Hubbry Logo
Medieval Warm PeriodMedieval Warm PeriodMain
Open search
Medieval Warm Period
Community hub
Medieval Warm Period
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Medieval Warm Period
Medieval Warm Period
Medieval Warm Period
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Global average temperatures show that the Medieval Warm Period was not a global phenomenon.[1]

The Medieval Warm Period (MWP), also known as the Medieval Climate Optimum or the Medieval Climatic Anomaly, was a time of warm climate in the North Atlantic region that lasted from about 950 CE to about 1250 CE.[2] Climate proxy records show peak warmth occurred at different times for different regions, which indicate that the MWP was not a globally uniform event.[3] Some refer to the MWP as the Medieval Climatic Anomaly to emphasize that climatic effects other than temperature were also important.[4][5]

The MWP was followed by a regionally cooler period in the North Atlantic and elsewhere, which is sometimes called the Little Ice Age (LIA).

Possible causes of the MWP include increased solar activity, decreased volcanic activity, and changes in ocean circulation.[6] Modelling evidence has shown that natural variability is insufficient on its own to explain the MWP and that an external forcing had to be one of the causes.[7]

Research

[edit]

The MWP is generally thought to have occurred from about 950 CE to about 1250 CE, during the European Middle Ages.[2] Some researchers divide the MWP into two phases: MWP-I, which began around 450 CE and ended around 900 CE, and MWP-II, which lasted from about 1000 CE to about 1300 CE; MWP-I is called the early Medieval Warm Period while MWP-II is called the conventional Medieval Warm Period.[8] In 1965, Hubert Lamb, one of the first paleoclimatologists, published research based on data from botany, historical document research, and meteorology, combined with records indicating prevailing temperature and rainfall in England around 1200 CE and around 1600 CE. He proposed,[9]

evidence has been accumulating in many fields of investigation pointing to a notably warm climate in many parts of the world, that lasted a few centuries around 1000–1200 CE, and was followed by a decline of temperature levels till between around 1500–1700 CE the coldest phase since the last ice age occurred.

The era of warmer temperatures became known as the Medieval Warm Period and the subsequent cold period the Little Ice Age (LIA). However, the view that the MWP was a global event was challenged by other researchers. The IPCC First Assessment Report of 1990 discussed the:[10]

Medieval Warm Period around 1000 CE (which may not have been global) and the Little Ice Age which ended only in the middle to late nineteenth century.

It stated that temperatures in the:[10]

late tenth to early thirteenth centuries (about 950–1250 CE) appear to have been exceptionally warm in western Europe, Iceland and Greenland.

The IPCC Third Assessment Report from 2001 summarized newer research:[11]

evidence does not support globally synchronous periods of anomalous cold or warmth over this time frame, and the conventional terms of 'Little Ice Age' and 'Medieval Warm Period' are chiefly documented in describing northern hemisphere trends in hemispheric or global mean temperature changes in past centuries.

Global temperature records taken from ice cores, tree rings, and lake deposits have shown that the Earth may have been slightly cooler globally (by 0.03 °C or 0.1 °F) than in the early and the mid-20th century.[12][13]

Palaeoclimatologists developing region-specific climate reconstructions of past centuries conventionally label their coldest interval as "LIA" and their warmest interval as the "MWP".[12][14] Others follow the convention, and when a significant climate event is found in the "LIA" or "MWP" timeframes, they associate their events to the period. Some "MWP" events are thus wet events or cold events, rather than strictly warm events, particularly in central Antarctica, where climate patterns that are opposite to those of the North Atlantic have been noticed.

Using methods of historical climatology, Christian Pfister and Heinz Wanner reconstructed the seasonal temperature conditions for Western and Central Europe in 2021 on the basis of indices from CE 1000 to 1999 (the autumns only from 1500 onwards).[15][16]

Global climate during the Medieval Warm Period

[edit]

The nature and extent of the MWP has been marked by long-standing controversy over whether it was a global or regional event.[17][18] In 2019, by using an extended proxy data set,[19] the Pages-2k consortium confirmed that the Medieval Climate Anomaly was not a globally synchronous event. The warmest 51-year period within the MWP did not occur at the same time in different regions. They argue for a regional instead of global framing of climate variability in the preindustrial Common Era to aid in understanding.[20]

North Atlantic

[edit]
Greenland ice sheet temperatures interpreted with 18O isotope from 6 ice cores (Vinther, B., et al., 2009).[citation needed] The data set ranges from 9690 BCE to 1970 CE and has a resolution of around 20 years. That means that each data point represents the average temperature of the surrounding 20 years.
See also: Tropical cyclones and climate change

Lloyd D. Keigwin's 1996 study of radiocarbon-dated box core data from marine sediments in the Sargasso Sea found that its sea surface temperature was approximately 1 °C (1.8 °F) cooler approximately 400 years ago, during the LIA, and 1700 years ago, and was approximately 1 °C (1.8 °F) warmer 1000 years ago, during the MWP.[21]

Using sediment samples from Puerto Rico, the Gulf Coast, and the Atlantic Coast from Florida to New England, Mann et al. found consistent evidence of a peak in North Atlantic tropical cyclone activity during the MWP, which was followed by a subsequent lull in activity.[22]

Iceland

[edit]

Iceland was first settled between about 865 and 930, during a time believed to be warm enough for sailing and farming.[23][24] By retrieval and isotope analysis of marine cores and from examination of mollusc growth patterns from Iceland, Patterson et al. reconstructed a stable oxygen (δ18 O) and carbon (δ13 C) isotope record at a decadal resolution from the Roman Warm Period to the MWP and the LIA.[25] Patterson et al. conclude that the summer temperature stayed high but winter temperature decreased after the initial settlement of Iceland.[25]

Greenland

[edit]
The last written records of the Norse Greenlanders are from an Icelandic marriage in 1408 but were recorded later in Iceland, at Hvalsey Church, which is now the best-preserved of the Norse ruins.

The Mann et al. study found warmth exceeding 1961–1990 levels in southern Greenland and parts of North America during the MWP, which the study defines as from 950 to 1250, with warmth in some regions exceeding temperatures of the 1990–2010 period.[22] Much of the Northern Hemisphere showed a significant cooling during the LIA, which the study defines as from 1400 to 1700, but Labrador and isolated parts of the United States appeared to be approximately as warm as during the 1961–1990 period.[2] Greenlandic winter oxygen isotope data from the MWP display a strong correlation with the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO).[26]

1690 copy of the 1570 Skálholt map, based on documentary information about earlier Norse sites in America.

The Norse colonization of the Americas has been associated with warmer periods.[27] The common theory is that Norsemen took advantage of ice-free seas to colonize areas in Greenland and other outlying lands of the far north.[28] However, a study from Columbia University suggests that Greenland was not colonized in warmer weather, but the warming effect in fact lasted for only very briefly.[29] Around 1000 CE the climate was sufficiently warm for the Vikings to journey to Newfoundland and to establish a short-lived outpost there.[30]

L'Anse aux Meadows, Newfoundland, today, with a reconstruction of a Viking settlement.

Around 985, Vikings founded the Eastern and Western Settlements, both near the southern tip of Greenland. In the colony's early stages, they kept cattle, sheep, and goats, with around a quarter of their diet from seafood. After the climate became colder and stormier around 1250, their diet steadily shifted towards ocean sources. By around 1300, seal hunting provided over three quarters of their food.

By 1350, there was reduced demand for their exports, and trade with Europe fell away. The last document from the settlements dates from 1412, and over the following decades, the remaining Europeans left in what seems to have been a gradual withdrawal, which was caused mainly by economic factors such as increased availability of farms in Scandinavian countries.[31]

Europe

[edit]

Substantial glacial retreat in southern Europe was experienced during the MWP. While several smaller glaciers experienced complete deglaciation, larger glaciers in the region survived and now provide insight into the region's climate history.[32] In addition to warming induced glacial melt, sedimentary records reveal a period of increased flooding, coinciding with the MWP, in eastern Europe that is attributed to enhanced precipitation from a positive phase NAO.[33] Other impacts of climate change can be less apparent such as a changing landscape. Preceding the MWP, a coastal region in western Sardinia was abandoned by the Romans. The coastal area was able to substantially expand into the lagoon without the influence of human populations and a high stand during the MWP. When human populations returned to the region, they encountered a land altered by climate change and had to reestablish ports.[34] In the Iberian Central Range, there was elevated lake productivity and soil erosion, along with frequent intense runoff events.[35]

Other regions

[edit]

North America

[edit]

In Chesapeake Bay (now in Maryland and Virginia, United States), researchers found large temperature excursions (changes from the mean temperature of that time) during the MWP (about 950–1250) and the Little Ice Age (about 1400–1700, with cold periods persisting into the early 20th century), which are possibly related to changes in the strength of North Atlantic thermohaline circulation.[36] Sediments in Piermont Marsh of the lower Hudson Valley show a dry MWP from 800 to 1300.[37] In the Hammock River marsh in Connecticut, salt marshes extended 15 kilometres (9.3 mi) farther westward than they do in the present due to higher sea levels.[38]

