Hubbry Logo
Doctor ThorneDoctor ThorneMain
Open search
Doctor Thorne
Community hub
Doctor Thorne
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Doctor Thorne
Doctor Thorne
Doctor Thorne
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Doctor Thorne is a novel by the English author Anthony Trollope, published in 1858. It is the third book in his Chronicles of Barsetshire series, between Barchester Towers and Framley Parsonage. The idea of the plot was suggested to Trollope by his brother Thomas.[1] Michael Sadleir places it as one of the five best of Trollope's novels and the best of the Barsetshire novels.[2]

Key Information

The novel is set in Greshamsbury, a village fifteen miles from the town of Barchester. Most of the narrative revolves round the three families of Gresham, Thorne and Scatcherd. The Greshams are commoners, but an old and respected family, based at Greshamsbury Hall and headed by Francis Newbold Gresham. His wife, Lady Arabella, is sister of the Earl de Courcy. Doctor Thorne lives in the village with his niece Mary. He and Gresham have become friends and he has helped Gresham by negotiating loans, mostly from Sir Roger Scatcherd, originally a stonemason in Barchester who has become wealthy and has purchased a large property between Greshamsbury and Barchester.

Plot summary

[edit]

When their father dies, Doctor Thomas Thorne and his younger brother Henry are left to provide for themselves. Thomas begins to establish a medical practice, while Henry seduces Mary Scatcherd, the sister of stonemason Roger Scatcherd. When Roger finds out that Mary has become pregnant, he decides to give Henry a thrashing, but Henry dies from a blow to the head. While her brother is in prison for the death, Mary gives birth to a girl. A former suitor offers to marry Mary and emigrate to America to start a new life, but not if she keeps the baby. Doctor Thorne persuades Mary to accept the offer and she tells Roger that the baby has died. Thorne promises to raise his niece, naming her Mary Thorne, but keeps her parentage secret, and arranges for her to be looked after on a nearby farm and later to attend a boarding school.

The doctor had visited Scatcherd in prison and they became friends. Scatcherd accepted the doctor's financial advice and continued to do so in later life. After prison, Scatcherd rises quickly in the world through his competence in railway contracts. When Thorne became the Greshams' family doctor he also became advisor to Frank Gresham. About this time an heir had been born at Greshamsbury Hall, but Lady Arabella was at some loss as to dealing with the infant. Thorne knew that Mrs Scatcherd had been left high and dry by her husband's imprisonment and readily adopted the role of nurse to young Frank.

Meanwhile, time has passed and 12 year old Mary came to Greshamsbury from her school in Bath. Quite soon she is invited to music lessons and gradually becomes as an extra sister to the children at the big house. Dr Thorne feels he has to inform Frank Gresham, in strictest confidence, of Mary's background to allow him to decide if there may be an objection to her associating with his family. She has neither family nor money which gives Lady Arabella some qualms but the Squire overrules her. However, unknown to nearly everyone, Mary's maternal uncle, Roger Scatcherd, has risen from humble beginnings to great wealth. Thorne persuades Scatcherd to lend increasing sums to the head of the family, the local squire. Eventually, much of the Gresham estate is put up as collateral for these loans.

As young adults, Mary and Frank Gresham – the only son and heir of the squire of Greshamsbury – fall in love. However, his parents need him to marry wealth; the squire has squandered much money on expensive and fruitless campaigns for a seat in Parliament and is grieved that he can leave little to his son. As Mary is penniless and of suspect birth, such a marriage is inconceivable to his mother and to her relatives, the aristocratic de Courcys. They wish Frank to marry the eccentric 30-year-old heiress Martha Dunstable instead. Frank reluctantly visits Courcy Castle in order to meet Miss Dunstable, and they become friends. He foolishly and playfully proposes, but she wisely demurs, knowing that he does not love her.

Sir Roger Scatcherd is a chronic drunkard, and Doctor Thorne tries in vain to get him to curtail his drinking. In his will, Scatcherd leaves the bulk of his estate to his only son, the dissolute Louis Philippe. However, he leaves Doctor Thorne in control of the inheritance until Louis Philippe reaches the age of 25. Should Louis die before then, Scatcherd stipulates that the estate goes to his sister Mary's eldest child. Thorne, knowing that Scatcherd is thinking of the children Mary had in America, is forced to divulge Mary's parentage to Scatcherd, but Scatcherd leaves the will unchanged.

Roger Scatcherd eventually dies of drink. The son proves just as much an alcoholic as the father, and his weaker constitution quickly brings him to the same end before he turns 25. After consulting with lawyers, Doctor Thorne confirms that his niece Mary is the heiress, now wealthier than even Miss Dunstable.

Unaware of these developments, the still resolute Frank finally persuades his doting father to consent to his marriage to Mary. When all is revealed, the rest of his relations heartily congratulate him.

Characters

[edit]

The Thornes

[edit]
  • Dr Thomas Thorne, the uncle of Mary Thorne, who works as a doctor and apothecary. He is the confidant of both Squire Gresham and Sir Roger.
  • Mary Thorne, the niece of Dr. Thorne and Sir Roger

The Scatcherds

[edit]
  • Sir Roger Scatcherd, a poor stonemason with a talent for business, who later becomes a very wealthy building contractor.
  • Lady Scatcherd, wife of Sir Roger and mother of Louis Philippe. She was Frank Gresham's wet nurse when he was a child and remains very fond of him.
  • Sir Louis Philippe Scatcherd, the only son of Sir Roger Scatcherd.

The Greshams

[edit]
  • Mr Francis Newbold Gresham, senior, the squire of Greshamsbury
  • Lady Arabella, his wife, née de Courcy, who is most anxious for Frank to "marry money"
  • Francis "Frank" Newbold Gresham, junior, the squire's eldest child, only son and heir
  • Augusta Gresham, Frank's youngest sister
  • Beatrice Gresham, Frank's sister and Mary Thorne's best friend

The de Courcys

[edit]
  • The Earl de Courcy, Lady Arabella Gresham's brother
  • Lady de Courcy, wife of the Earl
  • Lady Alexandrina, their eldest daughter

The Oriels

[edit]
  • Caleb Oriel, a clergyman who later marries Beatrice Gresham
  • Patience Oriel, Caleb's sister, and a close friend of Beatrice

Others

[edit]
  • The Duke of Omnium, an extremely wealthy bachelor who figures in a number of Trollope's Barsetshire and Palliser novels
  • Martha Dunstable, a kind-hearted, wealthy heiress of the "oil of Lebanon" business
  • Mr. Moffat, one-time suitor of Miss Augusta Gresham, who later withdraws his proposal in order to seek a more advantageous match, and is horsewhipped by Frank for it
  • Dr. Fillgrave, a Barchester doctor who detests Dr Thorne

Adaptations

[edit]

An ITV adaptation, Doctor Thorne, starring Stefanie Martini as Mary Thorne and Harry Richardson as Frank Gresham aired on 6 March 2016.[3] The script was written by Julian Fellowes, the creator and scriptwriter for Gosford Park and Downton Abbey.

