Hubbry Logo
Paymaster GeneralPaymaster GeneralMain
Open search
Paymaster General
Community hub
Paymaster General
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Paymaster General
Paymaster General
Paymaster General
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia
Not to be confused with Paymaster of the Forces.
Not to be confused with Paymaster-General of the United States Army.
United Kingdom
His Majesty's Paymaster General
Royal Arms of His Majesty's Government
since 8 July 2024
Cabinet Office
StylePaymaster General (informal)
The Right Honourable (formal; within the UK and Commonwealth)
AppointerThe King
(on the advice of the Prime Minister)
Inaugural holderHenry Parnell
Formation27 April 1836
WebsiteOfficial website
This article is part of a series on
Politics of the United Kingdom
Lesser arms of the United Kingdom
Constitution
The Crown
Royal coat of arms of the United Kingdom

King Charles III

Prince of Wales's feathers

William, Prince of Wales

Executive

Royal coat of arms of the United Kingdom

Charles III
(King-in-Council)

Royal coat of arms of the United Kingdom

Starmer ministry (L)

Keir Starmer (L)

David Lammy (L)
Legislature

(King-in-Parliament)
Crowned portcullis

Charles III

Composition diagram of the House of Lords

Composition diagram of the House of Commons

Judiciary
Charles III
(King-on-the-Bench)

The Lord Reed

The Lord Hodge

Bank of England

Andrew Bailey

Monetary Policy Committee

Elections and referendums


UK general elections

Endorsements

European Parliament elections (1979–2019)

Scottish Parliament elections

Northern Ireland Assembly elections

Senedd elections

UK referendums
Devolution
England
Northern Ireland
Scotland
Wales
Administration
England
Northern Ireland
Scotland
Wales
Crown Dependencies
Overseas Territories
Foreign relations
flag United Kingdom portal

His Majesty's Paymaster General or HM Paymaster General is a ministerial position in the Cabinet Office of the United Kingdom. The position is currently held by Nick Thomas-Symonds of the Labour Party.

History

[edit]
Until 1939 the Office of the Paymaster General was at 36 Whitehall (an extension of Horse Guards formerly occupied by the Paymaster to the Forces).[1]

The post was created in 1836 by the merger of the positions of the offices of the Paymaster of the Forces (1661–1836), the Treasurer of the Navy (1546–1835), the Paymaster and Treasurer of Chelsea Hospital (responsible for Army pensions) (1681–1835) and the Treasurer of the Ordnance (1670–1835).

Initially, the Paymaster General only had responsibilities in relation to the armed services but in 1848 two more offices were merged into that of Paymaster General: the Paymaster of Exchequer Bills (1723–1848) and the Paymaster of the Civil Service (1834–1848), the latter followed by its Irish counterpart in 1861. They thus became 'the principal paying agent of the government and the banker for all government departments except the revenue departments and the National Debt Office'.[2]

From 1848 to 1868, the post was held concurrently with that of Vice-President of the Board of Trade.

The longest-serving holder of the post was Dawn Primarolo, whose portfolio covered HM Customs and Excise and the Inland Revenue (which during her tenure became merged as HM Revenue and Customs) and who served from 1999 to 2007.

Role

[edit]

Today, the Paymaster General is usually a minister without portfolio available for any duties which the government of the day may designate. The post may be combined with another office, or may be left unfilled.

Though the Paymaster General was titular head of the Paymaster General's Office, their executive functions were delegated to the Assistant Paymaster General, a permanent civil servant who (though acting in the name of the Paymaster General) was answerable to the Chancellor of the Exchequer.[2]

Office of HM Paymaster General

[edit]

The Paymaster General was formerly in nominal charge (and at one time in actual charge) of the Office of HM Paymaster General[3] (OPG), which held accounts at the Bank of England on behalf of government departments and selected other public bodies. Funds which were made available from the Consolidated Fund were then channelled into OPG accounts, from where they were used by the relevant body. OPG operated a full range of accounts and banking transaction services, including cheque and credit, BACS and CHAPS services for its customers via an electronic banking system. Integration of OPG accounts held with commercial banks was provided by the private company Xafinity Paymaster which is now part of the Equiniti group.

However, in 2008, the government announced that the Office of the Paymaster General would be incorporated into a new body, the Government Banking Service,[4] which also provides banking operations for HM Revenue & Customs and National Savings and Investments. Following the Bank of England's decision to withdraw from providing retail banking services,[5] retail banking and payment services for the GBS are provided by a range of financial institutions including Barclays, Citibank, NatWest, and Worldpay,[6] although the Bank of England still plays a role in managing the government's higher level accounts.[7]

List of paymasters general

[edit]

19th century

[edit]

