Hubbry Logo
Star ProphecyStar ProphecyMain
Open search
Star Prophecy
Community hub
Star Prophecy
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Star Prophecy
Star Prophecy
Star Prophecy
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Star Prophecy (or Star and Scepter prophecy) is a Messianic reading applied by Jewish Zealots and early Christians to Numbers 24:17.

Bible narrative

[edit]

אראנו ולא עתה אשורנו ולא קרוב דרך כוכב מיעקב וקם שבט מישראל ומחץ פאתי מואב וקרקר כל־בני־שת ‎

Er’ennū wə-lō ‘attāh, ’ăšūrennū wə-lō qārōḇ; dāraḵ kōḵāḇ mî-Ya‘ăqōḇ, wəqām šêḇeṭ mî-Yiśrā’êl, ū-māḥaṣ pa’ăṯê Mō’āḇ, wə-qarqar kāl-bənê-Šêṯ.[1]

I shall see him, but not now: I shall behold him, but not nigh: there shall come a Star out of Jacob, and a Sceptre shall rise out of Israel, and shall smite the corners of Moab, and destroy all the children of Sheth.

— Numbers 24:17

Messianism

[edit]

The prophecy was often employed during the troubled years that led up to the Jewish Revolt, the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem (70 CE) and the suicidal last stand of the Sicarii at Masada in 73 CE. The Star Prophecy appears in the Qumran texts called the Dead Sea Scrolls. "This was the prophecy that was of such importance to all resistance groups in this period, including those responsible for the documents at Qumran and the revolutionaries who triggered the war against Rome, not to mention the early Christians".[2]

The Star Prophecy was applied to the coming Messiah himself in contemporary radical Jewish documents, such as the apocalyptic War Scroll found at Qumran. In a pesher applied to the text from Numbers, the War Scroll's writer gives the following exegesis:

…by the hand of the Poor whom you have redeemed by Your Power and the peace of Your Mighty Wonders… by the hand of the Poor and those bent in the dust, You will deliver the enemies of all the lands and humble the mighty of the peoples to bring upon their heads the reward of the Wicked and justify the Judgement of Your Truth on all the sons of men.

Some have speculated that the Romanized Jewish historian Josephus, applied the prophecy to Vespasian, who was campaigning against the Jewish Zealots in Palestine, and "who was to come out of Israel and rule the world." According to Robert Karl Gnuse, it is not certain that Josephus was referring to the Star Prophecy:

"In his history Josephus observes that Vespasian was destined to be the world ruler who would come out of Judea, and not a Jewish messiah, as the revolutionaries had erroneously anticipated (War 6.312-314). … Josephus may have drawn upon the texts in Daniel 9:25-26 primarily and Genesis 49:10, Numbers 24:17, and Daniel 7:13-14 secondarily. He may have used an Essenic understanding of a messianic world ruler in addition."[3]

The star has been externalized as an actual star in the sky, the Star of Bethlehem, in the narration of the Gospel of Matthew. The fulfilled Star Prophecy is one of numerous instances of the asserted fulfillment of prophecies that are a main theme of this text.[citation needed]

Simon bar Kokhba

[edit]

The prophecy was also applied to Simon bar Kokhba, messianic leader of the Second Jewish Revolt of 132, whose adopted name bar Kokhba means "Son of a Star" in Aramaic.

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Star Prophecy

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The Star Prophecy denotes the ancient Hebrew in Numbers 24:17, delivered by the non-Israelite prophet , which states: "I shall see him, but not now: I shall behold him, but not nigh: there shall come a Star out of , and a shall rise out of ." This verse, part of Balaam's compelled blessings on amid Balak's futile attempts to them, employs celestial and royal imagery to predict dominance over neighboring peoples, including , , and the Amalekites. Historically, the prophecy fueled messianic expectations among first-century Jewish groups, such as the Zealots, who invoked it during revolts against Roman rule as signaling an imminent royal deliverer from Israel. Early Jewish texts, including Dead Sea Scrolls like 4QTestimonia, grouped it with other passages anticipating a prophet-like leader, affirming pre-Christian messianic readings. In Christian tradition, it is linked to Jesus of Nazareth, with the "star" evoked in New Testament accounts of the Magi following a celestial sign to his birthplace, symbolizing divine kingship fulfilled in Revelation 22:16 where Christ identifies as "the bright and morning star." Interpretations diverge: Jewish often applies it to historical conquerors like or symbolic national resurgence, while Christian views emphasize its typological anticipation of the Messiah's universal authority; some scholars debate its original intent as immediate political versus eschatological foresight. The 's enduring influence appears in theological, astronomical, and cultural discussions of celestial signs heralding , though empirical astronomical models for a literal "star" remain speculative and unverified.