Prolonged droughts affected many parts of what is now the Western United States, especially eastern California and the west of Great Basin.[12][39] Alaska experienced three intervals of comparable warmth: 1–300, 850–1200, and since 1800.[40] Knowledge of the MWP in North America has been useful in dating occupancy periods of certain Native American habitation sites, especially in arid parts of the Western United States.[41][42] Aridity was more prevalent in the southeastern United States during the MWP than the following LIA, but only slightly; this difference may be statistically insignificant.[43] Droughts in the MWP may have impacted Native American settlements also in the Eastern United States, such as at Cahokia.[44][45] Review of more recent archaeological research shows that as the search for signs of unusual cultural changes has broadened, some of the early patterns (such as violence and health problems) have been found to be more complicated and regionally varied than had been previously thought. Other patterns, such as settlement disruption, deterioration of long-distance trade, and population movements, have been further corroborated.[46]

Africa

[edit]

The climate in equatorial eastern Africa has alternated between being drier than today and relatively wet. The climate was drier during the MWP (1000–1270).[47] Off the coast of Africa, Isotopic analysis of bones from the Canary Islands' inhabitants during the MWP to LIA transition reveal the region experienced a 5 °C (9.0 °F) decrease in air temperature. Over this period, the diet of inhabitants did not appreciably change, which suggests they were remarkably resilient to climate change.[48]

Antarctica

[edit]

The onset of the MWP in the Southern Ocean lagged the MWP's onset in the North Atlantic by approximately 150 years.[49] A sediment core from the eastern Bransfield Basin, in the Antarctic Peninsula, preserves climatic events from both the LIA and the MWP. The authors noted, "The late Holocene records clearly identify Neoglacial events of the LIA and Medieval Warm Period (MWP)."[50] Some Antarctic regions were atypically cold, but others were atypically warm between 1000 and 1200.[51]

Pacific Ocean

[edit]

Corals in the tropical Pacific Ocean suggest that relatively cool and dry conditions may have persisted early in the millennium, which is consistent with a La Niña-like configuration of the El Niño-Southern Oscillation patterns.[52]

In 2013, a study from three US universities was published in Science magazine and showed that the water temperature in the Pacific Ocean was 0.9 °C (1.6 °F) warmer during the MWP than during the LIA and 0.65 °C (1.2 °F) warmer than the decades before the study.[53] In the northeastern Pacific, however, sea surface temperatures (SSTs) were actually cooler during the MWP than the LIA.[54]

South America

[edit]

The MWP has been noted in Chile in a 1500-year lake bed sediment core,[55] as well as in the Eastern Cordillera of Ecuador.[56]

A reconstruction, based on ice cores, found that the MWP could be distinguished in tropical South America from about 1050 to 1300 and was followed in the 15th century by the LIA. Peak temperatures did not rise as to the level of the late 20th century, which were unprecedented in the area during the study period of 1600 years.[57]

East Asia

[edit]

Ge et al. studied temperatures in China for the past 2000 years and found high uncertainty prior to the 16th century but good consistency over the last 500 years highlighted by the two cold periods, 1620s–1710s and 1800s–1860s, and the 20th-century warming. They also found that the warming from the 10th to the 14th centuries in some regions might be comparable in magnitude to the warming of the last few decades of the 20th century, which was unprecedented within the past 500 years.[58] Generally, a warming period was identified in China, coinciding with the MWP, using multi-proxy data for temperature. However, the warming was inconsistent across China. Significant temperature change, from the MWP to LIA, was found for northeast and central-east China but not for northwest China and the Tibetan Plateau.[59] During the MWP, the East Asian Summer Monsoon (EASM) was the strongest it has been in the past millennium[60] and was highly sensitive to the El Niño Southern Oscillation (ENSO).[61] The Mu Us Desert witness increased moisture in the MWP.[62] Peat cores from peatland in southeast China suggest changes in the EASM and ENSO are responsible for increased precipitation in the region during the MWP.[63] However, other sites in southern China show aridification and not humidification during the MWP, showing that the MWP's influence was highly spatially heterogeneous.[64] Modelling evidence suggests that EASM strength during the MWP was low in early summer but very high during late summer.[65]

In far eastern Russia, continental regions experienced severe floods during the MWP while nearby islands experienced less precipitation leading to a decrease in peatland. Pollen data from this region indicates an expansion of warm climate vegetation with an increasing number of broadleaf and decreasing number of coniferous forests.[66]

Adhikari and Kumon (2001), investigating sediments in Lake Nakatsuna, in central Japan, found a warm period from 900 to 1200 that corresponded to the MWP and three cool phases, two of which could be related to the LIA.[67] Other research in northeastern Japan showed that there was one warm and humid interval, from 750 to 1200, and two cold and dry intervals, from 1 to 750 and from 1200 to now.[68]

South Asia

[edit]

The Indian Summer Monsoon (ISM) was also enhanced during the MWP with a temperature driven change to the Atlantic Multi-decadal Oscillation (AMO),[69] bringing more precipitation to India.[70] Vegetation records in Lahaul in Himachal Pradesh confirm a warm and humid MWP from 1,158 to 647 BP.[71] Pollen from Madhya Pradesh dated to the MWP provides further direct evidence for increased monsoonal precipitation.[72] Multi-proxy records from Pookode Lake in Kerala also reflect the warmth of the MWP.[73]

Middle East

[edit]

Sea surface temperatures in the Arabian Sea increased during the MWP, owing to a strong monsoon.[74] During the MWP, the Arabian Sea exhibited heightened biological productivity.[75] The Arabian Peninsula, already extremely arid in the present day, was even drier during the MWP. Prolonged drought was a mainstay of the Arabian climate until around 660 BP, when this hyperarid interval was terminated.[76]

Oceania

[edit]

There is an extreme scarcity of data from Australia for both the MWP and the LIA. However, evidence from wave-built shingle terraces for a permanently-full Lake Eyre[77] during the 9th and the 10th centuries is consistent with a La Niña-like configuration, but the data are insufficient to show how lake levels varied from year to year or what climatic conditions elsewhere in Australia were like.

A 1979 study from the University of Waikato found,[78]

Temperatures derived from an 18O/16O profile through a stalagmite found in a New Zealand cave (40°40′S 172°26′E / 40.67°S 172.43°E / -40.67; 172.43) suggested the Medieval Warm Period to have occurred between [... about 1050–1400 CE] and to have been 0.75 °C [1.4 °F] warmer than the Current Warm Period.

More evidence in New Zealand is from an 1100-year tree-ring record.[79]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]

Further reading

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Medieval Warm Period

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
The (MWP), approximately AD 950 to 1250, denotes a phase of comparatively elevated temperatures across multiple regions, especially the North Atlantic, substantiated by proxy indicators such as tree rings, ice cores, borehole thermometry, and . These data reveal climatic conditions enabling expanded human activities, including Norse settlement of Greenland's southern fjords where arable farming and livestock husbandry thrived, as corroborated by archaeological findings of over 620 farms and records indicating greater vegetation productivity than during the ensuing . Multi-proxy reconstructions, including hemispheric syntheses, demonstrate that MWP temperatures in locales like and margins often matched or surpassed early modern baselines, with summer warmth in and the supporting and crop yields atypical for higher latitudes. However, spatial and temporal heterogeneity prevails, with proxy ensembles indicating no globally coherent peak exceeding current anthropogenic-driven warming, though regional maxima challenge narratives minimizing pre-industrial variability; this asynchrony underscores natural forcings like and over uniform influences. The period's delineation follows the cooler Dark Age Cold Phase and anticipates the , framing it as a key interval in climate dynamics where empirical discrepancies arise from proxy uncertainties and model assumptions, often amplified by institutional tendencies to prioritize recent exceptionalism. Debates center on the MWP's scope and implications for attributing modern trends, with evidence from Pacific corals and Southern Hemisphere sediments showing divergent patterns—warmth in some extratropical zones but cooler —contrasting the spatially pervasive contemporary rise. Such variability informs causal realism by highlighting multi-decadal oscillations driven by ocean-atmosphere interactions, rather than solely , and cautions against overreliance on homogenized datasets that may understate historical amplitudes due to selective proxy weighting.

Definition and Chronology

Time Frame and Characteristics

The Medieval Warm Period (MWP) is dated approximately from 950 to 1250 CE, based on syntheses of proxy records including tree rings, ice cores, and sediments that show coherent warming signals across multiple Northern Hemisphere sites during this interval. Peak warmth in these reconstructions frequently occurred between 1000 and 1100 CE, distinguishing the MWP from cooler phases both before and after. Climatic characteristics included temperature elevations of 0.5 to 1°C above regional baselines in many proxies, with some records like Sargasso Sea surface temperatures indicating anomalies up to 1°C warmer relative to the ensuing Little Ice Age. Reduced sea ice coverage is evidenced in North Atlantic and Arctic proxies, correlating with expanded habitable zones and navigational feasibility during the period. The transition to the Little Ice Age around 1300 CE is marked by proxy shifts such as glacier readvances and cooling in multi-proxy reconstructions, underscoring the MWP's relative warmth without implying uniformity or magnitude comparable to modern trends.

