both from antenna (over the air) and cable (unencrypted QAM tuner or encrypted with a Cable Card) in addition to normal standard definition television from the same sources. Unlike the HR10-250, neither the Series3 nor Series4 units can record from the DirecTV service; conversely, the HR10-250 cannot record from digital cable. Other TiVo models may be connected to a high definition television (HDTV), but are not capable of recording HDTV signals, although they may be connected to a cable HDTV set-top box and record the down-converted outputs.

In 2008, some cable companies started to deploy switched digital video (SDV) technology, which initially was incompatible with the Series3 and TiVo HD units. TiVo Inc worked with cable operators on a tuning-adapter with USB connection to the TiVo to enable SDV. Some MSOs now offer these adapters for free to their customers with TiVo DVRs.

Drive expansion

[edit]

TiVo has partnered with Western Digital to create an external hard drive, the My DVR Expander eSATA Edition, for TiVo HD and Series3 systems. The external drive plugs into the TiVo box using an eSATA interface. The first version of the eSATA drive shipped was a 500 GB drive that shipped in June 2008. In June 2009 the 1 TB version of the drive began shipping. The 1 TB version expands the TiVo HD and Series3 systems' capacity by up to 140 hours of HD content or 1,200 hours of standard programming.

TiVo was not designed to have an external drive disconnected once it has been added, because data for each recording is spread across both the internal and external disk drives. As a result, it is not possible to disconnect the external drive without deleting content recorded after the external drive was added. If disconnected, any recordings made will not be usable on either the internal or external drives. However, the external drive may be removed (along with content) without losing settings.

Various capacities of external drives have been shipped since the product was initially released. There were reports of product reliability issues,[30] and a brief period of unavailability.[31]

The Western Digital 1 TB and 500 GB My DVR Expander eSATA Edition and My DVR Expander USB Edition drives have been discontinued and replaced with the Western Digital My Book AV DVR Expander 1 TB drive. This drive has received a facelift from the previous generation, which now sports a glossy finish, and a tiny white LED power indicator, along with a push button power switch in the back. The biggest change is that this drive now includes both eSATA and USB in one device. This device is DirectTV, Dish Network, TiVo, Moxi, Pace, and Scientific Atlanta (Cisco) certified. Seagate has come out with their own DVR-oriented drive called the Seagate GoFlex DVR which comes in a 1 TB and 2 TB capacity.[32] TiVo has not approved the Seagate product for use with TiVo DVRs and they will not currently function with any TiVo products.[33]

Hacking

[edit]

Users have installed additional or larger hard drives in their TiVo boxes to increase their recording capacity. Others have designed and built Ethernet cards[34] and a Web interface (TiVoWeb), and figured out how to extract, insert and transfer video among their TiVo boxes. Other hacks include adding time to the start and end of recording intelligently[35] and sending daily e-mails of the TiVo's activity.

TiVo still uses the same encoding, however, for the media files (saved as .TiVo files). These are MPEG files encoded with the user's Media Access Key (MAK). However, software developers have written programs such as tivodecode and tivodecode Manager to strip the MAK from the file, allowing the user to watch or send the recordings to friends.

TiVo in the cloud

[edit]

On January 4, 2018, TiVo announced its next-gen platform, a catch-all product for providers like cable companies. It's available for multiple TV devices, including not only Linux- and Android TV-based set-top boxes and traditional DVRs, but also DVR-free streaming devices like Apple TV and Amazon's Fire TV, as well as phones, tablets and PCs. The platform allows providers to take advantage of TiVo's user interface, voice control, personalization and recommendations. TiVo expects its user interface could provide an advantage over competitors such as Netflix, Hulu, and Amazon Video "in a world where cord-cutting is increasingly popular."[36][clarification needed]

In the 2020s, Internet service providers such as TDS and Astound started using set-top boxes with TiVo user interfaces to provide TV and cloud DVR service to their customers. These devices can also run apps for streaming services such as Netflix and Prime Video.[37][38]

Competitors and market share

[edit]

While its former main competitor in the United States, ReplayTV, had adopted a commercial-skip feature, TiVo decided to avoid automatic implementation fearing such a move might provoke backlash from the television industry. ReplayTV was sued over this feature as well as the ability to share shows over the Internet, and these lawsuits contributed to the bankruptcy of SONICblue,[39] its owner at the time. Its new owner, DNNA, dropped both features in the final ReplayTV model, the 5500.

After demonstrating the WebTV capability at the same 1999 CES with TiVo and ReplayTV demonstrating their products, Dish (then named Dish Network) a few months later added DVR functionality to their DishPlayer 7100 (and later its 7200) with its Echostar unit producing the hardware while Microsoft provided the software that included WebTV, the same software Microsoft would later use for its UltimateTV DVR for DirecTV. The TiVo, ReplayTV, and DishPlayer 7100 represent very first DVRs that were in development at the same time and were released to market at about the same time.

SONICblue, the owners of ReplayTV would file for bankruptcy after being sued for its ability to automatically skip commercials and other features that were thought to violate copyrights; Echostar (Dish) would eventually sue Microsoft in 2001 for failing to support the software in DishPlayer 7100 and 7200 with Dish ending their relationship with Microsoft and cease offering the DishPlayer 7100/7200 to its subscribers and, instead, produce their own in-house DVR; and DirecTV would eventually drop Microsoft's UltimateTV and keep DirecTiVo as its only DVR offering for quite some time.

Other distributors' competing DVR sets in the United States include Comcast and Verizon, although both distribute third-party hardware from manufacturers such as Motorola and the former Scientific Atlanta unit of Cisco Systems with this functionality built-in. Verizon uses boxes fitted for FiOS, allowing high-speed Internet access and other features. However, TiVo is compatible with the FiOS TV service because when the TV programming arrives at the home via FiOS Fiber to the Home network, it is converted to CableLabs specification QAM channels exactly as those used by cable TV companies. AT&T is an IPTV service that is incompatible with the TiVo.

Despite having gained 234,000 subscribers in the last quarter of 2011,[40] as of January 2012 TiVo had only (approximately) 2.3 million subscribers in the United States. This is down from a peak of 4.36 million in January 2006.[41] As of January 31, 2016, TiVo reported 6.8 million subscribers.[42]

Issues

[edit]
Green screen of death encountered for serious errors on TiVo devices

Privacy concerns

[edit]

TiVo collects detailed usage data from units via broadband Internet. As units are downloading schedule data, they transmit household viewing habits to TiVo Inc. Collected information includes a log of everything watched (time and channel) and remote keypresses such as fast forwarding through or replaying content.[43] Many users were surprised when TiVo released data on how many users rewatched the exposure of Janet Jackson's breast during the 2004 Super Bowl.[44] TiVo records usage data for their own research and they also sell it to other corporations such as advertisers.[45] Nielsen and TiVo have also previously collaborated to track viewing habits. This data is sold to advertising agencies as a way of documenting the number of viewers watching specific commercials to their corporate clients.[46]

TiVo has three levels of data collection. By default, the user is in "opt-out" status, where all usage data is aggregated by ZIP Code, and individual viewing habits are not tracked. Certain optional features and promotions require the user to opt in, and individual information is then collected for targeted show suggestions or advertising. Users can request that TiVo block the collection of anonymous viewing information and diagnostic information from their TiVo DVR.[47]

Litigation

[edit]

TiVo holds several patents regarding digital video recorder technology, including one for its "Time Warp" feature, which have been asserted against cable TV operators and competing DVR box makers.[48][49]

Opposition by content providers

[edit]

Content flagging

[edit]

In September 2005, a TiVo software upgrade added the ability for broadcasters to "flag" programs to be deleted after a certain date. Some customers had recordings deleted, or could not use their flagged recordings (transfer to a computer or burn to DVD), as they could with unflagged material. The initial showing of this for random shows was a bug in the software.[50] It later was enabled on pay-per-view and video-on-demand content.

