Hubbry Logo
IjenIjenMain
Open search
Ijen
Community hub
Ijen
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ijen
Ijen
Ijen
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

3D model of Ijen

Key Information

Map of Ijen Crater, where sulfur is mined
Traditional sulfur mining at Ijen. This image shows the dangerous and rugged conditions the miners face, including toxic smoke and high drops, as well as their lack of protective equipment. The pipes over which they are standing serve to guide sulfur vapors and condense them, thereby facilitating production.[2]

The Ijen volcano complex is a group of composite volcanoes located on the border between Banyuwangi Regency and Bondowoso Regency of East Java, Indonesia. It is known for its blue fire, acidic crater lake, and labour-intensive sulfur mining.

It is inside an eponymous larger caldera Ijen, which is about 20 kilometres (12 mi) wide. The Gunung Merapi stratovolcano is the highest point of that complex. The name "Gunung Merapi" means 'mountain of fire' in the Indonesian language; Mount Merapi in central Java and Marapi in Sumatra have the same etymology.

Ijen Geopark stretches across the entire regency which is specifically in the Mount Ijen area, Pulau Merah Beach, and Alas Purwo National Park. It has various geological, biological, and cultural sites. It became part of UNESCO Global Geoparks in 2023.

West of Gunung Merapi is the Ijen volcano, which has a one-kilometre-wide (0.62 mi) turquoise-coloured acidic crater lake. The lake is the site of a labour-intensive sulfur mining operation, in which sulfur-laden baskets are carried by hand from the crater floor. The work is paid well considering the cost of living in the area, but is very onerous.[3] Workers earn around US$13 per day and, once out of the crater, still need to carry their loads of sulfur chunks about three kilometers to the nearby Paltuding Valley to get paid.[4]

Many other post-caldera cones and craters are located within the caldera or along its rim. The largest concentration of post-caldera cones runs east–west across the southern side of the caldera. The active crater at Kawah Ijen has a diameter of 722 metres (2,369 ft) and a surface area of 0.41 square kilometres (0.16 sq mi). It is 200 metres (660 ft) deep and has a volume of 36 cubic hectometres (29,000 acre⋅ft).

The lake is recognised as the largest highly acidic crater lake in the world.[1] It is also a source for the river Banyupahit, resulting in highly acidic and metal-enriched river water which has a significant detrimental effect on the downstream river ecosystem.[5] During a scientific expedition in 2001, the pH of the lake was measured at <0.3.[6] On 14–15 July 2008, explorer George Kourounis took a small rubber boat out onto the acid lake to measure its acidity. The pH of the water at the lake's edges was measured to be 0.5 and in the middle of the lake 0.13 due to a high concentration of sulfuric acid.[7]

Blue fire crater

[edit]
See also: Blue lava

Since National Geographic mentioned the electric-blue flame of Ijen, tourist numbers have increased.[8] The phenomenon has long been known, but midnight hiking tours are a more recent offering. A two-hour hike is required to reach the rim of the crater, followed by a 45-minute hike down to the bank of the crater.

The blue fire is ignited sulfuric gas, which emerges from cracks at temperatures up to 600 °C (1,112 °F). The flames can be up to five meters (16 feet) high; some of the gas condenses to liquid and is still ignited.[9][10]

Ijen is the largest blue flame area in the world. Local people refer to it as Api Biru (Blue Fire).[11] The other location at which blue fire can be seen is in Dallol Mountain, Ethiopia.[12]

Sulfur mining at Ijen

[edit]

An active vent at the edge of the lake is a source of elemental sulfur and supports a mining operation. Escaping volcanic gases are channeled through a network of ceramic pipes, resulting in condensation of molten sulfur.[citation needed]

The sulfur, which is deep red when molten, pours slowly from the ends of these pipes and pools on the ground, turning bright yellow as it cools. The miners break the cooled material into large pieces and carry it away in baskets. Miners carry loads ranging from 75 to 90 kilograms (165 to 198 lb) up 300 metres (980 ft) to the crater rim, with a gradient of 45 to 60 degrees, and then 3 kilometres (1.9 miles) down the mountain for weighing. Most miners make this journey twice a day.

A nearby sulfur refinery pays the miners by the weight of sulfur transported; as of September 2010, the typical daily earnings were equivalent to approximately $13 US. The miners often receive insufficient protection while working around the volcano[13] and complain of numerous respiratory afflictions. There are 200 miners, who extract 14 tons per day — about 20% of the continuous daily deposit.[14]

Media

[edit]

Ijen and its sulfur mining was featured in the 1991 IMAX film Ring of Fire, and as a topic on the 5th episode of the BBC television documentary Human Planet.