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Doctor Thorne

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Doctor Thorne is a by the English author , first published in three volumes in 1858 by Chapman and Hall. It forms the third installment in Trollope's series, shifting focus from clerical life to the secular concerns of county gentry in the fictional rural setting of Greshamsbury, near Barchester. The central narrative follows Frank Gresham, the young heir to the debt-ridden Greshamsbury estate, who falls in love with Mary Thorne, the orphaned niece and ward of the local physician, Doctor Thomas Thorne. Despite familial pressure on Frank to marry an heiress to restore the family's fortunes—urged by his ambitious mother, Lady Arabella, and influential relatives like the Earl de Courcy—the romance is complicated by Mary's uncertain social status and lack of fortune. Doctor Thorne, a principled and compassionate figure, harbors a secret about Mary's parentage as the illegitimate daughter of his disgraced brother and the sister of the self-made railway magnate Sir Roger Scatcherd, whose and wealth play pivotal roles in the unfolding events. The novel delves into Victorian social issues, including the rigid class structure that impedes true love, the corrosive effects of and on landed families, and the stigma of illegitimacy, all while portraying the redemptive power of moral over inherited . Themes of are highlighted through Sir Roger's decline, contrasting with the novel's optimistic resolution where inherited wealth unexpectedly bridges social divides. Trollope drew inspiration for the plot from conversations with his brother during a trip to , emphasizing realistic character motivations over dramatic plot twists. Regarded as one of Trollope's finest works despite the author's own toward it, Doctor Thorne was the best-selling of his forty-seven novels during his lifetime, praised for its acute social observation and engaging portrayal of provincial life. The book has seen several adaptations, most notably a 2016 three-part ITV miniseries scripted by , starring as Doctor Thorne and as Mary, which modernized the pacing while retaining the novel's class satire.

Publication History

Composition

Anthony Trollope composed Doctor Thorne between October 20, 1857, and March 31, 1858, while employed as a postal surveyor for the , a role that demanded extensive travel and administrative duties across rural . Adhering to his rigorous writing regimen, Trollope produced an average of 40 pages per week—each comprising about 250 words—often drafting on a portable tablet during railway journeys or in the early mornings before his workday began at 5:30 a.m. The novel's plot originated from an idea suggested by his brother Thomas Adolphus Trollope during a visit to , and Trollope completed the manuscript in amid a demanding Post Office tour, beginning his next work, The Bertrams, the following day despite the physical toll of the voyage. The novel drew inspiration from Trollope's firsthand observations of rural English society, gained through his postal surveys in counties including , where he oversaw mail services and interacted with local , farmers, and professionals. These experiences illuminated the intricate class dynamics of mid-Victorian countryside , from landed estates strained by economic pressures to the social barriers between professionals and aristocrats, which Trollope captured with a realism rooted in his travels across Devonshire, , and other regions. His work establishing rural postal networks further exposed him to the rhythms and hierarchies of provincial communities, informing the novel's depiction of everyday social interactions beyond urban centers. Trollope deliberately expanded the Barsetshire fictional world—initially centered on clerical figures in (1855) and (1857)—to encompass the and medical professionals, reflecting his interest in broadening the series' social canvas while maintaining its English rural essence. This shift allowed exploration of secular themes, such as among doctors and the tensions within landed families, drawing on Trollope's evolving view of Barsetshire as a microcosm of county life. Autobiographical elements permeated the work, particularly Trollope's critiques of laws and advocacy for , shaped by his family's of financial ruin, , and disputed legacies following his father's . His observations of the Irish famine and inadequate government relief in the deepened his commitment to themes of equity and mobility, influencing portrayals of unjust entailments and the need for legal changes to alleviate class rigidities. These personal insights lent authenticity to the novel's examination of moral and societal constraints on individual fortunes.

Initial Editions and Serialization

Doctor Thorne was published in London by Chapman and Hall in May 1858 as a three-volume novel, the standard format for Victorian "triple-decker" fiction, priced at 31s 6d. This edition marked a departure from Trollope's previous Barsetshire novels, The Warden and Barchester Towers, which had been serialized in magazines prior to book form; instead, Trollope sold the outright copyright to Chapman and Hall for £400, forgoing serialization due to the lucrative contractual terms. The initial print run totaled 750 copies, which sold out quickly enough to prompt a second edition of 250 copies just one month later, indicating strong early demand. Trollope later described Doctor Thorne in his as the most popular of his during his lifetime, a attributed in part to its accessible themes of class, , and romance. The saw multiple reprints in the ensuing years, including a one-volume edition issued by Chapman and Hall in 1860, which made it more affordable for a broader readership. International distribution followed soon after the British release, with Harper & Brothers publishing the first American edition in New York in 1858, capitalizing on Trollope's growing transatlantic reputation. A continental edition also appeared that year from Bernhard Tauchnitz in , facilitating access in without infringing on British through the informal Anglo-German arrangement. These early editions underscored the novel's immediate commercial viability within the Barsetshire series.

Context in Trollope's Works

Position in the Barsetshire Chronicles

Doctor Thorne is the third novel in Anthony Trollope's series, following (1855) and (1857), and preceding (1861). Published in 1858, it marks a shift in focus from the and intrigues dominating the first two novels to the social and economic concerns of rural life. The novel introduces a range of non-clerical characters, including physicians and landed , thereby broadening the scope of the fictional county of Barsetshire beyond its clerical center in Barchester. This expansion populates the surrounding countryside with new families and estates, such as the Greshams of Greshamsbury, located near Barchester, enhancing the series' portrayal of provincial English society. In terms of internal chronology, the events of Doctor Thorne unfold concurrently with those of , set amid the social landscape of rural in the 1850s. Trollope intended the Barsetshire novels to form a cohesive fictional world, with recurring locations and interconnected narratives that build upon one another across the series. He described this development in his autobiography, noting how the series evolved from a single cathedral-focused story into a comprehensive chronicle of the county's diverse inhabitants and locales.