Pop-up advertisements

[edit]

During early 2005, TiVo began test marketing "pop-up" advertisements to select subscribers, to explore it as an alternative source of revenue.[51] The idea was that as users fast-forward through certain commercials of TiVo advertisers, they would also see a static image ad more suitable and effective than the broken video stream.[52][53]

At its announcement, the concept of extra advertisements drew heavy criticism from subscribers. Some lifetime subscribers were upset that they had already paid for a service based upon their previous ad-free experience, while others argued that they had purchased the service for the specific purpose of dodging advertisements. In 2007, TiVo made changes to its pop-up ad system to show pop-up ads only if the user fast-forwards through a commercial that has a corresponding pop-up ad.[54][55]

In 2019, some TiVo DVRs began running "pre-roll advertisements." These ads are short, but mandatory. The ads run before the user can play a recorded program. The ads are downloaded from the Internet, so a brief delay occurs before the mandatory ads begin, further delaying playback. Only TiVo DVRs using TiVo Experience 4 software (Roamio, Bolt, Edge, etc.) have this forced advertising, earlier TiVo software does not deploy pre-roll ads.

GNU General Public License and Tivoization

[edit]
Main article: Tivoization

In 2006, the Free Software Foundation decided to combat TiVo's technical system of blocking users from running modified software.

This behavior, which Richard Stallman dubbed Tivoization, was tackled by creating a new version of the GNU General Public License, the GNU GPLv3, which prohibits this activity.[56]

The kernel of the operating system of TiVo-branded hardware, the Linux kernel, is distributed under the terms of the GNU GPLv2. The FSF's goal is to ensure that all recipients of software licensed under the GPLv3 are not restricted by hardware constraints on the modification of distributed software.

This new license provision was acknowledged by TiVo in its April 2007 SEC filing: "we may be unable to incorporate future enhancements to the GNU/Linux operating system into our software, which could adversely affect our business".[57]

CableCard Support Uncertainty (USA)

[edit]

In September 2020, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) changed its rules so that cable television providers no longer must support CableCard. Providers may choose to keep supporting CableCard, but TiVo owners have no assurance. The cable television provider may discontinue CableCard support at any time.[58]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

TiVo

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
TiVo is an American technology company that developed the first consumer (DVR), a device that stores television programming on a hard drive and enables features such as pausing live broadcasts, instant replay, and commercial skipping through patented "Time Warp" software. Founded in 1997 by engineers Jim Barton and Mike Ramsay, TiVo launched its inaugural Series 1 DVR in 1999 as a subscription-based , initially compatible with cable and satellite systems. The innovation disrupted linear television scheduling by empowering viewers with time-shifted consumption, earning induction into the Hall of Fame despite limited due to from integrated provider DVRs. TiVo generated substantial revenue through patent enforcement, securing settlements exceeding $1 billion from entities including () for $500 million and Verizon for $250 million, affirming the legal validity of its core DVR technologies. In 2019, TiVo merged with Rovi Corporation under parent , shifting focus from hardware; by October 2025, it discontinued standalone DVR sales after 26 years, continuing software licensing and service support amid streaming dominance.

Origins and Early Development

Founding and Initial Concept (1997–1999)

TiVo was founded in 1997 by Jim Barton and Mike Ramsay, two engineers with backgrounds in systems, in Alviso, . Barton had served as lead software architect on Time Warner's Full Service Network (also known as the Orlando project), an experimental initiative from 1994 to 1997 that explored set-top boxes with hard drives for video-on-demand and networked content delivery, though the project ultimately failed due to technical and cost barriers. Ramsay, who had sold workstations for media applications, partnered with Barton to commercialize hard drive-based video storage ideas derived from these experiences. The company's initial concept centered on a gateway or network server designed to centralize and manage across household devices, reflecting the founders' vision for integrated . However, early feedback revealed that abstract networking benefits were difficult to demonstrate and explain to consumers, prompting a strategic pivot toward a more tangible application: a (DVR) that digitized, compressed, and stored signals on an internal . This shift emphasized user-centric features like pausing live broadcasts, instant replay, and time-shifted playback, addressing practical needs such as interrupting viewing for unforeseen delays. Prototype development in 1997–1998 focused on overcoming hard drive fragmentation issues for seamless real-time recording, recruiting engineers from to implement defragmentation algorithms. Hardware selections included Sony's MPEG-2 encoder for video compression, IBM's PowerPC processor for computation, and drives for storage, paired with a customized —the first real-time modification of for —to ensure low-latency performance without dropped frames. These demos effectively showcased the DVR's value, such as skipping commercials via fast-forward, which secured initial funding and validated the hybrid model of one-time hardware purchase plus monthly subscription for program guide data and recommendations. By late 1998, the concept had evolved into a viable product framework, setting the stage for commercial trials in 1999.

Launch and First Products (1999–2000)

TiVo's inaugural shipped to customers on March 31, 1999, manufactured in partnership with as the company's first commercial hardware product. This Series 1 model, internally codenamed "" due to the rare astronomical event coinciding with the release date, represented the debut of a standalone consumer DVR capable of recording television without videotapes, using a for storage. The device featured basic functionalities including scheduled recording via an and playback controls such as pause and rewind during live TV, powered by TiVo's running on a MIPS processor with 8 MB of RAM. Priced at $499 plus a required subscription fee for the service guide data, the initial units offered recording capacities ranging from 14 to 30 hours depending on the hard drive size, targeting early adopters in the U.S. market. The 1999 launch followed a prototype demonstration at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) earlier that year, where TiVo showcased its time-shifting capabilities to generate industry interest amid competition from cable set-top boxes and VCRs. handled production and retail distribution through consumer electronics channels, enabling TiVo to focus on while avoiding full-scale . Initial units required users to phone in for activation and relied on dial-up modem connections for periodic guide updates from TiVo's servers, a process that underscored the nascent state of always-on connectivity in homes at the time. By 2000, TiVo expanded its product lineup with the first DirecTiVo units, integrating DVR functionality directly into DirecTV satellite receivers co-developed with the satellite provider and Philips. These hybrid devices, released starting in early 2000, combined TiVo's recording software with DirecTV's tuner hardware, offering seamless integration for satellite subscribers and capacities up to 20 hours on initial models. This partnership marked TiVo's pivot toward licensed technology in set-top boxes, broadening accessibility beyond standalone purchases and addressing limitations of the original Series 1's compatibility with analog cable or antenna inputs. The DirecTiVo launch helped TiVo navigate early market challenges, including high upfront costs and the need for consumer education on DVR benefits over traditional recording methods.

