Hubbry Logo
Rae-raeRae-raeMain
Open search
Rae-rae
Community hub
Rae-rae
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Rae-rae
Rae-rae
Rae-rae
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Rae-rae are transfeminine people in Tahitian culture related to Māhū (meaning "in the middle"), a gender category in Polynesia.

History

[edit]

Connection to French military presence and sex work

[edit]

The development of the Rae-Rae identity coincided with the opening of Fa‘a‘a International Airport and the establishment of the Centre d’Expérimentation du Pacifique (CEP) for nuclear testing, which brought an influx of military personnel and tourists to French Polynesia.[1] This influx led to a booming sex trade, prompting Māhū to adopt a more feminine appearance to attract Frenchmen, thus leading to the distinction of Rae-Rae from traditional Māhū.[2]

The term Rae-Rae emerged in Tahiti in the 1960s to describe a type of Māhū who began expressing their gender more overtly as women in society.[3] Māhū initially provided sexual services to Frenchmen, and over time, those who feminized their gender expression more successfully attracted these foreigners, which led to the emergence of the term "Rae-Rae" to distinguish these more feminized Māhū from others.[1]

In Polynesian Society

[edit]

Comparison with Māhū identity

[edit]

In French Polynesian culture, there are two distinct third-gender categories: Māhū and Rae-Rae. Māhū, indigenous to the Islands, with a long cultural history dating back to the pre-contact period, are often described as "half-man, half-woman," engaging in feminine-coded labor and viewed positively as good advisers and caretakers.[1] Māhū are considered "traditional" and "culturally authentic."[2] While Māhū may dress as men using their given names and occasionally wear women's clothing without typically pursuing body modifications, Rae-Rae are viewed as a more modern category, often living openly as women, adopting women's names, wearing female clothing and makeup, and sometimes undergoing hormone treatment and gender-affirmation surgery.[3] Rae-Rae are often critical of what they perceive as ambiguity and cowardice in Māhū gender expression.[3]

Place within French Polynesian society

[edit]

Rae-Rae face varying levels of acceptance across different communities. Unlike Māhū, Rae-Rae often encounter malignment, ridicule, and harassment.[1] On Tahiti, Rae-Rae are frequently marginalized and viewed negatively due to their association with sex work, Western-style transgender identities, and white femininity, which significantly impacts their social acceptance.[4] While they find more acceptance in larger cosmopolitan areas, Rae-Rae face increased marginalization on smaller, conservative islands like Rurutu.[2] On Bora Bora, both Māhū and Rae-Rae are integrated and valued within their families and the tourist industry, with Rae-Rae not being labeled as sex workers despite engaging in similar activities.[1] Although Rae-Rae, like Māhū, are integrated into family structures and social life, they tend to stretch the limits of an accepted third-gender traditional role more than Māhū do.[3] This often leads to Rae-Rae being viewed as incompatible with the traditional Polynesian worldview and sometimes seen as culturally inauthentic due to their associations with French patrons and contemporary lifestyles.[5]

Relationships with families

[edit]

Family support is crucial for both Māhū and Rae-Rae individuals in Polynesian society, with Māhū generally experiencing tolerance while Rae-Rae often face rejection and expulsion from their homes.[2] Rae-Rae encounter significant challenges within conservative or religious families, exacerbated by a prevalent belief among older generations that prostitution is their only viable future.[2]

Law and recognition of gender identity

[edit]

Despite progressive French laws governing French Polynesia, which provide LGBTQ+ rights and allow legal gender changes without surgery, cultural recognition of Rae-Rae remains limited, especially on smaller islands.[2] Rae-Rae often seek recognition as women rather than a separate third-gender identity, but face negative perceptions in Tahitian society due to their perceived focus on sexuality and Western influences.[4] This lack of acceptance and limited opportunities in conservative communities drive many Rae-Rae to migrate to urban areas or mainland France.[2] Those seeking gender-affirming surgeries often travel abroad to countries like France, Thailand, or Turkey for better healthcare options and lower costs, although these procedures remain expensive.[2][4]

Characteristics

[edit]

Gender expression and presentation

[edit]

Rae-Rae individuals in Polynesian society express their femininity through various means, characterized by cosmopolitan fashion style and extensive makeup, often emulating Euro-American fashion-model aesthetics.[1] Unlike Māhū, who wear men's clothes and balance masculine and feminine traits, Rae-Rae engage in deliberate feminine expression by adopting female gender roles, wearing women's clothing, and using female names in their daily lives.[3] This commitment to feminine expression extends to participation in transgender beauty contests and taking on roles as advisors on fashion and cosmetics, as well as teachers of traditional dances.[3]

Rae-Rae frequently undergo bodily modifications, including hormone therapy, dieting, breast enlargement, and sometimes gender-affirming surgery, to align their physical appearance with their gender identity.[1] However, the approach to body modification among Rae-Rae is not uniform. While many use hormones to feminize their bodies and seek gender-affirming surgeries, others hesitate due to potential side effects like weight gain or impacts on sexual pleasure.[3]

Outside French Polynesia

[edit]

Intersection with LGBTQ+ identities

[edit]

Both Māhū and Rae-Rae are considered part of the broader LGBTQ+ spectrum in French Polynesia, but they represent different aspects of gender identity. The Rae-Rae identity aligns more closely with Western concepts of transgender women and intersects with Western notions of gay and transgender identities.[2] This Western influence has contributed to a negative perception of Rae-Rae in Tahitian society.[4]

