Hubbry Logo
Rachel FreierRachel FreierMain
Open search
Rachel Freier
Community hub
Rachel Freier
logo
8 pages, 0 posts
0 subscribers
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Be the first to start a discussion here.
Rachel Freier
Rachel Freier
Rachel Freier
View on Wikipedia
from Wikipedia

Rachel "Ruchie" Freier (born April 2, 1965)[1] is a New York Supreme Court justice.[2]

Key Information

In 2016, she campaigned and was elected as a Civil Court judge for the Kings County 5th judicial district in New York State, thereby becoming the first Hasidic Jewish woman to be elected as a civil court judge in New York State,[3][4][5] and the first Hasidic woman[6] to hold public office[7] in United States history.[8] Although she ran for the Civil Court, after her election, she was assigned to serve on the Criminal Court in the Kings County 5th judicial district.[9]

In January 2023 she was appointed to fill a vacancy on the New York Supreme Court, and in November 2023 she was elected to the position in her own right. She previously worked as a real estate attorney and community activist, and served as a volunteer court lawyer in the New York City Family Court.[10]

Early life and education

[edit]

Freier was born in Borough Park, Brooklyn,[11][9] the eldest of five children in a Hasidic Jewish family.[12] While attending the Bais Yaakov high school in Borough Park, she took a course in legal stenography,[13] and she graduated from high school in 1982.[14] At age 19 she married David Freier, with whom she has three sons and three daughters.[12]

Freier worked first as a legal secretary, and, in 1994, as a paralegal at law firm Willkie Farr & Gallagher,[12] in order to support her husband in kollel.[15] Her husband went on to complete an accounting degree at Touro College,[12] and in 1996,[16] she also decided to pursue a college education. She began studying law at age 30 after realizing she was working for lawyers younger than her.[17]

She enrolled at Lander College, part of the Touro College and University System,[18] where she became director of the women's pre-law society, and graduated six years later with a bachelor of science degree in political science.[12][13][15]

She then entered Brooklyn Law School,[19][20] completing her degree in four years, graduating in June 2005.[12][15]

Career

[edit]
Rachel Freier meeting with President Bill Clinton & Hillary Clinton

Freier passed the New York State Bar exam in 2006.[9] She is also licensed to practice law in New Jersey and the District of Columbia.[13]

Freier and her husband shared an office in Borough Park, where she practiced commercial and residential estate law, and he did commercial financing.[5][15]

Freier also had a law office in Monroe, New York, where she did business with Hasidic residents of nearby Kiryas Joel.[21] She advocated for the Satmar[22] Hasidic Community by speaking to residents of Orange, Sullivan, and Rockland counties, to help correct misconceptions people might have about Hasidic life in Kiryas Joel,[23] and to better understand the Hasidic neighbors in their midst.[24]

Freier began her political career in 2001 as an intern in the Manhattan office of then-U.S. Senator from New York Hillary Clinton.[25] She also interned for other elected officials.[26]

Civil court judge

[edit]
US Vice President Kamala Harris with Rachel Freier at the Hanukkah reception in the VP Official Residence

In April 2016, Freier announced her candidacy for civil court judge, running for the spot on the bench vacated by Judge Noach Dear.[27][28]

In the September 2016 Democratic primary election for Civil Court Judge of the Kings County 5th judicial district, Freier garnered 4,730 votes (40.9 percent), followed by Jill Epstein with 3,993 votes (34.5 percent), and Morton Avigdor with 2,835 votes (24.5 percent).[29] She entered the November general election, with Avigdor as a Conservative Party challenger, and received 68,088 votes (74.4 percent), to his 23,393 votes (25.6 percent).[30]

Freier was endorsed in the three-way race during the elections by The Jewish Press[31] and the New York Daily News.[32]

On December 22, 2016, she was sworn-in at Brooklyn Borough Hall.[33] She delivered a speech that included Hebrew and Yiddish phrases and concepts which she translated into English.[34] Her inauguration ceremony was carried live on WABC-TV[8] and News 12.[35]

On hand for her swearing-in was Hasidic singer Lipa Schmeltzer, who sang "The Star-Spangled Banner" with bits of Yiddish[36] and "God Bless America" in full Yiddish version.[37][38]

Subsequent to her swearing-in, Freier was assigned to serve on the New York City Criminal Court.[9]

NY Attorney General Letitia James swearing-in Rachel Freier as Supreme Court Justice of NY, at her inauguration in Brooklyn Law School

In December 2017, Megyn Kelly welcomed Freier to the Today Show[39] as the woman The New York Times has called “the Hasidic superwoman of night court”; she was featured in the series “She’s Got Faith,” marking her one-year anniversary on the bench.[40]

In July 2022, Freier announced her candidacy for Supreme Court Judge, running for one of the 10 vacancies on Brooklyn's Supreme Court.[41][42]

In January 2023, Freier was appointed as acting New York Supreme Court justice by her supervisors to fill a vacancy on the Supreme Court, Religious leaders say she is the first Hasidic woman to hold this role.[43][44][45]

In August 2023, Freier was nominated as a Supreme Court Justice candidate for a 14-year term, the vote was conducted by Brooklyn District Leaders at the Judicial Convention.[46][47] On November 7, 2023, she was elected to the court in her own right in the general election.[48]