Technological Innovations

Core DVR Functionality

The core functionality of TiVo's (DVR) involves capturing television signals from sources such as antennas, cable set-top boxes, or satellite receivers, digitizing and compressing the analog video onto an internal hard drive for storage and on-demand playback. This time-shifting capability, first commercialized in TiVo's Series 1 models released on March 31, 1999, allowed users to record programs without the limitations of analog , such as degradation or . The initial devices supported up to 14 hours of standard-definition storage on a 30 GB hard drive and retailed for $499 plus a subscription fee for the (EPG) data. A hallmark feature was buffering signals for approximately 30 minutes, enabling users to pause broadcasts mid-stream, rewind to review content, or fast-forward through segments during playback. Recordings could be scheduled manually or automatically via the on-screen EPG, which displayed program listings fetched periodically over a dial-up phone connection; single-show or "season pass" options facilitated one-touch setup for recurring series. Playback controls included variable-speed fast-forward and rewind, , and frame-by-frame advancement, all processed through the device's compression for efficient storage. TiVo DVRs integrated tuners to decode incoming signals, with early models featuring a single tuner for basic recording while viewing another channel via pass-through, though simultaneous operations required workarounds like external splitters. The system operated independently of the subscription service for core recording and playback once content was captured, but relied on it for guide updates and metadata, underscoring the device's hybrid hardware-software . This foundation distinguished TiVo from prior VCRs by enabling to recordings and seamless integration of live and stored content.

Hardware Evolution

TiVo's initial hardware, the Series 1 DVRs, launched on March 31, 1999, through partnerships with (HDR110) and (SVR-2000), utilized PowerPC processors and encoding for standard-definition recording on hard drives ranging from 13 to 60 GB. These units supported cable, antenna, and inputs but lacked high-definition capabilities and multi-tuner support, limiting simultaneous recordings to one channel. The Series 2, introduced in 2002, marked a redesign with integrated USB ports for networking and external storage expansion, alongside larger hard drives of 40 to 250 GB. This generation enabled basic playback and improved responsiveness, though still focused on SD content. High-definition recording debuted in integrated DirecTiVo units like the Philips DSR6000 in 2000 and the HR10-250 in 2006, but standalone Series 3 HD models followed in 2006 with hard drives (initially 250 GB ), supporting up to 300 hours of SD or 32 hours of HD recording. These featured metallic , dual tuners for cable or OTA, and outputs, enhancing compatibility with modern TVs.
SeriesRelease YearKey Hardware Specs
Series 11999PowerPC CPU, 13-60 GB HDD, single tuner, SD-only
Series 22002Redesigned platform, 40-250 GB HDD, USB networking, SD-focused
Series 32006250 GB HDD, dual tuners, , 32 HD hours capacity
The Series 4 (2010) expanded to larger drives and refined remotes, while Series 5 Roamio (2013) introduced models with 1 TB (150 HD hours) to 3 TB (450 HD hours) storage, support for four simultaneous digital cable recordings, and improved processors for faster navigation. Series 6 Bolt (2015) added 4K UHD support and QuickView thumbnail previews, with 3 GB RAM and multi-tuner OTA/cable hybrids. The Series 7 Edge (2019) upgraded to a BCM7278 CPU, 4 GB RAM, ports, and / compatibility, enabling faster boot times and enhanced streaming integration. TiVo ceased production and sales of its DVR hardware in October 2025, shifting focus to software and IP licensing after 26 years of hardware development.

Software Features and Subscriptions

TiVo's software provides core recording capabilities, including pausing, rewinding, and fast-forwarding with frame-accurate control, which revolutionized time-shifted viewing by buffering incoming signals for instant access. The interface features a unified system that integrates linear TV, streaming apps, and on-demand content through an intuitive grid guide and search functionality. Advanced search tools allow users to query by title, , director, keyword, or category, with results spanning broadcast, cable, and streaming sources. A signature feature is OnePass, which automatically records and organizes every available episode of a selected series into a dedicated My Shows folder, pulling from multiple providers without manual intervention per episode. Complementing this, WishList searches continuously scan programming for matches to user-defined criteria—such as specific performers, genres, or phrases—and prioritize recordings accordingly, enabling proactive content discovery across channels. User feedback mechanisms, including thumbs-up and thumbs-down ratings, refine personalized recommendations, adapting suggestions based on viewing habits and preferences. As of 2025, TiVo's subscription model requires ongoing service fees to access guide data, recording features, and software updates, with plans varying by device and commitment level. Monthly options include $14.99 for TiVo EDGE devices with a one-year commitment (plus a $75 early termination fee) or $19.99 without commitment, covering essentials like program listings and cloud connectivity. Lifetime service, priced at $549.99 for eligible hardware, eliminates recurring fees but is limited to pre-2025 purchases following the discontinuation of standalone DVR manufacturing on October 1, 2025. Annual plans were phased out in September 2025, transitioning subscribers to monthly billing at rates like $9.95 for legacy users. These subscriptions underpin TiVo OS deployments on smart TVs and partner devices, emphasizing software licensing over hardware sales.

Business Evolution

Growth and Partnerships (2000s)

Following its 1999 launch, TiVo experienced rapid subscriber growth in the early , expanding from a small retail base to tens of thousands of users through hardware partnerships and satellite integrations. By mid-2000, the company had approximately 48,000 subscribers, driven by initial manufacturing collaborations with and , which produced TiVo-enabled devices for consumer purchase. In 2000, TiVo secured a pivotal deal with to co-develop set-top boxes incorporating TiVo software, which by 2005 accounted for 60% of TiVo's subscribers and facilitated broader adoption among satellite TV households. Financial metrics reflected this expansion amid heavy marketing investments; first-quarter 2000 revenues from subscriptions reached $424,000, though net losses stood at $24 million due to scaling efforts. By October 2000, quarterly revenues had risen 39% to $1 million, underscoring accelerating service uptake despite ongoing losses of $64 million for the period. Additional capital infusions, such as 's $200 million investment in 2000 for an AOL TV integration, bolstered TiVo's ability to innovate features like enhanced program guides while pursuing content partnerships with networks including and . Mid-decade partnerships with cable operators marked a shift toward operator-deployed DVRs, countering in-house solutions from providers. In March 2005, TiVo announced a multi-year alliance with , enabling the cable giant to offer TiVo-powered DVRs to subscribers, with terms emphasizing service commitments over minimum deployment guarantees to align incentives. This deal, alongside a 2005 advertising agreement with , expanded TiVo's revenue streams beyond hardware sales to include service fees and targeted ads. Subscriber additions slowed relative to market-wide DVR proliferation—TiVo gained 623,000 net subscriptions from 2005 to 2007, while total U.S. DVR households surged 161% to 23.5 million—but these alliances positioned TiVo as a premium software layer amid rising competition from integrated cable boxes.