References

[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Rae-rae

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Rae-rae (also spelled rae rae) refers to a category of biologically male individuals in Tahitian society who adopt feminine presentation, including clothing and mannerisms, and who are predominantly involved in prostitution, particularly catering to tourists. The term emerged in Tahiti during the 1960s amid post-colonial urbanization and increased Western tourism, marking a shift from the traditional māhū—effeminate males integrated into communities through familial and ceremonial roles without routine commercial sex. Unlike māhū, whose liminal gender status historically conferred social acceptance and duties such as child-rearing in female-absent households, rae-rae are often viewed as marginal or inauthentic, concentrated in urban areas like Papeete and linked to nocturnal sex work. This distinction reflects broader tensions in Polynesian gender systems, where anthropological observations from the late noted rae-rae as a newer, more overtly sexualized variant of male , influenced by economic pressures and foreign demand rather than indigenous spiritual traditions. Rae-rae face , including and health risks such as elevated rates due to unprotected sex work, yet some ethnographic accounts highlight their agency in navigating economic opportunities unavailable to traditional . The term itself carries pejorative connotations for certain māhū communities, who associate it with degradation rather than cultural continuity. Despite occasional romanticization in , empirical studies emphasize rae-rae's precarious position, shaped by causal factors like tourism-driven of sex rather than innate gender variance alone.

Terminology and Origins

Etymology and definitions

The term rae-rae (variously spelled raerae or rae rae) refers to biological males in Tahitian culture who adopt feminine presentation, behaviors, and social roles, often involving , makeup, and in some cases or surgical modifications to align appearance with womanhood. This identity emerged specifically in during the 1960s, distinguishing it from broader Polynesian gender concepts, and is typically associated with to men. Etymologically, the precise origin of rae-rae is uncertain, though anthropologists trace it to in the mid-20th century, potentially as the nickname of a (traditional third-gender figure) involved in sex work amid the influx of French military personnel during nuclear testing eras. In , the term initially bore derogatory connotations, linked to slang for , , or terms like "whore" and "cock sucker," reflecting its ties to urban sex trade dynamics rather than ancient indigenous roots. Unlike pre-colonial Polynesian terms, rae-rae represents a modern sociological category, critiqued by some traditionalists for emphasizing overt feminization over liminal gender balance.

Distinction from māhū and other Polynesian gender concepts

Rae-rae represent a distinct category within Tahitian gender variance, emerging in the as a more overt feminine expression compared to the traditional , who embody a liminal identity historically recognized across as "in the middle" between male and roles. have pre-colonial roots, serving as spiritual healers, advisors to royalty, and community caretakers without adopting full presentation or medical interventions, maintaining ambiguous dress and behaviors that integrate both genders. In contrast, rae-rae typically identify and present exclusively as women, utilizing attire, makeup, and often hormone treatments or surgeries, reflecting a binary alignment rather than . This distinction underscores rae-rae's modern urban origins, tied to post-colonial influences like French military presence and economic shifts, whereas roles emphasize cultural continuity and non-sexual social functions. Societally, rae-rae face greater marginalization than , with the term initially carrying connotations of sex work and , leading some to reject it as an abject deviation from traditional respectability. enjoy broader acceptance, particularly in rural islands like , where they fulfill familial duties such as childcare and elder care, viewed as integral to Polynesian heritage despite colonial suppressions by missionaries in the . Rae-rae, however, often migrate to urban for opportunities in entertainment or service industries, with varying stigma that diminishes in cosmopolitan settings but persists due to associations with and bodily modifications costing thousands of dollars. Anthropological accounts highlight that while both groups are biologically male and attracted primarily to men, rae-rae's explicit female embodiment challenges the balanced duality of , positioning them as a post-1960s influenced by rather than indigenous . Beyond , rae-rae diverge from analogous Polynesian concepts like Samoan fa'afafine or Tongan fakaleiti, which parallel in their traditional, non-binary frameworks rooted in pre-contact societies and emphasizing community integration without urban commodification or surgical transitions. These other identities, similar to , historically involved ceremonial and domestic roles without the binary female orientation or marginal economic ties seen in rae-rae, which remain largely confined to and reflect French Polynesia's unique colonial-urban dynamics rather than pan-Polynesian norms. Such distinctions highlight rae-rae as a culturally bounded evolution, critiqued by traditionalists for departing from the revered of and kin concepts.

Historical Context

Pre-colonial Polynesian gender roles

In pre-colonial Polynesian societies, including and , gender roles were largely binary, with males responsible for warfare, deep-sea fishing, canoe construction, and political leadership, while females handled , , childcare, and household management. However, a culturally recognized category, māhū (meaning "in the middle" or embodying both male and female essences), allowed for individuals assigned male at birth to adopt feminine attire, behaviors, and occupations from childhood, such as domestic tasks, crafting, and performing women's ceremonial dances like , where they often represented goddesses. This role was not merely performative but integrated into daily life, with māhū serving as mediators between genders due to their perceived balanced spiritual qualities. Māhū occupied esteemed positions in society, functioning as healers, teachers of cultural lore, advisors to chiefs, and participants in sacred rituals from which women were excluded, such as certain temple ceremonies in Hawaiian traditions. Ethnographic reconstructions, drawing from 18th-century European explorer accounts and indigenous oral histories, indicate māhū were socially accepted and viewed as natural variations rather than deviations, contributing to community harmony by filling niches for those physically or temperamentally unsuited to male duties. Robert Levy's fieldwork in the 1960s–1970s on confirmed continuity of these roles from pre-contact eras, describing māhū as assuming full women's social and occupational responsibilities without inherent stigma. Evidence for these practices derives primarily from early contact-period observations, such as those compiled by Douglas Oliver in his 1974 reconstruction of ancient Tahitian society, which posits as adaptive social roles predating European arrival around 1767. While direct pre-colonial artifacts are scarce, the absence of in documented accounts and the persistence in post-contact oral traditions support their embeddedness in Polynesian cosmology, where gender liminality aligned with spiritual dualities rather than modern identity frameworks. This contrasts with later colonial disruptions, but pre-colonial represented functional integration rather than marginalization.