On November 15, 2023, Freier was sworn-in by New York Attorney General Letitia James as Supreme Court Justice of NY.[49][50] Her inauguration ceremony was held at Brooklyn Law School,[51] and it was carried live on TV News 12.[52]

NYC Mayor Eric Adams giving Rachel Freier an award at her inauguration in Brooklyn Borough Hall
Election history
Location Date Party Votes Results
Brooklyn Civil Court
District 5 		Sept
2016 		Democratic 4,730
3,993
2,835 		√ Rachel Freier 40.9%
Jill Epstein 34.5%
Morton Avigdor 24.5%
Brooklyn Civil Court
District 5 		Dec
2016 		General 68,088
23,393 		√ Rachel Freier (D) 74.4%
Morton Avigdor (R) 25.6%


New York Supreme Court
District 2 		Nov 7
2023 		General 138,498
135,789
134,410
131,223
128,437
105,852
33,377
 √ Sharon Clarke (D) 17.1%
√ Rachel Freier (D) 16.8%
√ Joanne Quinones (D) 16.6%
√ Saul Stein (D) 16.3%
√ Heela Capell (D) 15.9%
√ Caroline Piela Cohen (D) 13.1%
Timothy Peterson (R) 4.1%

Volunteer activities

[edit]
Rachel Freier appeared in ads for 93Queen Ezras Nashim in NYC on MTA Bus Stops, publicized by The Mayor's Office of Media Entertainment

In 2005, Freier established Chasdei Devorah, Inc.,[53] a non-profit charity organization to help poor Jewish families, in memory of a young friend.[54]

In 2008,[15] Freier was one of the founders of B'Derech, a GED program for Haredi youth at-risk.[16][55] The organization also helps troubled teens with therapy and hypnosis.[56]

The program launched in partnership with the New York branch of Bramson ORT College adding a Men's Division[57] and Women’s Division.[58]

In 2010, Freier advocated to save Breslov Yeshiva in Williamsburg, in spite of opposition from some who harassed the students and maligned the Rabbi, Yoel Roth.[59] Freier received threats for defending the yeshiva, but she won the court case.[60]

In 2011, she founded Ezras Nashim, an all-female Orthodox Jewish volunteer EMT ambulance service established with the goal of preserving women's modesty in emergency medical situations, especially childbirth.[61]

Affiliations

[edit]

Freier is a licensed EMT, and has completed advanced training to qualify as a New York State paramedic.[16][55][62] She has served on Borough Park's Community Board 12, and performed pro bono legal services for the New York City Family Court.[55]

Freier appeared in a documentary about Ezras Nashim, entitled 93Queen, which was directed by filmmaker Paula Eiselt.[63] The film premiered on May 1, 2018, at the Hot Docs Canadian International Documentary Festival.[64][65] The film aired on PBS's POV, marking its television debut, on September 17, 2018.[66]

Freier honored at the New York City Council Chambers with a Proclamation Award for being elected as the first Hasidic woman to public office in New York City, September 7, 2017

Honors and awards

[edit]

In September 2017, Freier was honored at the New York City Hall in the Council Chambers with a "Proclamation Award" presented by the Speaker & Council-members of the Jewish Caucus for her achievement of becoming the First Hasidic Woman elected to Public Office in New York City.[67][68]

In 2017, Freier was chosen by The Jerusalem Post, an Israeli newspaper, as #40 of the "50 Most Influential Jews" in the world.[69][70] In 2016, she was named one of the "15 Most Influential Jews" in the world by Makor Rishon, another Israeli newspaper.[71][72]

Freier with a delegation of Ezras Nashim members were recognized in the New York State Capitol in Albany

Also in 2016, Freier's judgeship was selected by Kings County Politics as one of the "Top 10 Stories" among political events in New York City that year.[73] She was also listed by City & State magazine as one of the "Winners" among politicians of New York State that year,[74] and was a recipient of Jew in the City's "Orthodox Jewish All Stars Award".[75][76][77]

In September 2018, Freier was named by the Algemeiner Journal among the "J100" list of "top 100 people" positively influencing Jewish life.[78] In December 2018, Freier was named in The "Forward 50"[79] list of American Jews who have a profound impact on the American Jewish community.[80] In October 2018, Freier was inducted into the Brooklyn Jewish Hall of Fame;[81] she received an award recognized among the leading Brooklynites.[82]

In May 2019, Freier was awarded by Lufthansa Airlines for saving the life of a passenger who had a medical emergency onboard, when she was able to provide medical care in mid-flight.[83][84]

In January 2020, Freier along with a delegation of Ezras Nashim members were recognized in front of the entire New York State Assembly in the Assembly Chambers of the New York State Capitol Building in Albany, a resolution was passed recognizing the EMT members for their volunteer efforts of preserving women’s dignity during emergencies,[85] Freier and the delegation had afterwards a private meeting with New York Governor Kathy Hochul in the Capitol Building.[86]

Rachel Freier meets with New York Governor Kathy Hochul in Albany

Personal life

[edit]