Historical Recognition

![Hvalsey Church ruins, site of Norse settlement in Greenland][float-right] The Medieval Warm Period was first identified through analyses of historical records in the 19th and early 20th centuries, with European chronicles providing evidence of milder conditions enabling agricultural expansions such as viticulture in northern England during the 11th to 13th centuries. These accounts, including monastic annals documenting extended growing seasons and reduced severe winters, suggested a climatic regime warmer than subsequent centuries, though initial interpretations focused on regional European variability rather than a unified global event. Viking sagas and Icelandic annals contributed to early recognition by describing the successful colonization of around 985 CE under , portraying the island's southern coasts as habitable for farming and , conditions attributed to contemporaneous warmth that facilitated Norse expansion across the North Atlantic. These narratives, combined with archaeological evidence of sustained settlements like the Eastern Settlement, were interpreted by historians as indicators of favorable climate from approximately 950 to 1250 CE, predating systematic paleoclimatic studies. Formal scientific acknowledgment crystallized in the mid-20th century through Hubert H. Lamb's reconstructions, particularly his 1965 analysis of central England temperature series derived from harvest dates and phenological records, which delineated a "Medieval Warm " peaking around 1000–1200 CE with temperatures 1–2°C above the 20th-century average in that region. Lamb integrated these documentary sources with preliminary and tree-line data from , noting elevated timberlines and expanded birch forests as corroboration of warmer summers supporting Norse activities, thus establishing the period's empirical basis prior to advanced proxy modeling. Early 20th-century studies in further validated these inferences by revealing increased arboreal percentages during the 9th–13th centuries, indicative of climatic suitability for tree growth at higher latitudes.

Evidence from Proxies and Records

Documentary and Historical Accounts

Historical chronicles and manorial records from medieval document evidence of warmer conditions through observations of agricultural productivity. In , the of 1086 CE inventories vineyards at over 40 sites, primarily in southern and western counties such as and , enabling wine production that ceased after the 14th century due to cooler temperatures. Monastic annals, including those from , record earlier grape harvests and extended frost-free periods around 1000–1200 CE, with reduced winter severity allowing cultivation in marginal areas. Norse sagas and settlement records provide direct accounts of habitable conditions in during the late 10th to early 11th centuries. Erik the Red's expedition in 982 CE described the eastern settlement area as grassy and suitable for pasturage, supporting and cultivation for several centuries thereafter, as corroborated by farmstead inventories and church records like those from until the . Chinese historical annals, such as Song Dynasty (960–1279 CE) court records, note milder winters and facilitated navigation on the River due to reduced ice cover around 1000–1200 CE, contrasting with more frequent freezing events in subsequent periods. These documents describe fewer severe frosts impacting in eastern regions, with phenological observations of extended growing seasons. Arabic medieval texts, including chronicles from scholars like al-Mas'udi (d. 956 CE) and later Abbasid records, report periods of increased rainfall and agricultural expansion in semi-arid zones of and the during the 10th–12th centuries, alleviating prior droughts and enabling broader cultivation of crops like olives and grains in marginal areas such as the oasis. These accounts, drawn from meteorological notations in historical manuscripts, indicate episodic relief from aridity, though interspersed with variability.

Tree-Ring and Dendrochronological Data

Tree-ring width (TRW) and maximum latewood density (MXD) from high-elevation and high-latitude serve as primary dendrochronological proxies for reconstructing past summer temperatures, as growth in these environments is primarily limited by thermal conditions rather than moisture. During the (MWP, circa 950–1250 CE), numerous chronologies from the exhibit wider TRW and higher MXD values compared to subsequent periods like the , indicating anomalously warm growing seasons. For instance, European MXD networks reconstruct summer temperatures during the MCA (Medieval Climate Anomaly, overlapping the MWP) as comparable to those of the early , with peaks around 1000–1100 CE exceeding later baselines by 0.2–0.5°C in . Empirical evidence from dated subfossil tree remains documents tree-line advances during the MWP, reflecting upward shifts in the altitudinal limit of forest growth due to prolonged warm summers. In the , () macrofossils dated to 900–1200 CE occur 100–200 meters above the modern tree-line, implying a summer temperature increase of approximately 0.5–1°C based on environmental lapse rates of 0.6°C per 100 meters. Analogous patterns appear in Siberian () records, where elevated tree-lines and enhanced growth rates corroborate regional warming sufficient to expand arboreal habitats poleward and upslope. These macro-scale indicators provide direct causal evidence of thermal anomalies, as tree establishment requires sustained multi-decadal warmth exceeding modern thresholds in those locales. Bristlecone pine (Pinus longaeva) chronologies from the White Mountains of further support MWP warmth through MXD measurements, which correlate positively with warm-season temperatures and show elevated densities during 950–1250 CE, indicative of conditions rivaling mid-20th-century levels without the confounding influence of anthropogenic CO2 fertilization observed in recent decades. These long-lived trees (spanning millennia) yield robust, annually resolved records less prone to biological age trends, with MWP-era densities suggesting sustained summer warmth that promoted dense latewood formation. Select tree-ring syntheses calibrate MWP peaks against prior epochs, revealing instances where extratropical temperatures exceeded (circa 100–300 CE) maxima by 0.1–0.3°C in composite chronologies. For example, millennial-length reconstructions from TRW and MXD identify the interval starting circa 968 CE as among the warmest 100-year periods of the past two millennia, surpassing Roman-era warmth in sensitivity-tested models. However, a 2023 Fennoscandian study using earlywood cell refines these estimates, indicating medieval summers approximately 1°C cooler than the in that region, thereby aligning older proxy inferences more closely with simulations of . This highlights ongoing refinements in proxy calibration, where micro-anatomical data may capture nuances missed by traditional metrics but do not negate macro-evidence of regional MWP anomalies.

Ice-Core and Glacial Records

Ice cores from , such as the GISP2 record drilled at , reveal elevated temperatures during the through analysis of oxygen ratios (δ¹⁸O). Reconstructions indicate that around 1000 CE, central surface temperatures were approximately 1°C warmer than the late 20th-century average, with decadal means exceeding the 2001–2010 baseline of -29.9°C. Associated lower snow accumulation rates in these cores point to drier atmospheric conditions, consistent with enhanced evaporation under warmer temperatures. Antarctic ice cores, particularly from the Peninsula region including eastern sites like , provide evidence of relative warmth during the MWP, with stable data showing reduced ice-rafted debris and indicators of ice-free conditions in some intervals. These signals suggest a degree of synchrony with warming, though high southern latitude records exhibit a delayed onset, potentially by centuries, as simulated and observed in excess and coastal profiles. Glacial records from mid-latitude ranges, including the and , document minima between roughly 950 and 1250 CE, marked by glacier retreats, diminished snowfall accumulation, and exposure of previously ice-covered terrain. In the , sediment cores from capture multiproxy evidence of this warm phase through pollen and geochemical shifts indicating reduced ice extent and warmer, possibly drier local climates. Alpine glaciers similarly persisted at reduced volumes during this interval, with dynamics showing accelerations linked to minimal ice cover, contrasting with advances in the subsequent . These retreats correlate with proxy-inferred temperature elevations, supporting regional warmth during the MWP.

Sediment, Coral, and Other Proxies

cores from the in the subtropical North Atlantic provide direct evidence of (SST) anomalies during the Medieval Warm Period. A radiocarbon-dated box core from the Bermuda Rise, analyzed using planktonic foraminiferal assemblages and oxygen isotopes, indicates SSTs approximately 1°C warmer around 1000 CE compared to the late 20th-century baseline (roughly 1960–1990 average), with conditions cooler by a similar magnitude during the circa 400 years ago. This record highlights regional oceanic warming in the North Atlantic, potentially linked to enhanced subtropical gyre circulation, though the precise mechanisms remain debated due to potential influences from and variations. Coral-based proxies, particularly oxygen isotope (δ¹⁸O) ratios from fossil specimens in the tropical Pacific, reconstruct past SST and hydrological conditions with sub-decadal resolution. Spliced records from reveal a characterized by persistent La Niña-like states, featuring cooler eastern Pacific SSTs, stronger zonal gradients, and reduced ENSO variance relative to the and modern eras. These patterns imply relatively expanded western Pacific warm pools due to enhanced , contributing to drought-forcing teleconnections over , though tropical mean SSTs appear comparable to or slightly below 20th-century levels without evidence of uniform basin-wide warming. Complementary Sr/Ca ratios from corals in regions like the and eastern corroborate seasonal SST elevations during parts of the Medieval Climate Anomaly (900–1300 CE), with anomalies up to 0.5–1°C in localized western margins. Lake sediment records, including annually laminated (varved) deposits, yield terrestrial temperature proxies through biological remains insensitive to marine influences. In European sites like varved lakes in the and , chironomid (non-biting ) head capsule assemblages infer July air s 1–2°C above minima during Medieval Warm Period intervals, reflecting shifts toward warm-adapted taxa. stratigraphy from Asian varved lakes, such as Sugan Lake in the , documents increased percentages of thermophilous arboreal species (e.g., Pinus and Betula) around 1000 CE, signaling higher summer insolation-driven warmth and vegetation expansion beyond modern distributions. These proxies underscore continental summer biases in Medieval Warm Period signals, with counts enabling precise dating but susceptible to local hydrological biases in chironomid inferences.

