Hubbry Logo
EnnahdaEnnahdaMain
Open search
Ennahda
Community hub
Ennahda
logo
7 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Ennahda
Ennahda
Ennahda
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

The Ennahda Movement (Arabic: حركة النهضة, romanized: Ḥarakatu n-Nahḍah;[6] French: Mouvement Ennahdha), also known as the Renaissance Party or simply known as Ennahda, is a self-defined Islamic democratic[7][8][9][3] political party in Tunisia.

Key Information

Founded as the Movement of Islamic Tendency in 1981,[10] Ennahda was inspired by the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood[11] and through the latter, to Ruhollah Khomeini's own propelled ideology of "Islamic Government".[12]

In the wake of the 2011 Tunisian revolution and collapse of the government of Zine El Abidine Ben Ali, the Ennahda Movement Party was formed,[13] and in the 2011 Tunisian Constituent Assembly election (the first free election in the country's history),[14] won a plurality of 37%[14] of the popular vote[15][16][17][18] and formed the government. Uproar in the traditionally secular country over "Islamization" and assassinations of two secular politicians however, led to the 2013–14 Tunisian political crisis, and the party stepped down[19] following the implementation of a new constitution in January 2014.[20] The party came in second with 27.79% of the vote, in the 2014 Tunisian parliamentary election, forming a coalition government with the largest secular party, but did not offer or endorse a candidate in the November 2014 presidential election.[21]

In 2018, lawyers and politicians accused Ennahda of forming a secret organisation that had infiltrated security forces and the judiciary. They also claimed the party was behind the 2013 assassinations of Chokri Belaid and Mohamed Brahmi, two progressive political leaders of the leftist Popular Front electoral alliance. Ennahda denied the accusations and accused the Popular Front of slandering and distorting Ennahda. It said that the Popular Front was exploiting the two assassination cases and using blood as an excuse to reach the government after failing to do so through democratic means.[22]

Ideology

[edit]

Following 2011 and the "Arab Spring" mainstream media reports, journalist Robert F. Worth calls it "the mildest and most democratic Islamist party in history."[23] Others oppose this by highlighting the ideological adoption of the velayat-i feqih[24] by the movement's founder Rached Ghannouchi,[25] who has remained its president since 1984.

Rached Ghannouchi says textually in his book: "The Islamic government is one in which: 1- supreme legislative authority is for the shari'a, which is the revealed law of Islam, which transcends all laws. (...)" [26]

According to associate professor of political science Sebnem Gumuscu, there were competing views within the party about liberal democracy in its early years, but since the 1990s, liberal Islamists pulled Ennahda towards democratic principles.[27]

History

[edit]

Early years

[edit]

Succeeding a group known as Islamic Action, the party was founded under the name of "Movement of Islamic Tendency" (French: Mouvement de la Tendance Islamique (MTI), Arabic: حركة الاتجاه الإسلامي Ḥarakatu l-Ittijāhu l-Islāmī) in 1981.[10][28] After the Tunisian bread riots in January 1984 the government suspected the MTI of involvement in the disturbances, and arrested many of its supporters. The MTI leaders had encouraged their followers to join in the riots, but the government produced no proof that they had organized them. The persecution of the MTI enhanced its reputation as an organization committed to helping the people.[29] In 1989, it changed its name to Ḥarakat Ennahḍha.[30]

The party has been described as one of many parties/movements in Muslim states "that grew up alongside the Iranian revolution",[31] and it was originally inspired by the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood.[11] The group supported the 1979 takeover of the U.S. embassy in Tehran, claiming that "It was not an embassy, but a spy centre".[31][32] Their influence in 1984 was such that, according to Robin Wright, a British journalist living in Tunisia, stated that the Islamic Tendency was "the single most threatening opposition force in Tunis. One word from the fundamentalists will close down the campus or start a demonstration."[33]

Rached Ghannouchi speaking at an Islamist rally around 1980.

Although traditionally shaped by the thinking of Islamist thinkers Sayyid Qutb and Maududi, the party began to be described as "moderate Islamist" in the 1980s when it advocated democracy and a "Tunisian" form of Islamism recognizing political pluralism and a "dialogue" with the West. Its main leader Rached Ghannouchi, has been criticized for calling for jihad against Israel[34] and "openly threatened U.S. interests, supported Iraq against the United States and campaigned against the Arab-Israeli peace process".[35] Others described him as "widely considered ... a moderate who believes that Islam and democracy are compatible".[36]

In the 1989 elections, President Ben Ali banned the party from participating but allowed some members to run as independents. These received between 10% and 17% of the vote nationally according to official figures of the regime,[37] and despite what some observers thought was "widespread fraud".[36] Allegedly surprised by Ennahda's popularity,[36] two years later Ben Ali banned the movement and jailed 25,000 activists. Many Ennahda members went into exile.[36]

Ennahda's newspaper Al-Fajr was banned in Tunisia and its editor, Hamadi Jebali, was sentenced to sixteen years imprisonment in 1992 for membership in the un-authorized organisation and for "aggression with the intention of changing the nature of the state". The Arabic language television station El Zaytouna is believed to be connected with Ennahda. The party was strongly repressed in the late 1980s and early 1990s and almost completely absent from Tunisia from 1992 until the post-revolutionary period.[38] "Tens of thousands" of Islamists were imprisoned or exiled during this time.[16]

Revolution and return to political scene

[edit]

In the wake of the Tunisian Revolution, thousands of people welcomed Rached Ghannouchi on his return to Tunis. The party was described as moving "quickly to carve out a place" in the Tunisian political scene, "taking part in demonstrations and meeting with the prime minister."[39] Earlier Ghannouchi announced that the party had "signed a shared statement of principles with the other Tunisian opposition groups".[40] The New York Times reported mixed predictions among Tunisians for the party's success, with some believing the party would enjoy support in the inland part of Tunisia, but others saying Tunisia was "too secular" for the Ennahda Party to gain broad support.[40] On 22 January 2011, in an interview with Al Jazeera TV, Rached Ghannouchi confirmed that he is against an Islamic Caliphate, and supports democracy instead, unlike Hizb ut-Tahrir, (whom Ghannouchi accuses of exporting a distorted understanding of Islam).[41]

Members of the Ennahda Party, 2011

The party was legalised on 1 March 2011.[42] A March 2011 opinion poll found the Ennahda Party ranked first among political parties in Tunisia with 29%, followed by the Progressive Democratic Party at 12.3% and the Ettajdid Movement at 7.1%.[43] It was also found that 61.4% of Tunisians "ignore political parties in the country."[43] This success has caused some secularist to call for the postponing of elections in what many described as "secularism extremism" who were hellbent on denying Ennahda forming the government despite what election observers described as free and fair democratic process.

In May 2011, Ennahda's General Secretary Hamadi Jebali traveled to Washington, D.C., on the invitation of the Center for the Study of Islam and Democracy[44] He also met U.S. Senators John McCain and Joe Lieberman.[45]

Ennahda's leaders have been described as "highly sensitive to the fears among other West about Islamic party". "We are not an Islamist party, we are an Islamic party, that also gets its bearings by the principles of the Quran." Moreover, he named Turkey a model, regarding the relation of state and religion, and compared the party's Islamic democratic ideology to Christian democracy in Italy and Germany.[46]

On a press conference in June 2011, the Ennahda Party presented itself as modern and democratic and introduced a female member who wore a headscarf and a member who didn't, and announced the launching of a youth wing. Süddeutsche Zeitung noted that, unlike leftist parties of Tunisia, the moderately Islamic party is not against a market economy.[47]

On 31 December 2021, Ennahda claimed in a statement that the party's Vice President and member of the Tunisian parliament, Noureddine Bhiri, had been abducted by “security forces with civilian clothes and taken to an unknown destination.”[48][49] On 2 January 2022, AFP reported that Bhiri had been rushed to intensive care at a hospital in the northern town Bizerte and was in a "critical condition".[50] The speaker of Tunisia's suspended parliament, Rached Ghannouchi wrote to President Kais Saied asking him to reveal Bhiri's whereabouts and condition.[51]

2011 Constituent Assembly election

[edit]
Ennahda members in the Constituent Assembly

Ahead of the Constituent Assembly election on 23 October 2011, the party conducted extensive electoral campaign, extensively providing potential voters, especially from the lower class, with promotional gifts, meals for the end of Ramadan feasts, and sponsoring events.[52]

In the 23 October 2011 Tunisian Constituent Assembly election, the first free election in the country's history with a turn out of 51.1% of all eligible voters,[14] the Ennahda Party won 37.04% of the vote (more than the next four biggest vote-getters combined) and 89 of the 217 seats,[53] making it by far the strongest party in the legislature.