She married David Freier, a Bobover Hasid, with whom she has three sons and three daughters.[9] They reside in the Borough Park Hasidic community of Brooklyn.[9] Freier credits support from family and her husband for success.[87] Freier spends her personal time inspiring Jewish women in Judaism by speaking at Jewish schools,[88] Jewish organizations i.e. OU Kosher Headquarters[89] and Jewish Federations.[90] Freier also speaks at Chabad Centers[91] all over the world, inspiring Jewish woman bringing them closer to Judaism known as the "Kiruv Movement".[92]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
[edit]
Revisions and contributorsEdit on WikipediaRead on Wikipedia

Rachel Freier

View on Grokipedia
from Grokipedia
Rachel "Ruchie" Freier (born April 2, 1965) is an American Hasidic Jewish judge serving as an Acting Justice on the . Elected in 2016 to the Civil Court in Kings County's 5th judicial district, she became the first Hasidic woman to win elected public office in the United States. Prior to her judicial career, Freier practiced after earning her from in 2005 and becoming licensed in New York, , and . As director of Ezras Nashim, the first state-approved all-female volunteer ambulance service for Brooklyn's Hasidic community founded in 2014, she provides emergency medical response while adhering to religious modesty standards that prohibit male responders treating women. A mother of six children, Freier exemplifies a commitment to both family and community service within orthodox Hasidic traditions, including volunteer duties. Her 2023 elevation to the further solidified her pioneering status as the first Hasidic female justice in that court.

Early Life and Education

Upbringing in Borough Park

Rachel Freier was born on April 2, 1965, in , a neighborhood renowned for its dense concentration of Hasidic Jewish residents adhering to strict religious observance. As the eldest of five children in a Hasidic family, she was immersed from childhood in a community emphasizing , Yiddish language, and separation from secular influences, with her parents themselves being children of . Her father was born during the Holocaust era, underscoring the intergenerational trauma and resilience shaping her family's values of faith and communal solidarity. Freier's early years were marked by traditional Hasidic education tailored for girls, attending Bais Yaakov schools that focused on religious instruction, modesty, and domestic preparation rather than advanced secular academics. She graduated from Bais Yaakov High School in 1982, reflecting the community's norms where females were encouraged toward marriage and homemaking over professional ambitions. This upbringing in a "heimishe Hasidishe family"—a Yiddish term denoting an insular, pious household—instilled deep religious commitment, with daily life revolving around synagogue attendance, kosher observance, and Shabbat rituals amid Borough Park's Yiddish-infused streetscape. The Borough Park environment, home to sects like Bobov and , reinforced gender-segregated roles and skepticism toward external institutions, yet Freier's family background as descendants of survivors emphasized perseverance and ethical living grounded in (Jewish law). By age 19, she married David Freier, a Bobover , transitioning into early adulthood while remaining rooted in the neighborhood's communal fabric. Freier completed her at Bais Yaakov High School in Borough Park, graduating in 1982 at age 17. Following her marriage at age 19 and the birth of her children, she deferred higher education for over a decade, working initially as a and to gain practical exposure to the legal field while prioritizing family responsibilities in her Orthodox Jewish community. At age 30 and as a mother, Freier enrolled at Touro College's Lander College of Arts and Sciences in , , completing a degree in in 2001. She then pursued legal training at on a part-time basis to balance coursework with raising six children, earning her in 2005. Freier passed the New York State Bar Examination the following year, in 2006, marking her formal entry into legal practice.

Professional Career

Prior to her to the bench, Rachel Freier commenced her legal career in support roles, working first as a and subsequently as a at the firm starting in 1994, while raising a and pursuing part-time. Following her graduation from with a J.D. in 2005 and admission to the bar, Freier established a solo legal practice in , concentrating on commercial and residential transactions within the Hasidic community. She was licensed to practice in the states of New York and , as well as in . In this capacity, Freier also acted as an advisor and advocate for residents of Kiryas Joel, a Hasidic village in , addressing local legal needs in and community matters. Her practice emphasized practical support for Orthodox Jewish clients, reflecting over a decade of immersion in Brooklyn's legal environment before transitioning to judicial candidacy in 2016.

Election and Service as Civil Court Judge

In the Democratic primary election on September 13, 2016, Rachel Freier secured the nomination for judge of the Civil Court of the City of New York in the 5th Municipal District of Kings County, Brooklyn. In the general election on November 8, 2016, she defeated Republican opponent Morton Avigdor, receiving 68,088 votes (74.4 percent) to his 23,393 (25.6 percent). Her victory made her the first Hasidic Jewish woman elected to serve as a civil court judge in New York State, as well as the first woman from her community to hold elected public office. Freier assumed office on January 1, 2017, for a 10-year term covering civil disputes up to $50,000, small claims, housing matters, and criminal cases in encompassing neighborhoods such as Borough Park, , and Sunset Park. During her tenure, she presided over cases in both Civil and Criminal Terms of the Kings County , including guardianship petitions heard on weekdays and motions related to such matters. Freier maintained courtroom procedures emphasizing timely filings and virtual appearances where applicable, with her part assigned to Room 297. Her service concluded in February 2023 when she was appointed acting justice of the , 2nd Judicial District, to fill a vacancy, though she continued handling civil court duties in an acting capacity until her formal elevation. Throughout her civil court role, Freier drew on her prior experience as a private attorney specializing in , matrimonial, and criminal defense law, while balancing her commitments as a volunteer EMT.