Emergence linked to French military and colonization (1940s–1960s)

The establishment of as an overseas territory of in 1946, following the territory's support for the Free French forces during , intensified colonial administration and economic ties, laying groundwork for later social transformations. This period saw gradual urbanization in and increased French influence, though traditional Polynesian gender roles like māhū persisted with diminished prestige due to earlier missionary and colonial pressures promoting binary norms. The term raerae emerged in Tahiti during the 1960s to denote biological males—often from māhū backgrounds—who adopted overtly feminine presentations, including clothing and mannerisms mimicking Western women, in contrast to the more liminal, integrated traits of traditional māhū. This shift coincided with France's relocation of nuclear weapons testing to the Moruroa and Fangataufa atolls starting in 1966, which deployed thousands of military personnel and support staff to the region, spurring economic booms in urban centers like Papeete alongside heightened demand for commercial sex. Raerae frequently entered sex work to serve French soldiers, who sought receptive partners in anal intercourse, fostering a category defined more by sexual commodification and Western-influenced transgender expression than by pre-colonial cultural functions. Anthropologist Robert I. Levy, conducting fieldwork in from the early to late , observed that rae-rae had only recently entered use by the late decade, becoming synonymous with male who emphasized feminine to attract clients, distinct from whose identities centered on gender rather than overt sexuality or economic exchange. This emergence reflected causal dynamics of colonial modernization: military-driven economies incentivized performative feminization among economically marginalized gender-variant individuals, embedding raerae within urban vice networks rather than traditional roles. While some sources attribute the term's to for oral or anal acts ("to suck" or "whore"), its rapid adoption underscored adaptations to foreign demand over indigenous evolution.

Post-colonial developments and urbanization influences

The term raerae emerged in Tahiti during the 1960s amid rapid social transformations triggered by France's nuclear testing program, which began in 1966 and relocated approximately 20,000 to the islands, stimulating a burgeoning sex trade. Many māhū—traditional third-gender individuals—adopted more overtly feminine presentations, including makeup and women's clothing, to participate in targeting French soldiers, distinguishing them from less performative māhū roles and associating raerae with economic opportunism rather than cultural integration. This period marked a shift from pre-colonial māhū acceptance toward a stigmatized category, with the term itself possibly deriving from a prominent sex worker's , reflecting causal links between military influx and altered gender expressions. Urbanization accelerated these developments, as economic growth from nuclear activities and concentrated populations in , Tahiti's capital, where over 70% of French Polynesia's 280,000 residents lived by the 1990s. Rural-to-urban migration disrupted traditional family structures, enabling raerae communities to form in the city's cosmopolitan environment, which tolerated greater visibility compared to conservative outer islands like , where familial oversight limited overt expressions. High urban living costs, exceeding rural norms by factors of 2-3 times in housing and goods, pushed many raerae into sex work for income and access to gender-affirming hormones or surgeries imported from , intertwining economic with . Post-1996, following the end of nuclear tests and increased autonomy under the 2004 Organic Law, raerae visibility persisted in urban settings amid expansion, which by 2019 drew 200,000 visitors annually to , exposing locals to and influences that further feminized raerae aesthetics beyond Polynesian traditions. However, urban density also amplified discrimination, with reports of trans-negative violence higher in than rural areas, though family support networks mitigated isolation for some, allowing raerae to pursue roles in or cultural performances. These dynamics underscore how fostered raerae as a hybrid identity—rooted in colonial-era disruptions but sustained by modern economic migrations—contrasting with māhū's enduring rural embeddedness.

Social Integration in French Polynesia

Societal perceptions and roles

In French Polynesian society, rae-rae are often perceived as adopting female identities, yet they encounter significant stigma, particularly due to associations with and their emergence as a post-colonial phenomenon distinct from traditional . This perception positions them as less culturally authentic than , who occupy a liminal third-gender role with broader social acceptance rooted in pre-colonial norms. On smaller islands like , evangelical Christian influences amplify derogatory views, leading to family rejection and restrictions on mobility, while urban centers like exhibit greater cosmopolitan tolerance. Rae-rae fulfill roles emphasizing feminine expression, including participation in cultural activities such as heiva dances—though typically confined to male-designated performances—and domestic or caregiving tasks within families. Economically, many engage in service-oriented jobs like hairstyling, waitressing, or dance instruction, but a notable proportion turn to sex work, with 36% of surveyed rae-rae reporting involvement at some point. This economic pattern reflects marginalization, as limited employment opportunities push them toward nightlife sectors, exacerbating perceptions of chaos or deviance. Social integration shows gradual improvement, with 64% of rae-rae expressing positive feelings about their identity in adulthood compared to 38% during childhood, and 62% noting maternal support. However, persists in rural areas and religious contexts, including and job barriers, hindering full community embedding. Family dynamics often involve financial contributions from rae-rae, fostering some acceptance, yet overall, their roles remain peripheral compared to māhū's more embedded status.