According to scholar Noah Feldman, rather than being a "puzzling disappointment for the forces of democracy", the Ennahda victory is a natural outcome of inevitable differences between revolution's leaders and the fact that "Tunisians see Islam as a defining feature of their personal and political identities." Rached Ghannouchi, the party's leader was one of the few "voices of resistance to the regime in the last 20 years."[15]

Subsequently, it agreed with the two runners-up, the centre-left secular Congress for the Republic (CPR) and Ettakatol, to co-operate in the Assembly and to share the three highest positions in state.[54] Accordingly, Ennahda supported the election of Ettakatol's secretary-general Mustapha Ben Jafar as President of the Constituent Assembly,[55] and of CPR-leader Moncef Marzouki as Interim President of the Republic. The latter, in exchange, immediately appointed Ennahda's secretary-general Hamadi Jebali as Prime Minister.[56]

2011–2014 Troika government

[edit]

Ennahda was part of the Troika government, along with Ettakatol, and CPR.[57] The government was criticized for mediocre economic performance, not stimulating the tourism industry, poor relations with Tunisia's biggest trading partner France. In particular it was criticized for not monitoring and controlling radical Islamists (such as Ansar al-Sharia) who were blamed for, among other things, attempting to Islamise the country, the 2012 ransacking and burning of the American embassy.

The Troika government faced many challenges domestically and regionally including reviving an economy that had contracted by 1.9% after the Revolution,[58] rising unemployment, managing the influx of over a million Libyan refugees due to the Libyan war,[59] and a wave of social protests.   The Troika government reasserted state control over 80 percent of the mosques that had been taken over by extremists in the chaotic period immediately after the revolution.[60]

On 19 February 2013, following the assassination of Chokri Belaid and ensuing protests, Prime Minister Hamadi Jebali resigned from his office,[61] a move which was deemed unprecedented by analysts.[62] The move followed his attempt to form a technocratic government. Ennahda, however, rejected his resignation insisting on a government of politicians and Jebali formally resigned after a meeting with President Moncef Marzouki saying it was in the best interests of the country. He said: "I promised if my initiative did not succeed I would resign as head of the government, and this is what I am doing following my meeting with the president. Today there is a great disappointment among the people and we must regain their trust and this resignation is a first step."[63]

Party leader Rached Ghannouchi then suggested a government of politicians and technocrats, while Jebali suggested that if he was tasked with forming a new government it would have to include non-partisan ministers and a variety of political representation that would lead to a new election.[63] Unnamed opposition figures welcomed the resignation. The same day, Standard & Poor's downgraded Tunisia's credit rating.[64] However, the IMF said that it was still in talks for a US$1.78 billion loan to the country.[65] On 14 March 2013, Ali Larayedh was elected as Ennahda's new Secretary General and officially took over as Tunisia's new Prime Minister.[66]

Ennahda ceded control of key ministries to technocrats, including foreign affairs, defence and the interior. Ennahda made up 28% of the government, down from 40% in the previous coalition, with independents forming 48% of the new cabinet.[67]

After stabilization of the political situation, the assassination of Mohamed Brahmi, member of the Assembly, in July 2013, led to turmoil and political deadlock. Following a National Dialogue and recognizing the continued need for national unity, on 5 October a "road map" was signed,[68] and in January 2014, Ennahda, CPR and Ettakattol stepped down and handed power to a caretaker technocratic government, led by Mehdi Jomaa, to prepare and organize the second democratic elections. Ghanouchi worked with secularist leader Beji Caid Essebsi to forge a compromise agreement, both were heavily criticized by their party rank and file and Ghanouchi received agreement from the Ennahda shura council after threatening to resign.[69] Outside observers called it a "model transition".[70]

In January 2014, after the new Tunisian Constitution was adopted by popular vote, Ennahda came second in the October 2014 parliamentary election with 27.79% of the popular vote and formed a coalition government with the larger secularist party Nidaa Tounes.

Ennahda did not put forward or endorse any candidate for the November 2014 presidential election.[21] Ghanouchi "hinted broadly" that he personally supported Beji Caid Essebsi,[71] (who won with over 55% of the vote).

2014–present

[edit]

In the 2014 Tunisian parliamentary election, Ennahda candidate Jamilia Ksiksi became Tunisia's first black female MP.[72]

Ennahda became the largest party in parliament in the 2019 election, but with just 52 of 217 seats, Ennahda attempted to court supporters of Kais Saied, the first-round winner of the presidential elections.[73] Ennahda not only backed Saied in the runoff elections, but also attempted to persuade Saied voters that Ennahda was their best opportunity for building a government supportive of a Saied president.[74] In February 2020 Ennahdha issued an official statement saying it will grant confidence to the Fakhfakh Cabinet.[75] The Fakhfakh administration had 32 members, six of whom were from Ennahda.[76]

In 2021, Ennahda faced widespread public anger as the country experienced a political crisis due to 2021 Tunisian protests. President Kais Saied dismissed the government and froze parliament, a move labeled a coup by Parliament Speaker Rached Ghannouchi.[77]

The Tunisian government has detained at least 17 current or former members of the party, including its head, and closed its offices around the nation since December 2022.[78] Tunisian authorities apprehended Ghannouchi and searched his headquarters in April 2023.[79]

Ennahda announced on the occasion of its 42nd anniversary that it would be unable to hold its eleventh congress due to "oppressive retaliatory measures taken by the authorities against the party's leader, some of its leaders, and its headquarters, which hinder the party's work and institutions.[80]

Chairmen

[edit]

During its first ten years of existence, presidency of Ennahda changed very often, while its leading figure Rached Ghannouchi was jailed until 1984 and then again in 1987. After going to exile he remained the party's "intellectual leader".[15] In November 1991 he also took back the formal presidency.

Following is a list of all former presidents of the party:[81]

  • June–July 1981: Abderraouf Bouabi
  • July–October 1981: Fadhel Beldi
  • October 1981 – August 1984: Hamadi Jebali
  • November 1984 – August 1987: Rached Ghannouchi
  • August 1987 – April 1988: Salah Karker
  • April–October 1988: Jamel Aoui
  • October 1988 – March 1991: Sadok Chourou
  • March 1991: Mohamed Kaloui
  • March 1991: Mohamed Akrout
  • April–June 1991: Mohamed Ben Salem
  • June–September 1991: Habib Ellouze
  • October 1991: Noureddine Arbaoui
  • October –November 1991: Walid Bennani
  • since November 1991: Rached Ghannouchi

Political positions

[edit]

In the wake of the compromise worked out by Ghanouchi and Beji Caid Essebsi, the party (or at least its leader), has been complimented for it willingness to compromise,[82] protecting Tunisia's democracy and civil peace from Egyptian style violence. However some Islamists see the party as having lost an opportunity to reverse the "social framework" of secularism in the country.[82][83]

The party is generally described as socially centrist with mild support for economic liberalism and has been compared to European Christian democrats.[62] However, liberals accuse its leaders of "doublespeak" in this regard.[84] The party wishes to revise the strong secular, Arab nationalist, and socialist principles that predominate among the other parties, and instead allow Islam into public life and be more accommodating to other viewpoints such as closer relations with the West and greater economic freedom. The party currently rejects radical Islamism as a form of governance appropriate for Tunisia, nevertheless Islam remains an important feature of the party;[85] in a debate with a secular opponent Ghannouchi stated, "Why are we put in the same place as a model that is far from our thought, like the Taliban or the Saudi model, while there are other successful Islamic models that are close to us, like the Turkish, the Malaysian, and the Indonesian models; models that combine Islam and modernity?"[86]

Political scientist Riadh Sidaoui explains that the Ennahda leader models his approach on the moderate Islamism of Turkey; he says: "The leadership was forced into exile in London for a long time [because of harassment by Tunisian police] and understood about the need to have a balanced outlook... No one wants a repeat of the 1991 Algerian scenario."[87]

On 13 November 2011, the party's secretary-general Hamadi Jebali held a joint rally in Sousse together with a parliamentary deputy of the Palestinian Hamas party. Jebali referred to the occasion as "a divine moment in a new state, and in, hopefully, a 6th caliphate," and that "the liberation of Tunisia will, God willing, bring about the liberation of Jerusalem." While the tone was said do be sharply in contrast to official statements of the party,[88] Jebali was appointed Prime Minister of Tunisia a mere month later.

When in January 2012, Hamas leadership arrived for another visit to Tunisia, people at the airport were heard shouting "Kill the Jews." Tunisian Jews said Ennahda leadership was slow to condemn the shouting.[89]

Ahmed Ibrahim of the Tunisian Democratic Modernist Pole political bloc complained to a foreign journalist that Ennahda appears "soft" on television, "but in the mosques, it is completely different. Some of them are calling for jihad".[90] The general manager of Al Arabiya wrote an editorial expressing the opinion that Ennahda is fundamentally a conservative Islamist party with a moderate leadership.[91] Ennahda has been described as a mixed bag with moderate top layers and a base defined by "a distinctly fundamentalist tilt".[92]

Although the party has expressed support for women's rights and equality of civil rights between men and women, the party chose to place only two women at first position out of 33 regional lists for the Tunisian Constituent Assembly. Ghannouchi noted that women have not held any de facto leadership positions under Ben Ali's governments and that it is a reality that only a few women are currently suited to leadership posts.[93]

The party is more moderate in urbanized areas such as Tunis, where secular and socially liberal beliefs predominate. However, Ennahda's compromises and abandoning of political Islam has made their core supporters lose faith in them.[62] Perhaps as a result, in 2018, the party declared that it would vote down a bill that would end gender discrimination and implement inheritance equality between men and women,[94] justifying its position because the bill proposed by the Tunisian president Beji Caid Essebsi is against the Quran and the beliefs of Tunisian people. The position sparked outrage among Tunisian progressives and liberals who accused the party of lying about its embrace of democracy, and turning back to its Islamic radical origins.

