Hubbry Logo
Classes of Tantra in Tibetan BuddhismClasses of Tantra in Tibetan BuddhismMain
Open search
Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism
Community hub
Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism
Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism
Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Part of a series on
Tibetan Buddhism
Tibetan Dharma Wheel
Schools
Key personalities
First dissemination
Second dissemination
Nyingma
Kagyu
Jonang
Sakya
Bodongpa

Samding Dorje Phagmo

Gelugpa
Teachings
General Buddhist
Tibetan
Nyingma
Practices and attainment
Major monasteries
Institutional roles
Festivals
Texts
Art
History and overview

Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism refers to the categorization of Buddhist tantric scriptures in Indo-Tibetan Buddhism. Tibetan Buddhism inherited numerous tantras and forms of tantric practice from medieval Indian Buddhist Tantra. There were various ways of categorizing these tantras in India. In Tibet, the Sarma (New Translation) schools categorize tantric scriptures into four classes, while the Nyingma (Ancients) school use six classes of tantra.

Sarma ("New Translation") classification

[edit]

The Sarma, "New Translation" schools of Tibetan Buddhism (Gelug, Sakya, Kagyu, Jonang) classify tantric practices and texts into four classes. In this, they follow Indian Tantric Buddhists such as Abhayākara, who makes this distinction in his Clusters of Quintessential Instructions. Tantras are classified according to the capacity of persons, the deities they use, the specific types of methods they employ and how they use desire (kama).[1][2]

Kriyā

[edit]
Illuminated Pages from a Dispersed DharanI Manuscript

Kriyā (Tib. bya ba, Action) tantras were taught for practitioners of lower ability who have an inclination for performing many external ritual activities for protection and purification purposes, such as ritual bathing, the sprinkling of scented water, the creation of a circle of protection, the use of mudras and the chanting of mantras.[1][2] There are also various prescriptions dealing with eating, drinking, and clothing.[3] According to Kongtrul, in Kriyā Yoga, one relates to the deity as a subject relates to their lord and only meditates on an external deity (not on oneself as being the deity).[4]

According to Kongtrul, "the essence of action tantra" is:

to view the profound truth with fear and apprehension due to an inferior intellect and to observe utmost cleanliness and purity, ablution, asceticism, and so forth; to not develop the pride of being the deity since there is no generation of oneself as the pledge deity; to be without the supreme bliss of the pristine awareness deity since the pristine awareness deity has not been invoked to merge into the pledge deity; not to be a receptacle for the sublime teachings since one is unqualified to receive teachings on what is sublime and extraordinary, the deep meanings that were spoken with specific intention; and due to the shortcoming of being unable to fathom the sublime, being conditioned by concepts about the purity or impurity of things, to train thoroughly in rituals of ablution, and so forth, and thereby to practice deity yoga in a subject-to-lord relationship with the deity.[5]

Regarding initiation, The Essence of Pristine Awareness states: "it is widely known that in action tantra there are the water and crown initiations."[6]

Each action tantra text generally centers on a particular Buddha or Bodhisattva, and many are based on dharanis. Some of these texts are actually titled "sutra" or "dharani". Action tantra includes various practices for deities such as Medicine Buddha, "the eleven faced" Chenrezig and Vajrapani. Examples of Action Tantra texts include:[7]

  • Mahāmegha Sutra,
  • Sacred Golden Light Sutra, notably a very popular sutra in East Asia
  • Dharani of the Eleven-Faced Avalokiteshvara
  • Marichi Dharani
  • Ārya-mañjushrī-mūla-kalpa, which notably states that mantras taught in the Saiva, Garuda and Vaisnava tantras will be effective if applied by Buddhists since they were all taught originally by Manjushri.[8]
  • Subhāhu-pariprcchā (Dialogue with Subahu),
  • Secret General Tantra
  • Susidhi Tantra
  • Manjushri Root Tantra
  • Supreme Knowledge of Vajrapani Tantra
  • Aparimitāyur-jñāna-hrdaya-dhāranī.
  • Heart Sutra (Prajñāpāramitāhṛdaya, which contains a mantra).

Regarding the practice of deity yoga in Action Tantra, Kongtrul outlines six main elements or deities, namely "Emptiness, letter, sound, form, Seal, and sign":

First, the deity as emptiness is to remain absorbed in emptiness, the essence of ultimate awakening mind, in which the essential principle of oneself and that of the deity are of an inseparability beyond concepts. Second, the deity as letter is to meditate on the particular deity [one is practicing] in the form of the written letters of the [deity’s] mantra resting on a moon disk (representing one’s mind) visualized in space [in front]. Also considered to be the letter deity is to meditate simply on the moon [omitting the letters]. Third, the deity as sound is to meditate on the resonant sounds of the mantra (on the moon) associated with one of the [three] deities of the three families to which the recitation practice for complete familiarization is directed. Fourth, the deity as form is to meditate on the complete form of the deity. [The first step involves] meditating that light radiating from the letters of the mantra fulfills two aims; then, [as the light reconverges, the letters] transform into the deity’s complete form. Fifth, the deity as seal is to perform the hand mudras for blessing, such as the mudra of the crown protrusion, and while reciting the appropriate mantra, to touch the corresponding places of the body with the mudra. Alternatively, one makes the pledge mudra of that particular [family]. Sixth, the deity as sign is to recall, in all circumstances, the form of the deity as meditated in the state of equipoise so that the appearances of the outer world and its inhabitants are regarded as pure visions, imagined as the deity’s residence, form, and resources.[9]

Caryā

[edit]
Panel from a Tibetan Buddhist Ritual Crown Depicting Buddha Vairocana, late 13th–early 14th century.

Caryā (spyod pa, Performance, or Conduct) tantras are meant for practitioners of middle ability. According to Tsongkhapa, it is for "those who balance external activities and internal meditative stabilization without relying on very many activities." The kind of desire it uses is the weakest kind, comparable to a couple looking at each other.[1][2] They are also known as Upa tantra, or Ubhaya tantra.

