Hubbry Logo
A Small PlaceA Small PlaceMain
Open search
A Small Place
Community hub
A Small Place
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
A Small Place
A Small Place
A Small Place
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Kincaid in 2019

A Small Place is a work of creative nonfiction published in 1988 by Jamaica Kincaid. A book-length essay drawing on Kincaid's experiences growing up in Antigua, it can be read as an indictment of the Antiguan government, the country's tourist industry and Antigua's colonial legacy. The book, written in four sections, "combines social and cultural critique with autobiography and a history of imperialism to offer a powerful portrait of (post)colonial Antigua."[1]

History and background

[edit]

In 1493, Christopher Columbus became the first European to visit Antigua on his second voyage. He named it Antigua after the Santa Maria de la Antigua, an icon found in Seville's cathedral. Sir Thomas Warner from England was able to colonise the island in 1632 by starting plantations that included tobacco and sugarcane. Warner also introduced slavery to the island. Slaves from West Africa worked on these plantations. Antigua became known as the English Harbourtown for its great location in the Caribbean. In 1834, slavery was finally abolished, but black peoples' economic conditions failed to improve due to "land shortages and the universal refusal of credit".[2]

In her work, Jamaica Kincaid presents her own perspective on her home country, Antigua, while it was under colonial rule and self-governance. She focuses on the impact of tourism and government corruption, both of which became prevalent after independence, on the citizens of Antigua and the consequent changes/continuity in their lives. This social critique led it being described as "an enraged essay about racism and corruption in Antigua" by one reviewer.[3] Kincaid is very unapologetic in her critique of these times, and challenges readers to face the reality and uncomfortable truths of power and oppression.

Content

[edit]

Part One: In this section, Kincaid speaks directly to the reader. She refers to the reader as "you" and describes the experiences of a tourist of Antigua. She begins with landing in the airport and follows the tourist through their stay in Antigua. In this section, Kincaid emphasises the idea that a tourist is an ugly human being. Kincaid emphasises how the tourism industry perpetuates systems of inequality in Antigua and forces Antiguans to act as servants to white tourists. She also notes how tourists just observe things at face value and do not gain a real understanding of Antigua. Kincaid suggests that tourists are oblivious to reality and use vacations as a way to escape the boredom of their own lives, which is something natives cannot do because they are too poor.

Part Two: In the second section, Kincaid reflects on the Antigua she grew up in. She starts the section by saying, "The Antigua that I knew, the Antigua in which I grew up, is not the Antigua you, a tourist, would see now. That Antigua no longer exists." Kincaid is referring to colonial Antigua, which did not become fully independent from Britain until 1981.[4] She discusses the history and legacy of British rule in Antigua, including her own experiences with the subject. Kincaid criticizes the difficulty of using English:

For isn't it odd that the only language I have in which to speak of this crime [colonialism] is the language of the criminal who committed the crime? And what can that really mean? For the language of the criminal can contain only the goodness of the criminal's deed. The language of the criminal can explain and express the deed only from the criminal's point of view. It cannot explain the horror of the deed, the injustice of the deed, the agony, the humiliation inflicted on me.[5]

As there is no indigenous Antiguan language, she notes how the colonized Antiguans are forced to choose between silence or the language of criminality. As noted by academic Keith E. Byerman, Kincaid "chooses the latter by adopting a discourse of superiority and objectification. She merely reverses the direction of discursive power. Thus, she concedes herself caught in the prisonhouse of the colonizer's language."[5]

Part Three: In this section, Kincaid contemplates post-colonial Antigua. She discusses government corruption and focuses on the desire to repair the library. She also critiques the idea of a Minister of Culture. Kincaid also contends with slavery and its legacy in Antigua. She critiques the way people speak of and remember slavery and act as if emancipation undid all of the issues created by slavery. This section also explains the significance of the title: A Small Place. Kincaid explains that Antigua is a small place not only physically but in the sense that it is interconnected within the community. Despite being a small place, Antigua is subject to a lot of foreign investment and intervention which Kincaid critiques and ties to much of the corruption in post-colonial Antigua. She discusses the drug industry, Swiss banking, French governmental aid, Japanese car dealerships, and Syrian and Lebanese investors.

Part Four: The fourth section is quite short. In this section, Kincaid discusses the almost unnatural beauty of Antigua. She emphasises the idea that Antigua is a small place. She summarises the history of Antigua saying how it was discovered by Columbus in 1493 leading to colonisation and then eventually independence. She refers to the European people who settled in Antigua as "human rubbish from Europe". She also states how the real Antiguans are descendants of slaves (whom Kincaid refers to as "noble and exalted human beings").

Themes

[edit]

Tourism as a neo-colonial structure

[edit]

In the first section of A Small Place, Kincaid employs the perspective of the tourist in order to demonstrate the inherent escapism in creating a distance from the realities of a visited place. Nadine Dolby dissects the theme of tourism in A Small Place and places Kincaid's depiction of tourism in a globalised context that justifies Kincaid's strong feelings toward it.[6] Dolby corroborates Kincaid's depiction of the tourist creating separation by "othering" the locale and the individuals that inhabit it. Furthermore, the tourist industry is linked to a global economic system that ultimately does not translate into benefits for the very Antiguans who enable it.