According to a 2020 study, members of parliament in the Ennahda movement who had lived abroad in secular democracies had more liberal voting records than their counterparts who had only lived in Tunisia.[95]

Homosexuality

[edit]

The party and its leaders have taken very hostile positions against homosexuality. In 2012, Samir Dilou, then minister of human rights and leader of Ennahda, said the LGBT people have no right to free speech, and they should respect the religion and heritage of Tunisia, he also said that homosexuality is a sexual perversion and a mental illness.[96] Amnesty International said that it was deeply disappointed by the comments of Dilou, especially since his portfolio is human rights.[97]

The presidential candidate of Ennahda in 2019, Abdelfattah Mourou, stated that homosexuality is a personal choice and that individual freedoms should be respected, but at the same time announced his support for the continuation of criminalization of homosexuality in Tunisia, where sodomy is punished by 3 years of imprisonment.[98]

In 2021, Fathi Layouni, Ennahda mayor of Le Kram, declared to a local radio station that the natural place for homosexuals is either prisons or psychiatric hospitals and that they are forbidden from entering his city. He also demanded the closure of the Association Shams, which is a Tunisian organization for LGBT rights.[99]

Election results

[edit]
Election year # of total votes % of overall vote # of seats Government
Constituent Assembly of Tunisia
2011 1,501,320 37.04%
89 / 217
 Coalition(2011–2014)
Technocratic Government (2014–2015)
Assembly of the Representatives of the People
2014 947,034 27.79%
69 / 217
 Coalition
2019 561,132 19.63%
52 / 217
 Coalition

See also

[edit]

Notes

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Ennahda

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia

The Ennahda Movement is a Tunisian rooted in Islamist ideology, founded in 1981 as the Movement of the Islamic Tendency by and Abdelfattah Mourou amid opposition to the secular authoritarian regime of . Drawing initial inspiration from the , Ennahda has since rebranded itself as a proponent of "Muslim ," emphasizing compatibility between Islamic principles, multiparty pluralism, and while rejecting . Following the 2011 Tunisian Revolution that ousted President Zine el-Abidine Ben Ali, Ennahda secured a plurality in the October 2011 elections for the , forming a that navigated the democratic transition amid economic challenges and rising security threats. The party led efforts to draft the 2014 constitution, compromising with secular opponents to establish a that omitted as a primary legal source and enshrined freedoms of belief and equality, marking a shift from rigid Islamist demands. However, its tenure faced controversies over perceived economic mismanagement contributing to stagnation and , as well as criticism for insufficient crackdowns on salafist networks that fueled a surge in jihadist attacks, including the 2015 Sousse and Museum incidents. Ennahda's electoral dominance waned after 2014, with subsequent losses attributed to governance failures and internal divisions, culminating in sharp decline under President Kais Saied's 2021 suspension of and power consolidation, which prompted Ghannouchi's 2023 arrest on terrorism-related charges and party fragmentation. Despite these setbacks, Ennahda's adaptation from to institutional player highlights tensions between Islamist mobilization and pragmatic governance in post-revolutionary , where empirical outcomes like persistent and inequality underscore causal limits of ideological moderation absent structural reforms.

Origins and Ideology

Founding and Early Influences

The Ennahda Movement traces its origins to the Islamic Tendency Movement (MTI), established on June 6, 1981, by and Abdel Fattah Mourou in . This founding occurred amid growing Islamist sentiment against the secular policies of President Habib Bourguiba's regime, which had suppressed religious expression in favor of a French-inspired modernization model. The MTI positioned itself as a revivalist force advocating for the integration of Islamic principles into public life, drawing from broader transnational Islamist currents. Ideologically, the MTI was heavily influenced by the Muslim Brotherhood's emphasis on Islamic revivalism, as articulated by figures such as , who promoted societal reform through moral and educational renewal, and , whose critiques of Western secularism underscored the need for governance aligned with . These influences shaped Ennahda's early opposition to Tunisia's , viewing it as a form of that eroded traditional values and . The movement sought to foster an Islamic society emphasizing ethical governance, anti-colonial resistance, and welfare provisions rooted in religious doctrine, rather than purely political power. In its nascent phase, the MTI engaged in underground activities to evade state repression, including the establishment of clandestine mosque-based networks for preaching (dawa) and community organizing. Student groups at universities formed key recruitment and mobilization hubs, where activists challenged the dominant secular narratives through informal study circles and publications critiquing Bourguiba's reforms. These efforts laid the groundwork for a grassroots base, focusing on cultural and educational outreach to counter the regime's control over religious institutions. In 1988, the group rebranded as the Ennahda Movement, signaling a more explicit political orientation while retaining its Islamist core.

Ideological Evolution from Islamism to Muslim Democracy

Ennahda, originally founded as the Movement of Islamic Tendency in 1981, initially advocated for an governed by principles, drawing inspiration from the and emphasizing the implementation of Islamic law in public life. Prior to the 2011 revolution, the party's clandestine operations under Ben Ali's regime reinforced its Islamist identity, with founder articulating a vision of that integrated religious authority with governance. Following Tunisia's 2011 uprising, Ennahda's participation in democratic processes prompted a pragmatic reevaluation, culminating in its 10th congress from May 20 to 22, 2016, where the party formally separated its political activities from religious preaching and cultural missions. This rebranding positioned Ennahda as a "Muslim Democratic" party, endorsing pluralism, human rights, and democratic institutions while maintaining Islam as a moral and cultural reference rather than a legal blueprint. Ghannouchi, re-elected as leader, framed this evolution as reconciling Islamic values with modern democracy, as detailed in his essays advocating for civic freedoms and opposition to clerical rule. Core tenets of this shift include the compatibility of with multiparty , rejection of , and acceptance of alternating power through elections, evidenced by Ennahda's updated party statutes prioritizing national consensus over literal application. However, the party retained advocacy for -inspired personal status s, reflecting a selective rather than wholesale abandonment of Islamist roots. Ghannouchi's writings, such as those compiled in On Muslim Democracy, emphasize 's inherent pluralism and support for , positioning Muslim as an alternative to that avoids imposing religious doctrine on non-believers. Critics, including internal hardliners and external analysts, debate the authenticity of this transformation, arguing it may represent tactical driven by electoral pressures and necessities rather than profound ideological change. Empirical indicators, such as ideal point analyses of parliamentary voting patterns, show Ennahda deputies converging toward centrist positions post-2011, suggesting genuine influenced by exposure to democratic institutions. Yet, persistent pushes for constitutional references to Islamic identity highlight incomplete , with some observers viewing the 2016 declaration as a strategic pivot to broaden appeal amid secular competition. Party documents from the congress affirm the shift's internal legitimacy, though factional tensions underscore ongoing negotiations between traditionalists and reformers.

Historical Development

Underground Operations Under Ben Ali (1981–2010)

Following the 1987 seizure of power by , the Islamic Tendency Movement (MTI), rebranded as Ennahda in 1988, sought legalization as a but was denied recognition by the regime. This refusal prompted initial tensions, including sporadic clashes between Ennahda sympathizers and security forces in the late 1980s, amid broader unrest. By 1989, leader fled to exile in , where he coordinated opposition activities from abroad, evading intensifying repression. The regime escalated crackdowns in the early , culminating in mass arrests after authorities alleged an Ennahda-orchestrated coup plot in 1991. Hundreds of members faced trials, with widespread reports of in detention; Ghannouchi was sentenced to in absentia. By 1992, Ennahda was formally banned, forcing the movement underground and into exile networks primarily in , where Ghannouchi continued ideological propagation through writings and international advocacy. Domestic cadres endured isolation, with estimates of thousands imprisoned over the decades, sustaining loyalty through clandestine cells. Post-1989, Ennahda adopted a strategic commitment to non-violence, rejecting armed resistance to avoid justifying further authoritarian measures and to appeal to broader democratic aspirations. Underground operations focused on infiltrating —via mosques, universities, and charitable networks—to build grassroots support, capitalizing on public disillusionment with Ben Ali's corruption and . This resilience, bolstered by exiles' European platforms, preserved organizational cohesion despite severe constraints, positioning Ennahda for resurgence after Ben Ali's 2011 ouster.