Although these tantras maintain numerous external ritual actions, the emphasis is now upon obtaining liberation through meditation. It is thus seen as maintaining a balance between inner and outer actions. It is externally similar to Kriyā tantra, and internally similar to Yoga tantra.[10]

According to Kongtrul, the main elements of Conduct tantra are:

To practice and train thoroughly in a vast range of deeds related to activations, which are sets of outer (physical and verbal) [actions] such as mudras and other characteristic focuses as taught in action tantra, and thus [to have] objects of practice that accord with that tantra; to cultivate inner (mental) contemplation that accords with yogatantra and to practice [deity yoga] in what is like a friend-to-friend relation-ship with the deity.[10]

Kongtrul further states, "conduct tantra is known to have five initiations: water, diadem, vajra, bell, and name."[11]

In this class of tantras, Vairochana is a principal deity. In Tibetan Buddhism, this tantra class includes practice lineages for the Mahãvairocanãbhisaṃbodhitantra ('Awakening of Great Vairocana'), for the Vajrapãṇyabhiṣekamahãtantra (Vajrapāṇi Initiation Tantra) and for Manjushri.[12][13]

The presence of Buddha Vairocana is often evident in tantras of this class where he is often depicted in the centre of a mandala with four other Buddhas of his retinue placed to the four quarters, the cardinal directions. Importantly, during the Caryā tantra class and literary period, there developed the salient innovation wherein the sadhaka is to cultivate identification with the deity in meditative absorption (known as "self generation"). This class of literature was also important to Chinese Zhenyan Buddhism and tantric masters such as Śubhakarasiṃha (637-735), Vajrabodhi (671–741) and Amoghavajra (705–774). This focus was later imparted by Amoghavajra's disciple Huiguo (746-805) to the monk Kūkai (774–835), leading to the development of Japanese Shingon Buddhism.

Guarisco & McLeod explain Jamgon Kongtrul's codification of this class as follows:

Conduct tantra, where conduct encompasses both outer ritual activity and inner contemplation, involves training in a vast range of deeds while entering the inner reality that presents itself in visual and audible divine representations. The notion here is that of being close to the state of a perfect divine being, a state not yet fully realized. This limited view is overcome by visualizing oneself as the deity, understanding that form to be the appearance aspect of emptiness.[14]

In Caryā yoga, the yogi visualizes themselves as the 'commitment being' (Sanskrit: samayasattva) and visualizes the 'gnosis being' (jñānasattva), who is envisioned in the relationship of a spiritual friend, in front of them. Various "meditations with signs" are part of this practice including: bija (seed syllable) and mandala visualization, mudra (hand seals), repetition of mantras, etc. as found in Action tantra. Conduct yoga also includes a special "yoga without signs", described by Kongtrul as follows:

The special yoga without signs is cultivated in conjunction with three minds: the minds of entering, abiding, and emerging, the essence of which is the ultimate awakening mind itself. The mind of entering is the realization of the unborn nature of all phenomena (the aggregates, etc.) gained by examining them in terms of the four extremes; the mind of abiding, the direct realization of the unborn nature as the essence of the nonconceptual state; and the mind of emerging, the ensuing great compassion directed to-ward suffering beings who lack such realization.[15]

Yoga

[edit]

Yoga tantra (rnal’byor) is, according to Tsongkhapa, meant for practitioners of high ability who "mainly rely on meditative stabilization and rely on only few external activities." The level of desire they use is said to be similar to a couple holding hands or embracing.[1] "Yoga" refers to the union or yoking of method and wisdom. One sees one's body, speech and mind as inseparably united with those of the deity.[3]

Kongtrul defines Yoga tantra thus:

Yoga tantra is so named because it emphasizes the inner yoga meditation of method and wisdom; or alternatively, because based on knowledge and understanding of all aspects of the profound ultimate truth and the vast relative truth, it emphasizes contemplation that inseparably unites these two truths.[16]

Yoga tantra is the last and highest of the outer tantras, and here external rites are seen as much less important than internal practices. The empowerments given are the empowerment of the 5 Buddha families, and the empowerment of the Vajra master, and disciples must take on the commitments of the 5 buddha families, and take the tantric vows.[17] The path is split into 4 seals; the great seal of body, the seal of the speech of Dharma, the seal of the mind of commitment, and the seal of enlightened actions.

Some Vajrasattva practices fall under this category, as well as the Tattvasaṃgraha Tantra (Summation of Essential Principles) and the Vajraśekhara Tantra (Indestructible Peak).[18][19] Other Yoga tantras include the All-Secret Tantra, the Victorious in the Three Worlds Tantra; and the Glorious Supreme Original Being.[20] While Vairochana maintains his position as principal deity, he is now envisaged as being in the center of 5 buddha families instead of 3, each family belonging to one of the Five Tathagathas.

The Shurangama Sutra and the Shurangama Mantra from which it (called the Shitatapatra Ushnisha Dharani) comes can be included in this category.

Unsurpassable Yoga

[edit]
A Hevajra Mandala
Deities of the Chakrasamvara Tantra

Anuttarayoga tantras (rnal ’byor bla med, Unexcelled or Unsurpassable yoga tantras), also known as Yoganiruttaratantra, are meant for practitioners of the highest ability who do not rely on external activities. It uses the highest level of desire, sexual union, and is thus also designated the “tantra of union of the two.” According to Kongtrul, only Highest Yoga includes both the generation and completion phases.[1][2] Kongtrul states that these are "supreme among all tantras" and "there is no other tantra above it."[21]

Anuttarayoga is characterized by the practice of Deity Yoga as well as various subtle body yogas (such as the six Dharmas of Naropa), to generate great bliss and attain the subtle clear light (luminous) mind. According to Miranda Shaw, Anuttarayoga Tantra texts "have remained at the forefront of contemplation, ritual, and interpretation throughout the Himalayan Buddhist sphere".[22]

In the classification of the Dzogchen system, used by the Nyingma, it is considered equivalent to the Mahayoga tantras.[23] The Dalai Lama XIV states: "old translation Dzogchen and new translation anuttarayoga tantra offer equivalent paths that can bring the practitioner to the same resultant state of Buddhahood".[24]

Kongtrul describes the essence of Unsurpassed Yoga Tantra as being

In the midst of an entourage of queens, in the form of an all-powerful sovereign such as Heruka (in mother tantra) or Vairochana (in father tantra); and by means of the contemplation of the great bliss of the male and female deities’ union, to be the “king who resides in the castle” (as is said in the tantras), which means to dwell perfectly in the queen’s bhaga, that is, in the divine palace in the source of phenomena; to train according to the sublime vajra words, the statements of six parameters—interpretable, non-interpretable, provisional, definitive, standard, and coined terminology—which are contrary to worldly human customs (as is said in the tantras, “Success is rapidly achieved by relying on one’s mother, sister, or daughter”) by performing extremely base acts; and thereby to effect ordinary and supreme powers.[25]

This statement contains various tantric terms to express the nature of Unsurpassed Tantra. Bhaga (ultimately) refers to the source of phenomena (chos ’byung, dharmodaya), or source of all awakened qualities, and also literally to the vagina of a female sexual consort (i.e. the queen, btsun mo).[26] Thus this statement references karmamudra, sexual union, which is a key element of the symbolism, thought and practice of Unsurpassed Yoga Tantras and which generates a great blissful consciousness (the "castle of great bliss") that is then directed to understanding ultimate reality.[26] Furthermore, when the tantras speak of relying on one's mothers, sisters etc., this refers to different types of tantric consorts.[26] Regarding the six parameters, this refers to "six levels of meaning in the content of the tantras" which express different ways of interpreting and understanding the tantras.[26]

Tantras

[edit]

Anuttarayoga tantras which became prominent in Tibet include:

In Sarma, they are sometimes further classified into "Father Tantras" (Wyl. pha rgyud), "Mother Tantras" (ma rgyud) and "Non-Dual Tantras" (gnyis med kyi rgyud).