Connections to Other Novels

Doctor Thorne establishes connections to the broader Barsetshire series through minor appearances of ecclesiastical figures from Barchester Towers. The Bishop of Barchester and his wife, Mrs. Proudie, make brief but notable cameos during a gathering at Courcy Castle, where the bishop is depicted as a "meek, good, worthy man, much attached to his wife," highlighting the ongoing influence of Barchester's clerical elite in provincial social events. Mrs. Proudie engages in conversation with the wealthy Miss Dunstable, showcasing her characteristic energy and social maneuvering, which contrasts with her husband's more passive demeanor. The novel foreshadows elements of (1861) through shared locations and overlapping social circles in Barsetshire. Central characters such as Dr. Thomas Thorne and his niece Mary reappear in the later work, with Dr. Thorne serving as a physician and advisor in Framley contexts, linking the Greshamsbury estate to the parsonage's rural dynamics. Sir Roger Scatcherd's family and business interests also extend into , where his parliamentary ambitions and railway ventures intersect with the county's gentry and clergy, reinforcing the interconnected provincial network. Thematically, Doctor Thorne maintains continuity with the Barsetshire series in its exploration of Victorian provincial life, depicting the tensions between , emerging industrial wealth, and in a fictional setting. However, it uniquely emphasizes medical and familial ethics, as seen in Dr. Thorne's moral dilemmas over , illegitimacy, and patient care, which distinguish it from the more clerical-focused narratives of preceding volumes while underscoring Trollope's interest in personal integrity amid . Trollope employs recurring motifs across the series, such as development, to symbolize modernization's impact on traditional society; in Doctor Thorne, Sir Roger Scatcherd's rise as a contractor from humble origins exemplifies this theme, mirroring broader Barsetshire concerns with economic upheaval and class mobility seen in later novels like .

Plot Summary

Volume One

The novel opens at Greshamsbury, a historic Tudor estate in East Barsetshire owned by Squire Francis Newbold Gresham, whose family has held the property for centuries but now faces severe financial difficulties due to extravagant expenditures on hunting, elections, and family support. The squire's mismanagement has forced the sale of a significant portion of the land, including the Boxall Hill farm, and compelled him to raise tenant rents while seeking loans to cover mounting debts, such as the mortgages held by Sir Roger Scatcherd. This strain is evident during the subdued celebrations for the coming-of-age of his son Frank, where the family's reduced circumstances limit the festivities despite their lingering social prominence. Lady Arabella, the squire's wife and daughter of a French count, exacerbates the pressures through her aspirations for higher status, often clashing with the squire over household economies. Dr. Thomas Thorne, a respected local physician and close friend of the squire, serves as guardian to his niece Mary Thorne, whom he has raised since infancy while concealing her true origins to shield her from scandal. Mary's illegitimacy stems from a tragic affair two decades earlier between Dr. Thorne's brother Henry, a promising young man, and Mary Scatcherd, the sister of a local stonemason; after Henry's seduction of her and their child's birth, her brother Roger Scatcherd killed Henry in a drunken rage, leading to Roger's imprisonment for manslaughter. Dr. Thorne later reveals this history to Mary herself during a moment of emotional vulnerability, assuring her that her mother's situation was unfortunate but not dishonorable, and affirming his commitment to treat her as his own daughter regardless of her birth. Integrated into Greshamsbury society through her uncle's connections, Mary forms close bonds with the Gresham children, particularly Frank's sister Beatrice, but her ambiguous status subtly undermines her position. As Frank Gresham reaches adulthood, he develops a deep romantic attachment to Mary Thorne, declaring his love despite their longstanding friendship and shared activities at the estate. This quickly draws opposition from Arabella, who views Mary as socially inferior and penniless, insisting that Frank must wed a wealthy heiress to alleviate the family's debts and preserve their standing. Beatrice warns Mary of the insurmountable class barriers, and after Frank's persistent proposals—which Mary initially rebuffs out of regarding their disparity— Arabella confronts Dr. Thorne and ultimately banishes Mary from Greshamsbury to prevent further entanglement. The conflict intensifies family tensions, with the reluctantly siding against the match while Frank remains resolute, highlighting the rigid social hierarchies that govern their world. Parallel to the Greshams' struggles, the narrative traces Sir Roger Scatcherd's extraordinary ascent from a humble stonemason in the Barsetshire quarries to a and railway magnate, amassing a fortune estimated at £300,000 through shrewd investments in projects during the boom. His success, however, is marred by chronic , a that fueled the fatal confrontation with Henry Thorne and continues to erode his health and reputation, leading to public brawls, professional rivalries with Dr. Thorne, and estrangement from his wife and son Louis Philippe. As a newly elected , Sir Roger grapples with his intemperance, rejecting medical advice from rivals like Dr. Fillgrave while confiding in Dr. Thorne about his regrets and a secretive will intended to benefit Mary, all amid worsening family dynamics and his physical decline toward .