The tourist may experience the beauty on the surface of Antigua while being wholly ignorant of the actual political and social conditions that the Antiguan tourism industry epitomises and reinforces.[7] Corinna McLeod points out the disenfranchising nature of the tourism industry in its reinforcement of an exploitative power structure. In effect, the industry recolonises Antigua by placing locals at a disenfranchised and subservient position in a global economic system that ultimately does not serve them.[8]

Racism and legacies of colonialism

[edit]

While Kincaid expresses anger towards slavery, colonialism and the broken Antiguan identity that it has left in its wake, she avoids retreating to simple racialization in order to explain the past and present, for doing so would further "other" an already marginalized group of people. Kincaid sheds light on the oppressive hierarchical structures of colonialism, which is still evident in the learned power structures of present-day, post-colonial Antigua.[7]

Poverty and Corruption

[edit]

One of the biggest critiques Kincaid makes about Antigua as an independent state is the corruption of the Antiguan Government. The withdrawal of European colonisation left Antigua in a state of poverty and corruption.[5] Kincaid's frustration with the Antiguan government was made clear throughout the novel, specifically when she referenced a library as a symbol of her perpetual resentment towards colonisation and decolonisation. Not only a symbol of Kincaid's perpetual resentment towards colonisation and decolonisation, but the library is arguably "the chief image of decline and corruption" for Kincaid. To her the island library was once a sacred space and a retreat away from the colonised world that plagued her homeland as a child. More importantly, the library acted as a sort of opening to the greater outside world away from the island.It was unfortunately destroyed by an earthquake in 1974, but after all these years has lacked any sort of reconstruction, only a sign posted that says "Repairs are Pending." This is likely because "the library provides the language and the texts by which Kincaid can learn how to attack the white world." Therefore Kincaid alludes to the reality that in the eyes of the corrupt government there should not exist any sort of tools, such as these library books, which could undermine their rule.[5]

In addition to this, Kincaid makes references towards illegal activities that the Antiguan Government was involved in such as drug smuggling, prostitution, and offshore bank accounts in Switzerland. In Kincaid's novel, poverty and corruption are seen as products of Europe's colonisation and decolonisation of Antigua.

According to academic Suzanne Gauch, while Kincaid acknowledges the racial justifications used by white colonists to institute oppressive policies during Antigua's colonial era, she also attempts to transcend the notions of an inescapable racialised past for Antigua. In doing so she attempts to shape readers' view of Antigua by creating a sense of agency.[7]

Critical reception

[edit]

Kincaid's work has received mixed reviews, both positive and negative.[9] Some of her overall reactions in the United States were characterised as immediate and enthusiastic.[9] The anger that people felt from her attacking nature in her reading simultaneously lent certain strength to her argument about the postcolonial condition of the Antiguan people by manifesting itself as an authentic and emotional account. She uses her anger about the situation as a way to definitively inform readers about the postcolonial Antiguan daily life. Being an enraged essay focusing on racism and the effects of colonialism, some people account for the most consistent and striking aspect of her work to be what critic Susan Sontag calls her "emotional truthfulness". Sontag describes Kincaid's writing as "poignant, but it's poignant because it's so truthful and it's so complicated. ... She doesn't treat these things in a sentimental or facile way."[10]

In 1988, A Small Place was criticised as a vitriolic attack on the government and people of Antigua.[11] New Yorker editor Robert Gottlieb refused to publish it. According to Jamaica Kincaid: Writing Memory, Writing Back to the Mother she was not only banned unofficially for five years from her home country, but she voiced concerns that had she gone back in that time, she worried she would be killed.[12]

Jane King, in A Small Place Writes Back, declared that "Kincaid does not like the Caribbean very much, finds it dull and boring and would rather live in Vermont. There can really be no difficulty with that, but I do not see why Caribbean people should admire her for denigrating our small place in this destructively angry fashion." Moira Ferguson, a feminist academic, argued that as "an African-Caribbean writer Kincaid speaks to and from the position of the other. Her characters are often maligned by history and subjected to a foreign culture, while Kincaid herself has become an increasingly mainstream American writer."[13]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

A Small Place

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
is a 1988 work of by Antiguan-American author , consisting of a book-length essay that appraises her native island of through a of , colonial legacies, and post-independence . The text, originally published by , employs a direct second-person address to immerse the reader alternately as an oblivious tourist and a disillusioned native, exposing the stark contrasts between the idyllic vacation facade and underlying socio-economic decay. Kincaid details 's history of British colonialism and slavery, which shaped its 10-by-12-mile landscape, and lambasts contemporary governance under leaders like Vere Bird for graft and neglect, including crumbling infrastructure and a library unrepaired since an earthquake. The essay's polemical tone has drawn acclaim for its unflinching candor in postcolonial discourse but also rebuke for its vituperative portrayal of Antiguans and perceived oversimplification of local agency. Central themes include as a form of neo-colonial exploitation, where visitors remain insulated from poverty and environmental degradation, and the persistent psychological scars of imperialism that hinder genuine independence. Kincaid's work underscores causal links between historical subjugation and modern dysfunction, privileging empirical observation of 's realities over sanitized narratives.

Author and Context

Jamaica Kincaid's Background and Motivations

Jamaica Kincaid, born Elaine Potter Richardson on May 25, 1949, in St. John's, Antigua, grew up amid the realities of British colonial rule in a family marked by economic hardship and strained relations. Her mother, literate and culturally engaged, taught her to read by age three and enrolled her in Moravian preschool before advancing to Princess Margaret School, where she pursued secondary education under the rigid British system. Kincaid's biological father, a carpenter, was absent from her life, having left her mother before her birth, which fostered dynamics dominated by her mother's authoritative presence and expectations. This upbringing instilled early familiarity with colonial hierarchies while highlighting personal familial tensions that later influenced her expatriate worldview. At age seventeen in 1966, Kincaid left for , dispatched by her mother to work as an amid financial pressures, a move that severed ongoing family contact and positioned her as a . She did not return until decades later, cultivating an outsider's detachment from Antiguan affairs while retaining intimate knowledge of its social fabric. In 1973, to shield her writing from familial interference—stemming from disapproval of her ambitions—she adopted the pen name , marking her entry into professional journalism. By 1974, she contributed pieces to 's "Talk of the Town" column, ascending to staff writer status in 1976, where her reportage honed a style blending personal insight with unflinching observation. Kincaid's drive to address Antigua critically stemmed from profound disillusionment with its post-1981 path, viewed from her U.S.-based vantage as a regression marked by entrenched and unaddressed colonial inheritances rather than promised . This afforded analytical distance, free from on-island conformities, allowing rejection of sanitized or touristic depictions in favor of grounded reckonings with observed failures. Her insider origins provided empirical depth, while outsider status enabled causal scrutiny unswayed by nostalgia or local partisanship, prioritizing verifiable societal trajectories over idealized self-conceptions.