Biblical Origins

The Oracle of Balaam in Numbers 24

In the biblical narrative of Numbers 22–24, Balak, king of , hires son of Beor, a Mesopotamian diviner from Pethor near the River, to curse the encamped on the following their victories over the Amorite kings Sihon and . , depicted as a professional seer capable of pronouncing effective blessings or curses for a fee, initially refuses after consulting , who forbids the journey, but later permits it with the instruction to speak only divine words. En route, Balaam's perceives an obstructing of invisible to him, leading to the animal's miraculous speech and Balaam's rebuke, after which his eyes are opened to the divine messenger. Upon arrival, accompanies to high places for sacrifices, but instead of cursing, he delivers two oracles blessing , prompting Balak's frustration and relocation to new vantage points. In Numbers 24, recognizing Yahweh's intent to bless , abandons omen-seeking and, with the Spirit of God upon him, utters the third (verses 3–9), likening to a that devours its prey undefeated. Balak urges silence, but proceeds to the fourth (verses 15–24), framed as the utterance of " the son of Beor, the man whose eye is opened, the of him who hears the words of God, who sees the vision of the Almighty, falling down with his eyes uncovered." This climactic oracle prophesies: "I see him, but not now; I behold him, but not near—a star shall come out of Jacob, and a scepter shall rise out of Israel; it shall crush the forehead of Moab and break down all the sons of Sheth. Edom shall be dispossessed; Seir also, his enemies, shall be dispossessed. Israel is doing valiantly. And one from Jacob shall exercise dominion and destroy the survivors of Ir!" The imagery evokes a future royal figure emerging from Jacob (Israel) to conquer Moab, Edom, and other foes, symbolizing triumphant dominion. Balaam, a non-Israelite, thus involuntarily proclaims Yahweh's sovereignty and Israel's destined ascendancy, concluding with oracles against additional nations like Assyria and Eber. Archaeological evidence, including a 9th–8th century BCE inscription from Deir Alla in Jordan mentioning "Balaam son of Beor, who was a seer of the gods," corroborates the figure's ancient Near Eastern recognition as a prophetic intermediary.

Linguistic and Symbolic Elements

The Hebrew term kôḵāḇ (כּוֹכָב) in Numbers 24:17 denotes "star," derived from a connoting blazing or rolling motion, and is employed metaphorically to signify a prince, leader, or illustrious figure rather than a literal celestial body. Similarly, šēḇeṭ (שֵׁבֶט), rendered as "scepter," stems from a root meaning to branch off or strike, encompassing a rod, staff, or tribal emblem that symbolizes authority, punishment, or governance, as seen in contexts of shepherding, ruling, or lineage. In ancient Near Eastern symbolism, the motif frequently represented deified kings or divine favor, linking earthly rulers to the celestial realm and implying over nations, a usage paralleled in Mesopotamian and Egyptian royal where kings were styled as stars. The scepter complements this by evoking instruments of and judgment, akin to staffs held by monarchs or shepherds asserting control, thereby portraying the prophesied figure as a conqueror wielding both cosmic legitimacy and temporal power. Linguistically, the oracle exhibits poetic parallelism and visionary phrasing, with verbs like yāṣāʾ ("come forth") for the star and qām ("rise" or "stand up") for the scepter, structured to convey emergence from Jacob/Israel and futurity ("not now... not near"), reflecting Balaam's ecstatic utterance style influenced by non-Israelite prophetic traditions. Ancient translations underscore interpretive nuances: the Septuagint renders kôḵāḇ as "man" to emphasize a human ruler, while Targum Onkelos specifies "king," highlighting the term's royal connotation over literal astronomy. These elements collectively frame the prophecy as a herald of triumphant leadership, grounded in shared Semitic imagery rather than unique Israelite innovation.