Ascension to New York Supreme Court

In December 2022, Rachel Freier was appointed as an acting justice of the , 2nd Judicial District (Kings County), to fill a vacancy left by a retiring judge. This interim role elevated her from her prior position as a Civil Court judge, allowing her to preside over higher-level civil and criminal matters while campaigning for a full term. To secure a permanent 14-year term, Freier required election through New York's judicial selection process, which involves party nominations followed by a general election. On August 10, 2023, she received the Democratic Party nomination at the Kings County Judicial Convention, marking her as the first Hasidic woman nominated for the Supreme Court bench; she also secured endorsements from Republican and Conservative parties. Her campaign drew support from Brooklyn's Orthodox clerical leaders, who praised her judicial experience and community involvement. Freier won the general election on November 7, 2023, defeating one opponent with effectively unanimous support in the 2nd Judicial District. She was sworn in on November 21, 2023, by New York at a ceremony hosted by , officially becoming the first Hasidic woman to serve as a justice on the . Her term extends until January 1, 2038. Freier is assigned to the Guardianship Part and other civil matters in Kings County .

Community and Volunteer Contributions

Establishment of Ezras Nashim

In 2014, Rachel Freier founded Ezras Nashim, an all-female volunteer (EMT) service dedicated to providing care to women in New York City's Orthodox Jewish communities, particularly in Brooklyn's Borough Park and surrounding areas. The organization addressed a gap in existing services like Hatzoloh, a male-dominated volunteer , by offering female responders to uphold religious standards of (), especially in sensitive situations such as , gynecological emergencies, or examinations where Orthodox women might prefer same-gender care to avoid discomfort or violation of communal norms. Freier, who trained as a certified EMT and at institutions including the Center for Allied Health and North Shore-LIJ, drew from her legal expertise to incorporate the nonprofit, secure necessary permits, and navigate regulatory hurdles for operations. The initiative stemmed from requests by a group of Chasidic women EMTs in Borough Park who sought a structured outlet to volunteer for female patients but faced barriers in male-only frameworks; Freier, motivated by community needs and personal commitment to public service, established the service to enable their participation while ensuring professional standards. Early efforts focused on recruiting and training Orthodox women as EMTs, emphasizing rapid response capabilities without compromising religious observance. By 2016, prior to Freier's election as a civil court judge, Ezras had expanded to include state-certified ambulances and branches in areas like and , operating a 24/7 line (718-232-1300) for dispatch. The service positioned itself as the only all-female EMT corps in the U.S. tailored to the Jewish community, prioritizing dignity, competence, and in neonatal, obstetric, and general care.

Founding of B'Derech and Youth Support Efforts

In 2008, Rachel Freier co-founded B'Derech, a focused on aiding at-risk Haredi through GED programs tailored to Orthodox communities. The initiative emerged from grassroots efforts to provide educational opportunities and support for adolescents facing challenges within Chassidic environments, emphasizing retention of communal values while addressing dropout risks. B'Derech's youth support efforts include counseling services and advocacy to help teenagers identify their potential and reintegrate productively, often in partnership with institutions like Bramson College. Freier, drawing from her legal background, positioned the organization to bridge gaps in formal for those disengaged from traditional systems, promoting self-sufficiency without secular assimilation. These activities reflect Freier's broader commitment to internal solutions for vulnerability, prioritizing empirical interventions over external critiques of Haredi educational structures. By 2010, B'Derech had gained recognition for treading a path aligned with Chassidic principles while advocating for children's opportunities, as evidenced in publications.

Social Positions and Public Stances

Views on Abortion and Life Issues

Freier has publicly disagreed with the U.S. Supreme Court's 1973 decision in , which established a to , reflecting a position aligned with traditional Orthodox Jewish teachings that generally prioritize fetal life except in cases of grave maternal danger. This stance drew scrutiny during her August 2023 endorsement by the Democratic Party for a vacancy, where critics, including progressive activists, highlighted her views as incompatible with expansive access, though Freier did not respond to requests for elaboration on potential judicial implications or policy exceptions. Her broader perspectives on life issues emphasize protection of vulnerable populations, informed by her founding of Ezras Nashim in 2014, a volunteer all-female Orthodox Jewish emergency medical service focused on modesty-preserving care for women, including during and reproductive emergencies, which underscores a communal commitment to supporting maternal and fetal well-being without endorsing elective terminations. Freier has not articulated positions on related matters such as or in public statements, but her advocacy for family-centric values in Hasidic communities implicitly favors policies safeguarding human life from conception through natural death, consistent with halakhic principles that view as permissible only under narrow rabbinic criteria rather than as a unrestricted right. Reports from community-oriented outlets note her opposition to "abortion rights" expansions post-Dobbs v. (2022), positioning her against secular frameworks that decouple from religious or ethical constraints, though mainstream media coverage often frames such critiques through a lens of partisan conflict rather than doctrinal nuance.