Family relationships and community dynamics

Rae-rae frequently encounter familial rejection, particularly from fathers and in religiously conservative households, where overt feminine expression conflicts with traditional expectations. In evangelical communities on islands like , parents may expel rae-rae from the home or restrict their movements to suppress gender nonconformity. A 2023 study of māhū and raerae found that none reported feeling closer to their fathers during childhood, in contrast to 47% feeling closer to mothers, with 21% describing early parental relationships as hostile. Maternal support often proves more enduring, with positive attitudes toward diversity rising from 51% in childhood to 62% currently among mothers, compared to 36% to 49% for fathers. Despite initial tensions, some rae-rae secure acceptance through demonstrated utility, such as financial contributions or caregiving; 38% in the study currently care for non-biological children, and 13% for elderly relatives, roles that mirror traditional familial duties and foster gradual integration. relations show moderate positivity, with 53% reporting supportive siblings in childhood, increasing slightly to 57% in adulthood. However, familial bonds remain fragile for many, prompting reliance on extended kin or migration to urban centers like , where academic success—such as one rae-rae gaining parental approval at age 11 through strong school performance—can mitigate rejection. In community settings, rae-rae experience marginalization beyond traditional roles, often confined to and facing due to stigma linked to sex work and perceived deviance from Polynesian norms. They compensate by forming tight-knit peer networks, such as clusters of rae-rae cousins who collaborate on transitions, social preparations, and mutual affirmation, providing emotional refuge absent in families. On conservative outer islands, rae-rae number fewer than (e.g., 10 versus 15 on ) and endure exclusion from cultural events, where they may be relegated to male-coded participation despite self-identification as women. Urban migration to or abroad enables greater visibility and activist support, though community-wide acceptance lags behind māhū, who benefit from historical as cultural caretakers. Older māhū occasionally mentor younger rae-rae in practical , including sex work navigation, fostering informal subcultural ties amid broader societal wariness. Friendships sustain 64% positive self-regard in adulthood (up from 38% in childhood), underscoring peer groups as primary buffers against minority stress.

Economic factors, including sex work prevalence

Rae-rae in often face socioeconomic marginalization due to gender nonconformity, which limits access to stable despite the territory's tourism-dominated accounting for 85% of as of 2012. High living costs in urban centers like , comparable to major global cities, exacerbate financial pressures, particularly for those funding gender-affirming hormones or surgeries not fully covered by healthcare systems. Family rejection and workplace further contribute to economic vulnerability, with some rae-rae experiencing exclusion from traditional roles or facing barriers in service-sector jobs prevalent in the region. While some rae-rae secure positions in tourism-related fields such as , , hairstyling, or even roles, these opportunities remain constrained by societal stigma and migration patterns from outer islands to for better prospects. , absence of unemployment benefits, and heavy indirect taxation amplify precarity, pushing many toward informal income sources amid limited social safety nets. Sex work represents a significant economic outlet for rae-rae, historically amplified by the influx of French during nuclear testing, which spurred a demand-driven trade. In , rae-rae constitute the majority of participants, with estimates of around 100 individuals involved overall and approximately 20 active daily as of the mid-2010s. A 2023 study of 47 and rae-rae found that 36% had engaged in sex work at some point, with 9% doing so regularly, often motivated by needs, quick earnings potential, and funding personal transitions rather than by pimps. This prevalence stems from economic necessity intertwined with social affirmation through partnerships, though community networks among sex workers provide mutual support absent in more structured industries.

Characteristics and Practices

Gender expression and daily presentation

Rae-rae in French Polynesia typically present with overt feminine , distinguishing them from the more liminal through consistent adoption of women's attire and mannerisms. A 2023 study of 126 gender-diverse individuals found that 74% of rae-rae participants wore clothing, with 43% doing so all the time, and 47% regularly using women's undergarments; they were more likely than māhū to use names and as women in public settings. This presentation often includes elegant, trendy outfits such as , pareos (traditional wrap skirts), and colorful floral-patterned attire, paired with makeup, , and effeminate gestures to affirm a female identity. In daily life, rae-rae integrate this feminine presentation into social and occupational roles, such as teaching Polynesian dances or working in fashion-related fields where they advise on style, reflecting a blend of cultural practices with modern influences. Approximately 49% have used to enhance feminine physical traits like , though surgical interventions such as breast implants or genital reconstruction remain rare at 4%. Unlike māhū, who often limit public expression to masculine or neutral clothing like shorts and T-shirts without makeup, rae-rae live openly as women, which can lead to marginalization in conservative rural areas but greater visibility in urban . This overt style aligns with a self-perception of womanhood among 74% of rae-rae, who view their expression as authentic despite societal stigma tied to associations with work.

Medical and surgical interventions

Rae-rae often pursue , typically involving estrogens and anti-androgens, to develop secondary female sex characteristics such as breast growth and softer skin, distinguishing their gender expression from that of traditional who generally avoid such modifications. In a 2023 study of 47 gender-diverse individuals in , including rae-rae, 49% reported prior use of female hormones, while 34% were currently taking them; participants noted motivations like enhanced but also concerns over side effects including reduced . Surgical interventions among rae-rae are less prevalent than , with procedures focused on , facial feminization, or genital reconstruction such as or . The same 2023 study found that only 4% had undergone and 4% genital surgery, though 49% had considered gender-affirming surgeries; limited local expertise in leads many to travel to , , or , where costs for such operations range from $1,500 for basic procedures to $50,000 for comprehensive genital surgeries. For instance, rae-rae individual Kaley Taputu underwent and a Brazilian butt lift in in the early , with plans for additional interventions. Access to these interventions in aligns with French national healthcare policies, where requires psychiatric evaluation and endocrinologist prescription, covered partially by social security, while surgeries often necessitate referral to specialized centers abroad due to insufficient infrastructure on the islands. Economic barriers, including high travel and procedure costs, restrict uptake primarily to those involved in sex work or with external support, contributing to uneven prevalence.

