Hubbry Logo
TawassulTawassulMain
Open search
Tawassul
Community hub
Tawassul
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Tawassul
Tawassul
Tawassul
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Tawassul (Arabic: توسل) is an Arabic word that originates from the word وسيلة, wasīlah, which stands for a means by which a person, goal or objective is approached, attained or achieved. In another version of the meaning of tawassul in another text: Tawassul is an Arabic word that comes from a verbal noun, wasilah, which according to Ibn Manzur (d. 711/1311) in Lisān al-'Arab means "a station of King, a rank, or act of devotion". In other words, it refers to a position of power due to one's proximity to the king or sovereign. While the tawassul or tawassulan is the use of wasilah for this purpose. In religious contexts, the tawassul is the use of a wasilah to arrive at or obtain favour of Allah.

Etymology

[edit]

Tawassul is an Arabic word that comes from a verbal noun, "wasilah", which means "closeness, nearness, proximity, neighbourship".[1] According to Ibn Manzur (d. 711/1311) in Lisān al-'Arab, wasilah means "a station with King, a rank, or act of devotion.[citation needed] The word wasilat had been stated in the Quran two times ([5:35],[17:57]). It is translated as “a means that can be used to gain nearness to God”. Therefore, the typical meaning of tawassul or tawassulanis use of wasilat to obtain nearness to God.[2]

Requesting assistance from a spiritual intermediary when seeking divine help. In conservative interpretations, only Muhammad can intercede with God on behalf of human beings because Islam teaches that every believer has direct access to God. In Sufism and popular practice, intercession is often asked of saints or holy people. Some reform movements oppose requests for intercession.

— The Oxford Dictionary of Islam[3][4]

Concept

[edit]

Tawassul, as the main habitude of supplications, has key role in to acceptation of them.[5][6]

O you who believe! be careful of (your duty to) Allah and seek means (wasilah) of nearness to Him and strive hard in His way that you may be successful (Q5:35)

Some classical commentators, including the great Sufi exegetes, such as al-Qushayri (d. 465/1074) explain the use of al-wasilah in this verse to mean avoiding what is prohibited, fulfilling what is enjoined on us, and drawing near to God through good actions.[citation needed] Both Raghib al-Isfahani and Sayyid Muhammad Husayn Tabataba'i opine that al-wasilah means to reach a certain goal through desire, inclination and willingness, and in fact wasilah towards God means observance of his path with knowledge and worship through adherence to the Sharia.[7] It can be deduced from the verse above that intercession (tawassul) is only with the "permission" of Allah.[8] Also, the practice of seeking intercession began during the time of the Islamic prophet Muhammad.[9] An oft-cited Hadith in support of this is one narrated from Uthman ibn Hunaif regarding a blind man who Muslims believe was healed through the process.

The Hadith is as follows:

A blind man came to the Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him & give him peace) and said: "I've been afflicted in my eyesight, so pray to Allah for me". The Prophet (Allah bless him & give him peace) said: "Go perform ablution (Wudu), perform two Rak’at Salat and then say: "O Allah! I ask you and turn to you through my Prophet Muhammad, the Prophet of Mercy. O Muhammad! I seek your intercession with my lord for the return of my eyesight, that it may be fulfilled. O Allah! Grant him intercession for me". The Messenger of Allah (Allah bless him & give him peace) then said: "and if there is some other need, do the same"

— Recorded by Ibn Majah: 1385, Tirmidhi, Abu Dawud, Nasa'i, Tabarani and others, with a sound chain of narrators.[10]

Various episodes from the life of Muhammad depict him interceding on behalf of his companions, mostly asking God to forgive their sins (Istighfar). For example, Aisha relates that he often slipped quietly from her side at night to go to the cemetery of Al-Baqi' to beseech forgiveness of God for the dead. Similarly, his istighfar is mentioned in the Salat al-Janazah and its efficacy explained.[11][12]

Another early example of tawassul is represented by the idea of turning to God by means of Muhammad. This appears in an account concerning the story of a blind man who asked Muhammad to pray to God for his health because of his blindness. This hadith is quoted in some major collections of traditions, such as Ahmad ibn Hanbal's Musnad:[11]

The Prophet ordered the blind man to repeat these words: “O God, I ask you and turn to You by means of Your Prophet Muhammad, the Prophet of Mercy, O Muhammad! By your means I turn to God.”[10]

In the Quran

[edit]

The Qur'an states:

If, when they had wronged themselves, they had come to you, and asked forgiveness from God, and the Messenger had asked forgiveness for them, they would have found God Relenting, Merciful.

— Al-Qur'an, Surah an-Nisa, 4:64

This verse raised the question as to whether or not Muhammad's mediation was still possible after his death. A number of Islamic scholars including Al-Nawawi, Ibn Kathir and Ibn al-Athir in his exegesis relates the following episode, aiming to demonstrate its effectiveness:

A Bedouin of the desert visited the Prophet’s tomb and greeted the Prophet, addressing him directly as if he were alive. “Peace upon you, Messenger of God!” Then he said, “I heard the word of God ‘If, when they had wronged themselves . . .,’ I came to you seeking pardon for my mistakes, longing for your intercession with our Lord!” The Bedouin then recited a poem in praise of the Prophet and departed. The person who witnessed the story says that he fell asleep, and in a dream he saw the Prophet saying to him, “O ‘Utbi, rejoin our brother the Bedouin and announce [to] him the good news that God has pardoned him!”[13][14][15]