Perspectives on Gender Roles in Orthodox Communities

Rachel Freier maintains that does not oppress women but instead places them on a high pedestal, as evidenced by practices such as matrilineal descent determining and women's role in transmitting religious observance through lighting and immersion in the . She argues that women in the Hasidic community can pursue , careers, and without violating , countering perceptions of inherent limitation by demonstrating personal success as a mother of six, , and while upholding and family priorities. Freier explicitly rejects the label of feminist, viewing it as implying a rejection of traditional gender distinctions, such as women assuming male religious roles like rabbis or participating in a minyan. Instead, she describes the Hasidic community as matriarchal in aspects like family decision-making and child-rearing, where women exert significant influence without encroaching on men's spiritual leadership duties. Her husband's support for her campaign—uncommon but pivotal in enabling her path—highlights how traditional partnerships can accommodate women's ambitions when aligned with communal values. In practice, Freier advocates for initiatives that reinforce gender separation to preserve tznius (modesty), such as her founding of Ezras Nashim, an all-female volunteer ambulance service, which allows women to receive emergency care from female providers and avoids physical contact with unrelated men during transport. This approach underscores her belief that strict customs on gender roles— including segregation in public spaces like buses and classrooms—enable rather than hinder women's contributions, provided they remain within halakhic bounds. She encourages community members to witness her trajectory as proof that secular achievements are compatible with remaining fully observant and integrated in Hasidic life.

Responses to Public Health Mandates and Cultural Pressures

During the , Freier, as director of , led the all-female volunteer corps in responding to emergencies in 's Orthodox Jewish hotspots, where infection rates were elevated due to community gatherings. Her team adapted protocols by donning full protective gear for patient transports and expanding homebound care services to mitigate risks, demonstrating adherence to guidelines amid heightened demand. Additionally, Freier personally administered doses, including second doses of the vaccine to elderly community members such as , aligning with efforts promoted by health authorities. Freier has addressed cultural pressures within and outside her Hasidic community by advocating for women's roles that preserve religious while enabling . In founding Ezras Nashim in 2014, she countered intra-community norms prohibiting women from interacting with unrelated men in medical emergencies, training over 100 female EMTs to provide culturally sensitive care without compromising halachic standards. This initiative responded to practical gaps in emergency response rather than yielding to external secular demands for gender integration in all spheres. Against broader secular cultural expectations, Freier has critiqued pressures on women to prioritize careers over large families, arguing in a 2013 that such views mischaracterize Orthodox motherhood as burdensome rather than fulfilling. She emphasized that in Hasidic communities, women's primary focus remains child-rearing and homemaking, free from the "success" metrics of American culture that often delay or limit childbearing, positioning her achievements in and as extensions of familial duty rather than alternatives to it. This stance reflects a resistance to assimilationist influences while navigating professional mandates in a pluralistic society.

Controversies and Public Scrutiny

Criticisms from Progressive and Secular Critics

Progressive and secular critics have primarily targeted Rachel Freier's opposition to abortion rights, viewing her stance as incompatible with Democratic Party values and judicial impartiality on reproductive issues. In a 2013 op-ed published in , Freier critiqued the reasoning in , arguing that motherhood reflects an innate maternal instinct and that the decision undermined the intrinsic value of prenatal life, though she affirmed support for women's choices in certain circumstances. This position resurfaced during her 2023 nomination for by the Brooklyn Democratic County Committee, prompting accusations that she was unfit to adjudicate abortion-related cases affecting the borough's 2.5 million residents. Carey Tan, a judicial delegate from Prospect Heights and vocal pro-choice advocate, contended that Freier's disagreement with Roe v. Wade "absolutely should have disqualified her," emphasizing a preference for candidates who "unequivocally support my right to have an ." An anonymous Democratic Party insider similarly described the endorsement as an "accident," warning that the party had elevated a "possibly anti- judge" to a position with potential influence over reproductive access post the 2022 overturning of Roe. These objections highlighted tensions within progressive circles, where Freier's religious conservatism was seen as clashing with secular expectations of ideological alignment on bodily autonomy, despite her prior electoral successes as a Democrat. Freier's rejection of the feminist label has also drawn scrutiny from secular observers, who interpret it as a reluctance to challenge patriarchal norms in Hasidic communities. In a 2017 New York Times profile, she distanced herself from , describing it as a "radical charge" implying a desire to "overstep and reject" traditional roles, a stance some progressive commentators viewed as reinforcing gender segregation rather than advancing women's equality. Academic analyses of initiatives like Ezras Nashim, featured prominently in her public profile, have similarly critiqued such efforts as accommodations within male-dominated systems, questioning whether they constitute genuine empowerment or mere compliance with orthodox hierarchies from a secular perspective.

Defenses and Support from Traditionalist Advocates

Traditionalist advocates, including Orthodox rabbis and community leaders, have defended Rachel Freier against criticisms by underscoring her fidelity to Hasidic values, such as gender modesty and family priorities, even as she pursues . Rabbi Eli Cohen of the Lubavitch Jewish Community in Crown Heights praised her as embodying "compassion, commitment and courage," noting her career-long dedication to aiding vulnerable families and at-risk youth while preserving her faith and traditions. Similarly, Rabbi Yirmi Levy of the Mill Basin Sephardic Congregation highlighted her honesty, fairness, and passion for , crediting her groundbreaking role as a mother of six who fights for equality without diluting religious observance. Freier's initiatives, like founding Ezras Nashim in 2014—an all-female volunteer ambulance service—have drawn commendation from traditionalists for upholding tznius () by enabling women to receive care from female providers, thereby avoiding physical contact with unrelated men in line with halachic standards. Community endorsements during her judicial campaigns, including rabbinical approvals sought by her family, reflect broad support for her model of achievement within communal boundaries, countering claims that her hinders or . In the face of scrutiny over her opposition to abortion expansion—evident in her public disagreement with Roe v. Wade—traditionalist backers, including clerical figures in Brooklyn, have affirmed her stances as rooted in Jewish ethical teachings on life, portraying her as a defender of moral consistency rather than an outlier. The Orthodox Jewish Chamber of Commerce honored her in 2023 for Women's History Month, recognizing her as the first Hasidic woman on the New York Supreme Court and a symbol of empowerment through adherence to tradition.