In the documentary film War Photographer, journalist James Nachtwey visits Ijen and struggles with noxious fumes while trying to photograph workers. Michael Glawogger's film Workingman's Death is about sulfur workers.

[edit]
  • Blue flames caused by the burning of sulfur in the Ijen caldera
    Blue flames caused by the burning of sulfur in the Ijen caldera
  • Kawah Ijen volcano and crater lake, Java, viewed from Landsat 8
    Kawah Ijen volcano and crater lake, Java, viewed from Landsat 8
  • The sulfuric lake of Kawah Ijen Mountain's cauldron, Indonesia
    The sulfuric lake of Kawah Ijen Mountain's cauldron, Indonesia
  • Mt. Merapi, Ijen
    Mt. Merapi, Ijen
  • Sulfur ornaments from Ijen mines
    Sulfur ornaments from Ijen mines
  • The "blue lava" of Kawah Ijen
    The "blue lava" of Kawah Ijen
  • Kawah Ijen sulfur miner
    Kawah Ijen sulfur miner
  • Kawah Ijen
    Kawah Ijen

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ijen

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Kawah Ijen is a situated at the eastern end of island in , forming part of a larger volcanic complex within a and distinguished by its turquoise of extreme acidity and the combustion of gases that produce vivid blue flames visible at night. The active measures approximately 722 meters in diameter and 200 meters deep, hosting the world's largest highly acidic volcanic lake with a surface area of about 0.41 square kilometers and a value below 0.5 due to elevated concentrations of and dissolved metals. Rising to an elevation of 2,769 meters, the 's solfatara field emits and gases, which ignite upon contact with oxygen to form flames reaching up to five meters in height, a phenomenon driven by the high-temperature oxidation of deposits rather than molten lava. Kawah Ijen also sustains a manual operation where workers extract solidified from the floor amid toxic fumes and steep terrain, carrying loads of up to 90 kilograms per trip down the mountain for export, often under grueling conditions that highlight the site's hazardous geothermal activity. The has recorded eruptions as recent as 1993, primarily events involving steam and ash, underscoring its ongoing fumarolic vigor within the tectonically active Sunda zone.

Geography and Geology

Location and Topography

The Ijen volcanic complex lies on the border between and Bondowoso Regency in province, , approximately 8°03′S 114°14′E. This region positions Ijen within the Sunda volcanic arc, part of the tectonically active subduction zone where the Indo-Australian Plate converges beneath the Eurasian Plate. The complex spans a rugged highland area in eastern , across the narrow strait from , contributing to its status as a Global recognized for volcanic landscapes. Comprising a group of stratovolcanoes and associated cones, the topography features Gunung Merapi as the highest peak at 2,799 meters elevation, with Kawah Ijen crater at 2,386 meters. The summit hosts a broad roughly 16 kilometers in diameter, enclosing steep inner walls rising up to 300 meters high around the acidic crater lake of Kawah Ijen, which spans about 1 kilometer in width. Flanking slopes exhibit dissected volcanic terrain with fertile soils supporting agriculture, including coffee plantations, amid frequent solfataric activity vents. The overall relief transitions from high volcanic plateaus to incised valleys, shaped by erosion and ongoing geothermal processes.

Geological Formation

The Ijen volcanic complex lies within the subduction zone, where the Indo-Australian Plate subducts beneath the Eurasian Plate at a rate of approximately 7 cm per year, generating calc-alkaline magmatism that fuels arc volcanism. This tectonic setting has produced a chain of volcanoes across , with Ijen's activity linked to of the subducting slab and overlying mantle wedge. Volcanism at Ijen commenced around 300,000 years ago, constructing a large termed "Old Ijen" through repeated eruptions of andesitic to dacitic lavas and pyroclastics. formation followed during the Pleistocene, resulting from the collapse of the after a major that ejected an estimated 80 cubic kilometers of material, though the precise timing remains unconstrained beyond occurring prior to 50,000 years ago. The resulting measures approximately 15 km in diameter and 200–300 m deep, enclosing a field of smaller post-caldera . Subsequent intracaldera activity generated at least 22 volcanic cones, including Kawah Ijen, a composite cone rising to 2,799 m elevation with a crater 722 m wide and 200 m deep. These cones formed via phreatomagmatic and effusive eruptions, depositing layered andesitic deposits that dominate the complex's . The caldera's structural evolution reflects episodic magma recharge and evacuation, characteristic of subduction-related systems prone to collapse.