Regional Evidence

North Atlantic and Europe

![Hvalsey Church, a ruin from the Norse Eastern Settlement in Greenland][float-right] The Norse colonization of Greenland around 985 CE coincided with climatic conditions that facilitated settlement and agriculture in the Eastern and Western Settlements, where summers were approximately 1–1.5 °C warmer than those of the late 20th century, as evidenced by lake sediment proxies from the Eastern Settlement. These warmer conditions, peaking between 900–1200 CE, reduced sea ice extent along the southwestern coast, enabling viable farming of barley and hay for livestock, and supporting a population estimated at up to 5,000 by the 12th century. Ice-core records from southern Greenland further corroborate this regional warmth, showing temperatures elevated relative to the subsequent Little Ice Age, with borehole thermometry and proxy data indicating summer anomalies of +1 °C or more during the Medieval Climate Anomaly (MCA). In , particularly the and , historical and proxy reconstructions by Hubert Lamb documented a period of enhanced warmth from roughly 900–1300 CE, with central temperatures averaging 1–2 °C higher than during the (LIA), based on phenological records, harvest dates, and early instrumental data analogs. Tree-ring width chronologies and documentary evidence, such as expanded into and , indicate reduced storm frequency and milder winters, attributed to persistent positive North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) phases that steered warmer oceanic influences northward. Multi-proxy syntheses for the North Atlantic rim confirm this pattern, with borehole temperatures and δ¹⁸O data showing peak warmth around 1000–1100 CE, exceeding LIA baselines by 0.5–1.5 °C in . Maritime evidence from the North Atlantic supports these terrestrial signals, including expanded Viking trade routes to and the , facilitated by diminished storminess and relatively higher relative sea levels compared to the , which improved harbor accessibility along European coasts. Sediment cores from the reveal decreased fluvial input and enhanced marine productivity, consistent with warmer sea surface temperatures (SSTs) of 1–2 °C above levels during 950–1250 CE. These regional indicators collectively portray the MWP as a coherent warm episode in the North Atlantic domain, distinct from asynchronous patterns elsewhere.

North America

Tree-ring chronologies from the , including networks of (Pseudotsuga menziesii) and piñon pine () sites, reconstruct severe mega-droughts spanning approximately 900–1300 CE, characterized by reductions exceeding 50% below modern averages in the Basin. These arid episodes, more persistent than 20th-century droughts, coincided with proxy-inferred warmer temperatures across the region, as evidenced by reduced ring-width sensitivity to under elevated rates typical of warmer conditions. Such continental interior patterns, driven by altered monsoon dynamics and feedbacks rather than proximal Atlantic forcing, underscore localized warmth amplifying severity during the Medieval Warm Period. Pollen records from lake sediments in central and eastern indicate elevated summer temperatures around 950–1250 CE, with increased abundances of thermophilous taxa such as (Carya) and (Quercus), signaling extended frost-free seasons conducive to . This warming facilitated the intensification of (Zea mays) cultivation, with archaeological radiocarbon dates placing sustained horticultural sites as far north as and the Middle Ohio Valley by 1000 CE, beyond the crop's typical modern limits without . These shifts reflect biome responses to mean annual temperatures 0.5–1°C above preceding centuries, independent of coastal influences. Borehole thermometry and ice-core δ¹⁸O ratios from Arctic Canada, including the and Agassiz Ice Cap, register peak medieval warmth around 1000–1100 CE, with winter temperatures up to 1.5°C above 20th-century means in interior highlands. These signals, decoupled from Greenland's North Atlantic-driven anomalies, align with responses evident in multi-proxy syntheses, confirming broad-scale positive temperature departures across northern continental interiors.

Asia

In , tree-ring chronologies and records indicate elevated warm-season temperatures during the (circa 900–1200 CE). Reconstructions from multiple proxies across the region reveal a warm interval following a multi-century cooling phase, with summer temperatures comparable to or exceeding those in subsequent periods prior to the . In , high-resolution δ¹⁸O and δ¹³C records from document climate anomalies aligning with the MWP, characterized by drier conditions and weaker East Asian summer monsoons, alongside evidence of milder overall thermal regimes. Complementary data from Yongxing further corroborate hydrological shifts, with reduced variability during this epoch consistent with regional warming influences. Tree-ring analyses in western , derived from chronologies spanning over 1300 years, identify the period around 800–1000 CE as the warmest since 618 CE, marked by enhanced growth indicative of higher temperatures. In northern , tree-ring width and density measurements from sites such as the tundra-taiga boundary demonstrate summer warmth levels during the MWP that rivaled 20th-century conditions, with no evidence of unprecedented recent warming in these proxies. Such records suggest continental-scale thermal anomalies, including potential advances in growth limits tied to prolonged growing seasons. Japanese historical documents, including court records and agricultural annals from the (794–1185 CE), describe climatic optima with abundant harvests, infrequent severe winters, and occasional summer floods attributable to intensified activity. These accounts align with proxy-inferred warmth, depicting a phase of relative stability and productivity before cooler conditions emerged around 1100 CE.

Africa, Middle East, and South Asia

Sediment cores from crater lakes in western , such as those analyzed in multiproxy studies, reveal evidence of drier conditions during the Medieval Climate Anomaly (MCA, approximately AD 1000–1200), characterized by low lake levels and lithological indicators of , consistent with enhanced under warmer regional temperatures. Similar patterns emerge from East African lake records, where reduced and heightened during this interval are linked to shifts in the , implying warmer overlying air masses that intensified hydrological deficits. In the and Arabia, the majority of onshore proxy records, including and data, indicate warmer MCA conditions across much of the Afro-Arabian domain, though with exceptions in the southern Levant where cooler and drier phases predominated during the early MCA (circa AD 900–1100). sequences from coastal document vegetation shifts compatible with a relatively warm and unstable , potentially enabling localized expansions in olive cultivation amid variable hydroclimate, as inferred from archaeological correlations with medieval agricultural practices. These proxies underscore a regionally heterogeneous MCA, with in the tied to weakened winter but overall warmth facilitating certain agrosystems in adjacent areas. Speleothem oxygen isotope records from northeastern exhibit stronger Indian Summer (ISM) from approximately AD 640 to 1060, overlapping the MCA and correlating with warmth through enhanced land-sea thermal contrasts that invigorated circulation. This intensified phase, evidenced by lower δ¹⁸O values indicative of heavier rainfall, contrasts with subsequent weakening but aligns with multi-proxy syntheses showing hydroclimatic variability tied to hemispheric temperature anomalies during the period. Such highlight the MCA's influence on South Asian , where warmer conditions periodically amplified moisture delivery despite spatial inconsistencies across the subcontinent.

Southern Hemisphere Regions

Tree-ring chronologies from Libocedrus bidwillii on New Zealand's reconstruct austral summer temperatures over the past 1,100 years, revealing elevated warmth during the 10th to early 11th centuries CE, with peaks around 1000 CE exceeding mid-20th-century levels by approximately 0.5–1°C in some reconstructions. This warmth aligns with broader patterns but exhibits variability, as the record shows cooler conditions by the . In , annually resolved oxygen isotope (δ¹⁸O) records from lake sediments in the indicate a peak in aridity and inferred warming during the Medieval Climate Anomaly (MCA, circa 900–1100 CE), marked by a weakened South American Summer Monsoon and δ¹⁸O values up to 2‰ higher than preceding centuries, suggesting reduced and higher rates consistent with elevated temperatures. Complementary evidence from Patagonian and fluctuations documents retreats during this interval, with records and sediment proxies showing diminished ice extent around 1000–1200 CE, followed by advances in the subsequent . These changes correlate with upslope shifts in zones and increased biological productivity in high-altitude lakes, further supporting regional warming. Australian proxy syntheses, including borehole temperature profiles and alpine dendrochronological data from southeastern regions, indicate variable but generally elevated temperatures during the MCA, spanning roughly 1100–1390 CE, with some sites recording warmth comparable to or exceeding early industrial-era levels amid reduced in monsoon-influenced areas. Multi-proxy assessments across , incorporating 15 sites, find that 10 exhibit relative warmth during 900–1500 CE relative to the preceding 1,500 years, though spatial inconsistencies highlight localized ocean-atmosphere influences. Antarctic coastal records, particularly from the , provide evidence of MCA warmth through oxygen excursions in ikaite pseudomorphs from marine sediments, showing positive δ¹⁸O shifts around 1000–1200 CE indicative of temperatures 1–2°C higher than the subsequent , extending patterns southward with a lagged response. Broader Antarctic compilations from 60 proxy sites, including cores and isotopes, map similar positive temperature anomalies in coastal sectors during this period, though continental interiors display muted signals due to effects. These findings underscore hemispheric asymmetry in proxy density but affirm warmth in accessible locales.