20th century

[edit]
Paymaster General Term of office Concurrent office(s) Political party Prime Minister
Frederick Lindemann
Viscount Cherwell 		30 October 1951 11 November 1953 Conservative Winston Churchill
(III)
George Douglas-Hamilton
Earl of Selkirk 		11 November 1953 20 October 1955
Office vacant 20 October 1955 18 October 1956 Anthony Eden
(Eden)
Walter Monckton
MP for Bristol West 		18 October 1956 16 January 1957
Reginald Maudling
MP for Barnet 		16 January 1957 14 October 1959 Harold Macmillan
(I)
Percy Mills
Viscount Mills 		14 October 1959 9 October 1961 Harold Macmillan
(II)
Henry Brooke
MP for Hampstead 		9 October 1961 13 July 1962 Chief Secretary to the Treasury
John Boyd-Carpenter
MP for Kingston-upon-Thames 		13 July 1962 19 October 1964 Chief Secretary to the Treasury Alec Douglas-Home
(Douglas-Home)
George Wigg
MP for Dudley 		19 October 1964 12 November 1967 Labour Harold Wilson
(I & II)
Office vacant 12 November 1967 6 April 1968 Harold Wilson
(II)
Edward Shackleton
Baron Shackleton 		6 April 1968 1 November 1968
Judith Hart
MP for Clydesdale 		1 November 1968 6 October 1969
Harold Lever
MP for Manchester Cheetham 		6 October 1969 23 June 1970
David Eccles
Viscount Eccles 		23 June 1970 2 December 1973 Minister for the Arts Conservative Edward Heath
(Heath)
Maurice Macmillan
MP for Farnham 		2 December 1973 4 March 1974
Edmund Dell
MP for Birkenhead 		4 March 1974 10 September 1976 Labour Harold Wilson
(III & IV)
Shirley Williams
MP for Hitchin 		10 September 1976 4 May 1979 Secretary of State for Education and Science James Callaghan
(Callaghan)
Angus Maude
MP for Stratford-on-Avon 		4 May 1979 5 January 1981 Conservative Margaret Thatcher
(I)
Francis Pym
MP for Cambridgeshire 		5 January 1981 14 September 1981 Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster
(5 January 1981 – 14 September 1981)

Leader of the House of Commons
(5 January 1981 – 5 April 1982)

Cecil Parkinson
MP for South Hertfordshire 		14 September 1981 11 June 1983 Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster
(6 April 1982 – 11 June 1983)
Office vacant 11 June 1983 11 September 1984 Margaret Thatcher
(II)
John Gummer
MP for Suffolk Coastal 		11 September 1984 1 September 1985
Kenneth Clarke
MP for Rushcliffe 		2 September 1985 13 July 1987 Minister of State for Employment
Peter Brooke
MP for City of London and Westminster South 		13 July 1987 24 July 1989 Margaret Thatcher
(III)
Malcolm Sinclair
Earl of Caithness 		25 July 1989 14 July 1990
Richard Ryder
MP for Mid Norfolk 		14 July 1990 28 November 1990 John Major
(I)
John Ganzoni
Baron Belstead 		28 November 1990 11 April 1992 Minister of State for Northern Ireland
John Cope
MP for Northavon 		14 April 1992 20 July 1994 John Major
(lI)
David Heathcoat-Amory
MP for Wells 		20 July 1994 20 July 1996
David Willetts
MP for Havant 		20 July 1996 21 November 1996
Michael Bates
MP for Langbaurgh 		21 November 1996 2 May 1997 Lord Commissioner of the Treasury
(17 October 1995 – 11 December 1996)
Geoffrey Robinson
MP for Coventry North West 		2 May 1997 23 December 1998 Labour Tony Blair
(I)

21st century

[edit]
Paymaster General Term of office Concurrent office(s) Political party Prime Minister
Dawn Primarolo
MP for Bristol South 		4 January 1999 28 June 2007 Labour Tony Blair
(I, II, III)
Tessa Jowell
MP for Dulwich and West Norwood 		28 June 2007 11 May 2010 Minister for the Olympics
Minister for the Cabinet Office
(from 5 June 2009)
Minister for London
(until 3 October 2008; from 5 June 2009) 		Gordon Brown
(Brown)
Francis Maude
MP for Horsham 		12 May 2010 11 May 2015 Minister for the Cabinet Office Conservative David Cameron
(I)
Matt Hancock
MP for West Suffolk 		11 May 2015 14 July 2016 David Cameron
(II)
Ben Gummer
MP for Ipswich 		14 July 2016 13 June 2017 Theresa May
(I)
Mel Stride
MP for Central Devon 		13 June 2017 23 May 2019 Financial Secretary to the Treasury Theresa May
(II)
Jesse Norman
MP for Hereford and South Herefordshire 		23 May 2019 24 July 2019
Oliver Dowden
MP for Hertsmere 		24 July 2019 13 February 2020 Minister for the Cabinet Office Boris Johnson
(I & II)
Penny Mordaunt
MP for Portsmouth North 		13 February 2020 16 September 2021 Boris Johnson
(II)
Michael Ellis
MP for Northampton North 		16 September 2021 6 September 2022 Minister for the Cabinet Office
(from 8 February 2022)
Edward Argar
MP for Charnwood 		6 September 2022 14 October 2022 Minister for the Cabinet Office Liz Truss
(Truss)
Chris Philp
MP for Croydon South 		14 October 2022 25 October 2022
Jeremy Quin
MP for Horsham 		25 October 2022 13 November 2023 Rishi Sunak
(Sunak)
John Glen
MP for Salisbury 		13 November 2023 5 July 2024
Nick Thomas-Symonds
MP for Torfaen 		8 July 2024 Labour Keir Starmer
(Starmer)