The mahāyoga-tantras of Pala Empire India became known in Tibet as 'Father Tantras' (pha rgyud). According to the Gelug view, following Tsongkhapa's reasoning, Father Tantras emphasize the creation of a Buddha form through the cultivation of an illusory body, on the basis of practices with the energy system of the subtle body. Earlier Sakya masters and Kagyu scholars had viewed Father Tantras as emphasising the practice of blissful awareness.[27] Father Tantras have also been seen as emphasizing the use of anger (pratigha) as the path of practice, focusing on the emptiness aspect of Buddha nature.

The yoginī-tantras which became known in Tibet as 'Mother Tantras' (ma rgyud) emphasize the development of enlightened awareness (the "mind" of the illusory body) through the cultivation of the fundamental pure mind of all beings, known as 'brilliance' (prabhāsvara) (frequently translated, following the Tibetan, as 'clear light'). They are considered to emphasize the utilization of desire (tṛṣṇā) as the path of practice, focusing on the brilliant (prabhāsvara) aspect of Buddha nature. Among the Mother Tantras, the most prominent is the Cakrasaṃvara.[28] The practice of Vajrayogini evolved out of the Cakrasaṃvara practice and is now a de facto practice in its own right (Vajrayogini being the consort of Cakrasamvara).[29] Other Mother Tantras are Hevajra Tantra and Caṇḍamahāroṣaṇa.

Non-dual tantras utilize both anger and desire as an antidote to delusion (avidyā), focusing on both the physical and mental, void and brilliant, aspects of enlightened mind. The example typically advanced for this category is the Kālacakra Tantra. The Sakya tradition also considers Hevajra to be a non-dual tantra but other traditions classify it as a yoginī-tantra. The practice of Yamantaka is also directed towards this aim.

Nyingma classification

[edit]

The Nyingma school meanwhile, has six main tantra categories, which make up the last six of the main Nyingma "nine yana" schema. According to Jean-Luc Achard, "in the Nyingma tradition, there are several ways of classifying the teachings of the Buddha into nine, ten, and sometimes twelve Vehicles. Most of these classifications have not survived in practical usage, except for that into nine. In this case, the ninth is considered to be the Vehicle of Dzogchen."[30]

The first three categories are essentially the same as the Sarma classification (Kriyā, Caryā or Ubhaya, and Yoga) and are called "Outer Tantras".[31]

The last three are the "Inner Tantras": Mahāyoga, Anuyoga and Atiyoga.[31]

  • Mahāyoga (rnal ’byor chen po), is a class of tantric texts and practices that emphasize the stage of generation and are sometimes also termed father tantras. The Net of Magical Manifestation (Māyājāla) collection contains the major Mahayoga works, The Guhyagarbha Tantra is the most influential of these.
  • Anuyoga (rjes su rnal ’byor) texts are associated with tantras that emphasize the stage of completion and are associated with mother tantras. They also teach a "principle of instantaneous perfection", which is not found in other tantras. An example of one of these texts is the All-Unifying Pure Presence (Kun ’dus rig pa’i mdo).
  • Atiyoga (Dzogchen). In Nyingma, Dzogchen ("Great Perfection") is seen as a non-gradual method which transcends the two stages of tantric yoga and focuses on direct access to the innate purity of things. Atiyoga is further divided into three main categories: Mind Series (semde), Space Series (longdé) and Instruction Series (menngakde). There are numerous tantras and texts associated with this vehicle, such as the Kunjed Gyalpo and the "Seventeen tantras of the esoteric instruction cycle" (man ngag sde'i rgyud bcu bdun).

According to Longchenpa's Great Chariot:

Mahāyoga, the father tantra, the nature of method [related to] appearance, [is taught] to benefit those whose strongest emotional affliction is aversion and who are subject to excessive discursiveness. Anuyoga, the mother tantra, the wisdom of the completion phase [related to] the essential reality of emptiness, [is taught] to benefit those whose strongest emotional affliction is desire and who delight in stillness of mind. Atiyoga, the nature of nonduality, [is taught] to benefit those whose strongest emotional affliction is delusion and who are tarnished by [attachment to] effort.[32]

Longchenpa's Finding Comfort and Ease in the Nature of Mind states:

Mahayoga emphasizes winds and the methods of the generation phase. Anuyoga emphasizes the constituent [of bliss] and the wisdom of the completion phase; Atiyoga emphasizes pristine awareness from which nothing is separate.[32]

Regarding the alternative schemas which are now rarely used in Nyingma, Achard writes:

In the classification into twelve Vehicles (such as in the surviving proto-doxographical works of O rgyan gling pa), Dzogchen is the ninth Vehicle as usual, but it is composed of three subdivisions which are also styled Vehicles (theg pa). In this case, Dzogchen is equated with Ati yoga. Then, the tenth Vehicle is that of the sPyi ti yoga; the eleventh is that of the Yang ti yoga; and the twelfth is the vehicle of the Great Limit (mtha’ chen). Such references to higher categories of Dzogchen teachings, said to surpass those of Ati yoga stricto sensu, have survived at least down to the revelations of mChog gyur gling pa in the 19th century. Since then, practically no one has used these unusual categories, especially that of the Great Limit which remains more than obscure.[30]

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Classes of Tantra in Tibetan Buddhism