The Qur'an also states:

O believers! Fear Allah and seek means (of approach to) His (presence and to His nearness and accessibility) and strive in His way so that you may prosper

— Al-Qur'an, Surah an-Maida, 5:35

The above verse lay emphasis on four things:

  • Faith
  • Piety (Taqwa)
  • Search for means of approach
  • Struggle for Allah's sake

According to the verse, the third regulation after faith in God and piety is " seeking means (of approach to) His (presence and to His nearness and accessibility)". Some of the religious scholars have interpreted wasilah (the means of approach) mentioned in the Quranic verse as faith and good deeds while others, who are majority have explained the word as the prophets, the righteous and favorites of Allah.[16][unreliable source?] Also, the verse reveals that a person seeking means of approach to Allah will have in the first instance a believer and Muttaqeen (a person who fear Allah). Thus wasilah does not amount to associating partner with Allah but rather reaffirms the oneness of Allah, according to the opinion of Muhammad Tahir-ul-Qadri.[16][unreliable source?]

Types

[edit]

There is this agreement among Muslim theologians that a means (tawassul) is acceptable concepts to draw near to Allah but they can't gain unanimity on what kind of means (Tawassul) is permissible. According to the main agreement people can draw near to Allah and invoke him by using of these permissible means such as their good act (their prayer, fasting and reciting the Quran) but there is the discussion on approach to Allah by means of the person of Muhammad and his dignity or other pious Muslims after the death.[2]

Sunni perspective

[edit]

Various episodes from the life of Muhammad depict him interceding on behalf of his companions, mostly asking God to forgive their sins (Istighfar). For example, Aisha relates that he often slipped quietly from her side at night to go to the cemetery of Al-Baqi' to beseech forgiveness of God for the dead....Similarly, his istighfar is mentioned in the Salat al-Janazah... and its efficacy explained.[11][12]

All jurists comprising Imami, Shafi'i, Maliki, Hanafi and Hanbali are unanimous on the permissibility of tawassul whether during the lifetime of Muhammad or after his death.[17][18] Syrian Islamic scholars Salih al-Nu`man, Abu Sulayman Suhayl al-Zabibi, and Mustafa ibn Ahmad al-Hasan al-Shatti al-Hanbali al-Athari al-Dimashqi have similarly released Fatwas in support of the practice.[19]

Al-Suyuti in his book History of the Caliphs also reports Caliph Umar's prayer for rain after the death of Muhammad and specifies that on that occasion ‘Umar was wearing his mantle (al-burda), a detail confirming his tawassul through Muhammad at that occasion.[11] Sahih al-Bukhari narrates similar situation as:

Whenever there was drought, 'Umar bin Al-Khattab used to ask Allah for rain through Al-‘Abbas ibn ‘Abd al-Muttalib, saying, "O Allah! We used to request our Prophet to ask You for rain, and You would give us. Now we request the uncle of our Prophet to ask You for rain, so give us rain." And they would be given rain."

— Sahih al-Bukhari Book 57 Hadith 59

In South Asia, Barelvi Sunni support tawassul while Deobandi and Wahabi oppose tawassul.[20][21]

Shia perspective

[edit]
See also: Ziyarat

Seeking Intercession (tawassul), similar to the Sunni school of thought, is widely accepted and even advised in Shia Islam. Shia Scholars refer to Quranic verses such as 5:3, 12:97 and 12:98 and justify its permissibility. During the tawassul prayer Shia Muslims call on the names of Muhammad and the Ahl al-Bayt and use them as their intercessors/intermediaries to God.[22] Shias always pray to and only to Allah, but as other Muslims, they accept tawassul as a means of seeking intercession.

Shia Muslims consider that Tawassul through prophets and Imams is the great justification of wasilah, because they had gain to the high degree of humanity and after death, they are alive and they are blessed by Allah. So they are kind of means that people use to gain nearness to Allah. Shia Muslim does not consider Tawasull as Bid‘ah and Shirk. According to their tenets, when Tawassul is forbidden that people don't attention that these means was created by Allah and their effect is raised from him.[23]

Shia Muslim visit from grave of Shia Imam and prophets of Allah and consider it as means to gain nearness to Allah.[24]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Tawassul

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Tawassul is a concept in Islamic theology denoting the practice of seeking a permissible means (wasilah) of drawing nearer to in supplication, typically by invoking His favor through the status or right of prophets, righteous persons, or one's own pious deeds, as derived from Quranic injunctions such as "O you who have believed, fear Allah and seek the means of nearness to Him" ( 5:35). This practice finds support in hadith narrations, including instances where companions sought rain through the Prophet Muhammad's uncle al-Abbas during his lifetime, and extensions to post-mortem intercession by the himself, endorsed by scholars across Sunni madhhabs like Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali traditions, as well as Shi'ite . Permissible forms emphasize directing supplication solely to Allah while using intermediaries as a medium for acceptance, distinguishing it from direct invocation of the deceased, which some reformist Salafi scholars deem impermissible or akin to shirk due to risks of compromising (pure monotheism). The debate centers on interpretive differences: traditionalists cite historical precedents and textual allowances for tawassul via the Prophet's rank even after death, viewing it as a legitimate expression of and reliance on prophetic favor, whereas stricter literalists prioritize avoiding any semblance of associating partners with , arguing that authentic means are limited to living intermediaries or personal faith. This contention has fueled broader discussions on (innovation) and the boundaries of devotional practices, particularly in contexts involving shrines or graves, without consensus on forms like istighatha (direct pleas for aid from the righteous).