List of shadow paymasters general

[edit]
Shadow Paymaster general Term of office Party Opposition Leader
Richard Ottaway 1 June 2000 1 June 2001 Conservative Hague
Stephen O'Brien 1 June 2002 1 June 2003 Conservative Duncan Smith
Andrew Tyrie 1 June 2004 1 June 2005 Conservative Howard
Mark Francois 10 May 2005 3 July 2007 Conservative
Cameron
Jack Dromey 14 May 2021 4 December 2021 Labour Starmer
Fleur Anderson 4 December 2021 4 September 2023 Labour
Jonathan Ashworth 4 September 2023 5 July 2024 Labour
John Glen 8 July 2024 8 November 2024 Conservative Sunak
Richard Holden 8 November 2024 Incumbent Conservative Kemi Badenoch

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Paymaster General

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Paymaster General is a senior ministerial office in the Government of the United Kingdom, currently held by Nick Thomas-Symonds MP, who was appointed in July 2024 following the Labour Party's general election victory and also serves as Minister for the Cabinet Office with responsibilities for the constitution and European Union relations. The position originated in the 17th century as the Paymaster of the Forces, established in 1661 to handle disbursements for the British Army during the Restoration, a role that involved managing substantial public funds often invested for personal profit until systemic reforms curbed such practices. By the 19th century, the office had evolved amid broader consolidation of military pay systems, with the Paymaster General of the Forces among departments merged or restructured before 1835 to improve efficiency and accountability in government expenditures. In its modern form, the Paymaster General typically functions without a fixed departmental portfolio, instead undertaking ad hoc duties assigned by the Prime Minister, such as supporting cabinet coordination or special policy initiatives, reflecting the office's adaptability in successive administrations.

Historical Origins and Evolution

Establishment in the 17th Century

The office of Paymaster of the Forces, a precursor to the modern Paymaster General, was established in amid the reorganization of military administration following the Restoration of Charles II. This creation coincided with the formation of a permanent , necessitated by the instability of the and the need for reliable troop payments to prevent mutinies and ensure loyalty. Funds were disbursed from allocations to regimental paymasters, with the central responsible for and distribution, though the system relied on manual ledgers prone to discrepancies. Sir Stephen , a who had served in Charles II's exiled household, was appointed the inaugural of the Forces in early 1661, holding the position until 1676. Fox's tenure involved managing payments for guards, garrisons, and expeditionary forces, drawing on bills and tallies for liquidity. The role's structure allowed the Paymaster to retain interest on unexpended balances, generating substantial personal income—Fox amassed a fortune estimated at over £20,000 annually by the 1670s from such perquisites, reflecting the office's dual function as administrative and instrument. Initially, the office operated without statutory oversight, leading to informal joint appointments by the late 1660s to distribute workload and risks, as seen when shared duties with figures like William Fox during campaigns. This arrangement underscored the position's political nature, tied to court favor rather than professional expertise, and set precedents for fiscal agency that influenced later reforms. By the 1670s, amid wars with the Dutch, the Paymaster's disbursements supported forces numbering around 20,000 men, highlighting its centrality to national defense financing.

Expansion and Reforms in the 18th and 19th Centuries

In the , the office of Paymaster General of the Forces expanded in scope and profitability as Britain's military commitments grew, particularly during conflicts like the Seven Years' War (1756–1763), which necessitated handling larger volumes of public funds for troop payments. The paymaster received monies from the and disbursed them to the army, but delays in expenditures often left substantial unspent balances under the holder's control, which could be invested in government securities or loans for personal gain through earned interest—a practice legally permitted but increasingly viewed as emblematic of and . Holders such as Henry Fox amassed fortunes estimated at £120,000 from these balances during the war, while deputies like Peter Taylor accumulated around £400,000 by 1763 via manipulations such as discrepancies and payments in undervalued coinage. Criticism of these arrangements intensified amid broader calls for economical reform, culminating in Edmund Burke's tenure as Paymaster General under the Rockingham ministry of 1782, when he introduced the Establishment Bill to regulate the office by mandating the prompt repayment of balances to the and curtailing opportunities for private profit. This reform addressed systemic abuses, such as the use of balances for pensions or investments, though it did not abolish the office's political value as a post. The changes reflected a shift toward greater fiscal , driven by parliamentary scrutiny of wartime expenditures, but enforcement remained inconsistent until further consolidations in the following century. By the early , the office underwent structural reforms amid the expansion of Britain's administrative apparatus, transitioning from primarily military disbursements to broader public fund management. In 1835, following Exchequer reforms under , the Paymaster General's Office consolidated four predecessor entities handling armed services payments: the Paymaster General of the Forces (established 1743), Paymaster and Treasurer of Chelsea Hospital (1681), Treasurer of the Ordnance (1670), and Treasurer of the (1546), centralizing military-related fiscal operations. This merger coincided with the creation of the Paymaster of the in 1834, marking an initial expansion into civilian government payments as the civil service burgeoned post-Napoleonic Wars. Further reforms in , via the Paymaster General Act (11 & 12 Vict. c. 55), integrated the offices of Paymaster of Bills and Paymaster of the into the Paymaster General's remit, establishing it as the principal agent for issuing government payments, including civil salaries, allowances, and bills. This consolidation streamlined disbursements amid rising administrative demands, reducing duplication and enhancing efficiency in handling public monies, though the ministerial role retained its Cabinet-level status without direct operational control over daily transactions. By mid-century, the office thus embodied a reformed apparatus responsive to fiscal modernization, supporting the Treasury's oversight of an expanding state .