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
In Tibetan Buddhism, the classes of Tantra represent a hierarchical classification of esoteric scriptures and practices aimed at achieving enlightenment through ritual, meditation, and yogic methods, with the Sarma schools (Gelug, Sakya, Kagyu, and Jonang) organizing them into four primary categories—Kriya, Charya, Yoga, and Anuttarayoga—while the Nyingma school expands this into six classes by incorporating three inner tantras. These classifications originated in Indian Buddhist traditions from the 7th to 12th centuries and were transmitted to Tibet during the 8th to 11th centuries, forming the core of Vajrayana (tantric) Buddhism as a swift path complementing sutra-based practices. The Kriya Tantra (Action Tantra), the foundational class in both systems, emphasizes external rituals such as purification, worship, and ablutions to cleanse defilements, viewing the practitioner as a servant to the and relying on symbolic actions rather than deep . Next, Charya Tantra (Performance Tantra) integrates with basic meditative visualization, treating the practitioner and as equals in conduct, often involving secret mantras and mudras to harmonize outer and inner practices. Yoga Tantra advances to internal yogic methods, centering on , visualizations (such as the Vajradhātu ), and the generation of blissful awareness to realize non-duality, with key texts like the Sarvatathāgatatattvasaṃgraha. The pinnacle in the Sarma classification is Anuttarayoga Tantra (Highest Yoga Tantra), which employs sophisticated techniques for manipulating subtle energies, including generation-stage visualizations and completion-stage practices involving the channels, winds, and drops of the body to swiftly attain , subdivided into father, mother, and non-dual tantras exemplified by texts like the Guhyasamāja and Cakrasaṃvara. In the Nyingma tradition, the outer three classes mirror the Sarma system, but the inner tantras elevate the framework: focuses on generation-stage practices and the view of phenomena as primordially pure, rooted in the ; Anuyoga stresses the completion stage through (skillful means) and prajña (wisdom), drawing from the Samdhisamgraha Sūtra; and Atiyoga (), the supreme class, emphasizes the direct recognition of the mind's innate luminosity without fabrication, transcending conventional tantric methods. This dual classification system underscores the diversity within , with the four-class model influencing monastic curricula and initiations in the newer translation schools, while the Nyingma's six-class (or nine-vehicle) approach integrates terma () revelations and emphasizes the primacy of as the ultimate vehicle. All classes require () from a qualified and adherence to samaya vows, ensuring ethical and transformative application in practice.

Background and Overview

Definition of Tantra

Tantra in refers to an esoteric system of spiritual practices derived from Indian traditions, emphasizing the use of visualization, mantras, mandalas, and initiations to achieve rapid enlightenment by uniting skillful means () with (). This approach, known as or the "Diamond Vehicle," views enlightenment as attainable within a single lifetime through transformative that purifies ordinary perceptions into enlightened qualities. The term "" itself, from meaning "to weave" or "continuity," underscores the unbroken thread of mental continuums leading to realization. Central to tantric practice is its integration of exoteric principles—such as , , and —with esoteric elements, including the three vows: pratimoksha (individual liberation vows for ethical conduct), (vows of and ), and (tantric commitments to maintain purity in and devotion). Unlike non-Buddhist tantric traditions, which may prioritize power or worldly siddhis without emphasizing and renunciation of cyclic existence, Buddhist maintains the core goal of universal while employing symbolic and methods to accelerate progress. These practices are framed within overarching classifications, such as the four classes of the Sarma schools and the nine vehicles of the tradition. Engaging in tantra requires strict prerequisites, including transmission from a qualified guru through empowerment rituals, a solid ethical foundation rooted in the three vows, and the renunciation of dualistic ordinary perceptions to recognize innate purity. Without these, practices risk misunderstanding and harm, as tantra's methods demand profound commitment. Uniquely, tantra regards the human body as inherently divine, a microcosm of enlightened qualities with subtle energy channels (nadis) and centers (chakras) that facilitate transformation. It employs taboo-breaking techniques, such as symbolic sexual yoga, to transmute afflictions like desire into paths of wisdom, always under guided supervision to avoid literal misapplication.

Historical Development

The tantric traditions of Buddhism emerged in India during the 7th and 8th centuries CE, developing as an esoteric extension of that incorporated ritual practices, , and meditative techniques centered on mandalas and mantras. This period marked a shift toward integrating worldly elements into spiritual paths, with foundational texts like the —likely composed around the —establishing core doctrines on practices and enlightenment through union of method and wisdom. The Sarvatathāgatatattvasaṃgraha (Compendium of Principles), dating to the early , further exemplified this evolution by systematizing tantric principles and rituals, influencing subsequent Indian and Tibetan developments. Transmission to Tibet occurred in two primary phases, beginning with the imperial period in the 8th century, when Indian masters like were invited by King to subdue local spirits and establish Buddhism, introducing key tantric texts and practices that formed the school's "old translation" (snga dar) tradition. This early dissemination involved state-sponsored translations under imperial patronage from approximately 700 to 842 CE, focusing initially on sūtras but increasingly on tantras, which were integrated into Tibetan monastic and ritual frameworks. The 9th-century persecution of Buddhism under King Langdarma led to a decline, but a revival in the 11th and 12th centuries—known as the "later dissemination" (phyi dar)—ushered in the Sarma schools through renewed Indian contacts. Translators such as Marpa (founder of the lineage), Drokmi (Sakya precursor), and Atīśa (influencing the Kadam and later traditions) brought fresh tantric materials from India, establishing the "new translation" schools alongside the lineage. This period saw economic recovery in Tibet spur systematic translation projects, distinguishing Sarma classifications from the earlier approach. Indian commentarial traditions played a pivotal role in shaping these Tibetan systems, with scholars like Abhayākaragupta (11th–early 12th century) authoring influential works on the Vajraśekhara Tantra, which provided exegetical frameworks for tantric hierarchies and rituals that were adapted in both and Sarma contexts. Similarly, commentaries on the informed the structuring of tantric classes by emphasizing progressive stages of practice, ensuring their transmission influenced the doctrinal foundations of across lineages.

Sarma Classification

Kriya Tantra

Kriya Tantra, the first and most foundational class in the Sarma schools' fourfold classification of tantras, emphasizes external rituals and purification practices to cultivate devotion and . It views the meditational as a superior master to whom the practitioner offers worship, fostering humility and faith while treating all phenomena as manifestations of purity. This approach is particularly suitable for beginners who possess strong devotion but limited into , enabling them to engage in tantric practice without advanced philosophical understanding. Key practices in Kriya Tantra revolve around simple , involving visualization of oneself as the figure, such as or Medicine Buddha, through a sixfold process: meditating on , generating the from syllables, reciting mantras, forming mudras, and dissolving into . Emphasis is placed on cleanliness, including bathing, wearing fresh white garments, and maintaining a vegetarian diet of three white substances (, , and ) to symbolize purity. Offerings like , flowers, and are central, alongside the four initiations— (for body purification), crown (for speech), (for mind), and bell (for )—which ripen the practitioner's faculties for realization. Prominent tantras associated with this class include the Susiddhikara Tantra, which details ritual accomplishment and purification methods; the Dhāraṇī of the Eleven-Faced , focusing on compassionate invocation through ; and the Mahāvairocana Tantra, outlining foundational mandalas and rites, though sometimes cross-classified in higher categories. Prerequisites for Kriya Tantra practice include taking refuge, generating , and receiving the appropriate empowerments, ideally from a qualified , to ensure ethical conduct and avoid violations. It particularly addresses afflictions like pride and jealousy by instilling a worshipful attitude toward the , leading to purification of gross negativities and accumulation of merit. Benefits encompass rebirth in pure lands such as Sukhāvatī or the realm of , attainment of worldly siddhis, and, at higher realization, the desire-realm level, paving the way for advanced tantric paths. This class parallels the outer tantras in the system through its ritualistic focus.