Historical Setting in Post-Independence Antigua

attained independence from the on November 1, 1981, as a within the , with Vere C. Bird Sr. of the Antigua Labour Party (ALP) sworn in as the first prime minister. The ALP, formed by Bird in the from labor union roots, secured a in the preceding elections, reflecting widespread support for self-rule after decades of colonial administration centered on plantations and limited local governance. Initial post-independence optimism centered on economic diversification and political autonomy, though the nation retained British-influenced institutions like the Westminster . The underwent a rapid transition from agriculture-dominated production to service-oriented sectors, with emerging as the dominant driver by the mid-1980s, contributing directly or indirectly to more than half of GDP and serving as the primary source of . in hotels, resorts, and fueled early GDP expansion, as the promoted the islands' beaches and climate to international visitors, marking a departure from the declining that had defined the colonial era. This shift aligned with broader trends post-decolonization, where small island states leveraged natural assets for export services amid challenges in industrializing or sustaining . Under Bird's prolonged rule, which extended through multiple terms until 1994, governance faced mounting scrutiny for and within the ruling family, with allegations surfacing by the mid-1980s involving arms and smuggling operations. A pivotal 1990 scandal implicated Bird's son, Vere Jr., in facilitating the sale of Israeli weapons to Colombian cartels, triggering international investigations and domestic protests that highlighted entrenched networks and misuse of public funds. These issues exacerbated fiscal strains, contributing to uneven public investment despite revenues, as family members held key positions in and state enterprises. In the wider decolonization context, grappled with inherited institutional dependencies on British legal and administrative frameworks, which initially supported stability but hindered adaptation to local needs, fostering economic disparities between tourism enclaves and underserved communities. Early growth masked vulnerabilities like overreliance on volatile visitor inflows and limited diversification, leading to fading post- enthusiasm as inequalities persisted amid lapses.

Publication and Form

Writing Process and Initial Reception Challenges

composed A Small Place during the mid-1980s, building on her established reputation after the 1985 release of her novel . The manuscript, an unconventional 81-page blend of and memoir eschewing traditional narrative structures, was first offered to , where Kincaid had contributed since 1974, but editor Richard Gottlieb declined it in the 1980s for its overtly angry tone. ultimately published the work in May 1988 as a standalone , reflecting Kincaid's aim to confront readers directly with unfiltered observations on Antiguan life, a process she later described as clarifying her political views. Upon release, A Small Place sparked immediate backlash in , where officials from the ruling Antigua Labour Party condemned it as vile and contemptuous toward the nation, prompting Kincaid to deem it unsafe to visit the island for a period afterward. communities and local patriots echoed these sentiments, decrying the text as unpatriotic for its stark depictions of governmental corruption and societal flaws. In contrast, U.S. literary reviewers lauded its bold, unflinching voice, appreciating the essay's raw critique amid Kincaid's rising profile in American publishing circles.

Structure and Stylistic Features

A Small Place is structured as four untitled sections that unfold in a progressive manner, beginning with an immersive depiction of the tourist experience and advancing toward broader historical introspection, thereby building rhetorical intensity through accumulation rather than linear plot. This division eschews conventional chapter headings or numerical markers, fostering a seamless, essayistic flow that mirrors the island's interconnected social layers while compelling readers to navigate the text as an unbroken confrontation. The absence of formal breaks enhances the work's disorienting effect, drawing the audience into an experiential mimicry of arrival and disillusionment without signaling shifts explicitly. Central to its stylistic approach is the extensive use of second-person narration, particularly in the opening section, where the pronoun "you" directly positions the reader as the oblivious visitor, implicating them in the privileges and blind spots of outsider observation. This technique generates rhetorical power by transforming passive consumption into active complicity, forcing confrontation with unexamined assumptions through imperative address and vivid sensory immersion. Subsequent sections shift to first-person reflections, creating a tension that evolves from accusatory distance to intimate revelation, thereby amplifying the text's persuasive force without relying on detached objectivity. Kincaid employs a stream-of-consciousness-like prose rhythm, marked by repetition of phrases and motifs to underscore emotional resonances and ironic reversals, which defies standard nonfiction's preference for chronological or analytical progression. Her tone interweaves —evident in poetic descriptions of landscape and memory—with biting , blending controlled rage against systemic inequities with evocative beauty to evoke a visceral, non-rational truth that prioritizes affective impact over empirical detachment. This stylistic fusion, characterized by short, incantatory sentences and rhetorical questions, subverts expectations of balanced reportage, instead cultivating a urgency that embeds within the form itself. The work's hybrid genre as a "creative nonfiction novella" challenges boundaries between , , and , at roughly 81 pages blending autobiographical elements with speculative intensity to privilege subjective veracity over verifiable chronicle. This form resists classification as mere travelogue or , employing novelistic compression and emotional layering to render abstract colonial dynamics palpably immediate, thus enhancing its capacity to provoke without adhering to documentary constraints. By foregrounding stylistic innovation over generic fidelity, A Small Place achieves a rhetorical efficacy rooted in its refusal of conventional .