20th-Century Transformations and Modernization

During the First World War, the Office of HM Paymaster General expanded its operations to handle increased government expenditures, managing payments through consolidated accounts at the , which facilitated centralized fiscal disbursements amid wartime demands. The ministerial role, however, began shifting toward oversight rather than direct administration, as civil servants assumed routine banking and payment functions, reflecting early 20th-century bureaucratization of . In the , the position retained its Treasury affiliation but saw occasional use for broader governmental coordination. held the office from 1922 to 1923 before ascending to higher roles, underscoring its utility as a stepping stone in ministerial careers. By , with growing state intervention in the economy, the Paymaster General's responsibilities indirectly supported expanded public spending mechanisms, though operational modernization emphasized efficiency in account reconciliation and fund allocation. World War II marked a pivotal transformation, as appointed Frederick Lindemann, 1st Viscount Cherwell, as Paymaster General on 28 October 1942, granting him cabinet rank to advise on scientific, statistical, and bombing policy matters without a dedicated department. This repurposing highlighted the office's adaptability, decoupling the minister from traditional payment duties—now fully delegated to civil servants—and leveraging it for specialized wartime expertise. Cherwell retained influence post-1945 under Churchill's peacetime government, exemplifying the role's evolution into a flexible advisory post amid post-war reconstruction planning. Post-1945, the position continued to modernize by accommodating diverse policy mandates. In 1968, designated the Paymaster General, initially Lord Shackleton and later Judith Hart, to oversee and initiatives, marking the first instance of dual female cabinet representation and expanding the role into constitutional reform. By the late , amid fiscal expansions and technological advancements in banking, the ministerial duties increasingly focused on strategic oversight within the , while the underlying office adapted to computerized payment systems and larger-scale public fund management, reducing the Paymaster General's direct involvement in transactional operations.

Core Responsibilities and Functions

Ministerial Oversight and Cabinet Integration

The Paymaster General functions as a senior minister within the , providing oversight for cross-departmental coordination and specific policy areas such as constitutional affairs and relations. Appointed on 8 July 2024, concurrently serves as in this role, ensuring accountability to for government-wide efficiency and alignment in administrative functions. This oversight extends to residual responsibilities from the Office of HM Paymaster General, including the management of certain public sector payment accounts, though operational delivery has been transferred to the Government Banking Service since 2008 to streamline fiscal processes. Integration into the Cabinet structure positions the Paymaster General as an attendee at full Cabinet meetings, contributing to collective decision-making on national priorities and inter-ministerial coordination. The role's embedding in the facilitates oversight of implementation across , bridging fiscal mechanisms with policy execution to maintain governmental coherence. The Paymaster General also participates in key Cabinet committees, such as the Parliamentary Business and Legislation Committee, which scrutinizes the legislative agenda and ensures parliamentary alignment with executive objectives. This committee membership, alongside up to four others depending on the administration, underscores the position's role in legislative oversight and policy integration, promoting unified government action without siloed departmentalism.

Office of HM Paymaster General Operations

The Office of HM Paymaster General (OPG) operated as a responsible for managing the central banking functions of the government, primarily handling the receipt, custody, and payment of public monies on behalf of departments and entities. Staffed by civil servants, it maintained dedicated accounts at the , through which it executed transactions drawn from or credited to the , ensuring secure and centralized control over fiscal disbursements. This structure, dating back to statutory provisions from the , positioned OPG as the government's internal banker, distinct from commercial institutions, to minimize risks associated with external lending and to align payments directly with parliamentary appropriations. Core operational activities included providing banking services such as issuing payable orders, bankers' drafts, and other negotiable instruments to facilitate government expenditures. OPG was statutorily authorized to borrow short-term funds from when necessary, invest surplus balances to optimize liquidity, and process inter-departmental transfers, thereby supporting efficient across the . It also oversaw the Clearing System, a mechanism for reconciling balances between government accounts and the , which helped prevent overdrafts and maintained fiscal discipline by netting out daily inflows and outflows. In safeguarding public funds, OPG emphasized risk mitigation through segregated accounts and adherence to guidelines, avoiding speculative investments and prioritizing principal preservation over yield. services extended to processing high-volume transactions for entities like the , including ledger maintenance and electronic fund transfers, though specifics varied by client department's needs. By 2008, these operations were deemed inefficient in a digitized era, leading to OPG's incorporation into the Government Banking Service, which assumed its banking mandate while leveraging consolidated for cost savings estimated at £20-50 million annually through standardized contracts with commercial banks. This transition marked the end of OPG as an independent entity in 2009, with its legacy functions persisting under the new framework to ensure continuity in public fund .

Fiscal Payment Mechanisms and Public Fund Management

The Office of HM Paymaster General (OPG), under the oversight of the Paymaster General, historically managed key fiscal payment mechanisms for the government, including the issuance of cheques, credits, (Bankers' Automated Clearing Services), and (Clearing House Automated Payment System) transactions on behalf of departments. Funds were safeguarded by holding public monies in the Paymaster General's accounts at the , minimizing exposure to commercial banking risks while enabling efficient inter-departmental transfers and supplier payments. Payable orders, a form of non-negotiable government-issued instruments, were routinely processed through OPG for domestic and certain international disbursements, ensuring and control over public expenditures. In 2008, the government integrated OPG's core banking functions into the Government Banking Service (GBS), a centralized entity subordinate to , to streamline operations and reduce costs; OPG formally closed in 2009, with GBS assuming responsibility for processing while excluding pension-related activities. GBS now facilitates public fund management for over 750 central government and customers, providing such as online account viewing, supplier s, and internal fund transfers via secure platforms partnered with banks like , , and . This includes real-time intraday reporting to on flows, monitoring of supplier performance against agreements, and advisory roles on to optimize and compliance with fiscal controls outlined in Managing Public Money. Contemporary mechanisms emphasize efficiency and security: for bulk low-value payments using dedicated Service User Numbers, for high-value sterling transfers settled same-day via the , Faster Payments up to £250,000 for urgent domestic needs, and international wires handled through correspondent banking networks. Card payments and payable orders persist for legacy or specialized cases, while GBS acts as the government's interface with the payments industry, advocating for standards that protect public funds from and operational disruptions. Overall, these systems prioritize causal safeguards—such as segregated accounts and daily reconciliations—to prevent misuse, with the Paymaster General retaining ministerial accountability for ensuring expenditures align with parliamentary appropriations and fiscal prudence.