Media Portrayals and Community Reactions

Rachel Freier has been depicted in mainstream media as a pioneering figure challenging traditional gender norms within the Hasidic community while adhering to its religious observances. The 2018 documentary 93Queen, directed by Paula Eiselt, centers on Freier's founding of the all-female volunteer ambulance service Ezras Nashim, portraying her as a determined leader navigating internal community opposition from male-dominated volunteer organizations. Reviews praised the film for providing a nuanced perspective on ultra-Orthodox Jewish life, with The New York Times noting it avoids simplistic stereotypes seen in other depictions, and The Guardian highlighting the "incredible story" of Hasidic women's self-empowerment efforts. A 2017 New York Times profile dubbed her the "Hasidic Superwoman of Night Court," emphasizing her roles as a judge, mother of six, EMT volunteer, and community advocate who persisted despite resistance from religious authorities. Freier has critiqued media tendencies to negatively portray Hasidic communities, arguing in a 2022 interview that such coverage often exaggerates insularity and overlooks internal progress, such as women's increasing involvement in public service. Her conservative stances, including opposition to abortion rights, have drawn criticism in progressive outlets; during her 2023 campaign for a higher judicial position, reports highlighted her disagreement with Roe v. Wade as a point of contention among Democratic endorsers, amid broader accusations of intra-party tensions. Within the Hasidic community, reactions to Freier's initiatives have been mixed, with initial pushback from established male volunteer networks against Ezras Nashim, reflecting concerns over altering traditional roles, though the service gained approval and support by 2014 for addressing modesty-related needs in emergencies. Her 2016 election as the first Hasidic woman to a New York civil court judgeship elicited praise from Orthodox advocates as a model of compatible religious observance and professional achievement, advancing community representation without compromising faith. Broader Jewish communal responses, as covered in outlets like , have lauded her as an "American trailblazer" who demonstrates Hasidic women's capacity for leadership. Some traditionalist elements, however, view her public prominence as overly modernizing, prompting internal debates on gender boundaries.

Personal Life and Values

Family Dynamics and Motherhood

Rachel Freier married David Freier at age 19, consistent with Hasidic traditions emphasizing early and family formation. The couple has six children—three sons and three daughters—and Freier is a grandmother. She experienced and early in her marriage before building her , which she regards as central to her identity within the Hasidic emphasis on progeny as a and legacy. Freier has consistently prioritized motherhood and family over her professional life, stating that raising her children constitutes her primary role, with legal work as a secondary endeavor. She entered after having three children and continued her studies and career amid raising the rest, determined to uphold traditional duties like baking for , performing daily prayers, and nurturing her household without compromise. This approach reflects Hasidic cultural norms that venerate large families, supported by communal structures such as postpartum care facilities that ease maternal burdens. Key to Freier's balance of roles has been robust family support, particularly from her husband, who provided assistance at every stage, including financing her judicial campaign—a rare stance for a Hasidic man traditionally focused on male breadwinning. Her mother also contributes significantly to childcare and household management. Freier has noted that without such backing from loved ones, sustaining her multifaceted life would resemble "an uphill battle." This dynamic enables her to extend her maternal instincts into , such as founding B'Derech to aid at-risk Hasidic youth, while maintaining strict observance.

Adherence to Hasidic Observance

Rachel Freier maintains strict adherence to Hasidic Jewish customs, including in dress, which entails wearing a sheitel (wig) to cover her hair as a married woman, long skirts, stockings, and other traditional attire that conceals elbows and knees in line with (modesty) principles central to Hasidic life. She avoids physical contact with unrelated men, such as handshaking, and refrains from consuming non-kosher foods like , reflecting core halakhic (Jewish legal) prohibitions observed rigorously in her community. Her observance of Shabbat and Jewish holidays necessitates accommodations in her judicial schedule; as a civil court judge, she primarily handles night court duties to minimize conflicts with Shabbat, which begins at sunset on Friday and ends Saturday night, during which work is prohibited under Jewish law. Freier does not own a television, limiting exposure to secular media, and participates in gender-segregated synagogue services without adopting male prayer garments like the tallis, preserving traditional roles. Freier's commitment extends to community initiatives that uphold Hasidic values, such as founding Ezras Nashim in 2011, an all-female volunteer ambulance corps designed to provide while respecting women's preferences against male EMTs in intimate situations. This aligns with her broader integration of religious observance into , where she views her faith as enhancing her judicial empathy and dedication, stating that her "commitment to the public and my commitment to my religion… go hand in hand." Despite professional demands, she prioritizes family duties, having married at age 19 and raised six children in a traditional Hasidic household, balancing motherhood with observance without compromising core tenets.