Volume Two

In Volume Two of Doctor Thorne, the narrative intensifies around the consequences of Sir Roger Scatcherd's deteriorating health and eventual death, which profoundly impacts the financial and social dynamics of Greshamsbury. Sir Roger, the self-made and brewer whose rise from humble origins has been shadowed by , suffers a fatal paralytic after excessive drinking, attended by Dr. Thorne and the London physician Mr. Rerechild. His will, executed with Dr. Thorne as , initially bequeaths his vast fortune to his son Sir Louis, but a codicil reveals an unexpected provision: if Sir Louis dies without legitimate issue before reaching age 25, the estate passes to Mary Thorne as Sir Roger's niece. This twist, concealed until after the funeral, sets the stage for revelations that upend the established social order, as Mary's potential inheritance promises to resolve longstanding tensions while exposing hidden . The Gresham family's estate crisis reaches a critical juncture amid Frank Gresham's mounting debts, exacerbated by a £10,000 held by Sir Roger on Greshamsbury property. With the estate on the brink of , Lady Arabella Gresham and her influential de Courcy relatives exert pressure on Frank to pursue a financially advantageous marriage, particularly to the wealthy heiress Miss Dunstable, whose fortune could redeem the family's holdings and avert ruin. Frank, however, remains steadfast in his affection for Mary, resisting overtures from society and enduring familial disapproval that frames his attachment as a reckless threat to the Gresham legacy. These economic pressures highlight the precarious balance of in mid-19th-century , where personal desires clash with the imperatives of and solvency. Central to the volume's climax is the revelation of Mary's true parentage, which Dr. Thorne has long guarded as a secret born of compassion. Mary, raised as the doctor's niece since childhood, learns she is the illegitimate daughter of Sir Roger's sister and thus his closest living relative, positioning her as the codicil's . This disclosure, prompted by Sir Roger's dying wish and confirmed after his passing, elevates Mary from social obscurity to of an immense railway-derived fortune, contingent only on Sir Louis's failure to produce an heir. Sir Louis's own decline—marked by inherited and reckless dissipation—culminates in his untimely death before age 25, without issue, thereby extinguishing the Scatcherd baronetcy and securing Mary's claim to the estate. Her newfound status not only vindicates Dr. Thorne's protective guardianship but also removes the barriers to her union with Frank, transforming her from an ineligible match to a savior of the Gresham patrimony. The resolutions unfold through a series of weddings that restore to Greshamsbury and underscore themes of redemption and alliance. Frank and Mary marry in a ceremony that unites love with financial salvation, enabling the repayment of debts and the preservation of the estate under joint stewardship. Concurrently, Beatrice Gresham weds Oriel, the principled rector whose initial reservations about clerical matrimony give way to a devoted , while Augusta Gresham enters a pragmatic union with Mr. Mortimer Gazebee, a steady solicitor whose position offers stability amid the family's upheavals. In contrast, the de Courcy family's schemes unravel, their meddling in the Greshams' affairs exposed as futile; political ambitions falter with Mr. Moffat's electoral defeat in Barchester, and Lady de Courcy's haughty influence diminishes, leaving the family isolated in their declining status. These events culminate in a renewed social equilibrium, with Dr. Thorne's household at the center, affirming the novel's vision of merit transcending birthright.

Characters

The Greshams

The Greshams form the core of the in Doctor Thorne, residing at the mortgaged Greshamsbury Park estate in East Barsetshire, where their as an ancient, respected underscores the novel's of aristocratic decline amid financial . As commoners with deep roots in Barsetshire, they embody traditional English gentlemanly ideals, with the squire's role as a reinforcing their influence, though internal strains from debt and marital ambitions reveal vulnerabilities in their household dynamics. Squire John Newbold Gresham, the , is a mild-mannered and reasonable landowner whose kind-hearted nature has been tempered by years of financial worry and familial pressures, leaving him patient yet often bitter about the estate's burdens. Once known for his joyous disposition, he now prioritizes the preservation of the Greshamsbury name and his heir's prospects, confiding frequently in Dr. Thorne as a trusted advisor while grappling with self-reproach over the inheritance he will pass on. His weaker resolve compared to his ancestors highlights the evolving challenges of leadership, fostering a dynamic of quiet support within the family despite ongoing economic constraints. Lady Arabella de Courcy Gresham, the squire's wife and sister to the de Courcy, represents the snobbish aristocratic influence in the household, her fashionable pride and ambitious temperament driving efforts to secure the family's status through strategic alliances. Authoritative and prone to emotional control, she enforces social proprieties and harbors distrust toward connections below their rank, often clashing with her husband's leniency and exacerbating tensions over household decisions. Her cold selfishness and focus on lineage create a matriarchal dominance that shapes the family's internal conflicts, particularly in guiding her children's matrimonial paths. Francis Newbold "Frank" Gresham, the squire's impetuous son and heir, embodies the youthful vigor of the at age twenty-four, having recently assumed his parliamentary seat while navigating the weight of familial expectations. Open-hearted and affectionate, he balances boyish charm with a sense of duty, his warm impulses often at odds with the pragmatic demands of estate preservation, leading to negotiations with his father on matters of gentlemanly conduct and personal choice. This father-son bond, marked by mutual regard and guidance, underscores the generational dynamics of maintaining amid personal inclinations. The Gresham daughters, notably Beatrice and Augusta, reflect varied facets of gentry womanhood, educated in music and social graces to uphold family prestige while embodying contrasting responses to parental ambitions. Beatrice, true-hearted and playful, prioritizes loyalty and affection in her role, offering a to the household's status-driven tensions through her supportive nature. Augusta, the eldest, is strong-minded and pragmatic, molded by de Courcy influences to pursue dutiful alliances that align with economic necessities, her resilience highlighting the daughters' collective navigation of romantic and familial obligations. These dynamics illustrate the women's pivotal yet constrained positions within the Greshams' social framework.

The Thornes

Dr. Thomas Thorne is the protagonist and moral anchor of Anthony Trollope's Doctor Thorne, portrayed as a principled physician practicing in the village of Greshamsbury, where he treats patients from all social strata with impartial skill and compassion. His professional routine involves dispensing medicines, conducting consultations with a philosophical bent, and charging modest fees while maintaining a steady but unremarkable that reflects his dedication to duty over personal gain. Despite occasional rivalries with other doctors, Thorne's brusque yet effective manner endears him to the local community, where he is respected for his integrity and willingness to attend anyone in need, regardless of rank. As Mary's devoted guardian, Dr. Thorne raises her as his own daughter after her birth, harboring the secret of her illegitimacy stemming from his brother Henry's scandalous affair, a burden that underscores his self-sacrificing nature and deep familial loyalty. Proud of his ancient Thorne lineage—tracing back to the Ullathorne branch—he is stubborn and combative when his principles are challenged, yet tender-hearted and patient, particularly toward Mary, whom he nurtures with unwavering affection and protects from societal judgments. This ethical stance positions him as a conservative figure who values personal honor and stability above ambition, often mediating family conflicts with quiet authority. Mary Thorne, Dr. Thorne's niece, emerges as a virtuous and intelligent young woman, characterized by her energetic spirit, quick wit, and principled resolve, which allow her to navigate with grace and resilience. Unaware for much of her life of the full circumstances of her birth, she grows up under her uncle's care, developing a thoughtful independence that prizes inner worth over external status, though her emotional depth reveals vulnerabilities in matters of the heart—such as her romance with Frank Gresham. Modest and affectionate, Mary forms deep bonds within her limited circle, reflecting a calm demeanor that masks her passionate undercurrents, making her a symbol of quiet moral strength amid personal uncertainties. Henry Thorne, the deceased younger brother of Dr. Thomas Thorne and father of Mary, represents a tragic contrast to the family's upright core, having led a profligate life marked by dissipation and poor associations that culminated in scandal. Expelled from for his wayward behavior, Henry relied heavily on his brother's support, straining family ties—particularly with the Ullathorne Thornes—due to his reckless choices, including the affair that resulted in Mary's illegitimate birth. His untimely death leaves a lasting shadow over the Thorne household, amplifying Dr. Thorne's protective instincts and commitment to shielding Mary from her father's tarnished legacy.