Officeholders

17th to 19th Century Appointments

The office of emerged in 1836 from the merger of predecessor financial roles, principally the Paymaster of the Forces—established in 1661 to disburse payments for the after the Restoration of the Monarchy—and the Treasurer of the Navy, with the aim of centralizing civil and military disbursements under oversight. Prior appointments to the Paymaster of the Forces, spanning the 17th and 18th centuries, were characterized by significant potential, as officeholders could retain and invest on unexpended public funds until parliamentary reforms curtailed this practice in the 1780s. This system fostered accusations of corruption; for instance, Richard Jones, 1st Earl of Ranelagh, who held the post from 1679 to 1699, faced prosecution in 1702 for and misuse of funds exceeding £30,000. Similarly, James Brydges, from 1705 to 1713, amassed a fortune estimated at over £600,000 from army remittances during the , enabling his rise to the dukedom of Chandos, though parliamentary inquiries cleared him of formal wrongdoing while highlighting systemic vulnerabilities. Sir Henry Brooke Parnell, appointed Paymaster-General of the Forces in May 1835 and transitioning to the consolidated role in 1836, served until January 1841 under Whig administrations led by Lord Melbourne, overseeing initial integration of payment mechanisms amid post-Napoleonic fiscal retrenchment. Subsequent 19th-century appointments reflected ministerial turnover and party alignments, often assigning the role to experienced parliamentarians as a adjunct without fixed salary, compensated via fees until standardization in the 1860s. Key holders included the Hon. William Cowper-Temple from 1859 to 1860 under Palmerston's Liberals; Sir William Hutt from 1860 to 1865, continuing fiscal oversight through the American Civil War's economic ripples; Sir Stephen Cave, who served 1866–1868 under Disraeli's Conservatives and again from 1874 onward, advocating pay reforms; and Spencer Cavendish, Marquess of Hartington, from 1868 to 1871 in Gladstone's first ministry. These incumbents, drawn predominantly from the , managed an expanding remit including payments, with annual disbursements reaching £20 million by the 1870s, underscoring the office's evolution from military toward broader coordination.

20th Century Appointments

The office of Paymaster General in the continued to function primarily as a ministerial post overseeing public fund disbursements, though holders increasingly took on ad hoc duties without portfolio, reflecting governmental needs during wartime and economic shifts. Appointments were made across Conservative, Labour, and coalition administrations, with terms varying from brief interim roles to multi-year tenures, often overlapping with other cabinet positions. Key appointments included:
NameTerm in office
Sir Savile Crossley1902–1906
Richard Causton1905–1910
Joseph Compton-Rickett1916–1919
1916 (interim)
John Walters1919–1922; 1931 (interim)
William Joynson-Hicks1923 (interim)
Archibald Boyd-Carpenter1923–1924
1923 (interim)
Harry Gosling1924 (interim)
Edward Turnour, Viscount Turnour1939 (interim)
Robert Gascoyne-Cecil, Viscount Cranborne1940–1944
William Jowitt1942 (interim)
1946–1947
Hilary Marquand1947–1948
1956–1957
1957–1959
Henry Brooke1961–1962
John Boyd-Carpenter1962–1964
George Wigg1964–1967
Judith Hart1968–1969
Harold Lever1969–1970
David Eccles1970–1973
1973–1974
Edmund Dell1974–1976
1976–1979
Angus Maude1979–1981
1985–1987
Peter Brooke1987–1989
Richard Ryder1990 (interim)
1996–1997
Geoffrey Robinson1997–1999
Notable holders included future prime ministerial candidates like and economic policymakers such as , underscoring the post's occasional role in grooming senior figures. During , the position supported wartime financial administration under coalition governments. The frequency of short-term appointments highlights its flexibility as a or transitional role amid cabinet reshuffles. Henry Brooke served as Paymaster General from 1961 to 1962 before ascending to higher offices, including Home Secretary. Walter Monckton held the position briefly in 1956–1957, amid post-war reconstruction efforts.