Core Content Summary

The Tourist's Perspective and Illusion

In the opening section of A Small Place, directly addresses the reader as a white tourist arriving by in , portraying the initial aerial view as one of overwhelming natural splendor—emerald hills, azure seas, and white beaches—that induces a perceptual blindness to the island's socioeconomic decay. This illusion persists upon landing, where the tourist encounters beggars pleading for money and ramshackle shantytowns clustered near luxury resorts, yet reframes these as incidental "exotic" features enhancing the vacation fantasy rather than indicators of entrenched and . emphasizes how the vacationer's —predicated on temporary escape—filters out these realities, allowing the visitor to "not see" the desperation amid the paradise. Sensory details amplify this distorted perspective: the blistering sun blinds the eyes, the humid heat saps awareness, and chaotic traffic of overloaded minibuses swerves unpredictably, yet the tourist remains insulated, focused on personal comfort rather than the surrounding disorder. Kincaid highlights the irony of the tourist's pale skin, which stands out starkly against the local population, marking them as an object of and economic exploitation, though the visitor perceives no such dynamic and instead feels entitled to the island's offerings. This obliviousness, Kincaid asserts, renders the tourist "ugly," complicit in a that consumes beauty while disregarding the human cost borne by Antiguans. By inverting the traditional tourist narrative, Kincaid forces the reader into self-confrontation, dismantling the illusion of innocent leisure and exposing how it perpetuates a one-sided encounter that prioritizes fantasy over factual engagement with the locale. This setup establishes the tourist's viewpoint as inherently superficial, primed for contrast with the author's ensuing insider critique, without delving into systemic economic dependencies.

Insider View of Antiguan Society

In A Small Place, depicts Antiguan daily life as riddled with hypocrisies, where political elites flaunt imported luxury cars and sprawling villas while ordinary residents face chronic shortages of potable water—sometimes lasting months—and dilapidated schools lacking basic supplies or qualified teachers. She illustrates this through the visible extravagance of ministers, who amass via contracts and offshore dealings, contrasting sharply with the public's reliance on inconsistent services, such as hospitals without medicines or functional equipment. These dysfunctions manifest in everyday routines: drivers navigate pothole-riddled roads funded poorly despite tourism revenues, and families endure power outages amid elite-hosted galas. Kincaid attributes Antiguans' tolerance of such disparities to a cultural resignation post-independence in 1981, where communal solidarity has yielded to veneration of foreign affluence—evident in the pursuit of American visas or European goods—and a normalization of graft as inherent to leadership. Citizens, she argues, admire politicians for redistributing pilfered funds through sporadic handouts or jobs, fostering a mindset that equates power with unchecked enrichment rather than accountability, eroding pre-independence mutual aid networks. This acceptance perpetuates cycles of underdevelopment, as public outrage remains muted despite tangible hardships like contaminated water sources or overcrowded classrooms. Social fissures compound these issues, with Kincaid recounting anecdotes of inverted : locals express blanket disdain for whites as historical oppressors yet covet their lifestyles, flocking to emulate "white" while resenting actual expatriates for perceived arrogance. Internally, divisions persist along class lines and skin color gradients, where lighter-complexioned Antiguans—often of mixed heritage—command social prestige and better opportunities, mirroring colonial hierarchies and fueling or that undermines against elite abuses. These dynamics, Kincaid observes, play out in mundane interactions, such as preferential treatment in hiring or social gatherings, reinforcing inequality without overt confrontation.

Personal Reflections on History and Change

In A Small Place, contrasts her childhood under British colonial rule with her adult returns to after in 1981, highlighting a loss of innocence in her perception of the island's evolution. As a child, she viewed colonial through a lens of relative order and access to enriching institutions, such as the in St. John's, described as a grand edifice with wooden tables, chairs, and breezy open windows that nurtured her early love of reading. This , a remnant of , offered a amid the broader exploitation of and that defined the island's history under British control for over 300 years. Kincaid's reflections reveal an : while critiquing colonialism's dehumanizing legacy, she acknowledges certain infrastructural and cultural benefits, like superior educational resources compared to the post-independence era. Upon revisiting , Kincaid observes the physical and symbolic decay of these landmarks, particularly the 's destruction in the 1974 earthquake, which left it in ruins with only a stalled reconstruction sign as evidence of governmental inaction. Over a decade later, the facility remains relocated to a dilapidated with neglected books, exemplifying post-independence and a disregard for public and heritage preservation. She attributes this neglect to Antiguan leaders who, rather than dismantling colonial oppression, mimic its authoritarian structures, amassing power through and foreign alliances while suppressing . Kincaid further notes enduring British cultural influences, such as the pervasive worship of , which she portrays as diverting officials—including the Minister of , who doubles as Minister of Culture—from addressing societal needs like library repairs. This fixation underscores the superficial nature of celebrations in , where political rhetoric masked continuity in exploitation and cultural , evoking her profound over erased historical sites as emblems of collective amnesia and stalled progress. Through these musings, Kincaid links personal memory to broader societal stagnation, arguing that Antiguans' inability to confront their perpetuates cycles of dependency akin to slavery's aftermath.

Central Arguments and Themes

Tourism's Economic Role and Critiques

In A Small Place, critiques tourism as a exploitative enterprise that treats Antigua's landscapes and people as commodities for transient pleasure, likening tourists to modern colonizers who remain oblivious to the underlying costs. She highlights how luxury resorts encroach on local , often displacing communities and fisheries, while offering primarily seasonal, low-skilled jobs that perpetuate economic vulnerability for Antiguans amid high outside peak seasons. Empirical assessments counter this by underscoring tourism's dominant economic function in 1980s , where it generated the bulk of foreign exchange earnings and contributed an estimated 60% to GDP when accounting for direct and indirect effects such as and services. The sector drove measurable expansion, with stopover visitor numbers rising by 16.2% in one year, 25.2% in the next, and 7% thereafter in the mid-1980s, alongside average annual cruise-ship arrival growth of 12.5% since 1970, which financed like expansions and networks essential for national development. Sustainability debates reveal trade-offs, with tourism-linked environmental strains—including , damage from , and freshwater depletion for hotels—threatening ecological bases like beaches that underpin the industry itself. Nonetheless, the sector's job creation, employing over half the workforce by decade's end, demonstrably reduced in a resource-scarce where alternatives like yielded due to limitations and barriers, aligning with Antiguan policymakers' deliberate emphasis on as a viable path to growth over uncertain diversification efforts.