Sexual orientation and partner dynamics

Rae-rae, biological males who adopt female gender presentation, exhibit sexual orientations characterized by predominant attraction to cisgender men, with minimal interest in women. In a study of 47 gender-diverse individuals including rae-rae across French Polynesia, 85% expressed plans for future sexual activity exclusively with men, while 0% anticipated relations with women; participants rejected homosexual self-identification, instead framing their attractions as heterosexual from the perspective of women partnered with men. This aligns with broader observations that rae-rae integrate feminine identity with androphilic orientations, distinguishing them from traditional māhū, whose roles historically emphasized non-sexualized fluidity over overt homosexuality. Sexual behaviors among rae-rae typically involve receptive roles with partners, often commencing at young ages. The average age of sexual debut was 11.8 years, predominantly with older men (average partner age 17.2), and 68% reported their first partner as , with 28% involving anal penetration. Lifetime partners varied widely, from 2 to thousands in cases linked to sex work, though roles were not rigidly binary—some flexibility in insertive or receptive positions occurred, but receptive anal intercourse predominated in descriptions. Only 13% reported any lifetime sexual experience with women, with no ongoing interest. Partner dynamics for rae-rae emphasize transient encounters influenced by socioeconomic factors like sex work, though many aspire to stable relationships. Partnerships with men averaged 39 months in duration, with rare long-term ; 60% desired enduring unions, yet social marginalization and economic reliance on limited such outcomes. These dynamics reflect rae-rae's positioning as feminine partners to men, often without stigma for male participants who perceive the relations as heterosexual, but contributing to rae-rae's to exploitation.

Gender recognition laws in French Polynesia

, as an of , adheres to metropolitan French law for civil status matters, including gender recognition on official documents. This framework applies uniformly without local overrides specific to transgender individuals or rae-rae. Since the decree implementing the 2016 Justice Act (Loi n° 2016-1547) took effect on , 2017, adults aged 18 and older may petition for a change in the sex marker on birth certificates and related records via a judicial procedure before the public prosecutor (procureur de la République). The process requires demonstrating a "discordance" between the sex assigned at birth and the with which the individual identifies, typically through evidence of sustained social transition, such as consistent presentation and documentation of life in the affirmed ; no surgical alteration, sterilization, hormonal , or formal medical diagnosis of is mandated. The prosecutor reviews the request and can oppose it only for limited reasons, including recent gender marker changes, fraudulent intent, or concerns, with appeals available to the tribunal judiciaire; approvals are routine when criteria are met, often within months. Minors require and judicial oversight under stricter conditions. No provisions exist for non-binary or third-gender markers, limiting recognition to male or female categories. For rae-rae, who frequently pursue surgical and hormonal , this enables alignment of legal identity with physical and social presentation, though cultural separation from identities means legal changes do not confer traditional societal roles. As of 2025, ongoing legislative proposals in seek to shift to administrative self-declaration without , but these remain unadopted and would extend to Polynesia if enacted.

Access to healthcare and anti-discrimination measures

French Polynesia, as an overseas collectivity of , extends French national laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of , enacted in 2012 through amendments to the Penal Code that criminalize such acts with penalties up to five years imprisonment and fines of €75,000. These protections apply uniformly across French territories, including , , and services, though specific enforcement data for gender identity cases in Polynesia remains limited. In practice, rae-rae individuals frequently encounter , with many unable to secure jobs outside sex work due to employer bias and social stigma, particularly on conservative outer islands like . No dedicated local anti-discrimination measures exist exclusively for rae-rae or gender-diverse persons in ; reliance is on metropolitan French frameworks, supplemented by broader LGBTQ+ protections such as bans on and enhancements. Local consultations on LGBTQ+ rights, held in December 2023, highlighted ongoing societal barriers despite legal safeguards, with rae-rae facing family rejection and community marginalization rooted in religious conservatism. groups have called for stronger implementation, as evidenced by 2013 campaigns against transvestite discrimination in , but measurable reductions in reported incidents remain undocumented. Access to healthcare for rae-rae falls under 's universal Sécurité Sociale system, which covers residents of and reimburses medically necessary treatments, including and certain surgical interventions for when prescribed. In proper, sex reassignment surgeries are fully funded by for eligible adults, a benefit extending to Polynesian residents who travel to metropolitan facilities; however, local availability in is constrained, prompting many rae-rae to seek procedures abroad in or at personal costs ranging from $1,500 to $50,000. A 2023 study of gender-diverse individuals in found 81% reported positive experiences with local doctors, who were described as professional and non-judgmental, though hormone provision remains inconsistent and specialized care like surgeries is rarely available on-island. Barriers to healthcare persist due to geographic isolation on smaller islands, where migration to or is often required for comprehensive services, exacerbating economic vulnerabilities tied to discrimination-driven . While 66% of surveyed gender-diverse persons had accessed HIV testing—reflecting targeted efforts—mental health support is underutilized, with only 26% consulting therapists, amid broader stigma that discourages seeking care. 's inclusion of transition-related care for minors, such as puberty blockers and under medical oversight, applies in , but local implementation faces scrutiny amid metropolitan debates over youth treatments. Overall, legal entitlements contrast with practical gaps, where cultural acceptance of traditional identities offers partial social buffering unavailable to more medically transitioned rae-rae.