Charya Tantra

Charya Tantra, the second class in the Sarma schools' fourfold classification of tantras, represents a balanced integration of external ritual conduct (carya) and internal meditative practices, distinguishing it from the predominantly external focus of Kriya Tantra. This class views the meditational () as an equal friend, allowing practitioners to visualize themselves as a form (pledge being) while perceiving the wisdom before them in a relational dynamic of parity. Such an approach equally emphasizes outer behaviors aligned with monastic discipline and inner cultivation of , making it suitable for individuals with mixed capacities, particularly those influenced by attachment or desire, as the practices help transform these afflictions through harmonious engagement. The initiations in Charya Tantra comprise five empowerments: the water initiation for purification, the crown initiation for receiving blessings, the initiation for skillful means, the bell initiation for wisdom, and the name initiation that confers a secret tantric identity upon the practitioner. These empowerments mature the disciple for the balanced practices, building directly on the foundational rituals of Kriya Tantra while introducing deeper internal elements. Practitioners maintain simple vows, which primarily involve upholding external conduct such as cleanliness and ethical behavior alongside commitments to recitation and visualization, without the more complex inner yogic pledges of higher classes. Key practices include secret recitation performed in a state of meditative absorption, often while embodying monastic-like conduct to stabilize the mind and body. This recitation accompanies visualizations of seed syllables, hand gestures (mudras), and forms, culminating in non-conceptual on the absolute nature of bodhichitta to foster the union of appearance and . The focus remains on transforming desire through these methods, harmonizing external actions with internal realization to cultivate and . Charya Tantra serves a transitional role between the ritual-heavy Kriya and the more inwardly oriented Yoga Tantra, providing a stepwise progression for practitioners. Associated texts include portions of the Tattvasaṃgraha Tantra, which outlines foundational mandalas and practices partially classified under Charya, and the Vajrapāṇi Abhiṣeka Tantra (Toh 496), a primary scripture detailing Vajrapani empowerments and rituals for the Vajra family. Other notable works encompass the Mahāvairocana Abhisambodhi Tantra (Toh 494) for the Tathagata family, emphasizing Vairocana visualizations, and the Nīlāmbaradhārī Vajrapāṇi Tantra (Toh 498), which supports conduct-oriented deity yoga. These tantras, though fewer in number compared to other classes, remain influential in Tibetan traditions for their accessible blend of ritual and meditation, benefiting practitioners by promoting mental and physical harmony essential for advanced tantric paths.

Yoga Tantra

Yoga Tantra represents the third class in the Sarma classification of tantric systems within , emphasizing the integration of the practitioner with the through internal meditative processes. In this class, the deity is viewed as inseparable from the practitioner's own mind and body, fostering a non-dual where the enlightened qualities of the Buddha-figure are recognized as inherent to oneself. This approach prioritizes inner practices over external rituals, uniting wisdom (the realization of ) and skillful means (compassionate action) in a harmonious embrace, often analogized to the bliss of two partners hugging each other. Unlike lower classes, Yoga Tantra introduces formless alongside visualization, allowing practitioners to dissolve dualistic perceptions more deeply. Central practices in Yoga Tantra involve advanced deity visualization, where the practitioner generates themselves as the Buddha-figure within an elaborate , such as the Vajradhātu mandala centered on . Mandala offerings are performed mentally, transforming ordinary perceptions into sacred environments, while contemplation of is integrated to realize the non-substantial nature of all phenomena. Elaborate mudras (hand gestures) play a key role, applied in four progressive levels to seal the practice and invoke enlightened activity. These methods address subtle emotional afflictions like aversion by cultivating and non-dual insight, leading toward direct perception of . Initiations in this class comprise the complete vase empowerment, including five vajra disciple empowerments for purification and the vajra master empowerment for authorizing advanced meditation. Prominent associated tantras include the Sarvadurgati Parishodhana Tantra, which focuses on purification rites for removing obstacles and guiding beings through intermediate states (), and the Vajrasekhara Tantra, an explanatory text outlining the with its 37 deities and emphasis on conquering the three worlds. These texts form the basis for practices in Tibetan traditions. Subdivisions distinguish general Yoga Tantras, which apply broadly to multiple deities, from specific ones tailored to individual Buddha-figures like or . Engaging in Yoga Tantra requires a solid foundation from Kriya and Charya Tantra, including mastery of preliminaries like the stages of the path (lam-rim) such as , bodhichitta, and voidness , often involving 100,000 repetitions of prostrations or other accumulations. Benefits include overcoming deep-seated aversion through internal union, achieving heightened concentration, and attaining siddhis (accomplishments) that facilitate direct experiential into reality's empty yet luminous , serving as a preparatory bridge to higher tantric stages.