Governance, Corruption, and Public Life

In A Small Place, Jamaica Kincaid levels pointed accusations against the administration of Prime Minister Vere C. Bird, portraying it as emblematic of entrenched graft where political elites siphon public funds through embezzlement and opaque dealings. She highlights the V. C. Bird International Airport, funded by Japanese aid in the mid-1980s, as a case where construction profits were allegedly diverted to ministers' pockets rather than public benefit, contributing to the 1987 runway extension scandal investigated by Sir Louis Blom-Cooper's Nedd Commission, which uncovered irregularities in contract awards and financial oversight. Kincaid contends that such corruption extends to ties with drug traffickers, reflecting broader regional scandals involving arms and narcotics smuggling under the Bird regime during the 1980s, though these claims drew from public whispers rather than formal convictions at the time of her writing. Kincaid emphasizes the impunity enabled by patronage networks, noting that Antiguans widely knew of ministers' theft—such as personal enrichment from state contracts—yet refrained from demanding accountability, perpetuating a cycle where loyalty to the Bird family trumped reform. This dynamic, she argues, stems from post-independence electoral choices favoring familiar leaders over systemic change, rather than inescapable colonial inheritance, as voters repeatedly returned the Antigua Labour Party to power despite evident self-dealing. Empirical records substantiate elements of her critique: by the late 1980s, the regime faced multiple probes, including misuse of a $25,000 health fund by Bird himself in 1992 (echoing earlier patterns), yet public tolerance persisted due to the family's foundational role in independence. The fallout manifests in degraded public services, which Kincaid details as direct consequences of misallocated resources: hospitals in disrepair with leaking roofs and inadequate supplies, streets clogged with uncollected garbage fostering disease, and an system mired in rote memorization of British imperial over vocational or critical skills, leaving graduates ill-equipped for local realities. These conditions, observable in 1980s , arose not from fiscal constraint alone—given tourism revenues—but from prioritizing private gain, underscoring Kincaid's view of as a deliberate societal failing amenable to agency rather than fate.

Colonial Legacies Versus Local Agency

In A Small Place, portrays colonial legacies in as deeply entrenched psychological and institutional barriers, including a lingering to white figures and a commodified sense of identity rooted in the and economies established under British rule from 1632 onward. She argues that these forces perpetuate adversarial and cultural inertia, framing post-colonial society as trapped in cycles of dependency that hinder authentic . However, empirical evidence underscores significant local agency exercised by Antiguans since on November 1, , when the nation transitioned to with free elections under a Westminster-style . Subsequent governments, including the long-dominant Antigua Labour Party, have pursued policies such as expanding —which grew to constitute over 60% of GDP by the 2000s—and introducing the Citizenship by Investment program in 2013 to diversify revenue and attract foreign capital, demonstrating proactive economic choices amid global market opportunities. These initiatives reflect deliberate prioritization of self-interested development over perpetual blame attribution to historical grievances, with real GDP per capita rising from approximately $2,500 in to over $17,000 by 2023 in nominal terms. Colonial inheritance also provided tangible infrastructural and institutional foundations that enabled such agency, including facilitating , established port facilities from the 18th-century strategic role as a British , and legal frameworks supporting property rights and contract enforcement. Cross-regional data from former British colonies in the and beyond indicate that longer exposure to British rule correlates with higher post-independence income and lower rates, attributable to transmitted norms like impartial and anti-corruption mechanisms, as opposed to total rejection of these elements. Comparative cases of self-improvement in other ex-colonies further highlight the primacy of local decisions: , another former British sugar island, achieved upper-middle-income status by leveraging inherited parliamentary stability and systems to build a diversified services , with HDI scores consistently above regional averages since in 1966. Similarly, Antigua's avoidance of the coups and civil strife seen in some French or Spanish counterparts post-decolonization points to causal efficacy of retained British-derived electoral accountability in fostering incremental progress, rather than inescapable victimhood. While Kincaid's critique validly identifies persistent challenges like , these are better explained by post-1981 governance choices—such as tolerance of in public contracts—than immutable colonial determinism.

Evaluations and Debates

Positive Assessments of Kincaid's Insights

Critics have praised Jamaica Kincaid's A Small Place (1988) for its unflinching honesty in dissecting the hypocrisies of and postcolonial governance in , highlighting the book's role in exposing the disconnect between idyllic tourist perceptions and local realities. Literary scholars commend Kincaid's vivid, second-person prose for reversing the colonial gaze, compelling Western readers to confront their own complicity in neocolonial exploitation rather than viewing the island as an exotic backdrop. This technique echoes Edward Said's critique of by turning the scrutinizing eye back on the observer, fostering a deeper understanding of power imbalances in small island nations. The work's literary merit lies in its concise yet incisive structure, which blends personal essay with to illuminate vulnerabilities inherent to postcolonial economies reliant on , prompting readers to question sanitized narratives propagated by travel industries. In postcolonial studies, A Small Place is valued for challenging the erasure of local agency under lingering colonial legacies, influencing analyses of how perpetuates economic dependency and cultural distortion. Its inclusion in key anthologies underscores this impact, positioning Kincaid's insights as a counter-discourse to dominant Western representations of the . Contemporary reviews in 1988 affirmed the book's "fierce intelligence" in portraying Antigua's social ills without romanticization, with Michiko Kakutani noting its effective nonfiction portrait of a "damaged paradise" marred by corruption and neglect. Kincaid's critiques of governmental graft gained retrospective validation through scandals like the 1990 arms deal involving Prime Minister Vere Bird's family, which exposed arms smuggling and financial improprieties, confirming patterns of elite corruption she described. These events underscored the prescience of her warnings about public complacency toward malfeasance, enhancing the essay's credibility in highlighting small-nation susceptibilities to unchecked power.