Etymology and Definition

Linguistic Origins

The term tawassul (تَوَسُّل) derives from the triliteral w-s-l (و س ل), which fundamentally denotes connection, attachment, or drawing near to an object or goal. This underlies the noun wasīla (وَسِيلَة), appearing twice in the (e.g., 5:35), where it signifies a "means" or "instrument" for attaining proximity, as in seeking a path to divine nearness. Tawassul functions as the (maṣdar) of the Form V verb tawassala (تَوَسَّلَ), emphasizing the active pursuit of such a connection through an or expedient. In , such as Ibn Manẓūr's Lisān al-ʿArab (compiled circa 1290–1311 CE), derivatives of w-s-l evoke notions of a "station" or "rank" facilitating access to authority, akin to approaching a via a trusted aide, thereby extending to appeals or petitions for linkage. and attest to the root's usage for "drawing near to what one desires" via a medium, predating its theological application and confirming its secular linguistic breadth in Semitic contexts of relational bridging. This etymological foundation underscores tawassul not as innovation but as an endogenous Arabic expression of instrumental approach, distinct from roots like w-ṣ-l (with ṣād, denoting mere arrival without mediation).

Core Concept in Islamic Theology

Tawassul, from the triliteral root w-s-l denoting connection or linkage, constitutes in Islamic theology the act of seeking a permissible (wasīlah) to attain proximity to , emphasizing direct while invoking means that enhance acceptance without attributing independent power to the intermediary. This underscores tawḥīd (Allah's oneness) by confining efficacy to divine will, where the intermediary—such as righteous deeds, prophetic status, or divine names—serves as a symbolic or causal prompt for 's mercy rather than a rival agent. Theologians maintain that true tawassul avoids shirk () by explicitly directing the request to , as in formulations like "O Allah, I ask You by the honor of Your ," thereby affirming causal dependence on alone. The core theological rationale derives from the imperative to employ means in worship, reflecting human recognition of divine hierarchy and the Prophet's enduring intercessory rank (maqām maḥmūd), which persists post-mortem as an aspect of his prophetic favor with Allah. Scholars like those in the Hanbali and Shafi'i traditions permit tawassul through the Prophet's person or status, citing its alignment with Quranic exhortations to seek access (wasīlah) and hadith precedents where companions invoked prophetic mediation during his lifetime, extending this logically to his permanent spiritual station. Conversely, certain rigorist theologians, including Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 1328 CE), classify post-mortem tawassul through specific individuals as innovative (bid'ah) or potentially idolatrous if it implies the dead possess autonomous influence, insisting instead on tawassul solely via one's own faith, obedience, or Allah's attributes to preserve unadulterated tawḥīd. This doctrinal tension highlights a broader theological between Allah's absolute sovereignty and the instrumental role of creation in facilitating divine response, with proponents arguing that rejecting prophetic tawassul diminishes the Prophet's unique rank affirmed in scripture, while opponents prioritize empirical avoidance of practices resembling pre-Islamic to avert even apparent shirk. Empirical patterns in early Muslim supplications, such as ibn al-Khattab's (d. 644 CE) invocation of the Prophet's uncle al-Abbas for rain, illustrate accepted forms through living intermediaries, informing debates on extension to the deceased. Ultimately, tawassul embodies a theological commitment to mediated access within , where validity hinges on intent, formulation, and conformity to prophetic precedent, with mainstream Sunni scholarship—spanning Ash'ari, Maturidi, and traditionalist strains—predominantly affirming its legitimacy when confined to Allah's permission.

Scriptural Foundations

Evidence from the Quran

states: "O you who have believed, fear and seek the means [of nearness] to Him and strive in His cause that you may succeed," where the term wasīla (means of nearness) is interpreted by scholars of the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali schools as permitting through righteous intermediaries, including prophets and the pious, to draw closer to . This verse is adduced as a general directive for tawassul, with Egyptian fatwa authority Dar al-Ifta affirming it as encouragement for via the Prophet Muhammad's status, deeming such practice preferable (mustahab). However, Salafi scholars, such as those at IslamQA, contend that wasīla refers exclusively to one's own good deeds or 's names and attributes, excluding through created beings, to avoid resembling polytheistic practices. Qur'an 4:64 provides: "And if, when they wronged themselves, they had come to you, [O Muhammad], and asked forgiveness of Allah and the Messenger had asked forgiveness for them, they would have found Allah Accepting of repentance and Merciful," which proponents of tawassul cite as endorsing the Prophet's role in intercession for forgiveness during his lifetime, with some extending this efficacy posthumously based on his enduring prophetic rank. Classical commentators like Imam al-Nawawi reference this verse in contexts of seeking the Prophet's intercession, linking it to reports of companions invoking his favor at his grave. Opponents, including certain Hanbali literalists, restrict its application to the Prophet's earthly presence, arguing it does not authorize direct appeals to him after death, as the verse conditions efficacy on his living supplication. Qur'an 17:57 notes: "Those whom they invoke seek means of access to their , [striving as to] which of them would be nearest," critiquing idolaters whose invoked entities themselves require wasīla to , which some scholars use to affirm tawassul's legitimacy only through divinely approved means like prophets, distinguishing it from invalid forms directed at powerless beings. This interpretation underscores tawassul's alignment with when confined to Allah's sanctioned channels, though it implicitly warns against excess that equates intermediaries with independent power. No Qur'anic verse explicitly mandates or prohibits tawassul through specific deceased figures, leaving room for interpretive variance rooted in broader theological frameworks.