Acquisitions and Restructuring (2010s–2020s)

In April 2016, Rovi Corporation announced its acquisition of for approximately $1.1 billion, consisting of $10.70 per share in cash and stock, a deal completed on September 8, 2016, after which the combined entity was renamed . This merger integrated TiVo's recording technology with Rovi's metadata and discovery services, expanding the company's patent portfolio to over 11,000 assets and aiming to enhance content recommendation capabilities across 28 million households. Prior to the acquisition's closure, TiVo Inc. initiated a in February 2016, eliminating 50 positions—roughly 7% of its workforce—to prioritize multichannel video programming distributor (MVPD) partnerships over retail hardware sales, amid declining standalone DVR demand. On December 19, 2019, entered a merger-of-equals agreement with Corporation, valued at around $3 billion, which closed on June 1, 2020, forming Holding Corporation and combining TiVo's video platforms with Xperi's audio, imaging, and connectivity technologies, including over 10,000 patents. The structure positioned IP licensing as a core revenue driver while maintaining TiVo-branded products and services. In May 2021, TiVo Corporation acquired select assets of bankrupt MobiTV Inc. for $18.5 million (including $17.4 million in cash and assumed liabilities), securing and customer contracts for application-based pay TV delivery to bolster its IPTV solutions and expand market reach among smaller operators. Later that year, TiVo experienced further restructuring, including departures of key product executives such as VP Chris Thun and his team, alongside SVP/GM Michael Hawkey, reflecting ongoing adaptations to streaming competition and reduced hardware reliance. By October 2022, Holding Corporation completed a corporate separation, spinning off its IP licensing operations (including much of the combined portfolio) as independent Adeia Inc., while retaining the product and platform business—encompassing TiVo video services, DTS audio, and —under , to streamline operations and focus each entity on distinct revenue models amid market pressures from . This divestiture followed years of integration challenges post-mergers, enabling targeted investments in software licensing over legacy hardware.

Shift to Software and Services (2020s)

In June 2020, TiVo completed its merger with Corporation, an all-stock transaction valued at approximately $3 billion that integrated TiVo's operations into a broader entity focused on licensing and software platforms for consumer entertainment. The merger emphasized synergies in IP , with TiVo's DVR technology, user interfaces, and recommendation algorithms licensed to pay-TV providers, manufacturers, and streaming services rather than sold as standalone hardware. This pivot aligned with declining demand for physical set-top boxes amid the rise of cloud-based DVRs and integrated operating systems. Post-merger, TiVo's revenue increasingly derived from licensing deals covering features like voice control, multi-screen synchronization, and personalized content discovery. For example, in February 2021, TiVo extended its IP licensing agreement with Sony Corporation, enabling integration of TiVo's search and recommendation technologies into Sony's connected TVs and media devices. Similar partnerships with operators such as Alticast reinforced TiVo's role in delivering software for video-on-demand and hybrid broadcast-broadband experiences, generating recurring royalties over one-time hardware sales. By prioritizing software scalability, the company reduced manufacturing costs and dependency on cable/satellite subscriptions, adapting to fragmented viewing habits driven by OTT platforms. This strategic evolution culminated in the discontinuation of standalone DVR hardware sales effective October 1, 2025, after 26 years of production, with the last model being the TiVo Edge released in 2019. TiVo redirected resources to branded operating systems and apps for smart TVs, emphasizing cloud-integrated services that support live TV pausing, series recording, and metadata-driven discovery without proprietary boxes. Existing subscribers retained service access, but new deployments favored licensed software embedded in operator gateways or , reflecting broader industry trends toward and IP-centric models.

Market Dynamics

Competitors and Adoption Barriers

TiVo faced early direct competition from , a rival DVR launched in 1999 by Replay Networks, which offered similar recording capabilities but included features like automatic commercial skipping and network sharing that drew legal challenges from content owners. initially competed on price and features, with models starting at around $700, but its market presence diminished after acquisitions and lawsuits, leaving TiVo as the dominant standalone DVR brand by the early . By the mid-2000s, the primary competitors shifted to proprietary DVRs from cable and providers, such as 's DVR rentals and DirecTV's integrated set-top boxes, which bundled recording functionality with subscription services without requiring separate hardware purchases. These operator-supplied devices gained traction because they eliminated compatibility issues with pay-TV signals and offered seamless integration, allowing providers to control the and upsell features like on-demand content. Cable companies like accelerated their own DVR deployments around 2004-2005, capturing significant market share as TiVo's standalone units struggled against these subsidized alternatives. Adoption of TiVo was hindered by high upfront costs, with initial models priced at $499 in 1999 plus a $9.95-$12.95 monthly service fee for guide data and features, making it less accessible compared to free broadcast or basic cable setups. Technical barriers included early incompatibility with analog cable systems, requiring users to rely on or over-the-air signals until support in 2003, which still involved complex setup and tuning adapter workarounds that deterred mainstream consumers. Cable operators further impeded adoption by resisting third-party devices that bypassed their set-top boxes, viewing TiVo as a to revenue from rented equipment and premium channels; this led to preferential promotion of in-house DVRs, which by 2007 accounted for the majority of U.S. DVR households while TiVo held under 10% . Limited licensing deals with providers like helped TiVo somewhat, but widespread operator cloning of DVR software without full IP payments fragmented the market and reduced incentives for consumers to choose standalone TiVo units over bundled services.

Market Share Trajectory

TiVo's subscriber base grew rapidly following its 1999 launch, reaching approximately 1.9 million installed units by early 2003 through direct retail sales and early partnerships. By 2005, TiVo accounted for about one-third of the roughly 6.5 million U.S. households equipped with recorders, reflecting its early dominance in the nascent DVR market amid limited competition. Retail subscriptions peaked at 4.45 million in December 2006, driven by consumer adoption of standalone boxes, before beginning to contract as multichannel video programming distributors (MVPDs) like cable and providers rolled out their own subsidized DVR services, eroding TiVo's standalone appeal. Total subscriptions, including those from licensing deals with MVPDs, rebounded in the , surpassing the 2006 peak to reach 4.5 million by April 2014 and climbing further to over 6.5 million by late 2015, bolstered by international expansions and operator deployments such as with in the UK. This growth masked underlying retail weakness, as MVPD-provided DVRs proliferated—by the mid-, over 50% of U.S. pay-TV households had DVR access, mostly via operator boxes rather than TiVo-branded hardware—reducing TiVo's to a fraction of total DVR penetration. The trajectory reversed amid and streaming's ascent, with linear TV viewership declining and services like surpassing TiVo's subscriber scale by (7.5 million vs. TiVo's 4.4 million). High ongoing service fees, limited integration with over-the-top platforms, and commoditization of DVR functionality in smart TVs and streaming devices accelerated erosion; retail demand waned as consumers favored ad-skipping via apps over dedicated hardware. By the , TiVo's hardware relevance diminished sharply, culminating in the discontinuation of physical DVR sales on October 1, , as the company pivoted to software licensing and advertising platforms amid shrinking pay-TV DVR markets. This exit reflected a broader causal shift: streaming's on-demand model obviated time-shifting needs, while MVPDs retained control over bundled DVRs, leaving TiVo's independent near zero in consumer hardware by .