21st Century Appointments

In the , the office of Paymaster General has primarily been held by Labour and Conservative politicians, often concurrently with duties focused on reform, efficiency, and constitutional matters. The role's aspects have diminished as it integrates more actively into al operations, with appointments reflecting prime ministerial priorities for administrative oversight. Dawn Primarolo served as Paymaster General from 4 January 1999 to 28 June 2007 under and , overseeing Treasury-related functions including tax credits implementation. Her tenure emphasized support amid New Labour's public spending expansions. held the position from 28 June 2007 to 11 May 2010, combining it with Olympics minister responsibilities during 's government, focusing on legacy planning and . Francis was appointed Paymaster General and from 12 May 2010 to 11 May 2015 under , driving civil service reductions and efficiency savings targeting £20 billion annually by 2014-2015. served from 11 May 2015 to 14 July 2016, continuing reforms with emphasis on skills and business innovation. occupied the role from 14 July 2016 to 13 June 2017 under , prioritizing public service mutualization and . Mel Stride acted as Paymaster General from 13 June 2017 to 2019, supporting preparations and departmental efficiencies. Penny Mordaunt served from February 2020 to September 2021, leading resilience and cyber defense initiatives amid the . Subsequent Conservative appointments included Michael Ellis from 16 September 2021 to 6 September 2022, , , in October 2022, and John Glen from November 2023, each handling portfolios including procurement and EU relations. Following the July 2024 general election, was appointed Paymaster General and by , with responsibilities for constitution and relations.
NamePartyTerm
Labour1999–2007
Labour2007–2010
Conservative2010–2015
Conservative2015–2016
Conservative2016–2017
Conservative2017–2019
Conservative2020–2021
Michael EllisConservative2021–2022
Others (Argar, Philp, Quin, )Conservative2022–2024
Labour2024–present

Opposition and Shadow Roles

Development of Shadow Paymaster General Position

The Shadow Paymaster General position emerged in the Conservative Party's opposition frontbench structure during the early 2000s, mirroring the governmental role's integration into the for oversight of payments and administrative efficiency. It was first formally appointed on 1 June 2000, when Richard Ottaway was designated to shadow Paymaster General under Hague's leadership, enabling targeted scrutiny of Labour's fiscal management amid post-1997 economic policies. This timing coincided with the Paymaster General's evolving remit under Tony Blair's administration, which emphasized cross-departmental coordination via the Office of Government Commerce, prompting opposition demands for equivalent accountability mechanisms. Subsequent Conservative appointments reinforced the role's focus on challenging government expenditure and procurement, with Stephen O'Brien succeeding Ottaway in 2001 and critiquing issues like Equitable Life policyholder compensation delays in 2003, highlighting perceived mismanagement in public funds. Howard Flight briefly held the post in 2001 before shifting to scrutiny, reflecting the position's occasional fluidity within Treasury-related shadows amid broader economic debates. By the mid-2000s, figures like assumed the role in 2005 under and , using it to probe Labour's public spending amid rising deficits, which peaked at £167 billion by 2009-10. The position's development paralleled the formalization of shadow cabinets post-1997, where opposition roles expanded to counter the incumbent's junior ministerial portfolios, though it remained less entrenched than major department shadows due to the Paymaster General's variable prominence. Labour adopted the Shadow Paymaster General role more prominently after , aligning with their opposition to Conservative-led efficiencies in . served until his death on 27 January 2021, after which assumed the position around early 2022, emphasizing scrutiny of operations including reforms. held it until September 2023, when was appointed amid Keir Starmer's reshuffle, focusing on holding the government accountable for procurement scandals like PPE contracts during the response, which involved £15 billion in disputed expenditures. Post-2024 election, Conservatives reinstated the role with John Glen briefly in July-November 2024, followed by Richard Holden, underscoring its utility in bipartisan opposition tactics despite intermittent vacancies reflecting the post's non-core status. Overall, the position's evolution underscores a pragmatic in parliamentary oversight, prioritizing empirical critique of fiscal mechanisms over ideological rigidity, with appointments often doubling as platforms for broader challenges.

Notable Shadow Appointments

Mark Francois served as Shadow Paymaster General for the Conservative Party from 10 May 2005 to 3 July 2007, scrutinizing the Labour government's handling of public funds and operations during a period of expanding fiscal oversight roles. In this capacity, Francois focused on Treasury-related accountability, drawing on his prior experience as Shadow Economic Secretary to the Treasury, before advancing to more senior defence scrutiny positions. Jack Dromey, a Labour MP and former Deputy General Secretary of the , was appointed Shadow Paymaster General in January 2021 by , holding the role until his death on 7 January 2022. Dromey's tenure emphasized opposition critiques of and pensions policy, leveraging his background to highlight worker-related fiscal issues, though the position's junior status limited its prominence amid broader reshuffles. Jonathan Ashworth, previously Shadow for Health and Work and Pensions, assumed the Shadow Paymaster General role on 4 September 2023, serving until the 2024 general election on 30 May 2024. As a senior Labour figure, Ashworth used the post to challenge Conservative fiscal management, including tax policies and public spending, in parliamentary debates and media appearances, such as interviews addressing economic critiques. Following Labour's 2024 election victory, John Glen, the immediate former Conservative Paymaster General (November 2023–July 2024), was appointed Shadow Paymaster General on 8 July 2024, holding it until 8 November 2024 amid post-election opposition restructuring. Glen's brief shadow tenure involved initial scrutiny of the new government's transitions, informed by his direct prior experience in the role. Richard Holden succeeded as Shadow Paymaster General on 8 November 2024, continuing in the position as of October 2025 while also serving as an . Holden's appointment reflects the Conservative opposition's emphasis on holding the Labour administration accountable for public fund allocation and efficiency, though specific initiatives remain ongoing.