Evidence from Hadith and Sunnah

Several hadiths are invoked in discussions of tawassul, the practice of seeking nearness to Allah through permissible intermediaries, though their interpretation as endorsement varies among scholars. One prominent narration, reported by Uthman ibn Hunayf, describes a blind man approaching the Prophet Muhammad during his lifetime and requesting supplication for healing. The Prophet instructed him to perform ablution, pray two rak'ahs, and then recite: "O Allah, I ask You and turn to You through my Prophet Muhammad, the Prophet of Mercy; O Muhammad, I seek your intercession with my Lord for my need, that it may be fulfilled. O Allah, accept his intercession for me." Upon doing so, the man's sight was restored. This hadith is classified as hasan (sound) by al-Tirmidhi, though some scholars, such as those following a strict Salafi methodology, contend it evidences tawassul only through the Prophet's supplication while alive, not independently through his person or status posthumously. Another authentic narration from recounts , during a drought after the 's death, requesting al-Abbas ibn Abd al-Muttalib—the 's uncle—to supplicate for . stated: "O , we used to ask our to invoke You for , and You would bless us with , and now we ask his uncle to invoke You for ." subsequently fell, and this is cited by proponents as evidence for tawassul through a living righteous individual, with explicitly transitioning from reliance on the deceased to al-Abbas, who was alive and capable of direct supplication. Opponents of broader tawassul forms argue this underscores the impropriety of invoking the deceased, emphasizing tawassul via living persons' prayers over inherent status. Narrations purporting tawassul through the after his death or via pre-existent prophetic status, such as Adam seeking forgiveness "by the right of ," are deemed fabricated or weak by major critics, lacking chains meeting sahih standards and thus providing no evidentiary basis. Scholarly consensus holds that the permits seeking Allah's favor through His names, attributes, obedience, or the supplications of living pious individuals, but extends no authentication to invoking the dead or absent as intermediaries independent of their direct action. These s, while central to debates, primarily affirm tawassul in contexts tied to the 's earthly presence or living companions, with posthumous applications remaining contentious and unsupported by undisputedly sahih reports.

Historical Development

Practices Among the Prophet's Companions

During the lifetime of Prophet Muhammad, his companions frequently sought tawassul by requesting his direct supplication to for various needs, such as during droughts, reflecting their recognition of his elevated status as an whose prayers were accepted. This practice aligned with the Prophet's role in interceding through du'a, as evidenced by instances where companions approached him collectively for istisqa' ( for ), and responded favorably. Following the Prophet's death in 632 CE, Caliph ibn al-Khattab continued tawassul through living righteous figures, notably the Prophet's uncle, al-Abbas ibn Abd al-Muttalib, during periods of drought. In , it is recorded that Umar would ask al-Abbas to invoke for , stating: "O ! We used to ask our to invoke You for and You would give us . Now we ask his uncle to invoke You for ." This supplication was followed by rainfall, demonstrating tawassul via the honor of familial proximity to the while emphasizing supplication to alone through a living intermediary. Umar's explicit reference to shifting from the Prophet's direct prayer to al-Abbas's indicates an adaptation to the Prophet's passing, avoiding invocation of the deceased. Other narrations attribute similar grave-visitation tawassul to companions like Bilal ibn al-Harith during Umar's caliphate, where a man reportedly addressed the Prophet's grave seeking rain for the ummah, after which precipitation occurred. However, this account's chain of narration is considered weak by many hadith scholars due to breaks in transmission and reliance on lesser-known narrators, limiting its evidentiary weight compared to authenticated reports like the Bukhari hadith. Overall, companions' practices underscored tawassul through living prophets or pious individuals whose du'a invoked Allah's mercy, without evidence of direct supplication to the Prophet post-mortem in sahih sources.

Evolution in Early Islamic Scholarship

In the period following the (successors to the Companions, roughly 1st-2nd centuries AH/7th-8th centuries CE), tawassul transitioned from anecdotal practices to more systematic discussion in jurisprudential and theological texts, with early scholars generally affirming its legitimacy as a means of drawing closer to through permissible intermediaries like the Prophet's status or righteous deeds, without evidence of widespread . This acceptance is reflected in the absence of fatwas against it among foundational figures, contrasting with later critiques, and aligns with broader hadith-based validations of . Among the eponymous Imams of the Sunni madhhabs, who codified in the 2nd and 3rd centuries AH, tawassul through the Muhammad was endorsed explicitly or implicitly. Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal (d. 241 AH/855 CE), founder of the , advised a supplicant facing hardship to "use the as a means in his to ," indicating approval for invoking the 's intercessory rank even after his death. Similarly, narrations attribute to Imam (d. 179 AH/795 CE) permission for tawassul by the 's position during times of scarcity, though some later evaluators questioned the reliability of certain chains transmitting these accounts due to narrator precision issues. Imams Abu Hanifah (d. 150 AH/767 CE) and (d. 204 AH/820 CE) contributed to this framework through their schools' broader acceptance of via prophetic merit, integrating it into routines of du'a without doctrinal opposition. This scholarly evolution marked tawassul as a non-controversial extension of practices, embedded in early works on and , with distinctions emerging only later between its universal forms (e.g., via Allah's names or deeds) and those involving physical relics or graves, which some early voices cautioned against to preserve . By the 3rd century AH, it influenced compilations like those of scholars, who preserved narrations supporting without impugning the practice, setting the stage for its normalization across Sunni until revived debates in subsequent eras.