Criticisms of Tone, Accuracy, and Omissions

Critics have faulted Kincaid's tone in A Small Place for its unrelenting bitterness and polemicism, which some reviewers described as patronizing toward both and fellow Antiguans, prioritizing over nuanced analysis. This approach, while evoking strong emotional responses, has been seen as overshadowing Antigua's socioeconomic advancements, such as the expansion of -driven employment that absorbed a significant portion of the labor force in services during the mid-1980s. The book's emphasis on systemic rot neglects how , as the dominant sector, fueled annual GDP growth averaging around 6-7% from the early to late 1980s, contributing to resilience amid post-independence challenges. Debates over accuracy center on Kincaid's portrayal of pervasive corruption as a blanket condition afflicting all public life, which detractors argue inflates elite-level graft into a caricature of universal Antiguan complicity, ignoring evidence of localized issues rather than wholesale societal decay. Local voices, including some Antiguan commentators, have dismissed such depictions as expatriate exaggeration, contending that Kincaid's distance from daily island realities led to slanderous overgeneralizations that unfairly tarnish national character without firsthand accountability. Omissions of quantifiable progress exacerbate this selectivity; for instance, Antigua's GDP rose from approximately $1,860 in to over $4,800 by 1988, reflecting tourism's role in elevating living standards through job opportunities in and related trades, metrics absent from Kincaid's narrative. From a perspective emphasizing personal agency over , certain critiques liken the book's worldview to fostering a dependency mindset, where colonial legacies and external blame supplant incentives for local and , potentially mirroring critiques of aid-driven stagnation in other contexts. This omission of Antiguan adaptability—evident in the sector's absorption of workers into expanding tourist —underscores a selective lens that privileges narratives, sidelining empirical indicators of post-1978 gains like diversified service .

Broader Interpretations in Postcolonial Discourse

In postcolonial , A Small Place is often positioned as a subversive inversion of the imperial , where Kincaid employs direct to tourists—predominantly from former colonial powers—to expose neocolonial continuities in tourism's economic exploitation of . This framework draws on concepts like Homi Bhabha's and Edward Said's , framing the text as that disrupts Western narratives of paradise by revealing infrastructure decay and cultural commodification as extensions of historical domination. Such interpretations emphasize Kincaid's role in deconstructing hybrid postcolonial identities, where Antiguans navigate essentialized local authenticity against imposed global . Critiques within and beyond these readings, however, highlight an overreliance on colonial legacies as explanatory, sidelining of endogenous failures that postcolonial theory sometimes attributes primarily to external structures. For instance, and Barbuda's persistent challenges, reflected in its 2023 score of 44 out of 100—indicating moderate-to-high perceived public sector comparable to other small developing states like (44) and (42)—suggest causal factors rooted in post-independence political and weak institutions rather than solely imperial residue. Academic postcolonial discourse, prevalent in Western institutions with documented left-leaning biases favoring systemic victimhood narratives, may thus underplay local agency deficits, as seen in 's repeated scandals involving elite embezzlement since independence in 1981, which predate and outlast direct colonial oversight. This contrasts with skeptical Caribbean voices like , whose The Middle Passage (1962) attributes regional stagnation to cultural and vacuums post-emancipation, urging causal realism over perpetual framing—a perspective echoed in debates on versus , where Kincaid's unyielding Antiguan particularism resists fluid identity models but risks essentializing local flaws as imported rather than homegrown. These broader interpretations thus invite scrutiny of postcolonial lenses' empirical robustness, testing Kincaid's claims against data like declining public service quality metrics—Antigua's water infrastructure failures, for example, stem from mismanaged in the 1980s onward, not unbroken colonial . While affirming the text's critique of as neocolonial extraction, truth-seeking analyses prioritize disaggregating verifiable local causal chains, such as electoral under the Antigua Labour Party's long dominance, from broader imperial histories to avoid conflation that obscures reform pathways.

Reception and Legacy

Contemporary Reviews and Controversies

Upon its publication in May 1988 by , A Small Place elicited mixed responses in the United States, with reviewers praising Kincaid's unflinching candor while critiquing the work's acerbic tone. Robert Garis, in a New York Times Book Review assessment on July 17, 1988, characterized the essay as "an enraged essay about and in ," noting its rhetorical force but highlighting its unrelenting bitterness as potentially alienating. Similarly, other critics admired the essay's clarity and jeremiadic power in exposing postcolonial inequities, yet faulted its one-sided for lacking nuance in portraying Antiguan society. In , the book provoked immediate backlash from government officials and locals, who dismissed its nonfiction claims as exaggerated or fictional distortions of island life. The administration under derided the work as "vile and contemptuous," reflecting broader resentment toward Kincaid's portrayal of systemic and cultural stagnation. Reports indicate the government effectively restricted its circulation, contributing to perceptions of informal amid fears of external critique undermining national pride. The essay's familial metaphors—likening Antigua to a —intensified personal controversies, amplifying Kincaid's existing estrangement from her mother and siblings, which had deepened after her literary success and relocation to the in 1969. Critics debated the legitimacy of authors like Kincaid critiquing their homeland from abroad, arguing such positions privileged detached outrage over lived accountability. Defenders countered that her vantage enabled uncompromised truth-telling, essential to countering in small, politically insular societies where risks reprisal. This tension underscored broader discussions on voices in , with some viewing Kincaid's polemic as a vital antidote to sanitized narratives of .