Traditional Interpretations

Jewish Messianic Expectations

In traditional Jewish , the prophecy in Numbers 24:17—"A star shall come forth from , a scepter shall arise from "—is interpreted as foretelling the arrival of the Mashiach, a future Davidic king who will establish Israel's sovereignty and subdue its enemies, including and the descendants of (encompassing broader powers). The "star" symbolizes the Messiah's radiant leadership and divine favor, emerging from the tribe of within 's lineage, while the "scepter" denotes royal authority and military dominion, fulfilling the promise of perpetual kingship in Genesis 49:10. This reading aligns with the verse's eschatological context in Balaam's oracle, envisioning ultimate redemption rather than immediate events. The , an authoritative translation from the early centuries CE, explicitly renders the verse messianically: "A king shall arise from the house of , and the shall be anointed from the house of ," linking the star and scepter directly to anointed kingship in the end times. (1040–1105 CE), in his commentary, connects to Israel's future exaltation beyond contemporary circumstances, interpreting the distant vision as pointing to enduring greatness through Davidic descendants, though he notes partial historical echoes in figures like King without limiting it to them. Later medieval commentators, such as those in the Chizkuni, occasionally emphasize Davidic fulfillment in conquests over but preserve the verse's orientation toward ultimate messianic victory. Jewish messianic expectations derived from this emphasize a human leader anointed to restore the Davidic , ingather the exiles, rebuild the , and impose universal by defeating hostile nations, as extrapolated from the verse's imagery of crushing Moab's forehead and dominating and Seir. Unlike immediate fulfillments claimed in antiquity—such as Akiva's application to (d. 135 CE), whom he dubbed "Bar Kochba" (son of the star) during the Second Jewish-Roman War—the remains unfulfilled in rabbinic tradition, awaiting a redeemer who achieves total subjugation of enemies and observance of worldwide. This view underscores causal realism in Jewish thought: redemption depends on collective merit and divine timing, with the star's emergence signaling irreversible triumph over assimilation and .

Christian Applications to Jesus Christ

Early Christian interpreters, including Justin Martyr in his Dialogue with Trypho (c. 155–160 AD), applied Numbers 24:17 to Jesus Christ as the promised Messiah arising from the lineage of Jacob, interpreting the "star" as a symbol of his divine origin and kingship, and the "scepter" as his eternal rule over Israel and the nations. Martyr explicitly linked the verse to Christ's emergence from Abraham's seed, arguing it demonstrated Moses' foreknowledge of a leader who would govern Israel spiritually and temporally. This exegesis positioned the prophecy as evidence of Jesus' fulfillment of Old Testament messianic expectations, with the "star out of Jacob" signifying his birth in Bethlehem from the tribe of Judah, as traced in Matthew 1:1–16 and Luke 3:23–38. The imagery of the star has been connected by patristic and later commentators to the described in :1–12, which guided the to the infant , portraying it as a celestial sign of the prophesied ruler's arrival. , such as frescoes in the Catacomb in dating to the 160s AD, depicts gesturing toward a star interpreted as the star, symbolizing recognition of Christ as the universal king foretold in the oracle. The "scepter" element underscores ' Davidic kingship, affirmed in his (Matthew 21:1–11) and prophesied eternal throne in Luke 1:32–33, where he exercises authority not through immediate military conquest but through redemptive victory over sin and death via and . Commentators like John Gill (1697–1771) elaborated that the prophecy's temporal distance—"I see him, but not now"—points to Christ's distant future advent from Balaam's era, culminating in his subjugation of spiritual foes like (symbolizing enmity toward God) through the gospel's spread, rather than solely physical dominion. This spiritual fulfillment aligns with themes, such as ' self-identification as the "root and offspring of , the bright morning star" in Revelation 22:16, evoking the star motif as emblematic of messianic light piercing darkness. While some traditions acknowledge partial historical echoes in Davidic victories (2 Samuel 8:2), Christian application reserves ultimate realization for Christ's eschatological reign, where enemies are decisively crushed (Revelation 19:11–21).

Historical Claimants and Events

Partial Fulfillment in King David

King David, a descendant of the tribe of Judah from Jacob's lineage, is regarded by numerous biblical commentators as providing a partial historical fulfillment of the "star" and "scepter" imagery in Numbers 24:17 through his rise to kingship and military dominance over Israel's enemies. As the second king of united Israel circa 1010–970 BCE, David's emergence as a prominent leader—symbolized by his victories and anointing—aligns with the prophecy's depiction of a "star" arising from Jacob, representing a shining, authoritative figure from within the Israelite tribes. David's conquest of , detailed in 2 Samuel 8:2, directly corresponds to the prophecy's reference to crushing "the of ," where he defeated Moabite forces, executed two-thirds of their by , and subjugated the survivors as tributaries, thereby breaking their power. This event, occurring during David's expansion of Israelite territory around 1000 BCE, is cited by interpreters as a typological or initial realization of the oracle's destructive judgment on , with the "" evoking a decisive blow to or strength. The prophecy's extension in Numbers 24:18 to Edom's subjugation also finds echo in David's campaigns, as 2 Samuel 8:14 records his garrisoning of Edom and the Moabites' tribute-bearing, portraying these nations as symbolic foes overwhelmed by Israelite rule under David. Medieval Jewish exegete Abraham Ibn Ezra explicitly linked the oracle to David, emphasizing these conquests over a messianic reading, though later traditions expanded it typologically. While some critical scholars confine the prophecy's scope to these Davidic events, denying a predictive element beyond the monarchy's establishment, others distinguish this as a near-term fulfillment greater eschatological victories, with David's dynasty serving as a for enduring royal symbolism in Judah. This interpretation underscores the oracle's layered application, rooted in verifiable historical actions rather than solely futuristic expectation.