Volcanic Activity and Eruptions

The Ijen volcanic complex exhibits primarily phreatic and phreatomagmatic activity centered on the Kawah Ijen crater, where interactions between the hyper-acidic crater lake (pH ~0.5) and rising magmatic gases or heat trigger explosions without significant magma extrusion in recent history. Fumarolic emissions, dominated by sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and hydrogen sulfide (H₂S), persist continuously, with measured SO₂ fluxes reaching up to 100,000 tons per day during heightened unrest, contributing to the formation of elemental sulfur deposits and occasional combustion phenomena. The last magmatic eruption occurred in 1817, after which activity has been limited to phreatic events, seismic swarms, and gas-driven plumes, reflecting a system sustained by volatile release rather than large-scale magma ascent. Monitoring by Indonesia's Pusat Vulkanologi dan Mitigasi Bencana Geologi (PVMBG) tracks seismicity, gas emissions, and lake level changes, maintaining the volcano at Alert Level 2 (moderate unrest) as of recent assessments. Historical eruptions, documented since 1796, are infrequent but recurrent, with eight confirmed events from Kawah Ijen between 1796 and 1999, typically of low explosivity ( [VEI] 1-2). The 1817 eruption stands out as the most destructive, commencing on January 15 and lasting until February 18 (approximately 33 days), involving phreatomagmatic explosions that ejected the , produced ash falls, and generated lahars inundating villages in the Rogodiambi plain, resulting in 50-100 fatalities and widespread agricultural damage. Subsequent events, such as the 1936 Strombolian-to-Vulcanian eruption (VEI 2, November 5-25), involved ash plumes and ejecta but minimal casualties.
DateEruption TypeVEIKey Details
17962Explosions and ash emission from Kawah Ijen.
1817 Jan 15–Feb 18Phreatomagmatic2Lake ejection, lahars, 50-100 deaths.
1917 Feb 25–Mar 141Minor explosions and gas emissions.
1936 Nov 5–25Strombolian-Vulcanian2Ash plumes, ; largest historic event post-1817.
1952 Apr 22–241Short-lived explosions.
1993 Jul 3–Aug 11Seismic tremors, gas bursts.
1994 Feb 31Isolated explosion event.
1999 Jun 281Two explosions at Sibanteng site, audible detonations.
Post-1999 activity has included unrest without confirmed VEI-classified eruptions, such as a on May 29, 2020, producing a plume rising 250-500 m above the lake surface, and seismic signals indicating ongoing in April 2024. These events underscore the hazard potential from sudden pressure releases in the hydrothermal system, though no fatalities have been reported since 1817.

Natural Phenomena

Crater Lake Characteristics

The of Kawah Ijen , located within the active summit , exhibits extreme physical and chemical properties characteristic of hyper-acidic volcanic lakes. It spans a of approximately meters and reaches a maximum depth of 200 meters, forming a significant reservoir influenced by ongoing hydrothermal activity. The lake's volume is estimated at around 30 million cubic meters, making it one of the largest acidic crater lakes globally. Chemically, the lake water maintains a pH below 0.5, often approaching 0.3 or less, rendering it comparable in acidity to battery acid and inhospitable to most life forms despite isolated reports of extremophile microorganisms. This hyper-acidity stems from high concentrations of sulfuric acid and dissolved metals, with sulfate levels exceeding 70,000 mg/kg, chloride around 21,000 mg/kg, and fluoride up to 1,500 mg/kg, alongside total dissolved solids surpassing 100 g/L. The turquoise coloration arises from the interaction of these acidic fluids with rock minerals, though the lake's appearance can vary with fumarolic activity and precipitation. Water temperatures typically exceed 30°C, with measurements ranging from 42°C to 43°C in recent observations, reflecting subsurface magmatic heat sources that sustain the lake's dynamic equilibrium. Fluctuations in volume and chemistry occur due to events, rainfall, and seepage through the walls, contributing to downstream acidification via outlets like the Banyupahit River. These characteristics underscore Kawah Ijen's role as a natural for studying acidic hydrothermal systems, though direct sampling remains hazardous due to toxic gas emissions.