Long-Term Influence and Adaptations

A Small Place has been incorporated into academic curricula focused on and critiques of travel writing, where it serves as a key text for examining hybrid genres and the inversion of tourist gazes. Scholars and educators highlight its pedagogical value in prompting discussions on colonial legacies and neocolonial economic structures, often pairing it with theoretical works on . In 2018, the book received a theatrical adaptation at London's Gate Theatre, directed by Matthew Xia and adapted by Anna Himali Howard and Season Butler, with performances running from November 8 to December 1. The production transformed Kincaid's essayistic into a by Nicola Alexis, emphasizing themes of racial inequality and colonial aftermath through direct and physical staging. Critics noted its bold translation of the text's rage into live polemical theatre, resonating with contemporary debates on exploitation in global . The work's critique of as a perpetuation of unequal global power dynamics has informed subsequent Caribbean literary explorations of experiences and economic inequities. It contributes to broader postcolonial discourse by modeling resistance narratives that challenge enclave models, influencing analyses of how reinforces historical dependencies in small island economies. Ongoing scholarly engagement debates the text's enduring prescience in highlighting structural tourism flaws against perceptions of its intense, era-specific anger, particularly as digital platforms now amplify similar local critiques of visitor impacts. While some view its unyielding tone as potentially limiting broader dialogue, others affirm its foundational role in ecocritical and studies of postcolonial spaces.

Empirical Outcomes in Antigua Since 1988

Vere Bird's administration continued to govern until the 1994 general election, marked by persistent corruption scandals including arms diversion and family-linked improprieties that prompted investigations but did not immediately end the Bird family's dominance. The Antigua Labour Party (ALP), under Bird's son , secured victory in March 1994, extending familial control until 2004, though subsequent governments faced similar governance critiques. Tourism expanded significantly post-1994, becoming the dominant economic driver and contributing over 50% to GDP by the , with direct and indirect effects nearing 60% in recent assessments. This sector fueled average annual GDP growth of around 3-4% in expansionary periods, such as 8.5% in one post-recession year, though volatility persisted due to external shocks. Natural disasters and global downturns highlighted tourism's vulnerabilities, as Kincaid implied in critiques of overreliance. Hurricane Luis in September 1995, a Category 4 storm, inflicted Antigua's costliest damage to date, destroying half of homes, disrupting and , and causing two deaths while overwhelming health facilities. The 2009 triggered Antigua's deepest contraction in decades, with tourism arrivals plummeting, tax revenues falling 20%, and widespread redundancies in a workforce of about 30,000. Corruption allegations endured into recent years, validating concerns of entrenched issues, including a 2025 vehicle involving unauthorized deals and public fund misuse, prompting calls for across administrations. However, policy adaptations like the 2013 citizenship-by-investment program generated record revenues, such as $63 million in the first half of 2024 alone, supplementing and funding . Poverty rates, estimated above 18% in some assessments from the onward, have stabilized around 12% in high-income classifications, reflecting -led income gains despite uneven distribution, with indigence nearing negligible levels through service-sector expansion. Efforts at diversification, including initiatives, medicinal legalization, and promotion, indicate local agency in mitigating dependency, though remains central. Empirical trends thus partially affirm warnings of stasis and fragility under tourism-led models, as shocks repeatedly exposed fiscal strains and eroded trust, yet overlook adaptive measures yielding sustained GDP rises to over $23,000 by 2024 and revenue streams like citizenship programs that enabled recovery without evident collapse. This suggests causal factors like market incentives and policy drove resilience beyond deterministic colonial inertia.