Emergence and Dominance Post-2011 Revolution

Following the ouster of President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali on January 14, 2011, Ennahda leader returned from 22 years of exile in on January 30, 2011, where he was greeted by thousands of supporters at airport. The party's formal legalization came on March 1, 2011, when Tunisia's interim government lifted the ban imposed under Ben Ali, allowing Ennahda to operate openly after decades of repression and enabling its participation in upcoming elections. This rapid rehabilitation capitalized on Ennahda's established underground networks and public perception of its members as political prisoners victimized by the secular authoritarian regime, contrasting with the discredited elites of the Ben Ali era. In the October 23, 2011, election for the National Constituent Assembly—the first free vote since —Ennahda secured a plurality with approximately 37 percent of the vote, translating to 89 of 217 seats, outpacing over 100 competing parties due to its superior grassroots organization and the fragmented opposition. This outcome reflected less a sweeping endorsement of Islamist and more a backlash against the secular Ben Ali system's corruption and repression, with Ennahda benefiting from voter turnout favoring change amid secular parties' disarray post-revolution. Unable to govern alone, Ennahda formed the Troika coalition with two smaller secular parties, Congress for the Republic (CPR) and Ettakatol, to share power and draft a new . As the dominant force in , Ennahda played a pivotal role in negotiating the 2014 , adopted on January 26, 2014, where it successfully incorporated references to as Tunisia's religion and a source of inspiration, while compromising by dropping demands for as a legal source amid secular pushback. These inclusions marked a partial infusion of Islamic identity into the state framework, balanced against protections for , though they fueled debates over the document's secular-Islamist equilibrium. Ennahda's ascent, however, coincided with emerging Islamist-secular tensions, exemplified by Salafist unrest in 2012, including riots against perceived insults to and clashes with , which secularists attributed to Ennahda's perceived leniency toward ultraconservative groups challenging the post-revolutionary order. Such incidents highlighted fractures between Ennahda's moderate pragmatism and harder-line Salafi elements, underscoring that the party's dominance stemmed from anti-regime sentiment rather than unified consensus on its vision.

Troika Governance and Challenges (2011–2014)

Following Ennahda's victory in the October 2011 elections, where it secured 89 of 217 seats in the (NCA), the party formed the Troika coalition government with the secular Congress for the Republic (CPR) and Ettakatol parties. Ennahda's Hamadi Jebali was appointed on December 24, 2011, leading efforts to stabilize the post-revolutionary transition amid economic contraction—GDP growth fell to 0% in 2011—and rising insecurity from returning jihadists and Salafi groups like Ansar al-Sharia. Jebali resigned on February 19, 2013, after failing to form a non-partisan cabinet following the February 6 assassination of opposition leader Chokri Belaid, which triggered nationwide protests accusing Ennahda of complicity with extremists; Ali Laarayedh, also from Ennahda, succeeded him on March 13, 2013. The Troika pursued a consensus-driven , adopting the 2014 document on January 26 after Ennahda withdrew its proposal for as a "complementary" source of amid secular opposition and protests, resulting in provisions emphasizing freedoms of belief, expression, and while recognizing Islam's cultural role without enshrining Islamic law. However, faltered under persistent challenges: hovered above 15%, revenues plummeted due to instability, and jihadist violence escalated, including the July 25, 2013, of Mohamed Brahmi—using the same weapon as in Belaid's killing—further eroding public trust and prompting opposition boycotts of the NCA. Critics, including secular parties, attributed policy paralysis to Ennahda's perceived leniency toward Salafists, despite crackdowns, as thousands of Tunisians joined jihadist ranks abroad. Facing deadlock and mass demonstrations, Laarayedh resigned on January 9, 2014, paving the way for technocratic Mehdi Jomaa and the Troika's dissolution, marking Ennahda's exit from power after three years of rule criticized for failing to deliver economic reforms or decisively counter while navigating Islamist-secular tensions.

Electoral Setbacks and Opposition Role (2014–2021)

In the October 26, , parliamentary elections, Ennahda secured 69 seats in the 217-member Assembly of the Representatives of the People, placing second behind , which won 85 seats. This outcome marked a significant decline from Ennahda's 89 seats in the 2011 , reflecting voter fatigue with the economic stagnation and security challenges during the prior Troika government, which Ennahda had led. In response, Ennahda conceded defeat and transitioned to an opposition role while pragmatically supporting Beji Caid Essebsi's presidential bid and the formation of a secular-led , emphasizing national consensus over confrontation. Ennahda's adaptation to minority status involved internal ideological recalibration, culminating in its 10th in May 2016, where the party voted to separate its political activities from da'wa (proselytizing), establishing a distinct entity for religious preaching to reinforce its commitment to partisan specialization. This decision, debated since the early , aimed to shed Islamist connotations and align with democratic pluralism, though it sparked tensions among traditionalists who viewed da'wa as integral to the movement's identity. Externally, Ennahda cooperated with secular rivals like on anti-corruption measures and constitutional reforms, adopting rhetoric framing itself as a "nationalist" force prioritizing Tunisian and economic revival over transnational Islamist ties. The October 6, 2019, parliamentary elections saw Ennahda rebound as the largest party with 52 seats, outperforming fragmented secular competitors amid low turnout of 41 percent. However, in the concurrent presidential race, Ennahda's candidate Abdelfattah Mourou garnered only 12.9 percent in the first round, failing to advance as independent won decisively. This positioned Ennahda to negotiate roles while maintaining opposition vigilance, continuing pragmatic alliances on governance issues like , though its deradicalized posture faced skepticism from critics attributing persistent polarization to unresolved ideological ambiguities. Throughout this period, Ennahda's voter base eroded due to lingering economic woes—unemployment hovered above 15 percent, with GDP growth averaging under 2 percent annually—partly traced to shortcomings during its 2011–2014 , fostering disillusionment among and urban constituencies. Ennahda's consensus-building efforts mitigated outright gridlock but contributed to a fragmented political landscape, where its alliances with former adversaries underscored tactical flexibility yet raised questions about the durability of its pivot from Islamist roots to pragmatic opposition.

Opposition to Saied's Consolidation and Recent Crises (2021–Present)

On July 25, 2021, President suspended parliament, dismissed Prime Minister , and assumed executive powers, actions Ennahda condemned as a constitutional coup and violation of democratic norms. The party, holding the largest bloc in the suspended assembly, called for national to restore legislative functions and rejected Saied's moves as undemocratic, aligning with broader opposition accusations of power seizure. Ennahda faced intensified repression following Saied's consolidation, including mass arrests of its leaders on charges of , , and foreign funding. , the party's founder and longtime leader, was arrested on April 17, 2023, and has remained detained since, receiving multiple convictions: one year in May 2023 for , three years in February 2024 for receiving illicit foreign funds, and 14 years in July 2025 for plotting against the state. Dozens of other Ennahda officials, including former ministers and parliamentarians, were similarly targeted in 2023–2025, with trials for economic crimes and security threats yielding prison terms amid claims by authorities of graft cleanup and by critics of politically motivated suppression. In response to electoral reforms under Saied's 2022 constitution, Ennahda boycotted or was effectively sidelined in key votes, contributing to its electoral marginalization. The party abstained from the 2022 parliamentary elections, citing undemocratic conditions, which saw record-low turnout of 11.2%. In the October 6, 2024, presidential election, opposition figures including Ennahda affiliates were imprisoned or barred, enabling Saied's landslide victory with 90.7% of votes on just 28.8% turnout, reflecting suppressed dissent and voter disillusionment. Internal fragmentation exacerbated Ennahda's decline, with factional exits, leadership disputes, and funding disruptions from convictions weakening organizational cohesion since 2021. Despite this, the party sustained resistance through street protests, joining demonstrations in 2023 and 2025 against Saied's rule, though its electoral base eroded amid ongoing crises and state pressure. Overall, Ennahda's opposition yielded limited institutional gains, highlighting the causal impact of judicial and security measures in curtailing its influence.

Leadership and Organization

Key Leaders and Chairmen

Rached Ghannouchi, born in 1941, co-founded the Ennahda Movement in June 1981 alongside Abdelfattah Mourou as a response to the secular authoritarianism of President Habib Bourguiba's regime. Ghannouchi emerged as the party's primary ideologue and long-serving president, shaping its evolution from an underground Islamist group influenced by the Muslim Brotherhood to a proponent of "Muslim democracy" during his exile in London from 1989 to 2011. His writings, such as those advocating Islamic pluralism and compatibility between sharia and modern governance, positioned Ennahda as moderate within the Islamist spectrum, though critics, including anti-extremism analysts, have accused him of underlying loyalty to transnational Brotherhood networks and employing taqiyya (strategic dissimulation) to mask radical aims. Ghannouchi's leadership faced severe repression under , including multiple imprisonments and torture in the 1980s, which radicalized some early members but prompted his ideological shift toward pragmatic pluralism through dialogues with European intellectuals during exile. Upon returning post-2011 , he guided Ennahda's participation in coalition governments, emphasizing consensus-building, yet his tenure ended amid internal strife and external pressures following President Kais Saied's 2021 power consolidation. In April 2023, Ghannouchi was arrested on charges of conspiracy against the state and incitement, linked to alleged support for jihadist travel to conflict zones, leading to his ongoing detention and a reported death sentence in absentia by mid-2024, exacerbating party fragmentation. Abdelfattah Mourou, the other co-founder, served as an early influential figure and later as Ennahda's interim president after the 2019 legislative elections, running as the party's presidential candidate that year and securing 12.9% of the vote. Mourou advocated for Ennahda's "political specialization" in 2016, separating da'wa (missionary) activities from partisanship to appeal to secular voters, reflecting moderation efforts amid governance critiques. Hamadi Jebali, an early executive from 1981 to 1984 and later (2011–2013), represented the party's technocratic wing but resigned amid post-revolution instability, highlighting tensions between ideological purity and pragmatic rule. Post-2021, Ennahda's intensified with over 100 officials resigning amid demands for Ghannouchi's ouster as parliamentary speaker, leading to interim arrangements and factional splits between loyalists and reformers, though no permanent successor has consolidated power by 2025. These dynamics, compounded by Saied's crackdowns, have weakened Ennahda's cohesion, with trials of veteran leaders underscoring the personal costs of their Islamist commitments.