Health and Demographic Realities

Prevalence of HIV/AIDS and associated risks

HIV prevalence in is low relative to global standards, standing at 6.9 per 10,000 inhabitants as of 2024, though this marks an increase from 5.4 per 10,000 in 2019, particularly among those aged 15-24. Incidence rates reached 7.5 new cases per 100,000 in 2024, with early epidemics driven by male-to-male sexual transmission following introduction in the early . Male-to-male sex accounts for 38.5% to 39.1% of transmissions in the region, positioning men who have sex with men (MSM) as a key affected population. Specific prevalence data for rae-rae remain unavailable in reports, reflecting gaps in targeted epidemiological studies for this subgroup. Rae-rae, often categorized alongside as gender-diverse individuals, exhibit heightened vulnerability due to frequent engagement in commercial sex work and receptive anal intercourse, practices associated with elevated HIV transmission risk. Studies among gender-diverse populations in note high awareness of HIV risks, yet participants perceive local prevalence as low, potentially underestimating threats from unprotected encounters. Associated risks for rae-rae mirror those in broader vulnerable groups, including multiple concurrent partners, inconsistent use in sex work, and injecting drug use, which contributes to 11.7% of regional cases. Stigma and illegal status may deter testing and treatment access, exacerbating transmission. Globally, women face HIV odds 49 times higher than the general adult population, with prevalence estimates around 19%, highlighting analogous perils for rae-rae absent localized interventions. Rates remain elevated among sex workers and other at-risk cohorts in compared to the general populace.

Mental health challenges and substance use patterns

Gender diverse individuals in , including rae-rae, exhibit patterns of mental health challenges influenced by stigma and social marginalization, though many report improved well-being over time. In a 2023 study of 47 participants identifying as or rae-rae across multiple islands, 64% expressed positive feelings about their gender identity at the time of survey, compared to 38% retrospectively during upbringing, suggesting and resilience despite early adversities. Only 26% had ever consulted a therapist, potentially reflecting limited access to services or cultural reluctance to seek formal support in a context where family and community dynamics play central roles. Rae-rae specifically encounter heightened emotional strain from overt and visibility, often leading to rejection fears and conditional acceptance. Personal accounts highlight the need to demonstrate exceptional achievements, such as academic success, to secure parental support, underscoring a conditional familial framework that can perpetuate internalized distress. Societal stigma portrays rae-rae as deviant in conservative communities, contributing to isolation and fractured relationships, as evidenced by reports of maternal disapproval tied to religious values. Substance use patterns among these groups are notable but lack granular rae-rae-specific prevalence data; urban environments like facilitate access to , , and amphetamines, with substance involvement described as not uncommon alongside risks like interpersonal . In the same study, 19% reported and 32% , factors causally linked to elevated vulnerabilities and potential through substances in marginalized populations. Despite these challenges, 85% self-reported good or excellent overall health, indicating that while patterns exist, they do not universally define experiences.

Controversies and Critical Perspectives

Debates on cultural authenticity vs. Western influences

The distinction between rae-rae and the traditional Polynesian identity has fueled debates over whether rae-rae embodies authentic cultural continuity or represents a hybridization driven by Western and colonial legacies. Anthropologists such as Niko Besnier argue that while are framed as rooted in pre-colonial Polynesian kinship systems and spiritual roles—often involving individuals raised from childhood in dual-gender functions within families—rae-rae emerged primarily in urban during the late , coinciding with increased exposure to , , and medical technologies like and surgery. This view posits rae-rae as "culturally inauthentic" relative to , associating the former with individualistic gender transitions and sex work economies linked to French colonial infrastructure and international visitors, rather than communal obligations. Critics of this framing, including some queer theorists, contend that dismissing rae-rae as a Western import overlooks Polynesian agency in adapting identities amid modernization, suggesting that rigid authenticity claims romanticize while ignoring historical fluidity in Pacific systems disrupted by missionary and colonial moralities in the . However, empirical observations from communities indicate widespread local perceptions of rae-rae as disruptive to traditional epistemologies, with rae-rae often adopting hyper-feminine presentations via imported and prosthetics—practices absent in traditions—and facing stigma for perceived vulgarity or promiscuity tied to urban networks that expanded post-1960s nuclear testing migrations. Sociocultural data from the onward, including surveys in , reveal that older invoke heritage to critique rae-rae as emblematic of moral decay from Western individualism, contrasting with 's historical prestige in rituals like ori dance. These debates highlight tensions between cultural preservationism and progressive inclusivity, with some academics cautioning against essentializing Polynesian gender as static, yet local narratives—drawn from ethnographic fieldwork—persistently differentiate rae-rae through causal links to post-war economic shifts, such as the influx of American military personnel during and subsequent tourism booms that commodified gender variance. Proponents of rae-rae authenticity argue for viewing it as an within Polynesia's adaptive resilience, but this is countered by evidence of higher prevalence and social marginalization among rae-rae groups, attributed to their detachment from familial support structures central to roles. Ultimately, the discourse underscores a causal realism wherein Western influences—via media and biomedical access—have reshaped expressions of non-binary identity, prompting calls for culturally grounded interventions over uncritical adoption of imported frameworks.