References

  1. https://us.macmillan.com/books/9780374527075/asmallplace/
  2. https://www.supersummary.com/a-small-place/summary/
  3. https://www.amazon.com/Small-Place-Jamaica-Kincaid/dp/0374527075
  4. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-small-place/summary
  5. https://scholarblogs.emory.edu/postcolonialstudies/2014/06/10/kincaid-jamaica/
  6. https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/smallplace/themes/
  7. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-small-place/themes/slavery-colonialism-and-independence
  8. https://bluemarblereview.com/a-small-place/
  9. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Jamaica-Kincaid
  10. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/literature-and-writing/jamaica-kincaid
  11. https://jwa.org/encyclopedia/article/kincaid-jamaica
  12. https://ablpantigua.com/our-history/
  13. https://2009-2017.state.gov/outofdate/bgn/antigua/106983.htm
  14. https://www.theguardian.com/news/1999/jun/30/guardianobituaries
  15. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-18706079
  16. https://hrlibrary.umn.edu/iwraw/publications/countries/antigua_and_barbuda.htm
  17. https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/2007/043/article-A001-en.xml
  18. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1990-07-16-mn-115-story.html
  19. https://www.nytimes.com/1990/06/16/world/island-s-hushed-scandals-unhushed.html
  20. https://tile.loc.gov/storage-services/service/ll/llglrd/2018298888/2018298888.pdf
  21. https://newworldjournal.org/independence/the-social-legacy-of-british-colonialism-in-the-caribbean/
  22. https://library.oapen.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.12657/34557/408881.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
  23. https://journals.openedition.org/esa/1236
  24. https://wereadjamaicakincaid.substack.com/p/a-small-place
  25. https://www.assayjournal.com/meghan-buckley-creative-nonfiction-novella-teaching-postcolonial-life-writing-and-the-8203hybrid-genre-of-jamaica-kincaidrsquos-a-small-place-51.html
  26. https://lucywritersplatform.com/2019/04/22/jamaica-kincaid-a-small-place-and-surpassing-small-minds/
  27. https://www.facebook.com/groups/269202760462518/posts/1387289301987186/
  28. https://www.theguardian.com/stage/2018/nov/14/a-small-place-review-gate-theatre-jamaica-kincaid
  29. https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/smallplace/summary/
  30. https://www.coursehero.com/lit/A-Small-Place/section-1-summary/
  31. https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/a-small-place/literary-devices.html
  32. https://www.shmoop.com/study-guides/a-small-place/narrator-point-of-view.html
  33. https://www.coursehero.com/lit/A-Small-Place/
  34. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-small-place/characters/jamaica-kincaid
  35. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3300123
  36. https://www.sparknotes.com/lit/smallplace/literary-devices/
  37. https://literariness.org/2020/05/26/analysis-of-jamaica-kincaids-stories/
  38. https://www.assayjournal.com/51-pedagogy.html
  39. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-small-place/chapter-1
  40. https://www.gradesaver.com/a-small-place/study-guide/summary-section-i
  41. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-small-place/themes/rot-and-corruption
  42. https://www.cliffsnotes.com/study-notes/6252907
  43. https://www.coursehero.com/lit/A-Small-Place/section-3-summary/
  44. https://www.gradesaver.com/a-small-place/study-guide/summary
  45. https://ijrpr.com/uploads/V3ISSUE10/IJRPR7583.pdf
  46. https://bkbcollege.in/upload/dpt_book/1669364755.pdf
  47. https://www.litcharts.com/lit/a-small-place/symbols/library
  48. https://www.supersummary.com/a-small-place/pages-41-52-summary/
  49. https://u.osu.edu/introhumanitiesonline/2020/04/27/a-small-place-by-jamaica-kincaid/
  50. https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/352471468009622886/pdf/multi0page.pdf
  51. https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/001/1988/083/article-A001-en.xml
  52. https://ageconsearch.umn.edu/record/11913/files/sp5.pdf
  53. https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/ft/scr/1998/cr9807.pdf
  54. https://countrystudies.us/caribbean-islands/97.htm
  55. https://brill.com/view/journals/nwig/97/3-4/article-p289_3.xml
  56. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-07-05-mn-2688-story.html
  57. https://www.the-independent.com/arts-entertainment/obituary-vere-bird-1103314.html
  58. http://sites.cortland.edu/wagadu/wp-content/uploads/sites/3/2018/07/v19-Boyce-Davies.pdf
  59. https://www.constituteproject.org/constitution/Antigua_and_Barbuda_1981
  60. https://cip.gov.ag/
  61. https://antigua-barbuda.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Prime-Minister-Gaston-Browne-Independence-2018-Message.pdf
  62. https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w12546/w12546.pdf
  63. https://www.nytimes.com/1988/07/16/books/books-of-the-times-portrait-of-antigua-warts-and-all.html
  64. https://nalans.com/index.php/nalans/article/view/64
  65. http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/record.jsf?pid=diva2:824018
  66. https://www.jstor.org/stable/41412504
  67. https://archive.org/details/postcolonialstud0000unse_q6m8
  68. https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1990/06/12/arms-scandal-hits-antiguas-ruling-clan/73f82663-4a8f-4cb3-85b7-40f8cb0b8a79/
  69. https://repozytorium.uni.wroc.pl/Content/131436/PDF/Ways_of_Knowing_Small_Places_D_Ferens.pdf
  70. https://www.ijitee.org/wp-content/uploads/papers/v8i7c/G10450587C19.pdf
  71. http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:824018/FULLTEXT01.pdf
  72. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD?locations=AG
  73. https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countries/atg/antigua-and-barbuda/gdp-gross-domestic-product
  74. https://awej-tls.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/10.pdf
  75. https://www.humapub.com/admin/alljournals/gssr/papers/db9xuoMlKH.pdf
  76. https://www.transparency.org/en/countries/antigua-and-barbuda
  77. https://www.academia.edu/144047527/Cities_in_Caribbean_Literature_a_study_of_V_S_Naipaul_s_Miguel_Street_and_Jamaica_Kincaid_s_A_Small_Place
  78. https://www.nytimes.com/books/97/10/19/home/kincaid-eyes.html
  79. https://thetyee.ca/Life/2004/03/15/In_Antigua_the_Troubled_Canuck/
  80. https://e-conf.usd.ac.id/index.php/lsc/lsc10/paper/download/1440/261
  81. https://www.jstor.org/stable/25112166
  82. https://themountaintopuu.org/day-20-jamaica-kincaid-sharing-words-rooted-in-home-and-exile/
  83. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/388034603_Not_Merely_a_Tourist_Site_Jamaica_Kincaid%27s_Evocation_of_Antigua_in_A_Small_Place
  84. https://bartyed.com/blog/ask-the-expert-tutor-a-small-place-ib
  85. https://exeuntmagazine.com/reviews/review-small-place-gate-theatre/
  86. https://www.thetimes.com/culture/theatre-dance/article/review-a-small-place-at-the-gate-theatre-w11-22r905w95
  87. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/256986999_Culture_and_postcolonial_resistance_Antigua_in_Kincaid%27s_A_Small_Place
  88. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2158244021997419
  89. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-03-05-mn-30146-story.html
  90. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1994-03-09-mn-31982-story.html
  91. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/3563709.stm
  92. https://www.economy.com/antigua-and-barbuda/indicators
  93. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG?locations=AG
  94. https://antiguaobserver.com/remembering-hurricane-luis/
  95. https://www.nhc.noaa.gov/data/tcr/AL131995_Luis.pdf
  96. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9170235/
  97. https://www.elibrary.imf.org/view/journals/002/2010/279/article-A001-en.xml
  98. https://www.bbc.co.uk/caribbean/news/story/2009/06/090601_caribbeanrecession.shtml
  99. https://antiguaobserver.com/major-scandal-rocks-govt-funds-recovery-and-accountability-demanded-over-unauthorized-vehicle-deals/
  100. https://antigua.news/2025/10/22/symister-calls-on-the-people-to-stand-up-following-vehicle-scandal/
  101. https://www.imidaily.com/intelligence/all-time-high-antigua-barbuda-cbi-application-volume-up-205-year-on-year-in-h1-2024/
  102. https://sk.sagepub.com/ency/edvol/worldpoverty/chpt/antigua-barbuda
  103. https://thecommonwealth.org/publications/rapid-readiness-assessment-transition-sustainable-blue-economy-pilot-project-antigua-and-barbuda/blue-economy-context-antigua-and-barbuda
  104. https://caribbeannewsglobal.com/antigua-barbuda-to-prioritise-economic-diversification/
  105. https://www.state.gov/reports/2024-investment-climate-statements/antigua-and-barbuda
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.