Internal Structure and Factions

Ennahda's internal structure is governed by a public charter that establishes a hierarchical framework centered on the Shura Council, a 150-member body elected partly by a general congress representing regional branches and party affiliates. The Shura Council serves as the highest decision-making authority between congresses, selecting the executive bureau—typically 7 to 11 members—and the party chairman, while overseeing policy formulation and disciplinary matters. Regional coordination occurs through provincial offices and local cells, which evolved post-2011 from clandestine networks under Ben Ali's repression into formalized party apparatuses to facilitate electoral mobilization and grassroots organization. This shift from militant, underground cells—characterized by secretive recruitment and survival tactics—to a conventional structure after the 2011 revolution enabled Ennahda to integrate into Tunisia's democratic institutions, though it strained traditional Islamist cohesion by prioritizing electoral over ideological purity. The 2016 "specialization" decision, ratified by the Shura Council, further separated political activities from religious preaching (da'wa), decentralizing some functions to affiliated groups but centralizing strategic control at the top, which critics argue diluted internal democratic accountability. Factional tensions have historically pitted hardline Islamists—favoring as a constitutional foundation and stricter enforcement of religious norms—against pragmatists advocating compromise for democratic inclusion, as evident in debates over the 2014 constitution where hardliners conceded to secular provisions amid pressures. Post-2021, rifts deepened over toward President Kais Saied's power consolidation, with pragmatists pushing for negotiated alliances and hardliners demanding uncompromising opposition; this led to mass resignations of over 100 officials in September 2021, who accused leadership of and failure to unify against Saied's measures. Funding primarily derives from membership dues, private donations, and state allocations under Tunisia's political finance law, yet transparency has faced scrutiny amid allegations of illicit foreign contributions, including a court audit citing undeclared inflows and a 2021 prosecutorial probe into anonymous and overseas campaign funds potentially violating caps. Ennahda has denied irregularities, emphasizing internal s, but persistent investigations into leaders' assets—such as claims of amassed wealth by figures like —have fueled debates on accountability, with no convictions reported as of 2023 despite evidentiary demands from opponents.

Political Positions

Views on Democracy, Economy, and Governance

Ennahda's ideological framework positions as compatible with Islamic principles, emphasizing a "civil democratic state" that ensures multiparty pluralism, free elections, and rotation of power. Party founder has argued that inherently supports democratic governance, viewing as a mechanism for collective (interpretation) rather than divine dictation, and asserting that greater freedoms and democratic participation serve as antidotes to . This stance distinguishes Ennahda from more rigid Islamist groups by rejecting in favor of where religious texts inform but do not override electoral mandates. In economic policy, Ennahda advocates a hybrid model integrating with derived from , such as (obligatory charity) and prohibitions on to promote equitable wealth distribution. The party has evolved from earlier socialist-leaning rhetoric toward endorsing private enterprise, foreign investment, and fiscal , while critiquing unchecked for exacerbating inequality; Ghannouchi has invoked Quranic injunctions like "God loves the rich" to justify as a good when paired with solidarity mechanisms. This approach contrasts with secular rivals' focus on secular welfare by embedding ethical constraints on economic actors, aiming for a "virtuous" market where fosters and reduces . On governance, Ennahda prioritizes ethical leadership rooted in religious piety and consensus-building (), seeking administrators who embody Islamic virtues to ensure accountable rule without clerical dominance. Unlike secular counterparts who emphasize technocratic expertise, Ennahda's vision integrates moral oversight into state functions, such as drives informed by faith-based integrity. Critics, however, contend this framework risks subordinating pragmatic policy to identity-driven moralism, potentially fostering gridlock by elevating ethical debates over structural reforms, as evidenced in theoretical tensions between pluralism and preferences for religiously aligned majorities. Ghannouchi has cautioned against that marginalizes minorities, yet party documents reveal an underlying preference for governance where Islamic norms guide public morality, raising questions about full parity with liberal .

Positions on Social and Cultural Issues

Ennahda has advocated for women's active participation in and public life, emphasizing complementarity within an Islamic framework rather than strict . During the drafting of the 2014 Tunisian constitution, the party supported Article 21, which declares male and female citizens equal in rights and duties, while rejecting proposals to enshrine as a primary source of legislation to avoid alienating secular constituencies. However, Ennahda opposed President Beji Caid Essebsi's 2017 draft for equal rights between sons and daughters, arguing it contravened Islamic jurisprudence where daughters typically inherit half the share of sons, thus preserving traditional family structures derived from principles in the Personal Status Code. Party leaders, including , have defended to , work, and political office—citing Ennahda's own female parliamentarians—as compatible with Islamic values, yet internal statements reveal tensions, with some members critiquing single motherhood protections as undermining family norms. On homosexuality, Ennahda maintains a stance rooted in teachings, viewing same-sex acts as prohibited and incompatible with religious morality, though the party avoids aggressive enforcement to prioritize social harmony. Founder stated in 2015 that while disapproves of , it does not mandate spying on private behaviors, reflecting a pragmatic tolerance for discretion amid Tunisia's Article 230 penal code criminalizing such acts with up to three years' imprisonment. Ennahda parliamentarian Abdellatif Mekki explicitly defended the law in 2016, describing as illegal practices posing a threat to social cohesion and rejecting LGBT associations as disruptive to public order. Critics, including observers, note this position aligns with traditionalist interpretations, contrasting Ennahda's public moderation claims, as evidenced by party affiliates labeling a "perversion" requiring treatment rather than rights-based protections. The muted discourse underscores a strategic restraint, avoiding confrontation while upholding doctrinal opposition. In , Ennahda has pushed for integrating Islamic values into curricula to counter secularist legacies, promoting as essential for cultural authenticity without mandating uniformity. The party supported lifting Ben Ali-era bans on in schools and universities post-2011, framing veiling as a personal religious freedom rather than a state-imposed secular , which aligned with broader demands for observant ' denied under prior regimes. During its 2011–2014 , Ennahda's sociocultural initiatives emphasized preaching and ethical instruction to instill Islamic principles, yet compromises limited overt Islamization to maintain coalition stability. This approach highlights tensions between modernist adaptations—such as endorsing democratic pluralism—and traditionalist undertones prioritizing Sharia-derived norms, with opponents arguing the party's "Muslim Democrat" rebranding yields to Western pressures while internally defending faith-based authenticity against full .

Foreign Policy and Regional Alliances

Ennahda's foreign policy has historically diverged from Tunisia's longstanding secular, pro-Western orientation under Bourguiba and Ben Ali, emphasizing solidarity with Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated movements and states supportive of . The party, rooted in Brotherhood ideology, aligned closely with and , which provided financial and political backing during the post- transition, including over $1 billion in Qatari aid to Tunisia's Ennahda-led government between and 2014. This "revolutionary diplomacy" prioritized ties with and over traditional allies like and the UAE, reflecting Ennahda's view that secular autocracies foster instability, as evidenced by the Arab Spring uprisings against long-ruling regimes in , , and elsewhere. Following the 2013 Egyptian military coup that ousted Brotherhood-linked President , Ennahda leaders, including , condemned the intervention by as a setback for democratic inclusion of Islamists across the region, advocating instead for power-sharing models that integrate religious parties to prevent and authoritarian relapse. This stance underscored Ennahda's post-Arab Spring push for regional acceptance of Islamist participation in , positioning the party as a bridge between Brotherhood networks and moderate democratic reforms, though it strained relations with Gulf states opposed to such groups. Despite these Islamist leanings, Ennahda maintained pragmatic engagement with Western powers, particularly the , to secure economic aid and investment, totaling hundreds of millions of euros in grants and loans during its 2011–2014 governance period to stabilize Tunisia's economy amid post-revolutionary turmoil. In recent years, amid President Kais Saied's pivot toward anti-Brotherhood allies like , , and the UAE—evident in deepened military and economic pacts since 2021—Ennahda has criticized this isolationist shift as detrimental to Tunisia's stability, urging renewed EU partnerships focused on migration control, trade, and to counterbalance Gulf influence and sustain democratic norms. This dual approach highlights Ennahda's strategic balancing act, leveraging Brotherhood solidarity for ideological cohesion while pursuing Western ties for pragmatic survival, though sources note persistent skepticism from secular Tunisian elites and Western policymakers wary of Islamist governance risks.