Blue Fire Mechanism

The blue fire phenomenon at Kawah Ijen arises from the combustion of sulfur-rich volcanic gases emerging from cracks in the crater walls. High-pressure gases, heated to approximately 600°C, contain sulfur vapor along with sulfur dioxide (SO₂), sulfur trioxide (SO₃), hydrogen chloride, and hydrogen fluoride. Upon exposure to atmospheric oxygen, the sulfur vapor ignites, producing intense blue flames that can reach heights of up to 5 meters. This process occurs primarily at night when visibility is enhanced, creating an appearance of flowing blue lava, though it involves no molten rock. Sulfur plays a central role due to its physical and chemical properties: it vaporizes at 444°C and combusts readily at around 600°C, with self-ignition possible as low as 248°C. The reaction primarily forms (SO₂) via S + O₂ → SO₂, but the characteristic hue results from the of excited atoms or molecules, where electrons return to by releasing photons in the wavelength. Unburned may condense into liquid form upon cooling, which flows briefly before solidifying or reigniting, contributing to the illusion of molten streams. These flames are concentrated in fields within the acidic environment, sustained by ongoing magmatic . The mechanism underscores Kawah Ijen's high sulfur flux, linked to its structure and proximity to zones, where mantle-derived volatiles enrich the . Observations confirm the flames' intensity correlates with gas emission rates, peaking during periods of heightened fumarolic activity without necessitating eruptions. This non-eruptive combustion poses hazards from toxic fumes but provides a rare surface manifestation of subsurface cycling.

Sulfur Mining Operations

Extraction Methods and Scale

Sulfur extraction at Kawah Ijen relies on manual labor to harvest deposits formed by the condensation of volcanic gases emanating from active vents. Miners descend approximately 200-300 meters into the using basic tools, including iron bars, shovels, and stones, to break solidified yellow blocks or slabs into manageable pieces. These fragments are collected and packed into handmade baskets, with typical loads ranging from 70 to 90 kilograms per carrier. The harvested sulfur is transported on the miners' shoulders along steep, narrow trails ascending to the rim, often amid choking fumes and extreme heat, before descending further to weighing stations at the volcano's base. A dedicated completes two to three round trips daily, navigating unmechanized paths that preclude the use of vehicles or animals due to the terrain's hostility and the site's status within a protected . Volcanic gases are channeled through rudimentary ceramic or metal pipes into condensation chambers, where they cool into liquid that solidifies for breaking and collection, sustaining the operation's primitive efficiency. Operationally, 200 to 300 miners, primarily local residents, engage in this work daily, yielding an estimated 14 tons of per day and positioning Kawah Ijen as one of Indonesia's largest natural producers. This output, extracted without modern machinery, represents only a portion of the site's potential yield, constrained by manual methods and safety limitations, with the supplying regional industries for applications in fertilizers, explosives, and chemical . Annual production sustains hundreds of families but remains vulnerable to volcanic activity fluctuations and health-related workforce reductions.

Economic Role and Labor Dynamics

Sulfur mining at Kawah Ijen serves as a primary economic activity for the remote Banyuwangi region in , , employing approximately 200 to 300 local men who otherwise face limited employment options such as subsistence farming. The operation, ongoing since 1968, produces for industrial uses including fertilizers, matches, and chemicals, with output transported via manual labor to buyers managed by state-linked enterprises. Daily yields depend on individual effort, with miners extracting and carrying 70 to 90 kilograms per load—often making two to three trips up steep, 3-kilometer paths from the crater floor at elevations over 2,700 meters. Labor dynamics revolve around a piece-rate system, where compensation is tied directly to the weight of delivered, typically yielding $7 to $15 per day for 10 to 12 hours of work, though earnings fluctuate with weather, gas emissions, and physical endurance. Miners operate in 15-day shifts followed by equal rest periods, lacking formal contracts, unions, or mandatory protective equipment, which exposes them to toxic and sulfuric gases without respirators in most cases. This informal structure sustains family incomes—often 1.5 times the regional average—but perpetuates health risks and income instability, as output-based pay discourages mechanization despite the site's status as one of the world's last labor-intensive mines. Despite these challenges, the job retains appeal over alternatives due to its relative pay premium in an area with high , though miners report stagnant wages amid rising living costs and tourism's indirect benefits.

Health and Safety Realities

Sulfur miners at Kawah Ijen face acute and chronic health risks primarily from of (SO₂) gas, which reaches concentrations exceeding safe limits by up to 40 times. Short-term exposure causes eye irritation, coughing, headaches, , and skin issues, as reported by workers during shifts in the crater. Long-term effects include elevated non-carcinogenic risks to the , potentially leading to chronic diseases, due to persistent SO₂ without adequate . Physical demands exacerbate health hazards, with miners transporting 70-90 kg loads of sulfur up steep, rocky paths multiple times daily, resulting in a risk of 5,032 times higher than in general occupations. Protective is minimal; most rely on damp cloths over the face rather than gas masks or gloves, as proper gear is often unaffordable or deemed to impede efficiency. Few miners use respirators consistently, increasing vulnerability to pulmonary infections and other gas-related ailments. Safety incidents underscore the perils, including falls, gas suffocation, and volcanic events; over four decades, 74 work-related deaths occurred, with 49 miners killed in a 1976 eruption from toxic gas release and landslides. No systematic protocols or regulatory enforcement adequately address these risks, leaving workers exposed to both environmental toxins and mechanical hazards in the absence of modern infrastructure.