Criticisms, Controversies, and Reforms

Perceptions as a Sinecure and Patronage Tool

The office of Paymaster General has historically been viewed as a , offering ministerial salary and Cabinet access with duties often absorbed by the or delegated, rather than requiring distinct operational responsibilities. In a 1916 House of Commons debate on the Board of Pensions Bill, Liberal MP Herbert Samuel described the Paymaster-General's role as "a office," arguing that if it lacked substantive work, it should be abolished rather than repurposed without remuneration adjustments. This perception persisted into the mid-20th century; during a 1942 House of Lords discussion on ministerial reconstruction, Lord Hankey referred to it explicitly as "the post of Paymaster-General," emphasizing that the title's holder performed oversight functions without it defining their core workload. Critics in the tied the position to broader excesses in , where like the Paymaster-General's enabled officials to draw emoluments with limited accountability. A 1817 Commons debate on the Finance Committee's report highlighted the office among persisting post-reform, noting resistance to full abolition despite public funds being involved, as compensation clauses protected incumbents' interests. Similarly, 1812 discussions on the Offices Bill considered including the Paymaster-General but ultimately exempted it after contention, reflecting how such roles evaded eradication through political maneuvering. As a patronage instrument, the role facilitates appointing loyalists or politically useful figures to salaried positions without tying them to departmental , allowing prime ministers to expand Cabinet influence flexibly. This utility stems from its non-departmental status, enabling assignments like chairing reviews or supporting functions, which critics argue prioritizes rewarding allegiance over merit-based allocation. In 1937 Commons scrutiny of ministerial salaries, Labour MP Rhys Davies cited the Paymaster-General among "sinecure offices" used for Cabinet elevation without equivalent workload, underscoring its role in distributing privileges to non-executive peers or allies. Such appointments, often to figures lacking specialized expertise, reinforce views of the office as a low-accountability vehicle for maintaining balance or elevating backbench supporters, as evidenced by its occasional pairing with honorary or temporary tasks rather than fixed policy domains.

Associated Individual Scandals

Geoffrey Robinson, who served as Paymaster General from May 1997 to December 1998, resigned on 23 December 1998 amid revelations of undeclared financial interests and a secret £373,000 loan he provided to , then for Trade and Industry. The loan, used by Mandelson to purchase a home in in 1996, was not declared to parliamentary authorities or the Prime Minister's office, prompting Mandelson's simultaneous resignation and triggering scrutiny of Robinson's own business dealings. Robinson, a millionaire industrialist with interests in companies like TransTec and a Jersey-based , faced investigations by the Department of Trade and Industry into potential conflicts of interest, including undeclared overseas assets and benefits from government-linked transactions. The Standards and Privileges Committee later ruled that Robinson had failed to register several interests properly, including shareholdings and directorships, breaching parliamentary rules on transparency. Although no criminal charges resulted, the highlighted vulnerabilities in ministerial appointments to the Paymaster General , which lacks a defined departmental portfolio and has historically facilitated placements of politically connected figures with ties. Robinson's resignation contributed to broader perceptions of ethical lapses in Tony Blair's early Labour government, with critics attributing the to lax vetting of business interests among cabinet members. Subsequent inquiries cleared Mandelson of in the loan itself but upheld findings of inadequate disclosure, while Robinson's TransTec collapsed in 2000 amid accounting irregularities, though unrelated directly to his tenure.

Calls for Abolition or Restructuring

In the early , parliamentary scrutiny targeted aspects of paymaster roles, with the Finance Committee recommending the abolition of positions like the second paymaster-general to eliminate unmerited emoluments and streamline operations. These efforts reflected broader post-Napoleonic War reforms aimed at curbing , though the core Paymaster General office persisted after prior changes, such as the 1782 Paymaster General Act, which curtailed personal profits from payments but retained the ministerial title. The Paymaster General Act 1848 further restructured the office by merging the roles of Paymasters of Bills and Civil Services into it, authorizing the to abolish redundant sub-offices and centralize duties under the Paymaster General, thereby reducing administrative fragmentation while preserving the position's flexibility for governmental tasks. This consolidation addressed inefficiencies in payment handling but did not eliminate criticisms of the office as a vehicle for appointing ministers without portfolio. In contemporary proposals, legal academic Graham McBain has advocated abolishing the Paymaster General outright as part of a comprehensive to modernize the , classifying it as a lacking independent functions and typically bundled with responsibilities, which he argues obscures accountability and duplicates roles like those of the of the . McBain's 2021 paper posits that eliminating such vestigial titles would simplify executive structures without impairing governance, transferring any residual duties to core departments. No major has formally endorsed abolition, reflecting the office's utility in accommodating reshuffles, though its connotations persist in discourse.