The Scatcherds

The Scatcherd family in Anthony Trollope's Doctor Thorne represents a newly risen industrial dynasty, originating from humble beginnings in Barchester and achieving prominence through enterprise in the burgeoning railway sector. Sir Roger Scatcherd, the patriarch, begins as a stonemason but amasses a fortune as a contractor for railways, quarries, docks, and government projects across , , and America, earning him a baronetcy and election as for Barchester. His rapid ascent symbolizes the era's economic transformations, though it is marred by chronic , often fueled by brandy, which frequently incapacitates him and contributes to his deteriorating health. Politically, Sir Roger emerges as a radical reformer, championing such as expanded voting rights, the , and economies in , while prioritizing infrastructure development to benefit the working classes. His campaign slogan, "Peace abroad and a big loaf at home," underscores his focus on affordable and national stability, reflecting opposition to aristocratic privileges. However, his parliamentary career ends in scandal when he is unseated due to by his election agent, an event that exacerbates his drinking and leads to his death at age 59 from induced by . In his will, Sir Roger bequeaths his vast estate, including £200,000, to his son Louis Philippe, with Doctor Thorne appointed as and guardian until the heir reaches 25. Lady Scatcherd, Sir Roger's steadfast wife, embodies practical resilience amid the family's volatility, managing the household at Boxall Hill with efficiency despite her husband's excesses and a prior for assaulting a peer. She remains deeply loyal, Sir Roger through his final illness and inheriting an of £1,000 per year after his death, which allows her to continue residing at the estate. Her unpretentious nature is evident in her discomfort with the title "my lady," and she occasionally extends hospitality to figures connected to the Thornes, such as Mary Thorne, whom Sir Roger reveals as his niece in a moment of . Louis Philippe Scatcherd, the sole heir, inherits both the baronetcy and fortune but proves dissolute from youth, expelled from Eton and for misconduct before traveling abroad under a tutor, only to succumb to shortly after age 21. His weakness of character manifests in a rejected to Mary Thorne, triggering a further decline marked by after a three-day drinking binge. He dies from before reaching 25, thus never assuming full control of the estate under Doctor Thorne's oversight, extinguishing the direct Scatcherd line and redirecting the inheritance.

The de Courcys and Oriel Family

The de Courcy family represents the scheming aristocratic elite in Doctor Thorne, exerting influence over the Greshams through familial ties and social ambitions. The de Courcy, a prominent Whig magnate residing at Courcy Castle, is characterized as politically active yet often absent from family affairs, prioritizing his status and alliances, such as with the Duke of . His wife, Lady de Courcy, dominates the household with her stern, dictatorial energy and unyielding focus on social rank, frequently manipulating events to secure advantageous marriages for her children and relatives; she insists, for instance, that financial necessity demands strategic unions, declaring, "He must marry money, doctor." Their eldest son, Lord Porlock, the heir, displays disinterest in social duties and a propensity for troublesome liaisons, while the second son, Honourable George de Courcy, is ambitious and flirtatious, engaging in pursuits driven by wealth rather than affection. The third son, Honourable , is more lighthearted and sport-oriented, offering casual advice on matters like horses and romance. The daughters—Lady Amelia, Lady Rosina, Lady Margaretta, and Lady Alexandrina—embody aristocratic arrogance and status-consciousness, with Amelia notably engaged in a loveless match that underscores the family's pragmatic approach to alliances; they collectively uphold rigid class standards, as Alexandrina remarks, "Rank, however, has its drawbacks, Miss Thorne, as well as its privileges." As Lady Arabella Gresham's relatives, the de Courcys actively scheme to advance the Greshamsbury estate's fortunes through plots, though these efforts often falter due to their presumptuous . Lady de Courcy, in particular, hosts gatherings at Courcy Castle to facilitate wealthy matches for her nephew Frank Gresham, opposing his attachment to Mary Thorne on grounds of her inferior social standing. Their involvement highlights the tensions between noble entitlement and practical necessity, with the family supporting political endeavors like electioneering while prioritizing personal gain. Mortimer Gazebee serves as the de Courcy family's solicitor and a pragmatic advisor to the Greshams, embodying middle-class ambition amid aristocratic circles. Lacking noble birth, Gazebee rises through professional acumen, managing the Gresham estate's debts with a focus on fiscal realism rather than social flair. His marriage to Lady Amelia de Courcy bridges the families, yet he remains a steady, unassuming figure who aids in navigating financial pressures without the de Courcys' ostentatious scheming. In contrast, the Oriel family provides clerical modesty and community support, offering a counterbalance to the de Courcys' elitism as allies to the Thornes and Greshams. Reverend Caleb Oriel, the young rector of Greshamsbury and a High Church adherent, is depicted as devout, enthusiastic, and effective in parish duties, viewing morning prayer as "an imperative duty, certainly." He fosters social ties through his role in local events and a minor romantic connection with Beatrice Gresham, contributing to communal harmony. His sister, Patience Oriel, is a lively, compassionate gentlewoman and steadfast friend to Mary Thorne, providing emotional refuge and advocating reconciliation during family estrangements; she warmly affirms Mary's value, stating, "I do think you are a happy girl." The Oriels' modest demeanor and supportive roles underscore themes of genuine friendship in the rural community, distinct from the de Courcys' calculated ambitions.