Environmental and Health Impacts

Gas Emissions and Pollution

Kawah Ijen's volcanic activity releases substantial quantities of sulfur dioxide (SO₂) and hydrogen sulfide (H₂S) through fumaroles and combustion at high-temperature vents. SO₂ emissions average 238 ± 194 tonnes per day, positioning Ijen as a notable contributor among Indonesian volcanoes, though modest compared to global standards. These gases, with SO₂ comprising approximately 67% of total sulfur in the plume and H₂S the remainder, arise from magma degassing and the oxidation of H₂S during the blue fire phenomenon, which converts H₂S to additional SO₂. Ambient SO₂ concentrations around the crater vary from 480 to 6960 (ppb), consistently surpassing regulatory thresholds for safe exposure and indicating pervasive in the vicinity. In sulfur mining zones, levels escalate to 3.14–18.24 mg/m³, exceeding the U.S. EPA acute exposure limit of 1.97 mg/m³ and posing immediate hazards to workers lacking adequate protective equipment. Hazard quotient indices exceed 1.0 for both short-term and prolonged exposures, signaling elevated non-carcinogenic risks. Pollution from these emissions manifests in acute effects on miners and tourists, including eye irritation, coughing, headaches, , and skin rashes, attributable to irritant properties of SO₂ and H₂S. Chronic exposure correlates with respiratory disorders, though long-term epidemiological data remain limited. Environmentally, the gases contribute to acidic atmospheric deposition, potentially acidifying soils and vegetation downslope, while dispersing via prevailing winds to affect regional air quality without evidence of widespread transboundary impact.

Long-Term Ecological Effects

The hyperacidic of Kawah Ijen, with a consistently below 0.3, serves as the primary source of long-term ecological disruption through its discharge into the Banyupahit River, which spans approximately 45 kilometers and retains extreme acidity along its course. This natural volcanogenic pollution introduces elevated concentrations of toxic elements including aluminum, iron, , , and , rendering the river inhospitable to most aquatic life and altering downstream ecosystems. The persistent low inhibits macroinvertebrate populations and communities, fostering dominance by acid-tolerant microbial assemblages that exhibit reduced overall structured by the acidity gradient. Downstream agricultural soils irrigated with this contaminated water accumulate and trace elements over time, progressively degrading fertility and crop yields; for instance, paddies in Asembagus show elevated levels of and other metals in both and harvested crops, posing risks of in the . This , documented since at least the early 2000s, contributes to long-term desertification-like effects in affected lowlands, where elemental buildup correlates with diminished and nutrient cycling. Volcanic gas emissions, including from both natural fumaroles and intensified by activities, exacerbate localized acidification of soils and around the rim, though quantitative ecological data on mining-specific contributions remain limited compared to lake-derived impacts. While the itself harbors extremophilic microorganisms adapted to hyperacidity, such as acidophilic capable of reduction, these isolated niches do not mitigate broader riverine and terrestrial degradation. Seepage from geological faults further propagates acidic waters into tributaries like the Banyuputih , sustaining chronic pollution that affects fringes and coastal sediments, with heavy metal deposition observed as far as the Madura Strait. No comprehensive restoration efforts have reversed these effects, as the volcanic continuously replenishes the pollutant load, underscoring the dominance of endogenous geological processes over anthropogenic factors in driving persistent ecological alteration.

Tourism and Cultural Aspects

Development of Visitor Access

Visitor access to Kawah Ijen initially drew limited scientific interest, with French volcanologists Maurice and Katia Krafft documenting the site's unique features, including its acidic and deposits, during expeditions in 1971. Their work in the 1970s marked an early introduction of the volcano to international audiences, though public visitation remained minimal compared to the ongoing mining operations that began in 1954. Tourism expanded gradually in the late 20th and early 21st centuries, facilitated by the promotion of midnight hikes to observe the blue flames caused by combusting gases, a phenomenon long known locally but highlighted in media coverage starting around the . Local authorities in Banyuwangi and Bondowoso regencies began developing the site as a destination, constructing a primary from the Paltuding ranger post—a steep, approximately 3-kilometer path rising 1,200 meters in elevation, much of it paved for accessibility. The allows a 2- to 3-hour ascent to the crater rim, followed by a 45-minute descent to the lake floor, with guides often providing gas masks to mitigate exposure to toxic and emissions. By the mid-2010s, visitor numbers surged due to amplification of the and lake views, prompting enhancements such as expanded visitor centers offering geological and cultural information, online ticketing systems (with fees of 150,000 IDR per adult as of 2024), and improved road access from nearby Banyuwangi. The designation of the Ijen as a Global Geopark in 2023 further supported sustainable access development, emphasizing alternative trails and links to reduce environmental strain. Recent policies balance growing demand—peaking during the from April to October—with conservation, including monthly closures on the first Friday for recovery (Rijig Program) and temporary restrictions on proximity to limit gas exposure risks. Reopenings, such as in September 2024 following seismic monitoring, underscore , with authorities enforcing group tours and capacity limits to prevent on the narrow rim paths.