Patent Enforcement Victories

TiVo secured significant patent enforcement successes through litigation centered on its foundational U.S. No. 6,233,389, which covers the "Time Warp" technology enabling recording and playback functionality in DVRs. These efforts, spanning the and , resulted in verdicts, injunctions, and settlements totaling hundreds of millions of dollars, affirming the validity and infringement of TiVo's against major and cable providers. In a landmark case against Communications (later ), a federal jury in , on April 13, 2006, found willful infringement of the Time Warp patent and awarded TiVo $74 million in damages, leading to a permanent requiring EchoStar to disable DVR features on millions of set-top boxes. The U.S. District Court enforced the injunction, and subsequent contempt proceedings in 2010 resulted in an additional $300 million award for EchoStar's continued violations, partially upheld by the Federal Circuit in , which established a "colorably different" standard for assessing post-injunction infringement. This culminated in a May 2011 settlement where DISH and EchoStar paid TiVo $500 million, including an initial $300 million, while dismissing all litigation and dissolving injunctions. TiVo also prevailed in International Trade Commission (ITC) proceedings against Comcast. On November 22, 2017, the ITC issued a final determination finding infringement of TiVo patents related to set-top box technology, prohibiting Comcast from importing infringing devices and imposing a limited exclusion order. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed this in part on March 2, 2020, upholding the ITC's ban on Comcast's imports for a second infringement finding and reinforcing TiVo's claims on DVR and program guide innovations. Other enforcement actions yielded favorable outcomes, including a 2012 settlement with Verizon Communications for $250.4 million to resolve infringement claims on DVR patents and establish a licensing agreement, following TiVo's 2009 lawsuit. These victories collectively generated over $1 billion in licensing revenue and settlements from entities including cable operators and manufacturers by the mid-2010s, bolstering TiVo's amid competitive pressures.

Key Litigations Against Broadcasters and Tech Firms

TiVo engaged in extensive patent enforcement actions primarily targeting digital video recorder (DVR) technologies developed by cable, satellite, and telecommunications providers, asserting infringement of core patents such as U.S. Patent No. 6,233,389 covering "time-warp" functionality for buffering and replaying television content. These suits, initiated from the mid-2000s onward, generated over $1 billion in settlements and judgments, sustaining TiVo's business amid declining hardware sales, though critics contended the patents enabled aggressive licensing akin to a "TiVo tax" on ubiquitous DVR features. A landmark case was TiVo Inc. v. Corp., filed in 2004, where a federal jury found in 2006 that 's (now ) DVRs willfully infringed TiVo's time-shifting patents, awarding $74 million in damages with potential for trebling due to willfulness. The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit affirmed the infringement in 2008 and again in 2011 after contempt proceedings for non-compliance with an requiring DVR disablement, culminating in a $500 million settlement in May 2011 that included $300 million upfront and dismissal of all claims. TiVo pursued similar claims against , with litigation escalating after a licensing agreement expired in 2016; the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC) ruled in 2019 that certain Comcast set-top boxes infringed TiVo patents related to program guides and DVR functionality, recommending import bans later affirmed on appeal. The dispute, spanning multiple patents and courts including the Central District of , resolved in November 2020 via a 15-year cross-licensing deal covering intellectual property portfolios, ending four years of contention without disclosed financial terms. Other significant resolutions included a 2012 settlement with for at least $215 million through 2018, addressing U-verse DVR infringement, and a Verizon agreement yielding $250.4 million, comprising $100 million initial payment plus recurring royalties for wireless and FiOS services. These outcomes underscored TiVo's strategy of leveraging Federal Circuit precedents to extract value from providers adopting analogous recording technologies, though enforcement waned as streaming supplanted traditional DVRs.

Controversies and Criticisms

Tivoization and Open-Source Conflicts

refers to the practice of incorporating licensed under terms, such as the GNU General Public License version 2 (GPLv2), into hardware devices while implementing technological measures that prevent users from running modified versions of that software on the device. The term was coined by , founder of the (FSF), in 2007 during discussions surrounding the development of GPLv3, specifically naming it after TiVo's recorders (DVRs), which employed such restrictions. TiVo's devices, starting from models released in the early 2000s, ran a customized and components under GPLv2 but used cryptographic signing to verify software integrity, blocking unauthorized modifications primarily to safeguard against piracy and maintain service reliability. This approach sparked debate within the open-source community over GPL compliance and the scope of software freedoms. The FSF argued that undermined the GPLv2's intent by rendering user modifications effectively unusable on the original hardware, despite TiVo fulfilling the license's distribution requirements. In response, GPLv3 introduced an anti- provision in Section 6, mandating that device manufacturers provide installation instructions and keys for modified GPLv3 software, aiming to ensure users' "right to install." However, , creator of the , and many kernel contributors rejected GPLv3's anti- clause, viewing it as an overreach that imposed hardware obligations on software licensees and potentially deterred commercial adoption of . They maintained that TiVo remained fully compliant with GPLv2, as the license does not regulate hardware design, and emphasized that widespread use of in proprietary devices like TiVo advanced the kernel's development through contributions and testing. TiVo addressed the criticism by affirming its adherence to GPLv2 terms, including releasing modified for its Linux-based software upon request, but declined to adopt GPLv3, stating in that future software updates would not be compatible with the new license's restrictions. No legal enforcement actions were pursued against TiVo by the FSF or other GPL copyright holders, as its practices aligned with GPLv2's explicit requirements, highlighting a divide between ideological advocates and pragmatic developers prioritizing ecosystem growth. The controversy influenced broader open-source licensing dynamics, with the remaining under GPLv2 to avoid alienating hardware vendors, while GPLv3's clause addressed in projects seeking stricter user freedoms.

Content Provider Opposition and Restrictions

Content providers, particularly Hollywood studios and broadcasters, expressed significant opposition to TiVo's digital video recording capabilities from the early 2000s, primarily due to concerns over commercial skipping and unauthorized content distribution, which they argued threatened advertising revenue and intellectual property rights. In July 2004, major studios including Disney, Warner Bros., and Paramount, alongside the National Football League, petitioned the Federal Communications Commission to block TiVo's "TiVoToGo" feature, which enabled users to transfer recorded programs from TiVo devices to personal computers or portable players, citing risks of widespread piracy and redistribution. This opposition reflected broader industry fears that TiVo's time-shifting functionality, while upheld as fair use in precedents like the 1984 Sony Betamax case, facilitated ad avoidance at scale, potentially eroding the $50 billion annual U.S. television advertising market at the time. To mitigate such pushback, TiVo implemented various content protection measures, including compliance with the FCC's 2003 broadcast rule, which mandated digital tuners recognize a in high-definition broadcasts to prevent unencrypted copying or online sharing. TiVo's proprietary TiVoGuard was among four approved by the FCC in 2004 for enforcing these restrictions, limiting flagged content to within-device playback or short-range retransmission (e.g., 7 milliseconds proximity). Additionally, TiVo adhered to Macrovision analog standards, which blocked recording of "Copy Never" content, restricted transfers for "Copy Once" material to one generation, or limited "Copy No More" flagged recordings to seven days of unlimited playback before deletion. These concessions, while preserving core recording features, curtailed TiVo's expansion into portable or networked viewing, as evidenced by the company's software updates (e.g., version 7.2 in 2005) enforcing such flags even on analog inputs. Broadcasters and studios continued exerting influence through licensing agreements with cable and providers, often requiring DVRs like TiVo to disable or certain features during live events or premium content. For instance, networks could embed metadata to override auto-commercial detection in later TiVo iterations, though manual fast-forwarding remained available, underscoring providers' preference for technical and contractual barriers over outright bans. This dynamic persisted into the 2010s, with content owners against FCC proposals for open set-top box access in 2015–2016, arguing it would undermine negotiated protections against unlicensed streaming. Despite these restrictions, empirical data from the era showed TiVo users skipped commercials in only about 40–50% of viewings, suggesting opposition amplified perceived rather than actual threats to revenue models.