Other Supporting Figures

Mr. Moffat serves as a failed suitor to Augusta Gresham and a source of both and in the narrative, embodying the opportunistic social climber who prioritizes financial gain over genuine affection. As the son of a wealthy tailor and the Whig for Barchester, Moffat engages Augusta with calculated ambition, demanding a £6,000 from Gresham while displaying little warmth toward her. His unravels publicly during the East Barsetshire , where his and defeat lead to , including being pelted with eggs by the crowd and a subsequent thrashing by Frank Gresham in Pall Mall. Sir Abraham Haphazard, a prominent London barrister and Attorney-General, provides expert legal counsel on intricate matters such as estate settlements and election disputes, advancing subplots involving wills and political intrigue without dominating the foreground. Consulted by Dr. Thorne regarding the Greshamsbury title-deeds and Sir Roger Scatcherd's contested parliamentary seat, Haphazard's involvement highlights the novel's exploration of legal maneuvering among the gentry and newly risen industrialists. His detached, professional demeanor offers a satirical glimpse into the era's convoluted jurisprudence. Mr. Baker, a rival physician based in Silverbridge, underscores the competitive dynamics of provincial medical practice through his professional with Dr. Thorne and his familial ties to the local elite. As the father of Harry Baker—a companion to Frank Gresham with a stable of four hunters and a hack—Mr. Baker enjoys a moderate of £4,000 annually, enabling him to congratulate the Greshams on their fortunes while subtly contrasting his stability with Dr. Thorne's more precarious circumstances. His presence at social events like Frank's coming-of-age feast adds layers of understated and . The Greshamsbury tenants and Dr. Thorne's medical patients form a collective of peripheral figures that vividly illustrate the doctor's everyday practice and his role as a pillar, blending routine care with moments of humor and . Tenants such as Farmer Oaklerath appear at gatherings like Frank's feast, voicing loyalty and reminiscing about past prosperity, while patients range from the squire's episodes and Lady Arabella's ailments to villagers, servants like Umbleby, and even children for whom Thorne mixes doses in his apothecary-like routine. These interactions, including visits to an elderly woman in Silverbridge and extended stays at Boxall Hill to treat Sir Roger, reveal Thorne's compassionate yet hands-on approach, often blurring medical duties with financial and advisory support. Peripheral election candidates and their agents, such as Mr. Nearthewinde, Mr. Closerstil, and Mr. Romer, propel the political subplot through their efforts and scandals, injecting comic elements via Trollope's ironic portrayal of electoral machinations. Supporting figures like Nearthewinde, who aids Mr. Moffat's campaign with pro-government Whig tactics, and Romer, implicated in Scatcherd's charges leading to his unseating, represent the era's partisan fervor and without overshadowing the central between and radicalism. Their activities, marked by colorful banners—yellow for Moffat's supporters and scarlet for Scatcherd's—underscore the novel's satirical take on democracy's rough edges.

Themes

Social Class and Mobility

In Anthony Trollope's Doctor Thorne, the rigid Victorian class structure is critiqued through the juxtaposition of the declining old , represented by the Gresham and de Courcy families, and the disruptive rise of new wealth embodied by the Scatcherds. The Greshams, tied to their ancestral estate at Greshamsbury, cling to traditions of birth and breeding despite financial ruin, while the de Courcys exemplify aristocratic snobbery, viewing those below them with disdain and prioritizing noble connections over merit. In contrast, Roger Scatcherd ascends from a lowly stonemason to a through ruthless , yet his lack of refinement invites from the , highlighting the era's against self-made fortunes. This tension underscores Trollope's on class snobbery, where old money's moral superiority is illusory, and new wealth's vulgarity serves as a foil to expose aristocratic . Mary Thorne's arc from social outcast to heiress provides a pointed commentary on birth versus merit in . As the illegitimate daughter of a working-class woman and raised by her uncle, Dr. Thorne, Mary endures rejection and an due to her nameless status and lack of fortune, facing prejudice from figures like Lady de Courcy who deem her unsuitable for Frank Gresham. Her eventual inheritance of the Scatcherd fortune elevates her position, allowing into the and affirming Trollope's belief that intrinsic merit can transcend birth, though good breeding remains an ideal for true integration. This resolution critiques the arbitrariness of class barriers while reinforcing conservative notions of ethical worth over mere lineage. Dr. Thorne's profession as a physician plays a crucial role in bridging class divides, embodying amid hierarchical tensions. Positioned between the gentlemanly physicians and tradesman-like apothecaries, he navigates social strata with professional detachment, treating patients from all ranks without favoritism and mediating conflicts between the Greshams and Scatcherds. His stability as a middle-class figure contrasts with ambitious climbers, allowing him to facilitate alliances that unite "old " with emerging industrial wealth, thus illustrating medicine's potential to foster social equilibrium without upending traditional structures. Trollope satirizes as a mechanism for social ascent, particularly through the de Courcy family's failed alliances, which expose the mercenary underbelly of aristocratic maneuvering. Lady Arabella and the de Courcys pressure Frank to wed for money, pushing connections with wealthy but unsuitable partners, while Augusta's engagement to the upstart Moffat ends in , underscoring the folly of prioritizing status over compatibility. These plots mock the notion of as a ladder for class preservation, revealing how snobbery leads to personal and familial downfall.