Classifications and Types

Universally Accepted Forms

Tawassul through the Names and Attributes of is considered permissible by consensus among Muslim scholars, involving such as "O , I ask You by Your mercy and Your might" or invoking specific divine qualities to seek nearness and response. This form draws from Quranic injunctions like Surah Al-A'raf 7:180, which commands seeking by His beautiful names, and is exemplified in prophetic supplications reported in authentic collections. A second universally accepted form involves tawassul by one's in and His Messenger, as in phrases like "O , by the right of my in You and Your , grant me what I seek." This is supported by narrations such as the of (peace be upon him) seeking by 's covenant with , interpreted by scholars across sects as permissible due to the elevated status of prophetic in Islamic creed. Tawassul through righteous deeds or actions pleasing to constitutes the third agreed-upon type, rooted in incidents like the of the three men trapped by a rock, each invoking a specific good deed—such as charity, , or just ruling—to implore 's aid. Scholars affirm this as uncontroversial, as it aligns with the principle that virtuous conduct serves as a means to divine favor without implying of . Additionally, seeking the of a living pious individual is unanimously permitted, as it mirrors requesting from contemporaries whose prayers may invoke Allah's mercy on one's behalf. This practice is evidenced in where companions sought the Prophet's during his lifetime, extending logically to any righteous person present. These forms emphasize direct reliance on while using sanctioned intermediaries inherent to and deed, distinguishing them from disputed practices involving the deceased or absent figures. Scholarly consensus holds that they preserve by subordinating all means to Allah's will, as articulated in classical texts across Sunni and Shia traditions.

Disputed or Conditional Forms

Scholars dispute tawassul by invoking the rank, status, or person of the Muhammad or deceased righteous figures, such as phrasing supplications as "O , I ask You by the status of Your ." This form is permitted by traditional Sunni authorities in the Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and certain Hanbali traditions, who interpret it as drawing upon the elevated position these figures hold with , without implying direct agency or worship of the intermediary. Proponents cite narrations like the of the blind man in (d. 279 AH), where the instructed via his own status for sight restoration, and a post-prophetic incident involving the same companion ibn Hunayf advising a similar formula, which reportedly succeeded. In contrast, Salafi scholars, emphasizing strict adherence to the Salaf's practices, classify such tawassul as impermissible innovation () or even major shirk if it suggests the deceased can hear or effect outcomes independently, arguing no unambiguous Quranic or prophetic precedent exists beyond Allah's names, attributes, or one's deeds. They contend the blind man hadith's authenticity is weak or misinterpreted, as it pertains only to living , and warn that grave-site practices risk emulating pre-Islamic . Conditional permissibility arises in some views where tawassul through the deceased is allowed solely if the supplicant believes alone grants the request, using the figure's honor as a symbolic wasilah without expecting direct intervention, though this remains contested due to potential for misunderstanding among laypeople. A related disputed practice, istighatha—directly beseeching the dead or absent righteous for aid, as in "O , help me"—is broadly rejected across Sunni schools as it shifts from , resembling polytheistic calls and lacking evidentiary support in primary texts. These forms' validity often hinges on intent and formulation, with consensus holding that any tawassul implying partnership with violates .

Sectarian Perspectives

Sunni Interpretations

In , Tawassul—seeking nearness to through permissible intermediaries—is affirmed as legitimate by the majority of classical scholars, provided it maintains strict adherence to by directing solely to . This view draws from narrations such as the of the blind Companion ibn Hunayf, where the instructed "by my status with my Lord," extended by later jurists to posthumous use of the 's rank. The four Sunni madhhabs—Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi'i, and Hanbali—broadly concur on its permissibility, with many regarding tawassul via the 's life, status, or righteous deeds as recommended (), as evidenced in foundational texts like those of Imam al-Nawawi (Shafi'i, d. 1277 CE) and the consensus reported by Egyptian Dar al-Ifta scholars. Hanafi jurists, including later authorities like those at SeekersGuidance, permit tawassul through the Prophet's person or rank after his death, though some early texts caution against phrasing like "by the right of so-and-so" to avoid implying independent power in the intermediary. Maliki and Shafi'i scholars similarly endorse it, citing practices among the Companions and early Successors, such as invoking by the Prophet's favor during droughts or hardships, as reported in works by Imam al-Suyuti (d. 1505 CE). Hanbali tradition shows greater nuance, with foundational figures like Imam (d. 855 CE) allowing supplication through the Prophet's based on evidence, though later adherents diverged. A dissenting minority within Hanbali circles, led by Taqi al-Din Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 1328 CE), restricted tawassul to the Prophet's lifetime or to Allah's names and attributes, arguing that posthumous appeals to his person lack explicit proof from the Salaf and risk resembling unwarranted innovation (bid'ah). Ibn Taymiyyah acknowledged the blind man's hadith as valid for living intercession but deemed extensions to the deceased unsubstantiated, influencing subsequent Salafi-oriented scholars who classify broader forms as impermissible or even bordering on shirk if implying the Prophet's independent efficacy. This stance, while rigorous in prioritizing early textual evidence, contrasts with the predominant Ash'ari-Maturidi consensus among traditional Sunnis, who view such tawassul as an extension of prophetic honor without compromising divine oneness, as upheld in fatwas from institutions like Dar al-Ulum Deoband. Overall, Sunni interpretations emphasize contextual validity: tawassul by faith, , or the Prophet's remains undisputed, while invocations at graves or to awliya' (saints) are conditionally accepted by most but rejected by literalists to avert potential excess, reflecting a balance between evidentiary caution and historical practice.