Global Extent and Synchrony

Indicators of Broad Synchrony

Multi-site proxy records from tree rings, ice cores, and marine sediments demonstrate temporal overlaps in peak warmth during approximately 950–1100 CE across (NH) and (SH) locations, indicating broad hemispheric coherence rather than isolated regional anomalies. NH tree-ring chronologies and Greenland ice-core oxygen data reveal elevated summer temperatures centered around AD 1000, with anomalies exceeding the subsequent baseline by up to 1°C in select sites. Concurrently, SH sediment cores from the Pacific and Atlantic sectors, including varved lake deposits in and tree-ring series, register drier and warmer conditions synchronous with NH peaks, such as enhanced aridity in around 1000–1200 CE linked to shifted storm tracks. Spectral analyses of these diverse proxies uncover shared low-frequency oscillations (centennial-scale) that align across hemispheres, surpassing levels attributable to uncorrelated local and implying extratropical teleconnections. For example, multi-proxy compilations identify coherent variability in the 100–200-year band during the Medieval interval, consistent with amplified solar or ocean-atmosphere influences propagating globally. Such common signals appear in both NH dendrochronologies and SH records, where phase-locking of warm phases challenges purely regional interpretations. Multi-proxy reconstructions incorporating these alignments, such as Moberg et al. (2005), estimate NH temperature anomalies of 0.2–0.5°C above the pre-industrial mean during the ~950–1100 CE peaks, with SH proxy corroboration (e.g., 21 of 22 studies indicating warm conditions) extending the signal's footprint. This empirical coherence is further evidenced by global reorganization patterns, including opposing SST gradients in the tropical that synchronized in the and enhanced activity elsewhere around 1000 CE.

Evidence from Multi-Proxy Reconstructions

Multi-proxy reconstructions integrate diverse paleoclimate indicators, such as ice cores, sediments, and historical records, to estimate past temperatures while minimizing biases from individual proxy types. These approaches often employ empirical methods like averaging standardized proxy series, avoiding heavy reliance on statistical models that may smooth variability. For the (MWP, circa 950–1250 CE), such reconstructions reveal elevated temperatures in multiple hemispheres, with global means approaching or exceeding mid-20th-century levels in some datasets. The PAGES 2k Consortium's database compiles 692 temperature-sensitive proxy records from 648 locations worldwide, enabling subset analyses of regional and hemispheric patterns. During the MWP, approximately 40% of sites exhibited peak warmth synchronously within decades, indicating coordinated anomalies across significant portions of the and select locales, though full global uniformity remains debated. This empirical subset analysis underscores widespread, if not perfectly synchronous, warmth exceeding pre-industrial baselines in 40–60% of analyzed records when focusing on unadjusted proxy signals. Independent multi-proxy efforts excluding tree-ring data, such as Loehle's 2007 reconstruction from 18 non-tree-ring proxies (including temperatures, corals, and sediments), yield a global series where MWP temperatures averaged 0.3°C warmer than the 20th-century mean (1902–1980). This peak, centered around 950–1000 CE, rivals or surpasses subsequent centuries in amplitude before declining into the . Corrections to the dataset in 2008 confirmed minimal alterations to the MWP signal, validating the robustness of empirical averaging over model-dependent infilling. Additional reconstructions, like those by Moberg et al. (2005) incorporating low-frequency variability from multi-proxy sources, depict MWP global temperatures comparable to the early , with pronounced warmth. These findings contrast with tree-ring-heavy syntheses that attenuate pre-industrial peaks, highlighting the value of diverse proxies for capturing full climatic range. Empirical multi-proxy averages thus provide evidence of substantive MWP warmth, challenging narratives of exceptional modern uniformity when unadjusted data are prioritized.

Challenges to Asynchronous Narratives

Reanalyses of paleoclimate datasets have identified limitations in asynchronous narratives for the , stemming from proxy validation issues and uneven spatial coverage. Reconstructions asserting regional asynchrony, such as Neukom et al. (2019), rely on multi-proxy networks that exhibit significant sparsity in the —comprising only about 12-16% of records—potentially underestimating coherent warm signals there due to insufficient sampling of temperature-sensitive proxies like tree rings or ice cores. This imbalance favors dominance, where denser data may amplify perceptions of temporal offsets, while sparse Southern data limits detection of global-scale alignment. Raw proxy evidence further challenges model-dependent asynchronous interpretations by showing temporal alignment across distant sites. For example, the Sargasso Sea foraminiferal Mg/Ca record from Keigwin () documents sea surface temperatures peaking around 1000 AD, contemporaneous with North Atlantic and European terrestrial proxies, contradicting expectations of staggered regional peaks under purely asynchronous internal variability. Similar empirical peaks in tropical proxies, such as certain δ¹⁸O records from the , exhibit warmth centered circa 950-1100 AD, highlighting mismatches between unadjusted data and reconstructions that impose asynchrony through statistical . Causal mechanisms reinforce expectations of greater coherence than regional ocean modes alone would produce. Solar irradiance reconstructions indicate elevated levels during the Medieval period, prior to the Wolf solar minimum around 1280 AD, exerting a global that influences and heat distribution hemispherically, unlike localized ocean-atmosphere oscillations such as the El Niño-Southern Oscillation. Model simulations of preindustrial forcings confirm solar variations yield spatially extensive temperature responses, consistent with observed proxy alignments rather than fragmented regionality.

Proposed Causes

Solar Irradiance and Volcanic Activity

Reconstructions of solar activity using beryllium-10 (¹⁰Be) concentrations in polar ice cores indicate elevated solar output during the Medieval Warm Period, particularly around 1100–1250 CE, corresponding to a period of high sunspot activity and increased total solar irradiance (TSI). These cosmogenic isotope records reflect reduced cosmic ray flux due to stronger heliomagnetic modulation, implying TSI levels comparable to or exceeding those of the late 20th century, with estimated radiative forcing changes of approximately 0.2–0.5 W/m² relative to the subsequent Little Ice Age minimum. Such variations arise from modulations in solar magnetic activity, which influence Earth's energy balance through direct insolation and indirect effects on atmospheric chemistry. Volcanic forcing during the MWP featured reduced stratospheric aerosol loading, as evidenced by lower sulfate deposition fluxes in and ice cores between approximately 900 and 1200 CE. This period exhibited fewer large-magnitude eruptions capable of injecting significant into the , minimizing the reflective "veils" that typically induce multiyear cooling; for instance, major events like the 1108–1110 CE cluster were outliers amid an overall quiescent phase prior to intensified activity in the 13th century. The resultant low optical depth allowed unperturbed solar radiation to reach the surface, amplifying warming tendencies without the counteracting negative forcing from volcanic sulfates, which can exceed -2 W/m² for individual large eruptions. Climate model simulations incorporating these solar and volcanic reconstructions demonstrate that the combined natural forcings account for 50–70% of the observed hemispheric variance during the MWP, with driving centennial-scale trends and subdued enabling their expression. Energy balance models further quantify this by attributing ~0.1–0.3°C of warming to the net positive forcing imbalance, consistent with proxy-derived anomalies. These empirical drivers align with causal expectations, as enhanced solar input and absent volcanic perturbations directly elevate tropospheric via radiative physics, independent of internal variability amplifications addressed elsewhere.

Ocean Circulation and Atmospheric Patterns

Proxy reconstructions from tree-ring chronologies, historical documents, and speleothems indicate a persistent positive phase of the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) during the Medieval Climate Anomaly (MCA, circa 950–1250 CE), characterized by enhanced pressure gradients between the Icelandic Low and Azores High. This configuration intensified westerly winds across the North Atlantic, promoting greater poleward heat transport via the North Atlantic Current and reducing winter storm tracks over northern Europe, thereby amplifying solar radiative forcing effects on regional temperatures. Model simulations constrained by these proxies confirm that positive NAO phases increased meridional heat fluxes by up to 0.5 PW toward higher latitudes, sustaining warmer sea surface temperatures (SSTs) in the subpolar gyre despite modest external forcings. Shifts toward a positive Atlantic Multidecadal Oscillation (AMO)-like state are inferred from records showing reduced coastal and elevated SST anomalies across the North Atlantic basin during the MCA. For instance, foraminiferal assemblages and alkenone proxies from Iberian margin cores reveal diminished nutrient fluxes and warmer subtropical waters, consistent with weakened and gyre circulation that limited cold deep-water entrainment. These patterns, with multidecadal spectral peaks at 50–70 years, suggest internal ocean-atmosphere feedbacks amplified basin-wide warmth, extending heat anomalies equatorward and poleward to reinforce NAO-driven transport. Teleconnections linked circulation anomalies to Southern Hemisphere responses during the MCA, with proxy evidence of atmospheric bridges propagating solar-modulated signals southward. Reconstructions indicate that positive NAO-AMO phases altered cross-equatorial energy fluxes, potentially shifting the (ITCZ) and influencing SSTs via propagation and expansions. Coral and δ¹⁸O records from the tropical Pacific and margins show coherent La Niña-like conditions and reduced upwelling variance, implying damped ENSO activity that facilitated hemispheric warmth synchrony beyond local radiative inputs. These modes thus acted as amplifiers, with NAO-driven North Atlantic heat convergence influencing global reorganization patterns evident in multi-proxy syntheses.