Privacy and User Data Concerns

TiVo's recorders have collected anonymized viewing from subscribers since the company's early years, aggregating information on program tune-ins, pauses, and rewinds to generate audience metrics sold to advertisers and networks. This practice, central to TiVo's beyond hardware sales, raised concerns as early as 2001, when the Foundation alleged that TiVo's user manuals misleadingly downplayed the extent of transmission to company servers, potentially tracking household viewing patterns without explicit consent. TiVo responded by asserting that remained detached from personally identifiable information, emphasizing aggregation over individual profiling. By 2003, TiVo formalized plans to monetize this through quarterly subscription reports and customized datasets detailing viewing habits by time of day, prompting critics to highlight risks of inferring sensitive personal details—such as political leanings or issues—from aggregated patterns, even without names attached. Users could of certain sharing via service settings, but default collection persisted, fueling debates over in an era predating widespread GDPR-like regulations. In , partnerships like one with Viacom amplified scrutiny, as TiVo's second-by-second from over 2 million households informed ad targeting for billions of viewers, with advocates questioning the adequacy of anonymization against re-identification techniques. Security vulnerabilities compounded these issues; in 2021, identified unencrypted data transmission in the TiVo Stream 4K device, exposing viewing metadata to interception risks until patched following disclosure. No major class-action lawsuits directly targeting TiVo's data practices emerged, unlike disputes, but ongoing opt-in/out mechanisms in TiVo's —covering personalized ads and third-party sharing—reflect persistent user control demands amid evolving streaming analytics. TiVo maintains that such data enhances service recommendations without compromising , prioritizing empirical aggregation over granular tracking.

Decline and Recent Developments

Hardware Discontinuation (2025)

In September 2025, , under parent company , ceased sales of its EDGE DVR hardware products, including set-top boxes and associated accessories, both directly online and through retail partners. This marked the end of TiVo's 26-year involvement in manufacturing physical DVR devices, with the company confirming that production had halted and remaining inventory was depleted. The discontinuation applied specifically to standalone and cable-integrated EDGE models, which had been TiVo's flagship hardware offerings for recording and time-shifting broadcast and cable content. The decision reflected TiVo's strategic shift away from hardware amid declining demand for DVR boxes in a market dominated by streaming services and integrated platforms. spokespeople emphasized that TiVo would continue providing software updates, service subscriptions, and technical support for existing hardware owners, ensuring functionality for devices under active TiVo service agreements. However, no new hardware development or partnerships for future DVR production were announced, signaling a full exit from the physical device sector. This move aligns with broader industry trends where consumers increasingly favor app-based recording on smart TVs and cloud DVRs from providers like or cable operators, reducing the viability of dedicated TiVo boxes. TiVo's pivot prioritizes licensing its operating system and analytics software to third-party TV manufacturers, aiming to embed its interface in millions of smart TVs by late 2025. Critics noted that while the hardware discontinuation ends an era for enthusiasts valuing TiVo's robust and OnePass features, it underscores the company's adaptation to software-as-a-service models over capital-intensive .

Pivot to Streaming and Analytics

In response to the obsolescence of standalone DVR hardware amid the dominance of streaming services, TiVo, operating under parent company Xperi Inc., ceased manufacturing and sales of physical DVR products, including the TiVo Edge series, effective October 1, 2025. This shift marked the end of TiVo's 26-year hardware era, with the company depleting remaining inventory and committing to ongoing software support for existing devices but redirecting resources toward platform-agnostic software solutions. The pivot was driven by market realities, including fragmented streaming ecosystems and consumer preferences for integrated, app-based viewing over dedicated set-top boxes. TiVo's streaming strategy centers on TiVo OS, a software platform deployed on smart TVs and connected devices, enabling unified access to live , on-demand content, and streaming apps with features such as personalized recommendations, , and cross-service discovery. By Q2 2025, TiVo One—a cross-screen aggregation service integrating broadcast, cable, and streaming—reached 3.7 million monthly active users, up from 2.5 million earlier in the year, with targeting 5 million by year-end 2025 and 7 million by 2026 through partnerships like for embedded OS deployment. These efforts emphasize reducing viewer fragmentation by bundling services, as evidenced by TiVo's Q3 2025 Video Trends Report, which found U.S. households averaging $212 monthly on video services—a 20% rise from $176 two years prior—and 62% of consumers favoring bundled packages over standalone apps to simplify navigation. Complementing its streaming focus, TiVo has expanded into and via TiVo for , providing data-driven insights to content providers and advertisers on viewer behavior, content discovery, and ad effectiveness across linear and streaming environments. Quarterly Video Trends Reports, drawing from anonymized usage data of millions of households, highlight trends such as declining time spent on traditional (down to 2.8 hours daily) and rising demand for ad-supported tiers, informing strategies for operators facing pressures. Xperi's Q2 2025 earnings reported $105.9 million in revenue, with product and technology segments—including TiVo OS licensing and ad platforms—contributing amid broader macroeconomic challenges like reduced demand. This arm positions TiVo as a mediator in the evolving media landscape, licensing IP for and rather than hardware sales.

Cultural and Industry Impact

Revolutionizing Consumer Control Over Media

TiVo's debut digital video recorder (DVR), launched on March 31, 1999, marked a pivotal shift by enabling consumers to pause, rewind, and record live television using a hard drive rather than cumbersome VHS tapes. This innovation introduced a 30-minute buffer for live broadcasts, allowing viewers to halt programming mid-airing—addressing practical interruptions like phone calls or family needs—and resume without loss of content. Unlike prior VCR systems, which demanded manual tape insertion, timer programming, and suffered from quality degradation over repeated use, TiVo automated recording via an electronic program guide, storing up to 14 hours of standard-definition content on its initial model priced at $499. The device's "Season Pass" feature permitted automatic, ongoing recording of preferred series, while "WishList" functionality scanned incoming broadcasts for keywords or actors, proactively curating content without viewer intervention. These capabilities empowered users to consume media on personal schedules, decoupling viewing from rigid network timetables and fostering time-shifting as a standard practice. Empirical data indicates DVR adoption, pioneered by TiVo, boosted overall television viewing by 10-12% through flexible access, as users recorded conflicting programs or revisited favorites at convenience. TiVo further enhanced control by facilitating fast-forwarding through commercials, wresting scheduling authority from advertisers and broadcasters who previously dictated ad exposure via linear broadcasts. This ad-skipping option, combined with multi-room viewing and networked transfers via later features like TiVoToGo (introduced 2005), transformed passive spectators into active curators of their entertainment experience. Though initial industry fears exaggerated universal ad avoidance—studies later showed varied fast-forward rates—TiVo's model undeniably prioritized consumer agency, influencing subsequent set-top boxes and streaming interfaces to incorporate similar on-demand functionalities.