Simon bar Kokhba and the Second Jewish-Roman War

Simon bar Kokhba, originally named Simon ben Kosiba, emerged as the leader of the Jewish revolt against Roman rule in 132 CE, following Emperor Hadrian's decrees to rebuild Jerusalem as the pagan city Aelia Capitolina and prohibit circumcision, which many Jews viewed as provocative assaults on their religious practices. Rabbi Akiva, a prominent Jewish scholar, endorsed bar Kokhba as the Messiah, reinterpreting his name as "Bar Kokhba" (son of the star) in direct reference to the prophecy in Numbers 24:17: "A star shall come forth out of Jacob, and a scepter shall rise out of Israel." This attribution drew on the verse's imagery of a messianic deliverer arising from Jacob to conquer enemies, positioning bar Kokhba as the prophesied figure who would restore Jewish sovereignty and smite oppressors like Rome, akin to Moab in the oracle. Akiva's proclamation significantly bolstered recruitment, framing the revolt as divinely ordained fulfillment of ancient and rallying disparate Jewish factions under bar Kokhba's command; coins minted during the uprising bore messianic slogans such as "Freedom of " and "For the Redemption of ," reflecting these eschatological hopes. The rebels initially achieved striking successes, capturing briefly and establishing a that controlled rural and parts of the for over two years, utilizing guerrilla tactics, cave networks for refuge, and an estimated force of up to 200,000 fighters. Bar Kokhba's administration issued legal documents and , signaling a short-lived autonomous state, while his military acumen—reportedly including feats like producing honey from stones to sustain troops—further reinforced his messianic aura among supporters. The Roman response, led by General Julius Severus and involving legions from across the empire, systematically dismantled the rebellion through scorched-earth tactics, besieging strongholds and cutting supply lines; ancient historian recorded that 50 fortified Jewish towns and 985 villages were razed, with Jewish combat deaths alone numbering 580,000, excluding those lost to , , and . Roman casualties were also severe, prompting to omit the customary "I and my army are well" from dispatches, indicative of heavy losses among the estimated 12 legions deployed. The revolt culminated in the fall of the fortress at in late 135 CE, where bar Kokhba perished, marking the decisive end of organized resistance and the prophecy's apparent unfulfilled application to him. In the aftermath, renamed the province to erase ties to the land, banned from except on , and imposed mass enslavement and displacement, decimating Judea's population and shifting toward non-messianic, scholarly traditions; later Talmudic sources critiqued Akiva's endorsement as erroneous, dubbing bar Kokhba "Bar Koziba" (son of falsehood) in retrospect. This failed claimant underscored the perils of prophetic literalism amid political desperation, as the star's promised dominion over foes did not materialize against Rome's imperial might.