Orbital and Internal Variability Factors

Orbital variations, as described by , exerted a minor influence on climate during the Medieval Warm Period (circa 950–1250 CE), with changes in summer insolation contributing less than 0.15°C to average European temperatures over the preceding millennium. These cycles—encompassing eccentricity, obliquity, and —had already initiated a long-term decline in NH summer insolation since the early peak around 10,000 years ago, fostering a backdrop of relatively higher seasonal forcing compared to later epochs like the , though the centennial-scale shifts during the MWP remained subdued. Internal variability, manifested through multi-decadal ocean-atmosphere oscillations analogous to the modern (AMO) and (PDO), modulated regional temperature and precipitation patterns during the period. Proxy reconstructions and model simulations indicate a positive AMO-like phase prevailed in the North Atlantic, elevating sea surface temperatures and amplifying drought conditions across while enhancing warmth in extratropical regions. PDO analogs, characterized by La Niña-like conditions combined with warm AMO phases, similarly influenced Pacific variability, contributing to hemispheric-scale coherence in hydroclimatic shifts without implying global uniformity. Empirical analyses from models reveal that while internal dynamics accounted for spatial heterogeneity and some temporal persistence in MWP warmth, they fell short of replicating the reconstructed amplitude of hemispheric anomalies, which exceeded typical unforced variability by factors requiring external radiative inputs. Multi-model ensembles further constrain this limit, showing internal fluctuations capable of generating regional anomalies on par with observations but insufficient for the sustained, multi-proxy corroborated elevations without synergistic forcings.

Comparisons to Current Warming

Peak Temperature Levels

Proxy-based reconstructions of extratropical temperatures during the (MWP) reveal regional peaks exceeding 1°C above mid-20th-century levels in unadjusted multi-proxy analyses. For instance, extra-tropical land temperature variability over the past two millennia indicates MWP maxima around AD 950–1050 reaching approximately 0.7°C relative to the 1880–1960 reference period, comparable to or surpassing early 20th-century records prior to accelerated anthropogenic CO2 increases. Sea surface temperature proxies from the corroborate elevated MWP warmth, with values approximately 1°C higher than late 20th-century observations around AD 1000, derived from radiocarbon-dated sediment cores reflecting unadjusted isotopic signals. Tree-ring chronologies in further support this, showing summer temperatures during the MWP (circa AD 900–1200) as warm as those in the 20th century, based on maximum latewood density and ring width measurements. Global multi-proxy syntheses incorporating such records, including and tree-ring data, estimate MWP averages 0.1–0.3°C warmer than pre-industrial baselines (circa AD 1400–1850), though variability stems from proxy density rather than inherent global coolness. This lack of empirical mandate for a cooler global MWP highlights how sparse coverage in reconstructions can attenuate hemispheric signals when averaged without weighting for or resolution.

Spatial Uniformity and Rate of Change

Proxy reconstructions reveal that Medieval Warm Period (MWP) warmth displayed less spatial uniformity than the spatially coherent global warming observed since the late , with robust signals across land areas but sparser and more variable evidence in the . multi-proxy syntheses, incorporating tree rings, , and documentary records, indicate hemispheric-scale coherence in extratropical regions during circa 950–1250 CE, encompassing , , and . In contrast, SH proxies—such as New Zealand tree rings peaking later around 1200–1300 CE and limited data showing minimal change—exhibit delayed or subdued responses, attributable in part to fewer high-resolution medieval-era records rather than absence of warmth. This data asymmetry has fueled arguments for MWP regionality, though empirical hemispheric patterns suggest broader coverage than SH sparsity alone implies, challenging claims of modern uniqueness without accounting for proxy distribution biases. The transition into MWP conditions occurred over centuries, with proxy-inferred warming from the preceding Dark Age Cold Period unfolding gradually across 200–400 years, as seen in European and North Atlantic sediment and tree-ring series. This contrasts with the accelerated modern onset, where instrumental data record rates exceeding 0.2 °C per decade in the since the . Averaged hemispheric rates during MWP peaks approximate 0.1–0.15 °C per century, derived from low-frequency proxy trends, enabling sustained warmth over multiple centuries without the decadal-scale inflections evident in recent observations. Proxy smoothing and resolution constraints likely attenuate detection of shorter MWP fluctuations, providing context for rate comparisons and underscoring that empirical long-term changes lack the abruptness claimed as unprecedented when viewed through instrumental lenses alone.

Empirical Data vs. Model Projections

Climate model hindcasts of the (MWP), typically driven by reconstructions of natural forcings such as variations and volcanic aerosol loading, frequently understate the magnitude of warming evident in proxy-based reconstructions, particularly in northern extratropical regions. For example, multi-model simulations from paleoclimate intercomparison projects reveal systematic biases, with simulated global mean temperatures during the circa 950–1250 CE interval falling short of proxy-inferred peaks by up to 0.5–1°C in hemispheric averages, as proxies from tree rings, ice cores, and speleothems indicate more pronounced multidecadal anomalies. These discrepancies persist even when internal variability is incorporated via methods, highlighting limitations in models' representation of low-frequency dynamics and forcing efficacy. In the tropics and , proxy-model mismatches further underscore overreliance on forcings in standard simulations. oxygen isotope records and lake sediment proxies from the and South American sectors document hydroclimatic shifts and localized warmth during the MWP that deviate from model outputs, which often predict subdued responses due to damped equatorial sensitivity. Similarly, deuterium data reveal positive temperature anomalies of 1–2°C in coastal regions around 1000 CE, contrasting with model hindcasts that overestimate cooling or fail to simulate enhanced snowfall and warmth linked to altered . Such regional inconsistencies suggest that models tuned to modern greenhouse-driven scenarios inadequately capture teleconnected ocean-atmosphere modes, like shifts in the Southern Annular Mode, which proxies imply amplified MWP signals beyond volcanic or solar inputs alone. These empirical-model divergences imply that assumptions of high equilibrium (ECS > 3°C per CO2 doubling) in many general circulation models may inflate feedback amplification, as lower-sensitivity configurations (ECS ≈ 1.5–2.5°C) better reconcile natural forcings—primarily a 0.2–0.5% increase in total from 900–1100 CE—with observed proxy amplitudes without excessive water vapor or lapse rate enhancements. Simulations incorporating reduced volcanic activity alongside solar maxima demonstrate that direct radiative perturbations suffice to drive hemispheric-scale responses matching proxy variances, diminishing the necessity for strong positive feedbacks that dominate projections of anthropogenic warming. This alignment supports causal attribution to external forcings modulated by internal variability, rather than unverified amplification mechanisms.

Societal and Environmental Impacts

Agricultural and Economic Effects

The Medieval Warm Period (c. 900–1300 CE) brought milder conditions to , with summer temperatures 1–2 °C above modern levels and growing seasons extended by 5–7 weeks, enabling the expansion of into previously marginal areas. records from eastern document a doubling of cultivated land between AD 700 and 1200, accompanied by a 400% rise in human-modified vegetation, reflecting intensified farming practices such as two-course rotation and improved iron tools. These changes boosted crop yields, particularly of and oats, supporting higher across the region. Agricultural gains contributed to substantial population growth, with densities increasing to around 4 persons per km² during the Viking Age (AD 800–1050), compared to 0.1 persons per km² in the Neolithic era, driven by surplus production amid the warm climate. This demographic expansion, estimated in some analyses to have raised Scandinavian populations by factors linked to climatic amelioration, facilitated interior colonization and resource exploitation but also generated pressures that spurred overseas ventures. Economically, the period's navigable ice-free seas enhanced maritime trade, particularly in the Baltic where Viking networks expanded commerce in , furs, and slaves along ancient routes invigorated by reduced winter ice cover. Agricultural surpluses from and Norse outposts, such as Greenland's and farms established around AD 985, further integrated these settlements into transatlantic exchange systems, yielding commodities like for European markets. In , proxy evidence from Byzantine records indicates favorable harvest conditions during the early Medieval Climate Anomaly, with extended seasons supporting production and regional economic resilience.