Electoral Performance

Major Elections and Results (2011–2024)

Ennahda achieved its strongest electoral performance in the October 23, 2011, election to the National Constituent Assembly, securing 89 of 217 seats with 1,254,489 votes, equivalent to 37.04% of the valid votes cast, amid a turnout of 52.57%. This result positioned Ennahda as the leading force in post-revolution Tunisia, enabling it to form a coalition government with secular parties. In the October 26, 2014, parliamentary elections, Ennahda's support declined to 69 seats out of 217, with a vote share of approximately 27.8%, placing it second behind , which won 85 seats. Voter turnout was 67.7%, reflecting a shift toward secular opposition amid economic challenges and security concerns during Ennahda-led coalitions. In the concurrent , Ennahda supported incumbent , who advanced to a runoff but lost to with 39.0% against 56.7%. The October 6, 2019, parliamentary elections saw further erosion, with Ennahda obtaining 52 seats and 19.6% of votes (522,509), again the largest single party but requiring coalitions for governance. Turnout dropped to 41.6%, signaling disillusionment. Ennahda did not endorse a presidential candidate in the first round, where independent won outright with 72.7% in the runoff. Following President Saied's 2021 suspension of , Ennahda opposed subsequent reforms, including the July 2022 constitutional , which it . In the December 17, 2022, parliamentary under revised rules reducing seats to 161, Ennahda participated but won zero seats amid 11.2% turnout and dominance by pro-Saied independents. The party's marginalization intensified due to arrests of leaders like and legal restrictions. In the , 2024, , Ennahda called for a ; Saied secured 90.5% of votes with 28.6% turnout from 9.75 million registered voters. Ennahda's vote share decline from 37% in to under 20% by stemmed from voter backlash against and shortcomings attributed to its 2011–2014 tenure, alongside competition from secular and populist forces. Post-2021, Saied's consolidation further eroded Ennahda's institutional access, with opposition boycotts and low participation underscoring polarized Islamist-secular divides.
Election YearVote Share (%)Seats WonTotal SeatsTurnout (%)
2011 (Constituent)37.08921752.6
2014 (Parliamentary)27.86921767.7
2019 (Parliamentary)19.65221741.6
2022 (Parliamentary)N/A (minimal)016111.2

Controversies and Criticisms

Accusations of Islamist Infiltration and Taqiyya

Critics, including secular Tunisian politicians and analysts interviewed by researchers, have accused Ennahda of employing —a concept of permissible dissimulation rooted in Islamist traditions—to mask deeper ambitions of embedding Islamic governance within Tunisia's secular institutions while publicly embracing democratic pluralism. These allegations posit that Ennahda's moderation, evident in its 2016 decision to separate political and religious activities, represents tactical pragmatism rather than ideological evolution, allowing the party to infiltrate state structures through mosque networks and electoral gains without overt confrontation. Ennahda's origins as the Movement of Islamic Tendency in 1981, directly inspired by the Muslim Brotherhood's transnational model of gradualist Islamization, fuel claims that its rhetoric of compatibility between serves as a strategic , echoing Brotherhood tactics observed in and elsewhere. A primary empirical flashpoint cited by detractors is Ennahda's governance during the 2011–2014 troika period, where it won 89 of 217 seats (approximately 41%) in the October 2011 elections but refrained from enshrining as the principal source of legislation in the 2014 constitution, opting instead for Article 1's declaration of as a "Muslim state" with complementary civil s. Critics argue this compromise exemplified , as internal party debates and Rached Ghannouchi's earlier writings—such as his 1993 book Al-Hurriyat al-Ammah fi al-Dawla al-Islamiyyah advocating Islamic pluralism adaptable to modernity—contrasted with persistent pushes for religious complementarity in articles on and s, which secular opponents viewed as subversive footholds. Ghannouchi himself, in a 2012 statement, affirmed the party's rejection of imposing , emphasizing over , yet skeptics highlighted his pre-exile radicalism in the 1970s–1980s, when Ennahda precursors justified violence against Ben Ali's regime as defensive . Further evidence invoked includes Ennahda's alleged tolerance of Salafist agitation post-2011, such as the 2012 occupation of Manouba University by hardliners demanding gender segregation and veiling, which the party government addressed leniently amid broader unrest like the September 2012 U.S. embassy attacks linked to Ansar al-Sharia. Reports from think tanks describe Ennahda leaders viewing Salafis as "wayward" extensions of their base, providing rhetorical distance while avoiding crackdowns that could alienate conservative voters, thereby enabling Islamist cultural infiltration via unchecked mosque preaching and protests against perceived secular insults, like the 2012 film Persepolis. Ex-Ennahda members and secular figures, such as those in , have pointed to this as proof of a dual-track strategy: electoral moderation to consolidate power, paired with tacit support for parallel Islamist mobilization to erode secular norms over time. Ennahda defenders counter that such accusations overlook verifiable concessions, including the 2014 constitution's protections for individual freedoms and equality—ratified with Ennahda's support despite Salafist opposition—and the party's 2013 pivot against jihadists after the assassinations of Chokri Belaid and Mohamed Brahmi, which precipitated its from government. Nonetheless, persistent critiques from sources like the emphasize causal inconsistencies: Ennahda's failure to decisively purge Salafist sympathizers from its ranks or mosques during its tenure allowed radical ideologies to flourish, suggesting infiltration via institutional patience rather than outright imposition. These claims, often voiced by ideologically opposed secularists, underscore debates over Ennahda's heritage, where empirical moderation coexists with structural Islamist embeddedness in Tunisian society.

Governance Failures and Economic Stagnation

During its tenure as the dominant partner in the Troika (2011–2014), Ennahda oversaw an economy marked by sluggish growth and persistent structural weaknesses, with annual GDP expansion averaging below 2.5% after a recession in 2011 (-1.9%). This contrasted sharply with pre-revolution averages of around 5% from 1997–2010, as political instability and delayed reforms exacerbated fiscal deficits and public debt accumulation. , a key driver of the 2011 uprising, remained critically high at over 30% for ages 15–24 throughout the period, with rates exceeding 50% among university graduates due to mismatches between education outputs and market needs, alongside insufficient job creation in private sectors. Critics attribute much of this stagnation to Ennahda's prioritization of networks over bold structural adjustments, including the appointment of affiliates to state enterprises and ministries, which inflated spending without enhancing or attracting foreign . Economic policy implementation faltered amid infighting and resistance to subsidy cuts or labor market , as Ennahda leaders emphasized consensus-building in constitutional matters—such as debates over Islam's in —over urgent fiscal stabilization measures recommended by international bodies like the IMF. While Ennahda contributed to the National Dialogue Quartet's stability pact, which averted total collapse and facilitated technocratic transitions, these political gains failed to translate into economic momentum, as budgets went underutilized and tourism/phosphate sectors stagnated amid concerns. The assassinations of opposition leaders Chokri Belaid (February 6, 2013) and Mohamed Brahmi (July 25, 2013) intensified governance paralysis under the Troika, triggering mass protests, government reshuffles, and a six-month deadlock that postponed key reforms and deepened . This indecision compounded Ennahda's ideological focus, where securing provisions for religious freedoms and complementary interpretations in the 2014 constitution diverted legislative energy from pragmatic policies like privatization or export diversification, leaving reliant on volatile remittances and aid. Empirical indicators, including a budget deficit swelling to 6.5% of GDP by 2013, underscore how such sequencing—favoring before economic imperatives—prolonged malaise, with growth near zero and regional disparities widening. Ennahda's subsequent opposition role has seen it critique similar failures in later governments, yet its governing record highlights the tensions between Islamist mobilization and technocratic delivery in resource-constrained settings.

Alleged Ties to Extremism and Security Lapses

Following the 2011 Tunisian revolution, the Ennahda-led government initially pursued a policy of tolerance toward Salafist groups, including attempts at co-optation and dialogue, viewing them as potential allies in the Islamist spectrum rather than immediate threats. This approach included the release of thousands of prisoners, among them convicted jihadists, as part of post-Ben Ali amnesties, which critics argued facilitated the resurgence of groups like Ansar al-Sharia Tunisia (AST). Opponents, including secular parties, alleged that Ennahda's leniency enabled radical preaching in mosques and vigilante actions, contributing to a spike in extremist activity, such as the September 2012 attack on the U.S. embassy in Tunis. The assassinations of opposition leaders Chokri Belaid on February 6, , and Mohamed Brahmi on July 25, —both attributed to Salafist perpetrators—marked a turning point, prompting widespread protests and accusations that Ennahda's governance had fostered insecurity through lax border controls and inadequate intelligence sharing. In response, Ennahda pivoted toward cooperation, designating AST as a terrorist organization on August 26, , and supporting military operations against extremists, including enhanced border patrols to curb flows of fighters to and . This shift aligned with national dialogue processes, leading Ennahda to cede power to a technocratic in amid demands for on failures. Critics have alleged direct ties, including Ennahda members facilitating jihadist ; a 2022 judicial probe implicated senior figures, such as leader , in investigations over the dispatch of Tunisian recruits to extremist groups abroad, amid data showing as the largest source of foreign fighters to and affiliates, with over 6,000 individuals departing between 2011 and 2016. Some reports highlighted Ennahda MPs' visits to Salafist figures or implicit endorsements, though Ennahda denied orchestration and attributed to socioeconomic marginalization rather than party influence. Ennahda countered these claims by emphasizing fatwas and statements condemning violence as un-Islamic, alongside legislative pushes for anti-terror laws, though detractors questioned their sincerity as reactive measures post-crisis. Left-leaning analysts have downplayed direct links, framing jihadist surges as legacies of Ben Ali-era repression rather than Ennahda policy. Following President Kais Saied's suspension of parliament in July 2021, Tunisian authorities initiated a series of legal actions targeting Ennahda leaders and members, often on charges of conspiracy against state security. Rached Ghannouchi, Ennahda's founder and leader, was arrested on February 3, 2023, and charged with conspiracy and related offenses, leading to an initial sentence of one year in May 2023, followed by additional convictions. In April 2025, a court sentenced opposition figures, including Ennahda affiliates, to prison terms ranging from 13 to 66 years for conspiring against the state. By July 2025, Ghannouchi received a 14-year sentence in absentia for plotting against the state, amid trials criticized by human rights groups for lacking fair trial standards and serving to eliminate political rivals under the guise of anti-corruption efforts. These prosecutions extended to broader arrests of Ennahda supporters, with over 100 members detained in coordinated raids in September 2024 ahead of presidential elections, described by the party as an unprecedented campaign of violations. In May 2023, authorities moved to dismantle Ennahda through judicial measures, including threats of party dissolution, framing the actions as necessary to combat and foreign influence, though observers noted the selective targeting of Saied's primary opposition. At least 97 individuals faced in pre-election crackdowns by September 2024, exacerbating Ennahda's operational constraints while Saied's administration justified the measures as protecting against destabilizing elements. The legal pressures contributed to internal fragmentation within Ennahda, marked by vacuums from detentions and a reported decline in organizational strength post-2021. Mass resignations, including 18 members in one instance, highlighted fissures, with the party shaken by convictions and arrests leading to splintering dynamics and reduced membership cohesion. Empirical indicators of decline include diminished political influence and fading internal unity, as arrests disrupted hierarchical structures and prompted debates over strategic adaptation amid repression. While Saied's supporters viewed these developments as rooting out entrenched power, the combined external legal assaults and internal strains underscored Ennahda's vulnerabilities exposed by prolonged challenges.