Inheritance and Economic Pressures

In Doctor Thorne, illustrates the constraints imposed by and entailment on the , particularly through the Gresham family, whose vast estate at Greshamsbury generates an income of £14,000 annually yet leaves them mired in poverty due to unalterable legal structures that prioritize male and prevent the sale or subdivision of entailed lands. These mechanisms, designed to preserve family estates across generations, instead trap the Greshams in a cycle of , as the cannot liquidate portions of the to cover mounting obligations from extravagant living and failed agricultural ventures, forcing reliance on high-interest loans from usurers. The entailment's rigidity underscores Victorian inheritance laws' role in perpetuating for the , where ancestral lands become both a of status and an inescapable burden. Contrasting sharply with this aristocratic decline is the meteoric rise of Sir Roger Scatcherd, a self-made whose fortune, amassed through speculative railway contracting in the and , reaches £300,000 and exemplifies the era's industrial "new money" disrupting traditional rural economies. Scatcherd's transformation from a humble stonemason to a wealthy highlights how railway expansion—fueled by parliamentary acts and capital investment—enabled for the working classes while eroding the economic dominance of land-based elites like the Greshams, whose debts are ironically secured against Scatcherd's loans. This critiques the obsolescence of old wealth in a modernizing Britain, where industrial ventures like Scatcherd's railways symbolize both opportunity and vulgarity, as his uncouth manners alienate the even as his capital sustains them. Trollope employs legal twists surrounding Scatcherd's will as a to expose flaws in Victorian laws, particularly the vulnerabilities of codicils and conditional bequests that invite disputes and moral quandaries. The will's eccentric provision—bequeathing the estate to Scatcherd's dissolute son Louis only if he abstains from alcohol for a year, otherwise redirecting it to Mary Thorne—serves as a of laws that allow such personal contingencies to override equitable distribution, mirroring broader concerns over primogeniture's injustices and the need for to accommodate changing social realities. Ultimately, Louis's death triggers the 's transfer to Mary, resolving the Greshams' but underscoring how arbitrary legal mechanisms can perpetuate inequality until disrupted by fate or . The novel's economic pressures reflect the Victorian transition from agrarian to industrial economies, where railways not only generated fortunes like Scatcherd's but also accelerated the decline of entailed estates by shifting investment toward and , challenging the sustainability of traditional systems. Trollope thus portrays as a battleground between old legal safeguards and emergent capitalist forces, with the Greshams' entrapment symbolizing the aristocracy's vulnerability to these shifts.

Romance and Moral Choices

In Doctor Thorne, the central romance between Frank Gresham and Mary Thorne exemplifies true love tested against societal pressures for arranged matches, with Frank's steadfast devotion highlighting themes of and personal over external expectations. Frank, the heir to Greshamsbury, pursues Mary despite her ambiguous social standing, refusing alternatives like a union with the wealthy Miss Dunstable, which underscores his commitment to emotional authenticity. This relationship contrasts sharply with the calculated pursuits orchestrated by the de Courcy family, whose sensational marital schemes prioritize status and alliance, revealing the ethical tensions between genuine affection and performative courtship. Dr. Thorne's secrecy regarding Mary's true parentage—concealing her as the illegitimate daughter of his brother and the sister of the alcoholic Sir Roger Scatcherd—serves as both a profound moral burden and a protective act, shielding her from stigma while grappling with the ethics of deception in familial love. This choice weighs heavily on Dr. Thorne, who balances his role as guardian with the imperative to preserve Mary's dignity and future prospects, embodying Victorian dilemmas of honor and compassion. His decisions ultimately facilitate the couple's union, illustrating how personal ethics can navigate inherited secrets without compromising core values. Subplots further illuminate these dynamics, such as Beatrice Gresham's quiet, demure romance with Caleb Oriel, which unfolds modestly and contrasts the de Courcys' overt, intrigue-laden pursuits that often border on manipulation. Beatrice's proceeds almost silently within circles, emphasizing understated mutual and emotional compatibility as ideals of . Trollope portrays as a balanced influenced by 19th-century norms, where ideals of gentlemanly conduct incorporate traditionally feminine traits like and compromise, allowing unions like Frank and Mary's to transcend rigid conventions through shared growth.

Adaptations

2016 ITV Miniseries

The 2016 ITV of Doctor Thorne is a three-part period drama miniseries written by and directed by Niall MacCormick, which originally aired on 6, 13, and 20 March 2016. This was the first television of the novel. Produced by in association with , the series updates Anthony Trollope's 1858 novel for contemporary audiences by condensing the narrative into a brisk format while preserving its core exploration of and inheritance. The cast features in the title role as the principled physician Dr. Thomas Thorne, as his orphaned niece Mary Thorne, and Harry Richardson as the young heir Frank Gresham, whose forbidden romance with Mary drives much of the plot. Supporting roles include as the snobbish Lady Arabella Gresham, as the indebted Squire Gresham, and as the boisterous railroad Sir Roger Scatcherd. Filmed at historic locations such as and , the production emphasizes lush 1850s visuals, with notable attention to period-accurate fashion and estate settings. Fellowes' screenplay heightens the romantic tensions and infuses additional humor into character interactions, making the story more accessible and lighthearted compared to the novel's subtler tone, while shortening peripheral subplots like extended medical and political threads to maintain pacing across the episodes. This approach amplifies the drama of class barriers and moral dilemmas, with visual flair in the by Colleen Kelsall, which highlights Victorian elegance and social distinctions through vibrant gowns and tailoring. The miniseries was a viewership success, with the premiere episode attracting a consolidated audience of 4.97 million viewers and subsequent episodes drawing 4.29 million and 4.52 million, respectively. It earned a nomination for the Royal Television Society Craft & Design Award in Best Picture Enhancement and received praise for its engaging portrayal of Trollope's themes, balancing accessibility with faithful elements of the original novel's social commentary.

Critical Reception

Contemporary Responses

Upon its publication in May 1858, Doctor Thorne elicited positive responses from several prominent periodicals for its realistic depiction of rural English society and nuanced character development. The unsigned review in The Athenaeum lauded the novel's "truthful and life-like" portrayal of country life, emphasizing the "well-drawn" figures who exhibited genuine depth and complexity, while acknowledging a "well-sustained narrative" interspersed with "touches of " that introduced sentimental undertones. Similarly, The Spectator's reviewer highlighted the book's "faithful picture of English life," noting how the characters "stand out with individuality" in their everyday authenticity, though it critiqued the pacing as "somewhat slow" and deemed certain passages "overly sentimental at times." The Leader echoed these strengths, describing Trollope's rendering of provincial existence as "natural and unforced" and his characters as "vividly realized" with "heartfelt emotion," without the exaggerated flourishes common in other contemporary fiction. This review drew explicit comparisons to , commending Trollope's subtler approach to social observation over Dickens's penchant for melodrama and caricature, positioning Doctor Thorne as a more restrained yet equally insightful commentary on human relations. Commercially, the novel achieved solid success, with the first edition selling out in little more than three months of release in three-volume format by Chapman and Hall, which solidified Trollope's reputation as a reliable mid-tier author among Victorian readers.