Anuttarayoga Tantra

Anuttarayoga Tantra, also known as Highest Yoga Tantra, represents the pinnacle of the Sarma classification of tantras in , emphasizing the most profound methods for achieving complete enlightenment in a single lifetime. This class focuses on the , comprising channels (Skt. nāḍī; Tib. rtsa), winds (Skt. prāṇa; Tib. rlung), and drops (Skt. bindu; Tib. thig le), to dissolve dualistic perceptions and realize the innate of mind. Unlike the preceding Yoga Tantra, which primarily involves generation-stage practices, Anuttarayoga Tantra incorporates both generation stage (Skt. utpattikrama; Tib. bskyed rim)—where the practitioner visualizes themselves as the —and completion stage (Skt. sampannakrama; Tib. rdzogs rim)—which employs advanced yogas to manipulate subtle energies for non-conceptual realization. Central to its practices is the identification of the practitioner with the deity as an expression of one's own , transforming ordinary perceptions into enlightened awareness through symbolic rituals and meditative absorption. The tantras of this class employ sophisticated symbolism, including the union of method (upāya) and (prajñā), often depicted as deities in embrace, to cultivate great bliss inseparable from . This approach aims to uproot all afflictive obscurations at their root, leveraging the subtlest level of mind—clear light (Skt. prabhāsvara; Tib. 'od gsal)—to directly cognize the ultimate nature of reality. Anuttarayoga Tantra is subdivided into three categories based on their primary emphasis: Father Tantras, Mother Tantras, and Non-dual Tantras. Father Tantras, such as the , prioritize method-oriented practices, focusing on the illusory body (Skt. māyākāya; Tib. sgyu lus) and the generation of bliss through control of the white drop at the crown . Mother Tantras, exemplified by the , emphasize wisdom and the innate bliss of , particularly through inner heat (Skt. caṇḍālī; Tib. gtum mo) to melt the red drop at the and access the central channel. Non-dual Tantras, like the Kalacakra Tantra, integrate method and wisdom equally, incorporating cosmological elements and time cycles to realize non-dual awareness beyond subject-object distinctions. These subdivisions guide practitioners toward balanced realization, with each tantra's vows () enforcing ethical conduct to protect the subtle realizations. Key practices within Anuttarayoga Tantra include the Six Yogas of , a completion-stage system derived from Mother Tantra lineages, comprising inner heat, illusory body, , dream , transference of consciousness (Skt. poṭa; Tib. 'pho ba), and intermediate state (Skt. antarābhava; Tib. bar do) yoga. These yogas progressively dissolve the subtlest winds into the indestructible drop at the heart, culminating in the direct experience of and the potential for (Tib. 'ja' lus)—a sign of complete physical and mental transformation. Sexual union symbolism, practiced physically only by highly advanced adepts or symbolically by most, serves as a potent for unifying bliss and , always under the guidance of strict vows to avoid degeneration. Engagement with Anuttarayoga Tantra requires prerequisites such as stable ground, profound compassion, and completion of preliminary practices like the , typically under the (Skt. abhiṣeka; Tib. dbang) from a qualified . It is suited for practitioners of superior capacity who can integrate intense visualizations and subtle yogas without attachment. The benefits include rapid transformation of all afflictions into wisdom, attainment of full , and the ability to benefit sentient beings through enlightened activity, far surpassing the gradual paths of lower tantras. In contrast to inner tantras, it shares an emphasis on work but structures practices through distinct Sarma lineages.

Nyingma Classification

Outer Tantras

In the Nyingma tradition of , the Outer Tantras comprise the foundational levels of tantric practice within the nine yanas (vehicles), a progressive schema that integrates and paths toward enlightenment. These include Kriya Tantra, focused on ; Charya Tantra, emphasizing balanced conduct between external actions and internal ; and Yoga Tantra, centered on inner meditative absorption and deity union. Together, they form vehicles 4 through 6 in the nine yanas system, bridging the three outer yanas of foundational (Sravakayana, Pratyekabuddhayana, and Bodhisattvayana) with the advanced Inner Tantras. A distinctive Nyingma feature is the integration of these tantras into a gradual path, where they are revitalized through terma () revelations attributed to and subsequent tertöns (treasure revealers), ensuring the teachings' purity and adaptability across eras. These Outer Tantras are viewed as essential preparations for the Inner Tantras (, Anuyoga, and Atiyoga), cultivating merit, purifying obscurations, and fostering the discipline needed for subtler realizations. In this context, they parallel the first three classes of the Sarma schools' tantric classification but are embedded in the Nyingma's broader nine-yana framework. Practices in the Outer Tantras involve rituals such as offerings, recitation, and visualizations of deities, often drawing from -specific lineages that incorporate as a central figure alongside tutelary deities like , Mañjuśrī, and . For instance, Kriya practices stress external purification through actions like ritual bathing and deity worship, treating the practitioner as a servant to the enlightened figure; Charya balances this with meditative equality to the deity; and emphasizes internal merger with the deity's wisdom, including visualizations to realize non-duality. These methods, transmitted via unbroken oral and textual lineages, adapt shared tantric elements to emphases on devotion and prophetic guidance from lamas. Prerequisites for engaging the Outer Tantras include receiving from a qualified tantric master, taking refuge and generating , maintaining ethical discipline, and cultivating faith and devotion, often alongside preliminary practices to ensure readiness. The benefits center on building an ethical foundation while transforming basic afflictive emotions: Kriya addresses pride through crown empowerments and purification; Charya targets desire via empowerments and balanced conduct; and counters aversion with bell empowerments and meditative insight, ultimately transmuting these into wisdom qualities like and clarity. This progression not only pacifies obstacles such as illness and conflict but also accelerates spiritual maturation, enabling practitioners to attain within a finite number of lifetimes—sixteen for Kriya, seven for Charya, and three for .
TantraPrimary FocusKey PracticesEmotions AddressedEstimated Lifetimes to Buddhahood
KriyaOfferings, , external devotion16
CharyaBalanced conductRitual-meditation integration, equality with Desire7
YogaInner union, visualizationAversion3

Mahayoga Tantra

Mahayoga Tantra, known as the "Great Yoga," constitutes the first of the three inner tantra classes in the school's nine-vehicle system, emphasizing the transformation of the conceptual mind through profound meditative practices. It focuses on the development or generation stage (bskyed rim), where practitioners generate elaborate visualizations of mandalas and mantras to realize the non-dual nature of phenomena as enlightened mind. This class integrates method (upāya) and (prajñā) in a non-dual framework, viewing all appearances as the play of intrinsic awareness and employing antinomian elements to transcend dualistic perceptions. Central to Mahayoga practices are detailed visualizations of wrathful deities and their mandalas, which serve to purify negative emotions such as and by embodying their energetic transformation into . Practitioners engage in actions, including the of mantras, of deities through seed syllables (like hūṃ), and the construction of mandalas in stages—beginning with meditation and progressing to the full assembly of deities. The eight herukas, or (such as Vajrakīla and Hayagrīva), form a core cycle known as the Eight Sadhana Teachings (bka' brgyad), which address the subjugation of inner obstacles through fierce s and the integration of bliss and . These practices, often conducted in group settings like the great accomplishment ceremony (sgrub chen), utilize techniques, such as focusing on winds in chakras, to stabilize the visualization and manifest siddhis. The primary associated text is the (Secret Essence), a foundational scripture comprising 22 chapters that outlines the generation of peaceful and wrathful mandalas, with 42 peaceful and 58 wrathful deities, synthesizing the essence of the eighteen tantras. This tantra teaches the view that "all phenomena without exception are included within mind and enlightenment itself," guiding practitioners toward the realization of the three kayas through . Complementing it are the Eight Sadhana Teachings, which provide practical liturgies for the practices. corresponds briefly to the Father Tantras within the Sarma schools' Anuttarayoga classification, sharing an emphasis on generation-stage methods. Prerequisites for engaging Mahayoga include a foundation in the outer tantras (Kriya, Charya, and ), along with receiving (dbang) from a qualified , such as through the supreme , and cultivating devotion and as emphasized in historical edicts like that of King Tri Desongtsen. These ensure the practitioner's readiness for its non-gradual, direct approach to enlightenment. Benefits encompass mastery over appearances, whereby all sensory experiences are recognized as mandala-like displays of mind, leading to the four levels of vidyādhara realization—ranging from maturation to spontaneous presence—and ultimate buddhahood through the integration of great bliss and non-conceptual gnosis. As part of 's inner vehicles, Mahayoga accelerates the path by collapsing the distinction between samsara and nirvana in the development stage.