Human Migrations and Settlements

Norse settlers expanded from Norway to Iceland around 870–930 CE, followed by colonization of Greenland beginning in 985 CE under Erik the Red, coinciding with the onset of the Medieval Warm Period (MWP, approximately 950–1250 CE). These migrations exploited reduced sea ice and milder North Atlantic conditions, facilitating transoceanic voyages that would have been more hazardous under icier regimes. Empirical proxy data, including borehole temperatures and glacier records from Greenland, indicate local warmth during this interval, correlating with viable farming at high latitudes in the Eastern and Western Settlements. However, while climatic amelioration provided opportunities, settlement success also depended on technological adaptations like turf-walled longhouses and pastoral economies suited to marginal environments. In the Pacific, Polynesian voyagers undertook extensive maritime expansions during the MWP, with evidence of favorable climate windows enhancing navigation to remote islands such as New Zealand around 1200–1300 CE. Warmer sea surface temperatures and potentially less variable El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) patterns during the Medieval Climate Anomaly (MCA, overlapping with MWP) are hypothesized to have produced consistent trade winds and reduced storm risks, aiding double-hulled canoe travel across vast distances. Archaeological dating of initial settlements in Central Eastern Polynesia aligns with these MCA conditions, suggesting empirical correlations between climatic stability and demographic dispersal from western origins like the Society Islands. Such patterns underscore adaptive seafaring strategies, including stellar navigation and resource scouting, rather than direct climatic determinism. In the , MWP conditions prompted inland migrations among indigenous populations, particularly in arid regions where prolonged droughts necessitated drought-tolerant agricultural shifts and relocations. Tree-ring and lake sediment records document megadroughts in western from approximately 900–1100 CE and 1100–1200 CE, correlating with the abandonment of large settlements like those in Chaco Canyon and subsequent dispersals to more resilient riverine or highland areas. These movements involved adaptations such as varieties resistant to water stress and diversified subsistence, evidenced by archaeological shifts in site distributions and . In , similar drought episodes during the MCA drove coastal-to-inland transitions among Chumash and other groups, with proxy indicating reduced prompting reliance on stored resources and mobility. Overall, these correlations highlight demographic responses to regional variability within the broader MWP framework, without implying uniform global drivers.

Ecological Shifts and Biodiversity

During the (approximately 950–1250 CE), warmer temperatures facilitated the altitudinal and latitudinal advance of s in , enabling the establishment of forests in regions previously limited by cold growing seasons. Megafossil remains of (Pinus sylvestris) in the Swedish Scandes Mountains indicate that the upper reached elevations 100–200 meters higher than modern levels, as evidenced by subfossil wood dated to this interval, reflecting extended frost-free periods and increased summer warmth. Similarly, and macrofossil records from central document enhanced radial growth and density of tree-line pines during the Medieval Climate Anomaly, supporting broader floral expansions that created new habitats. These vegetational shifts paralleled faunal responses, with warmer conditions promoting range expansions for mammals adapted to forested uplands, such as (Alces alces), whose presence in higher northern latitudes correlated with reduced snow cover and abundant browse. In tropical regions, coral reef ecosystems exhibited growth optima under the elevated sea surface temperatures of the period. Annual density banding in Porites corals from the reveals resilient skeletal and linear extension rates during the Medieval Climate Anomaly, with subfossil specimens indicating stable or enhanced growth compared to cooler phases, attributable to thermal windows favorable for reef accretion without excessive stress from modern acidification. This contrasts with variability in ENSO-driven disruptions, which were muted during parts of the interval, allowing sustained reef development. Wetland ecosystems in subtropical zones, such as Florida's , saw hotspots in tree islands thrive amid warmer, variably drier conditions, with and macrofossil proxies showing maintained or increased diversity and biomass on these features, serving as refugia for avian and reptilian . Cyanobacterial abundances in associated lakes peaked, reflecting nutrient dynamics under elevated temperatures. In contrast, the ensuing cooling (circa 1300–1850 CE) induced habitat contractions and reduced richness in these systems, underscoring the adaptive expansion enabled by natural Medieval warming.

Controversies and Debates

Disputes Over Global Warmth

Critics of reconstructions minimizing the global extent of the Medieval Warm Period (MWP) argue that datasets like the PAGES 2k multiproxy compilation underrepresent Southern Hemisphere (SH) warmth due to reliance on sparse proxy sites, with only about 16% of records from the SH and limited spatial coverage that may overlook broader signals. Fuller reviews of SH proxies, including tree rings, corals, and sediments, reveal evidence of anomalous warmth during the MWP in 21 out of 22 studies examined, suggesting selective proxy subsets in mainstream syntheses contribute to homogenized narratives downplaying hemispheric coherence. For example, a 1100-year tree-ring chronology from Tasmania indicates peak warmth around 1000 CE, aligning temporally with Northern Hemisphere (NH) records despite regional variability. Marine sediment cores from the further challenge strictly regional interpretations, recording sea surface temperatures during the MWP (circa 950–1250 CE) indistinguishable from 20th-century levels, with subsequent cooling of approximately 1°C unexplained by purely local ocean dynamics or NH-centric forcings. Similarly, ice-core records, such as those from the GISP2 , exhibit temperature anomalies of up to 1.3°C above the 1881–1980 reference during the MWP, corroborated by thermometry and consistent with solar-driven signals rather than isolated Arctic amplification. From a causal perspective, elevated during the MWP—evidenced by reduced cosmogenic isotopes like ¹⁴C in tree rings and ¹⁰Be in ice cores—represents a uniformly distributed forcing that should imprint globally, as validated by synchronous proxy responses across latitudes, including SH sites where volcanic or internal variability alone fails to account for the observed multimillennial coherence. This empirical pattern contradicts models assuming negligible global teleconnections, highlighting inconsistencies with narratives confining MWP warmth to NH landmasses.

Role in Climate Sensitivity Discussions

The Medieval Warm Period (MWP) functions as a quasi-experimental test for equilibrium (ECS), the expected long-term global temperature rise from a doubling of atmospheric CO2 concentration, because it occurred under stable pre-industrial CO2 levels of approximately 280 ppm, with estimated radiative forcing changes driven primarily by variations (up to 0.2–0.5 W/m² increase relative to subsequent centuries) and reduced volcanic loading. Simulations using intermediate-complexity models with ECS values around 1.8°C successfully reproduce European summer temperatures during the MWP comparable to late 20th-century levels, attributing the warmth to these natural forcings combined with land-use changes, without requiring amplified greenhouse gas effects. Such matches suggest that ECS below 2°C per CO2 doubling aligns with observed forcing-response relationships, as higher sensitivities would overpredict warming unless natural forcing efficacies are artificially diminished. High-ECS models (above 3°C) encounter challenges in hindcasting the MWP, often underestimating the amplitude of millennial-scale oscillations unless solar forcing is reduced below unity or other parameters are tuned to suppress variability. Empirical assessments indicate solar near or exceeding 1 relative to CO2 forcing, based on observed surface responses to 11-year solar cycles and proxy-inferred past changes, critiquing model assumptions that stratospheric cooling or pattern effects inherently weaken solar impacts. These discrepancies highlight potential over-reliance on low- solar representations in high-sensitivity frameworks, which fail to replicate the MWP's sustained warmth without adjustments. As a benchmark for pre-industrial dynamics, the MWP imposes empirical bounds on ECS by demonstrating that natural variability—encompassing solar, volcanic, and internal modes—dominated centennial-scale shifts under low CO2 forcing, with proxy-derived global or hemispheric anomalies of 0.2–0.6°C consistent with modest feedback amplification. This underscores that feedbacks operative during the MWP, such as and responses, did not engender runaway warming despite positive forcings, supporting ECS estimates in the lower half of assessed ranges (1.5–2.5°C) over higher values that would amplify past variability beyond observations.

Critiques of Mainstream Reconstructions

Critiques of mainstream paleoclimate reconstructions that diminish the prominence of the Medieval Warm Period (MWP) center on proxy selection biases and statistical artifacts that amplify 20th-century anomalies. The "hockey stick" series from Mann, Bradley, and Hughes (1998, 1999) depended heavily on strip-bark bristlecone pine chronologies from arid southwestern U.S. sites, which respond to non-thermal stressors like elevated CO2 levels and moisture availability rather than temperature alone, particularly after 1900. Statistical audits revealed that these series, comprising a disproportionate share of pre-1400 proxy variance, drive the flattened medieval shaft and upturned recent blade; truncating them yields reconstructions without the hockey-stick form, indicating methodological over-reliance on atypical proxies. Non-standard principal component centering further biased low-frequency medieval signals downward, while infilling sparse network gaps assumed inter-site correlations unsupported by raw data, inflating post-1850 uniqueness relative to earlier centuries. IPCC Assessment Reports from the Third onward integrated such reconstructions, yet critiques highlight selective emphasis on Northern Hemisphere (NH) data while downplaying Southern Hemisphere (SH) proxy alignments that suggest broader MWP coherence. AR4 acknowledged NH medieval warmth (950–1100) as anomalous in a 2,000-year NH context but invoked sparse SH evidence to imply regionality, despite raw, unsmoothed proxies exhibiting NH-SH covariations inconsistent with this narrative. Smoothing techniques applied in IPCC figures can artifactually reduce apparent pre-industrial variance, masking empirical discrepancies between raw series and model-derived uniformity. Studies purporting MWP asynchrony, such as the 2015 Lamont-Doherty () examination of glacier advances, have faced scrutiny for prioritizing localized SH-like signals in the to challenge global extent, while sidelining contiguous ice-core datasets showing medieval NH warmth peaks. This site-specific focus, using and glacial proxies from a narrow Canadian sector, overlooks network-wide Arctic borehole and records that align more closely with Eurasian and North Atlantic medieval optima, exemplifying proxy cherry-picking to fit asynchrony hypotheses over comprehensive empirical synthesis.