Shia Interpretations

In Twelver Shia theology, tawassul is interpreted as a permissible and recommended act of supplicating through intermediaries of high spiritual rank, such as the Prophet Muhammad, the infallible Imams from his progeny (), and righteous believers, whether living or deceased, provided the supplicant recognizes their dependence on divine permission. This practice underscores the intermediaries' proximity to due to their piety and authority (), without attributing independent power to them, thereby preserving strict (). Shia scholars emphasize that tawassul aligns with Quranic injunctions, such as in Surah (5:35), which commands believers to "seek the means of nearness to Him," interpreted as utilizing the spiritual stations of prophets and Imams as wasilah. Hadith narrations attributed to the s further support this view; for instance, (d. 765 CE) is reported to have instructed supplicants to seek Allah's favor through the Prophet and his family, affirming their role in facilitating divine response. Another tradition from (d. 661 CE) describes tawassul via the as a path to acceptance, drawing on their and intercessory role on the Day of Judgment as outlined in Shia eschatology. Practices include reciting Dua Tawassul, a supplication invoking the Prophet's daughter Fatima al-Zahra (d. circa 632 CE) and the for , commonly performed during times of need or in pilgrimage rituals like to shrines in or . Prominent contemporary Shia jurists, such as Grand Ali al-Sistani (b. 1930), rule tawassul through the Imams as appropriate and not constituting shirk, provided it entails requesting their supplication to rather than direct agency, aligning with the Quranic allowance for by His leave (Surah al-Baqarah 2:255). This interpretation contrasts with stricter Sunni reformist critiques but is defended by Shia exegetes like Sayyid Muhammad Husayn Tabatabai (d. 1981) in his tafsir al-Mizan, who argues it reflects causal chains in divine mercy without compromising 's sovereignty. Empirical observance in Shia communities, including annual Arba'een pilgrimages drawing over 20 million participants since the , demonstrates tawassul's integration into devotional life, often involving calls for the Imams' mediation amid hardships.

Controversies and Debates

Criticisms from Strict Tawhid Advocates

Strict advocates of Tawhid, particularly Salafis and adherents to the methodologies of Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 1328 CE) and Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab (d. 1792 CE), contend that certain prevalent forms of tawassul—especially invoking the Prophet Muhammad or righteous individuals (awliya) as intermediaries in supplication—constitute shirk (associating partners with Allah) by attributing independent power or efficacy to created beings. They maintain that true Tawhid al-Uluhiyyah (the oneness of Allah in worship) demands directing all acts of devotion, including du'a (supplication), exclusively to Allah, without reliance on any human intermediary, as this risks emulating pre-Islamic polytheistic practices where idols or deceased figures were beseeched for aid. Such critics cite Quranic verses like 35:13-14, which describe invoked entities besides Allah as powerless servants akin to humans, incapable of harm or benefit without divine permission, to argue that post-mortem tawassul through prophets or saints implies a false belief in their ongoing intercessory capacity independent of Allah's will. Ibn Taymiyyah, in works such as Majmu' al-Fatawa, categorizes tawassul practices at graves into tiers, deeming those involving direct appeals to the deceased (istighatha) as impermissible and akin to shirk akbar (major polytheism), since they divert from alone; he permits only tawassul by 's names, attributes, or one's own righteous deeds, rejecting by the Prophet's person or status after his as an innovation lacking precedent. Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab echoes this in Kitab al-Tawhid, explicitly condemning tawassul to the dead as addressing the "non-existent," which he equates with absurdity and shirk, allowing it solely for living persons under strict conditions but prohibiting grave-based rituals as gateways to observed in his era's practices. These scholars differentiate permissible tawassul—such as beseeching by His mercy or the Prophet's during his lifetime—from disputed forms, arguing the latter foster dependency on humans, contravening hadiths equating du'a with the essence of (e.g., 3371), thus reserved for exclusively. Critics further assert that even seemingly innocuous tawassul by the Prophet's "right" or status (bi haqqihi) post-death veers into shirk khafi (subtle ) by implying inherent virtue in the intermediary, unsupported by the Companions' practices, who never invoked the after his passing in reported narrations. Contemporary Salafi scholars like Ibn Uthaymin (d. 2001 CE) reinforce this, classifying valid tawassul narrowly to Allah's attributes or general faith, while deeming person-specific appeals—especially to absent or deceased figures—as (innovation) potentially leading to widespread grave veneration, as evidenced by historical excesses in regions like and the . They substantiate their stance with the Salaf's avoidance of such acts, per narrations from early imams like , prioritizing textual literalism over later Sufi or Ash'ari interpretive allowances.