Later Scholarship and Analysis

Later scholarship on Doctor Thorne has emphasized the novel's exploration of Victorian medical professionalism and its intersection with class structures. Scholars view Dr. Thorne as a transitional figure in the evolving medical profession, blending the roles of physician and apothecary while navigating the social hierarchies of the time. Unlike the more aristocratic Dr. Fillgrave, who adheres strictly to genteel practices like fixed guinea fees, Thorne engages in practical, distance-based charging and drug dispensing, reflecting the push toward professional reform prior to the 1858 Medical Act. This portrayal allows Trollope to depict medicine as a pathway for social mobility, with Thorne's uncertain class status enabling him to bridge divides between the declining gentry (Greshams) and rising industrialists (Scatcherds), ultimately facilitating Mary's marriage and family reconciliation. Analyses of class and in the novel highlight how and economic pressures constrain , particularly for women. The Gresham family's debt forces Frank to consider a wealthy match, underscoring the rigidity of landed systems that prioritize heirs and limit female portions. Women like Arabella actively manage these dynamics, pressuring Frank to "marry money" repeatedly, which challenges the notion of by portraying them as key agents in wealth transmission and matchmaking. This active role contrasts with the De Courcy sisters' vulnerability to spinsterhood due to inadequate dowries, illustrating Trollope's of gender-based economic inequalities. Gender scholarship has examined Mary Thorne's character through psychological lenses, identifying an rooted in her illegitimacy and social . Drawing on Alfred Adler's theory, her feelings of inadequacy stem from parental rejection, unfavorable comparisons to higher-status peers, and community disapproval, particularly from Lady Arabella, shaping her self-perception and romantic hesitations. This complex drives much of the narrative tension but resolves through inheritance, affirming her worth and enabling upward mobility. Broader feminist readings of Trollope's Barsetshire series, including Doctor Thorne, argue that while early heroines like Mary exert limited direct influence compared to later figures, the novel subverts Victorian norms by centering female resilience and moral agency in class negotiations. Recent studies also situate Doctor Thorne within Trollope's narrative techniques, praising his use of , indirect , and authorial commentary to dissect class rearrangements through . Love triumphs over opposition, rearranging hierarchies as the middle-class Mary ascends via the Scatcherd fortune, reflecting Trollope's interest in egalitarian unions amid Victorian social flux. These interpretations underscore the novel's enduring relevance to themes of and identity in a modernizing society.

References

  1. https://trollopesociety.org/book/doctor-thorne/
  2. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/doctor-thorne-9780198785637
  3. https://catalog.hathitrust.org/Record/100819654
  4. https://victorianweb.org/authors/trollope/tsociety/thorne.html
  5. https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/180416/doctor-thorne-by-anthony-trollope-introduction-by-n-john-hall/
  6. https://blog.oup.com/2016/03/adapting-trollope-for-tv/
  7. http://www.jimandellen.org/trollope/trollope.writing.chron.html
  8. https://ia600608.us.archive.org/0/items/in.ernet.dli.2015.235342/2015.235342.Anthony-Trollope_text.pdf
  9. https://britainunlimited.com/anthony-trollope/
  10. https://trollopesociety.org/trollope/post-office-career/
  11. https://writersinspire.org/content/victorian-publishing-history
  12. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/5978/5978-h/5978-h.htm
  13. https://www.jstor.org/stable/3044639
  14. https://artunderwraps.com/Anthony-Trollope.html
  15. https://www.ebay.com/itm/375543865072
  16. https://www.lornebair.com/pages/books/47481/anthony-trollope/doctor-thorne
  17. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/24923/24923-h/24923-h.htm
  18. https://victorianweb.org/authors/trollope/kincaid/4.html
  19. https://scalar.usc.edu/works/victorian-medicine-and-literature/doctor-thorn-by-anthony-trollope-1858
  20. https://academic.oup.com/book/59523/chapter/502227718
  21. https://trollopesociety.org/wp-content/uploads/Trollopiana-113.pdf
  22. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm
  23. https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/3166
  24. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/victorian-literature-and-culture/article/intercourse-between-the-squire-and-his-son-the-fatherson-marriage-plot-and-the-creation-of-the-english-gentleman-in-anthony-trollopes-doctor-thorne/BA4444CD48D86F0012221F3B832E04D6
  25. https://www.enotes.com/topics/doctor-thorne/characters
  26. https://literariness.org/2025/05/02/analysis-of-anthony-trollopes-doctor-thorne/
  27. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/literature-and-writing/doctor-thorne-analysis-major-characters
  28. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chapterII
  29. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chap15
  30. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chapterIX
  31. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chap36
  32. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chap16
  33. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chap37
  34. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3166/3166-h/3166-h.htm#chapterXXIV
  35. https://trollopesociety.org/bulletin/2021/on-rereading-doctor-thorne-half-a-century-later/
  36. https://arizona.aws.openrepository.com/bitstream/handle/10150/290300/azu_td_7223373_sip1_m.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y
  37. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/victorian-literature-and-culture/article/data/31925DD7150D39DCFEBD7B535C330DEC
  38. https://dewey.petra.ac.id/digital/get-file/5628
  39. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1300&context=etd
  40. https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/literature-and-writing/doctor-thorne-anthony-trollope
  41. https://docs.lib.purdue.edu/context/open_access_dissertations/article/1456/viewcontent/Nelson_Heather.pdf
  42. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4938084/
  43. https://www.hollywoodreporter.com/tv/tv-news/julian-fellowes-doctor-thorne-sells-875078/
  44. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4938084/fullcredits/
  45. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/05/20/arts/television/review-julian-fellowes-hosts-doctor-thorne-a-british-period-drama-on-amazon.html
  46. https://frockflicks.com/doctor-thorne-2016/
  47. https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/ast814567/doctor-thorne-viewing-figures-itv-julian-fellowes/
  48. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt4938084/awards/
  49. https://www.televisual.com/news/rts-craft-and-design-awards-announced_nid-6281/
  50. https://books.google.com/books?id=ZvV8GXvDcToC&pg=PA71
  51. https://books.google.com/books?id=ZvV8GXvDcToC&pg=PA73
  52. https://books.google.com/books?id=ZvV8GXvDcToC&pg=PA69
  53. https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/301
  54. https://egrove.olemiss.edu/aah_journal/vol33/iss2/9
  55. https://www.degruyter.com/document/doi/10.1515/9783110376715-018/html
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.