References

  1. https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers
  2. https://discovery.nationalarchives.gov.uk/details/r/C229
  3. https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/volume/1660-1690/member/fox-stephen-1627-1716
  4. https://rapc-association.org.uk/pay-services-history/notes-on-army-pay-2.html
  5. https://www.pepysdiary.com/encyclopedia/848/
  6. https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/volume/1754-1790/survey/iii-members
  7. https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/volume/1754-1790/member/fox-henry-1705-74
  8. https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/volume/1754-1790/member/burke-edmund-1729-97
  9. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/11-12/55/enacted/data.html
  10. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Neville-Chamberlain
  11. https://winstonchurchill.org/publications/finest-hour/finest-hour-195/the-professor-and-the-prime-ministerfrederick-lindemann-and-winston-churchill/
  12. https://hansard.parliament.uk/lords/1942-12-16/debates/e86dcecc-f8bd-4499-9ac6-bfe2ccd55399/ReconstructionMinisterSPosition
  13. https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1968-11-12/debates/fb39959a-5518-4962-8df5-c31d45f70382/Paymaster-General%28Duties%29
  14. https://womenshistorynetwork.org/labour-women-in-power-cabinet-ministers-in-the-20th-century-dr-paula-bartley/
  15. https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199900/cmselect/cmtreasy/154/cor15402.htm
  16. https://www.gov.uk/government/ministers/paymaster-general
  17. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-of-hm-paymaster-general/about
  18. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/cabinet-office
  19. https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/cabinet-committees
  20. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a74a9a040f0b619c8659693/0626.pdf
  21. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/11-12/55/enacted
  22. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2006/607/pdfs/uksiem_20060607_en.pdf
  23. https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm199900/cmselect/cmtreasy/154/cor15406.htm
  24. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/5a74beb4ed915d4d83b5e9cb/government-banking-service.pdf
  25. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/office-of-hm-paymaster-general
  26. https://www.bis.org/cpmi/paysys/unitedkingdomcomp.pdf
  27. https://www.gov.uk/government/groups/government-banking-service-gbs
  28. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/684ae4c6f7c9feb9b0413804/Managing_Public_Money.pdf
  29. https://www.lexisnexis.co.uk/legal/commentary/halsburys-laws-of-england/constitutional-administrative-law/406-the-paymaster-general-the-government-banking-service
  30. https://rapc-association.org.uk/pay-services-history/new-military-finance.html
  31. https://globalmaritimehistory.com/the-battle-for-control-of-the-royal-navy-1801-1835/
  32. https://www.library.stiami.ac.id/index.php?p=fstream-pdf&fid=38&bid=11336
  33. https://canonsparkfriends.org/corruption-canons-and-the-duke-of-chandos/
  34. https://www.historyofparliamentonline.org/volume/1820-1832/member/parnell-sir-henry-1776-1842
  35. https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/offices/paymaster-general
  36. https://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/SN04657/SN04657.pdf
  37. https://www.theyworkforyou.com/peer/10489/baroness_primarolo
  38. https://www.gov.uk/government/people/francis-maude
  39. https://www.gov.uk/government/people/matthew-hancock
  40. https://www.gov.uk/government/people/ben-gummer
  41. https://www.gov.uk/government/people/penny-mordaunt
  42. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/ministerial-appointments-25-october-2022
  43. https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/live-blog/cabinet-reshuffle-november-2023
  44. https://www.gov.uk/government/people/nick-thomas-symonds
  45. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/general-election-2015/11462813/Why-Im-standing-down-from-Parliament-Sir-Richard-Ottaway-MP-for-Croydon-South.html
  46. https://www.instituteforgovernment.org.uk/explainer/shadow-cabinet
  47. https://www.theguardian.com/money/2003/jun/28/equitablelife.business
  48. https://www.moneymarketing.co.uk/analysis/howard-flight/
  49. https://www.rayleighandwickfordconservatives.com/rt-hon-mark-francois-mp-0
  50. https://www.fleuranderson.co.uk/my-time-as-shadow-paymaster-general-has-come-to-an-end/
  51. https://www.bbc.com/news/live/uk-politics-66701628
  52. https://members.parliament.uk/member/4051/career
  53. https://members.parliament.uk/member/1444/career
  54. https://www.gov.uk/government/people/mark-francois
  55. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/obituaries/2022/01/09/jack-dromey-labour-shadow-minister-former-senior-trade-unionist/
  56. https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/jan/09/jack-dromey-obituary
  57. https://members.parliament.uk/member/4244/contact
  58. https://uk.linkedin.com/in/johnpglen
  59. https://members.parliament.uk/member/4813/career
  60. https://www.facebook.com/Richard4BasildonAndBillericay/videos/-new-role-as-shadow-paymaster-general-/1536619636974669/
  61. https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1916-11-30/debates/182d94f5-3a45-4168-ae7c-4584bdf0ed7f/BoardOfPensionsBill
  62. https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1817-05-05/debates/a537602a-a092-467f-b354-9249784d08ab/FirstReportOfFinanceCommittee%25E2%2580%2594AbolitionOfSinecures
  63. https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1812-05-04/debates/90698235-a271-4247-a383-9fab301d78b0/SinecureOfficesBill
  64. https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1965-02-10/debates/62898ce7-ca10-4c9a-a8a7-0859cb6c5386/Clause1%25E2%2580%2594%28RevisedRatesOfSalariesForMinisters%29
  65. https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1937/apr/29/clause-3-additional-salaries-to-cabinet
  66. https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1946-05-29/debates/95136082-0678-4eba-8923-20f98f8c2aa9/MinisterialSalariesBill
  67. https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB914429637254955500
  68. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2000/oct/17/qanda.mandelson
  69. https://www.nytimes.com/1999/01/05/world/3d-blair-official-steps-down-in-scandal-over-secret-loan.html
  70. https://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/255159.stm
  71. https://www.economist.com/leaders/1998/12/31/a-christmas-catastrophe
  72. http://www.inquiriesjournal.com/articles/1124/three-men-and-a-loan-the-fall-of-peter-mandelson
  73. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/Vict/11-12/55/body/enacted
  74. https://doi.org/10.5539/ilr.v11n1p62
  75. https://ccsenet.org/journal/index.php/ilr/article/view/0/0
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.