Defenses Based on Traditional Scholarship

Imam Yahya (d. 1277 CE), a prominent Shafi'i jurist, defended tawassul through the Prophet Muhammad as permissible, citing the of the blind Companion Uthman ibn Hunayf, in which the Prophet instructed supplication using his own status as a means to , and extending this to post-mortem application based on the continuity of the Prophet's . In his Al-Adhkar, recorded narrations endorsing tawassul at the Prophet's grave, such as touching the noble chamber and invoking through the Prophet's right, deeming it a valid means of drawing divine favor without implicating shirk. Other classical scholars, including (d. 1355 CE) and (d. 1449 CE), reinforced these positions by interpreting 5:35—"O you who have believed, fear and seek the means [wasilah] to Him"—as encompassing through prophets and the righteous, arguing that prohibition would contradict established prophetic guidance and Companion practices, such as ibn al-Khattab's tawassul through al-Abbas during . They critiqued stricter Hanbali views, like those later amplified by Ibn Taymiyyah (d. 1328 CE), as overly restrictive and unsupported by consensus, noting that even (d. 855 CE) implicitly allowed intermediary supplication through the living and extended it analogically. In the Hanafi and Maliki traditions, scholars such as (d. 933 CE) and (d. 1273 CE) upheld tawassul via righteous deeds or the Prophet's person as an enhancement to direct supplication, grounded in linguistic analysis of "wasilah" as any permissible conduit to divine proximity, evidenced by unchallenged historical practices among the without reports of prophetic rebuke. These defenses emphasized causal distinction: tawassul invokes alone as the ultimate agent, using intermediaries for efficacy, not divinity, thereby preserving while aligning with empirical patterns of accepted fulfillment in early Islamic sources.

Modern Applications and Rulings

Contemporary Fatwas and Scholarly Opinions

Egypt's Dar al-Ifta, a prominent Sunni fatwa institution affiliated with Al-Azhar University, has ruled that tawassul through the Prophet Muhammad—such as supplicating Allah by his status or rank—is permissible and preferable (mustahab), drawing on Quranic verses like 5:35 that encourage seeking means of nearness to Allah. In 2020, Al-Azhar issued a fatwa explicitly affirming the legitimacy of tawassul, positioning it as a shared Islamic practice and critiquing Wahhabi prohibitions as deviations from classical scholarship. Conversely, Saudi Arabia's Permanent Committee for Scholarly Research and Ifta, representing Salafi perspectives, deems tawassul through deceased prophets, righteous individuals, or their relics as impermissible and akin to shirk, permitting only directly to or through one's own while alive. Similarly, IslamQA, a Salafi-oriented fatwa site, prohibits tawassul by the Prophet's status after his death, arguing it lacks authentic prophetic precedent and risks associating partners with , though it allows seeking the Prophet's during his lifetime. In Shia jurisprudence, contemporary marja' such as and the late endorse tawassul to the Prophet, Imams, and awliya, viewing it as a means to invoke without compromising , supported by narrations from the Imams permitting through their names or persons. Hanafi-oriented bodies like Darul Iftaa () distinguish permissible tawassul—such as through living righteous persons or one's faith—while prohibiting istighatha (direct appeals for help) to the deceased, citing risks of excess leading to grave worship, though they affirm classical allowances for supplicating via the Prophet's honor in limited forms. These divergent rulings reflect ongoing tensions between reformist strictures emphasizing unadulterated and traditionalist endorsements rooted in historical practices and interpretations.

Practices in Current Muslim Societies

In Shia-majority societies such as and , tawassul through the Imams forms a core devotional practice, prominently featured during mass pilgrimages to holy shrines. The annual Arbaeen walk to Imam Husayn's shrine in , , attracted over 21 million pilgrims in 2025, with participants commonly reciting supplications invoking the Imams' intercession for divine favor. Similarly, nearly 8 million Iranians visited Iraqi shrines in the preceding year, engaging in rituals like nazr (votive offerings) and direct appeals at sites such as and to seek proximity to God via the . Among Sunni communities with strong Sufi traditions, particularly in and , tawassul often involves visitation to saints' tombs (mazaars or dargahs) for blessings and . In Pakistan's Indus region, devotees maintain rituals centered on the perceived spiritual presence of Sufi saints at their graves, including prayers for personal needs and communal gatherings that affirm metaphysical connections to the deceased righteous. In , such practices persist in urban and rural settings; for instance, in City, tawassul serves as a shortcut to God's grace through named intermediaries during grave visits, though it sparks debate over its alignment with scriptural purity. At sites like the tomb of Nyai Hamdanah Asnawi, supplicants perform tawassul specifically for and other life concerns, blending with offerings. In contrast, Salafi-influenced Gulf states like enforce strict prohibitions on tawassul via deceased prophets or saints, viewing it as shirk (polytheism) that compromises . Religious curricula and fatwas classify through graves or righteous figures as innovation (), limiting grave visits to simple recitation of prayers without to the buried. Public enforcement includes demolition of structures historically associated with such practices, channeling devotion exclusively toward direct appeals to .