Scholarly and Theological Debates

Prophetic Scope and Timing

The phrase "I see him, but not now; I behold him, but not near" in Numbers 24:17 explicitly signals a prophetic horizon distant from Balaam's era, conventionally dated to the late 15th or early BCE during Israel's wilderness wanderings. This temporal qualifier distinguishes the from immediate geopolitical forecasts in Balaam's preceding utterances, orienting it toward a long-term dynastic or eschatological emergence of rulership from lineage. The scope encompasses the rise of a sovereign figure—symbolized by a "star" denoting brilliance and guidance, and a "scepter" evoking authority—who will subdue Israel's historic foes, commencing with Moab's "forehead" (a metaphor for leadership or strength) and extending to broader antagonists like Edom, Seir, and Amalek in verses 18–20. Scholarly analyses, including intertextual links to Genesis 49:10's perpetual scepter from Judah, frame this as predictive of enduring Israelite dominance rather than transient tribal skirmishes, though debates persist on whether the imagery literalizes military conquest or typifies ultimate vindication. Conservative interpreters emphasize its transcendence beyond any single earthly monarch, given the oracle's divine inspiration via the Spirit upon Balaam (Numbers 24:2). Interpretations diverge on timing and layered fulfillment. Some scholars, such as Mowinckel and Seybold, attribute an initial realization to David's campaigns circa 1010–970 BCE, where he decimated Moabite forces (2 Samuel 8:2) and garrisoned (2 Samuel 8:14), viewing the prophecy as inaugurating the . However, this faces critique for incompleteness, as Moab reasserted independence by the BCE (2 Kings 3:4–5), and the oracle's futurity clause precludes a near-term resolution; Olson and others thus deem it typological rather than exhaustive. In Jewish rabbinic tradition, the prophecy anticipates a future Davidic , with the "star" evoking celestial endorsement of redemption in the end times, as echoed in and later applications like Akiva's endorsement of as "son of the star" during the 132–135 CE revolt. texts further bolster this eschatological scope, linking it to a priestly-kingly figure amid final battles. Christian , drawing on Revelation 22:16's self-identification of as the "bright morning star," posits primary fulfillment in his first-century CE advent, with the star motif paralleling Matthew 2's Bethlehem sign and ultimate enemy subjugation deferred to his return. This view, advanced by patristic writers like , integrates historical typology () with soteriological climax, though it encounters Jewish counterarguments that did not enact the prophesied territorial dominions. Theological debates hinge on vatic authenticity amid Balaam's pagan origins, with evidence from inscriptions affirming his seer status circa 800 BCE, yet affirming divine compulsion over human agency. While some minimalists reduce the scope to exilic redaction promoting national hope, the oracle's Mosaic-era embedding and lack of anachronistic traits support genuine predictivity, unresolved between historical kernel and transcendent .

Connections to the Star of Bethlehem and Astronomy

Early Christian writers, such as Irenaeus (c. 130–200 AD), explicitly associated the star in Balaam's oracle (Numbers 24:17) with the celestial phenomenon guiding the Magi to Bethlehem in Matthew 2:1–12, viewing it as a prophetic sign of the Messiah's advent. Similarly, Justin Martyr (c. 100–165 AD) invoked the verse in his First Apology to affirm the Incarnation, linking the "star out of Jacob" to the star heralding Jesus' birth as evidence of fulfilled Old Testament prophecy. This interpretive tradition posits the Star of Bethlehem as a literal manifestation of the oracle's imagery, where the star symbolizes both a royal descendant from Jacob's lineage and a visible heavenly sign announcing dominion over Israel's enemies. In ancient Near Eastern symbolism, stars often represented kings or deities, suggesting Balaam's "star" (Hebrew kokab) primarily denotes a human ruler rather than a literal celestial body, though early exegesis allowed for dual fulfillment in both metaphorical leadership and astronomical portent. Matthew's narrative, while not quoting Numbers 24:17 directly, likely alludes to it through the star's role in revealing the "king of the Jews," aligning with the oracle's scepter-wielding conqueror from Jacob. Proponents of this connection argue that the star's appearance during Herod's reign (c. 37–4 BC) temporally fits a messianic signal from Israelite territory, as the prophecy envisions an emergent authority "out of Jacob." Astronomical hypotheses for the Star of Bethlehem, such as the 7 BC triple conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn in Pisces—interpreted by some ancients as signaling a king's birth in Judea—have been proposed as potential natural correlates, though these events were visible globally and lacked the Gospel's described precision of halting over a specific location. Other candidates include the 3–2 BC helical risings of Jupiter near Regulus in Leo (associated with Judah's tribe, per Genesis 49:9–10) followed by a Jupiter-Venus conjunction in 2 BC, which produced exceptional brilliance but occurred after Herod's death in 4 BC, complicating alignment with Matthew's timeline. These theories, advanced by astronomers like those modeling planetary retrogrades via software such as Stellarium, aim to explain visibility to Persian Magi (familiar with Babylonian astrology), yet they presuppose the star's behavior conformed to predictable mechanics, which the text's "stood over" motion (Matthew 2:9) defies under known physics. Scholarly assessments highlight that no single astronomical event fully matches the Star's attributes—unprecedented appearance, directional guidance, and stationary hover—leading many to favor a or theologically interpretation over naturalistic ones, even while acknowledging the prophecy's potential of skies. Critics of astronomical explanations note that ancient astrologers would not uniformly link such conjunctions to a Jewish without prior tradition like Balaam's, and peer-reviewed analyses often conclude the phenomenon resists empirical reduction, serving instead as divine revelation akin to the 's visionary mode. Thus, connections between Numbers 24:17 and the Star remain interpretive bridges in , with astronomy providing circumstantial but inconclusive data.