Media Portrayals and Public Perception

Media coverage of Kawah Ijen has prominently featured its nocturnal blue flames, produced by the of sulfuric gases escaping volcanic cracks at temperatures exceeding 600°C, as showcased in National Geographic's 2014 article describing the phenomenon as "stunning electric-blue flames" that form lava-like rivers of light. echoed this in 2014, reporting the flames' origin from high-pressure sulfuric gas vents igniting on contact with air, amplifying global fascination with the site's otherworldly visuals. Such portrayals, including BBC's "" series footage from 2011 depicting miners amid the crater's toxic environment, have positioned Ijen as a rare geological spectacle visible primarily at night due to daylight obscuring the flames. Documentaries have delved into the human element, with "Where Meets " (2013) following four miners navigating the volcano's active , emphasizing the juxtaposition of ethereal beauty and perilous labor. ARTE's "Kawah Ijen: The of " (date unspecified in available data) portrayed miners extracting in extreme conditions, rotating shifts in the 's inferno while exposed to lethal gases, framing the operation as an infernal toil. WIRED's 2020 profile described Mt. Ijen as "one of the most dangerous workplaces on ," detailing miners' daily descents into the without protective gear, breathing levels far above safe thresholds. Public perception reflects this duality, viewing Ijen's as mesmerizing and unique— one of only two global sites for consistent blue flames—while evoking sympathy for miners carrying 70-90 kg loads up steep paths for meager wages equivalent to $10-15 daily. Tourism surged post-media exposure, with noting in 2018 that the sulfur mine became a controversial draw, where visitors observe miners amid hazards, prompting debates on exploitation as tourists photograph workers for . Critiques, such as in a 2023 analysis questioning if tourists exploit miners by treating their labor as spectacle, highlight ethical concerns, though miners often view the work as voluntary economic necessity in a region lacking alternatives. Overall, portrayals prioritize visual drama over systemic analysis, fostering at phenomenon but underemphasizing miners' agency and the absence of mechanization due to and , shaping a perception of Ijen as a site of raw endurance amid rather than solely peril.

Controversies and Policy Debates

Labor Practices Scrutiny

Sulfur extraction at Kawah Ijen has faced international scrutiny primarily for hazardous working conditions that deviate from modern occupational safety standards. Miners, numbering approximately 200 to 300, manually break and transport deposits from the crater floor, carrying loads of 70 to 90 kilograms up steep, unstable paths rising over 200 meters, often two to three times per shift starting before dawn to avoid daytime heat and gas buildup. Exposure to high concentrations of gas, which can reach lethal levels without warning, occurs without mandatory use of respirators or other protective gear, relying instead on wet cloths or nothing. This labor-intensive model persists as one of the few remaining manual operations worldwide, contrasting with industrialized byproduct recovery elsewhere. Wages, structured on a per-kilogram basis at roughly 800 to 1,000 (US$0.05 to US$0.06) per kilogram, yield daily earnings of US$10 to US$17 for successful porters completing multiple trips, exceeding local agricultural or casual labor rates but criticized as inadequate compensation for the physical strain and long-term health deterioration, including chronic respiratory issues and skeletal damage. Miners operate in 15-day cycles of work followed by rest, as independent contractors rather than formal employees of the overseeing state enterprise, PT Kawah Ijen, which lacks comprehensive oversight or provisions. Over the last 40 years, at least 74 fatalities have been recorded from sudden gas releases, falls, and exhaustion-related incidents, prompting petitions from activists urging intervention for enhanced safety protocols and . Advocacy groups and media reports, such as those from and , highlight these practices as emblematic of exploitative informal economies, attributing persistence to economic desperation in East Java's rural areas where alternatives like farming yield far less. However, miners interviewed in recent accounts emphasize voluntary participation driven by relative advantages, with some rejecting offers that could reduce or earnings, underscoring a causal disconnect between external reform demands and local risk-reward calculus. Regulatory efforts by Indonesian authorities remain minimal, with no enforced shift to automated methods despite global sulfur surpluses rendering manual economically marginal.