Anuyoga Tantra

Anuyoga, known as the "vehicle of scriptural transmission following ," constitutes the second of the three inner tantras in the school's nine-yāna classification, emphasizing the completion stage practices that build upon the development stage of . As a mother tantra, it prioritizes wisdom and , viewing all phenomena as the creative expression of the indivisible unity of absolute space and primordial awareness, with primordial enlightenment manifesting as the three mandalas: primordial suchness, spontaneously perfect nature, and original bodhichitta. Its core focus lies on the , particularly the channels (tsa), winds-energies (), and essences (tiklé), through which practitioners cultivate nonduality transcending form while penetrating samsara and nirvana with unceasing pristine awareness. The practices of Anuyoga center on subtle body yogas, including techniques involving the upper and lower gateways to generate bliss and emptiness, alongside luminosity meditation that fosters non-conceptual bliss-emptiness. These integrate sound and light via the three yogas of cause, condition, and result, employing mantra recitation, seed-syllable visualization, and deity generation to rest in the natural state or analyze reality. Meditation unfolds along two paths: one of liberation through non-conceptual samādhi and conceptual deity practice, and one of skillful means emphasizing the inner yoga of channels, winds, and essences to realize the nonduality of ultimate dimension and awareness. Conduct in Anuyoga transcends dualistic adoption or rejection, recognizing all perceptions as displays of great bliss wisdom. Key associated tantras include the All-Unifying Pure Presence Tantra (Kun ’dus rig pa’i mdo), which outlines the foundational views and practices. Prerequisites for Anuyoga involve maturation through 's empowerments, often the 36 initiations divided into four rivers—outer, inner, accomplishing, and secret—to establish the ground for completion-stage work. Its benefits transform ignorance into great bliss and wisdom, culminating in direct realization of the at the level of Samantabhadrā via the five yogas and ten stages, completing the yoga process initiated in Mahayoga while remaining within the completion stage, unlike Atiyoga's transcendence of stages altogether. In parallel with the Sarma schools' mother tantras, Anuyoga shares an emphasis on wisdom-oriented completion practices.

Atiyoga

Atiyoga, also known as Dzogchen or the Great Perfection, represents the pinnacle of the Nyingma school's tantric classification, regarded as the supreme yoga that transcends gradual approaches by directly introducing practitioners to the innate purity of the mind. This path emphasizes the recognition of rigpa, the primordial awareness that is naturally luminous, empty, and free from conceptual elaboration, allowing practitioners to realize the mind's original state without reliance on contrived methods. Structured into three series—the Mind Series (Semde), which focuses on the essential nature of mind; the Space Series (Longde), which explores expansive awareness; and the Instruction Series (Mengagde), which provides direct pointers to realization—Atiyoga integrates these to unveil the non-dual reality inherent in all phenomena. Central to Atiyoga practices are Trekchö (cutting through), a method of decisively severing delusions to rest in the natural state of , and Tögal (leaping over), which involves visionary practices that manifest lights and forms as expressions of awareness, culminating in advanced realizations. Unlike lower tantras, Atiyoga eschews and external rituals, prioritizing unmediated experience of awareness over symbolic visualizations or transformative stages. These practices are transmitted through foundational texts such as the and the Kulayarāja Tantra, which articulate the view of primordial purity and spontaneity. The tradition's preservation relies on termas (hidden treasure teachings) revealed by tertöns and systematized by key figures like (1308–1364), whose commentaries, such as the Seven Treasuries, elucidate the profound nuances of for authentic transmission. Atiyoga is intended for individuals with exceptionally sharp faculties, requiring preliminary initiations and direct introduction from a qualified to stabilize rigpa and avoid misinterpretation. Its benefits include the direct dissolution of afflictive emotions without sequential purification, potentially leading to the rainbow body (jalü), where the practitioner's form dissolves into light at the time of passing, signifying complete enlightenment. As the culmination of the Nyingma's nine vehicles, Atiyoga offers a swift path for those ready to integrate all teachings into immediate awareness.

Comparisons Between Classifications

Shared Elements

Across the Sarma and classifications of in , the three outer s—Kriya, Charya, and —form a shared foundational structure emphasizing progressive stages of purification through ritual actions and meditative integration. These classes provide a common framework for practitioners to engage in external rituals and internal contemplations aimed at cleansing obscurations and cultivating enlightened qualities, serving as preparatory bases for higher tantric practices in both traditions. Universal practices unite these systems, including deity yoga, where practitioners visualize themselves as enlightened figures to embody buddha qualities; initiations (abhiṣeka) that empower participants for tantric meditation; mandalas representing sacred environments for practice; and samaya vows that establish commitments to maintain the purity of the path. The overarching goal of these practices is to transform afflictive emotions, such as ignorance and desire, into corresponding aspects of wisdom, thereby realizing the innate purity of mind. Philosophically, all tantric classes in Tibetan Buddhism are grounded in Mahayana principles of emptiness (śūnyatā), which affirms the lack of inherent existence in phenomena, and compassion (karuṇā), which motivates the welfare of all beings. This foundation integrates skillful means with wisdom, often employing deities from the vajra family—such as Akṣobhya and Vajrapāṇi—to symbolize the indestructible nature of enlightenment and the transmutation of aversion into mirror-like wisdom. Historically, both Sarma and traditions draw from shared Indian tantric sources transmitted to , including texts like the , which influenced yogic and ritual elements across schools despite varying emphases in classification. These overlaps reflect mutual influences during 's second diffusion of (11th–13th centuries), where translators and masters from both lineages collaborated on scriptural preservation and practice lineages.