Legacy in Time-Shifting and IP Precedents

TiVo's introduction of recording technology in 1999 marked a pivotal advancement in consumer time-shifting, enabling seamless pausing, rewinding, and fast-forwarding of through its buffer-based "Time Warp" system. This functionality, which stored up to 30 seconds of incoming video for instant replay and extended to full-program recording without videotapes, extended the principles established in the 1984 decision Sony Corp. v. Universal City Studios, where analog VCR time-shifting was deemed noninfringing. Unlike earlier devices, TiVo's software-driven approach integrated guide data for automated "Season Pass" recordings, fostering habitual deferred viewing and reducing reliance on linear broadcasts; by 2005, TiVo reported over 4 million subscribers, correlating with industry-wide shifts toward on-demand consumption that presaged streaming dominance. The technology's proliferation normalized time-shifting, prompting cable providers to integrate DVR features into set-top boxes by the mid-2000s, effectively commoditizing TiVo's innovations while diluting its . TiVo's features, including one-touch series recording and commercial-skipping capabilities, faced early scrutiny from content owners concerned over ad revenue erosion, yet courts generally upheld digital time-shifting as congruent with , absent evidence of market harm beyond theoretical displacement. This legacy endures in modern platforms, where on-demand playback and ad-skipping defaults trace roots to TiVo's disruption of scheduled viewing, with U.S. households averaging 4.6 hours of daily TV time in 2023—42% nonlinear—mirroring patterns TiVo accelerated. In , TiVo established enduring precedents through aggressive enforcement of its core , particularly U.S. Patent No. 6,233,389 covering video stream indexing and buffering for nonlinear playback. The landmark TiVo Inc. v. EchoStar Corp. litigation, initiated in 2004, culminated in a 2006 jury verdict of willful infringement against 's DVRs, awarding TiVo $74 million in and issuing a permanent with infringement and disablement provisions. 's purported redesigns failed to evade findings; in a 2011 en banc Federal Circuit ruling (7-5), the court affirmed the district court's "more than colorably different" standard for evaluating post- modifications, rejecting 's good-faith claims and upholding $90 million in sanctions, a decision the declined to review. This precedent strengthened patent holders' tools for enforcing injunctions against incremental software changes in tech products, influencing contempt proceedings by prioritizing objective similarity over subjective intent, as distinguished from Supreme Court guidance in GTE Sylvania. The case spurred a $500 million settlement with and in May 2011, alongside ongoing royalties, validating TiVo's IP as foundational to the DVR ecosystem and compelling competitors like to license technologies in subsequent International Trade Commission and district court disputes. Despite these victories, the rulings highlighted tensions in software patent enforceability amid rapid industry evolution, where court wins preserved revenue streams—totaling over $1 billion in settlements by 2018—but could not stem TiVo's hardware marginalization.