References

  1. https://www.dar-alifta.org/en/article/details/163/supplication-through-the-prophet-muhammad-al-tawassul
  2. https://www.minhajbooks.com/english/book/Islamic-Concept-of-Intermediation-Tawassul/read/txt/btid/783/
  3. https://daruliftaa.com/aqidah-belief/tawassul-supplicating-allah-through-an-intermediary/
  4. https://al-islam.org/shiite-encyclopedia/tawassul-resorting-intermediary
  5. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/114142
  6. https://daruliftaa.com/aqidah-belief/various-forms-of-tawassul-and-istighatha-and-their-rulings/
  7. https://www.abuaminaelias.com/tawassul-asking-by-the-prophet/
  8. https://corpus.quran.com/qurandictionary.jsp?q=wsl
  9. https://en.wikishia.net/view/Tawassul
  10. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/tawasul
  11. https://al-mustaqeem.tripod.com/id34.html
  12. https://arabiclexicon.hawramani.com/
  13. https://al-islam.org/divine-link-study-wasilah-and-tawassul-kazim-dhalla/general-discussion-tawassul
  14. https://iqraonline.net/tawassul-and-istighatha-a-holistic-overview/
  15. http://islamicresearchmission.blogspot.com/2012/11/surah-nisaas-verse-no64-is-enough-to.html
  16. https://systemoflife.com/tawassul-refutation-series-athar-utbi/
  17. https://systemoflife.com/meaning-of-seeking-waseelah/
  18. https://al-islam.org/new-analysis-wahhabi-doctrines-muhammad-husayn-ibrahimi/tawassul-resorting-inter-mediation-death-and
  19. https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:3578
  20. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/97600
  21. https://sunnah.com/bukhari:1010
  22. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/118099
  23. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/60041
  24. https://islamqa.info/en/answers/979
  25. https://alkarbala.org/team/uploads/Tawassul_in_Light_of_Quraan_and_Hadeeth.pdf
  26. https://www.scielo.br/j/trans/a/FSGxcwqBPpZh67ZrNCdTfJr/?format=pdf&lang=en
  27. https://al-islam.org/message-thaqalayn/vol5-n4-2000/tawassul-seeking-way-unto-allah-abd-al-karim-bi-azar-shirazi/tawassul
  28. https://786nasir.wordpress.com/tag/islamic-article-part-8-views-of-four-imams-of-madhhab-re-tawassul-visiting-graves-is-sunnah-of-prophet/
  29. https://www.abuaminaelias.com/tawassul-prophets-saints-graves/
  30. https://baharemadinah.com/proclaim-ya-concept-tawassul/
  31. https://abdurrahman.org/2015/02/03/the-correct-tawassul-means-of-nearness-to-allaah-and-its-types-shaykh-ibn-uthaymeen/
  32. https://www.scribd.com/document/24718414/The-Agreed-upon-Types-of-Tawassul
  33. https://www.islamieducation.com/the-hadith-proofs-for-tawassul-intercession/
  34. https://www.islamweb.net/en/fatwa/89352/tawassul-through-a-dead-person
  35. https://alsalafiyyah.github.io/ruling-on-visiting-graves-supplicate-the-dead/
  36. https://thethinkingmuslim.com/2020/12/12/istighatha-and-tawassul-in-the-hanbali-school-a-discussion-with-sh-kareem-helmy/
  37. https://seekersguidance.org/answers/islamic-belief/is-tawassul-through-the-prophet-permissible-in-the-hanafi-school/
  38. https://www.islamweb.net/en/fatwa/89076/permissibility-of-tawassul
  39. https://seekersguidance.org/answers/hanafi-fiqh/is-tawassul-permissible-in-the-hanafi-school/
  40. https://al-islam.org/articles/tawassul-ahl-al-bayt
  41. https://iqraonline.net/quranic-evidence-for-the-impermissibility-of-tawassul-through-the-awliya-an-overview-and-critique/
  42. https://thethinkingmuslim.com/2021/03/22/ibn-taymiyyah-on-istighatha-and-tawassul/
  43. https://www.ahlus-sunna.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=57&Itemid=116
  44. https://www.thinkingislam.com/p/ya-muhammad-madad-sunni-scholars
  45. https://darulfatwa.org.au/en/in-defense-of-at-tawassul-a-reason-for-the-fulfillment-of-needs/
  46. https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicQuran/comments/1ft2zor/how_mainstream_was_tawassul_through_the_prophet/
  47. https://alsunna.org/wp/blog/2023/04/29/ibn-taymiyahs-prohibiting-the-tawassul-by-the-prophets-and-awliya-and-the-tabarruk-by-them-and-their-traces-v/
  48. https://www.darulfatwa.org.au/en/in-defense-of-at-tawassul-a-reason-for-the-fulfillment-of-needs/
  49. https://ijtihadnet.com/new-clear-fatwa-of-al-azhar-regarding-tawassul-a-prelude-to-decline-of-wahhabi-dominance/
  50. https://abdurrahman.org/2015/01/10/fatwa-on-tawassul-permanent-commitee/
  51. https://najat.seratonline.com/33309/view-of-famous-contemporary-shia-scholars-on-istigatha-and-tawassul/
  52. https://iqna.ir/en/news/3494261/over-21-million-pilgrims-attend-2025-arbaeen-in-iraq-authorities-say
  53. https://www.tehrantimes.com/news/518979/Iranians-top-list-of-pilgrimage-tourists-to-Iraq
  54. https://dash.harvard.edu/bitstreams/9c34ae90-f85d-4326-9b0a-71fff8d0d0c8/download
  55. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/374416814_A_Living_Quran_Exploration_of_Tawassul_Practices_in_Palu_City_A_Shortcut_or_a_winding_road_to_God%27s_Grace
  56. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/396631814_Spirituality_and_Matcmaking_An_Analysis_of_Tawassul_Practices_at_the_Tomb_of_Nyai_Hamdanah_Asnawi
  57. https://www.hrw.org/news/2021/02/15/saudi-arabia-further-textbook-reforms-needed
  58. https://www.islamweb.net/en/article/157717/permissible-and-prohibited-tawassul
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.