Economic Benefits vs. Regulatory Pressures

Sulfur at Kawah Ijen provides essential employment for 200 to 300 local workers in a region with limited economic opportunities, where miners carry loads of 70 to 90 kilograms multiple times daily and earn approximately $13 per day—rates surpassing those from alternative local occupations like . This manual extraction, ongoing since 1968, positions Ijen as one of 's largest sulfur sources, supplying industrial demands and sustaining family incomes amid sparse formal job markets. The activity bolsters the broader local economy through indirect effects, including drawn to the mining spectacle, which generates revenue for nearby , , and retail sectors via a multiplier impact. Community-level benefits include economic resilience for households dependent on remittances, though earnings remain modest relative to physical demands and risks. Regulatory pressures, however, intensify due to acute health hazards from exposure, with concentrations often 40 times permissible limits, causing respiratory damage and other non-carcinogenic effects among unprotected miners using rudimentary . Traditional practices evade stringent oversight, prompting scrutiny from labor advocates for formal standards on equipment, exposure limits, and age restrictions, as informal operations lack enforced safety protocols akin to industrialized . Tensions arise as potential interventions—such as mandatory protective gear or emission controls—could elevate operational costs, reduce incomes, or limit access, pitting short-term economic necessities against long-term worker imperatives in a context where alternatives remain scarce. Initiatives for economic diversification, including integration and skill training, seek to mitigate reliance on while addressing these pressures without abrupt disruptions.