References

  1. https://cp.copernicus.org/articles/2/99/
  2. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/14563996/
  3. https://news.northwestern.edu/stories/2019/02/study-shows-that-vikings-enjoyed-a-warm-greenland
  4. https://est.ufba.br/sites/est.ufba.br/files/kim/medievalwarmperiod.pdf
  5. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.292.5524.2011b
  6. https://e360.yale.edu/digest/tree-ring-study-medieval-warm-period
  7. https://skepticalscience.com/medieval-warm-period.htm
  8. https://archive.ipcc.ch/ipccreports/tar/wg1/070.htm
  9. https://pastglobalchanges.org/publications/pages-magazines/pages-magazine/7489
  10. https://www.nature.com/articles/s43247-023-00734-4
  11. https://theconversation.com/climate-explained-what-was-the-medieval-warm-period-155294
  12. https://www.nature.com/articles/srep32984
  13. https://pastglobalchanges.org/sites/default/files/download/docs/newsletter/2011-1/NL2011-1_highres.pdf
  14. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2892219
  15. https://www.co2science.org/subject/m/summaries/mwparctic.php
  16. https://www.int-res.com/articles/cr2003/23/c023p089.pdf
  17. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2003RG000143
  18. https://cp.copernicus.org/articles/2/99/2006/cp-2-99-2006.pdf
  19. https://history.aip.org/climate/xLamb.htm
  20. https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geology/article/47/3/267/568708/Medieval-warmth-confirmed-at-the-Norse-Eastern
  21. https://pastglobalchanges.org/publications/pages-magazines/pages-magazine/7504
  22. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00173130510010477
  23. https://www.ltrr.arizona.edu/~rtouchan/Mediterranean_publications/med_book2005.pdf
  24. http://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2002AGUFMPP71C..09L/abstract
  25. https://cp.copernicus.org/articles/16/1873/2020/
  26. https://phys.org/news/2012-02-ancient-arabic-scientists-piece-climate.html
  27. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/13629387.2016.1239079
  28. https://www.medievalists.net/2012/02/arabic-sources-show-extreme-weather-hit-medieval-baghdad/
  29. https://pastglobalchanges.org/publications/pages-magazines/pages-magazine/7498
  30. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/30/14/jcli-d-16-0526.1.xml
  31. https://factreview.s3.eu-central-1.amazonaws.com/uploads/2023/04/How-Warm-Was-the-Medieval-Warm-Period-Crowley-et-al-2000.pdf
  32. https://www.ltrr.arizona.edu/trt/current.pdf
  33. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/2024GL109799
  34. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1125786520300965
  35. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2011gl049444
  36. https://www.sciencedirect.com/topics/earth-and-planetary-sciences/medieval-warm-period
  37. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0033589401922525
  38. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/252155288_A_delayed_medieval_warming_observed_and_simulated_in_high_southern_latitudes
  39. https://tc.copernicus.org/articles/15/1157/2021/
  40. https://www.mdpi.com/2571-550X/6/2/32
  41. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2024RG000847
  42. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/370628104_Revisit_the_Medieval_Warm_Period_and_Little_Ice_Age_in_Proxy_Records_from_Zemu_Glacier_Sediments_Eastern_Himalaya_Vegetation_and_Climate_Reconstruction
  43. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.274.5292.1504
  44. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8929406/
  45. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2009GL042239
  46. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0031018222005454
  47. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6534512/
  48. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/0959683609348253
  49. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/229415563_A_2700-year_high_resolution_pollen_record_of_climate_change_from_varved_Sugan_Lake_in_the_Qaidam_Basin_northeastern_Tibetan_Plateau
  50. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0341816222001928
  51. https://www.meteo.psu.edu/holocene/public_html/shared/articles/medclimopt.pdf
  52. https://www.thegwpf.org/content/uploads/2015/02/Lamb.pdf
  53. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3003080/
  54. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2022GL098781
  55. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0921818111001573
  56. https://mspace.lib.umanitoba.ca/bitstream/1993/7822/1/Flynn_Cultural_Responses.pdf
  57. https://www.co2science.org/subject/n/summaries/northamericamwp.php
  58. https://cp.copernicus.org/articles/8/227/2012/cp-8-227-2012.pdf
  59. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-26038-8
  60. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0277379102002408
  61. https://cp.copernicus.org/articles/16/475/2020/
  62. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/244942179_1300_Years_of_climatic_history_for_Western_Central_Asia_inferred_from_tree-rings
  63. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0277379113001856
  64. https://ijkh.khistory.org/upload/pdf/12-06.pdf
  65. https://researchmap.jp/read0019953/published_papers/12861327/attachment_file.pdf
  66. https://cp.copernicus.org/articles/10/1581/2014/
  67. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution/articles/10.3389/fevo.2018.00223/full
  68. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/2017PA003237
  69. https://leilan.yale.edu/sites/default/files/publications/article-specific/kaniewski_et_al_2011_medieval_climate_anomaly_gpc.pdf
  70. https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4433/10/1/29
  71. https://data.mendeley.com/datasets/58bs5hctxr/3
  72. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0012825216302136
  73. https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms7309
  74. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2001GL014580
  75. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1003719108
  76. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1040618218308322
  77. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-018-22766-z
  78. https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/abs/10.1139/er-2019-0012
  79. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0012821X12000659
  80. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0031018219303190
  81. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/2001GL014580
  82. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00382-010-0914-z
  83. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1066208
  84. https://stephenschneider.stanford.edu/Publications/PDF_Papers/MobergEtAl2005.pdf
  85. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1260/095830507782616797
  86. https://www.asc.ohio-state.edu/mcculloch.2/AGW/Loehle/Loehle_McC_E&E_2008.pdf
  87. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-019-1401-2
  88. https://www.nature.com/articles/sdata201788
  89. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277379122001688
  90. https://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article/122/11-12/1981/125529/Sub-Milankovitch-solar-forcing-of-past-climates
  91. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/16/24/1520-0442_2003_016_4094_vasfoc_2.0.co_2.xml
  92. https://svalgaard.leif.org/EOS/Earth-Climate-Evolution/ch15.pdf
  93. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/2014JD021561
  94. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2011PA002130
  95. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0921818111001172
  96. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/2023JD039966
  97. https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20140001050/downloads/20140001050.pdf
  98. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/26/18/jcli-d-12-00826.1.xml
  99. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258489485_The_extra-tropical_NH_temperature_in_the_last_two_millennia_reconstructions_of_low-frequency_variability
  100. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/24/23/2011jcli4145.1.xml
  101. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1029/2003GL017814
  102. https://archimer.ifremer.fr/doc/00225/33648/32092.pdf
  103. https://pastglobalchanges.org/publications/pages-magazines/pages-magazine/7502
  104. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/26/18/jcli-d-12-00108.1.xml
  105. https://scholarworks.umt.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4881&context=etd
  106. https://wires.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wcc.691
  107. https://notrickszone.com/2022/07/18/new-study-the-reality-of-the-medieval-warm-period-confirmed-by-changes-in-agricultural-practices/
  108. https://glossary.wein.plus/medieval-warm-period
  109. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/am/pii/S0277379115301281
  110. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0277379124006589
  111. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.1408918111
  112. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1191/0959683606hl901ft
  113. https://www.ldeo.columbia.edu/~jsmerdon/papers/2016_wirescc_cooketal.pdf
  114. https://digitalcommons.law.lsu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1422&context=faculty_scholarship
  115. https://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1014&context=ssci_fac
  116. https://landscape-online.org/index.php/lo/article/view/LO.201542
  117. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/ecology-and-evolution/articles/10.3389/fevo.2014.00020/full
  118. https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2503428122
  119. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0921818124001036
  120. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0088790
  121. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/2019PA003742
  122. https://esajournals.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1890/0012-9615%25282006%2529076%255B0565%253AROETIT%255D2.0.CO%253B2
  123. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0048969720321227
  124. https://pastglobalchanges.org/publications/pages-magazines/pages-magazine/7492
  125. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/222527263_Medieval_Warm_Period_Little_Ice_Age_and_20th_century_temperature_variability_from_Chesapeake_Bay
  126. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1674987123002414
  127. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/34/8/JCLI-D-20-0312.1.xml
  128. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.gsf.2023.101774
  129. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1674987123001172
  130. https://www.rossmckitrick.com/uploads/4/8/0/8/4808045/hockey-stick-retrospective.pdf
  131. https://rucforsk.ruc.dk/ws/files/57584372/The_Hockey_Stick_controversy.pdf
  132. https://www.jstor.org/stable/44397247
  133. https://archive.ipcc.ch/publications_and_data/ar4/wg1/en/ch6s6-6.html
  134. https://news.climate.columbia.edu/2015/12/04/study-undercuts-idea-that-medieval-warm-period-was-global/
  135. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4673052/
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.