Key Differences

The Sarma schools of , encompassing the , , , and traditions, classify tantric texts into four progressive classes—Kriya, Charya, , and Anuttarayoga—wherein the inner tantras are consolidated under the highest class of Anuttarayoga, emphasizing a structured ascent from external rituals to subtle internal realizations. In contrast, the school employs a six-class system, retaining the first three outer classes (Kriya, Charya, ) shared with the Sarma but expanding the inner tantras into three distinct categories: , Anuyoga, and Atiyoga, which separate development-stage practices, completion-stage methods, and transcendent insight, respectively. This structural divergence arose from the Nyingma's reliance on earlier translations from the 8th century, while the Sarma drew from later Indian transmissions starting in the . Within the highest inner tantras, the Sarma's Anuttarayoga is subdivided into (method-oriented), (wisdom-oriented), and Non-dual categories, with variations across sub-schools—such as the distinguishing only two, while and include the non-dual—tailored to specific deity practices and energy systems. The , however, delineates as focused on generative visualization (development stage), Anuyoga on subtle body completion (including channels and winds), and Atiyoga as the pinnacle of direct, non-gradual realization through . These subdivisions reflect differing interpretive frameworks, with Sarma integrating all advanced practices under a unified highest umbrella, whereas Nyingma's tripartite inner structure allows for a more layered progression toward innate awareness. Philosophically, the Sarma classification adopts a gradualist approach, prioritizing methodological cultivation of bliss and through staged tantric paths that build upon sutric foundations, often aligning with or other systems but remaining method-centric. The Nyingma, by contrast, integrates Dzogchen's emphasis on immediate recognition of primordial purity (), viewing Atiyoga as transcending dualistic constructs altogether, and occasionally framing tantras within broader schemas like the nine vehicles to underscore direct over progressive accumulation. This leads to a more holistic philosophical scope in Nyingma, where tantric vehicles address the explicitly—Mahayoga transforming anger, Anuyoga desire, and Atiyoga ignorance—fostering non-dual integration from the outset. Practically, the Nyingma's terma () tradition introduces elements of , with teachings revealed through tertöns (treasure revealers) to ensure relevance for specific eras, contrasting the Sarma's reliance on rigorous, publicly transmitted Indian commentaries and unbroken oral lineages that emphasize scholarly and standardized empowerments. These differences influence transmission: Sarma practices demand methodical adherence to commentarial precision for efficacy, while Nyingma's approach allows for adaptive, concealed revelations tailored to practitioners' karmic conditions, such as targeting through wrathful deities to expedite emotional purification. Overall, such variances underscore the Nyingma's innovative, insight-driven adaptability versus the Sarma's disciplined, foundational orthodoxy.

References

  1. https://chinesebuddhiststudies.org/wp-content/uploads/chbj2306Steve-131-166.pdf
  2. https://treasuryoflives.org/bo/foundations/view/9/182029
  3. https://library.brown.edu/cds/BuddhistTempleArt/buddhism2.html
  4. https://encyclopediabuddhicaf19.andrewquintman.wescreates.wesleyan.edu/blog/t/tantra/
  5. https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/tantra-theory/making-sense-of-tantra/the-meaning-of-tantra
  6. https://philarchive.org/archive/CMMOT
  7. https://www.lamayeshe.com/article/various-aspects-tantra
  8. https://oxfordre.com/religion/display/10.1093/acrefore/9780199340378.001.0001/acrefore-9780199340378-e-59
  9. https://www.jstor.org/stable/41694230
  10. https://www.academia.edu/109217648/The_Yoga_Tantras_and_the_Social_Context_of_Their_Transmission_to_Tibet
  11. https://collab.its.virginia.edu/wiki/tibetantexts/history%20of%20ngb.html
  12. https://www.academia.edu/114223761/Mandala_of_the_Tantra
  13. http://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/tantra-advanced/kriya-tantra-practice/kriya-tantra-six-deities-practice
  14. https://encyclopediaofbuddhism.org/wiki/Kriya_tantra
  15. https://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Kriya_Tantra
  16. https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/tantra-theory/the-differences-among-the-four-classes-of-tantra
  17. https://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Charya_Tantra
  18. https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=2914
  19. https://84000.co/translation/toh498
  20. https://www.du.ac.in/du/uploads/departments/BuddhistStudies/Study%20Material/21052020_BS402F_Four%20Sections%20of%20Tantra.pdf
  21. https://www.chibs.edu.tw/ch_html/chbj/23/Steve%20131-166.pdf
  22. https://encyclopediaofbuddhism.org/wiki/Highest_Yoga_Tantra
  23. https://84000.co/translation/toh384/UT22084-079-011-introduction
  24. https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/tantra-advanced/why-tantra-is-more-efficient-than-sutra/the-efficiency-of-anuttarayoga-tantra-gelug
  25. https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=6550
  26. https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/tantra-advanced/introduction-to-the-six-yogas-of-naropa
  27. https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/tantra-advanced/introduction-to-the-six-yogas-of-naropa/six-yogas-of-naropa-the-generation-stage
  28. https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/16/9/1133
  29. https://wisdomexperience.org/product/hidden-teachings-tibet/
  30. https://www.shambhala.com/introduction-to-tibetan-buddhism-2266.html
  31. https://escholarship.org/content/qt3qw0h86d/qt3qw0h86d_noSplash_4010b9ab84c8770bcefe379ad24b3c28.pdf
  32. https://journals.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/index.php/jiabs/article/download/8959/2852/8753
  33. https://buddhanature.tsadra.org/index.php/Key_Terms/Nyingma
  34. https://www.lotsawahouse.org/tibetan-masters/alak-zenkar/nine-yanas
  35. http://abhidharma.ru/A/Tantra/Content/0007.pdf
  36. https://wisdomcompassion.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/The-Treasury-of-Knowledge-The-Elements-of-Tantric-Practice.pdf
  37. https://www.upaya.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/Longchen-Rabjam-The-Precious-Treasury-of-Philosophical-Systems.pdf
  38. https://encyclopediaofbuddhism.org/wiki/Three_outer_tantras
  39. https://www.saet.ac.uk/Buddhism/VajrayanaRitual
  40. https://dakinitranslations.com/2022/06/14/the-unbreakable-diamond-vajra-marriage-commitment-ring-of-samaya-until-awakening-do-us-part-vajrayana-samaya-commitments-and-the-fourteen-root-downfalls-in-parti/
  41. https://www.luminouswisdom.org/index.php/publications/gateway-to-the-vajrayana-path/3887-sutra-and-tantra-similarities-and-differences-based-on-the-view-of-rongzom-pandita
  42. https://tricycle.org/beginners/buddhism/bodhicitta/
  43. https://www.himalayanart.org/search/set.cfm?setID=2919
  44. https://academic.oup.com/book/626/chapter/135333076
  45. https://tricycle.org/buddhism-tibetan/
  46. https://studybuddhism.com/en/advanced-studies/vajrayana/dzogchen-advanced/the-major-facets-of-dzogchen
  47. https://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Six_classes_of_tantra
  48. https://www.rigpawiki.org/index.php?title=Destructive_emotions
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.