References

  1. https://biblehub.com/numbers/24-17.htm
  2. https://www.biblestudytools.com/commentaries/gills-exposition-of-the-bible/numbers-24-17.html
  3. https://biblehub.com/commentaries/numbers/24-17.htm
  4. https://intertextual.bible/text/numbers-24.17-matthew-2.2
  5. https://biblehub.com/q/What_does_the_star_in_Numbers_24_17_mean.htm
  6. https://www.gotquestions.org/star-of-Bethlehem.html
  7. https://www.icr.org/home/resources/resources_tracts_whentheysawthestar/
  8. https://evidenceunseen.com/old-testament/numbers/difficulties/does-this-passage-predict-jesus
  9. https://answersingenesis.org/astronomy/stars/what-was-christmas-star/
  10. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Numbers%2022%3A1-6&version=ESV
  11. https://www.biblicalarchaeology.org/daily/biblical-topics/hebrew-bible/balaam-part-one/
  12. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Numbers%2022%3A22-35&version=ESV
  13. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Numbers%2024%3A1-9&version=ESV
  14. https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Numbers%2024%3A17-19&version=ESV
  15. https://rsc.byu.edu/creation-sinai/balaam-book-numbers
  16. https://biblehub.com/hebrew/3556.htm
  17. https://alittleperspective.com/kowkab-star-strongs-h3556/
  18. http://biblehub.com/hebrew/7626.htm
  19. https://www.balashon.com/2020/05/shevet-and-matteh.html
  20. https://www.goarch.org/-/the-star-of-bethlehem-the-star-of-jacob
  21. https://sats.ac.za/wp-content/uploads/2019/10/Thesis_MTh_2018_BlackmanN.pdf
  22. https://tips.translation.bible/story/translation-commentary-on-numbers-2417/
  23. https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/563/jewish/The-Star-of-Jacob.htm
  24. https://www.sefaria.org/Onkelos_Numbers.24.17?with=TARGUM%20ONKELOS%2C%20VOCALIZED%20ACCORDING%20TO%20THE%20YEMENITE%20TAJ
  25. https://www.sefaria.org/Onkelos_Numbers.24.17
  26. https://www.sefaria.org/Rashi_on_Numbers.24.17
  27. https://messiahprophecyandhistory.co.uk/2021/02/03/numbers-2417-a-star-shall-come-out-of-jacob-a-sceptre-shall-rise-out-of-israel/
  28. https://jewsforjesus.org/messianic-prophecies/the-messiah-would-be-the-star-coming-out-of-jacob
  29. https://www.sefaria.org/Rashi_on_Numbers.24.17.1
  30. https://christiancourier.com/articles/did-balaam-prophesy-concerning-the-messiah
  31. https://earlychurchhistory.org/beliefs-2/balaam-the-star-of-bethlehem/
  32. https://enduringword.com/bible-commentary/numbers-24/
  33. https://www.studylight.org/commentary/numbers/24-17.html
  34. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/the-bar-kokhba-revolt-132-135-ce
  35. https://www.jewishhistory.org/bar-kochba/
  36. https://www.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/2713668/jewish/Bar-Kokhba-Revolt.htm
  37. https://www.livius.org/articles/religion/messiah/messianic-claimant-18-simon-ben-kosiba/
  38. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/shimon-bar-kokhba
  39. https://www.livius.org/articles/concept/roman-jewish-wars/roman-jewish-wars-8/
  40. https://evidenceunseen.com/old-testament/numbers/difficulties/does-this-passage-predict-jesus/
  41. https://icr.edu/when-they-saw-star
  42. https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004410732_018
  43. https://www.zygonjournal.org/article/13932/galley/28241/download/
  44. https://lupinepublishers.com/anthropological-and-archaeological-sciences/fulltext/the-star-of-bethlehem-and-the-conjunction.ID.000346.php
  45. https://bibleinterp.arizona.edu/articles/2014/02/ada388004
  46. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/394209625_Between_Astronomy_and_Revelation_Reassessing_the_Star_of_Bethlehem_in_Matthew_21-12
  47. https://www.pharosjot.com/uploads/7/1/6/3/7163688/article_29_106_4__regular_issue_august.pdf
  48. https://adsabs.harvard.edu/full/2000JAHH....3R.169D
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.