References

  1. https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-consumer-electronics-hall-of-fame-tivo
  2. https://xperi.com/blog/celebrating-25-years-of-tivo-party-like-its-1999/
  3. https://blog.tivo.com/?p=24333
  4. https://cecritic.com/news/news/tivo-ends-an-era-dvr-pioneer-exits-hardware-after-26-years
  5. https://www.irell.com/ourwork-recent-matters-23
  6. https://about.dish.com/news-releases?item=122830
  7. https://variety.com/2025/tv/news/tivo-stopped-selling-dvrs-exits-hardware-business-1236552025/
  8. https://www.pcmag.com/news/times-up-for-a-timeshifting-trailblazer-tivo-discontinues-its-standalone
  9. https://www.ithistory.org/honor-roll/mr-jim-barton
  10. https://www.notablebiographies.com/news/Ow-Sh/Ramsay-Michael-and-Barton-James.html
  11. https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-1-4302-0327-8_14
  12. https://onezero.medium.com/they-thought-it-was-black-magic-an-oral-history-of-tivo-7503d0ada8e0
  13. https://www.tivopedia.com/tivo-history.php
  14. https://www.encyclopedia.com/books/politics-and-business-magazines/tivo-inc
  15. https://electronics.howstuffworks.com/tivo.htm
  16. https://www.tivopedia.com/tivo-networking-features.php
  17. https://www.zippia.com/tivo-careers-11645/history/
  18. https://www.tivopedia.com/directv-and-tivo-history.php
  19. https://www.cnet.com/reviews/tivo-series3-32-hd-hours-review/
  20. https://www.tivopedia.com/model-tivo-series3.php
  21. https://www.weaknees.com/tivo-roamio-series5-faq.php
  22. https://www.weaknees.com/tivo-guide.php
  23. https://zatznotfunny.com/2019-10/the-incremental-tivo-edge-upgrade/
  24. https://www.tivo.com/products/tivo-os
  25. https://tivoidp.tivo.com/tivoCommunitySupport/s/article/How-to-Use-WishList-Searches
  26. https://tivoidp.tivo.com/tivoCommunitySupport/s/article/OnePass-FAQ
  27. https://www.tivo.com/support/how-to/how-create-wishlist-search
  28. https://tivoidp.tivo.com/tivoCommunitySupport/s/article/TiVo-Payment-Plans-and-Policies/
  29. https://www.amazon.com/TiVo-Cable-Streaming-Player-Vision/dp/B07YBT2YVQ
  30. https://tivocommunity.com/threads/tivo-annual-plans-being-eliminated.596728/
  31. https://www.cliffsnotes.com/study-notes/16697999
  32. https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/a-collective-obsession-with-tv-transforms-tivo-from-idea-to-reality/
  33. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna26534006
  34. https://variety.com/2000/biz/news/tivo-grows-subscriber-list-1117780779/
  35. https://variety.com/2000/digital/news/tivo-revs-subscribers-rise-losses-increase-1117788052/
  36. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB111084678955179372
  37. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB111089847979879900
  38. https://variety.com/2005/digital/features/tivo-records-deal-1117920639/
  39. https://abcnews.go.com/Business/story?id=3539926&page=1
  40. https://variety.com/2016/digital/news/tivo-rovi-acquisition-1-1-billion-1201763363/
  41. https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1088825/000108882516000265/jointpressreleasissuedbyth.htm
  42. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/30/business/dealbook/rovi-buys-tivo-in-1-1-billion-deal.html
  43. https://ipwatchdog.com/2016/05/05/tivo-rovi-merger/
  44. https://www.nexttv.com/news/tivo-cuts-50-jobs-amid-restructuring-402924
  45. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2020/Xperi-and-TiVo-Complete-Merger/default.aspx
  46. https://www.theverge.com/2019/12/19/21029945/tivo-xperi-merger-dvr-rovi-deal-patent-licensing
  47. https://techcrunch.com/2019/12/19/tivo-merges-with-technology-licensor-xperi-in-3-billion-deal/
  48. https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210512006063/en/TiVo-Corporation-Agrees-to-Acquire-MobiTV-Assets-From-Chapter-11-Bankruptcy
  49. https://www.lightreading.com/video-broadcast/tivo-wins-mobitv-auction-with-bid-of-18-5m
  50. https://zatznotfunny.com/2021-05/more-tivo-layoffs/
  51. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2022/Xperi-Inc.-Completes-its-Spin-Off-to-Become-an-Independent-Public-Company/default.aspx
  52. https://www.tvtechnology.com/news/xperi-completes-adeia-spin-off
  53. https://investors.adeia.com/news-releases/news-release-details/xperi-announces-details-completion-separation
  54. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2019/Xperi-and-TiVo-to-Combine-Creating-a-Leader-in-Consumer--Entertainment-Technology-and-IP-Licensing/default.aspx
  55. https://www.theverge.com/news/798997/tivo-stops-dvr-hardware-production-sales
  56. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2021/TiVo-Extends-IP-Licensing-Agreement-with-Sony/default.aspx
  57. https://www.accessnewswire.com/newsroom/en/banking-and-financial-services/wired-news-tivo-announces-renewed-ip-license-deal-with-alticast-set-t-493273
  58. https://business-stage.tivo.com/about-us/licensing
  59. https://entertainment.slashdot.org/story/25/10/08/0621226/tivo-exiting-legacy-dvr-business
  60. https://cordcuttersnews.com/tivo-stops-selling-dvrs-marking-the-end-of-an-era/
  61. https://www.chron.com/business/technology/article/Competitors-chipping-away-at-TiVo-s-throne-1557759.php
  62. https://www.latimes.com/business/story/2025-10-09/say-goodbye-to-tivo-the-box-that-revolutionized-how-we-watch-television
  63. https://fortune.com/2015/10/25/tivo/
  64. https://www.strategy-business.com/blog/How-TiVo-Confronted-the-Disruptors-Dilemma
  65. https://www.ecommercetimes.com/story/tivo-growth-triples-to-1-9-million-subscribers-36163.html
  66. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna6835553
  67. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tivo-surpasses-record-4-5-123700674.html
  68. https://www.wsj.com/articles/tivo-revenue-rises-on-record-quarterly-subscriber-additions-1448402557
  69. https://www.investors.com/news/technology/click/tivo-beats-forecasts-with-q1-sales-and-earnings/
  70. https://inspireip.com/why-tivo-failed/
  71. https://www.advanced-television.com/2025/10/06/tivo-exits-dvr-market/
  72. https://www.thedailybeast.com/tivo-is-finally-dead-as-company-pulls-device-off-market/
  73. https://ca.news.yahoo.com/tivo-stops-selling-dvrs-exiting-010331383.html
  74. https://www.irell.com/ourwork-recent-matters-20
  75. https://kollox.com/tivo-won-legal-battles-but-lost-the-streaming-revolution/
  76. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna12306690
  77. https://ir.echostar.com/news-releases/news-release-details/tivo-dish-network-and-echostar-announce-half-billion-dollar
  78. https://ipwatchdog.com/2011/05/02/tivo-dish-and-echostar-the-500-million-patent-settlement/
  79. https://www.reuters.com/article/technology/tivo-wins-set-top-box-patent-case-against-comcast-idUSKBN1DM0UT/
  80. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2020/ITC-Reaffirms-TiVos-Second-Infringement-Victory/default.aspx
  81. https://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/25/business/media/verizon-to-pay-250-million-to-tivo-in-patent-settlement.html
  82. https://deadline.com/2012/09/tivo-verizon-settle-patent-suit-342432/
  83. https://modern-counsel.com/2016/tivo/
  84. https://www.nexttv.com/news/comcast-and-tivo-reach-agreement-end-4-year-patent-fight
  85. https://www.mckoolsmith.com/newsroom-news-947
  86. https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/att-to-pay-tivo-215-million-to-settle-patent-lawsuit/
  87. https://sfconservancy.org/blog/2021/jul/23/tivoization-and-the-gpl-right-to-install/
  88. https://www.linfo.org/tivoization.html
  89. https://blog.codinghorror.com/tivoization-and-the-gpl/
  90. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna5482232
  91. https://www.wired.com/2004/07/hollywood-nfl-fight-tivo-sharing/
  92. https://www.fox19.com/story/2079704/tivo-vs-hollywood/
  93. https://cdt.org/wp-content/uploads/copyright/20040726tivoflag.pdf
  94. https://www.tvtechnology.com/opinions/fcc-approves-content-protection-technologies-for-broadcast-flag-use
  95. https://tivoidp.tivo.com/tivoCommunitySupport/s/article/Copy-Protection-FAQ
  96. https://www.cnet.com/culture/tivo-copy-protection-bug-irks-users-1/
  97. https://zatznotfunny.com/2006-08/tivo-macrovision-and-the-stealth-broadcast-flag/
  98. https://www.tvtechnology.com/news/content-owners-seek-to-block-tivo-plans
  99. https://deadline.com/2016/02/fcc-tom-wheeler-set-top-boxes-hollywood-oppose-1201704105/
  100. https://www.eff.org/id/deeplinks/2004/07/hollywood-finally-turns-tivo-part-ii
  101. https://www.orlandosentinel.com/2001/03/27/privacy-experts-uneasy-over-tivo-recorders/
  102. https://www.campaignlive.co.uk/article/watchdog-questions-tivo-privacy-issues/13274
  103. https://www.recordnet.com/story/news/2003/06/03/tivo-to-collect-sell-data/50730624007/
  104. https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-lazarus-20151106-column.html
  105. https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2015/nov/15/consumer-confidential-tivo-users-your-tv-watching-/
  106. https://www.consumerreports.org/electronics-computers/streaming-media/tivo-fixes-security-flaw-in-stream-4k-streaming-device-a5170806878/
  107. https://www.engadget.com/entertainment/tv-movies/tivo-has-discontinued-its-dvr-boxes-123037999.html
  108. https://thedesk.net/2025/10/tivo-stops-selling-dvrs/
  109. https://people.com/tivo-has-officially-stopped-selling-dvrs-after-more-than-25-years-heres-why-11831828
  110. https://www.webpronews.com/tivo-exits-dvr-hardware-market-pivots-to-smart-tv-software/
  111. https://lifehacker.com/tech/tivo-discontinued-its-dvrs
  112. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2025/Xperi-Inc--Announces-Second-Quarter-2025-Results/default.aspx
  113. https://ottverse.com/xperi-pushes-tivo-one-platform-forward-amid-tough-ctv-market/
  114. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/tivo-latest-video-trends-report-130000311.html
  115. https://blog.tivo.com/tivo-for-business/tivos-video-trends-report-finds-tv-viewers-are-spending-less-watching-smarter/
  116. https://s201.q4cdn.com/428489777/files/doc_financials/2025/q2/2025-Q2-Xperi-Earnings-Release-Final.pdf
  117. https://investor.xperi.com/news/news-details/2025/TiVo-Achieves-Significant-Growth-Milestones-in-Smart-TVs-and-Cross-Screen-Advertising/default.aspx
  118. https://blog.tivo.com/tivo-for-business/celebrating-25-years-of-pushing-the-boundaries-of-innovation/
  119. https://www.wsj.com/lifestyle/tivo-dvr-cord-cutting-5a428638
  120. https://nscreenmedia.com/from-tivo-to-netflix/
  121. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2004-nov-17-et-tivo17-story.html
  122. https://www.nytimes.com/2007/02/16/business/16commercials.html
  123. https://daringfireball.net/linked/2025/10/15/tivo-stops-selling-dvrs
  124. https://supreme.findlaw.com/legal-commentary/are-personal-video-recorders-such-as-replaytv-and-tivo-copyright-infringement-devices.html
  125. https://www.theverge.com/tech/802254/tivo-time-warp-patent-courtoom-battles-lost-tv-war
  126. https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=901062
  127. https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/cafc/09-1374/09-1374-2011-04-20.html
  128. https://caselaw.findlaw.com/us-federal-circuit/1564179.html
  129. https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/update-tivo-v-echostar
  130. https://www.wiley.law/newsletter-3767
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.