Criticisms of conflation with traditional māhū identity

Critics argue that equating rae-rae with the traditional identity overlooks fundamental distinctions in historical roles, social acceptance, and behavioral patterns, thereby eroding the cultural specificity of as a pre-colonial Polynesian construct rooted in spiritual and communal functions rather than commercial sexuality. , documented in ethnographic accounts as embodying a liminal position—often involving child-rearing, artistic expression, and duties without inherent ties to —contrast sharply with rae-rae, a term emerging in the mid-20th century amid colonial and tourist influences, where individuals frequently pursue , , and engage in sex work targeting foreigners. This conflation, according to self-identified , imposes a stigmatizing overlay, as one interviewee stated: "I hate the term rae-rae, which appeared in the , because it makes us look like prostitutes," highlighting a deliberate separation to preserve 's non-sexualized prestige. Anthropological analyses further contend that blurring these categories risks retrofitting Western frameworks onto indigenous non-binary traditions, ignoring how rae-rae expressions—marked by overt hyper-femininity and economic motivations—deviate from 's balanced, "in-between" ethos uninfluenced by modern medical interventions or market-driven behaviors. Such equivalence has been criticized for amplifying health disparities attribution to broadly, when empirical data links elevated prevalence primarily to rae-rae's receptive anal intercourse in contexts, not the relational or passive sexual roles historically attributed to . This misattribution, scholars note, stems from post-colonial disruptions, including French military presence and , which commodified rae-rae identities absent in traditional narratives. Proponents of distinction emphasize that uncritical undermines efforts to reclaim māhū authenticity against Western sexual pathologies, potentially justifying interventions that pathologize liminal identities rather than recognizing their adaptive cultural resilience. By maintaining separation, Polynesian advocates and researchers argue for policies and discourses that honor māhū's historical reverence—evident in oral histories and artifacts predating European contact—while addressing rae-rae's contemporary vulnerabilities without . This perspective aligns with broader critiques of globalization's role in hybridizing identities, where rae-rae represent adaptation to economic rather than continuity of māhū's spiritual equilibrium.

Exploitation, stigma, and social costs

Rae-rae individuals frequently engage in as a primary economic strategy, given their routine and limited access to alternative livelihoods in Tahitian society. This involvement centers their social identity on sexual activity, rendering them vulnerable to physical , economic by clients, and inconsistent against risks during encounters. Stigma against rae-rae manifests in widespread , ridicule, and familial rejection, distinguishing them from more culturally integrated by associating their overt feminine presentation with deviance and poverty rather than traditional roles. Such perpetuates , with rae-rae often lacking community support networks beyond peer groups, and contributes to heightened vulnerability to without recourse to institutional protections. These dynamics impose broader social costs, including elevated rates of transmission linked to unprotected sex work among rae-rae, which aligns with French Polynesia's relatively high regional —among the highest in the Pacific as of through the 2010s. Additional burdens arise from patterns of , incarceration, and premature mortality within the group, straining limited and in a already facing resource constraints for infectious disease management.

Global and Contemporary Extensions

Intersections with international LGBTQ+ frameworks

, as an of , benefits from national legislation aligned with international standards, including protections against on grounds of in , housing, goods and services, healthcare, and education, implemented progressively from 2001 to 2014. and crime laws prohibiting incitement to hatred or violence based on have been in place since 2005 and strengthened in 2017, respectively, extending directives and UN commitments applicable via . These frameworks provide rae-rae individuals with legal recourse against bias, though enforcement in a culturally conservative Pacific context remains inconsistent, with reported transphobic aggressions underscoring practical limitations. International organizations such as ILGA-World document these protections but offer no targeted or reports specifically on rae-rae, reflecting the subculture's marginal status and divergence from Western transgender paradigms emphasized in global SOGI (sexual orientation and gender identity) resolutions at the UN Council. Rae-rae, often characterized by informal feminization through hormones or prosthetics amid sex work and urban poverty, do not prominently feature in ILGA's regional analyses, which prioritize legal reforms over culturally embedded phenomena tied to stigma and health vulnerabilities. Similarly, entities like or UN special rapporteurs on SOGI have not issued Polynesia-specific interventions addressing rae-rae, despite broader Pacific focus on third-gender rights in nations like (fa'afafine). This gap highlights how international frameworks, shaped by advocacy from activist networks, may overlook subgroups not fitting narratives of dignified identity affirmation. Regionally, intersections emerge through Pacific dialogues, as seen in the November 7-8, 2023, consultations at the University of themed "Our voices, our rights, our Pacific Way," which explicitly discussed rae-rae alongside other third-gender identities and involved delegates from , , , and . Hosted by local groups like Cousins-Cousines de Polynésie, the event acknowledged traditional Polynesian acceptance of gender variance while proposing an LGBTQ+ policy roadmap, though a related bill for full reimbursement of hormonal treatments failed in the Territorial Assembly amid budgetary debates. Such initiatives draw on forums like the , which addresses SOGI indirectly via health and , but rae-rae participation remains peripheral due to . Visibility efforts, including Polynesian contestants like Kalea Hanere in the 2022 Miss Trans Star International pageant and local events such as the crowning of O'omaka Gendron as Miss T 2023 on October 25, signal tentative alignments with global transgender networks, yet persistent —such as a May 13, 2023, assault reported in —reveals tensions between legal frameworks and societal realities. Overall, while providing a baseline of , international LGBTQ+ structures intersect unevenly with rae-rae experiences, prioritizing universal legal norms over culturally specific interventions for a group marked by exploitation and limited institutional engagement.