Impact and Legacy

Trailblazing Role for Hasidic Women

Rachel Freier achieved a historic milestone in 2016 when she became the first Hasidic woman elected to public office in the United States, securing a position as a Civil Court judge in Kings County's 5th judicial district, which includes Brooklyn neighborhoods like Borough Park and Kensington. She won the Democratic primary on September 13, 2016, and was sworn in on December 22, 2016, demonstrating that adherence to Hasidic customs, including modest dress and family priorities, did not preclude professional advancement in the legal field. In 2023, Freier was elected to the New York Supreme Court, 2nd Judicial District, marking her as the first Hasidic woman to serve in that capacity as well. Prior to her judicial elections, Freier founded Ezras Nashim in 2014, the first all-female volunteer emergency medical service in tailored to the needs of Orthodox Jewish women. This initiative addressed a practical gap in the Hasidic community, where religious modesty prohibitions often deterred women from seeking timely medical aid from mixed-gender crews; Ezras Nashim provides female EMTs to handle emergencies, thereby enabling women to access care without violating halachic standards. Freier, a licensed herself, established the service to empower women by integrating emergency response roles with traditional observance, and it has since expanded operations, responding to calls across and influencing similar modesty-compliant models elsewhere. Freier's accomplishments have served as a model for Hasidic women seeking professional roles without cultural assimilation, illustrating that internal community reforms—rooted in religious compatibility—can foster empowerment. By balancing motherhood to six children, grandmotherhood, and full-time observance with careers in and services, she has inspired subsequent generations of Orthodox women to pursue education and within the bounds of their , as evidenced by increased participation in female-led initiatives in ultra-Orthodox enclaves. Her approach contrasts with external pressures for , emphasizing through adherence to first principles of Jewish and community needs.

Influence on Judicial Diversity and Community Empowerment

Rachel Freier's election as a Civil Court judge in Kings County in November 2016 marked her as the first Hasidic Jewish woman to achieve this position in New York State, thereby advancing judicial diversity by incorporating perspectives from the ultra-Orthodox community into the bench. Her subsequent appointment in February 2023 as an Acting Justice of the New York Supreme Court further solidified this milestone, making her the first Hasidic woman to serve on the state's trial court of general jurisdiction. This representation challenges the predominance of secular or less traditional viewpoints in the judiciary, demonstrating that adherence to strict religious observance is compatible with public service and legal adjudication. Freier's judicial tenure has influenced diversity by exemplifying how women from insular religious groups can ascend to positions of authority without compromising communal norms, potentially encouraging similar candidacies among Hasidic and other Orthodox women. Experts note no prior Hasidic female judges in the U.S., underscoring her role in broadening the demographic composition of the courts to include voices from communities often underrepresented due to cultural barriers. Her success, achieved through a Democratic primary victory despite opposition from some community leaders, highlights the viability of grassroots campaigns rooted in community needs rather than external ideological alignments. Beyond the judiciary, Freier has empowered the Hasidic community through founding Ezras Nashim in 2014, the first all-female volunteer emergency medical service in tailored to Orthodox women's modesty requirements, which provides culturally sensitive care and has trained dozens of female EMTs. This initiative addresses gaps in male-dominated Hatzolah services, enabling women to pursue certifications and leadership roles while preserving religious standards, thereby fostering and professional development within the community. Community events and training fairs organized under her direction have expanded access to emergency response skills for women, reducing reliance on external services and enhancing local autonomy. Freier's efforts underscore a model of that prioritizes internal solutions over assimilation, influencing broader discussions on integrating traditional values with modern exigencies.