Impact and Legacy

Contributions to Tunisian Democratization

Ennahda, as the largest party in the National following the October 2011 elections, initiated the drafting of Tunisia's 2014 constitution through inclusive consultations that incorporated secular and opposition voices. The party conceded on contentious issues, such as enshrining protections for and freedoms of expression, to secure broad consensus among diverse political factions. This process, marked by repeated compromises, resulted in a adopted on January 26, 2014, by 94% of assembly members, establishing a semi-presidential system with checks on executive power. Ennahda participated in the 2013-2014 national dialogue facilitated by the , which resolved a political deadlock triggered by opposition boycotts and assassinations, preventing escalation into broader conflict. The Quartet's efforts, culminating in a roadmap for transitional governance, earned the in 2015 for fostering pluralistic democracy amid post-revolutionary instability. Ennahda's adherence to this framework included ceding power to a technocratic government in January 2014, setting a for voluntary power-sharing in the Arab Spring context. Under Ennahda-led coalitions from 2011 to 2014, experienced initial expansions in , including improved press freedom and association rights, as evidenced by rising scores in international indices during this period. These gains stemmed from necessities that compelled Ennahda to moderate its positions, integrating Islamist principles with democratic pluralism to sustain . However, such moderation was pragmatic rather than ideological, driven by electoral realities and opposition pressure, with subsequent polarization underscoring the fragility of these early democratic foundations.

Long-Term Challenges to Secularism and Stability

Ennahda's normalization of Islamist discourse post-2011 challenged the secular foundations established by , who from 1956 onward enforced policies like banning the in public institutions and promoting civil law over , fostering a laicist state that marginalized religious politics. By winning 89 of 217 seats in the October 2011 elections and leading the 2014 constitution-drafting process, Ennahda elevated Islamic identity as a political priority, framing through reformist Islamic lenses rather than Bourguibist , which eroded the against public religiosity. This shift correlated with increased societal polarization, as evidenced by debates over Article 1 of the 2014 constitution designating as the while nominally protecting freedoms, yet enabling conservative pressures on issues like blasphemy laws and . Tunisia's post-revolution youth , peaking with approximately 7,000 Tunisians joining by 2015, stemmed partly from the permissive environment under Ennahda-led governments (2011–2016), where Salafist networks proliferated amid vacuums and economic despair, exporting the highest per capita foreign fighters globally. Empirical data links this to Ennahda's initial tolerance of ultraconservative groups as allies against secularists, fostering a cultural contestation that undermined on religious interpretation and contributed to lapses, including over 50 terrorist attacks between and 2015. While optimists argue Ennahda planted seeds of pluralistic compromise by conceding on non-constitutionality, realists highlight causal incompatibilities between Islamist priors—prioritizing moral legislation—and modern demands like and individual rights, as seen in stalled reforms and persistent identity conflicts fueling instability. The 2021 power consolidation by President Kais Saïed, including parliament suspension on July 25 and Ennahda leader Rached Ghannouchi's arrest in 2023, reflects a backlash against Ennahda-era failures in delivering stability, with GDP growth averaging under 2% annually from 2011–2019 amid scandals and networks. Saïed's revival of Bourguibist rhetoric, such as public disavowal of fasting, positions his authoritarian turn as a corrective to unresolved secular-Islamist tensions, tracing Tunisia's 2024 democratic —marked by media crackdowns and referendum-approved changes—to Ennahda's legacy of politicized religion without institutionalizing secular checks. Ennahda's adaptive model for affiliates elsewhere, emphasizing electoral over , succeeded short-term but exposed long-term vulnerabilities, as Islamist governance struggles with modernity's pluralism requirements, perpetuating cycles of inclusion, , and populist reversion.