References

  1. https://www.usgs.gov/publications/kawah-ijen-volcanic-activity-a-review
  2. https://geology.com/volcanoes/kawah-ijen/
  3. https://volcano.si.edu/volcano.cfm?vn=263350
  4. https://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/images/84305/acid-lake-in-java
  5. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/science/article/140130-kawah-ijen-blue-flame-volcanoes-sulfur-indonesia-pictures
  6. https://www.volcanodiscovery.com/ijen.html
  7. https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20190109-sulphur-mining-at-kawah-ijen-volcano-in-indonesia
  8. https://www.unesco.org/en/iggp/geoparks/ijen
  9. https://www.peakbagger.com/peak.aspx?pid=35556
  10. https://volcano.oregonstate.edu/ijen
  11. https://buletingeologi.com/index.php/buletin-geologi/article/view/311
  12. https://academic.oup.com/petrology/article/48/6/1155/1564285
  13. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00445-014-0885-8
  14. https://ijenplateau.com/the-activity-of-ijen-volcano/
  15. https://www.volcanodiscovery.com/ijen-eruptions.html
  16. http://volcanolive.com/ijen.html
  17. https://volcano.si.edu/showreport.cfm?doi=10.5479/si.GVP.BGVN199909-263350
  18. https://volcano.si.edu/showreport.cfm?wvar=GVP.WVAR20200527-263350
  19. https://volcano.si.edu/showreport.cfm?wvar=GVP.WVAR20240807-263350
  20. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214750025000174
  21. https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsl/books/edited-volume/2021/chapter/106715312/New-insights-into-the-Kawah-Ijen-hydrothermal
  22. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0377027399001596
  23. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/7879190_Natural_Pollution_Caused_by_the_Extremely_Acid_Crater_Lake_Kawah_Ijen_East_Java_Indonesia_7_pp
  24. https://www.globemad.com/the-science-of-blue-lava/
  25. https://www.thoughtco.com/how-blue-lava-works-607589
  26. https://www.forbes.com/sites/trevornace/2015/11/07/stunning-electric-blue-molten-streams-rare-volcano/
  27. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/photography/article/the-struggle-and-strain-of-mining-devils-gold
  28. http://kevin-mcelvaney.com/portfolio/sulfur-mining/
  29. https://www.generalkinematics.com/blog/sulphur-mines-kawah-ijen-breathtakingly-beautiful/
  30. https://www.drmartinwilliams.com/kawah-ijen-sulphur-mine-on-java-in-indonesia-html/
  31. https://pomortzeff.com/eng/sulphur
  32. https://ijenvolcanotour.com/sulfur-producing-ijen-crater-inside-the-worlds-largest-source-of-sulfur/
  33. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11533650/
  34. http://www.xinhuanet.com/english/asiapacific/2019-07/18/c_138237880.htm
  35. https://studycorgi.com/producing-the-devils-gold-mining-practices-and-labor-standards-in-indonesian-sulfur-mines/
  36. https://edition.cnn.com/2016/07/07/asia/indonesia-volcano-ijen-sulfur-miners
  37. https://borgenproject.org/tourists-at-kawah-ijen-crater/
  38. https://indotravelteam.com/blog/the-miners-of-kawah-ijen/
  39. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/349388655_Towards_Family_Economic_Sustainability_The_Transformation_of_Traditional_Sulphur_Miners_in_Ijen_Crater
  40. https://inkstickmedia.com/scars-on-my-body-the-sulfur-miners-at-indonesias-mount-ijen/
  41. https://www.scmp.com/news/asia/southeast-asia/article/3205226/why-miners-indonesia-risk-their-lives-get-sulphur-inside-active-volcano
  42. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39497761/
  43. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2214750024001550
  44. https://journals.eco-vector.com/0016-9900/article/view/638967
  45. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-12301421
  46. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/travel/article/pictures-kawah-ijen-volcano-east-java
  47. https://www.borgenmagazine.com/sulfur-mining-indonesia/
  48. https://insu.hal.science/insu-03696475/document
  49. https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/books/edited-volume/chapter-pdf/6922395/9781786202918_ch03.pdf
  50. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15859115/
  51. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0377027308003636
  52. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17033856/
  53. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10653-005-0827-7
  54. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/7528099_The_Impact_of_the_Hyperacid_Ijen_Crater_Lake_Part_I_Concentrations_of_Elements_in_Crops_and_Soil
  55. https://astrobiology.com/2023/11/kawah-ijen-crater-lake-is-highly-acidic-but-home-to-life.html
  56. https://iwaponline.com/wst/article/89/8/2177/101671/The-influence-of-the-acid-water-of-the-Banyupait
  57. https://volcano.si.edu/gallery/ShowImage.cfm?photo=GVP-00765
  58. https://www.tourbanyuwangi.com/who-was-the-first-to-introduce-kawah-ijen-banyuwangi-to-the-world/
  59. https://www.indonesia-travel.com/guide-indonesia/destination/kawah-ijen
  60. https://theroamingshoes.com/2024/08/hiking-to-ijen-crater-in-java-an-unforgettable-adventure/
  61. https://www.airial.travel/attractions/indonesia/kawah-ijen-CnFoKPVs
  62. https://ijenbromotours.com/ijen-opened-for-froreign-tourist/
  63. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/390584324_ANALYSIS_OF_THE_DEVELOPMENT_STRATEGY_OF_THE_IJEN_CRATER_TOURIST_ATTRACTION_BANYUWANGI_DISTRICT
  64. https://javagoldentour.com/entrance-ticket-in-ijen-crater-2024/
  65. https://proirofonic.upnjatim.ac.id/index.php/proirofonic/article/download/89/87/400
  66. https://ijenplateau.com/mt-ijen-crater-is-closed-to-visitors-2025/
  67. https://surabayabromotour.com/ijen-blue-fire-closed/
  68. https://ijenvolcanotour.com/ijen-volcano-area-tourism-park-reopening-to-the-public/
  69. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/volcano-erupts-in-bright-blue-flames-stunning-photos/
  70. https://youtu.be/NQULD1GRoGw?t=3m5s
  71. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt2042711/
  72. https://distribution.arte.tv/fiche/Des_volcans_et_des_hommes_26___8_20_____Indonesie____Kawah_Ijen___dans_l_enfer_du_soufre
  73. https://www.wired.com/story/sulfur-miners-volcano-indonesia/
  74. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4jPGTFY-TNc
  75. https://matadornetwork.com/view/kawah-ijen-miners-java/
  76. https://ijenvolcanotour.com/facts-about-ijen-sulfur-miners-harsh-conditions-labor-intensive-process-and-economic-realities-at-ijen-volcano/
  77. https://www.yalejournal.org/publications/sulfur-miners-of-kawah-ijen
  78. https://en.clickpetroleoegas.com.br/extracao-de-enxofre-e-um-dos-empregos-mais-perigosos-do-mundo-mineradores-se-arriscam-sem-nenhum-equipamento-de-protecao-para-ganhar-apenas-us009-por-quilo/
  79. https://www.change.org/p/united-nations-provide-kawah-ijen-miners-good-life-conditions-on-their-work
  80. https://revolve.media/views/toxic-fumes
  81. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/309270635_The_Efforts_to_Increase_the_Income_of_Sulfur_Miners_through_Economic_Transformation_in_Mount_Ijen_Banyuwangi_Indonesia
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.