References

  1. https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/rachel-ruchie-freier
  2. https://www.brooklaw.edu/news-and-events/news/2023/11/hon-rachel-freier-05-celebrates-supreme-achievement-at-brooklyn-law-swearing-in-ceremony/
  3. https://www.jta.org/2016/10/27/united-states/a-brooklyn-judge-becomes-americas-first-hasidic-woman-to-serve-in-public-office
  4. https://ezrasnashim.org/judge-rachel-freier/
  5. https://jewishjournal.com/cover_story/298636/female-chasidic-judge-breaks-the-mold/
  6. https://www.jpost.com/diaspora/article-724638
  7. https://forward.com/culture/399616/ruchie-freier-hasidic-judge-american-trailblazer/
  8. https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world/article/r1cjrtnao
  9. https://ww2.nycourts.gov/sites/default/files/document/files/2022-05/Judge%2520Freier.pdf
  10. https://www.recordonline.com/story/news/2007/05/06/living-in-two-worlds-rachel/52906878007/
  11. https://www.brooklaw.edu/news-and-events/brooklyn-law-notes/fall-2017/inside_freier/
  12. https://trellis.law/judge/rachel.e.freier
  13. https://www.touro.edu/news--events/stories/lcw-ruchie-freier.php
  14. https://brooklyneagle.com/articles/2023/11/21/first-hasidic-female-supreme-court-justice/
  15. https://www.brooklaw.edu/news-and-events/news/2017/2017-01-03/
  16. https://www.jta.org/2016/09/14/united-states/in-first-hasidic-woman-elected-to-serve-as-civil-court-judge-in-ny-state
  17. https://www.usatoday.com/elections/results/race/2016-11-08-other-NY-36570/
  18. https://www.timesofisrael.com/in-first-hasidic-woman-elected-to-serve-as-civil-court-judge-in-ny-state/
  19. https://forward.com/fast-forward/350004/trailblazing-hasidic-woman-elected-as-brooklyn-judge/
  20. https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/2jd/kings/civil/FreierRules.shtml
  21. https://5townscentral.com/2023/02/08/rachel-freier-chosen-to-fill-vacancy-on-the-supreme-court/
  22. https://jewishjournal.org/2022/12/12/rachel-freier-is-one-unusual-woman-civil-court-judge-parademic-hasid-and-mother-of-6/
  23. https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/rachel-freier-believed-to-be-first-hasidic-woman-to-be-new-york-state-supreme-court-judge/
  24. https://politicsny.com/2023/08/04/acting-supreme-court-judge-rachel-freier-garners-support-from-brooklyns-clerical-leaders/
  25. https://vinnews.com/2023/08/10/another-milestone-for-freier-who-becomes-first-hasidic-woman-nominated-to-supreme-court-bench/
  26. https://ballotpedia.org/Rachel_Freier
  27. https://results.elections.ny.gov/candidate/12980
  28. https://ww2.nycourts.gov/courts/2jd/kings/civil/judgesrules.shtml
  29. https://www.i24news.tv/en/news/international/americas/133581-161226-first-female-ultra-orthodox-judge-appointed-in-ny-state
  30. https://www.yu.edu/news/93queen-and-ezras-nashim
  31. https://ezrasnashim.org/
  32. https://www.gothamist.com/news/an-interview-with-the-first-hasidic-woman-elected-to-public-office-in-the-us
  33. https://www.hindahelps.com/templates/articlecco_cdo/aid/6352317/jewish/Judge-Freier.htm
  34. https://stljewishlight.org/world-news/a-brooklyn-judge-becomes-americas-first-hasidic-woman-to-serve-in-public-office/
  35. https://www.psu.edu/news/campus-life/story/rachel-freier-nations-first-hasidic-female-judge-spoke-penn-state
  36. https://vinnews.com/2010/05/11/new-york-treading-b%25E2%2580%2599derech-hachassidus-and-advocating-for-our-children/
  37. https://www.thecity.nyc/2023/08/17/brooklyn-judge-democratic-clubhouse-abortion-roe-wade-rachel-freier/
  38. https://www.shtetl.org/article/shtetl-news-roundup-judge-ruchie-freier-faces-criticism-south-williamsburg-fire-ny-ag-ends-investigation-of-ally-more-haredi-news-this-week
  39. https://www.nytimes.com/2021/04/19/us/ezras-nashim-womens-EMT.html
  40. https://forward.com/opinion/172778/a-mother-is-who-i-am/
  41. https://www.kveller.com/4-things-you-may-not-know-about-the-first-hasidic-woman-elected-to-public-office-in-the-u-s/
  42. https://www.cbsnews.com/news/rachel-freier-trailblazing-hasidic-woman-judge-from-new-york-dont-give-up/
  43. https://ny1.com/nyc/brooklyn/news/2020/06/03/all-female-paramedics-group-responds-to-coronavirus-hotspot-in-brooklyn
  44. http://www.yanapaskova.com/visual-project-management--grant-work/ezras-nashim---helping-women/Ezras_Nashim_001
  45. https://www.nytimes.com/2017/11/17/nyregion/judge-ruchie-the-hasidic-superwoman-of-night-court.html
  46. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.5703/shofar.38.2.0001
  47. https://njjewishnews.timesofisrael.com/chasidic-woman-judge-keeps-her-faith/
  48. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/24/movies/93queen-review.html
  49. https://www.latimes.com/entertainment/movies/la-et-mn-93queen-review-20180814-story.html
  50. https://www.theguardian.com/film/2018/jul/25/93queen-the-incredible-story-of-the-all-female-hasidic-emergency-service
  51. https://www.jta.org/2022/12/11/united-states/rachel-freier-is-one-unusual-woman-civil-court-judge-parademic-hasid-and-mother-of-6
  52. https://www.timesofisrael.com/trailblazing-hasidic-woman-judge-its-the-american-dream/
  53. https://www.ynetnews.com/jewish-world/article/5072939
  54. https://wigreports.com/why-jewish-women-wear-wigs/
  55. https://www.cbsnews.com/newyork/news/first-hasidic-civil-court-judge/
  56. https://coopersquared.com/2024/07/01/ezras-nashims-chief-operating-officer-on-personal-life-work-and-balancing-it-all/
  57. https://jta.org/2022/12/11/united-states/rachel-freier-is-one-unusual-woman-civil-court-judge-parademic-hasid-and-mother-of-6
  58. https://www.touro.edu/news--events/events/kadish-judge-freier-touro-talks-11222.php
  59. https://legalnews.com/Home/Articles?DataId=1436804
  60. https://www.hadassahmagazine.org/2018/08/08/rachel-ruchie-freier/
  61. https://nycremsco.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Part-1-Ezras-Nashim-FINAL-10-10-19.pdf
  62. https://www.93queen.com/about1
Add your contribution
Related Hubs
User Avatar
No comments yet.