References

  1. https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/tunisia-and-decline-political-islam
  2. https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/assessing-ennahda-tunisias-winning-islamist-party
  3. https://www.counterextremism.com/content/muslim-brotherhood-tunisia
  4. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/from-islamists-to-muslim-democrats-the-case-of-tunisias-ennahda/
  5. https://www.mei.edu/publications/putting-fight-tunisias-counterterrorism-successes-and-failures
  6. https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1298&context=eilr
  7. https://ctc.westpoint.edu/the-salafist-temptation-the-radicalization-of-tunisias-post-revolution-youth/
  8. https://www.brandeis.edu/crown/publications/crown-conversations/cc-14.html
  9. https://www.ispionline.it/en/publication/tunisia-where-has-ennahda-gone-203316
  10. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/ennahda-from-within-islamists-or-muslim-democrats-a-conversation/
  11. https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/ASPJ_French/journals_E/Volume-05_Issue-1/Webb_e.pdf
  12. https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/rachid-ghannouchis-thought-career
  13. https://www.insightturkey.com/articles/transformation-of-the-ennahda-movement-from-islamic-jamaah-to-political-party
  14. https://academic.oup.com/book/6703/chapter/150759605
  15. https://www.counterextremism.com/extremists/rached-ghannouchi
  16. https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2019/09/ennahdas-uneasy-exit-from-political-islam?lang=en
  17. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/inside-tunisias-alnahda/rethinking-politicization/B83A67556D8DBA82EB302C0F432B9246/core-reader
  18. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/american-political-science-review/article/from-islamists-to-muslim-democrats-the-case-of-tunisias-ennahda/C0D3D82CA222E3C28B108B28ED5A4DD4
  19. https://www.middleeasteye.net/discover/muslim-democracy-charting-evolution-rached-ghannouchis-political-and-theological-ideology
  20. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/tunisia/political-islam-muslim-democracy-ennahda
  21. https://academic.oup.com/book/46788/chapter/413404003
  22. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/13540688231192393
  23. https://www.amazon.com/Muslim-Democracy-Dialogues-Religion-Politics/dp/0197666876
  24. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/391286427_The_Evolution_of_the_Ennahda_Movement_From_Religious_Ideology_to_Political_Force_in_Tunisia%27s_Post-Revolution_Era
  25. https://english.legal-agenda.com/democratic-islam-according-to-ennahda-first-appraisal/
  26. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Zine-al-Abidine-Ben-Ali
  27. https://jamestown.org/program/jailed-extremists-pardoned-in-tunisia/
  28. https://academic.oup.com/book/6703/chapter/150762950
  29. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-12318824
  30. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-12611609
  31. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2011/11/14/final-tunisian-election-results-announced
  32. https://www.nytimes.com/2011/10/26/world/africa/tunisia-liberals-see-a-vote-for-change-not-just-for-islamists.html
  33. https://www.wilsoncenter.org/article/tunisia-the-best-bet
  34. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2012/5/27/tunisian-salafists-clash-with-security-forces
  35. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-18416327
  36. https://www.mapsofworld.com/list-of/prime-ministers-tunisia/
  37. https://worldview.stratfor.com/article/tunisias-post-arab-spring-struggles
  38. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/Tunisia_Marks-FINALE-5.pdf
  39. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-21508498
  40. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-23452979
  41. https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/elections-tunisia-steps-toward-democratic-consolidation
  42. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-29828706
  43. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2014/10/30/tunisia-results-confirm-nidaa-tounes-win
  44. https://www.nytimes.com/2014/10/28/world/africa/nidaa-tounes-ennahda-tunisian-parliamentary-election.html
  45. https://www.france24.com/en/20141027-tunisia-secular-party-nidaa-tounes-lead-general-election
  46. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/10/10/tunisia-election-preliminary-results-show-ennahda-in-the-lead
  47. https://www.france24.com/en/20191009-islamist-inspired-ennahdha-party-leads-tunisia-election-initial-results-show
  48. https://www.cartercenter.org/resources/pdfs/news/peace_publications/election_reports/tunisia-2019-final-report.pdf
  49. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/winners-and-losers-of-tunisias-parliamentary-elections/
  50. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/327274813_When_Islamists_Lose_The_Politicization_of_Tunisia%27s_Ennahda_Movement
  51. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-africa-57976005
  52. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/7/27/ennahda-calls-for-dialogue-to-resolve-tunisias-political-crisis
  53. https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/tunisian-democracy-crisis-after-president-ousts-government-2021-07-26/
  54. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/kais-saieds-power-grab-in-tunisia/
  55. https://carnegieendowment.org/middle-east/diwan/2023/04/rashed-ghannouchi-the-head-of-tunisias-islamist-ennahda-party-has-been-arrested?lang=en
  56. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/4/20/judge-orders-tunisian-opposition-leader-rached-ghannouchi-jailed
  57. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2023/05/tunisia-ghannouchi-sentencing-marks-aggressive-crackdown-on-saied-opposition/
  58. https://www.hrw.org/report/2025/04/16/all-conspirators/how-tunisia-uses-arbitrary-detention-crush-dissent
  59. https://www.dw.com/en/tunisia-presidents-far-reaching-clampdown-targets-opponents/a-73241559
  60. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/4/18/allies-say-ghannouchi-unjustly-held-as-he-marks-2-years-in-tunisian-jail
  61. https://www.npr.org/2024/10/08/g-s1-26834/tunisia-kais-saied-election-2024-arab-spring
  62. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cx25ree1g18o
  63. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/10/7/saieds-low-turnout-win-in-tunisia-election-sparks-repression-concerns
  64. https://nawaat.org/2024/04/10/between-authoritarian-crack-down-and-internal-crisis-can-ennahda-rise-again/
  65. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jan/14/thousands-protest-against-tunisian-president-kais-saied-seizure-of-near-total-power
  66. https://www.reuters.com/business/media-telecom/tunisians-protest-aginst-president-saied-call-country-an-open-air-prison-2025-07-25/
  67. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/mepo.12786
  68. https://www.britannica.com/topic/Ennahda-Party
  69. https://henryjacksonsociety.org/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/HJS-Ennahda-Report.pdf
  70. https://www.britannica.com/biography/Rachid-al-Ghannouchi
  71. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/4/20/who-is-ghannouchi-the-ennahdha-party-leader-arrested-in-tunisia
  72. https://academic.oup.com/book/6703/chapter/150758145
  73. https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/more-than-100-officials-tunisias-islamist-ennahda-party-resign-amid-crisis-2021-09-25/
  74. https://pomeps.org/did-egypts-coup-teach-ennahda-to-cede-power
  75. https://academic.oup.com/book/45421/chapter/389408332
  76. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/politics-and-religion/article/an-organizational-perspective-on-fading-systemness-insights-from-ennahdas-postspecialization-period-20162021/D788192D75A7F0803B6A090908879740
  77. https://gsi.s-rminform.com/articles/ennahda-the-ascendancy-of-the-pragmatists
  78. https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/tunisia-officials-resign-ennahda-party-leadership
  79. https://www.dw.com/en/tunisia-opposition-officials-resign-amid-political-crisis/a-59310390
  80. https://www.files.ethz.ch/isn/167265/WP_Tunisia.pdf
  81. https://www.arabnews.com/node/1901796/middle-east
  82. https://english.aawsat.com/home/article/1575851/tunisia-ennahda-condemns-inquiry-its-leaders%25E2%2580%2599-bank-accounts
  83. https://see.news/tunisiansvs-ennahda-ghannouchis1bfortuneunderfire
  84. https://www.journalofdemocracy.org/articles/islam-and-democracy-in-tunisia/
  85. https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/politics-and-religion/article/god-loves-the-rich-the-economic-policy-of-ennahda-liberalism-in-the-service-of-social-solidarity/2DF08A6647AC7D7F3B083012CBAF56ED
  86. https://english.alarabiya.net/articles/2011%252F11%252F13%252F176916
  87. https://thearabweekly.com/tunisia-lgbt-people-brave-threats-and-hostility-speak-out
  88. https://www.fletcherforum.org/home/2016/9/6/ennahdas-split-personality-identity-crises-in-tunisian-politics
  89. https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/menasource/tunisia-s-foreign-policy-a-delicate-balance/
  90. https://carnegieendowment.org/sada/2018/12/saudi-arabias-uncertain-investment-in-tunisia?lang=en
  91. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/who-are-muslim-brotherhood-what-does-it-have-do-qatar-n782571
  92. https://sciencespo.hal.science/hal-03389336/document
  93. https://arabcenterdc.org/resource/risky-business-kais-saieds-regional-alliances/
  94. https://ecfr.eu/article/saieds-crackdown-how-the-eu-can-stand-up-for-human-rights-in-tunisia/
  95. https://www.france24.com/en/20111114-tunisia-official-election-results-islamist-ennahda-party-constituent-assembly-ben-ali
  96. https://www.cnn.com/2011/10/25/world/africa/tunisia-election-results
  97. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2014/10/28/tunisias-ennahda-faces-defeat-in-elections
  98. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tunisia-election-results/tunisias-moderate-islamist-party-ennahda-to-lead-fractured-new-parliament-idUSKBN1WO2PD/
  99. https://data.ipu.org/parliament/TN/TN-LC01/election/TN-LC01-E20221217
  100. https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/north-africa-west-asia/decline-of-political-islam-in-tunisia/
  101. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/07/MonicaMarks_re2SayidaOunissi2.pdf
  102. https://www.reuters.com/article/world/tunisias-ennahda-to-oppose-sharia-in-constitution-idUSBRE82P0E9/
  103. https://carnegieendowment.org/research/2014/04/beyond-tunisias-constitution-the-devil-in-the-details?lang=en
  104. https://english.alarabiya.net/articles/2012%252F03%252F27%252F203529
  105. https://mepc.org/commentaries/tunisias-islamists-ennahda-and-salafis/
  106. https://carnegieendowment.org/sada/2012/10/ennahdas-rule-of-engagement?lang=en
  107. https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/tunisia-2021-ennahda-vs-extremists
  108. https://www.investigativeproject.org/8432/misselling-tunisia-salafis
  109. https://bti-project.org/fileadmin/api/content/en/downloads/reports/country_report_2014_TUN.pdf
  110. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.MKTP.KD.ZG?locations=TN
  111. https://cadmus.eui.eu/server/api/core/bitstreams/65eb2b43-1b18-5cc6-8ca1-21dc8d0bb35a/content
  112. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.UEM.1524.ZS?locations=TN
  113. https://meea.sites.luc.edu/volume14/PDFS/Youth_employment_in_Tunisia.pdf
  114. https://www.americanprogress.org/article/tunisias-struggle-for-political-pluralism-after-ennahda/
  115. https://archive.uneca.org/sites/default/files/PublicationFiles/note_tunisie_eng.pdf
  116. https://merip.org/2015/07/tunisias-rotten-compromise/
  117. https://www.washingtoninstitute.org/policy-analysis/tunisian-jihadist-movement-ten-years-after-prisoner-amnesty
  118. https://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/28/world/africa/tunisia-broadens-crackdown-on-extremists.html
  119. https://cdn.americanprogress.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/Tunisia-reportv2.pdf
  120. https://thearabweekly.com/tunisia-probe-dispatch-extremist-recruits-reaches-top-ennahda-leaders
  121. https://www.hrw.org/news/2023/02/24/tunisia-wave-arrests-targets-critics-and-opposition-figures
  122. https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/tunisia-hands-jail-terms-ranging-13-66-years-opposition-figures-2025-04-19/
  123. https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/c04d1d71rx4o
  124. https://www.france24.com/en/africa/20250709-tunisian-court-sentences-opposition-leaders-for-plotting-against-the-state
  125. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2025/07/tunisia-mass-convictions-in-conspiracy-case-2-deepen-rule-of-law-crisis/
  126. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2024/9/14/tunisia-arrests-dozens-of-opposition-members-in-pre-election-crackdown
  127. https://www.middleeasteye.net/news/scores-opposition-supporters-arrested-tunisia-ahead-elections
  128. https://www.hrw.org/news/2023/05/11/tunisia-move-dismantle-countrys-largest-opposition-party
  129. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/09/tunisia-at-least-97-arrested-as-authorities-escalate-pre-election-crackdown/
  130. https://www.epc.ae/en/details/scenario/after-a-decade-in-power-tunisia-s-ennahda-movement-at-a-crossroads
  131. https://futureuae.com/ar/Mainpage/Item/6695/a-possible-downfall-the-implications-of-the-mass-resignations-within-the-ennahda-movement-in-tunisia
  132. https://carnegieendowment.org/sada/2014/01/tunisias-compromise-constitution?lang=en
  133. https://www.brookings.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Ennahda-Approach-Tunisia-Constitution-English.pdf
  134. https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/peace/2015/press-release/
  135. https://carnegie-production-assets.s3.amazonaws.com/static/files/WP_Meddeb_Ennahda.pdf
  136. https://freedomhouse.org/country/tunisia/freedom-world/2025
  137. https://www.opengovpartnership.org/trust/youth-radicalisation-and-distrust/
  138. https://sharangrewal.com/s/Grewal-APSR.pdf
  139. https://www.rusi.org/explore-our-research/publications/commentary/tunisias-authoritarian-turn
  140. https://www.mdpi.com/2077-1444/12/6/408
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.