Media representations and tourism impacts

Media representations of rae-rae remain limited but have gained visibility through artistic and cinematic works. In 2020, photographer Namsa Leuba's series Oevae portrayed rae-rae in ritualistic attire against volcanic landscapes, emphasizing their transfeminine expressions alongside māhū subjects to challenge exoticized narratives. The 2022 film Pacifiction, directed by Albert Serra and selected for Cannes, features a rae-rae character entangled in geopolitical intrigue on Tahiti, depicting them as socially integrated yet marginalized in post-colonial contexts. Such portrayals often highlight tensions between cultural acceptance and Western influences, though mainstream media coverage tends to sensationalize rae-rae through lenses of prostitution or gender liminality rather than everyday integration. The advent of rae-rae in the aligned with French Polynesia's tourism surge, driven by nuclear testing infrastructure and international visitors, which amplified demand for sex work among feminized males. Many rae-rae entered —36% of surveyed gender-diverse individuals reported such engagement, often for amid high costs and access to gender-affirming care—frequently targeting foreign clients including tourists. This has entrenched economic reliance on , where rae-rae constitute a notable portion of Tahiti's informal sex sector, perpetuating exploitation and health risks while providing income in a tourism-dependent accounting for over 80% of service . Conversely, rae-rae visibility bolsters niche tourism, with official promotions touting Polynesian third-gender traditions to draw LGBTQ+ travelers seeking cultural authenticity. Yet, the prostitution linkage fosters stigma, deterring family acceptance in rural areas and reinforcing urban marginalization, as rae-rae face ridicule when associating with transient tourist economies. Scholarly accounts note this dynamic shifts traditional roles toward commodified femininity, exacerbating social costs without proportional benefits to broader tourism infrastructure.

References

  1. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11500545/
  2. https://www.mdpi.com/2075-471X/2/2/51
  3. https://www.academia.edu/5532957/Queer_History_and_Its_Discontents_at_Tahiti_The_Contested_Politics_of_Modernity_and_Sexual_Subjectivity
  4. https://newlinesmag.com/reportage/french-polynesias-third-gender-identities/
  5. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/297902326_RaeRae_and_Mahu_Third_polynesian_gender
  6. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26966855/
  7. https://www.tate.org.uk/tate-etc/issue-20-autumn-2010/men-women-pacific
  8. https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=11093&context=etd
  9. https://phmuseum.com/projects/transgender-idendity-in-the-pacific-area
  10. https://www.cia.gov/the-world-factbook/about/archives/2022/countries/french-polynesia
  11. https://journals.openedition.org/temporalites/2919
  12. https://doi.org/10.1080/26895269.2023.2291128
  13. https://www.service-public.fr/particuliers/vosdroits/F34826
  14. https://www.equaldex.com/region/french-polynesia
  15. https://www.tripsavvy.com/gender-identity-in-french-polynesia-5409496
  16. https://www.liberation.fr/societe/sexualite-et-genres/transidentite-apres-le-senat-la-proposition-de-loi-sur-la-facilitation-du-changement-de-genre-a-letat-civil-deposee-a-lassemblee-nationale-20241120_YKAF4LI3VJHOVNUICLFHCSVTXE/
  17. https://www.mfat.govt.nz/assets/OIA/OIA-2024/Formal-message-French-Polynesia-Gender-Equality-Ambassador-Pacific-visit-and-participation-in-LGBTQIA-Conference.pdf
  18. https://www.rnz.co.nz/international/pacific-news/504542/french-polynesia-reflects-on-lgbtqia-rights-place-in-society
  19. https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/pacific/209839/call-to-end-discrimination-of-tahiti-transvestites
  20. https://lawgratis.com/blog-detail/health-care-law-at-french-polynesia-france
  21. http://programme.exordo.com/epath2017/delegates/presentation/170/
  22. https://www.equaldex.com/log/19521
  23. https://www.service-public.pf/arass/wp-content/uploads/sites/46/2024/12/BSS47-S47-2024.pdf
  24. https://www.infectiologie.com/UserFiles/File/formation/2024/2024-j-infectiologie-pf-vih-en-pf-2024-1.pdf
  25. https://cns.sante.fr/sites/cns-sante/files/2024/10/DROM-COM_Annexe_Rapport-dexperts_-20241021.pdf
  26. https://www.adb.org/sites/default/files/publication/27968/cultures-contexts-matter.pdf
  27. https://www.aidsdatahub.org/sites/default/files/resource/turning-tide-open-strategy-response-aids-pacific-2009.pdf
  28. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4949308/
  29. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.7448/IAS.19.3.21259
  30. https://transreads.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/07/2021-07-29_6102ebf67a512_GenderontheEdgeTransgenderGayandOtherPacificIslandersbyNikoBesnierz-lib.org_.pdf
  31. https://www.degruyterbrill.com/document/doi/10.1515/9780824840198-002/html?lang=en
  32. https://outadventures.com/gay-travel-blog/mahu-french-polynesias-tahiti-third-gender/
  33. https://lgbtqia.wiki/wiki/Rae-rae
  34. https://www.canlii.org/en/commentary/doc/2013CanLIIDocs910
  35. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26966855
  36. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/277450785_Sodomy_Laws_and_Gender_Variance_in_Tahiti_and_Hawai%27i
  37. https://www.pphsn.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/04/Surveillance-pages23-37.pdf
  38. http://www.sexarchive.info/GESUND/ARCHIV/IES/FRENPOL.HTM
  39. https://database.ilga.org/french-polynesia-france-lgbti
  40. https://www.cnn.com/style/article/namsa-leuba-photographer
  41. https://www.thepost.co.nz/nz-news/360711422/social-cinema-pacifiction-foreboding-surreal-depiction-post-colonial-tahiti
  42. https://www.tahititourisme.com/campaign/lgbt/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.